The URL can be used to link to this page

94-1465 �� -- n �= / ��l � � Council File # ��'�I�� °' � + � q L Green Sheet # ESOLUTION CI OF S I P U, MINNES TA �� Presented By �'�/" ( Referred To Committee: Date WHEREAS, the City of Saint Paul has e acted Chapter 293 of its Legislative Code pertaining to the regulation of noise and WHEREAS, said Chapter permits the gra ting of an exemption or variance from such regulation upon a determination of un easonable hardship upon the community or applicant; and � G(�� f l./ WHEREAS, the Department of Public Wor s has applied for a variance from sound level restrictions from October 10, 1994 t ough � 1995 for a public work referred to as Davern Outlet "B" Combined Sewer Se a ation Pro'ect, located at Stewart Street immediatelv west of Alton Street; and i. Y•t WHEREAS, the City Council conducted public hearingson said matter on October 5,/ � ,� �� now, therefore be it � RESOLVED, that th City Council here grants to the Department of Public Works and its agent or contrac or a variance from e requirements of Chapter 293 from October 10, 1994 through 1 1995 with the f lowing condi�ions:;c 1) Variance shall be granted from 6:00 `g`. 3:�--88- p.m. 2) Any source of noise opera ing between �CX�p.m. and 6:00 a.m. shall not exceed a L10 noise level f 65 dBA measured at a point of human activity which is nearest the nois source and which is in a noise receptor C1ass II as described in Sec. 293. 9, Noise Source Limitations. 3) Most higher noise level w rk will be performed during daylight hours. 4) Ventilation equipment, ge erators, compressors and other similar equipment will be enclosed if possi le and/or provided with the best available noise abatement devices. _ ��,,.; 5) Surface work shall be lim'ted to the hours of 6:00 p.m-. to �i:Of1-p.m. whenever possible. and be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Director f the Department of Public Works shall furnish a copy of the resolution to any contra tor performing in said project and shall assist in the variance enforcement. Requested by Department of: Yeas. Navs Abs nt a e u.� Office of License, Inspections and rimm uerin � '` Environmental Protection arri s —�� e ar �. ettman — T une � —� B �'' Adopted by Council : Date � - , � - �" � Form Approved by City Attorney Adoption Certified by C�uncil Secreta y . �\ B � -ZC'r/ By: -� -� ,:}' �.._.._.�- A roved b M O: Date � pp y ( � Approv d�y Mayor for mission to Counc'1� i ' � i 1' ��,, , By: �' �t'"��(./� By : i � � /1, ; 4�—i��a�' , DEPARTM[NTIOFFi(:EJCOUNCIL DATE I TED i LIEP 9 6/94 GREEN SHEET r�o -�0 83 OONTACT PERSON E PNONE INITIAU DA7E INITIAUDATE , � DEPARTMENT DIREC � GTV OOUNpL " ! Peter Kishel 266-9133 �� C11Y A7TORNEY � GTY CIERK � MUST BE OM COUNGL AQENOA BV (DAT� � BUOOET DIRECTOR � fIN. d MOT. BERVICEB DIR. � October 5, 1994 � tiu►voR �oR �ssisvwn � � TOTAL A� OF SIGNATURE PAOE8 ( (CLIP LOCATIONS FOR 81QNATURE) ACTION REGUESTED: Council Resolution ratifying a varian to Chapter 293. (St. Paul Noise Ordinance) requested by St. Paul Public Works De rtment. � oOWIMENDAT10N8: MP�� (N a► �(AI RGI REPORT _ PLMINII�Ki OOMMIBSION _ qVIL 8ERVIGE COMMISSION ANAL PFIONE NO. i _ GB OOAiMAITTEE _ _ STAFF _ COM . - D�� ,� _ I BUPPORTS NMlf�l COUNGL OBJECTIVET , � INRUTINO PROBLEM. I�UE� OPPORTUNITY (Who. W�et, WMn, WMn� Why): This variance will allow sound levels in excess of those in Chapter 293 (St. Paul Noise Ordinance), for a Public Works ro�ect referred to as the Davern Outlet "B" � Combined Sewer Separation Project, lo ated at Stewart Street immediately west of Alton Street. The variance with cond tions is only for Construction work in said project from October 10, 1994 th ough � l, 1995. Noise source will be i support equipment for underground wor . �Q� ' i Resolution includes recommended vari ce