98-562Council File # 16 ' SL a-
Green Sheet # /sZ�� /
RESOLUTION
O� �� r �, r A CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
�lVH �
Presented By t�� ��
Refened To
�.
Committee:
57
WI�REAS, the licensee East Side Hospitality, Inc. d/b(a H' crest Entertainment Center
(License ID No. 82839), located at 1560 White Beaz Avenue rth in Saint Paul failed cigazette
compliance checks on January 14, 1997, and again on April , 1998; and
WHEREAS, on Apri12, 1997, under C.F.97361 th Saint Paul City Council imposed a fine
in the amount of $200.00 for a first violation of sellin cigazettes to a minor, as identified in the
Presumptive penalties for violations, Saint Paul Le ' lative Code §324.07(b), the penalty for a
second violation being a$400.00 fine; and
WI�REAS, on both occasions, the licen e did not have a valid cigarette license for the
license periods 1496-1997 or 1997-1998, b has since obtained a cigazette license for the current
license period; and
WHEREAS, the licensee should required to pay the license fee far a cigarette license
during a111icense periods for which ' is known that he offered cigarettes for sale to the public;
now therefare, be it
RESOLVED, that the censee is hereby ordered to pay the standard license fee in the
amount of $317.00 for a cig ette license for the 1996-1997 license period. The licensee is
fitrther ordered to pay the dazd late fee for obtaining the cigazette licenses for the 1996-1997
and the 1997-1998 lice e periods in the amount of $158.50 for each license period. The
licensee is further ord ed to pay a fine of $400.00 for the second violation of the sale of tobacco
ar tobacco products a minor. The total of fees and fines owed equals $1,034.00.
Said pen ty shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection wi thirry (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature
by the Mayo .
1 ��-S�a-
a
3 This resolution and the acrion of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts
4 contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the compliance report, and such
5 azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were nQt
6 contested by the licensee. /
��
��� �
�� �\
r -��
V
ORiG1NAL
Adopted by C cil: ➢ate
Adoption rti£ied by Council Secte[avy
SY:
Approved by Mayoi: Date
BY:
Requested by Department oE:
- //�i �!!� rf�Y_'il -
Poxm Approved by City Attoxney � / /
� �1� �/' � r�.�
Approved bY Mayo or Submissnon Co Council
BY:
LIEP
X1MAC7 PERSON 8 PF10NE
Robert Ressler
�1UST BE ON COUNCIL AGQJI
June 24, 1998 -
6f12J98
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
qg -st�-
No 62161
v�.,u,�� ��,.�.._
❑ fl1YAiTOR1EY ❑ CRYq.FAK
❑w�wcu��a�aMCFSm�. ❑wu�c��m�n.ecto
❑r�vo�troMwamsrAxt) ❑
(CL1P ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR�
Concerning adverse action against licenses held by East Side Hospitality, Inc., dba
Hillcrest Entertainment Center, 1560 White Bear Avenue. (Uncontested)
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CNIL SERVICE COMMISSIQN
IFAPPROVED
RSONAL SERViCE CONiRACTS MUST ANSWER iHE FOLLOWIN6 QUESTiONS:
Has this PersarJfim erer waked untler a contiact fw this departmwR')
YES NO
Has Mie persaMrm e.er been a ciry empbyee7
YES NO
Daes thi6 P���m P�ss a sldli no[ riom�alNP�ssed bY arry curreM city emPbYee?
YES NO
Is this peisoNfirm a qrp�etl vendoR
YES NO
AMOUNT OP TRANSACTION S COST/REVENUE BUDfiETm (CIRCAE ONE! YES NO
ACTNI7Y NUMBER
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Peg Birlr, City AttOrney q g ��` ��
J
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colemm; Mayor
June 11, 1998
Charles F. Senkler
Civil Division
400 City Hall Tekphone: 612 266-8710
IS lYestXeIIoggBlvd Facsimile: b11298-5679
Saint Pau{ Minneso7a 55101
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING � r�•
CiO;S�iC�i �?S?a: =:, .,_:;: _�..,t
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 White Beaz Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55106
�L y'
RE: All licenses held by East Side Hospitality, Inc. d/b/a Hillcrest Entertainment Center for the
premises located at 1560 VJhite Beaz Ave. in St. Paul
License ID No. :82839
Our File Number: G98-0165
Dear Mr. Senkler:
Please take notice that a hearing conceming the above-named establishment has been scheduled for
5:30 p.m., Wednesday, June 24,1998 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City
Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the
City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts conceming the
failwe to obtain a cigarette license for the license yeazs 1997 and 1998 while still selling cigazettes
at the licensed establishment, and the April 1, 1998 unlawful sale of cigazettes to a minor have not
been disputed. You will have an oppoitunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written
remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Ve�y yours, ��
.-,.tti
Virginia . Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Ann Woods, Executive Director, District 2 Community Council, 2169 Stillwater Ave., St.
Paul MN 55119
q g - S�a-
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING
Licensee Name: East Side Hospitality, Inc, d!b/a Hillcrest
Entertainment Center
Address: 1560 White Bear Avenue North
Councii Hearing Date: June 24, 1998
Violation: 1.) Failure to have appropriate cigarette license
for the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 license periods
2.) Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor
Minn. Stat. § 609.685
St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07
Date: Aprit 1, 1998
Place: Licensed Premises
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
Immediate Suspension of aff ticenses until alt license fees and
fines have been paid including:
1.) license fees and late fees for the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998
license periods �
2.) $400.00 fine (2" violation of unlawful sale to minors)
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. April 10, 19981etter to Charles Senkler
4. License information
5. Compliance Report
OFFICF OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Peg Bir. y At[orney � e �S `.+
6 �r'
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colemmt, Mnyor
Civll Divirion
400 City Hall
I S West Kettogg Blvd
Saint Paul, �nnesom 55702
Telephone: 611 166-8 710
Facsimile: 612198-3679
May 13, 1998
A'OTICE OF VIOLATION
Chazles F. Senkler
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 iUhita Bear Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55106
RE: All license held by East Side Hospitality, Inc. d/b/a Hillcrest Entertainment Center
for the premises located at 1560 �Jhite Beaz Ave. in St. Paul
License ID No.: 82839
Dear Mr. Senkler:
The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will reconunend
that adverse action be taken against all yout licenses held at the above-named address. This
recommendation is based on the foilowing:
On Apri11,1998, you or another employee sold cigarettes to a minor under the
age of 18 years in the licensed premises. This is an offense under Minn. Sta�
§609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. Additionally, you are not
licensed to sell cigarettes at the licensed establishment.
If you do not dispute the above facts, please send me a letter with a statement to that effect
by Friday, May 22, 1998. The matter will then be scheduled before ihe City Council for a public
hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You wiil have an opportunity to appeaz before
the Council and make a statement on your own behaif as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed.
If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative Law Judge.
At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and
cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St Paul City Council will ultimately decide the case. If
this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangborn, and we will take the necessary
steps to set up that ALJ hearing. He can be reached at 266-8710.
Page 2
Hillcrest Entertainment C ..er � b �S
May 13, 1998 � L�
If we have not heard from you by Tuesday, May 26, 1998, we will assume that you do not
contest the facts and will schedule this before the City Council for hearing.
If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� ����1
Virgini�. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Ann Woods, Exec. Director, Dist. 2 Community Council, 2169 Stillwater Ave., St. Paul, MN
55119 .
�� -S(�2-
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SSRVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on May 14, 1998, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Charles F. Senkler
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 White Bear Avenue
St. Paul, MI3. 55106
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 14th �y of �Iay, 1998 .
-��7ER F• P�INGBORN
NOTAqy ppg��C - MINNESOTA
OFF : OF Tf� CITY AT1'ORNEY
PegBir� CiryAnomey � �` S � ^ —
J�
CITY OF SAII�t'T PAUL
Narm Colemm; Mayos
��
April 10, 1998
Charles F. Senkl
Hillcrest Bntertainment Center
1560 White Beaz Avenue North
Saint Paul, MN 55106
RE: Cigazette Sale to a Minor
Deaz Mr. Senkl:
Civi7Division
400 City Hall
IS Wes[ Kellogg Btvd
Saim Pau; �nnesota 55701
Telephone: 6I2 266-8770
Facsimik: 672 298-5619
As you aze aware, a tobacco compliance check was done at Hillcrest Entertainment
Center on April 1, 1998 and a clerk sold tobacco to a minor. This is a violation of Saint Paul
Legislative Code § 324.07 and Minn. $tat § 609.685. Additionally, since you have no license
to sell cigazettes, this sale was a violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code § 324.01(a} .
Normally, the City would proceed with an adverse action against your cigarette license,
but because you do not have such a license, the City could elect to proceed with adverse action
against your other licenses. Another opfion would be for you to obtain a cigarette license, and
have the City assess the fine against that license. That option would require you to waive any
argument that you did not have such a license, but in return the City would not proceed against
your other licenses. It is my understanding from a conversation with Kris Schweinler, the license
inspector in this matter, that you told her that you were unawaze that you had no cigarette license,
and would take steps to obtain such license and pay the fine fot the violation. In light of that, the
second option may be one you aze interested in pursuing,
I will shortly be preparing a Notice of Violation letter, and would like to know how you
wish to proceed. Please feel free to contact me at 266-&71Q to discuss this matter in more detail.
Sincerely,
���-� �.��
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
�g- s`a-
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on April 13, 1998, she served the attached LETTER on the
following named person by placing a true and correct copy hereof in
an envelope addressed as follows:
Charles F. Senkl
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 White Bear Avenue North
St. Paul, MI3. 55106
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the United tates mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota.
�
JOANNE
Subscribed and sworn to before me
c� g- s c. a.
