Loading...
94-1233 Council File # f 7 Jc3 ORIGINAL Green Sheet # a� RESOLUTION CITY OF • AINT PAUL, MINNESOTA ? L 7 Presented By O.., ' z , Referred To Committee: Date 1 2 Whereas, Julie Magle , 1317 4th Street East, saint Paul, 3 Minnesota, made application to the Board of Zoning Appeals for a 4 variance from the strict a = pplication of the provisions of the 5 Saint Paul Zoning Code fo property located at 1317 4th Street 6 East, legally described a�- w 1/2 of Lot 18 and all of Lot 17, 7 Block 5, Chas. A. B. Weid-'s subdivision No. 5; and 8 9 Whereas, The purpose,of the application was to vary the 10 standards of the Zoning C.de so as to conduct a home occupation 11 from a detached garage dui to a physical condition; and 12 13 Whereas, The Board o Zoning Appeals conducted a public 14 hearing on June 6, 1994, after having provided notice to affected 15 property owners, and the :oard, by its Resolution 94 -099, adopted 16 June 20, 1994, decided toldeny the application based on the 17 following findings and co clusions: 18 19 1. Section 60.'08(H) of the Zoning Code defines 20 home occupa as "an occupation carried on 21 in a unit b' the resident thereof providing 22 that the us is limited in extent and 23 incidental •nd secondary to the use of the 24 dwelling un t for residential purposes and 25 does not chnge the character thereof." The 26 Maglers hav- a mailing service business that 27 is typicall carried on in the basement of the 28 house and o'casionally in the garage also 29 when, the M.glers say, they want to be able to 30 supervise t eir children while they work. The 31 business as in the basement of the 32 house quali ies as a home occupation. 33 34 2. Section 60. 12(7) of the Zoning Code identifies the 35 several req��irements for home occupations, 36 including ( ) which states that "a home occupation 37 shall be ca on wholly within the main 38 building. o home occupation shall be allowed in 39 detached ac essory buildings or garages." However, 40 this provis on can be waived for handicapped 41 persons. Sction 60.412(7) of the Zoning Code 42 states that! "home occupations for handicapped 43 persons tha do not meet these conditions may be 44 reviewed byithe Board of Zoning Appeals which may 45 modify or wive the requirements a through g." 46 47 3. The only ev dence the applicants submitted to 48 document th•ir physical handicaps were brief forms 49 from a chir.practor saying they should not lift or 50 carry heavy boxes, especially going up stairs. The C OIGINAL forms do no say their back problems are permanen 1233 t disabilitie No further medical documentation was 3 submitted. According to the Maglers, most of the 4 lifting andlcarrying is done for them by their 5 children. either Mr. nor Mrs. Magler's handicap 6 is so serio s that driving a car or getting on a 7 bus is diff for them. Working at home appears 8 to be based Ion financial considerations more than 9 on physical ones. The provision for waiving home 10 occupation , ules for handicapped persons was 11 intended to 'provide an alternative for persons with 12 more seriou handicaps than the Maglers' handicaps, 13 particularl' Mrs. Maglers. 14 15 4. As an addit onal reason for requesting permission 16 to conduct .usiness in the garage, the applicant 17 stated thatltheir current use of the garage for 18 home occupa ion purposes is infrequent and related 19 to the need'for parental supervision of their 20 teenage chi dren. Although supervising teenagers 21 is a critic 1 responsibility of all parents, it is 22 not a legit mate basis for waiving zoning 23 standards. 24 25 Whereas, Pursuant to t e provisions of Section 64.205, Julie 26 Magler, duly filed with t City Clerk an appeal from the 27 determination made by thelBoard of Zoning Appeals, requesting 28 that a hearing be held be ore the City Council for the purpose of 29 considering the actions t by the said Board; and 30 31 Whereas, Acting pursua t to Sections 64.205 through 64.208, 32 and upon notice to affecthd parties a public hearing was duly 33 conducted by the City Cou cil on August 3, 1994, where all 34 interested parties were g ven an opportunity to be heard; and 35 36 Whereas, The Council, aving heard the statements made, and 37 having considered the var application, the report of staff, 38 the record, minutes and r-solution of the Board of Zoning 39 Appeals, does hereby 40 41 Resolve, That the Cou it of the City of Saint Paul does 42 hereby reverse the decisi.n of the Board of Zoning Appeals in 43 this matter and the modification allowing the use of the garage 44 for the home occupation i- granted subject however to the 45 condition that the modif' ation and permission hereby granted 46 shall continue only so 1• g as the property is owned and occupied 47 by the Julie Magler, bas = on the following findings of fact and 48 conclusions and based on he findings of the Council that the 49 Board of Zoning Appeals •'d commit errors in its findings and 50 conclusions; 51 52 1) The applic• t stated that the use of the 53 garage for home occupati•' purposes is infrequent and related to 54 the need for parental su•1-rvision of their teenage children when 55 they use the garage spac - for recreation activities. The 56 applicant stated that he husband left the employment of Chicago 57 Northwestern Railroad in 1991 on a medical retirement related to 58 a sciatic nerve problem 'n his back. He still has this problem 59 and has, at times, been .ompletely bedridden due to the 60 debilitating effects of .'his problem. The applicant has a 61 deteriorating disc in he• back that will occasionally cause great • qLJ -r233 . 1 1 pain and disrupt her work e and business. She noted that she and 2 her husband have had thes physical problems for the past decade. Q 3 They rely on their teenage children to perform the carrying and 4 lifting of boxes that is equired for her business. —5 co 6 2) The applicant's busines requires the periodic and daily 7 lifting and carrying of b. of envelopes, labels and mailers CC 8 both into their home and rom their home to their vehicles for O 9 transporting to the Post 1ffice. The applicant noted that they 10 rely heavily upon their tenage children to perform these lifting 11 and carrying tasks due to their back problems. It is clear that 12 their back problems subst ntially limit their lifting and 13 carrying abilities and ac ivities. The applicant stated that 14 they have medical records relating to their back problems and 15 would be willing to provi'e these records if needed to verify 16 these problems. 17 18 3) The applicant stated teat the sciatic nerve problem of her 19 husband is not expected t. improve much over time. In addition, 20 she noted that the disc p oblem in her back also will not improve 21 over time. She speculate. that if her disc problem gets any 22 worse she might have to h.ve spinal fusion surgery. It is clear 23 that the physical conditi.ns of both the applicant and her 24 husband are anticipated t. continue and are thus expected to 25 limit their carrying and ifting abilities into the foreseeable 26 future. 27 28 and be it 29 30 Further Resolved, That the appeal of Julie Magler be and is 31 hereby granted; and, be 1 32 33 Finally Resolved, That the City Clerk shall mail a copy of 34 this resolution to Julie agler, the Zoning Administrator, 35 Planning Commission and B''ard of Zoning Appeals. 1 Blakey Yeas Nava Requested by Department of: Harris � Timm I Gueriq Megard Rettman Thune Y i By: Adopted by Council: Dat= AUG4 r Form App ved by City Attorney Ado ti Certifi=> y _4,.. 1 Secret. ,y By r � f" , ' ,f , IF Y p B y' > Approved by Mayor ``for Submission to Approved Mayor: Date i , '' Council ' - f ( AA ' i ,;�✓ By By: L. - - L ( I I jy- /02 DEPARTMENT/OFFICE/COUNCIL DATE INITIATED No 2803 CITY COUNCIL 8J5/94 GREEN SHEET CONTACT PERSON t< PHONE D DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR IAL/EkITE D CITY COUNCIL — Councilmember Dino Guerin F O CITYATTORNEY O CITY CLERK MUST BE ON COUNCIL AGENDA BY (DATE) ROILING ED BUDGET DIRECTOR [ FIN. a MGT. SERVICES MR. ORIER 0 MAYOR (OR ASSISTANT) Ei TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CLIF ALL. LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) ACTION REQUESTED: 441^ Granting an appeal of Julie Hagler, 1317 E. Street, by reversing a decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals to permit_tte use of the garage as a home occupation. (Council Public Hearing held on Auglst 3, 1994). RECOMMENDATIONS: Approve (A) or Re)ect (R) PERSONAL SERVICE CONTRACTS MUST /ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS: _ PLANNING COMMISSION — CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION 1 Has this parson/firm ever worked under a contract for this department? YES NO CIS COMMITTEE 2 Has this person/firm ever been a city employee? .