Loading...
94-1109 ORIGINAL Council File # / /v9 Green Sheet # 2 ?3( ESOLUTION CI OF INT PAUL, MINNESOTA 9a- Presented By 4 1 _ 4 Referred To Committee: Date 1 2 RESOLVED, that the Intoxi , ating Liquor On Sale, Restaurant, Gambling 3 Location, and Sunday On Sale Liqu + r licenses, I.D. No. 19509, held by G -Brud, Inc. dba 4 Starting Gate, for the premises at 2 16 West Seventh Street in Saint Paul are hereby 5 suspended for a period of fourteen 14) consecutive days; and be it 6 7 FURTHER RESOLVED, t ot seven (7) of those days' suspension is hereby 8 stayed for a period of 18 months, u on the condition that there being no further 9 violations by the licensee, and upon the following two express conditions which shall 10 continue for all of the above licens:•.. for the licensed premises so long as they shall be 11 held by Dean Gubbrud, G -Brud, In ., or any person, firm or corporation in which Dean 12 Gubbrud shall have an interest: 13 14 1. Dean Gubbrud shall unde go drug and alcohol assessment and treatment, if he 15 has not already done so, and shall cooperate fully in such assessment and 16 treatment. 17 18 2. Dean Gubbrud, for as lon ;; as he shall hold these licenses or have any interest 19 in such licenses, shall be an ctive and participating member of Alcoholics 20 Anonymous for both alcohol and drug treatment, and shall attend weekly 21 meetings of such organizatio while he holds such licenses or has any interest in 22 them. 23 24 and be it 25 26 FURTHER RESOLVED, t at the seven (7) day suspension shall commence on 27 the fourth Sunday following Counc action in this matter, to wit, Sunday, August 14, 28 1994, at 12:01 a.m. and continue th ough Saturday, August 20, 1994, at 11:59 p.m.; and 29 be it 30 31 FURTHER RESOLVED, t i at to the extent this penalty is a deviation from the 32 presumptive penalty in Section 409 6 of the Legislative Code, it is based on the reasons 33 specified in the written recommen . ition made by the Office of the City Attorney on 34 behalf of the Director of LIEP. 35 36 This Resolution and the act e n taken above are, in addition, based upon the facts 37 contained in the Notice of Violatio dated May 2, 1994, the facts in the stipulation and 38 police reports furnished to the Co cil for its deliberations in this matter, and all of the 39 other documents in the materials p ovided to the Council as part of this agenda item. 40 The facts as outlined in the notice, stipulation and police reports are not contested by 41 the licensee. The action taken is also based on the facts, circumstances and arguments 42 presented by and on behalf of the icensee during the public hearing. 43 ORIGINAL Ye Nays Abyent Requested by Department of: Blakey Harris Grimm Guerin := , Me Re tman / mune By: . , `��� Form Approved by City Attorney Adopted by Council: Date 6,eri Adoption Certified:by'Council Secretary B : . By: `• , L: - ' ... .,- Approv Mayor for Submission to � �� re Counc' Approved by k= o ate / / / By: f� By. • y: 4 / 29E: / 4/" ? DEPARTME OFFICE/COUN DATPINITIATED "° 2 8 0 3 City Council, 7 _2 .! (31 SHEET CONTACT PERSON & PHONE L_.;.1 DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR !ALlDATE CITY COUNCIL Council'tnember- Barris rr 1 CITYATTORNEY Q CITY CLERK IRSMIER FOR MUST BE ON COUNCIL AGENDA BY (DATE) totem ❑ BUDGET DIRECTOR, D FIN. & MGT. SERVICES DIR. DATER 0 MAYOR (OR ASSISTANT) TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIONATUREE) ACTION REQUESTED: Finalize City Council adverse ac -ion taken on July 20, 1994, pertaining to licenses held by Starting Gate, .516 West Seventh Street: RED: Approve (A) or Reject (R) PERSONAL SERVICE CONTRACTS MUST •AINWiIR THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS: PLANNING COMMISSION CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION 1. Has this pinion/firm ever Worked under a sOntraet tor this department? _ CIS COMMITTEE YES NO 2 Has MIS person/Ent *vat bent a City employe.? STAFF YES NO DISTRICT COURT ._ _ 3 Does•thls persoiJfIrrn possess p skill not normally possessed by any current city :employee? SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? YES NO teapiain all y.$• answers on $ parsto sheet and attach to grain shoot INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNITY (Who, What, When, Where, Why) ADVANTAGES IF APPROVED: DISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED: DISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION If COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO FUNDING SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER FINANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN) f OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Timothy E. Mara City Attorney FsA[Nr 1 1 log P A U L CITY OF SAINT PAUL Civil Division Norm Coleman, Mayor 400 City Hall Telephone: 612 266-8710 15 West Kellogg Blvd. Facsimile: 612 298 -5619 E A A A A Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 orrimmr Council snit Center June 28, 1994 JUN 2 8 1994 Joseph