The URL can be used to link to this page

97-360�� ,' � i� � 1'� � �` � i ' �; ��' , , . -.. . . , . .__ Presented By Referred To Committee: Date �5 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, David M. Kroona d/b/a Eastern Heights Amoco (License ID No. 17309), located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a muior. Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the investigation report, and such azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. � r,;;,..; � � ri� z; �;� y # i �� *...' , , i �. - t o �, _ , � _. Requested by Department of: Adopted by Council: Date }�,_ �� J"'l Adoption Certified by Council Secretary Approv�y Mayo� D�k. e � �� By. �V v RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA € �'�, F �_ C011I1C11 File # �' � 0 4 a /� Green Sheet # V � I�� Form Approved by City Attorney By: __��[��G�_� ��c��T_ V Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By: q'1-'� t� DEPMRTMIENTAFFICE/COUNpL DATE INITIATED � V� v,�/ Office of LIEP 3-5-1997 GREEN SHEE CONiAGT PER$ON & PMONE INITIAVDATE IPIRIALIOATE �DEPARTMENTOIRECTOR �CITYCOUNdL RobeitKessler, 266-9112 A��N CRYATfORNEV CT'CLEFK MUST BE ON CAUNCIL AGEN�A BY (OATE) NUNBEH FOR O�� pIflECTOR O FlN. & MGT. SEAVICES DIR. ROU7ING A Ill �L IJ9�I � PI1t1jIC HC ORDER O MAYOR (OR ASSISTAIJn � TOTAL # OF SfGNATURE PAGES (CLiP ALl LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACTION REQUESTE�: Concerning adverse ac6on against licenses held by Aavid M. Kroona, dlbla Eastern Heights Amoco, located at 1785 Suburban Avenue. (Uncontested) RECOMMENDATIONS: Approve (A) or Rejaet (F) pERSONAL SERVICE CANTRACTS MUST A!lSWER THE FOLIOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLANNING COMMISSIQN _ GML SERVICE COMMISSION ti- Has this person7firm ever worked under a contrect for this departme�n? _ CIB COMMITfEE _ YES NO _ STAFF 2. Has this person/Firm ever been a oiry employee? — YES NO _ asTFiICT COURi _ 3. Does this person/firm possess a skill not normally possessetl by any current city employee? SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL O&IECTIVE? YES NO Explain all yes answers on sepa�ate sheet antl attacM1 to green sheet INITIATING PROBLEM. ISSUE, OPPEIRTUNITV (Who, What, When, Where, Why): �'i�31lI1C6� �'a?�'��i.P� �tti�i Ci��t 6 5 €�� ADVANTAGESIFAPPROVED DISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED' DISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVE�' TOTAL AMOUN7 OF 7RANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDIWG SOURCE ACTIVITV NUMBER FINANpAL INFORN7ATION' (EXPLAIN) OFFICE OF Tf� CITY ATTORNEY CITY OF SAINT PAUL Civi7 Division � 1-' ` O Norm Coleman, Mayor 400 City Hall Telephorre: 6I2 ?66-8710 IS West Kel7ogg Blvd Facsimile: 611298-5619 Samt Paul, �nnesata 55102 i February 28, 1997 - ��:; ° �`°'` f `'� "�`��'� � _r . , li � i.�:1 � NOTICfi OF COUNCIL HEARING David M. Kroona Eastern Aeights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119 RE: Cigarette license held by David M. Kroona d/b/a Eastern Heights Amoco for the premises located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in St. Paul License ID No. 17309 � Our File Number: G96-0646 Dear Mr. Kroona: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 4:3� p.m., Wednesday, April 2, 1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be £or a$200.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, , �/G,��.,� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Robert Kessler, Director, Christine Rozek, LIEP Cathy Lue, Community Council, 2090 Conway Council Secretary LIEP Organizer, Dist. 1 Community St., Rm 126, St. Paul, MN 55119 .� UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING � � " � � Licensee Wame: David M. Kroona dib/a Eastern Heights Amoco Address: 1785 Suburban Avenue Council Hearing Dafe: April 2, �1997 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Stat. § 609.685 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Date: November 26, 1996 P{ace: Licensed Premises Presumptive Penatty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Letter of licensee or attorney agreeing not to contest the facts 3. Notice of Violation and folfow-up letter 4. License information 5, Compliance Report 6. City Attorney License Adverse Action Summary �� David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Ave. St.Paul, MN 55119 February 24, 1937 r City of St.Paul-Office of the City Attorney CIvil Division Attn: Vlrginia D. Palmer 400 City Hall 15 West Kellogg Blvd, St.Pau1, MN 55102 Dear Virginia Palmer: FE8 2 S 1997 �� f� q�-��o It has been hrouglzt to my attention that we sold tobacco to a minor on November 2b, 1996. I do not wish to dispute the facts but do ask for leniency in this matter. As you Y.now from your records and compliance checks in the past we have never had a problem at this store. I would ask you to suspend all penaities/fines at this time, and let us use this as an example for our employees on the importance of checking Id's. If you have any questions or concerns please feel free to contact me at 483-1219 David M. Kro OFFICE OP, THE CITY ATTORNEY CITY OF SAINT PAUL Civil Division Na�m Coleman, Mayor 400 City Hall 15 Wes1 Kellogg Blvd Saint PauZ M'mnesom 55102 i February 6, 1997 , NOTIC& OF VIOLATION Mr. David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119 �!• JLO 7'eTephane: 611766-Si10 Facsimile: 612 298-5619 RE: Cigarette lice-:se held by David M. Kroona d/b/a Eastern Heights Amoco for the premises located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in St. Paul License ID No.: 173Q9 Our File Number: G96-06?6 Dear Mr. Kroona: Our office sent you a letter dated December 12, 1996, in which you were notified of a violation involving the sale of cigarettes to a minor on November 26, 1996, at the licensed establishment. The letter asked that you contact this office to let us know whether you disputed that fact. If we have not 1997, we will violation. We the Saint Paul imposed. heard from you in writing by Friday, February 14, assume that you do not intend to dispute the will then schedule this matter for hearing before City Council to determine what penalty will be If you have any questions, I can be reached at 266-8710. Sincerely, � �/��,.�-� �� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorr_ey cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy director, LIEP Cathy. Lue, Community Organizer, Dist. 1 Community Couricil, 2090 Conway St., Rm 126, St. Paul, MN 55119 �(1-�GC STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MATL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on February 7, 1997, she served the attachea NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue St. Paul, MN. 55119 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 7th day of February, 1997. __��'1I� //� Q�#�J ��l� Notary Public o • RITA Rd. SOSSAFD � C � 6SY Pl:vL4G— �r;ii',�:cSGTA 2 ` � RANSEY GOUN�' f $ My Corr,m. Ezpires Jan. 31. 2000 5 � e OFFICF z THE CITY ATTORNEY T+mathy t . .ar,K Ciry Anorney CITY OF SA.INT PAUL crv;iD;�u,o„ Norm Coleman, Mayor 44Q Ciry HaU I S WesJ Kellagg BHd Saint PauZ Mmrresom 55102 r�.��r December 12, 1996 NOTICS OF VIOLATIQN Mr. David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119 a'? -7Co Telephone: b721b6-8i70 Facsim"rle: 672 298-5679 RE: Cigarette license held by David M. Kroona d/b/a Easter Heights Amoco for the premises located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in St. Paul License ID No.: 17309 Dear Mr. Kroona: The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will recommend that adverse action be taken against your cigarette license held at the above-named premises. This recommendation is based on the following: On Novembar 26, 1996, you or another employee sold cigarettes to a minor under the age of 18 years in the licensed premises. This is an offense uader Minn. Stat. §609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the Cit�r Council. You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the Council as to the proper penalCy, if any, to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before an Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross- examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decided the case. If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangborn, within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps to set up that ALJ hearing. Ee can be reached at 266-871Q. Page 1 q�- �c� If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, �- � /� �f��- � �,,.� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City •Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Cathy Lue, Community Organizer, Dist. 1 Community Council, 2090 Conway St., Rm 126, St. Paul, MN 55119 Page 2 q�-�c� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on December 13, 1996, she szrved the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Mr. David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue St. Paul, MN. 55119 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 13th day of December, 1996. ��``. ��.✓�/ i / . . �7 E G. CLE NTS ■ � � RITq A,�. BOSSF.=D NOTAAYPU?LIC—h9;::cSOTA � � RANScY CQU(v7Y . My Comm. ExP�res Jari. 31. 2000 � Lic ID ................... 17309 STAT ..................... AC Business I3ame.._......... KROOI3A, DAVID M Address .................. 1785 SL3BURBAN AVE Zip ...................... 55119 Doing Business As........ EASTERN HEIGHTS AMOCO License Name ............. CIGARETTE . GROCERY (C) . RESTAURANT (A)- ZERO-12 SEATS . GAS STATS013 Exp Date ................. 03/31/97 q'1-��a Insurance Carrier........ Ins. Policy Number....... Insurance Effective Date. Ins. Expiration Date..... NOTE AREA ................ INSP CHANGB FROM O1 TO 02 ON 3/20/92 . 1/1/93 PER BOB - ADD'L GAS PUMP LICENSE ELIMINATED Tax Id ................... 