98-317Council File # l ' �
Green Sheet # O �
ORIGINAL
Presented By
Referred To
Committee: Date
Z9
On January 5, 1998, an adverse action was initiated against the Auto Repair Gazage License
held by Mary P. Fasching d1bJa M.F. Automotive (License ID No. 14762), located at 1728 Selby
Avenue in St. Paul, when aNOTICE OF VIOLATION which identified several violations of e�sting
license conditions was mailed to the licensee.
Subsequent to this NOTICE an agreement has been reached between the licensee and the
Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection for the placement of additional
restrictions on the existing Iicense. The licensee agrees that these conditions will appear as
restricrions on the existing license and failure to operate within these requirements could be grounds
for revocation of the license. Therefore;
BE IT RESOLVED, that the current adverse action against the licenses held by Mary P.
Fasching d/b/a M.E Automotive is hereby withdrawn and the following conditions are placed on the
license:
1. Parking for customers and employees shali be arranged on the lot as shown on the
attached site plan. No more than sixteen (16) vehicles sha11 be parked out doors on
the lot. The exception to the number of vehicles is the dump truck which will be
parked along the south side of the building in the area shown on the site plan. This
vehicle shail not be used for the storage of parts or refuse. The dump truck must be
operable and used in the conjunction with the business.
2. AIl vehicles parked outdoors on the Iot must be completely assembled with no parts
missing. Vehicle salvage is not permitted.
3. Vehicle parts, partially disassembled vehicles, tires, oil, vehicle hoist ar similar items
will not be stared outdoors. Trash wiil be stored in the dumpster in the existing
enclosed area. All such rraaterials presently stored oufdoors on the site must be
removed by Wednesday, April I5, 1998.
4. No repaix of vehicles will occur on the exterior of the Iot or on the public right-of-
way. Vehicles attached to tow trucks shall not be parked in the public right-of-way.
RESOLUTION
OF SQINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
5. The proposed site improvements shall be completed by September 1, 1998 as
detailed on the plan. This shall include fencing, striping for the parking spaces (#1
thru #8), landscaping and the chain device restricting entrance to the property both
during business hours and after the business is closed. A pernut is required from the
a� - ���
1 Office of License, Tnspecfions and Environmentai Protection to install the fence.
2
3 6. The curb-cut on Herschel neazest Selby Ave. Must be removed and replace with curb
4 and gutter, to city specifications, by September 1, 1949. Until, this work is
5 completed, the driveway opening shall be closed for vehicle access with a chain or
6 other appropriate restraint. A permit from Public Works Sidewalk Division is
7 required for work in the public right-of-way. Only contractors ticensed with Public
8 Works may da driveway removad and boulevard restoration.
9
10 7. The remaining active driveways to the properiy will be closed with a chain or similar
11 gated device during the times when the business is closed.
12
13
Requested by Department of:
$Y � iLJ�LGrLY'6 G�l %�'.��C+v `---
Form Approved by City Attorney
BY: ��,,��� � �.�-�
Approved by Mayor fox Submission to Council
Y� `L By:
pproved by Mayor Da e
✓�
ldopted by Council: Date \O ��g
�doption Certified by Council Secretary
�
LIEP
ONTACT PERSON 8 MiONE
Rabert Kessler 266-9112
4-22-98 Public
416/48
TOTAL. # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
�l$' �1'j
GREEN SHEET No 608'7�
� u �.,�.� ��,�_
� ❑ �.,n� ❑ �„«� —
❑ ww¢utamxccsuu� ❑ nuxeu�miw�ecrn
❑ WYORlaMA89dfYlT� ❑
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Concerning the Auto Repair Garage License held by Aiary P. Fasching d/b1a M.F. Automotive
located at 1728 Selby Avenue.
PLANNING COMMISSION
C16 COMMRTEE
C1V1L SERVICE COMM{SSION
RSONqLSERVICE CONTRACfS MUSTANSWFR7NE FOLLOWING QIlESTIONS:
Has this percoNfirtn everworked urider a oonfract farthis dM�rtmenYt
YES NO
Hes tMC P��rm ever heen a uH emDbYeeT
YES NO
Dcee Mis persoMml P�s a s16tl not normairy0osaessed bY anY CurtHR ciN emGbYee?
VES NO
is this pelaor✓firtn a targetetl veridoY7
YES NO
Coimc�l RQsearch Gent�r
.�: � y � :,' d B�F�
�
IF APPROVED
�OUNT OF TRANSAC?ION S COST/REVENUE BUDfiETED (CIRCLE ONk�
SOURCE ACTIVRT NUMeER
INFORAtA'f10N (EXP WN)
YES NO
PUBLIC HEARING
Licensee Name:
Address:
Mary P. Fasching d/b!a M. F. Automotive
1728 Selby Avenue
Council Hearing Date: April 22, 1998
Violation: Viofation Of License Conditions Related to:
Prohibited Vehicle Repair of Street
Limitation of Vehictes on Lot
Date:
Place:
August 11, '1997, September 17, '1997,
December 19, 1997
Licensed Premises
Matrix Presumptive Penalty: Revocation of License
�tY
Recommendation vf Assistant City Attorney on behatf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection;
Additian of 7 conditions on license
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. 4/1/98 Letter from LIEP to Mary Fasching with Proposed
Conditions
3. Notice of Violation
4. License information
5. License restrictions
CITY OF SAINT FAUL
Norm Coleman, Mtryor
April 1, 1998
Mary Fasching
1728 Seiby Avenue
Saint Paul MN 55104
RE: 1728 Selby Avenue
Ms. Fasching:
OFFICE OF LiCENSE, INSPECTIONS AND
ENV[RONMENTALPROTECTION q�+ 1t�
Ro6ert Kessler, Direcror
LOWRYPROFESSIDNALBUILDI��G Telephone:672-266-9090
Suite 300 Facsimile: 612-166-9099
350 S[ Peter St�eet 6I2466-9124
SairuPaul,Minnesota551Q2-I5T0 g ,��., y ,.�, :r . # � t � ' � j
�a3s`�� $ � �i.�
AP�t 4 Z 19g8
'`��,� E $ ������� {
On March 3, 1998, we met in my office to discuss on-site parking, landscaping and
related issues for your auto repair business at the referenced address. Your
attorney-, Charles Bethei, was also there at that meeting. I reviewed a site pian you
prepared.
Based on our conversation and the plan submitted, we wili approve the proposed
changes to the site subject to the following conditions:
1) Parking for customers and employees shali be arranged on the lot as shown on
the attached site pfan. No more than 16 vehicles shall be parked out doors on
the lot. The exception to the number of vehicies is the dump truck which wi11 be
parked along the south side of the building in the area shown on the site plan.
This vehicle shaii not be used for the storage of parts or refuse. The dump truck
must be operabie and used in the conjunction with the business.
21 Ail vehicles parked outdoors on the lot must be completeiy assembied with no
parts missing. Vehicle satvage is not permitted.
