The URL can be used to link to this page

93-39 V��'�� Council File � �� ° - � G7 Green Sheet ,� �J L� ' RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT`PAUL, MINNESOTA , Presented By Referred To Committee: Date 1 2 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Liquor Village, Inc., (License ID# 17314), for 3 the premises located at 2289 Ford Parkway in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine 4 of $200 for the violation of sale of tobacco products to a minor. 5 6 Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental 7 Protection within thirty days of publication of this resolution as adopted. 8 9 This Resolution and the action taken above are based upon the facts contained in 10 the attached notice of complaint, dated November 18, 1992. The facts as outlined in this 11 letter are not contested by the licensee, as evidenced by the attached letter, dated 12 November 24, 1992, signed by Georgia Scheu, President. This action is also based on 13 the circumstances and arguments presented by and on behalf of the licensee during the 14 Public Hearing. Yeas Nays Abaent Requested by Department of: rimm i-' uerin �-- on �- acca ee _C e m n �- —'1' un e � i son �— BY� �p� � � �9�� Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date Adoption Certi,�ie by Council Secretary gy: , �, /�,.-/(p -9L ��/'� A � � ` ' /f' /^ SL.::� . / ,/' BY� / �" Approved by Mayor for Submissfon to Approved by or: Da � R " ?�J:� Council ;" �/ �t, / �� B By: ,,,Gf;�C�i/f, y' 9 y+'�P��'eY�i'� � �) _. __� c w ��3 i ' .,, j� � �0 N4T PUT IN TRACIfER �� "+ � �, . � � on �N �� 7' 1 LIEP 12/23/92 G��'3�� v"��''�,� _ +� , �oe�Nt��JD� ° d crrv c�ouNCi� " :�� Janet Odaleri �. 29$-5056 +� ` �cmrnrrvaa�ev .�j cmcx,��c - � a�a �ro" �euDO�r�`_ , '° (�.Fxu.s Mer.�AU�s ain, .�a�nuary 12, 1993 []w�r�tort�r� �� T�O�i#t OF 81�iNATURE�PM1p�$ (CUP IU.L Lt�CIATWN$E�A.$i�1Tt�) ' AC71bN"�D: _ - � . ' UNCONTESTED ADVEItSE` LICENSE ACTION ::` '' . (Liquor i�illage, Inc.) , � , ��PP�(A)or Aa�ad l�` ', - PEASdiIAt 8ER111Gt��3dM�N�#��T�R T1�E�LOWMIA C1��8:' _P�ADtldWO COAAAaB�tOP1. ._CfVIC BERVIGL CqIr1M�lON 1. Hq 14�is Pe►s�lCbm�r wOrksd.uridec A contrad 10r1bis�eparUMnt4 ,'�. _.._.CIECOMWNTTEE _ YES �NO� ' 2., Ha�'�Sia per�Ordflrm svMrh�n e dly ampbyae? --�� — YE$ idb; , - . _qa7Al�r COURT — 3. Ebesthis fi�'{�a'��h P�'tiY�Y cutra�t dh bmpbyel�?. ' s�i�+ontts wH�+cc�wCa oe;�cnve� Y�& N13 ExpiNn aU Yp sas�W�w"ai��1i1�•�1�'and'�t6l�h'to�nsn�1�R . iwmATi►�G'a�L�.,t�oaruHiTv�wno.wna�.wnsn.w�wrs.vwnk _ Sale of Gigarettes to a minor , , � (Liquor� Village, Inc.) _ . . 2283 Ford�`Parkw,ay , . ��Q; . - � D�i1D�VANfiRQE81F 11PPROVED:. . ; , ,< . , j , . . . R�C�fVEp. �.. , . ,. � DEC 2 . 8 1992 _ CITY CLEF�� _ �: ��: , . , . Tcn�.�c��,ws�cnoN : cos�rr�v��d�o�� . :;� � No ,_ ~ ��. , ac�nmr� , FiNni+�u►�x��rro►�:�zauwy . , -� NOTE: �1�3N�PCC�'E ENRE�7'K�la�1��N THE(�t�E��7'1NSTRlJCTIONAL � M/t�tUAL AVl11i.11�€1�1 T#��i�S�BFFtG�(PHONE i�.298-4�,25), , . y. f; � RtH1TIN(3 ORDER: Bebw are oorrect ro�tlnps tor dis Nvs m�t freqtfept tyy�oi�ar�►ts=� '`. CONT�iACTS(asaurtes autharized 6i`udpst.sxists) GOUNCIi.RE3CaLU`flOkl(Anfend BudpNe/Axept.(irar�� i. Outside Agency ' 1. Deparlment Diredor ( . , 2. Depaetmant Diroctor 2. Buclpet D�ectoc 3. Ci.ty Attorne� 3. 