Loading...
97-592�- Lo� C�5 f-�, �-� Presented By � Re£erred To 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 14 counci� File ,4� �'r1 — � �I � Green Sheet ¥ 31194 RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA RFSOLVED, that upon the execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint Paul, the proper City officers are hereby authorized and d'uected to pay out of the Tort Liability Fund Q9070-0511 to Steven Shoals and Marc Kurzman, his attorney, the sum of $3,000.00 in full settlement of his claims for damages arising out of the occunence on May 30, 1945, in the City of Saint Paul. 3� Requested by Department of: By= 4�� a—. t—���__ � Approved by Mayor: Date �( Z�l 4�- BY: � G _T City Attorney By: � � I� Form Approve by City Attorney sy: Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY' �.��(.GL� G��'� Adopted by Council: Date � � � Adoption Certified by Council Secretary �t rt - S`t2- DEPARTMENT/OFFI FJCOUNCIL DATE INITIATED N� 31 19 4 c�t Attorney s/s/9� GREEN SHEE __ __ CONTAGTPEflSON & PHONE INITIAVOATE INITIAIJDA7E O DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR � CIN COUNCIL Gail Lan £leld 266-8748 A���'N aC�NATfORNEY �CT'CLERK MUST BE ON COUNCIL AGENDA 8Y (DATE) NUYBER FOR ❑ BUDGET DIFiECTOfl O FIN. & MGT. SERVICES Olp. ROUfING OBDER � MAVOR (OR ASSISTANT) � TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACf70N REQUESTED: Approval of resolution settling claim o£ Steven Shoals against the City of Saint Paul in the amount of $3,000. RECOMMENDA710NS: Approve (A) w Reject (R) pERSONAL SERVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWEH THE FOLLOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CYYIL SERVICE CAMMISSION 1. Has this personRrm ever wwk,etl undar a contract for this departmenl? - _ CIB CAMMITfEE _ YES NO __ STAFF 2. H25 thiS PCf30Nfii�11 EV2f b¢Zit 2 City EIi1pIGYCe? — YES NO _ aSiRfCT COURT _ 3. Does this parson/firm posse55 a skiH not nortnaly possessed by arry curtent cify employee? SUPPOPTSWHICHCOUNCILOBJECTIVE7 YES NO Ezplain all yes answers on separate sheet an0 aKach to grean sheet INITIATING PROBLEM. ISSUE.OPPOR7UNITY (Who, Whaq When, Where, Why): On May 30, 1995, Steven Shoats was leaving a friend's apartment at SQS 5elby Avenue in St. Paul, Minnesota. Lorrie Dorrance, a St. Paul Police officer, also lives at that address. Officer Dorrance, was off-dury, and was returning to her home at appro�rimately 11:00 p.m. Dorrance saw Shoals, who she did not recognize as a resident run from the building to a nearby fenced area. Because of the late hour, Shoal's suspicious behavior, and the fact that Dorrance did not AovAHn. between Shoals and Dorrance regarding Shoal's right to be on the property. Donance was hoiding on to Shoals' bicycle and as Shoals attempted to move away, Dorrance and Shoals fell over with the bicycle. Dorrance's boyfriend was also present during this incident and is accused of making a threatening remark and gesture toward Shoais. Shoals sustained a minor injury as a result of this altercation. Shoals made a complaint to the St. Paul Police Department as a result of this incident. After the o�sAO��wTACE����on rt was oun t at orrance was actmg as a po ice o cer w en s e was mveshgahng the suspicious behavior at her apartment building. Dorrance was disciplined for conduct unbecoming a police officer as a result of the investigation. Shoais initiated this action in Ramsey County District Court alleging Dorrance committed and assault and battery, and violated his constitutional rights. Shoals also alleged the City had failed to properly train its police officers. DISAOVANTAGES IF NOT AVPROVED: The defendants have denied Plaintifl's claims and asserted various defenses. s case is ready for trial. Our office has entered into a settlement agreement with �pi�����m of $3,000.00 in exchange for release of all claims against the defendants. Our a�ffice recomm s approval of this settlement. �c'�`i'�€9 r��:;..��,'�,P G����.