97-801Council File # ` / � � � V O �
Green Sheet # V �
���������
Presented By
RePerred To
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Committee: Date
�
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Tuan A Pham d/b/a Tuan Auto Repair (license ID No.
32119) located at 1459 University Avenue West in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of
$1,000.00. Said fine shall be paid to the O�ce of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection within tlurty (30) days of the adoption of this resolufion by the Council and signature
by the Mayor.
This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter aze based upon the facts
contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee and such arguments as may have been
presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee.
xequested by Department of:
I �'
I�` ���� � � � f /� _ _
Adopted by Covncil: Date
Adoption Certified by
By:
Approved by Mayor: Date
By: �
�__2S l`� Form Approved by City Attorney
Secretary �
&y: `�/li`c�[ix.�F'. �� E
� / Z l�� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
C
By:
3$227
DERriMENTADFFICEACAUNCIL o June 11 �1997 GREEN SHEE � 1'� 0 �
INRIAL/DATE INRIAVDATE
CONTAGf PERSON & PHONE O DEPARTMENT �IRECTOFi � CITY CAUNCIL
Robert Kessler 266-9112 assicx � arvanoaNev � cmc�aK
MUST BE ON CAUNCILAGEN�A BY (�ATE) NUYBER FOR O BUDGET DIRECTOR � FIN. & MGT. SERVICES DIF.
HOUTING
7une 25, 1997 Public Hearing OflDEN O �,�pyOA (OR ASSI5TANn �
TOTAL # OP SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
AC(ION REQUESTEO:
Conce rnin�v adverse acrion against Tuan A. Pham, d/b/a T�an Auto Repair, 1459 University Avenue. (Uncontested)
RECOMMENDATIONS: npprova (A) or Rejact (R) PERSONAL SEflVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER TXE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS:
_ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION �� Has [his personlfirm ever worked under a coMrect for Mis tlepartment?
_ CIB CAMMITfEE YES NO
— 2. Has this persoNfirm ever been a city employee?
— STaF� — YES NO
_ OISTFIC7 COUR7 _ 3. Does ihis personMirm possess a skill not normally possessed by any current city employee?
SUPPORTS WHICM COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? VES NO
Explain all yes answers on separete sheet and attach to green sheet
INIiIATING PHOBLEM, ISSUE, OPPOiiTUNITY (Who, Whet, Whan. Where, Why):
ADVANTAGES IFAPPROVED:
� �i��`
a��� 1 � i�`�7
-�---_
. -- --_ - --------�-'"-�:�!
DISADVANTAGES IFAPPROVED:
DISADVANTAGES IF NOTAPPfiOVED:
TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSAC710N $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCIE ONE) YES NO
FUNDIfdG SOURCE AC7IVITV NUMBER
FINANCIAL INFORhiATION: (E%PLAIN) ,
q ' 1 -�o�
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING
Licensee Name: Tuan Anh Pham
Address: 1459 University Avenue
Council Hearing Date: June 25, 1997
Violations: Illegal parking and storage of inoperable and/or
unlicensed vehicles and outside storage of auto
parts and miscellaneous items.
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protecfion:
One Thousand Dollar ($1,000.00) Fine
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. letter from licensee agreeing not to contest the facts
3. Notice of Violation
4. license information
5. photocopies of 10 photographs of site
6. complaint history and complaints
OFFICE OF TI� CITY ATTORNEY
Peg Birk, Ciry Anorney �O �
��
CITY OF SAINT PALTL Civil Division
.Norm Coleman, Mayor 400 Ciry Ha!! Telephone: 672 266-8770
IS West Kellogg Blvd Facsimile: 611198-5679
Sainr Paul, M"mnesam SSIO2
June 10, 1997 �9�Y �'��
5 �i:n
Jt.l�! 1 � f.
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING
Tuan Anh Pham
Tuan Auto Repair
1970 Dayton Avenue
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55104
Re: All Licenses held by Tuan Anh Pham d/b/a Tuan Auto Repair for
the premises at 1459 University Avenue
License ID No.: 32119
File Number: G97-0222
Dear Mr. Pham:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning your Auto Repair
Garage License has been scheduled for 4:30 p.m., Wednesday, June
25, 1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City
Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents
which will be presented to the City Council for their
consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
concerning the illegal parking and storage of inoperable and/or
unlicensed vehicles and auto parts have not been disputed. You
will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral
and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed.
The recommendation of the license office will be for a$1,000.00
fine.
If you have any guestions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very tr yours,.
_ � � � cc�...,.
//
Virgini� D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant
Robert Kessler, Director,
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Council Secretary
LIEP
q�_�ol
Ple�se let me kacx _a writi=� no later th�� Monday, ?�ay 5, 1997 :cw
you wish to procee3. If I have not heard from you in writing by
May 5, 1997, I will ass�e that you are not contesting the facts
outlined above, an3 will sc`_edule the matter for the hearing before
the City Council.
Sincerely,
\
`�/�°L',.[-C� �J'.i ..�.-rt�
C.J
Virg_-��a D. ?al,:,e_
assistGrt City A��c_r_ey
cc: 3ebert Resslo=, �==ec�_r c' LI=?
Christine 3cze:�, �e��_: Dir>_ctcr c� LIE�
{ris Schwein_er, �-ce-se :-=_eector
��Z �
, "�s
������� �
l d'v
� � ��e+��ti ,
���
;�?�-
�iL cn �C�c �Gt{"
c�f�st yo L��
�� ��2� a �� y���Sf
C. � f
� v �,.� /f� i,, � ��,. yav �� �-
Jj�LiY� �n f cz� ��cen1" � rn y l�✓siiusS �ds` ��h.
✓ �/
(?��.�n�G� O ��t-. �j�e�se �/1�CSTigdf'� CtvY�
✓
�n� � .��� �
H �/ J
v �' ` / r� C � �
b� �rt.e
��-lc'nG� /
eGf I/� !`°. !� C'-i'l)'/��
� y'P,�,� ��.�<i� y-� �
���
�----
OFF]C F THE CITl' ATTOR\E1'
Prg 6+rk. t m� .Srrornrc
CITY OF S:�I\T PALZ
?�orn: Coleman, ,1fa��or
Cn�il D"n�ision
+00 Ciq� Ha11
IS If'es1 Kellogg Bh•d
Scint Pau7, .dlinnesoto 5�102
q�
Telephone: 61? ?66-5%10
Facsnr.ile: 6!? :9R- 5 6/9
�pr;l 25, 1997
NOTIC3 OF VIOLATION
TuGa ;::h Pham
Tu�n Au�o RenG_r
1970 DGyton Av=r��e
Sa ?aul, ?✓�? =�=�a_
RB: All Lice�=_�s =�ld - �an ^-� n Ph�m d � ;
�y - � , /b/a Tu�n ALto �e�a_r
�cr the pre-._s�s at 1�=: University �venue
License I� _. 323�9
Dear Sir:
The Director c= t'�2 C'_=ice of License, Inspections G�d
Environmental ?re�ection w_11 recommend that adverse action be
taken against your licer.ses.based on the foilowing information:
The parking lot adjoining your business has
been the subject of repeated complaints
regarding the illegal parking and storage of
inoperable and/or unlicensed vehicles and
outside storage of auto parts and
miscellaneous itexs. Because you are located
in a P-1 district, you may not use the parking
lot for storage of vehicles, equipment or
supplies of any kind. Photographs taken in
March and April of 1997 show numerous vehicles
stored under mouncs of snow, piles of debris,
miscellaneous junk parts and continued long-
term storage of vehicles, all in violation of
the zoning code.
If you do not disa���e that t:e above facts, please send me a lett�r
so that the matt=_r can be sc:eduled before the City Council for a
hearing on what p=_-�lty, i= a-•y, to impcse. You will be allowed to
speak on your be}a_'_ at tna� hearing.
If }'011 DEIIEVE t:c_ �l':° idC�3 Si.nteC� abcve are 117 error, y011 d:2
entit t0 d71 �V_�=n�1dY �earing beiore an administrative Zc'vJ
judge. In that ev<_-�, you r.-c•�ld receive a notice of hearing, with
the date, time ard place =' the nearing and the name of the
administrative law �ndge.
a�-�
Please ZEt IDE }CIICW '_�} Wri�j-J -;0 �c�EY thfl:1 N,ond N:d}� 7� 1997 :�w
you wish to proce�d. Zf I �ave not heard from you in writing by
May 5, 1997, I will assume that you are not contesting the facts
outlined above, ar.d will sc�edule the matter for the hearing befcre
the City Council.
Siacerely,
` :,.c.GTL �'�.i//c�--(''�'�
Vira_n�D. ?al�,.er
Assistart City A�_:raeY
cc: 3obert Kessler, �irec�cr c' �I_?
Christine Rcz�;c, �eD�.�� �1�=ctor c' LI�?
Rris Schk�ei�:�:, Licer_s= ___=Dectcr
a� -��
S': �T� C? MI?��'=�G" :'_
COU?�TY CF ,'��IvNS=V
ss.
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JC- C-. l.. _"_=V -_"3 _:YS� Q:�_Y SWOY? C2PCS c? SaL'
t.-nGl. __ A�v�� L�� i/ � S�C� �=YVC.�L t.�.� G :\OTIC.'.+ Vi V I VL_']1_�._\
C i L.1�.. TCl, OW=�_, __3.'..�Q _S_� DJ U_� GC=� � LYU2 �P_G CC'_':c^Ct CC: V
��Er2C_ 1ri ari c'��_;D2 u...._=SSEQ �S �O�!CWS: "
"�_' A^_7 � _^.di1
__3__ a"-,',:�0 �2
__-_ DGytc�: Aver•�e
�_. �aw_ 1�N. >j�.�d
__�._ �:_� _�am
'_��. LT�'_v=rsi:y Avenue
S�. ?a::_, :�T_Q. 55104
(which is the - ias� ��cwn ac�_=ss=s
the same, with pcs=age pre�a_d, in
Paul, Ninnesot�.
Subscribed and swcr� to be�cre me
this 25th day of Ftiril, 1957.
��c� / `/• %�"J--JCL-L�'(
' Notary Publ_c
�� RITA M. BOSSARD ��
NOTARY PUBGG - H,I�;NiSCTA
S RAMSEY COUNiY
: My Comm, Expires Jan 's7. 20C^
�_
cf said person) ar.d deposit_-a
�he united States mails at 5�.
a ' 1 -g°1
r.�c ID ...................
