The URL can be used to link to this page

94-1463 -`� ��;�, t 1 `. ��\)� � �_� -._ `l"_' �: . ( ��'.( qy ' �� '\ ( Council File # 0 R I G I N A L Green Sheet # �� RESOLUTION � CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNE OTA Presented By �� SS« '/ Referred To Committee: Date WHEREAS, the City of Saint Paul ha enacted Chapter 293 of its Legislative Code pertaining to the regulation of no se; and WHEREAS, said Chapter permits the ranting of an exemption or variance from such regulation upon a determination of unreasonable hardship upon the community or appl icant ; �� and WHEREAS, the Department of Public orks has a lied for a variance from sound level restrictions from October 10, 1994 through 1 1995 for a public work referred to as Davern Outlet "B" Combined Sewer S aration Pro'ect, located at Stewart Street from Davern to Mavnard Drive; and ..Y�-,� ��.�� WHEREAS, the City Council conducte �public hearin�on said matter on October 5/ 1994, now, therefore be it � �� RESOLVED, that the City Co cil he grants to the Department of Public Works and its agent or contrac r a variance fro the requirements of Chapter 293 from October 10, � 1994 through 1 1995 with the following conditions: �_ _� �,�;,, 1) Variance shall be grant d from 6:00 �� to� �--9�A–p:m-. 2) Any source of noise ope ating between ��II=�zii and 6:00 a.m. shall not exceed a L10 noise leve of 65 dBA meas7.�red at a point of human activity which is nearest the no se source and whicYi is in a noise receptor Class II as described in Sec. 29 .09, Noise Source Limitations. 3) Most higher noise level work will be performed during daylight hours. 4) Ventilation equipment, enerators, compressors and other similar equipment will be enclosed if pos ible and/or provided with the best available noise abatement devices . �_� . �,;, r :: t �� 5) Surface work shall be 1 mited to the hours of 6:00 �-�, to �3•3�-:-�@- p.m. whenever possible. and be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Directo of the Department of Public Works shall furnish a copy of the resolution to any cont actor performing in said project and shall assist in the variance enforcement. Requested by Department of: Y� Navs sent a ev Office of License, Inspections and — (�'rimm � . uerin a „ " Environmental Protection Harri s - � �t tman � ' une �� , By: Adopted by Council : Date (� r - - � �<< ` Form Approved by City Attorney Adoption Certified by Council Secre ary By: \ c�. � �->�. ,` \ . B �'` c �� Approved by a� . Date � Approv b Mayor for bmission to Counc' By: �f By: , � 6r�' �� q�-�� DEPARTM[NT/OFFI(�/COUNqL E INITIATED � LIEp 9i26i94 GREEN SHEET No. s� 8� � CONTACT PERSON R PNONE 1NITIAU DATE I TE � DEPARTMENT DIREC � CITY COUNCIL I Peter Kishel 266-9133 �� c�rr �rroANer � prn c�ruc MUST BE ON COUNGL AGENOA BY (DAT� � BUDOET DIRECTOR � flN. 3 MOT. SERVICEB DIR. October 5, 1994 � MAV�i (OR ASSISTANTI � TOTAL #► OF SK#NATUi� PAQE8 � ( IP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SKiNATUR� ACTION REOUESTED: � Council Resolution ratifying a var ance to Chapter 293. (St. Paul Noise Ordinance) requested by St. Paul Public Works Department. ' I�oo�ENDaTi0N8: �vw�+ W o► �(pl REPORT _ PIANPNNO COA�IMISSION _ CML 8ERV1� COAAMIBSION Y8T PFI�E NO. _ CIB OOAiMYN1TEE _ _ 8TAFF _ ENT8: _ DIB1'RICT' OOURT SUPPORTS YVMICN COUNdL OBJECTIVE9 II�NTIMINO PROBLEM. 