97-358'� �-; i r- ! r, f P. §
.,� t � - . . a _ . . .,
�
Presented By
Referred To
Counail File # � `� +�S$
Green Sheet # ✓�V ��
MiNNESOTA
Committee: Date
�3
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, River House Corporation d/b/a Buon Giorno Italian
Market (License ID No. 16076), located at 335 University Avenue East in Saint Paul is hereby
ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to
a minor.
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the
Mayor.
This resolution and the action of the Council in flus matter are based upon the facts
contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the investigation report, and such
azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not
contested by the licensee.
Requested by Department of:
��i� �� � ti��
L!i�i��. •
Adopted by Council: Date � a��qr'� Form Approved by City Atto�ney
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary B �/ .� `��,
Y� �/r7���
,.,l� ,,� , J
By:
Approved by Mayor: Date
� By:
Approved by Mayor Eor Submission to Covncil
By:
9�1 - 3S$
DEPAAiMENTOpFFIGE/GOUNGII DATE INITIATED J � � � �
o��ofr.�r 3-5-1997 CREEN SHEE
CONTACT PEpSON & PHONE lNIT1AV�ATE INITIAIIDATE
ODEPARTMENTDIRECTOR �CRYCOUNCIL
Robert Kesslei, 266-9112 �� � Q qN ATfORNEY � qiY CLEFK
MUST BE ON CqUNCIL AGENDA BV (OATE) ROUTNG � BUDGET OIflECTOR � FlN. 8 MGT. SERVICES DIR.
A ril 9 7 OROEN � MpYOR lOR ASSISTAIJn ❑
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (C4IP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
AGIION REQUESTED.
Concerning adverse acrion against licenses held by River House Corporarion, DBA Buon Giorno Italian Market, located
at 335 University Avemxe East. (Uncontested)
RECAMMENDATIONS: Approve (n) m Re�ect (P) pERSONAL SERYICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER TXE FQILQWMG QUESTIONS:
_ PLANNMG COMMISSION _ CIVIL SEqVICE COMMIS$ION �� Has tM5 personRirm ever worked under a coMrad for this tlepartmsM?
_ GBCAMMrt7Ee ,_ YES "NO
_ SiAFF 2. Has this persontfirm ever been a cily empbyee?
— VES NO
_ �I5TRiCi COURT _ 3. Does [his personRirm
possess a skill not normally possessetl by any currant city employee?
SUPPORTS WHICH CAUNCIlO&fECTIYE? YES NO
Explain all yas answers on seperate sheet and attaeh to green sheet
INITIATING Pp00LEM, ISSUE. 9PPOATUNf'tY (Who, Whet, Wheq Where, Why):
ADVANTAGESIFAPPROVED�
D7SADVANTAGE$ IF APPROVED:
������? s:te�::�: �;.. �' �:,�>
�'t;i;'.;: i, � 3�'��
.�..e,..�.xt>�s. .,
�ISAOVANTAGESIFNOTAPPROVED: � � � �
707AL AMOUNT OF TRANSACiION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIHCLE ONE) VES NO
FUNOIf2G SOURCE ACTWITY NUM6ER
FINANCIAL INFORFSA710N' (EXPIAIN)
OFFICE OF TF� CITY ATTORNEY
Peg B'v15 Ciry Attarney
9� - �5$
CITY OF SAIN'I' PAUL Civrl Divirion
Norm Cokman, Mayor 40D Ciry HaA 7elephone: 611266-8710
I S West Kellogg Blvd Facsimik: 6I2 298-5619
Samt Pau� M'mnesaW SSIO2
�� � iA � ,, �
liUiz�,b� C'� �"�:�.'�ie.�. G�iBW`?
March 3, 1997
.�.. .� � � I���
I30TICF OB COVNCIL HEARING
.�
Frank MacKondy
Buon Giorno Italian Market
335 University Avenue East
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
RE: Cigarette license held by River House Corp. d/b/a Buon Giorno
Italian Market for the premises located at 335 University Ave.
East in St. Paul
License ID No. 16076
Our File Number: G97-0092
Dear Mr. MacKondy:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named
establishment has been scheduled for 4:30 p,m., Wednesday, April 2,
1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City
Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents
which will be presented to the City Council for their
consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes
have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the
Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the
penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license
office will be for a$2�0.00 fine.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours
���� � `���„ �
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Sue Vannelli, Community Organizer, Payne Phalen Dist. 5
Planning Council, 1014 Payne Ave., St. Paul, MN 55101
°l'1- 35g
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARfNG
Licensee Name: River House Corporation d/b/a Buon Giorno
italian Market
Address: . 335 University Avenue East
Council Hearing Date: April 2, 1997
Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor
Minn. Stat. § 609.685
St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07
Date: February 4, 1997
Place: Licensed Premises
Presumptive Penafty: $200.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behaif of client, Office
of License, lnspections and Environmental Protection:
$200.00 fine (first offense)
Attachments:
1. Proposed resotution
2. Letter of ticensee or attorney agreeing not to contest the facts
3. Notice of Violation
4. License information
5. Compliance Report
6. City Attorney License Adverse Action Summary
��C�����
g�,.�s�-
FE$ 7 3 1997
�Buon C�iarno
t;��i�.�Qr�
�-� �r
,
�:.. ....�.___.
�/a/��
i/�Y-eti FeCc-ivr%�� y�� /�h`r� /'jih'c� C< u:O�Ti�yl �� �' "�7�
Sc��i1y C, y�z;/� � �c �i?.4v4 �� as ��.�/r' � i�'/✓-�l�G i� Jz Cv
/ / /
CUrriiyrL`7G �S (�'U/7Cc=v/! i✓� Oc4 !2`CrJQ�f f1�/h fi��v Z� � �c ���/��
si�i.nj. o�cr�Y�li�.
�✓rrt�✓G�- <. " G�/�" /' G�c ��r l�c�cs� io / oeu}5�j�i�.
t�%�it ��y� s�//� c;,�:� � /,'a �c �-
d��/C �c�an- �ir� s� �a�,�� r�/ ��.r;h� -7.��
�'-i7y'l'Y2� / �CL"� C�G7�2'yrK �y S. �cc:�� .za'�ii7� , �r 4i7� '
�'' �2 �� 9n� s3rrs� , /' _/J /
�.�„ �?��.�/y�f ✓�al /�'� - ��t�cc=o�
� Gu� /7/3,�� Ct/�� �L /
�` �' �'�cv �Gc �� /°I �l,".hi�
J��l�i� .fe� Gr/G.' (�S(/q�� CY�.yi/ j2f,t/LO � «,� �L�✓�/�G�
�� � ��. �� � ����� � s� ���
tiw� ������ � ����������
�- �o��� ,�i„� �Z,�,�l ���� ��� �� s�� �
��� ��r��oi� G�� ,�u� U,�,� ��
/�� �u�Gl�, w�s ��,•�. �����tiy"y�o�
H�S �JiV/jrT� � F'vf9 - ���I�/7E�97 , l/JErJ ���i',/CS�Xls�l� /J e
� ` ��j.?l /lic� Or�Y:S.t r c'vly�cerX��t'•
��% /J'/.�I-f in �!/J/t .��.� r�c� � �Zc
�. azvt J �. G�� y�Ji G. ���i�zrl 9cc�.�cc� fJr��
/1�cc� crc �i sz C/c•r�.leQ• 7�j¢�,f y � ��
335 UNIVERSiTYAVENUE, EAST • SAINTPAUL, MI N�OT/C5510�� TE�PH0���8�'
�
QFFICF ^ � THE CITY ATTORNEY
CITY OF SAINT PAUL Cndl Divirion
hbrm Coleman, Mayar 400 Ciry Halt
IS Wesr Kel7ogg Blvd
Sarnt Paul, Mrnnesota SSIO2
February 7, 1997
NOTIC& OF VIOLATION
Owner/Manager
Buon Giorno Italian Market
335 University Avenue East
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
q� _ 3s�-
Telephone: 6I1166-Bi10
Facsimite: 672 298-5619
RE: Cigarette license held by River House Corporation d/b/a Buon
Giorno Italian Market for the premises located at 335
University Avenue East in St. Paul
License ID No.: 16D76
Dear Sir/Madam:
The Director of the Of�ice of License, Inspections and
Environmental Protection (LI3P) wi11 recommend that adverse action
be taken against your cigarette license held at the above-named
premises. This recommendation is based on the following:
On February 4, 1997, you or another employee sold
cigarettes to a minor under the age of 18 years in the
licensed premises. This is an offense under Minn. Stat.
�609.685 aad Saiat Paul Legislative Code §324.07.
If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that
effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the City Council.
You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the
Council as to the proper penalty, if any, to be imposed. The
recommendation of,the licensing office is for a$200.00 fine.
If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before an
Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City
will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross-
examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decided
the case. If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant,
Peter Pangborn, within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps
to set up that ALJ r=aring. 'r_e can be reached at 266-8710.
Page 1
9'� -�S�"
If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
�1 j y� ;�
C,�� %z9�vuti� � y � �
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Directcr, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Sue Vannelli, Community Organizer, Payne Phalen Dist. 5
Planning Council, 1014 Payne Ave., St. Paul, MN 55101
Page 2 -
q1 -'.�f'
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COITNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on February 11, 1997, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Owner/Manager
Buon Giorno Italian Market
335 University Avenue E.
St. Paul, MN. 55101
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this llth day of February, 1997.
�/���i� / /! - ��� �l � �/�
� Notary Public �
s �
�� RITA M. SOSSARD
k3.S\ NQikRY PUBUC MIt.t1ES�TA
�� RANsSEY COUNTY
My Camm. Expires Jan.31.2�W
a�-� 3s�
Lic ID ...............•••. 16076
STAT ..................... AC
Business Name............ RIVER HOUSE CORPORATION
Address .................. 335 UNIVERSITY AVE E
Zip ...................... 55101
Doing Business As........ BUON GIORNO ITALIAN MARKET
License Name ............. CIGARETTE
. RESTAUR.ANT (A)- ZERO-12 SEATS
. LIQUOR - OFF SALE
- . GROCERY (D)
. FOOD PROCESSOR TO 2000 SQ. FT.
Exp Date ................. O1/31/98
Insurance Carrier........ PARK GLEN NAITONAL
Ins. Policy Number......_ MNLL97Q2�4
Insurance Effective Date. O1/28/97
Ins. Expiration Date..... O1/31/98
NOTE AREA ................ INSP CHANGE FROM O1 TO 02 ON 3J20f92
. 10395
. 4/10/95 NICHOLAS F. & CATHERINE MACKONDY REMOVED
. AS OFFICERS PER LETTER RECEIVED--LAP-LIC
. 3j27/96 CIG CODE ADDED FR/ID# 72231--LAP-LIC
. 12/11/96 CODE CHAI3GED FR/2467 TO 2667 PER NEW
. ORDINANCE EFFECTIVE 12/23f96 PER GARY PECHMAI3N-LAp
Tax Id ................... 51�8625
Worker Comp Exp Date..... 05f17J94
Telephone ................ 224-1816
TOBACCO COMPLIANCE CI�CK FORM �/ S�
DATE: �il TIME: ��•�. LICENSELD.NUMBII2: � CP C1
NAME OF COMPLIANCE CHECI�RR: i:. �,0. `.A�1rJ Q t'� NAME OF OFFICER: �� Yt S
NAME & ADDRESS OF LICENSED VENDOR: � �!'1 (7 � f, / Yt [� y�0.l,i� ��� YYI fx Y Ir r�
WAS Tf� TOBACCO: SII,F-SIItVE? _ ASSISTID? � _ MACfIIIIE? _
DID TT-IE MACHINE HAVE THE PROPER REMOTE DEVICE7 - .
s.4[.s wAS �E: , yss � xo axarm: y11�� r, ��a � n 't�s
NAA�OFCLERK: � n�.�.�.
� `
DESCRIPTfON: ' ` � 1� = r„ '�.�, },._,'�„
CHECK ABORTED: YES
ADDITIONAL COIvA4ENTS:
NO
SEX: M F '
a'.�J`� .
� . _ s �.
_ 8` ,,;.- Y , t °°
�,` _ •
,� ��. - �fi�- �.;.. .. .
�, �:
K` c „ _
�
�
o�:
�o:
��:
a�:
H 2 �
� � •
a �
O V
S � \
0
�� � �_
V F Y�] y n y Y �
: � a uy.�, m 0�� o C � u g
a� F 0� p: w w o m u ` 6
� 4 � R U w w Y N\ 0 4 Y �
V `l o o- n u� � p v H �£ J
� V V O� „ Q V V 2 6 O U � V
H 4
� � n S O >
r u� w n� r�+ � n�„ Z m n in
O £
i K C C % K
4 W 6 6 q �
` m a � a
� i � P z'i g'6E ° m 4" �
w d �' o � o y � ° w s o 0
� o- o F � f N � Y� 4 e o F e F O F
. ° o o °. o °i �i - 8 ° o 0 0 0 0 0
Y y j a> u N V a V.�+ � � j p> rv>
» y
�� �'`�" �g �yy ea�g< AG �€
� . . ��� "'° �..g , �
�
e
0
.�.
>
�
° v �
E O
O �+
�
• Y
` � o
^ V °i z
E O Q �
v i �
i o n W '
x x o x xx' `� � x x
i�� �� �g�����E�E �� �� ��
Hg�
� " �
� a a �q
z � � m o w r..
F x m y z z i
4
fJ N � LL
o ° g ° ° �
V ? v ur N r ii U N N N
� �' ` W � � �
�ce p p
V a% O O N S V U V
E. � F v 5 � 0. F. F
� us 2 u S i v n p O 2 2 Y
m m
B 3 �3 a
V V U V
�
?
W
N
�
0
� �
£ �
O
4 g V
4 $
�
m
i
3
4 a
G C
4 G
�
�
V
�
a
�
a ° d
0
n
c
R
�
u '
� � � c
V
Z V
4 Z 2 V
4 � 4
u � J
� O
V
a �
at w � 6
� m �Z
�& �� ag 'o
� O o O O O O O
° o> ° n> > .;:>
N F � N N N P y
� x n x e x e x
V£ 4 S U£ V S
P � � O
N N N
8 S � E
H F
z ° z ° z z
� � � �
� � � �
V U U V
�J R 4
N °r °
� � � � � a
� a o 0 0 0
� v
4 0� � �a�' �..
