Caricom FiEvE��'��
. FEB 2 8 2013
NOTICE OF CLAIM FORM to the City�q�,�ZimG�aul, Minnesota
Minnesota State Stutute 466.05 states that "...every person...who claims dumages from any municipaliry...shall cause to be presented to the
governing body of the munictpality within 180 days a�ter the alleged loss or injury is discovered a notice stating the time,place,and
circumstances thereof,and the amount of compensation or odher relief demanded."
Please complete this form in its entirety by clearly typing or printing your answer to each question. If more space is
needed,attach additional sheets. Please note that you will not be contacted by telephone to clarify answers,so provide as
much information as necessary to explain your claim,and the amount of compensation being requested. You will receive a
written acknowledgement once your form is received. The process can take up to ten weeks or longer depending on the
nature of your claim. This form must be signed,and both pages completed. If something does not apply,write`N/A'.
SEND COMPLETED FORM AND OTHER DOCUMENTS TO: CITY CLERK,
15 WEST KELLOGG BLVD, 310 CITY HALL, SAINT PAUL, MN 55102
First Name ��/�-'�� Middle Initial L Last Name �� ���
Company or Business Name N'/�
Are You an Insurance Company? Yes�f Yes,Claim Number?
Street Address Z� 31 �S�t/( /Q1��
City Sl���f ��'r� State 1'�� Zip Code
��ro g
Daytime Phone(�!�8'fal�►3 Cell Phone(6�)�����7'' Evening Telephone(��07� b/3�
Date of Accident/Injury or Date Discovered T�13 Time ���� pm
Please state,in detail,what occurred(happened),and why you are submitting a claim.Please indicate why or how you
feel the City of Saint Paul or its employees are involved and/or responsible for your damages.
St S�f k 'T�J o LAR S t�Jf.�L� �
n f u�c.4�;�v�. N�r I�1 ��N �o --
�o i.J o `r '�; ' ._
J W�'.+J h�r� vS �r.rt A�l�•1��0
Please check the box(es)that most closely represent the reason for completing this form:
❑ My vehicle was damaged in an accident ❑ My vehicle was damaged during a tow
❑ My vehicle was damaged by a pothole or condition of the street ❑ My vehicle was damaged by a plow
�VIy vehicle was wrongfully towed and/or ticketed ❑ I was injured on City property
❑ Other type of property damage—please specify
❑ Other type of injury—please specify
In order to process your claim vou need to include copies of all applicable documents.
For the claims types listed below,please be sure to include the documents indicated or it will delay the handling of
your claim. Documents WILL NOT be returned and become the property of the City. You are encouraged to keep a
copy for yourself before submitting your claim form.
O Property damage claims to a vehicle: two estimates for the repairs to your vehicle if the damage exceeds
$590.00;or the actual bills and/or receipts far the repairs
�Towing claims: legible copies of any ticket issued and a copy of the impound lot receipt
O Other property damage claims: two repair estimates if the damage exceeds $500.00; or the actual bills
and/or receipts for the repairs;detailed list of damaged items
O I�jury claims: medical bills,receipts
O Photographs are always welcome to document and support your claim but will not be returned.
Page 1 of 2—Please complete and return both pages of Claim Form
i
. y
, ,.. . �-
�, 3 •T ; �. `+ . �` •. . ..
.�� •t
� ', , ' '. +. . : �. �..
' � � � • ,�•�., , .
, . _, , ' .,?� ::x�` r"� ���t�i ��s' q 1,`+� �!y
• . . . , i'. �':
... •,E .~,• >. �.� . ,�4.,}, � . ��� . . .+i .. �.�' . t ^k:�. �� � r� . . ' O.x,'*'i•
S.e �
' ..R.:r�.�.i '�.i i�`��. 1 . �.,j 4•� �+�_"r i: ;"1� \� •^�i . . . . •3'��. '�.. � �i ,a?� ..xi�� .i;`���� ��� .
, , r�t,'�'� �,�A f �� �ti _. �> .,y`•;"Jt:. .,;�1 4 i ��-4t 1�iy i�'..� l :
. . � :�: at �—. � z � ,:�i ? ��.��; . . •i f• � y� .
- -_ • .
Failure to complete and return both pages will result in delay in the handling of your claim.
