97-425,
��J2U.
Council File # / Z
Green Sheet # �� `� `�
.- , �_ . . _ _ , RESOLUTION
� ;- � ' CI SAWT AUL, MfNNESOTA aD
2resented By
Referred To Committee: Date
1 RESOLVED, that, upon execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint Paul,
2 the proper City officers are hereby authorized and directed to pay from the Tort Liability
3 Fund, 09081-0511, to State Farm Insurance as subrogee for Mary and Thomas Scanlan, the
4 sum of $'7,349.52 in full settlement of their subrogation claim for daruages sustained on
5 December 10, 1996 as a result of an accidern with a City-owned velucle at ar near Robert
6 Street and Isabel Street.
Requested by Department ot
Adopted by Council: Date A
Adopuon Certified by Council Secretary
BY: — n _� ���,��
Approved by Mayor: Date u(��
�
Technolo and Man emen�t S�} ces
BY� �'��,J`LIA.QkO, �a"'
Approval Recommended by Budget D'uector:
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council:
By: �
��-�������
�,���E,��N��� DATEINITIATED GREEN SHEET
Technology & Mgmt ServiceslRisk Mgmt 4/2/97
COMACTPER$pN 8 PHONE INITIAVOATE INITIAl/OATE
ODEPARTMENTDIqECTOB CRYCOUNCIL
Steve Voldal 266-8587 ASSIGN � q7yATfORNEY �J C(TYCLEFK
MUST BE ON COUNpL AGENDA BY (DATE) po��FOR O BUOGET DIRECTOR � FW. & MGT. SEflVICES OIFi.
N!A o"o� � �1YOR (OP ASSI5TANT) �
TOTAI # OF SIGNATURE PAGES � (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR Sf6NATURE)
ACTION REQUESTE�:
Approval of Resolution settling the property damage claim of State Farm Insurance as subrogee for Mary and Thomas Scanlan
against the City of Saint Pau! in the amount of 57349.52.
RECOMMENDA710N5� Approve iA) or Rejeti (ii7 pERSQNAL SERVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER THE FOILOWING QUESTIQNS:
_ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVICE GOMMISSIpN �- Has mis personlFirm ever worked under a contract for this department?
_ CIB CAMMfTTEE _ YES NO
_ SiaFF 2. Has this personftifin evef bean a ciry emplOyee?
— YES NO
_ DISiA1C7 COURi _ 3. Ooes this pefson(tirm possess a skill not normally possessed hy any cunent ciry empluyee4
SUPPORTSWHICHCWNCILOBJEC71VE4 YES NO
Explatn all yes answers on separate sheet and attaeh to green aheet
INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNYTY (Wlro, Wliet Whan, NTere, Why):
On December 10, 1996 a City of Saint Paul police car, driven by Joseph Jenkins, pulled from a private drive into Robert Street,
colliding with a 1992 Honda Civic, owned and driven by Thomas Scanlan. Mr. Scanlan was proceeding south on Robert Street
a�d braked his vehicle in an attempt to avoid coiliding with the police car. As a resuit of the coilision, Mr. Scanlan's vehicle was
a total loss. I have reached a settlement with his insurance carrier in the amount of 57,349.52.
ADVANTAGES IFAPPROVEO'
RECE�YFD
APR 0 9 i997
�r1Yf} i � OFFiC�
DISADVANTAGES IF APPflOVED:
"^3.. � �:�� dva}? @'d n ..E
.. _, ._.; P {'� �..,A�:.-
� n ���
� u _ _„ , dcSVB
OISADVANTAGES IF PWT APPflOVE�: - ' ' ' ' ' " � �
7349.52
TOiAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETEp (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO
FUNDIfiG SOURCE GL 001 TOrt Lidbilfty ACTIVITY NUMBER 09081
FINANCIAL INfORFnAT10N: (EXPLAIN}
f;lusers\ga ugha n\wpfiles\resoladm\gmsht.wDd
,
��J2U.