3) Vehicle parts, partial{y disassembfed vehicfes, tires, oil, vehicie hoist or simiiar
items witl not be stored outdoors. Trash wilt be stored in the dumpster in the
existing enclosed area. AII such materials presently stored outdoors on the site
must be removed by Wednesday, Apri/ 15, 1998.
4) No repair of vehicles will occur on the exterior of the lot or on the public right-of-
way. Vehicles aitached to tow trucks shali not be parked in the public right-of-
way.
5) The proposed site improvements shatl be completed by September 1, 1998 as
detailed on the plan. This shali include fencing, striping for the parking spaces
(#1 thru #8), landscaping and the chain device restricting entrance to the,
property both during business hours and after the business is cfosed. A permit
is requi�ed from thrs office to insta!! the fence.
�1 � -� ��
April 1, 1998
Mary Fasching
Page 2 of 2
6) The curb-cut on Fierschet nearest Selby Ave, must be removed and replaced
with curb and gutter, to city specifications, by September 1, 1999. Until, this
work is completed, the driveway opening shall be closed for vehicle access with
a chain or other appropriate restraint. A pe�mit fiom Public Works Sidewa/k
Division is requrred for work in the public right-of way. Only contractors
licensed with Public Works may do driveway removal and bouleva�d
resioratians.
7) The remaining active driveways to the property wili be closed with a chain or
similar gated device during the times when the business is closed.
These conditions will appear as restrictions on your license and failing to operate
within these requirements could be grounds for revocation of the license.
Piease call me at 266-9083 with a�y questions.
G�L[T�'�'k'tII.. �.
Lawrence R. Zangs
Zoning Technician
enc.
cc: Charles E. Bethel
Phii Byrne
Robert Kessler
Ginger Palmer
/ �•
? 7Z8 S:��a°r
av�AF: � �'_r^:.°<<�car, ? � �'x i ��''
� a' 3 0� �' . 3'0' 3 0 5 `�' Co"'
10'
6'
37'
�
1 '
r
i
i
i
I
�
�__ ..
�
� f
j � i
� I
i i
t i
,
�-� ._ r
SI.�?�ti`:h! :;
C _�' �
Gt:C s=
N � :� J'�
� i ;
i i
; ; �
� 2 • 3 ; �}
� I
I � '
t
,
�DAY '�� '� ' � ,
i 2 j"/%�� �'
�%,� ��� t��� �.
;
�� �t �������� /
� � _.:���.�$�s�vl
1.��' J1. :���.� �
_
�e �t � , � _ r r�r ��� i
� : �=_. :- " � ��s
^3< E�JGG�Mnn!'3 �.r��
<o - f C�� t�a
�lan�c� ¢ VGly Zi �
T � .., �
73?�_ f:.Y;A'T � ,
� �, ;
.
t �
� ;
a��laictr�I�u;,,� j
-�--
l�cr o55 cp '� 1
� � �
-` \ �
<
� —! i } �
� l � � � , � �<
( i i.
� ' 1 �
� � � �
G � � . I .
6 ��a y` ��� � .�1 I �Z
����� 1 1
,�1 ( l I
� 1 ) 1
C�ASS
E �'
�
;13
�
;
�R\Y=`alF.Y � ��u' �'i A�,'v
BA j�
i /
�1�' �»:
�� ���
sz' � �
By
Fil� # %� �
I�
l zo°
AnY ai` � e�n� f•�r a,• £+r:�
r-' ,; c,�� rt�., ..�„,
o� V b��°���2�iS�s"�jvt^;��_,S;/;
� ; � . � � ; .'�: �,/ ,
. i / j � � �� $AY
� � � �, /, j j : - , � ;
/' / , '� '/,'
� , ;' ;
' �Jrn� `L'J_;c � � � ( �
�� ���.o I�� 1��. 1,� I
_ _ _ -- — — — £�i5 �0�� � �
� �� � �r��'v.� a� { !_ �
,� '(�._QP i I 1 �
r z�
u $' � __ �s'
�
a
3 �'
i
i
-c�-
;
29' ;
�--
(
23' :
�
\ i
2 0'
". , -. OFFZC^ OF T8$ CITY ATTORN&Y
P B' A
eg u.. . .ry aorney � � —� � �
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Cole�nan, Mayor
January 5, 1998
NOTICE OF VIOLATIOTd
Mary Fasching
M.F. Automotive
1728 Se1by Avenue
Saint Paul , MN 55104
CivilDivision
400 Ciry Hall
IS Wert%Ilogg Slvd
Saini Pau� M'uenuala 55102
Tefephan¢: 6I2 266-877�
Faaimilc 613298-567�
RE: General Repair Garage License held by Mary Fasching d/b/a
M.F. Automotive
License #14762
Dear Ms. Fasching:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection
(LIEP) wi11 recommend that adverse action be taken against the
general repair garage license held by you at the above address_
The basis for that action is as follows:
There are conditiona on your license which
prohibit repair of vehicles on the street, or
outside the buildiag. Additionally there is a
limit of twelve cars which can be in your
parking lot both duriag and after business
hours. On December 18, 1997 work was being
done oa a piek-ug truck on the street outside
the building. The truck was later moved to
the business parking lot. On August 11, 1997
there were sixteen cara parked in the lot and
on September 17, 19897 there were mare than
twelve cars parked on the lot.
If you do not dispute the facts stated above, please write a
letter stating that fact and the matter can be scheduled before
the City Council for a hearing on what, if any penalty, should be
impased on your license.
If you dispute the facts, you are entitled to a hearing before an
administrative law judge. If you wish to have such a hearing,
please let me know that in writing. The matter will then be
- - scheduled for a h and you will receive,^ti� notice letting you
know the date, ti : and place of the hearing;. and giving you a
short explanation of the procedures. If you have questions Q p 3\1
regarding this matter, you may contact me at 266-8710. If I have
not heard from you by January 16, 1998, I will assume that you
are not contesting the facts, and will schedule the matter £or a
hearing before the City Council.
Sincerely,
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, DepuCy Director of LIBP
Kristina Schweinler, License Inspector
RfiSTRICTIONS INQUIRY SCRfiEN
LICENSE ID: 14762
DBA:M.F. AUTOMOTIVFs
NOTE: 1:021188 PH ON APPN FOR GENSRAL, REPAIR GARAGE LICENS
2:E APP'D WITH CONDITIONS AS FOLLOWS C.F. 88-209
3:1. NO ON STRSST REPAIR.
4:2. THE 'I'HI2EE OFF-STREET PARFCING SPOTS ON THE SITF
5: OF THB BUSINESS NEs'XT TO HPRSCHEL STREET WILL BE II
6: SED BY CUSTOMERS AI3D EMPLOYEES .
7:3. THFS PARKING LOT CAN HOLD NO MORE THAN 12 CARS
8:BOTH DURING ANS� AFTER BUSINESS HOURS.
9:4. NO CARS BE LPsFT IN TH& PARICING LOT ON A JACK O
10:R LIFT.