C:�1... ""' ... " ""- "'
3�siness Na�:e............
An3ress ..................
Z17J ............... " " "'
�0.1IlJ 3llS1_^_ESS F.S. .......
�=_cense Na�� .............
�x� Date .................
L^s�.�rance Carrier........
_ =•s. Folicy !��ns�ber. . . . . ..
I�surar_ce =f=ec�ice Da�e.
?�s. Expira�_on �ate.....
1OT� F,.''�BA ................
laX Id ...................
Wor'.�er Comp Exp Date.....
Telephone ................
=21_9
' '�.N � _ ..r_� �
__5° u'�=�-:SI��' �v� t4
�:iOS
=�i y:;=� :=a�_�
_ � 'O �-_ _'-:- < G =�T�G�
_7/Co'/�7
-\5? �_=\�? r30M 02 TO Ol ON a/09/52
--��=
�SOo'97 ?r �_�T E??N r0� GEN REP GAR LIC APP'D W=1^3 S
-=?S. C.F. 87-11a8
__;g-c� __, CO?���T101TS MET.�H.
==-17-:5 - SC�? granted for expar_sion of garaae -
�-o��.�r �s�vice bGy to be added. Thr=e addit=cral
c�na=�`_ors were placed on SCUP. See zoning �_ie 55
-226. Zor_-g to inspect to see if exnansion has ta
:��n plac=. car/lic
::83C5:
�:�L7�i�
=47-0274
-.�' _
`�` - < _ _- _--
=�= �
.
A
� .s .
E�
•��
� �� � �
.� :.�, �_
. � �` ��.
_ � ---'- -
_`� �
- �.. 1 �,�..?Ff:
� }
� �'ti .
'�� C,
a 1' . 4 :
:�` ,
�
a ���,
� _
a l _
�{,� .�:�� • . 3 ' � .\
�� �T s ��r ��.1 ' ` ��: _� .� �
i� i- -!� . � .� ���: . ;�
�����'�-'.`. r � . ' �. ' i I � �
' ! J• '- '• \
�'=1.� �: �: f' i � � � j � 1
{.� \
..� �t�9''�� �:..i:`� ..�y e
���� { <�_f . � C� " .
� ` �. �
C�� ' � i
/ - � � }/
_;>. R/ '\ . �', \_: �' '� '
Y ��\ � �
��: - j - ' j ;� ;,
::i'� � / � �
, :,;` ; :
',. � ; a ', ;�, '
� , " � �, y
. , �. , �.� ,.
, �� .��
;�� �,,. . .� � '\ / ; .
� T�v'E , �� � � �.� e i
� i•�� t y .
t �ti i'� , / ; , •�_ .
' `t : .,, ._ � 1 � \ . � � .r =-. =
� % s �:t '� � �- ' `�-k . i '-.:
'\� �; �`'� \: ' ',. " ' � � y ` �
�`� �. �,, k� ;. � � , � �` � �,^J�`:
= �� i. � � V ' ` r •w���L
-. ♦ L ��* r Y`; 1',
.$• � K4 . ` 4 � 7 �i� �
yi ' ^ s�''.:�� `�. ♦ ..-�'�' :�L�r . '' .
_ f�': _
—..
�
� \=
�,. .,_ , . - � _� �-� - .- -:`_'�-:'� ,�( ,,� "�R,�f
l�. /`t �'`. ;'�_. i``. � �. .'`� �t .i ��\ .Y
. � �\ � �\ l��. .�\. _'�` � � ` . � . `�... `.
�\�.��/`�/���._ . �'� =��;�<.; ``�,.. `.
�/�/�/�i�,4, �
��.�/t/t/`/�i ��;�,�;�'�;,
'� �� � /t � � �� � � /�- ,� ;(��� ,�
•'\ /� /� /� i � � � ,� �� y� � �. �
'` ��/�� � ��� ��;� :t;.:•.
!^�"��7`+- %� � ` l '1i•` �,
�` ,'\/` '° ��f�a�:;�`f ;
�'� ..�/. .,1/t �.1l�+�
� �- � /� ,�l �t iti ; k.h /` ..
,. � � /1 ,♦ ♦ , � ��'� - �. /-
, 1�3`..i�._ A�, h 4"i � i. ,.
.
�� �.�7�1M =.� � :; , � / '�
y �
� \ .\
�
��'...
�
��f� �
�4 -'.�
��.� ��n
d
�
� .' �- �` �" � `-
�-�� \\ \�� -�_ �--.�-=�
... '�: � _ ' -
. .� .'�'�: '„ "�� ✓4,>
"s,.'� \� \\ \ \/��/V� ��
.� � ,��
� f �.' l � �
\ \�i.����� i. i...,
�\:���:
\ \ \'
\"\ '
�
\ �.' \
\...\.
" \
� - ���.��
�'' ..�
�� �}.
�� / .
�� � �
. ' � ` ,
, -'r � i\ :. ` .` \\ \1 ��.
; i
. ` ` `-, �."� �� \ 1' ! \
:� ` � �' �� �.
� � � '1;��
\
..., \ , \ `. ` '�
� ., \\� �. � \`����
\
��t' � `�
�
✓b"V�
\-
l( �� �
c •�
�: �� \
�����
��y��G .. _
f H.'. / . J
� � � �
S
� _
� '�
�•\ �'..i'. . .. �.�.
'��
a"'.
�
,,�� J �
+
`L_
6�� i �
/ �_
��
I
7\�
,
t :.
�1�'�:��
: � . i �w,�':
� j : t F `1�
� J r`ti i , ':..
—_, �
,.,:: ' r . �
��'. .-'�',
��� �'_ f.�i, � � � ' ' :
!� � .a �._ i -- �t' �. —
�'' j "' \: %,/
i . \ ��
' ' / _\
� ;•:_;
�
y}
:.�:. :
� � "�� �� �\� ' ]( t' � '�\
�� � ; L (G/'t'���.. ', \ �� .. \ �1. _ �'�1 t �.
� �":
I " r � \ � \ �� / �'- � �� ` L � \ }�+�
�� a:s.�\ 1`�/� �/ �, � /E; � � +'� ..
�
°:<��- � _ -��',1��. `�/�� � , �% \1 �.:
�✓ �i
\ �r�`{� \r
. � /
F q r
, � � � . \ .,
� '
3
'"'.'^,"'.'�. '
I _._- "
,.''. :` :^:
• , f.
r
`\.
�� " ����
f� _
�,
�'_\ • r
� �r
�� � 1 �� � ..
i
, v� �`� e�� �
. '� .
�/\ � ����'�. L Y�J' ...:
/\ \ � Z \ , \ 'e �. Y.
�
/ /
� A � tz y `���\.�
r_��� � y � .I �/ 3 . �.
�` � `� _��1 \� \ 1
� � `, ��. •, � `�+�
� �
i��. f e . /� :
. . .� ��.J L i..\_a � . �.�. -�.
� �...__.
tl
L "-.
b� '
;s' � �
�� -
,`;`.
`�Sj�, ti
�. `��
i ... .r;: ; :< 1
:' ;..
� �` -' r _7"i
}� -.J;
.. � �
C.i� ' •/
�
,� f a A�:
- . . F�t
-_ � " + t �i� h--
. - ���' , -�, � � � ��� -. . -
►� -" . `. `� \ . -
� ,,�-�,._ ,\ \ \\\ .'� . �. \
� i
.� :` ° ��������.��
f '
..
�_
• �.,_+
: �t'
� c�:, /
:� V'-i._L�.�C `.. .
AF ._ .
� r-_I-�'�
" �.. ,.����
�. .\, \ ,
� �r
� ' �
..,
ti
��
_— ;
_�.� � I
, � ������.
12..,.
`�.
..._. � --•
=#�i.itR?;::: <..� �
'���li-?7:. '. _ '
����i�
�f��: � ? y:�'. .
� �� " ..
. . „ y : ..:. �
i�3:
� �.
Clll' OF SAI\T PACL
Sorm Calemcn. .l:airor
DATE: ?vIarch 12, 1997
T0: Kris Sch���einier
Senior License Inspzctor
FROM: Peg Fuller
Zoning Inspeccor
OFFICE OFl.ICC�:SE. IASP!_Z�llO�ti -1�'U
G�\'IRO\�1CXT:1L PROTt�CT10`: ^ p ,
Rahrrt,i'estler Dvcc�or /� � /\ '
V`
6L7LDI.��GISSPECT/O.�'AA�D Tclephoue:6;=-'66-9090
DESIG>� Fatsimile� 67=-'GG-9099
i �0 St Pertr Slreet
s�,rre ;nn
SanvtPcul. 4linnesoto ji103-]JIO
RE: Tuan Auto Repair
1459 University A��enue (Business Location}
1456 Sherburne A.enue (Parki-�g Lot)
A brief history of the referenced propem• re�arding zoning violations:
08/18/94 Complaint re�ardinQ parking/storing of inoperable, unlicensed vehicles in parkin�
lot.
09/09/94 Inspection. Gave Tuan Pham �erbal orders to bring parking lot into compliance with
the Special Condition Use Permit (SCUP) conditions (see higtilighted conditions of
attached SCUP).
9/27/94 Letter sent to Mr. Pham reiterating 9/9/94 verbal orders (see attached).
10/15/94 Inspection. Parkin� lot impro��ed and Mr. Pham stated the remaining unacceptable
vehicles would be removed from the property soon.
10/24/94 Inspection. A few ��ehicles remaining in violation, generally parking lot is very
much improved.
11/02l94 Inspection. Three uniicensed ��ehicles remaining , referred complaint to Housing so
they could issue orders for unlicensed vehicles (orders were issued on 11/8/44).
12/06/94 Two vehicles still unlicensed. Housing issued abatement orders, so I closed the
complaint.
03/Ol/96 Complaint regarding vehicles, tires, Qeneral mess of parking lot and the neglect of a
-.
i �
r�
,
doQ. Called'�1r. Pham and told him I�z�ould be comina out for an inspection.
03/05/96 D1et with licence inspector and �ir. Pham on site for 35 minutes discussing
�•iolations.
03/21;96 Letter sent as a follo��-up to o��: 3i5196 meetina (letter attached).
04/10;96 ?�4uch improlzmenr in parkinQ lot conditions.