J. Dudley, Jr. Dudley and Smith 101 E. Fifth Street NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Suite 2602 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55111 Re: Licenses of the Start ng Gate — QS %(o `� • `1 ��` S Dear Mr. Dudley: Please take notice that a hearing concerning the above - mentioned establishment has been sc eduled for 3:30 p.m., July 20, 1994, in the City Council Chambers Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed please find a cop of the materials that will be submitted for the consideration o the City Council. This will be an uncontested hearing, base• on stipulated facts, police reports, and other documentation. Very truly yours, 1)6;(1 ) (1141- Philip B. Byrne Assistant City Attorney cc: (w /o enclosures) Robert Kessler, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIEP Lt. Nancy DiPerna, SI Nancy Anderson, Counc l Secretary Gayle Summers, C.O. Highland Area Commu ity Council 1978 Ford Parkway Saint Paul, Minneso a 55116 qq 1109 • OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Timothy E. Mara City Attorney SAINT P A U L CITY OF SAINT PAUL Civil Division Alt Norm Coleman, Mayor 400 City Hall Telephone: 612 266-8710 15 West Kellogg Blvd Facsimile: 612 298 -5619 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 AAAA w July 8, 1994 Joseph J. Dudley, Jr. Dudley and Smith 101 E. Fifth Street NOTICE OF COUNCIL HEARING Suite 2602 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55111 Re: Licenses of the Starting Gate Dear Mr. Dudley: Please take notice that hearing concerning the above - mentioned establishment has been sc eduled for 3:30 p.m., July 20, 1994, in the City Council Chamber-, Third Floor, Saint Paul City Hall and Ramsey County Courthouse. Enclosed please find a copy of the materials that will be submitted for the consideration •if the City Council. This will be an uncontested hearing, base' on stipulated facts, police reports, and other documentation. Very truly yours, 1/ ; Philip Byr Assistant City Attorney cc: (w /o enclosures) Robert Kessler, LIEP Christine Rozek, LIE Lt. Nancy DiPerna, S AJ fancy Anderson, Coun•il Secretary Gayle Summers, C.O. Council Research Center Highland Area Comm nity Council 1978 Ford Parkway JUL 11 1994 Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 __ter 9t-tt - i ti o4 UNCONTESTED LICENSE HEARING Licensee Name: Starting Gate Bar Address: 2516 West Seventh Street Date: July 20, 1994 Violation: Please see Notice of Violation letter, dated May 2, 1994, for specific violations Date: January 2, 1994 Time: Approximately 3:00 p.m. Place: Licensed premises Matrix Presumptive Penalty: Section 409.26(b)(1) calls for revocation for the "commission of a felony related to the licensed activity." No other penalty applies. Recommendation by Assistlxnt City Attorney on behalf of client, Office of License Inspections and Environmental Protection (if any): Two weeks's suspension, with one week stayed for a period of 18 months, and compliance with the conditions specified in the Stipulation. Downward departure is based (1) on the fact of the similarity of this case with Wallace's Westsider Bar, and the penalty imposed in that case; (2) on the fact that the licensee has sought and will remain in a alcohol and drug treatment as long as he holds a license; and (3) on the fact that it appears he 14as not a drug dealer, using the licensed premises for the sale of drugs, but rather was principally a dependent user. Attachments 1. Proposed resolution 2. Stipulation 3. Police reports 4. License informat_on 5. Letter of license or attorney agreeing not to contest the fact$ 6. Notice of Violation Q� -- I] STIPULATION OF FACTS On January 2, 1994, a search warrant was executed at the premises of the Starting Gate Bar. Dean O. Gubbrud was arrested by the police for possession of controlled substances, including cocaine and marijuana, discovered in a basement room of the bar which he used, and to which he had the keys and gave them to the police for the p rpose of the search. Those substances were determined to be cocaine and rijuana. As indicated in the police reports, the room also contained drug p. aphernalia. The foregoing violates state law, and furnish a basis for advers- action under Sections 310.06(b)(6), (7) and (10), and 409.06(c). In addition, gambling paraph: rnalia was found on the licensed premises. Undercover officers had previosly observed Gubbrud gambling on the licensed premises, and a pen register t ereafter placed on the bar telephone indicated calls in furtherance of such g. •ling. This violates Section 409.08(6) of the Saint Paul Legislative Code. he foregoing matters also constitute grounds for adverse action against al j the licenses held for that premises. The attached police reports c•rroborate the foregoing and are a part of the record upon which disciplinar action may be taken by the Council. The licensee does not contest these facts, and the facts contained in the police reports to the extent t