The URL can be used to link to this page

84-1677 WHITE - C17Y CLERK PINK - FINANCE COI1flC11 / CANARV yDEPARTMENT GITY OF SAINT PAUL /�j� 7 BLUE - MAVOR File NO. �� " v • � • � � r in�nce Ordinance N 0. �7�� Presented By L-- , Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, § 462.357 and § 64.210 of the Legislative Code, William J. Smith duly petitioned to rezone Lot 12, Block 28, Saint Anthony Park North located at 1356 Eustis Street from R-3 to RT-1 for the purpose of constructing a duplex, the petition having been certified by the Planning Division on October 3, 1984, as having been consented to by at least 67% of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous property within one year preceding the date of ` the petition; and WHEREAS, The Zoning Committee on October 18, 1984, conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition be granted; and WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on October 26, 1984, and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on November 3, 1984, and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned; and WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council , having been conducted on November 15, 1984 where all interested persons were heard, and the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, COUNCILMEN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Fletcher Drew [n Favor Masanz Nicosla B Schelbel A gai n s t Y Tedesco Wilson Form Approved by ity Attorne Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary BY By Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Ma r for Submission to Council By By WHITE - CITV GLERK PINK - FINANCE GITY OF SAINT PAITL Council CANARV r DEPARTMENT - Fll@ NO. �� /�� CUE -MAVOR • Or indnce Ordinance N 0. l�� Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Section 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul , Sheet No. 1, as incorporated by reference in Section 60.301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows : That property located on the east side of Eustis Street between Chilcombe and Doswell Avenues being more particularly described as Lot 12, Block 28, Saint Anthony Park North, be and is hereby rezoned from R-3 to RT-1. Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. COUNCILMFN Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays ^F1aW+a*.:Sc�►�VM6t� � Drew In Favor Masanz d Nicosia V B scnetbe� Against Y Tedesco Wilson JAN i 0 19�� Adopted by Council: Date Form Approve y City Attorney Certified Pa s oun il e r BY By App by Mayor: Dat ` JA � 5 � Approved ayor for Submission to Council By By PUBLISHE�D J A� 1 � 1985 _ � ;1, ,i� � ( . � _ ,3, }-` i �., _Y � 'S "�f-• ' \ � � ,`w��AI� Y . . . .J `� � . . . , . - �` I i .. ��1 `� § . . � � .. :l�� - ,��., - 1 ' ' �. . -� . ! ��,'t � t .,� . .. . . � :.t "7 •i� i . - t� � � � _ _ �� :•ti . . . � , , �. .. . � r ,.. . , . . � : . _. , .� . , . , . . . � _ . � ,� .� . .��. .. . .. � � - ' - � .. �� • � .- � � y. - .. . .,-,t � '`• `°z* r�: . , , . �, ,, ,.. . -. : � .. .. : � . � - , i - �...� _ � � .` � /�' . \ t� r . ,• . . � ' ,M1 :.', _ . _.' . ' . : _ . .. . . . '.: , z ' i '. �� ' � . . . /, � _ „s;. � .. . ' ' �I: � .. .. . , �'Me�r+�t+laC''�S�, 1984 _ ,.' - ; ;, , . - ,, � , , ,. ,, � - � , � � , ' ' � < � , — '. , . r , �. �s. �� -3'�.aa�!!�.St,a�f�_ �aa��,;s►$ �t#�cm � � ll�b°lloor � , , � G�t� �+(t�i'� � 'i _ , , �° � ,:- ��os�►r 'I�. �.'�4vt�,r�� . , . - , � , � . , - - � : r , , , . � ,, , . .,, . :, , ; _ - t• , ` � . Deta� $�t . . � �� ' ;- �;U _ , , . � , . > . � _ , .�. � . -. , .: . , .; � , T't�a '�� o�c.il td�fa�'s: �l�'�a�€�put�iic �'�; �'veit�I, � :�t�'��►v� �tZe� ��tiaa�-°f : , b� .I�Y�1#.�a;l�ert`�Y.�h �ket t#s+�aGilt'�r�" A'-�► >tta R'!'!-I�-�pAACt� �L"<�.3"�'`�tsC?rs, �t�,.e�a' + r`' ;,�'[� -��=a#c�tr �it- f �b��e�be e�d.I�osi��,.°�; �L'+e�;f�'�d•e�F,��iaca�r {�,st�1 � , -:I7; �d ,;;�a►��fi.�Ap�oAy P�rk �os�`i'j�, ��t'�'+��'�ut¢��#L��'�e �� .rv , , :� ; . �iona a�` �s�fl,:��ing C��'t+� : �!�1�az�tr��i��de'�c�<tc+a�r +�1 c r , �ppra�i pf r�sou�g' the ,r�cauatC l+bt - '�ini,,�, ,af..�e#�o�ii�g �' th�'s��t '� �`e�ily 'tioas�.- -Wf��jroa ��ee� pr�►iKr� � rp��c�p�� +t��d��c�':isp��g � � �.� ��i�1a , _ ` i ' 3�' . . N . `,. µ. � '\ '1... � � - .. •�t' � .• J 1� •� ��.!��' �x 1 � `� / � ,/ - � �� -�F . . �1 / ''I � { k�qr,t B. a�san , � ' • � CiL�;.�]:�ir�-. f , t� •; , � ' � _ <�� , -�` . ,A�D:.1� . { � ';: . . �. , � � � , c�: �it�r. Atto��►sy ' , �` ��_ s, '� � ►sy ' . . , . , _ . � � ' i � . . , , . ; , : , ,, . • ; �,, , _ , F ' • i � �;` � ' � � ;�y � �' ,: , - . , , . . . . - � �.. ... �� . .� � ... �. ' .. . '. . :,,. . .. " ...��'�� .('�� i^: ' , f , . i ! . � �� ' :� Y � ;}� •� .,, �.. .h ^ . . . , . �.. '.. ..�.' .�� , '.... ,.".'. ' .�.�...�. . ... . '.:. . ^ , . �'� � ' � . �'I . . . � ' . . . � ..: .. ...: . � �.;... � � � , .,-� i �., ; . , . ., ; ' : .� . �-.:.. . .. • . .•. ,4 i . . -�. :: . ., � . , . � .- .!` , r i � '- -�.