Loading...
98-127Council File # � 1 �� ORIG1NAt Presented By Referred To Committee: Date 1997 Sales Tax Revitalization (STAR) Program Annuai Report RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby accept the 1997 Annual Report of the Sales Tax Revitalization Program as attached. P �( O Adopted by Council: Date �,� _\$ 1`i`lR' � Adoption Certified by Council Secretary: � � � Green Sheet # `�� a` RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 23 Planning & Economic Development: Form Approved by City Attorney: : Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council: � �i dr - �a� �hh�n DEFi�R7YEMiqFFICE/COUNpL DATE INITIA7E0 � v � T c��y co,���i ziiii9s GREEN SHEE CONTACT PERSON & PHONE INITIAUDATE INITIAVDAlE Mazcia Mcermond 2�-8570 � OEPAHTMENT DIRECTOR � QTV COUNpL ASSIGN � CITYATTORNEV O CITY 0.ERK MUST BE ON CAUNCIL AGENOA BY (DATE) NUMBEN FOR � BUIX3ET DIRECTOR � FIN. & MGT. SEflVICES DIR. Feb I8.1�8 OHDEN �y � nv.roa roa nss�srnr�T) � TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACiION RE�UESTED. Approval of resolution accepting the 199"/ Annual Report of the Sales Tac Revitalization (STAR) Program. RECOMMENDA710NS Approve (A� or Rejea (Fi) pERSONAL SERVICE CON7HACTS MUS7 ANSWER TME FOLLOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVII SERVICE COMMISSION �� Has thls pef50Mifm BVef Worked untlef a ContraCt fOr [hi5 tlepartmeM? _ CIB COMMITTEE _ YES NO _ S7AFF 2. Has this personHirm ever been a ciry employee? — YES NO _ oisiaici coURi _ 3. Does this Oerson/firm ossess a skill not normall p y possessed by any curreM ciry employee? SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? YES NO Explain all yes answers on separate sheet antl attach to green sheet INITIATMCa PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITV (Who. Whffi, WheO. Where, Why): ADVANTAGESIFAPPqOVED� DISADVANTAGESIFAPPROVED: DISADVANTAGES IF NOTAPPROVED. � TOTAL AMOUNT OFTRANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) VES NO FUNDItiG SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBEP FINANCIAL INFORFfiATION (EXPLAIN) 9�'1�1 STAR PROGRAM STATISTICS Total Final Applications Neighhorhood STAR 1995 1996 1997 Total 50 47 32 � 129 Totai Awards 22 20 21 63 Total $$$ Awarded $3,695,448 4,064,055 4.482.000 $12,241,503 Average Award $167,975 203,203 213.428 $194,310 Neighborhood Small Grants 1995 1996 1997 Total 22 21 13 56 14 13 12 39 $175,254 183,374 227.500 $586,128 $12,518 14,106 18.958 $15,029 Cultural STAR 1995 1996 1997 Total 26 15 10 51 11 11 9 31 $504,600 778,200 790.382 $2,194,582 $45,873 70,745 87.820 $70,793 With the exception of the average award, the above figures are contained in the 1997 STAR Annual Report. * In 1997, the Neighborhood STAR Board received 44 pre-applications, and recommended 35 for final application consideration. °I� -la�� �t Nei hborhood STAR Board Member Address List 2/98 �k Dr. Bruce Corrie iiii99 eXp. Marjorie Ebensteiner iilioi exP. Foundation Rep District Cotutcil Rep 729 Parkview Drive 2091 East Arlington Avenue Saint Paul MN 551 i 6 St. Paul, MN 55119 Phone: 487-1625 (home) Phone: 778-8580 (home) (work) 296-5472 (work) Fax: Fax: 296-8887 John Fahey 1i1i99 exp. Stephen D. Gordon 1/1/01 exp. Community Development Rep Planning Commission Rep 180 Mazia Avenue 492 Holly Avenue Saint Paul MN 55106 Saint Paul, MN 55102 Phone: 291-0083 (home) 333-0201 (work) Phone: 772-0229 Fax: 291-0086 Michelle Ketcham vvoi eXp. John Loban (CHAIR) 1/1/Ol exp. Neighborhood Business Rep At-Large Rep 200 Gilbert Building 823 Portland Avenue 413 Wacouta Street Saint Paul, MN 55104 Saint Paul, MN 55101-1957 Phone: 222-7227 (work) Phone: 221-0202 (home) Fax: 223-5229 Fax: 292-1588 John Margot iiiioi eXp. Russell J. Miller iivoo eXp. CIB Rep Neighborhood Business Rep 1818 Wellesley Avenue 267 White Bear Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55105 Saint Paul, MN 55106 Phone: 698-2994 (home) Phone: '�"�` 774-6394 (home) (call home #) 639-4742 (work) 738-2688 (work)* Thomas A. Oksak iil/o0 exp. Charles F. Senkler 1/t/99 exp District Council Rep Community Development Rep 1050 W Hoyt Avenue 1899 Fairmont Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55117 Saint Paul, I�11V 55105 Phone: 488-7437 (home) * 359-4606 (work) (call work #) Phone: 225-9414 (work) Fax: 338-4840 759-3371 (cell) " Olesak prefers all STAR calls at his work number. ** Miller prefers all STAR calls at his home number. CONTINUED ONREVERSE � Kathleen Sundberg tn/oo eXp Kou Vang 1/1/99 exp. District Council with Business Rep At-Large Rep 1375 Van Buren Avenue Norwest Bank East Saint Paul, MN 55104 875 Minnehaha Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55106 Phone: 659-9734 (home) Phone: 205-8400 645-2647 (work) Fax: 205-8412 Michelie Vojacek iniol e�. Steve Wellington, Jr. 1/1/00 exp. Financial Community Rep C.W. For-Profit Developer Rep 773 East Cottage Avenue 350 Gilbert Building Saint Paul, MN 55106 413 Wacouta Street Saint Paul, MN 55101-1957 Phone: 776-0452 (home) 874-3326 (work) Phone: 292-9844 Fax: 872-8995 Fax: 292-0072 Ron Whitcomb 1/IlOO exp. Financial Community Rep 1781 Hillcrest Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55116 Phone: 690-9472 @ome) 690-8201 (work) FaY: 698-2477 STAR Staff Bob Aainmer Jill Hughes Planning & Economic Development Plamung & Economic Development 1400 City Hall Annex 1400 City Hall Annex 25 West Fourth Street 25 West Fourth Street Saint Paul, MN 55102 Saint Paul, MN 55102 Phone: 266-6693 Phone: 266-6650 Fax: 228-3220 Fax: 228-3220 Paul Mordorski Planning & Economic Development 1400 City Hall Annex 25 West Fourth Street Saint Paul, MN 55102 Phone: 266-6683 FaY: 228-3320 H:\APPISTAR\\STARTEMINHDBOARD.LST REVISED 2/4/98 � � _ ..�: �� � � , , � � �� � �; ., r �> � � F, ;� , ,��,, , , , �:. � � ;, .� �F; ', ;. ,., ;, ,, ry � . i . " �� .� �i � O •r T rJ{` ♦V N .,.., � � � � � 7 � � � � 4-. E-" � � -~ � U c/� ��� Q 0 � Z�Q � N a 9�-�a7 Sales Taar Revitalization (STAR) Progrann 1997 Annuai Report This Report St. Paul's Sales Tax Kevitalization (STARJ Program has just completed ifs tliird yeaz of awarding loans and grants for capital improvement projects in St. Paul neighborhoods and the downtowa cultural disuict. Tfiis annual report on tfie STAR Program includes: o an overview of the STAR Program o key program features o application and project selecrion process o estimated future sales tax collections o STAR awards by project type and geographic area 0 1997 distribution of STAR fund balance o program accomplishments to date 0 outside investment and job creation o Ioan program features o contracting process What is the STAR Program? The Minnesota State I,egislature provided legislauve authorizauon for the Ciry of Saint Paul to levy an addirional 1/2 percent sales talc in May, 1993: T1te authorizing legislation states that revenues may be used to pay all or a portion of the capital expenses for expansion and remodeling of the St. Paul Civic Center complex. The legislation further states, "The remainder of the funds must be spent for capital projects to funher residential, cultural, commercial and economic development in both downtown St. Pau1 and St. Paul neighborhoods". The City determined that 40% of the sales tax proceeds would pay for 30 yeaz bonds issued to fuiance the renovarion and expansion of the Saint Paul River Centre (formerly the Saint Paul Civic Center). The remaining 60% of sales tax proceeds would be spent on other capital nnprovement projects in Saint Paul. In mid-1994, the City Council established the Sales Tax Revitalizarion (STAR) Program, which includes the Neighborhood STAR and Cuitural STAR Programs, to distribute the remaining sales tax proceeds. The Neighborhood STAR Program awazds loans and grants for capital improvement projects in Saint Paul neighborhoods, and is funded with 50% of the sales tax proceeds. The Cultural STAR Program, funded with the remaining 10% of sales tax proceeds, awards loans and grants for capital improvement projects that further cultural ac6vities in Saint Paul. However, changes to the state legisla4on during the 1997 session will enable the City to use funds in the Cultural STAR Program for cultural organization operating expenses as well, beginning in 1998. Both the Neighborhood and C�Ihual STAR Programs have completed three annual funding cycles, which were administered by the City's Department of Planning and Economic Development. N w ��wy ���<;� G rn io� C � � �• � w.a5 � G5'� � ����� R . a � �' G `� .- ro O � ry � � � � � � �; r-�i w � � f'I w �•�p. Sv � � � `�� � � n ry �° c A. CL N .'Y p� � O � A N r.'�S. � O �` � °: � m b � w � � � � a ub U � O � �. ���u � � 'C! N KT; 0 �' cn � � p. O -�f � � -n m � � a `�° � � a P v'� bq v O .�. o °, 'n �55 ^ tlq � 2 �- o w. co m � a m � `� w � C. ro ,ti �' 0 °° �.°^*, � �• � �'i vo a O � y k w o ��� �p o �' 6� p �Y �? a �r � � Q, a � " � � ��� 'V y F G � n a� � � � �' O � � � � .q � � W • �, a � � � K l 1 � � � H ! � /_ � � �� � � �� w � ao � � �' a .w y o' b N O W � � a� � � �' o � N `C '� O � � o a b a o �? � � a � � � p. n � `� C� c�o � � p � �'� � � ., � �� � �b c a c��c' .�'.. (> n � � N °' ' w � ro ,b a. O � 0 � � �. y N o C � �] � � � m � N � �• � G � m u�' '� a � �, � � � �. � � � `C � � � p � M a O a ❑ � a p 0 � � � � � b � a o b � � � p � � � � a �� aroo � � y��°�� � w � w H �• b .� rn �'w �n �•� � ��� � p � ° � � � � 9 a c�i�� �» i'p � � �� � �. �' o x 5' , � w a �G'o �'� o � d � �-' 't7 �b�cc�. � � T C. � • G � y � m 5 c w b p b : �.b •o�o C n i-n . UQ W n. �.row �b �; � y `° � o ' � � � C �. w � 'b �u�o caro.o H w .� A' N b � �' O y � w � o �y 0 �•b°�w 'G � d� a'� � � � � C C � � O O rn�°° .�r' � �rn �.� 'O 'd � A� � a 0 t�i � � p � � .h'. �GJ G `� �. � �/Q y ny u O � :: � ,� M � O O � � b y b � H a ,d KY O� - . s ' P. � o ro � 0 a c�o � .'7 �' � �. M � � � N y � � r"1" y ro' '" 0 �° � o a � �. � J � 0 aa � r o' �' �, � �� E'r � a � C G . � o n 0 a�,io � v G � b � �. O � � � N a° � � � � o � � °. o n M � G � p � � �'p"o � " � �a o p' M ('� �� � n � � � ~ `� � � y ry � �. rn w � o � � � a `; m cn � � m .