ey prove the foregoing matters. The foregoing reports do not show, and the icensee does not admit to, the felony offense of sports bookmaking. The licensee does not contest the facts that show he was in possession of cocaine and marijuana as indicated above and in the police reports. Based on the foregoing, an the attached police reports, it is the recommendation of the licen -e office that the City Council impose a suspension of all licenses fora period of two weeks, of which one week would be stayed for a period of 18 m•nths. The recommendation of the license office is also that this license sha l be further conditioned for as long as Dean Gubbrud shall hold the licens:s for the sale of alcoholic beverages or have any interest in said license,lby the following express conditions: 1. Dean Gubbrud shall undergoldrug and alcohol assessment and treatment, if he has not already done so, a • shall cooperate fully in such assessment and treatment. 2. Dean Gubbrud, for as long as he shall hold these licenses or have any interest in such licenses, s all be an active and participating member of Alcoholics Anonymous for both alcohol and drug treatment, and shall attend weekly meetings of such organ'zation while he holds such licenses or has any interest in them. In the event that the Cit Council does not accept this case as an uncontested matter, and dire•ts that it be heard by an administrative law judge, neither party will, be bound by any of the agreements or representations herein. The 1;icense office may use the facts in the police reports and such other evide ce as may be available, but will not use the agreements of the licensee no his lack of contest of certain facts against the licensee. - 0, NV) S . PAUL POLICE DEPARTMENT .: SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT ❑ CON NUATION OF: ❑ ORIGINAL REPORT ❑ SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Date & Time of Report Off 'nse /Inadent Time of Arrest 01/03/94 Po - C.S. /Unlawful Gambling • NARRATIVE.:;.. : Arrest Number - Last Name First Middle Address DOB Age Sex Race Based on information p ovided by a confidential reliable informant ._(CRI), I initiated :n investigation into unlawful gambling activities on or about October 11, 1993. The target of the inve- tigation was a person identified as GUBBRUD, DEAN OTTO, d.���.b. 05/03/52. CRI stated that GUBBRUD owns the STARTING GATE BAR located at 2516 West Seventh Street, St. Paul and that GUBBRUD Iegularly conducts sports bookmaking at this location. Through the License 'vision of L.I.E.P., City of St. Paul I confirmed that GUBBR ei holds a current business license for 2516 West Seventh Street under the name G -RUD INC. and lists himself as president under licens- ID #19509. Based on the information furnished by the CRI, I, along with Special Agent WILLIAM', THOMPSON, Minnesota Department of Public Safety, Gambling Enfo• cement Division . did, on 10/14/93 enter the STARTING GATE BAR i an undercover capacity. z 0 0 0 - On 11/15/93 I obtaine. A District Court order from Ramsey County District Court for aut ority to install a pen register on 612-693 - 5911 and other telephs.ne numbers subscribed to the STARTING GATE BAR. The pen registe. was activated on 11/19/93. Through pen register t pes it was determined that calls were placed Texas Sportsline a 639 -1119; The Scoreboard at 825 -6222 and - := Scores at 339 - 339 on days when college and /or professional Assisting Officer : Emp. No - - - Reporting Officer. Emp. No.: Sgt. D. Cavanaugh 100980 Report Reviewed By/Unit Commander. Emp. No.: O.T„ , yp s , R•O» Code: `� ame Entry: DYes CI No 1 - \ . HF. ❑ Hom: • • ❑ Rob ❑ Jtry ❑ Coord ❑ ID MI (Rec CI - ❑ Sex ❑ Rptr ❑ Other ❑ D/c ; C 394 Q Theft ❑ Prop ❑ CAU ❑ Fd.F • Auto ❑ DAO ❑ CO . ❑ HumSery , * ?M 622.92R • • • t A oNTINUE NARRATIVE HERE '" � 1 0 r • football games were be ng played. These are local services. and = provides informati•in such as "lines", i.e., point: spreads "on sports events, player 'njury reports, scores on games.in. progress and' final scores. _ _ On 12/31/93 I drafted •wo search warrants. The first warrant was for DEAN GUBBRUD and he STARTING GATE BAR, 2516 West Seventh Street, St. Paul and tie second warrant for DEAN GUBBRUD and his residence, 1115 Elway •,.artment 402, St. Paul as well as two motor vehicles which register -d to GUBBRUD: 503 BAL, a 1985 Olds and 489 HZS, a 1983 AUDI. Both warrants were pres,nted to and signed by District Court Judge J. CAMPBELL on 12/31/91. At or about 1500 hrs., 01/02/94, executed search warrant on 2516 West Seventh Street. Assisting with the wa rant was: Lt. RON RYAN, Commander, SIU; Sergeant P. TREDAL, SI ; Sergeant G. KUEHL, SIU and Special Agent WILLIAM THOMPSON. Squad 426, Officer D. ABEL and Squad 450, Officer W. GILLET also assisted. When we entered, I obse GUBBRUD standing at the bar, talking to a customer. There wer= approximately 20 -30 customers present. I approached GUBBRUD ani identified myself and told him I was executing