The URL can be used to link to this page

97-234,^- :�. . # 9� -�3y ��_,,, i�' i°� f � Council File 4.0' t `� � ' �' ''s 6 L :"��, " Green Sheet # � �� RESOLUTIOPf ' \OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA � \) � Presented By Referred To Committee: Date RESOLVED, that the Licensee, James Kennedy dlbia Kennedy Pharmacy (License ID No. 80608), located at 334 Robert Street North in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspecfions and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the investigation report, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. xequested by Department of: " .� i �u7,�� 1�� s iUC�I'1 Form Ap �d by C' y torney Adopted by Council: Date �L � f Adoption Certified by Council Secretary g�,. B�'= �°"`—� �' - Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council Approved by Mayor: Date �� F y !f �.��" `7 By: By: C_ �t� -�.�y DE NFF1C6(COUNC�L DATE INITIATED 3 8 0 2� Office of LIEP 2-19-1997 GREEN SHEE CONTACT PERSON & PHONE INRIAIJDATE INITIAIlOATE O DEPARTMENT DIRECTOfi Q CItY COUNCIL Robert Kessler, 266-9112 +�+�N 0 cm nrroRNFr � C1T' CIERK NUNBEHFOP MUST BE ON COUNCIL AGENDA BY (DATE) qp�� O BUWE'! �IHECTOR � FIN. & MGL SERYICES �IR. M'dTC11 5 997 Public e �DER � MAYOR (OR ASSISTANn � TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACCI�N REQUESTEO: Concerning adverse acrion against licenses held by James Kennedy, DBA Kennedy Pharmacy, located at 334 Robert Street North. (Uncontested) RECOMMENDAnONS: Approva (A) or Reject (R) pERSONAt SERYICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWEH THE FOILOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLqNNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION 1. Has this persoNfirm ever worKetl under a corrtract for this department? _ q6 COMMI'fTEE _ YES NO _�� 2. Has this personffirtn ever been a c�ty employee? — YES NO _ oiS7FiC7 coUxr _ 3. Does this Dersonlfirm possess a skilf not no}mally possessetl � by any Current ciry employee. SUPPOflT5 WHICH COUNCIL O&IECfIVE? YES NO Explatn all yes answers on separeta sheet antl attech to green aheet INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITY (Who, What, Wben. Where, Why}: ADVANTACaESIFAPPROVED: DISADVANTAGES IF APPqWED: Cou�cii Research Center !�`�� °��7 OISADVANTAGES IF NOT kPPROVEO: TOTAL AMOUPIT OF TRANSACTION S COSTfREVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDIWG SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMHER FINANCIAL INFORFnAT10N. (EXPLAIN) OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY ��.��4 CITY OF SAINT PAUL r�o� co�„�x na�.o, cNa QN��an 400 City Ha4 IS West KeZlogg Blvd Saint Paul M�nmesom 55102 Telephone: 611266-87I0 Facsimile: 61129&5619 February 14, 1997 NOTICE OF COtTN�IL HEARING Alan W, Weinblatt Weinblatt & Associates Pioneer Building, Suite 1616 336 North Robert Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 RE: Cigarette license held by James Kennedy d/bJa Kennedy Pharmacy for the premises located at 334 Robert Street North in St. Paul License ID No. 80608 Our File Number: G96-0637 Dear Mr. Weinblatt: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 4:30 p.m., Wednesday, March 5, 1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and I2amsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. ly yours, J. ristie , City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Mary Nelson, Community Organizer, Capitol River Council/Dist. #1�, 445 Minnesota St., Suite 524, St. Paul, MN 55101 �� • a�.3y UNCIJNTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: James Kennedy d/b/a Kennedy Pharmacy Address: 334 Robert Street North Council Hearing Date: March 5, 1997 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Sta� § 609,685 St. Paut Legislative Cade § 324.07 Date: November 19, 1996 Place: Licensed Premises Presumptive Penafty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorr�ey on behalf of client, OfFce of License, Inspections and Environmentat Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 7. Proposed resolution 2. Letter of licensee or aftorney agreeing not to contest the facts 3. Notice of Violation 4. License information 5. Compiiance Report 6. City Attorney License Adverse Action Summary a �-a3`i Kennedy Pharmacy disptays "We Card" signs very visibie to all customers who purchase cigarettes in our store. To visually check for age is the first poficy and is our staff is riot sure, to chedc for an ID is our secorzd step. Everyone in our store foliows these steps on a regular basis. Over 90°� of our customers are in our store on a regular basis being we are inside an office compiex, the Pioneer Building. On November 19, 1996, a woman wearing dark glasses who fooked to be at ieast 25 years old entered and purchased a pack af cigareftes from me. Very short{y thereafter, a woman walked up to me and asked me my name. She told me i had just soid a pack of cigarettes to a minor. I assumed that she was talking about the woman with the dark glasses because she was the only one I had sold cigarettes to within the last 10 minufes or so. The woman handed me a card and said I wouid be fined and warnad me not to do it again or I could be fined very heavily soon. She never asked to see a manager or owner. She never showed me any proof. She lefit me in tears being upset about a fine. I have no idea how I could have handled the mafter d'rffererrtly. fn complete good faith and based on many years of wor4cing at Kennedy Pharmacy, I believed {and stiN do) that the customer was at ieast 25 years oid. I am very against seliing cigarettes to a minor. i beiieve the way this "sting" was handled was unfair to us. Making someone look 25 years old and sending them in feeis like entrapment. ! also believe if 4 was to ask someone to remove their glasses it could be considered discrimination. �CZLC�-�� )',�'I� �C��.t�� Maureen McNaughton �� J es B. Kenne�� License Hoider and Store Owner OFFICE '� THE CITY ATTORNEY Timothy E � Ciry Arromey - a� a�y CITY OF SAINT PAUL c�;r orv;�on No�m Cokman, Mcyor 400 Ciry Hal1 Telephone: 612 266�710 I S Wesf Kelfogg Blvd Fau'vnik: 612 298-3619 Saint Pau{ ,y'mpetara 55702 i December 12, 1996 230TICS OF VIOLATION James Kennedy Kennedy Pharmacy 334 Robert Street North Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 RE: Cigarette license held by James Kennedy djb/a Kennedy Pharmacy for the premises located at 334 Robert Street North in St. Paul License ID No.: 806�8 Dear Mr. Kennedy: The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will recommend that adverse action be taken against your cigarette license held at the above-named premises. This recommendation is based on the following: On November 19, 1996, you or another employee sold cigarettea to a minor vnder the age of 18 years in the liceased premises. This is an offense uadez Minn. Stat. 5609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the City Council. You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the Council as to the proper penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before ari Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross- examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decided the case. If this is your cho_ce, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangborn, within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps to set up that ALJ hearing. :-:e can be reached at 266-8710. Page 1 q1-a If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, �/�� Virginia D. Palmer . Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Directcr, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Mary Nelson, Community Crganizer, Capitol River Council/Dist. #17, 445 Minnesota St., Suite 524, St. Paul, MN 55101 Page 2 q��a�`� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ss. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) JOANNE G. CLENENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on December �.3, 1996, she served the attached NOTICE OF V20LATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: James Kennedy Kennedy Pharmacy 334 Robert Street No. St. Pau1, MN. 55101 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 13th day of December, 1996. , , � ��'- �i.� � ' Notary Public � RITA M. BOSSARD � NOTARY PUBLIG- MINNeSOTA FiAMSEY CA1�(VTY MyComm. Exprea.lan.37.'tO�D a • Lic ID ................... STAT ..................... Business Name..........._ Address .................. Zip ...................... Doing Business As.....,.. License Name ............. Exp Date ................. Ir.surance Carrier........ Ins. Policy Number....... Insurance Effective Date. Ins. Expiration Date..... NOTE AREA ................ Tax Id ................... Worker Comp Exp Date..... Telephone ................ 80608 AC KENNEDY, JAMES 334 ROBERT ST N 55101 KENNEDY PHARMACY CIGARETTB ORIGINAL CONTAINER 03f31J97 INSPECTOR CHANGE 3676999 07/O1/94 227-5559 FROM RICH TO DENVER - lf6/92 q�-a�� ItOUTE: #7 �. � �' 2. � 3 ITRSPECTOR KRIS SCFiVJETI�Z.ER CIGARETTfi PRED�SE CHECKS � 4. --Z � 5. � s 1 6. � � 7, ��_ 8. , �. 9. CROWN STERLIATG SUITbS HOTEL 175 IOTH ST_ E. SUITE SHOPPE 175 lOTH ST. E. M1I�' S DO«'NTOWN STAI�TDARD 542 ROBERT ST. N. . '� �'�:. � ' c u 429 ROBERT ST. N. 7 & L TOBACCO 51�� `� _�,,.� 425 FtOBERT ST. 2d. �290 �"� S ''''�'�" ' V �� THE OLD FLA�'vIE �00 R4BERT ST. N ��1 � � , ^.c�.C��.�`-: ,'�,.,`�.. _c_.