� �� N Ci a •• � a b � �� � ?» c �� n � o a� b o � r M � O '" N N N � � G w ob �� �„ " a � "I � ai p. o w ° ' � b � �� o °' ro N N o � � 0 �'1 � y W O � 0 Fn � 0 0 ° o �� � 0 ., ao � a � � .. .. �17 �' 'ti 'd Q "C � N �. o. � °. G M F/� y� N o �' � ��� �� x � w `�' a' � �' N � N �' N ry � � Q;'O � � �, � N �� �.^� o a rn � � � a � � Ky C w �� ' �' � � ���o x "V ry � � o o �o o � rn �, � y � y c�o �• °a b � C, O a �' ,�'.. � r � � O G b. � y. �, d w va � T � o • C�' b �' � � �, � �G m � � . � � c � N � y � � b � v� p �• ry b � ro�� o . � � x a o � � C � � � ro � ro � < � �• :� � b C� N � a ° � � �o n c °� � � d� M � � a � � �, o b a � �. o ao � � � � 'O � w b o' N ro 0 w � 0 c� o� p 0 � N �. � - � � � w � � M � � a� � � � °; � G m � • �� � � � p� � w g• � � w � � �. a N � � c � 'rJ � O 0 � b O � O � a �' 0 � U�a � � � a y C � w a G � N I--� .� N O N ., m � G � � y N � w G � a G � b a ° a 'a � � � °< � y � w � � c�i m a � °, � W �n e a � � � N a � �. �c � x w O 'L �. N 'V ro �' o' � � � y GO 71 �� � � �� b � U�a �i � � "� $. � H m �' � � a. � ti w � w a~ ro :-" �. �. w N u' � � " , o o � M n N n N � N � � 0 �a a � N � m � a N b � � a v�a, � p M � �o � �h � n � w � M d w � �� � oz ry �. N � � o b �r � � w � � � � � c � � Oq� �. c� � � �� O � � °� � a � 0 H a N �. � � � � y a � � � � � � � C' M $ a y � y O � na� � � o � � � � � w �o w w ��,� � o b � � � �aro � � o, p O �i �n w 3'n o � c� � � �'; �� a N � � G w � EP � a' C n p y ,�, � �. � � � � �'xd QQ p� y. � �. C � M b � y 0 � o � a �•'� � �� C b . ti � N fJ Oo VC �* _ __�fl ^ C�' � � 01.� J r� � r 2� � � a F C�7 � �o � � "2 � W E � � � 0 � 0 � .� z � .-i v o � �� � y Q O � �U � � b � � � � a� O ~ O U yy'".. •,[.' � � � � h ti '° .� a � � y � r q rn O� •� O � a� .� b � bA w O � v� � � N � N � v U � [�r w a � 3 � � .� N a � � � b .� ~ C � CL � � � � � •� a a� �•�b � ro � U t� y `' :c�5 � ° � rn N U A ro .� •^�i N o ,>, ° . � W � a on � � � � � y U N U U U � U •� N N N ..—, ,^ •,-, �—, •—, o a r °' Q., a a a ca � �--i .. rn m v� 'n .. � .. �. � .. � � � � � � � � N N � � M � U U U U .� '^'' a� a� a� a� O y O b 1 � 0 �p �p �" •^� 0 � a a aa aa ,-� Q, rn �t V � � '. �..i �..i �..i � � � � � S � M O .--i .--i N �O � � : -. '� a' U +m' U '�'' y U y U � '0 '� 'p •-�i 'p ��' ,-°�.� a a °� a a o, � � M � � � �..+ �..i � v � ..i � � � � � � N M N m M 7 � � � V d � � ;, � � � �''� U a �" i '� � N � � � � � v� o � � '� � � ~ � � � � � b a�i � I � - � � C � , b o V .7� �� rx v� aa� w�v� a, � �.�.�� a o � o rn �a a � o w p ai a w�p U h � � � � � V � ti � U � `� fV }� � pD U . .�'J . 00 � " w °� � '� o N � � �' U 'tr �r I � I � b � F �� O � � � Q � F�a ..�i � Vl �vl � .`", 'O F :� � cd � m ,. m .°: ,'� � � o 0 " o w° .-�. a� N N N m °n p Z d' ,C p E nn E u u y� F•' O Fy � 'f" U ���� N� `� r �.-�. ��0�� 'O �.� ��� O N M O� M vl F.' � O�, C`? O N N O y Q" A 64 N a,aaao � �� a�i o °' ¢��z �� � � �,-�� M�sa�o .--i m � � � � •� ~ y bq U ._^. � .'�'. '� .�°, a� �'�o � b '� � � ��:�.� C �U Ci l� ���p l� �( � A � � � .� � � O � „ a w' � o o � N o� � C O �.. °� � w � .q � u, C� �.��ao�d nu � q p > c�a N�� p w o H za' Nb�° � ' d U �„�� w 0 'N F ^ N N � � o a> W U C% Q.� o a a�i,� � I ^� 3 � F � .� ti�� �� � �oN -. � � � m � m � �+ � N � O ',� G U G�y S w � W p bu . � M � O U ,� � � o ,.� b� � ° o. o � `" °' `n ' o .0 m � � � w � °•°-'-,yw �� � �° � N bA � 'i7 C]r Ci r' v N � � b � 4� ,?; •Y .� � .S 0 0 � a� � �, a� CL W ;O � `" Q U �.�. � .� � U �•°-;��o �a �•�� �� W cd U O� y� � , c� � ,� u�. " 'O O � t4 G U � p � :: o � � Q � � � U �a . g .� c� � � � � O� C� N 1-I a b Y GJ � . td y ..'rJ' F� a�. .� �� b N��� a' 7 - � o � � � b G � � �.9b�s�y � V" U i(1 �o .•� M U �� q N v� v�, 0 N '� � U O � N 7� � � O�� G N N y � b �n �, w o � r �� �b �s'�s ° � .� � `d `� a o O � � p � .+ 0 a� o �� N o � �U b N G.�-� r.�, N� d �W' ° '� ° .G o w a ti i �'�'°o �w �� ;; oo 3� p �a�r�.R+j N F� N Q� •.. v�i '3' N � 1 �' ' ti�.� � W '� � O a�i ��O � � �L b�.�� U W.�. � 7,m �b c a � � � N � G+ p .,'�. '� F�' P�" C y . 'r�' F� o �..�o ��'� d w�q�-�+,� � o �, a �; w .� � � Q � � , . � a. � o ro�.�� G c� T U � 'a7 C ~ � U W c�tl �" G := N N 0���': c a wa��yw 3'a��i 3� � ;; ;; o o � � .n w �d ❑ +'J d � ti C� 0 o• � U U � � '" a a.'� °� ���wH c� �i 0 0 .� .� � A H a OJO � � on �. � � a? b � � � � � � � 3 � Y � � � � � � "'d � y � � � •C � � �a o � � p w C w p � Pa � '�n c�i a' � ° b o a G� U w � bA '7' .d „ n� �, o ��'C�p �b C rn � b �P.i � �F+ �' � � �, .a a �� ` � � � 3 '� p . � � O •O O � b td . �+ .y P' OP.. ,� � U m o cd � � � � � o � a��i . p � a cd G� � .o � ` �i � � p �' 0 0 °G,, .o �� � �o .a � ��a � � � � � .� o �' o u' o � a� ������ �wA� � N N �V C O O � .� N O � •v�i O �+ > aa� a�a�,��. � y � � U i �G �, � F '� •.� F u � � v o bA � � O y N M � � � � p N � � � O � � F �� � �� NN�b �,- � � F �� O� � F b ^ �rnrnrn� o ,., ,-. ,-. F .:i' z N N '-I V�i a i�+ � � ro ,� ornrnrnF � z o W � N � � W � r � � N � ��-+�M N����i, ��rnrnH � U � 0 � p � U � � � 0 � b � � .V. o . ,� � •� � .�w � .� � � h 0 � M .ti � .� '� a� '> ,�F .�a N o �i� �� '� a H � 0 � a � � ', � i�'�Il1 M ��L , . ; nrrrn �nr I, � ► � � � � � � ( U CS � F r.a O � r� � � � � � � y.�+ U � � a a � u � •� Q ^�� ^ � � C O W � � � H A bo a ¢ � S 0 0 t s OG z r�. y a� � r N %�, •- � �O O O +'�i P. a O. � � � � � � � N N .. h r. �p � U U � � '^ '^ '" �'' a o. � � � � b� b� � � � ^ � 1n N U 47 a 'o ..�'� ' � a a a � � � b� `� S e � m O w � � � o ,� , v a 'y u � � F+ •� Y y `J � � � a � on � UO Uv� v� � 0 �' � � � U � � � � w � w N O � U p � O w � .'f.-1' a '� o `� a � ���n cV � �' � W a � � O h � h b � � .-�. '�i N C M � .�i � � � L' � � � w � �.�0 � y O U O p+ y :� �oA,ps�> .. � � �;� a eu .� o o � '° � 3 � R ' a � i � � �� � �s rn ^� o � ,..., w rn a c, N 0 "C'on��•� �•� � � � � O vi �� .� N � U � ,.�.. P ti ti U p W r' V w � �U ow•�,� � O O � . ' 'C .�J F. a, �c�a � G c�d bq �,�� Hw' �•� b c3 � '� ,o .� °,'o d •� a � " U a N c"u rn v� y �n �,� � ,. � c�d c�2 � � •d y v `3 bq H � �d '.� p Q � � a� '� � U N p � O U � N ,., N �� v a on i B o a� �:�� � � °� � Uv �a �U�a.� �.9 � 0 8 0 0 S �° � � 00 00 $ o 00 0 0 o g o$ oS o8 So S S 8 ° o ° o ° � ° ° o ° c ° o ° o ° o n �� �� H� V3� � 6�9 YI �' � O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Q g o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 oov�0000 00o v; o0 0 00 oS VI O O O� Vi O O O O O O l� O O O Vl O V? l� N O O d' N O N Vi O O O N1 �D O O N h �O O f9N N �'^�� N Ndi (5N �^ �� W�R Hi' A fA Nf W U) !A A � V N M 1� N N V^ d' d' h t� N N C h�� b t1 N� N � � F v 6 e � o m ❑ W U 5,� �� � �° ° o, � � � � � d N V � � M O J N �-• O 'O O ' �R O U.`G"' d (' ��,�` � O � S l:` O�� O U O N 3?.+' y 'O N ❑ '�' V O� � U N� V� U C4 C C> O , F V �� e �.��.���G� S V � � o � QUUa oinv E °� � °.o �i ����v.�'�v��.Fb'G�'� WU �v�z Na °.o CL 'SCI u `�',� 6 m oh �« `� m�U:� m '0, � o � °�' x � � � G c .�d •. �' � ° n �n , �' G + �a�i ' VE�j. m V° 6� .C. �+' � ° � m c � � � 'O .0 .° X C �] � F. �' p. � p � �a w C'. m Q v�G � u. i`d °u ❑ v v v o a °� �' p W 3�1 L1wL1 wwC7'.'Cx'xn�� �Z,'Z v�'? ,. v C � � C a O F � d[-� N ? N Y. � O N C �.., a> � . � cw � °'v N v� w S�^ m °� E' `� � � n'� 3 o .a w � � � r" � � x' r °- � � m o `° fL v� O� V G O b C q t� N p. O�� y o �ou c a+' r o`n C7 A �" � p 9 o W o P1 °" O R7 � a o .°"� �'�' a v`� N� � a x� s� v u`�' ou �o K� a '�' a m� w m c v� c`� o o� w' 8 m 5� �, y c nY v� Q o w'� a�i E rn ' m'� o ° o� �" v.c ��� a�� v� �i � Q U s` ^�� o'z e vi E a a� o fi �v �'°a cc3 va$i °��.,V o Uw � N a� q P. Q v �� r m 5 v� m� � O� o'` 9 ° O�n r W U� �o awq ri�m,xC7x�n`�UUSw ��.�Z O �D O� N M O� O Vl �O 1� W O� O m M W O� M O O O O O O N N N CI N N N M M m V O r 1� 1� C� h l� I� f� 1� h 1� l� h 1� h 1� 1� l� 1� 1� t� l� l� O� O+ P O. O� O� O� O� T G� O� O� O� O� P O. P O+ O� O� P T O� a� u � � � � W E� � d � W 0 � O � � � A W � a � C7 E h d h �ro��.��y o� 3 `��" ' � >, �3 iy O . .� T � `❑� � c�v > � p '7 id o'��o� a�i o . �, � � .�4 � � ¢' U � ..�i .. � � � y,+ �' �. � � � Q N N x' �-�' � '� � � � U ❑ ^ V � o � O iC � �-�. � 'ti � � O V � � �+ '� � � � '� O F '�d �+ A. ,�-,� � a� �' � � ° a vq� �� � � � o o �" � � o $ y '� � o a a�i 'p V .� � � .O a � V bD � � N Q Q �17 � � ,a�, .� � � � Q � O � � � U O �A V � `'��oo°`�' �r�i� ��ao�`' a . �caop�.�'3 o '� � � .en'° p p�, ��bA:��� � cdU �U �, v ' V � � _r .k N � Vi� �7 'O N . �G,'�' � N � � .�". � W , f 0 0-� �,^ U �p� ��°' ����� �' O O V '.� ,^ O � �b �� o�� Hz �'� ° �ar C�J � � L� "C! � W � � � � d R� ^� U 'o s. a O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O v t O O O O O O N O N M� N Q� O N O O O O O N ViFANidiVidifA�W �O N N^+ " r'+ �O V r' N^� � d d V � " �' ❑ o v x U Y ,� � �� � U�.°�`� > Vl ,�'j' � � Q�' 7 Q y .F1 �� w�i a,p 'O u E C p�b N C.L C? °o y ?+�j�� ° °Ll 5 ° mU � �� y .c c a.5 �� o[0 � G a o 09 � � � L�OV�i=p, � '�'L m �axd o c `� >.V a � �> n C ps v� o � c n, fi v'� S°OS °' cn' � `� W c' O � x o?�,d�C c> , o c C7C7.�.lw'Z.�.Zv � O F a N V C ti O v� 1` Y1 � � v L � � � � � � N G U Y N V N y m � v ccj a°� >°� z a a W � a m a� � � 41� V L � �' W L �'_] ti 7 N t '" �� ; x � a o� b3 g .� p °' � �` w V n�i w o tl� R��@� �a > �` V W a, � o i. �. �v � + � E��u u¢rn Ro D N."y E Q ��� O F aC7�Uww�.a �nv rnrn N M V vl �O 1� G� O�^�n O O O O O O O O O o O O O O o O O O o O t4�r' l��t<t�td ��t�� rn rn rn rn rn rn rn m rn rn rn rn 000 000 � �� o00 � Q O O O O O� O �+�OOo V vi �n O� � .�-� O O O O � O O O O O O O O V) �A �A h M N O� m r-i ; � N Q � A�pQAQ QQ�Q aa.aaaa awaa Y � � � ; � '° p, � o v, Q o b " � � m $ a .. x:� b > � �] � � �A ° � b °',�� b � �i � � � � � O � j? � '�C Zi o � U� 5o E'" '� O O ..O O 4+'7 ci. �., o�� j c�i ca ��. ,v� v' �wA �' �ra"a� �d � ao�a�cn ��V �,o . � � � o �� � � � W � ¢' � " A °� �.� � � �UH `�.