'City At�omey. 4. Ma�cx(tor contracts ovsr s�5.00Q) 4. MayodAssi�tant ' S. Hu�nen-Righta(tor caonkects eyer SSO.Q00) 5. City CouncN - _ 8.. Finance and'Msnagernsnt 5en►kes DMector 6. 6hief Accou�tant,Finanoe and Manapernei�t Servicas 7`• Ffisancs�/lixour�ing _ , ' ltOMINiSTRATlVE ORt?ERS(B�bgN>Re'�iM�o�t) COUNGN_ii�$011,il'ION(1�1 od�a�e�d Ek�dk�nc��) 1. Acfivity Manage� - �. R�pa�tn�st�t f�ect� 2. Dspartment Accountant 2.. `C.�/I�Om�Y 3. Depertmenf Qi�ector - 3., ��i._ . 4. 8udgetDlr�tor +t..;�,'� 5. Gy.Gerk 6. Chief Accountant,Finance and AABnape+�eM Services . - ;�kt�A1NlSTRA�lVE ORDER&(eN othets) , . � 1. Department Director 2. City Af�c�ey 3. Finance`and Managsment ServiCes Dirocttx 4. 'City Clerk TOTl1l Nt�MBER OF SICiNATURE PAGES , ` kldicate the�of pagea on wtiich af�taluros are,r��sA;�rid p�CNp ar flao -' Meh of thase`pages. _ . ,. IkCI`I('�1 REQUESTED E D�e what Ms pr�ecfAroque�t peaks to a�p�ehip li�r:�- :oW�o�ieror tuder of importance.�r is moM�e�@�ialb t+ar�Fi�'` . ies�e.0o not wdte compbte seMenoes.8�yin each qem��rour��h a verb. . - fi�Cd�dENDATIONS ` 'Gorn�ete if the isaus in quss�has bs�n phatnted'bafore a�iY bod�►.Rublic - or prirate. . SUPPURTS WHt�H.CQIN�IL OB.tECTtYE? ' Indic�le iirbid�Coundl.Q6�pd[ve�s)Yaur,proJecUCe4►�at a�o�ts bY��9 ' the1�y woM(s�(IiQUSIf�;AECflEA71CN�1,N1�K'aHeORHfJ€�DS,EfANOMIC DEVEIOPME�II`'. 8U4(3'�T�SEWEH$EWt�iATION�.{SEE CUMPLETB�LIST M11N5TRktCTK31�iAL MANUAtJ 'PERSONAI SERVtCE CONTE�AC7'S: ' _. ; . This infomtation wr�l:tle used to deteanihs iM dg►�S NabWib►for vv�ks�s oqrrpsnsetio�`Ck�ns,tax�s e�propsr t�sNrrie��hltN�p ndss. tNiTiATING PROBLEM. ISStJE.QRPORTUNITY Ea�plain the Situation or CCntlitbns thet croaNd a nsed tar yo�u project , . . or�equest. , ADYANTAGES IF APPROV�D ' I�Micate whiether thi�is sGr�ly ar�ar�+Q1 b�tl9st requi�ed by taw/ . - . �F+elder or wF�ether there are spscili�wsys in which��t��+� .it�►S�f SaMt Raui and its dtix�s wia beneflt trom Ehis prc�aUe�i�. ' pl&AOVANTAGES IFAPPROVED Whai_neyetive eifects or me�chan�s:to,�0 a'�st Processes+M9h� this projsCt/raque6t.prodt+�e if iC'is peseed{�.p:.t[aMiC delays,.rwiee. tax incraepes or asseS�Ms)?To Wha�m?VVI�t�Fbr'how bng? DISADVANtIt�'aES IF N10T APPROVED , What wiN be tMe rnegative conse4uences�ths promiaed,ac�ton fs not approv8d?Irtability to deNver servfos�Co�dr�dfiigh tratiic,raise. �ident Fab?F.oss oi revenue? FINA�IAC{MPACfi `, . . Aithough you must taibr the in(ormatbn'Y�P►'�`�de he►s to ihe issue you a[e.addressing,�n general yoci mi�st.�ti�r two�t�uessUorfst How ntt�ch b ft �i^9'to coat?Who ia going to pey? - r, ' '- :_ ' , � � q3 �� ✓ . UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: Liquor Village, Inc. Address: 2289 Ford Parkway Date Of Council Hearing: January 12, 1993 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a minor § 324.07. Date: November 7, 1992 Place: Licensed Premises Matrix Presumptive Penalty: N/A Recommendation by Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License Inspections and Environmental Protection: To impose a $200 fine for the sale of cigarettes to a minor. Attachments 1. Proposed resolution 2. License information 3. Notice of Violation 4. Letter of licensee or attorney agreeing not to contest the facts - a3 - �9 �/ Date: Nov 18 Business License Master Inquiry LICENSE I.D. 17314 LICENSE NAME LIQUOR VILLAGE INC FIRST