��
la
� iW
�
o I��
� I� rn
U
R � � N
a I Ico
�o
t'
O
C
�
C
O
::�
R
�
�
w
C
d
w
c
m
V
J
N
� �
:.°. -o
� �
�a
c N
U V
J Q
U
� U
aa
� o
a� �
N ++
C �
U �
,J �
U
�
`m
��
w
>
¢
�
Q
m
N
W
d
a � Qi00
I� �
�
Z
F-
�
F
Z
u�
m �
W
Q �
m V
� �_
m
m
0
n
W
N
c
N
�
�
�
Z
U
O
a
U
C
N
N
G
N
�
E
�
Z
N
C
a o
N �`
N
C �
�
�N �
....
� v
� � � Z
¢ Z � W
~ c ����
a � m
� � a
v � EI= U Em
fD �
Z = �O c�i
— M �
I� N � H 7 @ (O
U aD c0 (A tn �
I "� O d Q C
0 11.1 N �
c �
_ �
C
�LF�Qm
���mc
���vm
� �� � 7
O{�Q C� N
� a'
L6 � C�J d
�NW q��fp
�� `1�c
���m73
� �
CO D� yY
O dc�7 CUp
.+ � it N a LL
fnN d� N n
L C � a
�mU���
m
�Z�°
NL(O � V�
�dm�CIJOD
U U �
C J ~ L
� an_L LL
3�� � d
ONN N �
ta ,p
a c C� O J
dNN— � �
ro � mJ C
O� N m c �
�li N N i O R N N
� p 0.�.� �-'J�rL
LL� d a@ d� �� N
QQ � om
(J aa� d 2 �p c rn�
aQtiu�..�-V n�o�
Q NJJ �C�(OF-O O'
Qpcc�cco
VQ'OOL f6^ mERQ'
pV U UU�C o
J N tn ��k V,,, f/1
L' IO IO.-
adoO�WLLOa�
� o � � ' �
m�n�nn N m�n
� �rn�°'�
Dm�O�� U� �c+D�
Qa�o�rnm2�1-M�
�t�t -s��
�,
io
�
� iW
,
O N I�
N i � Irn
� ' V i
� _f i�
a I�
�
C
a
�
C
O
o+
�
�
�
O
w
�
d
N
L
d
ti
..I
N
� C
f6 �p
� c
�a
U �
J Q
a
N
N
U
C
O
� J
IC �
I �
i _J �
U
� �
W
�T � E
� I�
Z
I� rn
; m c7
C .aD
I L� JO
�
I�
>
¢
�
w
N F-
LI �
v��
Coo
� �
r t()
Z
H
�
H
Z
�, w
zw
Q �
m V
0 J
S
Q
F-
a
�
�O
_
(0 Ll.l
n
o �
a �
�
m
�
X
W m
N �
c �
^ n
N
O
�
N
�
7
Z
U
a 'n
rn
c �
� J
N J
C �
�
Z
c
J
E ¢
U Z
v W
c �
N
C Q
- a
N
�
�
7
z
N
C
0
a n
y N
N
C I�
I j •n^.-
�M
xlw
m �rn
�p
N
�
c
N � c U U
{�p y�Om � O.fl.� LL
c o
��oa� 3��� a�
O V �� 0 N N N �
tA �m��N L� LL �
� � � d Q N a C G C O J
CO � 47 �7 i R� y(V (V = N �
� tOSJO Maoo �V CI
m. c � �rn N�F'm �� c
O .. N O Q_ ,,,
��� a N N� p@ N"N
11.�G J�m +...=_N aJ�c
� � � O 20.0 i.
NCL100.L.+CnCI.LLt"Qa�"� O@N
�� Y �Om U O N U �-�U �
���3 � LL Q a�i
� c�'i�m� �m QY Q6� �¢ oo ..
N �N 67 NZ CQ NJJ C E(OF-��p �
O� M C U p� Q O C C� C M N N d
� �� �a� � ��00��� rnr»�
d UJ N Qf6JU ln fq �.�„4k�'a h
� � c � a�a a��OaWLLOa�
� dU � N� � mv o� y ���
o 'o•� a � y�w��nn� dn f0 rn'�
(y � V� l0 CN��� UNLNp�i
L
arn�C��mv>Qw�<c�xct-ch.-
°18 - s cs--
�
I�
0
,a
Ix
�W
o i N ��
M i � ��
y U �
R J I�
a co
0
r
O
1
�
C
O
i+
R
�
�
w
C
m
e
d
�
J
�
� c
;9 a
c
N �
a
U �
J q
C
(0
w
d
�
`� m
IW @
I N l
U
J �
�
m �
rn �
a
m ��
Z
I C O�p
I�I�
LJo
a
I ��
W
Q
�
w
m
m
N =
� �
4 lO o
�
��
Z
F
�
w
F
Z
u�
Z W
Q �
m V
0 J
_
F-
J
F
a
�
�O
2
Z p
C (n
0
a I¢
W
a�
m
0
n
W �
N �
c �
� �
�
N
�
O
�
d
Q
�
�
z
U
o �
a �
c �
(�0 �
3 J
N Z
C �
�
m
� Z
c
�
I a F-
o z
U
U W
� J
N �
c �
— a
` N
s
E
�
z
C
a o
n
N
C �
7 ^
m �
0�
F- �
�
0
N
Z
� a� �
�
Et
C�y�m
pm�c
li' N t�ii (�
N
�
m
c
a�
�
�
.
�
�
�( g —S c. �
�
0
i�-
�
W
o �N�
� l
��
d �,
R IJ N
n' L�
�
O
a.
�
C
O
ia
0
c
d
N
L
d
V
J
N
3 C
'� �
�a
N
U �
J Q
N '
I tQ m
NU
C �
N �
`-' 3
J p
m
-�
m
�
us
¢
�
4
m
a`�i ~
v`
a
Q p
� �
Z
h
Q'
�-'
Z
w
ZW
Q �
U
O �
_
a�
..
m
0
a
w o,
N �
c �
_ n
N
�
0
�
�
7
V
a �
rn
U 0
� J
� �
N Z
C �
d
n
�
7
N
c
a o
N ~
N
N
N (p
c i..
'� ti
� v
� "
� s � z
� z � w
�, � � ¢
~ � J m �
� � G 1-
m I� �IO oZ
d. I 7
tD lZ i N W Z �
Z � U J �
t�nM �!n `U' � F'S
mv� �� `�m
J° o a W a N �
G
�L� C U U p
�F�Om =JJ~ �
0
U'� ��� � 3'�°� � �
� U N 7� O N N U C
� N N[/)... LT�� p IQ
� o°°mQm ac�c o .�
� (ONJiQ'�ryNN3 �� �
� � C J�'N � O1J C
O"Or-- N O p��� N m C �
i �Ofn 3 ._ ¢ � LL '6'6 ` 'm fl.
��t6.+L ��� mG1� pJ N�
C J _ � �. �
7 (0 O.fl.0 i �
a�wooyv�ciiLLQ¢m�
O(ON
�`� ~ =oUna�d=a��=.
�n`''� � p_Omp cd d�U a�U �
°'dcm�3 Q�tL a oa�
� � m � �ma NJJ � �Q Op �
Or1t")C U CC�CMyN�
� J UOOU��rnu��
� � C � a�.0 ND�.flW Od0
UNV �d�o
o 'o�m- o � Nrnw�jrnn�rn a"i� �
O)L��J V��CN��� VN NN�
�drn�U' J�NQao�<M2�Fch�
��
�,
io
I°
�
W
o ; � �m
� , � Irn
R J IN
a ��o
�'
Q
�
C
O
�+
A
�
w
C
m
y
c
m
u
J
N
3 �
� 'a
(n C
�a
a�i >
V U
J Q
H �
� �
U N
J C
W
I�
� � �
w
>
¢
�
¢
y W
N
N � a`
Q�o
� �
z
�
�
w
Z
y W
f z w
I J
� J
S
m
m
0
Q
W p�
y �
c �
N
O
�
a�
�
'
Z
U
o �
a a ,
m �
� J
C �
`m
�
E
�
��
c
0
an
N �
C �
'y n
m �
iv
� �
� n Z
Q z
� � >
� IT 3 ��
a @ J C]
� � a �
a I i `" I � O Z �m
ia �o ',�{ U Z �
d rn � I � c J �ch �S
N M ' C I(O (p C X� �
c�.i � @ i(A v�i � {"' �(O
a � � 'n
J O l J J d N e-
�
N � � c� c�
EFO�IDm JJ�
m���,.. �aa� o
��o�� 3��� d
I O V � 7 � N N N �
a� ycn� ��� a
p � j �O N N �" 'O'C C O J
� Q �CC._
(�O (O q) U L0.' yNN_ N �
� COYJ O Ma o 0 3 � V N
m f» c �� i�m 1 - I - o rn� c
ov�...a�oadrnd m c
�?'Ov) �� y 'y °-u'
p��p,_, 6 Q�V-NN oc°��
tL�c��d�atoaa��a
dul'o o�in=ti�'-QQ m c� o m w
u�i� � aa�i a U n�U °'
°� � c m� 3 �¢u'u'LL a o�
N �N d �ZmQ y,J Jp�� �p �
� N(`�CUO�Q O C G RCMN(�y�
��U J JUOO�'��axsr�
N'OL C � O'�� NO��WIL� ��
U� O Ntn� j N �n�� N Ipa
rn � � �� °���rnrn� �� �co�
d�_a
(VL(p Ua- t 6 CN01W�=NtN�
�d��C�IJ F-c'7.-
°l g' —�` 1--
��
��
,o
�,`
�
x
O �y �
� �I d i'�
m '� �
a I �
u�
�
C
�
C
O
i+
F
�
�
O
�
C
d
N
m
U
J
N
3 C
:°. �a
(n C
�a
m y
V U
J Q
R
a
c
�
�
N d
a�
T �
� c
O
V O
J a
...i
m �
� I�
m I
Z
IN M
U �
J �
0
a
���
u�
>
¢
�
¢
m
�
N
a`
U
Q � O
� �
.�- �
Z
H
�
W
F-�
Z
� W
� W
Q �
m U
� J
_
�
Q
F
a
I �
�O
2
I 2 p
C (n
O
a¢
W
�
m
�
a
x
w
N �
c �
N
�
O
�
�
�
�
Z
U
a '�
W
c ° r
N O
� J
C �
N
�
R
Z
T
C J
o_ F-
o Z
vIW
� J
R �
C �
- a
N
Q
E
�
N
c
a o
y n
N
C �
'h n
m �
O M
F- I�
�
O
N
Z
�
�
�
�
�--
- N 1 C U U
� FO1O(Il JJF�- �..