�:4 �t— r �� I�232�'EDY PHARMACX , �'ROBERT ST. N. � �� ! cb � �—�- PAT'S SMOKE SHOP 55 STH ST. E. ¢OBBI� TOP HAT LOUI3GE 134 STH ST. E. " � 10. • NBTLEE - ST. MARIE' S � �, 101 STH ST. E. #221 �� . FIRST HERITAGE 332 MII��TESOTA ST: � �t�i�$�� ti A a1,� -a�'�. ��'EEK:.,, �,�— �tj t�� 1 J, � '1, 5 S --�-o�-U-Q- . DnTE: t 1 � I =� nn�: NAME OF COMPUANGE CfiECl�R T06WC(� COMPLIANCE CHECK FORM # , �� 3.� TAX 6 �. NUMB� ° I 1 �,=,�.. w�rnEOFO�c� �� 5 NAMEANDA[36RESSOfUCENSEDVF1dDOR T.�.��tn.n,.,. u-s �J�� t.. j-- WAS 7NE TOHACCA - SEIf SERVE? ASSlSiED? t� MACH6JE1 SALE WAS NWdE YES �_ � N0: BR4N0: �,f i('i f n:, _��+ti� - NAME OF CtFRK: ' J tv��;, �-.� � 1 , ° � 1� �:�.:.;�h{� �. F: _� OESCRIPTION: y f �t,'n.� ,� � � �-t' r �t r1 < < CHECKABOFITED: YES N0: ADDITIONALCANMENTS: 2 ��J f � o� F 2 4 � 4 � � F 9 � � 6 � a � o � n V � � � O O o o n o 0 a � � f 3 v � � z � 0� o� w m c'�i � � � � � n {.� � G y t5 �° o u°` E E .`� 6 � ti Y u �' � � q 2 = p .. � � � U Z � �'a y V m � j � J � Z � V V N�, m U M U V Z �r �] � E � Q �] V p e .i .i � J a ri £ j � �r�" � $ ° v c u E �d o o �i v $ �' � � � �' � � �u H � o > a � a � � . � s r ': .�. N w`"�r3� � C rv n � A r w � � N .. a � z i m .. � . � n � .. e 1 m e �°� a m � ¢ `� w "' n o", � R ° n ; 6 � ° Q � a a i e g ° u � o � o � o � o i � � . � .� ° ° ry � �°. a o � z a a^. " i ry� m z z a m �$ ° o F ° F . o Z a a O F e F O E o{� O E �w °oo °.? � 00 �.:�d . oo �o <'o ° o� oa °.5 oS °3 U o O o O o w O O � � v. s ° o > .. N � o �$ o � z i ° e > fl > ° o > �°. > ° n > °'. s °. s � > Y V� � N �� n W!0 y a C 4 N � N � � H H F � y � F ^ F �� n N � o- . , �� gg , , , , . q % , j '% m X N O O N% w R N '� % a M u K 1� % i'I % v% V X N%< v � � ti� c; i ti g.�. $ ti$� s 3 w ti� ti� u� v��a' �i � u� ii $ ti� u� 0 < ry � w H ti ro � � M1 (�u u � u 2 � q W 41 O K F i K 2 N F� X w a 4 e � aoo � � � � � e g � � � � o � 0 0 0 � u� .. E " �n s z _ �. o F � + � H [? m �n � y � m � � � w � o a � � 'i � 5 0 �i o k� o � H � E U { � U V � r V V V U V O � N q N U � 4 � N p D O O Y } = f� N ��n Z a S�n n O O 2 2 2 .2 Z 5 S T O O > 2 � G 4 • � O � R` � w � � � � � w w � r�u 6 o" � � � � � � � � d � � � � � o � u u o a a o 0 o u o u o 0 � a � �S o a o 0 •> � y £ 4 i� � � C� 4 Z o p 0 e 4Q Y Y 43 K y V � ��' 4 � 4 Z O � u m }p O r ` P p O p� m �� y� w 0 O m q � N a� R 3� e � 5° F i � V V N U t� � 4 4 � s V P � � a a � v u�� a a i .�. Y y� Y� '° ¢ wwa �o : ? Q - W �� o �� yy F o y � �^> � N 4 V O C O D � 1 K 4 U 6 yq J V S 2� w> 6 � n 6� R 0 � �� a S � a �£ 4� � 4 4 F a�-a�� n za oo: �� t� Fz. �a, �: o� ��,_ __ , _ Fo 4 V Q � � � � ' U U V V Y V U 4 V rl V��] : � c � c � a � € �' � � a � � � �� o 0 � I � � � � � E � �l � � C a n m a � 5 C � r� ti a� .� �n V� N w .+ ± q 0 K C f�Y K d C t�p fY u1 41 6 W p p 6 Z 6 6 � a � i*�9 �� O W O i O p O 4 O � O � O ti O p � os �o �o 0o So >'o 00 00 0300 � « > « > �°. > ° n > a > .°,. > �� ti � y µ H ' y N " � H N y �� g V 2 in % w % �c % �o % V % N % �e % � tr S V 4 2 V£ U S 4 S ta S U Z V i U S � 2 � O • F � 4 r � O � f�J Y � 0 6 t+ � F y F N N N ^ : � � � � � � V V V V ; O � O O F O Z z z z ° a z 9 O • 7 9 t G � O r F F � � F F W � � °a .� � � � � � k o .'. ✓ O O F • 4 R Z F W e> o e u� � g �' m n � � . � R o `�'� z z oPa �e �W < �� q S~>�� aH �F �� m � a �' �� Y " �o ° d��' �� g4 6➢ n � 4 H R Y m V m 0 W H E � W !�O y H � E h z i � F � � � � V V V c o . 4 ui � �C a� 8a �€ r m � m � V � O E w 0 Z V V Y V � � �€ G �u � � � � ��o ] i 3 W � � fby u � � u y w .] n � V �}' .� w �n < O (� \ _ � ry � 2 Z M 0 4 O fu D >°3 05 °3 0 o a o> .:> R> N '� - F � N m X �e X rv X 4 Y 6� R{+ Z U£ V S V a £ Y � � II o N N N V��i � O � � � V V V V ° z ° z ° z z m w � � � � � V V V U V w a Z y 0 4� O � 4 V t�i m ° � z z �A5 S a E g � : ��°' o Rp € a �' �" . � � �° � g y `� r � zt,m x � o 0 � � n y � n 4� � 3 4 S� G R L H V V �,�.a��i ' � o�: F. =4. oo, a�: F=, �a �: O V � � 6 V Y V X U V O U Y Y Y Y V � �1 ul 41 N � V U U ; � � � c c c c �� E b � 'c € d � �!� � � � � � �� s:a � � o � � �� = o E � V V V V e 6 G� 4 V V V N � � � �n v u� n n n .a � t�} R rv .� n �e m u� n m c a s e x w w n r�n � � b (� y 6 � � 41 z �p 2 2 GI M n N��„ � 4 � O� � O � y y � N Y N � O � O W O 4 w � O y p 4 a F O F a E o F e F O F > f O F O[�+ o p p(� �g °.3 05 '3 'S 'S '3 °3 'S oS >S °3 °S o� 0 o e o 0 0 = o 0 o e o a o 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ` y ° e > "'. > ° n i ° n > �°. > R n ° n N > « > "l > .",. > �°+ > ° n s ^e a F� � P . F � y a N N N N N N N N ry N u N N N N N N U T� N X � C ' �n % y � v� % in X n X R ' 6 r w% w X n F V� M1 H 6 F 6 F 6 F 4 H 6 F s F 0. H 4 F 6 F G 4� F q W • V 4 2 £ U i V£ V£ V L V i V L V 2 V'L V S U S V£ V 5 � O � F 4 � � £ � O O O� V F F F N ^ a ; O � O � F F � x 2 b O a a i > � � � � o w m � � g � : c3 3 3 ° a q �1 O p r V V V S i Y i 4 � O � • ' O �(� � � V y O :"o€ � �r � d N ou�z�� S- y � � F v V � a : Q O N ¢ a N 3 % Y � � u >>a .�� u�l � t�rl � � f��i � u�l f�J � N N N N H N N� � N N N � � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V V U U � Z S Y � Z � S y � � a � � � 4 V V F � N ° �a �� F � ��8 <i � � �n N m 4 '�`s E .�°. $ o ° � �< a, ��o � q � a � � � � � 3 d 3 3 c3 3 � 3 V V V V [a U U V N 4 K S U O � r � � � V � N Z m r+ N ..l Y 4. Y o 0 tj V Q U � O � � p � � � u � ; V � F 4 N � O � �� G a o �? 4 �� m� `z�� o z c i � F O 4 3 G Z V Z r Q O �� o �. �.� �� g� g �11-a�y u 2 4 O O � �+ e : 4 � : �° �i O V Y a � � F O 4 U Q � � � N � � ,a ° v � £ E F .�i V Z V N V V V V V � V V f V V U E o c�i a � � � ° �u � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � E � 8 � � � 3 � E € � � § s �d � � � " a .". u 6 u m � z � z� a � z � z � z �° � � z � z ° o � z X � z� z �° z 0 0 o c. o m o �. o a r a � o � .. a o a a F F o F O F o E e h F � F O F o F o F 4 4 R o F F 3 e3e3 °5 °� °3 03 S3 03 °3 e3 x 0505 OS o . o 0 0 0 0 0 0 � o � o 0 0 0 o w . o 0 0 � o > a 5 w n "> �°. "> R "> % "> S "> .�.�. "> rv "> .�n "> S "> .',� "> % S y � N ry N K N N N '+ N y N � F m N N N N � N N N 2 � N � tu 2 r r r � • • r r � � O � • y � p{ �o % v� u� „ n% m% n w �o y� x �+ % o E m% m X �n % F W F q L. � 6 d F q n F q !u E 1 F 4� 0. F R F W q F o O 4 N 6( i F S V£ U S V£ V S U£ V S U� V£ V� V S m i U� U S V£ Z • O � 4 � Y G G u � F � Z � V V F H � ° z ° z e 0 � z � w 4 O V O ° o � o � V U J O .> a � L � o � o :,a�� V p � � � ry .t bgw ;? �� z z z 6 R p p S F i fu 4 6 �'1-a�y e � �u ° r�. m w ° � w m r. n F E y N F F F y F E N 8 8 � � � a � � � � � � ° a ° z ° z � �Z z i ¢ � � z z � � V S � O � � C � � C � � � � C � � � � v � � �3 � � � V V V U V 4 V V V V a N 2 o n K U ¢ � � a � � � � � � 5 � q a < a � $ � " � � o m � � ° o � � �°+ .a N y o 4 t� 5 � e. z � rt o= C Q Q � � N . y� .I FJ C C W p N $$ �(�C f�Y N� F Y W A �p N E 4 � O Y g V O z 8 r �� F cE" i "' G ° a.� � V V� a£ U F 5 N 2 u 2.l � s � � � � V u R w � N � F O F � 4 z $ ' O 0 m � o�; h. za, a o � � � a � : F z • y o " a w.. D V N � 4 � 0 � r Y Y U Y Y V U Y � V V W V � N � N � i F� V a E�i G � Fl V � G f° �+ u � � z� ' � 'd �d � �a�' 'd � �d : � � � � � � � € � � c � L ¢ d b � � m h N tl 6 ( Q z a � z � z � i ° a a � � � a �° y i o a o m w � o i w z� `� �» o rv w V O o H a F o f. a F n H o F o� Z o F W F F O a O o O o p o O � O o O v p� F o O � O a O �� N �F "y »y �F�'�€ 'F »w �F �� P� _ - ��gg� '� . , , , �� . ex rx ex ex «x Nx�K w nx � eK N � �ix� tii ti� tii vn' sii ti x�� tii �ix� ti� O � 4 � R ♦ 0 6 � v a � o ; E ,z a 0 i > z O � O F M N , � � G � V E O O n > � a � n q � [�f n 5 � V � Z N I � M Q �' y � O � p � O � � v � � O F V p ` S m � T 0 0 �" �fia N • 6 O z n � o 8 < o u .+ z w m s s L � � a 0 6 O O �"> � a � z �+ ° Y i V �d � 6 � y o � N y �� i � S 4 p O /� 6 � G � P C O N � y h F F � F m u�" N $ � �i ° v � �i �i �i o � s o� s s � s z� s = z z z z z e W � � � � � � � U V V V V V Q � Q �+ D ! 3 � r G q q � V G K {n � Q d £ 4 � � ? � q N £ W a 5 �� y� O 9 $ S y � n a R � o e/ � i 4 � F � F �� k $ � � j' � $ k s a a » N U V V V 7 F Q e � < 9 ,� o � U p 4 v N � 4 � � n s Q K N 'f t+ E y u m Z N z Z h 4 m H F � C� fY O y= F 6 �y °a �s �� V O � r�i V 0 �� V V V O a P 4 O O „ O C � � V a ►� .1�''� P a o� F 2 4 O G � � F Z 3 6 �i O U f � \ p V � 2 yZ � Y p a d O�� [ 2 m V N � g S � � V � 6 � 4 F� U .l V U� 6 N � O q F O O ! � : °j c � £ � ° f � � � z � . � � � � u o � c` u� Z � Z 8 M o R � < [`¢'' V� g n w a w O F Q+ $ Z� F Z � Q�� n K C � Z4 V ti S. [i n R O u 4�� F C Z �$ P O N� �i V " $Bq��N� . . ^� "��am� ,.. � a€ m ^� ea�g�$�>� :a8a�a ,. m � ° � � a o � �. " � y � � y � H " � r] I � n O 4 O 4 p ~ O � p � N n Z p 4�p „ a �� ° o= o 0 0 0 0 = o z�� ° o = o F ; ° > rv s m > � > ° 'n � ° " ° s n s V 2 N N N y O N N N �� O � N N N � � J N N �n % N% N X � X Z N% d X � 4 F 0 F W E 6 F 6� 2 � V Q 4 W F d fr � u� v x ti x ti i u �° ° z � a 2 �� ti i O F 0 Z °1 � _7,�`�► z . F 4 � } O O S F F � � � � V U ; H� F z z a � 0 > ° v w � o m � � $ ° d + S 1 � ° � F O � V V O .�a r U z ♦ > : � " � sas�� u � Z a N � t O ~ y 3 g i 3 9 St ° o ' �O a :>a ;�o 4 v v 4 H N N � E 8 � � � � � � a � � V 4 z � r � F 4 �s �i' C N N � 0 � o � u�i v � � V U `� a � o O Z 0 Q u w p � d a d �m o� S .] Y N � M 5 Z � B v � z � 0 � a R ° a � a o .l i O f O E � V � �i � � � O V � � " a ° 03 0 o > ti � w u i ti W N N N V �V ° z z � Ei u � � � � � V V V V o w " `a4 i � � o � a €' � E N � � p V d �� 5 � a c � g �e e� �o � oi � "s a F. �.a � 0 =a oa ��: 4 .l � y F Z r d 6 � .l � � O U � O � . � y � V � V �' Y V V U V j � U [' � CI t � t t y � V G t' ti M i Vy � V N � (� V M U V V � � N F N � V F � ` � � � R 3 F „ b 2 6 � � 2 , .] � a 6 a U � Pi V £ �V Pi Pi � V � Yl V E I` ` .�r V � In n .+ n n w � n n w� w .. .