07/12/96 ?�4r. Pham once aRain in �•iolation of SCti�P.
Many times in 1996 I attempted to concact the property ou ner. I never heard from the
property oN�ner, nor �;as I successful in contacting them.
CITY OF S.AIt1TT P_�LZ
i�'nnn Colrmm�, A9cyor
rlarch 21, 1996
?�ir. Tuan Pham
Tuan Auto Repair
1�59 University A� zr.u�
Saint Paul, MN »IO-�
RE: 1456 Sherbume ��enue Parkins I,ot
Dear Mr. Pham:
OFFICE OF LICESSE, i\5°ECTIO�S A\D
E�\'II20\�7E�TAL PFOTECTIO�
R�i+<rr 3,?rsla, D�re<tm ^ � �,
� `�
Z0.1i�'G.9D.311,A7S7'R9T70.\' Td.�
750 StPrtt� Srrttt Fucsimile: 61:-_'66-�Y9
S,r,"n Si0
Sain; Pmd..Ninr�esota 5510:-]
As you are awaze, «z r;cendy recei�; d a complaint regardin� the storino of ��ehicles, auto
parts and additional miscellaneous items. This property is located in a P-1, a vehicle
parkin� district.
As we discussed, this parl:ing facility may not be used for the storino of vehicles
equipment or supplies of any I:ind. The referenced property may be used solely for private
passenger vehicles business vehicIes, and a limited number of vehicles awaiting service
(for short periods of tune) according to Sections 60.72I, 60.723(2} and 60.723(3) of the
City's Legislative Code. Fxterior storage is not permitted in This zonin� district. Exterior
stonge is first permitted in an I-1, an Industriai zoning district.
Additionally, an auto sales business is not permitted without first obtaining a dealership
license. A Special Condition Use Permit was appro�°ed last fall for expansion of an auto
repair facility, not for an auto sales business.
All miscellaneous exterior storage items and stored vehicles must be removed from the
referenced property by April 8, 1446. After that date, I will be reinspecting for
compliance with the Legisiative Code and the Special Condifion Use Permit.
If you have any questions or concems regarding this matter, piease call me at 266-9085.
Sincerely,
Peg Fuller
Zoning Inspector
cc: Kris Schweinler, Senior License Inspector
OFFICE OF LICENSE, L'�SPECI'IONS A7�'D
Eh'�"0.'Oh".SEh7AL PROTF.CI'ION
Robca K�ssler, Dircrwr Q � I � � `
`
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
T'om Coleman, Dfcyor
ZO�7�ti'G ADM/A7S7RATfON
350 St Pcur Street
Suiu 310
Sci�u Pau(, N.iruusam SSIO2-ISIO
7ckphont: 67? ?6b9�8
Facrimik: 612-?659099
September 27, 1994
Mr. Tuan Pham
Tuan Auto Repair
1459 University A��er.ue
Saint Paul, MN 5� 104
RE: Parldng Lot At 1456 Sherbu:ne Avenue
Dear Mr. Pham:
As you are aware, «�e ha��e recendy received a complaint regarding the parking of
inoperable vehicles at the referenced address. This property is located in a P-1, a Vehicle
Parldng District. Per Sections 60.721, 60.723(2) and 60.723(3) of the Cify's I.egislative
Code, the pazking facility may not be used for stor2ge of vehicles and may be used solely
for private passenger vehicles (see enclosed copies).
When I met with you earlier this month, you stated that you were keeping some of the
vehicles because customers had not paid their biIIs. You also stated that 3 or 4 additional
vehicles were used as storage for auTo parts. Stora;e of any kind, including inoperable
and/or unlicensed vehicles is not a permitted use in this Parldng District.
To comply with zoning requiremenu, all stored vehicles must be removed by October 14,
1994. All remaining vehicles must be licensed. If you need additional time to find a
space for your vehicles or have any questions regarding this matter, please call me at 266-
9085.
Sincerely,
Peg Fuller
Zoning InspecTor
enc.
cc: I,awrence M. Sw�2rtz
-_--�-� - __--= -._ � -- �-- -
__=_=,� _ ==-=
�
��.��1
�-..==- -,�_��_`_: �:
�-�___ ��--� 1�,
�__ _�_� = ��:_-
��'�__^ __�?�__��
�--�-- �`-�_—
=----= �_- -?<,__
�.�. _. _.. _� _.,_.. =Y'r__c.
---�- -� _.,��....� �`�--• - _�-- _��_
_. `_�_ _ `____. .,_..'.^,=ILL _
____--X _ _'__Y = _,.:_._�.
�- .. .�C „J .. ` y = _ �;1
�v..-�t-_� ____.\_� ____�.___ _�. _.�._�
.-Gl,�. __..._ 'S/
Sar:e _�=. �_�-- - -�r.?n - -- -
-- -- -- --�,---_- _-�__ _�ce^s2 ID °��:z�
'=-�-s'�r co L I�
��re�t �' er i97C S�'-`�_- =, _ �io1: U:!:L
�=__ct- .'�v?':° Dl-_XTGic :�,-�__ _ .
.' _ � 1 = L , i
�_-1 S J.: ti�G�� ;,'„'V� ��p ���0�? P:!Orc 6?62"iG0
L�C�cS " T^' - n -. .._ ..._ (��
�.iI�J? C _ �J ' ': 1J� ^J L_ lJ\� L /V�IJ2
2:�13?u_
�: ���SL�� P= �.� -._ =-� =l � ��?�: K�_ Ci?K Li� AP;�'D �9_T1
C"1aJ. �.._. ...,-__'& -K .�
5:6-13-34, ~��_. ,:OA�� aTC_�S ?✓=T.J3.
6:?1-17-95 - Sri7p arar,t=_3 �or expansion of garage -
7:another s=_ :ay to b� aqded. Three additi�n�l
-- _ ----- &:conditicn� -s:�Ye place� �n SCuP. See zq 1 11n5_fi le--9� - . -
RnS^_K=CTIOtiS :1�QUSRY SCREEN
r.-C=';SE S�: �21i9
��r:1'tiP?�� AII_O REPAIR
AOTB: i:080687 P_PP'D W/ ti'=r`i:P_`S'?O:dS �.:. H7-1
? _ 1. ?��0 ? ;R�I?'�G C= `1--_CL?S P;==':I'_�:: ?�?'�IK OR RBCENT
3:�Y KB?�IR�D ON =_� _-���T.
5:2_ T✓�IN_AI?Q 8 C='~S=3B.;1 =F=-c`_n� S_F_C?S iN �D�"IO
S:N :0 T�OSB SPAC=� �:=T3IN ��- '=p�czG� LR�F.
J : `
7 :
s:
_ L : _`_'_'_ _'—__—___"__"— __— __ __ __—__
__l.'_�_ "_"�r�. �,/^/ ^ G•� -
�-=� . _.�
-�n �' / !�.�c?J
=7 :_ _
--C=.._ ZL. .�__._,
Da:e: Nar 12
Council File # ` / � � � V O �
Green Sheet # V �
���������
Presented By
RePerred To
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Committee: Date
�
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Tuan A Pham d/b/a Tuan Auto Repair (license ID No.
32119) located at 1459 University Avenue West in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of
$1,000.00. Said fine shall be paid to the O�ce of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection within tlurty (30) days of the adoption of this resolufion by the Council and signature
by the Mayor.
This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter aze based upon the facts
contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee and such arguments as may have been
presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee.
xequested by Department of:
I �'
I�` ���� � � � f /� _ _
Adopted by Covncil: Date
Adoption Certified by
By:
Approved by Mayor: Date
By: �
----aS �_ Form Approved by City Attorney
Secretary �
&y: `�/li`c�[ix.�F'. �� E
� / Z l�� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
C
By:
3$227
DERriMENTADFFICEACAUNCIL o June 11 �1997 GREEN SHEE � 1'� 0 �
INRIAL/DATE INRIAVDATE
CONTAGf PERSON & PHONE O DEPARTMENT �IRECTOFi � CITY CAUNCIL
Robert Kessler 266-9112 assicx � arvanoaNev � cmc�aK
MUST BE ON CAUNCILAGEN�A BY (�ATE) NUYBER FOR O BUDGET DIRECTOR � FIN. & MGT. SERVICES DIF.
HOUTING
7une 25, 1997 Public Hearing OflDEN O �,�pyOA (OR ASSI5TANn �
TOTAL # OP SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
AC(ION REQUESTEO:
Conce rnin�v adverse acrion against Tuan A. Pham, d/b/a T�an Auto Repair, 1459 University Avenue. (Uncontested)
RECOMMENDATIONS: npprova (A) or Rejact (R) PERSONAL SEflVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER TXE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS:
_ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION �� Has [his personlfirm ever worked under a coMrect for Mis tlepartment?
_ CIB CAMMITfEE YES NO
— 2. Has this persoNfirm ever been a city employee?
— STaF� — YES NO
_ OISTFIC7 COUR7 _ 3. Does ihis personMirm possess a skill not normally possessed by any current city employee?
SUPPORTS WHICM COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? VES NO
Explain all yes answers on separete sheet and attach to green sheet
INIiIATING PHOBLEM, ISSUE, OPPOiiTUNITY (Who, Whet, Whan. Where, Why):
ADVANTAGES IFAPPROVED:
� �i��`
a��� 1 � i�`�7
-�---_
. -- --_ - --------�-'"-�:�!
DISADVANTAGES IFAPPROVED:
DISADVANTAGES IF NOTAPPfiOVED:
TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSAC710N $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCIE ONE) YES NO
FUNDIfdG SOURCE AC7IVITV NUMBER
FINANCIAL INFORhiATION: (E%PLAIN) ,
q ' 1 -�o�
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING
Licensee Name: Tuan Anh Pham
Address: 1459 University Avenue
Council Hearing Date: June 25, 1997
Violations: Illegal parking and storage of inoperable and/or
unlicensed vehicles and outside storage of auto
parts and miscellaneous items.
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protecfion:
One Thousand Dollar ($1,000.00) Fine
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. letter from licensee agreeing not to contest the facts
3. Notice of Violation
4. license information
5. photocopies of 10 photographs of site
6. complaint history and complaints
OFFICE OF TI� CITY ATTORNEY
Peg Birk, Ciry Anorney �O �
��
CITY OF SAINT PALTL Civil Division
.Norm Coleman, Mayor 400 Ciry Ha!! Telephone: 672 266-8770
IS West Kellogg Blvd Facsimile: 611198-5679
Sainr Paul, M"mnesam SSIO2
June 10, 1997 �9�Y �'��
5 �i:n
Jt.l�! 1 � f.