All Claims—nlease complete this section � ---
Were there wimesses to the incident? Yes No U__.nknow�� (circle)
Provide their names,addresses and telephone numbers:
Were the police or law enforcement called? Yes No Unknown (circle)
If yes,what department or agency? Case#or report#
Where did the accident or injury take place? Provide street address,cross street, intersection, name of park or facility,
closest landmark,etc. Please e as detailed as possible. If necess�y att ch a diagram
D��h1 LI l tW✓� ��7)-1�. ?��f� �F,Gd w+ Yt y r�r� �— r'��A � /L,l-r�l f.��ar',�0
Please indicate the amoun�t/you e seeking in compensation or what you would like the City to do to resolve this daim
to your satisfaction. jY s��• DO�
Vehicle Claims—please complete this section ❑ check box if this section does not apply
Your Vehicle: Year Make Model
License Plate Number State Color
Registered Owner
Driver of Vehicle
Area Damaged
City Vehicle: Year Make Model
License Plate Number State Color
Driver of Vehicle(City Employee's Name)
Area Damaged
Injurv Claims—please complete this section ❑check box if this section does not applv
How were you injured?
What part(s)of your body were injured?
Have you sought medical treatment? Yes No Planning to Seek Treatment(circle)
When did you receive treatment? (provide date(s))
Name of Medical Provider(s):
Address Telephone
Did you miss work as a result of your injury? Yes No
When did you miss work? (provide date(s))
Name of your Employer:
Address Telephone
Check here if you are attaching more pages to this claim form. Number of additional pag �.
By signing this form,you are stating that all information you have provided is true and correct to the best
of your knowledge. Unsigned forms will not be processed.
Submitting a false claim can result in prosecution. Date form was completed T�-� ��
Print the Name of the Person who Com�eted this Form: ����" �• �2'N�G�M�
.
Signature of Person Making the Claim: -----_.__
Revised February 201 I
F�'. �, �. .� . .R• •�':��� . i'.,_�a • }� 1t1.. �i }�f�,�i�' •.�2_� .:�' � '. '�.t�� .. `� ��t'1 � ..�•1�,��• .
. .�-* •. .t . ''�
� ' .
• • .
'�a •. '� •j 'y, ..'%� ' . . ' � . 2.�r .
Dan Carnicom
2131 Doswell Avenue
St. Paul, Minnesota 55108
612-840-6134
Dan@DLC3.com
To: Ciry of Saint Paul
From: Dan Carnicom� �
�--�
2i3i Doswell
Date: February 2�, 2oi3
RE: Supplement to"Notice of Claim Form"
Filed 2/2�/i3 regarding wrongful ticket and tow 2/u/i3
I am providing this summary and additional information as evidence supporting my claim against the Ciry for a
wrongful ticket and tow—twice—on February ii,2oi3. I am a resident of Saint Paul at the noted address since
2008,and certify that the information provided herein is true and correct.
FACTS
Snow emergency was declared 2/io/13 by the City.I received notice via text and e-mail from the City.I
accordingly moved my two vehicles from in front of my residence that afternoon(Doswell is an east-west night
plow street)on the afternoon of 2/io.Because the garage was temporarily full of project materials,I drove down
my alley behind the house and parallel to Doswell and parked on the west side of Hythe near poswell.I then
walked over half the block of Hythe,noting other cars parked on the street,and noting that there were no(zero,
none)signs indicating a night plow street.So,I had both cars parked on Hythe overnight February io.
The cars were ticketed and towed between 6:go and�:ooam,arriving at the City impound lot at�:o6am. I
discovered the loss of the vehicles at 7:45am when I went to move the vehicles back in front of my residence.
EXHIBITS
The following is provided to assist in the documentation of this claim:
• Exhibit i is a map of the neighborhood printed from Google Maps,and highlighted in pencil with
approximate alley and parking locations.The location of my cars that are noted as boxes i and g on Hythe
near poswell. Box 2 was another car that was not ticketed and towed that was between my two vehicles as
illustrated.At the north end of the Hythe block is a circle indicating the location of a street sign noting
"snow emergency—no night parking"noted as Si.The distance between the cars towed and this sign Si is
over 50o feet and around a bend in the street.As can be observed,it is possible to traverse the alley
behind the 2i3i Doswell residence,turn left/south on Hythe,and never see a"snow emergency—no
night parking"sign.Further,it is clear that my walking the block over half way north would not provide
visibility to the posting.