188UE. OPPORTUNRY (Who� Wh�t� Whsn.,WMn. This variance will allow sound lev ls in excess of those in Chapter 293 (St. Paul � Noise Ordinance), for a Public Wor s pro�ect referred to as the Davern Outlet "B" i ` Combined Sewer Separation Pro�ect, located at Stewart Street from Davern to i 1 � ', Maynard Drive. The variance with onditions is only for construction work in � said project from October 10, 1994 through 3� 1, 1995. Noise source will be ; support equipment for underground ork. /�tC.� ' Resolution includes recommended v iance conditions from LIEP Environmental Health. � ADVANTAQEB IF APPR�IED: � ; Granting of the variance will allo the contractor performing in said pro�ect to work � '� ' �, 24 hours per day. Ma3ority of wor will be done underground in tunnels. This will � allow for completion of the pro�ec so that other sewer pro�ects that are planned ; for the summer of 1995 can be com eted. � � ; � DISADYMITAOE8IF APPROVED: Residents living near the project ill be exposed to aayt�e ana nighttime noise ' that is greater than current back ound noise levels. - � i ; , j , � as�ov,wr�s iF Nar �c: � � � Violations of Chapter 293 (St. Pa 1 Noise Ordinance) would likely occur if yariance � is not granted. If underground w k is not allowed to occur 24 hours per day, the � pro�ect could not be completed by the date indicated. This would result in delays � in the start of other Sewer Proje ts scheduled to begin in the summer of 1995. � � ; � ' TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRAN�ACTION i N/A COST�vENUE euDOErED (C��x.E ON� rES � i � �NO sout� N/A �criv�rr NuMS�n { FlNANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN� i . � i , :`. .... NOTE: C�APLETE DIRECTIONS AF� INCLUDED IN THE OREEN SHEET INS'fRUCT10NAL MANUAL AVAILABLE IN THE PUACHASIN�i OFFICE (PFIONE NO.'�2�. � ROUTIHKi ORDEH: � <€ Below are prsferred routings for ths fiw rrwst f►equent typss of docwr�nb: CONTRACTS (wsum�s auttwrized COUNCIL RESOLUTION (Amsnd. Bdpts./ budgst sxistsj nccept. Oranta) t. Outside ApenCy 1. Dsputmsnt DireCtor �� 2. Initiatinp Departmsnt 2. BudpM arector �� 3. ; � 4. May�or�� 4. MayONA8sIstaM �� 5. Ffnance fl Mgmt 3vca. Dirsc�or 5. City Coundl 8. Flnencs AacourrUng 8. Ghief Acoour�taM. Fln d� INpmt Svcs. Yt ` � AQMINI3TRATIVE ORDER � OOUNCIL RE30LUTION (� �a�� J! � 1. Activiry Mana�pr 2. In�'�u' A� rtment Director 2. DepsrtmsM Ac�ouMaM 3, p�� p��p 3. May�oNAtNstant 4. Budpst DireCtor 4. qty COUnCU 5. City Clerk � 8. Chisf AccouMant. Fln 3 M�mt S�res. :� ADMINISTRATIYE ORDERS (dl otNsrs) ;� 1. Initiatinp Depertrr�t 2. Cfty Attorrrey ;� � 3. MayoNAqistant � � 4• qty Clsrk ;� + TOTAL NUMBER OF SICiNKNRE PAOES .; ,. � t � � of pspss a� whk�t N�n�tures are requirod and a�srclip x� � �� x = ACTiON RE�UESTED �� cal o►der ordsr of i�tros, wt�Cl� +�s� �� i appr� for �� 1 �� issue. Do na write oanpist� tentenoss. Bspin e�ch item in your Ust with � � a,�. � RECOAAMENDATIONS ' � Coir�plete if ths iaue in quedion has be�n preesntsd bsfore any body. Pub�ic or privats. 3UPPORT3 WHICH COl1NqL OBJECTIVE? '�' Indk�te which Council obj�+re(e) Y'ai� Prol�ro4� � bY ��9 ths key w�ord(s) (HOU31Nti. RECREATION, NEKiHBORHO0D3. ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, '� BUD(3ET, SEWER SEPARATION). (8EE COMPLETE U3T IN INSTRUCTIONAL MANUAL.) �� COUNdL COUAMITTEElRESEARCH REPORT - OPTIONAL A3 REQUESTED BY COUN(;IL INITIATINO PROBLEM, 133UE, OPPORTUNITY '� Explafn the situatbn or c�rMidona tl�et creued a nead for Your project � « ��. � ADVANTAQES IF APPROVED Indk,ate Nrt�sther this is eimpy an annual bud�t procedure nquired by Iaw/ � chartsr or whMhsr tMro en sp�aflc ways in which tho City of 8afnt Pwl and Its citlzsns wiN bsneM from thie pro�Ctlaction. , `� DISADVANTAOES IF APPROVED What nspatNre ethcts or major chanp�s W existing or pwt procs�es mipht � M'ol�►equ�t produoe N k is passsd (�.g.� traffic dslaye� nofae� ` tex incnases or asmsmenb)? To Whom? When7 For how �ng? , A ' � : DISADVANTAOES IF NOT APPROVED � VYhat will bs tl» rre�atiw oorasqusnces H the promised action is not approvsd4 Inability to delivsr asrvic;e? ConUnued high trafflc, noiae, aocWsM rate? Lo� of rovenus? ' + � FINANqAL IMPACT �� Although you mwt t�lbr ths i�formation you provide here to the iaeus you � aro �ldreaing, in psnoral you muet answer two queetions: How much is ft � poinp to oost4 Who is �Oin9 to WY� � . q�.� -1��03 . OFFICE OF LICENSE, INSPECTIONS AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECI'ION Robert Kessler, Direcror CITY OF SAINT PAUL ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH Telephone: 612-266-9130 Norm Coleman, Mayor SERVICES Facsimile: 612-266-9124 350 St Peter Street, Suite 330 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102-I510 � DATE: September 28, 1994 TO: Nancy Anders I Council Investi ation & Research FROM: Peter T. Kishe LIEP - Enviro ntal Health SUBJECT: Public Hearing Noise Variance Wednesday, O ober 5, 1994 Attached is the background i ormation for the public hearing scheduled for October 5, 1994 for the Publi Works project known as the Davern Outlet "B" Combined Sewer Separation Project, loc ted at Stewart Street from Davern to Maynard Drive, from October 10, 1994 through Ju y 1, 1995 . PTK/pb • A� —t�.co3 Application or Sound Level Variance City o St. Paul Noise Ordinance �aP�� 3 of the St Paul Legislative Code 1• Organizarion orperson seeking varianc ; ` ,,�'SJ- � n �' v � c., W �`S' Kl�� 2. Address: ' � �� _ � � � � SS/o Z 3. Resposible person: �� 4. Title or posidon: , j�(� 5. Telephone: - �� . 6. Briefly describe the noise source and equ pment involved: � _ - h7/Sih�I /2� G(�Z4nc /�� / / �c0� •y, , , y .. � • ` !.[i!l�i1 G Gn0/�'i �� 7. Address or legal descripdon of noise sour e: � �-��Dr<<�. 8. Noise source time of operation: ' '� � 5 9. Briefly describe the steps that wiil be take to minimize the noise levels: o , / �f� a✓Lr��w � fj �rl� c ,` /Z1�S , I�.� �' . � �/ 1 C Y C � � � 10. Briefly state reason for seeldng variance: ' .�'Sv�r K�., ,� - / S -�' �. � -� ��f n,�<. � 11. Dates durino which the variar�ce is request : Q � - ID x�s.�,/ � / / 995 . Signature�oF responsible person �� - Date � y - Return completed Application and $150. 0 fee to Office Use Only - Date Rec'd. - CITY OF SAINT pqUL Reviewed ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH Date Public Notice Sent 350 ST. PETER STREET, #330 Referred to Council - SAINT PqUL, MN 55102-1510 266-9130 ;z �� Pt � a� --�� , , . 1 1 4. � p 736.254 y '� e • N139.070� 586 ST1NG SHAFT. ? E551.796. 