�.� :'�.. . . • .. - . :. �... �.. . . _'. : �.�, . ,.� . F ��' .�•� � :l- __� ' �1 T . . � %% '( �q 1 . . , � �- -,-.� _ ,. � . . ,. ;.. e �` , ,�.� . . . . . ,' . :. . . , , ' , , �. ...,. . . , .��:� ..-.�... .. . .,i..� . , . `::' - �,^' '♦.� .�.t . . . . �. ..t . . _ .j � �:j�. �� _ ` Y f�� y Y ./j ; hi,� . .. � - � 1�.,;t.:. . . . . . . , .. . . ,. - � . . . . , . . . _ . . . . . . ...�.... , . .J . A, _.. _ ..,, .. . � . � � � : � ��r7 R�$G t 4 Y �R '+ l /C/�� CITY OF SAINT PAUL � �� ro DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT `,>m "�� v' DIVISION OF PLANNING ,s,• 25 West Fourth Street,Saint Paul,Minnesota,55102 612-292-1577 GEORGE LATIMER MAYOR November 9, 1984 Albert Olson, City Clerk Room 386 City Hall St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 RE: Zoning File #9649 - Smith City Council Hearing: November 15, 1984 PURPOSE: Rezone 2 lots at 1356 Eustis Street from R-3 to RT-1 to permit construction of a duplex on the northerly lot and conversion of the existing single family home to a duplex. PLANNING COMMISSION DECISION: Approve rezoning of the vacant lot, deny ,,,\� rezoning of the single family house. ZONING COMMITTEE DECISION: Approve rezoning of the vacant lot, deny rezoning of the single family house (4-0) . STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approve rezoning of the vacant lot, deny rezoning of the single family house. SUPPORT• None OPPOSITION: 1 letter was received, a petition with 8 signatures and 2 people testified. The District Council recorr�nended approval of the rezoning of the vacant lot, and denial of the rezoning of the single f amily lot. Dear Sir: On October 18, 1984, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Comnission held a public hearing on this rezoning. A staff report was received recomnending approval of rezoning Lot 12, the vacant lot, to RT-1 and denial of the rezoning for Lot 11, which contains a single family house. The petitioner appeared and stated that the staff recomnendation was acceptable to him. The District 12 Community Council testified in favor of the rezoning of the vacant lot and questioned the ownership of the property. The petitioner stated that he had sold the property on a contract for deed but that the contract had been in def ault and he is now sole owner of the property. At the close of the public hearing, the Committee voted 4 to 0 to approve the rezoning to RT-1 of Lot 12 and to deny the rezoning of Lot 11. � � ' � r��c/—/(77 �7�� Re: William J. Smith Page 2 On October 26, 1984, the Planning Comnission upheld the Zoning Comnittee's recommendation on a unanimous voice vote. This rezoning is scheduled to be heard by the City Council on November 15, 1984. Please notify me by November 14, 1984, if any member of the City Council wishes to have slides of the site presented at the public hearing. Sincerely, �---- - - �;. Patricia N. James City Planner PNJ:Im Attachments � � . � ' �s �� y-i 7� �� . P.�- a 9 .�9.�- i� (i��r�v �� / ' %��- �s�3� PETI'tIOTI TO A�IEND Z+ONRNG CODE �n'I�� CII'Y OF S�AINT PAUL ZONING OFFICE USE ONLY File �� Application ee �5�-�-�,j�e�y� Tentative Hearing Date __i�� ._-�-,�-��/ Number of Lots or � Size of Parcel TO THE HONORABLE�IIIAYOR AdVD CI[Y COUNCII. DATE �_�_y_, 19�f c/o Zoning Office 1100 City Hall Annex • St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Pursuant to Section 64.400 of the St. Paul Zoning Ordinance and Section 462.357 (5) of the Minnesota Statutes, �,P�Q� `_� , the owner of all of the land proposed for rezoning, hereby petitions your Honorable Body to rezone the following described property: Street Address: lot 1 d� �.� b1Q��,8 �1356 Bustis Street�� Legal Description: � _ __ Lot'�1 dc �,� '�]ock 28 } St. tho y ParIc �j��,� $�eX Co�tY. Mn. from a g��,e f � �� _�District to a HT-1 txo fa�ttiily District � forthe purpose of building a duplex on lot 12 T ._ _ . -•----f- _ '_ _' '-� . `4- "' _ _��.. <.._ - -�-r.. — � � .�.��. ' r � � . � Subscribed and sworn to By: Zl.��'`L �•• before this � day - � of l�T9�� Title. �4.c,177,Q/� � � Petitioner . � _ �� Notary Public � ��o„��E� �A�nd�MM�1N1nA%•.�R�.,�:^..�:1n.'.-`.r.,tr�L�FV+,t+� x��r�r�n. �„:z�R � S EP f� 1��± NOTARY M=,��tC_pp��pr�FA Page 1 of � �+a�r couivrY r° D�RT. f�f PL��G � ' Mr con�.�xPir�;auc.�s+,�qe� < �C�°'a��I1�iC DEVE��3PM�NT ,. " Mn�+��,- 4080 3/1/84 . � • � : ��-/l�77 ' ' i�a o� PETITION TO AMEND ZONING CODE PETITION OF WILLIAM J . SMITH FILE N0 . 9649 T0: The Honorable Mayor and City Council C/0 Zoning Office 1100 City Hall Annex St . Paul , Minnesota 55102 Whereas, we the undersigned having signed a petition by William J . Smith, File Number 9649, believe we signed that petition without fully understanding the meaning of that petition. We wish the City to know that we have reservations about the request made in that petition. We urge the City of Saint Paul to allow only the rezoning of Lot 12, Block 28 from R-4 single family to RT-1 two family for the purpose of building a duplex on Lot 12 . NAME ADDRESS � J / � � �f � r:?