d'� �..: � o_ o_ � o
� �N� ( 3JJ = N
�o�� O c
� om c�in 0.aa rn o m
a i V N Q d i c c c O J
� CUN��Q' � �
� (O Y O T� d 0 0 0 �- N
O'a� N O Q�6) NHI-p] C'JIL
o.°_'Ot�g-'q��-�d� p�dd
�-�3 -�@�'�to�aa=�aJ��
NW 00�(n caC�O f�6 N
� V E� C O 2 ❑ C m C
�n"�a ��0�1�aa�i a�iLLU a�U �
°'dcm�3 4�u. o- oy
�
N.� m��maG1JJ��¢�O�
�c�Va l�Ca' OCC��i��d'
E��00
a�N �� y Q m y��?��.� N
� dc Oa�
c o ° 'o
00'NDUNW
N�CO � �?� (6 CN��� �NrN�
.-arn�c�_,wv�a�o�.-�xvr��
�tS -Sc.�.--
�
I�
0
a
r ,. W
r. d
O N ip�
ti �� i�
d �
a J �(q
_i0
1'
c
�
C
O
m
�
�
O
w
C
m
fA
C
V
J
N
3 C
� �
(A =
�a
m >
J Q
N
O
0
N
>
A O
F� �
C
C �
U �
-..1 O'
.-1
�
I �
�
W
�
Q
d'
Q
m
N W
d—
a
Q O O
� �
Z
F
�
�"
Z
w
m u�i
Z �
m V
0 =
N
(0
�
X
rn
��
c ,
N
O
N
a
�
7
Z
U
a '�
U O
N �
� J
C �
m`
�
�
7
Z
N
c
0
an
N
C �
'N �
m
r � N) Z
Q IZ c � W
7' � "'� Q
F- � J m [].
pp � � O_ � x[
� I� � O � Z �
� N W U
c�o f � Z �
IZ Z � U J 0
W M 0 Cn . �� M .iL)
F-- �Y m�
� o a ¢ � ¢ o
O W 6. N .--
G
�_�� UU
m d�� � ao_i o`
LL
� �O- ` �iJJ C N
�O V � � �{N N LL
� Nhfn»+ � �V �
p� Om � � aaa m O 3
Q C C,
� (ONJ�Q_'�NNN3 � �
O"O� N O 6�m N�f'-m C_.-1 C
i��(n 7 ._ ���p�p y N 0.
��(0...����U'NN� Q@NN
LL C�J d m� D O.O_C �`�J��
NW 00�(q l6C�Ol9 w
�v Ef-}� c oU aa� d= a�0 c o�c
�n � n Om� am mLLU a�U �
°���m�3 QLLLL Q o
� aoo_� vc Q �
`m [II. m,�, a�c Qa � o.�
N�N y�Z C a U7JJ m�
� d M C U O� C O C C� L M W N d
C ik Naty, C U2'D�L (Oti �flQ'
47 UJ N n N N�.,�„�kw'a N
a�i-dL � � a�.n d��nW�Oa�
U�U�pN�CN�o o �yV�No
o�oi°� �a'W�°�
�LCO �� U� f0 CN W W� vNtN�
dW��J�CnQW'-rM2�{-Me'�
�
�'' j' —f ..a 7� N �l� t�'RT�� .
_:�]�,l1.K��L����:�r �t_ nyi � _. ° a��� -- .. . "�.�"�.'e�'�_:5�.�_iU��'�.y
i ��'�' Ms�""i ' ') ..f � 5 . ' - ��.�-+' i
�'f -- . 4 t z ,1 ,.� . _ , - ' Y �.
- � .. - . ' �'.�
� *- TOBACCO COMPLIANCE CI�CKFORM' -
� `:�'-: _ _ ' ''�:- �,
DATE: � � � 1 -� �s �rn�: a �cExss r.D. rr�m: � �s39 `'-' .'�
,u� - - �/ � , ��� - —
NAME OF CAMPLIANCE CI-IECI�R: � . , _ - NAME OF OFFICER: " �1y .'. ` , _ _
NAME & ADDRESS OF LICENSID VENDOR: 1 1� C V�S� �`�. v� c�:..� ,++,-�) {�-�r .` ``
n
wAS x� zosacco: s�-s�vs� _
�S CL U l�S��+
nss�s�n7 _ r,�acfm�� 1�
DID THE MACHII�IE HAVE Tf� PROPER REMOTE DEVICE? ��
SALE 4TAS MADE: YES � NO ' BRAND: I'11, �1'�-� ,� Xi_.!- I I �z ]7 �
NAMEOFCLII2K Sco1'f"�'1��� ,.�Nrr 2Z n Ia*ic� SEX: M�_ F
DESCRIPTION:
CHECK ABORTED: YES
,
NO
ADDITIONAL CO2vA�fENTS: � .,S ? ' � � �'�.Q � � .� �*> �.i�-� �• � �..^-� •
r�' C4'1c t 1' t'.xt �'• ��1 " t E�� �
� �:� ,�n —3� L�2.FP'7 �- �i
. n l _ 1( 1 _ �
� ^Ai _
_ .�,t _f.: _
5
" rl. � `� a ;5,
a - ,_ ' t.,.� .-� - _ �' _
' __ . - .- -, _ _ �� -� �_ _ " "
_ . _ " ' ' _ ` _ _ i
> . .. . :.
Council File # 16 ' SL a-
Green Sheet # /sZ�� /
RESOLUTION
O� �� r �, r A CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
�lVH �
Presented By t�� ��
Refened To
�.
Committee:
57
WI�REAS, the licensee East Side Hospitality, Inc. d/b(a H' crest Entertainment Center
(License ID No. 82839), located at 1560 White Beaz Avenue rth in Saint Paul failed cigazette
compliance checks on January 14, 1997, and again on April , 1998; and
WHEREAS, on Apri12, 1997, under C.F.97361 th Saint Paul City Council imposed a fine
in the amount of $200.00 for a first violation of sellin cigazettes to a minor, as identified in the
Presumptive penalties for violations, Saint Paul Le ' lative Code §324.07(b), the penalty for a
second violation being a$400.00 fine; and
WI�REAS, on both occasions, the licen e did not have a valid cigarette license for the
license periods 1496-1997 or 1997-1998, b has since obtained a cigazette license for the current
license period; and
WHEREAS, the licensee should required to pay the license fee far a cigarette license
during a111icense periods for which ' is known that he offered cigarettes for sale to the public;
now therefare, be it
RESOLVED, that the censee is hereby ordered to pay the standard license fee in the
amount of $317.00 for a cig ette license for the 1996-1997 license period. The licensee is
fitrther ordered to pay the dazd late fee for obtaining the cigazette licenses for the 1996-1997
and the 1997-1998 lice e periods in the amount of $158.50 for each license period. The
licensee is further ord ed to pay a fine of $400.00 for the second violation of the sale of tobacco
ar tobacco products a minor. The total of fees and fines owed equals $1,034.00.
Said pen ty shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection wi thirry (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature
by the Mayo .
1 ��-S�a-
a
3 This resolution and the acrion of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts
4 contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the compliance report, and such
5 azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were nQt
6 contested by the licensee. /
��
��� �
�� �\
r -��
V
ORiG1NAL
Adopted by C cil: ➢ate
Adoption rti£ied by Council Secte[avy
SY:
Approved by Mayoi: Date
BY:
Requested by Department oE:
- //�i �!!� rf�Y_'il -
Poxm Approved by City Attoxney � / /
� �1� �/' � r�.�
Approved bY Mayo or Submissnon Co Council
BY:
LIEP
X1MAC7 PERSON 8 PF10NE
Robert Ressler
�1UST BE ON COUNCIL AGQJI
June 24, 1998 -
6f12J98
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
qg -st�-
No 62161
v�.,u,�� ��,.�.._
❑ fl1YAiTOR1EY ❑ CRYq.FAK
❑w�wcu��a�aMCFSm�. ❑wu�c��m�n.ecto
❑r�vo�troMwamsrAxt) ❑
(CL1P ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR�
Concerning adverse action against licenses held by East Side Hospitality, Inc., dba
Hillcrest Entertainment Center, 1560 White Bear Avenue. (Uncontested)
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CNIL SERVICE COMMISSIQN
IFAPPROVED
RSONAL SERViCE CONiRACTS MUST ANSWER iHE FOLLOWIN6 QUESTiONS:
Has this PersarJfim erer waked untler a contiact fw this departmwR')
YES NO
Has Mie persaMrm e.er been a ciry empbyee7
YES NO
Daes thi6 P���m P�ss a sldli no[ riom�alNP�ssed bY arry curreM city emPbYee?