6791901 Worker Comp Exp Date..... 04j01/94 Telephone ................ 735-4282 Press 'C' to continue, `P` to print, or 'R' to redisplay... Alt-Z FOR HELP° VT102 ° FDX ° 9600 E71 ° LOG CLOSED ° PRINT OFF ° ROUTE: # 12 CICTARETTE PREMISE CHECKS INSPECTQR: KRTS SCIIWEINLER q�-'�`D ��j�- WEEK:12/08/96 �� u ' 1. NORTH STAR STEEL �.� � .�,,� �'�: ` �� 1678 RED ROCK RD. �; �., : nc ,LL , .=-._>-- �-- "'-�� , 2. 3 SHAMROCK PLAZA LIQUOR 289 MC KNIGHT RD. S. SIJPERAMERICA #4425 275 MC KNIGHT RA. S. � �� }�- ��`_ 4. HOLIDAY II��?�T EASY GIFT SHOP� " 2201 BURI�IS AVE. � =1 _ r�'� �� .. 5, HU�.IDAY I'v1 - SAl?vT PAU7 E.4ST �..-- J201 BUFtIvTS AVE. �,� � _ ��, �"�' �___ 6. f �-- 7. � s. � � 9. � � 10. � a � � _ 11. �� 12. -,----- 13. OLSUN'S IiWII� FOflD i��ART 277 RUTH ST. �. Si�TYAER DRUG `�I'�`� IS9CSI3BUIZBANAV�.C+�c�<k �;z �� BY�P.LY' S ` � ` 1959 SUBURBAN AVE. ��{�el.<,� �� GROt3Nll ROUND �'. Z<-{- 1$25 SUBURB�'iN AVE. �,�_�2 �; y� EASTERN �-3EIGHTS AMOCO 1785 SUBL7RBAN AVE. �"2.n�,.�.'' -- �`"�--�--9 �a� � MGM LIQUOR WAREHOUSE_ , ��-`'�� 275 WHITE $EAR AVE. N. `� "`-'� TARGET STORE #T68 `-f �� I744 SUBiJRBAN AVE. ��-- = �tot `-=�'_=`� `�"` `� . �J MOj3NDS PARK QL'ICK STOP 243 POINT DOUGLAS RD. N. __._e on�: 1 �-(.� nn� NAME OF COMPLIANCE CHECI�R TOBACCO COMPUANCECHECKFORM S � / " �`� v �( �c�.�- 't - �5 ^�TAlf7. D. NUMBER � �x'�� r., t1 r� f: �ti. D n-� t NAME OF OFFlCER 1L . 5- NAME AND ADDRESS OF LICENSED VENDOft I"l �S 5 S��-� 5�.,,.,� l4 u- � G � .� e,._ `1�, �,?� �-' iv�C C � WAS7HE70BACC0-SELFSERVEI ASSISTED2 M SALE WAS MADE YES V N0: BWWD; i,R�'.4L� NAME OF CLERK: SEX: M F: ti� DESCPoP'fION: CHECKABOHiED: YES ADDITIONAL CONMFMS: N0: �� tl �V� � OEC 1 Q �996 ��`�� ►i��RN�Y � .;, � m h O F �{� � V F 4 � � F Z � � ¢ a : µ u � O y R V � Y � � Y �;� a p1 � V 9 i q 4 U �i , � £ O � V � N M1 ii " .,d '� �� o E� e o ° o U » > o > �� 1 ' �g x � i V £ V � � � % � � o � 4 � � � V 5 • O ♦ O W i y 9 W G � O � y $ � i O � V � • > Y. 2 w d o p m � o V 6 2 F �1 � � F Y ; tl � y n 6 O • M1 y n � 4 C M O 2 � V � I � � � � �� 3 x V F � � V � tl � W � C � / � p � U T d . � n M F P O 4 4 S j 2 4 �] �J n in 6 V O F , 6 j £ a � oE S E T�` ° g � V Y� pl P „ N � V F Q N V Qz O�\ g j K P n R� O n S r £ m m in n N �n L 4 W L K K � K �' � n z� z� y 6 6 ` m m o �C 2 m Z � ° � .°. "' 3 � ° � ° �° .°. °' €_� S a e o 0 0 ° o e o a o .�„n oE n`�o ."'..> ..> n a o> n a n> �a ru m o a F . F " „'y "'F `" " ° � � � � � � g . � , � � � woo':"xx�� mx >x ex «x ex �g��E�� N 2 r w n p " o o `Y yO y r y � N 2 N 2 N a a O ¢ o g p � � o a c y � m Z � U N F N y F N F N W 4 n M N 2 � � 2 Z 5� a% o \ Z� V V V V V� b£ u�i V b O O Z 2 Z 5 2 i � � U V Q N 4 4 � � O 2 � w 3 4 O 4 a V u q � w a i � o � V 5 2 4 Y 0 K � F F� � � � � V V V O 6 4 y � O � � N � � U � sa p� O V o m� v � � � y � N a 4 4 Z � 6 Y a !� Z F U U �� V V S N � � � U 4 V q Z „ � a 6 d £ o � �i V � (�i1 w L � � o o e o o o .^,.> . > m> -� �g�� e x m x c x V � V £ V Z ( � � o F � V U Pl F F L S 2 % � � � � � V V V V V 4 a 4 O O V a 4 „ �o � � 6 r O �� H � �e � ss V O � O s O � S a � F � £ � �� o O q�-�GO 2 4 O C � U F � 4 � i F a • � U f � ` p 4 V d pxl � V V V V Y V V V V V w� � l G t ti € t E / � � � tl � � .r a �; V V Z V (j V Vy 4 R Z 2 V �� F d S � Y y �l Q Z Q 4 � i E � � 8 � � � �' �' 8 a � rmo �o � . .. .. � � � � � � � � � � a iu c s rc '� z ` a a u ° � ` i �+ � ti o � z � z " z � z � z � z � z a o t .] b� O 4 O 6 O tu „ 4 O W O O Y V O o F e{-. e F o F a(� a F e E � p o F � o� o 0 0 0 0 0 ° 3 e o e o 0 0 ° o S o r> r> n > H> > > r> o° > o°, a S �'i �� H � eF �y µ y �H �H '€ � , � , , . , . � y � e y x � x p( � x e x � 6 F 4 F 4 F L. G F 4 F M1 F 6 F P 4 4 � U L V£ V L V£ U S U£ V L V i V S Y C � � V 2 � O • F � 4 � � O � W N N G (�il d �N N N V� N N F y F M N F N F � �� 5 2 Z 5 O � 5 � 2� y � V V V V V V U y � F f F F �+ � F M �i O � Z 2 2 Z 2 2 Z 2 2 5 O O i 5 a " �� C � } � � � � j � C � y � � aq � k a V �U � � f3 V V � V � 1 O • V U V V U V V V V U F p � W 4 = • i � c o '" o � � � v � `� � � � u y �.'"i i. �� r g a �7 u �. �` .�. .. � ° .". b � m R " 2 g g �p : `� p u� 6 6 o P � y b � n ul rf �� m P N �� O O N q 6 �°�� o: o: �k o ES�' o ga g �"a R tio" �� a� s,°� :� o �� H�"� a $ � �� m� �� m �� ° �� Y i 4 � 4 F 4 � V � Y x � w � w � � � U q � '' �^ i y � � � � � � y N� �� .. » � . � � �� a a a p � i Z O 4 O � 2� � O o O o p ° o > .,^. > > "H _�% �� , . r x � 4. E M1 F W� 9 V S U£ V£ 2 � a o 0 F N F F Z Z � V � V V Z y y 2 � � � � � � � � V U U V � s rv �' a � ° v S V V y Z L o � r w 08 �� y n N 0 8 rri � a.�. 9 .� ao � x y Y 4� y 3 4 � C � V P q�1-3Go � a�: F • Z 4 � O 6 • V F � f 2 � q a O U F O ` O � :� � � w � � � o u � � � � � � ia �� a a E C o �� [`��'� �� a� � � �v ~ F � M „ � .�l y F �c � � , M 4 „ „ � „ � � � a � y g ., � n � � $ � � 8 � � �S � o � � � E � � 8 � �� ,� e � " � � ��w � ., e � � a m z z a z u � w � � a X� a w n n � 0 a ° a a � �'i ' z z � z � a � o � z . z � o � a � z m o � o � o � o v 4 a N � C p O 4 O M1 M 4 p 4 Y O O R Z � V$ o F o N o 4 o F a l+ O F � D H o I+ o F o F o F o H °S oS '3 °3 °3 °3 °3 °5 e3 03� °3 °5 oS o.�. o 0 0 o e w o w o o e o o w a o a o e w o 0 0 0 e a » > rv > ° a �° > rv > ° n > ° n > .> > .;; > �°. > n > m a . �� 'g - w �H �y N �" �y `�h 'y 'y �w N o", - w » � d . . , , , . ; �x :x rx �x �� K �x hx e ;x :x ek � i� i� i� i� a� i F u: � i� i� w� n: � o: � . V ' ti i ti z ��i u i ti ti� u� � i ��x v`s' � Ss ti i v 0 i � u z ; o • F � 4 r � g £ � £ � O O� � O O P C � � �O O W � V y N E F 4 I �{� N N F F y F F ^ �� V O � O V � � � O O V O �� Q F � F O F Y F Z f f (+ F �F � z z z � i z z z z i ° a ° z z u 0 > `� m u :� � � � � � � g "^ : � � a � � � � +� �P • V V V V V V V • Y • 4 Y S v � O , 8 ,��. : y a 8 F X O �� Z r 2 � Y F 4 � �� Y o§ i y 42 ° m «� � ° � � � p . � � � � �' � � 8 o � o � �� o� y -� a 0 1 m } V N � � � x 3^� x 5 y � � � � � � � � . � i> n � i� i� Fi � � f+ a o a o.�. o � C G k k C � � � � � � � U V U V U U V 4 K �! V K 4 � Y � � y O � s i � N.l Y 4 9 6 q m b � � � c » � �� h � � � � � � �� ° �g �� N N ' ,'o� ° z m o z z z F F Q L 3 C 2 V W a G G 4 �� w o 4.. "� o'. � 8 8 a P �� w �� O O W F � 2 4 � O G • � F , 4 4 � F 2 • � 6 i � O U W � � 4 U C ` V U V W V U N u V U V V U � 3 5 ° � � b � � � � c � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 8 z s ' '' i s � { p s o U V u � � � � � V V � V V V � � n n N n n n n ti n \ n . � n Z 4 N� 4 K y u n p y M 6 � M1 a N � 6 t6 � i „ q�„ 2 O R 2 � H � O � O µ H � M Z » � O � O 6' � O� O Z 0 O Y � !+ � M o F O F o F o E N F o F a N o N g F O F � F S oSoS •S °3 °S S5 e5 05 °5 0� 0303 03 �= o . o 0 0 0 0 o r = o . o . o 0 o e o 0 o e . o 0 0 . o y[. > ° e > w > ° n 5 ° n > ° n > ° o > o a » > o > m s � o > {� .�°. > ° o > � r� N N � �v M µ N ,+ N y N � N � W m% N N a� N S � N in 2 � M g V 2� n N i .� n ra n H n .� n .. 6 O n �v r1 b n � n m m � m n u N m n n a y w. a. a� a", w� a: w: a. a °," a 03 e^,. o^, : {� a� N �!+ d Y Y F G F Y F R F O� F L F 4 F 0.� 41 F o O 6 F i F M1 F a ;� �i$�ix � S o� �i�s v S �i$ d� o� �i$ .��.> o�� ua � t � � � z � i �� : � c o q 0 0 � c � o a c � � � V F F F N y F m y F fi � � � F m � 1 � 2 OZ � o O Z � V V � S V V V V V V U f b+ � � F� F F� F F Z F F O � � 2 5 2 i Z 2 � 2 2 S Z 2 Y O � i y 2 O 4 � O � � C � � C � � � k C � �° � � � � a � � � � � � � � � B o . �„ � � c � � � c � G � � � 4 N 5 4 u O G Z �u" ry V � F s M1 A • > � �1 [� 6 � m 0 4 ; Q Ei .i V� u 4� 4� � s V ui � co � y Y � i � � n � G O . K� P V �l .r y O y` � a z � a o o G� „ �� x Q o a o a a F °9e�'' � _ �" � � $ 5.. - `' "> H °.''. o e � � � : a .i a m � { � y "' c a - `� „ � °' F a r ' ;� �,� .l P . Y > Fz q S y P N C Y n� � Z Q O S 3� Y� Q �� F � U gS N V p O S p 3 • O� Q Y �� y j Y � F� O W Z Q Y � 5 fN6J y 2 O � O �l 4 �l N O> q � f�i� O�� f�i. 4 � V V 6 V S U F � N S N ��l S S � q S C P o� f =a 00 �� a� E 2 � 6 u � � FE z . . y � o � V V V U V V V U N V V N ; � � � b � � � "� a � e � � § ; � � � � § � � � � � � � � � a E a � V � � � � E � �� 6 V � V O � V � V O V V y 9 8 a � ,°� � � e p n � � � � � ' u N � a n � L+. S m � p a ry a i .] I.�i �� O 6 O 0. p S O � O � O��`1 L H � w >� � Z p � V O o F e Y o(� o F F o Y o H O 5 0� o� o� a 3 C �� o 0 0 0 0 0 ' 3 ' o = o a" F e o � o o� o 0 S h �> l�a > N> rv> o> 1�a > w j 4 tt> o> . �'� - H �F �y �y �n", ��", �g �F �� y � � u � »x rK �x �x h. �K�gg� .x �x "u �, � �� a� �� ° � , � � z o � a' a ��: �; G � � G G � N � N IN N � N F F N y � i 8 � {� 8 [. � � {� E 8 � p 8 8 { � 8 p � pp � 2 2 S Z 2 2 n Z Z 5 Y S 0 i O > � ? � 4 q�-7 � a �� o� m o � � 50° � m a ° °z� m z s » a � z n o e > « �x �� :� � � � � � � � � � � � = o , � � � c � c � � c � � � S 'l F � q � � � a 0 � N p � � m £ � m y � O � ~ Z � „ W 6 o n 4 w 0 • ° ° � " � ° � o H � F m .. � 5 p �i � N o`�� " �� " -t $' o �� $� m� � � H � ~ [y £ O S� ? 0 � , � H U 4 N W F J U u � � p m � y y a q Z ¢ $ y 6 i � p y � .T� 5 M N a 6 i G> s i 5 Z y �r �2 h F n S �1 �2 ?�J y.] 7 � F % F � F 2 � V U V 'o m 0 � d O p � U � V a o za oo: �� 4 � F 2 • � J 0. N O (J � r � o o w n o 0 0 0 o [J s � x � '�"3�� k a&' . . z g 2 F� U l�i G 5 �(u 4 F w V � :�u � � € " �""� �, 3�:�� o �, � „ � € � � °_"�",�a� �� T T V O N y Z o �.i �.i V � w C 4 a 4 V � Fq Z m F 4 5 M A V : S S ` S �] 0. N Y 4 4� ^ K � � O P O N� � o V V 0. V LL K O F � 4 6� V F N O V F 4 � a � � � � a" o � m a 3 a m� N V v a r 4 O N � �� n � ... ` m� m a� �a��°�.g :�Se� .. � a � � � � � a � � " � � � � H � � < a°;aoa� °o "� "� �% �o do Y V O t-� O F a F O F a H � 4(yl o Q o� F� � � v � O O O o O o O o O M p� � a O S F Q>� Y N> N 7 ✓ryi > y o> M> �. � n N H Hn . F . N . N S �. o y N �' N Z 2 a �2 Y 6 i � � � J N � � ; N M� N% �n %� n% V% Y� a N v% � m( V F M1 G F L E R . F [ 2 � V y p P d F 4 q F • V£ £ V£ U S V£ i ^+ 3 4 V£ U S O M S N V Z O � 4 �� o 0 0 0 0 o c o V F F E F F F F ^ � ; � � � � , � � � � � • V U V V V V� V � F F O O y O O F F � 2 2 R Z 2 S Z 2 9 O O m � � r V O q�1 _ 7 4 a � � c 6 y N M y V V a � � � 6 F � O o > ua y y m % W M 0. V £ V w r H � 0 0 �+ F Z 2 ; C � � � k G � � � w �' w ;� � � � � � i � � � � 8 p • V V V V V V S U V V Y O � Z r m � F 4 4 N • Y N � y y� a m N Q �� 0 a p F t 4 � ti V .T O � ~ W g g Y' £ � 4 V N a �� o � z� S "' ° o s ° z .