�°W �Ac��wa� v,aaa � °^ g � 0 0° o M O M � Fq N d a` d � L Y '> U �D O O V O O O O O O v o o a o 0 0 0 o a r oo �o o�noo a m ri O"(`I O r N�VI�OO V N N N V N t� Vl N N m�MF9 M�d3 Y1HitAfH69 N c C c C c q C� C C . . . . .� � .� .� � G E v u v y p �C 1+ ') G' � /+ W � � � � _ � m Cd U = � v ��Ua � F.x `�y U S4 -� W d5 � .] � o`� m G r\ a � �� N � a a& N� U � F� N` �n � � � � � � o � � ° ooa� y ' ' �' � o`� � c v? o0 U U CO {�C7`.C� �O wx � O F o E �;a y N v�° W � � �� ��� � �. A' � LL N O '�" � E `_yP.���� 2« � n' '° y v� p u u a� °� N � 6 � O O µ � q a� �� h 7 �r� ° °.3a^ m ��� v0 ac�N �, V s � � ��naU m `�yv�i3 °c�r � C a 3^'� E y ro,�, � �= � o.`a� V v �' y �ovi,C rnU W U(70a=; OOx o—M �n� noo rno m�o O O O O O O O O V h N h h n� h n h h n p�. P p. a� P U� N P U 0 � � rb � � C� C � � � a N � ,a�,' � � .� o N p+•d N � � � N � a �� � N � `� � rn b �N � � � b N A � w O y '� � t' � �o ;; 3 O H � A U �pq'Ct � O z `� b�A G�.' � � � N N � 27 � C.� O Tl b O O i `� .. � o g � p . c+�' O �n O O � � � •� � '� � � �,.� ���� ���� � �, n b � � O� O �y rn •� � .� a � c .� ao O � p O Q o � d' b9 � ° o 0 ° o O 'V'� �s � y � �a:a F �C. �' > � � � N cG � 3 a � � N O � � � .k G�r c/1 �x *C a � � � a O m O .0 � � a b � � O rri .� � o ^� b � � � � �` O a�. � �� � O y N 0 0 � � a o � � a �° O O � � 0 C � o '^ � N � � h � o 'd � CJ on .'�. � m P� � � pq � p �' ,fl � � w � � � � � a,'� U o o �a o 00 �; b .� � O d � , ^ N E >' 7 w � rn .�y �. ��.",�0� 'O vi W V� � ob � 3 `� H � +�' (yi Vl N � a H � o �. � V� a O .� � p � a � � � � � � .^ U �'�� '� .n Z � '� O � � b M � � N y � � � a' a .�'+ 0 G N . w � � O ����� q v� o p �°"�` ° � � � � p �.�. .J � Y o, y c � � .� (tl O U � � b w � 0 a F�. �-+ U � � � � � � .� a � d' � � � � � r O C O � :-_' ,� m � � � ti .,�., .-1 O � ,� 4�q a � o ,= a �a°�� � a�� � a o� 'O H °�' .� � � � O 'C7 � � � � O �� G o a, o, o N � � .5 C � � ,.`�', ctl v� d . U O � � � � �.., a ou a.`"+ cd 0 'O O � a��i � � r a y a � � F @ � o � � � CA '� �p � � N '� � � .� '.� ctl � N .+ 4. w W. yw b i; � �C � b N y d " � ° � � F a a. O � � O U o � � a� v � A � � � � a ��. � �e� `° o � M p p � �e-- : > F s � 3 ,� � N � W � � � O ��°`� � � � y � � � � � � N N � a� .> ,a `�' ro � t � � 3 .� � '� � b � � c� � } � .� �� W _�! y U � +'�- V '� V] V t" C � � �i �G F +-' •' Q b�°� � �o.�o ." '�- � � ���� a' U -- � � � U y Vl O �� �� . y � � ° b � � � U Y � bu N � f"� ^ O �Nk3°� w � J � y y � 0 y � U .�' � b-0 � aa o � d � w a � a � � , °��' ^� `�-� O � ..� Y a � � �� p �1 � �a� � p, '�a ~° Y O .� v 'Iy > N N N t�d A f""' O � U U W w �+ • .. p '� ��" h a�r U O �' � b � � � ~ � � o N � � V h• C � .�..' 0. � m O O � � � � U �y o A N � (� �C M � T y � N A � F7 '� � �r, � � U r�'ii b w ro � � � g ai «. � b �'N � '� � O �i U a � a �a � � o � � � a 'So � G, � t+ �i.�,o °' a � �� � � � U J� , w � ��� b���� v > � •� ao � � V � a�+ F'i ����` t�'... � w O s. .� a�+ �� a�i �' a a� a�i � � � � � � ���"� � G °�':c� � �p rn `° O O'q P. t�V �� N itl t�V U Tr' y � v � y p .c � v� � -� a .° ,� a a� '� a N �, �O N h N � N � � � � ....... � b b � a d � C �'y d s � � w � Y � � .� �W w � ;: a > �A y � y °a p�y N p,d M y � � 'O j � '� h `° �, o �� � .°'. � � � �rn,� ��° �� °»"��Na� a,o b •o o � b� � � � v1 ,� N � N � � ..�'. � O y � "_' ;d N U � w ' d �� H"" U c O� ca O a � b � �"��p �� �,��a °�,� O O'�.,, O� F+ ?: � B � � � � N G'�j � OA � � G � � � � '� rn �w U „ w I.�i x � � �; � v�i `� a�i 'C �� a: k" N� Y abi � � V w N � •� G � F. � > a�+ � � N � O y.. `� � ¢, � N '� c� � ''"'' � a � �° a `" i �a � � � � > m � rn .`�'. +' 7- P' O c3 �'G � � 4. v � ' 3 .[: � [ p + .tj" �..� yr: C N � � �-, �d � � �� w�.o �� o �w � �� � y -n.1 O ` y � .� � �' b 6 � °� o �, ° � o `�' C V U °�,' � v c O�O b O y N>' N Q� N N U V �y a�, � s`�.'�U v�,.�w�o � � � �i^;y 5 �,, g � a� � N "' 'G .� p �'� � � C � ,,�', o � > U � �, .� � o ° `ba U � � .r ��o° (.�' U 0 � 1 N J�.+'.L' O� Y �'y N O � O ' � rn `� \/ � � Y � .� .� N N � .0 � � O y `� .a b � � �� � � .� � � U � p � F O .��� � � o � � � � � � � o � � � '� � � �nH o�a rn � b � y. � � O � W � aoa`� o � � F+� U FL 17 o ro .�.� x H °�d¢�' o .� �� • • • • � � d � a bA � � �.d O U a�+ F: N Vl q ZJ W Q ,� �y O N p y O��^ O b � a. O ,� � V � � C .fl � A 'h T F. N H b � � � � � ?: � � .+' a � a�i 3 '�� °' � a w � .� G a, � o 0 U � q `� � `�' � a�i � � � p y 3,� � 'O Y .L) o � �y � U C .� � �.+ A ':� �v .� � a 'i7 - .� 'O T� N � b c �a�j t�.� � N J� o � p � � � N F � U � O � Y ~.� �,r.�. � k a G. � b i/] .� � «� `� � � � •p ' °' ° °,� ° b �3��a'��a� � � � � b F � � �' , � N � "�.� ��'.. a�.i b b � � ro N � � � en �' � � 3 a O.� y t'�7 r� � `° � ,g � v 'd o �� ��� �� � � 3 � c� � `�+ � O � >� N�.� y �'O O p(n .������ � U ,, � " � � ~ � � b � � � � " � U � � o '� � � � .� !� c�n � y c� � U a �.� o W A.n o sa � a�a � ^.� O ti � � V � �p � � _^• p ,d y a � a.�.� N �, � ou Y tj o � o °' 'd 'O p N N � o ?3 m � q 4, �. N O � V � b a �3 rn ° o �, � N p V .� N .�C � � $ w,,� a � F " h � �i � N V� a� p '�w ��� b .� ; � ,� a ��o� � � � � � � o � � o ,�'ti � � � � •° q V � O N � � M � F'� � � U vi °'v'.° o ., �» o .,� .� � O � 'c� °`'�°� ' � �¢ �' N tn .� � U .� ry � V � U c� p � .^ O y ,� � �' �, � c,, �2 �n p y�j q � 1�3 � � � � p a � � ry ''� � � � o v '� y p '.� °: ,.��i aoa `" a � � � � � � N � � o � h .� b .� O � � U d ��x�'� o � c2 .a� h O N .�', > ^° c`"i � m .� mb b � .� �a�� a1 y '''� � O ��o�.� .� > � '3 ° a. b � � � � 'd ;O v�i � ��,�� ro ow.�� � � o 0 o g g o .j M � -i O� � A � � W v�i .--i a� 5iy �. N d' r`� a� rn C � ,�,� a� N o � '� v� '- � ° '� ttl a p � O � � � �..I �� � ~ h b � N 'd .n �o > � � �.od.�� .--i O � q��ia� More Information? For addirional copies of this report or informarion about the 1998 funding cycle, please call 266-STAR(7827). Credits City of Saint Paul Mayor Norm Coleman 1997 Neighborhood STAR Board Mazjorie Ebensteiner City Council President David Thune* John Fahey Councilmember Jerry Blakey Stephen Gordon Councilmember Dan Bostrom Lany Laughlin Councilmember Joseph Collins* John Loban Councilmember Mike Harris John Mazgot Councilmember Roberta Megard* Russell Miller Councilmember Gladys Morton* *Terms eacpired at the end of 1997. 1997 Cultural STAR Board Ruth Appelhof Brent Assink Richard Cook Sarah Lutman Frank Marzitelli Ronald W. Pauline Sam Verdeja Lois West, Chair Kathleen Wilson Dept. of Planning & Economic Development Pamela Wheelock, Director Amy Filice, Joan Trulsen, Donna Drummond - STAR Program Coordinators Jim Beaver and Fran Burns- intems Published January, 1998 12 Thomas Olesak Charles Senkler Kathleen Sundberg Kou Vang Michelle Vojacek Steve Wellington, Chair Ron Whitcomb Council File # � 1 �� ORIG1NAt Presented By Referred To Committee: Date 1997 Sales Tax Revitalization (STAR) Program Annuai Report RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby accept the 1997 Annual Report of the Sales Tax Revitalization Program as attached. P �( O Adopted by Council: Date �,� _\$ 1`i`lR' � Adoption Certified by Council Secretary: � � � Green Sheet # `�� a` RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 23 Planning & Economic Development: Form Approved by City Attorney: : Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council: � �i dr - �a� �hh�n DEFi�R7YEMiqFFICE/COUNpL DATE INITIA7E0 � v � T c��y co,���i ziiii9s GREEN SHEE CONTACT PERSON & PHONE INITIAUDATE INITIAVDAlE Mazcia Mcermond 2�-8570 � OEPAHTMENT DIRECTOR � QTV COUNpL ASSIGN � CITYATTORNEV O CITY 0.ERK MUST BE ON CAUNCIL AGENOA BY (DATE) NUMBEN FOR � BUIX3ET DIRECTOR � FIN. & MGT. SEflVICES DIR. Feb I8.1�8 OHDEN �y � nv.roa roa nss�srnr�T) � TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACiION RE�UESTED. Approval of resolution accepting the 199"/ Annual Report of the Sales Tac Revitalization (STAR) Program. RECOMMENDA710NS Approve (A� or Rejea (Fi) pERSONAL SERVICE CON7HACTS MUS7 ANSWER TME FOLLOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVII SERVICE COMMISSION �� Has thls pef50Mifm BVef Worked untlef a ContraCt fOr [hi5 tlepartmeM? _ CIB COMMITTEE _ YES NO _ S7AFF 2. Has this personHirm ever been a ciry employee? — YES NO _ oisiaici coURi _ 3. Does this Oerson/firm ossess a skill not normall p y possessed by any curreM ciry employee? SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? YES NO Explain all yes answers on separate sheet antl attach to green sheet INITIATMCa PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITV (Who. Whffi, WheO. Where, Why): ADVANTAGESIFAPPqOVED� DISADVANTAGESIFAPPROVED: DISADVANTAGES IF NOTAPPROVED. � TOTAL AMOUNT OFTRANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) VES NO FUNDItiG SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBEP FINANCIAL INFORFfiATION (EXPLAIN) 9�'1�1 STAR PROGRAM STATISTICS Total Final Applications Neighhorhood STAR 1995 1996 1997 Total 50 47 32 � 129 Totai Awards 22 20 21 63 Total $$$ Awarded $3,695,448 4,064,055 4.482.000 $12,241,503 Average Award $167,975 203,203 213.428 $194,310 Neighborhood Small Grants 1995 1996 1997 Total 22 21 13 56 14 13 12 39 $175,254 183,374 227.500 $586,128 $12,518 14,106 18.958 $15,029 Cultural STAR 1995 1996 1997 Total 26 15 10 51 11 11 9 31 $504,600 778,200 790.382 $2,194,582 $45,873 70,745 87.820 $70,793 With the exception of the average award, the above figures are contained in the 1997 STAR Annual Report. * In 1997, the Neighborhood STAR Board received 44 pre-applications, and recommended 35 for final application consideration. °I� -la�� �t Nei hborhood STAR Board Member Address List 2/98 �k Dr. Bruce Corrie iiii99 eXp. Marjorie Ebensteiner iilioi exP. Foundation Rep District Cotutcil Rep 729 Parkview Drive 2091 East Arlington Avenue Saint Paul MN 551 i 6 St. Paul, MN 55119 Phone: 487-1625 (home) Phone: 778-8580 (home) (work) 296-5472 (work) Fax: Fax: 296-8887 John Fahey 1i1i99 exp. Stephen D. Gordon 1/1/01 exp. Community Development Rep Planning Commission Rep 180 Mazia Avenue 492 Holly