conditions from LIEP Environmental Health. � � ADVAI�fiA(iE8 IF APPROVED: i Granting of the variance will allow t e contractor performing in said pro�ect to work � 24 hours per day. Ma3ority of work 11 be done underground in tunnels. This will ' allow for completion of the project s that other sewer projects that are planned for the summer of 1995 can be comple d. � j I . � � I � � � DISADVANTAGES IF A�OVEC: . . i a i � Residents living near the project wi 1 be exposed to daytime and nighttime noise ! � that is greater than current backgro nd noise levels. i, I ; � i , i ; aa�wwu�rr�u�s � Nor �vr+�oveo: � Violations of Chapter 293 (St. Paul oise Ordinance) would likely occur if variance ( is not granted. If underground work is not allowed to occur 24 hours per day, the � project could not be campleted by th date indicated. This�would result in delays � , in the start of other Sewer Projects scheduled to begin in the summer of 1995. f' ; ; TOTAL AMOUNT OF TMfISACTION N/A C08T/pEVENUE BUDOETED (CIRCLE ON!) YES O i FUNDINO SOURCE NIA ACTIVITY NUM9ER I flNANCUIL INFORMATION: (EXPL.AII� � ; � � ; 4a �� , NOTE: COMPLETE DIRECTK'Nd3 ARE INC�UDED IN THE CiREEN BHEET INSTRUCTIONAt �' MANUAL AVAILABLE IN THE PURCHA81NS3 OFFIC� (PHONE I�O. �. ROUTINC3 ORDER: Bsbw ere proferred routlr�s for the Hve rtwat frpwnt t�rpes of documsMs: CONTRAGTS (assumes sutho�ized COUNqI RESOLUTION (Am�nd� Bdgts./ budgst sxists) Accept. Orsnta) 1. Outtids A�cy 1. D�artmsrtt Director 2. Initlatinp DspertmsM 2. Budwt Director 3. (�ty Attom�r 3. dy Attomey 4. MByor 4. MayodAe�stant ' 5. Flnarx:s dc Mgmt 3vca. �r�ctor 5. qty Council 8. Finance M;couMirg 8. Chief /►ccountant. Fin 8 Mgmt Svca. ADMINISTRATIVE �tDER (Bud�et COUNCIL RESOLUTION (ali othera) Revision) end ORDINANCE 1. Activtty Manager 1. Ini�aNng Deputmsnt drecMr 2. DepsrtmeM AccouMaM 2 • �Y Ana�Y 3. M /A�s�nt 4. Bud�r�CtDi a� 4. Gt�CoUndl . 5. CFty Clsrlt 6. Chisf Axountant� Fin � M�mt Svcs. ADMINISTHATNE ORDERS (s�N others) 1. InRf�Mg Dspertmsnt � 2. Gty /lttorney 3. MayoNAsNaant ` 4. City Clerk €+ TOTAL NUMBER OF SKiNATURE PAOES �` I�e tt� # of pepss on which siy�aituros aro required and papsrc�ip '; eech ofthse� pegss. ACTION REQUE8�ED �' Dsscxies whad ths proj�at/rpus� sNka to axomplf�h M eitMr chronolopi- ;� cel ordsr or ordsr � Importance, wFdchs�rer fs rrwst �proprfete for the iaus. Do not wrtte oompl�b semsncoa. Begin each item in your Ibt with a verb. REOOMMENDATIONS Complete if Hw iaw in qusstior► has bsen pcessMsd bsFore anY �Y� Iw�� or p�ivate. 3UPPORTS WHI(Xi COUNqL 08JECTIVE? . Indkxte which Councfl obl��N�) I� P��'e4� BUPP�s bY ��►9 ths key word(s) (HOU8ING, REf:REATION, NEIOHBORHOODB, EOONOMtC DEVELOPMENT, � BUDl3ET, SEWER SEPARATION). (3EE OOMPLETE LIST IN IN8TRUCTIONAL MANUAL.) COUNCII C�MMITTEE/RESEARqi REPORT - OPTIONAL A3 RECIUE8TED BY COUNGL � , i INITIATINO PROBLEM. IS3UE. OPPORTUNITY � - Explain the situeGon or oonditlons thet cre�t�d a ne�d for your project or requsst. " i ADVANTADES IF APPROVED Ir�cate wh�ther thb Is simply an annwl budpst procedure roquirod by lawl cheRsr or whsthsr there an spaciflc in wh�h the City of Sairtt Paul end ks citizens will benefk from Mis pr�o�laction. DISADVANTA(iES IF /1PPROVED What nepstive eifecta or myor chenpss to �xisung or paat processes mlght this Prol�ct/requs� Produos H it is p�ss�d (e.g., traNic delays, noise. ten inc� ar esaea�)? To MVhom? Wfan4 For how bnp? DI3ADVANTAC9ES IF NOT APPROVED Wh�t will be the negativs coneequer�ces if ths promiaed adion is not epProved? InabiNty to dsli�rer ssnios4 ConUnued high t�aiHc, noise, aocident ►ate? Loss of rownus?' FlNANqAL IMPACT Althargh you muat tailor the informatfon you provide hsre to the issue you an addreesiny, fn pen�l you must ans� two qu�tiona: H�r much is it �oiinp to coN? Who ia yoing to pay? � _ . a�4 �r�co � . OFFICE OF LICENSE, INSPECTIONS AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION Robert Kessler, Director CITY OF SAINT PAUL ENYIRONMENTAL HEALTH Te[ephone: 612-266-9130 Norm Coleman, Mayor SERYICES Facsimile: 612-266-9124 350 St Peter Street, Suite 330 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102-1510 `''�`'''„ DATE: September 28, 19 4 TO: Nancy Anderson I Council Investiga on & Research FROM: Peter T. Kishe �. LIEP - Enviro rital Health SUBJECT: Public Hearing N ise Variance Wednesday, Octo er 5, 1994 Attached is the background inf ation for the public hearing scheduled for October 5, 1994 for the Public orks project known as the Davern Outlet "B" Combined Sewer Separation Project, loca d at Stewart Street immediately west of Alton Street, from October 10, 1994 through July 1, 1995 . PTK/pb �� rw� Application fo Sound Level Variance � City of St. Paul Noise Ordinance Chapter 293 the St Paul Legislative Code � 1 1. Organization or person seeking variance: �� r a f.S� � ��, /, � �U 7 2. Address: � � .� w f� /1'IiU _� 2 3. Resposible person: .�. 4. Title or position: �vb/, � L(�c ��d,, c, �, � 5. Telephone: o`�Co , - O .3 6. Briefly describe the noise source and equi ent involved � -� !a�-��ro d!n�'�rinca �,z�„ . � uc.�'� s� � !�� r � +L� Z ' .l a�s7l �✓ l h G •• � ' ce . 7. Address or legal description of noise sourc :�� S�Lv� S> , n,,� a��Q�,� �� ,-L' A/ S � 8. Noise source time of operadon: � .— �Q. O qy J�ll / � 9. Briefly describe the steps that will be take to minimize the noise levels: �110,5� �i��z� ,�c�� ho�r, � � � � i G U ! -P.t74l.C� C U CC , t �✓, GE 10. Briefly state reason for seeldng variance: . S'�,,,-� ,�,�, ,Q '� � � crz�� ►� u�av K' c.� E�».�?� f�� /�y 11. Dates during which the variance is request d: (}� / D, /� y�/ .,4, .�'� /� /Q qS Signature of responsibie person Date 9 �9 l� Return completed Application and $15 .00 fee to Office Use Only Date Rec'd. CITY OF SAINT PAUL Reviewed ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH Date Public Notice Sent 350 ST. PETER STREET, #33 Referred to Counci! SAINT PAUL, MN 55102-151 266-9130 �' � t ° �--I��oS � � 5Tr �� 5 • " O �4' END DE-AERATION , CHAI+BER � I �' �� 5 i I� � � . � , � , , � , , �. o I � I �� 30' 1R � ( � � �I � � i � , DE-AERATION I � + • CHA►BER 5 I • � I t �, ' - - I � p � � � u , �I 1�� ' ' DROPSHAF.T (5?RUCTURE 2) `� —�•' � i �TA.22+22.50. 3.00'RT � �: - — �- � : z I � W I TRANSIT1pN STRUCTUR ' ' < ' I ISTRUCTURE i) � I ; � � � APPROACH CHANNEL STA. 22+93.00. 2.25'RT I � t STRUCTURE N0.1 � ; � ! 3 I . � � ��- I j � � 9• Y T R N 'PI 2.25'RT i� � �� PI STA.22+93.00. 6.T5'LT �N1�0.149.013 � � t � r N7�0.75t.580 N,qNHOL ' E556.692.�8� 1T \ . 17A E556.680.01H -- ' _ , I STA.10»-�: -- �� i i N140.191. i -- -- i I. ) -- -- -- E556.677. : ' I / , � i � � 17 4 . � - i � y 6• J 29• ►IITERED BEND (� � A T N TR T — _ _ ��, , �� 19 L 0 S EE PI STA.23+16.00. 70 R 1� .15 . �i - pAYS-T E556.T08.139 ;� 6 6• �— END 66' RCP STUBOUT � 8-52 �,� STA.10 10'RT 20 � ' � y � -91:�i � � � 8 T BLR �.-� -- -- -- __ � � � 1 2 - �; I �� ( i '- -- -- ;� O � • M T R N 1MSH-25 �•�I ; �' PI A�TON ST. STA.10+65. N110.219.255 ALTON ST. STA.10+0 00� '>' � E556.6T6.073 �'� � T ' � N140.159.590 ':� i ( � i; � . E556.703.380 I �, � � i � I� � I� i� I` ± � ' MANHOLE 20 ��! � ��a�i i� i STk•23+40.00. 10'RT �p � END 60' RCP STUBOUT I �:I i j�Io;� I � 1 i• STA.23+52.00. 10'RT �� , 1 ��!