The URL can be used to link to this page

Untitled OFFICE OF HUMAN RESOURCES ` Angela S. Nalezny, Director RISK MANAGEMENT CITY OF SAINT PAUL 200 City Hall Annex Telephone: 651-266-6500 Christopher B. Coleman, Mayor 25 West Fourth Street ��.c��i�631-266-8886 Saint Paul MN SS/02-1631 L1 MAR 0 6 ZO l2 � �I�""��;�� February 2, 2012 Dahir A. Abdi 163 Mount Airy Street Saint Paul, MN 55130 RE: Claim Against City of Saint Paul File Number C-110333 Dear Mr. Abdi: As I had told you earlier, your vehicle is a constructive total loss, meaning that the cost to repair the vehicle is more than the value of the vehicle. While you state that you believe your vehicle is worth $8,000, I am enclosing the valuations obtained from the internet that support the valuation of $2,783.00 for your vehicle. Since you went through your insurance carrier for a rental vehicle, I am reimbursing your carrier for that cost directly. You are also entitled to the full proceeds from the sale of your vehicle at the salvage yard, if you have not already sold the vehicle. Enclosed you will find a release for the amount of $2,783.00 regarding your claim against the City of Saint Paul. You should sign the release before a notary public and two witnesses, and return it to my office. Upon receipt of said release, I will request that payment be made. It will take approximatety five to ten days after I receive your signed release for the City to issue a check directly to you. � Sincerely, � , Z�� Sandra Bodensteiner Claims Manager SB Enclosures AA-ADA-EEO Employer 2000 Chevrolet Venture Passenger Extended Minivan 4D Trade In Values - Kelley Blue Book Page 2 of 2 Kelley Blue BookO Private Party Value'-This is the starting point for negotiation of a used-car sale between a private buyer and seller.This is an"as is"value that does not include any warranties.The final price depends on the car's adual condition and local market factors. Excellent Condition:3%of all cars we value meet this criteria.This car looks new and is in excellent mechanical condition.It has never had paint or bodywork and has an interior and body free of wear and visible defects.The car is rust-free and dces not need reconditioning.Its clean engine compartment is free of fluid leaks.It also has a clean title history,has complete and verifiable service records and will pass safety and smog inspection. Very Good Condition:23%of all cars we value meet this criteria.This car has minor wear or visible defects on the body and interior but is in excellent mechanical condition,requiring only minimal reconditioning.It has little to no paint and bodywork and is free of rust.Its clean engine compartment is free of fluid leaks.The tires match and have 75°/a or more of tread.It also has a clean title history,with most service records available,and will pass safety and smog inspection. Good Condition:54%of all cars we value meet this criteria.This car is free of major mechanical problems but may need some reconditioning.Its paint and bodywork may require minor touch-ups,with repairable cosmetic defects,and its engine compardnent may have minor leaks.There are minor body scratches or dings and minor interior blemishes,but no rust.The tires match and have 50%or more of tread.It also has a clean title history,with some service records available,and will pass safety and smog inspection. Fair Condition: 18%of all cars we value meet this criteria.This car has some mechanical or cosmetic defects and needs servicing,but is still in safe runnin9 condition and has a clean title history.The paint,body and/or interior may need professional servicing.The tires may need replacing and there may be some repairable rust damage. cQ 1995-2012 Kelley Blue