Avenue Saint Paul MN 55106 Saint Paul, MN 55102 Phone: 291-0083 (home) 333-0201 (work) Phone: 772-0229 Fax: 291-0086 Michelle Ketcham vvoi eXp. John Loban (CHAIR) 1/1/Ol exp. Neighborhood Business Rep At-Large Rep 200 Gilbert Building 823 Portland Avenue 413 Wacouta Street Saint Paul, MN 55104 Saint Paul, MN 55101-1957 Phone: 222-7227 (work) Phone: 221-0202 (home) Fax: 223-5229 Fax: 292-1588 John Margot iiiioi eXp. Russell J. Miller iivoo eXp. CIB Rep Neighborhood Business Rep 1818 Wellesley Avenue 267 White Bear Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55105 Saint Paul, MN 55106 Phone: 698-2994 (home) Phone: '�"�` 774-6394 (home) (call home #) 639-4742 (work) 738-2688 (work)* Thomas A. Oksak iil/o0 exp. Charles F. Senkler 1/t/99 exp District Council Rep Community Development Rep 1050 W Hoyt Avenue 1899 Fairmont Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55117 Saint Paul, I�11V 55105 Phone: 488-7437 (home) * 359-4606 (work) (call work #) Phone: 225-9414 (work) Fax: 338-4840 759-3371 (cell) " Olesak prefers all STAR calls at his work number. ** Miller prefers all STAR calls at his home number. CONTINUED ONREVERSE � Kathleen Sundberg tn/oo eXp Kou Vang 1/1/99 exp. District Council with Business Rep At-Large Rep 1375 Van Buren Avenue Norwest Bank East Saint Paul, MN 55104 875 Minnehaha Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55106 Phone: 659-9734 (home) Phone: 205-8400 645-2647 (work) Fax: 205-8412 Michelie Vojacek iniol e�. Steve Wellington, Jr. 1/1/00 exp. Financial Community Rep C.W. For-Profit Developer Rep 773 East Cottage Avenue 350 Gilbert Building Saint Paul, MN 55106 413 Wacouta Street Saint Paul, MN 55101-1957 Phone: 776-0452 (home) 874-3326 (work) Phone: 292-9844 Fax: 872-8995 Fax: 292-0072 Ron Whitcomb 1/IlOO exp. Financial Community Rep 1781 Hillcrest Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55116 Phone: 690-9472 @ome) 690-8201 (work) FaY: 698-2477 STAR Staff Bob Aainmer Jill Hughes Planning & Economic Development Plamung & Economic Development 1400 City Hall Annex 1400 City Hall Annex 25 West Fourth Street 25 West Fourth Street Saint Paul, MN 55102 Saint Paul, MN 55102 Phone: 266-6693 Phone: 266-6650 Fax: 228-3220 Fax: 228-3220 Paul Mordorski Planning & Economic Development 1400 City Hall Annex 25 West Fourth Street Saint Paul, MN 55102 Phone: 266-6683 FaY: 228-3320 H:\APPISTAR\\STARTEMINHDBOARD.LST REVISED 2/4/98 � � _ ..�: �� � � , , � � �� � �; ., r �> � � F, ;� , ,��,, , , , �:. � � ;, .� �F; ', ;. ,., ;, ,, ry � . i . " �� .� �i � O •r T rJ{` ♦V N .,.., � � � � � 7 � � � � 4-. E-" � � -~ � U c/� ��� Q 0 � Z�Q � N a 9�-�a7 Sales Taar Revitalization (STAR) Progrann 1997 Annuai Report This Report St. Paul's Sales Tax Kevitalization (STARJ Program has just completed ifs tliird yeaz of awarding loans and grants for capital improvement projects in St. Paul neighborhoods and the downtowa cultural disuict. Tfiis annual report on tfie STAR Program includes: o an overview of the STAR Program o key program features o application and project selecrion process o estimated future sales tax collections o STAR awards by project type and geographic area 0 1997 distribution of STAR fund balance o program accomplishments to date 0 outside investment and job creation o Ioan program features o contracting process What is the STAR Program? The Minnesota State I,egislature provided legislauve authorizauon for the Ciry of Saint Paul to levy an addirional 1/2 percent sales talc in May, 1993: T1te authorizing legislation states that revenues may be used to pay all or a portion of the capital expenses for expansion and remodeling of the St. Paul Civic Center complex. The legislation further states, "The remainder of the funds must be spent for capital projects to funher residential, cultural, commercial and economic development in both downtown St. Pau1 and St. Paul neighborhoods". The City determined that 40% of the sales tax proceeds would pay for 30 yeaz bonds issued to fuiance the renovarion and expansion of the Saint Paul River Centre (formerly the Saint Paul Civic Center). The remaining 60% of sales tax proceeds would be spent on other capital nnprovement projects in Saint Paul. In mid-1994, the City Council established the Sales Tax Revitalizarion (STAR) Program, which includes the Neighborhood STAR and Cuitural STAR Programs, to distribute the remaining sales tax proceeds. The Neighborhood STAR Program awazds loans and grants for capital improvement projects in Saint Paul neighborhoods, and is funded with 50% of the sales tax proceeds. The Cultural STAR Program, funded with the remaining 10% of sales tax proceeds, awards loans and grants for capital improvement projects that further cultural ac6vities in Saint Paul. However, changes to the state legisla4on during the 1997 session will enable the City to use funds in the Cultural STAR Program for cultural organization operating expenses as well, beginning in 1998. Both the Neighborhood and C�Ihual STAR Programs have completed three annual funding cycles, which were administered by the City's Department of Planning and Economic Development. N w ��wy ���<;� G rn io� C � � �• � w.a5 � G5'� � ����� R . a � �' G `� .- ro O � ry � � � � � � �; r-�i w � � f'I w �•�p. Sv � � � `�� � � n ry �° c A. CL N .'Y p� � O � A N r.'�S. � O �` � °: � m b � w � � � � a ub U � O � �. ���u � � 'C! N KT; 0 �' cn � � p. O -�f � � -n m � � a `�° � � a P v'� bq v O .�. o °, 'n �55 ^ tlq � 2 �- o w. co m � a m � `� w � C. ro ,ti �' 0 °° �.°^*, � �• � �'i vo a O � y k w o ��� �p o �' 6� p �Y �? a �r � � Q, a � " � � ��� 'V y F G � n a� � � � �' O � � � � .q � � W • �, a � � � K l 1 � � � H ! � /_ � � �� � � �� w � ao � � �' a .w y o' b N O W � � a� � � �' o � N `C '� O � � o a b a o �? � � a � � � p. n � `� C� c�o � � p � �'� � � ., � �� � �b c a c��c' .�'.. (> n � � N °' ' w � ro ,b a. O � 0 � � �. y N o C � �] � � � m � N � �• � G � m u�' '� a � �, � � � �. � � � `C � � � p � M a O a ❑ � a p 0 � � � � � b � a o b � � � p � � � � a �� aroo � � y��°�� � w � w H �• b .� rn �'w �n �•� � ��� � p � ° � � � � 9 a c�i�� �» i'p � � �� � �. �' o x 5' , � w a �G'o �'� o � d � �-' 't7 �b�cc�. � � T C. � • G � y � m 5 c w b p b : �.b •o�o C n i-n . UQ W n. �.row �b �; � y `° � o ' � � � C �. w � 'b �u�o caro.o H w .� A' N b � �' O y � w � o �y 0 �•b°�w 'G � d� a'� � � � � C C � � O O rn�°° .�r' � �rn �.� 'O 'd � A� � a 0 t�i � � p � � .h'. �GJ G `� �. � �/Q y ny u O � :: � ,� M � O O � � b y b � H a ,d KY O� - . s ' P. � o ro � 0 a c�o � .'7 �' � �. M � � � N y � � r"1" y ro' '" 0 �° � o a � �. � J � 0 aa � r o' �' �, � �� E'r � a � C G . � o n 0 a�,io � v G � b � �. O � � � N a° � � � � o � � °. o n M � G � p � � �'p"o � " � �a o p' M ('� �� � n � � � ~ `� � � y ry � �. rn w � o � � � a `; m cn � � m .� �� N Ci a •• � a b � �� � ?» c �� n � o a� b o � r M � O '" N N N � � G w ob �� �„ " a � "I � ai p. o w ° ' � b � �� o °' ro N N o � � 0 �'1 � y W O � 0 Fn � 0 0 ° o �� � 0 ., ao � a � � .. .. �17 �' 'ti 'd Q "C � N �. o. � °. G M F/� y� N o �' � ��� �� x � w `�' a' � �' N � N �' N ry � � Q;'O � � �, � N �� �.^� o a rn � � � a � � Ky C w �� ' �' � � ���o x "V ry � � o o �o o � rn �, � y � y c�o �• °a b � C, O a �' ,�'.. � r � � O G b. � y. �, d w va � T � o • C�' b �' � � �, � �G m � � . � � c � N � y � � b � v� p �• ry b � ro�� o . � � x a o � � C � � � ro � ro � < � �• :� � b C� N � a ° � � �o n c °� � � d� M � � a � � �, o b a � �. o ao � � � � 'O � w b o' N ro 0 w � 0 c� o� p 0 � N �. � - � � � w � � M � � a� � � � °; � G m � • �� � � � p� � w g• � � w � � �. a N � � c � 'rJ � O 0 � b O � O � a �' 0 � U�a � � � a y C � w a G � N I--� .� N O N ., m � G � � y N � w G � a G � b a ° a 'a � � � °< � y � w � � c�i m a � °, � W �n e a � � � N a � �. �c � x w O 'L �. N 'V ro �' o' � � � y GO 71 �� � � �� b � U�a �i � � "� $. � H m �' � � a. � ti w � w a~ ro :-" �. �. w N u' � � " , o o � M n N n N � N � � 0 �a a � N � m � a N b � � a v�a, � p M � �o � �h � n � w � M d w � �� � oz ry �. N � � o b �r � � w � � � � � c � � Oq� �. c� � � �� O � � °� � a � 0 H a N �. � � � � y a � � � � � � � C' M $ a y � y O � na� � � o � � � � � w �o w w ��,� � o b � � � �aro � � o, p O �i �n w 3'n o � c� � � �'; �� a N � � G w � EP � a' C n p y ,�, � �. � � � � �'xd QQ p� y. � �. C � M b � y 0 � o � a �•'� � �� C b . ti � N fJ Oo VC �* _ __�fl ^ C�' � � 01.� J r� � r 2� � � a F C�7 � �o � � "2 � W E � � � 0 � 0 � .� z � .-i v o � �� � y Q O � �U � � b � � � � a� O ~ O U yy'".. •,[.' � � � � h ti '° .� a � � y � r q rn O� •� O � a� .� b � bA w O � v� � � N � N � v U � [�r w a � 3 � � .� N a � � � b .� ~ C � CL � � � � � •� a a� �•�b � ro � U t� y `' :c�5 � ° � rn N U A ro .� •^�i N o ,>, ° . � W � a on � � � � � y U N U U U � U •� N N N ..—, ,^ •,-, �—, •—, o a r °' Q., a a a ca � �--i .. rn m v� 'n .. � .. �. � .. � � � � � � � � N N � � M � U U U U .� '^'' a� a� a� a� O y O b 1 � 0 �p �p �" •^� 0 � a a aa aa ,-� Q, rn �t V � � '. �..i �..i �..i � � � � � S � M O .--i .--i N �O � � : -. '� a' U +m' U '�'' y U y U � '0 '� 'p •-�i 'p ��' ,-°�.� a a °� a a o, � � M � � � �..+ �..i � v � ..i � � � � � � N M N m M 7 � � � V d � � ;, � � � �''� U a �" i '� � N � � � � � v� o � � '� � � ~ � � � � � b a�i � I � - � � C � , b o V .7� �� rx v� aa� w�v� a, � �.�.�� a o � o rn �a a � o w p ai a w�p U h � � � � � V � ti � U � `� fV }� � pD U . .�'J . 00 � " w °� � '� o N � � �' U 'tr �r I � I � b � F �� O � � � Q � F�a ..�i � Vl �vl � .`", 'O F :� � cd � m ,. m .°: ,'� � � o 0 " o w° .-�. a� N N N m °n p Z d' ,C p E nn E u u y� F•' O Fy � 'f" U ���� N� `� r �.-�. ��0�� 'O �.� ��� O N M O� M vl F.' � O�, C`? O N N O y Q" A 64 N a,aaao � �� a�i o °' ¢��z �� � � �,-�� M�sa�o .--i m � � � � •� ~ y bq U ._^. � .'�'. '� .�°, a� �'�o � b '� � � ��:�.� C �U Ci l� ���p l� �( � A � � � .� � � O � „ a w' � o o � N o� � C O �.. °� � w � .q � u, C� �.��ao�d nu � q p > c�a N�� p w o H za' Nb�° � ' d U �„�� w 0 'N F ^ N N � � o a> W U C% Q.