� � �, sc�E ALTON ST./STEWART ST INTERSECTION SEWER PLAN DAVERN OUTLET PHASE B '- �� t T TIFT THpT TWS PLAN YAS PFiEPARfD 87 - PMB P£ OR VaER MT DIRECT �YERVISIW MD T1MT I AM 9 4-5— __ er�n ts of noi a� � cu�r nmsTV+�a rs�essta� acn+m+ uoFx 8085B aucna� a+nvnc DaD nf urs oF r►E sTA� oF ►un+ESOra sc�a on, - - e p� � �Q�+�'+'� � tt on.c. no slss - - ff NoT oE D+cyi ut � Pw8 ras s�r, �n.nsT ,,�,p r+a oare er nevcst su�s �i�r PMe onre � 8-ll - 94 �, �, 2779 q�-�4�� '� OFFICE OF LICENSE, INSPECI70NS AND ENVIROtv'MENTAL PROTEC770N Robert Kessler, Direclor CIT'Y OF SAINT PAUL E,4'17RDA'MFJ�TAL HF.lLTH Telephone: 612-266-9130 A'orm Coleman, Mayor SERI7CFS Focsimile: 612-266-9124 350 St Pe�er S�reet, $uhe 330 Saint Paul, A�innesora 53102-ISIO �. September 15, 1994 N TICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Dear St. Paul Property Ow r: This is to inform yon of application to request a variance from the sound level limitations as indicated in e St. Paul Noise Ordinance (Chapter 293 of the St. Paul Legislative Code). A public hearing before the ity Council on this variance request will be held on: Date: Wedn sday, October 5, 1994 Time 3:30 m. Location: 3rd FI or, City Hall Council Chambers VYithin fifteen 15 da �s the mailin date on this notice v�Titten comments or ob'ections ma be filed v�� h the: City of St. Paul Office of License, I pections and Environmental Protection Environmental Heal 350 St. Peter Street, uite 330 Saint Paul, Minneso 55102 Description of Varia�;e: Location: On St wart Street immediately West of Alton Street Noise Source: Const ction of a storm sewer shaft/tunnel in preparation for sewer projec construction. Noise sources are expected to be from .. suppo equipment needed for underground work on storm sewer tunnel and drop shafts. Equipment such as a crane for raising and lower g men, equipment and materials, a generator, ventilation units, and air compressor for power and ventilation for under round work. � �� ' Page 2 Sound Level Variance Notice ' � Most hi I h noise level work will be performed during daytime hours. uipment that may operate for extended periods of time will be e closed if possible and/or be equipped with available noise abateme t devices. The vari nce is being requested from October 10, 1994 to July 1, 1995. uring this period work can be expected to often occur 24 hours pe day, including weekends. However, there may be days when w rk will not occur 24 hours per day. This will be depende t on the contractor and meeting the construction deadline. This wo k must be completed on or before the date indicated so that the 995 sewer projects can begin and be completed in a timely � manner. If you have any questions, pl se feel free to call me at 266-9133. Your ly, .e!��• Peter T. Kishel Safety and Health Analyst PTK/ko .. � i -�` � l � I � ---� ��'' :��. f � `� 1 C__ /�� ! C�ncil File # "1'�1 � R 1 � I � � � � � ` � \ � ` , --:� Green Sheet # � - �j ESOLUTI� , \ � CIT OF S I P UL, MINNES TA �•JnQ � �/� Presented By ��7!" f Referred To Committee: Date WHEREAS, the City of Saint Paul has e acted Chapter 293 of its Legislative Code pertaining to the regulation of noise and WHEREAS, said Chapter permits the gra ting of an exemption or variance from such regulation upon a determination of un easonable hardship upon the community or applicant; � � � and WHEREAS, the Department of Public Wor s has applied for a variance from sound level restrictions from October 10, 1994 th ough �x 1995 for a public work referred to as Davern Outlet "B" Combined Sewer Se a ation Pro'ect, located at Stewart Street immediatelv west of Alton Street; , and �� WHEREAS, the City Council conducted � public hearingSon said matter on October 5 1994, now, therefore be it � RESOLVED, that th City Council hereb grants to the Department of Public Works and its agent or contrac or a variance from t e requirements of Chapter 293 from October 10, 1994 through 1 1995 with the fo lowing conditions: � 1) Variance shall be granted rom 6:00 �p.m. to iQ1:00 p.m. 2) Any source of noise operat ng between 1�:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. shall not exceed a L10 noise level 0 65 dBA measured at a point of human activity which is nearest the noise source and which is in a noise receptor Class II as described in Sec. 293.0 , Noise Source Limitations. 