�,/l'�f'`yG!�+ LLtic-_` �L`�0'�_��( �� ,��'�1 f'S ✓'�G/� ----------- . —' —�— . > _ ,� , .,�, ->i -� ..L. ,� . 4..,_ _y� =��=_< _c' c,�..,_ _� . . Z -�- �-- - -- ----- -- = - —----- --- --- � � _ C i' -��P,-�.-�-�r�—.��..�—��-�--- —�-�.��--��--�'i-��-`�------ � . , � a.,..,_ •. .s ._ � . ', _ _i z �� : � ', -�-=--��r�1=� - r.-...�.''��3�� . _ ��i:_�,__�_��'�^�...,.�'�-�-------- ��'�-?=--��-�`-'�------ - 1�5�,-��- -��---�°-=-�-��- �E``-Y � �`` ------ �-=��—�—�=/`�-�=�=�=�"`�--J��--1_.� � %�-6� �`us�i� �'� �,��-�� - - ---- ---- ----------- ----------------- � ��%y.d �__L �� :�3-�)-�.,�- �L`-Y------ � �N---------------------- ------------------------------- :1��,�� 0 �T 1 J i.yr.� �� ofi��.�. ��-�� Mi�p�t��r��p�� t� _ �. � � . ' : 1��1�077 � � i7a� � STATE OF MINNESOTA) . ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) �f j�� "�_� , being f irst duly sworn, deposes and states that he is the person w cu ate e wit in petition and consent, consisting of ,3 pages; that affiant is inform� and believes that the parties described are the owners respectively of the lots placed immediately following each name, that affiant is informed and believes that each of the parties described above is the owner of property which is within 100 feet from any property owned � �� retitic�n�x c r scic by petitioner within one (1) year preceding the date of this petition which is contiguous to the property described in the petition; that except for none of the parties described above has purchased or is purchasing property rom petitioner contiguous to the above described property within one (1) year of the date of the petition; that t1�is consent was signed by each of said owners in the presence of this affiant, and that the signatures are the true and correct signatures of each and all of the parties so described. /�.�.,2 ��1 s� ��i•�9��"�= �`' Ad�ress �h,¢-<'v�r�' ��z..✓ .si-,�'y �ep one um ers� `f�� ;�.�� Subscribed and sworn to before 7 v � ' �0 7 / �bu�) me this _� day of , 19� � T otary u ic s nni�nnnnn.�nnnr`nn�.v�.v:�.°•.��J�p,;�Y�:'•�,:� � , JO/!��fdl.�cLZF.R I�TARY f't:�tC—tt.I�fP:ESA4A <� � RAN6E11 COUtiTr � .. MY QOMM.E1IPI11�AUG.Z9.19A9 �: tt V VV+ n .'�ppruved as to form - Feb. 80 r,,,�;; .� �., Ylanning Uepartment �� `�� Pa e of � � � � � � : (� �y-/�7 7 � � /�a�� CONSENT OF ADJOINING PROPERTY OWNERS TO REZONING We, the undersigned, owners of property within 100 feet of the total contiguous descriptions of real estate owned by Petitioner or sold by�Petitioner within one year preceding the date of this petition, acknowledge that we have been furnished with the following: 1. A copy of the Petition of William J. Smith ___ __ __ 2. A copy of Sections 64.400 __ through 462•357 ___�, inclusive, of the St. Paul Ordinance; and acknowledge that we are aware of the uses permitted under a � single faaiily... ___ District zoning classification; and hereby consent to the rezoning of the property described in the Petition of IsLillia�m J. Smith _ to a RT-1 two family __ District. RECORD OWNER SIGNATURE LOT BLOCK ADDITION , � _ � � ` ^ z �' S� ��S � J ': ��w C, " � _'.,�.�;��. ` c,�w i. :.;_J�l�r / J`� � ,^u zl !��v �� L �, ,'� C� ,��r/P�' � C f ��:.�, 7 ��.� � C � l� i ✓ �� i- � �-�i�! :%� /� � � �- S� ✓ .�� 2 "! C�) , � � __� � . : ,: ti-�i � : • �.-=.i '::;; � .�' ._� �t_.� - �:�.-z� -��a � D,s� u.� -/ ,_...._ �S�D 71 � �� >> � � . � _l�� ✓,�� . �-� � . �-�L -a� ��' " � . � , � �. _i,��C"'� �v � �� ; ��i��.�/J�� / � �z\ � , , � � , �`�.�" J ' � Petitions shall not be considered as officially filed until the lapse of 7 working days after a petition is received in the Zoning Office. Any signator of any petition may withdraw his name therefrom by �,��ritten request within that time. '! A.�� F I�.E ��!�. Pa e 2 of I g �— � : � � � : ��r-i� �y � � �ya�� P7INUTES OF THE 7_O�JING COf�tP�iITTEE IN CITY COUt�CIL CHAh1aCRS, ST. PAUL, MINfdESOTA OtJ OCTOf3ER 1.8 , 19�4 PRESENT: P��es. Summers , Tracy and Zienan; f�ir. Panyal of the Zoning Committee ; h1�•. Seyal , Assistant City Attorney; f�1s. Lane of the Division of Housing and Guilding Cocie Enforcement; Ms. Murphy, hts. James and f�ir. P1cGuire of the Planning Divisior� Staff. Af3SEPJT: P1me. P�orton; Messrs. Galles , Lanegran , and Levy The meeting was chaired by Joseph Pangal , Chairm�n. 4�JILLIAP4 J. SP�ITH (#9549) : Rezone property located at 1356 Eustis from fz-3�to'�R7-��rto create�two duplexes. The applicant was present. There ti,�as opposition present at the hearing. i�ts. James shoG��ed slides and revieYaed the staff report with a recommendation to approve rezoning of lot 12 to RT-1 and deny rezoning of lot 11. She said that 1 letter in opposition and a petition with 8 names in partial cpposition UJdS submitted. Qill Smith, 1632 E. Shakopee Avenue, Shakopee , stated that he wanted to put an efficiency apartment in the front of the house and 3 bedrooms and a ruok area in the