� C a � 6 g d d � q � ( y y � M1 I� ^ � . � Z �C � 5 41 N z .l W� O a O Fi » (u � z „ � O � M W O M1 O Z w � O 6 O � O W O V O � Y o F � h O F 6 k� a F �!� D h o H � F a E a F O F e F � E 3 . 5 0 5 ° 5 8 S ° 3 0 3 ° 5 ° 3 � o � o 0 0 � o 0 0 � o 0 0 0 0 ° �O o o ° o o e o 0 0 } > i ° e > rv > s > ° o > ° n > i > ° rv > « > ° rv > ° n s N� F » N oi (+ � y a�n y »� t�i E N y � F H F N N N N F � � , , y _ y �+x x y � � x .+x �ox +.M ..,x �z a x .-x �eu n x � x •� Y' W F i F 6 F u. E LL F 4. H� d H W F W F 4 R P � •� V£ V£ V S U S U£ V Y U S fa � U£ V£ V£ V� (/ £ O � F i 6 � z � � Z V r s � > z � o xo � 3 O � ° i g N � O a;,s�� o�;�� ;� :>: , G G � O 0 O � 0� p O v � N F F N N 1/�i F F [.. N � {{��[-� F+ F y { � � 2 Z 3 � � � Z 2 S 2� V U V pp V V V V V � O F O Z 2 2 2 F z z ° z a �Z z o a c y h � F �{.� O u O O � z z z � � � � � � � � � � � w � � � � � � � � � � � � � � (a V V V V V () U V [� V U C � N I Y V 7 � 4 j Y � m � �a s g o o d a � � a � E � n ai w m a a o`�}' o � o�. 5 4 G O „ H C ; Z m p e 3 V � m 4 Q �� S F = o F 4 Y V F N N � `] o { d � a . . � � � �� -" "°�� a c� o.� p i. � w x� m -" �• :' 4�°xn � u u a q £ p N N w � Q u N � �� 8 Ep s� Eo �$ € E� ��o �y � a� � ,�� @ a om a� �� 4 �A F 2 � 6 � � � � � 4 U � U [� U Y % W W ti 4 V : z U G .�i t E Fi � ; � � � � � � u � i i S6 i Fp :.i a a r V V V $ V V : � ,� � � : � � � � z � �c �' .] (� r 4 O fu O � O 4� O > O � O O r o O o O o O a O a O o O y U rv} n> N> M1 7 N 1 N> M� � y N y • y � y � H � y V � r% e� ft n M rv% rv% rv% � U S V S V£ V 2 V� V S O � 6 � d � N n N i O � z S ; 0 � > e �: � o 4 N Y H m � � � � � V V V V s o s s s z z z z z C w � � a ° � � � � +� � • V V V V � � � 0 � Y O � � p • > � � G e� 'j n n � � y Z � r l W� 3 y n O� � C � �£ � 90 >��'�� ° � � 8 G :e� ��" F� S"�a � P� 6 � M1 V a a 4 O. o. V V � V V V V Y � � ° �i o � � � � � � � � � � � � � a a .a a a .. � � � � � � � � � : � � � � > z z Z c z' �° � � � Z p i � O � O 4 O 4„ W O 4 O 0. O 6 O e3 03 ° 3 °5 °5 �S o3 �5 0 0 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 ° o 0 0 0 N? '�n 'i w> tt> n> » 7 O> i y h µ� ��+ �^ ' F n N � y y � p � y � �n % r u m% ur X� W'n W q M d F R F d H 4 H 4� u. q H V£ V S V£ V£ U S U S V£ V p Z 1 5 � F � � G C � � F F F F { F F n o ° � G o 0 0 0 0 V � S V V U � F F � F � O Z z o. u i z ° z z z C � � � � � � Y O � � y d : n � � V n u � � �� "� � o, y m o �3 `�' u K 6� 0. O w k w � C � � � � � � n � V U U 4 U V V � K N S � a Q 'a a n� N � �+ � F m 0 � r� 4 G 3 n J� Y V F 4 4 N � � � � 4 a ° a a � U o � o V " a z" ° S �� 3 a U Z ti y V q �� $ m � ��.+ R z`-' � E z w a O 6 C F � u�l �6' O K£ K N N F �,� ,� 3 �. P M1 O u] F Z 4 y O V G 4 � F 2 � p a 4. n H � �4 V � � u g � V „ W i Z M �o' �" o F rv > U 2 N F n % � V S W " M c � h 2 b S a 03 e o u�i> N e M w � 5 • O � ^� 4 � a Y : o O 0 w r�'i+ m T � � � � V V h F F .z � P O � ' N 9 O � Q W yN W N Y a � � 3 O > ` r� i a G " � � 2 6 .] � 4 a� 4 Y� p� \ M p - 4 d i sd � S' ra u N o a z � ° a ' o — � w � :: � ` �� 4$ � w> a . w F� w a ` O V Y Y V Y w 4 Y X U U U U V d U U w V � W fY � �u � c � , � � � 5 � y � 3 � V Z q y U U V Z q V V e U Z V V V y U Z F Y R N �+ 4 M> R N Y 6 4 a � a o' ° a � a � fip � U � O O U O �p O q V O � U � V V U V ri V �e ' l \ V m � N N m ., .� � N V ti �e m n .� a rJ P� 6 p 0 h� 6� p � Z 2 S � Z � 41 R Z Z Z W Z T W O 0 O � w O Y O 4 O W 0 � O ~ O � O C O ° � ° � e � ° o � ° � ° o � o � o o ° e o o °� ° � e o 0 0 . o 0 0 . o p o e w o 0 �°+> ri i °o> °n> °o> .:> .�> .;:> ,$> N N �� N � N � F � 2 � F � N .r N u y � N � y - N N X n X % % % .n % y n X C 4� C F m t-� W[� LL� 6 F P Y� s F W� 6 F 4 u¢ � i v$ v i ��Z u$ �� S v� � g ci i u � o c � d o c � o 0 0 m H oi � m � y y h � y y g ��`O g g g � � � o o � o � � x x� s x� s�� V G V V V V tl V V V V o � 8 � R 4 m � y o 0 �° s z = ' � � � � � a �ii 0 t�pa dp •WI V V . . R V $ J i U V F f � N � U a (�j a ry b � 8 8 � "o >> �° '� `��' a 5 8 5� c 5 Y m a p 3 `��' o� � ��x " gg �'� �� o :w a� ` �� N N N.t� N� N N� N ol y N N N N y k� .l q�� a o� F: a�: a�: F 2 • 3 � : o " m � � � � � o� � � � L 1 � 4�1 � V U V V U V V � � 'e � `c � � � "- c � � w a � � � � � � � � � � ��'a � � � � E; a " a E s :, � a � ; a ., 8 g € �4 � � � � � � � � € ;� � � g , 6 � � a � � " a p a � � N : � z " � a 6 w ° n � z �° o � o '"c z � z x x � z ,�. z � z � o S N 4� Y W y Y„ 6 H R O 0 W O Y 0 4 O � O M 4� F O f+ � E F 4 F c F (+ Q[+ O F O F O F a 4 ��^ 03 oS '3 e3 .5 SS e5 °3 °.S °S o5 °5 ' o 0 0 0 0 . o 0 0 . o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 " » > » > ° > e > 5 ° > » > , a w > e > u > c > � �i N �� ag �« �N �y �y - H �� ' �� 'H �H V a x e x e F n x � x n� m x e x � x r w . x e x�, � �� ti� o:k c:� c:� m� u� w� aF iF a�' iF P p :� u� �� $ u$ v� u i u� u�i �$ �� u�a .i i ° z G < � V 2 � F 4 � U � F F y F F F � F F �+ F F F N E {� {. (.� y {� ~ � � N 5 � Z Z Z � o F 2 Z 2 V � U V U V V V U V V � 2 2 2 Z 2 2 � Z E Z � � i C O y 7 N P n O � � � F f W N f� � � � � � a � � � � � � � � � � � � o � � 5 � � � o � � G 0 � o � u � � a ° m ti x ti ° • T � O W � � ti F n m r a N YI �� O' 9 a � v � F 4 � R F � 4 w .". w � `o � � z � o � � a � E ° m � � � �i 8 R � 4 � a o � � e��iF �� '� N � �� es ��,. �� $� S� � F j � � i w � p u� m m u � m �� n 3p E� _ A y 1 i p N O 0 0 3 � � w� o a �Z F � `� F � "� °� � F � e � r„ ti H �'�' u � �,f � q a S 4 O � i £ 4 n Z m � n q � �� N 7 P � V � V �+ .l rn 2 f B H 0 F 0 � N b O n F p F p a ��y 2; 3 �� q.'�' � o- q �.�3� 1 o� t 4 O� � V F 4 � a � i O V F O 4 U � � U w � U � g C� V Z <} N V S r O � E� � 4 � � � fi C S Y H y 7 Z 9 � O + S 1 i O f w t � i � � O � ' M N o d � � � ^ U 4 f O u � ♦ � � O � s > 0 • !i V V U o- 0 �i t�i i m Z � Z � y V R 4 4 i J O O 2 £ 2 i V V V O O F O 3 � � E � > .. e e z z � m 0. p K Z y � O � O � O n F O n o F 05 Qo 03 »"> N N N rv N % X V £ V £ V £ � O �F F 2 Z V � � a � E 4 4 U V U U F O O z F 6 r 4 4 � � O Z G 4 ? p 3 V Z V a � = N p V � O N � 2 W Z W � O � W Y � 1 6 � 4 .] � 3 .l ,^- :�. . # 9� -�3y ��_,,, i�' i°� f � Council File 4.0' t `� � ' �' ''s 6 L :"��, " Green Sheet # � �� RESOLUTIOPf ' \OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA � \) � Presented By Referred To Committee: Date RESOLVED, that the Licensee, James Kennedy dlbia Kennedy Pharmacy (License ID No. 80608), located at 334 Robert Street North in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspecfions and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the investigation report, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. xequested by Department of: " .� i �u7,�� 1�� s iUC�I'1 Form Ap �d by C' y torney Adopted by Council: Date �L � f Adoption Certified by Council Secretary g�,. B�'= �°"`—� �' - Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council Approved by Mayor: Date �� F y !f �.��" `7 By: By: C_ �t� -�.�y DE NFF1C6(COUNC�L DATE INITIATED 3 8 0 2� Office of LIEP 2-19-1997 GREEN SHEE CONTACT PERSON & PHONE INRIAIJDATE INITIAIlOATE O DEPARTMENT DIRECTOfi Q CItY COUNCIL Robert Kessler, 266-9112 +�+�N 0 cm nrroRNFr � C1T' CIERK NUNBEHFOP MUST BE ON COUNCIL AGENDA BY (DATE) qp�� O BUWE'! �IHECTOR � FIN. & MGL SERYICES �IR. M'dTC11 5 997 Public e �DER � MAYOR (OR ASSISTANn � TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACCI�N REQUESTEO: Concerning adverse acrion against licenses held by James Kennedy, DBA Kennedy Pharmacy, located at 334 Robert Street North. (Uncontested) RECOMMENDAnONS: Approva (A) or Reject (R) pERSONAt SERYICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWEH THE FOILOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLqNNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION 1. Has this persoNfirm ever worKetl under a corrtract for this department? _ q6 COMMI'fTEE _ YES NO _�� 2. Has this personffirtn ever been a c�ty employee? — YES NO _ oiS7FiC7 coUxr _ 3. Does this Dersonlfirm possess a skilf not no}mally possessetl � by any Current ciry employee. SUPPOflT5 WHICH COUNCIL O&IECfIVE? YES NO Explatn all yes answers on separeta sheet antl attech to green aheet INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITY (Who, What, Wben. Where, Why}: ADVANTACaESIFAPPROVED: DISADVANTAGES IF APPqWED: Cou�cii Research Center !�`�� °��7 OISADVANTAGES IF NOT kPPROVEO: TOTAL AMOUPIT OF TRANSACTION S COSTfREVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDIWG SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMHER FINANCIAL INFORFnAT10N. (EXPLAIN) OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY ��.