3) Most higher noise level wo k will be performed during daylight hours. 4) Ventilation equipment, gen rators, compressors and other similar equipment will be enclosed if possib e and/or provided with the best available noise abatement devices. 5) Surface work shall be limi ed to the hours of 6:00 �.m. to 1�:00 p.m. whenever possible. and be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Director o the Department of Public Works shall furnish a copy of the resolution to any contrac or performing in said project and shall assist in the variance enforcement. Requested by Department of: Yeas Navs Abse t a e Office of License, Inspections and rimm uerin Environmental Protection Harri s e ar ettman / une By: Adopted by Council: Date Form Approved by City Attorney Adoption Certified by Council Secretar � � BY� �� 'Z� �y , - -� pproved by Mayor: Date Approved by Mayor for Su mission to Council � � � % /. � � �� BY : � � " ' 1 , � � ; � � � i,. (, [.-�'' g , / � � ,,��if ,;", 1.,� �i- � Y= � q�k — ( �4co S JEPARTM[NT/OFFICE/CAUNCII DATE INITIATED '•. i LIEP 9/26/94 GREEN SHEET No. 00.83 -��; INITIAU DATE INITIAUD�1`T'E T ' CONTACT PERSON 6 PHONE � DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR � CITY COUNCIL Peter Kishel 266-9133 N M FOR 0 CITY ATTORNEY � CITY CLERK I MUST BE ON COUNCIL AGENDA BY (DATE) ROUTINO � BUDCiET DIRECTOR � FIN. & MOT. SERVICES OIR. Oc tober 5, 1994 ORDER � MAYOR (OFi ASSISTANn � TOTAL M OF SIGNATURE PAGES � (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACTION REOUESTED: Council Resolution ratifying a variance to Chapter 293. (St. Paul Noise Ordinance) requested by St. Paul Public Works Department. , RECOMMENDATIONS: Approve (A) w Heject (R) COUNCIL COMMITTEE/RESEARCH REPORT OPTIONAL ANALYST PHONE NO. _ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVIC� COMMISSION _ CIB COMMITTEE _ COMMENTS: _ STAFF - ' _ DISTRICT COURT _ SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL O&IECTIVE9 fNI71ATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITY (Who, What, When, Where, Why): This variance�will allow sound levels in excess of those in Chapter 293 (St. Paul Noise Ordinance), for a Public Works project referred to as the Davern Outlet "B" Combined Sewer Separation Project, located at Stewart Street immediately west of Alton Street. The variance with conditions is only for Construction work in said project from October 10, 1994 through � 1, 1995. Noise source will be support equipment for underground work. �a� Resolution includes recommended variance conditions from LIEP Environmental Health. AOVANTA�ES IF APPROVED: Granting of the variance will allow the contractor performing in said project to work 24 hours per day. Majority of work will be done underground in tunnels. This will allow for completion of the project so that other sewer projects that are planned for the summer of 1995 can be completed. DISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED: _ Residents living near the project will be exposed to daytime and nighttime noise that is greater than current background noise levels. DISADVANTAOES IF NOT APPROVED: Violations of Chapter 293 (St. Paul Noise Ordinance) would likely occur if variance is not granted. If underground work is not allowed to occur 24 hours per day, the project could not be completed by the date indicated. This would result in delays in the start of other Sewer Projects scheduled to begin in the sur.uner of 1995. TOTAI AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION S N�A COST/REVENUE BUDCiETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDING SOURCE N � A ACTIVITY NUMBER FINANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLA�N)