�. i �;,a� � �y a fo o "s o� �� 4 � y ry G V U � V .G+ m o V;£� � y m N j 2 4 4 n i� � .l r�l y q 9 O�w � N S N ZI w 0 ''� V Y N >> S o:� �3�§ � :� � x 4 � �� ? 8 • O� O Q � 4 U S b O� u O j F N O o p £ i > a .' � � o . ° a ff .a � x .`�i $ ° ."i a ,yi P a�; �. E 4 • O 0 � V F 4 .] � 4 r F 2 � � 6 � i � o' u F O \ \ 4 V . � Y ]C Y Y Y w E c �u € a � �u , � �u 8 y � a 'd� � � � 'd� � � � � 8 '' z V a a u `s `s '' � 8 g � 8 8 � V c Y N V � � u�i .� n �+ u�i n n � .1 .�i � Z C � 6 � C � � K O C a o � o � : � : � o � o � : � g � o � o � o t �o ao � o ?� V$ F o F F O F � F o f � F o F a F � F o F � C � S ' ."S o � ' .'S o S ' S o S ' .`S : S ° o .S ' . a o e o . o 0 0 . o � o 0 0 0 0 � o 0 0 S y � > r > o > ° n a o > i > ° n > ° r > o > r > M u� N N N � N N N � F N N � N N N N N � N y N � V y � � i � � r � � � � a X [a „¢ t� % �' % m% w X u� % N M a� % t- % y ; F 4 F 0.[+ 4 F b[�+ 6 F 4 i�^ m P � m F fu N a ' x� � i u i u i d� u� o i �� c�i � � i � a' O t � u Z � O • F r 4 � G � p Y � O m m G G �� W G � P G� � F F y N M F y F " � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V F � Z � 2 2 Z 2 Z 2 y $ O � O 7 � 9 Y � O a�-�c.o U a V � E � w � � � a n d z p z s U V V ti W a C N : � "� ">o �a D O o O o O � > n � n > . N N N � N a. c u c n G °� q ° a � [ 4 £ V £ U £ Y 4 W N N N � � � V V V F 2 Z � � k C � � k � k k � � � . » � � � � 3� � � � � � � � P r , w j O � U V V V V V V V V V V V 3 O C F y � £ V � � R� S � m v � a . a S y a" o � m H i z m z z c ci v m � �O �, a ° d a „ . " � �a � o o � µ S �£ ' � � ° Q .`. �" o y $ ° o � . o '„�' $ ti � m u m o m� f° " `d o " � vi �.a F Q ti N d. o .�+ � � � � � A K . �� O � y N v � H � v O O� Fn 4 U H v� ¢� � tl F ,� £ W 4 m y�� ; r N ;� � . � � �� o� � W o d � O N � Y �� J J � � q � X t F 4 N > >">a , � �i� �8 �o fx Eo €8 $ �m �� C � V W d w c � �H u �� d� P � o�: a 4 � o O r V F 4 � r F z 3 ° a � 4 v w �S F O 4 V � V U U Y X ; � � (] V V a � € � � t � � � � � � � a ' � c 8 8 � � € � n � � � � � � � N § a a a a a ' � � � � � � s a m N w w ° o m o n o i o M V O o 4 o F c 4 e H a F a F p o� o 0 0 0 ° o 0 0 0 0 �o ° �o � yy r> rv> ei> n �°.> � 1 n�� N N N N � N N N N N N N Y u � � � � � � U � x x x x � i� G i�� i� i� a� i� oN � 4£ V£ V£ V£ U£ U F < F U O , 4 �� , O {? 5 O . � 5 � . � ; O � O �� G G G � m H � ;� � � � � � : � � � � � � 8 � . 3" „ > e ? 0 " o ;� � k � � � o� ;� � � � � � � G • V V V V V U � � � O C � 4 a W � • > : � 4 � .�. � o ,�;"� � � �� R � �o °o'�W;S� � 88 G C �ti � i z s " N r � n w�L �� G� 5�� 4 �� q'1-1to o n o O O .�i O a y Y X � �€ � � �€ b b � a �a � � i � � � � � Q � � a � 6 E E " � � E ° � a � � d a � i � � � � �„ � �„ w �� o O o O O p O p o O � O O O » > � S �°, > a i n > » > ° e > ,°+ > �n N � R N F » F N N � N N M N N % % % % X X % q �( 6 Q a � U S U Z V£ V£ V£ V£ G£ V£ � V � a o � o 4 c I � ° � 0� % F N H u N F � H V � £ �U �U � � U a F � 6 O O O O O O 2 u 2 2 2 5 2 2 � V µ s 0 � u u u � a � � � � � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V V � � a n m � � s o 8 � " 8 o ; �m � � � a � u o o a a ' N Q �] � C � O 4 m 4 � � � � V � y V � V Y C C U F � 2 a � Z � U 8 '��d � 3 � 3 q m ` � " c ° F o�'i o n 2� �� rc o rc z c� � F P o� F 2 4 O } 0 U f 4 � F Z a � a m .. m � n ° 2 � � � V �] 8 V V „ O V a�-7�o V U V V u � V^ u V U V N � i � � � , a � a � b t € � � Z Z Z V Z y F V N V � Y Y F „ a F F � „ � � R � £ M1 6 6 X ' 6 p £ ; , £6 £ V V V V V � V�l V V V � U n M \ \ O \ n in m N .y n vi V n b m .+ n 2 C 2 � � 6 W C n W W u 6 6 � � � ° � � a d ` � � � m � j � o � z � Q � H 6 0 � M � M � M � o � � � Q � „ � o � � ��E °5 05 ° .5 °3 05 05 °5 03 0� �S e5 05 ° .3 � o 0 0 0 0 0 0 o N w = o . o o o 0 0 0 0 p � Z r> .;:> n a �°+> > > > ° o> 1"na �> .;:> ° i � y .. y � N � F .. F �n F � ti �� N N N N N ' N N N N tl a � � � � i i u y x x x x x x x x � o: � u: � m� o: � i� u: � i� a e: P p i� i� c: � V� n �°� u� u a' u i ti i ti i ti`Y � v E ti i ti`� u`� � z � 0 � y 4 F U 5 � E a : � O : u m ° v u U F F 4 F w I � y Y a � V V V S e ; � � z : � e 0 i 0 > z � a" � � � � �t � � U U V V � 0 � O V > F „ in . �� y � s w..a� � S` �"�' �� ° n � 9 i� j a a �� a ; � � jp �� $g � Y a N r� a�1 �� "�m g€ �� >">. .�F� �� y w� u� ° �n � ° ° m m w m ° y � � m H h ,{'i m `r.'� � ° � 8 � ° E E � E � � z � � � x � � � � � � � � � � 3 � � V U V V 4 : o „ � � � ' o 0 y - � y 0 0 0 � � � U N M m E 4 o �� o � 6 y S a P !�i J y �2 k' Sl �� o� yy G � � � � � � V V V 4 0 0 � 3 ° S m S ; � y e N V 4 V a 55 S5 5 � � � � � �y �� ' � � V U y N � � " � 'a y a a o J i � � o � �� P q1-�co K 2 4 O o V f i 4 � � N 2 � 3 6 i � { O u U F� O ` Q � � � y . � � V V V V U U V V U V N � Of .] V � � � � ♦ � V � � � �� u F j X „ F � � V � 4 4 p „ �] �I �l ri n S �l V £ V � V , , E 'g � � � � � � � � � O �� . ., a � � .. � � .. ., � � e � . � � � : � � a a ° a' z s p`z H � o ° i o °' o � o � o � w � o � o m o � o � o "' o s�d V$ F o F o F O F F o F E F o F o E O F O p O H O F �E 5 eS o3 °3 e3 `3 oS e3� °S °5 °3 0 .:s o e o 0 0 . o 0 0 . o 0 0 0 0 0 0' o 0 � > » > n > o > °� > o > » > ° n > ,°. y ° e > � i� y .: H a g N N �� .�i '�"w `w �v �u �° N n 4 -y M % % % % % X % % M M % % m n� � 2 V S V S V£ V E V S V S V S V Y V£ U£ V S V£ ¢ S O Y a ti � � e 0 m > z � n a o� �9 J O � Y � � . oy ��, �" :� ° o: � �:�' ea M1 7 4 ° u ° m r°u o c F F F F F F M � � � � � � � 8 8 � � R F O O O O O 2 2 Y 2 y 5 2 N a i � O F F E F 8 F Z Z F F F � � � U U V M f ° z ° z z � � � � G � � � G � k k � � � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V V 4 V U V m O u � � r N Y n j o� � �� o� � � � '� Ha - � ' � . . � �" � o �� ° 8� a., `o H� a� �8 �� y'� H�� a3 :�f g� $� g� � o% � � � � o m a � m � � 5 � � i � �� ; �; � y � � j �� m � �� p O O y � � F 0 N C M m y �� 0 m n £p O F � n 4 V � V � 4 3 H S N F C.� f s 'n � �� a g�: Z t. a P r � � : 4 � : F Z � 3 � �t � O V N � � � 6 U O 2 V U U F c � � 0 � £ I � � Z � Z � Z Y � V 4 « Y E i. � a ia � s � 00 � F O � m � � � � 7 V w �p e C 6 0. a w � � o � � � o y s o� os os �� o0 00 � � > > n s V � n M n N N N m % O M v % 6 F 4 F W 4 i U £ U £ U £ Z r F 6 � � � a p � r i r �: F " � � � 8 � � � � ffi . z z z � 0 Y N V L1 0 � O y L1 F W F F � � w � U � � Q � V V V > N 4 4 � � � � � „ m � � u i �Q i a tu n � �,c � C O� a � f � O � � V � � ~ � f � � � O m � O K 5 S as� ;� � ��s �;s 0 ct'1-'� c. ° Y �� ,' � i� � 1'� � �` � i ' �; ��' , , . -.. . . , . .__ Presented By Referred To Committee: Date �5 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, David M. Kroona d/b/a Eastern Heights Amoco (License ID No. 17309), located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a muior. Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the investigation report, and such azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. � r,;;,..; � � ri� z; �;� y # i �� *...' , , i �. - t o �, _ , � _. Requested by Department of: Adopted by Council: Date }�,_ �� J"'l Adoption Certified by Council Secretary Approv�y Mayo� D�k. e � �� By. �V v RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA € �'�, F �_ C011I1C11 File # �' � 0 4 a /� Green Sheet # V � I�� Form Approved by City Attorney By: __��[��G�_� ��c��T_ V Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By: q'1-'� t� DEPMRTMIENTAFFICE/COUNpL DATE INITIATED � V� v,�/ Office of LIEP 3-5-1997 GREEN SHEE CONiAGT PER$ON & PMONE INITIAVDATE IPIRIALIOATE �DEPARTMENTOIRECTOR �CITYCOUNdL RobeitKessler, 266-9112 A��N CRYATfORNEV CT'CLEFK MUST BE ON CAUNCIL AGEN�A BY (OATE) NUNBEH FOR O�� pIflECTOR O FlN. & MGT. SEAVICES DIR. ROU7ING A Ill �L IJ9�I � PI1t1jIC HC ORDER O MAYOR (OR ASSISTAIJn � TOTAL # OF SfGNATURE PAGES (CLiP ALl LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACTION REQUESTE�: Concerning adverse ac6on against licenses held by Aavid M. Kroona, dlbla Eastern Heights Amoco, located at 1785 Suburban Avenue. (Uncontested) RECOMMENDATIONS: Approve (A) or Rejaet (F) pERSONAL SERVICE CANTRACTS MUST A!lSWER THE FOLIOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLANNING COMMISSIQN _ GML SERVICE COMMISSION ti- Has this person7firm ever worked under a contrect for this departme�n? _ CIB COMMITfEE _ YES NO _ STAFF 2. Has this person/Firm ever been a oiry employee? — YES NO _ asTFiICT COURi _ 3. Does this person/firm possess a skill not normally possessetl by any current city employee? SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL O&IECTIVE? YES NO Explain all yes answers on sepa�ate sheet antl attacM1 to green sheet INITIATING PROBLEM. ISSUE, OPPEIRTUNITV (Who, What, When, Where, Why): �'i�31lI1C6� �'a?�'��i.P� �tti�i Ci��t 6 5 €�� ADVANTAGESIFAPPROVED DISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED' DISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVE�' TOTAL AMOUN7 OF 7RANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDIWG SOURCE ACTIVITV NUMBER FINANpAL INFORN7ATION' (EXPLAIN) OFFICE OF Tf� CITY ATTORNEY CITY OF SAINT PAUL Civi7 Division � 1-' ` O Norm Coleman, Mayor 400 City Hall Telephorre: 6I2 ?66-8710 IS West Kel7ogg Blvd Facsimile: 611298-5619 Samt Paul, �nnesata 55102 i February 28, 1997 - ��:; ° �`°'` f `'� "�`��'� � _r . , li � i.�:1 � NOTICfi OF COUNCIL HEARING David M. Kroona Eastern Aeights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119 RE: Cigarette license held by David M. Kroona d/b/a Eastern Heights Amoco for the premises located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in St. Paul License ID No. 17309 � Our File Number: G96-0646 Dear Mr. Kroona: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 4:3� p.m., Wednesday, April 2, 1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be £or a$200.