a search war ant and handed him a copy of the warrant. I then asked GUBBRUD ii he would ask the customers to leave so as to expedite the search and avoid any contamination of the search site. GUBBRUD compile.; and the patrons left. Allowed to stay was . an employee/bartender: HOLISKY, JEFFREY JAMES, d.o.b. 12/02/66, • 2228 Stewart, ph: 696 --207. At this time, G :BRUD appeared to be under the influence /intoxicated. I: searched GUBBRUDS p --rson and recovered $470.00 cash which I recorded on the invent.ry. - -Sergeant TREDAL turned over to me a black carrying case which he recovered from the base ent. The following items were inventoried from this case: _ • t a • 2 °' 2 S . PAUL POLICE DEPARTMENT y- - l 1 O • �) SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT © CON i NUATION OF: ❑ ORIGINAL REPORT © SUPPLEMENTAL REPOR Date & Time of Report Off _'nse /Incident: Time of Arrest 01/03/94 Pots C.S. /Unlawful Gambling NARRATIVE. Arrest Number Last Name First Middle Address DOB Age Sex Race - water soluble pa p eer - Pager MINN COMM 538 -4767 - various slips of paper with numbers recorded - various sheets o paper with names, addresses and phone #'s - piece of cardboa d with address label to ROBERT PANNO and a return address of a company that manufactures water soluble paper Also turned over to me for inventory were the following: - Vehicle inspection report on 503 BAL, recovered from GUBBRUDS vehicle by Special Agent THOMPSON. From the basement area -5 separate amoun s of case and checks as follows 1. $1,000. ash 2. $ 705. ash; 3 checks for $30.; $30. and $35•. 3. $ 300. 'ash 4. $ 100. ash; 2 checks for $20. and $30. 5. $ 442. sash; 5 checks for $25.;$50.;$25.;$15.;$100. - 1 mirror with su -pect cocaine residue -1 bong -1 bag suspect ma ijuana and seeds - 1 white tube - 1 sifter - 1 razor blade -1 spoon -1 bag suspect co aine - 1 white plate o -2 bags of trash • From cash drawers ta from two cash registers and two cash drawers -taken from a s :fe inside the office area: 0 - $747. cash and check for $20: °o • V From the office area: - letter addressee to MICHAEL MUNZEN - letter addressee to DEAN GUBBRUD - NSP bill yellow sheet wi h numbers __ Assisting Officer. Emp. No.: Reporting Officer. \‘, Emp. No.: Sgt. D. Cavanaugh 100980 Report Reviewed By/Unit Commander. Emp. No.: O.T.: Typist R.O. Code: same Entry: • ❑Yes ❑ No ❑ CHF ❑ Hom ❑ Rob ❑ Juv ❑ Coord ❑ ID 1I Lab ❑ Rec ❑ Team ❑ Sex ❑ Rptr ❑ Other ❑ INC ❑ Bury ❑ Theft ❑ Prop ❑ CAU ❑ F &F 111 Auto ❑ DAO ❑ CO ❑ HumSery P M 622.92R { r y ONTINUE NARRATIVE HERE l 1 /Q When we first entered aid prior to GUBBRUDS arrest, GUBBRUD stated he is the sole owner of the STARTING GATE BAR and that he rents the building from MICHAEL ZEN (deceased). GUBBRUD identified the black case recovered from the basement as belonging to him but d -nied ownership of its contents. GUBBRUD stated he uses the b- sement area but denied knowledge of any suspect cocaine. GUBBRis did however identify the money recovered from the basement as we-kend bar receipts. • GUBBRUD was advised tha a search warrant would be executed at his residence and he provi•ed us with keys to his'apartment so as to make entry. After the cocaine was 1.cated I informed GUBBRUD that he was under arrest for possession o» controlled substance and felony gambling violation(s). I then advised GUBBRUD of miranda which he stated he understood. GUBBRUD then stated h: wanted an attorney present during any questioning. No furthe, questions were asked of GUBBRUD. GUBBRUD was given a copy of the inventory and transported for booking by Officer GILL T. Refer to CN 94 000 797. .. = 4 , r 3 v t .. q C I" ..- // 7 r / S :. PAUL POLICE DEPARTMENT LS LO O t 6 iiii page ___1� ( GENERAL REPORT 1111111111111111111111111111 – Day Month Date Year Time: Squad: Team: OHen : I ( 2. QC/ if: a0 1 7 p a- sw r'c Cis sr-0. t r Class: Location of Cali: Location of Crime Scene: '1!"� Time of Arrest: i q I u--' z S/ . w .— 7 Time & Date of O ccurrence: Bus. Phone: Home Phone: Occurred ❑ At ❑ Between: hrs. on and RECEIVED Complainant's Name (Last, First, Middle): • '.dress: APR 2 1994 Articles Recovered: Disposition: ❑ Records ❑ Crime Lab Locker J (( -\ El Crime Lab ❑ Property Room et c Q � ) ��� �` i�'7",�l �'} F t°'l� ( NARRATIVE �, r ; " 1 Arrest Number Last Name First Middle Address DCB Age Sex Race 1 ossis tc•d w 4 t"A e smock- 6.4 waeAA .,.. -/ 4 f t4, ‘4.4 ,.f% vL1 G.th 64r i 2S'/4 (.J . , 7- , &..7e"ft.- !,) e e Ift t .. �c ) ov14 Wi s c c i r e oe t' s �9 a :17 4.4)c...,..04- /s^• "tt bAI ci. cs�✓ t, +.1. Seba✓'0-4• ,- ( .1 -Peke i d Ce d la e I (01%., y / be 1% et c.a t o f 'L a I 10 sot /01 Iae.40 h k •• Co eK s file e. f' sue+ d a 7 00, 9 4.-, 71, c t o ai d c. s afro "6 X. of ve N o fa 7'7'0... f r e la > toll 7`e 9 0 .'S, ` /�'�- S 2 _ / . 