Council File # / Z
Green Sheet # �� `� `�
.- , �_ . . _ _ , RESOLUTION
� ;- � ' CI SAWT AUL, MfNNESOTA aD
2resented By
Referred To Committee: Date
1 RESOLVED, that, upon execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint Paul,
2 the proper City officers are hereby authorized and directed to pay from the Tort Liability
3 Fund, 09081-0511, to State Farm Insurance as subrogee for Mary and Thomas Scanlan, the
4 sum of $'7,349.52 in full settlement of their subrogation claim for daruages sustained on
5 December 10, 1996 as a result of an accidern with a City-owned velucle at ar near Robert
6 Street and Isabel Street.
Requested by Department ot
Adopted by Council: Date A
Adopuon Certified by Council Secretary
BY: — n _� ���,��
Approved by Mayor: Date u(��
�
Technolo and Man emen�t S�} ces
BY� �'��,J`LIA.QkO, �a"'
Approval Recommended by Budget D'uector:
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council:
By: �
��-�������
�,���E,��N��� DATEINITIATED GREEN SHEET
Technology & Mgmt ServiceslRisk Mgmt 4/2/97
COMACTPER$pN 8 PHONE INITIAVOATE INITIAl/OATE
ODEPARTMENTDIqECTOB CRYCOUNCIL
Steve Voldal 266-8587 ASSIGN � q7yATfORNEY �J C(TYCLEFK
MUST BE ON COUNpL AGENDA BY (DATE) po��FOR O BUOGET DIRECTOR � FW. & MGT. SEflVICES OIFi.
N!A o"o� � �1YOR (OP ASSI5TANT) �
TOTAI # OF SIGNATURE PAGES � (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR Sf6NATURE)
ACTION REQUESTE�:
Approval of Resolution settling the property damage claim of State Farm Insurance as subrogee for Mary and Thomas Scanlan
against the City of Saint Pau! in the amount of 57349.52.
RECOMMENDA710N5� Approve iA) or Rejeti (ii7 pERSQNAL SERVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER THE FOILOWING QUESTIQNS:
_ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVICE GOMMISSIpN �- Has mis personlFirm ever worked under a contract for this department?
_ CIB CAMMfTTEE _ YES NO
_ SiaFF 2. Has this personftifin evef bean a ciry emplOyee?
— YES NO
_ DISiA1C7 COURi _ 3. Ooes this pefson(tirm possess a skill not normally possessed hy any cunent ciry empluyee4
SUPPORTSWHICHCWNCILOBJEC71VE4 YES NO
Explatn all yes answers on separate sheet and attaeh to green aheet
INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNYTY (Wlro, Wliet Whan, NTere, Why):
On December 10, 1996 a City of Saint Paul police car, driven by Joseph Jenkins, pulled from a private drive into Robert Street,
colliding with a 1992 Honda Civic, owned and driven by Thomas Scanlan. Mr. Scanlan was proceeding south on Robert Street
a�d braked his vehicle in an attempt to avoid coiliding with the police car. As a resuit of the coilision, Mr. Scanlan's vehicle was
a total loss. I have reached a settlement with his insurance carrier in the amount of 57,349.52.
ADVANTAGES IFAPPROVEO'
RECE�YFD
APR 0 9 i997
�r1Yf} i � OFFiC�
DISADVANTAGES IF APPflOVED:
"^3.. � �:�� dva}? @'d n ..E
.. _, ._.; P {'� �..,A�:.-
� n ���
� u _ _„ , dcSVB
OISADVANTAGES IF PWT APPflOVE�: - ' ' ' ' ' " � �
7349.52
TOiAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETEp (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO
FUNDIfiG SOURCE GL 001 TOrt Lidbilfty ACTIVITY NUMBER 09081
FINANCIAL INfORFnAT10N: (EXPLAIN}
f;lusers\ga ugha n\wpfiles\resoladm\gmsht.wDd
,
��J2U.
Council File # / Z
Green Sheet # �� `� `�
.- , �_ . . _ _ , RESOLUTION
� ;- � ' CI SAWT AUL, MfNNESOTA aD
2resented By
Referred To Committee: Date
1 RESOLVED, that, upon execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint Paul,
2 the proper City officers are hereby authorized and directed to pay from the Tort Liability
3 Fund, 09081-0511, to State Farm Insurance as subrogee for Mary and Thomas Scanlan, the
4 sum of $'7,349.52 in full settlement of their subrogation claim for daruages sustained on
5 December 10, 1996 as a result of an accidern with a City-owned velucle at ar near Robert
6 Street and Isabel Street.
Requested by Department ot
Adopted by Council: Date A
Adopuon Certified by Council Secretary
BY: — n _� ���,��
Approved by Mayor: Date u(��
�
Technolo and Man emen�t S�} ces
BY� �'��,J`LIA.QkO, �a"'
Approval Recommended by Budget D'uector:
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council:
By: �
��-�������
�,���E,��N��� DATEINITIATED GREEN SHEET
Technology & Mgmt ServiceslRisk Mgmt 4/2/97
COMACTPER$pN 8 PHONE INITIAVOATE INITIAl/OATE
ODEPARTMENTDIqECTOB CRYCOUNCIL
Steve Voldal 266-8587 ASSIGN � q7yATfORNEY �J C(TYCLEFK
MUST BE ON COUNpL AGENDA BY (DATE) po��FOR O BUOGET DIRECTOR � FW. & MGT. SEflVICES OIFi.
N!A o"o� � �1YOR (OP ASSI5TANT) �
TOTAI # OF SIGNATURE PAGES � (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR Sf6NATURE)
ACTION REQUESTE�:
Approval of Resolution settling the property damage claim of State Farm Insurance as subrogee for Mary and Thomas Scanlan
against the City of Saint Pau! in the amount of 57349.52.
RECOMMENDA710N5� Approve iA) or Rejeti (ii7 pERSQNAL SERVICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER THE FOILOWING QUESTIQNS:
_ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVICE GOMMISSIpN �- Has mis personlFirm ever worked under a contract for this department?
_ CIB CAMMfTTEE _ YES NO
_ SiaFF 2. Has this personftifin evef bean a ciry emplOyee?
— YES NO
_ DISiA1C7 COURi _ 3. Ooes this pefson(tirm possess a skill not normally possessed hy any cunent ciry empluyee4
SUPPORTSWHICHCWNCILOBJEC71VE4 YES NO
Explatn all yes answers on separate sheet and attaeh to green aheet
INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNYTY (Wlro, Wliet Whan, NTere, Why):
On December 10, 1996 a City of Saint Paul police car, driven by Joseph Jenkins, pulled from a private drive into Robert Street,
colliding with a 1992 Honda Civic, owned and driven by Thomas Scanlan. Mr. Scanlan was proceeding south on Robert Street
a�d braked his vehicle in an attempt to avoid coiliding with the police car. As a resuit of the coilision, Mr. Scanlan's vehicle was
a total loss. I have reached a settlement with his insurance carrier in the amount of 57,349.52.
ADVANTAGES IFAPPROVEO'
RECE�YFD
APR 0 9 i997
�r1Yf} i � OFFiC�
DISADVANTAGES IF APPflOVED:
"^3.. � �:�� dva}? @'d n ..E
.. _, ._.; P {'� �..,A�:.-
� n ���
� u _ _„ , dcSVB
OISADVANTAGES IF PWT APPflOVE�: - ' ' ' ' ' " � �
7349.52
TOiAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETEp (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO
FUNDIfiG SOURCE GL 001 TOrt Lidbilfty ACTIVITY NUMBER 09081
FINANCIAL INfORFnAT10N: (EXPLAIN}
f;lusers\ga ugha n\wpfiles\resoladm\gmsht.wDd