NAME MIDDLE INITIAL BLD STREET NUMBER 2289 STREET DIRECTION STREET NAME FORD STREET TYPE PK CITY ST. PAUL STATE MN ZIP 55116 UNIT BILLING NAME BLD STREET NUMBER STREET DIRECTION STREET NAME STREET TYPE CITY STATE ZIP UNIT D.B.A. LIQUOR VILLAGE COMBINE CODE LIC.EXP.DATE 03/31/93 TAX ID 6685492 SSN 468-48-6724 CEN.TK 362 PHONE NUMBER 612-6997070 TERR O1 DENVER DEALER NUMBER BADGE.NO FIRE Mailing License to the Billing Address (Y/N) EFFECTIVE DATE Alt-Z FOR HELP° VT102 ° FDX ° 9600 E71 ° LOG CLOSED ° PRINT OFF ° Date: Nov 18 Business License Master Inquiry LICENSE I .D. 17314 LICENSE NAME LIQUOR VILLAGE INC FIRST NAME MIDDLE INITIAL BLD STREET NUMBER 2289 STREET DIRECTION STREET NAME FORD STREET TYPE PK CITY ST. PAUL STATE MN ZIP 55116 UNIT BILLING NAME BLD STREET NUMBER STREET DIRECTION STREET NAME STREET TYPE CITY STATE ZIP UNIT D.B.A. LIQUOR VILLAGE COMBINE CODE LIC.EXP.DATE 03/31/93 TAX ID 6685492 SSN 468-48-6724 CEN.TK 362 PHONE NUMBER 612-6997070 TERR O1 DENVER DEALER NUMBER BADGE.NO FIRE Mailing License to the Billing Address (Y/N) EFFECTIVE DATE Alt-Z FOR HELP° VT102 ° FDX ° 9600 E71 ° LOG CLOSED ° PRINT OFF ° OFFIC�JF THE CITY ATTORNEY `-1� ��"I , Natalie E.Hiedson, Ciry Aaomey j �/ CITY OF SAINT PAUL soo�ndma.k Tow� Telephone James Scheibel,Mayor 345 St.Pe�er Saeet Civil:298-5121 Soirrt Paul,Minnesota 55102 Criminal:298—f271 Facsimile:612-298-5619 w� November 18, 1992 NOTICE OF COMPLAINT Manager Liquor Village Inc. 2289 Ford Parkway Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 Re: All licenses held by Liquor Village Inc. for the premises located at 2289 Ford Parkway, Saint Paul. Dear Manager: The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will recommend that adverse action be taken against all the licenses you hold at the above-named premises. This recommendation is based on the following: On November 7, 1992, a clerk or other employee sold cigarettes to a minor under the age of 18 years in the licensed premises. This is an offense under Minn. Stat. §609 . 685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the City Council. You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the Council as to the proper penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before an Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross- examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decide the case. If this is your choice, please let me know within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps to set up that ALJ hearing. Call me at 298-5121. Very truly yours, � . Philip B. Byrne Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler Director, LIEP Terry Hislop License Division . . q�3-� , LIQUOR VILLAGE, INC. � � 2Z89 FORD PARKWAY 699-7070 ` e - 5T.PAUI,MINNE50TA 55116 November 24 , 1992 - :�,`c�� , 199z , v Mr . Philip B. Byrne. , ' Assistant City Attorney � OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY 800 Landmark Towers ' 345 St . Peter Street Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 Re : All licenses held by Liquor Village Inc. for the premises located at 2289 Ford Parkway , Saint Paul . Dear Mr . Byrne : Your letter of November 18 was received in this office Navember 19. I am responding to you within the five working days of your letter . The policy of Liquor Village , Inc , is a very definite policy and we very specifically comply to the law regarding sales to minors of any products here on our premises . However , on November 7 , 1992 , a young woman protrayed to be older by her dress and makeup was not carded and we did in fact sell cigarettes to a woman alleged to be' under 18 years of age . We here at Liquor Village would like to stand on our past record since 1975 , and state that this is the first time any charges such as this have been made against us and ask that you be lenient in penalty , if any , in our reqard . Thank you, I remain . � Your� Very Truly , . �' �� Georgia Scheu President GS/sc ' OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY JANE A.MC PEAI� CITYATTORNEY 4� ' 3� ✓ CTTY OF SAINT PAUL 800 Landmark Towen Telephone James Schei6el,Mayor 345 St Peter Street Civil:298-5121 Saint Pau�Minnesota 55102 CYiminal:298-4271 Facsimile:612-298-5619 �� v�� December 16, 1992 �nEC 18 1992 CITY CL�:,�iK NOTICE OF HEARING Georgia Scheu President Liquor Village, Inc. 2289 Ford Parkway Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 RE: Licenses held by Liquor Village, Inc. for the premises located at 2289 Ford Parkway in Saint Paul. Dear Ms. Scheu: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-mentioned establishment has been scheduled for 9 :00 o'clock a.m. , January, 12, 1993 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. 3 Enclosed please find a copy of the proposed resolution, with attachments, for consideration by the City Council. This is an uncontested hearing, in that facts contained in the notice of complaint have been admitted to. You will have the opportunity to present oral and/or written argument as to the appropriate sanction, if any, to be imposed. If you have any questions, please call me at 298-5121. Very Truly Yours, _ _ � PHILIP B. BYRNE Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler LIEP Terry Hislop LIEP Molly O'Rourke City Clerk � � q3- 3Q UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: Liquor Village, Inc. Address: 2289 Ford Parkway Date Of Council Hearing: January 12, 1993 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a minor § 324.07. Date: November 7, 1992 Place: Licensed Premises Matrix Presumptive Penalty: N/A Recommendation by Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License Inspections and Environmental Protection: To impose a $200 fine for the sale of cigarettes to a minor. Attachments 1. Proposed resolution 2. License information 3. Notice of Violation 4. Letter of licensee or attorney agreeing not to contest the facts � �13 -� Date: Nov 18 Business License Master Inquiry LICENSE I.D. 17314 LICENSE NAME LIQUOR VILLAGE INC FIRST NAME MIDDLE INITIAL BLD STREET NUMBER 2289 STREET DIRECTION STREET NAME FORD STREET TYPE PK CITY ST. PAUL STATE MN ZIP 55116 UNIT BILLING NAME BLD STREET NUMBER STREET DIRECTION STREET NAME STREET TYPE CITY STATE ZIP UNIT D.B.A. LIQUOR VILLAGE COMBINE CODE LIC.EXP.DATE 03/31/93 TAX ID 6685492 SSN 468-48-6724 CEN.TK 362 PHONE NUMBER 612-6997070 TERR O1 DENVER DEALER NUMBER . BADGE.NO FIRE Mailing License to the Billing Address (Y/N) EFFECTIVE DATE Alt-Z FOR HELP° VT102 ° FDX ° 9600 E71 ° LOG CLOSED ° PRINT OFF ° Date: Nov 18 Business License Master Inquiry LICENSE I .D. 17314 LICENSE NAME LIQUOR VILLAGE INC FIRST