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, , �/G,��.,� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Robert Kessler, Director, Christine Rozek, LIEP Cathy Lue, Community Council, 2090 Conway Council Secretary LIEP Organizer, Dist. 1 Community St., Rm 126, St. Paul, MN 55119 .� UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING � � " � � Licensee Wame: David M. Kroona dib/a Eastern Heights Amoco Address: 1785 Suburban Avenue Council Hearing Dafe: April 2, �1997 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Stat. § 609.685 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Date: November 26, 1996 P{ace: Licensed Premises Presumptive Penatty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Letter of licensee or attorney agreeing not to contest the facts 3. Notice of Violation and folfow-up letter 4. License information 5, Compliance Report 6. City Attorney License Adverse Action Summary �� David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Ave. St.Paul, MN 55119 February 24, 1937 r City of St.Paul-Office of the City Attorney CIvil Division Attn: Vlrginia D. Palmer 400 City Hall 15 West Kellogg Blvd, St.Pau1, MN 55102 Dear Virginia Palmer: FE8 2 S 1997 �� f� q�-��o It has been hrouglzt to my attention that we sold tobacco to a minor on November 2b, 1996. I do not wish to dispute the facts but do ask for leniency in this matter. As you Y.now from your records and compliance checks in the past we have never had a problem at this store. I would ask you to suspend all penaities/fines at this time, and let us use this as an example for our employees on the importance of checking Id's. If you have any questions or concerns please feel free to contact me at 483-1219 David M. Kro OFFICE OP, THE CITY ATTORNEY CITY OF SAINT PAUL Civil Division Na�m Coleman, Mayor 400 City Hall 15 Wes1 Kellogg Blvd Saint PauZ M'mnesom 55102 i February 6, 1997 , NOTIC& OF VIOLATION Mr. David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119 �!• JLO 7'eTephane: 611766-Si10 Facsimile: 612 298-5619 RE: Cigarette lice-:se held by David M. Kroona d/b/a Eastern Heights Amoco for the premises located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in St. Paul License ID No.: 173Q9 Our File Number: G96-06?6 Dear Mr. Kroona: Our office sent you a letter dated December 12, 1996, in which you were notified of a violation involving the sale of cigarettes to a minor on November 26, 1996, at the licensed establishment. The letter asked that you contact this office to let us know whether you disputed that fact. If we have not 1997, we will violation. We the Saint Paul imposed. heard from you in writing by Friday, February 14, assume that you do not intend to dispute the will then schedule this matter for hearing before City Council to determine what penalty will be If you have any questions, I can be reached at 266-8710. Sincerely, � �/��,.�-� �� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorr_ey cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy director, LIEP Cathy. Lue, Community Organizer, Dist. 1 Community Couricil, 2090 Conway St., Rm 126, St. Paul, MN 55119 �(1-�GC STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MATL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on February 7, 1997, she served the attachea NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue St. Paul, MN. 55119 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 7th day of February, 1997. __��'1I� //� Q�#�J ��l� Notary Public o • RITA Rd. SOSSAFD � C � 6SY Pl:vL4G— �r;ii',�:cSGTA 2 ` � RANSEY GOUN�' f $ My Corr,m. Ezpires Jan. 31. 2000 5 � e OFFICF z THE CITY ATTORNEY T+mathy t . .ar,K Ciry Anorney CITY OF SA.INT PAUL crv;iD;�u,o„ Norm Coleman, Mayor 44Q Ciry HaU I S WesJ Kellagg BHd Saint PauZ Mmrresom 55102 r�.��r December 12, 1996 NOTICS OF VIOLATIQN Mr. David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119 a'? -7Co Telephone: b721b6-8i70 Facsim"rle: 672 298-5679 RE: Cigarette license held by David M. Kroona d/b/a Easter Heights Amoco for the premises located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in St. Paul License ID No.: 17309 Dear Mr. Kroona: The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will recommend that adverse action be taken against your cigarette license held at the above-named premises. This recommendation is based on the following: On Novembar 26, 1996, you or another employee sold cigarettes to a minor under the age of 18 years in the licensed premises. This is an offense uader Minn. Stat. §609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the Cit�r Council. You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the Council as to the proper penalCy, if any, to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before an Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross- examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decided the case. If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangborn, within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps to set up that ALJ hearing. Ee can be reached at 266-871Q. Page 1 q�- �c� If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, �- � /� �f��- � �,,.� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City •Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Cathy Lue, Community Organizer, Dist. 1 Community Council, 2090 Conway St., Rm 126, St. Paul, MN 55119 Page 2 q�-�c� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on December 13, 1996, she szrved the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Mr. David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue St. Paul, MN. 55119 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 13th day of December, 1996. ��``. ��.✓�/ i / . . �7 E G. CLE NTS ■ � � RITq A,�. BOSSF.=D NOTAAYPU?LIC—h9;::cSOTA � � RANScY CQU(v7Y . My Comm. ExP�res Jari. 31. 2000 � Lic ID ................... 17309 STAT ..................... AC Business I3ame.._......... KROOI3A, DAVID M Address .................. 1785 SL3BURBAN AVE Zip ...................... 55119 Doing Business As........ EASTERN HEIGHTS AMOCO License Name ............. CIGARETTE . GROCERY (C) . RESTAURANT (A)- ZERO-12 SEATS . GAS STATS013 Exp Date ................. 03/31/97 q'1-��a Insurance Carrier........ Ins. Policy Number....... Insurance Effective Date. Ins. Expiration Date..... NOTE AREA ................ INSP CHANGB FROM O1 TO 02 ON 3/20/92 . 1/1/93 PER BOB - ADD'L GAS PUMP LICENSE ELIMINATED Tax Id ................... 6791901 Worker Comp Exp Date..... 04j01/94 Telephone ................ 735-4282 Press 'C' to continue, `P` to print, or 'R' to redisplay... Alt-Z FOR HELP° VT102 ° FDX ° 9600 E71 ° LOG CLOSED ° PRINT OFF ° ROUTE: # 12 CICTARETTE PREMISE CHECKS INSPECTQR: KRTS SCIIWEINLER q�-'�`D ��j�- WEEK:12/08/96 �� u ' 1. NORTH STAR STEEL �.� � .�,,� �'�: ` �� 1678 RED ROCK RD. �; �., : nc ,LL , .=-._>-- �-- "'-�� , 2. 3 SHAMROCK PLAZA LIQUOR 289 MC KNIGHT RD. S. SIJPERAMERICA #4425 275 MC KNIGHT RA. S. � �� }�- ��`_ 4. HOLIDAY II��?�T EASY GIFT SHOP� " 2201 BURI�IS AVE. � =1 _ r�'� �� .. 5, HU�.IDAY I'v1 - SAl?vT PAU7 E.4ST �..-- J201 BUFtIvTS AVE. �,� � _ ��, �"�' �___ 6. f �-- 7. � s. � � 9. � � 10. � a � � _ 11. �� 12. -,----- 13. OLSUN'S IiWII� FOflD i��ART 277 RUTH ST. �. Si�TYAER DRUG `�I'�`� IS9CSI3BUIZBANAV�.C+�c�<k �;z �� BY�P.LY' S ` � ` 1959 SUBURBAN AVE. ��{�el.<,� �� GROt3Nll ROUND �'. Z<-{- 1$25 SUBURB�'iN AVE. �,�_�2 �; y� EASTERN �-3EIGHTS AMOCO 1785 SUBL7RBAN AVE. �"2.n�,.�.'' -- �`"�--�--9 �a� � MGM LIQUOR WAREHOUSE_ , ��-`'�� 275 WHITE $EAR AVE. N. `� "`-'� TARGET STORE #T68 `-f �� I744 SUBiJRBAN AVE. ��-- = �tot `-=�'_=`� `�"` `� . �J MOj3NDS PARK QL'ICK STOP 243 POINT DOUGLAS RD. N. __._e on�: 1 �-(.� nn� NAME OF COMPLIANCE CHECI�R TOBACCO COMPUANCECHECKFORM S � / " �`� v �( �c�.�- 't - �5 ^�TAlf7. D. NUMBER � �x'�� r., t1 r� f: �ti. D n-� t NAME OF OFFlCER 1L . 5- NAME AND ADDRESS OF LICENSED VENDOft I"l �S 5 S��-� 5�.,,.,� l4 u- � G � .� e,._ `1�, �,?� �-' iv�C C � WAS7HE70BACC0-SELFSERVEI ASSISTED2 M SALE WAS MADE YES V N0: BWWD; i,R�'.4L� NAME OF CLERK: SEX: M F: ti� DESCPoP'fION: CHECKABOHiED: YES ADDITIONAL CONMFMS: N0: �� tl �V� � OEC 1 Q �996 ��`�� ►i��RN�Y � .;, � m h O F �{� � V F 4 � � F Z � � ¢ a : µ u � O y R V � Y � � Y �;� a p1 � V 9 i q 4 U �i , � £ O � V � N M1 ii " .,d '� �� o E� e o ° o U » > o > �� 1 ' �g x � i V £ V � � � % � � o � 4 � � � V 5 • O ♦ O W i y 9 W G � O � y $ � i O � V � • > Y. 2 w d o p m � o V 6 2 F �1 � � F Y ; tl � y n 6 O • M1 y n � 4 C M O 2 � V � I � � � � �� 3 x V F � � V � tl � W � C � / � p � U T d . � n M F P O 4 4 S j 2 4 �] �J n in 6 V O F , 6 j £ a � oE S E T�` ° g � V Y� pl P „ N � V F Q N V Qz O�\ g j K P n R� O n S r £ m m in n N �n L 4 W L K K � K �' � n z� z� y 6 6 ` m m o �C 2 m Z � ° � .°. "' 3 � ° � ° �° .°. °' €_� S a e o 0 0 ° o e o a o .�„n oE n`�o ."'..> ..> n a o> n a n> �a ru m o a F . F " „'y "'F `" " ° � � � � � � g . � , � � � woo':"xx�� mx >x ex «x ex �g��E�� N 2 r w n p " o o `Y yO y r y � N 2 N 2 N a a O ¢ o g p � � o a c y � m Z � U N F N y F N F N W 4 n M N 2 � � 2 Z 5� a% o \ Z� V V V V V� b£ u�i V b O O Z 2 Z 5 2 i � � U V Q N 4 4 � � O 2 � w 3 4 O 4 a V u q � w a i � o � V 5 2 4 Y 0 K � F F� � � � � V V V O 6 4 y � O � � N � � U � sa p� O V o m� v � � � y � N a 4 4 Z � 6 Y a !� Z F U U �� V V S N � � � U 4 V q Z „ � a 6 d £ o � �i V � (�i1 w L � � o o e o o o .^,.