__ STAFF YES NO DISTRICT COURT 3 Does this person/firm possess a std I not normally possessed by any current city employee? SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? YES NO Bttplaln MI yes answers on separate sheet and ettsoh to green sheet INITIATING PROBLEM. ISSUE. OPPORTUNITY (Who. Whet' When. Where. Why ADVANTAGES IF APPROVED: DISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED: { DISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION • COST /REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES 140 FUNDING SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER FINANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN) fL_ /23.3 (SAINT !PAUL Interdepartmental Memorandum lAht CITY OF SAINT PA JL OFFICE OF CITY ATTORNEY Suite 400 City Hall fi �;�` Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Phone: (612)- 266 -6710 FAX: (612)- 298 - 5619 .~ DATE: August 15, 1994 TO: Nancy Anderson Secretary to the City Council 3rd Floor City fall , jv FROM: Jerome J. Segal w, Assistant City Attorney SUBJECT: Magler Appeal- 1317 E. Yt-i§- Street Council Hearing Held August 3, 1994 Nancy: The Council conducted a public hearing on the appeal of Julie Magler from a decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals, and the Council voted to grant the appeal and to reverse the decision of the BZA. The action of the Council would be to permit the use of the garage as a home occu5ation so long as the property was owned and occupied by Julie Magler. I have prepared the Council resolution which grants the appeal, and which resolution is attached to this memo. The Council's hearing has already be conducted, and the resolution may be adopted without conducting a second public hearing. Let me know if you have any question. /� 33 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING .947 & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SAINT CITY OF SAINT PAUL Division of Planning PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor 25 West Fourth Street Telephone: 612 - 266 -6565 Saint Paul, MN 55102 Facsimile: 612 - 228 -3314 AAAAI July 11, 1994 Ms. Nancy Anderson City Council Research Office Room 310, City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Ms. Anderson: I would like to confirm that a public earing before the City Council is scheduled for Wednesday, August 3, 1994 for the •flowing zoning case: Applicant: Julie M gler File Number: 94 -144 Purpose: Appeal he decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals denying a reques to waive the requirements of a home occupation and allow ahome occupation to be conducted in a detached garage due to physical condition. Location: 1317 E 4th Street; northside between Johnson Parkway & Claren .' - Street Previous action: Board u�f Zoning Appeals: 6 -6 -94, Denied, 5 -2 My understanding is that this public hearing request will appear on the agenda of the City Council at your earliest convenienc:l and that you will publish notice of the hearing in the Saint Paul Legal Ledger. Please call me at 266 -6583 if you h.l e any questions. Sincerel Michael J. Kraemer Council Research Center Zoning Section cc: File #94 -144 JUL 1 2 1994 _ /Ai, 0.33 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING - & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT d SAI L CITY OF SAINT PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor Division of Planning 4 25 West Fourth Street Telephone: 612-266-6565 Saint Paul, MN 55102 Facsimile: 612 -228 -3314 ,AAAA July 21, 1994 Ms. Nancy Anderson City Council Research Office Room 310, City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota, 55102 RE: Zoning File #94 -144 Jul' Magler City Council Hearing: A I :ust 3, 1994 PURPOSE: Appeal the Board of I roning Appeals decision denying a request to waive the requireme s of a home occupation and allow a home occupation to be c• ducted in a detached garage due to a physical condition. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Overtur the BZA decision and approve the requested waiver the the requirement that a home occupation must be carr "Ld on within the main building on the conditi• that the waiver be limited to so long as the applica't resides at this property. SUPPORT: Petition with 8 sig atures. OPPOSITION: None Dear Ms. Anderson: On June 6, 1994 the Board of Zo ing Appeals held a public hearing on the request of Julie Magler to waiv the requirements of a home occupation to permit a home occupation to be .onducted in a detached garage due to a physical condition. The appella was present at the meeting. At the close of the public hearing the Board of1Zoning Appeals voted 5 to 2 to deny the requested waiver. The appeal is scheduled to be h =ard by the City Council on August 3, 1994. Please notify me by August 1, 1'94 if any member of the City Council wishes to have slides of the site present =d at the public hearing. 1 • DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING /�� 3-33 & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT 4 1J M _ SAINT CITY OF SAINT PAUL Division of Planning PAUL Norm Coleman, Mayor 25 Wen Fourth Street Telephone: 612 -266 -6565 Saint Paul, MIV 55102 Facsimile: 612 - 225 -3314 AAAA July 11, 1994 F _1 LE 9 a y lzoNING FILE Ms. Nancy Anderson City Council Research Office Room 310, City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Dear Ms. Anderson: I would like to confirm that a public he ;ring before the City Council is scheduled for Wednesday, August 3, 1994 for the fol •wing zoning case: Applicant: Julie Mager File Number: 94 -144 Purpose: Appeal th - decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals denying a request t. waive the requirements of a home occupation and allow a h. me occupation to be conducted in a detached garage due to a 'hysical condition. Location: 1317 E. 4,h Street; northside between Johnson Parkway & Clarence street Previous action: Board of 'oning Appeals: 6 -6 -94, Denied, 5 -2 My understanding is that this public h:Iaring request will appear on the agenda of the City Council at your earliest convenience a d that you will publish notice of the hearing in the Saint Paul Legal Ledger. Please call me at 266 -6583 if you hay: any questions. Sincere) • Michael J. Kraemer Zoning Section cc: File #94 -144 3 TN/ -0-3-3 ZONING FILE 9�t- To : Mary Bunnell, From: Julie Magler Re: Grant in Vari : nce for Zoning Date: Thursday, July 07 1994 The grounds for my appeal e based on the refusal of the Board of Zoning. - The Board never asked for our inp ; t. In their closed meeting they asked each other questions and made false assumpti ins that we would have happily answered. The Board's refusal seemed to be base on lack of documentation concerning our doctors. I mentioned that I would . e happy to get further documentation within two weeks of the adjournment. I belie e this documentation could save the board and the city council both time and mo y. Attached you will see doctors' reports for the concerns mentioned at the closed eeting. Please notify me in writing .t your earliest convenience concerning your judgment and reasons. I believe " i le Diagnostic Report," page 3-4 is the most crucial for your consideration. T lank you. II ! - i ZONLNG FILE 9`I -N g -- 3 ORTHOPEDIC, NEUROLOGICAL & PHYSICAL EXAMINATION 6 ) q NAME i .1 L l/ 1 A DATE % '3 '(3 8 ,: ' SITTING • HUNT PULSE NATE 1 L INMOINIII►rIN f. FYMLNLO 7 a erns sawn L MIIS?S lrMrANw1 MI rows IL INNA NOTIOSOEN a ENOONIAWIfIEE LNIASI NOS E. E. N. T. 1 r` t IENLIA l IL VMA IIMLLOA rOM /.....- / LUNGS HEIR) IL : ..-- . OWNS CRANIAL MERVN a AEEIIREIR IL NIIOE►OIrIL ITOININD ELOOD PROW= MIT EIVANRION L ` 4 �— OCC.TI[NDEN MOTES: ossem. ....„...t....-. \Q . 1 ..#2.3 ilIMIN.M. L ....... 60i• -\ \__ 1 2 woe US GR. L.• . PATELLA 'MGM fRM;NE am MI WI ■e IMMOM t wwrwR L . r. L �. OWNO. a.1.n.... CERVICAL FLEXION FONAMINA EXTENiION LATERAL FLEXION LATERAL NOTATION COMFRENION AMNIONS t .`: , ti ,,.. , 4' STANDING • - al AMBULATION � ,,,, NTNOUTANIETANCE NT. taut. / w sa++ Mt w wAss w PROTECTIVE STANCE 111111111111 ` _ — ._ A♦IETANCE OREEMFORT L — �_ CRAB MANIER IIR. a. N ........ — CANE L EMN TEA SON KEMFE UNABLE 1101lEROE EIOM 1 t t 4 88. • o ,� � Ole fr. � ..M L —�T� A A. L. R l \ 1 L. ell la DORSAL FLEXION TERAL EXTE NSION tEXION NOTATION MUSCLE STRENGTH (1.2.3 -4 -S) NOTES: MA News Ns* setmssn Tiwik Nnns Tank sewrsw. oimim Eno* mows, PMds sNssws SPINAL MUSCLES IN) W) ROTATOREE IC) IT) IL) IN) WI TRANEVENEALIE ICI IT) IL1 WI rat MULTIFIDt* IC) IT) ILI - IN) OP) INTER$FINALIE IC) IT) IL) , _ _ 1 7 - - T- 1a--33 J' r l -4. T O c ti.. l - L i T , N ... ' ' - 4 •, ( • (7.15) Q +rj M (h '� ` ` of . ` • '- .ter � /"... N N N V 2. k ' Z kNe a T T r 'O N r T 5 0 i , \ '5 — O \ _ ,�_ h. 7, 6 ,-... , „:-.1' ri N ( CI) ,... .cr ■ei L c., r' C (Cr N N L[. 