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING
Tuan Anh Pham
Tuan Auto Repair
1970 Dayton Avenue
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55104
Re: All Licenses held by Tuan Anh Pham d/b/a Tuan Auto Repair for
the premises at 1459 University Avenue
License ID No.: 32119
File Number: G97-0222
Dear Mr. Pham:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning your Auto Repair
Garage License has been scheduled for 4:30 p.m., Wednesday, June
25, 1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City
Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents
which will be presented to the City Council for their
consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
concerning the illegal parking and storage of inoperable and/or
unlicensed vehicles and auto parts have not been disputed. You
will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral
and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed.
The recommendation of the license office will be for a$1,000.00
fine.
If you have any guestions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very tr yours,.
_ � � � cc�...,.
//
Virgini� D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant
Robert Kessler, Director,
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Council Secretary
LIEP
q�_�ol
Ple�se let me kacx _a writi=� no later th�� Monday, ?�ay 5, 1997 :cw
you wish to procee3. If I have not heard from you in writing by
May 5, 1997, I will ass�e that you are not contesting the facts
outlined above, an3 will sc`_edule the matter for the hearing before
the City Council.
Sincerely,
\
`�/�°L',.[-C� �J'.i ..�.-rt�
C.J
Virg_-��a D. ?al,:,e_
assistGrt City A��c_r_ey
cc: 3ebert Resslo=, �==ec�_r c' LI=?
Christine 3cze:�, �e��_: Dir>_ctcr c� LIE�
{ris Schwein_er, �-ce-se :-=_eector
��Z �
, "�s
������� �
l d'v
� � ��e+��ti ,
���
;�?�-
�iL cn �C�c �Gt{"
c�f�st yo L��
�� ��2� a �� y���Sf
C. � f
� v �,.� /f� i,, � ��,. yav �� �-
Jj�LiY� �n f cz� ��cen1" � rn y l�✓siiusS �ds` ��h.
✓ �/
(?��.�n�G� O ��t-. �j�e�se �/1�CSTigdf'� CtvY�
✓
�n� � .��� �
H �/ J
v �' ` / r� C � �
b� �rt.e
��-lc'nG� /
eGf I/� !`°. !� C'-i'l)'/��
� y'P,�,� ��.�<i� y-� �
���
�----
OFF]C F THE CITl' ATTOR\E1'
Prg 6+rk. t m� .Srrornrc
CITY OF S:�I\T PALZ
?�orn: Coleman, ,1fa��or
Cn�il D"n�ision
+00 Ciq� Ha11
IS If'es1 Kellogg Bh•d
Scint Pau7, .dlinnesoto 5�102
q�
Telephone: 61? ?66-5%10
Facsnr.ile: 6!? :9R- 5 6/9
�pr;l 25, 1997
NOTIC3 OF VIOLATION
TuGa ;::h Pham
Tu�n Au�o RenG_r
1970 DGyton Av=r��e
Sa ?aul, ?✓�? =�=�a_
RB: All Lice�=_�s =�ld - �an ^-� n Ph�m d � ;
�y - � , /b/a Tu�n ALto �e�a_r
�cr the pre-._s�s at 1�=: University �venue
License I� _. 323�9
Dear Sir:
The Director c= t'�2 C'_=ice of License, Inspections G�d
Environmental ?re�ection w_11 recommend that adverse action be
taken against your licer.ses.based on the foilowing information:
The parking lot adjoining your business has
been the subject of repeated complaints
regarding the illegal parking and storage of
inoperable and/or unlicensed vehicles and
outside storage of auto parts and
miscellaneous itexs. Because you are located
in a P-1 district, you may not use the parking
lot for storage of vehicles, equipment or
supplies of any kind. Photographs taken in
March and April of 1997 show numerous vehicles
stored under mouncs of snow, piles of debris,
miscellaneous junk parts and continued long-
term storage of vehicles, all in violation of
the zoning code.
If you do not disa���e that t:e above facts, please send me a lett�r
so that the matt=_r can be sc:eduled before the City Council for a
hearing on what p=_-�lty, i= a-•y, to impcse. You will be allowed to
speak on your be}a_'_ at tna� hearing.
If }'011 DEIIEVE t:c_ �l':° idC�3 Si.nteC� abcve are 117 error, y011 d:2
entit t0 d71 �V_�=n�1dY �earing beiore an administrative Zc'vJ
judge. In that ev<_-�, you r.-c•�ld receive a notice of hearing, with
the date, time ard place =' the nearing and the name of the
administrative law �ndge.
a�-�
Please ZEt IDE }CIICW '_�} Wri�j-J -;0 �c�EY thfl:1 N,ond N:d}� 7� 1997 :�w
you wish to proce�d. Zf I �ave not heard from you in writing by
May 5, 1997, I will assume that you are not contesting the facts
outlined above, ar.d will sc�edule the matter for the hearing befcre
the City Council.
Siacerely,
` :,.c.GTL �'�.i//c�--(''�'�
Vira_n�D. ?al�,.er
Assistart City A�_:raeY
cc: 3obert Kessler, �irec�cr c' �I_?
Christine Rcz�;c, �eD�.�� �1�=ctor c' LI�?
Rris Schk�ei�:�:, Licer_s= ___=Dectcr
a� -��
S': �T� C? MI?��'=�G" :'_
COU?�TY CF ,'��IvNS=V
ss.
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JC- C-. l.. _"_=V -_"3 _:YS� Q:�_Y SWOY? C2PCS c? SaL'
t.-nGl. __ A�v�� L�� i/ � S�C� �=YVC.�L t.�.� G :\OTIC.'.+ Vi V I VL_']1_�._\
C i L.1�.. TCl, OW=�_, __3.'..�Q _S_� DJ U_� GC=� � LYU2 �P_G CC'_':c^Ct CC: V
��Er2C_ 1ri ari c'��_;D2 u...._=SSEQ �S �O�!CWS: "
"�_' A^_7 � _^.di1
__3__ a"-,',:�0 �2
__-_ DGytc�: Aver•�e
�_. �aw_ 1�N. >j�.�d
__�._ �:_� _�am
'_��. LT�'_v=rsi:y Avenue
S�. ?a::_, :�T_Q. 55104
(which is the - ias� ��cwn ac�_=ss=s
the same, with pcs=age pre�a_d, in
Paul, Ninnesot�.
Subscribed and swcr� to be�cre me
this 25th day of Ftiril, 1957.
��c� / `/• %�"J--JCL-L�'(
' Notary Publ_c
�� RITA M. BOSSARD ��
NOTARY PUBGG - H,I�;NiSCTA
S RAMSEY COUNiY
: My Comm, Expires Jan 's7. 20C^
�_
cf said person) ar.d deposit_-a
�he united States mails at 5�.
a ' 1 -g°1
r.�c ID ...................
C:�1... ""' ... " ""- "'
3�siness Na�:e............
An3ress ..................
Z17J ............... " " "'
�0.1IlJ 3llS1_^_ESS F.S. .......
�=_cense Na�� .............
�x� Date .................
L^s�.�rance Carrier........
_ =•s. Folicy !��ns�ber. . . . . ..
I�surar_ce =f=ec�ice Da�e.
?�s. Expira�_on �ate.....
1OT� F,.''�BA ................
laX Id ...................
Wor'.�er Comp Exp Date.....
Telephone ................
=21_9
' '�.N � _ ..r_� �
__5° u'�=�-:SI��' �v� t4
�:iOS
=�i y:;=� :=a�_�
_ � 'O �-_ _'-:- < G =�T�G�
_7/Co'/�7
-\5? �_=\�? r30M 02 TO Ol ON a/09/52
--��=
�SOo'97 ?r �_�T E??N r0� GEN REP GAR LIC APP'D W=1^3 S
-=?S. C.F. 87-11a8
__;g-c� __, CO?���T101TS MET.�H.
==-17-:5 - SC�? granted for expar_sion of garaae -
�-o��.�r �s�vice bGy to be added. Thr=e addit=cral
c�na=�`_ors were placed on SCUP. See zoning �_ie 55
-226. Zor_-g to inspect to see if exnansion has ta
:��n plac=. car/lic
::83C5:
�:�L7�i�
=47-0274
-.�' _
`�` - < _ _- _--
=�= �
.
A
� .s .
E�
•��
� �� � �
.� :.�, �_
. � �` ��.
_ � ---'- -
_`� �
- �.. 1 �,�..?Ff:
� }
� �'ti .
'�� C,
a 1' . 4 :
:�` ,
�
a ���,
� _
a l _
�{,� .�:�� • . 3 ' � .\
�� �T s ��r ��.1 ' ` ��: _� .� �
i� i- -!� . � .� ���: . ;�
�����'�-'.`. r � . ' �. ' i I � �
' ! J• '- '• \
�'=1.� �: �: f' i � � � j � 1
{.� \
..� �t�9''�� �:..i:`� ..�y e
���� { <�_f . � C� " .
� ` �. �
C�� ' � i
/ - � � }/
_;>. R/ '\ . �', \_: �' '� '
Y ��\ � �
��: - j - ' j ;� ;,
::i'� � / � �
, :,;` ; :
',. � ; a ', ;�, '
� , " � �, y
. , �. , �.� ,.
, �� .��
;�� �,,. . .� � '\ / ; .
� T�v'E , �� � � �.� e i
� i•�� t y .
t �ti i'� , / ; , •�_ .
' `t : .,, ._ � 1 � \ . � � .r =-. =
� % s �:t '� � �- ' `�-k . i '-.:
'\� �; �`'� \: ' ',. " ' � � y ` �
�`� �. �,, k� ;. � � , � �` � �,^J�`:
= �� i. � � V ' ` r •w���L
-. ♦ L ��* r Y`; 1',
.$• � K4 . ` 4 � 7 �i� �
yi ' ^ s�''.:�� `�. ♦ ..-�'�' :�L�r . '' .
_ f�': _
—..
�
� \=
�,. .,_ , . - � _� �-� - .- -:`_'�-:'� ,�( ,,� "�R,�f
l�. /`t �'`. ;'�_. i``. � �. .'`� �t .i ��\ .Y
. � �\ � �\ l��. .�\. _'�` � � ` . � . `�... `.