��4 CITY OF SAINT PAUL r�o� co�„�x na�.o, cNa QN��an 400 City Ha4 IS West KeZlogg Blvd Saint Paul M�nmesom 55102 Telephone: 611266-87I0 Facsimile: 61129&5619 February 14, 1997 NOTICE OF COtTN�IL HEARING Alan W, Weinblatt Weinblatt & Associates Pioneer Building, Suite 1616 336 North Robert Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 RE: Cigarette license held by James Kennedy d/bJa Kennedy Pharmacy for the premises located at 334 Robert Street North in St. Paul License ID No. 80608 Our File Number: G96-0637 Dear Mr. Weinblatt: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 4:30 p.m., Wednesday, March 5, 1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and I2amsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. ly yours, J. ristie , City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Mary Nelson, Community Organizer, Capitol River Council/Dist. #1�, 445 Minnesota St., Suite 524, St. Paul, MN 55101 �� • a�.3y UNCIJNTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: James Kennedy d/b/a Kennedy Pharmacy Address: 334 Robert Street North Council Hearing Date: March 5, 1997 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Sta� § 609,685 St. Paut Legislative Cade § 324.07 Date: November 19, 1996 Place: Licensed Premises Presumptive Penafty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorr�ey on behalf of client, OfFce of License, Inspections and Environmentat Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 7. Proposed resolution 2. Letter of licensee or aftorney agreeing not to contest the facts 3. Notice of Violation 4. License information 5. Compiiance Report 6. City Attorney License Adverse Action Summary a �-a3`i Kennedy Pharmacy disptays "We Card" signs very visibie to all customers who purchase cigarettes in our store. To visually check for age is the first poficy and is our staff is riot sure, to chedc for an ID is our secorzd step. Everyone in our store foliows these steps on a regular basis. Over 90°� of our customers are in our store on a regular basis being we are inside an office compiex, the Pioneer Building. On November 19, 1996, a woman wearing dark glasses who fooked to be at ieast 25 years old entered and purchased a pack af cigareftes from me. Very short{y thereafter, a woman walked up to me and asked me my name. She told me i had just soid a pack of cigarettes to a minor. I assumed that she was talking about the woman with the dark glasses because she was the only one I had sold cigarettes to within the last 10 minufes or so. The woman handed me a card and said I wouid be fined and warnad me not to do it again or I could be fined very heavily soon. She never asked to see a manager or owner. She never showed me any proof. She lefit me in tears being upset about a fine. I have no idea how I could have handled the mafter d'rffererrtly. fn complete good faith and based on many years of wor4cing at Kennedy Pharmacy, I believed {and stiN do) that the customer was at ieast 25 years oid. I am very against seliing cigarettes to a minor. i beiieve the way this "sting" was handled was unfair to us. Making someone look 25 years old and sending them in feeis like entrapment. ! also believe if 4 was to ask someone to remove their glasses it could be considered discrimination. �CZLC�-�� )',�'I� �C��.t�� Maureen McNaughton �� J es B. Kenne�� License Hoider and Store Owner OFFICE '� THE CITY ATTORNEY Timothy E � Ciry Arromey - a� a�y CITY OF SAINT PAUL c�;r orv;�on No�m Cokman, Mcyor 400 Ciry Hal1 Telephone: 612 266�710 I S Wesf Kelfogg Blvd Fau'vnik: 612 298-3619 Saint Pau{ ,y'mpetara 55702 i December 12, 1996 230TICS OF VIOLATION James Kennedy Kennedy Pharmacy 334 Robert Street North Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 RE: Cigarette license held by James Kennedy djb/a Kennedy Pharmacy for the premises located at 334 Robert Street North in St. Paul License ID No.: 806�8 Dear Mr. Kennedy: The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will recommend that adverse action be taken against your cigarette license held at the above-named premises. This recommendation is based on the following: On November 19, 1996, you or another employee sold cigarettea to a minor vnder the age of 18 years in the liceased premises. This is an offense uadez Minn. Stat. 5609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the City Council. You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the Council as to the proper penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before ari Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross- examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decided the case. If this is your cho_ce, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangborn, within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps to set up that ALJ hearing. :-:e can be reached at 266-8710. Page 1 q1-a If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, �/�� Virginia D. Palmer . Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Directcr, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Mary Nelson, Community Crganizer, Capitol River Council/Dist. #17, 445 Minnesota St., Suite 524, St. Paul, MN 55101 Page 2 q��a�`� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ss. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) JOANNE G. CLENENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on December �.3, 1996, she served the attached NOTICE OF V20LATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: James Kennedy Kennedy Pharmacy 334 Robert Street No. St. Pau1, MN. 55101 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 13th day of December, 1996. , , � ��'- �i.� � ' Notary Public � RITA M. BOSSARD � NOTARY PUBLIG- MINNeSOTA FiAMSEY CA1�(VTY MyComm. Exprea.lan.37.'tO�D a • Lic ID ................... STAT ..................... Business Name..........._ Address .................. Zip ...................... Doing Business As.....,.. License Name ............. Exp Date ................. Ir.surance Carrier........ Ins. Policy Number....... Insurance Effective Date. Ins. Expiration Date..... NOTE AREA ................ Tax Id ................... Worker Comp Exp Date..... Telephone ................ 80608 AC KENNEDY, JAMES 334 ROBERT ST N 55101 KENNEDY PHARMACY CIGARETTB ORIGINAL CONTAINER 03f31J97 INSPECTOR CHANGE 3676999 07/O1/94 227-5559 FROM RICH TO DENVER - lf6/92 q�-a�� ItOUTE: #7 �. � �' 2. � 3 ITRSPECTOR KRIS SCFiVJETI�Z.ER CIGARETTfi PRED�SE CHECKS � 4. --Z � 5. � s 1 6. � � 7, ��_ 8. , �. 9. CROWN STERLIATG SUITbS HOTEL 175 IOTH ST_ E. SUITE SHOPPE 175 lOTH ST. E. M1I�' S DO«'NTOWN STAI�TDARD 542 ROBERT ST. N. . '� �'�:. � ' c u 429 ROBERT ST. N. 7 & L TOBACCO 51�� `� _�,,.� 425 FtOBERT ST. 2d. �290 �"� S ''''�'�" ' V �� THE OLD FLA�'vIE �00 R4BERT ST. N ��1 � � , ^.c�.C��.�`-: ,'�,.,`�.. _c_.�:4 �t— r �� I�232�'EDY PHARMACX , �'ROBERT ST. N. � �� ! cb � �—�- PAT'S SMOKE SHOP 55 STH ST. E. ¢OBBI� TOP HAT LOUI3GE 134 STH ST. E. " � 10. • NBTLEE - ST. MARIE' S � �, 101 STH ST. E. #221 �� . FIRST HERITAGE 332 MII��TESOTA ST: � �t�i�$�� ti A a1,� -a�'�. ��'EEK:.,, �,�— �tj t�� 1 J, � '1, 5 S --�-o�-U-Q- . DnTE: t 1 � I =� nn�: NAME OF COMPUANGE CfiECl�R T06WC(� COMPLIANCE CHECK FORM # , �� 3.� TAX 6 �. NUMB� ° I 1 �,=,�.. w�rnEOFO�c� �� 5 NAMEANDA[36RESSOfUCENSEDVF1dDOR T.�.��tn.n,.,. u-s �J�� t.. j-- WAS 7NE TOHACCA - SEIf SERVE? ASSlSiED? t� MACH6JE1 SALE WAS NWdE YES �_ � N0: BR4N0: �,f i('i f n:, _��+ti� - NAME OF CtFRK: ' J tv��;, �-.� � 1 , ° � 1� �:�.:.;�h{� �. F: _� OESCRIPTION: y f �t,'n.� ,� � � �-t' r �t r1 < < CHECKABOFITED: YES N0: ADDITIONALCANMENTS: 2 ��J f � o� F 2 4 � 4 � � F 9 � � 6 � a � o � n V � � � O O o o n o 0 a � � f 3 v � � z � 0� o� w m c'�i � � � � � n {.� � G y t5 �° o u°` E E .`� 6 � ti Y u �' � � q 2 = p .. � � � U Z � �'a y V m � j � J � Z � V V N�, m U M U V Z �r �] � E � Q �] V p e .i .i � J a ri £ j � �r�" � $ ° v c u E �d o o �i v $ �' � � � �' � � �u H � o > a � a � � . � s r ': .�. N w`"�r3� � C rv n � A r w � � N .. a � z i m .. � . � n � .. e 1 m e �°� a m � ¢ `� w "' n o", � R ° n ; 6 � ° Q � a a i e g ° u � o � o � o � o i � � . � .� ° ° ry � �°. a o � z a a^. " i ry� m z z a m �$ ° o F ° F . o Z a a O F e F O E o{� O E �w °oo °.? � 00 �.:�d . oo �o <'o ° o� oa °.5 oS °3 U o O o O o w O O � � v. s ° o > .. N � o �$ o � z i ° e > fl > ° o > �°. > ° n > °'. s °. s � > Y V� � N �� n W!0 y a C 4 N � N � � H H F � y � F ^ F �� n N � o- . , �� gg , , , , . q % , j '% m X N O O N% w R N '� % a M u K 1� % i'I % v% V X N%< v � � ti� c; i ti g.�. $ ti$� s 3 w ti� ti� u� v��a' �i � u� ii $ ti� u� 0 < ry � w H ti ro � � M1 (�u u � u 2 � q W 41 O K F i K 2 N F� X w a 4 e � aoo � � � � � e g � � � � o � 0 0 0 � u� .. E " �n s z _ �. o F � + � H [? m �n � y � m � � � w � o a � � 'i � 5 0 �i o k� o � H � E U { � U V � r V V V U V O � N q N U � 4 � N p D O O Y } = f� N ��n Z a S�n n O O 2 2 2 .2 Z 5 S T O O > 2 � G 4 • � O � R` � w � � � � � w w � r�u 6 o" � � � � � � � � d � � � � � o � u u o a a o 0 o u o u o 0 � a � �S o a o 0 •> � y £ 4 i� � � C� 4 Z o p 0 e 4Q Y Y 43 K y V � ��' 4 � 4 Z O � u m }p O r ` P p O p� m �� y� w 0 O m q � N a� R 3� e � 5° F i � V V N U t� � 4 4 � s V P � � a a � v u�� a a i .�. Y y� Y� '° ¢ wwa �o : ? Q - W �� o �� yy F o y � �^> � N 4 V O C O D � 1 K 4 U 6 yq J V S 2� w> 6 � n 6� R 0 � �� a S � a �£ 4� � 4 4 F a�-a�� n za oo: �� t� Fz. �a, �: o� ��,_ __ , _ Fo 4 V Q � � � � ' U U V V Y V U 4 V rl V��] : � c � c � a � € �' � � a � � � �� o 0 � I � � � � � E � �l � � C a n m a � 5 C � r� ti a� .� �n V� N w .+ ± q 0 K C f�Y K d C t�p fY u1 41 6 W p p 6 Z 6 6 � a � i*�9 �� O W O i O p O 4 O � O � O ti O p � os �o �o 0o So >'o 00 00 0300 � « > « > �°. > ° n > a > .°,. > �� ti � y µ H ' y N " � H N y �� g V 2 in % w % �c % �o % V % N % �e % � tr S V 4 2 V£ U S 4 S ta S U Z V i U S � 2 � O • F � 4 r � O � f�J Y � 0 6 t+ � F y F N N N ^ : � � � � � � V V V V ; O � O O F O Z z z z ° a z 9 O • 7 9 t G � O r F F � � F F W � � °a .� � � � � � k o .'. ✓ O O F • 4 R Z F W e> o e u� � g �' m n � � . � R o `�'� z z oPa �e �W < �� q S~>�� aH �F �� m � a �' �� Y " �o ° d��' �� g4 6➢ n � 4 H R Y m V m 0 W H E � W !�O y H � E h z i � F � � � � V V V c o . 4 ui � �C a� 8a �€ r m � m � V � O E w 0 Z V V Y V � � �€ G �u � � � � ��o ] i 3 W � � fby u � � u y w .] n � V �}' .