5� �!E �O SANITARY �e 1N� � > i,'tit ��'� / � • P I A�2+8 � �� / 4� \ `` i N139.077. 71 ,�': � H � F C},�. -;�;`��''.;� Z¢4�� E55�.991. 50 . ; , , ,�,� ��` � 0/� 16i5H-23 : . _�� 1 • 1� STL' '��. E ISTING ►�w5H-21 � �' TO ' T BE ABANDONED N139.590.D78� o�' � 32' � N - E555.823.97� � CL '� r '5G.�� \`��\ STA �+76.00 EXiSTING SANITARY a � �, �� ',� ��, N739.146.531 SHAFT. NO? CONNECTION Z � � �'• E555.166.26T TO STORM �UNNEL: TO r , / ' , � -��` , `�� , \ - NEM �2' DIA SHAFT REMAIH ASI I5. -- � i r_ � I `\ `' �� i � � " -�r i �TO�BEING TUNr1E� �� - - - - - `�— �__ -�} - - i P' �ABANDONED I � �- OR 1 G I NAl TUNNEI 53 I ' XISTING T NE _�i I � ALIGNA�NT STA 0+�7.18 0 BE ABAN NE i Nt39.028.019 SEE SHEETS 8A7 �� E554.T36.306 P A �S S A EXISTING DAYERN STA 0*13.5T STA 70+00.00 H TREET TUNNEL N139.038.922 ��TFpNITF LD[�TtoN N179.131.751 E55� „ E55�.751.661 ' NEM ►HSH-21A E555.603.900 NEM � STA �+i1.p0 EX15T1HG SHAFT. SHAI N139.1t0.7T5 LINE TO STC! PI �►1 \ � �E555.111.998 STORM TUNNEL � N139.028.019 � �\ NEM �2' DIA SHAFT EL E55�.736.306 EXISTING DAVERN STATION EOUATION: TREET TUNNEL �+76.00 ALT. ALIGNMENT L ALT NATE TUNNEL AL1CN►rENT: FOR ��+76.00 OR1GiNAL ALIGNh�NT S TE Wt USE ITH JACKED RCP TUNNEL ONLY � ►H 5 � T. C � � � ��T C� 06. 0 1HSH-22 � � � � T.C.�10�.0 r ( � ' / , r— �t � I + � � 100 ZI'' �J. = �! �B� PRECAST MANHOL� , xa; INCLUDED iN BID PRIICE °�; I ELEV 98.0 SEE DETA � � u � �, WC' ' 8 �o� � EXISTING SHAFT t TO REMAIN AS IS I o rp� ~� 4 �+ 7 �� i OI N O � ►' N Y 6 � WI - � EX]STiNG 'X 2.5' NOWINAL � o� STORM SEM�R TUNNEL � NOTE: ROFILE SHOM'N 5 ASEO � ON ORI 1NAL ALIGNMEN � PROPOSED .5' OIA � NEM SHA T —� I I SEMER�TUNNEL 4 O � � T3.52' 7.5' OIA EOUIV. TUNNEL � I e . � � I j � _ 3 O — — --- % 1A 52��•5' DIA � EOU1V• TUNNQ. e 0.415X i I� I EOUIV• TUNN Q p,q15X 1 e O.��SX iNV EL 28.80 �� \ � i 2 � 'i INV EL 25.0] I ` iNV EL 26.6} h ' INV EL 23.3a- � \ i INV EL �.29 � , � � DAVERN OUTLET PHASE 8 =_ �� S �+ PMB I rEnEeY CEn TN4T TMS PLAH YAS PfiEPARF� 87 era ts o� no+ a ne oa uoEn Mr mr�sT arEnvssroi «o nwT i a, � A OtLT IE625TE7im �ESSIONAL ENGDFFJi UaEJi 94-5-6085B - - owcn+r� orw�rn+c o�D F , a 1 , n� u� �� sara � HoT oE ao+ a+ � Pw8 'urEA on. w. » oR.c. �a s�ss -- nas s�r.n�.rusT r�vw ' ►+a a+� er ion scr�es �n+ar awB p os -rl - a�e. w. 2779 � OFFICE OF LICENSE, INSPECTIONS AND � V t '`� �. . ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ' Robert Kessler, Direclor CITY OF SAINT PAUL ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH Telephone: 612-266-9130 Norm Coleman, Mayor SERVICES Facsimile: 612-266-9124 350 S� Peter Street, Suite 330 Sain� Paul, Minnesow 55102-IS/0 �r September 20, 1994 OTICE OF PUBLIC IiEARING Dear St. Paul Property O er: This is to inform you of n application to request a variance from the sound level limitations as indicated in e St. Paul Noise Ordinance (Chapter 293 of the St. Paul Legislative Code). A public hearing before th City Council on this variance request will be held on: Date: Wed sday, October 5, 1994 Time 3:30 .m. Location: 3rd F oor, City Hall Council Chambers Within fifteen 15 da s f the mailin date on this notice written comments or ob'ections ma be filed h the: City of St. Paul Office of License, I pections and Environmental Protection Environmental Heal 350 