> . > m> -� �g�� e x m x c x V � V £ V Z ( � � o F � V U Pl F F L S 2 % � � � � � V V V V V 4 a 4 O O V a 4 „ �o � � 6 r O �� H � �e � ss V O � O s O � S a � F � £ � �� o O q�-�GO 2 4 O C � U F � 4 � i F a • � U f � ` p 4 V d pxl � V V V V Y V V V V V w� � l G t ti € t E / � � � tl � � .r a �; V V Z V (j V Vy 4 R Z 2 V �� F d S � Y y �l Q Z Q 4 � i E � � 8 � � � �' �' 8 a � rmo �o � . .. .. � � � � � � � � � � a iu c s rc '� z ` a a u ° � ` i �+ � ti o � z � z " z � z � z � z � z a o t .] b� O 4 O 6 O tu „ 4 O W O O Y V O o F e{-. e F o F a(� a F e E � p o F � o� o 0 0 0 0 0 ° 3 e o e o 0 0 ° o S o r> r> n > H> > > r> o° > o°, a S �'i �� H � eF �y µ y �H �H '€ � , � , , . , . � y � e y x � x p( � x e x � 6 F 4 F 4 F L. G F 4 F M1 F 6 F P 4 4 � U L V£ V L V£ U S U£ V L V i V S Y C � � V 2 � O • F � 4 � � O � W N N G (�il d �N N N V� N N F y F M N F N F � �� 5 2 Z 5 O � 5 � 2� y � V V V V V V U y � F f F F �+ � F M �i O � Z 2 2 Z 2 2 Z 2 2 5 O O i 5 a " �� C � } � � � � j � C � y � � aq � k a V �U � � f3 V V � V � 1 O • V U V V U V V V V U F p � W 4 = • i � c o '" o � � � v � `� � � � u y �.'"i i. �� r g a �7 u �. �` .�. .. � ° .". b � m R " 2 g g �p : `� p u� 6 6 o P � y b � n ul rf �� m P N �� O O N q 6 �°�� o: o: �k o ES�' o ga g �"a R tio" �� a� s,°� :� o �� H�"� a $ � �� m� �� m �� ° �� Y i 4 � 4 F 4 � V � Y x � w � w � � � U q � '' �^ i y � � � � � � y N� �� .. » � . � � �� a a a p � i Z O 4 O � 2� � O o O o p ° o > .,^. > > "H _�% �� , . r x � 4. E M1 F W� 9 V S U£ V£ 2 � a o 0 F N F F Z Z � V � V V Z y y 2 � � � � � � � � V U U V � s rv �' a � ° v S V V y Z L o � r w 08 �� y n N 0 8 rri � a.�. 9 .� ao � x y Y 4� y 3 4 � C � V P q�1-3Go � a�: F • Z 4 � O 6 • V F � f 2 � q a O U F O ` O � :� � � w � � � o u � � � � � � ia �� a a E C o �� [`��'� �� a� � � �v ~ F � M „ � .�l y F �c � � , M 4 „ „ � „ � � � a � y g ., � n � � $ � � 8 � � �S � o � � � E � � 8 � �� ,� e � " � � ��w � ., e � � a m z z a z u � w � � a X� a w n n � 0 a ° a a � �'i ' z z � z � a � o � z . z � o � a � z m o � o � o � o v 4 a N � C p O 4 O M1 M 4 p 4 Y O O R Z � V$ o F o N o 4 o F a l+ O F � D H o I+ o F o F o F o H °S oS '3 °3 °3 °3 °3 °5 e3 03� °3 °5 oS o.�. o 0 0 o e w o w o o e o o w a o a o e w o 0 0 0 e a » > rv > ° a �° > rv > ° n > ° n > .> > .;; > �°. > n > m a . �� 'g - w �H �y N �" �y `�h 'y 'y �w N o", - w » � d . . , , , . ; �x :x rx �x �� K �x hx e ;x :x ek � i� i� i� i� a� i F u: � i� i� w� n: � o: � . V ' ti i ti z ��i u i ti ti� u� � i ��x v`s' � Ss ti i v 0 i � u z ; o • F � 4 r � g £ � £ � O O� � O O P C � � �O O W � V y N E F 4 I �{� N N F F y F F ^ �� V O � O V � � � O O V O �� Q F � F O F Y F Z f f (+ F �F � z z z � i z z z z i ° a ° z z u 0 > `� m u :� � � � � � � g "^ : � � a � � � � +� �P • V V V V V V V • Y • 4 Y S v � O , 8 ,��. : y a 8 F X O �� Z r 2 � Y F 4 � �� Y o§ i y 42 ° m «� � ° � � � p . � � � � �' � � 8 o � o � �� o� y -� a 0 1 m } V N � � � x 3^� x 5 y � � � � � � � � . � i> n � i� i� Fi � � f+ a o a o.�. o � C G k k C � � � � � � � U V U V U U V 4 K �! V K 4 � Y � � y O � s i � N.l Y 4 9 6 q m b � � � c » � �� h � � � � � � �� ° �g �� N N ' ,'o� ° z m o z z z F F Q L 3 C 2 V W a G G 4 �� w o 4.. "� o'. � 8 8 a P �� w �� O O W F � 2 4 � O G • � F , 4 4 � F 2 • � 6 i � O U W � � 4 U C ` V U V W V U N u V U V V U � 3 5 ° � � b � � � � c � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 8 z s ' '' i s � { p s o U V u � � � � � V V � V V V � � n n N n n n n ti n \ n . � n Z 4 N� 4 K y u n p y M 6 � M1 a N � 6 t6 � i „ q�„ 2 O R 2 � H � O � O µ H � M Z » � O � O 6' � O� O Z 0 O Y � !+ � M o F O F o F o E N F o F a N o N g F O F � F S oSoS •S °3 °S S5 e5 05 °5 0� 0303 03 �= o . o 0 0 0 0 o r = o . o . o 0 o e o 0 o e . o 0 0 . o y[. > ° e > w > ° n 5 ° n > ° n > ° o > o a » > o > m s � o > {� .�°. > ° o > � r� N N � �v M µ N ,+ N y N � N � W m% N N a� N S � N in 2 � M g V 2� n N i .� n ra n H n .� n .. 6 O n �v r1 b n � n m m � m n u N m n n a y w. a. a� a", w� a: w: a. a °," a 03 e^,. o^, : {� a� N �!+ d Y Y F G F Y F R F O� F L F 4 F 0.� 41 F o O 6 F i F M1 F a ;� �i$�ix � S o� �i�s v S �i$ d� o� �i$ .��.> o�� ua � t � � � z � i �� : � c o q 0 0 � c � o a c � � � V F F F N y F m y F fi � � � F m � 1 � 2 OZ � o O Z � V V � S V V V V V V U f b+ � � F� F F� F F Z F F O � � 2 5 2 i Z 2 � 2 2 S Z 2 Y O � i y 2 O 4 � O � � C � � C � � � k C � �° � � � � a � � � � � � � � � B o . �„ � � c � � � c � G � � � 4 N 5 4 u O G Z �u" ry V � F s M1 A • > � �1 [� 6 � m 0 4 ; Q Ei .i V� u 4� 4� � s V ui � co � y Y � i � � n � G O . K� P V �l .r y O y` � a z � a o o G� „ �� x Q o a o a a F °9e�'' � _ �" � � $ 5.. - `' "> H °.''. o e � � � : a .i a m � { � y "' c a - `� „ � °' F a r ' ;� �,� .l P . Y > Fz q S y P N C Y n� � Z Q O S 3� Y� Q �� F � U gS N V p O S p 3 • O� Q Y �� y j Y � F� O W Z Q Y � 5 fN6J y 2 O � O �l 4 �l N O> q � f�i� O�� f�i. 4 � V V 6 V S U F � N S N ��l S S � q S C P o� f =a 00 �� a� E 2 � 6 u � � FE z . . y � o � V V V U V V V U N V V N ; � � � b � � � "� a � e � � § ; � � � � § � � � � � � � � � a E a � V � � � � E � �� 6 V � V O � V � V O V V y 9 8 a � ,°� � � e p n � � � � � ' u N � a n � L+. S m � p a ry a i .] I.�i �� O 6 O 0. p S O � O � O��`1 L H � w >� � Z p � V O o F e Y o(� o F F o Y o H O 5 0� o� o� a 3 C �� o 0 0 0 0 0 ' 3 ' o = o a" F e o � o o� o 0 S h �> l�a > N> rv> o> 1�a > w j 4 tt> o> . �'� - H �F �y �y �n", ��", �g �F �� y � � u � »x rK �x �x h. �K�gg� .x �x "u �, � �� a� �� ° � , � � z o � a' a ��: �; G � � G G � N � N IN N � N F F N y � i 8 � {� 8 [. � � {� E 8 � p 8 8 { � 8 p � pp � 2 2 S Z 2 2 n Z Z 5 Y S 0 i O > � ? � 4 q�-7 � a �� o� m o � � 50° � m a ° °z� m z s » a � z n o e > « �x �� :� � � � � � � � � � � � = o , � � � c � c � � c � � � S 'l F � q � � � a 0 � N p � � m £ � m y � O � ~ Z � „ W 6 o n 4 w 0 • ° ° � " � ° � o H � F m .. � 5 p �i � N o`�� " �� " -t $' o �� $� m� � � H � ~ [y £ O S� ? 0 � , � H U 4 N W F J U u � � p m � y y a q Z ¢ $ y 6 i � p y � .T� 5 M N a 6 i G> s i 5 Z y �r �2 h F n S �1 �2 ?�J y.] 7 � F % F � F 2 � V U V 'o m 0 � d O p � U � V a o za oo: �� 4 � F 2 • � J 0. N O (J � r � o o w n o 0 0 0 o [J s � x � '�"3�� k a&' . . z g 2 F� U l�i G 5 �(u 4 F w V � :�u � � € " �""� �, 3�:�� o �, � „ � € � � °_"�",�a� �� T T V O N y Z o �.i �.i V � w C 4 a 4 V � Fq Z m F 4 5 M A V : S S ` S �] 0. N Y 4 4� ^ K � � O P O N� � o V V 0. V LL K O F � 4 6� V F N O V F 4 � a � � � � a" o � m a 3 a m� N V v a r 4 O N � �� n � ... ` m� m a� �a��°�.g :�Se� .. � a � � � � � a � � " � � � � H � � < a°;aoa� °o "� "� �% �o do Y V O t-� O F a F O F a H � 4(yl o Q o� F� � � v � O O O o O o O o O M p� � a O S F Q>� Y N> N 7 ✓ryi > y o> M> �. � n N H Hn . F . N . N S �. o y N �' N Z 2 a �2 Y 6 i � � � J N � � ; N M� N% �n %� n% V% Y� a N v% � m( V F M1 G F L E R . F [ 2 � V y p P d F 4 q F • V£ £ V£ U S V£ i ^+ 3 4 V£ U S O M S N V Z O � 4 �� o 0 0 0 0 o c o V F F E F F F F ^ � ; � � � � , � � � � � • V U V V V V� V � F F O O y O O F F � 2 2 R Z 2 S Z 2 9 O O m � � r V O q�1 _ 7 4 a � � c 6 y N M y V V a � � � 6 F � O o > ua y y m % W M 0. V £ V w r H � 0 0 �+ F Z 2 ; C � � � k G � � � w �' w ;� � � � � � i � � � � 8 p • V V V V V V S U V V Y O � Z r m � F 4 4 N • Y N � y y� a m N Q �� 0 a p F t 4 � ti V .T O � ~ W g g Y' £ � 4 V N a �� o � z� S "' ° o s ° z .�. i �;,a� � �y a fo o "s o� �� 4 � y ry G V U � V .G+ m o V;£� � y m N j 2 4 4 n i� � .l r�l y q 9 O�w � N S N ZI w 0 ''� V Y N >> S o:� �3�§ � :� � x 4 � �� ? 8 • O� O Q � 4 U S b O� u O j F N O o p £ i > a .' � � o . ° a ff .a � x .`�i $ ° ."i a ,yi P a�; �. E 4 • O 0 � V F 4 .] � 4 r F 2 � � 6 � i � o' u F O \ \ 4 V . � Y ]C Y Y Y w E c �u € a � �u , � �u 8 y � a 'd� � � � 'd� � � � � 8 '' z V a a u `s `s '' � 8 g � 8 8 � V c Y N V � � u�i .� n �+ u�i n n � .1 .�i � Z C � 6 � C � � K O C a o � o � : � : � o � o � : � g � o � o � o t �o ao � o ?� V$ F o F F O F � F o f � F o F a F � F o F � C � S ' ."S o � ' .'S o S ' S o S ' .`S : S ° o .S ' . a o e o . o 0 0 . o � o 0 0 0 0 � o 0 0 S y � > r > o > ° n a o > i > ° n > ° r > o > r > M u� N N N � N N N � F N N � N N N N N � N y N � V y � � i � � r � � � � a X [a „¢ t� % �' % m% w X u� % N M a� % t- % y ; F 4 F 0.[+ 4 F b[�+ 6 F 4 i�^ m P � m F fu N a ' x� � i u i u i d� u� o i �� c�i � � i � a' O t � u Z � O • F r 4 � G � p Y � O m m G G �� W G � P G� � F F y N M F y F " � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V F � Z � 2 2 Z 2 Z 2 y $ O � O 7 � 9 Y � O a�-�c.o U a V � E � w � � � a n d z p z s U V V ti W a C N : � "� ">o �a D O o O o O � > n � n > . N N N � N a. c u c n G °� q ° a � [ 4 £ V £ U £ Y 4 W N N N � � � V V V F 2 Z � � k C � � k � k k � � � . » � � � � 3� � � � � � � � P r , w j O � U V V V V V V V V V V V 3 O C F y � £ V � � R� S � m v � a . a S y a" o � m H i z m z z c ci v m � �O �, a ° d a „ . " � �a � o o � µ S �£ ' � � ° Q .`. �" o y $ ° o � . o '„�' $ ti � m u m o m� f° " `d o " � vi �.a F Q ti N d. o .�+ � � � � � A K . �� O � y N v � H � v O O� Fn 4 U H v� ¢� � tl F ,� £ W 4 m y�� ; r N ;� � . � � �� o� � W o d � O N � Y �� J J � � q � X t F 4 N > >">a , � �i� �8 �o fx Eo €8 $ �m �� C � V W d w c � �H u �� d� P � o�: a 4 � o O r V F 4 � r F z 3 ° a � 4 v w �S F O 4 V � V U U Y X ; � � (] V V a � € � � t � � � � � � � a ' � c 8 8 � � € � n � � � � � � � N § a a a a a ' � � � � � � s a m N w w ° o m o n o i o M V O o 4 o F c 4 e H a F a F p o� o 0 0 0 ° o 0 0 0 0 �o ° �o � yy r> rv> ei> n �°.> � 1 n�� N N N N � N N N N N N N Y u � � � � � � U � x x x x � i� G i�� i� i� a� i� oN � 4£ V£ V£ V£ U£ U F < F U O , 4 �� , O {? 5 O . � 5 � . � ; O � O �� G G G � m H � ;� � � � � � : � � � � � � 8 � . 3" „ > e ? 0 " o ;� � k � � � o� ;� � � � � � � G • V V V V V U � � � O C � 4 a W � • > : � 4 � .�. � o ,�;"� � � �� R � �o °o'�W;S� � 88 G C �ti � i z s " N r � n w�L �� G� 5�� 4 �� q'1-1to o n o O O .�i O a y Y X � �€ � � �€ b b � a �a � � i � � � � � Q � � a � 6 E E " � � E ° � a � � d a � i � � � � �„ � �„ w �� o O o O O p O p o O � O O O » > � S �°, > a i n > » > ° e > ,°+ > �n N � R N F » F N N � N N M N N % % % % X X % q �( 6 Q a � U S U Z V£ V£ V£ V£ G£ V£ � V � a o � o 4 c I � ° � 0� % F N H u N F � H V � £ �U �U � � U a F � 6 O O O O O O 2 u 2 2 2 5 2 2 � V µ s 0 � u u u � a � � � � � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V V � � a n m � � s o 8 � " 8 o ; �m � � � a � u o o a a ' N Q �] � C � O 4 m 4 � � � � V � y V � V Y C C U F � 2 a � Z � U 8 '��d � 3 � 3 q m ` � " c ° F o�'i o n 2� �� rc o rc z c� � F P o� F 2 4 O } 0 U f 4 � F Z a � a m .. m � n ° 2 � � � V �] 8 V V „ O V a�-7�o V U V V u � V^ u V U V N � i � � � , a � a � b t € � � Z Z Z V Z y F V N V � Y Y F „ a F F � „ � � R � £ M1 6 6 X ' 6 p £ ; , £6 £ V V V V V � V�l V V V � U n M \ \ O \ n in m N .y n vi V n b m .