11:5. ALL MAINPENANCE WORK WILL BE DONE INSID$ TH£s B
12:UILDING.
13:6. NO TOOLS OR PARTS WILL BE STANDING OUTSIDE TAE
14: BUILDING.
15:7. ALL CARS TIiAT ARTS LEFT IN LONG TERM STORAGE (1
Date: Sep 26
ai-���
Date: Sep 26
RBSTRICTIONS INQUIRY SCREEN
LICENSE ID: 14762
DBA:M.F. AUTOMOTIVE
NOTE:16: WEEIC) T+ITLL HAVE ALL BODY PARTS INTACT AND WILL B33
17: CLOSED.
18:8. IF OVER THItEE VERIFIABLS COMPLAINTS ARE RECSIV
19:ED WITHIN SIX MONTHS, THE COUNCIL WOULD CONSIDER T
20:HAT CAUSE FOR RfiVOCATION.
21:
22•
23-
24:
25-
26:
27:
2S:
29•
30:
a1Q -3�`l
Lic ID ...................
STAT.....................
Business Name............
Address ..................
Zip ......................
Doing Business As........
License Name .............
Exp Date .................
Insurance Carrier........
Ins. Policy Number.......
Insurance Effective Date.
Ins. Expiration Date.....
NOTE AREA ................
TaxId ........... .......
Worker Comg Exp Date.....
14762
RS
FASCHING, MARY P
1728 SELBY AVE
55104
M.F. AUTOMOTIVE
AUTO REPAZR GARI�GE
12/16/97
�1� '���
INSP CHANGE FROM 02 TO 01 ON 4/09/92
120Q2
021188 PH ON APPN FOR GENERAL REPAIR GARAGE LICENS
E APP'D WfCONDITIONS C.F. 88-209
checked 1OJ28/94
in compliance at time of insp.however,this busines
s requires frequent monitoring.R JENTS
10f30/95 CONTACTED MARY F.AND DICUSSED EACH INDIVI
DUAL RESTRICTION.IT APPEARS THAT THE RESTRICTION T
HAT STATES THAT ALL CARS THAT Al2E LEFT SN LONG TER
M STORAGE WILL HAVE ALL BODY PARTS INTACT.I BROUGA
T TO MARY'S ATTENTION THAT THEY WERE IN VIOLATION
OF THIS RESTR.AND SAOWED HER A GMC TRUCK 612-HRSWj
O A FRONT CLIP,SHE SAID THAT SOMEONE LBFT IT TAERE
I ASKED HER WHO,SHE STATED SHE DID NOT KNOW.I TOLD
HER TO REMOVE AS SOON AS POSS.SHE PR�MISED TO COM
PLY.THIS BUS.REQUIRES MUCH MONITORING.WILL KEEP AN
EYE ONTHIS,HOWEVER MARY THINKS SHE IS BEING HARRAS
11j21/96 WAITING FOR AL3 REPORT RJ
2/25J97 - FINE LETTER SENT ($1,000 DUE 3/21/97)-LB
2j19/97 - C.F. #97-163 APP'D IMPOSING $1000.00
FINE
3/21/97 - PAID $1,000.00 FINE - i.AR
3985334
Telephone ................ 646-0032
OFFICE OF TETE CITY ATTORNEY
PegBir$ CiryAttomey �� �1\�
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
Civil Divisian
400 Ciry Hal1
IS West Ke[Iogg Blvd
Sain[ Pau1, Minn¢sot¢ 55702
Telephone: 612 266-87I0
Facsimile: 612 298-5619
April 3, 1998
Chazles E. Bethel II
Mahlum & Associates
1020 Piper Jaffray Piaza
444 Cedar Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING
RE: General Repair Gazage License held by Mary P. Fasching d16/a M.F. Automotive for the
premises at 1728 Selby Ave. In St. Paul
License ID No.: 14762
Our file Number: G96-0337
Dear Mr. Bethel:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named estabiishment has been scheduled for
5:30 p.m., Apri122, 1948 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and
Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documettts wluch wi11 be presented to the
City Council for their consideration. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to speak
on behalf of yow client. Based upon the agreement to the placement of addirional conditions on the
e�sting license, the recommendation of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection will by that the current adverse action be withdrawn if the newly agreed upon conditions
aze added to the license. However, this is only a recommendation, which the Council is free to
reject. If that happens your client would then be entifled to a hearing before an ALJ on the original
Notice of Violation letter.
Page 2
Charles E. Bethel II
Apri13,1998
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
.����- �� ���.
Virguua D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
�� ����
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Directot LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Michelle McCafferty, Exec. Director, Le�ngton-Hamline Community Council, 1160 Selby
Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104
Council File # l ' �
Green Sheet # O �
ORIGINAL
Presented By
Referred To
Committee: Date
Z9
On January 5, 1998, an adverse action was initiated against the Auto Repair Gazage License
held by Mary P. Fasching d1bJa M.F. Automotive (License ID No. 14762), located at 1728 Selby
Avenue in St. Paul, when aNOTICE OF VIOLATION which identified several violations of e�sting
license conditions was mailed to the licensee.
Subsequent to this NOTICE an agreement has been reached between the licensee and the
Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection for the placement of additional
restrictions on the existing Iicense. The licensee agrees that these conditions will appear as
restricrions on the existing license and failure to operate within these requirements could be grounds
for revocation of the license. Therefore;
BE IT RESOLVED, that the current adverse action against the licenses held by Mary P.
Fasching d/b/a M.E Automotive is hereby withdrawn and the following conditions are placed on the
license:
1. Parking for customers and employees shali be arranged on the lot as shown on the
attached site plan. No more than sixteen (16) vehicles sha11 be parked out doors on
the lot. The exception to the number of vehicles is the dump truck which will be
parked along the south side of the building in the area shown on the site plan. This
vehicle shail not be used for the storage of parts or refuse. The dump truck must be
operable and used in the conjunction with the business.
2. AIl vehicles parked outdoors on the Iot must be completely assembled with no parts
missing. Vehicle salvage is not permitted.
3. Vehicle parts, partially disassembled vehicles, tires, oil, vehicle hoist ar similar items
will not be stared outdoors. Trash wiil be stored in the dumpster in the existing
enclosed area. All such rraaterials presently stored oufdoors on the site must be
removed by Wednesday, April I5, 1998.
4. No repaix of vehicles will occur on the exterior of the Iot or on the public right-of-
way. Vehicles attached to tow trucks shall not be parked in the public right-of-way.
RESOLUTION
OF SQINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
5. The proposed site improvements shall be completed by September 1, 1998 as
detailed on the plan. This shall include fencing, striping for the parking spaces (#1
thru #8), landscaping and the chain device restricting entrance to the property both
during business hours and after the business is closed. A pernut is required from the
a� - ���
1 Office of License, Tnspecfions and Environmentai Protection to install the fence.
2
3 6. The curb-cut on Herschel neazest Selby Ave. Must be removed and replace with curb
4 and gutter, to city specifications, by September 1, 1949. Until, this work is
5 completed, the driveway opening shall be closed for vehicle access with a chain or
6 other appropriate restraint. A permit from Public Works Sidewalk Division is
7 required for work in the public right-of-way. Only contractors ticensed with Public
8 Works may da driveway removad and boulevard restoration.
9
10 7. The remaining active driveways to the properiy will be closed with a chain or similar
11 gated device during the times when the business is closed.
12
13
Requested by Department of:
$Y � iLJ�LGrLY'6 G�l %�'.��C+v `---
Form Approved by City Attorney
BY: ��,,��� � �.�-�
Approved by Mayor fox Submission to Council
Y� `L By:
pproved by Mayor Da e
✓�
ldopted by Council: Date \O ��g
�doption Certified by Council Secretary
�
LIEP
ONTACT PERSON 8 MiONE
Rabert Kessler 266-9112
4-22-98 Public
416/48
TOTAL. # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
�l$' �1'j
GREEN SHEET No 608'7�
� u �.,�.� ��,�_
� ❑ �.,n� ❑ �„«� —
❑ ww¢utamxccsuu� ❑ nuxeu�miw�ecrn
❑ WYORlaMA89dfYlT� ❑
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Concerning the Auto Repair Garage License held by Aiary P. Fasching d/b1a M.F. Automotive
located at 1728 Selby Avenue.
PLANNING COMMISSION
C16 COMMRTEE
C1V1L SERVICE COMM{SSION
RSONqLSERVICE CONTRACfS MUSTANSWFR7NE FOLLOWING QIlESTIONS:
Has this percoNfirtn everworked urider a oonfract farthis dM�rtmenYt
YES NO
Hes tMC P��rm ever heen a uH emDbYeeT
YES NO
Dcee Mis persoMml P�s a s16tl not normairy0osaessed bY anY CurtHR ciN emGbYee?
VES NO
is this pelaor✓firtn a targetetl veridoY7
YES NO
Coimc�l RQsearch Gent�r
.�: � y � :,' d B�F�
�
IF APPROVED
�OUNT OF TRANSAC?ION S COST/REVENUE BUDfiETED (CIRCLE ONk�
SOURCE ACTIVRT NUMeER
INFORAtA'f10N (EXP WN)
YES NO
PUBLIC HEARING
Licensee Name:
Address:
Mary P. Fasching d/b!a M. F. Automotive
1728 Selby Avenue
Council Hearing Date: April 22, 1998
Violation: Viofation Of License Conditions Related to:
Prohibited Vehicle Repair of Street
Limitation of Vehictes on Lot
Date:
Place:
August 11, '1997, September 17, '1997,
December 19, 1997
Licensed Premises
Matrix Presumptive Penalty: Revocation of License
�tY
Recommendation vf Assistant City Attorney on behatf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection;
Additian of 7 conditions on license
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. 4/1/98 Letter from LIEP to Mary Fasching with Proposed
Conditions
3. Notice of Violation
4. License information
5. License restrictions
CITY OF SAINT FAUL
Norm Coleman, Mtryor
April 1, 1998
Mary Fasching
1728 Seiby Avenue
Saint Paul MN 55104
RE: 1728 Selby Avenue
Ms. Fasching:
OFFICE OF LiCENSE, INSPECTIONS AND
ENV[RONMENTALPROTECTION q�+ 1t�
Ro6ert Kessler, Direcror
LOWRYPROFESSIDNALBUILDI��G Telephone:672-266-9090
Suite 300 Facsimile: 612-166-9099
350 S[ Peter St�eet 6I2466-9124
SairuPaul,Minnesota551Q2-I5T0 g ,��., y ,.�, :r . # � t � ' � j
�a3s`�� $ � �i.�
AP�t 4 Z 19g8
'`��,� E $ ������� {
On March 3, 1998, we met in my office to discuss on-site parking, landscaping and
related issues for your auto repair business at the referenced address. Your
attorney-, Charles Bethei, was also there at that meeting. I reviewed a site pian you
prepared.
Based on our conversation and the plan submitted, we wili approve the proposed
changes to the site subject to the following conditions:
1) Parking for customers and employees shali be arranged on the lot as shown on
the attached site pfan. No more than 16 vehicles shall be parked out doors on
the lot. The exception to the number of vehicies is the dump truck which wi11 be
parked along the south side of the building in the area shown on the site plan.
This vehicle shaii not be used for the storage of parts or refuse. The dump truck
must be operabie and used in the conjunction with the business.
21 Ail vehicles parked outdoors on the lot must be completeiy assembied with no
parts missing. Vehicle satvage is not permitted.
3) Vehicle parts, partial{y disassembfed vehicfes, tires, oil, vehicie hoist or simiiar
items witl not be stored outdoors. Trash wilt be stored in the dumpster in the
existing enclosed area. AII such materials presently stored outdoors on the site
must be removed by Wednesday, Apri/ 15, 1998.
4) No repair of vehicles will occur on the exterior of the lot or on the public right-of-
way. Vehicles aitached to tow trucks shali not be parked in the public right-of-
way.
5) The proposed site improvements shatl be completed by September 1, 1998 as
detailed on the plan. This shali include fencing, striping for the parking spaces
(#1 thru #8), landscaping and the chain device restricting entrance to the,
property both during business hours and after the business is cfosed. A permit
is requi�ed from thrs office to insta!! the fence.
�1 � -� ��
April 1, 1998
Mary Fasching
Page 2 of 2
6) The curb-cut on Fierschet nearest Selby Ave, must be removed and replaced
with curb and gutter, to city specifications, by September 1, 1999. Until, this
work is completed, the driveway opening shall be closed for vehicle access with
a chain or other appropriate restraint. A pe�mit fiom Public Works Sidewa/k
Division is requrred for work in the public right-of way. Only contractors
licensed with Public Works may do driveway removal and bouleva�d
resioratians.
7) The remaining active driveways to the property wili be closed with a chain or
similar gated device during the times when the business is closed.
These conditions will appear as restrictions on your license and failing to operate
within these requirements could be grounds for revocation of the license.
Piease call me at 266-9083 with a�y questions.
G�L[T�'�'k'tII.. �.
Lawrence R. Zangs
Zoning Technician
enc.
cc: Charles E. Bethel
Phii Byrne
Robert Kessler
Ginger Palmer
/ �•
? 7Z8 S:��a°r
av�AF: � �'_r^:.°<<�car, ? � �'x i ��''
� a' 3 0� �' . 3'0' 3 0 5 `�' Co"'
10'
6'
37'
�
1 '
r
i
i
i
I
�
�__ ..
�
� f
j � i
� I
i i
t i
,
�-� ._ r
SI.�?�ti`:h! :;
C _�' �
Gt:C s=
N � :� J'�
� i ;
i i
; ; �
� 2 • 3 ; �}
� I
I � '
t
,
�DAY '�� '� ' � ,
i 2 j"/%�� �'
�%,� ��� t��� �.
;
�� �t �������� /
� � _.:���.�$�s�vl
1.��' J1. :���.� �
_
�e �t � , � _ r r�r ��� i
� : �=_. :- " � ��s
^3< E�JGG�Mnn!'3 �.r��
<o - f C�� t�a
�lan�c� ¢ VGly Zi �
T � .., �
73?�_ f:.Y;A'T � ,
� �, ;
.
t �
� ;
a��laictr�I�u;,,� j
-�--
l�cr o55 cp '� 1
� � �
-` \ �
<
� —! i } �
� l � � � , � �<
( i i.
� ' 1 �
� � � �
G � � . I .
6 ��a y` ��� � .�1 I �Z
����� 1 1
,�1 ( l I
� 1 ) 1
C�ASS
E �'
�
;13
�
;
�R\Y=`alF.Y � ��u' �'i A�,'v
BA j�
i /
�1�' �»:
�� ���
sz' � �
By
Fil� # %� �
I�
l zo°
AnY ai` � e�n� f•�r a,• £+r:�
r-' ,; c,�� rt�., ..�„,
o� V b��°���2�iS�s"�jvt^;��_,S;/;
� ; � . � � ; .'�: �,/ ,
. i / j � � �� $AY
� � � �, /, j j : - , � ;
/' / , '� '/,'
� , ;' ;
' �Jrn� `L'J_;c � � � ( �
�� ���.o I�� 1��. 1,� I
_ _ _ -- — — — £�i5 �0�� � �
� �� � �r��'v.� a� { !_ �
,� '(�._QP i I 1 �
r z�
u $' � __ �s'
�
a
3 �'
i
i
-c�-
;
29' ;
�--
(
23' :
�
\ i
2 0'
". , -. OFFZC^ OF T8$ CITY ATTORN&Y
P B' A
eg u.. . .ry aorney � � —� � �
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Cole�nan, Mayor
January 5, 1998
NOTICE OF VIOLATIOTd
Mary Fasching
M.F. Automotive
1728 Se1by Avenue
Saint Paul , MN 55104
CivilDivision
400 Ciry Hall
IS Wert%Ilogg Slvd
Saini Pau� M'uenuala 55102
Tefephan¢: 6I2 266-877�
Faaimilc 613298-567�
RE: General Repair Garage License held by Mary Fasching d/b/a
M.F. Automotive
License #14762
Dear Ms. Fasching:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection
(LIEP) wi11 recommend that adverse action be taken against the
general repair garage license held by you at the above address_
The basis for that action is as follows:
There are conditiona on your license which
prohibit repair of vehicles on the street, or
outside the buildiag. Additionally there is a
limit of twelve cars which can be in your
parking lot both duriag and after business
hours. On December 18, 1997 work was being
done oa a piek-ug truck on the street outside
the building. The truck was later moved to
the business parking lot. On August 11, 1997
there were sixteen cara parked in the lot and
on September 17, 19897 there were mare than
twelve cars parked on the lot.
If you do not dispute the facts stated above, please write a
letter stating that fact and the matter can be scheduled before
the City Council for a hearing on what, if any penalty, should be
impased on your license.
If you dispute the facts, you are entitled to a hearing before an
administrative law judge. If you wish to have such a hearing,
please let me know that in writing. The matter will then be
- - scheduled for a h and you will receive,^ti� notice letting you
know the date, ti : and place of the hearing;. and giving you a
short explanation of the procedures. If you have questions Q p 3\1
regarding this matter, you may contact me at 266-8710. If I have
not heard from you by January 16, 1998, I will assume that you
are not contesting the facts, and will schedule the matter £or a
hearing before the City Council.
Sincerely,
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, DepuCy Director of LIBP
Kristina Schweinler, License Inspector
RfiSTRICTIONS INQUIRY SCRfiEN
LICENSE ID: 14762
DBA:M.F. AUTOMOTIVFs
NOTE: 1:021188 PH ON APPN FOR GENSRAL, REPAIR GARAGE LICENS
2:E APP'D WITH CONDITIONS AS FOLLOWS C.F. 88-209
3:1. NO ON STRSST REPAIR.
4:2. THE 'I'HI2EE OFF-STREET PARFCING SPOTS ON THE SITF
5: OF THB BUSINESS NEs'XT TO HPRSCHEL STREET WILL BE II
6: SED BY CUSTOMERS AI3D EMPLOYEES .
7:3. THFS PARKING LOT CAN HOLD NO MORE THAN 12 CARS
8:BOTH DURING ANS� AFTER BUSINESS HOURS.
9:4. NO CARS BE LPsFT IN TH& PARICING LOT ON A JACK O
10:R LIFT.
11:5. ALL MAINPENANCE WORK WILL BE DONE INSID$ TH£s B
12:UILDING.
13:6. NO TOOLS OR PARTS WILL BE STANDING OUTSIDE TAE
14: BUILDING.
15:7. ALL CARS TIiAT ARTS LEFT IN LONG TERM STORAGE (1
Date: Sep 26
ai-���
Date: Sep 26
RBSTRICTIONS INQUIRY SCREEN
LICENSE ID: 14762
DBA:M.F. AUTOMOTIVE
NOTE:16: WEEIC) T+ITLL HAVE ALL BODY PARTS INTACT AND WILL B33
17: CLOSED.
18:8. IF OVER THItEE VERIFIABLS COMPLAINTS ARE RECSIV
19:ED WITHIN SIX MONTHS, THE COUNCIL WOULD CONSIDER T
20:HAT CAUSE FOR RfiVOCATION.
21:
22•
23-
24:
25-
26:
27:
2S:
29•
30:
a1Q -3�`l
Lic ID ...................
STAT.....................
Business Name............
Address ..................
Zip ......................
Doing Business As........
License Name .............
Exp Date .................
Insurance Carrier........
Ins. Policy Number.......
Insurance Effective Date.
Ins. Expiration Date.....
NOTE AREA ................
TaxId ........... .......
Worker Comg Exp Date.....
14762
RS
FASCHING, MARY P
1728 SELBY AVE
55104
M.F. AUTOMOTIVE
AUTO REPAZR GARI�GE
12/16/97
�1� '���
INSP CHANGE FROM 02 TO 01 ON 4/09/92
120Q2
021188 PH ON APPN FOR GENERAL REPAIR GARAGE LICENS
E APP'D WfCONDITIONS C.F. 88-209
checked 1OJ28/94
in compliance at time of insp.however,this busines
s requires frequent monitoring.R JENTS
10f30/95 CONTACTED MARY F.AND DICUSSED EACH INDIVI
DUAL RESTRICTION.IT APPEARS THAT THE RESTRICTION T
HAT STATES THAT ALL CARS THAT Al2E LEFT SN LONG TER
M STORAGE WILL HAVE ALL BODY PARTS INTACT.I BROUGA
T TO MARY'S ATTENTION THAT THEY WERE IN VIOLATION
OF THIS RESTR.AND SAOWED HER A GMC TRUCK 612-HRSWj
O A FRONT CLIP,SHE SAID THAT SOMEONE LBFT IT TAERE
I ASKED HER WHO,SHE STATED SHE DID NOT KNOW.I TOLD
HER TO REMOVE AS SOON AS POSS.SHE PR�MISED TO COM
PLY.THIS BUS.REQUIRES MUCH MONITORING.WILL KEEP AN
EYE ONTHIS,HOWEVER MARY THINKS SHE IS BEING HARRAS
11j21/96 WAITING FOR AL3 REPORT RJ
2/25J97 - FINE LETTER SENT ($1,000 DUE 3/21/97)-LB
2j19/97 - C.F. #97-163 APP'D IMPOSING $1000.00
FINE
3/21/97 - PAID $1,000.00 FINE - i.AR
3985334
Telephone ................ 646-0032
OFFICE OF TETE CITY ATTORNEY
PegBir$ CiryAttomey �� �1\�
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
Civil Divisian
400 Ciry Hal1
IS West Ke[Iogg Blvd
Sain[ Pau1, Minn¢sot¢ 55702
Telephone: 612 266-87I0
Facsimile: 612 298-5619
April 3, 1998
Chazles E. Bethel II
Mahlum & Associates
1020 Piper Jaffray Piaza
444 Cedar Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING
RE: General Repair Gazage License held by Mary P. Fasching d16/a M.F. Automotive for the
premises at 1728 Selby Ave. In St. Paul
License ID No.: 14762
Our file Number: G96-0337
Dear Mr. Bethel:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named estabiishment has been scheduled for
5:30 p.m., Apri122, 1948 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and
Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documettts wluch wi11 be presented to the
City Council for their consideration. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to speak
on behalf of yow client. Based upon the agreement to the placement of addirional conditions on the
e�sting license, the recommendation of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection will by that the current adverse action be withdrawn if the newly agreed upon conditions
aze added to the license. However, this is only a recommendation, which the Council is free to
reject. If that happens your client would then be entifled to a hearing before an ALJ on the original
Notice of Violation letter.
Page 2
Charles E. Bethel II
Apri13,1998
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
.����- �� ���.
Virguua D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
�� ����
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Directot LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Michelle McCafferty, Exec. Director, Le�ngton-Hamline Community Council, 1160 Selby
Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104
Council File # l ' �
Green Sheet # O �
ORIGINAL
Presented By
Referred To
Committee: Date
Z9
On January 5, 1998, an adverse action was initiated against the Auto Repair Gazage License
held by Mary P. Fasching d1bJa M.F. Automotive (License ID No. 14762), located at 1728 Selby
Avenue in St. Paul, when aNOTICE OF VIOLATION which identified several violations of e�sting
license conditions was mailed to the licensee.
Subsequent to this NOTICE an agreement has been reached between the licensee and the
Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection for the placement of additional
restrictions on the existing Iicense. The licensee agrees that these conditions will appear as
restricrions on the existing license and failure to operate within these requirements could be grounds
for revocation of the license. Therefore;
BE IT RESOLVED, that the current adverse action against the licenses held by Mary P.
Fasching d/b/a M.E Automotive is hereby withdrawn and the following conditions are placed on the
license:
1. Parking for customers and employees shali be arranged on the lot as shown on the
attached site plan. No more than sixteen (16) vehicles sha11 be parked out doors on
the lot. The exception to the number of vehicles is the dump truck which will be
parked along the south side of the building in the area shown on the site plan. This
vehicle shail not be used for the storage of parts or refuse. The dump truck must be
operable and used in the conjunction with the business.
2. AIl vehicles parked outdoors on the Iot must be completely assembled with no parts
missing. Vehicle salvage is not permitted.
3. Vehicle parts, partially disassembled vehicles, tires, oil, vehicle hoist ar similar items
will not be stared outdoors. Trash wiil be stored in the dumpster in the existing
enclosed area. All such rraaterials presently stored oufdoors on the site must be
removed by Wednesday, April I5, 1998.
4. No repaix of vehicles will occur on the exterior of the Iot or on the public right-of-
way. Vehicles attached to tow trucks shall not be parked in the public right-of-way.
RESOLUTION
OF SQINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
5. The proposed site improvements shall be completed by September 1, 1998 as
detailed on the plan. This shall include fencing, striping for the parking spaces (#1
thru #8), landscaping and the chain device restricting entrance to the property both
during business hours and after the business is closed. A pernut is required from the
a� - ���
1 Office of License, Tnspecfions and Environmentai Protection to install the fence.
2
3 6. The curb-cut on Herschel neazest Selby Ave. Must be removed and replace with curb
4 and gutter, to city specifications, by September 1, 1949. Until, this work is
5 completed, the driveway opening shall be closed for vehicle access with a chain or
6 other appropriate restraint. A permit from Public Works Sidewalk Division is
7 required for work in the public right-of-way. Only contractors ticensed with Public
8 Works may da driveway removad and boulevard restoration.
9
10 7. The remaining active driveways to the properiy will be closed with a chain or similar
11 gated device during the times when the business is closed.
12
13
Requested by Department of:
$Y � iLJ�LGrLY'6 G�l %�'.��C+v `---
Form Approved by City Attorney
BY: ��,,��� � �.�-�
Approved by Mayor fox Submission to Council
Y� `L By:
pproved by Mayor Da e
✓�
ldopted by Council: Date \O ��g
�doption Certified by Council Secretary
�
LIEP
ONTACT PERSON 8 MiONE
Rabert Kessler 266-9112
4-22-98 Public
416/48
TOTAL. # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
�l$' �1'j
GREEN SHEET No 608'7�
� u �.,�.� ��,�_
� ❑ �.,n� ❑ �„«� —
❑ ww¢utamxccsuu� ❑ nuxeu�miw�ecrn
❑ WYORlaMA89dfYlT� ❑
(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Concerning the Auto Repair Garage License held by Aiary P. Fasching d/b1a M.F. Automotive
located at 1728 Selby Avenue.
PLANNING COMMISSION
C16 COMMRTEE
C1V1L SERVICE COMM{SSION
RSONqLSERVICE CONTRACfS MUSTANSWFR7NE FOLLOWING QIlESTIONS:
Has this percoNfirtn everworked urider a oonfract farthis dM�rtmenYt
YES NO
Hes tMC P��rm ever heen a uH emDbYeeT
YES NO
Dcee Mis persoMml P�s a s16tl not normairy0osaessed bY anY CurtHR ciN emGbYee?
VES NO
is this pelaor✓firtn a targetetl veridoY7
YES NO
Coimc�l RQsearch Gent�r
.�: � y � :,' d B�F�
�
IF APPROVED
�OUNT OF TRANSAC?ION S COST/REVENUE BUDfiETED (CIRCLE ONk�
SOURCE ACTIVRT NUMeER
INFORAtA'f10N (EXP WN)
YES NO
PUBLIC HEARING
Licensee Name:
Address:
Mary P. Fasching d/b!a M. F. Automotive
1728 Selby Avenue
Council Hearing Date: April 22, 1998
Violation: Viofation Of License Conditions Related to:
Prohibited Vehicle Repair of Street
Limitation of Vehictes on Lot
Date:
Place:
August 11, '1997, September 17, '1997,
December 19, 1997
Licensed Premises
Matrix Presumptive Penalty: Revocation of License
�tY
Recommendation vf Assistant City Attorney on behatf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection;
Additian of 7 conditions on license
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. 4/1/98 Letter from LIEP to Mary Fasching with Proposed
Conditions
3. Notice of Violation
4. License information
5. License restrictions
CITY OF SAINT FAUL
Norm Coleman, Mtryor
April 1, 1998
Mary Fasching
1728 Seiby Avenue
Saint Paul MN 55104
RE: 1728 Selby Avenue
Ms. Fasching:
OFFICE OF LiCENSE, INSPECTIONS AND
ENV[RONMENTALPROTECTION q�+ 1t�
Ro6ert Kessler, Direcror
LOWRYPROFESSIDNALBUILDI��G Telephone:672-266-9090
Suite 300 Facsimile: 612-166-9099
350 S[ Peter St�eet 6I2466-9124
SairuPaul,Minnesota551Q2-I5T0 g ,��., y ,.�, :r . # � t � ' � j
�a3s`�� $ � �i.�
AP�t 4 Z 19g8
'`��,� E $ ������� {
On March 3, 1998, we met in my office to discuss on-site parking, landscaping and
related issues for your auto repair business at the referenced address. Your
attorney-, Charles Bethei, was also there at that meeting. I reviewed a site pian you
prepared.
Based on our conversation and the plan submitted, we wili approve the proposed
changes to the site subject to the following conditions:
1) Parking for customers and employees shali be arranged on the lot as shown on
the attached site pfan. No more than 16 vehicles shall be parked out doors on
the lot. The exception to the number of vehicies is the dump truck which wi11 be
parked along the south side of the building in the area shown on the site plan.
This vehicle shaii not be used for the storage of parts or refuse. The dump truck
must be operabie and used in the conjunction with the business.
21 Ail vehicles parked outdoors on the lot must be completeiy assembied with no
parts missing. Vehicle satvage is not permitted.
3) Vehicle parts, partial{y disassembfed vehicfes, tires, oil, vehicie hoist or simiiar
items witl not be stored outdoors. Trash wilt be stored in the dumpster in the
existing enclosed area. AII such materials presently stored outdoors on the site
must be removed by Wednesday, Apri/ 15, 1998.
4) No repair of vehicles will occur on the exterior of the lot or on the public right-of-
way. Vehicles aitached to tow trucks shali not be parked in the public right-of-
way.
5) The proposed site improvements shatl be completed by September 1, 1998 as
detailed on the plan. This shali include fencing, striping for the parking spaces
(#1 thru #8), landscaping and the chain device restricting entrance to the,
property both during business hours and after the business is cfosed. A permit
is requi�ed from thrs office to insta!! the fence.
�1 � -� ��
April 1, 1998
Mary Fasching
Page 2 of 2
6) The curb-cut on Fierschet nearest Selby Ave, must be removed and replaced
with curb and gutter, to city specifications, by September 1, 1999. Until, this
work is completed, the driveway opening shall be closed for vehicle access with
a chain or other appropriate restraint. A pe�mit fiom Public Works Sidewa/k
Division is requrred for work in the public right-of way. Only contractors
licensed with Public Works may do driveway removal and bouleva�d
resioratians.
7) The remaining active driveways to the property wili be closed with a chain or
similar gated device during the times when the business is closed.
These conditions will appear as restrictions on your license and failing to operate
within these requirements could be grounds for revocation of the license.
Piease call me at 266-9083 with a�y questions.
G�L[T�'�'k'tII.. �.
Lawrence R. Zangs
Zoning Technician
enc.
cc: Charles E. Bethel
Phii Byrne
Robert Kessler
Ginger Palmer
/ �•
? 7Z8 S:��a°r
av�AF: � �'_r^:.°<<�car, ? � �'x i ��''
� a' 3 0� �' . 3'0' 3 0 5 `�' Co"'
10'
6'
37'
�
1 '
r
i
i
i
I
�
�__ ..
�
� f
j � i
� I
i i
t i
,
�-� ._ r
SI.�?�ti`:h! :;
C _�' �
Gt:C s=
N � :� J'�
� i ;
i i
; ; �
� 2 • 3 ; �}
� I
I � '
t
,
�DAY '�� '� ' � ,
i 2 j"/%�� �'
�%,� ��� t��� �.
;
�� �t �������� /
� � _.:���.�$�s�vl
1.��' J1. :���.� �
_
�e �t � , � _ r r�r ��� i
� : �=_. :- " � ��s
^3< E�JGG�Mnn!'3 �.r��
<o - f C�� t�a
�lan�c� ¢ VGly Zi �
T � .., �
73?�_ f:.Y;A'T � ,
� �, ;
.
t �
� ;
a��laictr�I�u;,,� j
-�--
l�cr o55 cp '� 1
� � �
-` \ �
<
� —! i } �
� l � � � , � �<
( i i.
� ' 1 �
� � � �
G � � . I .
6 ��a y` ��� � .�1 I �Z
����� 1 1
,�1 ( l I
� 1 ) 1
C�ASS
E �'
�
;13
�
;
�R\Y=`alF.Y � ��u' �'i A�,'v
BA j�
i /
�1�' �»:
�� ���
sz' � �
By
Fil� # %� �
I�
l zo°
AnY ai` � e�n� f•�r a,• £+r:�
r-' ,; c,�� rt�., ..�„,
o� V b��°���2�iS�s"�jvt^;��_,S;/;
� ; � . � � ; .'�: �,/ ,
. i / j � � �� $AY
� � � �, /, j j : - , � ;
/' / , '� '/,'
� , ;' ;
' �Jrn� `L'J_;c � � � ( �
�� ���.o I�� 1��. 1,� I
_ _ _ -- — — — £�i5 �0�� � �
� �� � �r��'v.� a� { !_ �
,� '(�._QP i I 1 �
r z�
u $' � __ �s'
�
a
3 �'
i
i
-c�-
;
29' ;
�--
(
23' :
�
\ i
2 0'
". , -. OFFZC^ OF T8$ CITY ATTORN&Y
P B' A
eg u.. . .ry aorney � � —� � �
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Cole�nan, Mayor
January 5, 1998
NOTICE OF VIOLATIOTd
Mary Fasching
M.F. Automotive
1728 Se1by Avenue
Saint Paul , MN 55104
CivilDivision
400 Ciry Hall
IS Wert%Ilogg Slvd
Saini Pau� M'uenuala 55102
Tefephan¢: 6I2 266-877�
Faaimilc 613298-567�
RE: General Repair Garage License held by Mary Fasching d/b/a
M.F. Automotive
License #14762
Dear Ms. Fasching:
The Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection
(LIEP) wi11 recommend that adverse action be taken against the
general repair garage license held by you at the above address_
The basis for that action is as follows:
There are conditiona on your license which
prohibit repair of vehicles on the street, or
outside the buildiag. Additionally there is a
limit of twelve cars which can be in your
parking lot both duriag and after business
hours. On December 18, 1997 work was being
done oa a piek-ug truck on the street outside
the building. The truck was later moved to
the business parking lot. On August 11, 1997
there were sixteen cara parked in the lot and
on September 17, 19897 there were mare than
twelve cars parked on the lot.
If you do not dispute the facts stated above, please write a
letter stating that fact and the matter can be scheduled before
the City Council for a hearing on what, if any penalty, should be
impased on your license.
If you dispute the facts, you are entitled to a hearing before an
administrative law judge. If you wish to have such a hearing,
please let me know that in writing. The matter will then be
- - scheduled for a h and you will receive,^ti� notice letting you
know the date, ti : and place of the hearing;. and giving you a
short explanation of the procedures. If you have questions Q p 3\1
regarding this matter, you may contact me at 266-8710. If I have
not heard from you by January 16, 1998, I will assume that you
are not contesting the facts, and will schedule the matter £or a
hearing before the City Council.
Sincerely,
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Director of LIEP
Christine Rozek, DepuCy Director of LIBP
Kristina Schweinler, License Inspector
RfiSTRICTIONS INQUIRY SCRfiEN
LICENSE ID: 14762
DBA:M.F. AUTOMOTIVFs
NOTE: 1:021188 PH ON APPN FOR GENSRAL, REPAIR GARAGE LICENS
2:E APP'D WITH CONDITIONS AS FOLLOWS C.F. 88-209
3:1. NO ON STRSST REPAIR.
4:2. THE 'I'HI2EE OFF-STREET PARFCING SPOTS ON THE SITF
5: OF THB BUSINESS NEs'XT TO HPRSCHEL STREET WILL BE II
6: SED BY CUSTOMERS AI3D EMPLOYEES .
7:3. THFS PARKING LOT CAN HOLD NO MORE THAN 12 CARS
8:BOTH DURING ANS� AFTER BUSINESS HOURS.
9:4. NO CARS BE LPsFT IN TH& PARICING LOT ON A JACK O
10:R LIFT.
11:5. ALL MAINPENANCE WORK WILL BE DONE INSID$ TH£s B
12:UILDING.
13:6. NO TOOLS OR PARTS WILL BE STANDING OUTSIDE TAE
14: BUILDING.
15:7. ALL CARS TIiAT ARTS LEFT IN LONG TERM STORAGE (1
Date: Sep 26
ai-���
Date: Sep 26
RBSTRICTIONS INQUIRY SCREEN
LICENSE ID: 14762
DBA:M.F. AUTOMOTIVE
NOTE:16: WEEIC) T+ITLL HAVE ALL BODY PARTS INTACT AND WILL B33
17: CLOSED.
18:8. IF OVER THItEE VERIFIABLS COMPLAINTS ARE RECSIV
19:ED WITHIN SIX MONTHS, THE COUNCIL WOULD CONSIDER T
20:HAT CAUSE FOR RfiVOCATION.
21:
22•
23-
24:
25-
26:
27:
2S:
29•
30:
a1Q -3�`l
Lic ID ...................
STAT.....................
Business Name............
Address ..................
Zip ......................
Doing Business As........
License Name .............
Exp Date .................
Insurance Carrier........
Ins. Policy Number.......
Insurance Effective Date.
Ins. Expiration Date.....
NOTE AREA ................
TaxId ........... .......
Worker Comg Exp Date.....
14762
RS
FASCHING, MARY P
1728 SELBY AVE
55104
M.F. AUTOMOTIVE
AUTO REPAZR GARI�GE
12/16/97
�1� '���
INSP CHANGE FROM 02 TO 01 ON 4/09/92
120Q2
021188 PH ON APPN FOR GENERAL REPAIR GARAGE LICENS
E APP'D WfCONDITIONS C.F. 88-209
checked 1OJ28/94
in compliance at time of insp.however,this busines
s requires frequent monitoring.R JENTS
10f30/95 CONTACTED MARY F.AND DICUSSED EACH INDIVI
DUAL RESTRICTION.IT APPEARS THAT THE RESTRICTION T
HAT STATES THAT ALL CARS THAT Al2E LEFT SN LONG TER
M STORAGE WILL HAVE ALL BODY PARTS INTACT.I BROUGA
T TO MARY'S ATTENTION THAT THEY WERE IN VIOLATION
OF THIS RESTR.AND SAOWED HER A GMC TRUCK 612-HRSWj
O A FRONT CLIP,SHE SAID THAT SOMEONE LBFT IT TAERE
I ASKED HER WHO,SHE STATED SHE DID NOT KNOW.I TOLD
HER TO REMOVE AS SOON AS POSS.SHE PR�MISED TO COM
PLY.THIS BUS.REQUIRES MUCH MONITORING.WILL KEEP AN
EYE ONTHIS,HOWEVER MARY THINKS SHE IS BEING HARRAS
11j21/96 WAITING FOR AL3 REPORT RJ
2/25J97 - FINE LETTER SENT ($1,000 DUE 3/21/97)-LB
2j19/97 - C.F. #97-163 APP'D IMPOSING $1000.00
FINE
3/21/97 - PAID $1,000.00 FINE - i.AR
3985334
Telephone ................ 646-0032
OFFICE OF TETE CITY ATTORNEY
PegBir$ CiryAttomey �� �1\�
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
Civil Divisian
400 Ciry Hal1
IS West Ke[Iogg Blvd
Sain[ Pau1, Minn¢sot¢ 55702
Telephone: 612 266-87I0
Facsimile: 612 298-5619
April 3, 1998
Chazles E. Bethel II
Mahlum & Associates
1020 Piper Jaffray Piaza
444 Cedar Street
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING
RE: General Repair Gazage License held by Mary P. Fasching d16/a M.F. Automotive for the
premises at 1728 Selby Ave. In St. Paul
License ID No.: 14762
Our file Number: G96-0337
Dear Mr. Bethel:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named estabiishment has been scheduled for
5:30 p.m., Apri122, 1948 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and
Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed aze copies of the proposed resolution and other documettts wluch wi11 be presented to the
City Council for their consideration. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to speak
on behalf of yow client. Based upon the agreement to the placement of addirional conditions on the
e�sting license, the recommendation of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection will by that the current adverse action be withdrawn if the newly agreed upon conditions
aze added to the license. However, this is only a recommendation, which the Council is free to
reject. If that happens your client would then be entifled to a hearing before an ALJ on the original
Notice of Violation letter.
Page 2
Charles E. Bethel II
Apri13,1998
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
.����- �� ���.
Virguua D. Palmer
Assistant City Attomey
�� ����
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Directot LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Michelle McCafferty, Exec. Director, Le�ngton-Hamline Community Council, 1160 Selby
Ave., St. Paul, MN 55104