St. Peter Street, Suite 330 Saint Paul, Minneso 55102 Description of Variance: Location: On St wart Street from Davern to Maynard Drive Noise Source: Const ction of a storm sewer shaft/tunnel in preparation for sewer projec construction. Noise sources are ex�ected to be from , suppo equipment needed for underground work on storm sewer tunnel and drop shafts. Equipment such as a crane for raising and lower' g men, equipment and materials, a generator, ventilation units, and air compressor for power and ventilation for under round work. • � --l�co3 - � ' Page 2 ' Sound Level Variance Noti e � Most igh noise level work will be performed during daytime hours. Equipment that may operate for extended periods of time will b enclosed if possible and/or be equipped with available noise abate ent devices. The v riance is being requested from October 10, 1994 to July 1, 1995. During this period work can be expected to often occur 24 hours er day, including weekends. However, there may be days when work will not occur 24 hours per day. This will be depen ent on the contractor and meeting the construction deadline. This ork must be completed on or before the date indicated so that th 1995 sewer projects can begin and be completed in a timely mann . If you have any questions, lease feel free to call me at 266-9133. You ruly, .ei��0• Peter T. Kishel Safety and Health Analyst PTK/ko ,, ,, � ; �,, ; -,J q � - � � (�3 � , � � j � % �..� � L ` 4Council File # _ R n+ a � ` � ' / �_-� � . T � �'-- O I\ I� I 1 V! � ��'�, 1 �, ' `.'�� _ V� ' Gr en Sheet # 0� �- NJ , , , ' ' RESOLU�ION �� c ' '� . _ _..__ . � CI'�l( OF INT PAUL, MIN�IE �A --- � � , , � Presented By �� SS�" "� Referred To Committee: Date WHEREAS, the City of Saint Paul has nacted Chapter 293 of its Legislati�re Code pertaining to the regulation of nois ; and WHEREAS, said Chapter permits the gr nting of an exemption or variance from such regulation upon a determination of u reasonable hardship upon the community or applicant; il and �� (� U WHEREAS, the Department of Public Wo ks has a lied for a variance from sound level restrictions from October 10, 1994 t rough 1 1995 for a public work referred to as Davern Outlet "B" Combined Sewer Se ration Pro'ect, located at Stewart Street from Davern to Mavnard Drive; and � � � WHEREAS, the City Council conducted public'hearing5 on said matter on October 5, 1994, now, therefore be it �/J Q . / `'I � RESOLVED, that the City Co�rfcil her y grants to the Department of Public Works and its agent or contrac r a variance from he requirements of Chapter 293 from October 10, 1954 through 1 1995 with the llowing c�ditions: � 1) Variance shall be grante from 6:00 .m. to 1d:00 p.m. 2) Any source of noise oper ing betwe n 13�:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. shall not exceed a L10 noise level f 65 dBA measured at a point of human activity which is nearest the noi source and whicti is in a noise receptor Class II as described in Sec. 293. 9, Noise Source Limitations. 3) Most higher noise level rk will be performed during daylight hours. 4) Ventilation equipment, g erators, compressors and other similar equipment will be enclosed if poss' le and/or provided with the best available noise abatement devices. 