+ n 2 C 2 � � 6 W C n W W u 6 6 � � � ° � � a d ` � � � m � j � o � z � Q � H 6 0 � M � M � M � o � � � Q � „ � o � � ��E °5 05 ° .5 °3 05 05 °5 03 0� �S e5 05 ° .3 � o 0 0 0 0 0 0 o N w = o . o o o 0 0 0 0 p � Z r> .;:> n a �°+> > > > ° o> 1"na �> .;:> ° i � y .. y � N � F .. F �n F � ti �� N N N N N ' N N N N tl a � � � � i i u y x x x x x x x x � o: � u: � m� o: � i� u: � i� a e: P p i� i� c: � V� n �°� u� u a' u i ti i ti i ti`Y � v E ti i ti`� u`� � z � 0 � y 4 F U 5 � E a : � O : u m ° v u U F F 4 F w I � y Y a � V V V S e ; � � z : � e 0 i 0 > z � a" � � � � �t � � U U V V � 0 � O V > F „ in . �� y � s w..a� � S` �"�' �� ° n � 9 i� j a a �� a ; � � jp �� $g � Y a N r� a�1 �� "�m g€ �� >">. .�F� �� y w� u� ° �n � ° ° m m w m ° y � � m H h ,{'i m `r.'� � ° � 8 � ° E E � E � � z � � � x � � � � � � � � � � 3 � � V U V V 4 : o „ � � � ' o 0 y - � y 0 0 0 � � � U N M m E 4 o �� o � 6 y S a P !�i J y �2 k' Sl �� o� yy G � � � � � � V V V 4 0 0 � 3 ° S m S ; � y e N V 4 V a 55 S5 5 � � � � � �y �� ' � � V U y N � � " � 'a y a a o J i � � o � �� P q1-�co K 2 4 O o V f i 4 � � N 2 � 3 6 i � { O u U F� O ` Q � � � y . � � V V V V U U V V U V N � Of .] V � � � � ♦ � V � � � �� u F j X „ F � � V � 4 4 p „ �] �I �l ri n S �l V £ V � V , , E 'g � � � � � � � � � O �� . ., a � � .. � � .. ., � � e � . � � � : � � a a ° a' z s p`z H � o ° i o °' o � o � o � w � o � o m o � o � o "' o s�d V$ F o F o F O F F o F E F o F o E O F O p O H O F �E 5 eS o3 °3 e3 `3 oS e3� °S °5 °3 0 .:s o e o 0 0 . o 0 0 . o 0 0 0 0 0 0' o 0 � > » > n > o > °� > o > » > ° n > ,°. y ° e > � i� y .: H a g N N �� .�i '�"w `w �v �u �° N n 4 -y M % % % % % X % % M M % % m n� � 2 V S V S V£ V E V S V S V S V Y V£ U£ V S V£ ¢ S O Y a ti � � e 0 m > z � n a o� �9 J O � Y � � . oy ��, �" :� ° o: � �:�' ea M1 7 4 ° u ° m r°u o c F F F F F F M � � � � � � � 8 8 � � R F O O O O O 2 2 Y 2 y 5 2 N a i � O F F E F 8 F Z Z F F F � � � U U V M f ° z ° z z � � � � G � � � G � k k � � � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V V 4 V U V m O u � � r N Y n j o� � �� o� � � � '� Ha - � ' � . . � �" � o �� ° 8� a., `o H� a� �8 �� y'� H�� a3 :�f g� $� g� � o% � � � � o m a � m � � 5 � � i � �� ; �; � y � � j �� m � �� p O O y � � F 0 N C M m y �� 0 m n £p O F � n 4 V � V � 4 3 H S N F C.� f s 'n � �� a g�: Z t. a P r � � : 4 � : F Z � 3 � �t � O V N � � � 6 U O 2 V U U F c � � 0 � £ I � � Z � Z � Z Y � V 4 « Y E i. � a ia � s � 00 � F O � m � � � � 7 V w �p e C 6 0. a w � � o � � � o y s o� os os �� o0 00 � � > > n s V � n M n N N N m % O M v % 6 F 4 F W 4 i U £ U £ U £ Z r F 6 � � � a p � r i r �: F " � � � 8 � � � � ffi . z z z � 0 Y N V L1 0 � O y L1 F W F F � � w � U � � Q � V V V > N 4 4 � � � � � „ m � � u i �Q i a tu n � �,c � C O� a � f � O � � V � � ~ � f � � � O m � O K 5 S as� ;� � ��s �;s 0 ct'1-'� c. ° Y �� ,' � i� � 1'� � �` � i ' �; ��' , , . -.. . . , . .__ Presented By Referred To Committee: Date �5 RESOLVED, that the Licensee, David M. Kroona d/b/a Eastern Heights Amoco (License ID No. 17309), located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a muior. Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the investigation report, and such azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. � r,;;,..; � � ri� z; �;� y # i �� *...' , , i �. - t o �, _ , � _. Requested by Department of: Adopted by Council: Date }�,_ �� J"'l Adoption Certified by Council Secretary Approv�y Mayo� D�k. e � �� By. �V v RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA € �'�, F �_ C011I1C11 File # �' � 0 4 a /� Green Sheet # V � I�� Form Approved by City Attorney By: __��[��G�_� ��c��T_ V Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council By: q'1-'� t� DEPMRTMIENTAFFICE/COUNpL DATE INITIATED � V� v,�/ Office of LIEP 3-5-1997 GREEN SHEE CONiAGT PER$ON & PMONE INITIAVDATE IPIRIALIOATE �DEPARTMENTOIRECTOR �CITYCOUNdL RobeitKessler, 266-9112 A��N CRYATfORNEV CT'CLEFK MUST BE ON CAUNCIL AGEN�A BY (OATE) NUNBEH FOR O�� pIflECTOR O FlN. & MGT. SEAVICES DIR. ROU7ING A Ill �L IJ9�I � PI1t1jIC HC ORDER O MAYOR (OR ASSISTAIJn � TOTAL # OF SfGNATURE PAGES (CLiP ALl LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACTION REQUESTE�: Concerning adverse ac6on against licenses held by Aavid M. Kroona, dlbla Eastern Heights Amoco, located at 1785 Suburban Avenue. (Uncontested) RECOMMENDATIONS: Approve (A) or Rejaet (F) pERSONAL SERVICE CANTRACTS MUST A!lSWER THE FOLIOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLANNING COMMISSIQN _ GML SERVICE COMMISSION ti- Has this person7firm ever worked under a contrect for this departme�n? _ CIB COMMITfEE _ YES NO _ STAFF 2. Has this person/Firm ever been a oiry employee? — YES NO _ asTFiICT COURi _ 3. Does this person/firm possess a skill not normally possessetl by any current city employee? SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL O&IECTIVE? YES NO Explain all yes answers on sepa�ate sheet antl attacM1 to green sheet INITIATING PROBLEM. ISSUE, OPPEIRTUNITV (Who, What, When, Where, Why): �'i�31lI1C6� �'a?�'��i.P� �tti�i Ci��t 6 5 €�� ADVANTAGESIFAPPROVED DISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED' DISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVE�' TOTAL AMOUN7 OF 7RANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDIWG SOURCE ACTIVITV NUMBER FINANpAL INFORN7ATION' (EXPLAIN) OFFICE OF Tf� CITY ATTORNEY CITY OF SAINT PAUL Civi7 Division � 1-' ` O Norm Coleman, Mayor 400 City Hall Telephorre: 6I2 ?66-8710 IS West Kel7ogg Blvd Facsimile: 611298-5619 Samt Paul, �nnesata 55102 i February 28, 1997 - ��:; ° �`°'` f `'� "�`��'� � _r . , li � i.�:1 � NOTICfi OF COUNCIL HEARING David M. Kroona Eastern Aeights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119 RE: Cigarette license held by David M. Kroona d/b/a Eastern Heights Amoco for the premises located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in St. Paul License ID No. 17309 � Our File Number: G96-0646 Dear Mr. Kroona: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 4:3� p.m., Wednesday, April 2, 1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be £or a$200.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. Very truly yours, , �/G,��.,� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Robert Kessler, Director, Christine Rozek, LIEP Cathy Lue, Community Council, 2090 Conway Council Secretary LIEP Organizer, Dist. 1 Community St., Rm 126, St. Paul, MN 55119 .� UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING � � " � � Licensee Wame: David M. Kroona dib/a Eastern Heights Amoco Address: 1785 Suburban Avenue Council Hearing Dafe: April 2, �1997 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Stat. § 609.685 St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07 Date: November 26, 1996 P{ace: Licensed Premises Presumptive Penatty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 1. Proposed resolution 2. Letter of licensee or attorney agreeing not to contest the facts 3. Notice of Violation and folfow-up letter 4. License information 5, Compliance Report 6. City Attorney License Adverse Action Summary �� David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Ave. St.Paul, MN 55119 February 24, 1937 r City of St.Paul-Office of the City Attorney CIvil Division Attn: Vlrginia D. Palmer 400 City Hall 15 West Kellogg Blvd, St.Pau1, MN 55102 Dear Virginia Palmer: FE8 2 S 1997 �� f� q�-��o It has been hrouglzt to my attention that we sold tobacco to a minor on November 2b, 1996. I do not wish to dispute the facts but do ask for leniency in this matter. As you Y.now from your records and compliance checks in the past we have never had a problem at this store. I would ask you to suspend all penaities/fines at this time, and let us use this as an example for our employees on the importance of checking Id's. If you have any questions or concerns please feel free to contact me at 483-1219 David M. Kro OFFICE OP, THE CITY ATTORNEY CITY OF SAINT PAUL Civil Division Na�m Coleman, Mayor 400 City Hall 15 Wes1 Kellogg Blvd Saint PauZ M'mnesom 55102 i February 6, 1997 , NOTIC& OF VIOLATION Mr. David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119 �!• JLO 7'eTephane: 611766-Si10 Facsimile: 612 298-5619 RE: Cigarette lice-:se held by David M. Kroona d/b/a Eastern Heights Amoco for the premises located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in St. Paul License ID No.: 173Q9 Our File Number: G96-06?6 Dear Mr. Kroona: Our office sent you a letter dated December 12, 1996, in which you were notified of a violation involving the sale of cigarettes to a minor on November 26, 1996, at the licensed establishment. The letter asked that you contact this office to let us know whether you disputed that fact. If we have not 1997, we will violation. We the Saint Paul imposed. heard from you in writing by Friday, February 14, assume that you do not intend to dispute the will then schedule this matter for hearing before City Council to determine what penalty will be If you have any questions, I can be reached at 266-8710. Sincerely, � �/��,.