YES NO
Is this peisoNfirm a qrp�etl vendoR
YES NO
AMOUNT OP TRANSACTION S COST/REVENUE BUDfiETm (CIRCAE ONE! YES NO
ACTNI7Y NUMBER
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Peg Birlr, City AttOrney q g ��` ��
J
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colemm; Mayor
June 11, 1998
Charles F. Senkler
Civil Division
400 City Hall Tekphone: 612 266-8710
IS lYestXeIIoggBlvd Facsimile: b11298-5679
Saint Pau{ Minneso7a 55101
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING � r�•
CiO;S�iC�i �?S?a: =:, .,_:;: _�..,t
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 White Beaz Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55106
�L y'
RE: All licenses held by East Side Hospitality, Inc. d/b/a Hillcrest Entertainment Center for the
premises located at 1560 VJhite Beaz Ave. in St. Paul
License ID No. :82839
Our File Number: G98-0165
Dear Mr. Senkler:
Please take notice that a hearing conceming the above-named establishment has been scheduled for
5:30 p.m., Wednesday, June 24,1998 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City
Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the
City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts conceming the
failwe to obtain a cigarette license for the license yeazs 1997 and 1998 while still selling cigazettes
at the licensed establishment, and the April 1, 1998 unlawful sale of cigazettes to a minor have not
been disputed. You will have an oppoitunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written
remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Ve�y yours, ��
.-,.tti
Virginia . Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Ann Woods, Executive Director, District 2 Community Council, 2169 Stillwater Ave., St.
Paul MN 55119
q g - S�a-
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING
Licensee Name: East Side Hospitality, Inc, d!b/a Hillcrest
Entertainment Center
Address: 1560 White Bear Avenue North
Councii Hearing Date: June 24, 1998
Violation: 1.) Failure to have appropriate cigarette license
for the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 license periods
2.) Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor
Minn. Stat. § 609.685
St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07
Date: Aprit 1, 1998
Place: Licensed Premises
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
Immediate Suspension of aff ticenses until alt license fees and
fines have been paid including:
1.) license fees and late fees for the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998
license periods �
2.) $400.00 fine (2" violation of unlawful sale to minors)
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. April 10, 19981etter to Charles Senkler
4. License information
5. Compliance Report
OFFICF OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Peg Bir. y At[orney � e �S `.+
6 �r'
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colemmt, Mnyor
Civll Divirion
400 City Hall
I S West Kettogg Blvd
Saint Paul, �nnesom 55702
Telephone: 611 166-8 710
Facsimile: 612198-3679
May 13, 1998
A'OTICE OF VIOLATION
Chazles F. Senkler
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 iUhita Bear Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55106
RE: All license held by East Side Hospitality, Inc. d/b/a Hillcrest Entertainment Center
for the premises located at 1560 �Jhite Beaz Ave. in St. Paul
License ID No.: 82839
Dear Mr. Senkler:
The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will reconunend
that adverse action be taken against all yout licenses held at the above-named address. This
recommendation is based on the foilowing:
On Apri11,1998, you or another employee sold cigarettes to a minor under the
age of 18 years in the licensed premises. This is an offense under Minn. Sta�
§609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. Additionally, you are not
licensed to sell cigarettes at the licensed establishment.
If you do not dispute the above facts, please send me a letter with a statement to that effect
by Friday, May 22, 1998. The matter will then be scheduled before ihe City Council for a public
hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You wiil have an opportunity to appeaz before
the Council and make a statement on your own behaif as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed.
If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative Law Judge.
At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and
cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St Paul City Council will ultimately decide the case. If
this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangborn, and we will take the necessary
steps to set up that ALJ hearing. He can be reached at 266-8710.
Page 2
Hillcrest Entertainment C ..er � b �S
May 13, 1998 � L�
If we have not heard from you by Tuesday, May 26, 1998, we will assume that you do not
contest the facts and will schedule this before the City Council for hearing.
If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� ����1
Virgini�. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Ann Woods, Exec. Director, Dist. 2 Community Council, 2169 Stillwater Ave., St. Paul, MN
55119 .
�� -S(�2-
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SSRVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on May 14, 1998, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Charles F. Senkler
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 White Bear Avenue
St. Paul, MI3. 55106
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 14th �y of �Iay, 1998 .
-��7ER F• P�INGBORN
NOTAqy ppg��C - MINNESOTA
OFF : OF Tf� CITY AT1'ORNEY
PegBir� CiryAnomey � �` S � ^ —
J�
CITY OF SAII�t'T PAUL
Narm Colemm; Mayos
��
April 10, 1998
Charles F. Senkl
Hillcrest Bntertainment Center
1560 White Beaz Avenue North
Saint Paul, MN 55106
RE: Cigazette Sale to a Minor
Deaz Mr. Senkl:
Civi7Division
400 City Hall
IS Wes[ Kellogg Btvd
Saim Pau; �nnesota 55701
Telephone: 6I2 266-8770
Facsimik: 672 298-5619
As you aze aware, a tobacco compliance check was done at Hillcrest Entertainment
Center on April 1, 1998 and a clerk sold tobacco to a minor. This is a violation of Saint Paul
Legislative Code § 324.07 and Minn. $tat § 609.685. Additionally, since you have no license
to sell cigazettes, this sale was a violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code § 324.01(a} .
Normally, the City would proceed with an adverse action against your cigarette license,
but because you do not have such a license, the City could elect to proceed with adverse action
against your other licenses. Another opfion would be for you to obtain a cigarette license, and
have the City assess the fine against that license. That option would require you to waive any
argument that you did not have such a license, but in return the City would not proceed against
your other licenses. It is my understanding from a conversation with Kris Schweinler, the license
inspector in this matter, that you told her that you were unawaze that you had no cigarette license,
and would take steps to obtain such license and pay the fine fot the violation. In light of that, the
second option may be one you aze interested in pursuing,
I will shortly be preparing a Notice of Violation letter, and would like to know how you
wish to proceed. Please feel free to contact me at 266-&71Q to discuss this matter in more detail.
Sincerely,
���-� �.��
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
�g- s`a-
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on April 13, 1998, she served the attached LETTER on the
following named person by placing a true and correct copy hereof in
an envelope addressed as follows:
Charles F. Senkl
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 White Bear Avenue North
St. Paul, MI3. 55106
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the United tates mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota.
�
JOANNE
Subscribed and sworn to before me
c� g- s c. a.
��
la
� iW
�
o I��
� I� rn
U
R � � N
a I Ico
�o
t'
O
C
�
C
O
::�
R
�
�
w
C
d
w
c
m
V
J
N
� �
:.°. -o
� �
�a
c N
U V
J Q
U
� U
aa
� o
a� �
N ++
C �
U �
,J �
U
�
`m
��
w
>
¢
�
Q
m
N
W
d
a � Qi00
I� �
�
Z
F-
�
F
Z
u�
m �
W
Q �
m V
� �_
m
m
0
n
W
N
c
N
�
�
�
Z
U
O
a
U
C
N
N
G
N
�
E
�
Z
N
C
a o
N �`
N
C �
�
�N �
....
� v
� � � Z
¢ Z � W
~ c ����
a � m
� � a
v � EI= U Em
fD �
Z = �O c�i
— M �
I� N � H 7 @ (O
U aD c0 (A tn �
I "� O d Q C
0 11.1 N �
c �
_ �
C
�LF�Qm
���mc
���vm
� �� � 7
O{�Q C� N
� a'
L6 � C�J d
�NW q��fp
�� `1�c
���m73
� �
CO D� yY
O dc�7 CUp
.+ � it N a LL
fnN d� N n
L C � a
�mU���
m
�Z�°
NL(O � V�
�dm�CIJOD
U U �
C J ~ L
� an_L LL
3�� � d
ONN N �
ta ,p
a c C� O J
dNN— � �
ro � mJ C
O� N m c �
�li N N i O R N N
� p 0.�.� �-'J�rL
LL� d a@ d� �� N
QQ � om
(J aa� d 2 �p c rn�
aQtiu�..�-V n�o�
Q NJJ �C�(OF-O O'
Qpcc�cco
VQ'OOL f6^ mERQ'
pV U UU�C o
J N tn ��k V,,, f/1
L' IO IO.-
adoO�WLLOa�
� o � � ' �
m�n�nn N m�n
� �rn�°'�
Dm�O�� U� �c+D�
Qa�o�rnm2�1-M�
�t�t -s��
�,
io
�
� iW
,
O N I�
N i � Irn
� ' V i
� _f i�
a I�
�
C
a
�
C
O
o+
�
�
�
O
w
�
d
N
L
d
ti
..I
N
� C
f6 �p
� c
�a
U �
J Q
a
N
N
U
C
O
� J
IC �
I �
i _J �
U
� �
W
�T � E
� I�
Z
I� rn
; m c7
C .aD
I L� JO
�
I�
>
¢
�
w
N F-
LI �
v��
Coo
� �
r t()
Z
H
�
H
Z
�, w
zw
Q �
m V
0 J
S
Q
F-
a
�
�O
_
(0 Ll.l
n
o �
a �
�
m
�
X
W m
N �
c �
^ n
N
O
�
N
�
7
Z
U
a 'n
rn
c �
� J
N J
C �
�
Z
c
J
E ¢
U Z
v W
c �
N
C Q
- a
N
�
�
7
z
N
C
0
a n
y N
N
C I�
I j •n^.-
�M
xlw
m �rn
�p
N
�
c
N � c U U
{�p y�Om � O.fl.� LL
c o
��oa� 3��� a�
O V �� 0 N N N �
tA �m��N L� LL �
� � � d Q N a C G C O J
CO � 47 �7 i R� y(V (V = N �
� tOSJO Maoo �V CI
m. c � �rn N�F'm �� c
O .. N O Q_ ,,,
��� a N N� p@ N"N
11.�G J�m +...=_N aJ�c
� � � O 20.0 i.