�\�.��/`�/���._ . �'� =��;�<.; ``�,.. `.
�/�/�/�i�,4, �
��.�/t/t/`/�i ��;�,�;�'�;,
'� �� � /t � � �� � � /�- ,� ;(��� ,�
•'\ /� /� /� i � � � ,� �� y� � �. �
'` ��/�� � ��� ��;� :t;.:•.
!^�"��7`+- %� � ` l '1i•` �,
�` ,'\/` '° ��f�a�:;�`f ;
�'� ..�/. .,1/t �.1l�+�
� �- � /� ,�l �t iti ; k.h /` ..
,. � � /1 ,♦ ♦ , � ��'� - �. /-
, 1�3`..i�._ A�, h 4"i � i. ,.
.
�� �.�7�1M =.� � :; , � / '�
y �
� \ .\
�
��'...
�
��f� �
�4 -'.�
��.� ��n
d
�
� .' �- �` �" � `-
�-�� \\ \�� -�_ �--.�-=�
... '�: � _ ' -
. .� .'�'�: '„ "�� ✓4,>
"s,.'� \� \\ \ \/��/V� ��
.� � ,��
� f �.' l � �
\ \�i.����� i. i...,
�\:���:
\ \ \'
\"\ '
�
\ �.' \
\...\.
" \
� - ���.��
�'' ..�
�� �}.
�� / .
�� � �
. ' � ` ,
, -'r � i\ :. ` .` \\ \1 ��.
; i
. ` ` `-, �."� �� \ 1' ! \
:� ` � �' �� �.
� � � '1;��
\
..., \ , \ `. ` '�
� ., \\� �. � \`����
\
��t' � `�
�
✓b"V�
\-
l( �� �
c •�
�: �� \
�����
��y��G .. _
f H.'. / . J
� � � �
S
� _
� '�
�•\ �'..i'. . .. �.�.
'��
a"'.
�
,,�� J �
+
`L_
6�� i �
/ �_
��
I
7\�
,
t :.
�1�'�:��
: � . i �w,�':
� j : t F `1�
� J r`ti i , ':..
—_, �
,.,:: ' r . �
��'. .-'�',
��� �'_ f.�i, � � � ' ' :
!� � .a �._ i -- �t' �. —
�'' j "' \: %,/
i . \ ��
' ' / _\
� ;•:_;
�
y}
:.�:. :
� � "�� �� �\� ' ]( t' � '�\
�� � ; L (G/'t'���.. ', \ �� .. \ �1. _ �'�1 t �.
� �":
I " r � \ � \ �� / �'- � �� ` L � \ }�+�
�� a:s.�\ 1`�/� �/ �, � /E; � � +'� ..
�
°:<��- � _ -��',1��. `�/�� � , �% \1 �.:
�✓ �i
\ �r�`{� \r
. � /
F q r
, � � � . \ .,
� '
3
'"'.'^,"'.'�. '
I _._- "
,.''. :` :^:
• , f.
r
`\.
�� " ����
f� _
�,
�'_\ • r
� �r
�� � 1 �� � ..
i
, v� �`� e�� �
. '� .
�/\ � ����'�. L Y�J' ...:
/\ \ � Z \ , \ 'e �. Y.
�
/ /
� A � tz y `���\.�
r_��� � y � .I �/ 3 . �.
�` � `� _��1 \� \ 1
� � `, ��. •, � `�+�
� �
i��. f e . /� :
. . .� ��.J L i..\_a � . �.�. -�.
� �...__.
tl
L "-.
b� '
;s' � �
�� -
,`;`.
`�Sj�, ti
�. `��
i ... .r;: ; :< 1
:' ;..
� �` -' r _7"i
}� -.J;
.. � �
C.i� ' •/
�
,� f a A�:
- . . F�t
-_ � " + t �i� h--
. - ���' , -�, � � � ��� -. . -
►� -" . `. `� \ . -
� ,,�-�,._ ,\ \ \\\ .'� . �. \
� i
.� :` ° ��������.��
f '
..
�_
• �.,_+
: �t'
� c�:, /
:� V'-i._L�.�C `.. .
AF ._ .
� r-_I-�'�
" �.. ,.����
�. .\, \ ,
� �r
� ' �
..,
ti
��
_— ;
_�.� � I
, � ������.
12..,.
`�.
..._. � --•
=#�i.itR?;::: <..� �
'���li-?7:. '. _ '
����i�
�f��: � ? y:�'. .
� �� " ..
. . „ y : ..:. �
i�3:
� �.
Clll' OF SAI\T PACL
Sorm Calemcn. .l:airor
DATE: ?vIarch 12, 1997
T0: Kris Sch���einier
Senior License Inspzctor
FROM: Peg Fuller
Zoning Inspeccor
OFFICE OFl.ICC�:SE. IASP!_Z�llO�ti -1�'U
G�\'IRO\�1CXT:1L PROTt�CT10`: ^ p ,
Rahrrt,i'estler Dvcc�or /� � /\ '
V`
6L7LDI.��GISSPECT/O.�'AA�D Tclephoue:6;=-'66-9090
DESIG>� Fatsimile� 67=-'GG-9099
i �0 St Pertr Slreet
s�,rre ;nn
SanvtPcul. 4linnesoto ji103-]JIO
RE: Tuan Auto Repair
1459 University A��enue (Business Location}
1456 Sherburne A.enue (Parki-�g Lot)
A brief history of the referenced propem• re�arding zoning violations:
08/18/94 Complaint re�ardinQ parking/storing of inoperable, unlicensed vehicles in parkin�
lot.
09/09/94 Inspection. Gave Tuan Pham �erbal orders to bring parking lot into compliance with
the Special Condition Use Permit (SCUP) conditions (see higtilighted conditions of
attached SCUP).
9/27/94 Letter sent to Mr. Pham reiterating 9/9/94 verbal orders (see attached).
10/15/94 Inspection. Parkin� lot impro��ed and Mr. Pham stated the remaining unacceptable
vehicles would be removed from the property soon.
10/24/94 Inspection. A few ��ehicles remaining in violation, generally parking lot is very
much improved.
11/02l94 Inspection. Three uniicensed ��ehicles remaining , referred complaint to Housing so
they could issue orders for unlicensed vehicles (orders were issued on 11/8/44).
12/06/94 Two vehicles still unlicensed. Housing issued abatement orders, so I closed the
complaint.
03/Ol/96 Complaint regarding vehicles, tires, Qeneral mess of parking lot and the neglect of a
-.
i �
r�
,
doQ. Called'�1r. Pham and told him I�z�ould be comina out for an inspection.
03/05/96 D1et with licence inspector and �ir. Pham on site for 35 minutes discussing
�•iolations.
03/21;96 Letter sent as a follo��-up to o��: 3i5196 meetina (letter attached).
04/10;96 ?�4uch improlzmenr in parkinQ lot conditions.
07/12/96 ?�4r. Pham once aRain in �•iolation of SCti�P.
Many times in 1996 I attempted to concact the property ou ner. I never heard from the
property oN�ner, nor �;as I successful in contacting them.
CITY OF S.AIt1TT P_�LZ
i�'nnn Colrmm�, A9cyor
rlarch 21, 1996
?�ir. Tuan Pham
Tuan Auto Repair
1�59 University A� zr.u�
Saint Paul, MN »IO-�
RE: 1456 Sherbume ��enue Parkins I,ot
Dear Mr. Pham:
OFFICE OF LICESSE, i\5°ECTIO�S A\D
E�\'II20\�7E�TAL PFOTECTIO�
R�i+<rr 3,?rsla, D�re<tm ^ � �,
� `�
Z0.1i�'G.9D.311,A7S7'R9T70.\' Td.�
750 StPrtt� Srrttt Fucsimile: 61:-_'66-�Y9
S,r,"n Si0
Sain; Pmd..Ninr�esota 5510:-]
As you are awaze, «z r;cendy recei�; d a complaint regardin� the storino of ��ehicles, auto
parts and additional miscellaneous items. This property is located in a P-1, a vehicle
parkin� district.
As we discussed, this parl:ing facility may not be used for the storino of vehicles
equipment or supplies of any I:ind. The referenced property may be used solely for private
passenger vehicles business vehicIes, and a limited number of vehicles awaiting service
(for short periods of tune) according to Sections 60.72I, 60.723(2} and 60.723(3) of the
City's Legislative Code. Fxterior storage is not permitted in This zonin� district. Exterior
stonge is first permitted in an I-1, an Industriai zoning district.
Additionally, an auto sales business is not permitted without first obtaining a dealership
license. A Special Condition Use Permit was appro�°ed last fall for expansion of an auto
repair facility, not for an auto sales business.
All miscellaneous exterior storage items and stored vehicles must be removed from the
referenced property by April 8, 1446. After that date, I will be reinspecting for
compliance with the Legisiative Code and the Special Condifion Use Permit.
If you have any questions or concems regarding this matter, piease call me at 266-9085.
Sincerely,
Peg Fuller
Zoning Inspector
cc: Kris Schweinler, Senior License Inspector
OFFICE OF LICENSE, L'�SPECI'IONS A7�'D
Eh'�"0.'Oh".SEh7AL PROTF.CI'ION
Robca K�ssler, Dircrwr Q � I � � `
`
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
T'om Coleman, Dfcyor
ZO�7�ti'G ADM/A7S7RATfON
350 St Pcur Street
Suiu 310
Sci�u Pau(, N.iruusam SSIO2-ISIO
7ckphont: 67? ?6b9�8
Facrimik: 612-?659099
September 27, 1994
Mr. Tuan Pham
Tuan Auto Repair
1459 University A��er.ue
Saint Paul, MN 5� 104
RE: Parldng Lot At 1456 Sherbu:ne Avenue
Dear Mr. Pham:
As you are aware, «�e ha��e recendy received a complaint regarding the parking of
inoperable vehicles at the referenced address. This property is located in a P-1, a Vehicle
Parldng District. Per Sections 60.721, 60.723(2) and 60.723(3) of the Cify's I.egislative
Code, the pazking facility may not be used for stor2ge of vehicles and may be used solely
for private passenger vehicles (see enclosed copies).
When I met with you earlier this month, you stated that you were keeping some of the
vehicles because customers had not paid their biIIs. You also stated that 3 or 4 additional
vehicles were used as storage for auTo parts. Stora;e of any kind, including inoperable
and/or unlicensed vehicles is not a permitted use in this Parldng District.