�-� �� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City Attorr_ey cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, Deputy director, LIEP Cathy. Lue, Community Organizer, Dist. 1 Community Couricil, 2090 Conway St., Rm 126, St. Paul, MN 55119 �(1-�GC STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MATL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on February 7, 1997, she served the attachea NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue St. Paul, MN. 55119 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 7th day of February, 1997. __��'1I� //� Q�#�J ��l� Notary Public o • RITA Rd. SOSSAFD � C � 6SY Pl:vL4G— �r;ii',�:cSGTA 2 ` � RANSEY GOUN�' f $ My Corr,m. Ezpires Jan. 31. 2000 5 � e OFFICF z THE CITY ATTORNEY T+mathy t . .ar,K Ciry Anorney CITY OF SA.INT PAUL crv;iD;�u,o„ Norm Coleman, Mayor 44Q Ciry HaU I S WesJ Kellagg BHd Saint PauZ Mmrresom 55102 r�.��r December 12, 1996 NOTICS OF VIOLATIQN Mr. David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55119 a'? -7Co Telephone: b721b6-8i70 Facsim"rle: 672 298-5679 RE: Cigarette license held by David M. Kroona d/b/a Easter Heights Amoco for the premises located at 1785 Suburban Avenue in St. Paul License ID No.: 17309 Dear Mr. Kroona: The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will recommend that adverse action be taken against your cigarette license held at the above-named premises. This recommendation is based on the following: On Novembar 26, 1996, you or another employee sold cigarettes to a minor under the age of 18 years in the licensed premises. This is an offense uader Minn. Stat. §609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the Cit�r Council. You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the Council as to the proper penalCy, if any, to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before an Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross- examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decided the case. If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangborn, within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps to set up that ALJ hearing. Ee can be reached at 266-871Q. Page 1 q�- �c� If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, �- � /� �f��- � �,,.� Virginia D. Palmer Assistant City •Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Cathy Lue, Community Organizer, Dist. 1 Community Council, 2090 Conway St., Rm 126, St. Paul, MN 55119 Page 2 q�-�c� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on December 13, 1996, she szrved the attached NOTICE OF VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Mr. David M. Kroona Eastern Heights Amoco 1785 Suburban Avenue St. Paul, MN. 55119 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 13th day of December, 1996. ��``. ��.✓�/ i / . . �7 E G. CLE NTS ■ � � RITq A,�. BOSSF.=D NOTAAYPU?LIC—h9;::cSOTA � � RANScY CQU(v7Y . My Comm. ExP�res Jari. 31. 2000 � Lic ID ................... 17309 STAT ..................... AC Business I3ame.._......... KROOI3A, DAVID M Address .................. 1785 SL3BURBAN AVE Zip ...................... 55119 Doing Business As........ EASTERN HEIGHTS AMOCO License Name ............. CIGARETTE . GROCERY (C) . RESTAURANT (A)- ZERO-12 SEATS . GAS STATS013 Exp Date ................. 03/31/97 q'1-��a Insurance Carrier........ Ins. Policy Number....... Insurance Effective Date. Ins. Expiration Date..... NOTE AREA ................ INSP CHANGB FROM O1 TO 02 ON 3/20/92 . 1/1/93 PER BOB - ADD'L GAS PUMP LICENSE ELIMINATED Tax Id ................... 6791901 Worker Comp Exp Date..... 04j01/94 Telephone ................ 735-4282 Press 'C' to continue, `P` to print, or 'R' to redisplay... Alt-Z FOR HELP° VT102 ° FDX ° 9600 E71 ° LOG CLOSED ° PRINT OFF ° ROUTE: # 12 CICTARETTE PREMISE CHECKS INSPECTQR: KRTS SCIIWEINLER q�-'�`D ��j�- WEEK:12/08/96 �� u ' 1. NORTH STAR STEEL �.� � .�,,� �'�: ` �� 1678 RED ROCK RD. �; �., : nc ,LL , .=-._>-- �-- "'-�� , 2. 3 SHAMROCK PLAZA LIQUOR 289 MC KNIGHT RD. S. SIJPERAMERICA #4425 275 MC KNIGHT RA. S. � �� }�- ��`_ 4. HOLIDAY II��?�T EASY GIFT SHOP� " 2201 BURI�IS AVE. � =1 _ r�'� �� .. 5, HU�.IDAY I'v1 - SAl?vT PAU7 E.4ST �..-- J201 BUFtIvTS AVE. �,� � _ ��, �"�' �___ 6. f �-- 7. � s. � � 9. � � 10. � a � � _ 11. �� 12. -,----- 13. OLSUN'S IiWII� FOflD i��ART 277 RUTH ST. �. Si�TYAER DRUG `�I'�`� IS9CSI3BUIZBANAV�.C+�c�<k �;z �� BY�P.LY' S ` � ` 1959 SUBURBAN AVE. ��{�el.<,� �� GROt3Nll ROUND �'. Z<-{- 1$25 SUBURB�'iN AVE. �,�_�2 �; y� EASTERN �-3EIGHTS AMOCO 1785 SUBL7RBAN AVE. �"2.n�,.�.'' -- �`"�--�--9 �a� � MGM LIQUOR WAREHOUSE_ , ��-`'�� 275 WHITE $EAR AVE. N. `� "`-'� TARGET STORE #T68 `-f �� I744 SUBiJRBAN AVE. ��-- = �tot `-=�'_=`� `�"` `� . �J MOj3NDS PARK QL'ICK STOP 243 POINT DOUGLAS RD. N. __._e on�: 1 �-(.� nn� NAME OF COMPLIANCE CHECI�R TOBACCO COMPUANCECHECKFORM S � / " �`� v �( �c�.�- 't - �5 ^�TAlf7. D. NUMBER � �x'�� r., t1 r� f: �ti. D n-� t NAME OF OFFlCER 1L . 5- NAME AND ADDRESS OF LICENSED VENDOft I"l �S 5 S��-� 5�.,,.,� l4 u- � G � .� e,._ `1�, �,?� �-' iv�C C � WAS7HE70BACC0-SELFSERVEI ASSISTED2 M SALE WAS MADE YES V N0: BWWD; i,R�'.4L� NAME OF CLERK: SEX: M F: ti� DESCPoP'fION: CHECKABOHiED: YES ADDITIONAL CONMFMS: N0: �� tl �V� � OEC 1 Q �996 ��`�� ►i��RN�Y � .;, � m h O F �{� � V F 4 � � F Z � � ¢ a : µ u � O y R V � Y � � Y �;� a p1 � V 9 i q 4 U �i , � £ O � V � N M1 ii " .,d '� �� o E� e o ° o U » > o > �� 1 ' �g x � i V £ V � � � % � � o � 4 � � � V 5 • O ♦ O W i y 9 W G � O � y $ � i O � V � • > Y. 2 w d o p m � o V 6 2 F �1 � � F Y ; tl � y n 6 O • M1 y n � 4 C M O 2 � V � I � � � � �� 3 x V F � � V � tl � W � C � / � p � U T d . � n M F P O 4 4 S j 2 4 �] �J n in 6 V O F , 6 j £ a � oE S E T�` ° g � V Y� pl P „ N � V F Q N V Qz O�\ g j K P n R� O n S r £ m m in n N �n L 4 W L K K � K �' � n z� z� y 6 6 ` m m o �C 2 m Z � ° � .°. "' 3 � ° � ° �° .°. °' €_� S a e o 0 0 ° o e o a o .�„n oE n`�o ."'..> ..> n a o> n a n> �a ru m o a F . F " „'y "'F `" " ° � � � � � � g . � , � � � woo':"xx�� mx >x ex «x ex �g��E�� N 2 r w n p " o o `Y yO y r y � N 2 N 2 N a a O ¢ o g p � � o a c y � m Z � U N F N y F N F N W 4 n M N 2 � � 2 Z 5� a% o \ Z� V V V V V� b£ u�i V b O O Z 2 Z 5 2 i � � U V Q N 4 4 � � O 2 � w 3 4 O 4 a V u q � w a i � o � V 5 2 4 Y 0 K � F F� � � � � V V V O 6 4 y � O � � N � � U � sa p� O V o m� v � � � y � N a 4 4 Z � 6 Y a !� Z F U U �� V V S N � � � U 4 V q Z „ � a 6 d £ o � �i V � (�i1 w L � � o o e o o o .^,.> . > m> -� �g�� e x m x c x V � V £ V Z ( � � o F � V U Pl F F L S 2 % � � � � � V V V V V 4 a 4 O O V a 4 „ �o � � 6 r O �� H � �e � ss V O � O s O � S a � F � £ � �� o O q�-�GO 2 4 O C � U F � 4 � i F a • � U f � ` p 4 V d pxl � V V V V Y V V V V V w� � l G t ti € t E / � � � tl � � .r a �; V V Z V (j V Vy 4 R Z 2 V �� F d S � Y y �l Q Z Q 4 � i E � � 8 � � � �' �' 8 a � rmo �o � . .. .. � � � � � � � � � � a iu c s rc '� z ` a a u ° � ` i �+ � ti o � z � z " z � z � z � z � z a o t .] b� O 4 O 6 O tu „ 4 O W O O Y V O o F e{-. e F o F a(� a F e E � p o F � o� o 0 0 0 0 0 ° 3 e o e o 0 0 ° o S o r> r> n > H> > > r> o° > o°, a S �'i �� H � eF �y µ y �H �H '€ � , � , , . , . � y � e y x � x p( � x e x � 6 F 4 F 4 F L. G F 4 F M1 F 6 F P 4 4 � U L V£ V L V£ U S U£ V L V i V S Y C � � V 2 � O • F � 4 � � O � W N N G (�il d �N N N V� N N F y F M N F N F � �� 5 2 Z 5 O � 5 � 2� y � V V V V V V U y � F f F F �+ � F M �i O � Z 2 2 Z 2 2 Z 2 2 5 O O i 5 a " �� C � } � � � � j � C � y � � aq � k a V �U � � f3 V V � V � 1 O • V U V V U V V V V U F p � W 4 = • i � c o '" o � � � v � `� � � � u y �.'"i i. �� r g a �7 u �. �` .�. .. � ° .". b � m R " 2 g g �p : `� p u� 6 6 o P � y b � n ul rf �� m P N �� O O N q 6 �°�� o: o: �k o ES�' o ga g �"a R tio" �� a� s,°� :� o �� H�"� a $ � �� m� �� m �� ° �� Y i 4 � 4 F 4 � V � Y x � w � w � � � U q � '' �^ i y � � � � � � y N� �� .. » � . � � �� a a a p � i Z O 4 O � 2� � O o O o p ° o > .,^. > > "H _�% �� , . r x � 4. E M1 F W� 9 V S U£ V£ 2 � a o 0 F N F F Z Z � V � V V Z y y 2 � � � � � � � � V U U V � s rv �' a � ° v S V V y Z L o � r w 08 �� y n N 0 8 rri � a.�. 9 .� ao � x y Y 4� y 3 4 � C � V P q�1-3Go � a�: F • Z 4 � O 6 • V F � f 2 � q a O U F O ` O � :� � � w � � � o u � � � � � � ia �� a a E C o �� [`��'� �� a� � � �v ~ F � M „ � .�l y F �c � � , M 4 „ „ � „ � � � a � y g ., � n � � $ � � 8 � � �S � o � � � E � � 8 � �� ,� e � " � � ��w � ., e � � a m z z a z u � w � � a X� a w n n � 0 a ° a a � �'i ' z z � z � a � o � z . z � o � a � z m o � o � o � o v 4 a N � C p O 4 O M1 M 4 p 4 Y O O R Z � V$ o F o N o 4 o F a l+ O F � D H o I+ o F o F o F o H °S oS '3 °3 °3 °3 °3 °5 e3 03� °3 °5 oS o.�. o 0 0 o e w o w o o e o o w a o a o e w o 0 0 0 e a » > rv > ° a �° > rv > ° n > ° n > .> > .;; > �°. > n > m a . �� 'g - w �H �y N �" �y `�h 'y 'y �w N o", - w » � d . . , , , . ; �x :x rx �x �� K �x hx e ;x :x ek � i� i� i� i� a� i F u: � i� i� w� n: � o: � . V ' ti i ti z ��i u i ti ti� u� � i ��x v`s' � Ss ti i v 0 i � u z ; o • F � 4 r � g £ � £ � O O� � O O P C � � �O O W � V y N E F 4 I �{� N N F F y F F ^ �� V O � O V � � � O O V O �� Q F � F O F Y F Z f f (+ F �F � z z z � i z z z z i ° a ° z z u 0 > `� m u :� � � � � � � g "^ : � � a � � � � +� �P • V V V V V V V • Y • 4 Y S v � O , 8 ,��. : y a 8 F X O �� Z r 2 � Y F 4 � �� Y o§ i y 42 ° m «� � ° � � � p . � � � � �' � � 8 o � o � �� o� y -� a 0 1 m } V N � � � x 3^� x 5 y � � � � � � � � . � i> n � i� i� Fi � � f+ a o a o.�. o � C G k k C � � � � � � � U V U V U U V 4 K �! V K 4 � Y � � y O � s i � N.l Y 4 9 6 q m b � � � c » � �� h � � � � � � �� ° �g �� N N ' ,'o� ° z m o z z z F F Q L 3 C 2 V W a G G 4 �� w o 4.. "� o'. � 8 8 a P �� w �� O O W F � 2 4 � O G • � F , 4 4 � F 2 • � 6 i � O U W � � 4 U C ` V U V W V U N u V U V V U � 3 5 ° � � b � � � � c � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 8 z s ' '' i s � { p s o U V u � � � � � V V � V V V � � n n N n n n n ti n \ n . � n Z 4 N� 4 K y u n p y M 6 � M1 a N � 6 t6 � i „ q�„ 2 O R 2 � H � O � O µ H � M Z » � O � O 6' � O� O Z 0 O Y � !+ � M o F O F o F o E N F o F a N o N g F O F � F S oSoS •S °3 °S S5 e5 05 °5 0� 0303 03 �= o . o 0 0 0 0 o r = o . o . o 0 o e o 0 o e . o 0 0 . o y[. > ° e > w > ° n 5 ° n > ° n > ° o > o a » > o > m s � o > {� .