NCL100.L.+CnCI.LLt"Qa�"� O@N
�� Y �Om U O N U �-�U �
���3 � LL Q a�i
� c�'i�m� �m QY Q6� �¢ oo ..
N �N 67 NZ CQ NJJ C E(OF-��p �
O� M C U p� Q O C C� C M N N d
� �� �a� � ��00��� rnr»�
d UJ N Qf6JU ln fq �.�„4k�'a h
� � c � a�a a��OaWLLOa�
� dU � N� � mv o� y ���
o 'o•� a � y�w��nn� dn f0 rn'�
(y � V� l0 CN��� UNLNp�i
L
arn�C��mv>Qw�<c�xct-ch.-
°18 - s cs--
�
I�
0
,a
Ix
�W
o i N ��
M i � ��
y U �
R J I�
a co
0
r
O
1
�
C
O
i+
R
�
�
w
C
m
e
d
�
J
�
� c
;9 a
c
N �
a
U �
J q
C
(0
w
d
�
`� m
IW @
I N l
U
J �
�
m �
rn �
a
m ��
Z
I C O�p
I�I�
LJo
a
I ��
W
Q
�
w
m
m
N =
� �
4 lO o
�
��
Z
F
�
w
F
Z
u�
Z W
Q �
m V
0 J
_
F-
J
F
a
�
�O
2
Z p
C (n
0
a I¢
W
a�
m
0
n
W �
N �
c �
� �
�
N
�
O
�
d
Q
�
�
z
U
o �
a �
c �
(�0 �
3 J
N Z
C �
�
m
� Z
c
�
I a F-
o z
U
U W
� J
N �
c �
— a
` N
s
E
�
z
C
a o
n
N
C �
7 ^
m �
0�
F- �
�
0
N
Z
� a� �
�
Et
C�y�m
pm�c
li' N t�ii (�
N
�
m
c
a�
�
�
.
�
�
�( g —S c. �
�
0
i�-
�
W
o �N�
� l
��
d �,
R IJ N
n' L�
�
O
a.
�
C
O
ia
0
c
d
N
L
d
V
J
N
3 C
'� �
�a
N
U �
J Q
N '
I tQ m
NU
C �
N �
`-' 3
J p
m
-�
m
�
us
¢
�
4
m
a`�i ~
v`
a
Q p
� �
Z
h
Q'
�-'
Z
w
ZW
Q �
U
O �
_
a�
..
m
0
a
w o,
N �
c �
_ n
N
�
0
�
�
7
V
a �
rn
U 0
� J
� �
N Z
C �
d
n
�
7
N
c
a o
N ~
N
N
N (p
c i..
'� ti
� v
� "
� s � z
� z � w
�, � � ¢
~ � J m �
� � G 1-
m I� �IO oZ
d. I 7
tD lZ i N W Z �
Z � U J �
t�nM �!n `U' � F'S
mv� �� `�m
J° o a W a N �
G
�L� C U U p
�F�Om =JJ~ �
0
U'� ��� � 3'�°� � �
� U N 7� O N N U C
� N N[/)... LT�� p IQ
� o°°mQm ac�c o .�
� (ONJiQ'�ryNN3 �� �
� � C J�'N � O1J C
O"Or-- N O p��� N m C �
i �Ofn 3 ._ ¢ � LL '6'6 ` 'm fl.
��t6.+L ��� mG1� pJ N�
C J _ � �. �
7 (0 O.fl.0 i �
a�wooyv�ciiLLQ¢m�
O(ON
�`� ~ =oUna�d=a��=.
�n`''� � p_Omp cd d�U a�U �
°'dcm�3 Q�tL a oa�
� � m � �ma NJJ � �Q Op �
Or1t")C U CC�CMyN�
� J UOOU��rnu��
� � C � a�.0 ND�.flW Od0
UNV �d�o
o 'o�m- o � Nrnw�jrnn�rn a"i� �
O)L��J V��CN��� VN NN�
�drn�U' J�NQao�<M2�Fch�
��
�,
io
I°
�
W
o ; � �m
� , � Irn
R J IN
a ��o
�'
Q
�
C
O
�+
A
�
w
C
m
y
c
m
u
J
N
3 �
� 'a
(n C
�a
a�i >
V U
J Q
H �
� �
U N
J C
W
I�
� � �
w
>
¢
�
¢
y W
N
N � a`
Q�o
� �
z
�
�
w
Z
y W
f z w
I J
� J
S
m
m
0
Q
W p�
y �
c �
N
O
�
a�
�
'
Z
U
o �
a a ,
m �
� J
C �
`m
�
E
�
��
c
0
an
N �
C �
'y n
m �
iv
� �
� n Z
Q z
� � >
� IT 3 ��
a @ J C]
� � a �
a I i `" I � O Z �m
ia �o ',�{ U Z �
d rn � I � c J �ch �S
N M ' C I(O (p C X� �
c�.i � @ i(A v�i � {"' �(O
a � � 'n
J O l J J d N e-
�
N � � c� c�
EFO�IDm JJ�
m���,.. �aa� o
��o�� 3��� d
I O V � 7 � N N N �
a� ycn� ��� a
p � j �O N N �" 'O'C C O J
� Q �CC._
(�O (O q) U L0.' yNN_ N �
� COYJ O Ma o 0 3 � V N
m f» c �� i�m 1 - I - o rn� c
ov�...a�oadrnd m c
�?'Ov) �� y 'y °-u'
p��p,_, 6 Q�V-NN oc°��
tL�c��d�atoaa��a
dul'o o�in=ti�'-QQ m c� o m w
u�i� � aa�i a U n�U °'
°� � c m� 3 �¢u'u'LL a o�
N �N d �ZmQ y,J Jp�� �p �
� N(`�CUO�Q O C G RCMN(�y�
��U J JUOO�'��axsr�
N'OL C � O'�� NO��WIL� ��
U� O Ntn� j N �n�� N Ipa
rn � � �� °���rnrn� �� �co�
d�_a
(VL(p Ua- t 6 CN01W�=NtN�
�d��C�IJ F-c'7.-
°l g' —�` 1--
��
��
,o
�,`
�
x
O �y �
� �I d i'�
m '� �
a I �
u�
�
C
�
C
O
i+
F
�
�
O
�
C
d
N
m
U
J
N
3 C
:°. �a
(n C
�a
m y
V U
J Q
R
a
c
�
�
N d
a�
T �
� c
O
V O
J a
...i
m �
� I�
m I
Z
IN M
U �
J �
0
a
���
u�
>
¢
�
¢
m
�
N
a`
U
Q � O
� �
.�- �
Z
H
�
W
F-�
Z
� W
� W
Q �
m U
� J
_
�
Q
F
a
I �
�O
2
I 2 p
C (n
O
a¢
W
�
m
�
a
x
w
N �
c �
N
�
O
�
�
�
�
Z
U
a '�
W
c ° r
N O
� J
C �
N
�
R
Z
T
C J
o_ F-
o Z
vIW
� J
R �
C �
- a
N
Q
E
�
N
c
a o
y n
N
C �
'h n
m �
O M
F- I�
�
O
N
Z
�
�
�
�
�--
- N 1 C U U
� FO1O(Il JJF�- �..
d'� �..: � o_ o_ � o
� �N� ( 3JJ = N
�o�� O c
� om c�in 0.aa rn o m
a i V N Q d i c c c O J
� CUN��Q' � �
� (O Y O T� d 0 0 0 �- N
O'a� N O Q�6) NHI-p] C'JIL
o.°_'Ot�g-'q��-�d� p�dd
�-�3 -�@�'�to�aa=�aJ��
NW 00�(n caC�O f�6 N
� V E� C O 2 ❑ C m C
�n"�a ��0�1�aa�i a�iLLU a�U �
°'dcm�3 4�u. o- oy
�
N.� m��maG1JJ��¢�O�
�c�Va l�Ca' OCC��i��d'
E��00
a�N �� y Q m y��?��.� N
� dc Oa�
c o ° 'o
00'NDUNW
N�CO � �?� (6 CN��� �NrN�
.-arn�c�_,wv�a�o�.-�xvr��
�tS -Sc.�.--
�
I�
0
a
r ,. W
r. d
O N ip�
ti �� i�
d �
a J �(q
_i0
1'
c
�
C
O
m
�
�
O
w
C
m
fA
C
V
J
N
3 C
� �
(A =
�a
m >
J Q
N
O
0
N
>
A O
F� �
C
C �
U �
-..1 O'
.-1
�
I �
�
W
�
Q
d'
Q
m
N W
d—
a
Q O O
� �
Z
F
�
�"
Z
w
m u�i
Z �
m V
0 =
N
(0
�
X
rn
��
c ,
N
O
N
a
�
7
Z
U
a '�
U O
N �
� J
C �
m`
�
�
7
Z
N
c
0
an
N
C �
'N �
m
r � N) Z
Q IZ c � W
7' � "'� Q
F- � J m [].
pp � � O_ � x[
� I� � O � Z �
� N W U
c�o f � Z �
IZ Z � U J 0
W M 0 Cn . �� M .iL)
F-- �Y m�
� o a ¢ � ¢ o
O W 6. N .--
G
�_�� UU
m d�� � ao_i o`
LL
� �O- ` �iJJ C N
�O V � � �{N N LL
� Nhfn»+ � �V �
p� Om � � aaa m O 3
Q C C,
� (ONJ�Q_'�NNN3 � �
O"O� N O 6�m N�f'-m C_.-1 C
i��(n 7 ._ ���p�p y N 0.