To comply with zoning requiremenu, all stored vehicles must be removed by October 14,
1994. All remaining vehicles must be licensed. If you need additional time to find a
space for your vehicles or have any questions regarding this matter, please call me at 266-
9085.
Sincerely,
Peg Fuller
Zoning InspecTor
enc.
cc: I,awrence M. Sw�2rtz
-_--�-� - __--= -._ � -- �-- -
__=_=,� _ ==-=
�
��.��1
�-..==- -,�_��_`_: �:
�-�___ ��--� 1�,
�__ _�_� = ��:_-
��'�__^ __�?�__��
�--�-- �`-�_—
=----= �_- -?<,__
�.�. _. _.. _� _.,_.. =Y'r__c.
---�- -� _.,��....� �`�--• - _�-- _��_
_. `_�_ _ `____. .,_..'.^,=ILL _
____--X _ _'__Y = _,.:_._�.
�- .. .�C „J .. ` y = _ �;1
�v..-�t-_� ____.\_� ____�.___ _�. _.�._�
.-Gl,�. __..._ 'S/
Sar:e _�=. �_�-- - -�r.?n - -- -
-- -- -- --�,---_- _-�__ _�ce^s2 ID °��:z�
'=-�-s'�r co L I�
��re�t �' er i97C S�'-`�_- =, _ �io1: U:!:L
�=__ct- .'�v?':° Dl-_XTGic :�,-�__ _ .
.' _ � 1 = L , i
�_-1 S J.: ti�G�� ;,'„'V� ��p ���0�? P:!Orc 6?62"iG0
L�C�cS " T^' - n -. .._ ..._ (��
�.iI�J? C _ �J ' ': 1J� ^J L_ lJ\� L /V�IJ2
2:�13?u_
�: ���SL�� P= �.� -._ =-� =l � ��?�: K�_ Ci?K Li� AP;�'D �9_T1
C"1aJ. �.._. ...,-__'& -K .�
5:6-13-34, ~��_. ,:OA�� aTC_�S ?✓=T.J3.
6:?1-17-95 - Sri7p arar,t=_3 �or expansion of garage -
7:another s=_ :ay to b� aqded. Three additi�n�l
-- _ ----- &:conditicn� -s:�Ye place� �n SCuP. See zq 1 11n5_fi le--9� - . -
RnS^_K=CTIOtiS :1�QUSRY SCREEN
r.-C=';SE S�: �21i9
��r:1'tiP?�� AII_O REPAIR
AOTB: i:080687 P_PP'D W/ ti'=r`i:P_`S'?O:dS �.:. H7-1
? _ 1. ?��0 ? ;R�I?'�G C= `1--_CL?S P;==':I'_�:: ?�?'�IK OR RBCENT
3:�Y KB?�IR�D ON =_� _-���T.
5:2_ T✓�IN_AI?Q 8 C='~S=3B.;1 =F=-c`_n� S_F_C?S iN �D�"IO
S:N :0 T�OSB SPAC=� �:=T3IN ��- '=p�czG� LR�F.
J : `
7 :
s:
_ L : _`_'_'_ _'—__—___"__"— __— __ __ __—__
__l.'_�_ "_"�r�. �,/^/ ^ G•� -
�-=� . _.�
-�n �' / !�.�c?J
=7 :_ _
--C=.._ ZL. .�__._,
Da:e: Nar 12
Council File # ` / � � � V O �
Green Sheet # V �
���������
Presented By
RePerred To
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Committee: Date
�
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, Tuan A Pham d/b/a Tuan Auto Repair (license ID No.
32119) located at 1459 University Avenue West in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of
$1,000.00. Said fine shall be paid to the O�ce of License, Inspections and Environmental
Protection within tlurty (30) days of the adoption of this resolufion by the Council and signature
by the Mayor.
This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter aze based upon the facts
contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee and such arguments as may have been
presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee.
xequested by Department of:
I �'
I�` ���� � � � f /� _ _
Adopted by Covncil: Date
Adoption Certified by
By:
Approved by Mayor: Date
By: �
----aS �_ Form Approved by City Attorney
Secretary �
&y: `�/li`c�[ix.�F'. �� E
� / Z l�� Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
C
By:
3$227
DERriMENTADFFICEACAUNCIL o June 11 �1997 GREEN SHEE � 1'� 0 �
INRIAL/DATE INRIAVDATE
CONTAGf PERSON & PHONE O DEPARTMENT �IRECTOFi � CITY CAUNCIL
Robert Kessler 266-9112 assicx � arvanoaNev � cmc�aK
MUST BE ON CAUNCILAGEN�A BY (�ATE) NUYBER FOR O BUDGET DIRECTOR � FIN. & MGT. SERVICES DIF.
HOUTING
7une 25, 1997 Public Hearing OflDEN O �,�pyOA (OR ASSI5TANn �
TOTAL # OP SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
AC(ION REQUESTEO:
Conce rnin�v adverse acrion against Tuan A. Pham, d/b/a T�an Auto Repair, 1459 University Avenue. (Uncontested)
RECOMMENDATIONS: npprova (A) or Rejact (R) PERSONAL SEflVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER TXE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS:
_ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION �� Has [his personlfirm ever worked under a coMrect for Mis tlepartment?
_ CIB CAMMITfEE YES NO
— 2. Has this persoNfirm ever been a city employee?
— STaF� — YES NO
_ OISTFIC7 COUR7 _ 3. Does ihis personMirm possess a skill not normally possessed by any current city employee?
SUPPORTS WHICM COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? VES NO
Explain all yes answers on separete sheet and attach to green sheet
INIiIATING PHOBLEM, ISSUE, OPPOiiTUNITY (Who, Whet, Whan. Where, Why):
ADVANTAGES IFAPPROVED:
� �i��`
a��� 1 � i�`�7
-�---_
. -- --_ - --------�-'"-�:�!
DISADVANTAGES IFAPPROVED:
DISADVANTAGES IF NOTAPPfiOVED:
TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSAC710N $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCIE ONE) YES NO
FUNDIfdG SOURCE AC7IVITV NUMBER
FINANCIAL INFORhiATION: (E%PLAIN) ,
q ' 1 -�o�
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING
Licensee Name: Tuan Anh Pham
Address: 1459 University Avenue
Council Hearing Date: June 25, 1997
Violations: Illegal parking and storage of inoperable and/or
unlicensed vehicles and outside storage of auto
parts and miscellaneous items.
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office
of License, Inspections and Environmental Protecfion:
One Thousand Dollar ($1,000.00) Fine
Attachments:
1. Proposed resolution
2. letter from licensee agreeing not to contest the facts
3. Notice of Violation
4. license information
5. photocopies of 10 photographs of site
6. complaint history and complaints
OFFICE OF TI� CITY ATTORNEY
Peg Birk, Ciry Anorney �O �
��
CITY OF SAINT PALTL Civil Division
.Norm Coleman, Mayor 400 Ciry Ha!! Telephone: 672 266-8770
IS West Kellogg Blvd Facsimile: 611198-5679
Sainr Paul, M"mnesam SSIO2
June 10, 1997 �9�Y �'��
5 �i:n
Jt.l�! 1 � f.
NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING
Tuan Anh Pham
Tuan Auto Repair
1970 Dayton Avenue
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55104
Re: All Licenses held by Tuan Anh Pham d/b/a Tuan Auto Repair for
the premises at 1459 University Avenue
License ID No.: 32119
File Number: G97-0222
Dear Mr. Pham:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning your Auto Repair
Garage License has been scheduled for 4:30 p.m., Wednesday, June
25, 1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City
Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents
which will be presented to the City Council for their
consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
concerning the illegal parking and storage of inoperable and/or
unlicensed vehicles and auto parts have not been disputed. You
will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral
and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed.
The recommendation of the license office will be for a$1,000.00
fine.
If you have any guestions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very tr yours,.
_ � � � cc�...,.
//
Virgini� D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant
Robert Kessler, Director,
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Council Secretary
LIEP
q�_�ol
Ple�se let me kacx _a writi=� no later th�� Monday, ?�ay 5, 1997 :cw
you wish to procee3. If I have not heard from you in writing by
May 5, 1997, I will ass�e that you are not contesting the facts
outlined above, an3 will sc`_edule the matter for the hearing before
the City Council.
Sincerely,
\
`�/�°L',.[-C� �J'.i ..�.-rt�
C.J
Virg_-��a D. ?al,:,e_
assistGrt City A��c_r_ey
cc: 3ebert Resslo=, �==ec�_r c' LI=?
Christine 3cze:�, �e��_: Dir>_ctcr c� LIE�
{ris Schwein_er, �-ce-se :-=_eector
��Z �
, "�s
������� �
l d'v
� � ��e+��ti ,
���
;�?�-
�iL cn �C�c �Gt{"
c�f�st yo L��
�� ��2� a �� y���Sf
C. � f
� v �,.� /f� i,, � ��,. yav �� �-
Jj�LiY� �n f cz� ��cen1" � rn y l�✓siiusS �ds` ��h.
✓ �/
(?��.�n�G� O ��t-. �j�e�se �/1�CSTigdf'� CtvY�
✓
�n� � .��� �
H �/ J
v �' ` / r� C � �
b� �rt.e
��-lc'nG� /
eGf I/� !`°. !� C'-i'l)'/��
� y'P,�,� ��.�<i� y-� �
���
�----
OFF]C F THE CITl' ATTOR\E1'
Prg 6+rk. t m� .Srrornrc
CITY OF S:�I\T PALZ
?�orn: Coleman, ,1fa��or
Cn�il D"n�ision
+00 Ciq� Ha11
IS If'es1 Kellogg Bh•d
Scint Pau7, .dlinnesoto 5�102
q�
Telephone: 61? ?66-5%10
Facsnr.ile: 6!? :9R- 5 6/9
�pr;l 25, 1997
NOTIC3 OF VIOLATION
TuGa ;::h Pham
Tu�n Au�o RenG_r
1970 DGyton Av=r��e
Sa ?aul, ?✓�? =�=�a_
RB: All Lice�=_�s =�ld - �an ^-� n Ph�m d � ;
�y - � , /b/a Tu�n ALto �e�a_r
�cr the pre-._s�s at 1�=: University �venue
License I� _. 323�9
Dear Sir:
The Director c= t'�2 C'_=ice of License, Inspections G�d
Environmental ?re�ection w_11 recommend that adverse action be
taken against your licer.ses.based on the foilowing information:
The parking lot adjoining your business has
been the subject of repeated complaints
regarding the illegal parking and storage of
inoperable and/or unlicensed vehicles and
outside storage of auto parts and
miscellaneous itexs. Because you are located
in a P-1 district, you may not use the parking
lot for storage of vehicles, equipment or
supplies of any kind. Photographs taken in
March and April of 1997 show numerous vehicles
stored under mouncs of snow, piles of debris,
miscellaneous junk parts and continued long-
term storage of vehicles, all in violation of
the zoning code.