�°. > ° o > � r� N N � �v M µ N ,+ N y N � N � W m% N N a� N S � N in 2 � M g V 2� n N i .� n ra n H n .� n .. 6 O n �v r1 b n � n m m � m n u N m n n a y w. a. a� a", w� a: w: a. a °," a 03 e^,. o^, : {� a� N �!+ d Y Y F G F Y F R F O� F L F 4 F 0.� 41 F o O 6 F i F M1 F a ;� �i$�ix � S o� �i�s v S �i$ d� o� �i$ .��.> o�� ua � t � � � z � i �� : � c o q 0 0 � c � o a c � � � V F F F N y F m y F fi � � � F m � 1 � 2 OZ � o O Z � V V � S V V V V V V U f b+ � � F� F F� F F Z F F O � � 2 5 2 i Z 2 � 2 2 S Z 2 Y O � i y 2 O 4 � O � � C � � C � � � k C � �° � � � � a � � � � � � � � � B o . �„ � � c � � � c � G � � � 4 N 5 4 u O G Z �u" ry V � F s M1 A • > � �1 [� 6 � m 0 4 ; Q Ei .i V� u 4� 4� � s V ui � co � y Y � i � � n � G O . K� P V �l .r y O y` � a z � a o o G� „ �� x Q o a o a a F °9e�'' � _ �" � � $ 5.. - `' "> H °.''. o e � � � : a .i a m � { � y "' c a - `� „ � °' F a r ' ;� �,� .l P . Y > Fz q S y P N C Y n� � Z Q O S 3� Y� Q �� F � U gS N V p O S p 3 • O� Q Y �� y j Y � F� O W Z Q Y � 5 fN6J y 2 O � O �l 4 �l N O> q � f�i� O�� f�i. 4 � V V 6 V S U F � N S N ��l S S � q S C P o� f =a 00 �� a� E 2 � 6 u � � FE z . . y � o � V V V U V V V U N V V N ; � � � b � � � "� a � e � � § ; � � � � § � � � � � � � � � a E a � V � � � � E � �� 6 V � V O � V � V O V V y 9 8 a � ,°� � � e p n � � � � � ' u N � a n � L+. S m � p a ry a i .] I.�i �� O 6 O 0. p S O � O � O��`1 L H � w >� � Z p � V O o F e Y o(� o F F o Y o H O 5 0� o� o� a 3 C �� o 0 0 0 0 0 ' 3 ' o = o a" F e o � o o� o 0 S h �> l�a > N> rv> o> 1�a > w j 4 tt> o> . �'� - H �F �y �y �n", ��", �g �F �� y � � u � »x rK �x �x h. �K�gg� .x �x "u �, � �� a� �� ° � , � � z o � a' a ��: �; G � � G G � N � N IN N � N F F N y � i 8 � {� 8 [. � � {� E 8 � p 8 8 { � 8 p � pp � 2 2 S Z 2 2 n Z Z 5 Y S 0 i O > � ? � 4 q�-7 � a �� o� m o � � 50° � m a ° °z� m z s » a � z n o e > « �x �� :� � � � � � � � � � � � = o , � � � c � c � � c � � � S 'l F � q � � � a 0 � N p � � m £ � m y � O � ~ Z � „ W 6 o n 4 w 0 • ° ° � " � ° � o H � F m .. � 5 p �i � N o`�� " �� " -t $' o �� $� m� � � H � ~ [y £ O S� ? 0 � , � H U 4 N W F J U u � � p m � y y a q Z ¢ $ y 6 i � p y � .T� 5 M N a 6 i G> s i 5 Z y �r �2 h F n S �1 �2 ?�J y.] 7 � F % F � F 2 � V U V 'o m 0 � d O p � U � V a o za oo: �� 4 � F 2 • � J 0. N O (J � r � o o w n o 0 0 0 o [J s � x � '�"3�� k a&' . . z g 2 F� U l�i G 5 �(u 4 F w V � :�u � � € " �""� �, 3�:�� o �, � „ � € � � °_"�",�a� �� T T V O N y Z o �.i �.i V � w C 4 a 4 V � Fq Z m F 4 5 M A V : S S ` S �] 0. N Y 4 4� ^ K � � O P O N� � o V V 0. V LL K O F � 4 6� V F N O V F 4 � a � � � � a" o � m a 3 a m� N V v a r 4 O N � �� n � ... ` m� m a� �a��°�.g :�Se� .. � a � � � � � a � � " � � � � H � � < a°;aoa� °o "� "� �% �o do Y V O t-� O F a F O F a H � 4(yl o Q o� F� � � v � O O O o O o O o O M p� � a O S F Q>� Y N> N 7 ✓ryi > y o> M> �. � n N H Hn . F . N . N S �. o y N �' N Z 2 a �2 Y 6 i � � � J N � � ; N M� N% �n %� n% V% Y� a N v% � m( V F M1 G F L E R . F [ 2 � V y p P d F 4 q F • V£ £ V£ U S V£ i ^+ 3 4 V£ U S O M S N V Z O � 4 �� o 0 0 0 0 o c o V F F E F F F F ^ � ; � � � � , � � � � � • V U V V V V� V � F F O O y O O F F � 2 2 R Z 2 S Z 2 9 O O m � � r V O q�1 _ 7 4 a � � c 6 y N M y V V a � � � 6 F � O o > ua y y m % W M 0. V £ V w r H � 0 0 �+ F Z 2 ; C � � � k G � � � w �' w ;� � � � � � i � � � � 8 p • V V V V V V S U V V Y O � Z r m � F 4 4 N • Y N � y y� a m N Q �� 0 a p F t 4 � ti V .T O � ~ W g g Y' £ � 4 V N a �� o � z� S "' ° o s ° z .�. i �;,a� � �y a fo o "s o� �� 4 � y ry G V U � V .G+ m o V;£� � y m N j 2 4 4 n i� � .l r�l y q 9 O�w � N S N ZI w 0 ''� V Y N >> S o:� �3�§ � :� � x 4 � �� ? 8 • O� O Q � 4 U S b O� u O j F N O o p £ i > a .' � � o . ° a ff .a � x .`�i $ ° ."i a ,yi P a�; �. E 4 • O 0 � V F 4 .] � 4 r F 2 � � 6 � i � o' u F O \ \ 4 V . � Y ]C Y Y Y w E c �u € a � �u , � �u 8 y � a 'd� � � � 'd� � � � � 8 '' z V a a u `s `s '' � 8 g � 8 8 � V c Y N V � � u�i .� n �+ u�i n n � .1 .�i � Z C � 6 � C � � K O C a o � o � : � : � o � o � : � g � o � o � o t �o ao � o ?� V$ F o F F O F � F o f � F o F a F � F o F � C � S ' ."S o � ' .'S o S ' S o S ' .`S : S ° o .S ' . a o e o . o 0 0 . o � o 0 0 0 0 � o 0 0 S y � > r > o > ° n a o > i > ° n > ° r > o > r > M u� N N N � N N N � F N N � N N N N N � N y N � V y � � i � � r � � � � a X [a „¢ t� % �' % m% w X u� % N M a� % t- % y ; F 4 F 0.[+ 4 F b[�+ 6 F 4 i�^ m P � m F fu N a ' x� � i u i u i d� u� o i �� c�i � � i � a' O t � u Z � O • F r 4 � G � p Y � O m m G G �� W G � P G� � F F y N M F y F " � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V F � Z � 2 2 Z 2 Z 2 y $ O � O 7 � 9 Y � O a�-�c.o U a V � E � w � � � a n d z p z s U V V ti W a C N : � "� ">o �a D O o O o O � > n � n > . N N N � N a. c u c n G °� q ° a � [ 4 £ V £ U £ Y 4 W N N N � � � V V V F 2 Z � � k C � � k � k k � � � . » � � � � 3� � � � � � � � P r , w j O � U V V V V V V V V V V V 3 O C F y � £ V � � R� S � m v � a . a S y a" o � m H i z m z z c ci v m � �O �, a ° d a „ . " � �a � o o � µ S �£ ' � � ° Q .`. �" o y $ ° o � . o '„�' $ ti � m u m o m� f° " `d o " � vi �.a F Q ti N d. o .�+ � � � � � A K . �� O � y N v � H � v O O� Fn 4 U H v� ¢� � tl F ,� £ W 4 m y�� ; r N ;� � . � � �� o� � W o d � O N � Y �� J J � � q � X t F 4 N > >">a , � �i� �8 �o fx Eo €8 $ �m �� C � V W d w c � �H u �� d� P � o�: a 4 � o O r V F 4 � r F z 3 ° a � 4 v w �S F O 4 V � V U U Y X ; � � (] V V a � € � � t � � � � � � � a ' � c 8 8 � � € � n � � � � � � � N § a a a a a ' � � � � � � s a m N w w ° o m o n o i o M V O o 4 o F c 4 e H a F a F p o� o 0 0 0 ° o 0 0 0 0 �o ° �o � yy r> rv> ei> n �°.> � 1 n�� N N N N � N N N N N N N Y u � � � � � � U � x x x x � i� G i�� i� i� a� i� oN � 4£ V£ V£ V£ U£ U F < F U O , 4 �� , O {? 5 O . � 5 � . � ; O � O �� G G G � m H � ;� � � � � � : � � � � � � 8 � . 3" „ > e ? 0 " o ;� � k � � � o� ;� � � � � � � G • V V V V V U � � � O C � 4 a W � • > : � 4 � .�. � o ,�;"� � � �� R � �o °o'�W;S� � 88 G C �ti � i z s " N r � n w�L �� G� 5�� 4 �� q'1-1to o n o O O .�i O a y Y X � �€ � � �€ b b � a �a � � i � � � � � Q � � a � 6 E E " � � E ° � a � � d a � i � � � � �„ � �„ w �� o O o O O p O p o O � O O O » > � S �°, > a i n > » > ° e > ,°+ > �n N � R N F » F N N � N N M N N % % % % X X % q �( 6 Q a � U S U Z V£ V£ V£ V£ G£ V£ � V � a o � o 4 c I � ° � 0� % F N H u N F � H V � £ �U �U � � U a F � 6 O O O O O O 2 u 2 2 2 5 2 2 � V µ s 0 � u u u � a � � � � � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V V � � a n m � � s o 8 � " 8 o ; �m � � � a � u o o a a ' N Q �] � C � O 4 m 4 � � � � V � y V � V Y C C U F � 2 a � Z � U 8 '��d � 3 � 3 q m ` � " c ° F o�'i o n 2� �� rc o rc z c� � F P o� F 2 4 O } 0 U f 4 � F Z a � a m .. m � n ° 2 � � � V �] 8 V V „ O V a�-7�o V U V V u � V^ u V U V N � i � � � , a � a � b t € � � Z Z Z V Z y F V N V � Y Y F „ a F F � „ � � R � £ M1 6 6 X ' 6 p £ ; , £6 £ V V V V V � V�l V V V � U n M \ \ O \ n in m N .y n vi V n b m .+ n 2 C 2 � � 6 W C n W W u 6 6 � � � ° � � a d ` � � � m � j � o � z � Q � H 6 0 � M � M � M � o � � � Q � „ � o � � ��E °5 05 ° .5 °3 05 05 °5 03 0� �S e5 05 ° .3 � o 0 0 0 0 0 0 o N w = o . o o o 0 0 0 0 p � Z r> .;:> n a �°+> > > > ° o> 1"na �> .;:> ° i � y .. y � N � F .. F �n F � ti �� N N N N N ' N N N N tl a � � � � i i u y x x x x x x x x � o: � u: � m� o: � i� u: � i� a e: P p i� i� c: � V� n �°� u� u a' u i ti i ti i ti`Y � v E ti i ti`� u`� � z � 0 � y 4 F U 5 � E a : � O : u m ° v u U F F 4 F w I � y Y a � V V V S e ; � � z : � e 0 i 0 > z � a" � � � � �t � � U U V V � 0 � O V > F „ in . �� y � s w..a� � S` �"�' �� ° n � 9 i� j a a �� a ; � � jp �� $g � Y a N r� a�1 �� "�m g€ �� >">. .�F� �� y w� u� ° �n � ° ° m m w m ° y � � m H h ,{'i m `r.'� � ° � 8 � ° E E � E � � z � � � x � � � � � � � � � � 3 � � V U V V 4 : o „ � � � ' o 0 y - � y 0 0 0 � � � U N M m E 4 o �� o � 6 y S a P !�i J y �2 k' Sl �� o� yy G � � � � � � V V V 4 0 0 � 3 ° S m S ; � y e N V 4 V a 55 S5 5 � � � � � �y �� ' � � V U y N � � " � 'a y a a o J i � � o � �� P q1-�co K 2 4 O o V f i 4 � � N 2 � 3 6 i � { O u U F� O ` Q � � � y . � � V V V V U U V V U V N � Of .] V � � � � ♦ � V � � � �� u F j X „ F � � V � 4 4 p „ �] �I �l ri n S �l V £ V � V , , E 'g � � � � � � � � � O �� . ., a � � .. � � .. ., � � e � . � � � : � � a a ° a' z s p`z H � o ° i o °' o � o � o � w � o � o m o � o � o "' o s�d V$ F o F o F O F F o F E F o F o E O F O p O H O F �E 5 eS o3 °3 e3 `3 oS e3� °S °5 °3 0 .:s o e o 0 0 . o 0 0 . o 0 0 0 0 0 0' o 0 � > » > n > o > °� > o > » > ° n > ,°. y ° e > � i� y .: H a g N N �� .�i '�"w `w �v �u �° N n 4 -y M % % % % % X % % M M % % m n� � 2 V S V S V£ V E V S V S V S V Y V£ U£ V S V£ ¢ S O Y a ti � � e 0 m > z � n a o� �9 J O � Y � � . oy ��, �" :� ° o: � �:�' ea M1 7 4 ° u ° m r°u o c F F F F F F M � � � � � � � 8 8 � � R F O O O O O 2 2 Y 2 y 5 2 N a i � O F F E F 8 F Z Z F F F � � � U U V M f ° z ° z z � � � � G � � � G � k k � � � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V V 4 V U V m O u � � r N Y n j o� � �� o� � � � '� Ha - � ' � . . � �" � o �� ° 8� a., `o H� a� �8 �� y'� H�� a3 :�f g� $� g� � o% � � � � o m a � m � � 5 � � i � �� ; �; � y � � j �� m � �� p O O y � � F 0 N C M m y �� 0 m n £p O F � n 4 V � V � 4 3 H S N F C.� f s 'n � �� a g�: Z t. a P r � � : 4 � : F Z � 3 � �t � O V N � � � 6 U O 2 V U U F c � � 0 � £ I � � Z � Z � Z Y � V 4 « Y E i. � a ia � s � 00 � F O � m � � � � 7 V w �p e C 6 0. a w � � o � � � o y s o� os os �� o0 00 � � > > n s V � n M n N N N m % O M v % 6 F 4 F W 4 i U £ U £ U £ Z r F 6 � � � a p � r i r �: F " � � � 8 � � � � ffi . z z z � 0 Y N V L1 0 � O y L1 F W F F � � w � U � � Q � V V V > N 4 4 � � � � � „ m � � u i �Q i a tu n � �,c � C O� a � f � O � � V � � ~ � f � � � O m � O K 5 S as� ;� � ��s �;s 0 ct'1-'� c. ° Y