� w �n < O (� \ _ � ry � 2 Z M 0 4 O fu D >°3 05 °3 0 o a o> .:> R> N '� - F � N m X �e X rv X 4 Y 6� R{+ Z U£ V S V a £ Y � � II o N N N V��i � O � � � V V V V ° z ° z ° z z m w � � � � � V V V U V w a Z y 0 4� O � 4 V t�i m ° � z z �A5 S a E g � : ��°' o Rp € a �' �" . � � �° � g y `� r � zt,m x � o 0 � � n y � n 4� � 3 4 S� G R L H V V �,�.a��i ' � o�: F. =4. oo, a�: F=, �a �: O V � � 6 V Y V X U V O U Y Y Y Y V � �1 ul 41 N � V U U ; � � � c c c c �� E b � 'c € d � �!� � � � � � �� s:a � � o � � �� = o E � V V V V e 6 G� 4 V V V N � � � �n v u� n n n .a � t�} R rv .� n �e m u� n m c a s e x w w n r�n � � b (� y 6 � � 41 z �p 2 2 GI M n N��„ � 4 � O� � O � y y � N Y N � O � O W O 4 w � O y p 4 a F O F a E o F e F O F > f O F O[�+ o p p(� �g °.3 05 '3 'S 'S '3 °3 'S oS >S °3 °S o� 0 o e o 0 0 = o 0 o e o a o 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ` y ° e > "'. > ° n i ° n > �°. > R n ° n N > « > "l > .",. > �°+ > ° n s ^e a F� � P . F � y a N N N N N N N N ry N u N N N N N N U T� N X � C ' �n % y � v� % in X n X R ' 6 r w% w X n F V� M1 H 6 F 6 F 6 F 4 H 6 F s F 0. H 4 F 6 F G 4� F q W • V 4 2 £ U i V£ V£ V L V i V L V 2 V'L V S U S V£ V 5 � O � F 4 � � £ � O O O� V F F F N ^ a ; O � O � F F � x 2 b O a a i > � � � � o w m � � g � : c3 3 3 ° a q �1 O p r V V V S i Y i 4 � O � • ' O �(� � � V y O :"o€ � �r � d N ou�z�� S- y � � F v V � a : Q O N ¢ a N 3 % Y � � u >>a .�� u�l � t�rl � � f��i � u�l f�J � N N N N H N N� � N N N � � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V V U U � Z S Y � Z � S y � � a � � � 4 V V F � N ° �a �� F � ��8 <i � � �n N m 4 '�`s E .�°. $ o ° � �< a, ��o � q � a � � � � � 3 d 3 3 c3 3 � 3 V V V V [a U U V N 4 K S U O � r � � � V � N Z m r+ N ..l Y 4. Y o 0 tj V Q U � O � � p � � � u � ; V � F 4 N � O � �� G a o �? 4 �� m� `z�� o z c i � F O 4 3 G Z V Z r Q O �� o �. �.� �� g� g �11-a�y u 2 4 O O � �+ e : 4 � : �° �i O V Y a � � F O 4 U Q � � � N � � ,a ° v � £ E F .�i V Z V N V V V V V � V V f V V U E o c�i a � � � ° �u � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � E � 8 � � � 3 � E € � � § s �d � � � " a .". u 6 u m � z � z� a � z � z � z �° � � z � z ° o � z X � z� z �° z 0 0 o c. o m o �. o a r a � o � .. a o a a F F o F O F o E e h F � F O F o F o F 4 4 R o F F 3 e3e3 °5 °� °3 03 S3 03 °3 e3 x 0505 OS o . o 0 0 0 0 0 0 � o � o 0 0 0 o w . o 0 0 � o > a 5 w n "> �°. "> R "> % "> S "> .�.�. "> rv "> .�n "> S "> .',� "> % S y � N ry N K N N N '+ N y N � F m N N N N � N N N 2 � N � tu 2 r r r � • • r r � � O � • y � p{ �o % v� u� „ n% m% n w �o y� x �+ % o E m% m X �n % F W F q L. � 6 d F q n F q !u E 1 F 4� 0. F R F W q F o O 4 N 6( i F S V£ U S V£ V S U£ V S U� V£ V� V S m i U� U S V£ Z • O � 4 � Y G G u � F � Z � V V F H � ° z ° z e 0 � z � w 4 O V O ° o � o � V U J O .> a � L � o � o :,a�� V p � � � ry .t bgw ;? �� z z z 6 R p p S F i fu 4 6 �'1-a�y e � �u ° r�. m w ° � w m r. n F E y N F F F y F E N 8 8 � � � a � � � � � � ° a ° z ° z � �Z z i ¢ � � z z � � V S � O � � C � � C � � � � C � � � � v � � �3 � � � V V V U V 4 V V V V a N 2 o n K U ¢ � � a � � � � � � 5 � q a < a � $ � " � � o m � � ° o � � �°+ .a N y o 4 t� 5 � e. z � rt o= C Q Q � � N . y� .I FJ C C W p N $$ �(�C f�Y N� F Y W A �p N E 4 � O Y g V O z 8 r �� F cE" i "' G ° a.� � V V� a£ U F 5 N 2 u 2.l � s � � � � V u R w � N � F O F � 4 z $ ' O 0 m � o�; h. za, a o � � � a � : F z • y o " a w.. D V N � 4 � 0 � r Y Y U Y Y V U Y � V V W V � N � N � i F� V a E�i G � Fl V � G f° �+ u � � z� ' � 'd �d � �a�' 'd � �d : � � � � � � � € � � c � L ¢ d b � � m h N tl 6 ( Q z a � z � z � i ° a a � � � a �° y i o a o m w � o i w z� `� �» o rv w V O o H a F o f. a F n H o F o� Z o F W F F O a O o O o p o O � O o O v p� F o O � O a O �� N �F "y »y �F�'�€ 'F »w �F �� P� _ - ��gg� '� . , , , �� . ex rx ex ex «x Nx�K w nx � eK N � �ix� tii ti� tii vn' sii ti x�� tii �ix� ti� O � 4 � R ♦ 0 6 � v a � o ; E ,z a 0 i > z O � O F M N , � � G � V E O O n > � a � n q � [�f n 5 � V � Z N I � M Q �' y � O � p � O � � v � � O F V p ` S m � T 0 0 �" �fia N • 6 O z n � o 8 < o u .+ z w m s s L � � a 0 6 O O �"> � a � z �+ ° Y i V �d � 6 � y o � N y �� i � S 4 p O /� 6 � G � P C O N � y h F F � F m u�" N $ � �i ° v � �i �i �i o � s o� s s � s z� s = z z z z z e W � � � � � � � U V V V V V Q � Q �+ D ! 3 � r G q q � V G K {n � Q d £ 4 � � ? � q N £ W a 5 �� y� O 9 $ S y � n a R � o e/ � i 4 � F � F �� k $ � � j' � $ k s a a » N U V V V 7 F Q e � < 9 ,� o � U p 4 v N � 4 � � n s Q K N 'f t+ E y u m Z N z Z h 4 m H F � C� fY O y= F 6 �y °a �s �� V O � r�i V 0 �� V V V O a P 4 O O „ O C � � V a ►� .1�''� P a o� F 2 4 O G � � F Z 3 6 �i O U f � \ p V � 2 yZ � Y p a d O�� [ 2 m V N � g S � � V � 6 � 4 F� U .l V U� 6 N � O q F O O ! � : °j c � £ � ° f � � � z � . � � � � u o � c` u� Z � Z 8 M o R � < [`¢'' V� g n w a w O F Q+ $ Z� F Z � Q�� n K C � Z4 V ti S. [i n R O u 4�� F C Z �$ P O N� �i V " $Bq��N� . . ^� "��am� ,.. � a€ m ^� ea�g�$�>� :a8a�a ,. m � ° � � a o � �. " � y � � y � H " � r] I � n O 4 O 4 p ~ O � p � N n Z p 4�p „ a �� ° o= o 0 0 0 0 = o z�� ° o = o F ; ° > rv s m > � > ° 'n � ° " ° s n s V 2 N N N y O N N N �� O � N N N � � J N N �n % N% N X � X Z N% d X � 4 F 0 F W E 6 F 6� 2 � V Q 4 W F d fr � u� v x ti x ti i u �° ° z � a 2 �� ti i O F 0 Z °1 � _7,�`�► z . F 4 � } O O S F F � � � � V U ; H� F z z a � 0 > ° v w � o m � � $ ° d + S 1 � ° � F O � V V O .�a r U z ♦ > : � " � sas�� u � Z a N � t O ~ y 3 g i 3 9 St ° o ' �O a :>a ;�o 4 v v 4 H N N � E 8 � � � � � � a � � V 4 z � r � F 4 �s �i' C N N � 0 � o � u�i v � � V U `� a � o O Z 0 Q u w p � d a d �m o� S .] Y N � M 5 Z � B v � z � 0 � a R ° a � a o .l i O f O E � V � �i � � � O V � � " a ° 03 0 o > ti � w u i ti W N N N V �V ° z z � Ei u � � � � � V V V V o w " `a4 i � � o � a €' � E N � � p V d �� 5 � a c � g �e e� �o � oi � "s a F. �.a � 0 =a oa ��: 4 .l � y F Z r d 6 � .l � � O U � O � . � y � V � V �' Y V V U V j � U [' � CI t � t t y � V G t' ti M i Vy � V N � (� V M U V V � � N F N � V F � ` � � � R 3 F „ b 2 6 � � 2 , .] � a 6 a U � Pi V £ �V Pi Pi � V � Yl V E I` ` .�r V � In n .+ n n w � n n w� w .. .� C a � 6 g d d � q � ( y y � M1 I� ^ � . � Z �C � 5 41 N z .l W� O a O Fi » (u � z „ � O � M W O M1 O Z w � O 6 O � O W O V O � Y o F � h O F 6 k� a F �!� D h o H � F a E a F O F e F � E 3 . 5 0 5 ° 5 8 S ° 3 0 3 ° 5 ° 3 � o � o 0 0 � o 0 0 � o 0 0 0 0 ° �O o o ° o o e o 0 0 } > i ° e > rv > s > ° o > ° n > i > ° rv > « > ° rv > ° n s N� F » N oi (+ � y a�n y »� t�i E N y � F H F N N N N F � � , , y _ y �+x x y � � x .+x �ox +.M ..,x �z a x .-x �eu n x � x •� Y' W F i F 6 F u. E LL F 4. H� d H W F W F 4 R P � •� V£ V£ V S U S U£ V Y U S fa � U£ V£ V£ V� (/ £ O � F i 6 � z � � Z V r s � > z � o xo � 3 O � ° i g N � O a;,s�� o�;�� ;� :>: , G G � O 0 O � 0� p O v � N F F N N 1/�i F F [.. N � {{��[-� F+ F y { � � 2 Z 3 � � � Z 2 S 2� V U V pp V V V V V � O F O Z 2 2 2 F z z ° z a �Z z o a c y h � F �{.� O u O O � z z z � � � � � � � � � � � w � � � � � � � � � � � � � � (a V V V V V () U V [� V U C � N I Y V 7 � 4 j Y � m � �a s g o o d a � � a � E � n ai w m a a o`�}' o � o�. 5 4 G O „ H C ; Z m p e 3 V � m 4 Q �� S F = o F 4 Y V F N N � `] o { d � a . . � � � �� -" "°�� a c� o.� p i. � w x� m -" �• :' 4�°xn � u u a q £ p N N w � Q u N � �� 8 Ep s� Eo �$ € E� ��o �y � a� � ,�� @ a om a� �� 4 �A F 2 � 6 � � � � � 4 U � U [� U Y % W W ti 4 V : z U G .�i t E Fi � ; � � � � � � u � i i S6 i Fp :.i a a r V V V $ V V : � ,� � � : � � � � z � �c �' .] (� r 4 O fu O � O 4� O > O � O O r o O o O o O a O a O o O y U rv} n> N> M1 7 N 1 N> M� � y N y • y � y � H � y V � r% e� ft n M rv% rv% rv% � U S V S V£ V 2 V� V S O � 6 � d � N n N i O � z S ; 0 � > e �: � o 4 N Y H m � � � � � V V V V s o s s s z z z z z C w � � a ° � � � � +� � • V V V V � � � 0 � Y O � � p • > � � G e� 'j n n � � y Z � r l W� 3 y n O� � C � �£ � 90 >��'�� ° � � 8 G :e� ��" F� S"�a � P� 6 � M1 V a a 4 O. o. V V � V V V V Y � � ° �i o � � � � � � � � � � � � � a a .a a a .. � � � � � � � � � : � � � � > z z Z c z' �° � � � Z p i � O � O 4 O 4„ W O 4 O 0. O 6 O e3 03 ° 3 °5 °5 �S o3 �5 0 0 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 ° o 0 0 0 N? '�n 'i w> tt> n> » 7 O> i y h µ� ��+ �^ ' F n N � y y � p � y � �n % r u m% ur X� W'n W q M d F R F d H 4 H 4� u. q H V£ V S V£ V£ U S U S V£ V p Z 1 5 � F � � G C � � F F F F { F F n o ° � G o 0 0 0 0 V � S V V U � F F � F � O Z z o. u i z ° z z z C � � � � � � Y O � � y d : n � � V n u � � �� "� � o, y m o �3 `�' u K 6� 0. O w k w � C � � � � � � n � V U U 4 U V V � K N S � a Q 'a a n� N � �+ � F m 0 � r� 4 G 3 n J� Y V F 4 4 N � � � � 4 a ° a a � U o � o V " a z" ° S �� 3 a U Z ti y V q �� $ m � ��.+ R z`-' � E z w a O 6 C F � u�l �6' O K£ K N N F �,� ,� 3 �. P M1 O u] F Z 4 y O V G 4 � F 2 � p a 4. n H � �4 V � � u g � V „ W i Z M �o' �" o F rv > U 2 N F n % � V S W " M c � h 2 b S a 03 e o u�i> N e M w � 5 • O � ^� 4 � a Y : o O 0 w r�'i+ m T � � � � V V h F F .z � P O � ' N 9 O � Q W yN W N Y a � � 3 O > ` r� i a G " � � 2 6 .] � 4 a� 4 Y� p� \ M p - 4 d i sd � S' ra u N o a z � ° a ' o — � w � :: � ` �� 4$ � w> a . w F� w a ` O V Y Y V Y w 4 Y X U U U U V d U U w V � W fY � �u � c � , � � � 5 � y � 3 � V Z q y U U V Z q V V e U Z V V V y U Z F Y R N �+ 4 M> R N Y 6 4 a � a o' ° a � a � fip � U � O O U O �p O q V O � U � V V U V ri V �e ' l \ V m � N N m ., .� � N V ti �e m n .� a rJ P� 6 p 0 h� 6� p � Z 2 S � Z � 41 R Z Z Z W Z T W O 0 O � w O Y O 4 O W 0 � O ~ O � O C O ° � ° � e � ° o � ° � ° o � o � o o ° e o o °� ° � e o 0 0 . o 0 0 . o p o e w o 0 �°+> ri i °o> °n> °o> .:> .