Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
185110
Original to City Clerk ORDINANCE COUNCIL FILE NO. 1 -(1 PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts , and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1 . That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts , and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from Light Industry District and "C" Residence District , to "A" Residence District : Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast corner of Mississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway, according t,; the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota . That such amendment and such rezoning hereunder shall be deemed to have been made concurrently upon the initiative of the Council and pursuant to the petition therefor, filed with the City Clerk. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force upon the expiration of thirty days after its passage, approval and publication. Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council DeCourcy Holland Mortinson in Favor Peterson Rosen — Against Winkel Mr.President (Dillon) Approved: Attest: City Clerk 7�,��_ 'y[///n/ Mayor 1M 12-57 8 l%�/'"v� �'"/� 2 Duplicate to Printer ORDINANCE COUNCIL FILE NO. PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts , and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from Light Industry District and "C" Residence District, to "A" Residence District : Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast corner of Mississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota. That such amendment and such rezoning hereunder shall be deemed to have been made concurrently upon the initiative of the Council and pursuant to the petition therefor, filed with the City Clerk. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force upon the expiration of thirty days after its passage, approval and publication. Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council DeCourcy Holland Mortinson In Favor Peterson Rosen Against Winkel Mr.President (Dillon) Attest: Approved: City Clerk Mayor 1M 1247 to Triplicate to the Comptroller ORDINANCE COUNCIL FILE NO. PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts , and Rezoning of certain properties in the Cit / of Saint Paul. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 'to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from Light Industry District and "C" Residence District, to "A" Residence District : Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast corner of Mississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota. That such amendment and such rezoning hereunder shall be deemed to have been made concurrently upon the initiative of the Council and pursuant to the petition therefor, filed with the City Clerk. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force upon the expiration of thirty days after its passage, approval and publication. Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council DeCourcy Holland Mortinson In Favor Peterson Rosen Against Winkel • Mr.President (Dillon) Approved: Attest: City Clerk Mayor 1M 12-57 Aro 8 Quadruplicate to Department ORDINANCE COUNCIL FILE NO.. PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the Cit of Saint Paul. • THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN; Section 1. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul. Legislative Code, as amended, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from Light Industry District and "C" Residence District, to "A" Residence District : Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast corner or lississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota. That such amendment and such rezoning hereunder shall be deemed to have been made concurrently upon the initiative of the Council and pursuant to the petition therefor, filed with the City Clerk. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force upon the expiration of thirty dais after its passage, approval and publication. Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council DeCourcy Holland Mortinson in Favor Peterson Rosen Against Winkel Mr. President (Dillon) Approved: Attest: City Clerk Mayor 1M 12-57 / Original to City Clerk ORDINANCE 810 COUNCIL FILE NO. : 51 PRESENTED BY /*/:. ��� ORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending Ordinance No. 5840, entitled: 'An ordinance for the purpose of p. omoting the public health, safety, order, convenience, prosperity and general welfare by providing for the classification, regulatio and restriction of the location of trades andlndustries, and of buildings used for human iabitation and for specified purposes, and the height and bulk of b buildings hereafter erected or altered; and regulating and determining the minimum size of lot line courts and other open spaces, and establishing the boundaries of districts for said purposes, " approved July 7, 1922, as amended. This is an emergency ordinance rendered necessary for the preservation of the public peace, health and safety. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOEgORDAIN: Section 1. That Ordinance No. 5840, approved July 7, 1922, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from Light Industry District and "C" Residence District to "A" Residence District, to-wit : Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast corner of Mississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota. Section 2, This ordinance is hereby declared to be an emergency ordinance rendered necessary for the preservation of the public peace, health and safety. Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force upon its passage, approval anOpublication. v`. ID a CSRPORATION COU EL Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council DeCourcy Holland _—In Favor Mortinson Peterson Against Rosen Ninkel Mr. President (Dillon) Approved:c,N Attest: CUL City Clerk ;i Mayor 1M 6-56 ,a �,8 Triplicate to the Comptroller ORDINANCE 185110 COUNCIL FILE NO. PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending Ordinance No. 5840, entitled: • "An ordinance for the purpose of promoting • the public health, safety, order, convenience, prosperity and gen.erel welfare by providing for the classification, reguletio and restriction of the location of trades an industries, and . of buildings used for human habitation and for specified purpo°ses, and the height and bulk of b bui l-'tngs hereafter erected or altered; and regulating and determining the kinimum eize of lot line courts and other open spaces, and establishing the boundaries of districts for said purposes, " approved July 7, 1922, as amended. This is an emergency ordinance rendered necessary for the preservatiun of the public peace, health and safety. THE COUNCIL CF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES/ORDAIN: Section 1 . That Ordinance No. 5840, approved July 7, 1922, as amended, be and the same i.s hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from Light Industry District and "C" Residence District to "A" Residence District, to-wit : Lots 6, 7, 6, 9 and 10 , Block e, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast cornea. of Mississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the kegister of Deeds in end for Ramsey County , Minnesota . Section 2. This . dinance ie hereby declared to be an emergency ordinance rendered necessary fox the preservation of the public peace, health and safety . Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force upon its passage, approval an uhlication. Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council DeCourcy Holland ic In Favor ortinson Peterson Against Rosen : inkel Mr. President (Dillon) Approved: Attest: City Clerk Mayor 1M 6-5G o. "'. 8 Original to City Clerk ORDINANCE COUNCIL FILE NO. PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul. - - - - - - - _ - pre serves-t ont—cf- t rter-- THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from Light Industry District and "C"Residence District, to "A" Residence District: Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast corner of Mississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota. That such amendment and such rezoning hereunder shall be deemed to have been made concurrently upon the initiative of the Council and pursuant to the petition therefor, filed with the City Clerk. iectian2. • ' - - - - • o— axed to be an - . ' . - . _ - • ed -rrece-ssary for the pre of The—pub-lies pee—ee- -Freaith and safetyL. Section-E:: This ordinance shall take effect and be in force - - - its passage, approval and publication. 1 di° ,7,1401/e, Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council DeCourcy Holland Mortinson Tn Favor Peterson Rosen Against Winkel Mr. President (Dillon) Approved: Attest: City Clerk Mayor 1M 12-57 8 Duplicate to Printer ORDINANCE COUNCIL FILE NO. PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul. This is an emergency ordinance rendered necessary for the preservation of the public peace, health and safety. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the Zoning Code, Chapters 5j to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from Light Industry District and "C"'' sidence District, to "A" Residence District: Lots o, 7, 8, ') and 1 :, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast corner of Mississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota. That such amendment and such rezoning hereunder shall be deemed to have been made concurrently upon the initiative of the Council and pursuant to the petition therefor, filed with the City Clerk. Section 2. This ordinance is hereby declared to be an emergency ordinance rendered necessary for the preservation of the public peace, health and safety. Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force upon its passage, approval and publication. Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council DeCourcy Holland Mortinson in Favor Peterson Rosen Against Winkel Mr.President (Dillon) Approved: Attest: City Clerk Mayor 1M 12-57 8 Triplicate to the Comptroller ORDINANCE COUNCIL FILE NO. PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters ee to e4 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of faint Paul . This is an emergency ordinance rendered necessary for the preservation of the public peace, health and safety. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF 'SKINT PAUL DUE6 ORDAIN: Section 1. That the Zoning Code, Chapters ee to U4 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, be and the same is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from Light Industry District and "C"Residence District, to '"A" Residence District : Lots r', 7, o, > and 1 , Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast corner of Mississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Minnesota. That such amendment and such rezoning hereunder shall be deemed to have been made concurrently upon the initiative of the Council and pursuant to the petition therefor, filed with the City Clerk. Section 2. This ordinance is hereby declared to be an emergency ordinance rendered necessary for the preservation of the public peace, health and safety. Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force upon its passage, approval and publication. Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council DeCourcy Holland Mortinson In Favor Peterson Rosen Against Winkel Mr.President (Dillon) Approved: Attest: City Clerk Mayor 1M 12-57 8 Quadruplicate to Department ORDINANCE COUNCIL FILE NO. PRESENTED BY ORDINANCE NO. An ordinance amending the Zoning Code, Chapters to A inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul . This is an emergency ordinance rendered necessary for the preservation of the public peace, health and safety. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the Zoning Code, Chapters ee to AA inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, pertaining to the Zoning Code, Use Districts, and Rezoning of certain properties in the City of Saint Paul, be and the sate is hereby further amended so as to rezone the following described property from Light industry District and "C"-'residence District, to "A." Residence District: Lots 6, 7, '6, 1 and 1 Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast corner of Mississippi Fiver Boulevard and Highland Parkway, according to the plat thereof on file and of record in the office of the Register of Deeds in and for Ramsey County, Pinnesota. That such amendment and such rezoning hereunder shall be deemed to have been made concurrently upon the initiative of the Council and pursuant to the petition therefor, filed with the City Clerk. Section 2. This ordinance is hereby declared to be an emergency ordinance rendered necessary for the preservation of the public peace, health and safety. Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force upon its passage, approval and publication. Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council DeCourcy Holland Mortinson in Favor Peterson Rosen Against Winkel Mr. President (Dillon) Approved: Attest: City Clerk Mayor IM 12-57 8 1 4 • mis . /4UQ clZ-'_' 4f-Ja_ ,0-<=t)-(- Azo-ifti-le �►-. Pte. �.� Le _J 3 �,. --- -- . LA>-(L-L-e. e t: - ° e C . • Lam-' _ _ zr-6 - ' sue- mg. w`-Re -.{— 161 4-eLerf2i s 06 Y yy"t_ m �� — ,campy, N 91 O'� eVL- G S r coo—J ' (4,21,Jz , '3 a--) r2r..„ ,4,-(--hia_k G� p C -(2±±-4-er, , , „ze2_1).a4... . As2.. 477, a/ a-exiL--t i�2E,4 v 7D./LJ. < erg 1 s ® l cr S GERALD E. FRISCH Notary Public, Ramsey County, Minn, My Commission Expires Jan. 23, 1%4. - s o 'Zt t 1 p � ; / Cl� fr-71 . �— — r )3r?roi - . e - k.s ,i,e44■3- ) 1/r/ \r -°r) -rrr(r n • T-� � 71 '15 -r‘ Vr r --pro _..,k_chx_ 30,7) in i/„ - ,�„ -rrx 4°1-112za-g * —4-)7>y, 2 -47-?,i-D-Ir 97f, ( 4-.-0-r - 92 24, ) 2,),)_ Fo 1 � U GERALD E. FRISCH Notary Public, Ramsey County, Minn. My Commission Expires Jan.23' 1964 0 , *.„,k,„_,L 1 tt -bd--\ , Q.....e,:a.„-(-anl,i,___ `6"-& 6 (-3-e-e-a--- / 7 s"--? G�--e '4-47, AtCt--.1-7:v J--z-, _ .....k--4.2-4-c...ote-4e,‘ 6-124-j-V. - - -Q- .-‘--11--w-IA--1.':i---- -- ck--4AP-- 0--- 6(2- cks2,2.._eQs... 0.,_ )1e-4-4.11 -.--.e--a-.-41. GERALD E. fiThSC}i Ramsey County,Minn. Notary Public,Ramsey Jan. 2�, inn mission Expires My Com --r Awyr .s/ z( -S97 'S?JW ' 111 = - - - - 'rter , 1 • --sue _6)_Dry) /, s.. 1/4_604/ o--h ss % r74—' C �c`�'`` 174 �---- 0 z, 7 (a.,,,,,,_"_ cJ- 14.2,1- 7// ,ECG cA- 7 G-� " ��-� > - i z Z-C/ a- ft 3 2 a `< .`% e. a, s lu:,-,n , a .Zei. , :_e. ZZ-- e-;,- a (,. .e'z_ w .1 ,-6 ---aci, a ,:?e,eice_(__ 7 ra_e, s----/- fia_c_._(' . /..erf.,2_,;,--L.-,), a-e--,-,--(_, 7- --->/ct-o-e---z_a_11 __e_,,„(...' .24_, Ae6,,e_x_e_.„3- I eit7----i.4__ 24...e a_ - V-z-61----c___ 7-a7 l•c-cre-ce saw8-x, 2 e i2.0 .,., c.zc�c�y 0 ° elf -z4.._e_. - Z 6? ,fie 'G _ ///-c-4-- - - - , ie-,:t-zz.,' ,4--e.,z,;,-e--tec-67 ,,(2-e. -Let - -4-4--ecz.._ - CQ9-L.Q. IT.-7,4 v_ (s), .d,t__,. .e .4)/c,ez__(z .- --)-z 4-erp-z--1 7.,ate ,-,e. Z61.GL,1 j-, . ----4-- /ze-- z� a' c -t— /2.-e ci Y-t' /2.44- S--2 v, Z-1: _ _ L-ez-z Y t 9 OeZe, , - . ---Zic iz/- 47-?:--e-''-- j' - Z c7 L9 a-6--6/ Is4t2L --thez,t4 ---Z4 fzet-7-)-Le_ 4 T--XicA,0-7-4_ /1 0--7,t_}-- --i---,-2 1 74-j.7.4 jet.A.4.- -- -.e).-t.,.' .4 -/?'-' j e>'err /16 - 74-0-2-) - ,9-. .ct-n- 6( Z- _art <2-€.--(_G A.i 7 .0 .---77. lJ .:t-e----L,4,4-0--- --.../ ‘c,JA-va-L--.-4,-A2-.Q 0-:4--ek. .C.---t....v--0.--t-,-...i 44-6--4.-e.._ -Y-et-,e,_. evL -- t d 1 9S% .A51--t-t02-e( r GERALD E. FRISCH Notary Public, Ramsey County, Minn. MY Commissjon Expires Jan. 23, 1964. O � ✓ Z ` 4:72t" t e Ca-r: 2424( GERALD E. FRISCH Notary Public, Ramsey County, Minn. My Commission Expires Jan.23, 1964. -ttA4S' • w j'-14 ciLl4Lr) L ;* 4)4 PkS1 14A- $1% DP Y-‘4-9 CZQ 20 42-4(YD 22 t-41 LIA , ``n 44 . • /1 U 0 "� ✓� .r te 0-e- �"A �""�� ru'rn e"r/ r. c„--^1 tcn - f)- Tho - w -t-6) -LIAA r e F 4 ro() <; - -v-e- � - / 3 -7- 4. - F _c# OP:Z7 Re..,(2„ 'f f '' ler re66`-"-z-N 144,4; I. • ex=1 e,0-4-4-7‘--f-- 06' 0--e 44* pc,„.a. J---41-4t fQ i! 1_01/AL ( 1. i C$ , t GERALD E FRISCH S'g Notary Public, Ramsey County, Minn. My Commission Expires Jan.23, 1964. t P AFFIDAVIT STATE OF MINNESOTA, SS . COUNTY OF RAMSEY. I, JACOB BOMBERG, being first duly sworn, do hereby state that I am married to Pearl Bomberg, and that my wife and I reside at 43 Thompson Avenue in the City of St . Paul , where I have resided for many years . I am also known and referred to as J . Bomberg. I have examined a petition presented to the City Council of St . Paul requesting the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" , residence and light industry, to "A" , residence, which petition contains the signature, Mir . J. Bomberg, 43 Thompson . " This purported signature is not my true signature, and the petition was not signed by me , nor was the signature affixed to this petition with my knowledge, permission or consent , and I wish to advise the City Council of the City of St . Paul that I live several miles from the property sought to be rezoned, that I have no interest whatsoever in the rezoning of this property and that the purported signature upon this petition is a forgery of my name . I am attaching to this affidavit a specimen of my signa- ture for comparison . Specimen Signature : Ar;.,„J! Jacob Bo' berg fil a ob Bombe Subscribed and sworn to before me this /3u,. day of October , 1958 . Notary Public , Ramsey County, Minnesota . My Commission Expires : Z�1 1 7 6 I. • City of Saint Paul, Minnesota P TITION TO Ai.IEND OR SIN NCE NO, 5840, THE BUILDING ZONE ORDINANCE The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted under the new classification before signing this petition. For further information about the re-zoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office Ca. 4-4312, Ext, 251 (Please type or print) �,++,� �-�� Date; �JC��d'P 1. i j /q57 TO TlrE NONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL `yo the City Clerk City of Saint Paul, iiinnesota Pursuant to Section 23, Ordinance 5840, we, the undersigned owners of two- thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real estate affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your ;:onorable Body to re- zone the following described property: (legal description and street address) Lots 3,7 , ,g, & 10, Block 2, idgecl_ le Add. No. 2. , "C" residence & light industry as indicated on zoning map from 4A / District to a "A" residence District, for the purpose of installing, constructing and/or operating the following (describe briefly the proposed facility) OWNER S - T 42 LOT BLOCX ADDITION Walter J. Rock ''��- / Edgeciiii Addt'n ,sth� . • 'E: v wTn c Second Church o_ '' ' %�� Christ Scientist ��., , ;�� l �� �, -4 10 # 0 Eleanor S. Woodf!.V1 ■ ' ' �' / Ronald A. r�oodg.Y 'r.! i ,/a, w ,l,2, 1 R verwood Addt'n Raphael Griver , tt Norma Griver 1,2,3 1 ,�illiam C. Smith G. f Ul 4 , 1 tt Isab�.