6a0/ t 4c L ... , %e* f isAft. loop Z .1 ( e litJ i f t' i 1 G e / 6As • iM Gam. - hord Ca'u m-a9/ SGvt &k/ /oelsa/ coos -.r , 7 .c td' G 4 Se ...IA./ / t)« fi GIB tit ey f to L c vivo.,, 0 , 4. e , A I. e kV, < 4110•1-e ■••■ •‘‘.., . O., k c_ y i r...... (, O 1 4 • j ^ ✓'e 64 r' vt ea to 7ze b afe w, coil /0 ace/ eho rot W t .S 7 Gv -c !c h Got .t �a Ir La -• Sel le' et• '�e f -e 1 a r dr/o- ' 4.)A 4 sApi 1/ - gc / #t,. GA to, o z e % des I- 44s $ a s A // /o e l col -race \ G k -e UT CC t 4-"Gyl a Clrsi r•h o4 f e" et", v Cl u I /ell ' c ‘ o . . - /A s' /r �4 t b, X w Al �l r, / r, Ca.: I H 0( 0 r C a cot. • li /"'/f � /. -e e 4 Assisting Officer. Emp. No.: Reporting te / Emp. No.: • _ re /, 6 gf 2 • sGo Report Reviewed By: � Emp. No.: OS.: i r Typist R.O.: —, Code: ••ame Entry: ❑Yes ❑ No I ° ❑ Hom ❑ Rob ❑ Juv • • • , 1 ID Rec ❑ Team ❑ Sex ❑ Rptr 0 Other ` .i : _ D /C ❑ Burg ❑ Theft ❑ Prop ❑ • ❑ F &F Auto DAD 9C0 HumSery =kit 621.92R y I� • Ali CONTINUE NARRATIVE HERE 9 - ir C I 11! in a4A J ee-dr a // G 0 If,. Q /�j � !/� s V h •i O -I )ei '' , �'a l t0 f.1-1 C0 H 1 / !" - e k 4 w L c p tit. &- a 7-4..c f /i ctc was Ay-, 0C-04/ }C4 a N/ Gu, I seed:. 17,...e - a-k. �.aH t G &C.ICA l ' �..eg. 1-- af..,f, . .L 4,1. �•,. 4 ' - e e 4 O X w•.) il 4 a bCe., s !l-t ic.r i j 4.4.4% a / tot 1 , •ati Z L 4 c/00 A. 1 011A J fwG bG f . a e a-ON-AA-1 ' PI t td 444 I c - G.s,1 r� T G fe ei- -Ekas4 t4 •cf wA S a /7 w /, •roeo,i . 60 4 t drm, Pa - -e j .f d li . Ot>• (,)a // S4 tlr w s 4 0-t el-4 / Col. d, 7 04' fit b oX a vrt i N6 , es tCc W., i rr v . t.,+ o f 4 ea"- oa 6 tide, w L!' i ! - t - ;A 4 eJ S 60h .r k i p 1 r es, `drt r A,., t if, • roi c t vc ees O/ 47/4, SIP-co. . 1 e e e e c l ,- t 0 i tie do- At, ✓'cA/ c. - 1 - t-44- . t Gw- d t m 4- H -eel f"4 ta., c h f o t o e e i 0, c (a - ra h Ci /f ‘ cx of/h-, , • � s kZe' • d P'9' S PAUL POLICE DEPARTMENT �'i V . 1; SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT 111 CONTI UATION O : ❑ ORIGINAL REPORT ❑ SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Da e & Time of - port: ( AMIFIFI or 0 3 ? . NARRATIVE.. , . Arrest Number Last Name First Middle Address DOB Age Sex Race ( /4./i le Ci.5 /reil 0 j*■fk'S.0 c2c2 CA-4-4/.14,6 S t M. V•-- i ' 5 /_ c. - 01 ^ - s ,I 5/“. Z � „ Z S-`G w, 7 t _ 0 -.....:.... _ . a-4... Se s.-4-4:EJ . C.Q . A,1 ---- k.) "t 1 4,...,,,..-f_4E..........._ t...-,,,„... -r.12_t . _ (.....,..4_ze Vie A. ii 016:5-0-4617- . • ` .. eQ (3-4-.4.4...4.-1-■-11■- dip_ •- i 4 0001Cm"....■ /1041.111:16."■74L. . 41.1:4..41. 41tt" , o* . lit ' /• may_' eµ•ertiL. U.1: . i A. ttle‘Y, 4 4 - C:14 =,.. ., _ , , ' c m...A_ ••• 0 :0***... er 1 ` • ■a... k S 0 -P-;:.2"-Q .' 2 S'74 7 S totc0404400 Li j.ai.4...a... '' 1 art.arii",.... si.".---0 ' °..111.4#4114 0 • •. L.60"0 • • V 0 L.., gal . , +" . a_ ,J tsK Q.•4..�. / ,.rte - "l 4 ....-4. - .4., ......J. - _ - IIIM (........o .1 : cli sr" - - ' 42-4 4 r 0 Assisting • cer• ililliiih '41M1# mp. No.: :: . i i i i i iii i i i a T o i rg h. 1 Emp. No.: O.T.: . •e: Name Entry: 1 1 . :.T Yes ❑ No r: - l O CHF ❑ Hom ❑ Rob ❑ Juv ❑ ... . 0 ID s' ❑ D/C ❑ Burg ❑ Theft ❑ Prop U ❑ F&F ❑ uto ❑ DAO ❑ CO ❑ Sex ❑ Rptr ❑Other ❑ ❑ HumSery .M 622•92R ^ ONTINUE NARRATIVE HERE 9tf- - 11 9 • ,., _. .01 6 " 6 " . 4L 40 114 .. XL....¢sL t 4 ' l -Y�.�- o , `. LJ.r O•� 0► • a I _ i / ...e , _4 44._%_:_ ...:%. , -. - _"" - , ,.. -. d.z.p -�. ` 1 . _ - coo ile...4.....kr 7-12....* • 41.412'neo■Ly GJ•wo'"t-LX C:1;#14'."'"rs • Cio.--k-L , • , ci...a-c2---tili ciza.4-4-- 1 , . . 0.......-.4. 1 e (-4.)- c3-10--J--- ..�:e . ice -... ,7-saf%.„..._ Gitazti,. ,..it......... . . .. ,,,9 i..t,„, „...N- ......,•,,,..c." 4‘......_ • --�,�. , .a... L 'J '" /f /s- , • - <: (bo) rte It ti6i IIJ hE h h Mif Y ... otc,_ -floc? P °4° / a i S PAUL POLICE DEPARTMENT . V SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT — CONTI UATION OF: ❑ ORIGINAL REPORT ❑ SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Date & Time of Report Off - 'se /Incident: Time of Arrest: y 12 ! 0 5° / — ( 4 9 jf Cif NARRATIVE Arrest Number Last Name First Middle Address DOB Age Sex Race Go e DA.r.i 'C 4 4 SeAtro•4 O c C4 e <S tot kt 7 2 A-vi 7 , / a .e• Z c v Ac/ d e et... Al t 4. t G64 gt. ✓• e ix,-eot es. A /es. r 'ot is r e D v v1 4 t c . - e, ,9 P f-- ,4 /at f fi4 f Z 0 / f r of 4 s 1 'f'vt t. • t t./'t 1 t ear • 4. R(ii" et , u, - Ec s # ef & A.4 4'. a !r c oi I Q J [ r COLA 4t. f - e 4 z ft. e`, s ea (-e0/ 4< Cm's 4 .'h a 144f ..ems / , V e !dr .e GL /t H'H e, ! ' 74 1 h *6 S 7 e pPe 0 to -1 moo,,,, s 14-c...... for ( , J • • 0 z • t O a ([ Assisting Officer. mp. No.: Reporting Offi- =r. i mp. No.: ■ A /....f < ✓ 2 - f`00 Report Revi =w- •0:y /Unit ?• r' • er. mp. No.: O.T.: Typist R.O.: , Code: tierce Entry: 1 ['Yes ❑ No D CHF ❑ Hom ❑ Rob ❑ ■ oord ❑ 10 ❑ - • d Rec ❑ Team ❑ Sex OR ptr `'❑ Other ❑ D/C ❑ Burg ❑ Theft ❑ P AU ❑ F&F ❑ uto ❑ DAO ❑ CO ❑ HumSery _ • Yv\ •'N 622 -92R ,., . l q4.-lloc? P ( or _, S PAUL POLICE DEPARTMENT . SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT CONT UATION OF: ❑ ORIGINAL REPORT ❑ SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Date & Time of Report Offe s In 'dent: Time of Arrest: rV I — y - Fy ss C S NARRATI E Arrest Number Last Name First Middle Address DOB Age Sex Race {{ 1...,..3 ded� > v'eAliZep 114.7 "767 / p `t a l24J( t•441 r f a v1"-eo' /ti ' Z'4 .r px will.) 4 y 7 0 9 - 0 s Cob. 7 SI cP g ot v 4 o, a 44 4 "—A/ Z w ei. / 1 - C - L c -E. L * I G..