�> .;:> ,$> N N �� N � N � F � 2 � F � N .r N u y � N � y - N N X n X % % % .n % y n X C 4� C F m t-� W[� LL� 6 F P Y� s F W� 6 F 4 u¢ � i v$ v i ��Z u$ �� S v� � g ci i u � o c � d o c � o 0 0 m H oi � m � y y h � y y g ��`O g g g � � � o o � o � � x x� s x� s�� V G V V V V tl V V V V o � 8 � R 4 m � y o 0 �° s z = ' � � � � � a �ii 0 t�pa dp •WI V V . . R V $ J i U V F f � N � U a (�j a ry b � 8 8 � "o >> �° '� `��' a 5 8 5� c 5 Y m a p 3 `��' o� � ��x " gg �'� �� o :w a� ` �� N N N.t� N� N N� N ol y N N N N y k� .l q�� a o� F: a�: a�: F 2 • 3 � : o " m � � � � � o� � � � L 1 � 4�1 � V U V V U V V � � 'e � `c � � � "- c � � w a � � � � � � � � � � ��'a � � � � E; a " a E s :, � a � ; a ., 8 g € �4 � � � � � � � � € ;� � � g , 6 � � a � � " a p a � � N : � z " � a 6 w ° n � z �° o � o '"c z � z x x � z ,�. z � z � o S N 4� Y W y Y„ 6 H R O 0 W O Y 0 4 O � O M 4� F O f+ � E F 4 F c F (+ Q[+ O F O F O F a 4 ��^ 03 oS '3 e3 .5 SS e5 °3 °.S °S o5 °5 ' o 0 0 0 0 . o 0 0 . o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 " » > » > ° > e > 5 ° > » > , a w > e > u > c > � �i N �� ag �« �N �y �y - H �� ' �� 'H �H V a x e x e F n x � x n� m x e x � x r w . x e x�, � �� ti� o:k c:� c:� m� u� w� aF iF a�' iF P p :� u� �� $ u$ v� u i u� u�i �$ �� u�a .i i ° z G < � V 2 � F 4 � U � F F y F F F � F F �+ F F F N E {� {. (.� y {� ~ � � N 5 � Z Z Z � o F 2 Z 2 V � U V U V V V U V V � 2 2 2 Z 2 2 � Z E Z � � i C O y 7 N P n O � � � F f W N f� � � � � � a � � � � � � � � � � � � o � � 5 � � � o � � G 0 � o � u � � a ° m ti x ti ° • T � O W � � ti F n m r a N YI �� O' 9 a � v � F 4 � R F � 4 w .". w � `o � � z � o � � a � E ° m � � � �i 8 R � 4 � a o � � e��iF �� '� N � �� es ��,. �� $� S� � F j � � i w � p u� m m u � m �� n 3p E� _ A y 1 i p N O 0 0 3 � � w� o a �Z F � `� F � "� °� � F � e � r„ ti H �'�' u � �,f � q a S 4 O � i £ 4 n Z m � n q � �� N 7 P � V � V �+ .l rn 2 f B H 0 F 0 � N b O n F p F p a ��y 2; 3 �� q.'�' � o- q �.�3� 1 o� t 4 O� � V F 4 � a � i O V F O 4 U � � U w � U � g C� V Z <} N V S r O � E� � 4 � � � fi C S Y H y 7 Z 9 � O + S 1 i O f w t � i � � O � ' M N o d � � � ^ U 4 f O u � ♦ � � O � s > 0 • !i V V U o- 0 �i t�i i m Z � Z � y V R 4 4 i J O O 2 £ 2 i V V V O O F O 3 � � E � > .. e e z z � m 0. p K Z y � O � O � O n F O n o F 05 Qo 03 »"> N N N rv N % X V £ V £ V £ � O �F F 2 Z V � � a � E 4 4 U V U U F O O z F 6 r 4 4 � � O Z G 4 ? p 3 V Z V a � = N p V � O N � 2 W Z W � O � W Y � 1 6 � 4 .] � 3 .l ,^- :�. . # 9� -�3y ��_,,, i�' i°� f � Council File 4.0' t `� � ' �' ''s 6 L :"��, " Green Sheet # � �� RESOLUTIOPf ' \OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA � \) � Presented By Referred To Committee: Date RESOLVED, that the Licensee, James Kennedy dlbia Kennedy Pharmacy (License ID No. 80608), located at 334 Robert Street North in Saint Paul is hereby ordered to pay a fine of $200.00 for the violation of the sale of tobacco or tobacco products to a minor. Said fine shall be paid to the Office of License, Inspecfions and Environmental Protection within thirty (30) days of the adoption of this resolution by the Council and signature by the Mayor. This resolution and the action of the Council in this matter are based upon the facts contained in the Notice of Violation letter to the licensee, the investigation report, and such arguments as may have been presented to the Council at the public hearing. The facts were not contested by the licensee. xequested by Department of: " .� i �u7,�� 1�� s iUC�I'1 Form Ap �d by C' y torney Adopted by Council: Date �L � f Adoption Certified by Council Secretary g�,. B�'= �°"`—� �' - Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council Approved by Mayor: Date �� F y !f �.��" `7 By: By: C_ �t� -�.�y DE NFF1C6(COUNC�L DATE INITIATED 3 8 0 2� Office of LIEP 2-19-1997 GREEN SHEE CONTACT PERSON & PHONE INRIAIJDATE INITIAIlOATE O DEPARTMENT DIRECTOfi Q CItY COUNCIL Robert Kessler, 266-9112 +�+�N 0 cm nrroRNFr � C1T' CIERK NUNBEHFOP MUST BE ON COUNCIL AGENDA BY (DATE) qp�� O BUWE'! �IHECTOR � FIN. & MGL SERYICES �IR. M'dTC11 5 997 Public e �DER � MAYOR (OR ASSISTANn � TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACCI�N REQUESTEO: Concerning adverse acrion against licenses held by James Kennedy, DBA Kennedy Pharmacy, located at 334 Robert Street North. (Uncontested) RECOMMENDAnONS: Approva (A) or Reject (R) pERSONAt SERYICE CONTRACTS MUST ANSWEH THE FOILOWING �UESTIONS: _ PLqNNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION 1. Has this persoNfirm ever worKetl under a corrtract for this department? _ q6 COMMI'fTEE _ YES NO _�� 2. Has this personffirtn ever been a c�ty employee? — YES NO _ oiS7FiC7 coUxr _ 3. Does this Dersonlfirm possess a skilf not no}mally possessetl � by any Current ciry employee. SUPPOflT5 WHICH COUNCIL O&IECfIVE? YES NO Explatn all yes answers on separeta sheet antl attech to green aheet INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITY (Who, What, Wben. Where, Why}: ADVANTACaESIFAPPROVED: DISADVANTAGES IF APPqWED: Cou�cii Research Center !�`�� °��7 OISADVANTAGES IF NOT kPPROVEO: TOTAL AMOUPIT OF TRANSACTION S COSTfREVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDIWG SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMHER FINANCIAL INFORFnAT10N. (EXPLAIN) OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY ��.��4 CITY OF SAINT PAUL r�o� co�„�x na�.o, cNa QN��an 400 City Ha4 IS West KeZlogg Blvd Saint Paul M�nmesom 55102 Telephone: 611266-87I0 Facsimile: 61129&5619 February 14, 1997 NOTICE OF COtTN�IL HEARING Alan W, Weinblatt Weinblatt & Associates Pioneer Building, Suite 1616 336 North Robert Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 RE: Cigarette license held by James Kennedy d/bJa Kennedy Pharmacy for the premises located at 334 Robert Street North in St. Paul License ID No. 80608 Our File Number: G96-0637 Dear Mr. Weinblatt: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above-named establishment has been scheduled for 4:30 p.m., Wednesday, March 5, 1997 in the City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and I2amsey County Courthouse. Enclosed are copies of the proposed resolution and other documents which will be presented to the City Council for their consideration. This is an uncontested hearing, in that the facts contained in the report concerning the unlawful sale of cigarettes have not been disputed. You will have an opportunity at the Council hearing to present oral and/or written remarks as to the penalty, if any, to be imposed. The recommendation of the license office will be for a$200.00 fine. If you have any questions, please call me at 266-8710. ly yours, J. ristie , City Attorney cc: Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary Robert Kessler, Director, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Mary Nelson, Community Organizer, Capitol River Council/Dist. #1�, 445 Minnesota St., Suite 524, St. Paul, MN 55101 �� • a�.3y UNCIJNTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: James Kennedy d/b/a Kennedy Pharmacy Address: 334 Robert Street North Council Hearing Date: March 5, 1997 Violation: Sale of Cigarettes to a Minor Minn. Sta� § 609,685 St. Paut Legislative Cade § 324.07 Date: November 19, 1996 Place: Licensed Premises Presumptive Penafty: $200.00 Fine Recommendation of Assistant City Attorr�ey on behalf of client, OfFce of License, Inspections and Environmentat Protection: $200.00 fine (first offense) Attachments: 7. Proposed resolution 2. Letter of licensee or aftorney agreeing not to contest the facts 3. Notice of Violation 4. License information 5. Compiiance Report 6. City Attorney License Adverse Action Summary a �-a3`i Kennedy Pharmacy disptays "We Card" signs very visibie to all customers who purchase cigarettes in our store. To visually check for age is the first poficy and is our staff is riot sure, to chedc for an ID is our secorzd step. Everyone in our store foliows these steps on a regular basis. Over 90°� of our customers are in our store on a regular basis being we are inside an office compiex, the Pioneer Building. On November 19, 1996, a woman wearing dark glasses who fooked to be at ieast 25 years old entered and purchased a pack af cigareftes from me. Very short{y thereafter, a woman walked up to me and asked me my name. She told me i had just soid a pack of cigarettes to a minor. I assumed that she was talking about the woman with the dark glasses because she was the only one I had sold cigarettes to within the last 10 minufes or so. The woman handed me a card and said I wouid be fined and warnad me not to do it again or I could be fined very heavily soon. She never asked to see a manager or owner. She never showed me any proof. She lefit me in tears being upset about a fine. I have no idea how I could have handled the mafter d'rffererrtly. fn complete good faith and based on many years of wor4cing at Kennedy Pharmacy, I believed {and stiN do) that the customer was at ieast 25 years oid. I am very against seliing cigarettes to a minor. i beiieve the way this "sting" was handled was unfair to us. Making someone look 25 years old and sending them in feeis like entrapment. ! also believe if 4 was to ask someone to remove their glasses it could be considered discrimination. �CZLC�-�� )',�'I� �C��.t�� Maureen McNaughton �� J es B. Kenne�� License Hoider and Store Owner OFFICE '� THE CITY ATTORNEY Timothy E � Ciry Arromey - a� a�y CITY OF SAINT PAUL c�;r orv;�on No�m Cokman, Mcyor 400 Ciry Hal1 Telephone: 612 266�710 I S Wesf Kelfogg Blvd Fau'vnik: 612 298-3619 Saint Pau{ ,y'mpetara 55702 i December 12, 1996 230TICS OF VIOLATION James