�. with , . .+,... ./.r pEverettLMitche1 �hr'��'' 61/7 Helen M- tii •• -1 - . _ /:. /I ,,/AJ.. ■ _ 5 _—i Asch c h ✓m%� 4)2 ___ Benjamin P. / 1 Rose.; r'iscii ` ,f 441L \ � �� tt Edward C. Schleh C OVV Myra A. chleh j t �rl f�a l� ,/�. _� 1 t / p/3effit,y_./t:oi4/7 i .042:-/ '7‘)'.'e; / ) lei State of ;. innesota) _._ County of Ramsey )ss .. .lter J. Rock being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 11 day October, 195`1- 4. "V Notary u ic, Ramsey County, iiinn, fly Commission expires Page of l pages. Notary FSRL '', ANSEIS, Approved as to form 7/2/54 R " )ubfic,rF`,r�seyDcu��, R. C'.+fice of the Corporation Counsel Y spires Dec. 10, 29 rt4 Z-1 2/19/57 c ar . City of Saint Paul, Minnesota ' PETITION` TO AMEND ORDINANCE NO. 5840, THE BUILDING ZONE ORDINANCE" ) The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted �'I' under the new classification before signing this petition. For further information about the re-zoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office Ca. 4-4612, Ext. 251. (Please type or print) Date: Oct. 3, 1957 TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL the City Clerk City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant to z;ection 23, Ordinance 5840, we, the/undersigned owners of two- thirds of the several descriptions of real estate situated within 100 feet of the real esc>.ce affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the cwners of 50% or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: (legal description and street address) Block 2 Lots 6,7,8 Edgecliff Addition No. 2 from n C District to a A District, (describe briefly the proposed facility) For the purpose- Of Maintaining the area to correspond to the adjacent area. RECORD OW1'ER SIGNA ' LOT BLOCK ADDITION �1 _.�_r___ i -t;--„' / ".. Edgecliff Addt'n . 'Walter & Esther H. Rock /l ; 1 No. 2 (/v econd Church of Christ -if. . -Wx- Y.' $ Scientists At . 4 10 2 "' eanor S. Woody r i , , �sr Ronald A Wood, 140. ,_/ 1 Riverwood Addition Ra hail Griner �} P ( / Norma Griper IN/AO_ _, ►.��i-, .0%' 1 " I, William C. Smith ,._ p Isabel M. Smith �._,•:�� /1 is " " • Everett L. Mitchell ".. i, Helen M. Mitchell rawly�- At WOO" �� " " Ben amin P. Asch ►.' 1 " n •00 Rose G Asoh � Edward G Schleh .• - A Schlep 7 .i& .G _ 9 1 " u ' b a Peterson t 41/''1 - $4erald Peterson P , ,a 1. .`� , 14 1 n " - 1 thur Paymar r 0( Betty C. Paymar t..4,..-u--e , 1 1 " " State of Minnesota)ss, County of Ramsey ) _being first duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of Toro pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the sign= ures above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of th- •_ -o cribed. S :ba c 4 5 b+wc: and orn t• before me �� - t1i:i5 -' O'if it : Al �� / =. --4- . Notary -"ubl , :� e, County nn. My Commis- on xpir'-s /" 7 O Page / of pages. ,a 4 Approved as to form 7 54 ' Office of the Corporation Counsel N. .= .- -- , n. M 1 te8 1,-mite, i Z-1 7%2/54 ' 4 --. . , City of Saint Paul, Minnesota PETITION TO AMEND ORDINANCE NO. 5840, THE BUILDING ZONE ORDINANCE . ' The signer should appraise himself of the uses permitted . under the new classification before signing this petition.. For further information about the re-zoning of property, call the Board of Zoning Office Ca. 4-4612, Ext. 251. (Please type or print) Date; TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL % the City Clerk City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Pursuant Section 23, Ordinance 5840, we, the undersigned q'wners of two- thirds i:-f tl:e several descriptions of real estate situated Within 100 feet of the real ei.* : .te affected, hereby acquiesce; and we, the owners of 50% or more of the frontage to be reclassified, petition your Honorable Body/to rezone the following described property: (legal description and street a dress) Block 2 Lots 6,7,8, Edgecliff Addotn No. 2 from a C District to a r __A District, f ZIXICiabaalit (describe briefly the proposed facility) For the rpose of Maintaining the area to correspond ./o the adgacent area. RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION Norman S. Smith .cam C gthel D. Smith -yt , %�' � 14 1 Riverwood Addition zHenry Pretsman - * -"; P Elsie Pretzman a a ' ' ' - 15 1 .. 'I m " ever '' Sarah S Wiener A,- � - �} 2 2 Edgecliff Addition No. 2 • State of Minnesota) County of Ram )ss * ,tom- being first duly sworn, deposes and states that b- is the person who circulated the within petition consisting of )7„„ pages; that the parties described above are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name; that this petition was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signa •.res above are the true and correct signatures of each and all of t part'.-s -o .es ribed. Subecdi ed an. - orn to before me Ali / • . , this r , is of C ` 1 ,— -�� ,s�g� ,,��= .,I J or Notary Publi , = +sey Coto ty, Minn. My Commissi xpir 1'7?-7/6 o Page s of -, pages. A - :"1.'" --. ' Approved as to form 7/2/54 N. • • ..lic R.i. • • , 'inn. Office of the Corporation Counsel My . -- . • :1, •63 r' I Z-1 7/2/54 e TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS -%a / / 2. / f 3• .;• fd- i •kia .1 74, 9 20/0y4, 4. .. Aw % As /:la. ..�. .., " o • @a_.._ dns...,/ 5. IL. - , t, • ) - • _al,-- A , . I _ -j 0,111 , 6. <77:y /20 -- /t/1- A-4 0 iti/:5 S Z ;?..4P-- 6ee-r-,-&• ! / 7),4., 7 8. 4do - 7L37r014-6-Air .'r' �-e.. $4)Vill4/4‘' (- - 10. . ` t tt . 11. ;L 1, ,� q ,r If 12.(AN., ' 1( tt // 13• 11/1".0. (21 r ,A.4. . - , • 15o ArAiraor----------- — — — ___ ....... . 16. ;' j ,, '. , %� 7 L3 41 . 7. / ot..-t,/L -' '''t \--3 .7, .,, 18. 7)2, 6) / .,,,,_ i .),_.,__ 7, 3 19. �./3 i' e. ,--r -' 1 Q ` ; i 4trkA,44 Pctickt j' (y jilo-.......- IP--/ i TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not - destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. ADDRESS ///1. / .�' .1` L, t� Ste ` 2. .fez L47- d/ 3• /..e, -,_., / , 4. —-- �- �• G1.i/ . 5. IZ I• /, 4 .r/ _ 6. / .w s I 6, - /,'..... _ - Le WNW 7. /Jr AI - -- "AINAWSD/W,W, i 8. i Iii I ef!_.- ` G' 0 r 10. _ . U-7i } ei_l e a 3 7 o 11. /?;4Lz- L' . .- 02:37 r ` • 12. / -Q oI, 3 2 R[ -vc fr/�..e r 3..(44.44 I l4. `J 15. 114 `� . __JCL. 17. ..-1,-)14,0 :71 ,/J!L6 -rte 2 /K r 18. �/ - (' p 19. 20. i TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so that the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS 1. %� !9L-1( -� , /0 g /�'�-a-uL wr ri-Z...t c - P2�_ __ /6 7X-k__ _L - 2. DI. c , le,,e/"...4.."(4.-- c:› 1r,f ' ! ✓/ ' /' te ---4— 4. l� • / (74-es) , Id �,�. _to 5• • L. --- �- e A 7. .' ) �i- /f , ,/ de) 8. '') i I '„ , t di/ / 10• Al0 AO 1 iII /it iv- /9 3 Sia.pt.le,4 A _.e 11. IL, , lit,,,� - , ,e.,„,,,, // / - , . .cam, 12. 12 214 s iJI-14'62-- i 6` '!/aL 13.7ivw1, 4 JTi-GLezi - /171V- 1=- 14. _ .>i, /r'7 Q.1LQ 15. Za , i, C� G� 1- _ { '. �_.tom /11 16. A / A , 020 7 9'U,LI. 1. a, r 17. ✓ ,� ; (2p 2 7 ///# , /,f,-.e, I 18. . .r.L..�a ....v �L.c.i ' /7,� n-C� ��t%?� 19. z-oz / (6) t ) - ir ii4p 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on Lhe Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. ADDRESS 1. 2. • //',j1.r���-,/I/ r 3• '7e-7 _ 4. V � o 5' 7,P/ 1, 6• Z-41_' 1- `C�! 1 i c a/At: vets' 7 �! ./�., j / -7 8. 2 I • 67-4i Vs �.. i 1—'/ 7 f:e.4.4 t, z 10. 4 11. ,It 12. 13. 14+. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,,hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS 1. A .%• - 4i97 717oun p`Cur-�G 2. C �. (AA AA 7-0 7 C u& 3 `�-'`� 4. `-WL, ►■ i 17 K 5 Y11. J� (� 07 ,3- 8. Ad a' ■finillje AO/ 9. /0I 11. 4, / `�7 &?. 4 U 13. p/4, , ,,lp,4017 14. - &$'41. ,l Y 7) 7 11.b- ,6. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so shat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, :the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS . 10424 /A/6 Algc.Z.,-..-0,- ■C-41-Roz4J 3. C-7 `z- 1 /G� - 4.._.0)1,0 . 