- .rid e ad -e,✓ - E - i� -01' s ‘ 1 't K,' h " `' lot o f t ?c't H.. r . .2` t,, t4 t a or 7 w t -rac4 h d G J 4' ?a 664 t, ,/ --c G, �.2) e x'4 41 J 4a AA/ 7 > /--e• G. .e v r s e* /.e , w f4 43/ .2,'y o C r, 4sZ . e "y - 1-7 v if ._C G / i h 4 bQ1 45 , ��".G�. /7 0 1 rKed / 4 t 'toe CAS' ‘ 144 /4 t -- rro.... G 4 4.4l rev'/ r o • 1 Q► O V Assisting Officer. Emp. No.: Reporting r. Emp. No.: , 4 � � X9 — �G0 Report Reviewed By /Unit Commander. Emp. No.: O.T.: Typist R.O.: • Code: ' Name Entry: ❑Yes ❑ No ' ❑ CHF ❑ Hom ❑ Rob ❑ Juv ❑ Coord ❑ 1D ❑ b ❑ Rec ❑ Team ❑ Sex ❑ Rptr ,- ❑ Other ❑ D/C ❑ Burg ❑ Theft ❑ Prop ❑ CAU ❑ F&F ❑ � uto ❑ DAO ❑ CO ❑ HumSery • PM 622 -92R • 1 • 94, P - ° - , , ° � / a — S PAUL POLICE DEPARTMENT - SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT — CONTI UATION OF: ❑ ORIGINAL REPORT ❑ SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Date & Time d Report: Offe -e/Incident: Time of Arrest: - i /,,)0 / '�A/f A 2 e L NARRATIVE Arrest Number Last Name First Middle Address DOB Age Sex Race C / / / � � i 6 c> �i/ . 4 1 7 e' -,) /// cam z0/7,4, c/1-t '4 /J ' / ' ,j / 2 3 L fi '2/ ice 5/ / �; < ��� ) ) , / 7 5/1. ®,, ,/ /'/2/�.e .3; _ O/ eAt evi-5 >A1-47 /'t/ 5 ,42 4;4-/ c /4D -7V) ,2 »' ,2; 1 � 4,f' /li'. fe_4/ /c / 4 /' CL /5 /j - 6 f/ it,/,) /2 / .E ee3 I n Z Assisting Officer. Emp. No.: '• Reporting Officer. Emp. No.: Report Reviewed By /Unit Commander. Emp. No.: O.T.: Typist '.•.: ° • • . k.ame Entry: ❑Yes El No , Mt ❑ Hom ❑ Rob ❑ Juv ❑ Coord ❑ ID ❑ Lab .4:3 Rec ❑ Team ❑ Sex ❑ Rptr ❑ Other •/ Burg ❑ Theft ❑ Prop ❑ CAU ❑ F &F 0 I Auto ❑ DAO] CO ❑ HumSery 622 -92R I� ( V AL S . PAUL POLICE DEPARTMENT � : SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT CON NUATION OF: ❑ ORIGINAL REPORT ❑SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Date & Time of Report Off 'nse /Incident: Time of Arrest: 1 -2 -94 1500 E ecute Search Warrant 15Of hrq NARRATIVE Arrest Number Last Name First Middle Address DOB Age Sex Race A :C S- i Gubbrud Dean Otto 1115 Elway St #402 5 -3 -52 41 M W ti I was dispatched to the "Sta ting Gate" Bar at 2516 W Seventh St to assist there with the Execution of .',Search Warrant. Upon arrival met Sgt Cavanaugh of the Vice Unit who directt =• me to count the paper currency in several cash register drawers which I did. Total amount came to $747.00 cash plus a $20.00 check #3267 from "Pruitt" to the bar, for a grand total of $767.00. This money placed in an envelope .Ind handed over to Sgt Cavanaugh. I was then directted to trans•ort suspect GUBBRUD to booking. Suspect booked at jail annex =s follows: Possession of a Controlled Substance - -- HOLD - -No Bail Sport Book Maki g - -- HOLD - -No Bail • o 1 • 4 to i sza Assisting Officer. Emp. No.: RWIng • / Emp. No.: lir Report Reviewed By/Unit Commander. Emp. No.: O.T.: Typist R.O.: r Code Name Entry Yes No `7�-- t • HF ❑ Hom ❑ Rob ❑ Juv ❑ Coord ❑ ID ❑ Lab �Rec Di Team ❑ Sex ❑ Rptr prOther aI D/C 0 Burg 0 Theft 0 Prop ❑ CAU ❑ F &F ❑ Auto ❑ DAO , �CO ❑ HumSery D M 622 -92R • . .... -4( (P p X y p y • C • w E • �0 E T Q 7,-, u `Q 'i. 0 V p C f7 V g p r ' ce N C V V V a, I > l V u- ca ° + LL cz ts 0 .= .. . 4 i o 0. i C O 111' • . o � ° c C N E V p: s : � o o V .` } al o m ` g U �Iao i 0 c o o f o_ a E E Q .; °' c 7, U a a U V " \.. t o .n -' CL '' U c O v N ` � Q V a a U V rn� CC Z V i , j C • `^ >` F c4 L d U > > N c 3 .. = o a� c C E Z jIIII -o ' , E O I 3 ' E O � i o�'V 47 , , Vt'' - v • .o < 2 u a il I w o , y F V c 4 1 ' E 0 0, c o y c -O _ Uo NJ d o i. LL 0 • I \ O a1 O o I- 3 s P. 1 \ O k f1 o a LL, O u L °�"' _ of 1- o O V` )42‘/N a C, v z V \ -�. u y al u cc q Q4 o f m tg \ O _ ; O v " ' O vl F c .i.:i a ,_ O ° ; :i p o v o a E r...: d Z _ Z • 0, 0 d Z o � M - - ? • _,..; E _1 k qt.' - iloq . t LLI i ; e • - o , „„ V .... t..- - g o ,..7:" U u a. •-• co 1 t - 1 1 1 1 o 2 co >. o_ — - t -.Y .........."••■....... I Alt I I.J- 0 U. 00 01. ' ...• '. 0...! \ • i .; .- ! 0 Nri .2- :. • •••■„,„,....... L. a) r) _y -F ") .: 'n- 0 E ...- 15 Zi - -J U 0 0 0 N E U - - - 1 _o -..1 ce _o e • r ..._ .. . u .c a) -..,.._1 o .. _, .. >. . \ N • .2 0 6 , 0 -0 .- o 7 7 - - 2 2 ) E 0 "6 o . U o- • o_ U u • „,...1 • 1 I o 22 I E , • _ I 0 „ I 't • a'''' I o I- _I = (I) 0 A.,, o - ,-1 _. ce _r* -V _. g - - - 0- •-- ..- V . ' •- Z Z E.1 . 1,....—, • CI ' 1.- ,--. U . C Ifs; \ik A > < .... , 0 -0 .Z• :.1 , .., v., _ , _ 113% 0 eg o. *E r e... • 0 . - • 2 = • ' VI ■,„ ,,_ a:. OSZ 1-7 0 E • c - o .- a; I 2 0 i .. .... i.,.., ,_, :.- —§ ,_ •= ..___ I ‘a D U . ' ili . a) - a... • D • CO Ce V Ce •- t E __ • • 7D C.. 0 Cr I . — - CC • 7 LSAI .... CG Il lik%„N. ---- I • < 0- I ° . • I -, -- \;_.A.... I 1 . 1 .,..., d ...`,f, - i c . - . 1z 6 5-c, —t-c, .., ,:. - .5 cr Ei 1 -071 • z .. a, 0 c7.. --I ,..