97-1374�me��e� - ����a���
Presented
Referred To
Council File # 97 -/,3
Green Sheet # 60777
Committee Date
1 BE IT RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby certifies and approves the November 4,1997
2 decision of the Legisiative Hearing Officer:
3 Pro�ertv Appealed
A�pellant
4 1141 Universitv Avenue Zachary L. Kimble ��a �� � U e 1�
5 Decision: Six-month extension granted to correct rainleader situation. �" ��`' - tO �����
6 1162 Ed�erton
7 Decision: Appeal denied.
8 222 Frank Street
9 Decision: Appeal denied.
Scott & Cazlyn Nuteson
Joel E. Stephens
10 271 Earl Street Croix Management
11 Decision: Variance granted allowing windows to be brought up to code when replaced.
12 1 &65 Wilson Avenue #305
13 Decision: Laid over to February 3,1998.
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
��
Floyd & Kira Fairow
LI
� 7 -i37 �/
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Yeas Nays Absent
Blakey y �
Bosh�om �
Harris �
Megazd �'
Morton �'
Collins �'
Thune
8 AdoptedbyCouncil: Date ,v � , \�����
9 Adoption C rtified by Council Se�tary�
10 By: ��.��,a ,.r�•�
11 Approved by Mayor: Date �2 2 5�'
12 By:
Requested by Deparhnent of
�
Form Approved by City Attorney
�
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
2
City Council Offices
Dave Thune 266-8620
11/04/97
9�-i,��Y
GREEN SHEET No 60"17'7
oE.µ,�rtw�.oR
ASSIGN
NUYB9tFOR ❑ CrtvAiTORIEY ❑ O11'CliRlt
ROIlfUlf.
� ❑HYMCJ�LfERYCFttlR IN4Y'JLLiF0.Y/�CCTO
❑ t1I�YOR(qt1ltlLLTl�lli) ❑
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Approving decision of the Legislative Hearing Officer on Property Code Enforcement
Appeals for November 4, 1997 meeting.
Property Locations - 1141 University Avenue, 1162 Edgerton, 222 Frank Street
271 Earl Street and 1865 Wilson Avenue 1/305
PLANNING COMMISSION
CIB CAMMITTEE
CML SERVICE COMMISSION
IF APPROYED
SOURCE
INPoRMAl10N(E%PWNJ
Has tnis ce�rm everworked under a convaa ror mie aepamnenn
YES NO
Has mis v��mi ever oeen e cM emworeeT
YES MO
Does this P�� P� a SIdN not nOnnal�YPOesessetl M�Y cutterR cih' emPl%'ee?
YES NO
fs Mia peisorvfim a taipHed ventla'7
1'ES NO
COST/REVQlUE BUDGEfm (pRCLE ONE) YES NO
ACTNRY NUMBER
q� - i��y
IvIINIJTES OF PROPERTY CODE ENFORCEMENT MEETING
November 4, 1997
Room 330, City Hall
Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing Officer
Staff: Karl Johnson, Maynard Vinge and Pat Fish
Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing Officer, called the meeting to order at 130 p.m.
1141 University Avenue (Kimble Chiropracuc Office}
Zachary Kimble, owner, stated that he sees no way to divert rainleaders into the sanitary
system from this building. This is one of the smailest lots on University Avenue. Dr. Kimbie
presented photographs, advising that the building is approatimately 20' wide hy 50' deep.
(1} The south side abuts the city sidewalk. (2) The west side abuts a vacant lot with the grade at
street level. Seepage from that lot runs toward Dr. Kimbles' building. (3) The east side is next
to a building with a distance of 30" between foundations and a grade approximately 1'/z feet
higher. Water flows onto Dr. Kimbles' property from the back. (4) With respect to the north
side, Dr. Kimble stated that an inspector suggested piacing a gusset in the roof or tapping into the
roof drain and running a pipe out. Dr. Kimble advised that this area is used for employee and
patient pazking. The dirt line runs up to five feet on the back of the building. If a gusset or pipe
is piaced there, 1,000 square feet of water will be transferred to 100,000 square feet of space.