Book Co.",Inc.All rights reserved.Copyright&Trademarks � Terms of Service � Privacy Policy � Ad Choices �O 2012 Kelley B/ue BookCo.,Inc.Al/rights reserved.1/27/2012-2/2/2012 Edition for Minnesota 55119.The speofic information�equired to de�rmine the value for this particdar vehiGe was wpplied by the persar generating this report.Vehide va/uations are opinions and may vary from�ehide to vehiGe.Actua/valuations will vary based upon market conditions,spxifications,vehicle condition o�other part.cular circumstan�s pertinerrf[o this particu'ar vehide o�fhe trensaction or the part�es to U�e transaction.This report is intended for[he individ�e/use of tlie person generating[hs report on/y and shall no[be sold or transmiKed to another party.Kelley Blue Book assumes ra responsibility for errors or omissions.(v.12020) http://www.kbb.com/chevrolet/venture-passenger/2000-chevrolet-venture-passenger/extended-minivan-4d/... 2/2/2012 Chevrolet Venture 2000 - Car Standard Equipment- NADAguides.com Official Site Page 2 of 3 Steering Wheel-Adjustable Steering-Power Windows-Power Music &Entertainment Audio-AM/FM Stereo Audio-Cassette Player Audio-CD Player Interior Auxiliary Pwr Outlet Floor Mats Seat-3rd Row Exterior Doors: 4 Door-Sliding-Rear Driver Side Door-Sliding-Rear Passenger Side Luggage Rack/Roof Rack Mirror(s)-Heated Rear Window Defogger Windows-Deep Tinted Wipers-Intermittent Wipers-Variable Speed Intermittent Tires Front Tire Size: P215/70R15 Rear Tire Size: P215/70R15 Spare Tire Size: T125/70R15 Wheels Front Wheel Material: Steel Rear Wheel Material: Steel Back to too Rough Trade-In: $975 Rough Trade-in values reflect a vehicle in rough condition. Meaning a vehicle with significant mechanical defects requiring repairs in order to restore reasonable running condition. Paint, body and wheel surfaces have considerable damage to their finish, which may include dull or faded (oxidized) paint, small to medium size dents, frame damage, rust or obvious signs of previous repairs. Interior reflects above average wear with inoperable equipment, damaged or missing trim and heavily soiled/permanent imperfections on the headliner, carpet, and upholstery. Vehicle may have a branded title and un-true mileage. Vehicle will need substantial reconditioning and repair to be made ready for resale. Some existing issues may be difficult to restore. Because individual vehicle condition varies greatly, users of NADAguides.com may need to make independent adjustments for actual vehicle condition. Average Trade-In: $1,600 The Average Trade-In values on �adaguides.com are meant to reflect a vehicle in average condition. A vehicle that is mechanically sound but may require some repairs/servicing to pass all necessary inspections; Paint, body and wheel surfaces have moderate imperfections and an average finish and shine which can be improved with restorative repair; Interior reflects some soiling and wear in relation to vehicle age, with all equipment operable or requiring minimal effort to make operable; Clean title history; Vehicle will need a fair degree of reconditioning to be made ready for resale. Because individual vehicle condition varies greatly, users of nadaguides.com may need to make independent adjustments for actual vehicle condition. Clean Trade-In: $2,100 Clean Trade-In values reflect a vehicle in clean condition. This means a vehicle with no mechanical defects and passes all necessary inspections with ease. Paint, body and wheels have minor surface scratching with a high gloss finish and shine. Interior reflects minimal soiling and wear with all equipment in complete working order. Vehicle has a clean title history. Vehicle will need minimal reconditioning to be made