� o a a�i,� � I ^� 3 � F � .� ti�� �� � �oN -. � � � m � m � �+ � N � O ',� G U G�y S w � W p bu . � M � O U ,� � � o ,.� b� � ° o. o � `" °' `n ' o .0 m � � � w � °•°-'-,yw �� � �° � N bA � 'i7 C]r Ci r' v N � � b � 4� ,?; •Y .� � .S 0 0 � a� � �, a� CL W ;O � `" Q U �.�. � .� � U �•°-;��o �a �•�� �� W cd U O� y� � , c� � ,� u�. " 'O O � t4 G U � p � :: o � � Q � � � U �a . g .� c� � � � � O� C� N 1-I a b Y GJ � . td y ..'rJ' F� a�. .� �� b N��� a' 7 - � o � � � b G � � �.9b�s�y � V" U i(1 �o .•� M U �� q N v� v�, 0 N '� � U O � N 7� � � O�� G N N y � b �n �, w o � r �� �b �s'�s ° � .� � `d `� a o O � � p � .+ 0 a� o �� N o � �U b N G.�-� r.�, N� d �W' ° '� ° .G o w a ti i �'�'°o �w �� ;; oo 3� p �a�r�.R+j N F� N Q� •.. v�i '3' N � 1 �' ' ti�.� � W '� � O a�i ��O � � �L b�.�� U W.�. � 7,m �b c a � � � N � G+ p .,'�. '� F�' P�" C y . 'r�' F� o �..�o ��'� d w�q�-�+,� � o �, a �; w .� � � Q � � , . � a. � o ro�.�� G c� T U � 'a7 C ~ � U W c�tl �" G := N N 0���': c a wa��yw 3'a��i 3� � ;; ;; o o � � .n w �d ❑ +'J d � ti C� 0 o• � U U � � '" a a.'� °� ���wH c� �i 0 0 .� .� � A H a OJO � � on �. � � a? b � � � � � � � 3 � Y � � � � � � "'d � y � � � •C � � �a o � � p w C w p � Pa � '�n c�i a' � ° b o a G� U w � bA '7' .d „ n� �, o ��'C�p �b C rn � b �P.i � �F+ �' � � �, .a a �� ` � � � 3 '� p . � � O •O O � b td . �+ .y P' OP.. ,� � U m o cd � � � � � o � a��i . p � a cd G� � .o � ` �i � � p �' 0 0 °G,, .o �� � �o .a � ��a � � � � � .� o �' o u' o � a� ������ �wA� � N N �V C O O � .� N O � •v�i O �+ > aa� a�a�,��. � y � � U i �G �, � F '� •.� F u � � v o bA � � O y N M � � � � p N � � � O � � F �� � �� NN�b �,- � � F �� O� � F b ^ �rnrnrn� o ,., ,-. ,-. F .:i' z N N '-I V�i a i�+ � � ro ,� ornrnrnF � z o W � N � � W � r � � N � ��-+�M N����i, ��rnrnH � U � 0 � p � U � � � 0 � b � � .V. o . ,� � •� � .�w � .� � � h 0 � M .ti � .� '� a� '> ,�F .�a N o �i� �� '� a H � 0 � a � � ', � i�'�Il1 M ��L , . ; nrrrn �nr I, � ► � � � � � � ( U CS � F r.a O � r� � � � � � � y.�+ U � � a a � u � •� Q ^�� ^ � � C O W � � � H A bo a ¢ � S 0 0 t s OG z r�. y a� � r N %�, •- � �O O O +'�i P. a O. � � � � � � � N N .. h r. �p � U U � � '^ '^ '" �'' a o. � � � � b� b� � � � ^ � 1n N U 47 a 'o ..�'� ' � a a a � � � b� `� S e � m O w � � � o ,� , v a 'y u � � F+ •� Y y `J � � � a � on � UO Uv� v� � 0 �' � � � U � � � � w � w N O � U p � O w � .'f.-1' a '� o `� a � ���n cV � �' � W a � � O h � h b � � .-�. '�i N C M � .�i � � � L' � � � w � �.�0 � y O U O p+ y :� �oA,ps�> .. � � �;� a eu .� o o � '° � 3 � R ' a � i � � �� � �s rn ^� o � ,..., w rn a c, N 0 "C'on��•� �•� � � � � O vi �� .� N � U � ,.�.. P ti ti U p W r' V w � �U ow•�,� � O O � . ' 'C .�J F. a, �c�a � G c�d bq �,�� Hw' �•� b c3 � '� ,o .� °,'o d •� a � " U a N c"u rn v� y �n �,� � ,. � c�d c�2 � � •d y v `3 bq H � �d '.� p Q � � a� '� � U N p � O U � N ,., N �� v a on i B o a� �:�� � � °� � Uv �a �U�a.� �.9 � 0 8 0 0 S �° � � 00 00 $ o 00 0 0 o g o$ oS o8 So S S 8 ° o ° o ° � ° ° o ° c ° o ° o ° o n �� �� H� V3� � 6�9 YI �' � O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Q g o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 oov�0000 00o v; o0 0 00 oS VI O O O� Vi O O O O O O l� O O O Vl O V? l� N O O d' N O N Vi O O O N1 �D O O N h �O O f9N N �'^�� N Ndi (5N �^ �� W�R Hi' A fA Nf W U) !A A � V N M 1� N N V^ d' d' h t� N N C h�� b t1 N� N � � F v 6 e � o m ❑ W U 5,� �� � �° ° o, � � � � � d N V � � M O J N �-• O 'O O ' �R O U.`G"' d (' ��,�` � O � S l:` O�� O U O N 3?.+' y 'O N ❑ '�' V O� � U N� V� U C4 C C> O , F V �� e �.��.���G� S V � � o � QUUa oinv E °� � °.o �i ����v.�'�v��.Fb'G�'� WU �v�z Na °.o CL 'SCI u `�',� 6 m oh �« `� m�U:� m '0, � o � °�' x � � � G c .�d •. �' � ° n �n , �' G + �a�i ' VE�j. m V° 6� .C. �+' � ° � m c � � � 'O .0 .° X C �] � F. �' p. � p � �a w C'. m Q v�G � u. i`d °u ❑ v v v o a °� �' p W 3�1 L1wL1 wwC7'.'Cx'xn�� �Z,'Z v�'? ,. v C � � C a O F � d[-� N ? N Y. � O N C �.., a> � . � cw � °'v N v� w S�^ m °� E' `� � � n'� 3 o .a w � � � r" � � x' r °- � � m o `° fL v� O� V G O b C q t� N p. O�� y o �ou c a+' r o`n C7 A �" � p 9 o W o P1 °" O R7 � a o .°"� �'�' a v`� N� � a x� s� v u`�' ou �o K� a '�' a m� w m c v� c`� o o� w' 8 m 5� �, y c nY v� Q o w'� a�i E rn ' m'� o ° o� �" v.c ��� a�� v� �i � Q U s` ^�� o'z e vi E a a� o fi �v �'°a cc3 va$i °��.,V o Uw � N a� q P. Q v �� r m 5 v� m� � O� o'` 9 ° O�n r W U� �o awq ri�m,xC7x�n`�UUSw ��.�Z O �D O� N M O� O Vl �O 1� W O� O m M W O� M O O O O O O N N N CI N N N M M m V O r 1� 1� C� h l� I� f� 1� h 1� l� h 1� h 1� 1� l� 1� 1� t� l� l� O� O+ P O. O� O� O� O� T G� O� O� O� O� P O. P O+ O� O� P T O� a� u � � � � W E� � d � W 0 � O � � � A W � a � C7 E h d h �ro��.��y o� 3 `��" ' � >, �3 iy O . .� T � `❑� � c�v > � p '7 id o'��o� a�i o . �, � � .�4 � � ¢' U � ..�i .. � � � y,+ �' �. � � � Q N N x' �-�' � '� � � � U ❑ ^ V � o � O iC � �-�. � 'ti � � O V � � �+ '� � � � '� O F '�d �+ A. ,�-,� � a� �' � � ° a vq� �� � � � o o �" � � o $ y '� � o a a�i 'p V .� � � .O a � V bD � � N Q Q �17 � � ,a�, .� � � � Q � O � � � U O �A V � `'��oo°`�' �r�i� ��ao�`' a . �caop�.�'3 o '� � � .en'° p p�, ��bA:��� � cdU �U �, v ' V � � _r .k N � Vi� �7 'O N . �G,'�' � N � � .�". � W , f 0 0-� �,^ U �p� ��°' ����� �' O O V '.� ,^ O � �b �� o�� Hz �'� ° �ar C�J � � L� "C! � W � � � � d R� ^� U 'o s. a O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O v t O O O O O O N O N M� N Q� O N O O O O O N ViFANidiVidifA�W �O N N^+ " r'+ �O V r' N^� � d d V � " �' ❑ o v x U Y ,� � �� � U�.°�`� > Vl ,�'j' � � Q�' 7 Q y .F1 �� w�i a,p 'O u E C p�b N C.L C? °o y ?+�j�� ° °Ll 5 ° mU � �� y .c c a.5 �� o[0 � G a o 09 � � � L�OV�i=p, � '�'L m �axd o c `� >.V a � �> n C ps v� o � c n, fi v'� S°OS °' cn' � `� W c' O � x o?�,d�C c> , o c C7C7.�.lw'Z.�.Zv � O F a N V C ti O v� 1` Y1 � � v L � � � � � � N G U Y N V N y m � v ccj a°� >°� z a a W � a m a� � � 41� V L � �' W L �'_] ti 7 N t '" �� ; x � a o� b3 g .� p °' � �` w V n�i w o tl� R��@� �a > �` V W a, � o i. �. �v � + � E��u u¢rn Ro D N."y E Q ��� O F aC7�Uww�.a �nv rnrn N M V vl �O 1� G� O�^�n O O O O O O O O O o O O O O o O O O o O t4�r' l��t<t�td ��t�� rn rn rn rn rn rn rn m rn rn rn rn 000 000 � �� o00 � Q O O O O O� O �+�OOo V vi �n O� � .�-� O O O O � O O O O O O O O V) �A �A h M N O� m r-i ; � N Q � A�pQAQ QQ�Q aa.aaaa awaa Y � � � ; � '° p, � o v, Q o b " � � m $ a .. x:� b > � �] � � �A ° � b °',�� b � �i � � � � � O � j? � '�C Zi o � U� 5o E'" '� O O ..O O 4+'7 ci. �., o�� j c�i ca ��. ,v� v' �wA �' �ra"a� �d � ao�a�cn ��V �,o . � � � o �� � � � W � ¢' � " A °� �.� � � �UH `�.�°W �Ac��wa� v,aaa � °^ g � 0 0° o M O M � Fq N d a` d � L Y '> U �D O O V O O O O O O v o o a o 0 0 0 o a r oo �o o�noo a m ri O"(`I O r N�VI�OO V N N N V N t� Vl N N m�MF9 M�d3 Y1HitAfH69 N c C c C c q C� C C . . . . .� � .� .� � G E v u v y p �C 1+ ') G' � /+ W � � � � _ � m Cd U = � v ��Ua � F.x `�y U S4 -� W d5 � .] � o`� m G r\ a � �� N � a a& N� U � F� N` �n � � � � � � o � � ° ooa� y ' ' �' � o`� � c v? o0 U U CO {�C7`.C� �O wx � O F o E �;a y N v�° W � � �� ��� � �. A' � LL N O '�" � E `_yP.���� 2« � n' '° y v� p u u a� °� N � 6 � O O µ � q a� �� h 7 �r� ° °.3a^ m ��� v0 ac�N �, V s � � ��naU m `�yv�i3 °c�r � C a 3^'� E y ro,�, � �= � o.`a� V v �' y �ovi,C rnU W U(70a=; OOx o—M �n� noo rno m�o O O O O O O O O V h N h h n� h n h h n p�. P p. a� P U� N P U 0 � � rb � � C� C � � � a N � ,a�,' � � .� o N p+•d N � � � N � a �� � N � `� � rn b �N � � � b N A � w O y '� � t' � �o ;; 3 O H � A U �pq'Ct � O z `� b�A G�.' � � � N N � 27 � C.� O Tl b O O i `� .. � o g � p . c+�' O �n O O � � � •� � '� � � �,.� ���� ���� � �, n b � � O� O �y rn •� � .� a � c .� ao O � p O Q o � d' b9 � ° o 0 ° o O 'V'� �s � y � �a:a F �C. �' > � � � N cG � 3 a � � N O � � � .k G�r c/1 �x *C a � � � a O m O .0 � � a b � � O rri .� � o ^� b � � � � �` O a�. � �� � O y N 0 0 � � a o � � a �° O O � � 0 C � o '^ � N � � h � o 'd � CJ on .'�. � m P� � � pq � p �' ,fl � � w � � � � � a,'� U o o �a o 00 �; b .� � O d � , ^ N E >' 7 w � rn .�y �. ��.",�0� 'O vi W V� � ob � 3 `� H � +�' (yi Vl N � a H � o �. � V� a O .� � p � a � � � � � � .^ U �'�� '� .n Z � '� O � � b M � � N y � � � a' a .�'+ 0 G N . w � � O ����� q v� o p �°"�` ° � � � � p �.�. .J � Y o, y c � � .� (tl O U � � b w � 0 a F�. �-+ U � � � � � � .� a � d' � � � � � r O C O � :-_' ,� m � � � ti .,�., .-1 O � ,� 4�q a � o ,= a �a°�� � a�� � a o� 'O H °�' .� � � � O 'C7 � � � � O �� G o a, o, o N � � .5 C � � ,.`�', ctl v� d . U O � � � � �.., a ou a.`"+ cd 0 'O O � a��i � � r a y a � � F @ � o � � � CA '� �p � � N '� � � .� '.� ctl � N .+ 4. w W. yw b i; � �C � b N y d " � ° � � F a a. O � � O U o � � a� v � A � � � � a ��. � �e� `° o � M p p � �e-- : > F s � 3 ,� � N � W � � � O ��°`� � � � y � � � � � � N N � a� .> ,a `�' ro � t � � 3 .� � '� � b � � c� � } � .� �� W _�! y U � +'�- V '� V] V t" C � � �i �G F +-' •' Q b�°� � �o.�o ." '�- � � ���� a' U -- � � � U y Vl O �� �� . y � � ° b � � � U Y � bu N � f"� ^ O �Nk3°� w � J � y y � 0 y � U .�' � b-0 � aa o � d � w a � a � � , °��' ^� `�-� O � ..� Y a � � �� p �1 � �a� � p, '�a ~° Y O .� v 'Iy > N N N t�d A f""' O � U U W w �+ • .. p '� ��" h a�r U O �' � b � � � ~ � � o N � � V h• C � .�..' 0. � m O O � � � � U �y o A N � (� �C M � T y � N A � F7 '� � �r, � � U r�'ii b w ro � � � g ai «. � b �'N � '� � O �i U a � a �a � � o � � � a 'So � G, � t+ �i.�,o °' a � �� � � � U J� , w � ��� b���� v > � •� ao � � V � a�+ F'i ����` t�'... � w O s. .� a�+ �� a�i �' a a� a�i � � � � � � ���"� � G °�':c� � �p rn `° O O'q P. t�V �� N itl t�V U Tr' y � v � y p .c � v� � -� a .° ,� a a� '� a N �, �O N h N � N � � � � ....... � b b � a d � C �'y d s � � w � Y � � .� �W w � ;: a > �A y � y °a p�y N p,d M y � � 'O j � '� h `° �, o �� � .°'. � � � �rn,� ��° �� °»"��Na� a,o b •o o � b� � � � v1 ,� N � N � � ..