• 0 ' = O 0 C- I • ta 0 ;+. • - .. 'N ( • I C. .r. ;- ■ CC . I- I 0 % al C 72 l” I — .V1 — d Z U- I 0 . , 7) iL- u 0 c ■_ ! L '''. co 0- 0 - a- . o '-;- c . - - . 7., '7.'-j1 ' S:14.1 o t ■ ••- >- S ■LI c- 8 0 0 s■ 1.,:i 0 0 0 (.. \II H.: 0 1.-- ...- ^: u CJ 0 ‘ 3,\ c- •A4 l< Illik E ' ce co '. --_ 0 cu ...- ..- E ° 0 N . 0 v, ...... •I r... • ,- c . 4) ..- ■- c2, 111111 -to t a g k"- : c -- E • _ ■ (.., c 1 . z % c " • r • ..-= Z 2 Z 2 7. _ r. ' h k ,: , co ..., .... , ,.- _ . _ • • J X �• .. • C 6 gifrs- 1 C W o U O V 44 i j p Y E ' o c N CO v V cc L 0' ■ X > W L) ..- i CO I CA N it V1 C. i W 1 1 1 1 0 2 ��_ JJJJ (^ < < a c L J< W. <) LL. m Q o V 1 ,- o e a N ' w p I, -C ^ c •.x E 4- / y 4 o' c .� ce c V E V C Q � d as o x I o c J J . }!J E S g V rvrr 111 i HJ v `'/ v V V • V�J 2 c • .. o � � _, -+ V c 0 . :. - 1 < U a. a. V U N a. Z U C CN N V o v y .. -' o al ] ` az E F a. I o . . „ L' LL au i . .. a. d O _ a 0 a l o 0 E •a C cc a■ 10 ` o g ce Ilikiiii.104 d W • a .444, o cc ' 1. ` 0 0 VI C i +, "C3 ' <i) . • t • d Q V • a. O o fvJ N �i N O a) _ ti i ) E Q E - 3 Z J • t` v [s a. 4 . W '' \ O a) ■ O ; E c o S O o . `, v s VI a, 4u 0 a t U Q 8 a c S S 111 O W O E s }aN = � � -� j !j 4 g o z 0 0 S p lV v • - --........ ..] LL o u� / al u ° C E rqi, o+ a < O o . o o c C 4.4, — o o J C 6 2 0 o o C a. 0 a Z d • , ^ C C. Z (�. aQ �, ..... o_ Z v Z Q v P �. �- ^ CO a z I * Op � ECl _ 4 9 ��llo E V d u V ° d i _ Q ` € c � m O w a a) M C0 (_ o '�u � 4 �Q� V m Q W, m v El a a c m v • t C s.- p E d y — a O .� u O `c 1 E `i z o .o ° c -0 - •- E V Ni % t4- C3 O J « w O V . - s g O x Z - o f a a E E V o < •2 E C •`O G , O U 2 d V u 6 0 - V ' O d d '- "i < V a a V V Ii — � �� N i �) m F � i p < ^ C / j v V v ` 3 L U� = .> . O `� v y _ O ° °' . , a s ° W > O �( o � `p O E a C Oo O (� E v V` E d 1 W ' ` E )- d ` 0 0 ° C •••., d !.:1: of W > d e Y r �Q 25 N W 4 s _ - z o � v • 1.- 1 gi O d if o� Y Z Q., --. ..7 ,.,_ a, `� c I-- ° 3 0 4 7 c v r V ` W ° ▪ y i �. • ~ Q W U Q j t a i` a S te— N C , V ° E y '� ' o t V ...4,_ d 'o Z O ,..., S 1.1- 1 ..., \ 0. t 4. 0 g < �O c p w c C F 0 ` .. � ° ° J z 'el, d O DO Q O 0) o o f F a F o_ 0"..., a_ Z LT o • Z J"'k aft vZ EZ Q m I -: c•-; ....• ..., `, w – a z , li 1 1 - q - tJo - ts O e E 'E - a ° •' V E o P � c Q c- 1 c C ° - ° �' E p V = c. 1 X > u- V L: 176 2 o a I 1 1 ( Q O N O c J Q LL V LL m Q tU 117 1 1• _ a'A O J U O C N t'1 D 6 O :c X J CC V N E V d i l V _O J V ••••• - E E o 1 Z - c o f c ° a E E Q V Qi c ' o c • V a a V U v y ^� ` H J ` .i •` R I t 1 1 m ' • G Oi \ .4. � Q V a a V V � C O✓ cc co c ° 'c / 7 L lJuj I o � y. .!o . — to �- v U O I �� � ° > W Q o � ? M N t LL e,i d a d N O 1 a I o Ir \ E O a C • E r• Z v -o i= C W y 1 w 0 0 � :v `J – a E _ 1 l E n � J 1 � M �� Q O I — 0 CC > to W �X > _ u ce 0O I ).. 0 Q ~41 2 1 1 W V o )11 d '� g 3 J• o m O m � `� Z - a tl a U I CO yr 24:R \ .. Z ( 's a, 0 Oj O.�M u 1_ c c I- - c a 1 r F -- m \ Q •� c V Q w 0 v F ti Q •a ' ., W Q d W Q` r C Y- E L ...--] :r 1 � 0 _ I-'1 i u u LL a� a � ~ a O �` o 0 m re U E a o � O 1 \ w _ y F o O O _0 c a m O `' O O p ° J O ° ° ° E • G- o \ ' � U a a Z o z d E L-: — Z o E o a Z 2 Z 2 U n co — °• Z i . . CI LF 4... 1 ( 0 14 . sl ! c J x C • o O V v ~N Y 0 B o $ V m a c a > V LL m . d a 0 B x p • NJ 1 1 1 1 e N O. 2 C O d I J Q IL V U. m 2V O kl 0. ` v 0 S p E a p o .a g .0 o E V LL 0 O ' . .r te • 3 V 'a co • ` c a o f o w • E S g V ,� ; Z e .e .. o Q > V _ • O o > 1' 1 1 1 1 Q y F- a� � - OC Iri � a U a V V g c JO Z I O U.; n V i v 0 :2 . es, ! 1 c m F • �i 1 f = C /� > > In C W \ d 1 � J tJ � ! Q ` W � �I t F ,,,i O ,� > 3 0. c: i I C tt. v� y d N . O ` 1 E „ G E I Z d '' O 0_ C p 1- :' E 0 1 O ,..,._ , . w I r � D ri N I\ d Q ~ N ce 61 a ( p i ~ u W O ° . Q O _'n V � c e� F ° a NI Z ‘'........_j Z u o C o is o. CO p O N u. '- • • _ ° t 3 s 1- .4 - o - O o ■ ov Q a n1 C "i o ` • V 1- E ., 5 - Q ° O o g C•1 t z *a Ti u •a °' o ° � �O C.: • 0 �O °` O o d.. o 0 •v . ° � a O ."--- . °O o . o c o c ° . E n E. • L a. a. Z ;�Z �,;• a E • E L' o a. F. • c• p; 1, CO ~ Z Z a Z a 94 log Lic ID 19509 STAT AC Business Name G-BRUD INC Doing Business As STARTI' GATE Address 2516 711 ST W Zip 55116 Exp Date 05/31/'I4 License Name LIQ-ON SALE-OVER 100 SEATS -B • SUNDAY ON SALE LIQUOR . RESTAU'. T (B) -MORE THAN 12 SEATS . GAMBLI G LOCATION (CLASS B) . ENTERT•INMENT -CLASS 3 NOTE AREA INSP C . GE FROM 02 TO 01 ON 4/09/92 • 12436 . 