... ; . • . ``t,� �
. Dan Carnicom
• F�chibit 2 is the Google street view looking south at from the corner of Hythe and Buford.The sign
indicating snow emergency parking is visible and noted as Si.
• E�ibit 3 is a picture taken by the writer 2/ii/i3looking south and noting the sign Si as still in place.
• Exhibit 4 is a picture taken by the writer 2/ii/ig looking south from the Si location.Note that the location
of Doswell Street and the location from the cars that were towed is not clearly visible due to the bend.
• Exhibit 5 is a picture taken by the writer 2/ii/ig indicating that a parking posting in mid-block of Hythe
does not include night snow emergency status. I walked to this sign on the afternoon of 2/io/i3 and
noted no night emergency sign present in mid block.
• F,xhibit 6 is a picture taken by the writer on 2/li/i3 of the parking sign posting on Hythe near poswell.It
will be observed that no snow emergency night parking prohibition is present.This sign is immediately
adjacent to where my cars were towed.
• Exhibit�is a picture taken by the writer 2/ii/i3 of the location where one of my cars were towed,from
immediately behind the silver car in the picture.This vehicle still shows snow cover.At 7:45 am there was
no disturbance of the front windshield except for the marks in the fresh snow where I looked for a snow
emergency ticket(there was none).
• Exhibit 8 is a picture taken by the writer 2/ii/i3 of the location immediately in front of the silver car in
E�ibit�,showing the location from which my second car was towed.It also documents that towing the
car was done too late in the time interval to allow plowing.In other words,towing the cars did not enable
the city to plow the street prior to shifting to day snow plow protocol,and the continued presence of the
noted silver colored vehicle(and other vehicles also parked on the west side of Hythe overnight that were
not tagged and towed)meant the towing resulted in no plowing in any event.
• Exhibits 9 and io are the copies of the tag and tow costs for each vehicle referenced above.
FACTS DOCUMENTED BY THE EXHIBITS
Facts documented by these exhibits include that there is only one night parking snow emergency sign on Hythe,a
north-south street.The sign is over 500'from where the towing occurred.Additionally,it is possible to enter the
parking location without the necessity to pass this single sign.Further,a resident attempting to follow the snow
emergency guidelines in good faith must rely upon the sign postings,which are not visible to those who look
within 300'of their parking location as did the writer.
Not documented in these pictures but observable today is that streets parallel to Hythe contain two or three snow
emergency signs per block.
INVESTIGATION OF CTTY SIGN POSTING PRACTICES
Investigation of the city sign posting practices by the writer indicates that there are many thousands of street
signs.In speaking on Tuesday 2/12 with Monica Beeman,city engineer,she indicated some concern about a single
sign.She indicated that due to the distance,bend in the street and other factors that she would likely recommend
that multiple signs be posted on this 600'super-block. She pointed out that at one time there may have been
multiple signs in place,perhaps not,but that her preliminary opinion would likely see that additional signs were
posted on Hythe based on the facts represented to her in that conversation.
2 6
Dan Carnicom
BASIS FOR CLAIM TO THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL FOR REIMBURSEMENT
(i)The area of the city street from which the tag and tow occurred was not marked as a night snow plow—no
parking within 500'. A city resident who made a good faith effort to comply with city ordinances for snow
emergency parking is unable to rely on city signage for that purpose in this specific case.The fact that other cars
were parked adjacent to the tag and tow location indicates that other residents were and are also not aware of the
status of this half a block on Hythe.
(2)The tag and tow enforcement was arbitrary.Over i2 other cars were parked in that immediate area on the west
side of Hythe towards Doswell and not one other car had a ticket on the windshield or was towed on 2/ii/i3.If the
City intends to tag and tow it is incumbent on the City to post and enforce its ordinances on all citizens.Why
should adjacent blocks have multiple snow emergency postings but not in this half block?If tag and tow is City
ordinance,why was not even one other car of over r2 was not towed or at least tagged by 7:45am?