back. Ile will accept what the staff has recommended, how;�ver. ��is. Zieman asked him if it was okay a�ith him if they were to approve the rezoning of lot 12 and deny rezoning of lot 11. t�r. Sr�ith stated that it v;as , since the house doesn' t comply ��rith zoning requirements. Mr. �angal asked him if he 4JdS the fee owner, or if anyone else had an interest in the property. Mr. Smith stated he was fee owner, and no one else has interest in the property. Ann Copeland, District 12 Community Organizer, read a letter to the Zonirig Committee stating that Lhe district council had met with the ap�licant and neighbo�s of the area. She said that the final decision of the district council was to ayree with immediately surrounding neighbors of the property and support rezoning of lot 12 and oppose rezoning of lot 11, conversion of the existing house. She also asked if Specialty P9anagerient Company held the deed to the property, since they are on record in the Taxation Department as the owners. Mr. Smith stated that they did hold the deed on the property for t��ro years, but as of September of this year he now owns the property. . - � : ��t/�/�77 � ' /7�� File #�9649 Page 2 Robert Shoffner, 1339 Eustis , spoke in opposition, he stated the �opography of the site is very hi�h , and that it �vtould take a lot of �nyineering to build a usable garage. Ne said that Eustis cannot handle a lot of parkinc� since there are apartments located across the street and the tenants park on the street and it is also a snow emergency �route. He also said he felt the ti�ahole area should be left as an �-3 use. Joan Taylor, 1353 arompton , spoke in opposition. She stated that in tf�e winter the alley in back of the property is nearly impassable. She also ��as concerned about who the dev�+oper of the land will be. She said that Specialty iianagem�nt is still on record in the Taxation Department as being t{�e owner of 1:he property. She said she felt the matter sf�ould be deferred until further investiyation is done. f�ear�ing no �'ur�ther testirnony, h1r. Pangal closed the publ ic I�earing portio of the meeting. ��s. Zier,�an asked if the lot vras 50 feet �r�ide and if a 4 car garage could fit on the lot. She also asked if any site plans had beer� submitted. P�9s. Jar�es said it was a 50 foot lot and that it would be possible to have garage parking for 4 cars. She said that no site plan had been submitted yet. P4s. Tracy asked if off-street parking would be required for the new duplex if it were allo�tied to be built. ��is. Ja�nes stated tr?at off-street parking would be required. hls. Surnmers asked if ther�e was sufficient square footage on the lot, and w��rted to knovd if, without a site plan, off-street parking will be allo�aed without variances. Ms. Jarnes stated there was adequate square foo�age on the lot , and br°iefly er,plained what vaould be required in the site plan. i�1s. Zieman moved approval of the rezoning of lot 12 Lo RT-1 and denial of rezoning of lot 11, vrhich would allow no conversion of the existing . single family hame, based on findings 1 through 9 and the staff analysis. P1s. Tracy seconded the motion, vahich passed on a roll call vote of 4-0. Submitted by: Approved by: �;�_f_"_�c�.�_ „��1 t==-��c�iY1�C.�/ - V /�) �� _�.:;�� .�.�. Patricia N. James �Josepfi Pangal , Chair�„y�'n � � � � � : ��/(�77 � /��e�'� ZONING COP-1MITTEk STA1=F REPORT ----------------------------- ------------------------------ FILE 79649 1 . APPLICANT: William J. Smith DATE OF HEARING: 10/18/84 2. CLASSIFICATION: Rezoning 3. LOCATION: 1356 Eus`tis (east side between Chilcombe & Doswell ) 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lots 11 and 12, Block 28, St. Anthony Park North 5. PRESENT ZONING: R-3 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: Sec. 60.420 6. STAFF INVESTIGATION & REPORT: DATE 10/9/84 BY Patricia N. James ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------�--- A. PURPOSE: Rezone two lots from R-3 to RT-1 to convert a single family home to a duplex and to construct a duplex on the vacant lot. B. SUFFICIENCY: Petition found sufficient by Planning Division on October 3, 1984. Parcels eligible: 16; parcels needed: 11; parcels signed: 11. C. PARCEL SIZE: Each lot is 50' (Eustis) X 150' = 7,500 sq. ft. D. EXISTING LAND USE: Lot 11 contains a single family dwelling with a garage in the rear. Both lots bank steeply above Eustis . The site has alley access . E. SURROI�NDING LAND USE: North: Single family and duplex residential (R-3) East: Single f amily residential (R-3) South: Single family and duplex residential (R-3) West: Multi-family residential (RM-2) F. ZONING HTSTORY: The site was zoned "A" Residence prior to 1975, and R-3 thereafter. G. FINDINGS. � lo Petitioner proposes converting the existing building to a duplex and constructing a new duplex on the lot to the north. 