� `.!' `4 $ a
z � � � "
? F t7 � � �
�� �� �� ��
�i'? — �Sd''
�i w
� U
i j
V �
z
� o � o
° e � » >
�g�H
N x .. x
V � L £
� O
N F
� �
M F
° z ° z
� � � �
� � � �
V U V V
� a
E 4
� ° z o
� z
c �
� y � � e
u o � o :
q � � 6 q
a ip 4 E
n� H �+ £ l
y u F � � c
4 Ol 4 4 4 F
A
Z 4
O G �
V F �
a � �
f z .
y � .
7
m �
o � �
0
� � �Y Y . V .O
; a s a � � � � � � ag�
m
� ! � � � � � � � � � � � �
s a � .. a � soa
� � U � � $ a � a ���
��,$
... .. M .. N � .. .. .. :s�
z a
e a z z
ru w m e
w
a z a �
� d � � o � o �a �d ' o � o ? o � o � o `" o
m
� i ' 3 ° 5 ° 5 4 3 °. 3 ° S ° 5 0 5<' 3
�., o 0 0 0 0 o e o = o e o e o
° n > �°. > > n > « > r > s > .°� >
�� `"„ '" y , `" "� y ." .g
V
y , �n % � v % y[ �u % N % �n % ry
4 F 4� M1 F m F C F 6 F 6 f n. F u F 5
� V£ V£ U S V� U S V� V£ V S E 5
2 �
F
K �
� � �
V � F
w
m � N
0
H
z
9
O
y 7
C Z
� O
� W F 0�1 � (�il N Ll �
F N N F F N N � N
o E � � o � o 0 0
V yp
2 x Z 2 4 Z y 2 Z
� F F F F � F
o ^ : � � � � � V
�1 q� � U U V V V V
8
O w K �
•> � 0 6 O N Y V
m N C
„ � o o � � � � o
' � '� M 9 o m ��' u
� " ` � ; § � � � J a � �i $
° y � a° Z�: o a 'o � `�'� F m ` � �' o
6^ N F F F 4�1 U 2 0
�y °� a� =y = �m a
0
9 "
>>� .�° �� �� m� �� m
V 4 �
V
V V V
O
� z
o � �
n � a
8 W � Y
my
�� ��
� 4 V �
� � � � r �
� � �
w w c n m
C�i G � c �
� � � �^
s , � d�
E £ � i N
8 � � �„y
ro a o
"°� .. ,. � a3
a
a a
6 � z
�o ° 'o z mo
03 03 ° .3
; e o = o
",> $ >
v y �. F � F
n % C� %
V £ V £ V £ 2�
m u�1 �
f F ! F
� � � �
� � 8
� O O U
z z z z
Y � � F �
� $ � � �
V 4 V V V
N O
O N
`� p S { � � g z
K V O y 4 V U�
� o S � Q F y z
d 4 £ . !� H r
�� 4 O V 9 F u w
��� �g �� �a
�i � f� U � . 4 � U �
��a�� c� C�
@
�
9�-35�
�
o�:
F i
2 4 .
O G •
U �� �
F �i •
� �
i �
O U
f � � � � � �
4 V
G �
Y X
Y V V U U O D U Y Y y
�, : � � � � � c � : F � � m u � o �€
�
�;� � � � � � ���� � � � � � � �
a a .a .a w u ' i a a a
�;€ � � 8 � 8 E x� m 8 8 � � � £ $
� es��
q . �n � �n n n n n� 17 4 n 'n u n m � m
� ti � r . . n � �
W � � s n 6 � �e a a � � a
� o. � a n a & en z a
7 F ' m N ° i o � w � o � w � w � o � o � F ° o � o � a �` o z
q �� o F o F o H a F o F O p O E F � F o F F O H O F
a � °5 03 °5 °3 °S °5 °5 °3 03 03 ° .3 '3 e5
o; o y o 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 0 0
a> .°.> w i r> ° w > .°.�> . .:> N> w>
S � � Q F y N � � N � � � ti � � � � � � >
q V � N p m N - N n q N N �+ N »
u 0. • � • i i • � • r i �
y C cC C X % % % C X w X %
y , 4. F x{+ R F Y�+ 6 F G + M1 M u. � 4. F s F M E G W� G 6 F 4[� W
9 P �(� S V�S' U i V 1 V£ V 2 V£ V S V.E U Y V S U 1 V£ V
F
t
N
u
z :
o �
F
6
�gi
4 O G P O C � 0� � � p p
L � N N � � N N N N y (Sil � ' N y N 0 N
^ ��U QZ � � V V L V V V V V V y V
U V {� p
� 2 Z L 5 E Z 2 Z L 2 2 2 i 2
C
O
N
0
4l i
>
v Z �
G
� O
I N W Fi F � F F F F F F F !-� �
$ � : � � � � � � � � � � � � a �
Y p • V V V V V G V V V V V
R
� � � 6 p �
O r� x 4 6 >
•> 6 y F � Y� O p
: L y F � y � 3 N �
V V % O T 4 � . � } F K Y w d 0
: Y p� M � 4 W O � � N M V V C Y � p . P G
i Z N % �
u u ol V U
� " � .. � ' � � a . �i o � � :
� 'n � � � o � � . � o � � � �g � M1 � m
O u � Z E F r V � p � O L� G �$ `q � p O� ( '�y •
� .] 4 � V� N � N � w r Z � S Y V� 4 m �
��� ° qg " � o „ � a c z o� m m w a oi z o z z z
� ° , 3 3 � � � ° S� 7 d ° � i ¢ "�� "� ° g a u � a ' q� 8 $ g
o". >> : u o � � i a a� o 0
P
�7 —3S�'
o�
�.
_.
oa:
Si F
<�
2 4 �
n 6 �
a
o�
e�
4 V
� � �
U U ]L Y V U X U Y Y U
€ � � & u c � € � � � � � €
' o
� � m �
� ; � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
$ '' ° x '' n i ' n ' i
� � ° E � 8 g € � 8 � � � g � 8
� �
� � � �" � � a � � = � �
a�fo �� �o �o �� �$ �o �� �a �$ � �x�s ��
V g F � F o N o F F o l+ � N � t o t+ o N o H 4 F O M F
§ x o ° o 3 0 0 � o � o ° o ° o ° 3 0 0 °o o � = 3 0 e 5
� p o 0
� � > ° o > � > r > rv s ° n > o > e i � > n > .^ > n ° o s �°.> > o >
w� N � N N N N N � N y N y N y N n% N N a N 2 � N N i � N
V W � Z
0. � � • • � O �
, X u� F V X 'n X �n % n H % t� M 'a % c X m% o f n X rt M m%
� � o; � u: � r� w� i� i� S o o. m a
� s u� ti i u$ �� �`Y ti S v i ti ti¢ �°� w a ti S ti z u`i
z �
F �
4 •
� £
O �
V
0
�
O
�
>
Y
� O
. o ° 1
S O �
Y T O £
P � J $ m
Q V I y F
� O u
a � �
4
1 �
q>a ,
q� G G Q � � G � � G G
y F f N F F F F y Y y F y
�� 8 ° E E E E E � E ° 8 �
z E � ° z z ° z � ° z i � i ° z s z
4 5
� �
�
V V
�
O
v r n
� � �
2 2 Z
g �S
w
�
�
V
8
3
0
�
�
w � � C � � � k w �
� � � o � � � � � �
V V V V U V V V U V
0 2 0
2G [�• � H ° s
p Po � IX � m V
a � a �
s 5 0 � o a � � N § � z
� m V S y K V O !� .] n N O
p q u m� 9 O a O N
u � _ y � F p �
� N S �� � v F h Y „ f� �n E 0
j 2
8 4 Ll �2 F �� £ p � $ � 4 Q
�� Yq � 6 � �� 4 �y� W N O Y
V' u V£ � F � N 2� S.�1 S i 2 p
�
�
V
Y a
�
F O
O y
F 4
N O
C S
00
:
_ ;
°I�-3s�
�
o�,
=d.
00
�r
a�
F=
�
�:
6 w
O V
N � � `
4 V
¢ 41 N
Y O t� V y
•� V iC ( V W V V u V f O � YJ
: 'c �€ � � � w u� � � � V E o p� �
a g � �d a � ° d �d � > d z d � �d � � ~ r �
S y :� "i � ' a u .a � � g o z a
V � � � � � 8 � � � � � S m ° " 8
H . � o
mza
za o
� e � .. � .. � ., < .. .. . � � a � .,
0
�° e � a � a °� o a � a � e
m
�" � a � �z �z��� �z �z �z �z �:
� r ° s i w " o i o � o a o 0 0�a w o .. o w o m o a o
U O a p F O F e E F o F R Z o(% � F o H F e N
q„ o p a O O d o O � O o p O e] V � o O � O o O o � O O
V � r „ v Y > N Y > O> n> u�i � 4 N Y o> N Y n> a?
F F N � 5 � F u�i F � y � E � S�
� � ° � r .��. N m N " � n u ' � � g � � ."'.
a � � � � � �
Y V
f1 % N% �n % �n % N% vl % N � o rv% !� % v X n X in X
� U£ U S U£ U S V Z U E V S 0.� R U£ V£ U S U£ � U�
O [
F
�� 0 O P O � O
V�� F y N � M
M y
S � � � � � � "E �
U � V U V U U V
W � F F F F �+
O i 2 2 � Z Z 2 v
a
0
0
m :
>
� �
`� o
' i � � � �" � � �
g° � � � 3 � a �
+1 Q O • U U V V C
3^
a o
" � � $ � _ �
q : 0 £
• � � U a d
J � r� � "' y 0
S : S p q
o P��.l � , a � 9 0 4
8 � a $ � � J �
Q " ` � � � � ..
: o � � �y �� ''g �� ��
o->e i� �� �� -;� 5� ��
W � N W
y N vi N
� � � �
V V V V
° z ° z a z
�
�
V
�
� � � � �
� u � � �
5
m �
m � � a o
o � � o g
y`" p" ° m
¢ Y F F C n Q
� � m 3 H
� z � `N � �
N o w a` � y u a
rc rc Q �' v � �
y a y
; ` ^�i i 1 '�S �i N Y
�
8
�
k
�
V
�
m
0
0
e
��
4 v
N
P
\ ( � �i ��
z F a
0 0 �
� � :
4 �
F 2 �
� 6
'1 �
p U m
� � � � �
O \
2 W
W O O� 6
W . [`��?' i� C��✓�j 4 (! � V N
r� � �i y W 6 N N U£ U �l ri � $ a u 6 F F V r � .
y� G 6 a � a � x Pi ����� 3 z m d � 3 � G
�,( mi 4 � V O o�£ y F O 2 V£ O N
Z Z z p�
p � 4 4 4 V Z a 2 v O $ 4 p � V s >
V ��.i a U r] � K H F 6 4/�L w Z m H�� 6 C � 6
� § �i � � ° n m o m R Q m w x `3 o s ° ° Q '� � � �i
n?� 3 4��� F q �� U� Z
` N ` � '� q � � � N $ � � � �O � m �
i n v�i P� m a Fl e 6 V��¢ f�u � F a 4(] 6 Y n m
K
a w a
c
p w
� o- L M Z 4 w
���o�"�.g 'o "o o �F �
� y � O O
Z V� O F a p M� e[+ o F G o F F o F
'J M e .i � ` l a � O y O 3 � Q p � �p �l � �1
� e O o p o O a O a O 2� ry � 9 o O
° > rv > » > i ". > o > �° >
V 2 N N y . F � F N N � N w= o � N N N
W
• i � J N
u� X rv% �n X n% v% �� �1 %
W F W H W� d E+ W� 2 O V 4 e p p p
� ti� ti�x vi� ti x v� i � i �i �ii'
z .
o ,
N �
4 �
� £ G �
y F
C
T � 0
( f
� R 2
O
O W
7
a z :
a
� o
F H
O m V �
y �tl V
e .. u
e
: �
• J O �i S
4 , (� w nf
o a 9 ,�
o � s � m �
o=
:
:;�' .��
4
i > a . � o
O m �
F y
� � O
z � � i
� �
V V
z �
� �
£ �
� N
N C
� �
o�
� �
� N
£ 4
4 �
o E Oo
O �
= o
��
�o
x° ��
f
�
V
O
F
�
V
�
O
£
�
O
m
O
a
x
� u
y
Z
V
9
O
N
5�
i
V V
� € Z
F 4
J ri
� �
C
c
�
4l � 4
Z
� O
e >
us F
%
w � r.
u �` v
� O
N f
O U
F F
2 2
N
� � � U
V V V V
a m w
4 N �
� a � j � a �
n [� j �
V 2
4 £ r £
� O � 4
� K V V P
�� s� �
> 'p
� y � m� po °
ni Y i S Y � O �
P
Z 4
V F �
4 � �
F 2 i
r 6 �
° o u
m � �
F O
4 V
O �
• �
X Y X ✓
V X V y V ` 1
� G �i � " S 6 G E o
�e � � � � � � � � � � a
� � £ � � � a � � � � �
V �
M Y
e� U
� � � .. .�. .� �`n .. N .. .. .". G
d� � a ° � ° n a a °
�` �` °j . � z �` � z z a � z
i ° w o i o � o m x � y r o i o �. o
� � O F a H 4 F a N F o F 4 F o E o F W E O f
§ � 5 °3 03 °3 03 °5 %3 °5 °3 05 °5
: o o a . o 0 0 . o a a . o 0 0 0 0 . o 0 0
" y '" „ y o° > ,.°, s °o > n > ° a > r 5 �4 >^ o° >
b F � N N N � F N N N N N N � t N N y N � f V - N
� ` � • • • r • . � � r �
� % p % X X y % % p y �
� � F W( n F !u F e. F W F W F fu (+ W F W f C E
�� U£ V£ V£ V S V S U£ V� U£ V£ V S
O
K
Y
V =
t� �
4 �
�� � O O C O � O G �
� Ci " N " N N " iA " N
� � � � � � � � � � � �
V q V U V {. U V V V
� 2 2 S 2 2 Z 2 S 2 3
0
O
7 W •
2 �
9
n O
� • •���
� `� V
G G t
� � �
a
° � gi
V U
m a a
� z �Z
' o � M i o
00 00 00
K > N > tt >
a N N N N N
�e X N v � %
U £ V S V £
� � m
N H ryF N
2 2 2
V V U
t p
Z Z 2
� W F F � � F � H F � � �
g` � � � � � � � � � � �
� p • V V U V f/ C V
� e m n y c m
.. o m � m i x u 'o � s o .
•> Q m � m z m � � '..` d".. �
� s `� o � e m ° � F °�
N y K W Q R d N Q y C j � N �
u u o�� O V Q � e 7 i O . a S U � Q
5 V O W U � y u� V m
� 4� w a o G`$ �$[ M N � � m n p 6 � r
� V i Z F 4 Z U N 9 � F ,� 4 N �� 3 V � ~
a w r a 4 i £�� m � j v
M�� � F O Z a K N �£ � 2� � T� y - O N V u
F j
"ia . � �� �8 �� f� �o �8 € $m �`�'A o-� �
H
�
V
a
m
C
�
R N
��
4 N
4
9� - �Sg'
�
o�
2 4
O [.. G
V F
4 ]
F 2
� 6
a
o u
4 U
C
% X
r 4 U X Y X
; � � � V V , � j V
m� m u w t E �i
� � � � � � � �
� � 3 , i i i
V � £ S L
' 8 8 � 8 8 E
h �
� s z " z a N
m
� 6 m � � y 6
: � Z � � �
C �l N 4� p tu O � O 4 O 4 O � O
� �i ° .5 ° .5 e5 ° .S °5 ° .5
� o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
� � � r > n > » s n > $ > rv >
N n� N N y N �� V - N N � F /1 N N
Y u � � � � � • �
V � e` X n% n% �v X N%
.� � U£ V£ V S V� U£ V S
�
R
F
V
Q
F
4 �
� Y � O O � O O O
�; N W 4 � F N
^ I � � � � � �
:s a a s s �
� F F F F M l+
� 2 Z Z 2 2 2
P
O
�
O
>
y 2 �
O
n Q
: � � � k w �
q � , � � � � � �
� p � V V U V U V
�
�o � e � � � o
•> � j 4 V V Z �
✓ n
� {� y N d p N
a� �� 2 4 � F F 2
` � � £ ' £ y q � �y b �
n I n O„ i m £ q m n Y
0 0� � O O � S P
�Z ��„� S 8 8 G C Y x
O ~ ryryry N S ��j � � ry
u u � F N
9 O H .] i f� S� y � 2
O • p � y .i � �
� i 6 � m V i? a a i 6 4 � 1 4
U V V U V V % Y
� � ° € c � t�i G
� � � � � � � �
i Y
� � �` 8 � � � �
o a a a a m n
� i m � a f� a
"' o °' o m o 4 o m o °' o � o � o
eS o3 .3 ° 5 ° 5 05 oS �5
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.: > » > s rv i �°. s � > ° o > rv >
- u v � N N H w H • E w F � vHi
�a Y a X % V M % N%� n X N X
d l+ b F 4 q f b� 4 F C{ M F fu H
V� V£ V£ U� U� V S U£ V£
3
V
q � y � C � O O 0
N t N N N oi N
� . � � � � � � �
V �£ V V V la V
,F� P � F F H f�+ (+ f
Z ° z z i z z
�
c
�
V
n
W
� �
� O
� � k � � � k
� � � � � v �
V V V V V V V
�
V O C � n O
O � 6 a O 4 f O
4 O u � 4 N �
„ +] � 4� � O 3
X U� 0 4 m n
O 4 � � V � �G O
}; E
% ( F 4N1 �. � �a `� �£ N
d U Y x o- V >� 3 4 3
e F �
V V 9 ¢ Y N N tl m ¢ S K
O 0. a� e� � u C O C S C v y N
4
q�-35 �
� F
2 } 6 r
V F
4 � �
� 6
O U
W �
F O
6 (1
�
� �
�
V .]
V
�] N ' ~ O
V O t+
O u � o O
U
y y rv >
F i � F
V �
• V S
U
w
G
�
J
O
U
6 O
0 4
a
n N
�
V �
V U V � U V �� l V U f W
� � � 'c � . �b � � a � � e �
� � � � � � �a � � � � �
> � £ a �
V O £ p O � O p�G � O E V V
V V V V�l U
V i
` O � �
N N m r� n N u+ V n V m n .y
0. N � � M1 W 6 p p � 6
y 2 6 � d Z � � 2 Z y z
� N W O 6 O r O � Y � a � � O �� 6 O m O �
'� °. 3 0 5 0 3 °. 5 ° 3 °� o S o 5 0 5 °. 5
O p o O O O • O o O � O e � O O o O a O
� rv> N 7 o S rv> �a > N 7 ��ia 7 H> n>
� H M f .. y tn F � N � N � F N N N N F N
i
n% tv X X % �^ % n X q K �e % v% n�{ in y.
V S U Z V� U£ V£ V£ V� V Q V q � 6 ¢ G V
p £ P S V£ V£
2 �
F �
R �
�g;
� c c o c o � � o c
Y F N N N � y H y F
T � 1 8 � S � 8 8 � � �
�� � � 2 � Z Z 2 Z
9
O
O
Y
y 9
O
� O
; � k � f: � � � k
g ° � � � � � � � � �
= O � U U V V U V V V V
O
O
Y „ 0 6 $ 0
w g Y � �
3 �' .z z o g o � ° �
� � �� o .� s = � ; � E
� :."'.o§ oa °,"a �� A � ��, � � �
N 3 p
a P� F 0�`l F� � N V V F N {y. i � ]
9 O Y Z F � i O '� � �� N p O Y Q� £ Y� �Y u
C K V O a y �1 2�
;� "�� �'' g€ a " �� a ` �� w° �
d>a ,��� »o� �H �� �� �� �� �� s
O p p p
F F f E� F
W H 4�1
� � � � �
� � � o F
z z z
� � �
� � �
U V U
a
o c
_ � <
a a o " o
U a V a y
V V V U V
� � � � �
g � � h �
� k
� �
V V
o �
N a
V N
O ol
4 Z
C Q
z o �
w o � F �l
v
O E
i 4
O G
U F
4 �
F 2
� 6
i
W r
O
� �
P
�7- � s�
X
( V � X Y g
N : �' � G E !�. t u � � � G G t
� ; � � � � � � � � � w � � �
Pi � a � 5 '' � £ p ° � i �6 �+ °� G q � £ p o
S V V � V V O D U V
V Z
� Y �1
� n c U N w in n n n n V �o in e
p � a a � z r a
w n �`.r
� i � ° c m 6 w z
o; z i z i z � z z � z z z s z .�. z � z . o m a � z
N N � O O D (u O r G� O R O O !y O 6 O fu O
V O F o F o F o F w F O F f� o F o F O F o F o F O F
��'o 00 oa 'S e3 00 °o Sa �3 00 �3 00 00
� '^> »"> ;> «> o> �°.> S"> �"."> R> r"> p"> »"> >
n� F N m Z V - N u y N y N H� . y � y � y N p . y N F
2 N
% X % % % % % % %(� % % % %
� F W F t F� 6 F 0 F fw F h M fu F� Y F W N 0 F Y N 4 t�
•£ U S U£ U S V S V£ U£ V S V� U� V£ V£ U£ �
9 •
F •
4 �
� � �
c o � o c � o � F � u ° w
V F F F b F F h N H y �+ F
^ � � � � � � � � � � � � �
V V V V V U V U V V V
F F 4 Y } t F f F F t� Y 4
• S Z Z Z Z 2 2 2 9 Z Z � z
n
0
w �
� z �
�
m
o �
� � � � � � � � � w � � �
o� � � � � � � � � � � � � o
�o . � � c c � � � � � s � � �
• m a
sa ° � a m �4 � �
• > H O � � Y F � m � [i
„ F � � F 4 N � V m N .� . F . � M
•� O Y U N O O� .�i � U y c V a m Y C �`� �� V P m
: z� � m o �� �ax �� �� �� m � �
o � 9 � � , o � m � � � N � �a a ° s : � H $ � $ � g � � �
-: ."� 3 L � $ o i� i �q c n� @ @ � o w a
M ti o .] 0 R � W y G �{^ p $!� � £ 4
��� p �� � O � f � H � � � e � F F N� � F m � F il 6 K K
a.. � �S �o ", s � �a ��S o ��^ £ p o Y �� �� �� �
P'J 4 � V � V �+ y � 2 � � m �� f n F F a
2 4
y O } C
U f
4�
F 2
� �
4 w
Y �
O V
� 2 Y
V V
m s G 6
'`e ' � u u
� V � N
� p F i �i
y Sf�'1 £ £
� O O U V
w K
3 '
�>"3 .. e
�
�
� m s o °' o
N
" o3 �3
� E : o S o
V
O 7 N >
J1 F
F ..i c�i y - F
U 2
♦ V � V £
S �
F
4
O �
w � � �
V
�
9
O
�
?
a
<
0
° a �
S O �
3 O
• >
f
Y � �
O
e q � y m
� V 4 2 F
. >
� O ~ 9p 2
� ] �
6 � 6 � •
>a x
f
O
f
2
�
�
W
�
O
�
O
V
2
�
°
V
X g
G
V
�
J
V
�
° o
oS
O p
x F
W F
U �
O
F
�
Z
�
�
V
m > �
4 4 O py
9 F 0 4
V �ry �U s
� N � �
C � y
W � O (C � O�
� � � V .l � V
�s ;,s
�,�..358'
'� �-; i r- ! r, f P. §
.,� t � - . . a _ . . .,
�
Presented By
Referred To
Counail File # � `� +�S$
Green Sheet # ✓�V ��
MiNNESOTA
Committee: Date
�3
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, River House Corporation d/b/a Buon Giorno Italian
Market (License ID No. 16076), located at 335 University Avenue East in Saint Paul is hereby
ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to
a minor.
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the
Mayor.
This resolution and the action of the Council in flus matter are based upon the facts
contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the investigation report, and such
azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not
contested by the licensee.
Requested by Department of:
��i� �� � ti��
L!i�i��. •
Adopted by Council: Date � a��qr'� Form Approved by City Atto�ney
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary B �/ .� `��,
Y� �/r7���
,.,l� ,,� , J
By:
Approved by Mayor: Date
� By:
Approved by Mayor Eor Submission to Covncil
By:
9�1 - 3S$
DEPAAiMENTOpFFIGE/GOUNGII DATE INITIATED J � � � �
o��ofr.�r 3-5-1997 CREEN SHEE
CONTACT PEpSON & PHONE lNIT1AV�ATE INITIAIIDATE
ODEPARTMENTDIRECTOR �CRYCOUNCIL
Robert Kesslei, 266-9112 �� � Q qN ATfORNEY � qiY CLEFK
MUST BE ON CqUNCIL AGENDA BV (OATE) ROUTNG � BUDGET OIflECTOR � FlN. 8 MGT. SERVICES DIR.
A ril 9 7 OROEN � MpYOR lOR ASSISTAIJn ❑
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (C4IP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
AGIION REQUESTED.
Concerning adverse acrion against licenses held by River House Corporarion, DBA Buon Giorno Italian Market, located
at 335 University Avemxe East. (Uncontested)
RECAMMENDATIONS: Approve (n) m Re�ect (P) pERSONAL SERYICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER TXE FQILQWMG QUESTIONS:
_ PLANNMG COMMISSION _ CIVIL SEqVICE COMMIS$ION �� Has tM5 personRirm ever worked under a coMrad for this tlepartmsM?
_ GBCAMMrt7Ee ,_ YES "NO
_ SiAFF 2. Has this persontfirm ever been a cily empbyee?
— VES NO
_ �I5TRiCi COURT _ 3. Does [his personRirm
possess a skill not normally possessetl by any currant city employee?
SUPPORTS WHICH CAUNCIlO&fECTIYE? YES NO
Explain all yas answers on seperate sheet and attaeh to green sheet
INITIATING Pp00LEM, ISSUE. 9PPOATUNf'tY (Who, Whet, Wheq Where, Why):
ADVANTAGESIFAPPROVED�
D7SADVANTAGE$ IF APPROVED:
������? s:te�::�: �;.. �' �:,�>
�'t;i;'.;: i, � 3�'��
.�..e,..�.xt>�s. .,
�ISAOVANTAGESIFNOTAPPROVED: � � � �
707AL AMOUNT OF TRANSACiION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIHCLE ONE) VES NO
FUNOIf2G SOURCE ACTWITY NUM6ER
FINANCIAL INFORFSA710N' (EXPIAIN)
OFFICE OF TF� CITY ATTORNEY
Peg B'v15 Ciry Attarney
9� - �5$
CITY OF SAIN'I' PAUL Civrl Divirion
Norm Cokman, Mayor 40D Ciry HaA 7elephone: 611266-8710
I S West Kellogg Blvd Facsimik: 6I2 298-5619
Samt Pau� M'mnesaW SSIO2
�� � iA � ,, �
liUiz�,b� C'� �"�:�.'�ie.�. G�iBW`?
March 3, 1997
.�.. .� � � I���
I30TICF OB COVNCIL HEARING
.�
Frank MacKondy
Buon Giorno Italian Market
335 University Avenue East
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
RE: Cigarette license held by River House Corp. d/b/a Buon Giorno
Italian Market for the premises located at 335 University Ave.
East in St. Paul
License ID No. 16076
Our File Number: G97-0092
Dear Mr. MacKondy:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named
establishment has been scheduled for 4:30 p,m., Wednesday, April 2,
1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City
Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents
which will be presented to the City Council for their
consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes
have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the
Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the
penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license
office will be for a$2�0.00 fine.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours
���� � `���„ �
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Sue Vannelli, Community Organizer, Payne Phalen Dist. 5
Planning Council, 1014 Payne Ave., St. Paul, MN 55101
°l'1- 35g
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARfNG
Licensee Name: River House Corporation d/b/a Buon Giorno
italian Market
Address: . 335 University Avenue East
Council Hearing Date: April 2, 1997
Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor
Minn. Stat. § 609.685
St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07
Date: February 4, 1997
Place: Licensed Premises
Presumptive Penafty: $200.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behaif of client, Office
of License, lnspections and Environmental Protection:
$200.00 fine (first offense)
Attachments:
1. Proposed resotution
2. Letter of ticensee or attorney agreeing not to contest the facts
3. Notice of Violation
4. License information
5. Compliance Report
6. City Attorney License Adverse Action Summary
��C�����
g�,.�s�-
FE$ 7 3 1997
�Buon C�iarno
t;��i�.�Qr�
�-� �r
,
�:.. ....�.___.
�/a/��
i/�Y-eti FeCc-ivr%�� y�� /�h`r� /'jih'c� C< u:O�Ti�yl �� �' "�7�
Sc��i1y C, y�z;/� � �c �i?.4v4 �� as ��.�/r' � i�'/✓-�l�G i� Jz Cv
/ / /
CUrriiyrL`7G �S (�'U/7Cc=v/! i✓� Oc4 !2`CrJQ�f f1�/h fi��v Z� � �c ���/��
si�i.nj. o�cr�Y�li�.
�✓rrt�✓G�- <. " G�/�" /' G�c ��r l�c�cs� io / oeu}5�j�i�.
t�%�it ��y� s�//� c;,�:� � /,'a �c �-
d��/C �c�an- �ir� s� �a�,�� r�/ ��.r;h� -7.��
�'-i7y'l'Y2� / �CL"� C�G7�2'yrK �y S. �cc:�� .za'�ii7� , �r 4i7� '
�'' �2 �� 9n� s3rrs� , /' _/J /
�.�„ �?��.�/y�f ✓�al /�'� - ��t�cc=o�
� Gu� /7/3,�� Ct/�� �L /
�` �' �'�cv �Gc �� /°I �l,".hi�
J��l�i� .fe� Gr/G.' (�S(/q�� CY�.yi/ j2f,t/LO � «,� �L�✓�/�G�
�� � ��. �� � ����� � s� ���
tiw� ������ � ����������
�- �o��� ,�i„� �Z,�,�l ���� ��� �� s�� �
��� ��r��oi� G�� ,�u� U,�,� ��
/�� �u�Gl�, w�s ��,•�. �����tiy"y�o�
H�S �JiV/jrT� � F'vf9 - ���I�/7E�97 , l/JErJ ���i',/CS�Xls�l� /J e
� ` ��j.?l /lic� Or�Y:S.t r c'vly�cerX��t'•
��% /J'/.�I-f in �!/J/t .��.� r�c� � �Zc
�. azvt J �. G�� y�Ji G. ���i�zrl 9cc�.�cc� fJr��
/1�cc� crc �i sz C/c•r�.leQ• 7�j¢�,f y � ��
335 UNIVERSiTYAVENUE, EAST • SAINTPAUL, MI N�OT/C5510�� TE�PH0���8�'
�
QFFICF ^ � THE CITY ATTORNEY
CITY OF SAINT PAUL Cndl Divirion
hbrm Coleman, Mayar 400 Ciry Halt
IS Wesr Kel7ogg Blvd
Sarnt Paul, Mrnnesota SSIO2
February 7, 1997
NOTIC& OF VIOLATION
Owner/Manager
Buon Giorno Italian Market
335 University Avenue East
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
q� _ 3s�-
Telephone: 6I1166-Bi10
Facsimite: 672 298-5619
RE: Cigarette license held by River House Corporation d/b/a Buon
Giorno Italian Market for the premises located at 335
University Avenue East in St. Paul
License ID No.: 16D76
Dear Sir/Madam:
The Director of the Of�ice of License, Inspections and
Environmental Protection (LI3P) wi11 recommend that adverse action
be taken against your cigarette license held at the above-named
premises. This recommendation is based on the following:
On February 4, 1997, you or another employee sold
cigarettes to a minor under the age of 18 years in the
licensed premises. This is an offense under Minn. Stat.
�609.685 aad Saiat Paul Legislative Code §324.07.
If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that
effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the City Council.
You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the
Council as to the proper penalty, if any, to be imposed. The
recommendation of,the licensing office is for a$200.00 fine.
If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before an
Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City
will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross-
examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decided
the case. If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant,
Peter Pangborn, within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps
to set up that ALJ r=aring. 'r_e can be reached at 266-8710.
Page 1
9'� -�S�"
If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
�1 j y� ;�
C,�� %z9�vuti� � y � �
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Directcr, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Sue Vannelli, Community Organizer, Payne Phalen Dist. 5
Planning Council, 1014 Payne Ave., St. Paul, MN 55101
Page 2 -
q1 -'.�f'
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COITNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on February 11, 1997, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Owner/Manager
Buon Giorno Italian Market
335 University Avenue E.
St. Paul, MN. 55101
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this llth day of February, 1997.
�/���i� / /! - ��� �l � �/�
� Notary Public �
s �
�� RITA M. SOSSARD
k3.S\ NQikRY PUBUC MIt.t1ES�TA
�� RANsSEY COUNTY
My Camm. Expires Jan.31.2�W
a�-� 3s�
Lic ID ...............•••. 16076
STAT ..................... AC
Business Name............ RIVER HOUSE CORPORATION
Address .................. 335 UNIVERSITY AVE E
Zip ...................... 55101
Doing Business As........ BUON GIORNO ITALIAN MARKET
License Name ............. CIGARETTE
. RESTAUR.ANT (A)- ZERO-12 SEATS
. LIQUOR - OFF SALE
- . GROCERY (D)
. FOOD PROCESSOR TO 2000 SQ. FT.
Exp Date ................. O1/31/98
Insurance Carrier........ PARK GLEN NAITONAL
Ins. Policy Number......_ MNLL97Q2�4
Insurance Effective Date. O1/28/97
Ins. Expiration Date..... O1/31/98
NOTE AREA ................ INSP CHANGE FROM O1 TO 02 ON 3J20f92
. 10395
. 4/10/95 NICHOLAS F. & CATHERINE MACKONDY REMOVED
. AS OFFICERS PER LETTER RECEIVED--LAP-LIC
. 3j27/96 CIG CODE ADDED FR/ID# 72231--LAP-LIC
. 12/11/96 CODE CHAI3GED FR/2467 TO 2667 PER NEW
. ORDINANCE EFFECTIVE 12/23f96 PER GARY PECHMAI3N-LAp
Tax Id ................... 51�8625
Worker Comp Exp Date..... 05f17J94
Telephone ................ 224-1816
TOBACCO COMPLIANCE CI�CK FORM �/ S�
DATE: �il TIME: ��•�. LICENSELD.NUMBII2: � CP C1
NAME OF COMPLIANCE CHECI�RR: i:. �,0. `.A�1rJ Q t'� NAME OF OFFICER: �� Yt S
NAME & ADDRESS OF LICENSED VENDOR: � �!'1 (7 � f, / Yt [� y�0.l,i� ��� YYI fx Y Ir r�
WAS Tf� TOBACCO: SII,F-SIItVE? _ ASSISTID? � _ MACfIIIIE? _
DID TT-IE MACHINE HAVE THE PROPER REMOTE DEVICE7 - .
s.4[.s wAS �E: , yss � xo axarm: y11�� r, ��a � n 't�s
NAA�OFCLERK: � n�.�.�.
� `
DESCRIPTfON: ' ` � 1� = r„ '�.�, },._,'�„
CHECK ABORTED: YES
ADDITIONAL COIvA4ENTS:
NO
SEX: M F '
a'.�J`� .
� . _ s �.
_ 8` ,,;.- Y , t °°
�,` _ •
,� ��. - �fi�- �.;.. .. .
�, �:
K` c „ _
�
�
o�:
�o:
��:
a�:
H 2 �
� � •
a �
O V
S � \
0
�� � �_
V F Y�] y n y Y �
: � a uy.�, m 0�� o C � u g
a� F 0� p: w w o m u ` 6
� 4 � R U w w Y N\ 0 4 Y �
V `l o o- n u� � p v H �£ J
� V V O� „ Q V V 2 6 O U � V
H 4
� � n S O >
r u� w n� r�+ � n�„ Z m n in
O £
i K C C % K
4 W 6 6 q �
` m a � a
� i � P z'i g'6E ° m 4" �
w d �' o � o y � ° w s o 0
� o- o F � f N � Y� 4 e o F e F O F
. ° o o °. o °i �i - 8 ° o 0 0 0 0 0
Y y j a> u N V a V.�+ � � j p> rv>
» y
�� �'`�" �g �yy ea�g< AG �€
� . . ��� "'° �..g , �
�
e
0
.�.
>
�
° v �
E O
O �+
�
• Y
` � o
^ V °i z
E O Q �
v i �
i o n W '
x x o x xx' `� � x x
i�� �� �g�����E�E �� �� ��
Hg�
� " �
� a a �q
z � � m o w r..
F x m y z z i
4
fJ N � LL
o ° g ° ° �
V ? v ur N r ii U N N N
� �' ` W � � �
�ce p p
V a% O O N S V U V
E. � F v 5 � 0. F. F
� us 2 u S i v n p O 2 2 Y
m m
B 3 �3 a
V V U V
�
?
W
N
�
0
� �
£ �
O
4 g V
4 $
�
m
i
3
4 a
G C
4 G
�
�
V
�
a
�
a ° d
0
n
c
R
�
u '
� � � c
V
Z V
4 Z 2 V
4 � 4
u � J
� O
V
a �
at w � 6
� m �Z
�& �� ag 'o
� O o O O O O O
° o> ° n> > .;:>
N F � N N N P y
� x n x e x e x
V£ 4 S U£ V S
P � � O
N N N
8 S � E
H F
z ° z ° z z
� � � �
� � � �
V U U V
�J R 4
N °r °
� � � � � a
� a o 0 0 0
� v
4 0� � �a�' �..
� `.!' `4 $ a
z � � � "
? F t7 � � �
�� �� �� ��
�i'? — �Sd''
�i w
� U
i j
V �
z
� o � o
° e � » >
�g�H
N x .. x
V � L £
� O
N F
� �
M F
° z ° z
� � � �
� � � �
V U V V
� a
E 4
� ° z o
� z
c �
� y � � e
u o � o :
q � � 6 q
a ip 4 E
n� H �+ £ l
y u F � � c
4 Ol 4 4 4 F
A
Z 4
O G �
V F �
a � �
f z .
y � .
7
m �
o � �
0
� � �Y Y . V .O
; a s a � � � � � � ag�
m
� ! � � � � � � � � � � � �
s a � .. a � soa
� � U � � $ a � a ���
��,$
... .. M .. N � .. .. .. :s�
z a
e a z z
ru w m e
w
a z a �
� d � � o � o �a �d ' o � o ? o � o � o `" o
m
� i ' 3 ° 5 ° 5 4 3 °. 3 ° S ° 5 0 5<' 3
�., o 0 0 0 0 o e o = o e o e o
° n > �°. > > n > « > r > s > .°� >
�� `"„ '" y , `" "� y ." .g
V
y , �n % � v % y[ �u % N % �n % ry
4 F 4� M1 F m F C F 6 F 6 f n. F u F 5
� V£ V£ U S V� U S V� V£ V S E 5
2 �
F
K �
� � �
V � F
w
m � N
0
H
z
9
O
y 7
C Z
� O
� W F 0�1 � (�il N Ll �
F N N F F N N � N
o E � � o � o 0 0
V yp
2 x Z 2 4 Z y 2 Z
� F F F F � F
o ^ : � � � � � V
�1 q� � U U V V V V
8
O w K �
•> � 0 6 O N Y V
m N C
„ � o o � � � � o
' � '� M 9 o m ��' u
� " ` � ; § � � � J a � �i $
° y � a° Z�: o a 'o � `�'� F m ` � �' o
6^ N F F F 4�1 U 2 0
�y °� a� =y = �m a
0
9 "
>>� .�° �� �� m� �� m
V 4 �
V
V V V
O
� z
o � �
n � a
8 W � Y
my
�� ��
� 4 V �
� � � � r �
� � �
w w c n m
C�i G � c �
� � � �^
s , � d�
E £ � i N
8 � � �„y
ro a o
"°� .. ,. � a3
a
a a
6 � z
�o ° 'o z mo
03 03 ° .3
; e o = o
",> $ >
v y �. F � F
n % C� %
V £ V £ V £ 2�
m u�1 �
f F ! F
� � � �
� � 8
� O O U
z z z z
Y � � F �
� $ � � �
V 4 V V V
N O
O N
`� p S { � � g z
K V O y 4 V U�
� o S � Q F y z
d 4 £ . !� H r
�� 4 O V 9 F u w
��� �g �� �a
�i � f� U � . 4 � U �
��a�� c� C�
@
�
9�-35�
�
o�:
F i
2 4 .
O G •
U �� �
F �i •
� �
i �
O U
f � � � � � �
4 V
G �
Y X
Y V V U U O D U Y Y y
�, : � � � � � c � : F � � m u � o �€
�
�;� � � � � � ���� � � � � � � �
a a .a .a w u ' i a a a
�;€ � � 8 � 8 E x� m 8 8 � � � £ $
� es��
q . �n � �n n n n n� 17 4 n 'n u n m � m
� ti � r . . n � �
W � � s n 6 � �e a a � � a
� o. � a n a & en z a
7 F ' m N ° i o � w � o � w � w � o � o � F ° o � o � a �` o z
q �� o F o F o H a F o F O p O E F � F o F F O H O F
a � °5 03 °5 °3 °S °5 °5 °3 03 03 ° .3 '3 e5
o; o y o 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 0 0
a> .°.> w i r> ° w > .°.�> . .:> N> w>
S � � Q F y N � � N � � � ti � � � � � � >
q V � N p m N - N n q N N �+ N »
u 0. • � • i i • � • r i �
y C cC C X % % % C X w X %
y , 4. F x{+ R F Y�+ 6 F G + M1 M u. � 4. F s F M E G W� G 6 F 4[� W
9 P �(� S V�S' U i V 1 V£ V 2 V£ V S V.E U Y V S U 1 V£ V
F
t
N
u
z :
o �
F
6
�gi
4 O G P O C � 0� � � p p
L � N N � � N N N N y (Sil � ' N y N 0 N
^ ��U QZ � � V V L V V V V V V y V
U V {� p
� 2 Z L 5 E Z 2 Z L 2 2 2 i 2
C
O
N
0
4l i
>
v Z �
G
� O
I N W Fi F � F F F F F F F !-� �
$ � : � � � � � � � � � � � � a �
Y p • V V V V V G V V V V V
R
� � � 6 p �
O r� x 4 6 >
•> 6 y F � Y� O p
: L y F � y � 3 N �
V V % O T 4 � . � } F K Y w d 0
: Y p� M � 4 W O � � N M V V C Y � p . P G
i Z N % �
u u ol V U
� " � .. � ' � � a . �i o � � :
� 'n � � � o � � . � o � � � �g � M1 � m
O u � Z E F r V � p � O L� G �$ `q � p O� ( '�y •
� .] 4 � V� N � N � w r Z � S Y V� 4 m �
��� ° qg " � o „ � a c z o� m m w a oi z o z z z
� ° , 3 3 � � � ° S� 7 d ° � i ¢ "�� "� ° g a u � a ' q� 8 $ g
o". >> : u o � � i a a� o 0
P
�7 —3S�'
o�
�.
_.
oa:
Si F
<�
2 4 �
n 6 �
a
o�
e�
4 V
� � �
U U ]L Y V U X U Y Y U
€ � � & u c � € � � � � � €
' o
� � m �
� ; � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
$ '' ° x '' n i ' n ' i
� � ° E � 8 g € � 8 � � � g � 8
� �
� � � �" � � a � � = � �
a�fo �� �o �o �� �$ �o �� �a �$ � �x�s ��
V g F � F o N o F F o l+ � N � t o t+ o N o H 4 F O M F
§ x o ° o 3 0 0 � o � o ° o ° o ° 3 0 0 °o o � = 3 0 e 5
� p o 0
� � > ° o > � > r > rv s ° n > o > e i � > n > .^ > n ° o s �°.> > o >
w� N � N N N N N � N y N y N y N n% N N a N 2 � N N i � N
V W � Z
0. � � • • � O �
, X u� F V X 'n X �n % n H % t� M 'a % c X m% o f n X rt M m%
� � o; � u: � r� w� i� i� S o o. m a
� s u� ti i u$ �� �`Y ti S v i ti ti¢ �°� w a ti S ti z u`i
z �
F �
4 •
� £
O �
V
0
�
O
�
>
Y
� O
. o ° 1
S O �
Y T O £
P � J $ m
Q V I y F
� O u
a � �
4
1 �
q>a ,
q� G G Q � � G � � G G
y F f N F F F F y Y y F y
�� 8 ° E E E E E � E ° 8 �
z E � ° z z ° z � ° z i � i ° z s z
4 5
� �
�
V V
�
O
v r n
� � �
2 2 Z
g �S
w
�
�
V
8
3
0
�
�
w � � C � � � k w �
� � � o � � � � � �
V V V V U V V V U V
0 2 0
2G [�• � H ° s
p Po � IX � m V
a � a �
s 5 0 � o a � � N § � z
� m V S y K V O !� .] n N O
p q u m� 9 O a O N
u � _ y � F p �
� N S �� � v F h Y „ f� �n E 0
j 2
8 4 Ll �2 F �� £ p � $ � 4 Q
�� Yq � 6 � �� 4 �y� W N O Y
V' u V£ � F � N 2� S.�1 S i 2 p
�
�
V
Y a
�
F O
O y
F 4
N O
C S
00
:
_ ;
°I�-3s�
�
o�,
=d.
00
�r
a�
F=
�
�:
6 w
O V
N � � `
4 V
¢ 41 N
Y O t� V y
•� V iC ( V W V V u V f O � YJ
: 'c �€ � � � w u� � � � V E o p� �
a g � �d a � ° d �d � > d z d � �d � � ~ r �
S y :� "i � ' a u .a � � g o z a
V � � � � � 8 � � � � � S m ° " 8
H . � o
mza
za o
� e � .. � .. � ., < .. .. . � � a � .,
0
�° e � a � a °� o a � a � e
m
�" � a � �z �z��� �z �z �z �z �:
� r ° s i w " o i o � o a o 0 0�a w o .. o w o m o a o
U O a p F O F e E F o F R Z o(% � F o H F e N
q„ o p a O O d o O � O o p O e] V � o O � O o O o � O O
V � r „ v Y > N Y > O> n> u�i � 4 N Y o> N Y n> a?
F F N � 5 � F u�i F � y � E � S�
� � ° � r .��. N m N " � n u ' � � g � � ."'.
a � � � � � �
Y V
f1 % N% �n % �n % N% vl % N � o rv% !� % v X n X in X
� U£ U S U£ U S V Z U E V S 0.� R U£ V£ U S U£ � U�
O [
F
�� 0 O P O � O
V�� F y N � M
M y
S � � � � � � "E �
U � V U V U U V
W � F F F F �+
O i 2 2 � Z Z 2 v
a
0
0
m :
>
� �
`� o
' i � � � �" � � �
g° � � � 3 � a �
+1 Q O • U U V V C
3^
a o
" � � $ � _ �
q : 0 £
• � � U a d
J � r� � "' y 0
S : S p q
o P��.l � , a � 9 0 4
8 � a $ � � J �
Q " ` � � � � ..
: o � � �y �� ''g �� ��
o->e i� �� �� -;� 5� ��
W � N W
y N vi N
� � � �
V V V V
° z ° z a z
�
�
V
�
� � � � �
� u � � �
5
m �
m � � a o
o � � o g
y`" p" ° m
¢ Y F F C n Q
� � m 3 H
� z � `N � �
N o w a` � y u a
rc rc Q �' v � �
y a y
; ` ^�i i 1 '�S �i N Y
�
8
�
k
�
V
�
m
0
0
e
��
4 v
N
P
\ ( � �i ��
z F a
0 0 �
� � :
4 �
F 2 �
� 6
'1 �
p U m
� � � � �
O \
2 W
W O O� 6
W . [`��?' i� C��✓�j 4 (! � V N
r� � �i y W 6 N N U£ U �l ri � $ a u 6 F F V r � .
y� G 6 a � a � x Pi ����� 3 z m d � 3 � G
�,( mi 4 � V O o�£ y F O 2 V£ O N
Z Z z p�
p � 4 4 4 V Z a 2 v O $ 4 p � V s >
V ��.i a U r] � K H F 6 4/�L w Z m H�� 6 C � 6
� § �i � � ° n m o m R Q m w x `3 o s ° ° Q '� � � �i
n?� 3 4��� F q �� U� Z
` N ` � '� q � � � N $ � � � �O � m �
i n v�i P� m a Fl e 6 V��¢ f�u � F a 4(] 6 Y n m
K
a w a
c
p w
� o- L M Z 4 w
���o�"�.g 'o "o o �F �
� y � O O
Z V� O F a p M� e[+ o F G o F F o F
'J M e .i � ` l a � O y O 3 � Q p � �p �l � �1
� e O o p o O a O a O 2� ry � 9 o O
° > rv > » > i ". > o > �° >
V 2 N N y . F � F N N � N w= o � N N N
W
• i � J N
u� X rv% �n X n% v% �� �1 %
W F W H W� d E+ W� 2 O V 4 e p p p
� ti� ti�x vi� ti x v� i � i �i �ii'
z .
o ,
N �
4 �
� £ G �
y F
C
T � 0
( f
� R 2
O
O W
7
a z :
a
� o
F H
O m V �
y �tl V
e .. u
e
: �
• J O �i S
4 , (� w nf
o a 9 ,�
o � s � m �
o=
:
:;�' .��
4
i > a . � o
O m �
F y
� � O
z � � i
� �
V V
z �
� �
£ �
� N
N C
� �
o�
� �
� N
£ 4
4 �
o E Oo
O �
= o
��
�o
x° ��
f
�
V
O
F
�
V
�
O
£
�
O
m
O
a
x
� u
y
Z
V
9
O
N
5�
i
V V
� € Z
F 4
J ri
� �
C
c
�
4l � 4
Z
� O
e >
us F
%
w � r.
u �` v
� O
N f
O U
F F
2 2
N
� � � U
V V V V
a m w
4 N �
� a � j � a �
n [� j �
V 2
4 £ r £
� O � 4
� K V V P
�� s� �
> 'p
� y � m� po °
ni Y i S Y � O �
P
Z 4
V F �
4 � �
F 2 i
r 6 �
° o u
m � �
F O
4 V
O �
• �
X Y X ✓
V X V y V ` 1
� G �i � " S 6 G E o
�e � � � � � � � � � � a
� � £ � � � a � � � � �
V �
M Y
e� U
� � � .. .�. .� �`n .. N .. .. .". G
d� � a ° � ° n a a °
�` �` °j . � z �` � z z a � z
i ° w o i o � o m x � y r o i o �. o
� � O F a H 4 F a N F o F 4 F o E o F W E O f
§ � 5 °3 03 °3 03 °5 %3 °5 °3 05 °5
: o o a . o 0 0 . o a a . o 0 0 0 0 . o 0 0
" y '" „ y o° > ,.°, s °o > n > ° a > r 5 �4 >^ o° >
b F � N N N � F N N N N N N � t N N y N � f V - N
� ` � • • • r • . � � r �
� % p % X X y % % p y �
� � F W( n F !u F e. F W F W F fu (+ W F W f C E
�� U£ V£ V£ V S V S U£ V� U£ V£ V S
O
K
Y
V =
t� �
4 �
�� � O O C O � O G �
� Ci " N " N N " iA " N
� � � � � � � � � � � �
V q V U V {. U V V V
� 2 2 S 2 2 Z 2 S 2 3
0
O
7 W •
2 �
9
n O
� • •���
� `� V
G G t
� � �
a
° � gi
V U
m a a
� z �Z
' o � M i o
00 00 00
K > N > tt >
a N N N N N
�e X N v � %
U £ V S V £
� � m
N H ryF N
2 2 2
V V U
t p
Z Z 2
� W F F � � F � H F � � �
g` � � � � � � � � � � �
� p • V V U V f/ C V
� e m n y c m
.. o m � m i x u 'o � s o .
•> Q m � m z m � � '..` d".. �
� s `� o � e m ° � F °�
N y K W Q R d N Q y C j � N �
u u o�� O V Q � e 7 i O . a S U � Q
5 V O W U � y u� V m
� 4� w a o G`$ �$[ M N � � m n p 6 � r
� V i Z F 4 Z U N 9 � F ,� 4 N �� 3 V � ~
a w r a 4 i £�� m � j v
M�� � F O Z a K N �£ � 2� � T� y - O N V u
F j
"ia . � �� �8 �� f� �o �8 € $m �`�'A o-� �
H
�
V
a
m
C
�
R N
��
4 N
4
9� - �Sg'
�
o�
2 4
O [.. G
V F
4 ]
F 2
� 6
a
o u
4 U
C
% X
r 4 U X Y X
; � � � V V , � j V
m� m u w t E �i
� � � � � � � �
� � 3 , i i i
V � £ S L
' 8 8 � 8 8 E
h �
� s z " z a N
m
� 6 m � � y 6
: � Z � � �
C �l N 4� p tu O � O 4 O 4 O � O
� �i ° .5 ° .5 e5 ° .S °5 ° .5
� o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
� � � r > n > » s n > $ > rv >
N n� N N y N �� V - N N � F /1 N N
Y u � � � � � • �
V � e` X n% n% �v X N%
.� � U£ V£ V S V� U£ V S
�
R
F
V
Q
F
4 �
� Y � O O � O O O
�; N W 4 � F N
^ I � � � � � �
:s a a s s �
� F F F F M l+
� 2 Z Z 2 2 2
P
O
�
O
>
y 2 �
O
n Q
: � � � k w �
q � , � � � � � �
� p � V V U V U V
�
�o � e � � � o
•> � j 4 V V Z �
✓ n
� {� y N d p N
a� �� 2 4 � F F 2
` � � £ ' £ y q � �y b �
n I n O„ i m £ q m n Y
0 0� � O O � S P
�Z ��„� S 8 8 G C Y x
O ~ ryryry N S ��j � � ry
u u � F N
9 O H .] i f� S� y � 2
O • p � y .i � �
� i 6 � m V i? a a i 6 4 � 1 4
U V V U V V % Y
� � ° € c � t�i G
� � � � � � � �
i Y
� � �` 8 � � � �
o a a a a m n
� i m � a f� a
"' o °' o m o 4 o m o °' o � o � o
eS o3 .3 ° 5 ° 5 05 oS �5
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.: > » > s rv i �°. s � > ° o > rv >
- u v � N N H w H • E w F � vHi
�a Y a X % V M % N%� n X N X
d l+ b F 4 q f b� 4 F C{ M F fu H
V� V£ V£ U� U� V S U£ V£
3
V
q � y � C � O O 0
N t N N N oi N
� . � � � � � � �
V �£ V V V la V
,F� P � F F H f�+ (+ f
Z ° z z i z z
�
c
�
V
n
W
� �
� O
� � k � � � k
� � � � � v �
V V V V V V V
�
V O C � n O
O � 6 a O 4 f O
4 O u � 4 N �
„ +] � 4� � O 3
X U� 0 4 m n
O 4 � � V � �G O
}; E
% ( F 4N1 �. � �a `� �£ N
d U Y x o- V >� 3 4 3
e F �
V V 9 ¢ Y N N tl m ¢ S K
O 0. a� e� � u C O C S C v y N
4
q�-35 �
� F
2 } 6 r
V F
4 � �
� 6
O U
W �
F O
6 (1
�
� �
�
V .]
V
�] N ' ~ O
V O t+
O u � o O
U
y y rv >
F i � F
V �
• V S
U
w
G
�
J
O
U
6 O
0 4
a
n N
�
V �
V U V � U V �� l V U f W
� � � 'c � . �b � � a � � e �
� � � � � � �a � � � � �
> � £ a �
V O £ p O � O p�G � O E V V
V V V V�l U
V i
` O � �
N N m r� n N u+ V n V m n .y
0. N � � M1 W 6 p p � 6
y 2 6 � d Z � � 2 Z y z
� N W O 6 O r O � Y � a � � O �� 6 O m O �
'� °. 3 0 5 0 3 °. 5 ° 3 °� o S o 5 0 5 °. 5
O p o O O O • O o O � O e � O O o O a O
� rv> N 7 o S rv> �a > N 7 ��ia 7 H> n>
� H M f .. y tn F � N � N � F N N N N F N
i
n% tv X X % �^ % n X q K �e % v% n�{ in y.
V S U Z V� U£ V£ V£ V� V Q V q � 6 ¢ G V
p £ P S V£ V£
2 �
F �
R �
�g;
� c c o c o � � o c
Y F N N N � y H y F
T � 1 8 � S � 8 8 � � �
�� � � 2 � Z Z 2 Z
9
O
O
Y
y 9
O
� O
; � k � f: � � � k
g ° � � � � � � � � �
= O � U U V V U V V V V
O
O
Y „ 0 6 $ 0
w g Y � �
3 �' .z z o g o � ° �
� � �� o .� s = � ; � E
� :."'.o§ oa °,"a �� A � ��, � � �
N 3 p
a P� F 0�`l F� � N V V F N {y. i � ]
9 O Y Z F � i O '� � �� N p O Y Q� £ Y� �Y u
C K V O a y �1 2�
;� "�� �'' g€ a " �� a ` �� w° �
d>a ,��� »o� �H �� �� �� �� �� s
O p p p
F F f E� F
W H 4�1
� � � � �
� � � o F
z z z
� � �
� � �
U V U
a
o c
_ � <
a a o " o
U a V a y
V V V U V
� � � � �
g � � h �
� k
� �
V V
o �
N a
V N
O ol
4 Z
C Q
z o �
w o � F �l
v
O E
i 4
O G
U F
4 �
F 2
� 6
i
W r
O
� �
P
�7- � s�
X
( V � X Y g
N : �' � G E !�. t u � � � G G t
� ; � � � � � � � � � w � � �
Pi � a � 5 '' � £ p ° � i �6 �+ °� G q � £ p o
S V V � V V O D U V
V Z
� Y �1
� n c U N w in n n n n V �o in e
p � a a � z r a
w n �`.r
� i � ° c m 6 w z
o; z i z i z � z z � z z z s z .�. z � z . o m a � z
N N � O O D (u O r G� O R O O !y O 6 O fu O
V O F o F o F o F w F O F f� o F o F O F o F o F O F
��'o 00 oa 'S e3 00 °o Sa �3 00 �3 00 00
� '^> »"> ;> «> o> �°.> S"> �"."> R> r"> p"> »"> >
n� F N m Z V - N u y N y N H� . y � y � y N p . y N F
2 N
% X % % % % % % %(� % % % %
� F W F t F� 6 F 0 F fw F h M fu F� Y F W N 0 F Y N 4 t�
•£ U S U£ U S V S V£ U£ V S V� U� V£ V£ U£ �
9 •
F •
4 �
� � �
c o � o c � o � F � u ° w
V F F F b F F h N H y �+ F
^ � � � � � � � � � � � � �
V V V V V U V U V V V
F F 4 Y } t F f F F t� Y 4
• S Z Z Z Z 2 2 2 9 Z Z � z
n
0
w �
� z �
�
m
o �
� � � � � � � � � w � � �
o� � � � � � � � � � � � � o
�o . � � c c � � � � � s � � �
• m a
sa ° � a m �4 � �
• > H O � � Y F � m � [i
„ F � � F 4 N � V m N .� . F . � M
•� O Y U N O O� .�i � U y c V a m Y C �`� �� V P m
: z� � m o �� �ax �� �� �� m � �
o � 9 � � , o � m � � � N � �a a ° s : � H $ � $ � g � � �
-: ."� 3 L � $ o i� i �q c n� @ @ � o w a
M ti o .] 0 R � W y G �{^ p $!� � £ 4
��� p �� � O � f � H � � � e � F F N� � F m � F il 6 K K
a.. � �S �o ", s � �a ��S o ��^ £ p o Y �� �� �� �
P'J 4 � V � V �+ y � 2 � � m �� f n F F a
2 4
y O } C
U f
4�
F 2
� �
4 w
Y �
O V
� 2 Y
V V
m s G 6
'`e ' � u u
� V � N
� p F i �i
y Sf�'1 £ £
� O O U V
w K
3 '
�>"3 .. e
�
�
� m s o °' o
N
" o3 �3
� E : o S o
V
O 7 N >
J1 F
F ..i c�i y - F
U 2
♦ V � V £
S �
F
4
O �
w � � �
V
�
9
O
�
?
a
<
0
° a �
S O �
3 O
• >
f
Y � �
O
e q � y m
� V 4 2 F
. >
� O ~ 9p 2
� ] �
6 � 6 � •
>a x
f
O
f
2
�
�
W
�
O
�
O
V
2
�
°
V
X g
G
V
�
J
V
�
° o
oS
O p
x F
W F
U �
O
F
�
Z
�
�
V
m > �
4 4 O py
9 F 0 4
V �ry �U s
� N � �
C � y
W � O (C � O�
� � � V .l � V
�s ;,s
�,�..358'
'� �-; i r- ! r, f P. §
.,� t � - . . a _ . . .,
�
Presented By
Referred To
Counail File # � `� +�S$
Green Sheet # ✓�V ��
MiNNESOTA
Committee: Date
�3
RESOLVED, that the Licensee, River House Corporation d/b/a Buon Giorno Italian
Market (License ID No. 16076), located at 335 University Avenue East in Saint Paul is hereby
ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to
a minor.
Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection
within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the
Mayor.
This resolution and the action of the Council in flus matter are based upon the facts
contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the investigation report, and such
azguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not
contested by the licensee.
Requested by Department of:
��i� �� � ti��
L!i�i��. •
Adopted by Council: Date � a��qr'� Form Approved by City Atto�ney
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary B �/ .� `��,
Y� �/r7���
,.,l� ,,� , J
By:
Approved by Mayor: Date
� By:
Approved by Mayor Eor Submission to Covncil
By:
9�1 - 3S$
DEPAAiMENTOpFFIGE/GOUNGII DATE INITIATED J � � � �
o��ofr.�r 3-5-1997 CREEN SHEE
CONTACT PEpSON & PHONE lNIT1AV�ATE INITIAIIDATE
ODEPARTMENTDIRECTOR �CRYCOUNCIL
Robert Kesslei, 266-9112 �� � Q qN ATfORNEY � qiY CLEFK
MUST BE ON CqUNCIL AGENDA BV (OATE) ROUTNG � BUDGET OIflECTOR � FlN. 8 MGT. SERVICES DIR.
A ril 9 7 OROEN � MpYOR lOR ASSISTAIJn ❑
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (C4IP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
AGIION REQUESTED.
Concerning adverse acrion against licenses held by River House Corporarion, DBA Buon Giorno Italian Market, located
at 335 University Avemxe East. (Uncontested)
RECAMMENDATIONS: Approve (n) m Re�ect (P) pERSONAL SERYICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWER TXE FQILQWMG QUESTIONS:
_ PLANNMG COMMISSION _ CIVIL SEqVICE COMMIS$ION �� Has tM5 personRirm ever worked under a coMrad for this tlepartmsM?
_ GBCAMMrt7Ee ,_ YES "NO
_ SiAFF 2. Has this persontfirm ever been a cily empbyee?
— VES NO
_ �I5TRiCi COURT _ 3. Does [his personRirm
possess a skill not normally possessetl by any currant city employee?
SUPPORTS WHICH CAUNCIlO&fECTIYE? YES NO
Explain all yas answers on seperate sheet and attaeh to green sheet
INITIATING Pp00LEM, ISSUE. 9PPOATUNf'tY (Who, Whet, Wheq Where, Why):
ADVANTAGESIFAPPROVED�
D7SADVANTAGE$ IF APPROVED:
������? s:te�::�: �;.. �' �:,�>
�'t;i;'.;: i, � 3�'��
.�..e,..�.xt>�s. .,
�ISAOVANTAGESIFNOTAPPROVED: � � � �
707AL AMOUNT OF TRANSACiION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIHCLE ONE) VES NO
FUNOIf2G SOURCE ACTWITY NUM6ER
FINANCIAL INFORFSA710N' (EXPIAIN)
OFFICE OF TF� CITY ATTORNEY
Peg B'v15 Ciry Attarney
9� - �5$
CITY OF SAIN'I' PAUL Civrl Divirion
Norm Cokman, Mayor 40D Ciry HaA 7elephone: 611266-8710
I S West Kellogg Blvd Facsimik: 6I2 298-5619
Samt Pau� M'mnesaW SSIO2
�� � iA � ,, �
liUiz�,b� C'� �"�:�.'�ie.�. G�iBW`?
March 3, 1997
.�.. .� � � I���
I30TICF OB COVNCIL HEARING
.�
Frank MacKondy
Buon Giorno Italian Market
335 University Avenue East
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
RE: Cigarette license held by River House Corp. d/b/a Buon Giorno
Italian Market for the premises located at 335 University Ave.
East in St. Paul
License ID No. 16076
Our File Number: G97-0092
Dear Mr. MacKondy:
Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named
establishment has been scheduled for 4:30 p,m., Wednesday, April 2,
1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City
Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse.
Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents
which will be presented to the City Council for their
consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts
contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes
have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the
Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the
penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license
office will be for a$2�0.00 fine.
If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710.
Very truly yours
���� � `���„ �
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Sue Vannelli, Community Organizer, Payne Phalen Dist. 5
Planning Council, 1014 Payne Ave., St. Paul, MN 55101
°l'1- 35g
UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARfNG
Licensee Name: River House Corporation d/b/a Buon Giorno
italian Market
Address: . 335 University Avenue East
Council Hearing Date: April 2, 1997
Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor
Minn. Stat. § 609.685
St. Paul Legislative Code § 324.07
Date: February 4, 1997
Place: Licensed Premises
Presumptive Penafty: $200.00 Fine
Recommendation of Assistant City Attorney on behaif of client, Office
of License, lnspections and Environmental Protection:
$200.00 fine (first offense)
Attachments:
1. Proposed resotution
2. Letter of ticensee or attorney agreeing not to contest the facts
3. Notice of Violation
4. License information
5. Compliance Report
6. City Attorney License Adverse Action Summary
��C�����
g�,.�s�-
FE$ 7 3 1997
�Buon C�iarno
t;��i�.�Qr�
�-� �r
,
�:.. ....�.___.
�/a/��
i/�Y-eti FeCc-ivr%�� y�� /�h`r� /'jih'c� C< u:O�Ti�yl �� �' "�7�
Sc��i1y C, y�z;/� � �c �i?.4v4 �� as ��.�/r' � i�'/✓-�l�G i� Jz Cv
/ / /
CUrriiyrL`7G �S (�'U/7Cc=v/! i✓� Oc4 !2`CrJQ�f f1�/h fi��v Z� � �c ���/��
si�i.nj. o�cr�Y�li�.
�✓rrt�✓G�- <. " G�/�" /' G�c ��r l�c�cs� io / oeu}5�j�i�.
t�%�it ��y� s�//� c;,�:� � /,'a �c �-
d��/C �c�an- �ir� s� �a�,�� r�/ ��.r;h� -7.��
�'-i7y'l'Y2� / �CL"� C�G7�2'yrK �y S. �cc:�� .za'�ii7� , �r 4i7� '
�'' �2 �� 9n� s3rrs� , /' _/J /
�.�„ �?��.�/y�f ✓�al /�'� - ��t�cc=o�
� Gu� /7/3,�� Ct/�� �L /
�` �' �'�cv �Gc �� /°I �l,".hi�
J��l�i� .fe� Gr/G.' (�S(/q�� CY�.yi/ j2f,t/LO � «,� �L�✓�/�G�
�� � ��. �� � ����� � s� ���
tiw� ������ � ����������
�- �o��� ,�i„� �Z,�,�l ���� ��� �� s�� �
��� ��r��oi� G�� ,�u� U,�,� ��
/�� �u�Gl�, w�s ��,•�. �����tiy"y�o�
H�S �JiV/jrT� � F'vf9 - ���I�/7E�97 , l/JErJ ���i',/CS�Xls�l� /J e
� ` ��j.?l /lic� Or�Y:S.t r c'vly�cerX��t'•
��% /J'/.�I-f in �!/J/t .��.� r�c� � �Zc
�. azvt J �. G�� y�Ji G. ���i�zrl 9cc�.�cc� fJr��
/1�cc� crc �i sz C/c•r�.leQ• 7�j¢�,f y � ��
335 UNIVERSiTYAVENUE, EAST • SAINTPAUL, MI N�OT/C5510�� TE�PH0���8�'
�
QFFICF ^ � THE CITY ATTORNEY
CITY OF SAINT PAUL Cndl Divirion
hbrm Coleman, Mayar 400 Ciry Halt
IS Wesr Kel7ogg Blvd
Sarnt Paul, Mrnnesota SSIO2
February 7, 1997
NOTIC& OF VIOLATION
Owner/Manager
Buon Giorno Italian Market
335 University Avenue East
Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101
q� _ 3s�-
Telephone: 6I1166-Bi10
Facsimite: 672 298-5619
RE: Cigarette license held by River House Corporation d/b/a Buon
Giorno Italian Market for the premises located at 335
University Avenue East in St. Paul
License ID No.: 16D76
Dear Sir/Madam:
The Director of the Of�ice of License, Inspections and
Environmental Protection (LI3P) wi11 recommend that adverse action
be taken against your cigarette license held at the above-named
premises. This recommendation is based on the following:
On February 4, 1997, you or another employee sold
cigarettes to a minor under the age of 18 years in the
licensed premises. This is an offense under Minn. Stat.
�609.685 aad Saiat Paul Legislative Code §324.07.
If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that
effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the City Council.
You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the
Council as to the proper penalty, if any, to be imposed. The
recommendation of,the licensing office is for a$200.00 fine.
If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before an
Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City
will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross-
examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decided
the case. If this is your choice, please advise my legal assistant,
Peter Pangborn, within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps
to set up that ALJ r=aring. 'r_e can be reached at 266-8710.
Page 1
9'� -�S�"
If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710.
Sincerely,
�1 j y� ;�
C,�� %z9�vuti� � y � �
Virginia D. Palmer
Assistant City Attorney
cc: Robert Kessler, Directcr, LIEP
Christine Rozek, LIEP
Sue Vannelli, Community Organizer, Payne Phalen Dist. 5
Planning Council, 1014 Payne Ave., St. Paul, MN 55101
Page 2 -
q1 -'.�f'
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COITNTY OF RAMSEY
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL
JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says
that on February 11, 1997, she served the attached NOTICE OF
VIOLATION on the following named person by placing a true and
correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows:
Owner/Manager
Buon Giorno Italian Market
335 University Avenue E.
St. Paul, MN. 55101
(which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the
same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul,
Minnesota.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this llth day of February, 1997.