1 S T T T 3 a f / (T T ` PI , o T \ ' tr i 0" 1. cr) , \ �q ..� (,J _ c � '` F in` Lo N r T � • O tiZ.,. ''.4 t ‘'N i G \•-• VI a- o'c., 2 ,c7 .-- •[__ T r ' V "f . ,,,,i c ,.._ ....,.. r-- G _ .. O tug fi (� C) i, te r' N N N ii N y. .� r 1 l' L. .. .....„ .., ..: �� `` I� mac. O _� -- , _ 1- . J J c' n g aiming (1 ...::. ..- ;i ••' --zi. (0.... (7) th t k 1/46. ..z ti\ N N � ' /� ■ r T r 3A1133('AAS 3AI1o3PA • Xa U F- _,..i ; N : ti 0 0 0 0 0 . _ g h t -- 0-33 . 1 ... _ . - - j - C \I ....c....z.; .........1 1 3;1 T- 0 T— cr) co ,.., D , LU 1 c Nr O. I ......1 c U. t.7 P o N CJ T T I- ( \ ri T t. 1_ ._i 1 Z t 1. 0 0-, co k.... 1 . 0 I I C I C —C j ■■• ,b \,......./`• t E a., . T" V T 4 •••3 CV T 1 T T 0 T < - . ,\\ • N e-.- 0 co 0E g in tr) S Nt Nr NI- I * cv , n Q , , 3 L. , 0) 03 C IC h. 1 -. _ ,.. r gm. 0 CO p 4 vi- i•-c..i co ...z. ig Nk N CV .4.1Q. .. N 1— L. \C Y, o ,-- T— ..) 4 . .., 1.-- N •-t. •-•../ CD (I3 7) in Lo to P s . z . ' \--v._ nr v- •zr c co cr) l --NZ. ----. a rr` \-1 ■''' u..., c.... cm cm c\I g - 1 3A11331311S 3A1.1.33r : _ x a 0 _ - 0 f-- . --1 - - - _ _ _ • / 12-33 T T _ 0 T r •OJ _ ti e' (� G `7 YYII �� a r r r , r m r U O :k,,,, r o T pld o) i Lie n III" d Ou' v� a r r T J m N M Q_ , r U O T 1 4,_ - T a ,4 o T co p. cc aO In p e ek di ill IZI' t NT. 41 Y N∎ O O N N ' p ¢ T T T 3 C a m N O _ to r V O T T 0 T H Q) 4 CO N. J ,u nr r M p F ► N � .43 • 2 0. T T T 1 ° L CV 2 U o 1 '' T O . V l , .J n ;... ..... ok.., , S' i (.75 t ell ..•.- W a T T T v: , 3ALLo3rGns 3n1133r80 _ Xa U F- J oQ o 0 0 o e o 0 1 . 2 o `n 1> ti _ U o il:11 \7 (--- . r LW U ;,,,, LA i. .z n. v._ . 1 J �,! ( ..Z _ cn n: 0 ‘n \ .:S: N s. g _ 0 1 t4 U a Cr) 1 c Y J � -,„ , ,..,„ F- - I ,....,• ,..„ .. , c.,..„ ,... ,. \‘, , , ,....„,.._,: ri 1 \ ... : 0: (...) ■ . 2 1 U o -. L 2 I - J 1 [.� \` c. ^ !� >_ 3 v • , �, z a M 16 0 U o L,. , , , . (. 0.,,,„„ Nj 2 q „_.\-' k \ ' 1 I 4 LI k---i,_q -c- c..:.1- 1 vil a. V v a 1 tti 0 - a: lb 3AOl33rens xa / 3mio3reo . - rav 5 o_ 2 a 8 0 8 8 _ -- ZONING FILE 9y - m uirkk-z �f'� G� I -V-t� � C � d Gc /* LA c� -kG� et-5 u wt. bc_i. r i7Cc{�lGyt . It L -11P-16 ibrdi cifctrs cicr,e),t±uct4-c_ct. 1(11G ✓l f.ed fh'I biiC_cc_f Cyr Crt L-ci c).p(cus 1 z-t$ ■■ T)/1 • '`2 i s e6c � � e� p/ TondLik:/:s /the co_le.ro . "r)erc. 14/10,_5-+ 4 04e, cti----t7h_e < r 5 .(1-e 4 4.c/ erie of L L`4 i S i ✓1 C v�'St de `f Si c)(\ L 6, rid 3 tc-r L9c - r+cc&. Ct. - 0 - t7 TIIE CENTER FOR DIAGNOSTIC t M n c, t N c 0 5775 Wayzata l3oule rd • Suite 190 • Minneapolis, MN 55416 • (612) 541 -1840 • FAX: (612) 541-0877 ❑ 2800 Chicago Ave e • Suite 100 • Minneapolis, MN 55407 • (612) 872 -1246 • FAX: (612) 871 -0803 ,910 Sibley Memori.' Highway • St. Paul, MN 55118 • (612) 455 -5500 • FAX: (612) 455 -6106 An Affiliate of Medi Scanning Consultants, P. A. REFERRING PHYSICIAN: MARK J.1TAHIJA D.C. PATIENT NAME: MAGLER, JULIE ,. SEX: F DOB: 08/04/55 58#: 471 -70 -6935 EXAM DATE: 06/19/92 ACCT #: 584332 TYPE OF EXAM: CT LUMBAR SPINE 'ITHOUT CONTRAST CLINICAL INFORMATION: 36- year�old female with lower back pain without specified radiation. There is�no history of prior surgery. Rule out disc herniation. Rule out spi al stenosis. INTERPRETATION: AP and latera scout digital radiographs reveal five true lumbar type vertebrae wit a transitional next most caudal segment which is shown to be partially sacralized on the left and lumbarized on the right. There is also pseusojoint formation noted between the left transverse processes of this v body and the rest of the sacrum. For the purposes of this repor , this level is numbered S1 -•2 with most caudal disc being numbered S1- . S1 -2: Again noted is sacraliz tion of the Si vertebra on the left and lumbarization on the right wit pseudojoint formation between left transverse processes of Si and S2. This can be a source of localized back pain and clinical correla ion in that regard is suggested. The dorsal margin of Sl -2 disc app unremarkable, without demonstration of pathologic disc bulging, di.c herniation, central canal or lateral stenosis. The facet joints ar- hypoplastic bilaterally. L5 -S1: There is moderate broai -based dorsal protrusion of the L5 -S1 intervertebral disc. The size of this abnormality would favor broad -based contained disc her although differentiation from annular bulging is difficult o' the basis of CT examination alone. Regardless, this moderate disc protrusion which measures approximately 4 to 5 mm in anteroposterior d is seen to encroach upon the ventral aspect of the thecal s•c resulting in mild central spinal canal stenosis as well as moderate ti marked bilateral subarticular recess stenosis at this level where t e S1 nerve roots arise from the thecal sac. Findings would seem bord-rline abnormal for encroachment upon these Si nerve root origins an lack of symptomatology of the lower extremities would suggest thatlfrank impingement is not evident. However, if additional disc pr•trusion occurred with weightbearing, twi or bending movements, encroachment upon the S1 nerve roots might ensue and clinical correlation in that regard is suggested. L5 nerve roots exit cephalad a -pects of L5 -S1 intervertebral nerve root canals without impingement. T e facet joints appear unremarkable. There is no CT demonstration o spondylolysis. L4 -5: The dorsal disc margin - ppears intact, without demonstration of pathologic disc bulging, disc erniation, central canal or lateral stenosis. The facet joints appear unremarkable. • L3 -4 and L2 -3: Survey axial i,ages at these levels are unremarkable. FILE - . 1y ---- � (CONTINUED) ZONING FIL 9 � .± D><agnosdcReport 19 . , a 4.. ivy - - -v`, ...;.'. Li r- 1 X' 3 ACCT. # ') AST_ ' ME a r u - M.I. DATE CLOSED l Cy� ADDRESS _ ZIP c> HOME# 1 WORK# INS. CO. .M o Z INC NC FILE 941-'41- //.,,7° z SECONDARY 1 j � INSURANCE i o�c R ! 1 2 3 �JQ w ,,, 6 kJOR COMPLAINT & SYMPTOMS a ka / f;' :V 3 D. Ate di-- / A C 1TOt01 1..) Vdz, 1• Nopa , 0.' )NTRAINDICATIONS 10•Wo o a / / V 7 <n AGNOSIS 01 Z / z / / EXAM FINDINGS CERVICAL / THORACIC 4 /7 A0 Tf# v ADJUSTMENT ADJUSTMENT F ftp - - E TEST LUMBAR / PELVIC pi) Po (SI z ADJUSTMENT ADJUSTMENT l T '6 f OA J1' / / / 0 PROGRESSING / 0 V w AS EXPECTED XRAY FINDINGS A w - / / w TE 1 1 VIEWS I a / / CONTINUE / `-/ SCHEDULE OF CARE Q / p, a. / 7 / NEXT APPOINTMENT DAY / FREQ. /, 1 2 3 4 D• 3X• 2X• 1W• 2W• 1M• 2M•PRN /� rei in SCHEDULE OF CARE I 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 2 30 31 G � S F P 4 ° I IL- C( J• 1 _ ■ ■ ■ ■ 2 - 3 4 5 6 _ 7 8 9 10 11, 21 q4 42-33 ZONING FILE 9 T WRY • MAG s E cA RE 0 RD S 7 -ey 10 *m.4.ior3 e a7�rk w 2 J ` $9 �.� 01/1 ems, � / �t 16. Is the condition int. ierring with your work? 51A-) / � <011O 33 17. Did you notice any other Sx such as frequent urination, constipation, 6 etc? 18. Have you consulted other physicians? 19. Were X -rays taken? j\/ f 20. What was the diagnosis? 21. Are you on any kind of medication? 22. Have you been hospitalized at any time in the last 5 years? 23. Have you ever had back surgery or were advised to have one? 24. Has any one in your family ever had: Cancer, Diabetes, High B.P., Heart disease? 25. Are there any members in your family that have the same problem? i I Remarks: d j dt /219ys i (/vc✓\ ZONING ING FILE 9 4.1" -) 9 _ Patient signature - _ _ Date / / _ 25. _ ZONING FILE 94-- e , 33 . �; :.,, -, : i :t t. `. ;Ft , : .p,'R.'- a . 1 e; `+ Y Y Ct: : v _ ' f ;, ' h' {{ i fix *� 1. ISO es ... _ .. MIMS Fe L Willi. (� , ( + saws arberen 'ILkre 9 111044 saUTTletnrT TUT tDTO • PMMPE:NSA TEST etll 1411 T ' •.,. t lia •� LwnR �j w . • t r Dlv L —_ L...... w .wMuS " 0 I �L� a. L. ,b L—_ LASEOUE $IOII 1 a11AOQARp UST IHCSCYtA SW 1 NOM: ' 2\ �TO RIMS •141140.!1 ••••44 L 1 L _ t FAaURE. PAT111CIC TILT LIO MCP TUT PALPATICIS .... . -. '. c"rr i _ .- 1 ...r ' a 42'4 11': ''II! PRONE 2 6 r -C - . ��f V { �}_ V 4 t *1 TI Sa11 1a T natP►tSaAL 41 V 7 tr IpierAss11 " �-�._ AYM $NQITIYtTY TUT t 1166 IN11■100 I. **GLUM SAC AL�A/tXt'a ELY'S � O t 11) rein (21 Tw4411ww tip L...+ Forting V.,. 1� ., ,orrz r � - - 1. ' SP • 114 (I :: I 1111 ! 1 i c s , AT P AX • t � t \ fit i � \ i \ 1 • � , 1 itt • • " . . CU. T „c7ci . 4 I % 1 It lit -.--.- — Y . * or) v I • I o f ..IA • • 1•r NOTES: L VP. CORD MR • – S. • rr =. PR. PAY. MP. to • . .� S. SIL PAY. POOL. 11 • I1. IL • ��� 2 • 3 . IlIc i. !. 1 L • - • _ - _ 1 ZONING q ,_... .. 3 .,h'1 r �; '5 . d 1 4 ,_ ' ;..4 � 1 : i° .24.1i' wA `� `a . -� .: SY stwi . 4 .. }aT� y . ,L,-.. , .:�73•>.Ni ;,, : . .. . 0 ci R 4, . 1 'n US maw «•...... it IQ CI "•01k4r* •N=%........... . alb 048,■ a -J L. ISOAi VICASTNIVAIT TUT C M • MAr.'_t7 UST w W .w.owRw MI 116511441 en IV MOW Ye LASE out SION tRAOOAIO MT ROOM INNI 1 NOM: • • Itt WIN L i nns 1Rw• •t twwear isi.