��(0...����U'NN� Q@NN
LL C�J d m� D O.O_C �`�J��
NW 00�(q l6C�Ol9 w
�v Ef-}� c oU aa� d= a�0 c o�c
�n � n Om� am mLLU a�U �
°���m�3 QLLLL Q o
� aoo_� vc Q �
`m [II. m,�, a�c Qa � o.�
N�N y�Z C a U7JJ m�
� d M C U O� C O C C� L M W N d
C ik Naty, C U2'D�L (Oti �flQ'
47 UJ N n N N�.,�„�kw'a N
a�i-dL � � a�.n d��nW�Oa�
U�U�pN�CN�o o �yV�No
o�oi°� �a'W�°�
�LCO �� U� f0 CN W W� vNtN�
dW��J�CnQW'-rM2�{-Me'�
�
�'' j' —f ..a 7� N �l� t�'RT�� .
_:�]�,l1.K��L����:�r �t_ nyi � _. ° a��� -- .. . "�.�"�.'e�'�_:5�.�_iU��'�.y
i ��'�' Ms�""i ' ') ..f � 5 . ' - ��.�-+' i
�'f -- . 4 t z ,1 ,.� . _ , - ' Y �.
- � .. - . ' �'.�
� *- TOBACCO COMPLIANCE CI�CKFORM' -
� `:�'-: _ _ ' ''�:- �,
DATE: � � � 1 -� �s �rn�: a �cExss r.D. rr�m: � �s39 `'-' .'�
,u� - - �/ � , ��� - —
NAME OF CAMPLIANCE CI-IECI�R: � . , _ - NAME OF OFFICER: " �1y .'. ` , _ _
NAME & ADDRESS OF LICENSID VENDOR: 1 1� C V�S� �`�. v� c�:..� ,++,-�) {�-�r .` ``
n
wAS x� zosacco: s�-s�vs� _
�S CL U l�S��+
nss�s�n7 _ r,�acfm�� 1�
DID THE MACHII�IE HAVE Tf� PROPER REMOTE DEVICE? ��
SALE 4TAS MADE: YES � NO ' BRAND: I'11, �1'�-� ,� Xi_.!- I I �z ]7 �
NAMEOFCLII2K Sco1'f"�'1��� ,.�Nrr 2Z n Ia*ic� SEX: M�_ F
DESCRIPTION:
CHECK ABORTED: YES
,
NO
ADDITIONAL CO2vA�fENTS: � .,S ? ' � � �'�.Q � � .� �*> �.i�-� �• � �..^-� •
r�' C4'1c t 1' t'.xt �'• ��1 " t E�� �
� �:� ,�n —3� L�2.FP'7 �- �i
. n l _ 1( 1 _ �
� ^Ai _
_ .�,t _f.: _
5
" rl. � `� a ;5,
a - ,_ ' t.,.� .-� - _ �' _
' __ . - .- -, _ _ �� -� �_ _ " "
_ . _ " ' ' _ ` _ _ i
> . .. . :.
Council File # 16 ' SL a-
Green Sheet # /sZ�� /
RESOLUTION
O� �� r �, r A CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
�lVH �
Presented By t�� ��
Refened To
�.
Committee:
57
WI�REAS, the licensee East Side Hospitality, Inc. d/b(a H' crest Entertainment Center
(License ID No. 82839), located at 1560 White Beaz Avenue rth in Saint Paul failed cigazette
compliance checks on January 14, 1997, and again on April , 1998; and
WHEREAS, on Apri12, 1997, under C.F.97361 th Saint Paul City Council imposed a fine
in the amount of $200.00 for a first violation of sellin cigazettes to a minor, as identified in the
Presumptive penalties for violations, Saint Paul Le ' lative Code §324.07(b), the penalty for a
second violation being a$400.00 fine; and
WI�REAS, on both occasions, the licen e did not have a valid cigarette license for the
license periods 1496-1997 or 1997-1998, b has since obtained a cigazette license for the current
license period; and
WHEREAS, the licensee should required to pay the license fee far a cigarette license
during a111icense periods for which ' is known that he offered cigarettes for sale to the public;
now therefare, be it
RESOLVED, that the censee is hereby ordered to pay the standard license fee in the
amount of $317.00 for a cig ette license for the 1996-1997 license period. The licensee is
fitrther ordered to pay the dazd late fee for obtaining the cigazette licenses for the 1996-1997
and the 1997-1998 lice e periods in the amount of $158.50 for each license period. The
licensee is further ord ed to pay a fine of $400.00 for the second violation of the sale of tobacco
ar tobacco products a minor. The total of fees and fines owed equals $1,034.00.
Said pen ty shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection wi thirry (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature
by the Mayo .
1 ��-S�a-
a
3 This resolution and the acrion of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts
4 contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the compliance report, and such
5 azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were nQt
6 contested by the licensee. /
��
��� �
�� �\
r -��
V
ORiG1NAL
Adopted by C cil: ➢ate
Adoption rti£ied by Council Secte[avy
SY:
Approved by Mayoi: Date
BY:
Requested by Department oE:
- //�i �!!� rf�Y_'il -
Poxm Approved by City Attoxney � / /
� �1� �/' � r�.�
Approved bY Mayo or Submissnon Co Council
BY:
LIEP
X1MAC7 PERSON 8 PF10NE
Robert Ressler
�1UST BE ON COUNCIL AGQJI
June 24, 1998 -
6f12J98
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
GREEN SHEET
qg -st�-
No 62161
v�.,u,�� ��,.�.._
❑ fl1YAiTOR1EY ❑ CRYq.FAK
❑w�wcu��a�aMCFSm�. ❑wu�c��m�n.ecto
❑r�vo�troMwamsrAxt) ❑
(CL1P ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR�
Concerning adverse action against licenses held by East Side Hospitality, Inc., dba
Hillcrest Entertainment Center, 1560 White Bear Avenue. (Uncontested)
PLANNING CAMMISSION
CIB COMMITTEE
CNIL SERVICE COMMISSIQN
IFAPPROVED
RSONAL SERViCE CONiRACTS MUST ANSWER iHE FOLLOWIN6 QUESTiONS:
Has this PersarJfim erer waked untler a contiact fw this departmwR')
YES NO
Has Mie persaMrm e.er been a ciry empbyee7
YES NO
Daes thi6 P���m P�ss a sldli no[ riom�alNP�ssed bY arry curreM city emPbYee?
YES NO
Is this peisoNfirm a qrp�etl vendoR
YES NO
AMOUNT OP TRANSACTION S COST/REVENUE BUDfiETm (CIRCAE ONE! YES NO
ACTNI7Y NUMBER
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Peg Birlr, City AttOrney q g ��` ��
J
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colemm; Mayor
June 11, 1998
Charles F. Senkler
Civil Division
400 City Hall Tekphone: 612 266-8710
IS lYestXeIIoggBlvd Facsimile: b11298-5679
Saint Pau{ Minneso7a 55101
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING � r�•
CiO;S�iC�i �?S?a: =:, .,_:;: _�..,t
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 White Beaz Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55106
�L y'
RE: All licenses held by East Side Hospitality, Inc. d/b/a Hillcrest Entertainment Center for the
premises located at 1560 VJhite Beaz Ave. in St. Paul
License ID No. :82839
Our File Number: G98-0165
Dear Mr. Senkler:
Please take notice that a hearing conceming the above-named establishment has been scheduled for
5:30 p.m., Wednesday, June 24,1998 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City
Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the
City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing in that the facts conceming the
failwe to obtain a cigarette license for the license yeazs 1997 and 1998 while still selling cigazettes
at the licensed establishment, and the April 1, 1998 unlawful sale of cigazettes to a minor have not
been disputed. You will have an oppoitunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written
remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Ve�y yours, ��
.-,.tti
Virginia . Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Ann Woods, Executive Director, District 2 Community Council, 2169 Stillwater Ave., St.
Paul MN 55119
q g - S�a-
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING
Licensee Name: East Side Hospitality, Inc, d!b/a Hillcrest
Entertainment Center
Address: 1560 White Bear Avenue North
Councii Hearing Date: June 24, 1998
Violation: 1.) Failure to have appropriate cigarette license
for the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998 license periods
2.) Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor
Minn. Stat. § 609.685
St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07
Date: Aprit 1, 1998
Place: Licensed Premises
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection:
Immediate Suspension of aff ticenses until alt license fees and
fines have been paid including:
1.) license fees and late fees for the 1996-1997 and 1997-1998
license periods �
2.) $400.00 fine (2" violation of unlawful sale to minors)
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. Notice of Violation
3. April 10, 19981etter to Charles Senkler
4. License information
5. Compliance Report
OFFICF OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Peg Bir. y At[orney � e �S `.+
6 �r'
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Colemmt, Mnyor
Civll Divirion
400 City Hall
I S West Kettogg Blvd
Saint Paul, �nnesom 55702
Telephone: 611 166-8 710
Facsimile: 612198-3679
May 13, 1998
A'OTICE OF VIOLATION
Chazles F. Senkler
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 iUhita Bear Avenue North
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55106
RE: All license held by East Side Hospitality, Inc. d/b/a Hillcrest Entertainment Center
for the premises located at 1560 �Jhite Beaz Ave. in St. Paul
License ID No.: 82839
Dear Mr. Senkler:
The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will reconunend
that adverse action be taken against all yout licenses held at the above-named address. This
recommendation is based on the foilowing:
On Apri11,1998, you or another employee sold cigarettes to a minor under the
age of 18 years in the licensed premises. This is an offense under Minn. Sta�
§609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. Additionally, you are not
licensed to sell cigarettes at the licensed establishment.