Kazl Jol�nson, Public Works, advised that the storm sewer is on the south side of
University and Ar. Kimbles' property is on the north side. Mr. Johnson stated that he believes
storm water from other commercial buildings on the north side of University goes to the ground.
Mr. Johnson presented photographs and advised that Public Works believes running to the north
side of the building is a viable option. They suggest lowering the grade, understanding that there
will be some water and ice.
With respect to the suggestion of lowering the grade on the north side, Dr. Kimble stated
that the retaining wall on the west side would have to be dealt with. Also, a retaining wall will
be needed on the east side. Estunated cost is $3,004-$4,00�.
In spite of the fact the owner is difficult to contact and deal with, Dr. Kimble indicated he
will attempt to ask for pemussion to pipe water onto the vacant property on the west side. He
witl investigate options with respect to the back azea as well.
Gerry Strathman, Legislarive Hearing Officer, granted a six month ea�tension to correct
this situarion.
1162 Edgerton
Maynazd Vinge, Public Health, reported that a failed altempt was made to inspect the
property on the moming of November 4�' . He cannot verify that anything has been corrected.
The property owners did not appeaz at this meeting. Gerry Strathman, Legislative
Hearing Officer, denied the appeal.
222 Frank Street (Laid over from October 21�
The property owner, 7oe1 Stephens, did not appear. Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing
Officer, denied the appeal.
271 Eart Street
Pat Fish, �'ire Prevention, reported that the escape/rescue windows do not meet code
requirements.
Sean Alden, representing Croix Management, stated that the windows met code
requirements at the time of construction. A plan is in place and is being executed to correct the
situation. Mr. P,lden is requesting an ea�tension of time.
Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing Officer, granted a variance allowing the windows
to be brought up to code as they are replaced.
1865 Wilson Avenue #305
Pat Fish, Fire Prevention, reported that an order to vacate by November 15�' was issued
due to overcrowding. Unit #305 is occupied by Floyd & Kira Fairow and four children, ages 8
and under. ,
Laura Jelinek, attomey, asked that tfie vacate date be e�ctended in order to avoid a
homeless situation for this family. Ms. 7elinek presented photographs of the current living space
which she feels is adequate. Her office, however, is searching for other housing. Ms. Jelinek
regorted this can be accomplished within several months.
Ms. Jelinek stated her concern that tlus situation was initiated by the landlord out of
retaliation. Mr. Fairow stated that there were some problems with the landtord and also that he
no longer lives there himself.
Gerry Slrathman, Legislative Hearing Officer, granted a ninety (90) day extension to the
family to find new housing. Mr. Strathman laid this matter over to February 3, 1998.
The meeting was adjourned at 235 p.m.
�me��e� - ����a���
Presented
Referred To
Council File # 97 -/,3
Green Sheet # 60777
Committee Date
1 BE IT RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby certifies and approves the November 4,1997
2 decision of the Legisiative Hearing Officer:
3 Pro�ertv Appealed
A�pellant
4 1141 Universitv Avenue Zachary L. Kimble ��a �� � U e 1�
5 Decision: Six-month extension granted to correct rainleader situation. �" ��`' - tO �����
6 1162 Ed�erton
7 Decision: Appeal denied.
8 222 Frank Street
9 Decision: Appeal denied.
Scott & Cazlyn Nuteson
Joel E. Stephens
10 271 Earl Street Croix Management
11 Decision: Variance granted allowing windows to be brought up to code when replaced.
12 1 &65 Wilson Avenue #305
13 Decision: Laid over to February 3,1998.
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
��
Floyd & Kira Fairow
LI
� 7 -i37 �/
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Yeas Nays Absent
Blakey y �
Bosh�om �
Harris �
Megazd �'
Morton �'
Collins �'
Thune
8 AdoptedbyCouncil: Date ,v � , \�����
9 Adoption C rtified by Council Se�tary�
10 By: ��.��,a ,.r�•�
11 Approved by Mayor: Date �2 2 5�'
12 By:
Requested by Deparhnent of
�
Form Approved by City Attorney
�
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
2
City Council Offices
Dave Thune 266-8620
11/04/97
9�-i,��Y
GREEN SHEET No 60"17'7
oE.µ,�rtw�.oR
ASSIGN
NUYB9tFOR ❑ CrtvAiTORIEY ❑ O11'CliRlt
ROIlfUlf.