� �,66t 80 �`� �;�r�as i2 i�3T �3�i�� TOTAL AMOUNi OF TRANSACTION $ 3� OOO . OO CO57/REVEIJGE BUDGETED (CIHCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDINGSOURCE TOT't Liability ACTIVITYNUMBER 09070 FINANCIAL INFOFMATION: (EXPLAIN) �- Lo� C�5 f-�, �-� Presented By � Re£erred To 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 14 counci� File ,4� �'r1 — � �I � Green Sheet ¥ 31194 RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA RFSOLVED, that upon the execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint Paul, the proper City officers are hereby authorized and d'uected to pay out of the Tort Liability Fund Q9070-0511 to Steven Shoals and Marc Kurzman, his attorney, the sum of $3,000.00 in full settlement of his claims for damages arising out of the occunence on May 30, 1945, in the City of Saint Paul. 3� Requested by Department of: By= 4�� a—. t—���__ � Approved by Mayor: Date �( Z�l 4�- BY: � G _T City Attorney By: � � I� Form Approve by City Attorney sy: Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY' �.��(.GL� G��'� Adopted by Council: Date � � � Adoption Certified by Council Secretary �t rt - S`t2- DEPARTMENT/OFFI FJCOUNCIL DATE INITIATED N� 31 19 4 c�t Attorney s/s/9� GREEN SHEE __ __ CONTAGTPEflSON & PHONE INITIAVOATE INITIAIJDA7E O DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR � CIN COUNCIL Gail Lan £leld 266-8748 A���'N aC�NATfORNEY �CT'CLERK MUST BE ON COUNCIL AGENDA 8Y (DATE) NUYBER FOR ❑ BUDGET DIFiECTOfl O FIN. & MGT. SERVICES Olp. ROUfING OBDER � MAVOR (OR ASSISTANT) � TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACf70N REQUESTED: Approval of resolution settling claim o£ Steven Shoals against the City of Saint Paul in the amount of $3,000. RECOMMENDA710NS: Approve (A) w Reject (R) pERSONAL SERVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWEH THE FOLLOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CYYIL SERVICE CAMMISSION 1. Has this personRrm ever wwk,etl undar a contract for this departmenl? - _ CIB CAMMITfEE _ YES NO __ STAFF 2. H25 thiS PCf30Nfii�11 EV2f b¢Zit 2 City EIi1pIGYCe? — YES NO _ aSiRfCT COURT _ 3. Does this parson/firm posse55 a skiH not nortnaly possessed by arry curtent cify employee? SUPPOPTSWHICHCOUNCILOBJECTIVE7 YES NO Ezplain all yes answers on separate sheet an0 aKach to grean sheet INITIATING PROBLEM. ISSUE.OPPOR7UNITY (Who, Whaq When, Where, Why): On May 30, 1995, Steven Shoats was leaving a friend's apartment at SQS 5elby Avenue in St. Paul, Minnesota. Lorrie Dorrance, a St. Paul Police officer, also lives at that address. Officer Dorrance, was off-dury, and was returning to her home at appro�rimately 11:00 p.m. Dorrance saw Shoals, who she did not recognize as a resident run from the building to a nearby fenced area. Because of the late hour, Shoal's suspicious behavior, and the fact that Dorrance did not AovAHn. between Shoals and Dorrance regarding Shoal's right to be on the property. Donance was hoiding on to Shoals' bicycle and as Shoals attempted to move away, Dorrance and Shoals fell over with the bicycle. Dorrance's boyfriend was also present during this incident and is accused of making a threatening remark and gesture toward Shoais. Shoals sustained a minor injury as a result of this altercation. Shoals made a complaint to the St. Paul Police Department as a result of this incident. After the o�sAO��wTACE����on rt was oun t at orrance was actmg as a po ice o cer w en s e was mveshgahng the suspicious behavior at her apartment building. Dorrance was disciplined for conduct unbecoming a police officer as a result of the investigation. Shoais initiated this action in Ramsey County District Court alleging Dorrance committed and assault and battery, and violated his constitutional rights. Shoals also alleged the City had failed to properly train its police officers. DISAOVANTAGES IF NOT AVPROVED: The defendants have denied Plaintifl's claims and asserted various defenses. s case is ready for trial. Our office has entered into a settlement agreement with �pi�����m of $3,000.00 in exchange for release of all claims against the defendants. Our a�ffice recomm s approval of this settlement. �c'�`i'�€9 r��:;..��,'�,P G����.