2. Land Use Plan policy 4.1-5 states: The city will establish criteria to allow sensitive reuse and conversion of existing housing structures. The criteria will address density, lot characteristics, structural characteristics, parking, open space and neighborhood impact. 3. Housing Plan policy 1-5 recorr�nends duplexes on scattered vacant infill sites in lower density areas. 4. The Planning Commission has developed guidelines to implement these Comprzhensive Plan policies. 5. Each lot has a frontage of 50' and an area of 7,5Q0 sq. ft. meeting the first guideline. 6. The lots are in a mixed density neighborhood with apartment buildings across Eustis, meeting the second guideline. 7. The existing house is 958 sq. ft. at ground level according to Tax Department records, and is 1 3/4 stories, for an estimated total floor area of 1,676.5 sq. ft. This is smaller than the 1,800 sq. ft. required. 8. There is a tv�o-car garage in the rear of lot 11, meeting the guideline for converstion of existing struci:ures. ,, 9. The District 12 Plan r•ecorr�nends maintaining all'� existing residential uses in St. Anthony Park. . _ ,. � � : � � � � : �,'_��-� � � ��a� File �9549 Page 2 H. STAFF ANALYSIS: Both lots meet the conditions set forth in the Planning Co��nission's inl:erim duplex conversion guidelines. Ho��ever, the existing structure on Lot 11 is smaller than that required for conversion. I. STAFF RECOMPIENDATION: Based on findings 1-9 and the staff analysis , staff recommends approval of the rezoning of lot 12 to RT-1, and denial of the rezon�ng of 1 ot 11. r ,, i . : - � . � : � � ��y-� �so � � i�� a°� �2� ��1��' 12 ��1��Jt�t`�Y ��UN��L ��° '�� y°�A 2��0 �ar�pde� • S�.Paut, I�titt�nesota 55114 � -�9 646-8884 / � L�- WE57MID�NAY-� . OCtObel� 1 5 , 1984 �oning Office Ci ty Ha7 1 Annex St. Paul , Minnesota 55102 Re: File No . 9649 The District Council has discussed this proposed rezoning at both a Physical Committee and District Council meeting . After discussions with hoth the owner of the property, William Smith, at the Physical Committee meeting , and at the District Council meeting with the neighbors , the District Councii approved the rezoning of onl the vacant lot on a 6 to 5 vnte with two abstensions . Mr . Smith indicated to the Council that he would build a duplex similar to one now located around the corner on Dos- well Street and that he would provide a double garage for each unit of the duplex . Mr. Smith further indicated to both the District Council and the neighbors that he planned to rent the units to families . The Council discussed this at length because it concerned spot rezoning of a lot in the midst of single family housing, although there are apartment buildings across the street. There was a division of opinion on the Council but the ultimate decision was to eoncur with the opinion of the immediately surrounding neighbnrs . Sincerely j Cl� G - Ann Copel d Community Organizer AC: sb cc ; William Snith Richard Cain �—� l�0�� ......,.,,°„` ' . ' •� C 1 TY O F A!N T P . ;� '��r r o'nU =w�"; •��'q � . 1 �• '"� x; DEPART�NSENT OF CO,'vtMUNITY SER CES T O l' '�i s`y Ptijrtl��1(I( �s '�,• � DIViSiON OF HOUSING AND BUILDING CODE ENFORCEIvIEN7 J�4j''� "" 445 City Hall,St. Paul, Minnesota 551U2 'n�m�..noS�'• GEORGE LATIMER 612-298-4212 MAYOR — �F��9��_��I ,ErJ October 23, i 984 �lA�'��il�� `�. - �� r,IT�� r�� ,,��► William J . Smith 1632 E. Shakopee Ave. �CT 2 3 1�� Shakopee, MN 55379 RE: 1356 �Eustis St . Dear Mr. Smith: At the public hearing before the Planning Commission 's Zoning Committee on October 18, 1984 , evidence was presented to suggest that the building _ at the referenced property has already been converted to a two-family dwelling . If your application to rezone this property to RT-1 is denied by the City Council , the second unit must be removed and the structure deconvert ed to a single family dwelling . We wi.11 be setting up an inspection shortly after the Council 's decision , if it is for denial , to verify its use as a single family dwelling . Questions reg arding this matter may be addressed to 4•Jendy Lane at this office. • � Si cerely, ti'�� `�, �'�-�-c�Q-�-F7��c.� Glenn A. Erickson Zoning Admi.nistrator GAE/WL:km �. cc:�, atricia James , Planning Division Ann Copeland , District 12 . �Fs9.��n . : � � � � : � �=i�� , . . ��a� �-� °� ( o Qv� . y V�5 i 6�►�� R � ��lJ�� i �OU1�1�I� r �2,� �� "� °ZA 2350 �ar��den • St.P�u1, IO�snnesofa 55114 9 6�6-8884 � WEST MIDWAY--, Oc to ber 1 5 , 1984 E�i��L=�`�� `� e'Y: PL4i'�t�{f'JC-, �)�' �EC• -- r.�Tti• �r� =:R :��,;,; �oning Office Ci ty Ha] 1 Aranex OCT 1 9 1984 St. Paul , P4innesota . 55102 Re: File No . 