� ❑HYMCJ�LfERYCFttlR IN4Y'JLLiF0.Y/�CCTO
❑ t1I�YOR(qt1ltlLLTl�lli) ❑
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Approving decision of the Legislative Hearing Officer on Property Code Enforcement
Appeals for November 4, 1997 meeting.
Property Locations - 1141 University Avenue, 1162 Edgerton, 222 Frank Street
271 Earl Street and 1865 Wilson Avenue 1/305
PLANNING COMMISSION
CIB CAMMITTEE
CML SERVICE COMMISSION
IF APPROYED
SOURCE
INPoRMAl10N(E%PWNJ
Has tnis ce�rm everworked under a convaa ror mie aepamnenn
YES NO
Has mis v��mi ever oeen e cM emworeeT
YES MO
Does this P�� P� a SIdN not nOnnal�YPOesessetl M�Y cutterR cih' emPl%'ee?
YES NO
fs Mia peisorvfim a taipHed ventla'7
1'ES NO
COST/REVQlUE BUDGEfm (pRCLE ONE) YES NO
ACTNRY NUMBER
q� - i��y
IvIINIJTES OF PROPERTY CODE ENFORCEMENT MEETING
November 4, 1997
Room 330, City Hall
Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing Officer
Staff: Karl Johnson, Maynard Vinge and Pat Fish
Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing Officer, called the meeting to order at 130 p.m.
1141 University Avenue (Kimble Chiropracuc Office}
Zachary Kimble, owner, stated that he sees no way to divert rainleaders into the sanitary
system from this building. This is one of the smailest lots on University Avenue. Dr. Kimbie
presented photographs, advising that the building is approatimately 20' wide hy 50' deep.
(1} The south side abuts the city sidewalk. (2) The west side abuts a vacant lot with the grade at
street level. Seepage from that lot runs toward Dr. Kimbles' building. (3) The east side is next
to a building with a distance of 30" between foundations and a grade approximately 1'/z feet
higher. Water flows onto Dr. Kimbles' property from the back. (4) With respect to the north
side, Dr. Kimble stated that an inspector suggested piacing a gusset in the roof or tapping into the
roof drain and running a pipe out. Dr. Kimble advised that this area is used for employee and
patient pazking. The dirt line runs up to five feet on the back of the building. If a gusset or pipe
is piaced there, 1,000 square feet of water will be transferred to 100,000 square feet of space.
Kazl Jol�nson, Public Works, advised that the storm sewer is on the south side of
University and Ar. Kimbles' property is on the north side. Mr. Johnson stated that he believes
storm water from other commercial buildings on the north side of University goes to the ground.
Mr. Johnson presented photographs and advised that Public Works believes running to the north
side of the building is a viable option. They suggest lowering the grade, understanding that there
will be some water and ice.
With respect to the suggestion of lowering the grade on the north side, Dr. Kimble stated
that the retaining wall on the west side would have to be dealt with. Also, a retaining wall will
be needed on the east side. Estunated cost is $3,004-$4,00�.
In spite of the fact the owner is difficult to contact and deal with, Dr. Kimble indicated he
will attempt to ask for pemussion to pipe water onto the vacant property on the west side. He
witl investigate options with respect to the back azea as well.
Gerry Strathman, Legislarive Hearing Officer, granted a six month ea�tension to correct
this situarion.
1162 Edgerton
Maynazd Vinge, Public Health, reported that a failed altempt was made to inspect the
property on the moming of November 4�' . He cannot verify that anything has been corrected.
The property owners did not appeaz at this meeting. Gerry Strathman, Legislative
Hearing Officer, denied the appeal.
222 Frank Street (Laid over from October 21�
The property owner, 7oe1 Stephens, did not appear. Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing
Officer, denied the appeal.