0- iCtigcn--- �i i y A A 1 1 %�1�1. J /5. �//I ,, 4 �✓ Div (I / , ./ /0 , 6. / . (. Aie 222 ilt / / T 7. JAWAVAef, .....u.,, .-liNliffiffr / ' . 8. , k.:7 t 3 3 / 7,,_4}‘ik2-;.-,. 'd d /--,-,---,-". 4„_.., , y. 0 rK, k. ,Ir 1 `Y, W _5.4.. 27-2• 10. Id et' a'41_,../ / c" ,...ivh 4`--44, ..:' ' r 11. fdj � :, ' ` '13. Wrter _ - f � 1 � 15• t c.•- k /L�`. . -)( -z` L..(. -----" 16. tt.- = St Ad.' !x / /.0 -1.k .... _ ,-, , ,, 4, ,,,..,..74..., /Ire .7-1 1/'0 11..)-4.4 (.7 ,zi,„,-, - 19. _.-__.--;----/-7-2 ._ e_i.4.' 7/ f.:1- . ,,.: / 7-,:.., s.,,,, ...,..„..,„ i ,,,,,,, , 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so shat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. 41$ ADDRESS 1. ."3. s 3T � �-Cs-t- t i 2. i _ G 3. /.. .jam!�.!- -- /6S- 7'I- et-M):) Agri A. w......7 6. J / , if r - )41 '7. ■ /1. 4 ■ 4161..011141_L - /1 /1„, / / 8. 1. . y t A 6),e-ea,-J. 9. ..df ....,-_,...,...... I :'"'"'"''.1,F ol.3 ot-a_m-,:, 10. - & - - d� -7. . 11. J a,u., / , rTh14.4.1 _ p Z J o , euC 12. 472.4!ie�f j :' e.ii- 74 1 p �' C � 13. I � _ � � r_ iit r nE. 3e0 env:. d 14. 7// -J( 15. "".",---ks..„ _ ,74( .,/ ,.4:-4.... ,___ AO 16. L� . :. 9/- - c..,._.._,.L / ' A ,, _ill AP 17• eAliitic4.►.Cfi- • - r/ i L.. L 18. (- 2 .4.4„ / /,"Q �p S 9 �✓�e�mac Cii � 19. 411-.‘ 1 20.7 i�;>d igli l/.-' . '/�' I�/ /ii,� -, i i TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so shat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS 1. 2. -1(h (.;, (.0 ,e-c-t- - /-G, ,L. . 11 3- a e _, _ - . k0, 1 1 . . -- (244A-40K... r, .. mriffrera _ Apr,k, 6. lilliglir l L?\ 24-2/...t_e_. 7• Il %u.�4 04.-.. ' _ s , 8. twupgrros 70 5' eu_ Kl. --- ---- ..,. 9. ..•-e-7-)‘i,e.,...-7'.f---71----..‘ ' 10. . %T .Ao 44-,-,-- gel, 714 zioN11. / 1 / .v 0, .2-ate,.-o.z re-vAe. 12. A , I 4.. . . . . • .4 / 7..9-1 vLcdA /'L.d- (2 . 13. ......, l - / , - /7.2, /, 15.x,` „, /. /P3 S 16. � a I a * ZA, I `?c •z s 17. � _.41 L.:. • t ��� . .1 , . ir ' P..--( W AV ‘ la. 19' . ti it ( I 20. Mr TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on she Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,..hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. > NAME ADDRESS 1. . 2. � Z2 ' 3. i A.A.-..-.16,4 4. v IK `, , ak / :, -L, ,t " --tf Z� rte. '; "Ar 5. J.e L-e ,t.,c.-- —i.-,, Al 7 ,...ii ...AAIIMIIF...• .,„It ..? ;0' ir • ...a. APVY. 8. 3-.3c` ; j L. - vx-�' l _ n .i if) . ,,,,, ,,, , • ,.....„..,,• ,,,F„,,. ... , ,MN r6 / 11. 12.".14( .-.._..._„- .. . 1 001.. .., ', . ' (: /;7( ' 1 `I i ' 1 61-' 0 _ . ..---dx-e_ iv/ ,Ai ----ii , 15. -L-----. 1::, 16. At � \ , = , ` 1- 7 13 a-- r 17. L�� 6t S, ./ e . /� ,-Al ire ar 18. i` - .mil. ice..+Ill All 4111. 19. 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so shat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS 1. f 3 3 ) L , 2. (. - O a 3. / /✓— 411111.r- "ii ' 1" . , i 4. Aic /.. / • ,f, 5. 1 i , E . 1/(.-C.- _ . 6' ICL./ ,6J,w-'P/ 6. /FM 111I�1� -I / /t) ci ) C i��i�r// ��0 7- '.. .._ '' /..._ ,,.i ' II" e...c..&.„. Ali. —41 'f' a. ,4.1i 11-.A 7 l� 0 kr , 10. ��,� �, c c4 3 , 11. tic•I-.._......._&41-- fz.___,„ 2..c_s_L a I/n 14/. ., .4..*.e..,..r,..' 12. a ,'t ,q/ 9 13. - 6, 7' J- 1 f� l4. %, A an. 14 if kki 15• _; ,,.; l 7 / .—Q..e<.-t,s-Q 4 16. .c, /[ .._.....r ,5`IG /4/4/4-4;k, ;rc 17. ' ,/r .e eleee... .1.■ 2a 3 2/ , , la. ; \ /J e i'2A4-,,.._ 19. / I .e_. J / (24-ja . TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL. HONORABLE MEMBERS: 3Je, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkiray on i;he Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so .hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment, s NAME ADDRESS 8. r -- ImPil cot 1 OW ' 4. Ade: 7/_/YZA.-c_e___-2 , • - • „ r)-),Z i 4/1 42/4.1-z_e& g'- ‘),t 5. d`_ y .may / _ �- - - - A r,- 7• 1 It..11 . / r r',`. i 1 8. / ' , ../ 4,,,// y/// 1,4; ,,4/ i . ,/ argirgill 4 - c z, .rs/ 10• � A �_ a WWI! � R 11. � � go — -1-011aUllillegillPIVIVIIIroP/ , ,Irwilirr Ii �. ,c 13. 0 idrailiM„LjIPIIIMINI,...-LA f . ANNIVIWArr 14. M _ W4 • r' . a -/ 16. - 17. _- -.14„„ ' - & I . -J'. .4,4 ' . C "2_4-- 18. q' - ` 6,7/ �'�.����:�-z /o , , 20. 417-Agx.--V-1-4 6 7y- K/ 0,44 „,-- TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on 6he Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so shat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ," 2 //, ADDRESS • ,f irttry 7j'7..c■-fa7'27-C ‘€44, 3• • 4. 5• 6. 7• 3. J• 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so shat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. Sta ADDRESS 1.//7.60;JA 1. 220-41).N.41ij iri) __/;"--, ,e#Y11,--te-tednese61->e) 2. .rii %..ir/✓.! ' +w .roL-- e/ ,- . ,' 4., =/4,-..",./ 3• .t. 0 ,0 c�' 4. Al , g -21. 5. /1. .-v-c-,� ,� .o�,3z) ,.y° , .42.t .e.... 6. y 4.-. 3- ../X.r,�. . a 7. 6 *.4 Z ` . . ) . 4 4. 8. „2 i • -/ /:v 'gx--- .24 3 6'/V-v ct 1 it L - 10. 0' , -. „e..G. :...rte .1.v.-. ).5` 1 � , , l • 11. ., , 12. %t� , - -us'z,.."/ _, L/Aa 2 r7 ' 1 / i j(Ant?! 2244i OL.CZek /1)7 1 13. j114 '1(?et-17Z e • ./;:c1,7e. __„?.,g.v-r. _ 1./Ilet-i-t ce......_. . 4.-4-1 ' -k/ _ x, 5 J I / / ��� I 16. //i ,� ,; , t'..; '-et. , / '""�,, III. r 17• ' .. ! / t ..._ ; �"."'11/14t .,. 18. A : X11 i✓ ► 7 /i I ✓ , ,w ffi /19. ',7 i r -I0 ��i e 7 20. ji .La L f` .� , ..- . TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE M NBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so '.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS 2.G.c1�b..QA 1 . . Q C 1 U.) ` i;t A \,k Rcti.A_Q 3. -` %/ or - ..� / , /! i ..6. 4. Akiir 4111 ,110% dr / / C” 0-7. , -wWD-- , 5• .IL �, .-� " 6. J 7 0 Vg V 7./0/0-14Ai KietAAL-1_,,..A.1 7 .!') ‘/ ( 1 1 1 F 9. ./1 t-4/ . A/. ei, li. - M■V" 10. 0..��i L��, /� / --0.- _ -• <_r_.J _/ ,1�! TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the ueauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. AWIRESS 1. ,, , ,,if ) 2. ( f , ._ ' , , i 2a . 6 , 3. )2/ . a; /3 v 44:1",...(3,k, 4.'.7 ,,, O t l�-� G 5- 21214- 12)1 l' , (-t.' 'LG L -,.., , , P - / -.5W 6- e,."' rfrz e ii,..,i/C7 ,, / -D..-(37e:c7-: .- - -7-1---)' (ii-'?/*- -- �,7 A ` 1 10. 7 11. -- Ji- , . !� / ? „ 13• / i - ,c ' /j 14. �,; L ._ i —2 , .. 15. -G /i- .2..-vti.�..- 16 /Z-5/- _ ,-.4,4-ei--,.---D( 4'-.---- -- 17. 18. 19. 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,,hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. //h1/1) , ADDRESS 1. jr ,,,t, (4 , 7 - ‘:,? 7 '2A,/('' 4- cA.._ 2. ,-- -1' -) ( , Uc-t-- 1: ,>,--C.---7 ) -.6-7.A ?772-•Y (u4,4A '3,4/—eP r , A • / 5e '>•062.-/e4.44) ‘o 6 ;g4)-.,ge.4,04.4"2, /41-6/r.4. w i• ...:44.1 ', Ca 4. "74_,G., 6,- .u,.., 6° 7. II .,A/ Z . ./' 2.)-3o /V-4-41/1-A- '6i-it& 8. 1/L,/,/, C et--0,02.,et2-,' // /, // I 10• •AlleAlW,....:5....i.! ,■....„ 1....,A, A 1 I IL A I I I: ' 11. . _ . VA/04/114 T �iA//, (� 3 ,� -Ti .,, 1-2. r ... i . hi 1 a i� 1 t' i ii.• -,ZAIMIAWMINnifirMilrigralii i 0 ' J Lu di 15. li f- 6 Z/. ' , -c.'-e_tre f-4,--.0 0 -- l- tI 1 qle,/b.A .' -.), 1, 5-0 73,,_.L.p 17. A 't . , .P A-4-414.v' 1 2 e l84:•. di %.-1.51,17 /, 19. Z r : ..2-4-. 4 _ .'' .7,1--t-. 44.:_.Z_-__, ;2. ,- '3 /3 / t/ - 20. - '�1.. r U V v v . Z f _e��+�. ..te e TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS n 1. ::- Iiii . / 7 _ 40644 i p. _a.; / / 2. i ' ... . •.iiiii-iiisa; id ...,...A.........._......./4 1 (42 . °-2- ..-„,.. ,,, AIL I 3. . /.' _ -te..., A 4 - 4 / - or / r.a[ 6. /Liit x ` � J - 9• , 4 - ( 'fp V L • iI. 4 /I/ 4.0A- . , 10. .. k, IMAM I .3 `�2 ll � L1 L .. .{ 11. .4 , r,,0 _ . .644,(„w} . . 12. ) r 13. LA cr . (77-cl- ---- ' - ' i' l4. i _ r- e s-- e f v 15 l /) ? - 16. /Mow `Ali; '- .fib �..,.' I-- Al 'k 17. .. . � c 18.42.-104( -, /92 ----fr i-#7r,(-%•,e--- _,e -if,,,/ 19., ))/s.? f" / �- i '��,t -J 3 / 1/A- / Cec`si 20. V e. . `�� ,.., ` : MIIIMNIMEnnialli ■ ;' OFFICE OF CITY CLERK JOSEPH R. OKONESKI City Clerk BUREAU OF RECORDS HAROLD J. RIORDAN Council Recorder 386 City Hall and Court House St. Paul 2, Minnesota 185110. November 7, 1957 Mr. Marshall F. Hurley Corporation Counsel Building Dear Sir: The City Council requested that you prepare an ordinance providing for the rezoning of Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, located at the northeast corner of Mississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway, to Class "A" Residence District, as petitioned for in the attached file. Very truly yo s, L4r r i 1 City Clerk ' fz. .; . 1' N111/,..11 ra ir '1 �_• _IP:li ,:1711.. 111 h 7 , + R1t11 1.0 1 I J, CITY OF SAINT PAUL - MINNESOTA i:�'r'r:• ::�f:•i: 4'4 Ilk„10.4 > # RD OF ZONING, CITY OF SAINT PAUL •••• `:4?: EtAN.SIR►F'231.232.233 1313 CITY MAIL AND COURT HOUSE SAINT PAUL 2,/AiNNI1OfA November 7, 1957 Mr. Joseph Okoneski City Clerk Building Dear Sir: This is in the matter of the petition of Walter J. Rock to reclassify from Light Industry and "C" Res. to "A" Res. property located adjacent to the northeast corner of Miss. River Blvd. and Highland Pkwy. This property is described as Lots 6,7,8,9 & 10, Block 2 , Edgcliff Add. No. 2. It has a frontage of 240.65 ft. on Miss. River Blvd., 256.7 ft. along Highland Pkwy. in an east-west dimension and has a dimension of 228 ft. along its easterly boundary. The southerly 121.5 ft. of this property is presently occupied by the Church of Christ Scientist. The remaining 107 ft. to the north is vacant and is presently-contemplated for development as a 19 unit apartment site. The zoning history of the property under consideration goes back to 1922 when it was placed in an "A" Res. classification at the time St. Paul adopted its original zoning ordinance. In 1923 the southerly 121.5 ft. of the tract under consideration was zoned Light Ind. as part of the comprehensive rezoning of the Ford Motor Co. district which occured at that time. In 1939 under two separate actions the easterly or rear 100 ft. of the Church of Christ Scientist proper,��,,t�yqq p us the land presently proposed for an apart- ment house site was rezoned from Lighta`�Inc�'., cf "C" Res. The remainder of the church property was retained in a Light Ind. classification and is presently so zoned. This petition presently before the Council would place both tracts in an IIA" Res. zone. The adjacent land uses are as follows: Miss. River Blvd. is to the west, there are single family homes to the north and to the east. There are apartments across Highland Pkwy. to the south adjacent to the southwest and southeast corners of Highland a Ploodlawn. The property adjacent to the southeast corner o: Miss. River Blvd. and Highland Pkwy. is vacant and zoned "C" Res. The Zoning Board, after having the benefit of the testimony of the interested parties involved on both sides of this issue, is unable to find that the present zoning classi- faction of "C" Res. is improper from the standpoint of the most' suitable use of the land and the interest and equities of all parties affected. In this connection is should be noted that Light Ind. is not the best classification for the portion of the church property so zoned, and desirably should be corrected in a separate action. In making this recom- mendation it takes note of the existance of the church immediately to the south with its attendant parking and traffic, and other apartment developments in the immediate vicinity. It is also mindful of the general desirability of making provision for a variety of dwelling unit types to meet the range of requirements for housing which occur in every neighborhood. PUBLISx _ D_ - 7 W. J. Rock Nov. 7, 1957 Page 2 In considering the most appropriate development of the land under its present zoning classification, it should be noted that the Board of Zoning under date of Oct. 4, 1957 has filed a recommendation that the parking lot plan presently on file for the apart- ments under consideration be denied. In spite of this, the Zoning Board does feel that the nature of the property under consideration is such that it lends itself to develop- ment of an apartment site in a manri-r compatible with the interest of adjacent property owners and all applicable city regulations. In consideration of these factors the Zoning Board recommends that this petition to rezone the land under consideration from "C" Res. & Light Ind. to "A" Res. be denied. Sincerely, C. �. Look Planning Directo Executive Secretary Board of Zoning CDL:RJK Enc. CITY OF SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE CONARD C. SEAMER CLIFFORD M. NYSTROM Valuation Engineer MRS. DONALD M. DeCOURCY, Commissioner Chief Cashier ELTOR A. DEHN HARRY A. JOHNSON Asst. Valuation Engineer JOHN W. BASKFIELD, Deputy Commissioner Chief Clerk 113 Court House, Zone 2 CApital 4-4612 October 14, 1957 To the Council City of St. Paul Gentlemen: I have examined the attached petition, filed in the matter of rezoning Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2 (Located at northeast corner of Mississippi River Boulevard and Highland Parkway) from class "C" residence and light industry district to class "A" residence district, and find that said petition is sufficient. Respectfully submitte %& ) Mrs. Donald M. DeCourcy Commissioner of Finance CH:se c.c. Mr. Alfred Schroeder CITY CLERK FILE APPLICANT Z,f N ,f. 7 y: ,,, / FEDERAL 6-4376 FINE & ROBINS (ATTORNEYS AT LAW 609 MINNESOTA FEDERAL BUILDING MINNEAPOLIS 2 WILLIAM I.FIN E MICHAEL L.ROBINS October 15, 1958 City Council Court House St. Paul, Minnesota Attention: City Clerk Re: Re-hearing on zoning petition, Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2 Gentlemen: This office represents A. S. Fine, the owner of Lots 1 through 5, Block 3, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, which tract is located near the subject property, and the owner of many additional tracts in the general vicinity of the subject property. Mr. Fine wishes to place himself on record as being opposed to the contemplated re-zoning from Class C to Class A for the following reasons : 1. This area is desirable for high grade multiple dwelling unit construction. 2. Such structures will properly blend into the surrounding area. 3. To re-zone property without the owner' s consent is inequitable and unjust . 4. To restrict multiple unit construction without adequate cause deprives the city of needed increment to its tax base. 5. To prohibit multiple dwelling unit construction in this area deprives many residents of the city from en- joying the natural geographic beauty of this area City Council - Page 2 - .r. October 15, 1958 Thank you for this opportunity to present these views. Sincerely yours , FIN & ROBINS William. I. Fine WIF:mh • • • ALLEN I. NILVA ATTORNEY AT LAW E227 UNIVERSITY AVENUE SAINT PAUL 14. MINNESOTA MIDWAY 6-7901 October 20, 1958 v . ,11 , Hon . Joseph E . Dillon, Mayor AM °C7-2 7 City of St . Paul {i8,9 Court House St . Paul 1 , Minnesota / 8/17 i12�11g� ' Dear Mayor Dillon : Re : Edgecliffe Investment Company In connection with the re-hearing for the attempted re-zoning of Lots 6 , 7 , 8, 9 and 10 , Block Two , Edgecliffe Addition No . 2 , from Class "C" and light industry to Class "A" , I am enclosing herewith the following items , which I trust you will examine in connection with your consideration of this matter : 1 . Letter from A . S . Fine, owner of the property located at the southeast corner of Mississippi River Boulevard and High- land Parkway, setting forth reasons for objection to the re- zoning. 2 . Copy of affidavit of Jacob Bomberg, whose name was affixed to a petition previously presented to the Council , stat- ing that his signature was affixed without his knowledge, permission or consent, and that it is definitely a fraud upon the Council of the City of St . Paul . 3 . Letter of Herbert J. Garelick withdrawing his name from the letter circulated by the petitioners for re-zoning, a copy of which is attached. I wish to advise further that the owners of this property have revised the plans for the proposed apartment building, reduc- ing the size thereof and reducing the number of apartments from 22 to 15, and in the revised plan there is private means of in- gress and egress without requiring the use of the alley at the rear of the premises in any manner whatsoever . 1 riDEPAL 49-•376 FINE 8r. ROBINS ATTORNEYS AT LAW 609 MINNESOTA FEDERAL BUILDING MINNEAPOLIS 2 WILLIAM I.FIN[ MICHAEL L P O 6 I N 4 , October 15, 1956 City Council Court House St. Foul, Minnesota Attention: City Clerk Re: Re-hearing on zoning petition, Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Gentlemen: This office represents A. S. Fine, the owner of Lots 1 through 5, Block 3, idgecliffe Addition No. 2, which tract is located near the subject property, and the owner of many additional tracts in the general vicinity of the subject property. Mr. Fine wishes to place himself ors record as being opposed to the contemplated-re-zoning from Class C to Class A for the following reasons: 1. This aces is desirable for high grade multiple dwelling unit constr.ction. 2. Such structures will properly blehd into the surrounding area. 3. To re-zone property without the owner's consent is inequitable and unjust. 4. To restrict multiple unit construction without adequate cause deprives the city of needed increment to its tax base. 5. To prohibit 'multiple dwelling unit construction in this area deprives many residents of the city from en- joying the natural geographic beauty of tits .aroa. te, (.4 ct-ti v(z.„ /� 6 1i(�`p-��-e� :t '�e .ti S(r (114-i - 4 _ )14^, tet /-2L,t4 , r y a 1 L Lei a- ,/ • V-0 1-0--c-e-pc,i--t_.4.4 kev-4, 1*(-k. ‘t_ _d t tt,t1.4 t5 rit eci 4-6 ,;*/ 177-*g-6-"/-4-r ().-e A-51-y3-702-eQ c lt-k l 7 oA, _ y-44 Cif 6,�.et-tom.e l r" �-�a iillirsir Mill F I 1 r ell . ! r _... ., . •.--- ,, , 0 ' ,i, ... 1 l IIIP , 1-7-1:: [1 C—1 0 t, r-V . ,.. . ,:''' t > CITIZENS OF HIGHLAND PARK How can we protect our property values? We have pioneered the beautification of our area. We have invested our savings in building beautiful homes in our section, Woodlawn and River Road at Highland Parkway. After we have spent years developing this prop- erty, Herman Paster informed us that he intended to build a large apartment building on the adjacent property. Did he do this before we built our homes? Not He waited until we had improved the area. We have gone to the City Council, and after a fair hearing the Council voted in our favor, 6 - 1, to keep out an apartment building. But did this stop the business interests that own the property? No, again! Through stalls and legal maneuvers which the Ramsey County Court itself termed "premature", they have prevented a final approval of this ordinance for about a year. Now we are told that a "re-hearing" is scheduled for October 22. How long must a group of citizens fight big money to maintain its fundamental constitutional rights granted all of us - to build and own our own home in the surroundings of our own choice? We as small home owners don't have the funds to match those at the command of these other interests. If this is permitted, no citizen in Highland Park can be assured that his home is safe from undesirable encroachment of buildings not in har- mony with the fine neighborhood he and his neighbors have developed. Should the City Council and we citizens be continually harassed with this kind of activity? HIGHLAND PARK HOME-OWNERS '% �Z2,c / Ile / ',...,/,:-.....-1-7,74.4"7 _A ei ,..„ C ✓ lid - ,a c� ill ,ar if irher ,i74,,,,,,,,,x44, . . cm- . ,,, ,,..,..,.....„ 4,,-,:- .i , ( .e.3 1,._-,.......4,i____, AMC illt Oct. 9, 1958 J Hon. Mrs. Donald M. DeCourcy Comar. of Finance Building Dear Madam: The City Council will hold a re-hearing on Oct. 22nd in the matter of a petition to rezone Lots 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, Block 2, Edgecliffe Addition No. 2, from "C" ,, r) Residence and Light Industry to "A" Residence, and requested that,you send notices to affected property owners in the area and also a notice to Allen I. Nilva, Attorney at Law, 2227 University Ave. Very truly yours, City Clerk • MATON, INC. Painting - Decorating 305 Selby Avenue St. Paul 2, Minnesota Phone—CApital 6-0335 Cct. 20, 1958 Honorable Mayor and City Council of St. Paul, Court House, St. Paul 2, Minn. Gentlemen: RE: Edgecliff Investment Property We are familiar with the property owned by the Edgecliff Investment Company on Mississippi River Blvd. near Highland Parkway in the 0ity of St. Paul. We have examined the plans ='or the proposed apartment building intended to be constructed on this property. We believe that the proposed apartment building will be of. the finest type and that the proposed beautiful building with the proposed landscaping, trees and shrubbery will blend in with the general area and be of a credit to the community. The City of St. Paul is in definite need of housing facilities that will be , provided by this fine apartment building. It will releave the present unsightly condition of the area, with a modern beautiful building that will enhance all the property in this area. This proposed building provides for the expenditure of several hundreds of thousand dollars in construction work, materials, and labor that will benefit the business men, skilled workers, and laborersil the city. We employ seventy skilled workers in our company and urge the continuation of worth while and beneficial projects, that will provide steady employment in our city. In view of all the benefits to be gained, we strongly urge the Council to deny the petition to re-zone the Edgecliff Investment Property from Class C to Class A and allow the Edgecliff Investment Company to proceed with the construction of this fine apartment building. Respectiveurs, r Elton Patchell President EJP:ph Masonry For Permanent Beauty ROGER SORENSEN CONST. Co. , //yy �+ TELEPHONE: LICENSED AND BONDED 152 1GLI'geYJ., $5 X$ WARWrCK< MIDWAY 8-7809 BRICK WORK GLASS BLOCK ST. PAUL 5, MINN. SPLIT-ROCK �`• ==J CEMENT BLOCK r �� s r' STONE _ ,z_f` -_` CEMENT WORK October 20, 1958 Honorable H a yor City Council of City of St. Paul Court House St . Paul, Minnesota Gentlemen: I have lived in the Highland Park area for many years, and I am thor- oughly familiar with the Edgecliffe Investment 0o . property on Missi- ssippi River Blvd. and Highland Pkwy. , that has sought to be rezoned from Class C to Class A. I have seen the plans of the Edgecliff Investment Co. for the proposed apartment building to be constructed on this site. � I sincerely believe that the luxury type apartment intended to be built on this property would be a proper buffer between the church property and the residential property, and that the beautiful apartment together with the proposed trees, shrubbery and landscaping would blend in and harmonize with the general area and indeed be a credit to it. The construction of this apartment would also provide housing facilities that is greatly needed in this area and would provide considerable erri- ployment for a large number of men. In view of these factors, I sincerely urge the City Council to deny the petition for rezoning, because to permit the Edgecliffe Investment Co. to ccr..struct this proposed luxury apartment,will mean progress in our community and will stand a definate+ credit to the City of St. Paul . Respectfully su' itt ed, R.qe . Sorensen KATZ Plumbing and Heating Co., Ine. 778 GRAND AVENUE — ST. PAUL 5, MINNESOTA CAPITAL 5-7831 Oct. 20, 1958 Honorable Mayor and City Council of St. Paul, Court House, St. Paul 2, Minn. Gentlemen: Re: Edgecliff Investment Re—zoning Matter We understand that a rehearing is scheduled for the proposed re—zoning of the Edgecliff Investment Property on Mississippi River Blvd. near Highland Parkway. We are thoroughly familiar with this property and know that it has been Class C and Light Industry zoned for many years and was purchased by the present owners in reliance of the zoning classification in good faith. The present owners desire to construct a beautiful luxury appartment building which we are definitely lacking in this city. The plans also provide for t beautifying the grounds in harmony with the general area. This proposed V` project will be a credit to the City of St. Paul. It will provide definitely needed housing facilities of the finest type. It will actually beautify the area and create a natural buffer between the Church and the residential property. It will place more property on the tax roles of the city and it will provide work for contractors, skilled workers and laborers that is urgently needed at this time. We therefore sincerely urge the Council to deny the request to re—zone this property and to allow the Edgecliff Investment Company to construct the proposed apartment building in the interest of progress and for the best interest of the City of St. Paul. Respectively yours, KATZ PLUMBING & HEATING COMPANY, INC. D44-�a i% rg V Pre' . •w o SELL r�r INSTALL • A SERVICE • GUARANTE MEM 6ER If l. ALL io BUILD 111411111k4117 _ `' °� SNELLING LUMBER COMPANY 2389 W. SEVENTH ST. ST. PAUL 16, MINN. ••••••■••••••10 ,,,„ , 7.:. A0 Aig41.1,1,.. �R R October 20, 1953 A sL pion. Mayor and City Council City of St . Paul Court House St . Paul, Minnesota Honorable Gentlemen : He : Edgecliffe Investment Company We are in the general lumber business and serve a great part of the Highland Park area, and are well acquainted with the property owned by the Edgecliffe Investment Company on Mississippi River Boulevard near Highland Parkway , which property is now being considered for re-zoning from Class Q1C" to Class 'A" . The Edgecliffe property has been Class ''C" and light industry for many years and is in the general area of many apartment buildings and commercial development . We have seen the revised plans for the proposed construction of an apart- ment building by the Edgecliffe Investment Company and we believe that this plan would provide an exceptionally beauti- ful apartment building and would provide urgently needed luxury apartments in this area. To re-zone the subject property and deny the owners the right to build an outstand- ✓' ing apartment on this site would result in an unwarranted financial loss and great detriment to the owners . We are interested in providing good housing and in promoting and developing our city, and in providing continuous employment for the skilled workers and labor in our community . We there- fore request that your honorable body will deny the petition for re-zoning the Edgecliffe property and that you will permit the owners to construct the beautiful building proposed that will prove to be an asset to the community and a credit to the City of St . Paul . . Respectfully yours, SNELLING p LUMB R COMPANY r4i,; .Theodo e :"Johnson, President gx MIDWAY 5-4601 T. PAUL LINOLEUM & CARPET CO. INCORPORATED Acoustical "Can4acto44 and $ 4 e ne4s aj Redi1iesd 4laozs" Tile 1505 UNIVERSITY AVENUE ST. PAUL 4,MINNESOTA October 21, 195$ Formica Tops Honorable Mayor and City Council of St. Paul, Plastic Court