9649 The District Councii has discussed this proposed rezoning at both a Physical Committee and District Council meeting . After discussions with both the owner of the property, William Smith , at the Physical Committee meeting , and at the District Council meeting with the neighbors, the District Council approved the rezoning of only the vacant lot on a 6 to 5 vote with two abstensions . Mr. Smith indica�ed to the Council that he would build a duplex similar to one now located around the corner on Dos- well Street and that he would provid� a double garage for each unit of the duplex . Mr. Smith further indicated to both the District Council and the neighbors that he plann�d to rent the units to families . The Council discussed this at length because it concerned spot rezoning of a lot in the miast of single family housing, although there are apartment buildings across the street, There was a division Qf opinion on the Council but the ultimate decision was to eoncur with the opinion of the immediately surrounding neighbors . Sincerely j �1� G � Ann Copei d Community Organizer AC: sb cc : Wiliiam Smith Richard Cain �(J � , ` . • � a" �CF.p�y,�� `, �•N "r-'� � �a t ''' (`N `/�/—O � /�t'�� • �� `at�i i `'v�� +ri�� fi. �� ~` v, /7�e� 24i7 Dcs�:ell. Avenue Ct, paul$ Asinnesota 55108 16 October I.�84 Zraning Ccm..�ittae 2S W, �th Street ` S±�. Paul, ;�Sinn:�sc�� 5iCs2 = �: � �_ ) :�.t?: .i.�.iC? �' ' ��' - �Y'i`F:'': � '..t:� :. d.i 1.: . B�.CCK 2�� St. t�.17t;10:Tr �-'ii?�� `��:�;i.:ii J I �m sorry T am not ab�.e �o atterxt the hearing in �erson, but arranQements T made last year take me out of the counfiry at this ti�e, I a�; ?:Oi in favor af rezoning this property trom R-�4 to RTd1 . idii�,iam Smirh stopped by my home wi�h a request to sign a petition to have the "lot" rezoned so a dtzp�ex could be built. I bel�.eved he was referring to the vacant lot north �f the dwel2y_n�; at 1356 Eusti.s, I did xu�t sign tY�e oetitior. because I wanted to think it over . The fol.),.owzn� day I receiced a telephotie call fror.: Ann Copelarxi, �istrict 12, asking how I fe�t about a pcssibie rezon.in� a� 1356 Eustis so the house couyd be con- verted to a du�lex, and rezenin�, of the vacant lot so a duplex could be built, I tdther srom thzs that the "lot" is �oin� to be divided� I believe the house has alread, beer. converted to a;:her than single �ar�ily use, I am ;�t in favar of rezonir.; any propertg just �o maKe i1Ze�;a1 chanF;es 1ega1. Alsop the parkin,g facilities at the apartment b�xildings across the street fro:n these lchs, cr "lot", are ir�dequate and rr�an� tenants park on the street often partially blocicing my dr•iveway, This area daes ziot need any more mul.tiple dwell�.ngs, Sincerely, t'�v�7!'7f�/ ,�!-P�r'�,e��j"�=� / ' V d Carro'lyh Shephef�d cc: Ann Copeland, District 12 Joseph Pangal Ga}le Summers Gladys P�Iorton Joseph Levy John Galles Kathleen Zieman David Lanegran Nancy Tracy _ ,_-t. < - 7 ' ��. ,. `:r' v..,..... , ' '� „ � , _ . - _ $ . _ _ _ .. :, . _��__.. _ _�- � ��-��---. . �^ . �:.� ' {� . ' _ t -�. ,�. �_ _ . . �� . � o o ��o c� Q -��o �o a ;�-`�� ,� � �;.� � � � �.. , Q ,. ,- �� ,� �:1: � M1 �� . � � � � � �� / ^i � �,f�� !t�� - `.�.j.a.SsiSwfO�w.. 1 / f ( / � � ' • I �� t _ _ Y-. �„ � � i �', I � � �� ;: �,: : ._ . _ , ., � I - - - �, o �o ,� a o ;o a o � b a,:c� lbi o � � � �= l -� � , . , �. � , � , - - - -- . a V� LE � i 4 � E A!! �. �� j � A-� � o , s 5 _-:`� � .�`�-�� --- - - � ° ° � ° � ° � ° - ' ,�o, :� �� ,'f - .,� V , � ' /,} �z � \ �%� \ . ; L o � 'i � t�. � � �� 1 � __ � x _. I �� O � � � . . __ �`-. :; .� .� a o � oo � o 000 0 � 0 � o � , , , , � � , , � , � .� _ � _ � , , � �� ' G � lL.C � � � � c� �`tK��r ��, �� ', �n -o- o �-' - _ �.; � - _ -- -- r�, o 0 0 �o 0 0 0 0 0 � o � o �_ ? = o� o o � � � o � � -- � _. �._ � �.� �`` _ : �p C °'t�� a .� � f�:� �: � � � � � �J � ; � � , � o.o � o ��: -� � �� ~ -- -� - - - - ' � �! i p Q O , - - -� �1 � QQ O Z�S; Oi � O O ' � A - - O � � � L L. o 0 0 � 5 ; � � - --- � : _ � � `p O � � � O_�- � -�p- : O , �,, O ,p p � O a,�J � �A � � ` ;�:; � f ,��' � =�' � � � ,; .; _ � O tn j �� ; �� ....� �. �' �� ,. 0 p -- --�j ^ .��- hi � � � � 0 � : a � 00 ,� _ , ��- � ��. � _ � � . �� i .� � � � �, . 4: � � ��1;. . 000�00000ao+ � � o � c� :r; o ., : x. (, 1 i 1 � � � . ,,Y'j �`-- � � i � , � �� - � � � �. :� �� O T-- , � (� ` � � t � � � � ? _ � i � � � i � �,(" � �'� . ��- � ( t � � , O O � �� ( � � : 1 � ` \ �\ � � �-- � 'o� ';;Q �� '�' � � O , ; � . o e � � � ��:::� �� ,t• ,r/_� �� c� a��.i�____ L EG E iV D AP�LICANT �� ---�- Znn?!�G DIS7RICT 8�JiVO:aRY � G �/,� Sl�BJECT PROPERT� �' L��'11� PUi�::��OSE � � � �� O 0�� 1MiLY P�aUVi�� '�' '�� "��°",� DISTRIST �� j TV�O FAMlLY � FiLE N0. �� -�j- ,� MULTIPLE FAMlL.Y DATE - o � n COMMERCtAL SCALE� l��= 200` _ NORTt� _ � �` � »DUSTRIAL. n�aP rro. � � SA�0.�T pAU� i'LANNING 8oat�D V VACANT � �� . -... . � .. . ..� .. ._. ., _. .. . :..� , . ... . . .-r _ . �`,r ,.--�. . .. . , ...� ,'. ., . f_ _ q-' F � � ` r , �'�� . ° �`` � � �• � 4 �{,��..�� 'A . ' `t ,:1� f� �t a.' '�1��..'e�L��*� "#'( r�d�� ti . . , :�. �� ,. ... � t� } c � �. t1 �- �"{ r� A ,. 1 Y yY ( ,j �r.4 � ' '!' t . � '3�ij � �! k i t �'.� � � . 1 M1. � � ��{�S F 1 l I� , . . S , . , � :� �k �. ��t �Y� A � ... , - , � , " � . . . .�. �- } ) J � ' � - � � 4 , t=ihi�t . ; ; . ' ' ' .- . � . ' ".�. � :. . . ... , . �. .�. v- , � 1 A` - .' . .. �'. ,k I 1. ��} ] �� N Y5. �� ' r _�3�� ,I.�'.M� � � �� . t . I d \' ..r� }�' ?,t. � � � . .. . .:�i c. � � ��;f s�:�<,�, ��;�� . �. . ,f r f' 1 '�,i, a y �t / , � ;� •.i � �� yt� i.� � . . . _ . / . . A r ., f.� s � ��'�1+9�7t`�j�lC'�� R3�� . , � .,�� '� �: , _ Ri+4`IY� �F�N'� 4r�;.�{�� .;,; . , � ,� ,4 ' � /t�,-a � �lc", a+ir.'t �� ' `�� . . .� f .� i- � �� r " a/.�car ��i'C r � - � � ,i � . ,i �+�l 1 �' ' � ., '` ` r' +,- �� a.,.. .;, � F :�. f �, :',' ., . . �., ., , . � . - ., . . . d �� 4 � � �'��s�.�'�� ► �ili,sc� t�ty od" C,r.;:�-��r.� ��r �� x�o� � ; s # �: � , , � . , . ,�� y�y ■'�y _ . ♦��y � � a��k�;,,.T�. was ��1�':��!�� l� E �'� . {�{ T �i < �� ' ` , .. ,. : . ., . . , ., /' w[ i �j " ±Y_, a Y � _ 'S"�, _ _ j kr i F` r' � - - _ . ' S .�,.. �.r Vi� �1"��,��i =# ' � � ` � ,. � , '� �. x ��t�� .��u� " � �. + � , �, r � �� ..� / r 1 .,�{ t �k. .. y�� . \'. +4"�i�'` i . . ;1 1 I y. ��'k��. � b� . i `` . ; �,;� � � � ,. �.� r l . 3 f � �1� �v �, S, �+�r'� - - � - ._ � � r� � ,�,. � � t ' 4 � .� � � i i L.i� � ��aWi4� ' 'r . � ,� a �`�'. � .s� . � ^t. - ' ' � �� + c. �_, � - , + f., 1 { �.�. e � � � t� �� j �k �' . �. � 'i d �' � � , :� � � � �•, - . ,-t ' w , . " r; l �' � � r t �, ' + u � 1 � �� T �? � .. � .. { � � 4V'F�� ' � � � � �� '� � � � �� 's � ' l � / �i� � \� r ''�x � � S . ;� :'I ;` . • I :� ', ^'.,/ _�'f '� ,l; � C .. .i , � t � �. ��,, �� ' o� � � '.�y ; .,4 .. - � �h:e'�i r { � � '�;T 3 �' (`� I `Fr � 1rt��Y 4 _ . . t .�� - �� ZF t � x �� }`�� ; (�� }� � ;�� x� i � Y � �7`�Y�'. ! ''�! 4 � ~ V r r l t. � � � �� r � f t - � i 1..Z t�. �f� � t��}� \ 4 . 1 Y °4 4 ��S " t G�l l I � i a �t� t � E � r« � r � � ' t � � ., t . �r � I � � � =I '�� e . i� y i 1 '� �, � r . r � � � � �� 1��°�I , .,� ,A,' . ('�. _ X. _ � � l ss�,7 i.�2 %f ` :. . . ;� I f f k}- 'W. 1 , � J � ±� 4� '� . . �\ p i t h i � t t r '{ �F �, � � P i � .�E r � :1�� , `i - ., 2 r ' ,� ' s� .x �rr. i� r > t � ti¢a {_x� ,f i z -1� x'• , � ,+. t ' f ;� L� `,i� � ��r _.ti ,� '��-� r` ' f �� : r�{� � `�� "�.Y �, ,� �, - ..;_ � A1 �,;� � ��} �i�� . .,. . , . .. .t ti'. . . . . . . .. ,. „ ._ , . f.r` . � > _ . .�z;r_ .,, ..� v � 63—?.. ',*� �.Yr� �. o . . . ._,. � � . -� - ' � ��-��6 � � � �� : �� L'� C� �„ STATE OF MINNESOTA ) County of Ramsey ) ss. CITY OF SAINT PAUL ) �.,y I� . . . . , . .Albert B., Olson. . . . . . . .�. . . . . , .. _ „City Clerk of the c� w �.: City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have .-C�� compared the attached copy of Council File No. . 84�1677_ . . . . . . . , . . �,_, as adopted by the City Council. . . . . .JanuarX.10�.. . . . . _ . , 1985. . . , � and apprwed by the Mayor. . . . . . . . . . .JanuarX.l5�, . . . . . . . . . . 1985, . . . with the original thereof on file in my office. I further certify that said copy is a true and correct copy of said original and the whole thereof. WITNESS my hand and the seal of the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota this , , , . ,llth. . . . , day of . , ,Apri1 , . . . . . . . , ,A.D. 1985. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . �.. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . __ City Clerk. �; , . r - �� ',;,, -� .f' � ��r, ld�Y. �l -: ! } a� �, : ,./�-;i �'�.��;: F ;' � ��1� a, `.� �1 �� t. �� . i - � fA 3.. � � 6�0 �U 4,�iu - : / wH17E - GITY CLERK � � . P�riK - FINANCE TT COLI1C11 ��A��AFA-eDEPARTMENT G I Tlr O�"F �A�NT �A lJ L /{� 7 ' Bl.li�T - MAYOR ' � . Flle NO. ��_ �`� / � � • ~ � � Z/LGIIZCP. Ordinance N O. I��6'� , Presented By , �- � Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date An Ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul � Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof. �WHEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes, § 462.357 and § 64.210 of the Legislative Code, William J. Smith duly petitioned to rezone Lot 12, Block 28, Saint Anthony Park North located at 1356 Eustis Street from R-3 to RT-1 for the purpose of constructing a duplex, the petition having been certified by the Planning Division on October 3, 1984, as having been consented to by at least 67% of the owners of the area of the property to be rezoned, and further having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the total contiguous property within one year preceding the date of � the petition; and 41HEREAS, The Zoning Committee on October 18, 1984, conducted a public hearing for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to Section � 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning � Commission that the petition be granted; and � WHEREAS, The Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its � meeting held on October 26, 1984, and recommended that the City Council approve �j � the petitio-�; and � WHEREAS, Notice of a public hearing before the City Council on the said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City an November 3, 1984, and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected prop�rty and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property sought to be rezoned ; and WHEREAS, A public hearing before the City Council , having been conducted on November 15, 1984 where all interested persons were heard, and the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore, COUHCI[,MEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: Fletcher Drew I[1 FBVOC Masanz Nicosfa B scne+bei Against Y �Tedesco Wilson Form Approved by ity Attorne Ac'.+�.pted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary By f3y Approved by Mayor: Date Approved by Ma r for Submission to Council By gy � ->��n — FiNANCE � T� = .r+nav ,. o[nqRTrnENT GITY 0.,�� '�T,AINT r�� COURCII / y✓J �;.JE +— MAYOR � FIIE' NN. �� /�Y / I • } ��GLZ/t�n�� Ordinance NO. .�C�' Presented By Referred To Committee: Date Out of Committee By Date. THE COUNCI� OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: " Section 1. .� . . 't That the zoning map of the City of Saint Pa�+1 ,- Sheet No. 1, as incorpor�ted by reference in Section 60.301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended„is hereby further amended as follows : ; ' That property located on the east side of Eustis - Street between Chilcombe and Doswell Avenues being � more particularly described as Lot 12, Block 28, ' � Saint Anthony Park North, be and is hereby rezoned . ' � from R-3 to RT-1. � , � Secti on 2. . __ . � This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirt C�+ y (30) days from and �:. after its passage, approval and publication. COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays Requested by Department of: -�tau�er,�vV`�Y6t� Drew .�_ In Favor Masanz � Nicosia scneibe� Against Bx Tedesco YYiison �q �dopted by Council: Date `'�� »�� Form Approve y City Attorney • Certified Pa s �d oun il e r By By � �''� A roved b a or for Submission to Council �pp by Mayor: Dat • JA � � �y�1 PP Y P,y gy �t;��s�;to JAP� 1 � i985 � ,.w _ • � E . � ' ' ' r • �? �t. . � � � . �, �« �. � � � � �� :� � :� � � � ' � �� J v� v',' n� c7 � 1�. � �`: � � � �i =. V�� q 4 m � �� : ;�, c� .;. � .�:, �� r �. � n. o �. : � � �� '�/s,�� '�� '�. •, � + y `� -}� � C .. ;n � � 4, � � � � :.� 2_�� ., � � �, �± � r -s .,� a.. � (� r��y fa � n � Z �c.l r � :� ;� O� � y 3 m (� •` o � ��,� 7f %� � c,. .°,-*�• � � � � O �,a.`� C) (�'j a o � s D ti�- � f� � ° � �" � �, � � � , � � � �' m ,.� � -. ...... � , _ %� x n n, � � � ''"1� �.._ N � � c . ,� � � a c r► � .�� . _ • . ��KR�S 4FFlC S7 PAUI, ��'fNN: � � � ��'��0�� , , ST. P�4UL CITY COUN ''°�� .�b- PU6LIC HEAR ING �� C�1�1�� CrJ'f �, M � ZONING --�'a�' �� T g�; ; S�� i� . �r�� T0: Property Owners within 350 feet; Representatives of Planning District 12 FIL E N 0. 9649 PAGE PURPOSE Rezone property from R-4 to RT-1 to create two duplexes. LOCATION 1356 Eustis Street (E.S. between Chilcombe & Doswell) PETITIONER WILLIAM J. SMITH H E A R IN G �ursday, November �5, 1984 lo:o� A.M. Cit Council Chambers, 3rd Floor City Hall - Court House Q U E S TIO N S Zoning 298-4154 (patricia James) Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, Minnesoia 55102 Cega1 DeScription: Lots 11 & 12, Block 28, St. Anthony Park North - Notice sent 11-2-84 � . � -� . - � � � �--�� . . , , . � , _ �� ST. P�4UL CIT` Y COI�NClL PUBI. iC H �ARlNG NOTIC� � ZON1 �U� ,.��- t, �� . �' T0: Property Owners within 350 feet; Representatives of Planning District 12 FIL E N 0. 9649 PAGE PURPOSE Rezone property from R-4 to RT-1 to create two duplexes. LOCATION 1356 Eustis Street (E.S. between Chilcombe & Doswell) PETi�iorvE� WILLIAP�I J. SMTTH � HEARI�IG Thursday, Novem6er �5, 1984 io:oo A.M. Citv Council Chambers, 3rd Floar City Hall - Court House �U�ST�ONS Zoning 298-4154 (Patricia James) Contact the Zoning Section of the Planning and Economic Development Department, Room 1101, City Hall Annex, 25 W. 4th Street, St. Paul, MinnesoLa 55102 __ _ . . . _.. .. . . � Lega1 Description: Lots 11 & 12, Block 28, St. Anthony Park North iJotice sr.nt �1-2-84 ' . � � ; ��`�/-/� �y , . ��a� NOTlCE OP SiA�II�Tti . . PatiWn N+Amwe , . .---�-_-�;>. j A p�ition h°v�°'R tr�m.�i'�9!!ettinL fhat the 2a�niea Orrlia�iloi 4t t6e Chy"o�$t.Piul, bl�8meddod ao as to 3�emot tram R-!to R7-1 V�dar¢�ibed as Lot}lI A�14,Btodt�!. St. Anthony Park Iimrt6. T�e ptoperty is lxated at 139tl tmtis St�eet.7he Copadl oi t4e Citr�ol�St iPaul�e�liaN tMe 1BW bd �ber,1. at 36�O�L1�in tlM�oype{l '�'La� nth� ii�po;said.Clq.+��t: arid time md P1ao4�e Catn4ll-�i11 B�rr�ll yersoas aQd �Lt ob�srtsc;as,'a�a ' �sis�t,.,�.ave t� nce ��a mcea ors�ao.iee�. a�sa�s.or.sox ci�c�x � (Novanber 3,19Bq - i ' � lst � - %�'�y � �2nd �/.;? -.a7�-�'�� 3rd /- .J�� Adopted /- /d -�� Yeas �aYs ��-- �C� 7 ' � DREW ' ��' }•,,, ' �t� 7�,{� �7�7 i �� ;+'��,'� l'1L1S L"11`I Z �1L�y� �.'�.r . . . . •,�'.�i;� .. NICOSIA .� "�?�� 1 ��a SCHEIBEL l•�,� ' t�,�s SONNEN �'�i:o's--�'�: :._ WILSON MR. PRESIDENT TEDESCO —.�, , —.. i{�� ._�.�:; t:;��;�� . �� ' � l �� - ; ,, ! i �-: � '.-