If you do not dispute the above facts, please send me a letter with a statement to that effect
by Friday, May 22, 1998. The matter will then be scheduled before ihe City Council for a public
hearing to determine what penalty, if any, to impose. You wiil have an opportunity to appeaz before
the Council and make a statement on your own behaif as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed.
If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be scheduled before an Administrative Law Judge.
At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and
cross-examine the other's witnesses. The St Paul City Council will ultimately decide the case. If
this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangborn, and we will take the necessary
steps to set up that ALJ hearing. He can be reached at 266-8710.
Page 2
Hillcrest Entertainment C ..er � b �S
May 13, 1998 � L�
If we have not heard from you by Tuesday, May 26, 1998, we will assume that you do not
contest the facts and will schedule this before the City Council for hearing.
If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
� ����1
Virgini�. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Ann Woods, Exec. Director, Dist. 2 Community Council, 2169 Stillwater Ave., St. Paul, MN
55119 .
�� -S(�2-
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SSRVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on May 14, 1998, she served the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION
on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy
thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Charles F. Senkler
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 White Bear Avenue
St. Paul, MI3. 55106
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 14th �y of �Iay, 1998 .
-��7ER F• P�INGBORN
NOTAqy ppg��C - MINNESOTA
OFF : OF Tf� CITY AT1'ORNEY
PegBir� CiryAnomey � �` S � ^ —
J�
CITY OF SAII�t'T PAUL
Narm Colemm; Mayos
��
April 10, 1998
Charles F. Senkl
Hillcrest Bntertainment Center
1560 White Beaz Avenue North
Saint Paul, MN 55106
RE: Cigazette Sale to a Minor
Deaz Mr. Senkl:
Civi7Division
400 City Hall
IS Wes[ Kellogg Btvd
Saim Pau; �nnesota 55701
Telephone: 6I2 266-8770
Facsimik: 672 298-5619
As you aze aware, a tobacco compliance check was done at Hillcrest Entertainment
Center on April 1, 1998 and a clerk sold tobacco to a minor. This is a violation of Saint Paul
Legislative Code § 324.07 and Minn. $tat § 609.685. Additionally, since you have no license
to sell cigazettes, this sale was a violation of Saint Paul Legislative Code § 324.01(a} .
Normally, the City would proceed with an adverse action against your cigarette license,
but because you do not have such a license, the City could elect to proceed with adverse action
against your other licenses. Another opfion would be for you to obtain a cigarette license, and
have the City assess the fine against that license. That option would require you to waive any
argument that you did not have such a license, but in return the City would not proceed against
your other licenses. It is my understanding from a conversation with Kris Schweinler, the license
inspector in this matter, that you told her that you were unawaze that you had no cigarette license,
and would take steps to obtain such license and pay the fine fot the violation. In light of that, the
second option may be one you aze interested in pursuing,
I will shortly be preparing a Notice of Violation letter, and would like to know how you
wish to proceed. Please feel free to contact me at 266-&71Q to discuss this matter in more detail.
Sincerely,
���-� �.��
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
�g- s`a-
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on April 13, 1998, she served the attached LETTER on the
following named person by placing a true and correct copy hereof in
an envelope addressed as follows:
Charles F. Senkl
Hillcrest Entertainment Center
1560 White Bear Avenue North
St. Paul, MI3. 55106
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the United tates mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota.
�
JOANNE
Subscribed and sworn to before me
c� g- s c. a.
��
la
� iW
�
o I��
� I� rn
U
R � � N
a I Ico
�o
t'
O
C
�
C
O
::�
R
�
�
w
C
d
w
c
m
V
J
N
� �
:.°. -o
� �
�a
c N
U V
J Q
U
� U
aa
� o
a� �
N ++
C �
U �
,J �
U
�
`m
��
w
>
¢
�
Q
m
N
W
d
a � Qi00
I� �
�
Z
F-
�
F
Z
u�
m �
W
Q �
m V
� �_
m
m
0
n
W
N
c
N
�
�
�
Z
U
O
a
U
C
N
N
G
N
�
E
�
Z
N
C
a o
N �`
N
C �
�
�N �
....
� v
� � � Z
¢ Z � W
~ c ����
a � m
� � a
v � EI= U Em
fD �
Z = �O c�i
— M �
I� N � H 7 @ (O
U aD c0 (A tn �
I "� O d Q C
0 11.1 N �
c �
_ �
C
�LF�Qm
���mc
���vm
� �� � 7
O{�Q C� N
� a'
L6 � C�J d
�NW q��fp
�� `1�c
���m73
� �
CO D� yY
O dc�7 CUp
.+ � it N a LL
fnN d� N n
L C � a
�mU���
m
�Z�°
NL(O � V�
�dm�CIJOD
U U �
C J ~ L
� an_L LL
3�� � d
ONN N �
ta ,p
a c C� O J
dNN— � �
ro � mJ C
O� N m c �
�li N N i O R N N
� p 0.�.� �-'J�rL
LL� d a@ d� �� N
QQ � om
(J aa� d 2 �p c rn�
aQtiu�..�-V n�o�
Q NJJ �C�(OF-O O'
Qpcc�cco
VQ'OOL f6^ mERQ'
pV U UU�C o
J N tn ��k V,,, f/1
L' IO IO.-
adoO�WLLOa�
� o � � ' �
m�n�nn N m�n
� �rn�°'�
Dm�O�� U� �c+D�
Qa�o�rnm2�1-M�
�t�t -s��
�,
io
�
� iW
,
O N I�
N i � Irn
� ' V i
� _f i�
a I�
�
C
a
�
C
O
o+
�
�
�
O
w
�
d
N
L
d
ti
..I
N
� C
f6 �p
� c
�a
U �
J Q
a
N
N
U
C
O
� J
IC �
I �
i _J �
U
� �
W
�T � E
� I�
Z
I� rn
; m c7
C .aD
I L� JO
�
I�
>
¢
�
w
N F-
LI �
v��
Coo
� �
r t()
Z
H
�
H
Z
�, w
zw
Q �
m V
0 J
S
Q
F-
a
�
�O
_
(0 Ll.l
n
o �
a �
�
m
�
X
W m
N �
c �
^ n
N
O
�
N
�
7
Z
U
a 'n
rn
c �
� J
N J
C �
�
Z
c
J
E ¢
U Z
v W
c �
N
C Q
- a
N
�
�
7
z
N
C
0
a n
y N
N
C I�
I j •n^.-
�M
xlw
m �rn
�p
N
�
c
N � c U U
{�p y�Om � O.fl.� LL
c o
��oa� 3��� a�
O V �� 0 N N N �
tA �m��N L� LL �
� � � d Q N a C G C O J
CO � 47 �7 i R� y(V (V = N �
� tOSJO Maoo �V CI
m. c � �rn N�F'm �� c
O .. N O Q_ ,,,
��� a N N� p@ N"N
11.�G J�m +...=_N aJ�c
� � � O 20.0 i.
NCL100.L.+CnCI.LLt"Qa�"� O@N
�� Y �Om U O N U �-�U �
���3 � LL Q a�i
� c�'i�m� �m QY Q6� �¢ oo ..
N �N 67 NZ CQ NJJ C E(OF-��p �
O� M C U p� Q O C C� C M N N d
� �� �a� � ��00��� rnr»�
d UJ N Qf6JU ln fq �.�„4k�'a h
� � c � a�a a��OaWLLOa�
� dU � N� � mv o� y ���
o 'o•� a � y�w��nn� dn f0 rn'�
(y � V� l0 CN��� UNLNp�i
L
arn�C��mv>Qw�<c�xct-ch.-
°18 - s cs--
�
I�
0
,a
Ix
�W
o i N ��
M i � ��
y U �
R J I�
a co
0
r
O
1
�
C
O
i+
R
�
�
w
C
m
e
d
�
J
�
� c
;9 a
c
N �
a
U �
J q
C
(0
w
d
�
`� m
IW @
I N l
U
J �
�
m �
rn �
a
m ��
Z
I C O�p
I�I�
LJo
a
I ��
W
Q
�
w
m
m
N =
� �
4 lO o
�
��
Z
F
�
w
F
Z
u�
Z W
Q �
m V
0 J
_
F-
J
F
a
�
�O
2
Z p
C (n
0
a I¢
W
a�
m
0
n
W �
N �
c �
� �
�
N
�
O
�
d
Q
�
�
z
U
o �
a �
c �
(�0 �
3 J
N Z
C �
�
m
� Z
c
�
I a F-
o z
U
U W
� J
N �
c �
— a
` N
s
E
�
z
C
a o
n
N
C �
7 ^
m �
0�
F- �
�
0
N
Z
� a� �
�
Et
C�y�m
pm�c
li' N t�ii (�
N
�
m
c
a�
�
�
.
�
�
�( g —S c. �
�
0
i�-
�
W
o �N�
� l
��
d �,
R IJ N
n' L�
�
O
a.
�
C
O
ia
0
c
d
N
L
d
V
J
N
3 C
'� �
�a
N
U �
J Q
N '
I tQ m
NU
C �
N �
`-' 3
J p
m
-�
m
�
us
¢
�
4
m
a`�i ~
v`
a
Q p
� �
Z
h
Q'
�-'
Z
w
ZW
Q �
U
O �
_
a�
..
m
0
a
w o,
N �
c �
_ n
N
�
0
�
�
7
V
a �
rn
U 0
� J
� �
N Z
C �
d
n
�
7
N
c
a o
N ~
N
N
N (p
c i..