NAME MIDDLE INITIAL BLD STREET NUMBER 2289 STREET DIRECTION STREET NAME FORD STREET TYPE PK CITY ST. PAUL STATE MN ZIP 55116 UNIT BILLING NAME BLD STREET NUMBER STREET DIRECTION STREET NAME STREET TYPE CITY STATE ZIP UNIT D.B.A. LIQUOR VILLAGE COMBINE CODE LIC.EXP.DATE 03/31/93 TAX ID 6685492 SSN 468-48-6724 CEN.TK 362 PHONE NUMBER 612-6997070 TERR O1 DENVER DEALER NUMBER BADGE.NO FIRE Mailing License to the Billing Address (Y/N) EFFECTIVE DATE Alt-Z FOR HELP° VT102 ° FDX ° 9600 E71 ° LOG CLOSED ° PRINT OFF ° OFFIC�JF THE CITY ATTORNEY �� Natalie E.Hudson, Ciry Anornry CITY OF SAINT PAUL soo�ndma.k Tow� Telephane James Scheibe�Mayor 345 St Peter Saeet Civil:298-5121 Saint Pnu�Minnesota 55102 Criminal:298-4271 Facsimi/e:612-298-5619 �....�.. November 18, 1992 NOTICE OF COMPLAINT Manager Liquor Village Inc. 2289 Ford Parkway Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 Re: All licenses held by Liquor Village Inc. for the premises located at 2289 Ford Parkway, Saint Paul. Dear Manager: The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will recommend that adverse action be taken against all the licenses you hold at the above-named premises. This recommendation is based on the following: On November 7, 1992, a clerk or other employee sold cigarettes to a minor under the aqe of 18 years in the licensed premises. This is an offense under Minn. Stat. §609 . 685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the City Council. You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the Council as to the proper penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before an Admini�trative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross- examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decide the case. If this is your choice, please let me know within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps to set up that ALJ hearing. Call me at 298-5121. Very truly yours, � . Philip B. Byrne Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler Director, LIEP Terry Hislop License Division . 4� �Q LIQUOR VILLAGE, INC. � 2289 fORD PARKWAY 699-7070 ` e - ST.PAUL,MINNESOTA 53118 November 24, 1992 - �ti'()'.:� ti:� 1S92 . ; -: ; ,, Mr . Philip B. Byrne. � � ' Assistant City Attorney � OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY 800 Landmark Towers ' 345 St . Peter Street Saint Paul , Minnesota 55102 Re : All licenses held by Liquor Village Inc. for the premises located at 2289 Ford Parkway , Saint Paul . Dear Mr . Byrne : Your letter of November 18 was received in this office Navember 19 . I am responding to you within the five working days of your letter . The policy of Liquor Village , Inc . is a very definite policy and we very specifically comply to the law regarding sales to minors of any products here on our premises . However , on November 7 , 1992 , a young woman protrayed to be older by her dress and makeup was not carded and we did in fact sell cigarettes to a woman alleged to be� under 18 years of age . We here at Liquor Village would like to stand on our past record since 1975 , and state that this is the first time any charges such as this have been made against us and ask that you be lenient in penalty , if any , in our reqard . Thank you, I remain. � Yonr� Very Truly , . �' 9 Georgia Scheu President GS/sc