5) Surface work shall be li ited to the hours of 6:OO�.m. to 1�:00 p.m. whenever possible. and be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Director f the Department of Public Works shall furnish a copy of the resolution to any contr tor performing in said project and shall assist in the variance enforcement. Requested by Department of: Yeas Nays Ab ent B a e Office of License, Inspections and rimm Guerin Environmental Protection Harris MecTar Rettman T une By: Adopted by Council: Date Adoption Certified by Council Secret ry Form Approved by City Attorney By: ,� ` — "L� � . pproved by Mayor: Date Approved by �Mayor for ubmission to Council ; � �� 7 " By. ��;. �� i � �2��.- � . gy � � q�—t�c�3 DEPA — DATE 9� T 26�94 GREEN SHEET NO. `�+T -�¢ " INITIAU DATE O O INITIAUDATE � - CONTACT PERSON 3 PHONE � DEPARTMENT DIfiECTOR � CITY COUNCIL Peter Kishel 266-9133 ��aN CITV ATTORNEY CITY CLERK NUMBER FOFi � � MUST BE ON CAUNCII AGENDA BY (DATE) ROUTINO � BUOOET DIRECTOR � FIN. S MOT. SERVICES DIR. October 5� 1994 OROER � MAYOH (OR ASSISTANn � TOTAL � OF SIGNATURE PAGES � (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) � ACTION FiEOUESTED: Council Resolution ratifying a variance to Chapter 293. (St. Paul Noise Ordinance) requested by St. Paul Public Works Department. RECOMMENDATIONS: Approve (A) or Reject (R) COUNCIL COMMITTEE/RESEAFiCH REPORT OPTIONAL _ PLANNING COMMISSION _ CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION �A�YST PHONE NO. _ CIB COMMITTEE _ COMMENTS: _ STAFF _ _ DISTfiICT COURT — SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? INITIATINO PH08LEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITY (Who, What, When, Where, Why): This variance will allow sound levels in excess of those in Chapter 293 (St. Paul Noise Ordinance), for a Public Works project referred to as the Davern Outlet "B" Combined Sewer Separation Project, located at Stewart Street from Davern to Maynard Drive. The variance with conditions is only for construction work in said project from October 10, 1994 through .� 1, 1995. Noise source will be support equipment for underground work. /j' �J Resolution includes recommended variance conditions from LIEP Environmental Health. ADVANTAGES IF APPROVED: Granting of the variance will allow the contractor performing in said project to work 24 hours per day. Majority of work will be done underground in tunnels. This will allow for completion of the project so that other sewer projects that are planned for the summer of 1995 can be completed. DISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED: Residents living near the project will be exposed to daytime and nighttime noise that is greater than current background noise levels. DISADVANTA(3ES IF NOT APPROVED: Violations of Chapter 293 (St. Paul Noise Ordinance) would likely occur if variance is not granted. If underground work is not allowed to occur 24 hours per day, the project could not be completed by the date indicated. This would result in delays in the start of other Sewer Projects scheduled to begin in the summer of 1995. TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION s N/A COST/REVENUE BUDCiETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDING SOURCE N � A ACTIVITY NUMBER FINANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN)