Loading...
263361 WHITE — CITY CLERK , �� PINK -✓FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAITL Council � t)t..�-�� CANARY — DE ARTMENT BL�IE — MA�OR File NO. c f � G/ Ordin�nce Ordinance N0. � 7 10�� Pre�ented By Referred To � �"�'�`� Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending Ordinance No. 3250, entitled: "An administrative ordinance relati.ng to the Civil Service Commission and the Civil Service Office of the City of Saint Paul approving and adopting rules and regulations necessary to the administration of the City personnel system on a merit basis, " approved August 20, 1914, as amended. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That Ordinance No. 3250, approved August 20, 1914, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended by inserting in Section 6, under the heading "Professional" Group, the following titles in the grade s indicated: City Planning Research Analyst I Grade 34 City Planning Re search Analyst II Grade 38 City Planning Research Analyst III I Grade 41 Community Facilities Planner LII " Economic Planner III '' Environmental Planner III " Housing Planner III " Land U s e P lanne r III " Public Systems Planner III " _ 1 _ COUIVCILMEN Yeas Nays �u�sted by Department of: Hunt Konopatzki '• ` . ``. I� �•aV�r R � Levine ° ` Meredith Against � Sprafka Tedesco Mme.President Butler Adopted by Council: Date Form A prov d by City ttorney Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY ` Bv � Approved by Mayor: Date Approved May bm' ' n t cil By BY WH17E - CITY CLERK l PINK -�FINANCE CO1111C11 ��`3��� BL48ERy- MAYORTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL U , File N�. r � _ Ordin�nce Ordinance N�. ���� _ Pres�nted By � _ Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date City Planning Research Analyst IV Grade 47 Coxnmunity Facilities Planner IV " Economic Planner IV " Environmental Planner IV " Housing Planner IV " Land Use Planner IV " Public Systems Planner IV " Deputy Coordinator for Comprehensive Policy Planning Grade 53 Chief of Public Systems Planning and Development Grade 59 Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty days after its passage, approva.l, and publication. �,._� Appr ove d: • � .,� Chairman Civil Service Commission COUNCILMEIV Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays �� .�_ In Favor � Levine Meredith � Against BY �ax�icac Roedler '�eo Mme.President ��'� Adopted by Council: Date M AY 1 �974 Form Ap o d by C' Attorney Certified P.a�e y Co cil Secre�ary BY <--:.�- - � / � By', Appro by May : Date Approved Mayor b ' to o cil By By PususH� MAY 4 1974_ 1 �`}�'.��..�4�1�_0�-q 1 CITY OF SAINT PAUL OFFICE OF THE CITY ADMINISTRATOR FRANK D. MARZITELLI April 9, 1974 To: Hon. Lawrence D, Cohen, Mayor 347 City Hall � From: Frank D. Marzitelli City Administrator ` �. 365 City Hall Subject: Ordinance establishing various new City Planning titles to meet staffing needs within their new organizational structure We respectfully request that the attached ordinance be submitted to the City Council. � � , �� ir � � .� ' ����. .�`` �- �: � r t' � City Hall, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55�02 O . . . . � ����� ■. . The attached ordiaance establishes varic�us nee�►► City Planning titles in the grades indieated belaw. �he�e titles will be nsed by City Plamai.ag is meeti�g their staffing needs within their n�r orgariizatioria]. strnctnre. Grade 3� R C3ty Pl.anr�in� Research Aaal3rst I A B C D E F 10-yr. 15-yr. 389.50 �t�8.00 427.50 �8.� �69.c�o 49i.00 5c�4.�o 518.50 . Grade 38 . R City Pl.�,ning Research �al.yst II A B C D E F 14-yr. 15-yr. 436.50 �+56.00 �+78.c�o 500.00 52�+.50 5�9.00 565.c�o 581.00 Grade �l 8 City Planning Reses�rch Analyst III C�nity Facilities Pl.anner III Tc�nvmic P].anaer III F.n�iros�er�tal Plaaner III Hov.sing Planaer III La�ad Use Planaer III Public Systems Planner III A B C D E F 14-yr. 15-yr. �+7�+.00 �+96.50 52o.5c� 5�+5.00 571.a� 598.00 616.00 634.00 Grade �7 R City Plas�nin.g Researeh Analyst N Co�ait� Faeilities Pl.�nner IY Econc�mic Planner IV �v3.roamental Plan�er IY Housing P].a�er IY I,arid Use P].an�er IV Pablic Syste�es Planaer I9 A B C D S F 10-yr. 15-yr. 562.00 588.oc� 616.50 6�6.50 676.50 709.50 73o.t�o 751.00 Grade 53 R Deputy Coordinator for ComprehensiYe Peliey Plarising A B C D E F 10-yr. 15-yr. 665.00 697.00 731.00 766.50 803.50 8�+2.00 867.00 892.a� Grade 59 R Ch3ef of Rtblic Systexas P7.a,nnisg aad Develop�eat A B G D E F 10-gr. 15-yr. 789.50 828.00 868.50 910.50 95�.50 1t�40.50 1029.5t� 1c�6c�.00 Do not detach thfs memorandum from the ordinance so that this information will be av�llable to the City Council. .. . .. . � . . . 1 � � ./.. . `� .. V,` � - . •.. ' .. . !. � � . .I- � .. .'I . . . . � �i n. , � . .' . . t �. .. . . \ ; . .. - � � � . ,� � • � , ,�� . . .. _ x ,. � . �� . . . � .. . , . � � . . . . , . . _ '� . . . � � �� . � � . . � � � �, . • �i • , , .. . . . . . � , . . . � . . , . .. ' � ..c ` � I ' I f ; 1 � i . , � � 1 � , _ ? ' . i. , � . � � . . . � � . .. v . . .. . .. .} . . , ., ; � � `�t . . . ' . . , . i� �, i . . . . . . � �� � ��i � �~ A. � � ' � 1. � � ' � ��� - ' t " ' i I i • . . . . . � � , �� i... , .' 4 � o . . h I�' � ..,'� � j . � . ' . ,f: ,, .,i f£+ ; I � �' , " Y , ' j S da, , �: ��• i.! . , ,� ; � .�� ;i ` � i' 7 r� 1 Y` � ti " s � { � i ' . 7 � ' + ` , �I , !. f �, , �' � � ' �� � � i _ ' . ��; . . � Y- ° K ��`���f ��'� � 1 1 � , . , � � • !� � � ' , �' �. . � r ' . . . � - . . .-:+• . .° �: �.ti .. � `�� � '� �. �� . . . �, . ... ;. „ � . .. . . ' .`;, , .' ' . . , , . . . . i�. . , . � . r � • ,�. / . , . . _. . . . . � �.� , � ( . , ` ..�' ���� , � "; I. : , ' . �Z�.`���C �� $1i���r 1 ' � � ' , �, � �:���' i t ; `,j + F + . . �.ag�.sl�t Lan (�ittMe � ' ' ' � � ' ' Rflom �`x9; Cit�y l�al'� � ' St, �'aa Mi , . , t , . �;��i t��st��a �r , � � � � . + � • � � �� , � �• .; , , .�ts:' Co��;��F�le. �ti. �b�I ' . '`' Cc►+�al.� lk"3:�.t ��. �$63�6�t{. ' ' . , ,� ; � ' De�tr M��m:, ' ` - , . �. ,`. , . ,, .>. , , . I � `� � . �rn.'�'�c�,cw,a c�i�d3�sao.s rres�e� ics#".a���d ta► ���s..�(t�€�i� r+oma�.cr�s , ,\f } �;' ( `"�' . , .�g tha �t� '��i.1 �et �ts ,�1pzi,� 3.�;', �4�14::1���: ' � ", `� , � . ✓� � .Taf��ma���',R��T. �; �`; . .. , ; ` �# ' ' ' , , • ,, . �r��� . , . ,, / , ��''� , � : ,�, t��� ;Clet� � � ,.t , , �, , . , F�i , �, . I�C5:�j f I , � � 1'� 1 . . . � � ., . . ., Y: . 73 . . .. . �♦ � .� . i , . . . . . , ' , �: :, l9r�sk D.' Mars�t�13,1 ` � ^ ' f y�,, � �; , � . , � � i i , ' ' _�_ b 7p�; , ` -1� � �. � . �' � `��"a � � 9�: � ` � � . ,� � Lt �+� , F,+ ��� �r . ; � I , ; ' ,, �' ��y . , � . ; . , , � ,. ;, . . , .:: � �� � , , ,, � � � � � � � � � � " � ' � � � ' �� � �``� "�� . � • , , , . � , �• � � �. ���. , ' ' �'``�, .. , � 1 , ; � `f x �� �� YX / i .. . . '. I . .. . . ♦ ,.l . I . , , r � 1�'�-1 . . .. .. . \ . . . � . . ' � � v . � . jy,,.�"^���I� � ' . . . . , . 1 � � ` � . , �. ,. . . � ' - � � 7 . . . . � . . t � " r � . k � P �.� . ':.�� I . . . . � . . , .. . " . ' ��. . - �I��' . � � _ ' i 1 � i. . � . 1 � t 4 " � � ^ , . . . + . 1 � . � 1 � `t1 i 7�q�� y; � . f ... � � ' �;�y�1'::2k��k �'.. � . � . . . ' ! . .. . . . . . _ . i . �� � .. � 'I _ . .r.... .... . . .. . , ... . a. � yl�33 b 1 g\TY qF ��� _ .�� ?.b336� w, = aT � n 8 � MRS. RUBY HUNT CITY OF SAIiVT PAUL MRS. FRANCIS BOYDEN Counei Iman OFFICE OF THE COUNCIL Legislative Aide CITY HALL AND COURT HOUSE SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102 April 19, 1974 MEMO T0: City Council ,Members City Clerk�/ FROM: Ruby Hunt, Chairman �� Council Legislation Commlttee The attached ordinances, amending Ordinances 3250 and 7607, in regard to City Planning titles, were reviewed by the above committee on April 18, 1974. The committee adopted a motion to recommend these ordinances for Council approval . att. rs .. 55 WH17E - CITY'CLERK ���.Y�� � PIN����""'.+/FINANCE � COl1llC11 �.� BLj�(LR� -MAYpRTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAZTL File NO. � �1 Ordin�znce Ordinance N0. , X/ J iI /Y�� Presented By r��- � L Referred To lj1-�A���`t- � "�' �`� Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending Ordinance No. 325t�, entitled: "An administrative ordinance relating to the Civil Service Commission and the Civil Service Office of the City of Saint Paul approving and ad.opting rules and regulations necessary to the administration of the City personnel system on a merit basis, " approved August 20, 1914, as amended. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section l. That Ordinance No. 3250, approved August 20, 1914, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended by inserting in Section 6, under the heading "Professional" Group, the following titles � in the grades indicated: City Planning Research Analyst I Grade 34 ' City Planning Research Analyst II Carade 38 City Planning Research Analyst III Grad.e 41 Community Facilities Planner III " Economic Planner III " Environmental Planner III " Housin� Planner III " Land U s e P lanne r III " Public Systems Planner III " - 1 - COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of; liunt K�n�Patzki In Favor Le�•ine ` 1leredith Against BY Sprafka Tedesco Mme.President Butler Adopted by Council: Date Form A prov d by City ttorney , Certified Passed by Council Secretary By Bv Approved by hlayor: Date Approved May bm' ' n t cil � � By BY IP NKE y�FINANCE RK � COl1I1C11 �}�.,��C� �_L.`y€'�- MEIYORTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAITL File NO. V �'� ' ' , O�dZn�n`,e Ordinance PIO. Presented By - Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date City Planning Research Analyst IV Grade 47 Commu.nity Facilities Planner IV " Economic Planner IV " Environmental Planner IV " Housing Planner IV " Land Use Planner IV " Public Systems Planner IV " Deputy Coordinator for Comprehensive Policy Planning Grade 53 Chief of Public Systems Planning and Development Grade 59 Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty days after its passage, approval, and publication. Appr ove d: - J 7 . "i Chairman Civil Service Commission COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: � Butler Konopatzki In Favor Le�ine Meredith Against BY �nx�fkac Roedler Tedesco Mme.President �HUIlt Adopted by Council: Date Form Ap ov d by C' Attorney � Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved Mayor b ' to o cil By BY WFi1TE,,. e.Gl-L�Y-{LERK C�1111C11 /���s� PYNK - 'FIN74NCE GITY OF SAINT PAZTL File NO. '�'� � GANARY - D�PARTMENT BL.t1E - �AYOR . - . • � Ordin�nce Ordinance N�. Presented By Referred To :, �`` �'�� �1� T rl Committee: .Date Out of Committee By Date An ordinance amending Ordinance No. 7607, entitled: "An ordinance fixing the duties and responsibilities and the minimum qualifications for the various classes of positions in the Classified Service of the City, " approved February 13, 1935, as amended. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDALN: Section 1. That Ordinance No. 7607, approved February 13, 1935, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended by striking out the specifications for - City Planner I City Planner II City Planner III City Planner IV and by substituting in lieu thereof the following: - 1 - COUtiCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Hunt I�cnopatzki In Favor Le�ine Meredith Against BY Sprafka /� Tedesco � � Mme.President Butler Form prov,�d by City Attorney � Adopted by Council: Date .. �' ' Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by yor f issi Co '1 Approved by Mayor: Date - By By . a ' ' .,• , ' c; i.. ..c. . .,.,, . �• — — r ..... . . . . . i , ,. i . ' � �:�� , . . ..�. . ,. . �i. . . . . � : .�i. '� � .. �.�..� ,. . . ., . ' ,. .. . „ "�.. '.I'. . . . .. , . .. .,�.J I�.�....../- ::1 1��.'.i. ��l. i�� 1;�:' ,. . . '.+_ ... . C' ' . , ��.. . :_�.',:'�?�r il'��; ',il:.� �O ''1i:i':�O.