• R L.......... 1 /MUM ?ATROCKTWIT LEO DROP TUT PALPATION = PRONE ► ., - 114 ........"...C.. v OeAWOTOtMIs •1 1"""••••••....... *.+N4 - Iv ►AA/rIIRAL s.aaJrss. (1- 7TVTTYMT L -. L L. 4- 1 ' Y *Wm. OVA .�' t ACN1LLi! SACRAL -MIX PR WelTL•T 4 J � I 111 /.1n (2) To Worm. (31 Us ell holing ,� ��i/'�L r r l � • /.....-......t • 1. SP 111 ii et � rei i ■ ; \ 1 I kk V 11 fk • 1 • • i r : . ,..,-.C1. .... .. • I P ..0. r )1 4 . l 1/4. UM i ki • u 1 ► k ..LL • , NOM: 1. VP. CORO MOIL • — 11 • 1r !.M. PAX RIP. 10 • S. I L PAY. MOM It ► :•. Y-- P.) n '_ k.........--- c • • S r / - 0-33 ZONING y... ING FIL 9 L.s.. 1'ntr ,,34,F1; A,•t 0s.i:-: Y i , SUPINE Ammorm 1. � .... •fir �� I. ....A.,de. 0. ` R c v flo ...... L. P$OAm SOLIOTIIIMIT MT Ni1'O • ISATT27,011 TUT . . li ell t1111 I 14) Mate 042"110 Pall•MIND on 1•1111••• . y L \J . al MN N. • 1 LAS10Ut pal 110.A40011O MT 11001101111 1100Y211 MI NOM: 1 ,5 l rf j; crr V 7 w. L i .,. , J ,, 1. fly L L - 1 R _ FAISAL PATTI=TUT 1.11110110P TUT MOAT= '“ x 0 '7.' - ' PRONE 41. 81115111MINIMINIEME1111011111111 V* I ..• 17101M111111110 =.. e! LIMO • A ►ORIfTTY TUT ''': i‘ a L - -, v L 2 r ACMRLU t1ACMlJVEXFII tlY'IYIIT i�i �iertZ .� -� 111 Flan 121 T.M.rrwo. 131 LM .1 Fe.Nn� r 1!. • r �: s l f +4 I i� � �j i a c , A7 r f I II / w ∎$i . .. il t r \ i \ I 1 r r" .. • r .d. 7 . r . f r �� r 1 v � . 1► r v i . ` I id f c u r .'LL NOTU: 1.O►.000D FMS.. f- r rr !. NL PAM. MP. 10 • M i IL MT. POOL 11 r ": I 12 • •�: / L • 1 ,...... r • • • r • r • r __ 31 - - 1 _ '4 - N • T T T O T co • IIIIIMM " Q CO C� !to to t1) M M CT) 4 1: N N N d T T T N T t • - T 0 T Q) CO r '' ^^ (D CO VJ LO U)to 1 I M co CO :1 A N N N t O d T T T N T 1 T d C) T Y d i N. .4. . ■ b ' ►t) to \, ) VV �. \ j CO CO M S`% �' . '+ C ,r N N N k v 3 r ! T V T .D Z II T i cm co P • I to N. r•-• 0 ><-1 to d- NI- 'i M Q M M M r Z 1 N N N \c P&' SI tj 4. N d T ? "" 1-- A s T L 0 � - v. d T N c7 ti 2 t o to tC (E, ni -1- w 'Cr 4 t v X -1' - f.. ... co co CO c� - 3A11o3r ns _ 3A1133ra g - xa - 0 t- -1 o a o 0 OI ci_ in 9 4 — I C= r ? o o I m . r f ti .. v •) co N►_ C o Q n co 3 (t) co C T) •. 4 0 4 2 CO V) CO f ' , a: ....% t i C‘I N cm 5 ` T U o A T 11 1 r i CO CO 7 - ^ 4- i CO 0 • • 0 _ 1%. O S - 1) v 1 Y ' v 1 c' M c) I 6 d. ,_ �. Q N N N T r r r U p f r r 1 / O f r ) Q �� �. cc o r a, G CD co u) 4 z Q °^ Q � 3 M N co ' 1 o pp a O N N 3 °. d r T r % ♦ ll • CM V Lo r T Q Y = T _ 1 a � co V to to cn o.. O ` N N in N ; a: T r r 4. U o r 1 r 0 co a r , �����VTTTT��1111 `` „' CD to N 1. ] i 2 in . in . 024 1/4% 1 v cl co v ° C I N N N d T r r 3AI133P8f1S 3AI1J3f 80 x a V 1 . j o o - 0 0 0 o o - ✓` 9 .- 0'3 I ,- H i r o :7...- T r , 10 < CO , j • - lLI r L CO Q 4 III /y N N CO 'O a �1 ` T r r ‘).° r �• .n Z o T IsA0 cn , ('N 2 CO OW 1 /.‘ N. _ -` CO u, U) g. 1Z - Q� M M M I �` f kiz C N N N V H 8 a `� o r r r N U C II r 1 T r 1 - O o T .5' 1 4 }..,. co : • } M C` M M rn ;Q � � E `1J a N. a fA , (3- '''") co t j in s,,,; ii I Q I N N N VVVV ���' a r r r 1 2 r 2 0 o r 0 , I r .n 3v N. g ...0 / / CI CD LO C7) v ID 4 ' '1 -- ---44. 5 • . •4' M `t / c co M e 1 , I' F. , p � N N N LL g {i II \` a r T •••• - CC 3 A11�3('8t1S 3A1133113 xa U I -. ° a c 0 CO 0 8 o 0 0 - r - - _ 37 1 .7y-/.)-53 ... 0-. in T ., r . P v ' o i a 00 j T N co i M ` 11 O ..''. N N a r r r If 2 " 2 a.. c O 2 6 T 0' T c. . � o Li i c/ —' ,� v cn I t- . 0 I .4 ,0 eV in t Z /�_ N N N l� ►^ O a r r r L.%%°1 I V O cm T T r M T a CO \ 7 s '',0 t us ■ Y �t ,� v 0 0 �-, v \ i N N N \� v \t...\,..• i N a �n t‘k7S �- O I r T T V n co co cn �� Nr I co CO N N N f' ` 1 g . a T T r VVV L4 ,0 OCL O '0... - / 1 in g 4. 01 45... - , N QD (1:6) S V co ch P7 M �� a, 1 -� 1 N N N 3 �, • a 0 a r r r 3AI103('9(1S ' 3A1133('8 • j xa 1 U I— J Q o 0 0 8 8 o CO 0 34 rF 1 • , t f of . K;n t +` .F _ �' h cif 'ra r ,, - � kAlt ':o 3 . his •' O 1 7 ....0. : r r }is : : s 4 I - O 17.< r -_ s'T t1� . >S '' ,. - mss; .. UJ OW ' v r ur - k .,% 0 N ` � • p .."fl 27 3 ', v i • 0 J J. , �t. a. .:-. 0 c ,.-.,..; ..,:,. :: :),-,- ? 2 --....;- ,:'.-!-. -, ,c,„ - 4 . _ . ,T.:> 4 :' , , -.. -: , "/..;- - ..,, ..... L . .. �T �; � 1 t 4 - i f r 5 • < r• �{ s t _ I - 4 3 - , 3 •; • 0:: O / fi t' w Y F -, .t'7--.,, ( �i R ,....."...,,ti:.1.,„,,,,,t......„..i...„,_:.:.., . • • Y �F. •. 3tj 4- ✓ ',�^ 1 . K ' . • y Z ? - ,F • -S,-' i r 4.y. ' .. a i. 1i �• .. C d : s, N _ A[ .`t s s J fit¢ C • � dF F =� '.L'i -h Off : 1 U al ma c '_, . �F t^ +�� rVt , q • i c T f . ' S J G tr: • • :C y _ F •,; - -.7, - LL33P8f1S XO / 3 AI1�3� 80 - Cid o � - S � o : � 9/--)3 - - - - NAME - 1;vr x 7 1")G-v' DATE \•- } 3 \ - C_ D - CHIEF COMPLAIN A4pc. l '' i a 6 B C • D - i) HT A_ 5_ _ 0 2) WT A_ 8_ C_ 0_ 3) TEMP A_ B C D_ -4) PULSE A 8 C_ _ D 5) RESPIRATIONS A B • C D 1 — --- - -- . - 6) BLOOD PRESSU `E A_ /___ B_ /_ C_!_ D_ /_ 7) VBUGEORGES ' E.E.N.TJHEARULUNGS: — — Neurobgic: BICEPS ' A. LT RT • B. LT RT C. LT RT D. LT RT TRICEPS A. LT RT B. LT RT C. LT RT D. LT RT RADIAL A. LT RT B. LT RT C. LT RT D. LT RT PATELLER A. LT RT B. LT RT C. LT RT D. LT RT ACHILLES 1 A. LT RT B. LT RT C. LT RT D. LT RT 1 DYNAMOMETER GRIP TEST • l7' A. LEFT RIGHT B. LEFT RIGHT C. LEFT RIGHT D. LEFT RIGHT ' 1 '1 ' c) .`Jo 1 1 1 T O ZoL 2 2 2 3 'Co lo' 3 3 3 lea CERVICAL RANGE OF sTION MAIGNES - FLEXION 65 6_ EXTENSION SO c , L ROTATION 80 . Z RT. ROTATION 80 .7 b C TT•,.✓ -- Z LT. LAT. FLEX , 55 0 RT. LAT. FLE • 55 r'• (-i J »./ • N ORTHOPOEDIC: (Cervical) Compression 1 i Manual Tract Foramina Comp .}. di i f - •'FPS .. Soto Hall MUSCLE TEST-UPPER EXT. MUSCLE TEST-LOWER EXT. SCM FLEX EXT. ©ICEP TFI CEP TRAPS OM rw HAMS PIRIIOIMIS GLU1S T r 1. i`: :(2 A t.. t, R. 5 L.5 R. S LS R. j L. C ITS L. S n.5 L.r) R.5 A L R L. R. L R. L. n L It 1 . B L. R L. R L. R L. R. L. R. L. R. B L. R L. R. L R 1. R L. R L C L R • L. R. L. R. L. R. L. n L. R. C 7 R t. R. L. R. L R. L. R. L. D L. R L. R. L. R. L. R. L R. _ L. R. u. L _ -- f . L. n. L n L n L R L. PINWF jEE� A. "^ B. C. 1 V. 1 OTHER SIGNIFICANT 0 - - _1 L'i7 leAta'fi.tl` . 'f - 4 C ' — ` , '..41 . • 11n.:. ..Y47- 91./4 33 ACCT. # LAST AME r _ l @T M.I. DATE CLOSED (/ ADDRESS _ ZIP �� HOME# WORK# INS. CO. OA N / \ i - ZO FILE qq', 1 / / = r INSURANCE D CT .1k°Cg2ej N jj,�� � • 1 3 AJOR COMPLAINT & SYMPTOMS �.l> 1'� / y S' i yr <<� / 77 / 0 1 TO , U 14 No •In D: / I / ONTRAINDICATIONS t0•w rst o 7 / // / / 7 1n IAGGNOSIS • I . z / / Z U_ / EXAM FINDINGS CERVICAL THORACIC (� V �. ADJUSTMENT / ADJUSTMENT ` ✓ ,TE TEST LUMBAR PELVIC ,/ V • 1 z AD / ADJUSTMENT / V rv. / ' 01 h- / 7 v T 1- PROGRESSING / / J 1 w AS EXPECTED / / XRAY FINDINGS W / \TE VIEWS 1 a / 0 CONTINUE SCHEDULE / //J Y OFCARE Q / a • / vv NEXT APPOINTMENT DAY / FREQ. .% 1 2 3 4 D• 3X• 2X• 1W• 2W• 1M•2M•PRN SCHEDULE OF CA RE _ 7:Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 14 15 16 17 18 19120 21 22 231 ?4 25 26 27 2 29 30 31 G O \ E ' A I 0 I 1 0 P roc) I I 1 _ - 3 4 5 6 7 8 _ 9- 10 11 �tjs - • ._ - - - 1 - _ 99-1)35 NORTH ST. PAUL MEDICAL CENTER, P.A. 2579 EAST SEVENTH AVENUE NOR"H ST. PAUL. MINNESOTA 55109.3084 PHONE: 777-7514 FAX: 77 .7839 HAROLD R. ERDMAN, M.D. !, CERTIFIED BY THE WILLIAM R. SCHROEDER. M.D. AMERICAN BOARD OF FAMILY PRACTICE THOMAS P. HAAS, M.D. EDWARD M. DENNISON, M.D. June 13, 1994 j ZONING FILE 99 Re: Terry Magler To Whom It May Concern: Mr. Magler should not carry anything up stairs. This is secondary to, his back condition. This restriction will be for an indefinate period of time. Thank you. Sincerely, William R. Schroeder, M.D. WRS /jt • _ 417 033 NORTH S. PAUL MEDICAL CEN TER, PA. - - 91/'— 2579 EAST SEVENTH WEN_UE NORTH ST. PAUL. MIN 4ES4TA 55109.3084 PHONE: 777.74 4 FAX 777.7835 E TH BY TH HAROLD R. !WOMAN. M.D. AMERICA COMM N BOARD OF BY E PRACTICE WILLIAM R. SCHROEDER, M.D. THOMAS P. HAAS. M.D. EDWARD M. DENNLSON, MD. 1 ZONING FILE 941.4444 July 18, 1994 Re: Terry Magler To Whom it May Concern: • Mr. Magler should not carry anyhing up stairs due to sciatica and degenerative joint disease of the back. • This restriction will be for an indefinite period of time. Thank you for your cooperation.'i Sincerely, • u >, . L^ William R. Schreoder,M.D. II WRS:mll • • • • • _ ! _ - I I 9 /1,p-33 File #94 -099 Page Two Ms. Bogen asked if the staff recommendation is approved and the waiver expires when their children turn 18 yeas old, wouldn't they probably need to come back to the Board at that time to continue working out in the garage because the children aren't around to help carry the boxes? Ms. Magler replied maybe. Ms. Maddox stated that she noticed the Magler's had a meter on the garage and asked if they also had one on tte house. Ms. Magler replied that the meter on the garage is for their electric' bills and they also have one on their house. They receive two separate bills from NSP and it is their preference. She said they also have a security systen in the garage. Jerry Magler, 1317 E. Fourth St stated that working out in the garage is a convenience. Hearing no further testimony, Mi Maddox closed the public portion of the meeting. Ms. Bogen stated that when she read through the staff report for the first time she had a problem with using the garage for parental supervision as a justification for the waiver. he stated that it didn't seem to be related to their disabilities. The more she thought about it the more she thought that a permanent waiver would make more sense because the applicants are going to have to come back to the Board if their business is still going in the year 2000. They won't have their children thereto help them carry the boxes then. She stated she has done a lot mailings and knows how heavy the boxes are. She said she would be okay with eliminating the condition that the waiver expires in the year 2000. Ms. Maddox spoke in favor of till condition. She can see the Board granting the waiver up to the year 2000, but then she would like to reevaluate it. What if the business is extreme_y large at that point? She doesn't believe a large business belongs in a neighborhood. Ms. Bogen asked if there are requirements on how many employees a home occupation can have. Ms. Lane replied that you can have a maximum of two employees and one has to live im the dwelling. Mr. Alton asked Mr. Segal whether Section 60.412(7) defines handicapped person and /or elaborates under what circumstances the Board can grant a waiver to a handicapped person. Mr. Segal replied that there is no definition in the Zoning Code for handicapped person. The only the thing the code says is that home occupations for handicapped persons that do not meet these conditions may be reviewed by the BZA which may modify or waive the requirements of a through g, which includes the requirement that a_1 of the work must be done in principal residence. There are no further guidelines. This is not the same as a variance, but he suggested the 3oard might consider some of the same principles. 51 File #94 -099 Page Four and 15 and will need to continua; to do that until their youngest child is 18 years old. The BZA has never bfore, in considering a home occupation for the handicapped, given a waiver whe there has been no evidence of a handicap s condition. These are lifting r trictions, they are not handicaps. In addition, he believes the appli. are trying to get a relief from a requirement of the Zoning Code o that they can continue to use their garage in a way that is illegal. They have a separate meter for their garage. This is a separate living space in their garage for which they don't have the proper authority. This is a waver that should not be given at all. Ms. Maddox asked Mr. Soderholm f staff asked for any other medical information from the applicant. Mr. Soderholm replied that Mr. Bunnell discussed that with the applicats and he doesn't know if they brought additional medical information ith them or not. Ms. Maddox stated she would be illing to reopen the public portion of the hearing to hear from the applic nt if they did have any further medical information for the BZA. Mr. Magler replied that he does 't have any further medical information at - home but he could obtain it fro his doctor. He stated he was told he could work in his garage if it was at ached to his home. Ms. Lane stated that the home o cupation of the Zoning Code does say under Finding #2, "A home occupation 'hall be carried on wholly within the main building. No home occupation s all be allowed in detached accessory buildings or garages." She stated that i the garage were attached and it were not a garage, but rather a second flo r living space above a garage, then that would not be considered a garage. It would be considered an addition to the main dwelling. But as to whether or not home occupations can be in garages the Zoning Code specifically says n , whether it is attached or detached. Ms. Liston stated that the form filled out by the chiropractor were for non - occupational work limitations. There is no indication that this was a occupational work limitation. he asked if that is correct. Mr. Magler replied that he isn't suppose t lift anything of substantial weight. Ms. Bogen stated that the findi state Mr. Magler had a medical retirement. She asked Mr. Magler if he was .n workman's comp prior to retirement. She asked if the injury was caused •t work. Mr. Magler replied that the injury was not caused at work and he w sn't on workman's comp. Hearing no further testimony, M . Maddox closed the public portion of the meeting. Ms. Maddox stated that the Boar' does have a motion on the floor to approve the request with no waivers tha has been seconded. _ _ 53 r 1233 - File #94 -099 - Page Six Mr. Alton stated that the fact .) at there are no objections doesn't change the fact that it doesn't fit within the ordinance. The applicants chose to build a living quarter attached to th: garage rather than put an addition on their house. The result is that they ow want to conduct their home occupation in their new living quarters attac ed to their garage. The BZA shouldn't give them a waiver for that reason. Mr. Tully asked if you need to eve a physical disability in order to have a home occupation. The applicant is asking to waive the requirement that their work be carried on wholly withi the main building. Mr. Alton stated that the only way you can obtain that wa er is if you have a handicap condition. Ms. Lane stated that the condit on that was added to the motion, "that the current residents would have to remain there," would be an ongoing condition that staff would continue to ch :ck on at an annual basis. Mr. Davis asked about Ms. Lane'- suggestion about limiting truck size and asked for suggestions about wha. kind of limitation that could be. Ms. Lane stated that the BZA may want to the applicant how many deliveries they currently have and from what si-e trucks so that they could only continue along the same volume. - Mr. Alton stated that he doesn' think the board should restrict trucks on the grounds that Maglers' are worki in the garage. They will get the deliveries through their alley anyway. Woking in the garage would not make any difference. They wouldn't have that restriction if they were conducting the occupation entirely in their ho'e. Mr. Davis stated he was impressed with Mr. Alton's comment relative to the fact that the applicants appear to be capable of doing this kind of work elsewhere and has changed his p.sition on the waiver request. The motion failed on a roll cal vote of 2 to 5 (Davis, Liston, Tully, Alton, Maddox). Mr. Tully moved to deny the wai based on the fact that he doesn't find the applicant's circumstance a hand cap. Mr. Liston seconded the motion. Mr. Segal suggested the Board a include in their motion the statement that Mr. Alton made that there hasn' been a showing that the work has to be performed in the garage and tha it couldn't be performed in the house just as easily. Mr. Alton stated that there are other family members that do all the lifting for the applicants. Mr. Scherman asked how the Boar' can make a finding_that there is no handicap when you have evidence that the e is a handicap? - - '3 3 //,, CITY OF SAINT PAUL BOARD OF ZONING APPEA S RESOLUTION ZONING FILE NUMBER: 94 DATE: June 20, 1994 WHEREAS, JULIE MAGLER, 1317 4TH ' E, has applied for a waiver, due to her and her husband's physical handicaps, of the requirement in Se i tion 60.412 (7)(c) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code that a home occupation may not be conducted in e garage; and WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Board of Zonin: Appeals conducted a public hearing on 06/06/94, pursuant to said appeal in accordance with the requirem I nts of Section 64.205 of the Legislative Code; and WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Board of Zonin: Appeals based upon evidence presented at the public hearing, as substantially reflected in the minutes, ma. e the following fmdings of fact: 1. Section 60.208(H) of the Zoning Code efmes home occupation as "an occupation carried on in a unit by the resident thereof providing that . e use is limited in extent and incidental and secondary to the use of the dwelling unit for residential • urposes and does not change the character thereof." The applicant's home occupation appears t be limited in extent and secondary to the use of the dwelling unit for residential purposes. 1317 4th treet E. is the home of the Maglers and their three teenage _ children. The Maglers have a mailing 1 rvice business that is typically carried on in the basement of the house and occasionally in the garage . .0 when, the Maglers say, they want to be able to supervise their children while they work. Mrs. Magle ; started the business and she now employs Mr. Magler. The business as conducted in the basement'.f the house qualifies as a home occupation. 2. Section 60.412(7) of the Zoning Code entifies the several requirements for home occupations, including (c) which states that "a hom- occupation shall be carried on wholly within the main building. No home occupation shall be allowed • detached accessory buildings or garages." However, this provision can be waived for handicapped persons. Section 60.412(7) of the Zoning Code states that "home occupations for handicapped pe that do not meet these conditions may be reviewed by the Board of Zoning Appeals which may , 1 odify or waive the requirements a through g." Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary, with a 199 copyright, defines handicapped as "having a physical or mental disability that substantially limits activi , especially in relation to employment or education." 3. The applicant's request for a zoning w i 'ver is based on their claim that both Mr. and Mrs. Magler suffer from back problems that limit t . eir ability to lift heavy boxes, and in the case of Mr. Magler limits his ability to find employment o , tside the home. Mrs. Magler stated that her husband left the employment of Chicago Northwestern ' ailroad in 1991 on a medical retirement related to a sciatic nerve problem in his back. She said . he still has this problem and has, at times, been completely bedridden due to the debilitating effe of this problem. The applicant stated that she has a deteriorating disc in her back that will • 'onally cause great pain and disrupt her work and business. She noted that she and her husband h ve had these physical problems for the past decade. 4. The only evidence the applicants sub.., tted to document their physical handicaps were brief forms from a chiropractor saying they should not or carry heavy boxes, especially going up stairs. The forms do not say their back problems are perm. 'cut disabilities. No further medical documentation was submitted. According to the Maglers, ost of the lifting and carrying is done for them by their children. Working in the garage soul • save some trips up and down the basement stairs, but most of �7 Viz/ P-33 File #94 -099 Page Three CERTIFICATION: I, the undersigned Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals for the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, do hereby certify that 1 have compared the foregoing copy with the original record in m office; and find the same to be a true and correct copy of said original and of the sole thereof, as based on approved minutes of the Saint Paul Board of Zoning Appeals meeting held on June 6, 1994 and on record in the Saint Paul Planning Division Office, 25 West Fourth Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota. SAINT PAUL BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS - /1 — cc n Secretary to the Board i IC I II . Ii-f„)?..33 ' �"-j I –C 1t-7[U 4 • ' I�� F1 —J J - ' - - d` ,• H 'L._Ji -. ;rj•: L..s>� __ • . 1 � . � \ 1 • • s - r - . . J I ,I. 1' .. 1 a I ]E :I °� , - ' t' IL ; l y .aai!'.- _ _ _ A iL i L- ', t I it • _ 1 1 . , — _ -] q�- jr , i C °� LL "`:L • s . ) C 1 1r '� ..J! ! I- - `.fi t ---iHr—� I �y _-] 1 1 11:-.4;p0,_ l 7C_ r ' � _ �' s L I .•.• • ^ � .J Z -- -- = D. , , 1 ... -iii' � l 1 I ° ; ' ' ' , .—.. _ ✓ . � p I j T;IT���� 1 4 .=T ` 1 - r-L- 1 , r' I_ �� J - –:_ -- - 1 _ : -1 ' 1J . � r ' ` 7. "–" ' ' -1 ✓'._p,- fir.. -� ►� ;,,........12 Pr -z- 7 :. �r iu:._ _ – ._- { ''o. tt J ' D ' ----- r : `• -.. -i lam'__" \ \-_ _ j I { , k l \ --t7 n . r• :i a \ _L r = %; �,._ ...,_ . - - – .. ' ' /� ^ - 1 } - � r , • r..'.. c /l \ ' I f" wj t � y` .7 . • ant • y /` - � . 711 — -.� ( \' S _ c yam` .. ' .,1/_ ��,: ; i -r.L �� " _ . ' i � � 99 • ' ,n X . ' "-. ^ d � :% — I'. �� — e r r -- % , , . _ i � . t . I V : •Vi'VX,<( . \- ,. ., \ • ) i ...y' -\'.' ,,7'" ,„ — ,_„_.., ] . .?6 �'� r \ . ■ DAYTON'S BLUFF • DISTRICT cN gr-- �� ---°�° ;.... T'° el �r - '°� '°° .tdvialips , samor- -, 1 . - „NiNG FILE • • • • • BOARD OF Z'NING_APPEALS STAFF REPORT 1. APPLICANT: HAGLER, JULIE FILE # 94 -099 2. CLASSIFICATION: Minor Vari :nce DATE OF HEARING: 06/06/94 3. LOCATION: 1317 4TH ST E (No th side between Johnson Pkwy. & Clarence St.) 4. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: W 1/2 o Lot 18 and all of Lot 17, Block 5; Chas. A. B. Weide's Subdivision No. 5. PLANNING DISTRICT: 4 6. PRESENT ZONING: R -4 ZONING CODE REFERENCE: Section 60.412 (7) 7. STAFF INVESTIGATION AND RE'SRT: DATE: 05/31/94 BY: Mary Bunnell A. PURPOSE: To conduct a hom= occupation from a detached garage due to a physical condition. B. ACTION REQUESTED: A varia e to waive the requirement that a home occupation must be carried en wholly within the main building. C. SITE AND AREA CONDITIONS: lot area is 7,800 square feet (60' x 130'). The property slopes down a••ut 2 feet from the rear to the front and is about a foot over the grad. of Fourth Street. The alley is about 4 feet over the grade of the rear ,ard. The applicant has a relatively small single family house on a r = atively large lot. The applicant's yard has some small trees and veget-tion along the eastern lot line. A 26' x 36' three -stall garage includi a sizable storage space with double windows facing both south and port on the second level is located in the northeastern corner of the •roperty. Surrounding Land Use: Sin :le family residential D. BACKGROUND: On September 0, 1991 the applicant sought a one -story variance at a Board of Zone g Appeals public hearing to construct a two - story 26' x 36' two- stall : arage. Staff had recommended denial of the request partially based on the concern that the proposed garage would provide an excessive amoun. of usable area in an accessory building that potentially could be used .s living space in the future. At the close of the meeting the applicant .ecided to discuss his proposed plans with BID staff and attempt to resole the matter or revise his plans; subsequently the applicant withdrew his variance request promising to reduce the height of the garage. 3 q'f2 File #94 -099 Page Three s is infrequent for home occupa purposes i q uent and related to the need for parental supe., ision of their teenage children when they use the garage space for r creation activities. It is appropriate to link the discontinuanc=' of the use of the garage for infrequent home occupation activities .o a specific date when it will not be necessary for them to -upervise their children. 3. The applicant stated t at her husband left the employment of Chicago Northwestern Railroad n 1991 on a medical retirement related to a sciatic nerve problem n his back. She pointed out that he still has this problem and has, :t times, been completely bedridden due to the debilitating effects o this problem. The applicant pointed out that she has a deterioratin; disc in her back that will occasionally cause great pain and disrupt ! her work and business. She noted that she and her husband have had tese physical problems for the past decade. She pointed out that t.ey rely on their teenage children to perform the carrying and lifti g of boxes that is required for her business. 4. Section 60.412(7) of t e Zoning Code states that "home occupations - for handicapped person, do not meet these conditions may be reviewed by the Board f Zoning Appeals which may modify or waive the requirements a through g." Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary, with a 199 copyright, defines handicapped as "having a physical or mental dis that substantially limits activity especially in relationito employment or education." The applicant's business requires the eriodic and daily lifting and carrying of boxes of envelopes, la.els and mailers both into their home and from their home to their ve icles for transporting to the Post Office. The applicant noted th they rely heavily upon their teenage children to perform th lifting and carrying tasks due to their d back problems. It is ear that their back problems substantially limit their lifting an; carrying abilities and activities. The applicant stated that hey have medical records relating to their back problems and woul be willing to provide these records if needed to verify these proble S. The applicant stated t at the sciatic nerve problem of her husband is not expected to improv much over time. In addition, she noted that the disc problem in he back also will not improve over time. She speculated that if herd disc problem gets any worse she might have to have spinal fusion sur' :ery. It is clear that the physical conditions of both the applicant =nd her husband are anticipated to continue and are thus expected to 1;mit their carrying and lifting abilities into the foreseeable future F. DISTRICT COUNCIL RECOMMEND TION: As of the date of this staff report, the Dayton's Bluff Communi Council has not made a recommendation in this matter. _ I 10.7 , _- -. 0 Z_F - 94-017 0 .. _ ZONING Bs 'RD Mht/OA. i APP CATION FOR ZONING ORDINANCE VARIANCE . .. . - CITY OF SAINT PAUL 1 4 3 7 7 7 CD 6 .41 kci ) et-) A VARIANCE OF - ONING CODE CHAPTER • SECTIOZ 0 . 0 PARAGRAPH IS REQUESTED IN CONFORMITY WITH THE POWERS VESTED IN THE BOARD OF ZONING AP— PEALS TO PERMI THE \.r.)Orki .0 .3 ,..) +1..,.‘, 5 K`c i‘')■ k. ON PROPERTY DESCRIBED BELO . . A. Applicant; - ME: "-- S " ‘)\ \ q... % I IN VI N\ ‘.. V" • 'DRESS I 31 7 5 ' Ss . • YTIME TELEPHONE NO. 7 7 8 - / fs' I ZIP CODE ______ 1. Property i terest of applicant: (owner, contract purchaser, etc.) 2. Name of • ner (if different) B. Property Descr •tion: ADDRESS /317 E 1-1*h Si-. . 1. Legal des. iption: LOT 1 - 7 BLOCK 5" ADD.V) > Lck 18 2. Lot size: • 0 : / 0 3. Present U lel - to. % . utresent Zoning Dist. R - I-7 - C. Reasons for Re uest: 1. Proposed se ....\-- \* . ox _ C Fax Ty INNTNIC".'14\S 1"" C I V : 1% "'• ? ' *) h. rog tn‘...A S s . • . 2. What phys al characteristics of the property prevent its being used for any of the permitted uses in your zo e? (topography, soil conditions, size and shape of lot, etc.) ? 1 . . . . . . , 1 ! • • 3. State the s , cific variation requested, giving distances where appropriate. -- 1 - 10 ‘..)C3rk I r4 IN l' cs ,-Y, t „4 ON' ovy- G Avivt t, . 4 . . Explain h. your case conforms toeaCh of the ?ollowing: - ' ' s - a. That t strict application of the provisions of the Zoning Ordiance would result in peculiar or exce•tional practical difficulties, or exceptional undue hardships. . . . . . ----_------ Li /12/94.pAstilgRs ;..1..sE.onwe:c: 47t,0--- b. That t - granting of a variance will r..:. i . 4060 ,;r. :.C7 * . ;:.) .-- not be a substantial detriment to CHE 4 . ;,. - _ : g.' , . ...- public • •od or a substantial impair- CK ment o the intent and purpose of ....-. thelo ng Ordinance. _ • NOTE: THIS ILL NOT BE PROCESSE • WITHOUT A COMPLETE SITE PLANI _ ' i / *- __ . . ,_ Signature _ . a.A.. i 1 .g. 4 . - - _ / - el" 1 1 _ I Date Received - -- 1 - - - _ N-- ov T. -k 5- 'r4 - tt - 41.1- 1 33 r . z 1i o v s ¢. - 10 1 - . 43 21 , , iS9vArk 0 S 1 1 gV fi‘ s Nro 3 Fec4 E 1rJ _ a. O 0. T I i N 4 1 ' • 26 H W . ...1 . . , LL 1 / _ Z 6 Ac Ate .,.. - l •' 3 • 1:ede - J M 0 G. /cam - £ Q 7 , 778 —/�'1 y _ _ •v N 1 r" t' c o v e c) A\ \t y 69 9L((2 13c1Wcz ZONING FILE 9 /-0 9 9, Creek Chiroprcicti Mark F. LaVallie, D.C. EMPLO E'S WORK LIMITATION SLIP Oc upational XX Non — occupational NAME Julie Magl -r DATE 3 -22 -9 EMPLOYER The above named employee is nder treatment in this office. We recommend that his/her work be limited as follows: NO EXCESSIVE OR REPE . TED: Bending Kne: ing Twisting Turning Climbing Squatting Stoo ling Pulling Pushing NO PROLONGED: Standing Sittin Walking XXX Restricted from heavy l ifting (25 lbs. men, 10 lbs. women) OTHER RESTRICTIONS: • should not be carry'i'ng boxes, especially up stairways LIMITATION WILL BE T : MPORARY FOR: unknown at this tim_ Days Weeks _ Months REMARKS: DOCTORS NAME: /11 ' 1 293 S. McKnight _Road - • Si; Paul, Minnesota 55119 • (612) 731 -1880 ■ 9 HOMEOCCUPATION ZONING FILE q2 .== { City of Saint Paul Saint Paul Zoning Ordinance - Section 60.208(H) and 60.412(7) (May 23, 1988) • Home Occupation: An occupation 'carried on in a unit by the resident thereof providing that the use is limited in extent and incidental and secondary to the use of the dwelling unit for residential purposes and does not change the character thereof. PERMITTED USES Home Occupation which are compatible with other residential uses and which maintain and preserve the character of residential neighborhood subject to the following requirements: a. A home occupation shall not involve the conduct of a retail business, a manufacturing business, a commercial food service requiring a license, or auto service or repair for any vehicle other than those registered to residents of the property. b. A home occupation may include professional offices, small service establishments or offices, or homecrafts which are typically accessory to a dwelling unit. c. A home occupation shall be :tarried on wholly within the main building. No home occupation shall be allowed in detached accessory buildings or garage. d: All home occupation activities in dwelling units of less than 4,000 square feet of total living area, excluding a cellar and attic, shall be conducted by no more than two (2) persons, one of whom shall reside within the dwelling unit. All home occupation activities in dwelling units of 4,000 or more square feet of total living area, excluding a cellar and attic, shall be conducted by no more than three (3) persons, one of whom shall reside within the dwelling unit. e. No structural alterations or enlargement shall be made to the dwelling for the primary purpose of coniucting the home occupation. f. Service occupation shall serve no more than one party per employee at a time and shall not serve groups. g. There shall be no exterior storage of equipment, or supplies associated with the home occupation nor parking of more than one business car, pick - up any truck or small van nor an additional vehicles except.those for permitted employees identified under paragraph d. h. There shall be no detriments to the residential character of the neighborhood due to noise, Odor, smoke, dust, gas, heat, glare, vibration, electrical interference, traffic congestion, number of deliveries, hours of operation, or any other annoyance resulting from the home occupation. i. A home occupation may have an identification sign no larger than two (2) square feet in area which shall not be located -in a required yard. Home occupation for handicapped 'persons that do not meet these conditions may be reviewed by the Board of Zoning Appeals which may modify or waive the requirements a through g. 1 -1 -91 , . . • J , Li . ir :. : .,.y I. .; .,:... ir, . __TI I; \_\___I' I, t L i ' : ' _ ..•' , I 1 kl_ ' i • - - 1 - , : , ,J,• = t. ' .L - -- l' .1,24 7 --"".. ''. --- l' • - ,, - .. . .; , - ', •••••■•;• . : r• ..-.=•,,r-fr•----- i r pli 1 1 .- :'•: *: T: Jr . 1 0- -1.1 r?::1 -- '.-- i II :;- i t-L -_- -h- ---.fr : I t ! 4- ' t., , - . i i'7,1-- . ' • , I 1} ..,c, -. t_-: • . I l --'--p-. L - -- . ' .`_-'` -=-. •--./.:0..- -- [ ---- 1 " 1 - 1 k • I. I :1 :'.. ,.': ' -'• ft-- Ili I'iF I il'=' - I- - I- ''' --- 1- It - .h ' c , = • ‘..• -' ...•-• '..-". _ t... ,...,, 1 4 i I .,1.. _ , l.-J . I .11- ..- . - - -11, „.,..),....-- --:. ..,-,,,, ■ IA . ‘ A ...... ... i • I ..... --.. ' -- - - N ■. 1 " 0 `(- - •RF .r. J ILJLE r j)',ZLIELL'--1C"; 1 - ' . 4.__ — ._ _ 1, L....,, __ . ii • .., • '%. ...,.....,,.. - •- --.: ,...,....,, ^ , L -- -- • ' 1r - 1 ■ ,,_• '. I ----1,-- - R' ,,,, - . - .: •.tr- . , 1 • . - c 'i.• , I, 1! ; !: ibiL ,*--- - ° 'so ''' -- 1 • "-^ ', - ' - - - 1 i - - -. - - In ----- -, 1 . Z. 7 7 - - .7. . . • wa-k-s, ' • ...-- :.= ■ :_::., ,.., .-.. ... . _. _ j7 H.. L.. -. . - 1 L...=_ ,. ___=)1. .. :_ r En_ . --. j . 71 L_—J ■: E:1_" , v .. :.. \ . ,... r •, , ---...--;,- - • !:.1 1' : •?--•,. , -1.- 1 ' ' • • - - ---- ..., i• : - ---- L.' ---- --------.- •-. • •,:.-- ....._ l' .... - 1 . ! I - :. "":. ,:; ; - • II -- r i r - -- am Q.. .; . , - --- - - ..:: - -- .. .1. . ;..-- ...: : - . .• . • : . I?F . ,, _......:n...- - ,........„ - .::...7 , ,7-... , t,-; , ==' , - , r- 1,-- ----1,_ ' - 7 r" --.I L " - ...7 • ;■•■ : : - : , : •• • 1 ' : i re''"''', ' '''''' ' - . • , 1 i t ' t --- - 1 ' ; n ' - '1; , 11 .). • i',: :, ,, I ._=._ „" :•._ . - --.:-:.',' • .. 4: '-- -=,•-• -- '1.,._ /1,.; ... J ii: , .. j 1 0 LE--11:i7.2.-jt,*J---r ___ur --! ,,_,.-' , .,,.. _ • _ 1 ..., • . .., _,,..,.....< , :. 11: ,.....=',..:1 ,.....,_.■ - - 1 0 r r7-771. C...-,- .......... - . - -, j 1 1-- j:._ .... 1.1;11....___JI___J - IN L---1L-. .-16.,,, - I 1 I._ • f.rr _- .1 --,- r i 1 =,...= -7; - - - r - ' !---.. E..::j T..= I [. .. j j 1 . ,,-- .. - 3 . I ,)...".,,,4 : ,.;_=-_—_,...::,.._—..,._-4,1.a.• -711 ( ::-, I . i o l :. ,_. r ) _ ._. , i ., 2 I , 1 etas f,:'. ...... 7 - - b. , - F I: ILi! ' -1- . 1 3 r, ! '-' • :. .. , ,' .: _ 2_..—J l'' ' , ' --- -- " :":- \;_ii. '1 ;' ,. .Ei II Pt • -;.-...-11 ii.!... ' i: '.;-s-: /. • ... - ... :;: - : - :- •• i) ,... ',1 '1' • 1 j .1 _ 1 - ' I 1 . ...."- ./.:1 L__ .,, L _:: ...-. __K _ _ _._ i; ,.. _,.-_.• __, ,, --' -I-. ------ i - !.. 1 -. 1. rik r • r li F;-RF 77 '1E-E:=3w.- - - -- t..',, H- --,- -"..--_--=_-,., ---, L. I ..-....„.. ; ,, , : ,:ii,, L L, F , , , ____, r . ‘.,...• N.f....i i - ‘ I..7 4 - " . •" !1-2" ... e. ";7..- 1 7 .-"' 1-17 ! r17-4-- Ej. __.. - . .. ,....,,,......,... -„_._ .- .:.:_. : _--_';-_- \ *-- -77 - i l--°. Pr 3 it - i' - . ''' .