�/���i� / /! - ��� �l � �/�
� Notary Public �
s �
�� RITA M. SOSSARD
k3.S\ NQikRY PUBUC MIt.t1ES�TA
�� RANsSEY COUNTY
My Camm. Expires Jan.31.2�W
a�-� 3s�
Lic ID ...............•••. 16076
STAT ..................... AC
Business Name............ RIVER HOUSE CORPORATION
Address .................. 335 UNIVERSITY AVE E
Zip ...................... 55101
Doing Business As........ BUON GIORNO ITALIAN MARKET
License Name ............. CIGARETTE
. RESTAUR.ANT (A)- ZERO-12 SEATS
. LIQUOR - OFF SALE
- . GROCERY (D)
. FOOD PROCESSOR TO 2000 SQ. FT.
Exp Date ................. O1/31/98
Insurance Carrier........ PARK GLEN NAITONAL
Ins. Policy Number......_ MNLL97Q2�4
Insurance Effective Date. O1/28/97
Ins. Expiration Date..... O1/31/98
NOTE AREA ................ INSP CHANGE FROM O1 TO 02 ON 3J20f92
. 10395
. 4/10/95 NICHOLAS F. & CATHERINE MACKONDY REMOVED
. AS OFFICERS PER LETTER RECEIVED--LAP-LIC
. 3j27/96 CIG CODE ADDED FR/ID# 72231--LAP-LIC
. 12/11/96 CODE CHAI3GED FR/2467 TO 2667 PER NEW
. ORDINANCE EFFECTIVE 12/23f96 PER GARY PECHMAI3N-LAp
Tax Id ................... 51�8625
Worker Comp Exp Date..... 05f17J94
Telephone ................ 224-1816
TOBACCO COMPLIANCE CI�CK FORM �/ S�
DATE: �il TIME: ��•�. LICENSELD.NUMBII2: � CP C1
NAME OF COMPLIANCE CHECI�RR: i:. �,0. `.A�1rJ Q t'� NAME OF OFFICER: �� Yt S
NAME & ADDRESS OF LICENSED VENDOR: � �!'1 (7 � f, / Yt [� y�0.l,i� ��� YYI fx Y Ir r�
WAS Tf� TOBACCO: SII,F-SIItVE? _ ASSISTID? � _ MACfIIIIE? _
DID TT-IE MACHINE HAVE THE PROPER REMOTE DEVICE7 - .
s.4[.s wAS �E: , yss � xo axarm: y11�� r, ��a � n 't�s
NAA�OFCLERK: � n�.�.�.
� `
DESCRIPTfON: ' ` � 1� = r„ '�.�, },._,'�„
CHECK ABORTED: YES
ADDITIONAL COIvA4ENTS:
NO
SEX: M F '
a'.�J`� .
� . _ s �.
_ 8` ,,;.- Y , t °°
�,` _ •
,� ��. - �fi�- �.;.. .. .
�, �:
K` c „ _
�
�
o�:
�o:
��:
a�:
H 2 �
� � •
a �
O V
S � \
0
�� � �_
V F Y�] y n y Y �
: � a uy.�, m 0�� o C � u g
a� F 0� p: w w o m u ` 6
� 4 � R U w w Y N\ 0 4 Y �
V `l o o- n u� � p v H �£ J
� V V O� „ Q V V 2 6 O U � V
H 4
� � n S O >
r u� w n� r�+ � n�„ Z m n in
O £
i K C C % K
4 W 6 6 q �
` m a � a
� i � P z'i g'6E ° m 4" �
w d �' o � o y � ° w s o 0
� o- o F � f N � Y� 4 e o F e F O F
. ° o o °. o °i �i - 8 ° o 0 0 0 0 0
Y y j a> u N V a V.�+ � � j p> rv>
» y
�� �'`�" �g �yy ea�g< AG �€
� . . ��� "'° �..g , �
�
e
0
.�.
>
�
° v �
E O
O �+
�
• Y
` � o
^ V °i z
E O Q �
v i �
i o n W '
x x o x xx' `� � x x
i�� �� �g�����E�E �� �� ��
Hg�
� " �
� a a �q
z � � m o w r..
F x m y z z i
4
fJ N � LL
o ° g ° ° �
V ? v ur N r ii U N N N
� �' ` W � � �
�ce p p
V a% O O N S V U V
E. � F v 5 � 0. F. F
� us 2 u S i v n p O 2 2 Y
m m
B 3 �3 a
V V U V
�
?
W
N
�
0
� �
£ �
O
4 g V
4 $
�
m
i
3
4 a
G C
4 G
�
�
V
�
a
�
a ° d
0
n
c
R
�
u '
� � � c
V
Z V
4 Z 2 V
4 � 4
u � J
� O
V
a �
at w � 6
� m �Z
�& �� ag 'o
� O o O O O O O
° o> ° n> > .;:>
N F � N N N P y
� x n x e x e x
V£ 4 S U£ V S
P � � O
N N N
8 S � E
H F
z ° z ° z z
� � � �
� � � �
V U U V
�J R 4
N °r °
� � � � � a
� a o 0 0 0
� v
4 0� � �a�' �..
� `.!' `4 $ a
z � � � "
? F t7 � � �
�� �� �� ��
�i'? — �Sd''
�i w
� U
i j
V �
z
� o � o
° e � » >
�g�H
N x .. x
V � L £
� O
N F
� �
M F
° z ° z
� � � �
� � � �
V U V V
� a
E 4
� ° z o
� z
c �
� y � � e
u o � o :
q � � 6 q
a ip 4 E
n� H �+ £ l
y u F � � c
4 Ol 4 4 4 F
A
Z 4
O G �
V F �
a � �
f z .
y � .
7
m �
o � �
0
� � �Y Y . V .O
; a s a � � � � � � ag�
m
� ! � � � � � � � � � � � �
s a � .. a � soa
� � U � � $ a � a ���
��,$
... .. M .. N � .. .. .. :s�
z a
e a z z
ru w m e
w
a z a �
� d � � o � o �a �d ' o � o ? o � o � o `" o
m
� i ' 3 ° 5 ° 5 4 3 °. 3 ° S ° 5 0 5<' 3
�., o 0 0 0 0 o e o = o e o e o
° n > �°. > > n > « > r > s > .°� >
�� `"„ '" y , `" "� y ." .g
V
y , �n % � v % y[ �u % N % �n % ry
4 F 4� M1 F m F C F 6 F 6 f n. F u F 5
� V£ V£ U S V� U S V� V£ V S E 5
2 �
F
K �
� � �
V � F
w
m � N
0
H
z
9
O
y 7
C Z
� O
� W F 0�1 � (�il N Ll �
F N N F F N N � N
o E � � o � o 0 0
V yp
2 x Z 2 4 Z y 2 Z
� F F F F � F
o ^ : � � � � � V
�1 q� � U U V V V V
8
O w K �
•> � 0 6 O N Y V
m N C
„ � o o � � � � o
' � '� M 9 o m ��' u
� " ` � ; § � � � J a � �i $
° y � a° Z�: o a 'o � `�'� F m ` � �' o
6^ N F F F 4�1 U 2 0
�y °� a� =y = �m a
0
9 "
>>� .�° �� �� m� �� m
V 4 �
V
V V V
O
� z
o � �
n � a
8 W � Y
my
�� ��
� 4 V �
� � � � r �
� � �
w w c n m
C�i G � c �
� � � �^
s , � d�
E £ � i N
8 � � �„y
ro a o
"°� .. ,. � a3
a
a a
6 � z
�o ° 'o z mo
03 03 ° .3
; e o = o
",> $ >
v y �. F � F
n % C� %
V £ V £ V £ 2�
m u�1 �
f F ! F
� � � �
� � 8
� O O U
z z z z
Y � � F �
� $ � � �
V 4 V V V
N O
O N
`� p S { � � g z
K V O y 4 V U�
� o S � Q F y z
d 4 £ . !� H r
�� 4 O V 9 F u w
��� �g �� �a
�i � f� U � . 4 � U �
��a�� c� C�
@
�
9�-35�
�
o�:
F i
2 4 .
O G •
U �� �
F �i •
� �
i �
O U
f � � � � � �
4 V
G �
Y X
Y V V U U O D U Y Y y
�, : � � � � � c � : F � � m u � o �€
�
�;� � � � � � ���� � � � � � � �
a a .a .a w u ' i a a a
�;€ � � 8 � 8 E x� m 8 8 � � � £ $
� es��
q . �n � �n n n n n� 17 4 n 'n u n m � m
� ti � r . . n � �
W � � s n 6 � �e a a � � a
� o. � a n a & en z a
7 F ' m N ° i o � w � o � w � w � o � o � F ° o � o � a �` o z
q �� o F o F o H a F o F O p O E F � F o F F O H O F
a � °5 03 °5 °3 °S °5 °5 °3 03 03 ° .3 '3 e5
o; o y o 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 0 0
a> .°.> w i r> ° w > .°.�> . .:> N> w>
S � � Q F y N � � N � � � ti � � � � � � >
q V � N p m N - N n q N N �+ N »
u 0. • � • i i • � • r i �
y C cC C X % % % C X w X %
y , 4. F x{+ R F Y�+ 6 F G + M1 M u. � 4. F s F M E G W� G 6 F 4[� W
9 P �(� S V�S' U i V 1 V£ V 2 V£ V S V.E U Y V S U 1 V£ V
F
t
N
u
z :
o �
F
6
�gi
4 O G P O C � 0� � � p p
L � N N � � N N N N y (Sil � ' N y N 0 N
^ ��U QZ � � V V L V V V V V V y V
U V {� p
� 2 Z L 5 E Z 2 Z L 2 2 2 i 2
C
O
N
0
4l i
>
v Z �
G
� O
I N W Fi F � F F F F F F F !-� �
$ � : � � � � � � � � � � � � a �
Y p • V V V V V G V V V V V
R
� � � 6 p �
O r� x 4 6 >
•> 6 y F � Y� O p
: L y F � y � 3 N �
V V % O T 4 � . � } F K Y w d 0
: Y p� M � 4 W O � � N M V V C Y � p . P G
i Z N % �
u u ol V U
� " � .. � ' � � a . �i o � � :
� 'n � � � o � � . � o � � � �g � M1 � m
O u � Z E F r V � p � O L� G �$ `q � p O� ( '�y •
� .] 4 � V� N � N � w r Z � S Y V� 4 m �
��� ° qg " � o „ � a c z o� m m w a oi z o z z z
� ° , 3 3 � � � ° S� 7 d ° � i ¢ "�� "� ° g a u � a ' q� 8 $ g
o". >> : u o � � i a a� o 0
P
�7 —3S�'
o�
�.
_.
oa:
Si F
<�
2 4 �
n 6 �
a
o�
e�
4 V
� � �
U U ]L Y V U X U Y Y U
€ � � & u c � € � � � � � €
' o
� � m �
� ; � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
$ '' ° x '' n i ' n ' i
� � ° E � 8 g € � 8 � � � g � 8
� �
� � � �" � � a � � = � �
a�fo �� �o �o �� �$ �o �� �a �$ � �x�s ��
V g F � F o N o F F o l+ � N � t o t+ o N o H 4 F O M F
§ x o ° o 3 0 0 � o � o ° o ° o ° 3 0 0 °o o � = 3 0 e 5
� p o 0
� � > ° o > � > r > rv s ° n > o > e i � > n > .^ > n ° o s �°.> > o >
w� N � N N N N N � N y N y N y N n% N N a N 2 � N N i � N
V W � Z
0. � � • • � O �
, X u� F V X 'n X �n % n H % t� M 'a % c X m% o f n X rt M m%
� � o; � u: � r� w� i� i� S o o. m a
� s u� ti i u$ �� �`Y ti S v i ti ti¢ �°� w a ti S ti z u`i
z �
F �
4 •
� £
O �
V
0
�
O
�
>
Y
� O
. o ° 1
S O �
Y T O £
P � J $ m
Q V I y F
� O u
a � �
4
1 �
q>a ,
q� G G Q � � G � � G G
y F f N F F F F y Y y F y
�� 8 ° E E E E E � E ° 8 �
z E � ° z z ° z � ° z i � i ° z s z
4 5
� �
�
V V
�
O
v r n
� � �
2 2 Z
g �S
w
�
�
V
8
3
0
�
�
w � � C � � � k w �
� � � o � � � � � �
V V V V U V V V U V
0 2 0
2G [�• � H ° s
p Po � IX � m V
a � a �
s 5 0 � o a � � N § � z
� m V S y K V O !� .] n N O
p q u m� 9 O a O N
u � _ y � F p �
� N S �� � v F h Y „ f� �n E 0
j 2
8 4 Ll �2 F �� £ p � $ � 4 Q
�� Yq � 6 � �� 4 �y� W N O Y
V' u V£ � F � N 2� S.�1 S i 2 p
�
�
V
Y a
�
F O
O y
F 4
N O
C S
00
:
_ ;
°I�-3s�
�
o�,
=d.
00
�r
a�
F=
�
�:
6 w
O V
N � � `
4 V
¢ 41 N
Y O t� V y
•� V iC ( V W V V u V f O � YJ
: 'c �€ � � � w u� � � � V E o p� �
a g � �d a � ° d �d � > d z d � �d � � ~ r �
S y :� "i � ' a u .a � � g o z a
V � � � � � 8 � � � � � S m ° " 8
H . � o
mza
za o
� e � .. � .. � ., < .. .. . � � a � .,
0
�° e � a � a °� o a � a � e
m
�" � a � �z �z��� �z �z �z �z �:
� r ° s i w " o i o � o a o 0 0�a w o .. o w o m o a o
U O a p F O F e E F o F R Z o(% � F o H F e N
q„ o p a O O d o O � O o p O e] V � o O � O o O o � O O
V � r „ v Y > N Y > O> n> u�i � 4 N Y o> N Y n> a?
F F N � 5 � F u�i F � y � E � S�
� � ° � r .��. N m N " � n u ' � � g � � ."'.
a � � � � � �
Y V
f1 % N% �n % �n % N% vl % N � o rv% !� % v X n X in X
� U£ U S U£ U S V Z U E V S 0.� R U£ V£ U S U£ � U�
O [
F
�� 0 O P O � O
V�� F y N � M
M y
S � � � � � � "E �
U � V U V U U V
W � F F F F �+
O i 2 2 � Z Z 2 v
a
0
0
m :
>
� �
`� o
' i � � � �" � � �
g° � � � 3 � a �
+1 Q O • U U V V C
3^
a o
" � � $ � _ �
q : 0 £
• � � U a d
J � r� � "' y 0
S : S p q
o P��.l � , a � 9 0 4
8 � a $ � � J �
Q " ` � � � � ..
: o � � �y �� ''g �� ��
o->e i� �� �� -;� 5� ��
W � N W
y N vi N
� � � �
V V V V
° z ° z a z
�
�
V
�
� � � � �
� u � � �
5
m �
m � � a o
o � � o g
y`" p" ° m
¢ Y F F C n Q
� � m 3 H
� z � `N � �
N o w a` � y u a
rc rc Q �' v � �
y a y
; ` ^�i i 1 '�S �i N Y
�
8
�
k
�
V
�
m
0
0
e
��
4 v
N
P
\ ( � �i ��
z F a
0 0 �
� � :
4 �
F 2 �
� 6
'1 �
p U m
� � � � �
O \
2 W
W O O� 6
W . [`��?' i� C��✓�j 4 (! � V N
r� � �i y W 6 N N U£ U �l ri � $ a u 6 F F V r � .
y� G 6 a � a � x Pi ����� 3 z m d � 3 � G
�,( mi 4 � V O o�£ y F O 2 V£ O N
Z Z z p�
p � 4 4 4 V Z a 2 v O $ 4 p � V s >
V ��.i a U r] � K H F 6 4/�L w Z m H�� 6 C � 6
� § �i � � ° n m o m R Q m w x `3 o s ° ° Q '� � � �i
n?� 3 4��� F q �� U� Z
` N ` � '� q � � � N $ � � � �O � m �
i n v�i P� m a Fl e 6 V��¢ f�u � F a 4(] 6 Y n m
K
a w a
c
p w
� o- L M Z 4 w
���o�"�.g 'o "o o �F �
� y � O O
Z V� O F a p M� e[+ o F G o F F o F
'J M e .i � ` l a � O y O 3 � Q p � �p �l � �1
� e O o p o O a O a O 2� ry � 9 o O
° > rv > » > i ". > o > �° >
V 2 N N y . F � F N N � N w= o � N N N
W
• i � J N
u� X rv% �n X n% v% �� �1 %
W F W H W� d E+ W� 2 O V 4 e p p p
� ti� ti�x vi� ti x v� i � i �i �ii'
z .
o ,
N �
4 �
� £ G �
y F
C
T � 0
( f
� R 2
O
O W
7
a z :
a
� o
F H
O m V �
y �tl V
e .. u
e
: �
• J O �i S
4 , (� w nf
o a 9 ,�
o � s � m �
o=
:
:;�' .��
4
i > a . � o
O m �
F y
� � O
z � � i
� �
V V
z �
� �
£ �
� N
N C
� �
o�
� �
� N
£ 4
4 �
o E Oo
O �
= o
��
�o
x° ��
f
�
V
O
F
�
V
�
O
£
�
O
m
O
a
x
� u
y
Z
V
9
O
N
5�
i
V V
� € Z
F 4
J ri
� �
C
c
�
4l � 4
Z
� O
e >
us F
%
w � r.
u �` v
� O
N f
O U
F F
2 2
N
� � � U
V V V V
a m w
4 N �
� a � j � a �
n [� j �
V 2
4 £ r £
� O � 4
� K V V P
�� s� �
> 'p
� y � m� po °
ni Y i S Y � O �
P
Z 4
V F �
4 � �
F 2 i
r 6 �
° o u
m � �
F O
4 V
O �
• �
X Y X ✓
V X V y V ` 1
� G �i � " S 6 G E o
�e � � � � � � � � � � a
� � £ � � � a � � � � �
V �
M Y
e� U
� � � .. .�. .� �`n .. N .. .. .". G
d� � a ° � ° n a a °
�` �` °j . � z �` � z z a � z
i ° w o i o � o m x � y r o i o �. o
� � O F a H 4 F a N F o F 4 F o E o F W E O f
§ � 5 °3 03 °3 03 °5 %3 °5 °3 05 °5
: o o a . o 0 0 . o a a . o 0 0 0 0 . o 0 0
" y '" „ y o° > ,.°, s °o > n > ° a > r 5 �4 >^ o° >
b F � N N N � F N N N N N N � t N N y N � f V - N
� ` � • • • r • . � � r �
� % p % X X y % % p y �
� � F W( n F !u F e. F W F W F fu (+ W F W f C E
�� U£ V£ V£ V S V S U£ V� U£ V£ V S
O
K
Y
V =
t� �
4 �
�� � O O C O � O G �
� Ci " N " N N " iA " N
� � � � � � � � � � � �
V q V U V {. U V V V
� 2 2 S 2 2 Z 2 S 2 3
0
O
7 W •
2 �
9
n O
� • •���
� `� V
G G t
� � �
a
° � gi
V U
m a a
� z �Z
' o � M i o
00 00 00
K > N > tt >
a N N N N N
�e X N v � %
U £ V S V £
� � m
N H ryF N
2 2 2
V V U
t p
Z Z 2
� W F F � � F � H F � � �
g` � � � � � � � � � � �
� p • V V U V f/ C V
� e m n y c m
.. o m � m i x u 'o � s o .
•> Q m � m z m � � '..` d".. �
� s `� o � e m ° � F °�
N y K W Q R d N Q y C j � N �
u u o�� O V Q � e 7 i O . a S U � Q
5 V O W U � y u� V m
� 4� w a o G`$ �$[ M N � � m n p 6 � r
� V i Z F 4 Z U N 9 � F ,� 4 N �� 3 V � ~
a w r a 4 i £�� m � j v
M�� � F O Z a K N �£ � 2� � T� y - O N V u
F j
"ia . � �� �8 �� f� �o �8 € $m �`�'A o-� �
H
�
V
a
m
C
�
R N
��
4 N
4
9� - �Sg'
�
o�
2 4
O [.. G
V F
4 ]
F 2
� 6
a
o u
4 U
C
% X
r 4 U X Y X
; � � � V V , � j V
m� m u w t E �i
� � � � � � � �
� � 3 , i i i
V � £ S L
' 8 8 � 8 8 E
h �
� s z " z a N
m
� 6 m � � y 6
: � Z � � �
C �l N 4� p tu O � O 4 O 4 O � O
� �i ° .5 ° .5 e5 ° .S °5 ° .5
� o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
� � � r > n > » s n > $ > rv >
N n� N N y N �� V - N N � F /1 N N
Y u � � � � � • �
V � e` X n% n% �v X N%
.� � U£ V£ V S V� U£ V S
�
R
F
V
Q
F
4 �
� Y � O O � O O O
�; N W 4 � F N
^ I � � � � � �
:s a a s s �
� F F F F M l+
� 2 Z Z 2 2 2
P
O
�
O
>
y 2 �
O
n Q
: � � � k w �
q � , � � � � � �
� p � V V U V U V
�
�o � e � � � o
•> � j 4 V V Z �
✓ n
� {� y N d p N
a� �� 2 4 � F F 2
` � � £ ' £ y q � �y b �
n I n O„ i m £ q m n Y
0 0� � O O � S P
�Z ��„� S 8 8 G C Y x
O ~ ryryry N S ��j � � ry
u u � F N
9 O H .] i f� S� y � 2
O • p � y .i � �
� i 6 � m V i? a a i 6 4 � 1 4
U V V U V V % Y
� � ° € c � t�i G
� � � � � � � �
i Y
� � �` 8 � � � �
o a a a a m n
� i m � a f� a
"' o °' o m o 4 o m o °' o � o � o
eS o3 .3 ° 5 ° 5 05 oS �5
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.: > » > s rv i �°. s � > ° o > rv >
- u v � N N H w H • E w F � vHi
�a Y a X % V M % N%� n X N X
d l+ b F 4 q f b� 4 F C{ M F fu H
V� V£ V£ U� U� V S U£ V£
3
V
q � y � C � O O 0
N t N N N oi N
� . � � � � � � �
V �£ V V V la V
,F� P � F F H f�+ (+ f
Z ° z z i z z
�
c
�
V
n
W
� �
� O
� � k � � � k
� � � � � v �
V V V V V V V
�
V O C � n O
O � 6 a O 4 f O
4 O u � 4 N �
„ +] � 4� � O 3
X U� 0 4 m n
O 4 � � V � �G O
}; E
% ( F 4N1 �. � �a `� �£ N
d U Y x o- V >� 3 4 3
e F �
V V 9 ¢ Y N N tl m ¢ S K
O 0. a� e� � u C O C S C v y N
4
q�-35 �
� F
2 } 6 r
V F
4 � �
� 6
O U
W �
F O
6 (1
�
� �
�
V .]
V
�] N ' ~ O
V O t+
O u � o O
U
y y rv >
F i � F
V �
• V S
U
w
G
�
J
O
U
6 O
0 4
a
n N
�
V �
V U V � U V �� l V U f W
� � � 'c � . �b � � a � � e �
� � � � � � �a � � � � �
> � £ a �
V O £ p O � O p�G � O E V V
V V V V�l U
V i
` O � �
N N m r� n N u+ V n V m n .y
0. N � � M1 W 6 p p � 6
y 2 6 � d Z � � 2 Z y z
� N W O 6 O r O � Y � a � � O �� 6 O m O �
'� °. 3 0 5 0 3 °. 5 ° 3 °� o S o 5 0 5 °. 5
O p o O O O • O o O � O e � O O o O a O
� rv> N 7 o S rv> �a > N 7 ��ia 7 H> n>
� H M f .. y tn F � N � N � F N N N N F N
i
n% tv X X % �^ % n X q K �e % v% n�{ in y.
V S U Z V� U£ V£ V£ V� V Q V q � 6 ¢ G V
p £ P S V£ V£
2 �
F �
R �
�g;
� c c o c o � � o c
Y F N N N � y H y F
T � 1 8 � S � 8 8 � � �
�� � � 2 � Z Z 2 Z
9
O
O
Y
y 9
O
� O
; � k � f: � � � k
g ° � � � � � � � � �
= O � U U V V U V V V V
O
O
Y „ 0 6 $ 0
w g Y � �
3 �' .z z o g o � ° �
� � �� o .� s = � ; � E
� :."'.o§ oa °,"a �� A � ��, � � �
N 3 p
a P� F 0�`l F� � N V V F N {y. i � ]
9 O Y Z F � i O '� � �� N p O Y Q� £ Y� �Y u
C K V O a y �1 2�
;� "�� �'' g€ a " �� a ` �� w° �
d>a ,��� »o� �H �� �� �� �� �� s
O p p p
F F f E� F
W H 4�1
� � � � �
� � � o F
z z z
� � �
� � �
U V U
a
o c
_ � <
a a o " o
U a V a y
V V V U V
� � � � �
g � � h �
� k
� �
V V
o �
N a
V N
O ol
4 Z
C Q
z o �
w o � F �l
v
O E
i 4
O G
U F
4 �
F 2
� 6
i
W r
O
� �
P
�7- � s�
X
( V � X Y g
N : �' � G E !�. t u � � � G G t
� ; � � � � � � � � � w � � �
Pi � a � 5 '' � £ p ° � i �6 �+ °� G q � £ p o
S V V � V V O D U V
V Z
� Y �1
� n c U N w in n n n n V �o in e
p � a a � z r a
w n �`.r
� i � ° c m 6 w z
o; z i z i z � z z � z z z s z .�. z � z . o m a � z
N N � O O D (u O r G� O R O O !y O 6 O fu O
V O F o F o F o F w F O F f� o F o F O F o F o F O F
��'o 00 oa 'S e3 00 °o Sa �3 00 �3 00 00
� '^> »"> ;> «> o> �°.> S"> �"."> R> r"> p"> »"> >
n� F N m Z V - N u y N y N H� . y � y � y N p . y N F
2 N
% X % % % % % % %(� % % % %
� F W F t F� 6 F 0 F fw F h M fu F� Y F W N 0 F Y N 4 t�
•£ U S U£ U S V S V£ U£ V S V� U� V£ V£ U£ �
9 •
F •
4 �
� � �
c o � o c � o � F � u ° w
V F F F b F F h N H y �+ F
^ � � � � � � � � � � � � �
V V V V V U V U V V V
F F 4 Y } t F f F F t� Y 4
• S Z Z Z Z 2 2 2 9 Z Z � z
n
0
w �
� z �
�
m
o �
� � � � � � � � � w � � �
o� � � � � � � � � � � � � o
�o . � � c c � � � � � s � � �
• m a
sa ° � a m �4 � �
• > H O � � Y F � m � [i
„ F � � F 4 N � V m N .� . F . � M
•� O Y U N O O� .�i � U y c V a m Y C �`� �� V P m
: z� � m o �� �ax �� �� �� m � �
o � 9 � � , o � m � � � N � �a a ° s : � H $ � $ � g � � �
-: ."� 3 L � $ o i� i �q c n� @ @ � o w a
M ti o .] 0 R � W y G �{^ p $!� � £ 4
��� p �� � O � f � H � � � e � F F N� � F m � F il 6 K K
a.. � �S �o ", s � �a ��S o ��^ £ p o Y �� �� �� �
P'J 4 � V � V �+ y � 2 � � m �� f n F F a
2 4
y O } C
U f
4�
F 2
� �
4 w
Y �
O V
� 2 Y
V V
m s G 6
'`e ' � u u
� V � N
� p F i �i
y Sf�'1 £ £
� O O U V
w K
3 '
�>"3 .. e
�
�
� m s o °' o
N
" o3 �3
� E : o S o
V
O 7 N >
J1 F
F ..i c�i y - F
U 2
♦ V � V £
S �
F
4
O �
w � � �
V
�
9
O
�
?
a
<
0
° a �
S O �
3 O
• >
f
Y � �
O
e q � y m
� V 4 2 F
. >
� O ~ 9p 2
� ] �
6 � 6 � •
>a x
f
O
f
2
�
�
W
�
O
�
O
V
2
�
°
V
X g
G
V
�
J
V
�
° o
oS
O p
x F
W F
U �
O
F
�
Z
�
�
V
m > �
4 4 O py
9 F 0 4
V �ry �U s
� N � �
C � y
W � O (C � O�
� � � V .l � V
�s ;,s
�,�..358'