�iti . - � _ ., ...' ._. . . " .. . . . 'C _ _ .,� �. ..,. . .. .. 'J� , , ., . � . .. � ?i:. �.. ... �. '. . -i-' . .. �?.l_.:"�;' ..J.'�._ C1 .. ,_ . ' .. , . . . . , - . � ._._. .. . .. .�i �. .'�" . c,.. .vF .. 1�. .�C!.l L.�l�a-C.al� , �: , .. . t•. , � .. ' .. . • �v�. vli:'' �,Y1:,l�1� ::iJ.G �.: . _� i' , _ . �'J . , ..�_ . ..._ .,. � ^ . ..f. .,� ..... !�. _ _...' _. . �,� �_ G:.�.,. :+�r� CC,u ���.��.�.i.^il v., ..�;.�._,_ .�:!^�. - �_:;� � ,_?: .,"G ��i: 'G1 . ^, .C.. ,�.':'v�.C:� ?.,.��� y C.:',,.''::,^, �, 'C, ;li'�_C:; C:�i];.;�:.."� 'r' , r..1�^ :i�,. .,�._. .?��:..� .. ':�, ..;�'. �^". ..�Z��'�'�•,rC: t�.�.'�;T'r:i.A?n�'o .. _�,� , � ... _ i'` .-,^ �_'(i .�,•.`.�r ..�. ., '.1�. . ._ - l'.i,.`i..f��t.1 i.�.�.� .11.i..� .,1 ....�.�C.. ..� I 1..C...., i=S�`.C.'l;'I,QLi�J O:'. 1i11C � . ._�.,. - . _ C .1,� �...., 1.7:1' ._., ,.l'y.�:,�, .�.:�.'_� �1:? i�.. �..i��L�.��!. <..�C�.�. . .�<.� w�,� J..,ii . . �.__ . .• . ......... .,. ... l� ....ul Ji�� .�:,��:.,�. i�_ i�_ .. .. '..�'.L�C�� i.�!.�� f)Lj .;1:�.,�,.�_..)' . ...i �. . .�: �:.�•�, y)�!��.i�'.�l_,i,�. �7.��i ...., .�'-�..:t� �l_.. lJ~ 1.1�C..� :��.11.1�.��.��.[i ��''.._:1.!:��6?:1. �_'i. .:1,:C�, , C'r::� ti i`, ^.'l'� C'. ,��C " �'P �„ i,.:i:i. (•;Ct C�.^Il'[i?^Il'i^.�. ,�, •���.:i�.,�. ' � `'L';l C�'_:.' ! .. . .' :>i`.�. . ��L).i..� .. :�..' :�i.'. ..i;�_ ... _ C:,il.'�. ,_ ..P �...iJ� i .� .':il:�l;; L�.:.�'�:.',. :i,t?!:'�.CS� �;• ':L. _�_., ti, . ..i'..... . ... .. . . � � .. ..-'.i'? ..�'.:i::�.;;C:�''t?.'C .... .'.... ,C: .j �: .....,:.i_.i.�C'i,i�.::C, _., ,�. , , , ; : _ 1... C.•_��.? 4,._� t.'.',.�. .._ ..:,. :.��.` .... 4_. . C_���[t'' :::..�_ . ;C�f. :;•^.C_''i 1�,.�. (�:' '� i ,, ,- � �� ,-... ., � ,.r�:.': ''' _�2_ C',.. .,C`. 1.., .. .,. . �.�'.I'::� '.II:. i, i s.':it;'C:� �li0 :t:�t�vt�:.�.1?����i � _.,,.. Ct... ...'i;:. ... `, _ 9 _. f ..' � . '- . . �. . .. TiLle or cl��c: � c7.�:�Y �'T.:-.I�±i�"LR �T. � Dt_'c��ec r..r__, rc^ron�::l?'.���..�:c^ �;• � •-�-� cai_necl:ion vra.th . L'r_c1er. eltT.C_,r':t:,•�C,1t� •i;J i).^.:::�G'!i,l �"_'C:��C,. !_ .'_�.� �...11s lT.� J...� ^4 ... � n f� N1.n)1.��1CY. C:?�J �'i�-�n_�.a.r.�; :..i1C1. ti^ i;C::_0=:1i1 7'C�_�.uCti �tiGT�i �.., L•`. . --'' ', 'CC :%'" :'C' ��G',,•;'U�r��; ,:)_�_�:,.,.lyi._ _. � ...... .. ' . . ... �i j� ' ....:� y�, ,1'.�`', " ",7 1 � �'1 �'I 1 !.O C:7.. .CC'� �..tv.. C .. i,!wt�, i,il(_ CC:'•:_1. .a_L' u�Lc;�..u�4—CS• r,J 1�•_.,,•�,�,:2C !:l:,?�U� C'•'��.:'�i�.",� ;.;?'�:,?:11"; G::.%:.`i7:i.'� c3.0"��t,�-,i1S; CQ�Ol CCZ xeaderin;s, _ t.���:� �;��;��� ;CC i;:..', c.��:���,::_.:�,;:,� . �l'� �:..'G:!,"'G ,::�.�i;il "�i�C �C G�f�;l ..�1:� �:."�„-"^Ll i; �i L:1�::}C"'C�qy�fl S�:C G:tQ;l i O:�' 'L�iA G:�'''v L,:lC�. 'L�' . ..'C�,�.C��:C�..^.'!:)''.CiAV �:i '17.�.:�.41t1�r'i� i;:"Cc�. �� To �.�si;c o�;l�c:� z��,o:'ecu-i.o?;w?. ���.�luie�°s �i� cl:�,x�;c o:� 2on:tng, tzroa,n de�_�.��. ecoi�c;a�c �nti'���:iu, ��onv�!,�-�:�.ox? �o.�eea^'c�.n�, trai�spor-ca•c:iou, � �;Cn C3'^.�. �.O:;i;-::'�11"C i)�_�;1111'?12� G�' O"�:lZCa 71.z.'Oi;i^.Lt� Oi �i1C �C�::i'��CT]i. �U ��?C� C.".Sf ::.:.'_-NC. lU ��U�%iS"� :'-=1 i.�1C j�?:'Cj,�ti?:�:'i+_.O?1 CJ:" Sr:.".1�."i.i,C21 :t'C1�QT"�S `�!',11t�. �^,�l?C�.1@G� c'�Y2C� OYl ncc���?cil ��o �:�vc �r�,�. �:��c,erA�a:��ion�� 4•�, �zec�L��t?;;s oi •cl�.c P�wnnin� C:;.�::t_.u,��c1�, ��� r..� a'.ice��n"u o:° v�.,::�.ou,^ C`L`v7.0 �rc�u?�> �.Zt? �ozreai�en'cWl . c`�..�jClll".�!�.'u. �.i'�11�.i?;tY"1 GiU.��':.�.°:��C�"i,�.d11U: �.'Ci�.�C�C v��L.{�.U^i.:!Gi� 7.11 1.1�:Aic7.'i.l ].?�::?11Y1:�11(,��'1 U_t'UC:21 5'�;L?d.lCSy �C0�3.'C,13hy, e�:gineer:ill,n,-.�� •. � ' �a �_�`11.':;CL':i�C i;."Cl?.:!.'i,�."C"�li:.'C� Oti �'27:'C�.1:�.�CU1:LLa.'(: c,Y]f�. Gi".L' '�3"C^,:c.' 1�1L?�'C:�:�1Ca � ?�.?.;',l:l�::'.i1`; C:��C%.'�.Ei�CC j O'i' � ��^N"LC_+.'�� (i.�i:;:`CC lil llr}�^i� j���Y'TL�1244: LL":�c.Il �-�.uc?�.es; :�i�b���.c <:.c?_�:�i,�-�;�?�L�.�c�.o��., or �;cc�;�.�^p?�y aa� one o:" .Ll�e closely _,��, � ; �_" w:., �; :�_;c�� �C�C?1C�5; o:^ cai_lc;� �;��r�ua.��o�i �.nd ��ro �c,. ^,�cc_ oc- �.w o:• ��;I �� _ ,..._ ?7 t .7� .{, n t •.••� ':� ry e' "' t ?r �� 1 1 i' (� '1��'�'��. �lY.�. ut�l).ri 1i3.4��1i�On �r•�w,i'� C��iJC�....C_.,CC .;... �;. C::I;J 1wri1:.C._ I a�:� e us�l... xa:c ec?uc�:-c�.oz�,.} ^ _„ .� . : . . _ - . �_ , . '_ _ , � . . _ Tit1.e of c�^.s3: � ����x PI,P,t�, �i.� Dtr�ies ur..d. resncn:�::i?z��.�-�-c y: � t'r.1cr ctizec-ci��?, �o �c:tt"c_�.i si�pe�•���sor3t Profe��i.on�� 4:ork a.n comuectioa T;z�th Ci�y i`I4r�i����'r �.,�d '�o y�cr�ar� xel��ec� trorlt 2� 4ssigried. - . �-;��.��nlc s o:^ t;e:���: t�cr.:�°o�:•_:�c:i,. , '�o Ms;,:�{;11, d�.�•�c�; -^cr�,c-;, s._�ncav�.sc, �izc�. txain �xar�ssioaa,'! planneTs ,. &Ilcl 'T��I.:«a.'2?l.°lll,''�' �C;C).il?�.C13,T!". . To c�11C.LlCG :i�.i:�.(d uu.':LJs, ��:� cc�.11ec�� tia��. �'L��r.a;in� la.rid use, - �o��u�,�L��on c'ys�:�'=1�u�:o�.�, aizcl }�I�y�icul, econoraic aria soc:ioloBa.0 C011�!"�:tUilu. To �eco��d c.u��a; •�o do a c;�^�'cI� �,ro7�1:, �.nd. •c� eo•���31e s��•t3sties 3n conllcc'c��oii ;r_�,�eh u�ct�c'�:�.eu w?zc�. ;urve�ts. To wi��ly::.� palica.c� re:l.�.ted �:o �h;�u:i.c�]., econo�ic, o?• soci�l devel.o�ent and �to �ss:i.s�: t�r�-L-11 tl?.e c7evc?.opne�rt oi al�;e��na�i.:ivc poZicy �ropos�3.s. To crxx'�e ?•e;�or�cu u. j•ec�u:trecl �ca c�=,r.r;� oic(; p1wnzz�.n� �c�i�or�sib:�].i��es. �i'o r�.�escn�i; stu��_:i.cu �z'��� �a?�,iln��l�;; },;�cpo;^lc -�o �11e Ptaix�.in� Com!:z�.sslon � aizd 'co clee�ec� oaiici�ls a� requi:c•ei�. �o mcc�� stl'ch c3.-L-��,cn a��c� s�ecia2 in�L-c�cs'c �?�ovps wu �^cqtu.�ed -'ca � ea�Nu�e b�,o�.cZ cc�i-rav�3�.��y Uw1�t�.c�pu�ioti :�n r"�..�^:��in�. . 2•��.r_iL�vw� qU.��;L'r''!C�'G:!.OI,1�: t'olle`�C �?'4,C?il�':l::�Gll '?71 U�'�):^.i2 _lJ�.�."t7F1:1.?l�� Uib�?1 �^a'GllC�:!.6'S7 �f-'0`.`.r���'�Phy9 eizg���icorinv, e=:cii?�ceC�cu:�e, or lwr..c�sc2pe w:�cl�s�cec'ct�c anc� •c32rce ye�rs t p:�o:icu�io�za?. ��.��,;�:i.i�.� G�:pC�ie21C� t��. 1�^s�L 'i;v*o yew�'s ox t;shich D?ust h�,ve �een e,s a C.�ty �'1��.�2��e�• :IT o:� eruiv�.3.ent; or � T2�,s�es�`s c.e�ree in u?�b�.n rla,�a�z����.�;, u�t��n s�i;u�':.4.es, �co��:���i1ay, c�� ��ul�lic t�c��.nistra�ion �nd t�.To yC�as oz° p:•c:ce�sa.ona,? �n1�n��ir.� e�ez�:ience; or colle�e �r�.c�uw�:ion a,n�. :�ou�, YC�T.�J' nroicusio��.^.�_ �:��,rxliz�� e:��eri.eiice, •t;�ro yc�.i c az �*Ii:�.clz �.iuu�L laa-rc bcen. �.s �, C:�.i;y Pl�,nrier II or cqu:�valent. �T��o sL}b s'ci�Luc�woil io^ ec�ucafi.��cii.� . - � _ � _ _ . � , ' � ' - �':i•'cIe oi' cl�;�s: ����S� t.'_l.�'i� ��!ri�'1'i�Li ��r ,_, 17tti;ie� a;�zc1 s°e;��,ora�_uiJ.'_•�..r.:.. t1T12C�Ci C!:L2'CGi,'?�ll� 'i3O .�;t,�,i'i:Q�'i; C'.�.i'.:i;�.Cl?�:i; ��1(� l.:�.L;)1�.�7 ;�C`.,'j9011�:t�)a.0 sir�erv�.sory � n n' n r^ ^�..,, � '-` ' i t i ..n � . 1"1�'O.�CG�al.Ol��.�. ? V«�11 ..�.L� I.JA:iZCC'i.:!Ui:t 1.'.�.'�.i�. C%:�.'C��j P�.���1:�:lYl�� 'l40 cZUUL�II��i�TC c^.C'Li'�..:..�17'!�^��:��'u:�.ti'C C.I:C�: O:.'(�:.::1�.5:�:�::'tCi�.":'_ :.'Cf>i�:%Ii,^>:1.1�'t.�.:i.t;:+.0£"i 3.11t'O�.VCC7. :I.Tl ti�.1B � O�.Ci�,i•�.Qll Oi �.il;j C��l.'�:_��:s.C�i?G 'i:�?".i; i;?�:;,' t1C C:,'i;�^,.��.:l.s11eC� t;?.'Lliy,� the L'1'�i,}�' . ;F�l�,r.li:�.11,f_; �CT!^.�`��L1Ci:.'i;, �.i:C+. "i,Q ;�;Q:..•`•��.,LZ �.G�„�i;C(.l. T'"G:.'�i c^.S 8,.^a.�,�.�1�.CCZ. L:��'.Illl)��S Ol Z�::�3''L }�C:t'1'O�'i:CC�: To liwve cii�.}��;c o:i er..c o:� r��::c r��C���.DIi� oi i1.e Pl�.nnin� Depu�icr�en•c. To or��z�:�..e �.�:� corxc�uc'c r"�c��. surve;�s, co�.?ect dG,ta ?:e,�,raing land uUeu, r��t_l�c_;.o� niN�t;s't'�u�_ian, �nci �xzy�ica�., ecoz�c��.c and �ociola�3.c _ ec�icli�Lxon;. , Tp �3c�ce��.�i;ae ;oii��ccs o�" c?��w, c?evel.o�� d���.-rollcci:�.ii; sys�Lcr�s, conduct 3'CuCw�'CIl� �1`1.CC C'V�?�LT:?.�C VRC lC.`~ll�'GS 07� SG'11C�.1Ci`.'� �31C3. Slll'VEy3• `�.'O �?,I?�.1 jT'LC. 7]�.L?C:LCG :LC��.j:^C� '�O 1���Vn:LCW�.� CC�110iii.i.0 OY' SOC'?w�. C;CVC.'�.O�G'Yl'�` �,nd �o �:s�-�;,� :r:i.�cli -ul�c deti�c7�r�.c;i'c o:e^ �?-ce�°r���5.ve policy p�°o��osals. � To t�r����.-cc :.�ep�z�cs �s �°ea,,ttuJ^ec� •'co c;���:',l c��i, ;��1,^r.niiZ� res�o_z:ibili�t:ies. �'a presen�c ��ct�c3icN �i��. 7�1�n r�°opc�suls �Lo �;he Planr�in� Commiss:t.on and ��o C�.4C�:Ct1 0�:�7.C:���u �u z�nL�.��,a. 1�0 l':3.CC"G �'T].'i,�l C�.v:k..;,^.I1 �.tl('. ;;j)CC::u� 1I1+:C'�'C'u'i; {�'':'OU-],�S wS i'CCytl1l"CC� t,0 ei�ct.ic b�ou� co��:..,r�zr��;;r �:,�r�i;�tc�j,�a��:ton 3�z�. Z�:�.�.nr�:i.;.z�. ii�.111?T1L!1 C3L1^.�:+.��+.C�'i,:iG21N: _ �.0��.C,�'�C �3"c.Ciltc'3,�:LC.�1� ;.21 il_'1J�^-�12 �?�C',,i�.l��.Ilv,., LL''IJu11 u'LttC�.1.G:i� Ol^ {�L't��T:Cf'..�Z�lf� �T1G�. �'011:i �rCC,Tut �:iG:�CS�;:tUl��Z �1�wi�i1'!11� f-;��Ci':�.CI1C@ �.i, l.e�°.5'G 'LZ:O jlCc�..�'S Of z�7I11.C�1 T'ilU.N'G hWtre ue�x� �r� , C�.-�y I':L^11i.'2C:C X�� or ec�tzivwlen•t; a�° w F•3�ster's dc�ree i.n urb�.�i E�lw:�i�:���.�;, u:�°l;�.n stucl��c;, �cogr�.plly, or puul��c - �,c��:�.i��s��°a-c�.az� �x�.J •�).�:°ee ycu:�s t r�o:ce:N�iflizal planning e�ex:ience; or CO?_�CUC �,i'4,cX1}�,'i;"!�il �llC�. s:i"VC �TC^.i�t �]l OiCSulG313�. pl�ilil��.�.� eX�GI°].CT1CC 6L"� 1ew^•� -c�:o yc�,:.s S�rli-�cl� i:�u:�t l�a;re beei� as a C:i�y Pia,nner TII ot equ�.valen'c. �I�ro uu:��Ni,:�.�ucion :iar ec�ucw�cioi�.� - 5 - _ � i . ^ F ��- WH17E �— CITYCLERK - � � �,. �� � COL1T1C11 �7 " f�a�'a� - •�� PINK — FINANCE � GITY OF SAINT PALTL. r�u�t.�:���..r CAN 4RY — DEPARTMENT ' . � � Fll@ NO. � BL.1JE — 4AAYOR . � . . - - � oa • y'LLZ'n�nCe Ordinance NO. _ Presented By - Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date - Section 2. That said ordinance, as amended, be and the same , ' is hereby further amended by inserting in tr.eir proper alphabetical order , � the titles and specifications for - - . Chief of Public Systems Planning and Development - ' City Planning Research Analyst I City Planning Research Analyst II City Planning Research Analyst III . - ' City Planning Research Analyst IV k� Community Facilities Planner III : ,; Community Facilities Planner IV . - Deputy Coordinator for Comprehensive Policy`Planning � � - Economic Planner III � , Economic Planner IV � ,' Environmental Planner III � Environmental Planner IV � � Housing Planner III Housing Planner IV �- Land Use Planner III Land Use Planner IV � Public Systems Planner III ' Public Systems Planner IV Y _ 6 _ COUKCILMEN - Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Hunt Konopatzki In Favor , Levine � ` Meredith Against By Sprafka Tedesco Mme.President Butler - Form pr ved by C' y Attorney Adopted by CounciL• Date " " Certified Passed by Council Secretary By By ' Approv y May _ ubmission uncil '� Approved by Mayor: Date ; � - By BY � --� x , ; __ . __ - . - - . , - _ _ .:..� , . _ . ';-z •• �,: •:- • - �. . ,, . . , :. . ,. . � . ; . .`:'� � `+'. �� � :: ,� �<-� :�.. , v:+., ,! :l-;.�zt�.�� i:�:t:� ;°�. `)�.:Si. :s�j��{ i �_,.�:.... � : °..'_:., � ..'E' .;'�'t�•. :C' 1:- :,� :; .�i:. . '�, n':.�it'��t:''':Fi E�Gfl;'"� 'e�)ti' ni�M;3�'li'��'9� • ii�~ �l�.... ��. - � . : �� ....... '�:L ... .t .4�.. t+•:1 '.���;(ii, IV�7�'a1��r�1 �.7i1.7�vy� . y }7 /'� � a ..L �'. .. •1++. -.4�� _ � . .... . ..r4. t�.. ... � _-.�'�Jl ��..•'��f�..l�r!:JFf� V� SsA2� kl��� . � . .a.. +�:. . . �, , . -. , � � .1 � ': t.' � l�Y�h n q '7 _ t'i�` . . . . .. 4 . ,�'t.,i'.. . : �."�1.7 L�..�.J�;G'j�:.�. . L r�'�. . .. � ... � .�.1'�!' . :1�:._. . :. ,.�:, ._ . �� . ... =:I�:r .. :E�� :r:' a E: �-:� ��. {c.;��f:� ��a �r�-��: �=K 7 ^ g �: „ ,��.. ,-.r, irs n�s. . V�: �.i'~..i�1,�� `wi.i•✓ iR.:.,�:i}r � ..,.r."J i,^,.-,t�:r..�J;J,-.�i � . '�..i's � �� '''...,v.�' +� ' t;- '�- '; �'� �-,�'x�'a''' s"'�f,��''�:$ �t'J �:.h�' .r.�S�lE�+��3:7 �ste:�. ± �`J. y .,�l�S:�+..L C�`5. �oYGa i �.u..�s Claii,. � . 't�il .�GS'�:::1.�: '.�� ?f�r ii. 'b i�.'.'in l+.J x . . Rw� . t s u;1 :� :`a- ��':i�':� c:i'� 1.. !S.�' 3 r'-� e"." ����?�'`S� �� ��E'��'�i3 !L j a�, .. :�:� ,. ,.�'+ �� .. ��•k a: :.�lJ:�.�:'ix. ,i � . ?.5fi,�.li;y...Y �v .,�. .A,�t. .: "� 'irrr,a. �t' �:�� ;i:ti�r r� ,:':�:�t��LZ`'� ���:C��+1..�'� s'�ti� b�i�t'} �a� ��"" ;'"�'�.., �.;::�,... :'n . , c:'t..t �"' �' `,: 9 y. v,� �e .-. 3.L�i � .�' �3 avJ :' �:i�f�:?.,,�+f� �i v�5 �U:::. .;I �F"� R�l}i�i� k��Ca� «�i ..,?,l':.» 1�� E� �.Z...�� C.ii:�}i '�,.°r:'t,..<�.r Ctii� C1L��:i:6.�;��'..J� lt�;'� b�� .. .i u"e. �", �:., =C'� �i' .. .�::`'� e�..3 '..� �a CR'�'� � n:,..C+% .� f . �,... c,., L:a . . ,; v�_. .�_ �'1�.,._�at?2� 6?,�y.�.�3�c'! ,t�, �.`�,.. i.�,�`�.� ,.:}"js, s 't;7 'f^R 1`. .,.....l �a �,`i 3 ry"' k� '� �3'� w.. J �+,rc , ����� S . . c.tt }��'i+� lt_��t::� a, r3 .� ,,,...l,zr i. L�: . „ ..:g. ,��..`� P.�'^s�.',f :s;'�; C9�.'� �. ,F i y"v���'�� �3 �c�d l;�ii t.�� a ,,;.- . ..y..f)�'.r.:�`: �.� . .�4�':.v+;�..._ s ��'3� ._ ;��a `4. 4s�; r�'� . 9D: €>c.!Z � ':;;j �l i�.;� �i2" Gb"�;=.�! �?:�'d.��£?5 E�i��RD �:GwY'S@a '!fi .�'v:,itP :'��..� C:..`.c a,... ;'c`�.,. .. �. .r;s'���'?�" '3'" 's'�'w��Y�`C�' c?t1C� '!�,- 4s n q > (� � c..tP�'dri� iw4 ,........ i� 5.:�(..y ��...�. ,s SS !:�i ...�t .i�::.�ie f's?��L''�`. 5��t��.�. G:'s C: �s����f �lf��]���)�S� i:.:�c3::C�i�`�:i �:Si^�t� �i S.. '4i� c� .otl�f,.:�Fw.'.�i r}:� Mi�� f�l�w �;�"�z_Si:��S. �� . . a �' Y : f � �.a i.:Rs��r� s��'..��:'d- .� €T�` s-"`� 7� ;".;�:��Z .i�ai f,�'' .:'a'' C��S���;�" :�`s?'�:@tr �'t3f��Cu� ��' r:.9�:¢G�� �f. �;. �i�r�. �v��''.>:,..,- >it �T7e��,.t~,:�+�:.�:�,.`�.a .F.��:� ��+$St~ �Ck:'Jr �'��i�r��C��.p ��.i: �r :i�_�-eaG:y f�.z� . i ...,,:..�..� . .'ip LS�tiU y.��.:�.._i�.��i �'l: t'4 v�if:si fi;:�;��L �t�..:�G i,r�.."�..'�� QCJ � � =a^l.�.x I��:i.7 r.ix� rf. ;�. ,fy ,�.Y;�;F�f:�'v c..i `We t�":L��.:ilt'sa�;`'a�:rg 4�� � �+�a`1.���5� . . r'�..��;: �.� '�� L��� �:.,.� s �'� �qt,r•�3� ,t3 �:.�i.� .�iiP`S'i�3.c...�ry CJy,G�:,.�v�iE.�i�`J.9 �w_'Si���� �LSi�i�`. . . . . �i.��Lt.,..,��.r':� }.:4' !{�..,., i.t��1 �.l��:. :b.l._ e'�� �'�:'���ts`.:t.� �65���►'ai�i� �i �'lwri�! � .. `~t�� "C� � � i.t r ..�' i.`T a4t�7��.��:s cnS:iR '�_`i� ,�'�t�,i�`�S ��'�i�.�.�Yi�i�it�0 'J,.;J?: t��s;`� '.? �c� �.'��.}.° '; ?±1:3 �"*.'..W�;;.Yx"�:'�:. q�"�.: 3!'svS�.:'�'�:C:'�';�'iII1 2�3:° ��i{�.:ra'��fl33.�1 f . . . ` � . - . .. i. F +. �� � . . . . . � . . i . . � . . .. � . � I 1 I .. _ . _ -. . . . - _ . . .. ._.�___. . .. _. ._ . . . - . .. . . . � ^ �� _ ' -_ _. -__ . . w:. ._. _ • _ - •���t� �,� _ ''.'��� . E:i.�'�S; ��. , .�. .- < . �' . .. . r ..��.. � . .�i.�i� �.�'.��:. . :.J�..�1��.°l. a... � 4 1 ..�CSy'�� � , . ._,.i }. . .'P� .., -, �.'-r r-.:. . 'Ja � 4;� . . ..@L. � '.6' eS����j•�� �4S�J�i'��.ril4,7{� . .. .���,. . . . , " . _.... ':?:.� .4; �': ;�; C.r: :fw.i,.`?� �?:�:r� �.s?3`!.''�;�a•��y �_:; . �.�:.�: ��. ..� �. ��LS, . :;:: . 3�'. .. <�.a . :f.:c�. Ji-'a� Y;�:��Q� �d�'� � . D , -. .... F•'� _ :� t_ ., ' �. ..., :.`.` .�; ��.' .�::i:T�S'?��'ic��lCBit ... ., L,~.,�4 if.�:. �., �,l t. �.. �.u. i.t �e. _�f.� e1:tJk 'Ji�:•i l:{ ��FL�,�ItM ��.�l�C:tifa . . .��i .�.a.�... .•�tJ . . .. ..„vr .r ... ..i� ,...t'1.' ..�; y.�i1�". .p'��? C�tZi?�.P,.�a �1�+1[O .. _ .� ;;.�..,. �' .._... ' . � i�t.i.. ..... ... .. . .. .... .1.1:��}�..._��. � �i�� i�'�'t" .::: i..! . P;`,�r z:.:`,� K:�i �.., .:;:.�a'x'i:;.' �'i:U'�� .�?�:� 7i� i;E�s� �"?Jy�':�"i �: . dY_... :�w �'t,`.., .��*:J r ��:_��...5l�.•�,j C:?F� CA...'>,s:'lai.�s�—�..t�`.+ - . . �v . . -�..r . � + , "t y �.- � �qt �+ � � `'t'�t:s!�a�l'Y,.C'= c';'�i t. ���'..Z, ��;;`.�jC r.;a s.Z�';':9� �.1�} �4�:!RL y��ta�iC 5 Vi� ��:7'iy . , i:i z � '::i: y r�t, �:>m `,"E;>:".:'..�,�.t�'� , �;���, S�� ;?., t"':it� 5;�.�ilaliiS;:Sv�s t'tiE:��2 6:f... ... . rT. ,..�. .. . ..,... i:o:. _ ...:�t�.1::,' i.i. '.:.,_ ;.�-:.t� .`;i C,�tE.i�r�:: �J•{�[�.��,3 C,s! =��. ... . 4,..:i:�.,L.�.f., � �'..�__. 4? l.i:. , �.�.�L � ..\.� ",•t�G's YY�..�•Sis.e ��: _ _ ��_` ��..` r +� � �� .._t;� . ., � � � . i� e �°a� t".�'�i.:�.. ., �..�•� Rt�4 �L.. �.,s:�.;:� R� n+z±r::�., f`�.,t..,. �._ ��:'_:�e�P� � ����+�•�r y%g„ . . r .. ..., _'_� . .1 i. � ,.`.'. . . . ..�i4� .t��.:`y t . ...�3 ��.,..���:.�T',.�4}�'J� �, r� -.i f.S'a ''�.: 'dfu�' i�'? .y,._`•;e�, . �' �,i. ..�Y � �..t � y .., i , u�k J .,. . .. ,�it. ... . . . . �fr sb::..�r -- � -.'�. . .. _ �.:"�;'`�.�".. , �,=: W :i�:�4t ,is ;i;�`. . �6 �.._.:-. .. �.-::'t:4 �����. e�l�.�:.:. ..5:� u.: ...,._ .>..:E�.3 ..:����'�,r� � ��3:2�.�1� �y��,j45 . � . r' L .�'.. .,_ y ' ? "+�. � ,�. ..:l. ���5 :'�3if���i s�-.�,C 8�.� -� . . :.�, - . , �'s. ` - ..; � � {, .,s < �:.�.�:,� ; � '"s�t �,�:�� __ . ._, ,. , a� � . __ . ..., ..., w.:'i.,� .:i ..�t. ,�a 5� t?:t�t�'3�':�Y+'7Fi s .�._ii�t�..^�•�_..- �.. 3vf.5�..:1..t_6w.��-;:.�y L. =:Y .e�Y.� ��...'�.v6:.i,!'aTf.�. �i.�.�LL i,l.'�:�+r �Lv±�+�? , . .'U�i��'�:i i�"'::.. , 1 c..b.: 3 , � r� A�..i� ..�... .` �i".tc3� i�,!s� ��?i?'�° �':i3���f1 �.:�..�t. ;.,i,i�Jz,,: !_4;",x� �.... zy i..ti•53:...,4j.��� ;..�y �4:�r c��L�Sf�S i't�C._9::'��� ��� l�i � .. ,.. l:'i"*.i� .��:G . ,g ,_. .. ..�''�,..s...:'�Z(� ,tdt .:l ...Ait74 �.�1'��i�%tll�ut��:i9. 4sj[JL-.td .J�k:47lf:.,7� � . . .. . . � r !�,l }+�+� ,(� q, ��p q�. �...'.l`�fE.t:�=: �K`�y (.{ �a.� be.'�.rti.'f.:� %.�� vS'.Z�i�.�»v��:�� iAC��t+llFjlsl.�dl�Y�: �57� ,. . t T c} �� S � Yo�:i�?�i. �v,!� ., �. .."WF;ttii�4ee.� �;'•:;tsY.xYx`.k� � �� �>_. �u�Yc�;: f�4 �+��GL.:�y � � . � . . ,' � �r i c�i.r^.. L� t'i::..�L..'R�.:;;` �`'��a��,�'e;�i:�� i:' .� i:£����r�� �y�s.L;.�z�'�.�S9�i , � �._. ��•:.�r: �� ., a.`.u:Y�.�.�1.'����r.i �}�G.i.M:�lEa� �`EL���'i.:��`�6�yr�p f�� �'L�E::.iL - . . � . - , - '�'''�:9 E' . .C'�r �:�° ._.^t',',? �?.?JV �..;" E,t�:�� ��S E�. i.i,:�`.�e:.;�a�a� ��C�:����"��S ��Y'� ..:':�?� ��.t °."'.�' �4. .`..'�a.���:�.. (�:�: u°?�.'�.af,.�v�.6si�i� IC.3�y �Life,�'.C�.V��"if�j ' " t� + x , _ F' - ,, � _ . _ � � . Y � - :�6��� ' . � ��- . ��:. ; . • . . . - .:; ' ;'. { .' � _ w, y,'��. . . �.1:�, . . .��:,7- . � � . 4•�. .. , � �� , . _. .. , . _-.�'1. �*. � . „<. ' .. . . .�'...� -'..,C,,..'�'�J�V1[:� C�L+�+1 . - . . . . ,." - , ,:�� . . . . . . � _. . > ::��� i�i 5`� G�f '�:�� � i�, �... . � .: , , . .,... . . �.� .,. . . � '. . : . . . :4' �R �al,f����.riki . , . , ., _ ..�_,. , . . �. .. _ _�:�.� i j��:.'�. .. ..'T�i. ...� .i c . � �. . . ..,... . . 7t�; ._. ._ . ...� ..... ... ....,. .. .i.,..�.'� ��tiSi, .. .�fC . .V�..•:Li. :i�;i'.. ��.C�.'ti�i:i� . . . �i�� t��n ��f', . ��i Q,. G+�; .i,.Ce f' � � : . . . ,_ _:1 4. , . ...�i ,� .. . ,i* �'. . .� �', ..:° :'t�'�.M... �:'. �.:e`, z.� .�� ... t3'9� i.Yte: r.,U:,..:��'C.�iesl .�c� rs�:s , .f,,�. , ;� , r�,;� , _ � .. . : 3w {i::�,��'. .c �:,i:"....��,t ti?�W C.�rC�f�: �., S 1�y�+�.�!,. `-;`: �3 �t..'�+:��!i�:'.� �a;'.'.`. ,.;�.��'-��..� �5��y., � . . , :f '.,s .. .e: �..':::" ::.i'. • . ., . _ -.^ti r , y .'i• � rs'^' t "�r:y . _ .,.,. . ..... .. . . �. .�:�:� . t,� G:``:5r i�� 3�S �z�: ii-�y i ` i�.1 ,,...•�: ?.t:.� �..5...Y :��..i' ,.�,: ..:i�,� ! i.�: �V4:i:�. . - . m-� �(` ' t� �^t •��e r�� �/rS o� i� r+'��f� 4 :F� [ P<: �t• '� o^.�. 'i�' . . CJ f�_:J��lA. .� ,._......:u1�- sa _,.�.:; 6- .�s ....yt..� .� .��. �f.n��. fh�>%. ��Ot:(.�1�)a � . ,.j a a.:13 'i � - '�"S.. �%,�\`f, e 1l `���..,.:�r .�.i:,.�, w. f. ..:�t4.:�:.f�. C;�� �ti��4�::.r. i,2 �.•:i L:';„ .. •... . . . �`.� �,�. ._.a. � �,� ._ �,. � . � _... �.. .. u.,. .i , .... 4'� ._. . n .v.. E... , ` ,:d1... . ,'� Wa��,.� A'� . . ....,'.1 •e�.,e � :fti�{.y�5.�._ .ef.. :.� Y.,�� .. ..��.'�. �.�.a.? .L.'�L't4,.9:i�?�.'!'�z:��9� � . ��.. ►: .�. :�r: .. ,.. _.:r, �..::-� �..o:.-.�'`� ..'"x�y , ... �� �r:���:°� �,.��i� ,._....�::? �� K� ,. . .. . ... �^�"� �.. �:s.:Y:.,,�.� ��u..o.'i;1; r����.'cE'3�s.'Sb _,` , , ._� �a I ,�.•s,�� } ..,•<��. *t�,}1�p � L'.�•.. �y� _. . . N• _. �, . .. �1;,....... .�5�.�,i ..l(.r. 4.al+�,� �7. 4�r*[�..'.:bLY< J. Vy;�_9 . . . . �•�� W�1�,. � . . 1... J ��t..��.i..�9F.., s �i.6'. ._ .�5',�\iY�l� �Y 'r+Ii�.�•�,3�J♦ � . � . . . . i��*35..�,E;:... 1.��-..L3 . . �A -r,C. ..��.,.`,.`)`. . � � � � � I .. ��. ,i ry`:ty ,,, ..` . .. T° . ? ... -�. .. "' � .., � `.'�"�k�: `�"�"t?��''�� (3�" k�� � •`,.' _ .�: E. ;� .�. :i:�,� . p ;��:i.�...,..: � ' . � .. J . . .. J:�• . `.r'3{: . ,. .. S: �C:L;Cji��:���,.�1� :!!.�� , 1.�^. cn �, -a t _ r. '� � e�c-i- t n:s �� _ . {.:. c. ... t :± �.. �s.� ,.., .c:"���Y .sy �.:��. ;< ... �C,i: �i�t:Gt!¢r 4.k`�� ya.e�� . . ( � , � � � .'.,v".. ,. ....1.f.` Elr.�.�.�#i _:��? � #.�.. � �':.,...r.i:,.. �SL :�E�:�l.se�'�.:� [V�C �{:fiiel.�ii:i�� � .. � . . r'�i:.7i:ili: si�� ' i7. .rt.� ��'�b.� �iL�' �: e`is�:�47..�`�'G''SJ 'il�i�ti��t�.6l��� ��i���i��.���� � .. . � � . t'."s �':.�: .._._�;:�` ?.'-�`_ .±.,.'.`_V. e,_':i€��. .::.;�fa,t7:? �£:u�.+6C i$fs't:srii`s��l"��{(b3'! . �Y' i: F".. oL o' �'r.?fi `. '.`'. :�+0`:''z�� �i' �33;;'S'iC:�:i �:'rf."Rt'.2 W7 i.Fi ' _ �... „_r � ' ' ..n, er6:_ � �.a•�.y a ,��, �• � - � �v�.t:sv 4.��s� '�d? =�,� ..�ae�.S :;i:� 'f",►.-_ ��':i �.>���'�5�tQ:��� ��l�f'!�iaiZ� �'3:�L�'ii:�t�.: 1','.;:;�`� " 4':`s i�'3 �^:,��,��i'�i: �'.�.:'stft�� t�t' ��'�:�G , re^c.•'ut��.z,'!�:i s'`;�'.� 's�l.t. ,1,':: ,. ,:� �."'t�`i'n�,�'iG'":i S ��c.?i11�€�C� G'n�l:i"�f��1C�* . • .. ti� ��..�'::�� ��..`�v �rn��}�- �uCi���3 �:�"F�� r:�L�.cL�i:. ie o.:� ft`�J �£i C��������a�:���1�a� lb � . . � - . ��.- �;" CGi.i��°i'.��:?� �i�'.'3�t '�`•:-`?'�f $[fl ��.'�'i`�.'�34; ;.'�+:? az'c���. �e�� ��.;'s.t��'Y�����G''i� , lF�;' �U�.riC•`:i�i:,:':`t.� � ` — 1� — , .� . _ Ti-�Ie G:L c�.�NU: - ' �ntTrUlT�.i;�:�L i LAI:II,�� �EI - L�t�ic� �.?��?. �eN�:cnr:�b��.:i.���_+.c�; Lnc?c:�° �r.�,r�t��.a:ion, �o r;c��°o:�� c�li?CZ'v�.CC:•f t�roress�c�aal t��oik iri C.^.li:':C:,1G11 ?T:�'Vil C.^.G?.'(i�l.�,��:�i?:� L'i2;'':tTC;":.Cil�:?,.� c�ua.�i-i;y pl.ennit� �etivi.ti�s u.� '�i?C 3�U21:C21�?7 1.CJt`�_ .?..i�. ('.C�C�_O�:il�� i.ile Cl��.�:; enyi�ar.m�en��Ql 1G11�::,C'� ;?u�C�C;�:CIwJN 9 c.2}ti. GA j'-C:i.�:�Ti.t :i C�^:i:Ct? Z?O;:a &S N£57.�L'@t�.. - i,.;.�i�±n1.c� c�= '�.ro��c �e::��:,��:�ec�.: `.�.'O ).'..`��:C'T �):'C.�^,C:.l'i: :.LC'G'!'•:�:i'L:IC� �i:.�.^�,'i;t?C: 'i3O i;:ie iun�.nten�icc �� Cllti'a.:i.'Gl'�':!^.iliul C�li�:.�.:l.'G�r l;.l S'ii• _���11a.• ��O 1.':'�-1'i:i;:3�. :.1�'�i.'G��O�'s'�uli� u��v? �'.Tlf�, l,'�."i::t0'lu,� �'J.�.:LC;I C�,C TP.�.Oj�I3C�Il�S _ :i C�.?Z:CCi t:0 Cl's'�':i.:'Ol�.^.elri,^� Qllr.��.�3f' CG),1'�?'O�. �:2t�. �O `�,v5:1�.^>L Z.�1 CC?O?'C?.=.�12�."i,.'!.11? �C l�!.1I�l��.C'u �� 'I:I1C Y1L�.rii C?j3�_L Z.C'VC'�.. 10 �,F�:�'�S� :21 c;eve�on�.nv cz�v-i2�017�?CI1j:?,?_ I1'i'.1�C� uw.^�ess;�ea��� proceflt�es o.nd r�c�;h�d.o'!o�,� _?o� ��lae C E�1iJ• , Tc asN��� :ii�z c'lc:rC.�.Or711� a�?�. iu?�Zeraen�:i�1�; .��nd u:,e con�crols t��.�ed ' �a.pon m��.i�tez��z�ce o_f' c�.z�._��o���-;~ez�i,^.7_ ru��_:ity. '1'� ass��u u ii1 c:ev;���p:��i;; �4��.��. :imZ��.c��cnc��.n�; e�cr.. s�w�e n'l�nnin; for �he City. To under�Li�c resc�.rch Y�o:�l�, cnc? re�fl���s a.ud to �s��st; wi�:h i�hc ;�3.^(:�?�:i��,..i:'�Oil O:C :iC?.0.�'i,.^,. `l'O �l;:l��^.�^�I"�.�^,Cy C�_�.'CCi. L�.11C? i•?."�'�..:i.).1 �+:`C�'C5.^�]A::�^..�. r�u2ii:C'iS wnc? -Lechn.ic�.�ns. To .�ice� wi-ch c-?�L-izc�.s uzlc? s�;ec,�_L :in�c_ces�c �rou�� ws rec�u�red to ei��l?�c U�oec? co�,�iau.z:�•c�r ��^�����c-��:�,�;�or� •�.n cziv���oi�sen•t�,l p3.�nnin� 2C'L'1C�"�'L��.eS9 �:1C7 pl^CuCb�.i, �i:i��,iQSCt_� j?�.wtl; �.11C. 5'G:'ry'���;�CS 'ifl SL1Cr1 ��.�oup^, -co �ci:c P��..:�r:ii�� Co�:�:i;NU:i�n �,i�.ci �;o ezec'ccd �f:f3.Gi�3.s c?.G I'CCjL:7.�'C��.. P�:;n��i� r1u�.�_•?fic:,�c�o�1s: Cr�1l.ege ���,duL�c:i�z1 z•rs•L-1� �. ��j or :;.i� t���'�un p?w�n��n�, enri��ot+�ten��al p?annin,;, io��c;,�L-.ry ��aa ���,�1>u r��.n�;,;evient�. o=ecgr��hy, or urb�n e�uc3.3.e� a,nc? 'chrec ;;re4 r�' ��:�oicsu?on��? �?J^.ilri:�.11� en��c:seace, �,-� 1.eas-c tero �ears � o� rhich r�us�c h��,re be�ii �„� w C�-'�.� �?��;k2�:� �I c� equiv�3.en�: a.nvolviag e:1v�i.?•or.�.ental pl�:�z�.�.n�; or a RI�=u�c�=s �.c:�z cc ir. u�ban p1�,rtn�n�,, e:��viron.nien-�w�. pl�r.n7 r.r��, sores�c:wy an�. ��x�.s ��n��ement, geo�x��hY, iu:b,:.n s•ct�c.ie:, o.r pLiU?.ic �,�;::i.n:is�x�i;iax�z r:,nc3. t��ra ye�rs' �rnfessicn�l - 3��.ann_i.n� e���:e--^:tC11C� ��-ro�.v�n� cnvsro�l.r�e.'c;,.:'. �?