271 Eart Street
Pat Fish, �'ire Prevention, reported that the escape/rescue windows do not meet code
requirements.
Sean Alden, representing Croix Management, stated that the windows met code
requirements at the time of construction. A plan is in place and is being executed to correct the
situation. Mr. P,lden is requesting an ea�tension of time.
Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing Officer, granted a variance allowing the windows
to be brought up to code as they are replaced.
1865 Wilson Avenue #305
Pat Fish, Fire Prevention, reported that an order to vacate by November 15�' was issued
due to overcrowding. Unit #305 is occupied by Floyd & Kira Fairow and four children, ages 8
and under. ,
Laura Jelinek, attomey, asked that tfie vacate date be e�ctended in order to avoid a
homeless situation for this family. Ms. 7elinek presented photographs of the current living space
which she feels is adequate. Her office, however, is searching for other housing. Ms. Jelinek
regorted this can be accomplished within several months.
Ms. Jelinek stated her concern that tlus situation was initiated by the landlord out of
retaliation. Mr. Fairow stated that there were some problems with the landtord and also that he
no longer lives there himself.
Gerry Slrathman, Legislative Hearing Officer, granted a ninety (90) day extension to the
family to find new housing. Mr. Strathman laid this matter over to February 3, 1998.
The meeting was adjourned at 235 p.m.
�me��e� - ����a���
Presented
Referred To
Council File # 97 -/,3
Green Sheet # 60777
Committee Date
1 BE IT RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul hereby certifies and approves the November 4,1997
2 decision of the Legisiative Hearing Officer:
3 Pro�ertv Appealed
A�pellant
4 1141 Universitv Avenue Zachary L. Kimble ��a �� � U e 1�
5 Decision: Six-month extension granted to correct rainleader situation. �" ��`' - tO �����
6 1162 Ed�erton
7 Decision: Appeal denied.
8 222 Frank Street
9 Decision: Appeal denied.
Scott & Cazlyn Nuteson
Joel E. Stephens
10 271 Earl Street Croix Management
11 Decision: Variance granted allowing windows to be brought up to code when replaced.
12 1 &65 Wilson Avenue #305
13 Decision: Laid over to February 3,1998.
RESOLUTION
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
��
Floyd & Kira Fairow
LI
� 7 -i37 �/
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Yeas Nays Absent
Blakey y �
Bosh�om �
Harris �
Megazd �'
Morton �'
Collins �'
Thune
8 AdoptedbyCouncil: Date ,v � , \�����
9 Adoption C rtified by Council Se�tary�
10 By: ��.��,a ,.r�•�
11 Approved by Mayor: Date �2 2 5�'
12 By:
Requested by Deparhnent of
�
Form Approved by City Attorney
�
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By:
2
City Council Offices
Dave Thune 266-8620
11/04/97
9�-i,��Y
GREEN SHEET No 60"17'7
oE.µ,�rtw�.oR
ASSIGN
NUYB9tFOR ❑ CrtvAiTORIEY ❑ O11'CliRlt
ROIlfUlf.
� ❑HYMCJ�LfERYCFttlR IN4Y'JLLiF0.Y/�CCTO
❑ t1I�YOR(qt1ltlLLTl�lli) ❑
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLJP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE)
Approving decision of the Legislative Hearing Officer on Property Code Enforcement
Appeals for November 4, 1997 meeting.
Property Locations - 1141 University Avenue, 1162 Edgerton, 222 Frank Street
271 Earl Street and 1865 Wilson Avenue 1/305
PLANNING COMMISSION
CIB CAMMITTEE
CML SERVICE COMMISSION
IF APPROYED
SOURCE
INPoRMAl10N(E%PWNJ
Has tnis ce�rm everworked under a convaa ror mie aepamnenn
YES NO
Has mis v��mi ever oeen e cM emworeeT
YES MO
Does this P�� P� a SIdN not nOnnal�YPOesessetl M�Y cutterR cih' emPl%'ee?