(3)The Ciry proclaims that it is the most livable city in America,but failure to honor this claim would be evidence
that this tag is not supported by City actions.For example,in 2oio when a huge limb fell on one of the cars on the
city street in front of 213i Doswell(one that was towed on 2/ii/i3)from a dangerous tree on the City boulevard
and caused over$5,00o in damage the City claimed"an act of God"and declined reimbursement.When the City
receives complaints that the i-hour limit on-street parking in front of 2i3i Doswell is never enforced any more,
nothing is done.Indeed,the City explains that the traffic enforcement staff has been diverted to other priorities,
resulting in university student parking in such force and seeming impunity that it often prevents resident parking
due to a lack of space due to cars parked a day at a time.Thus,cars who do not display resident permits displace
those residents who do buy and display such permits.Finally,the City is known to make a margin over cost of
towing from snow emergencies,but profit from towing that does not result in plowing seemingly is just another
disguised t�on city residents.
(4)To balance the"livability"quotient and take responsibility for its own actions,the City must reimburse for
those inadvertent actions wherein the City and the resident both acted in good faith,but City sign posting was
incomplete or changed over time from the original installation and other factors.
(5)To save on the time,person power and cost that will go into the appeal and political process that will follow
denial of a reasonable request for reimbursement in this claim as citizens exercise their due process rights in the
administrative and political channels available.
3 •
_
__ _ _
2/18/13. Google Maps
� -„ You can enter notes here
G��������� �. .
�� ,� ,��� / . ,n�� Get Google Maps on your phone
«� /"� � Texttheword"GMAPS"to466453
�
�
i_____.._.._ . .__.. ___ _.___.. ._----.-- _.____.-- -.__.__--------._.__,.---.____ _ _
_____. .------ ___ _ . , ._._ _
� z
�
i
�''8u/ordAve ,
.N Bu{o�d Ave W Buford Ave
n
; �
N S�o
0
a
�
' Z �T
!W
�
�4 �
E � �
0
a
� � <
i rn
' � i y."
� ,f r
T� �fi
.�i I � � pL,j''
1 a ; - '�� I
! ry�
�� _� P��'� W Doswel[Ave
4
�
�e
. ���i e��p- �
�" 05� �
v Sy0 3
L o
�'� n
n�.+ D
Z �
J� �
—a os�e11��e �
' �0
�
�
ve '�
��os�e��P o
a
➢
<
�o
�
Couege
Pa��c
Cnil-��Park. -
"-nr;Court�'
02013 Google Iv1ap data 02013 Google
. . . • ... - .�,
� •• . . .
�
•
�— �,�,ti. �fr...
.
:" � • ��4 r� s�`�. ��
w��'� � ��' ,9�•,_
�� ,. ••
��'� �
�=
R
�
�� � • �
�31�.,..�. �.: � . � ri � • i �
� � f�
* �� �• � .��� 7 ��
'� p � . _o �p. . . -+ F
r ..�`r . � ,,.: ,"a. . ���'� „�•,�.. .s� I��`, �;i '!��' �.
+�•'�r .� �.4� vit - • • 4�e'���,.3'�: ..a���:.ti. ` ` 1, . .
�+�ur� ti� .a�'� Y� ' xit..�. ��,'�" • '� �'`��, •�:", l`",. �.
.. �� �
y t ,
R„ � .� �� c *,�. �'' �� �Ir `e•`��� ���•�, :��'� ;:"ti.�. .�'.� � �
.
.
.,, � �� "
� � s� . .. ',f,� .
.._. -� . . . x -� �
,: �� � . �� }�' -• � � r�p � '4p1� s + .�_ � `�•'
� ,yrr �.� •��ii����.+ • �,.
�.Jb�� 3� �%+ .
3'�. �'' ��... _,.'T+'iJi, �
�a�. � r- _�+, . �.� _� �„ � �:���, .
. � ���! �; � � -'!� �� � - �;��a. (�,�. ��'*t
r� ��� �c'� �i►-.t� r�� ���� � •�...�.r.�. .. �.
� a �.,� .. .rs
- + �+� � f~ ��� . . ya�t
� �,
.� �. e.. t . . '�* � --- . � ' .,
,• ._ ^�-:,a, '� .• -
, t
�, � . a3 i�+ s � �
�� ` �. .:�� .. �.�"�� ,�,. .. . �� �
• ��.,. �atr .rS<;. » ;� . ,
..+n. �_��. � ��� � -`�-��.?:'�4�e '�e,�r._��� • •"_� ... � .