House, Wall Tile St. Paul 2, Minnesota RE: Edgecliff Investment Property Linoleum Gentlemen: We understand that a rehearing for the rezoning of the Carpets Edgecliff Investment property located on Mississippi River Blvd. near Highland Parkway is scheduled for October 22, 1958. Asphalt Tile We are familiar with this property and are familiar with the plans for the proposed Luxury Apartment building sought to be constructed on this property. Rubber Tile We are interested in providing good housing facilities, in the promotion and development in this city, and providing work and employment, for labor and skilled workers. Kencork Tile Since this property has been properly zoned for apartment building construction for many years and the proposed apartment building Lino-Wall will be of a type that will actually be a credit to the community) we as employers of more than 100 skilled workers in the city of St. Paul sincerely urge that the petition for rezoning of the Edgecliff property from Class C to Class A be denied and that Rugs the owners of this property be allowed to proceed with the construction of the proposed apartment building. Respectfully yours, ST. PAUL LINOLEUM & CARPET CO. by: W. C. Groth Vice President WCG:l j 4 CEMSTONE PRODUCTS CO. 1520 EAST M I N N E H A H A AVENUE SAINT PAUL 6, MINNESOTA d „>61/J74/ October 21, 1955 Honorable Mayor and City Council of Saint Paul Court House Saint Paul 2, Minnesota RE: Edgecliff Investment Property Gentlemen: Vie have been in business in the city of St. Paul continuously for over forty- five years, and we are interested in all projects that will promote and develop our city, that will provide fine housing facilities, and that will provide employment for our citizens. Vie employ over fifty people in our business and are sincerely interested in all projects that will provide continous employment which is the basic factor in any progressive community. Vie are advised that you are considering the petition to prevent the construc- tion of a fine modern luxury apartment building on Mississippi River Blvd. near Highland Parkway. We are familiar with this property and with the proposed plans for the apartment building. Since the property is now properly zoned for an apart- ment building and the building intended to be built on this site will be of the very finest type and will be an asset to the community and a credit to our city, as well as provide the expenditure of large sums of money for materials and supplies and will also provide work for many people, we respectfully recommend to the City Council of St. Paul that the action to rezone this property be denied and that the owners be allowed to proceed with the construction of the building. Your favorable consideration in this matter will be sincerely appreciated. Respectfully yours, CISiSTOUE PRODUCTS CO tPAllY Manufacturers of T. A. Becken, President 471 G**VU MIX • PITTSBUKGH PLATE GLASS COMPANY 459 JACKSON STREET, ST. PAUL 1, MINN. October 21, 1958 Honorable Mayor and City Council of Saint Paul Court House Saint Paul 2, Minnesota RE: Edgecliff Investment Property Gentlemen: It is our understanding that a re-hearing for the re-zoning of the Edgecliff Investment Property, which is located on Highland Parkway and Mississippi River Boulevard, is scheduled for October 22. We have seen the plans for this apartment building, and it is our feeling that this project would add greatly to the neighborhood and be a credit to the community. We have been in business in St. Paul for over sixty years, and we employ a great number of people in the city. We are naturally interested ,° in progress providing good housing facilities, and in the promotion and development of all worthy projects which will provide employment for our skilled workers, and which will be a credit to the city of St. Paul. We sincerely urge that the petition for re-zoning of the Edgecliff property from Class C to Class A be denied, and that the owners be allowed to proceed with the construction of the proposed apartment building. Any favorable consideration you may give this request will be appreciated. Respectfully yours, /PITTSBURGH PLATE GLASS CO. A. M. Maxson Manager AMM/baa NCI-10R BLOCK COMPANY 565 ALDINE STREET • ST PAUL 4, MINNESOTA • Phone MI 6-6507 t CONCRETE MASONRY t SHADOWAL t HAYDITE t LINTELS f CHIMNEYS t PATIO f PRECAST PRODUCTS October 21, 1958 Honorable Mayor and City Council of Saint Paul Court House Saint Paul 2, Minnesota RE: Edgecliff Investment Property Gentlemen: We have been in business in the city of Saint Paul for over thirty years and we employ a great number of people in the city. We are interested in progress and in the promotion and development of all worthy projects that will be a credit to the city of Saint Paul . We understand that an attempt is being made to prevent the Edgecliff Investment Company from constructing a beautiful luxurious apartment building on Mississippi River Boulevard near Highland Parkway. We have seen the plans for this building and are familiar with the property on which it is located. Since this property is presently zoned to allow the construction of an apartment building, and the building intended to be constructed on this property will be of the very finest U'. type, we sincerely believe that it will be to the best interest of the community that the petition to rezone this property from Class C to Class A be denied and that the owners be allowed to proceed with their project . Your favorable consideration of this request will be greatly appreciated. Respectfully yours AN OR BLOCK C 0 .PANY ' -‘g ) i. i . Nerhaugen, JHN:lw President ALLEN I. NILVA ATTORNEY AT LAW 2227 UNIVERSITY AVENUE SAINT PAUL 14. MINNESOTA MIDWAY 6-7901 October 3, 1958 Mr. Bernard T. Holland Commissioner of Playgrounds & Public Buildings Court House St . Paul , Minnesota Dear g,„.„, In accordance with our telephone conversation I am enclosing herewith a copy of the order signed by Judge Stewart regarding the rezoning of the property on Mississippi River Boulevard. I ask you to particularly observe the memorandum the Judge has written in connection with this matter . I would greatly appreciate it if before the last hearing a motion could be made to set this matter over to a definite date in the future and to notify all parties concerned for an opportunity to be heard before final action is taken in the passage of this matter . This would give us an opportunity to present our revised plans for the proposed apartment building, which would reduce the number of apartments from twenty-two to fifteen and eliminate the use of the alley entirely. In addition, there would be no con- gestion as far as parking, and I believe all the other objections that were previously raised could be overcome. I am also in a position to show to the council that many of the objectors who signed the petition that was circulated live in Minneapolis , Roseville, West St . Paul and South St . Paul , and were not even residents of the City of St . Paul , and in one particular case two people whose names appear have signed affidavits that it is not their signatures on the petition and that they were placed thereon without their authority, permission or consent . I am writing this letter to you setting forth the above facts in order that you may have all the information before you if this matter should come up for final reading, and I will appreciate your efforts in having the matter passed for a sufficient length ,'of time to afford us another hearing before the council . Thank you for all of your courtesies and consideration. . 400) , Yours very truly, 11en/ I. Nilva A I N :kw ,41415):),,?...r y Enclosure : Copy of Order Oct 4u, tei - iq ,ce. WO 2 C71L0L,f64 Cktt Cetl-U s Cam. ee47 6 Soi allf-t-:/04 , )4 V4,4* .it-3*c. • OLA- ,eakt �Q k .-e Ld 4!„,,ep cL5 2A.-c-ez-it_t. oh-A4 11--O 7Z-4, C,24 �..- . rA-4 — )L) W-tc-<2 e0-A-cf/ C - a Iii- ctf-P-(A,L-0-eQr tr-2AA-L et- eP l4:6LauL4,-t_ , • , 1,__1,{ u Gee a cteu,-- ' /' ;‘,/ 4aLbeete / /441AVaileg al Ills. .� 1I�.ti11k3I �►�'lam ■ MO Itt 111 yt I -[G .�� ;`� — E ' f. J�',o JFr 1 /J F '.." - ; F�' �j, ,�, . ., F 4� ..., .