ready for resale. Because individual vehicle condition varies greatly, users of NADAguides.com may need to make independent adjustments for actual vehicle condition. Clean Retail: $3,925 Clean Retail values reflect a vehicfe in clean condition. This means a vehicle with no mechanical defects and passes all necessary inspections with ease. Paint, body and wheels have minor surface scratching with a high gloss finish and shine. Interior reflects minimal soiling and wear with all equipment in complete working order. Vehicle has a clean title history. Because individual vehicle condition varies greatly, users of NADAguides.com may need to make independent adjustments for actual vehicle condition. Note: Vehicles with low mileage that are in exceptionally good condition and/or include a manufacturer certification can be worth a significantly higher value than the Clean Retail price shown. http://www.nadaguides.com/Cars/2000/Chevrolet/Venture-V6/Extended-Van-4D/Standard-Equipment/Print 2/2/2012 Chevrolet Venture 2000 - Car Standard Equipment -NADAguides.com Official Site Page 3 of 3 The consumer values on NADAguides.com are based on the Consumer Edition of the NADA Official Used Car Guideo and should not be utilized for industry purposes. The cons�mer values may vary from the NADA Official Used Car Guide�values presented to you by insurance companies, banks,credit unions,government agencies and car dealers due to vehicle condition, regional market differences and frequency of updates. - -.. __._-._ .-�---__ __.._. _- _.__... - - �-- . . . __ ... ADVERTISEMENT . _ _._._ _ ----- -- ' �--- ----- . _ �----- --- . --------- �� ---. . . __ ---�� - I i - - - . _----_--- � _-..--- �- -----� . -- -- -----.. ' _- -- - ---.. ---_. -- , -.-- .-__. �- .. .. -------- _ �. __.. . -_._---- -- � . .. _._- - --�--- �--._. _. -- -... �O Copyright 2012 National Appraisal Guides Inc. All Rights Reserved. http://www.nadaguides.com/Cars/2000/Chevrolet/Venture-V6/Extended-Van-4D/Standard-Equipment/Print 2/2/2012 2000 Chevrolet Venture Passenger Extended Minivan 4D Trade In Values - Kelley Blue Book Page 1 of 2 �'� ' ��i� L7��o �7��t�€r aai,�Y�c��eu�t,ucr;» Used Car Trade-In Values �y.�r 2000 Chevrolet Venture Passenger Extended Minivan 4D Mileage:154,780 VALUES FOR JAN 27 2012-FEB 2 2012 Values Vehicte Highlights Trade-In Private Party MPG:City 17/Hwy 24 Max Seating:8 Excellent $2,139 $3,519 Doors:4 Engine:V6,3.4 Liter very Good $2,064 $3,294 Drivetrain:FWD Transmission:Automatic Good $1,864 $3,169 EPA Class:Minivan Body Style: Extended Van Fair $1,389 $2,619 Country of Origin:United States Country of Assembly:United States Your Configured Options Our pre-selected options,based on typical equipment for this car. Options that you added while configuring this car. Engine Braking and Traction Safety and Security V6,3.4 Liter ABS(4-Wheel) Dual Air Bags Transmission Comfort and Convenience Cargo and Towing Automatic Air Conditioning Roof Rack Drivetrain ' Pcw°r�Nindows Wheels and Tires Power poor Locks Steel Wheels �� ' Cruise Control Accessory Packages Steering LS Power Steering TiR Wheel Entertainment and Instrumentation AM/FM Stereo CD(Single Disc) Glossary of Terms Kelley Blue Bookp Trade-in Value-This is the amount you can expect to receive when you trade in your car to a dealer.This value is detertnined based on the style,condition,mileage and options indicated. http://www.kbb.com/chevrolet/venture-passenger/2000-chevrolet-venture-passenger/extended-minivan-4d/... 