.�
.w - ���' :,�:� n� .. ■ .- ,�y. .; � ,.
�!� �� x ... '. � ..:. -.,: ..
, I _`. ,.: .,'„ �: ..� �
�
-�rY�p� ..,.�"'}. -
..,. ' . _- � �. � _. . "A�.� ' ..,:..�..� . ..",.,
f
� �` , �.,.�:�.;_:. .
� {s"-*. '�?�
. _
� .,.- .� _..; -:. �w.�F •:a:.. ,.: ' ri.. :.. ��.�.,,,.,.�,.
_ . +�: _ ,�.,'ea�-e
O 1 ��� -
�
�
1 —'
�r
� �
X
�
��� � � � � �� .
�
'f' �,��y�;,�tr' 1 ; \ f�— �
. �+',y r..{�!�\ \ � �� j .
�
l
♦ .��_ �� , ',/f'�y �1_�� � 1�.
�}F �! c:, qI .�•.'jl �r
�`,j� ,�;;,.. �+��� *��+ . �I � . �j
�' ' ;�� :
� �� ., . � �����:,���4a� ����
���; ,. :
. ,� �.1���4�`� ., ' �'
R"a11�i.VT � •
l�;�p��'la� � 4',r ,�� � •
�
�qc,-� .� ��+��• �' ���'� �`�., •
�r ' ' , �`�a'` .r'��� f �.,''�, \
x '-� � y
�. ti: , �'_�. ,, ���r�� �`�'. _ '
� ( '
�„�,,��� '\. �± ,� ��*��: � \� � .� 3 � �
�� �'c;t, - �,� �' �,i. •Y .,, f `v� v��f� 'f
-�--�'3' - �_ � � ,.._.,� ��
� � `'� ` ��=� '4 �, : —_.._ �;
:--'' e r
� i ��' 4 �„f ,X *` k"�. _1^S r ,
s;j' ����iv 4' � ,% l�l`��"/
:t�'"� � � �� � .,/ �r'�'r � J�'�y .E i �. ... F� � :
ti /` f
' �s: � . tA� �� 1
. , � / 1 �. /��. f• ..' ���,�,�fS�J��y � N� ' . r :.
4 " .�3�� w�i� H�t �1 '� . 7 �/:,.�; 'i
�i ,[ 7r �`ti�.....trq '"`3`.�(� �k •.Z+.,�y.i. r '� j
� f f� �l��� ;, rr� T ���t�' ���"' . Y `�
, r Zrr�^.� "�T�s/� ��'"�`�� - .�v� �
.-.�,�.;�,- ���������s,�;..,�.... �f�tt�.
� _, ;� � i �,�� �3_ � ,��' 3!'t
���. r•:
.�a� ' ;P ' �
• M �
i �
t'�! � � ! a
,y,� � t
��t� ��. f 5� :.� .
4�� S E� � .:� . �� f
� �:::
�.� y
r�
"S^:�k�\ L�t
"\
. Vkr'='w ._
� �t. '�.:`i� R.',� ;�� :`:� , _ ''Sw '�� �� .�� � �, / . ,
� � �'� . l�~� �f EJ ��I'r / l ��'qn •�`` '"�_ � .��-• ; :�' '
• •:j t Rh�i.��� . � �} �, �__� � /��� ��r
� ♦��',� ��'M.. � 'e+. ..,�� .: < :^,� �.y�j�� �%:
\�7�� � r��;t �*�'' :it • .r���j�i`Z��t . �.rY�',~� " �� ; ��;eri`' . ;�/�,-,
�� •,� \ � 4 t� � 1 r, i<.� . � ..`. . r � ;
��,�j,,� }�' � ` 'e '-r ` �a ��
y� i r s
�y,~\\��i �t �~ �'')f'9t�:f E�t`� '•P �y�.a'� '* _����,�'3' , �F"�;
. �� �., ,\1 ',j..'4f`, x „�r�'r . � f � ::� . ^✓��r.�l1+.t'
���� k 1 � ��T��T4�1 .�:w'���� r y :1`z�, � , ':
.\ {} ��`��1 �I�D.��! ���'� F11F� ./'�,_�� �� '�_�r� ,I
^i�� �l� t� 1� ��y�';,j*'��i ti. �„ r.� Q�.� ,`�S• aa,;9'r �^w �J�r��•. � � ('��".]� i
<"".. ��w a � �tar x r��`5�, < � "�,`��f ,y �� Y s� .s�� �'� ► 1
!rt�r��C`�'� 4 T��7+r �`y "` �'� ,q. � � � .. v�N���� �.� r i ;��
� � � �1� M� �,�':: ��::(.,.,� �� r.n �
r�' �� ����\\\T � i� � -� ��-r i w. ..� � F.. � ��; .r �j �"'.,� � . �
�" �` � } �.��'�- � i i t a7�� , �l'� � �1 �
�` �' y� � ��� f�c .`�' � ����� p� � : /i +'`� , '���� �� � � ",�:.: ,)
�.�� Y��.r,l��f\Y� `�G�•�" T�.�'--��!� i _1�`� � ,./ ' . . �� ��'� _ �,. .�
� . .