� �,66t 80 �`� �;�r�as i2 i�3T �3�i�� TOTAL AMOUNi OF TRANSACTION $ 3� OOO . OO CO57/REVEIJGE BUDGETED (CIHCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDINGSOURCE TOT't Liability ACTIVITYNUMBER 09070 FINANCIAL INFOFMATION: (EXPLAIN) �- Lo� C�5 f-�, �-� Presented By � Re£erred To 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 14 counci� File ,4� �'r1 — � �I � Green Sheet ¥ 31194 RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA RFSOLVED, that upon the execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint Paul, the proper City officers are hereby authorized and d'uected to pay out of the Tort Liability Fund Q9070-0511 to Steven Shoals and Marc Kurzman, his attorney, the sum of $3,000.00 in full settlement of his claims for damages arising out of the occunence on May 30, 1945, in the City of Saint Paul. 3� Requested by Department of: By= 4�� a—. t—���__ � Approved by Mayor: Date �( Z�l 4�- BY: � G _T City Attorney By: � � I� Form Approve by City Attorney sy: Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council BY' �.��(.GL� G��'� Adopted by Council: Date � � � Adoption Certified by Council Secretary �t rt - S`t2- DEPARTMENT/OFFI FJCOUNCIL DATE INITIATED N� 31 19 4 c�t Attorney s/s/9� GREEN SHEE __ __ CONTAGTPEflSON & PHONE INITIAVOATE INITIAIJDA7E O DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR � CIN COUNCIL Gail Lan £leld 266-8748 A���'N aC�NATfORNEY �CT'CLERK MUST BE ON COUNCIL AGENDA 8Y (DATE) NUYBER FOR ❑ BUDGET DIFiECTOfl O FIN. & MGT. SERVICES Olp. ROUfING OBDER � MAVOR (OR ASSISTANT) � TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACf70N REQUESTED: Approval of resolution settling claim o£ Steven Shoals against the City of Saint Paul in the amount of $3,000. RECOMMENDA710NS: Approve (A) w Reject (R) pERSONAL SERVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWEH THE FOLLOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CYYIL SERVICE CAMMISSION 1. Has this personRrm ever wwk,etl undar a contract for this departmenl? - _ CIB CAMMITfEE _ YES NO __ STAFF 2. H25 thiS PCf30Nfii�11 EV2f b¢Zit 2 City EIi1pIGYCe? — YES NO _ aSiRfCT COURT _ 3. Does this parson/firm posse55 a skiH not nortnaly possessed by arry curtent cify employee? SUPPOPTSWHICHCOUNCILOBJECTIVE7 YES NO Ezplain all yes answers on separate sheet an0 aKach to grean sheet INITIATING PROBLEM. ISSUE.OPPOR7UNITY (Who, Whaq When, Where, Why): On May 30, 1995, Steven Shoats was leaving a friend's apartment at SQS 5elby Avenue in St. Paul, Minnesota. Lorrie Dorrance, a St. Paul Police officer, also lives at that address. Officer Dorrance, was off-dury, and was returning to her home at appro�rimately 11:00 p.m. Dorrance saw Shoals, who she did not recognize as a resident run from the building to a nearby fenced area. Because of the late hour, Shoal's suspicious behavior, and the fact that Dorrance did not AovAHn. between Shoals and Dorrance regarding Shoal's right to be on the property. Donance was hoiding on to Shoals' bicycle and as Shoals attempted to move away, Dorrance and Shoals fell over with the bicycle. Dorrance's boyfriend was also present during this incident and is accused of making a threatening remark and gesture toward Shoais. Shoals sustained a minor injury as a result of this altercation. Shoals made a complaint to the St. Paul Police Department as a result of this incident. After the o�sAO��wTACE����on rt was oun t at orrance was actmg as a po ice o cer w en s e was mveshgahng the suspicious behavior at her apartment building. Dorrance was disciplined for conduct unbecoming a police officer as a result of the investigation. Shoais initiated this action in Ramsey County District Court alleging Dorrance committed and assault and battery, and violated his constitutional rights. Shoals also alleged the City had failed to properly train its police officers. DISAOVANTAGES IF NOT AVPROVED: The defendants have denied Plaintifl's claims and asserted various defenses. s case is ready for trial. Our office has entered into a settlement agreement with �pi�����m of $3,000.00 in exchange for release of all claims against the defendants. Our a�ffice recomm s approval of this settlement. �c'�`i'�€9 r��:;..��,'�,P G����.� �,66t 80 �`� �;�r�as i2 i�3T �3�i�� TOTAL AMOUNi OF TRANSACTION $ 3� OOO . OO CO57/REVEIJGE BUDGETED (CIHCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDINGSOURCE TOT't Liability ACTIVITYNUMBER 09070 FINANCIAL INFOFMATION: (EXPLAIN)