�nninU; ar co��e�e ° g�ac�uatici� �nci, icitr ye,::rs` ;��xo:�c�s:ton�'! �J_�r,a�.n�; e^�er�.ence, a� 1ea,s-� ttiro ye�r� or ��rh-�ch r,�uut �z�,ve been in,vol�red t�.th enva.�anment�,l . plann�in�. �i3a sub��i•f;�rt':oz� �'o:� ec�uc^-ti�z�. � , _ �7 _ _ ' __ _- - _ - 18 - � - . , � . � • _ ..��1L-: 3i C:i.:��: . � - - � , . � �i�; j;�i .. � .... . .... .�t� .:_:�_. ......._. .. . . . . � � i......,. , i_�i?.i !'nr.-:;:... I_{.:..:.1_'�.i.i `_w , . . t .. .. . �, ti._�. �.... �: t? _ . , f:0:.,!l 7 ... _.. . _.. tiz<� .l', •-�� s-'.:j`J:i�:iiJ�.�? ali.�)o;� �� �..u��a:cy �.�.....� . .�_ .. . - il k. 3.-_ l}.4:� . ..,... ..� . . �?� . . � �' .- :G-� ����i^�'. 5 �'-1� t ��� . t. . . _ _ _ t,:� . _r�. r1�: a.1ci r:�...�a .:�.'. r� , . . _ . ._.. .J�.Y"�.,_ � .. �,. ... [.�._� _ c... . 4:'. . . .:lii:�. . ..... _� . �.. s.:�..�i.. 3�. c"�;i::L£:,11F,.-'L•.. ._.... ._...v ..._ ..�. �. .. 1�;1.L.<:J.6:.._. . � .. �. .. (2:..,. _C1 .. GC'��:'- --° .:t: ..lf? •i..: C.(::1�;_.'_fih:Yi�?2.. `�r �'.r1.`_f. �?':''? l'J?i..E':::j.Vi:�'• ��L 11�:...7," . �1 ...�_�.".�l.i.. ?��_�i.�% ��ij..,��_Ft�., .,... t-'a�.���� �.:_�_�....� �i'J Li'�{Iv�.P:'j ,.5�i,�Lii}�.��. . ' � . r,• _ ,__ .O _r!� .;:...k.._ w_ C�... : �a _ i`,f� ... '"�.,! ?�'�.r."�:.'z.o?�.C.� l.�r c, i.L'Ll�'.__'<; ,_�-a�r:�0?"Sr �y:�rGZil �Il:� _ i� "3.'. ui..,_, .f�....t'';.. t:':. F_���'l_ix�;, r j^(�'I.�E,:an:�' <iC� �7iJ0'L�:'�� �i::."`'� l.f.: f...�.7 . ' ,s {; ��;�r '-3�-e� i� ' �. � ,� ,f1- - ..0 t.ti... ..__J ,... . '.2t:f,: ..-.i e... . .:l._.. _ t•:.�::3 S"'- k;;t_C:u�.^�t.:.lu c"�::.CE Ci��i:7T"� � .. ,.. ..J ... 1..:6.Y47.C...ci• . , .:'' t.. .._. �..:G:.`.'__`s_�T T.i�.z��... C�i:"1�.:: 'i��.c..�i..::'.?.'u �f) C��)r9?'...i.:c:i.C. 1,�;+ a �cs c • �- s .:i.�1i_., �i��.�C���... �'?.'et.��2 ��:.. :T "C�:i`: .CC rTc��,-i„%nc i.:.. Oi.�'-_�"+' _v, [._T t:��. .f_ i3;'G<.:3. . u�;u?.S �.� fi.i . (:y _ . ...... .._ , _. _.:.i::� ��......;.� r'%'iii.:.....';iM.C�.?c�. �='3.s..>!�.{-_'S":i �:� LE�i?"r? tf'C'. . i-- _ I�') .�1L�'���.�1.c.�.'�? 5:... ..�..wt.C.�. �"- ��...�.l.:. Z.f� _..i.i.. �-�i,'i .� �....�..�:'i�. ..... �c.:..:.Z� i1:2L L�:nv° . .. .� ..- � /.C. .�.. . . +_�..�L� ....._ . .. .._. , ... r..:,���... i`: ........ .. . .._. 1.,.... ;�f,i4'�^_ .>... l._ r�1�_. ?.... ...ar.�.;� i UL�.:'?.F_3:1L0;.. w��.,.i t,rJ . _ `�:'Lc.-'` G r_. .._L' �:, •:�-I•'X-r�;_j,� �.�.0 ::iti��.: C•:;.'::ii !.!.:.�.:'^, ...� �..i_ z�ilt�C:1_�.Y.�. '!:"E'"_:::�:'.:,�`' f,[.O,z��3 ii.� L'�!�i�a.i:c�."L� :tJ �?Ii:3�,17..;: _ �... :,-^_EF. C{!.:i_'v .»t:)T i A:�;::�.:'_T:":t�i.i�1� ... i a�_.�::!??x:LS��� '_"�. . ;l� Z ..f�._ .:�.• . ....� � ,:-,_�s l,c,�: �.i_: i�> ...F:.,e> �:s =ic...��:? � .. :�.:_: i .,:`,; �l.'��,>: .L:':C�:.�f.':i ._,li;: )'�.Il� - �:...._ .. Q� J� .l.�t _..._._ �1:... � ,��.�,�.t t� z , �,t..���.�...�� .��. ...Vc::;i. Li/l'+ y��r?.��u '`..S'_ �..�i2.t.Ch :':l:ii. 41� � �- 7a�4 '3:-__?% �?.`.� ti. 1-: :��.�:1;J i.1.:?:�:P,�:'3.' .T.�.� G . C�-:`.:_ ::+..�.:;�:.�j i:k.' '��.. t:��..^y�:'?'::T w (�L:��':.'C? '.i1 .'_ir..:�,_ ' � y.... .... L.i..f.?"e. .���'til'..i,'. 1iy � r���.. ��'_ l.�'i" `:uu.b?:�(: ..`�i::?_1"t:.3�.::�t.�_^,I? .^�_._ tic��ee .-_ .�. , w�' .._ ., �?.! ;� .�.z�._z� � ^ c ;;� �. '+ ,. -�.. . . , . �, A �ie:ti c� .. _ t E��s�, f:�aa yu��°r; ';�t_ Ci�c�L::.1 I::... c�. ...`:�. _ .. '`.�.iZ .'_i:� �;�:.' ..� .-. �.M.t._.._:t« ��.�.��. L?i_' V::.. ��..'.Zi•.:a.C?Il�y Ox' . � � � � i;�]� . .a _�. _,.. ,.,. w1�.�%,��- �vC`�-�' ��� � '� :�:...� .J'.•�'J�:. °�'rul�- `�:[.L'1_....._;��(J�. ..._ �_�''..t?`Z�;i'�; ''T)�.'.�:.C� ,C;" _...._ _._ ,.. . , 1� � r. _ �. �I` , ,S� �^::'iL' �Z�7C' y'"c:....'S it`: l��:r:l.j;t. ..';5�. . .__,"C ...._._[.1 i?^ t i..�.'�,i.Li.,.=� P1 R?'"' �II� . / .:.x:T:.:1 .�. n�` f��li.�_t�.�.t'.'"li.a [ � _ .. t� .... .T�� .`.lSis .li?� .r.'a_�.7.i.^c!?.�al'1of � . „ . . . " ?rF .. � . .� � - ,. �. . . '. .. .. ,. . . . - 21 - .,- — - _ ___ _— - — . " NN,*s; � C1T`( CLERK , - pt��� �PARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PATIL Council �yNK File N O. ������ , . e�LL� �AYOR . - . „ ` ; Ordin�nce Ordinance N0. Presented By _ Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date Section 3. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty days after its passage, approval, and publication. _ 25 _ � COU(�CILMEN Yeas Butler Nays Requested by Department of: � Konopatzki [n Favor Levine blerc�dith Against BY �t3c�c Roedler Tedesco Mme.President �DC2Bi Hllrit Adopted by Council: Date Form A ro ed b 'ty Attorney Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved May n ncil By By (s�ru�) znr�QZS�a� o:s�a� � �Q�ox�. xsza�x� � �nun� a �����9� �ZS�aouox�._ ��g „ � s��u � " �. s�a� � �� 1 � pa�dop'� ��' � �� �tp £ , , �: �j� ; �� �.Sz � �, �, � 1 � : � . ��� : � , � . -� � � F� �. . . ;�� . . s�:�hl �;.�..__. ;��.,n, ' . . ♦ .w�—��_��- ...._..e..i�_.�...._.... . ...........�....� � WHITE - CITY CLERK � �-���� �� PINK - FI.�IANCE � y COUI1C11 � 'r � � CANARY - DEPARTMENT GITY �F SAINT PAITL Mi � C�' BLV E - A'�AJ'�R . ;,� File N O. . • ' / S Ordin�znce Ordinance N0. �5� 4 Presented By Referred To _. �� �f 1 Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date _...� An ordinance amending Ordinance No. 7607, entitled: ".An ordinance fixing the duties and responsibilities and the minimum qualifications for the various classes of positions in the Classified Service of the City, " approved Februa.ry 13, 1935, as amended. .---- THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: �� Section 1.