:,n'~'S'`-a`,, ��,r. `w r�..`` \C�r. :4��,. �� .. \ `;7 Y �i �3
� ��}� ���F� �j .,�.j.,•�. � , 'i�i t� �•� , : � ° �
s $r�.���.. �� �t�� � �..A � G� �•�5 .l ��1� _��
: .e: . .•• '.. -,
'� � � �' - ' 1 ��
.
� ` .' / ��
^ . _ r
� ' ' �. ..•. � .Y .. :
t �- ' ,::::. � .. , �.. .� '
i ��1.-._._'�� .. .�� . �+ ;�`',�„�`�- .,. � ,�� 4..; ��- ../ -�
-�Ci►. .. 4 ,. ...� - .. r,,.. . ... .. �•-
..--°----- ��, ;. , . L _..�_
. � !
. �
��- ---_ .
_ . . ,,.:.
� '-:,
_��.... .. ;.. .
� � ,.. �_ ,
. ... T. ._, . ,. .. ..
�
_ x e
. .\�- .,�F£ s..`. -
h± � <'� ' � ♦�^ " .
� � ' �'` '�
�
`V '
\
i �
�
/ �
�
�
�
� � x �r.
:>- �l. � .,•�. .�,'•. C� 1�.T � �,w� , ,
•.�� 4 � '.
.. -r; ? ; ��~`�*�`� �,\� �
S�� � �"�.. `'�+ f l
r..
_ � y � �V�'. �{ ��,� ���'�•.��\ / '
. � � �� �'�.;��� '� �,t�,f��y'�� � ��� ' �
- �..�- _'1; , h��� �:1,\,���, y d i i Y�.; �,n� . _
� � ,`v� � _\F. \{` r j\ J� .�. . '�
�„a�, �} ' � '�'a-'�-�`�� ,y�� �
� �p -� �� -
�f.:" --, .-, �
^- �- �;t -`� r `_ , ,~ ,�, �
� .� ,s ,' � ,�,� �ii �p ...:�,�a
� t� ! i ir M� t �
�''� r -iN t . /.�� �C r P z+t .- . t •
� ��� �� r '���. (��'11 �C`� ",+.d �� �,
'� �. �r, `�,, .��'/ ''lj�/ �'r �'�;.::: •� Ir"��
R.� �(
) A �
.� r. .���F f/ J„ � ��M
� t ,� �a ,ly'� � ! fJ�F��--� �Y" • .
�,�, r ��. ,�Y r � .,j, .��j��-- � `�,j ._.
`�� � � � .�c.�� `_' °��`'�{• }'
>'� ,kr ; {+ �_
. . .r .
�, ,.;� ,�.=,� �fi;� _
. � � . J,.J'� v���� �..
} =o j y .'
, ���t� � ���`, �~� 4
_ • �` ��`�� '�,�,t <'�'�9sj� ��\t �'��
rvu• �°"
�".,,� �• ;`- �l��,i. � ,, .
r1 �
_� ,�i_. �-.��.r y .
. . �' 1'lC,, �E '�.' M1i ,
'3 �fV �'��. 1
. .��i�` + �'
k_1h . �'-�' �
, . . . ', -.JA�c�r � {i ,f �=.� .
�
, .�t'�,��� t s�M. •
.''�. �ti��� �� �1"\'� ., �i 1,:� '�. . .