2/2/2012 Chevrolet Venture 2000 - Car Standard Equipment -NADAguides.com Official Site Page 1 of 3 �,; E � �� , The P�r+v�r af Y�hitEe Infc�rmali+Crn � Close Window NA.DAg�ades.cam 2/2/2012 2000 Chevrolet Venture Extended Van 4D NADAguides.com Price Report Rough Average Clean Clean Trade-In Trade-In Trade-In Retail Base Price $900 $1,525 $2,025 $3,825 Mileage: 154,780 miles -$100 -$100 -$100 -$100 Options: Aluminum/Alloy Wheels Incl Incl Incl Incl LS Pkg $175 $175 $175 $200 TOTAL PRICE �97rj �1�60� �2�1�� $3,92 Standard Equipment Standard Equipment Details Engine Specifications Type: Gas V6 Size: 3.4L/207 Horsepower: 180 @ 5200 RPM Torque: 205 @ 4000 RPM Max Towing Capacity: 2000 Drive Train Drive Train: Front Wheel Drive Transmission: 4 speed Electronic Automatic w/OD Safety Air Bag-Frontal-Driver Air Bag-Frontal-Passenger Air Bag-Side Body-Front B ra kes-ABS Brakes-Type-Front Disc/Rear Drum Child Safety Rear poor Locks Daytime Running Lights Engine Immobilizer Headlights-Automatic Comfort &Convenience Air Conditioning-Front Air Conditioning-Rear Cruise Control Keyless Entry Max Seating Capacity: 7 Mirror(s)-Power Mirrors-Vanity-Driver Mirrors-Vanity-Passenger Power Locks Rear Seat Heat Ducts Seat Trim-Cloth Seat-Rear Pass-Through Seats-Front Bucket http://www.nadaguides.com/Cars/2000/Chevrolet/Venture-V6/Extended-Van-4D/Standard-Equipment/Print 2/2/2012 http://www.edmunds.com/ 2000 Chevrolet Venture - What Your Car is Worth � � _ : - �� F - � , � :e , � �; �� ,, � �� . � �� ,�YV�IIh, V''��iy�i��W��u�buY�� Il��d� fi��IlYI�iR s^ +�e��;.M: Photos Videos 360 Please enter a valid 5-digit Zi Code 55130 UpdatePricing for Saint Paul, MN True Market Value� Trade-in $631 Private Party Sale $1,130 Dealer Retail $1,972 Customized True Market Value° Prices Trade-In Private Party Dealer Retail National Base Price $1,064 $1,543 $2,342 Optional Equipment $65 $85 $128 8 Passenger Seating $21 $28 $42 Roof Rack $15 $20 $30 AM/FM/CD Audio System $29 $37 $56 Color Adjustment-Red $0 $0 $0 Regional Adjustment-for Zip Code 55130 $0 $0 $0 Mileage Adjustment- 154,780 miles $-498 $-498 $-498 Condition Adjustment-Clean $0 $0 $0 Total $631 $1,130 $1,972 � Property Damage Release File Number C-110333 For the sole consideration of two thousand seven hundred eighty three dollars and no cents ($2,783.00), the receipt and sufficiency whereof is hereby acknowledged, the undersigned hereby releases and forever discharges the City of Saint Paul, Parks & Recreation Department, Jordan Carlson, their heirs, executors, administrators, agents, and assigns, and all other persons, firms or corporations liable, or who might be liable, none of whom admit any liability, from any and all claims, demands, damages, actions, causes of action or suits of any kind or nature whatsoever, to property which has resulted, or may develop in the future from an incident which occurred on or about the 12t" day of October, 2011, at or near, Saint Paul, MN. The undersigned hereby declares that the terms of this settlement are fully understood and voluntarily accepted for the purpose of making a full and final compromise adjustment and settlement of any and all claims, disputed or otherwise, on account of the property damage mentioned above. I hereby state that I have read this release, know the contents thereof, and have signed the same, relying on my own udgment and on no re resentations of others, and of my own free will and accord this�_day of � - , 20��,. ' a� L In the presence of: C� � r� Witness Dahir A. Abdi Witness Subscribed and sworn to before me on this��day of r� r�ti , 20� . .--.' �..r. .y.-� � a Pub 'c � iwwrwwwr►� LORt JEAN SIEBENALER UIOTAtiY PUBLIC.W�A Mr co�o��,i,�+.a�.mu � AlMp`+atit�4'W'•"4'+,�'_,f�I=:'*d`x"y'N"..'.AaceR.'..:.�.,r,�;;:.,:�.,.. :.sa.:rc � �. ''i � y4 j "Ai : j t �" . _µ ; � !i� ��F�� s� d�1;,'r dA �. :a V i��::..orw'�:? r:„. �: -.....1:. .3�':', ...:•!� � � .� '��/f�M�f,�� `��'�i�lv'1F