'� ti
� v
� "
� s � z
� z � w
�, � � ¢
~ � J m �
� � G 1-
m I� �IO oZ
d. I 7
tD lZ i N W Z �
Z � U J �
t�nM �!n `U' � F'S
mv� �� `�m
J° o a W a N �
G
�L� C U U p
�F�Om =JJ~ �
0
U'� ��� � 3'�°� � �
� U N 7� O N N U C
� N N[/)... LT�� p IQ
� o°°mQm ac�c o .�
� (ONJiQ'�ryNN3 �� �
� � C J�'N � O1J C
O"Or-- N O p��� N m C �
i �Ofn 3 ._ ¢ � LL '6'6 ` 'm fl.
��t6.+L ��� mG1� pJ N�
C J _ � �. �
7 (0 O.fl.0 i �
a�wooyv�ciiLLQ¢m�
O(ON
�`� ~ =oUna�d=a��=.
�n`''� � p_Omp cd d�U a�U �
°'dcm�3 Q�tL a oa�
� � m � �ma NJJ � �Q Op �
Or1t")C U CC�CMyN�
� J UOOU��rnu��
� � C � a�.0 ND�.flW Od0
UNV �d�o
o 'o�m- o � Nrnw�jrnn�rn a"i� �
O)L��J V��CN��� VN NN�
�drn�U' J�NQao�<M2�Fch�
��
�,
io
I°
�
W
o ; � �m
� , � Irn
R J IN
a ��o
�'
Q
�
C
O
�+
A
�
w
C
m
y
c
m
u
J
N
3 �
� 'a
(n C
�a
a�i >
V U
J Q
H �
� �
U N
J C
W
I�
� � �
w
>
¢
�
¢
y W
N
N � a`
Q�o
� �
z
�
�
w
Z
y W
f z w
I J
� J
S
m
m
0
Q
W p�
y �
c �
N
O
�
a�
�
'
Z
U
o �
a a ,
m �
� J
C �
`m
�
E
�
��
c
0
an
N �
C �
'y n
m �
iv
� �
� n Z
Q z
� � >
� IT 3 ��
a @ J C]
� � a �
a I i `" I � O Z �m
ia �o ',�{ U Z �
d rn � I � c J �ch �S
N M ' C I(O (p C X� �
c�.i � @ i(A v�i � {"' �(O
a � � 'n
J O l J J d N e-
�
N � � c� c�
EFO�IDm JJ�
m���,.. �aa� o
��o�� 3��� d
I O V � 7 � N N N �
a� ycn� ��� a
p � j �O N N �" 'O'C C O J
� Q �CC._
(�O (O q) U L0.' yNN_ N �
� COYJ O Ma o 0 3 � V N
m f» c �� i�m 1 - I - o rn� c
ov�...a�oadrnd m c
�?'Ov) �� y 'y °-u'
p��p,_, 6 Q�V-NN oc°��
tL�c��d�atoaa��a
dul'o o�in=ti�'-QQ m c� o m w
u�i� � aa�i a U n�U °'
°� � c m� 3 �¢u'u'LL a o�
N �N d �ZmQ y,J Jp�� �p �
� N(`�CUO�Q O C G RCMN(�y�
��U J JUOO�'��axsr�
N'OL C � O'�� NO��WIL� ��
U� O Ntn� j N �n�� N Ipa
rn � � �� °���rnrn� �� �co�
d�_a
(VL(p Ua- t 6 CN01W�=NtN�
�d��C�IJ F-c'7.-
°l g' —�` 1--
��
��
,o
�,`
�
x
O �y �
� �I d i'�
m '� �
a I �
u�
�
C
�
C
O
i+
F
�
�
O
�
C
d
N
m
U
J
N
3 C
:°. �a
(n C
�a
m y
V U
J Q
R
a
c
�
�
N d
a�
T �
� c
O
V O
J a
...i
m �
� I�
m I
Z
IN M
U �
J �
0
a
���
u�
>
¢
�
¢
m
�
N
a`
U
Q � O
� �
.�- �
Z
H
�
W
F-�
Z
� W
� W
Q �
m U
� J
_
�
Q
F
a
I �
�O
2
I 2 p
C (n
O
a¢
W
�
m
�
a
x
w
N �
c �
N
�
O
�
�
�
�
Z
U
a '�
W
c ° r
N O
� J
C �
N
�
R
Z
T
C J
o_ F-
o Z
vIW
� J
R �
C �
- a
N
Q
E
�
N
c
a o
y n
N
C �
'h n
m �
O M
F- I�
�
O
N
Z
�
�
�
�
�--
- N 1 C U U
� FO1O(Il JJF�- �..
d'� �..: � o_ o_ � o
� �N� ( 3JJ = N
�o�� O c
� om c�in 0.aa rn o m
a i V N Q d i c c c O J
� CUN��Q' � �
� (O Y O T� d 0 0 0 �- N
O'a� N O Q�6) NHI-p] C'JIL
o.°_'Ot�g-'q��-�d� p�dd
�-�3 -�@�'�to�aa=�aJ��
NW 00�(n caC�O f�6 N
� V E� C O 2 ❑ C m C
�n"�a ��0�1�aa�i a�iLLU a�U �
°'dcm�3 4�u. o- oy
�
N.� m��maG1JJ��¢�O�
�c�Va l�Ca' OCC��i��d'
E��00
a�N �� y Q m y��?��.� N
� dc Oa�
c o ° 'o
00'NDUNW
N�CO � �?� (6 CN��� �NrN�
.-arn�c�_,wv�a�o�.-�xvr��
�tS -Sc.�.--
�
I�
0
a
r ,. W
r. d
O N ip�
ti �� i�
d �
a J �(q
_i0
1'
c
�
C
O
m
�
�
O
w
C
m
fA
C
V
J
N
3 C
� �
(A =
�a
m >
J Q
N
O
0
N
>
A O
F� �
C
C �
U �
-..1 O'
.-1
�
I �
�
W
�
Q
d'
Q
m
N W
d—
a
Q O O
� �
Z
F
�
�"
Z
w
m u�i
Z �
m V
0 =
N
(0
�
X
rn
��
c ,
N
O
N
a
�
7
Z
U
a '�
U O
N �
� J
C �
m`
�
�
7
Z
N
c
0
an
N
C �
'N �
m
r � N) Z
Q IZ c � W
7' � "'� Q
F- � J m [].
pp � � O_ � x[
� I� � O � Z �
� N W U
c�o f � Z �
IZ Z � U J 0
W M 0 Cn . �� M .iL)
F-- �Y m�
� o a ¢ � ¢ o
O W 6. N .--
G
�_�� UU
m d�� � ao_i o`
LL
� �O- ` �iJJ C N
�O V � � �{N N LL
� Nhfn»+ � �V �
p� Om � � aaa m O 3
Q C C,
� (ONJ�Q_'�NNN3 � �
O"O� N O 6�m N�f'-m C_.-1 C
i��(n 7 ._ ���p�p y N 0.
��(0...����U'NN� Q@NN
LL C�J d m� D O.O_C �`�J��
NW 00�(q l6C�Ol9 w
�v Ef-}� c oU aa� d= a�0 c o�c
�n � n Om� am mLLU a�U �
°���m�3 QLLLL Q o
� aoo_� vc Q �
`m [II. m,�, a�c Qa � o.�
N�N y�Z C a U7JJ m�
� d M C U O� C O C C� L M W N d
C ik Naty, C U2'D�L (Oti �flQ'
47 UJ N n N N�.,�„�kw'a N
a�i-dL � � a�.n d��nW�Oa�
U�U�pN�CN�o o �yV�No
o�oi°� �a'W�°�
�LCO �� U� f0 CN W W� vNtN�
dW��J�CnQW'-rM2�{-Me'�
�
�'' j' —f ..a 7� N �l� t�'RT�� .
_:�]�,l1.K��L����:�r �t_ nyi � _. ° a��� -- .. . "�.�"�.'e�'�_:5�.�_iU��'�.y
i ��'�' Ms�""i ' ') ..f � 5 . ' - ��.�-+' i
�'f -- . 4 t z ,1 ,.� . _ , - ' Y �.
- � .. - . ' �'.�
� *- TOBACCO COMPLIANCE CI�CKFORM' -
� `:�'-: _ _ ' ''�:- �,
DATE: � � � 1 -� �s �rn�: a �cExss r.D. rr�m: � �s39 `'-' .'�
,u� - - �/ � , ��� - —
NAME OF CAMPLIANCE CI-IECI�R: � . , _ - NAME OF OFFICER: " �1y .'. ` , _ _
NAME & ADDRESS OF LICENSID VENDOR: 1 1� C V�S� �`�. v� c�:..� ,++,-�) {�-�r .` ``
n
wAS x� zosacco: s�-s�vs� _
�S CL U l�S��+
nss�s�n7 _ r,�acfm�� 1�
DID THE MACHII�IE HAVE Tf� PROPER REMOTE DEVICE? ��
SALE 4TAS MADE: YES � NO ' BRAND: I'11, �1'�-� ,� Xi_.!- I I �z ]7 �
NAMEOFCLII2K Sco1'f"�'1��� ,.�Nrr 2Z n Ia*ic� SEX: M�_ F
DESCRIPTION:
CHECK ABORTED: YES
,
NO
ADDITIONAL CO2vA�fENTS: � .,S ? ' � � �'�.Q � � .� �*> �.i�-� �• � �..^-� •
r�' C4'1c t 1' t'.xt �'• ��1 " t E�� �
� �:� ,�n —3� L�2.FP'7 �- �i
. n l _ 1( 1 _ �
� ^Ai _
_ .�,t _f.: _
5
" rl. � `� a ;5,
a - ,_ ' t.,.� .-� - _ �' _
' __ . - .- -, _ _ �� -� �_ _ " "
_ . _ " ' ' _ ` _ _ i
> . .. . :.