V
`
. �
�
�
�1
�
��,.,• `��Y+:ti„'d'�,� ; j� �, ,1�
��. ��, ,
I' I ��
r ,��:.� [�
\f`Y 1 �& l � "`�-.
. ' ?1��� j � .
l Y�
�., i :' �l ,�, .
` �, �� �`;' �'.y, Y S� 4�
•� � � a. »rf' :�,..,.,__�
� : . s � • {iY r.�'•� '�.?� �� k� ,
�•• ,', .
:, ( 'i . y� �..,_.
:�{ ,,�,q � � {':%l.. r„ * � .� LL
. . � 1 � f'� _ 1._ -
� `` .�� .�^. Fc'_'
� .� �ta.. �
,..;E , ' ` i. ,`�-/ `_ - _ ,u.,T�.,-
.��r ��i� � • � � .:•?( �� y „� _
\� I� � �;; �"� ' -
� �� � � #
� }` � �`r
� � ��
" � i '�'{ � �;� :� �` ,� ,�
;
�� �:
, _ , �• ��Yf -�. ;;
� �t .. - � �YR����%�����: t � - . �'
� .
.n��__.�� \ '�.
��. p� .'.�:;� »� Ff:�, ... ��
� . '. �';`� .
�. �
1 �•�i`� ��
.,:,�.r' ¢�� �
r
� - .Mj�\ 4 .
,�i.w• ,� � ,
��;� � �f��.'��. ��. � '?�
' � -
_ r:T � � ' ,-.
•: ' { �_ ,����� .
i��• -. . � .,..�,.. �,.s.."�,�r ..
��,., .�—/��\�, 1�, , r".� rr*�•,� `i
;• �--�e,pae�'rr .q.
�� � .'. �������
,;:;;:�. r� z � -,... �,
���'', . , ''�` 1 _.
. �
���;: ��� ��..
.
!'���ti !' �, ': F
.�/u,��1•.�.��,� (-y. `.J-. ,(. .�
`.h�l��'�^ir`• t'7�; �J � , - «�•
I
�
�
1 �`
�
�
� �
, • �
` �.,:
-a.... �" '" C�
,x� :� � ° = s
`;_� �--. # ���� � �� ��7 -
'` \ ..g\^ �;i � r.r.�, .
'r�,.� �� ..�e: (..
a'�°
' J �.
•r v �1�� � � .Ll�. `'r
y � 7�•°` ._..� �,
� ,.+1 /� ; 4 J�
` � � +�
-v� r�w- � 1 I
�'F.,.�f`f^�'r�'�'k r�.��. ' 't
.} t.�
� �;__ t��_.:..:..
'�'�t��'�.' '-�,���y,
:3�'4v r��..,,,.�,y,' :
-�-....�e.1
�bm�,�^. �� �n
~- ,���.r' �` �`� `
z—�yi
->..,'`.`l.-i��"t� a'`�;=:,:.
��i
�/��.;� �"
.1 ���"��'`rv�
i���� , ��
A si k,Riw
� �.
'��j./�'f �':R �
/ / -�`� � ,...y,,..r � '�;
Yi� `..,-�� +y. �
,_� "�ry .? —
_ �,
..���sS�r _ r�1 �
Y �`"` `� ,�,w`�
.-r° r,�,+ �
, x ; �,�,,�f
�i� ��: � 1'i M .� � r '.
�T �.' f� .� _ h
%.�, ��'-.�-�-... -� ��§..
il's �`\ � .���Si . a,a � '.:
..�� . —ki�.;
c�- . . :����.
h �_ ' N. } , . . �,��.
=����F�L'�. �;`�1'' .��.�:. �I[ �r ' � � �:y.:�.
'✓f`�/ , -.� . . ��. c
�;� �..- .�}' ���� . � - . . �,.�
�'""�f!�°:.��Fi+r-.,� ..a iw+�li� i' . .�.. � .
�
` �
t,.�
�
f �
�
�
�
Y s'-.����; _ .•ti` - � , j� r
,. - '•. ��
.'��, ` �
�*-�-, _
.,,.
� ��r
� �$'', .'�
1; .t,�n,,�t,�� za�, i '
t, t �i`', , r , . �
f :e.�;�.<v��r-- '�. t �
'�'*.� r�r!`�. l �� \"'
���„� � � � j "
��T"y�+� �� �.� ► - i.