YES NO
fs Mia peisorvfim a taipHed ventla'7
1'ES NO
COST/REVQlUE BUDGEfm (pRCLE ONE) YES NO
ACTNRY NUMBER
q� - i��y
IvIINIJTES OF PROPERTY CODE ENFORCEMENT MEETING
November 4, 1997
Room 330, City Hall
Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing Officer
Staff: Karl Johnson, Maynard Vinge and Pat Fish
Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing Officer, called the meeting to order at 130 p.m.
1141 University Avenue (Kimble Chiropracuc Office}
Zachary Kimble, owner, stated that he sees no way to divert rainleaders into the sanitary
system from this building. This is one of the smailest lots on University Avenue. Dr. Kimbie
presented photographs, advising that the building is approatimately 20' wide hy 50' deep.
(1} The south side abuts the city sidewalk. (2) The west side abuts a vacant lot with the grade at
street level. Seepage from that lot runs toward Dr. Kimbles' building. (3) The east side is next
to a building with a distance of 30" between foundations and a grade approximately 1'/z feet
higher. Water flows onto Dr. Kimbles' property from the back. (4) With respect to the north
side, Dr. Kimble stated that an inspector suggested piacing a gusset in the roof or tapping into the
roof drain and running a pipe out. Dr. Kimble advised that this area is used for employee and
patient pazking. The dirt line runs up to five feet on the back of the building. If a gusset or pipe
is piaced there, 1,000 square feet of water will be transferred to 100,000 square feet of space.
Kazl Jol�nson, Public Works, advised that the storm sewer is on the south side of
University and Ar. Kimbles' property is on the north side. Mr. Johnson stated that he believes
storm water from other commercial buildings on the north side of University goes to the ground.
Mr. Johnson presented photographs and advised that Public Works believes running to the north
side of the building is a viable option. They suggest lowering the grade, understanding that there
will be some water and ice.
With respect to the suggestion of lowering the grade on the north side, Dr. Kimble stated
that the retaining wall on the west side would have to be dealt with. Also, a retaining wall will
be needed on the east side. Estunated cost is $3,004-$4,00�.
In spite of the fact the owner is difficult to contact and deal with, Dr. Kimble indicated he
will attempt to ask for pemussion to pipe water onto the vacant property on the west side. He
witl investigate options with respect to the back azea as well.
Gerry Strathman, Legislarive Hearing Officer, granted a six month ea�tension to correct
this situarion.
1162 Edgerton
Maynazd Vinge, Public Health, reported that a failed altempt was made to inspect the
property on the moming of November 4�' . He cannot verify that anything has been corrected.
The property owners did not appeaz at this meeting. Gerry Strathman, Legislative
Hearing Officer, denied the appeal.
222 Frank Street (Laid over from October 21�
The property owner, 7oe1 Stephens, did not appear. Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing
Officer, denied the appeal.
271 Eart Street
Pat Fish, �'ire Prevention, reported that the escape/rescue windows do not meet code
requirements.
Sean Alden, representing Croix Management, stated that the windows met code
requirements at the time of construction. A plan is in place and is being executed to correct the
situation. Mr. P,lden is requesting an ea�tension of time.
Gerry Strathman, Legislative Hearing Officer, granted a variance allowing the windows
to be brought up to code as they are replaced.
1865 Wilson Avenue #305
Pat Fish, Fire Prevention, reported that an order to vacate by November 15�' was issued
due to overcrowding. Unit #305 is occupied by Floyd & Kira Fairow and four children, ages 8
and under. ,
Laura Jelinek, attomey, asked that tfie vacate date be e�ctended in order to avoid a
homeless situation for this family. Ms. 7elinek presented photographs of the current living space
which she feels is adequate. Her office, however, is searching for other housing. Ms. Jelinek
regorted this can be accomplished within several months.
Ms. Jelinek stated her concern that tlus situation was initiated by the landlord out of
retaliation. Mr. Fairow stated that there were some problems with the landtord and also that he
no longer lives there himself.
Gerry Slrathman, Legislative Hearing Officer, granted a ninety (90) day extension to the
family to find new housing. Mr. Strathman laid this matter over to February 3, 1998.
The meeting was adjourned at 235 p.m.