97-424-�l'� �J .
Covncil File # _l��
Green Sheet # � ��
, , ._. . ,., . ., RESOLUTION
�- __ CI F SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA / C�
� � �
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
RESOLVED, that, upon execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint Paul,
the proper City officers are hereby authorized and directed to pay from the Tort Liabiliry
Fund, 09081-0511, to Michael and Melinda Miller, the sum of $10,000.00 in full settlement of
their claim for damages as a result of the City's replacement of the sanitary sewer line on
Highland Parkway in 1994.
Requested by Department oE
Adopted by Council: Date �� �,4, _ �q q r'(
T
Adogrion Certified by CouncIl Secretary:
By� � a . ,....�
� / r
Approved by Mayor: ate �f f 3�! y-
By:
echnolo and Mana ement Servic
By: V� ��'t�_ �
Form A ioved by Ciry Atqorngy; �����
1 / /1 /1�+
By: tit�x :
�-
Apg by M apor for Su�n to Council
By: !�=-��
�����������
Technology & Mgmt ServiceslRisk Mgmt
Steve Voldal 266-8887
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
3%Z�r97 GREEN SHEET
INRIAUDATE—
� DEPARTMEM DiRECTOR
�+�N � cmxrroaNer
IBEN FON
TNG O BUWETfIIRECfOR
�� � MAYOR (OR ASSISTAN'n
(CIIP AlL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
MRIAUOATE
CT' COUNCIL
cm c�eaK
FlN. & MGT. SERVICES OIR.
Approval of Resolution settling the property damage claim of Michael and Melinda Miller against the City of Saint Paut in the
amount of 570,000.00.
MMENDATfONS: Approvo (A) or Raj[
PUINNING COMMISSION _
Cf8 CAMMITfEE _
STAFF !
01STRlCT C�URT _
CIVIL SEHVICE COMMISSION
OBJECln/E?
PERSONAL 3ERVECE CONTflACTS MUST ANSWER TFfE fOLLOWING pUEST10N5:
7. Has Ynis person/firm ever worked under a contract for this tlepartmen[?
YES NO
2. Has this person�rm ever been a ciry employee?
YES NO
3. Does this persoNfirm possess a skili not normaily possessed Dy any current ciry employee?
YES NO
Explain all yes answero on separate sheet antl ettaeh to grean shaet
:IATIrvG PROBIEM, ISSUE, OPP6IRTUNITY (Wlw, Wfiat, when, Where. Why):
As a result of the City replacement af a section of sanitary sewer during the Summer of 1994, the ground water was ailowed to
return to its natural state. The Miller's sewer service line was be{ow this natura{ ground water level and, due to some cracks on
their sewer line, the grou�d water caused a backup of the Miller's sewage. In order to repair their sewer Iine, extensive
dewatering activities were necessary. This greatly increased the cost of repair. The bill was in excess of $30,000. The Miller's
attorney has negotiated a compromisa of that bill. The City of Saint Paul will pay 570,000, and the Miller's will pay 59,000. In
addition, the Milier's agree to release the City of Saint Paul from any further claims they may have as a result of this incident.
IF APPflWED:
? � a�i s..>" �•'w
�lA.R 2� 1997
-:,E ��=r=;�
���rti.��-- ' '
,
���, .. -- _. ti.� ��;�
r�
`.!'iC i � F`���
- _.... __ _,._..,c.���: °
10,000,00
JTAI. AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION $
INDItAG SOUpCE GL 001 Tort Liabifity
IANCIAL WFORk�AtION� (EXPLAIN)
t:�users\gaughanlwpfileslresoiadmlgrnsht. wpd
COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (C1RClE ONE) YES NO
ACTIVITV NUMBER 09081
-�l'� �J .
Covncil File # _l��
Green Sheet # � ��
, , ._. . ,., . ., RESOLUTION
�- __ CI F SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA / C�
� � �
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
RESOLVED, that, upon execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint Paul,
the proper City officers are hereby authorized and directed to pay from the Tort Liabiliry
Fund, 09081-0511, to Michael and Melinda Miller, the sum of $10,000.00 in full settlement of
their claim for damages as a result of the City's replacement of the sanitary sewer line on
Highland Parkway in 1994.
Requested by Department oE
Adopted by Council: Date �� �,4, _ �q q r'(
T
Adogrion Certified by CouncIl Secretary:
By� � a . ,....�
� / r
Approved by Mayor: ate �f f 3�! y-
By:
echnolo and Mana ement Servic
By: V� ��'t�_ �
Form A ioved by Ciry Atqorngy; �����
1 / /1 /1�+
By: tit�x :
�-
Apg by M apor for Su�n to Council
By: !�=-��
�����������
Technology & Mgmt ServiceslRisk Mgmt
Steve Voldal 266-8887
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
3%Z�r97 GREEN SHEET
INRIAUDATE—
� DEPARTMEM DiRECTOR
�+�N � cmxrroaNer
IBEN FON
TNG O BUWETfIIRECfOR
�� � MAYOR (OR ASSISTAN'n
(CIIP AlL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
MRIAUOATE
CT' COUNCIL
cm c�eaK
FlN. & MGT. SERVICES OIR.
Approval of Resolution settling the property damage claim of Michael and Melinda Miller against the City of Saint Paut in the
amount of 570,000.00.
MMENDATfONS: Approvo (A) or Raj[
PUINNING COMMISSION _
Cf8 CAMMITfEE _
STAFF !
01STRlCT C�URT _
CIVIL SEHVICE COMMISSION
OBJECln/E?
PERSONAL 3ERVECE CONTflACTS MUST ANSWER TFfE fOLLOWING pUEST10N5:
7. Has Ynis person/firm ever worked under a contract for this tlepartmen[?
YES NO
2. Has this person�rm ever been a ciry employee?
YES NO
3. Does this persoNfirm possess a skili not normaily possessed Dy any current ciry employee?
YES NO
Explain all yes answero on separate sheet antl ettaeh to grean shaet
:IATIrvG PROBIEM, ISSUE, OPP6IRTUNITY (Wlw, Wfiat, when, Where. Why):
As a result of the City replacement af a section of sanitary sewer during the Summer of 1994, the ground water was ailowed to
return to its natural state. The Miller's sewer service line was be{ow this natura{ ground water level and, due to some cracks on
their sewer line, the grou�d water caused a backup of the Miller's sewage. In order to repair their sewer Iine, extensive
dewatering activities were necessary. This greatly increased the cost of repair. The bill was in excess of $30,000. The Miller's
attorney has negotiated a compromisa of that bill. The City of Saint Paul will pay 570,000, and the Miller's will pay 59,000. In
addition, the Milier's agree to release the City of Saint Paul from any further claims they may have as a result of this incident.
IF APPflWED:
? � a�i s..>" �•'w
�lA.R 2� 1997
-:,E ��=r=;�
���rti.��-- ' '
,
���, .. -- _. ti.� ��;�
r�
`.!'iC i � F`���
- _.... __ _,._..,c.���: °
10,000,00
JTAI. AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION $
INDItAG SOUpCE GL 001 Tort Liabifity
IANCIAL WFORk�AtION� (EXPLAIN)
t:�users\gaughanlwpfileslresoiadmlgrnsht. wpd
COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (C1RClE ONE) YES NO
ACTIVITV NUMBER 09081
-�l'� �J .
Covncil File # _l��
Green Sheet # � ��
, , ._. . ,., . ., RESOLUTION
�- __ CI F SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA / C�
� � �
Presented By
Referred To Committee: Date
RESOLVED, that, upon execution and delivery of a release in full to the City of Saint Paul,
the proper City officers are hereby authorized and directed to pay from the Tort Liabiliry
Fund, 09081-0511, to Michael and Melinda Miller, the sum of $10,000.00 in full settlement of
their claim for damages as a result of the City's replacement of the sanitary sewer line on
Highland Parkway in 1994.
Requested by Department oE
Adopted by Council: Date �� �,4, _ �q q r'(
T
Adogrion Certified by CouncIl Secretary:
By� � a . ,....�
� / r
Approved by Mayor: ate �f f 3�! y-
By:
echnolo and Mana ement Servic
By: V� ��'t�_ �
Form A ioved by Ciry Atqorngy; �����
1 / /1 /1�+
By: tit�x :
�-
Apg by M apor for Su�n to Council
By: !�=-��
�����������
Technology & Mgmt ServiceslRisk Mgmt
Steve Voldal 266-8887
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES
3%Z�r97 GREEN SHEET
INRIAUDATE—
� DEPARTMEM DiRECTOR
�+�N � cmxrroaNer
IBEN FON
TNG O BUWETfIIRECfOR
�� � MAYOR (OR ASSISTAN'n
(CIIP AlL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
MRIAUOATE
CT' COUNCIL
cm c�eaK
FlN. & MGT. SERVICES OIR.
Approval of Resolution settling the property damage claim of Michael and Melinda Miller against the City of Saint Paut in the
amount of 570,000.00.
MMENDATfONS: Approvo (A) or Raj[
PUINNING COMMISSION _
Cf8 CAMMITfEE _
STAFF !
01STRlCT C�URT _
CIVIL SEHVICE COMMISSION
OBJECln/E?
PERSONAL 3ERVECE CONTflACTS MUST ANSWER TFfE fOLLOWING pUEST10N5:
7. Has Ynis person/firm ever worked under a contract for this tlepartmen[?
YES NO
2. Has this person�rm ever been a ciry employee?
YES NO
3. Does this persoNfirm possess a skili not normaily possessed Dy any current ciry employee?
YES NO
Explain all yes answero on separate sheet antl ettaeh to grean shaet
:IATIrvG PROBIEM, ISSUE, OPP6IRTUNITY (Wlw, Wfiat, when, Where. Why):
As a result of the City replacement af a section of sanitary sewer during the Summer of 1994, the ground water was ailowed to
return to its natural state. The Miller's sewer service line was be{ow this natura{ ground water level and, due to some cracks on
their sewer line, the grou�d water caused a backup of the Miller's sewage. In order to repair their sewer Iine, extensive
dewatering activities were necessary. This greatly increased the cost of repair. The bill was in excess of $30,000. The Miller's
attorney has negotiated a compromisa of that bill. The City of Saint Paul will pay 570,000, and the Miller's will pay 59,000. In
addition, the Milier's agree to release the City of Saint Paul from any further claims they may have as a result of this incident.
IF APPflWED:
? � a�i s..>" �•'w
�lA.R 2� 1997
-:,E ��=r=;�
���rti.��-- ' '
,
���, .. -- _. ti.� ��;�
r�
`.!'iC i � F`���
- _.... __ _,._..,c.���: °
10,000,00
JTAI. AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION $
INDItAG SOUpCE GL 001 Tort Liabifity
IANCIAL WFORk�AtION� (EXPLAIN)
t:�users\gaughanlwpfileslresoiadmlgrnsht. wpd
COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (C1RClE ONE) YES NO
ACTIVITV NUMBER 09081