�/1'hat Ordinance No. 7607, approved February 13, 1935, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended by -. striking out the speci.fications for - City Planner I City Planner II City Planner III , City Planrier IV �and by substitutir�g in lieu ther�of the following: � . : ��E _ 1 _ L COUNCILMEIV Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Hunt Konopatzki In Favor Levine Meredith Against BY Sprafka Tedesco Mme.President Butler Adopted by Council: Date Form prov d by City Attorney Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY Bv Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by yor f nissi Co '1 By BY ._, . - - ,. r , . � . , ' , . i ■ � . `fitle of class: CITY PLANNER I Illuti.es and responsibilities: • D L'nder supervision, to be trained in and to perform work of a � professional level in the City Planning Department; and to perform related work as assigned. rExamples of work per£ormed: l To assist other professi.onal planners in zoning, urban design, economic analysis, population forecasting, transpurtation, general long-range planning or other programs of the Department as they may arise. Tu assist in thc cc,llection and recording of data and compilation of statistics relating to planning studies in transportation, conm�unity Lacilities, policy , l�nd use, economics, environment and housing. 'T�� assist in the preparation oi maps, charts, graphics, exhibit desi�ns, colored renderings, and perspective drawings pertaining to assi�ned prc�jects. Tu assist in the desi_gn and layout af undeveloped sections of r}lP l'.�t'V A»!� Y}1P Yn(jPVP�linmPnY n�r� I�liohro� orooc T: .:ssist i^ th� preparatio:�. cf .,-ritt�n repor�s ar�d stuui.es, and � on vccasien �o give oral presen�ations at meetings of the i �lanning Commis^ion, or at meet�_nQS of various c�vic groups and ' oovernmental agencies, � Minimum qualificat�ons: Colleg� graduation �J1tI1 major ccurses in urban planr.ing, urban ..t�dies, public administration, gec��raph,y, architectur.� or l.an�iscape architectare; or college graduat.ion in one of the clos;.ly related social or physical sciences and one year's planning experience. (No substitution for education.) � ' i � .. '� t . . • r � - . '� , . � � � � Title of class: CIT� PLANNEK II [�uties and respi�nsibilities: Under supervision, t� perform professional work in connection �:�itt� city plannin�; and to perform related caork as assigned. Er��mples of work performed: T�� collect and record data and compile statistics, and to analyze Lindings so as to identify needs resulting from the studies. To prepare maps, charts, graphs, exhib�t designs, colored renderings, and perspective drawings p�rtaining to those projects for which �� ;�cu are assiened. To assist witf� the design and l.�.yout of undeveloped sections of the City and the redevelopment •of blighted areas and to prepare rough plans in solution of these conditions. Io assist ottier �rofessional planners of zoning, urban desi.gn, econumic analysi_s, population forecasting, transportation, �;eneral long-ranhe �lanning or other programs of the Department as they may arise. 'lo a5sis� in tt�e preparation of ��ritten reports and studies, and _i__. .,....... .�,.: �.:, t,��� ..... t.�`oc.u�.u�i�uo u� iucc�i.iL�� vl L11C L1iti1Rli1� Commission, or at meetings ot various civic grcups and oovernmental ag<nc:ies. + N`inir�ium qualifications: College graduation in urban plar_ning, urban stud�es, geo�r.aphy, er�QineEring, landscape architec:turP, or. architecture and one year pr.ofessional planning experien�e; or a Masters degree in urban planning, urb41 studies,. public administratioii, or ;eography or one of the :;losely reiated social or physical sciences; or college graduation and 2 years ' exper�_ence as a City Planner I or equivalent. (No �ubstitution for education.) � • ; - t . Title of Class: ' CITY 1'LANN�R IV T)�ities and resZ�onsibilities: Under direction, to I�erform diLficult and hi�;l�ly responsiUle supervisory Proiessional work in connection with City Planning; to assume the administrative and organizational responsibilities involved in the operation of any divisions that may be establislied within the City Ylannin; Department; and to Perforni related work as assigned. I;xar�tples of work performed: � � r � �_ + . - . 'litle of Class: CITY PI,ANNER'IIT Duties and re�ponsihilities: ' Ilnder direction, to ��erform su�ervisor witIi City F,lannin�=• Y Professional work in connection �>, and to ��erform related ��ork as assigned. I:h�inples of work Performed: To assign, direct, review, supervise, and train planners and lannin technicians. P g To conduct field surveys, to collect data regarding land use, �orulation distribution, and physical, economic and sociologic condi.tions. To assist in directing researcli work, and to compile statistics in connection witti studies and surveys such as the migration study, housin�; needs study, and character of the city report. 1'o analyze ��olicies related to piiysical, economic or soci�.l !'.eveloPment and to assist with the develoi�ment of ali-ernative � l�olicy I�roposals for tlie comPrehensive plannin � �. T� c`r1�� reP�rts as r.equired to carry out planningPresponsibilities ��� Pr°sent studies and PlanninF P1-'�posal5 to tne Plannin Commi � and to elected off�cia.ls as requ�.red and also to nrovide an � ssion tl�ul;�lLlOi131 service to these policy makers. '1'o meet with citizen and spacial interest groups as re�ui en:;iire broad community Partici � � red t� jation in plannir.g. � P�tir.imu:n qualif?cations• �'ollege graduati�n in urhan plannin ! engineerin ; F� urban studies, geography, £ , arctiitecture, or lanuscaPe architecture an3 three years' J�rofe�sional I�lanning exp2rience aL least two years of which mus:: have been as a City Yl,.inner• II or equivalent; or a master's de�;ree in urban plannin�, urban studies adm�nistration and two years of � �eography, or publ.ic �r colle�e Professional i�laniiing experience; , graduation and four years' professional planning experience, two years of which �must have been as a City Planner II or equivalent. (No suostitut.-�on for educa�ion.j � � _ . _ __ : �_ } � .°.--��--�--�-- � �� ' �x � � ` , m �„ .., � ls�. =�'�� L�-��( '` t��. : 2nc� �� �.� ;�` �' �; 3rd ��Z.1�- �`, Adopted �`.�-'��L Yeas � � Nays - ;, BUTLER �� KONOPATZKI �"���� I � ��1I LE VINE MEREDITH � ROEDLER \ U TEDESCO ' Pi�SIDENT (HLJNT)