--_ �f� +`��1„1 = 1 �'rt F-?,Y 1 flit f,�.n ' 1 1 1 �— 1 ' ' I. • t .,_+.iv / CITIZENS OF HIGHLAND PARK How can we protect our property values? We have pioneered the beautification of our area. We have invested our savings in building beautiful homes in our section, Woodlawn and River Road at Highland Parkway. After we have spent years developing this prop- erty, Herman Paster informed us that he intended to build a large apartment building on the adjacent property. Did he do this before we built our homes? No! He waited until we had improved the area. We have gone to the City Council, and after a fair hearing the Council voted in our favor, 6 - 1, to keep out an apartment building. But did this stop the business interests that own the property? No, again! Through stalls and legal maneuvers which the Ramsey County Court itself termed "premature", they have prevented a final approval of this ordinance for about a year. Now we are told that a "re-hearing" is scheduled for October 22. How long must a group of citizens fight big money to maintain its fundamental constitutional rights granted all of us - to build and own our own home in the surroundings of our own choice? Ale as small home owners don't have the funds to match those at the command of these other interests. If this is permitted, no citizen in Highland Park can be assured that his home is safe from undesirable encroachment of buildings not in har- mony with the fine neighborhood he and his neighbors have developed. Should the City Council and we citizens be continually harassed with this kind of activity? HIGHLAND PARK HOME-OWNERS --/' 7'? -i'ole---e / 0 ,,,:,,,:....--- ---;.;41.1 i� / wimp./44---V-C-77 r#40 ,_ _3 „. ., , ;/ 7. e...) ,,,, 1:0---- ,1 , , ,_ 4 „,..e..„., (...e...) ( < ff./ , 7 , , , 4,,,„_ - .0,4a7 /__7(',),A4,____/..„ ,/,„1/414,,, ...,,.,,,, , .____i____ oriv 4..........a.A___. ate► mom. A - /4 _ .. . 1 •• ` e �' _ c. MI 0 EL-i-er ,... ' t), ,..-71.1-1,i, .ITT' 'ST1‘-' Nth ''' ‘.... �yj r, I / CITIZENS OF HIGHLAND PARK How can we protect our property values? We have pioneered the beautification of our area. We have invested our savings in building beautiful homes in our section, Woodlawn and River Road at Highland Parkway. After we have spent years developing this prop- erty, Herman Paster informed us that he intended to build a large apartment building on the adjacent property. Did he do this before we built our homes? No! He waited until we had improved the area. We have gone to the City Council, and after a fair hearing the Council voted in our favor, 6 - 1, to keep out an apartment building. But did this stop the business interests that own the property? No, again! Through stalls and legal maneuvers which the Ramsey County Court itself termed "premature", they have prevented a final approval of this ordinance for about a year. Now we are told that a "re-hearing" is scheduled for October 22. How long must a group of citizens fight big money to maintain its fundamental constitutional rights granted all of us - to build and own our own home in the surroundings of our own choice? We as small home owners don't have the funds to match those at the command of these other interests. If this is permitted, no citizen in Highland Park can be assured that his home is safe from undesirable encroachment of buildings not in har- mony with the fine neighborhood he and his neighbors have developed. Should the City Council and we citizens be continually harassed with this kind of activity? HIGHLAND PARK HOME-OWNERS 4 i,";/.......-'1.----..2,0-1--4" � / .Z4. o ....v. eat ,i %y 11 / ( 1)/__, S4427 7 /4-4<`)'/(0-2---- ,/titol_ji44.4401 / _____,„—. WAVAIIIP TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. t' ADDRESS f 1. CGS ""L. /e4 ci 9/ 2. / //, ��► / 1 -r 3 #11 PA; 20 (0 IMMIL., 4. j,2 s /Zel 6:-24.4-1Z,€/"- �s 3?3 r).., 0 „ . / 6 7 /41411,7 .• 6. r, tw ' ' , _ I, q 7. 13. _ N. Q ,/),:, eeeez...0.7.--,---,--- Ce...... 8. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14+. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. We the undersigned, residents of the Highland Park area hereby petition the City Council to act favorably upon petition to rezone area located at North- east corner of Highland Parkway and Mississippi River Blvd• so that the beauty of our area will not be destroyed by the building of proposed apartment on this site. et...4 g • i . . k.)- • i i--/-• i : c ) 71 fr t 7- —7b -It ,. . . . _. ._._ ,,, - ..,.....-- . ! . ) i / , L., „_‘,:L's v i/1 L.'t-A) - '1--t-i ' • - J le g • )1C-c-,j,d -, _ f - ••,, - , \ \) , - '.) 1 ' --. Cs) ..- ' ibIliA* . _,„.. 1..9 _.) ---2 -) s -.., , /)1.--s;1-1, . 1,----......., .../1)1•14, , c.)t-1.•1.k...----.. k....„ ..----e---1..• 1--- • TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: : We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on she Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. 1 DRESS 1. G(` t'/ %. _ ' 2 • ' . / cam`/ /' 2• "$.+l ,r 3, ..z.f c... ',T . CLI.,e-/.. / ,--' 41S-Z., ,241e/ 4/-- /'i r "7 , Rl2i 4. .(I." k /-) , ''l ' ) . (") /57 if -- , . .1.---/..-r/' , ./ '..t..-e -/ , 7 6 -. , ,/ _- , -v.v..- t.,?' 4,44-4,1...,,,e., t./ a , 7. li RL� ,,vrvuc; U1 tiI 1i/14.4,,La 8. ) ( ( . 3/ \-A -L - -- . 'ae, ri . ( , A ‘. 4" .- ... ‘ ? ..- 10. . ( 1 )*, '" ■ 2 2 . 6,2 e 11. t 1` , _ -c. 4 � G` . r o& /f'/ ti i C-C.--t. 12. d . 1b � ) 0,0J j 13. —S 1 \ (01-0fr-eA ‘ 17 i ././< /z/trerei 14. I- . ' i , .-..- " 15. / / kt ., .1 �,L 17. f/ 7 „ 6 `7, ' 18. --`7 / Co © 7 vie 19. 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS 1. i .� f-'.7%?/.v./69,? //> 2. 1 ' /L.. AgM ilgrA4114. 3' 4. � cf) ..r? 'fir 6 4 1 c g67 7.. _ .:�.� -- r? 8. m .. �, ...:� L 4n , � �%��,d 9 . 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on 6he Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS 1. )'vt. -, , �L�. �.� '.�-o--^- is i- I w- ; 2. Z /. e� • . �. . ,. ././- / 3./9144, 1/ ,� / /e) G / / 4f s 7. E 1' J 1 8. .I. i ��'- c/D / r y. , / 1• R s , `� 11. 12. • 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMB S: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so .hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDS ,�/'7 �/ ., 2. --� --Q - �'O l.u/- - 3. / . 1 4. me..,_ .". ,____,./..e. l.t._,„,„) c_,.-9/ 3 / .,. , 5.,2220 t a - 7C,5� 11 �� a�. _ . 6, )X-744,9, , 2-7(4_,,,z- C,Liv_.,— d l/�•-C.,c6�✓ G' GrG Ati 6/Zt/ZL,_C! k:-.4.,,,,64 . 6. ' - I,0A457-1.7 _ ..„,....,-.. 0(7.: 9 G ,:,,, --/- (...- ,-,---i.--- -:- /, ,/, . .., < 2 /14-1 i'-z-L1-, .--,,t / %,.(_Li„, LJ / _ I t , 10. i 4, , ekz,t, )4 ,/,—,,,v,k,s, ...2_, ,,, .,./ . , , ri- 111 11. / 1ti .'1L'../w i ' 1- � 1 r = -X!.. - Sri .. 12. r e, 4 , al ', 13. , 1 . .A ✓ 1 J 4^✓A.4.7 AM I 14. �411M1111lMMPBPIZPPA4 /V V P ,� �- N 15• 44- Al• A .'... l i t /G..g.., 16. 9‘ -3a 1'2--i , h . . 18. 19. 20. E TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME ADDRESS 1. 2. ,....4 _, I ,/ !:- An _. GtaotX ; ..L- _ 1 . / y.*" �i '. &_,- • I '14(�..-.�. _, / / 5. Yin • 1 f. 510 Q 6. /77,fr,Acii-el„ ail..j 7• I I_ A.,.f44._... . . ; / l . ". lo. __ .; it, t / 12.14f-e.4.— �tE_ 11. , .i_b - /6 go k1a .e-yt,. 12. .� b I`' 1 .Ux, 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,.hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME � 4 :' ESS /i / • ,? 3. ` ` O t r llii , 6 _ l 4. e%('C-cam ealiffinfillir - - r 1?e 6. + /Ud a," 1 ,- 3 7,--)--c_e-Lii; : f.- -- : a, A sr 44/Aims.■ ''' •( S: , '' '' ?, 9. / it -/ 2/ l ' / G fir . ' QQ 1 0 10. / 407 11. ifr 1- c: ";,.--cj',--,--- /167.,„d 7‘5"."' 6(/;ei/17:,/-2."6" -/e/ ...2.--..r."--(3. 3. •? / / Z � � 15. -I 1 /73..2-• -1 /-14 ,"L-L.,,c_il 16. ' 2 . C' 727. i2l�,,c1%-6 I 2 ' / 17. ter. • /, 44 ,4,% c i ,_, 18. ;) - , , Ar, - 12:70--/-4,,,,YZi. d" 1117—, , /a/ rtb..,,,,,,/4--,„ ce..„-c A . , , / . , i , , -..., ,...„, , ,.....," , , „ r . L TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on Lhe Mississippi River Drive fro0 "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so shat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NA ADDRESS ' , ` L iy , t 2. C .. G4, - C . ,�` v,., Z / 9 r ..�.,,.....� . 3• //G'� ' 4. /1i- A . ,,, -. , , "M4111..0.061.-----N_ r ' e ( 1/. / 6. qr -, A 14i-0 ,'- 20 0 - !, / , /, c ' 8• h -- -- U1. M Vii`"' 1-2---)--3 - .Q- yk.tr--j■--' (k a-L. 0 0 c._? f taao.e. (---- 4, 10.; Afi. 111/1 e_ ` /, 11 Wt,, v (,z-±, ; f-- •,,;., 1 / I-S 11(, /�✓v`c/ ✓t- •J _ 12. `-y;' « ,,. .bk_ ...-Z ?z 3 f{'•rte�,--e- g _ 13. / 4, 1.0.,, •1 et "31-- ' • i 15. -,- i., 4C`, ' 4:-.474 73 � �, (_s 17. if • if ' ,.„, . Ny 2,11,-- c=..-r., .--e, , _, ,, p-... . 18)14n ,i A I • 7 ) J. �d( TO: CITY COUNCIL OF SAINT PAUL HONORABLE MEMBERS: We, the undersigned citizens of Saint Paul, hereby request the City Council to act favorably on the petition to rezone the area north of Highland Parkway on the Mississippi River Drive from "C" residence and light industry to "A" residence so ,hat the beauty of our River Drive and the neighborhood will be maintained and not destroyed by the building of a proposed apartment. NAME /7)RESS 1. 2241 ( , ‘, 4 ,'_ ie., ` - 2. _a . �_ (2 . v� 6 A '7 i _,I-� 3. - da4...e. /t' .473/ h &L , 4. C:Ie-E,-.sLA,__E_ 0 cP_, i 3 6 *2- \-i,t) t‘41t1_0 t,-. L. 5.k.2 ,(� ,e ti 7_ - 2d--/ ,/ -_,- _ ,', 6- -, !/1.G' WtA, / /e d 7• i" �-- 49 - ,-I �,� c,�-�,,,,2. G -e_�• 8. !2 /� �--eL /ji/ ill -� � 9• Olto �i 4.0 �t (-,2 `.L` /( S •-i t. 0( ht.:\_ , 1111 • �,,,, 11. /lj)✓>.=� Allpir �.Y. .,.' _,.� MMIlr,,40111111WL i ` -4j 14. ./.i. 4 .� . Or ,/_ 15• l. i . .0<< • `'4 i / '7 /1 9' X• 7-• 16. /i«. 7K: S. /1/e._ 44—.,-._.,. _ -7 6 /,...._c.6.___ /L ,� .,/[ �7• "7 v . ( `? f i -1-&-16-,,-.---C--1,.- 6 . 18. 4.e.,471 ,/,' , �h /7/La 19. 114 1 (11 Qf., ',,... ...._ _.. , ,, ,,,a.„.4g.,___ „.,, , 20. '.