If you do not disa���e that t:e above facts, please send me a lett�r
so that the matt=_r can be sc:eduled before the City Council for a
hearing on what p=_-�lty, i= a-•y, to impcse. You will be allowed to
speak on your be}a_'_ at tna� hearing.
If }'011 DEIIEVE t:c_ �l':° idC�3 Si.nteC� abcve are 117 error, y011 d:2
entit t0 d71 �V_�=n�1dY �earing beiore an administrative Zc'vJ
judge. In that ev<_-�, you r.-c•�ld receive a notice of hearing, with
the date, time ard place =' the nearing and the name of the
administrative law �ndge.
a�-�
Please ZEt IDE }CIICW '_�} Wri�j-J -;0 �c�EY thfl:1 N,ond N:d}� 7� 1997 :�w
you wish to proce�d. Zf I �ave not heard from you in writing by
May 5, 1997, I will assume that you are not contesting the facts
outlined above, ar.d will sc�edule the matter for the hearing befcre
the City Council.
Siacerely,
` :,.c.GTL �'�.i//c�--(''�'�
Vira_n�D. ?al�,.er
Assistart City A�_:raeY
cc: 3obert Kessler, �irec�cr c' �I_?
Christine Rcz�;c, �eD�.�� �1�=ctor c' LI�?
Rris Schk�ei�:�:, Licer_s= ___=Dectcr
a� -��
S': �T� C? MI?��'=�G" :'_
COU?�TY CF ,'��IvNS=V
ss.
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JC- C-. l.. _"_=V -_"3 _:YS� Q:�_Y SWOY? C2PCS c? SaL'
t.-nGl. __ A�v�� L�� i/ � S�C� �=YVC.�L t.�.� G :\OTIC.'.+ Vi V I VL_']1_�._\
C i L.1�.. TCl, OW=�_, __3.'..�Q _S_� DJ U_� GC=� � LYU2 �P_G CC'_':c^Ct CC: V
��Er2C_ 1ri ari c'��_;D2 u...._=SSEQ �S �O�!CWS: "
"�_' A^_7 � _^.di1
__3__ a"-,',:�0 �2
__-_ DGytc�: Aver•�e
�_. �aw_ 1�N. >j�.�d
__�._ �:_� _�am
'_��. LT�'_v=rsi:y Avenue
S�. ?a::_, :�T_Q. 55104
(which is the - ias� ��cwn ac�_=ss=s
the same, with pcs=age pre�a_d, in
Paul, Ninnesot�.
Subscribed and swcr� to be�cre me
this 25th day of Ftiril, 1957.
��c� / `/• %�"J--JCL-L�'(
' Notary Publ_c
�� RITA M. BOSSARD ��
NOTARY PUBGG - H,I�;NiSCTA
S RAMSEY COUNiY
: My Comm, Expires Jan 's7. 20C^
�_
cf said person) ar.d deposit_-a
�he united States mails at 5�.
a ' 1 -g°1
r.�c ID ...................
C:�1... ""' ... " ""- "'
3�siness Na�:e............
An3ress ..................
Z17J ............... " " "'
�0.1IlJ 3llS1_^_ESS F.S. .......
�=_cense Na�� .............
�x� Date .................
L^s�.�rance Carrier........
_ =•s. Folicy !��ns�ber. . . . . ..
I�surar_ce =f=ec�ice Da�e.
?�s. Expira�_on �ate.....
1OT� F,.''�BA ................
laX Id ...................
Wor'.�er Comp Exp Date.....
Telephone ................
=21_9
' '�.N � _ ..r_� �
__5° u'�=�-:SI��' �v� t4
�:iOS
=�i y:;=� :=a�_�
_ � 'O �-_ _'-:- < G =�T�G�
_7/Co'/�7
-\5? �_=\�? r30M 02 TO Ol ON a/09/52
--��=
�SOo'97 ?r �_�T E??N r0� GEN REP GAR LIC APP'D W=1^3 S
-=?S. C.F. 87-11a8
__;g-c� __, CO?���T101TS MET.�H.
==-17-:5 - SC�? granted for expar_sion of garaae -
�-o��.�r �s�vice bGy to be added. Thr=e addit=cral
c�na=�`_ors were placed on SCUP. See zoning �_ie 55
-226. Zor_-g to inspect to see if exnansion has ta
:��n plac=. car/lic
::83C5:
�:�L7�i�
=47-0274
-.�' _
`�` - < _ _- _--
=�= �
.
A
� .s .
E�
•��
� �� � �
.� :.�, �_
. � �` ��.
_ � ---'- -
_`� �
- �.. 1 �,�..?Ff:
� }
� �'ti .
'�� C,
a 1' . 4 :
:�` ,
�
a ���,
� _
a l _
�{,� .�:�� • . 3 ' � .\
�� �T s ��r ��.1 ' ` ��: _� .� �
i� i- -!� . � .� ���: . ;�
�����'�-'.`. r � . ' �. ' i I � �
' ! J• '- '• \
�'=1.� �: �: f' i � � � j � 1
{.� \
..� �t�9''�� �:..i:`� ..�y e
���� { <�_f . � C� " .
� ` �. �
C�� ' � i
/ - � � }/
_;>. R/ '\ . �', \_: �' '� '
Y ��\ � �
��: - j - ' j ;� ;,
::i'� � / � �
, :,;` ; :
',. � ; a ', ;�, '
� , " � �, y
. , �. , �.� ,.
, �� .��
;�� �,,. . .� � '\ / ; .
� T�v'E , �� � � �.� e i
� i•�� t y .
t �ti i'� , / ; , •�_ .
' `t : .,, ._ � 1 � \ . � � .r =-. =
� % s �:t '� � �- ' `�-k . i '-.:
'\� �; �`'� \: ' ',. " ' � � y ` �
�`� �. �,, k� ;. � � , � �` � �,^J�`:
= �� i. � � V ' ` r •w���L
-. ♦ L ��* r Y`; 1',
.$• � K4 . ` 4 � 7 �i� �
yi ' ^ s�''.:�� `�. ♦ ..-�'�' :�L�r . '' .
_ f�': _
—..
�
� \=
�,. .,_ , . - � _� �-� - .- -:`_'�-:'� ,�( ,,� "�R,�f
l�. /`t �'`. ;'�_. i``. � �. .'`� �t .i ��\ .Y
. � �\ � �\ l��. .�\. _'�` � � ` . � . `�... `.
�\�.��/`�/���._ . �'� =��;�<.; ``�,.. `.
�/�/�/�i�,4, �
��.�/t/t/`/�i ��;�,�;�'�;,
'� �� � /t � � �� � � /�- ,� ;(��� ,�
•'\ /� /� /� i � � � ,� �� y� � �. �
'` ��/�� � ��� ��;� :t;.:•.
!^�"��7`+- %� � ` l '1i•` �,
�` ,'\/` '° ��f�a�:;�`f ;
�'� ..�/. .,1/t �.1l�+�
� �- � /� ,�l �t iti ; k.h /` ..
,. � � /1 ,♦ ♦ , � ��'� - �. /-
, 1�3`..i�._ A�, h 4"i � i. ,.
.
�� �.�7�1M =.� � :; , � / '�
y �
� \ .\
�
��'...
�
��f� �
�4 -'.�
��.� ��n
d
�
� .' �- �` �" � `-
�-�� \\ \�� -�_ �--.�-=�
... '�: � _ ' -
. .� .'�'�: '„ "�� ✓4,>
"s,.'� \� \\ \ \/��/V� ��
.� � ,��
� f �.' l � �
\ \�i.����� i. i...,
�\:���:
\ \ \'
\"\ '
�
\ �.' \
\...\.
" \
� - ���.��
�'' ..�
�� �}.
�� / .
�� � �
. ' � ` ,
, -'r � i\ :. ` .` \\ \1 ��.
; i
. ` ` `-, �."� �� \ 1' ! \
:� ` � �' �� �.
� � � '1;��
\
..., \ , \ `. ` '�
� ., \\� �. � \`����
\
��t' � `�
�
✓b"V�
\-
l( �� �
c •�
�: �� \
�����
��y��G .. _
f H.'. / . J
� � � �
S
� _
� '�
�•\ �'..i'. . .. �.�.
'��
a"'.
�
,,�� J �
+
`L_
6�� i �
/ �_
��
I
7\�
,
t :.
�1�'�:��
: � . i �w,�':
� j : t F `1�
� J r`ti i , ':..
—_, �
,.,:: ' r . �
��'. .-'�',
��� �'_ f.�i, � � � ' ' :
!� � .a �._ i -- �t' �. —
�'' j "' \: %,/
i . \ ��
' ' / _\
� ;•:_;
�
y}
:.�:. :
� � "�� �� �\� ' ]( t' � '�\
�� � ; L (G/'t'���.. ', \ �� .. \ �1. _ �'�1 t �.
� �":
I " r � \ � \ �� / �'- � �� ` L � \ }�+�
�� a:s.�\ 1`�/� �/ �, � /E; � � +'� ..
�
°:<��- � _ -��',1��. `�/�� � , �% \1 �.:
�✓ �i
\ �r�`{� \r
. � /
F q r
, � � � . \ .,
� '
3
'"'.'^,"'.'�. '
I _._- "
,.''. :` :^:
• , f.
r
`\.
�� " ����
f� _
�,
�'_\ • r
� �r
�� � 1 �� � ..
i
, v� �`� e�� �
. '� .
�/\ � ����'�. L Y�J' ...:
/\ \ � Z \ , \ 'e �. Y.
�
/ /
� A � tz y `���\.�
r_��� � y � .I �/ 3 . �.
�` � `� _��1 \� \ 1
� � `, ��. •, � `�+�
� �
i��. f e . /� :
. . .� ��.J L i..\_a � . �.�. -�.