Kennedy Kennedy Pharmacy 334 Robert Street North Saint Paul, Minnesota 55101 RE: Cigarette license held by James Kennedy djb/a Kennedy Pharmacy for the premises located at 334 Robert Street North in St. Paul License ID No.: 806�8 Dear Mr. Kennedy: The Director of the Office of License, Inspections and Environmental Protection will recommend that adverse action be taken against your cigarette license held at the above-named premises. This recommendation is based on the following: On November 19, 1996, you or another employee sold cigarettea to a minor vnder the age of 18 years in the liceased premises. This is an offense uadez Minn. Stat. 5609.685 and Saint Paul Legislative Code §324.07. If you do not dispute the above facts, and send me a letter to that effect within 5 days, the case will be set before the City Council. You will have a chance to appear and make a statement before the Council as to the proper penalty, if any, to be imposed. If you do dispute the above facts, a hearing will be set before ari Administrative Law Judge. At that hearing both you and the City will be able to appear and present witnesses, evidence and cross- examine the other's witnesses. The Council will ultimately decided the case. If this is your cho_ce, please advise my legal assistant, Peter Pangborn, within 5 days, and we will take the necessary steps to set up that ALJ hearing. :-:e can be reached at 266-8710. Page 1 q1-a If you have any questions, you may contact me at 266-8710. Sincerely, �/�� Virginia D. Palmer . Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Directcr, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Mary Nelson, Community Crganizer, Capitol River Council/Dist. #17, 445 Minnesota St., Suite 524, St. Paul, MN 55101 Page 2 q��a�`� STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ss. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) JOANNE G. CLENENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on December �.3, 1996, she served the attached NOTICE OF V20LATION on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: James Kennedy Kennedy Pharmacy 334 Robert Street No. St. Pau1, MN. 55101 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaid, in the United States mails at St. Paul, Minnesota. Subscribed and sworn to before me this 13th day of December, 1996. , , � ��'- �i.� � ' Notary Public � RITA M. BOSSARD � NOTARY PUBLIG- MINNeSOTA FiAMSEY CA1�(VTY MyComm. Exprea.lan.37.'tO�D a • Lic ID ................... STAT ..................... Business Name..........._ Address .................. Zip ...................... Doing Business As.....,.. License Name ............. Exp Date ................. Ir.surance Carrier........ Ins. Policy Number....... Insurance Effective Date. Ins. Expiration Date..... NOTE AREA ................ Tax Id ................... Worker Comp Exp Date..... Telephone ................ 80608 AC KENNEDY, JAMES 334 ROBERT ST N 55101 KENNEDY PHARMACY CIGARETTB ORIGINAL CONTAINER 03f31J97 INSPECTOR CHANGE 3676999 07/O1/94 227-5559 FROM RICH TO DENVER - lf6/92 q�-a�� ItOUTE: #7 �. � �' 2. � 3 ITRSPECTOR KRIS SCFiVJETI�Z.ER CIGARETTfi PRED�SE CHECKS � 4. --Z � 5. � s 1 6. � � 7, ��_ 8. , �. 9. CROWN STERLIATG SUITbS HOTEL 175 IOTH ST_ E. SUITE SHOPPE 175 lOTH ST. E. M1I�' S DO«'NTOWN STAI�TDARD 542 ROBERT ST. N. . '� �'�:. � ' c u 429 ROBERT ST. N. 7 & L TOBACCO 51�� `� _�,,.� 425 FtOBERT ST. 2d. �290 �"� S ''''�'�" ' V �� THE OLD FLA�'vIE �00 R4BERT ST. N ��1 � � , ^.c�.C��.�`-: ,'�,.,`�.. _c_.�:4 �t— r �� I�232�'EDY PHARMACX , �'ROBERT ST. N. � �� ! cb � �—�- PAT'S SMOKE SHOP 55 STH ST. E. ¢OBBI� TOP HAT LOUI3GE 134 STH ST. E. " � 10. • NBTLEE - ST. MARIE' S � �, 101 STH ST. E. #221 �� . FIRST HERITAGE 332 MII��TESOTA ST: � �t�i�$�� ti A a1,� -a�'�. ��'EEK:.,, �,�— �tj t�� 1 J, � '1, 5 S --�-o�-U-Q- . DnTE: t 1 � I =� nn�: NAME OF COMPUANGE CfiECl�R T06WC(� COMPLIANCE CHECK FORM # , �� 3.� TAX 6 �. NUMB� ° I 1 �,=,�.. w�rnEOFO�c� �� 5 NAMEANDA[36RESSOfUCENSEDVF1dDOR T.�.��tn.n,.,. u-s �J�� t.. j-- WAS 7NE TOHACCA - SEIf SERVE? ASSlSiED? t� MACH6JE1 SALE WAS NWdE YES �_ � N0: BR4N0: �,f i('i f n:, _��+ti� - NAME OF CtFRK: ' J tv��;, �-.� � 1 , ° � 1� �:�.:.;�h{� �. F: _� OESCRIPTION: y f �t,'n.� ,� � � �-t' r �t r1 < < CHECKABOFITED: YES N0: ADDITIONALCANMENTS: 2 ��J f � o� F 2 4 � 4 � � F 9 � � 6 � a � o � n V � � � O O o o n o 0 a � � f 3 v � � z � 0� o� w m c'�i � � � � � n {.� � G y t5 �° o u°` E E .`� 6 � ti Y u �' � � q 2 = p .. � � � U Z � �'a y V m � j � J � Z � V V N�, m U M U V Z �r �] � E � Q �] V p e .i .i � J a ri £ j � �r�" � $ ° v c u E �d o o �i v $ �' � � � �' � � �u H � o > a � a � � . � s r ': .�. N w`"�r3� � C rv n � A r w � � N .. a � z i m .. � . � n � .. e 1 m e �°� a m � ¢ `� w "' n o", � R ° n ; 6 � ° Q � a a i e g ° u � o � o � o � o i � � . � .� ° ° ry � �°. a o � z a a^. " i ry� m z z a m �$ ° o F ° F . o Z a a O F e F O E o{� O E �w °oo °.? � 00 �.:�d . oo �o <'o ° o� oa °.5 oS °3 U o O o O o w O O � � v. s ° o > .. N � o �$ o � z i ° e > fl > ° o > �°. > ° n > °'. s °. s � > Y V� � N �� n W!0 y a C 4 N � N � � H H F � y � F ^ F �� n N � o- . , �� gg , , , , . q % , j '% m X N O O N% w R N '� % a M u K 1� % i'I % v% V X N%< v � � ti� c; i ti g.�. $ ti$� s 3 w ti� ti� u� v��a' �i � u� ii $ ti� u� 0 < ry � w H ti ro � � M1 (�u u � u 2 � q W 41 O K F i K 2 N F� X w a 4 e � aoo � � � � � e g � � � � o � 0 0 0 � u� .. E " �n s z _ �. o F � + � H [? m �n � y � m � � � w � o a � � 'i � 5 0 �i o k� o � H � E U { � U V � r V V V U V O � N q N U � 4 � N p D O O Y } = f� N ��n Z a S�n n O O 2 2 2 .2 Z 5 S T O O > 2 � G 4 • � O � R` � w � � � � � w w � r�u 6 o" � � � � � � � � d � � � � � o � u u o a a o 0 o u o u o 0 � a � �S o a o 0 •> � y £ 4 i� � � C� 4 Z o p 0 e 4Q Y Y 43 K y V � ��' 4 � 4 Z O � u m }p O r ` P p O p� m �� y� w 0 O m q � N a� R 3� e � 5° F i � V V N U t� � 4 4 � s V P � � a a � v u�� a a i .�. Y y� Y� '° ¢ wwa �o : ? Q - W �� o �� yy F o y � �^> � N 4 V O C O D � 1 K 4 U 6 yq J V S 2� w> 6 � n 6� R 0 � �� a S � a �£ 4� � 4 4 F a�-a�� n za oo: �� t� Fz. �a, �: o� ��,_ __ , _ Fo 4 V Q � � � � ' U U V V Y V U 4 V rl V��] : � c � c � a � € �' � � a � � � �� o 0 � I � � � � � E � �l � � C a n m a � 5 C � r� ti a� .� �n V� N w .+ ± q 0 K C f�Y K d C t�p fY u1 41 6 W p p 6 Z 6 6 � a � i*�9 �� O W O i O p O 4 O � O � O ti O p � os �o �o 0o So >'o 00 00 0300 � « > « > �°. > ° n > a > .°,. > �� ti � y µ H ' y N " � H N y �� g V 2 in % w % �c % �o % V % N % �e % � tr S V 4 2 V£ U S 4 S ta S U Z V i U S � 2 � O • F � 4 r � O � f�J Y � 0 6 t+ � F y F N N N ^ : � � � � � � V V V V ; O � O O F O Z z z z ° a z 9 O • 7 9 t G � O r F F � � F F W � � °a .� � � � � � k o .'. ✓ O O F • 4 R Z F W e> o e u� � g �' m n � � . � R o `�'� z z oPa �e �W < �� q S~>�� aH �F �� m � a �' �� Y " �o ° d��' �� g4 6➢ n � 4 H R Y m V m 0 W H E � W !�O y H � E h z i � F � � � � V V V c o . 4 ui � �C a� 8a �€ r m � m � V � O E w 0 Z V V Y V � � �€ G �u � � � � ��o ] i 3 W � � fby u � � u y w .] n � V �}' .� w �n < O (� \ _ � ry � 2 Z M 0 4 O fu D >°3 05 °3 0 o a o> .:> R> N '� - F � N m X �e X rv X 4 Y 6� R{+ Z U£ V S V a £ Y � � II o N N N V��i � O � � � V V V V ° z ° z ° z z m w � � � � � V V V U V w a Z y 0 4� O � 4 V t�i m ° � z z �A5 S a E g � : ��°' o Rp € a �' �" . � � �° � g y `� r � zt,m x � o 0 � � n y � n 4� � 3 4 S� G R L H V V �,�.a��i ' � o�: F. =4. oo, a�: F=, �a �: O V � � 6 V Y V X U V O U Y Y Y Y V � �1 ul 41 N � V U U ; � � � c c c c �� E b � 'c € d � �!� � � � � � �� s:a � � o � � �� = o E � V V V V e 6 G� 4 V V V N � � � �n v u� n n n .a � t�} R rv .� n �e m u� n m c a s e x w w n r�n � � b (� y 6 � � 41 z �p 2 2 GI M n N��„ � 4 � O� � O � y y � N Y N � O � O W O 4 w � O y p 4 a F O F a E o F e F O F > f O F O[�+ o p p(� �g °.3 05 '3 'S 'S '3 °3 'S oS >S °3 °S o� 0 o e o 0 0 = o 0 o e o a o 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ` y ° e > "'. > ° n i ° n > �°. > R n ° n N > « > "l > .",. > �°+ > ° n s ^e a F� � P . F � y a N N N N N N N N ry N u N N N N N N U T� N X � C ' �n % y � v� % in X n X R ' 6 r w% w X n F V� M1 H 6 F 6 F 6 F 4 H 6 F s F 0. H 4 F 6 F G 4� F q W • V 4 2 £ U i V£ V£ V L V i V L V 2 V'L V S U S V£ V 5 � O � F 4 � � £ � O O O� V F F F N ^ a ; O � O � F F � x 2 b O a a i > � � � � o w m � � g � : c3 3 3 ° a q �1 O p r V V V S i Y i 4 � O � • ' O �(� � � V y O :"o€ � �r � d N ou�z�� S- y � � F v V � a : Q O N ¢ a N 3 % Y � � u >>a .�� u�l � t�rl � � f��i � u�l f�J � N N N N H N N� � N N N � � � � � � � � � � � V V V V V V V V U U � Z S Y � Z � S y � � a � � � 4 V V F � N ° �a �� F � ��8 <i � � �n N m 4 '�`s E .�°. $ o ° � �< a, ��o � q � a � � � � � 3 d 3 3 c3 3 � 3 V V V V [a U U V N 4 K S U O � r � � � V � N Z m r+ N ..l Y 4. Y o 0 tj V Q U � O � � p � � � u � ; V � F 4 N � O � �� G a o �? 4 �� m� `z�� o z c i � F O 4 3 G Z V Z r Q O �� o �. �.� �� g� g �11-a�y u 2 4 O O � �+ e : 4 � : �° �i O V Y a � � F O 4 U Q � � � N � � ,a ° v � £ E F .�i V Z V N V V V V V � V V f V V U E o c�i a � � � ° �u � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � E � 8 � � � 3 � E € � � § s �d � � � " a .". u 6 u m � z � z� a � z � z � z �° � � z � z ° o � z X � z� z �° z 0 0 o c. o m o �. o a r a � o � .. a o a a F F o F O F o E e h F � F O F o F o F 4 4 R o F F 3 e3e3 °5 °� °3 03 S3 03 °3 e3 x 0505 OS o . o 0 0 0 0 0 0 � o � o 0 0 0 o w . o 0 0 � o > a 5 w n "> �°. "> R "> % "> S "> .�.�. "> rv "> .