�'. � O y � "_' ;d N U � w ' d �� H"" U c O� ca O a � b � �"��p �� �,��a °�,� O O'�.,, O� F+ ?: � B � � � � N G'�j � OA � � G � � � � '� rn �w U „ w I.�i x � � �; � v�i `� a�i 'C �� a: k" N� Y abi � � V w N � •� G � F. � > a�+ � � N � O y.. `� � ¢, � N '� c� � ''"'' � a � �° a `" i �a � � � � > m � rn .`�'. +' 7- P' O c3 �'G � � 4. v � ' 3 .[: � [ p + .tj" �..� yr: C N � � �-, �d � � �� w�.o �� o �w � �� � y -n.1 O ` y � .� � �' b 6 � °� o �, ° � o `�' C V U °�,' � v c O�O b O y N>' N Q� N N U V �y a�, � s`�.'�U v�,.�w�o � � � �i^;y 5 �,, g � a� � N "' 'G .� p �'� � � C � ,,�', o � > U � �, .� � o ° `ba U � � .r ��o° (.�' U 0 � 1 N J�.+'.L' O� Y �'y N O � O ' � rn `� \/ � � Y � .� .� N N � .0 � � O y `� .a b � � �� � � .� � � U � p � F O .��� � � o � � � � � � � o � � � '� � � �nH o�a rn � b � y. � � O � W � aoa`� o � � F+� U FL 17 o ro .�.� x H °�d¢�' o .� �� • • • • � � d � a bA � � �.d O U a�+ F: N Vl q ZJ W Q ,� �y O N p y O��^ O b � a. O ,� � V � � C .fl � A 'h T F. N H b � � � � � ?: � � .+' a � a�i 3 '�� °' � a w � .� G a, � o 0 U � q `� � `�' � a�i � � � p y 3,� � 'O Y .L) o � �y � U C .� � �.+ A ':� �v .� � a 'i7 - .� 'O T� N � b c �a�j t�.� � N J� o � p � � � N F � U � O � Y ~.� �,r.�. � k a G. � b i/] .� � «� `� � � � •p ' °' ° °,� ° b �3��a'��a� � � � � b F � � �' , � N � "�.� ��'.. a�.i b b � � ro N � � � en �' � � 3 a O.� y t'�7 r� � `° � ,g � v 'd o �� ��� �� � � 3 � c� � `�+ � O � >� N�.� y �'O O p(n .������ � U ,, � " � � ~ � � b � � � � " � U � � o '� � � � .� !� c�n � y c� � U a �.� o W A.n o sa � a�a � ^.� O ti � � V � �p � � _^• p ,d y a � a.�.� N �, � ou Y tj o � o °' 'd 'O p N N � o ?3 m � q 4, �. N O � V � b a �3 rn ° o �, � N p V .� N .�C � � $ w,,� a � F " h � �i � N V� a� p '�w ��� b .� ; � ,� a ��o� � � � � � � o � � o ,�'ti � � � � •° q V � O N � � M � F'� � � U vi °'v'.° o ., �» o .,� .� � O � 'c� °`'�°� ' � �¢ �' N tn .� � U .� ry � V � U c� p � .^ O y ,� � �' �, � c,, �2 �n p y�j q � 1�3 � � � � p a � � ry ''� � � � o v '� y p '.� °: ,.��i aoa `" a � � � � � � N � � o � h .� b .� O � � U d ��x�'� o � c2 .a� h O N .�', > ^° c`"i � m .� mb b � .� �a�� a1 y '''� � O ��o�.� .� > � '3 ° a. b � � � � 'd ;O v�i � ��,�� ro ow.�� � � o 0 o g g o .j M � -i O� � A � � W v�i .--i a� 5iy �. N d' r`� a� rn C � ,�,� a� N o � '� v� '- � ° '� ttl a p � O � � � �..I �� � ~ h b � N 'd .n �o > � � �.od.�� .--i O � q��ia� More Information? For addirional copies of this report or informarion about the 1998 funding cycle, please call 266-STAR(7827). Credits City of Saint Paul Mayor Norm Coleman 1997 Neighborhood STAR Board Mazjorie Ebensteiner City Council President David Thune* John Fahey Councilmember Jerry Blakey Stephen Gordon Councilmember Dan Bostrom Lany Laughlin Councilmember Joseph Collins* John Loban Councilmember Mike Harris John Mazgot Councilmember Roberta Megard* Russell Miller Councilmember Gladys Morton* *Terms eacpired at the end of 1997. 1997 Cultural STAR Board Ruth Appelhof Brent Assink Richard Cook Sarah Lutman Frank Marzitelli Ronald W. Pauline Sam Verdeja Lois West, Chair Kathleen Wilson Dept. of Planning & Economic Development Pamela Wheelock, Director Amy Filice, Joan Trulsen, Donna Drummond - STAR Program Coordinators Jim Beaver and Fran Burns- intems Published January, 1998 12 Thomas Olesak Charles Senkler Kathleen Sundberg Kou Vang Michelle Vojacek Steve Wellington, Chair Ron Whitcomb Council File # � 1 �� ORIG1NAt Presented By Referred To Committee: Date 1997 Sales Tax Revitalization (STAR) Program Annuai Report RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul does hereby accept the 1997 Annual Report of the Sales Tax Revitalization Program as attached. P �( O Adopted by Council: Date �,� _\$ 1`i`lR' � Adoption Certified by Council Secretary: � � � Green Sheet # `�� a` RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 23 Planning & Economic Development: Form Approved by City Attorney: : Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council: � �i dr - �a� �hh�n DEFi�R7YEMiqFFICE/COUNpL DATE INITIA7E0 � v � T c��y co,���i ziiii9s GREEN SHEE CONTACT PERSON & PHONE INITIAUDATE INITIAVDAlE Mazcia Mcermond 2�-8570 � OEPAHTMENT DIRECTOR � QTV COUNpL ASSIGN � CITYATTORNEV O CITY 0.ERK MUST BE ON CAUNCIL AGENOA BY (DATE) NUMBEN FOR � BUIX3ET DIRECTOR � FIN. & MGT. SEflVICES DIR. Feb I8.1�8 OHDEN �y � nv.roa roa nss�srnr�T) � TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACiION RE�UESTED. Approval of resolution accepting the 199"/ Annual Report of the Sales Tac Revitalization (STAR) Program. RECOMMENDA710NS Approve (A� or Rejea (Fi) pERSONAL SERVICE CON7HACTS MUS7 ANSWER TME FOLLOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVII SERVICE COMMISSION �� Has thls pef50Mifm BVef Worked untlef a ContraCt fOr [hi5 tlepartmeM? _ CIB COMMITTEE _ YES NO _ S7AFF 2. Has this personHirm ever been a ciry employee? — YES NO _ oisiaici coURi _ 3. Does this Oerson/firm ossess a skill not normall p y possessed by any curreM ciry employee? SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? YES NO Explain all yes answers on separate sheet antl attach to green sheet INITIATMCa PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITV (Who. Whffi, WheO. Where, Why): ADVANTAGESIFAPPqOVED� DISADVANTAGESIFAPPROVED: DISADVANTAGES IF NOTAPPROVED. � TOTAL AMOUNT OFTRANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) VES NO FUNDItiG SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBEP FINANCIAL INFORFfiATION (EXPLAIN) 9�'1�1 STAR PROGRAM STATISTICS Total Final Applications Neighhorhood STAR 1995 1996 1997 Total 50 47 32 � 129 Totai Awards 22 20 21 63 Total $$$ Awarded $3,695,448 4,064,055 4.482.000 $12,241,503 Average Award $167,975 203,203 213.428 $194,310 Neighborhood Small Grants 1995 1996 1997 Total 22 21 13 56 14 13 12 39 $175,254 183,374 227.500 $586,128 $12,518 14,106 18.958 $15,029 Cultural STAR 1995 1996 1997 Total 26 15 10 51 11 11 9 31 $504,600 778,200 790.382 $2,194,582 $45,873 70,745 87.820 $70,793 With the exception of the average award, the above figures are contained in the 1997 STAR Annual Report. * In 1997, the Neighborhood STAR Board received 44 pre-applications, and recommended 35 for final application consideration. °I� -la�� �t Nei hborhood STAR Board Member Address List 2/98 �k Dr. Bruce Corrie iiii99 eXp. Marjorie Ebensteiner iilioi exP. Foundation Rep District Cotutcil Rep 729 Parkview Drive 2091 East Arlington Avenue Saint Paul MN 551 i 6 St. Paul, MN 55119 Phone: 487-1625 (home) Phone: 778-8580 (home) (work) 296-5472 (work) Fax: Fax: 296-8887 John Fahey 1i1i99 exp. Stephen D. Gordon 1/1/01 exp. Community Development Rep Planning Commission Rep 180 Mazia Avenue 492 Holly Avenue Saint Paul MN 55106 Saint Paul, MN 55102 Phone: 291-0083 (home) 333-0201 (work) Phone: 772-0229 Fax: 291-0086 Michelle Ketcham vvoi eXp. John Loban (CHAIR) 1/1/Ol exp. Neighborhood Business Rep At-Large Rep 200 Gilbert Building 823 Portland Avenue 413 Wacouta Street Saint Paul, MN 55104 Saint Paul, MN 55101-1957 Phone: 222-7227 (work) Phone: 221-0202 (home) Fax: 223-5229 Fax: 292-1588 John Margot iiiioi eXp. Russell J. Miller iivoo eXp. CIB Rep Neighborhood Business Rep 1818 Wellesley Avenue 267 White Bear Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55105 Saint Paul, MN 55106 Phone: 698-2994 (home) Phone: '�"�` 774-6394 (home) (call home #) 639-4742 (work) 738-2688 (work)* Thomas A. Oksak iil/o0 exp. Charles F. Senkler 1/t/99 exp District Council Rep Community Development Rep 1050 W Hoyt Avenue 1899 Fairmont Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55117 Saint Paul, I�11V 55105 Phone: 488-7437 (home) * 359-4606 (work) (call work #) Phone: 225-9414 (work) Fax: 338-4840 759-3371 (cell) " Olesak prefers all STAR calls at his work number. ** Miller prefers all STAR calls at his home number. CONTINUED ONREVERSE � Kathleen Sundberg tn/oo eXp Kou Vang 1/1/99 exp. District Council with Business Rep At-Large Rep 1375 Van Buren Avenue Norwest Bank East Saint Paul, MN 55104 875 Minnehaha Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55106 Phone: 659-9734 (home) Phone: 205-8400 645-2647 (work) Fax: 205-8412 Michelie Vojacek iniol e�. Steve Wellington, Jr. 1/1/00 exp. Financial Community Rep C.W. For-Profit Developer Rep 773 East Cottage Avenue 350 Gilbert Building Saint Paul, MN 55106 413 Wacouta Street Saint Paul, MN 55101-1957 Phone: 776-0452 (home) 874-3326 (work) Phone: 292-9844 Fax: 872-8995 Fax: 292-0072 Ron Whitcomb 1/IlOO exp. Financial Community Rep 1781 Hillcrest Avenue Saint Paul, MN 55116 Phone: 690-9472 @ome) 690-8201 (work) FaY: 698-2477 STAR Staff Bob Aainmer Jill Hughes Planning & Economic Development Plamung & Economic Development 1400 City Hall Annex 1400 City Hall Annex 25 West Fourth Street 25 West Fourth Street Saint Paul, MN 55102 Saint Paul, MN 55102 Phone: 266-6693 Phone: 266-6650 Fax: 228-3220 Fax: 228-3220 Paul Mordorski Planning & Economic Development 1400 City Hall Annex 25 West Fourth Street Saint Paul, MN 55102 Phone: 266-6683 FaY: 228-3320 H:\APPISTAR\\STARTEMINHDBOARD.LST REVISED 2/4/98 � � _ ..�: �� � � , , � � �� � �; ., r �> � � F, ;� , ,��,, , , , �:. � � ;, .� �F; ', ;. ,., ;, ,, ry � . i . " �� .