� �...__.
tl
L "-.
b� '
;s' � �
�� -
,`;`.
`�Sj�, ti
�. `��
i ... .r;: ; :< 1
:' ;..
� �` -' r _7"i
}� -.J;
.. � �
C.i� ' •/
�
,� f a A�:
- . . F�t
-_ � " + t �i� h--
. - ���' , -�, � � � ��� -. . -
►� -" . `. `� \ . -
� ,,�-�,._ ,\ \ \\\ .'� . �. \
� i
.� :` ° ��������.��
f '
..
�_
• �.,_+
: �t'
� c�:, /
:� V'-i._L�.�C `.. .
AF ._ .
� r-_I-�'�
" �.. ,.����
�. .\, \ ,
� �r
� ' �
..,
ti
��
_— ;
_�.� � I
, � ������.
12..,.
`�.
..._. � --•
=#�i.itR?;::: <..� �
'���li-?7:. '. _ '
����i�
�f��: � ? y:�'. .
� �� " ..
. . „ y : ..:. �
i�3:
� �.
Clll' OF SAI\T PACL
Sorm Calemcn. .l:airor
DATE: ?vIarch 12, 1997
T0: Kris Sch���einier
Senior License Inspzctor
FROM: Peg Fuller
Zoning Inspeccor
OFFICE OFl.ICC�:SE. IASP!_Z�llO�ti -1�'U
G�\'IRO\�1CXT:1L PROTt�CT10`: ^ p ,
Rahrrt,i'estler Dvcc�or /� � /\ '
V`
6L7LDI.��GISSPECT/O.�'AA�D Tclephoue:6;=-'66-9090
DESIG>� Fatsimile� 67=-'GG-9099
i �0 St Pertr Slreet
s�,rre ;nn
SanvtPcul. 4linnesoto ji103-]JIO
RE: Tuan Auto Repair
1459 University A��enue (Business Location}
1456 Sherburne A.enue (Parki-�g Lot)
A brief history of the referenced propem• re�arding zoning violations:
08/18/94 Complaint re�ardinQ parking/storing of inoperable, unlicensed vehicles in parkin�
lot.
09/09/94 Inspection. Gave Tuan Pham �erbal orders to bring parking lot into compliance with
the Special Condition Use Permit (SCUP) conditions (see higtilighted conditions of
attached SCUP).
9/27/94 Letter sent to Mr. Pham reiterating 9/9/94 verbal orders (see attached).
10/15/94 Inspection. Parkin� lot impro��ed and Mr. Pham stated the remaining unacceptable
vehicles would be removed from the property soon.
10/24/94 Inspection. A few ��ehicles remaining in violation, generally parking lot is very
much improved.
11/02l94 Inspection. Three uniicensed ��ehicles remaining , referred complaint to Housing so
they could issue orders for unlicensed vehicles (orders were issued on 11/8/44).
12/06/94 Two vehicles still unlicensed. Housing issued abatement orders, so I closed the
complaint.
03/Ol/96 Complaint regarding vehicles, tires, Qeneral mess of parking lot and the neglect of a
-.
i �
r�
,
doQ. Called'�1r. Pham and told him I�z�ould be comina out for an inspection.
03/05/96 D1et with licence inspector and �ir. Pham on site for 35 minutes discussing
�•iolations.
03/21;96 Letter sent as a follo��-up to o��: 3i5196 meetina (letter attached).
04/10;96 ?�4uch improlzmenr in parkinQ lot conditions.
07/12/96 ?�4r. Pham once aRain in �•iolation of SCti�P.
Many times in 1996 I attempted to concact the property ou ner. I never heard from the
property oN�ner, nor �;as I successful in contacting them.
CITY OF S.AIt1TT P_�LZ
i�'nnn Colrmm�, A9cyor
rlarch 21, 1996
?�ir. Tuan Pham
Tuan Auto Repair
1�59 University A� zr.u�
Saint Paul, MN »IO-�
RE: 1456 Sherbume ��enue Parkins I,ot
Dear Mr. Pham:
OFFICE OF LICESSE, i\5°ECTIO�S A\D
E�\'II20\�7E�TAL PFOTECTIO�
R�i+<rr 3,?rsla, D�re<tm ^ � �,
� `�
Z0.1i�'G.9D.311,A7S7'R9T70.\' Td.�
750 StPrtt� Srrttt Fucsimile: 61:-_'66-�Y9
S,r,"n Si0
Sain; Pmd..Ninr�esota 5510:-]
As you are awaze, «z r;cendy recei�; d a complaint regardin� the storino of ��ehicles, auto
parts and additional miscellaneous items. This property is located in a P-1, a vehicle
parkin� district.
As we discussed, this parl:ing facility may not be used for the storino of vehicles
equipment or supplies of any I:ind. The referenced property may be used solely for private
passenger vehicles business vehicIes, and a limited number of vehicles awaiting service
(for short periods of tune) according to Sections 60.72I, 60.723(2} and 60.723(3) of the
City's Legislative Code. Fxterior storage is not permitted in This zonin� district. Exterior
stonge is first permitted in an I-1, an Industriai zoning district.
Additionally, an auto sales business is not permitted without first obtaining a dealership
license. A Special Condition Use Permit was appro�°ed last fall for expansion of an auto
repair facility, not for an auto sales business.
All miscellaneous exterior storage items and stored vehicles must be removed from the
referenced property by April 8, 1446. After that date, I will be reinspecting for
compliance with the Legisiative Code and the Special Condifion Use Permit.
If you have any questions or concems regarding this matter, piease call me at 266-9085.
Sincerely,
Peg Fuller
Zoning Inspector
cc: Kris Schweinler, Senior License Inspector
OFFICE OF LICENSE, L'�SPECI'IONS A7�'D
Eh'�"0.'Oh".SEh7AL PROTF.CI'ION
Robca K�ssler, Dircrwr Q � I � � `
`
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
T'om Coleman, Dfcyor
ZO�7�ti'G ADM/A7S7RATfON
350 St Pcur Street
Suiu 310
Sci�u Pau(, N.iruusam SSIO2-ISIO
7ckphont: 67? ?6b9�8
Facrimik: 612-?659099
September 27, 1994
Mr. Tuan Pham
Tuan Auto Repair
1459 University A��er.ue
Saint Paul, MN 5� 104
RE: Parldng Lot At 1456 Sherbu:ne Avenue
Dear Mr. Pham:
As you are aware, «�e ha��e recendy received a complaint regarding the parking of
inoperable vehicles at the referenced address. This property is located in a P-1, a Vehicle
Parldng District. Per Sections 60.721, 60.723(2) and 60.723(3) of the Cify's I.egislative
Code, the pazking facility may not be used for stor2ge of vehicles and may be used solely
for private passenger vehicles (see enclosed copies).
When I met with you earlier this month, you stated that you were keeping some of the
vehicles because customers had not paid their biIIs. You also stated that 3 or 4 additional
vehicles were used as storage for auTo parts. Stora;e of any kind, including inoperable
and/or unlicensed vehicles is not a permitted use in this Parldng District.
To comply with zoning requiremenu, all stored vehicles must be removed by October 14,
1994. All remaining vehicles must be licensed. If you need additional time to find a
space for your vehicles or have any questions regarding this matter, please call me at 266-
9085.
Sincerely,
Peg Fuller
Zoning InspecTor
enc.
cc: I,awrence M. Sw�2rtz
-_--�-� - __--= -._ � -- �-- -
__=_=,� _ ==-=
�
��.��1
�-..==- -,�_��_`_: �:
�-�___ ��--� 1�,
�__ _�_� = ��:_-
��'�__^ __�?�__��
�--�-- �`-�_—
=----= �_- -?<,__
�.�. _. _.. _� _.,_.. =Y'r__c.
---�- -� _.,��....� �`�--• - _�-- _��_
_. `_�_ _ `____. .,_..'.^,=ILL _
____--X _ _'__Y = _,.:_._�.
�- .. .�C „J .. ` y = _ �;1
�v..-�t-_� ____.\_� ____�.___ _�. _.�._�
.-Gl,�. __..._ 'S/
Sar:e _�=. �_�-- - -�r.?n - -- -
-- -- -- --�,---_- _-�__ _�ce^s2 ID °��:z�
'=-�-s'�r co L I�
��re�t �' er i97C S�'-`�_- =, _ �io1: U:!:L
�=__ct- .'�v?':° Dl-_XTGic :�,-�__ _ .
.' _ � 1 = L , i
�_-1 S J.: ti�G�� ;,'„'V� ��p ���0�? P:!Orc 6?62"iG0
L�C�cS " T^' - n -. .._ ..._ (��
�.iI�J? C _ �J ' ': 1J� ^J L_ lJ\� L /V�IJ2
2:�13?u_
�: ���SL�� P= �.� -._ =-� =l � ��?�: K�_ Ci?K Li� AP;�'D �9_T1
C"1aJ. �.._. ...,-__'& -K .�
5:6-13-34, ~��_. ,:OA�� aTC_�S ?✓=T.J3.
6:?1-17-95 - Sri7p arar,t=_3 �or expansion of garage -
7:another s=_ :ay to b� aqded. Three additi�n�l
-- _ ----- &:conditicn� -s:�Ye place� �n SCuP. See zq 1 11n5_fi le--9� - . -
RnS^_K=CTIOtiS :1�QUSRY SCREEN
r.-C=';SE S�: �21i9
��r:1'tiP?�� AII_O REPAIR
AOTB: i:080687 P_PP'D W/ ti'=r`i:P_`S'?O:dS �.:. H7-1
? _ 1. ?��0 ? ;R�I?'�G C= `1--_CL?S P;==':I'_�:: ?�?'�IK OR RBCENT
3:�Y KB?�IR�D ON =_� _-���T.
5:2_ T✓�IN_AI?Q 8 C='~S=3B.;1 =F=-c`_n� S_F_C?S iN �D�"IO
S:N :0 T�OSB SPAC=� �:=T3IN ��- '=p�czG� LR�F.
J : `
7 :
s:
_ L : _`_'_'_ _'—__—___"__"— __— __ __ __—__
__l.'_�_ "_"�r�. �,/^/ ^ G•� -
�-=� . _.�
-�n �' / !�.�c?J
=7 :_ _
--C=.._ ZL. .�__._,
Da:e: Nar 12