F .�lr`���1 �'i�t���-:� I � .
��"Kt��/ � �dT��.s`� ,,. � 1
, ;� <.�%�rt?� C� � �
��f �'
�,R,:� �+'i��i - .` • (
tr�xs+:� �e?" '�r ; • . ' 1 � , �
s ��-i • `=,.'�.- . x r :
���� � • � � ���
r � '�5 �.� -
v j r a. c�
i ! rt.s'
I :�,�.� .. _'..r� . . �
y�/ �� vc•�' _'_"_ . '
��"' r�
� I..i' ± � ,
�
.. ����: �t_i ! �� ��
..�r�s"'.�±""'r��•�'`x" ' a�r._.
.f" '�^r� ".i ET�;� : ., � �-f{"'.�
, /.
, .. � �
_ ("','�.�' , _ i.
_ _ . ,�.. . �� ��3 ,v,�
NYfF�..7 '4 .�� /.+rr�J � ` � ;F�e
. ..1� �:. , . }` 1
�4+
` �..:� . ./'—.i ..
`
�
St. Paui Police Department for
Ramsey District Court _..���
RECEIPT �'i��
Date/Time: 02/11/2013 10:40 Invoice #: 18915
Vehicle Plate: UDG420/MN
Payor: OWNER Location Paid: Impound Snow Lot
Citation: Amount:
888745013 $ 53.00
Total Amount Paid: $ 53.00
Paid by: CREDIT CARD
KEEP THIS COPY FOR YOUR RECORDS
Saint Paul Police Impound Lot, 830 Barge Channel Road, vehicle Release Form
Make: HONDA License#: UDG420 CN: 13027844 Invoice#: 18915
Date/Time Released: 02/11/2013 10:40 Tow Charge: $ 123.95
Released to: TOTO Storage Charge: $ 0.00
Paid by: CREDIT CARD Admin Charge: $ 80.00 ���
Released by: ELISE Tax: (7.625%) $ 15.55
I,the undersigned,have recovered the vehicle described above. Subtotal: $ 219.50
I will check the vehicle for damage or any other problems that
may have occurred while this vehicle was in the custody of the Service Charge: $ 0.00
Saint Paul Police Department. I acknowledge I will report
damage and/or any other problems to the Impound Lot staff Total Charges: $ 219.50
on this form prior to leaving the impound lot.
Damage and/or other problem:
Police Report made: Yes_No_IF Yes, CN , If NO, Why?
TO PROTECT`�OUR RIGH�S REPORT ANY PROBLEMS/DAMAGE BEFORE LEAVING THE LOT
J �� � - - -
Signature � ���� t'°��'�!�-� 5�2000
St. Paui Police Department for
Ramsey District Court ��j
RECEIPT �
�
l �
Date/Time: 02/11/2013 10:41 Invoice #: 18977 I
Vehicle Plate: NONE/
Payor: OWNER Location Paid: Impound Snow Lot
Citation: Amount:
888745014 $ 53.00
Total Amount Paid: $ 53.00
Paid by: CREDIT CARD
NB COPY
Saint Paul Police Impound Lot, 830 Barge Channel Road, Vehicle Release Form
Make: HONDA License#: NONE CN: 13027844 Invoice#: 18977
Date/Time Released: 02/11/2013 10:41 Tow Charge: $ 123.95
Released to: TOTO Storage Charge: $ 0.00
Paid by: CREDIT CARD Admin Charge: $ 80.00
Released by: ELISE Tax: (7.625%) $ 15.55 �
/
I,the undersigned,have recovered the vehicle described above. Subt�tal: $ 219.50
I will check the vehicle for damage or any other problems that
may have occurred while this vehicle was in the custody of the Service Charge: $ 0.00
Saint Paul Police Department. I acknowledge I will report
damage and/or any other problems to the Impound Lot staff Total Charges: $ 219.50
on this form prior to leaving the impound lot.
Damage and/or other problem:
Police Report made: Yes_No_IF Yes, CN , If NO, Why?
�
TO PROTECT YOUFZ'RIGHTS�R Of�T ANY/PROBLEMS/DAMAGE BEFORE LEAVING THE LOT
� i
i, / �;--�-�..--____
Signature ` . �"��`�•-- ���J L��/�` 5i2000