�n "> S "> .',� "> % S y � N ry N K N N N '+ N y N � F m N N N N � N N N 2 � N � tu 2 r r r � • • r r � � O � • y � p{ �o % v� u� „ n% m% n w �o y� x �+ % o E m% m X �n % F W F q L. � 6 d F q n F q !u E 1 F 4� 0. F R F W q F o O 4 N 6( i F S V£ U S V£ V S U£ V S U� V£ V� V S m i U� U S V£ Z • O � 4 � Y G G u � F � Z � V V F H � ° z ° z e 0 � z � w 4 O V O ° o � o � V U J O .> a � L � o � o :,a�� V p � � � ry .t bgw ;? �� z z z 6 R p p S F i fu 4 6 �'1-a�y e � �u ° r�. m w ° � w m r. n F E y N F F F y F E N 8 8 � � � a � � � � � � ° a ° z ° z � �Z z i ¢ � � z z � � V S � O � � C � � C � � � � C � � � � v � � �3 � � � V V V U V 4 V V V V a N 2 o n K U ¢ � � a � � � � � � 5 � q a < a � $ � " � � o m � � ° o � � �°+ .a N y o 4 t� 5 � e. z � rt o= C Q Q � � N . y� .I FJ C C W p N $$ �(�C f�Y N� F Y W A �p N E 4 � O Y g V O z 8 r �� F cE" i "' G ° a.� � V V� a£ U F 5 N 2 u 2.l � s � � � � V u R w � N � F O F � 4 z $ ' O 0 m � o�; h. za, a o � � � a � : F z • y o " a w.. D V N � 4 � 0 � r Y Y U Y Y V U Y � V V W V � N � N � i F� V a E�i G � Fl V � G f° �+ u � � z� ' � 'd �d � �a�' 'd � �d : � � � � � � � € � � c � L ¢ d b � � m h N tl 6 ( Q z a � z � z � i ° a a � � � a �° y i o a o m w � o i w z� `� �» o rv w V O o H a F o f. a F n H o F o� Z o F W F F O a O o O o p o O � O o O v p� F o O � O a O �� N �F "y »y �F�'�€ 'F »w �F �� P� _ - ��gg� '� . , , , �� . ex rx ex ex «x Nx�K w nx � eK N � �ix� tii ti� tii vn' sii ti x�� tii �ix� ti� O � 4 � R ♦ 0 6 � v a � o ; E ,z a 0 i > z O � O F M N , � � G � V E O O n > � a � n q � [�f n 5 � V � Z N I � M Q �' y � O � p � O � � v � � O F V p ` S m � T 0 0 �" �fia N • 6 O z n � o 8 < o u .+ z w m s s L � � a 0 6 O O �"> � a � z �+ ° Y i V �d � 6 � y o � N y �� i � S 4 p O /� 6 � G � P C O N � y h F F � F m u�" N $ � �i ° v � �i �i �i o � s o� s s � s z� s = z z z z z e W � � � � � � � U V V V V V Q � Q �+ D ! 3 � r G q q � V G K {n � Q d £ 4 � � ? � q N £ W a 5 �� y� O 9 $ S y � n a R � o e/ � i 4 � F � F �� k $ � � j' � $ k s a a » N U V V V 7 F Q e � < 9 ,� o � U p 4 v N � 4 � � n s Q K N 'f t+ E y u m Z N z Z h 4 m H F � C� fY O y= F 6 �y °a �s �� V O � r�i V 0 �� V V V O a P 4 O O „ O C � � V a ►� .1�''� P a o� F 2 4 O G � � F Z 3 6 �i O U f � \ p V � 2 yZ � Y p a d O�� [ 2 m V N � g S � � V � 6 � 4 F� U .l V U� 6 N � O q F O O ! � : °j c � £ � ° f � � � z � . � � � � u o � c` u� Z � Z 8 M o R � < [`¢'' V� g n w a w O F Q+ $ Z� F Z � Q�� n K C � Z4 V ti S. [i n R O u 4�� F C Z �$ P O N� �i V " $Bq��N� . . ^� "��am� ,.. � a€ m ^� ea�g�$�>� :a8a�a ,. m � ° � � a o � �. " � y � � y � H " � r] I � n O 4 O 4 p ~ O � p � N n Z p 4�p „ a �� ° o= o 0 0 0 0 = o z�� ° o = o F ; ° > rv s m > � > ° 'n � ° " ° s n s V 2 N N N y O N N N �� O � N N N � � J N N �n % N% N X � X Z N% d X � 4 F 0 F W E 6 F 6� 2 � V Q 4 W F d fr � u� v x ti x ti i u �° ° z � a 2 �� ti i O F 0 Z °1 � _7,�`�► z . F 4 � } O O S F F � � � � V U ; H� F z z a � 0 > ° v w � o m � � $ ° d + S 1 � ° � F O � V V O .�a r U z ♦ > : � " � sas�� u � Z a N � t O ~ y 3 g i 3 9 St ° o ' �O a :>a ;�o 4 v v 4 H N N � E 8 � � � � � � a � � V 4 z � r � F 4 �s �i' C N N � 0 � o � u�i v � � V U `� a � o O Z 0 Q u w p � d a d �m o� S .] Y N � M 5 Z � B v � z � 0 � a R ° a � a o .l i O f O E � V � �i � � � O V � � " a ° 03 0 o > ti � w u i ti W N N N V �V ° z z � Ei u � � � � � V V V V o w " `a4 i � � o � a €' � E N � � p V d �� 5 � a c � g �e e� �o � oi � "s a F. �.a � 0 =a oa ��: 4 .l � y F Z r d 6 � .l � � O U � O � . � y � V � V �' Y V V U V j � U [' � CI t � t t y � V G t' ti M i Vy � V N � (� V M U V V � � N F N � V F � ` � � � R 3 F „ b 2 6 � � 2 , .] � a 6 a U � Pi V £ �V Pi Pi � V � Yl V E I` ` .�r V � In n .+ n n w � n n w� w .. .� C a � 6 g d d � q � ( y y � M1 I� ^ � . � Z �C � 5 41 N z .l W� O a O Fi » (u � z „ � O � M W O M1 O Z w � O 6 O � O W O V O � Y o F � h O F 6 k� a F �!� D h o H � F a E a F O F e F � E 3 . 5 0 5 ° 5 8 S ° 3 0 3 ° 5 ° 3 � o � o 0 0 � o 0 0 � o 0 0 0 0 ° �O o o ° o o e o 0 0 } > i ° e > rv > s > ° o > ° n > i > ° rv > « > ° rv > ° n s N� F » N oi (+ � y a�n y »� t�i E N y � F H F N N N N F � � , , y _ y �+x x y � � x .+x �ox +.M ..,x �z a x .-x �eu n x � x •� Y' W F i F 6 F u. E LL F 4. H� d H W F W F 4 R P � •� V£ V£ V S U S U£ V Y U S fa � U£ V£ V£ V� (/ £ O � F i 6 � z � � Z V r s � > z � o xo � 3 O � ° i g N � O a;,s�� o�;�� ;� :>: , G G � O 0 O � 0� p O v � N F F N N 1/�i F F [.. N � {{��[-� F+ F y { � � 2 Z 3 � � � Z 2 S 2� V U V pp V V V V V � O F O Z 2 2 2 F z z ° z a �Z z o a c y h � F �{.� O u O O � z z z � � � � � � � � � � � w � � � � � � � � � � � � � � (a V V V V V () U V [� V U C � N I Y V 7 � 4 j Y � m � �a s g o o d a � � a � E � n ai w m a a o`�}' o � o�. 5 4 G O „ H C ; Z m p e 3 V � m 4 Q �� S F = o F 4 Y V F N N � `] o { d � a . . � � � �� -" "°�� a c� o.� p i. � w x� m -" �• :' 4�°xn � u u a q £ p N N w � Q u N � �� 8 Ep s� Eo �$ € E� ��o �y � a� � ,�� @ a om a� �� 4 �A F 2 � 6 � � � � � 4 U � U [� U Y % W W ti 4 V : z U G .�i t E Fi � ; � � � � � � u � i i S6 i Fp :.i a a r V V V $ V V : � ,� � � : � � � � z � �c �' .] (� r 4 O fu O � O 4� O > O � O O r o O o O o O a O a O o O y U rv} n> N> M1 7 N 1 N> M� � y N y • y � y � H � y V � r% e� ft n M rv% rv% rv% � U S V S V£ V 2 V� V S O � 6 � d � N n N i O � z S ; 0 � > e �: � o 4 N Y H m � � � � � V V V V s o s s s z z z z z C w � � a ° � � � � +� � • V V V V � � � 0 � Y O � � p • > � � G e� 'j n n � � y Z � r l W� 3 y n O� � C � �£ � 90 >��'�� ° � � 8 G :e� ��" F� S"�a � P� 6 � M1 V a a 4 O. o. V V � V V V V Y � � ° �i o � � � � � � � � � � � � � a a .a a a .. � � � � � � � � � : � � � � > z z Z c z' �° � � � Z p i � O � O 4 O 4„ W O 4 O 0. O 6 O e3 03 ° 3 °5 °5 �S o3 �5 0 0 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 ° o 0 0 0 N? '�n 'i w> tt> n> » 7 O> i y h µ� ��+ �^ ' F n N � y y � p � y � �n % r u m% ur X� W'n W q M d F R F d H 4 H 4� u. q H V£ V S V£ V£ U S U S V£ V p Z 1 5 � F � � G C � � F F F F { F F n o ° � G o 0 0 0 0 V � S V V U � F F � F � O Z z o. u i z ° z z z C � � � � � � Y O � � y d : n � � V n u � � �� "� � o, y m o �3 `�' u K 6� 0. O w k w � C � � � � � � n � V U U 4 U V V � K N S � a Q 'a a n� N � �+ � F m 0 � r� 4 G 3 n J� Y V F 4 4 N � � � � 4 a ° a a � U o � o V " a z" ° S �� 3 a U Z ti y V q �� $ m � ��.+ R z`-' � E z w a O 6 C F � u�l �6' O K£ K N N F �,� ,� 3 �. P M1 O u] F Z 4 y O V G 4 � F 2 � p a 4. n H � �4 V � � u g � V „ W i Z M �o' �" o F rv > U 2 N F n % � V S W " M c � h 2 b S a 03 e o u�i> N e M w � 5 • O � ^� 4 � a Y : o O 0 w r�'i+ m T � � � � V V h F F .z � P O � ' N 9 O � Q W yN W N Y a � � 3 O > ` r� i a G " � � 2 6 .] � 4 a� 4 Y� p� \ M p - 4 d i sd � S' ra u N o a z � ° a ' o — � w � :: � ` �� 4$ � w> a . w F� w a ` O V Y Y V Y w 4 Y X U U U U V d U U w V � W fY � �u � c � , � � � 5 � y � 3 � V Z q y U U V Z q V V e U Z V V V y U Z F Y R N �+ 4 M> R N Y 6 4 a � a o' ° a � a � fip � U � O O U O �p O q V O � U � V V U V ri V �e ' l \ V m � N N m ., .� � N V ti �e m n .� a rJ P� 6 p 0 h� 6� p � Z 2 S � Z � 41 R Z Z Z W Z T W O 0 O � w O Y O 4 O W 0 � O ~ O � O C O ° � ° � e � ° o � ° � ° o � o � o o ° e o o °� ° � e o 0 0 . o 0 0 . o p o e w o 0 �°+> ri i °o> °n> °o> .:> .�> .;:> ,$> N N �� N � N � F � 2 � F � N .r N u y � N � y - N N X n X % % % .n % y n X C 4� C F m t-� W[� LL� 6 F P Y� s F W� 6 F 4 u¢ � i v$ v i ��Z u$ �� S v� � g ci i u � o c � d o c � o 0 0 m H oi � m � y y h � y y g ��`O g g g � � � o o � o � � x x� s x� s�� V G V V V V tl V V V V o � 8 � R 4 m � y o 0 �° s z = ' � � � � � a �ii 0 t�pa dp •WI V V . . R V $ J i U V F f � N � U a (�j a ry b � 8 8 � "o >> �° '� `��' a 5 8 5� c 5 Y m a p 3 `��' o� � ��x " gg �'� �� o :w a� ` �� N N N.t� N� N N� N ol y N N N N y k� .l q�� a o� F: a�: a�: F 2 • 3 � : o " m � � � � � o� � � � L 1 � 4�1 � V U V V U V V � � 'e � `c � � � "- c � � w a � � � � � � � � � � ��'a � � � � E; a " a E s :, � a � ; a ., 8 g € �4 � � � � � � � � € ;� � � g , 6 � � a � � " a p a � � N : � z " � a 6 w ° n � z �° o � o '"c z � z x x � z ,�. z � z � o S N 4� Y W y Y„ 6 H R O 0 W O Y 0 4 O � O M 4� F O f+ � E F 4 F c F (+ Q[+ O F O F O F a 4 ��^ 03 oS '3 e3 .5 SS e5 °3 °.S °S o5 °5 ' o 0 0 0 0 . o 0 0 . o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 " » > » > ° > e > 5 ° > » > , a w > e > u > c > � �i N �� ag �« �N �y �y - H �� ' �� 'H �H V a x e x e F n x � x n� m x e x � x r w . x e x�, � �� ti� o:k c:� c:� m� u� w� aF iF a�' iF P p :� u� �� $ u$ v� u i u� u�i �$ �� u�a .i i ° z G < � V 2 � F 4 � U � F F y F F F � F F �+ F F F N E {� {. (.� y {� ~ � � N 5 � Z Z Z � o F 2 Z 2 V � U V U V V V U V V � 2 2 2 Z 2 2 � Z E Z � � i C O y 7 N P n O � � � F f W N f� � � � � � a � � � � � � � � � � � � o � � 5 � � � o � � G 0 � o � u � � a ° m ti x ti ° • T � O W � � ti F n m r a N YI �� O' 9 a � v � F 4 � R F � 4 w .". w � `o � � z � o � � a � E ° m � � � �i 8 R � 4 � a o � � e��iF �� '� N � �� es ��,. �� $� S� � F j � � i w � p u� m m u � m �� n 3p E� _ A y 1 i p N O 0 0 3 � � w� o a �Z F � `� F � "� °� � F � e � r„ ti H �'�' u � �,f � q a S 4 O � i £ 4 n Z m � n q � �� N 7 P � V � V �+ .l rn 2 f B H 0 F 0 � N b O n F p F p a ��y 2; 3 �� q.'�' � o- q �.�3� 1 o� t 4 O� � V F 4 � a � i O V F O 4 U � � U w � U � g C� V Z <} N V S r O � E� � 4 � � � fi C S Y H y 7 Z 9 � O + S 1 i O f w t � i � � O � ' M N o d � � � ^ U 4 f O u � ♦ � � O � s > 0 • !i V V U o- 0 �i t�i i m Z � Z � y V R 4 4 i J O O 2 £ 2 i V V V O O F O 3 � � E � > .. e e z z � m 0. p K Z y � O � O � O n F O n o F 05 Qo 03 »"> N N N rv N % X V £ V £ V £ � O �F F 2 Z V � � a � E 4 4 U V U U F O O z F 6 r 4 4 � � O Z G 4 ? p 3 V Z V a � = N p V � O N � 2 W Z W � O � W Y � 1 6 � 4 .] � 3 .l