� �i � O •r T rJ{` ♦V N .,.., � � � � � 7 � � � � 4-. E-" � � -~ � U c/� ��� Q 0 � Z�Q � N a 9�-�a7 Sales Taar Revitalization (STAR) Progrann 1997 Annuai Report This Report St. Paul's Sales Tax Kevitalization (STARJ Program has just completed ifs tliird yeaz of awarding loans and grants for capital improvement projects in St. Paul neighborhoods and the downtowa cultural disuict. Tfiis annual report on tfie STAR Program includes: o an overview of the STAR Program o key program features o application and project selecrion process o estimated future sales tax collections o STAR awards by project type and geographic area 0 1997 distribution of STAR fund balance o program accomplishments to date 0 outside investment and job creation o Ioan program features o contracting process What is the STAR Program? The Minnesota State I,egislature provided legislauve authorizauon for the Ciry of Saint Paul to levy an addirional 1/2 percent sales talc in May, 1993: T1te authorizing legislation states that revenues may be used to pay all or a portion of the capital expenses for expansion and remodeling of the St. Paul Civic Center complex. The legislation further states, "The remainder of the funds must be spent for capital projects to funher residential, cultural, commercial and economic development in both downtown St. Pau1 and St. Paul neighborhoods". The City determined that 40% of the sales tax proceeds would pay for 30 yeaz bonds issued to fuiance the renovarion and expansion of the Saint Paul River Centre (formerly the Saint Paul Civic Center). The remaining 60% of sales tax proceeds would be spent on other capital nnprovement projects in Saint Paul. In mid-1994, the City Council established the Sales Tax Revitalizarion (STAR) Program, which includes the Neighborhood STAR and Cuitural STAR Programs, to distribute the remaining sales tax proceeds. The Neighborhood STAR Program awazds loans and grants for capital improvement projects in Saint Paul neighborhoods, and is funded with 50% of the sales tax proceeds. The Cultural STAR Program, funded with the remaining 10% of sales tax proceeds, awards loans and grants for capital improvement projects that further cultural ac6vities in Saint Paul. However, changes to the state legisla4on during the 1997 session will enable the City to use funds in the Cultural STAR Program for cultural organization operating expenses as well, beginning in 1998. Both the Neighborhood and C�Ihual STAR Programs have completed three annual funding cycles, which were administered by the City's Department of Planning and Economic Development. N w ��wy ���<;� G rn io� C � � �• � w.a5 � G5'� � ����� R . a � �' G `� .- ro O � ry � � � � � � �; r-�i w � � f'I w �•�p. Sv � � � `�� � � n ry �° c A. CL N .'Y p� � O � A N r.'�S. � O �` � °: � m b � w � � � � a ub U � O � �. ���u � � 'C! N KT; 0 �' cn � � p. O -�f � � -n m � � a `�° � � a P v'� bq v O .�. o °, 'n �55 ^ tlq � 2 �- o w. co m � a m � `� w � C. ro ,ti �' 0 °° �.°^*, � �• � �'i vo a O � y k w o ��� �p o �' 6� p �Y �? a �r � � Q, a � " � � ��� 'V y F G � n a� � � � �' O � � � � .q � � W • �, a � � � K l 1 � � � H ! � /_ � � �� � � �� w � ao � � �' a .w y o' b N O W � � a� � � �' o � N `C '� O � � o a b a o �? � � a � � � p. n � `� C� c�o � � p � �'� � � ., � �� � �b c a c��c' .�'.. (> n � � N °' ' w � ro ,b a. O � 0 � � �. y N o C � �] � � � m � N � �• � G � m u�' '� a � �, � � � �. � � � `C � � � p � M a O a ❑ � a p 0 � � � � � b � a o b � � � p � � � � a �� aroo � � y��°�� � w � w H �• b .� rn �'w �n �•� � ��� � p � ° � � � � 9 a c�i�� �» i'p � � �� � �. �' o x 5' , � w a �G'o �'� o � d � �-' 't7 �b�cc�. � � T C. � • G � y � m 5 c w b p b : �.b •o�o C n i-n . UQ W n. �.row �b �; � y `° � o ' � � � C �. w � 'b �u�o caro.o H w .� A' N b � �' O y � w � o �y 0 �•b°�w 'G � d� a'� � � � � C C � � O O rn�°° .�r' � �rn �.� 'O 'd � A� � a 0 t�i � � p � � .h'. �GJ G `� �. � �/Q y ny u O � :: � ,� M � O O � � b y b � H a ,d KY O� - . s ' P. � o ro � 0 a c�o � .'7 �' � �. M � � � N y � � r"1" y ro' '" 0 �° � o a � �. � J � 0 aa � r o' �' �, � �� E'r � a � C G . � o n 0 a�,io � v G � b � �. O � � � N a° � � � � o � � °. o n M � G � p � � �'p"o � " � �a o p' M ('� �� � n � � � ~ `� � � y ry � �. rn w � o � � � a `; m cn � � m .� �� N Ci a •• � a b � �� � ?» c �� n � o a� b o � r M � O '" N N N � � G w ob �� �„ " a � "I � ai p. o w ° ' � b � �� o °' ro N N o � � 0 �'1 � y W O � 0 Fn � 0 0 ° o �� � 0 ., ao � a � � .. .. �17 �' 'ti 'd Q "C � N �. o. � °. G M F/� y� N o �' � ��� �� x � w `�' a' � �' N � N �' N ry � � Q;'O � � �, � N �� �.^� o a rn � � � a � � Ky C w �� ' �' � � ���o x "V ry � � o o �o o � rn �, � y � y c�o �• °a b � C, O a �' ,�'.. � r � � O G b. � y. �, d w va � T � o • C�' b �' � � �, � �G m � � . � � c � N � y � � b � v� p �• ry b � ro�� o . � � x a o � � C � � � ro � ro � < � �• :� � b C� N � a ° � � �o n c °� � � d� M � � a � � �, o b a � �. o ao � � � � 'O � w b o' N ro 0 w � 0 c� o� p 0 � N �. � - � � � w � � M � � a� � � � °; � G m � • �� � � � p� � w g• � � w � � �. a N � � c � 'rJ � O 0 � b O � O � a �' 0 � U�a � � � a y C � w a G � N I--� .� N O N ., m � G � � y N � w G � a G � b a ° a 'a � � � °< � y � w � � c�i m a � °, � W �n e a � � � N a � �. �c � x w O 'L �. N 'V ro �' o' � � � y GO 71 �� � � �� b � U�a �i � � "� $. � H m �' � � a. � ti w � w a~ ro :-" �. �. w N u' � � " , o o � M n N n N � N � � 0 �a a � N � m � a N b � � a v�a, � p M � �o � �h � n � w � M d w � �� � oz ry �. N � � o b �r � � w � � � � � c � � Oq� �. c� � � �� O � � °� � a � 0 H a N �. � � � � y a � � � � � � � C' M $ a y � y O � na� � � o � � � � � w �o w w ��,� � o b � � � �aro � � o, p O �i �n w 3'n o � c� � � �'; �� a N � � G w � EP � a' C n p y ,�, � �. � � � � �'xd QQ p� y. � �. C � M b � y 0 � o � a �•'� � �� C b . ti � N fJ Oo VC �* _ __�fl ^ C�' � � 01.� J r� � r 2� � � a F C�7 � �o � � "2 � W E � � � 0 � 0 � .� z � .-i v o � �� � y Q O � �U � � b � � � � a� O ~ O U yy'".. •,[.' � � � � h ti '° .� a � � y � r q rn O� •� O � a� .� b � bA w O � v� � � N � N � v U � [�r w a � 3 � � .� N a � � � b .� ~ C � CL � � � � � •� a a� �•�b � ro � U t� y `' :c�5 � ° � rn N U A ro .� •^�i N o ,>, ° . � W � a on � � � � � y U N U U U � U •� N N N ..—, ,^ •,-, �—, •—, o a r °' Q., a a a ca � �--i .. rn m v� 'n .. � .. �. � .. � � � � � � � � N N � � M � U U U U .� '^'' a� a� a� a� O y O b 1 � 0 �p �p �" •^� 0 � a a aa aa ,-� Q, rn �t V � � '. �..i �..i �..i � � � � � S � M O .--i .--i N �O � � : -. '� a' U +m' U '�'' y U y U � '0 '� 'p •-�i 'p ��' ,-°�.� a a °� a a o, � � M � � � �..+ �..i � v � ..i � � � � � � N M N m M 7 � � � V d � � ;, � � � �''� U a �" i '� � N � � � � � v� o � � '� � � ~ � � � � � b a�i � I � - � � C � , b o V .7� �� rx v� aa� w�v� a, � �.�.�� a o � o rn �a a � o w p ai a w�p U h � � � � � V � ti � U � `� fV }� � pD U . .�'J . 00 � " w °� � '� o N � � �' U 'tr �r I � I � b � F �� O � � � Q � F�a ..�i � Vl �vl � .`", 'O F :� � cd � m ,. m .°: ,'� � � o 0 " o w° .-�. a� N N N m °n p Z d' ,C p E nn E u u y� F•' O Fy � 'f" U ���� N� `� r �.-�. ��0�� 'O �.� ��� O N M O� M vl F.' � O�, C`? O N N O y Q" A 64 N a,aaao � �� a�i o °' ¢��z �� � � �,-�� M�sa�o .--i m � � � � •� ~ y bq U ._^. � .'�'. '� .�°, a� �'�o � b '� � � ��:�.� C �U Ci l� ���p l� �( � A � � � .� � � O � „ a w' � o o � N o� � C O �.. °� � w � .q � u, C� �.��ao�d nu � q p > c�a N�� p w o H za' Nb�° � ' d U �„�� w 0 'N F ^ N N � � o a> W U C% Q.� o a a�i,� � I ^� 3 � F � .� ti�� �� � �oN -. � � � m � m � �+ � N � O ',� G U G�y S w � W p bu . � M � O U ,� � � o ,.� b� � ° o. o � `" °' `n ' o .0 m � � � w � °•°-'-,yw �� � �° � N bA � 'i7 C]r Ci r' v N � � b � 4� ,?; •Y .� � .S 0 0 � a� � �, a� CL W ;O � `" Q U �.�. � .� � U �•°-;��o �a �•�� �� W cd U O� y� � , c� � ,� u�. " 'O O � t4 G U � p � :: o � � Q � � � U �a . g .� c� � � � � O� C� N 1-I a b Y GJ � . td y ..'rJ' F� a�. .� �� b N��� a' 7 - � o � � � b G � � �.9b�s�y � V" U i(1 �o .•� M U �� q N v� v�, 0 N '� � U O � N 7� � � O�� G N N y � b �n �, w o � r �� �b �s'�s ° � .� � `d `� a o O � � p � .+ 0 a� o �� N o � �U b N G.�-� r.�, N� d �W' ° '� ° .G o w a ti i �'�'°o �w �� ;; oo 3� p �a�r�.R+j N F� N Q� •.. v�i '3' N � 1 �' ' ti�.� � W '� � O a�i ��O � � �L b�.�� U W.�. � 7,m �b c a � � � N � G+ p .,'�. '� F�' P�" C y . 'r�' F� o �..�o ��'� d w�q�-�+,� � o �, a �; w .� � � Q � � , . � a. � o ro�.�� G c� T U � 'a7 C ~ � U W c�tl �" G := N N 0���': c a wa��yw 3'a��i 3� � ;; ;; o o � � .n w �d ❑ +'J d � ti C� 0 o• � U U � � '" a a.'� °� ���wH c� �i 0 0 .� .� � A H a OJO � � on �. � � a? b � � � � � � � 3 � Y � � � � � � "'d � y � � � •C � � �a o � � p w C w p � Pa � '�n c�i a' � ° b o a G� U w � bA '7' .d „ n� �, o ��'C�p �b C rn � b �P.i � �F+ �' � � �, .a a �� ` � � � 3 '� p . � � O •O O � b td . �+ .y P' OP.. ,� � U m o cd � � � � � o � a��i . p � a cd G� � .o � ` �i � � p �' 0 0 °G,, .o �� � �o .a � ��a � � � � � .� o �' o u' o � a� ������ �wA� � N N �V C O O � .� N O � •v�i O �+ > aa� a�a�,��. � y � � U i �G �, � F '� •.� F u � � v o bA � � O y N M � � � � p N � � � O � � F �� � �� NN�b �,- � � F �� O� � F b ^ �rnrnrn� o ,., ,-. ,-. F .:i' z N N '-I V�i a i�+ � � ro ,� ornrnrnF � z o W � N � � W � r � � N � ��-+�M N����i, ��rnrnH � U � 0 � p � U � � � 0 � b � � .V. o . ,� � •� � .�w � .� � � h 0 � M .ti � .� '� a� '> ,�F .�a N o �i� �� '� a H � 0 � a � � ', � i�'�Il1 M ��L , . ; nrrrn �nr I, � ► � � � � � � ( U CS � F r.a O � r� � � � � � � y.�+ U � � a a � u � •� Q ^�� ^ � � C O W � � � H A bo a ¢ � S 0 0 t s OG z r�. y a� � r N %�, •- � �O O O +'�i P. a O. � � � � � � � N N .. h r. �p � U U � � '^ '^ '" �'' a o. � � � � b� b� � � � ^ � 1n N U 47 a 'o ..�'� ' � a a a � � � b� `� S e � m O w � � � o ,� , v a 'y u � � F+ •� Y y `J � � � a � on � UO Uv� v� � 0 �' � � � U � � � � w � w N O � U p � O w � .'f.-1' a '� o `� a � ���n cV � �' � W a � � O h � h b � � .-�. '�i N C M � .�i � � � L' � � � w � �.�0 � y O U O p+ y :� �oA,ps�> .. � � �;� a eu .� o o � '° � 3 � R ' a � i � � �� � �s rn ^� o � ,..., w rn a c, N 0 "C'on��•� �•� � � � � O vi �� .� N � U � ,.�.. P ti ti U p W r' V w � �U ow•�,� � O O � . ' 'C .�J F. a, �c�a � G c�d bq �,�� Hw' �•� b c3 � '� ,o .� °,'o d •� a � " U a N c"u rn v� y �n �,� � ,. � c�d c�2 � � •d y v `3 bq H � �d '.� p Q � � a� '� � U N p � O U � N ,., N �� v a on i B o a� �:�� � � °� � Uv �a �U�a.� �.9 � 0 8 0 0 S �° � � 00 00 $ o 00 0 0 o g o$ oS o8 So S S 8 ° o ° o ° � ° ° o ° c ° o ° o ° o n �� �� H� V3� � 6�9 YI �' � O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Q g o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 oov�0000 00o v; o0 0 00 oS VI O O O� Vi O O O O O O l� O O O Vl O V? l� N O O d' N O N Vi O O O N1 �D O O N h �O O f9N N �'^�� N Ndi (5N �^ �� W�R Hi' A fA Nf W U) !A A � V N M 1� N N V^ d' d' h t� N N C h�� b t1 N� N � � F v 6 e � o m ❑ W U 5,� �� � �° ° o, � � � � � d N V � � M O J N �-• O 'O O ' �R O U.