---- A N.)= 7 = - 0 .-- ____,,E--9E= .1; • LL- .:_ L E . .-- it-->.:: i .. i :. ' . I —Fo.,,..4-5 e" -- ,; i -.-- 1-,,, ' ).-- / 1 '.-. ' i - . '' 4 4 : . •• -,4. 1 - I ' . 4- - - t• : . - . . ,- 7.. . : .--; ni _ ErN7 i---. 1 -- - • 7 ..7 ;:- 1 : --4 -- k 1 it -.. I-- _2 i ....\c.____.!e. ..... .2 - -2. -- - 4 rj (i - '4. , :: , _.'" 7 :, i,... !,., - *. ,,. --- .T r T ..:-_--- )r - in __,-,__,_.„-,,,,- ..-.::::::„. , ,„ . , -.•., ...,-,-......,.._ . .„,. ,..„4..- •-,..,..., ,---.....1,-,-_,..-_---:;.--,,.,---%;,-----\\-,z_r--,....-_-: ... ,"1.1 !...k : ,./,. ; F. .• ,. ...._,._........._, . ,_ . n — . -..: - .v. - - -., s., '•,., ,- - 1 --; ' 1 ,,' =- 1 r . r — -,14,_____ \-\,,,‘ : -- ...... 7 - . .. ).• ,.. „,---,---..„,„.. .... . ---- ;:.-..._ ,' .:'''..- / .---,:- ; -', 7- _.:::::,,----,:"--"::-/,--, s.'".,i. 'r ' ^ -- ).\- r----- -......--I - .L=.j■ ,, nr,_.-rfarL--- - ;-,... N:,,--.- _ --:-. } s v . , .4/:.•=7=N- ' .• - .,! '. " , • • `. : 3.; .;:. ' ,-4/,,,--7'17 IE---,----- ,, .- , - ,f ..,- :. . e•-! k.‘..„ --- -^ A . ''..; .F • • ..--../. - 9..- , -----:.-,\ - ‘,41 t.-...-in.-..--' ----.....1------,.___•- ,,, '-------------.- ----.-- =-:=1- , - - . ,....:- . , ...... : ,,,,, ....,,,..s- \.,..,,,,: :,..,---.--... , ... •-_.,.. -- . ... -=--, .:-.1--=.----.- ____,...-■-_-_---":...„ ,. kk t --- _ .7 ,... / . .e''' '‘ ;X: \ \i c : ,.. \ \ : -..7e1, , 4/ s s A ‘") 11 ( ;-- \ \,- (-- -11= --- H ___ _ _ .A\ ",./\<7,, •\e‘k''..S ,';,.... 1 ;f - . ' - L' I ( • eZ =. 7i -_-. - ,__, ...-] ..'.,--,-..,!..., i . .'S• .,..,c ) Ifl ..'-‘:,.....!,,, - ' - : - :„.' '••\, ,. ,\•02 '''''' : _ , i, I.:. ',..:. i - ir , — . . pm --,-- • - ... , . ■____ ', • \-"- s _.,-...,-,'-' - - .• ` !, *. ,, -.....,_2;i---r /.> * >e .(Y‘•<, ,,''' ''' 1 ., „ ..... .. . . --.. - --.......„ . „ „..... ., I ,\) ' ,- '\-•e''''. v. \ ..... ss ---"", ...iil , .... - ....s •■.. / , .. ...... ' ......... • ...,:- . . ...: ..... NV ) ..• ..... .,..:: ' - . . ;..:.% .. • 4 - - • - . ■ '.-:-.,- - , :: , . .. 4 '.. , / • • .1„... . r." - -A ,.. ..• \ , \ \ .,,., ---.... \r" ... : •• • ....;/ \ ...7 t W4 i - - . 4.... •:, 'Z. • DAYTON'S BLUFF DISTRIC ' 4 SCALL on /Cu . aww-i-Ail if 1 Z NING ALE , . , . . _,.... _ . . _ _ )-33 NOTI I E OF PUBLIC HEARING The Saint Paul City Council will c nduct a public hearing on Wednesday, August 3, 1994 at 3:30 p.m. in the City Council C 'ambers, Third Floor, City Hall, to consider the appeal of Julie Magler to the decision of t e Board of Zoning Appeals denying a request to waive the requirements of a home occup tion and allow a home occupation to be conducted in a detached garage, due to a physic. condition, at 1317 East 4th Street (north side between Johnson Parkway and Clarence St et). Date: July 13 1994 Gerry Strathman City Council Secretary NOTICE • PUBLIC HEARING The Saint Paul City Council conduct a public hearing on Wednesday, August 3, 1994 at 3:30 p.m. in the • ty Council Chambers, Third Floor, City Hall. to consider the appeal of ie r to e:decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals den yin request to waive ths#1 home occupation and allow a home occupation to be conducted in e, • ue to a physical condition, at 1317 E. 4th Street (north side betweibt and Clarence Street). Dated July 13, 111p11 GERRY STR4I*4AN. City Council Slarelory (J y 15, 1994) • St. Paul legal tp gr —a IL.. gAl , . t:iraA96.d C ap ZONING FLE 91-)14 a ---7 -- 1 • /3/7 i_.. --ci___, ,71,,./...5- xy::: - /_1_11 s /cze...--7, --, ,4-/. ,....(_(/c)C.., t.:1;:e-:4 61. : --, -- 7 --e ffrc.. ...-Z-9.-z,,ki.,7 .--tc:t )i- ccer.-0.._. 1 , ... , _ 9*--0.3 arm LoAtb4- I') 00iNoz l/-e___ -6,t) ,'Il)A-Q-) - Lb TI t in aoiM lk j fie/ma° V -6P3 °( i - ,/ / //0 Q1 0-6(7 0-/ JO pL4,6io ‘A.- f to - &&iit640-o (712 ,i)/O 0 ' / . If t i " ' ' - ' tua , -) P i 'd 6 I 01 77)1// 0') d ' 404 WO 06 I i 1 ) . - S - tAIL.e sr d 4 , 1,60,k/n - t i- 4/21,/ ' bate 9---)-k& o-ai o-6/ -L(, cdk 1 -0-0 I ML L IA-k er e N i t JA JYL cow aoa& 1 .° • ufi-o , ii 0 1 n 0, cOikeJ cA va up : • 0 f ' , j Op am., --(/-L ,61 mcdix.2_,- u - i ff Lb (,g --6,' 1 ' cob-pN 0016 • a J 0140 s i - • , , 'R,Di2ziof2- u-oke) - Lb i ' - -- OW/7) e I JO 0 earl culap volm ; I.Q i C l , � J 1'� GAD Lac (Ivy C�'� II 0 , k_ c/04) l/�� g - ✓sue, � 31s E 1- 'iN S ' ►fi but > ran P) 7-) ZONING FILE 94-IyY- 9/33 , Z 0 N__1_N_ _ G _ ____F_11 El 1 . . . . . .. . ,,i,.. j . . . . . .. :.;.7 A :.- . 0-:, 41 7 Li _ 1 4 ci . . / 1 , • . ip .- . .. ._. ,. (..._ . /9 r . ... ,,, , .: . ,.. _....,,.,..:, / , _ _..... , .... ,... ,.. _____. A _ • - - •,...... - j''' , .., -, . ) b 1 / � [�riLi�QJ s 7 -- i,..„2 - __ F I . -..... .--... cl■ A– / - . � r d j • • - ' 44111 �� /. i • �� , i „;. i f i — t- r - - { . . b y c • t h. .- �r ii''' .^. ® / : - .- v t { - 1 s • yl i , is !: ':1 A. 4A ®.. L ∎ • w . ,.•...,,,,..„, ,.,._,,litin 10 -,s .,...,„.............. . - . 1 ..., .....„ .„..„...„ ,:,,,., ..... .9,-,. ,... „Q. y - „„- ... ; - �:.. ` �` .:`a-a . '' . ' 0 . s 4- 4 �'t.X �iwO / '5 *::' .. -. f r t I 'k'S= � � , •• :%'{' 4t ir2.�� "'Xiti xi"�t .� i / � +s.Y<'r .' 'ic ` -,;. rii.r y ' 7 ; 'ri'%� 'y ,. „F {rs3{",f �q.,cfa.._y 4x 3r ` t _ ..T'.il'# ' .••- r. ... ,ls ta c- `5f ..,1 - ,, •$ S i'W, �� t,.. i t ' l sy.r > - H Tar `s ' ` = � - f _ 3 .. r Fri ' _. s. . y , 3t' �' �g *. r..,,vs. � o - 7- 4A ` � ' :. �� • / � Y / `° t, I `41 t , .' .Lev 4'3% z' `. ® I / /- . . . .,..a. `6 "N- ,s r ' y t x ,,, 4'f , - z - . l+'9 s . .'. ,.... N..- „ t r f 4. .+* — w+ r r �z w -- 4 .`` s � ' �' } 'i` .. zli v ' z. " d J 3 r " F x -#: . a '°� r�C � r � eti L '�GC n • tr 3 � t ti y at +? ` � r- li� ar "� . yl �'�, l .. ,., � .7 ....��•• + per► } r � T,r $ -o . t x- , ,. ir..14 4:48. ,. L , e7„.::: `l ox �� .-.7 � M .eaf` 5}i7;r,t_. I I q /q - J; 3 1 ZONING FILE 9'1 ILI ± 1 r - — /Art . A— L .�� . f I L • L i1 i `t Jif / L / / :__ I�� ' � a �L ✓.I / L L J../ - • ( , _ . 1 I /L .. td `4 — L_.‘ _ - - - - -- - - - - - -- e...—.... — k 1-/ 3 y �, C .r r , '- ; : ea F. o!; '_4 , : ` _ � / � = , 3, - M/ ?^� - 4 s "+i :e ^7 e at a f r /7 y '.-. .c,,,-• ' 1i . ..� i/ LL l� ' / tz ' :_ ' . _ -- a a - • . / ,'' >` Y r / -1 � _ _ f� _ _ j '* t ,:, =�,.. ,,, y " d -`)� .rte ' 1_ 'ks. • ' . — . ,, riw; � tgs j . :0:4, {�'Yt• y. . ''1 Y' A 4. • ? e , C;1 , Y e '-.'7,-,,,N,'":" 3 / „,,,,:1,,,,...„--,..;.../ ,. £ p ; L •.".:;,p _ 4 - . • - 8 ck •N -•*1 •v` c tii!S w -i ' k '''.41 ^fi Y � A...4.___46-4.:-..r_ : ' � ac y + -. t. '\ w `.. 'aS r. 1�•�t - '$3 - R�' - 4 +Cs a i'4i d +i-”' �tp.['" -. ' � • �' e ' r •y t Y .;, n 3 , �i. S �ti'y. Y f ' may :4' I Lt/� . a ..,/ ! L �[ /�L I .. rs 5 :t ∎,, r > t 'C� J- 'r .yAa :...001,r-....q , r ,r `• - - � st ' t� Jgj��ys b .-"'.. . -... a , -9. ,�i•a 1 ..1-4. a li7` � �t ' - 1 ` '. .. . ''' .:d' C t '"}ir#3.`k ' ' ' ,., ' 3"Y�„ F 1 `.3 ^7.�� - F , . , ; , 1,t , , T S A : - s`,17 �. Y • �� ®) r- - . l ` , z t ,� 1 ,qtr x - , r� l 0.:.-A''' ' �+^ "." y' " « • - -- ,1,,+1 ..' 1= tt {"' T � ^ 0 r '' 3 ' Y -.* sr, " Y `` T � i ! . 1, _ . .r ar C•t -t5 ".4 ° II' r•; - rl ` � 7i `' t - 4 : 4 ,, � � , ' fh ,�' s , 4 . ;s. '''-'.-:-,,,...,z 1 :m,,�,,y• s1''t � A,3 i+t s u. M 4 #- c - ..yt v' $," • . ..„_ .e Ts ^S i , � r y; y V � t :... } , �� 7 F ,t : *s ■ . ii a 1Lvu� Sc;.+.� F'3 *+.'- ;.Mit'i ..ti wat.:� SZist .S � - r`� . v4. `� :.:: ' .1.>:.a -- �;:, .. _. ■ ' 1 )-33 ZONING FILE 941-1 1 1 • - , Y ® / // / / i / . i / ,d1111 _ - - _ LL L. /�_' - ��/ M6. . r • / _ � — - ��= ' 'aril � i -s.At AWOL -IL/A. ------ / , � � > 1 a I_ ` r .'.? Z;'1....=-;.‘";',----7:` Wit, 4 _. .r e� �� / / _/ L� - :° • ya , ..`l ; . , ' , +S'rt i-`.1 �' r•�. ` / .y„T " � ''C - q '� - f4 rs 3 t - - `v+R tea,,, - � ,� - '. ' „3, : - . `: , -,. -- G %� -- 1 1 • � J C , . a, w 5... .i ▪ ys r ' ' r 'i .� " , r -,- , F i' S t• f,, Y °''� >:1 l'.J. r tt +' - r 1 •'S� `5 :. i •', j1 . ,: ,y� v .:-_ S' .3 ,i- + �'^4 .`l t . -. t • Y r ' ;', 4 yh _ i t f r .' _Y/ . ;. / r " r t v d ` ' Y `� } u• - - - - --- 'rn ;- ' v .... 4+ r , ., , . , ..r - ., ', v / v€. , '. :e � _, �- _, } ,�;t' ‘;‘,:::::.'-..1.,:.- - • v� y xt -g t• v a £.9 li tb8 ® - w . ,®` �',� ; - i A r. ✓ T i' ,7-,....,t, e • . _'a "` :. '.4 a, 1 3 „ ' � ,Y;., .{ .1.... , k' x :-..,4,41, .a 'i' r t 4e• v 5- ' , s.9; t ','4 . �r - _ 1 / a �� r.� te a; . . -- _ .. sY t °i ..e - � � � s 4. fi +r i . „ . I ' 't _ r�1.6', =n sV'6 x a�Y.'t: .*SisAl' '=ct- •- % ?� .r x s .. c bY - � P” � J S " - am " '°4 ' -< r •t ,4.o e � � a fr. kh ,. iL � tr } . . •-n .,. • _5 . �� * r kik. A: ra. �*.af� s3'` afi ..:At.- .3X.. r:'*tf�-.YS ..s 4 .vd.: - '�5. 5 - , � � .. i r r � � A.4 - .w Irr' ..tg.,.v "- -•' ..:,..?,%.:. "" '� tw'C .c g f� . ' t" w - v , '' 4 i. . - r .v. 1 "' 4 O .5,a .� t �`'. ,dcA ., v t 4'.1.., 1 • r x �_ :I' ' a +rc. e=s., x' rl:. .:+ nr ». `° ! s ���g� R < .:tiStR � ��y