`G"' d (' ��,�` � O � S l:` O�� O U O N 3?.+' y 'O N ❑ '�' V O� � U N� V� U C4 C C> O , F V �� e �.��.���G� S V � � o � QUUa oinv E °� � °.o �i ����v.�'�v��.Fb'G�'� WU �v�z Na °.o CL 'SCI u `�',� 6 m oh �« `� m�U:� m '0, � o � °�' x � � � G c .�d •. �' � ° n �n , �' G + �a�i ' VE�j. m V° 6� .C. �+' � ° � m c � � � 'O .0 .° X C �] � F. �' p. � p � �a w C'. m Q v�G � u. i`d °u ❑ v v v o a °� �' p W 3�1 L1wL1 wwC7'.'Cx'xn�� �Z,'Z v�'? ,. v C � � C a O F � d[-� N ? N Y. � O N C �.., a> � . � cw � °'v N v� w S�^ m °� E' `� � � n'� 3 o .a w � � � r" � � x' r °- � � m o `° fL v� O� V G O b C q t� N p. O�� y o �ou c a+' r o`n C7 A �" � p 9 o W o P1 °" O R7 � a o .°"� �'�' a v`� N� � a x� s� v u`�' ou �o K� a '�' a m� w m c v� c`� o o� w' 8 m 5� �, y c nY v� Q o w'� a�i E rn ' m'� o ° o� �" v.c ��� a�� v� �i � Q U s` ^�� o'z e vi E a a� o fi �v �'°a cc3 va$i °��.,V o Uw � N a� q P. Q v �� r m 5 v� m� � O� o'` 9 ° O�n r W U� �o awq ri�m,xC7x�n`�UUSw ��.�Z O �D O� N M O� O Vl �O 1� W O� O m M W O� M O O O O O O N N N CI N N N M M m V O r 1� 1� C� h l� I� f� 1� h 1� l� h 1� h 1� 1� l� 1� 1� t� l� l� O� O+ P O. O� O� O� O� T G� O� O� O� O� P O. P O+ O� O� P T O� a� u � � � � W E� � d � W 0 � O � � � A W � a � C7 E h d h �ro��.��y o� 3 `��" ' � >, �3 iy O . .� T � `❑� � c�v > � p '7 id o'��o� a�i o . �, � � .�4 � � ¢' U � ..�i .. � � � y,+ �' �. � � � Q N N x' �-�' � '� � � � U ❑ ^ V � o � O iC � �-�. � 'ti � � O V � � �+ '� � � � '� O F '�d �+ A. ,�-,� � a� �' � � ° a vq� �� � � � o o �" � � o $ y '� � o a a�i 'p V .� � � .O a � V bD � � N Q Q �17 � � ,a�, .� � � � Q � O � � � U O �A V � `'��oo°`�' �r�i� ��ao�`' a . �caop�.�'3 o '� � � .en'° p p�, ��bA:��� � cdU �U �, v ' V � � _r .k N � Vi� �7 'O N . �G,'�' � N � � .�". � W , f 0 0-� �,^ U �p� ��°' ����� �' O O V '.� ,^ O � �b �� o�� Hz �'� ° �ar C�J � � L� "C! � W � � � � d R� ^� U 'o s. a O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O v t O O O O O O N O N M� N Q� O N O O O O O N ViFANidiVidifA�W �O N N^+ " r'+ �O V r' N^� � d d V � " �' ❑ o v x U Y ,� � �� � U�.°�`� > Vl ,�'j' � � Q�' 7 Q y .F1 �� w�i a,p 'O u E C p�b N C.L C? °o y ?+�j�� ° °Ll 5 ° mU � �� y .c c a.5 �� o[0 � G a o 09 � � � L�OV�i=p, � '�'L m �axd o c `� >.V a � �> n C ps v� o � c n, fi v'� S°OS °' cn' � `� W c' O � x o?�,d�C c> , o c C7C7.�.lw'Z.�.Zv � O F a N V C ti O v� 1` Y1 � � v L � � � � � � N G U Y N V N y m � v ccj a°� >°� z a a W � a m a� � � 41� V L � �' W L �'_] ti 7 N t '" �� ; x � a o� b3 g .� p °' � �` w V n�i w o tl� R��@� �a > �` V W a, � o i. �. �v � + � E��u u¢rn Ro D N."y E Q ��� O F aC7�Uww�.a �nv rnrn N M V vl �O 1� G� O�^�n O O O O O O O O O o O O O O o O O O o O t4�r' l��t<t�td ��t�� rn rn rn rn rn rn rn m rn rn rn rn 000 000 � �� o00 � Q O O O O O� O �+�OOo V vi �n O� � .�-� O O O O � O O O O O O O O V) �A �A h M N O� m r-i ; � N Q � A�pQAQ QQ�Q aa.aaaa awaa Y � � � ; � '° p, � o v, Q o b " � � m $ a .. x:� b > � �] � � �A ° � b °',�� b � �i � � � � � O � j? � '�C Zi o � U� 5o E'" '� O O ..O O 4+'7 ci. �., o�� j c�i ca ��. ,v� v' �wA �' �ra"a� �d � ao�a�cn ��V �,o . � � � o �� � � � W � ¢' � " A °� �.� � � �UH `�.�°W �Ac��wa� v,aaa � °^ g � 0 0° o M O M � Fq N d a` d � L Y '> U �D O O V O O O O O O v o o a o 0 0 0 o a r oo �o o�noo a m ri O"(`I O r N�VI�OO V N N N V N t� Vl N N m�MF9 M�d3 Y1HitAfH69 N c C c C c q C� C C . . . . .� � .� .� � G E v u v y p �C 1+ ') G' � /+ W � � � � _ � m Cd U = � v ��Ua � F.x `�y U S4 -� W d5 � .] � o`� m G r\ a � �� N � a a& N� U � F� N` �n � � � � � � o � � ° ooa� y ' ' �' � o`� � c v? o0 U U CO {�C7`.C� �O wx � O F o E �;a y N v�° W � � �� ��� � �. A' � LL N O '�" � E `_yP.���� 2« � n' '° y v� p u u a� °� N � 6 � O O µ � q a� �� h 7 �r� ° °.3a^ m ��� v0 ac�N �, V s � � ��naU m `�yv�i3 °c�r � C a 3^'� E y ro,�, � �= � o.`a� V v �' y �ovi,C rnU W U(70a=; OOx o—M �n� noo rno m�o O O O O O O O O V h N h h n� h n h h n p�. P p. a� P U� N P U 0 � � rb � � C� C � � � a N � ,a�,' � � .� o N p+•d N � � � N � a �� � N � `� � rn b �N � � � b N A � w O y '� � t' � �o ;; 3 O H � A U �pq'Ct � O z `� b�A G�.' � � � N N � 27 � C.� O Tl b O O i `� .. � o g � p . c+�' O �n O O � � � •� � '� � � �,.� ���� ���� � �, n b � � O� O �y rn •� � .� a � c .� ao O � p O Q o � d' b9 � ° o 0 ° o O 'V'� �s � y � �a:a F �C. �' > � � � N cG � 3 a � � N O � � � .k G�r c/1 �x *C a � � � a O m O .0 � � a b � � O rri .� � o ^� b � � � � �` O a�. � �� � O y N 0 0 � � a o � � a �° O O � � 0 C � o '^ � N � � h � o 'd � CJ on .'�. � m P� � � pq � p �' ,fl � � w � � � � � a,'� U o o �a o 00 �; b .� � O d � , ^ N E >' 7 w � rn .�y �. ��.",�0� 'O vi W V� � ob � 3 `� H � +�' (yi Vl N � a H � o �. � V� a O .� � p � a � � � � � � .^ U �'�� '� .n Z � '� O � � b M � � N y � � � a' a .�'+ 0 G N . w � � O ����� q v� o p �°"�` ° � � � � p �.�. .J � Y o, y c � � .� (tl O U � � b w � 0 a F�. �-+ U � � � � � � .� a � d' � � � � � r O C O � :-_' ,� m � � � ti .,�., .-1 O � ,� 4�q a � o ,= a �a°�� � a�� � a o� 'O H °�' .� � � � O 'C7 � � � � O �� G o a, o, o N � � .5 C � � ,.`�', ctl v� d . U O � � � � �.., a ou a.`"+ cd 0 'O O � a��i � � r a y a � � F @ � o � � � CA '� �p � � N '� � � .� '.� ctl � N .+ 4. w W. yw b i; � �C � b N y d " � ° � � F a a. O � � O U o � � a� v � A � � � � a ��. � �e� `° o � M p p � �e-- : > F s � 3 ,� � N � W � � � O ��°`� � � � y � � � � � � N N � a� .> ,a `�' ro � t � � 3 .� � '� � b � � c� � } � .� �� W _�! y U � +'�- V '� V] V t" C � � �i �G F +-' •' Q b�°� � �o.�o ." '�- � � ���� a' U -- � � � U y Vl O �� �� . y � � ° b � � � U Y � bu N � f"� ^ O �Nk3°� w � J � y y � 0 y � U .�' � b-0 � aa o � d � w a � a � � , °��' ^� `�-� O � ..� Y a � � �� p �1 � �a� � p, '�a ~° Y O .� v 'Iy > N N N t�d A f""' O � U U W w �+ • .. p '� ��" h a�r U O �' � b � � � ~ � � o N � � V h• C � .�..' 0. � m O O � � � � U �y o A N � (� �C M � T y � N A � F7 '� � �r, � � U r�'ii b w ro � � � g ai «. � b �'N � '� � O �i U a � a �a � � o � � � a 'So � G, � t+ �i.�,o °' a � �� � � � U J� , w � ��� b���� v > � •� ao � � V � a�+ F'i ����` t�'... � w O s. .� a�+ �� a�i �' a a� a�i � � � � � � ���"� � G °�':c� � �p rn `° O O'q P. t�V �� N itl t�V U Tr' y � v � y p .c � v� � -� a .° ,� a a� '� a N �, �O N h N � N � � � � ....... � b b � a d � C �'y d s � � w � Y � � .� �W w � ;: a > �A y � y °a p�y N p,d M y � � 'O j � '� h `° �, o �� � .°'. � � � �rn,� ��° �� °»"��Na� a,o b •o o � b� � � � v1 ,� N � N � � ..�'. � O y � "_' ;d N U � w ' d �� H"" U c O� ca O a � b � �"��p �� �,��a °�,� O O'�.,, O� F+ ?: � B � � � � N G'�j � OA � � G � � � � '� rn �w U „ w I.�i x � � �; � v�i `� a�i 'C �� a: k" N� Y abi � � V w N � •� G � F. � > a�+ � � N � O y.. `� � ¢, � N '� c� � ''"'' � a � �° a `" i �a � � � � > m � rn .`�'. +' 7- P' O c3 �'G � � 4. v � ' 3 .[: � [ p + .tj" �..� yr: C N � � �-, �d � � �� w�.o �� o �w � �� � y -n.1 O ` y � .� � �' b 6 � °� o �, ° � o `�' C V U °�,' � v c O�O b O y N>' N Q� N N U V �y a�, � s`�.'�U v�,.�w�o � � � �i^;y 5 �,, g � a� � N "' 'G .� p �'� � � C � ,,�', o � > U � �, .� � o ° `ba U � � .r ��o° (.�' U 0 � 1 N J�.+'.L' O� Y �'y N O � O ' � rn `� \/ � � Y � .� .� N N � .0 � � O y `� .a b � � �� � � .� � � U � p � F O .��� � � o � � � � � � � o � � � '� � � �nH o�a rn � b � y. � � O � W � aoa`� o � � F+� U FL 17 o ro .�.� x H °�d¢�' o .� �� • • • • � � d � a bA � � �.d O U a�+ F: N Vl q ZJ W Q ,� �y O N p y O��^ O b � a. O ,� � V � � C .fl � A 'h T F. N H b � � � � � ?: � � .+' a � a�i 3 '�� °' � a w � .� G a, � o 0 U � q `� � `�' � a�i � � � p y 3,� � 'O Y .L) o � �y � U C .� � �.+ A ':� �v .� � a 'i7 - .� 'O T� N � b c �a�j t�.� � N J� o � p � � � N F � U � O � Y ~.� �,r.�. � k a G. � b i/] .� � «� `� � � � •p ' °' ° °,� ° b �3��a'��a� � � � � b F � � �' , � N � "�.� ��'.. a�.i b b � � ro N � � � en �' � � 3 a O.� y t'�7 r� � `° � ,g � v 'd o �� ��� �� � � 3 � c� � `�+ � O � >� N�.� y �'O O p(n .������ � U ,, � " � � ~ � � b � � � � " � U � � o '� � � � .� !� c�n � y c� � U a �.� o W A.n o sa � a�a � ^.� O ti � � V � �p � � _^• p ,d y a � a.�.� N �, � ou Y tj o � o °' 'd 'O p N N � o ?3 m � q 4, �. N O � V � b a �3 rn ° o �, � N p V .� N .�C � � $ w,,� a � F " h � �i � N V� a� p '�w ��� b .� ; � ,� a ��o� � � � � � � o � � o ,�'ti � � � � •° q V � O N � � M � F'� � � U vi °'v'.° o ., �» o .,� .� � O � 'c� °`'�°� ' � �¢ �' N tn .� � U .� ry � V � U c� p � .^ O y ,� � �' �, � c,, �2 �n p y�j q � 1�3 � � � � p a � � ry ''� � � � o v '� y p '.� °: ,.��i aoa `" a � � � � � � N � � o � h .� b .� O � � U d ��x�'� o � c2 .a� h O N .�', > ^° c`"i � m .� mb b � .� �a�� a1 y '''� � O ��o�.� .� > � '3 ° a. b � � � � 'd ;O v�i � ��,�� ro ow.�� � � o 0 o g g o .j M � -i O� � A � � W v�i .--i a� 5iy �. N d' r`� a� rn C � ,�,� a� N o � '� v� '- � ° '� ttl a p � O � � � �..I �� � ~ h b � N 'd .n �o > � � �.od.�� .--i O � q��ia� More Information? For addirional copies of this report or informarion about the 1998 funding cycle, please call 266-STAR(7827). Credits City of Saint Paul Mayor Norm Coleman 1997 Neighborhood STAR Board Mazjorie Ebensteiner City Council President David Thune* John Fahey Councilmember Jerry Blakey Stephen Gordon Councilmember Dan Bostrom Lany Laughlin Councilmember Joseph Collins* John Loban Councilmember Mike Harris John Mazgot Councilmember Roberta Megard* Russell Miller Councilmember Gladys Morton* *Terms eacpired at the end of 1997. 1997 Cultural STAR Board Ruth Appelhof Brent Assink Richard Cook Sarah Lutman Frank Marzitelli Ronald W. Pauline Sam Verdeja Lois West, Chair Kathleen Wilson Dept. of Planning & Economic Development Pamela Wheelock, Director Amy Filice, Joan Trulsen, Donna Drummond - STAR Program Coordinators Jim Beaver and Fran Burns- intems Published January, 1998 12 Thomas Olesak Charles Senkler Kathleen Sundberg Kou Vang Michelle Vojacek Steve Wellington, Chair Ron Whitcomb