062791 PH ON APPN FOR NEW ON SALE LIQUOR -B, SUNDAY . , REST•URANT -D, GAMBLING LOCATION -B & ENTERTAINMEN . T -III I'ICENSE APP'D C.F. 91 -1202 . (FORME'LY LICENSED TO THE RAND BAR, INC. ID 78530) Bond Policy Number Bond Company Bond Effective Date Press <RETURN> to continue... Alt -Z FOR HELP VT102 1 FDX 1 9600 E71 1 LOG CLOSED 1 PRINT OFF Bond Expiration Date Insurance Carrier PARK GI N NAT'L INS CO. Ins. Policy Number MNLL93.267 Insurance Effective Date 06/09/ Ins. Expiration Date 05/31/'4 Associated Stock Holder DEAN 0 GUBBRUD Dealer No Tax Id 117776 Worker Comp Exp Date 04/09/•4 Telephone 698 -6407 Press 'C' to continue, 'P' to pr nt, or 'R' to redisplay... Alt -Z FOR HELP VT102 1 FDX 9600 E71 1 LOG CLOSED 1 PRINT OFF • • RECEIVED JUL 0 7 1994 DU II LEY AND SMITH } _ ATTORNEY • PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION ; t \ JOSEPH J. DUDLEY, JR. ATTO' NEYS AND COUNSELORS AT LAW I SHOREVIEW OFFICE DAVID W. LARSON SUITE 178 - ARDEN PLAZA PHILIP C. WARNER SUITE 2602 3585 NORTH LEXINGTON AVENUE STEVEN C. OPHEIM AME'NCAN NATIONAL BANK BUILDING ARDEN HILLS, MINNESOTA 55126 MICHAEL D. O'NEILL ST. P UL, MINNESOTA 55101 - 1896 - LISA M. AMUNDSON BURNSVILLE OFFICE ELEPHONE 612 - 291 - 1717 MICHAEL R. BRADLEY T LECOPIER 612 223 - 5055 SUITE 301 MIDWAY NATIONAL BANK BUILDING RETIRED JOSEPH J. DUDLEY June 29, 1994 14300 NICOLLET COURT BURNSVILLE, MINNESOTA 55337 G. WILLIAM SMITH R. E. LOW WOODBURY OFFICE 300E PARKWOOD PLACE 7650 CURRELL BOULEVARD Mr. Philip B. Byrne WOODBURY. MINNESOTA 55125 Assistant City Attorney V © Office of the City Attorney Civil Division 400 City Hall 15 West Kellogg Boulevard St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Re: The Starting Gate 2518 W. 7th St. St. Paul, MN 55116 Dear Mr. Byrne: Pursuant to our phone conversati I ns and in accordance with your letter of June 17, 1994, after lengthy discussions with D =an O. Gubbrud, owner and operator of The Starting Gate, he wishes not to contest th... allegations of violations of his liquor license as set forth in your May 2, 1994 letter. Mr. Gubbrud has taken it upon self to complete an outpatient program at St. Paul Ramsey Hospital and he was suc essfully discharged on April 12, 1994 (see attached copy of a Certificate indicating c s mpletion of Chemical Dependency Program). Since his completion of the program, he 1 s been a participant in AA and has sought out a sponsor who I have met and talked with. The sponsor agrees that Mr. Gubbrud recognizes his problem which is the hardest p. and has sought out others to assist him in his recovery. His sponsor believes he has coo •'-rated, participated in AA since his outpatient discharge. There is no allegation that his pa .t chemical problem had affected his business. Mr. Gubbrud's record as a licens holder is exemplary as it pertains to compliance with the rules, regulations, and police calls that the City tests operators on. He has had no gi 1101 Mr. Philip B. Byrne June 29, 1994 Page 2 prior violations and it is his inten to operate this business as he has for the past three years on a daily basis. Mr. Gubb d is a people person, he spends his days operating his business and enjoying the oppo 'ty to meet and serve his customers and the public. Mr. Gubbrud's business is an asset to the business community and the west end of St. Paul. Based on the above statements . d Mr. Gubbrud's record, we ask that the Council adopt the recommendation of the City ttomey for a one week closing and that he be given credit for an additional day that . the time the police came to his establishment they shut it down with the loss of $1,000- '1,500 of revenue and the removal of over 30 of his patrons from the establishment u em 3:00 p.m. for the remaining portion of the day. We believe this is an extreme burden for a small business owner. Mr. Gubbrud's fmancial condition has been hurt substanti: ly in the past two years with the majority of his business coming from the airpo ' and the Eagan area and the west end of St. Paul, the road construction, the closing of e Mendota Bridge, the revamping of 494 and Highway 5, and the road construction on ' est 7th Street, have reduced his gross revenues by 35- 40 %. It is his hope that business will return to the level that he enjoyed when he first purchased the business three ye. s ago. This brings me to address the matter of the fine. We believe the closing for a wee or six days is approximately a $10,000 loss in gross revenue and with the already red ced revenue because of the construction, we would urge the Council to adopt that no fine Ibe imposed or that it be minimal with time to pay. If there is any additional inform. ;on the Council or the City Attorney needs, Mr. Gubbrud will gladly comply. Very truly yours, DUDLEY AND SMITH, P.A. Jo - s J. Dudley, Jr JDJ:kuob Enclosure l cc: Mr. Dean 0. Gubbrud is .. • qL - JJo9N . . • i ,. . 1154 - C *IS 41 \ i IMMO t. al 11814100 CY) a C. 4•11 U p 1 , E 0+ a . p C. 14lit a) SS d A .,, .. d •ice+ ♦ y .� d m a = tt v se iLA lle I 1W CZ +. m C a+ L7 IA CO Q •r y A pi* W fl }+ L / „ k it" =IMOD ea ,� E . ip Q a • d iL ory U OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY Timothy E. Mara City Auomey At TIr PAU L CITY OF SAINT PAUL Civil Division 4,111 Norm Coleman, Mayor 400 City Hall Telephone: 612 266-8710 15 West Kellogg Blvd. Facsimile: 612 298 -5619 Saint Pau4 Minnesota 55102 ;AAAA May 2, 1994 Dean O. Gubrud G -Bud Inc., dba Starting Gate Notice of Violation 2516 West 7th Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55 16 RE: All licenses held b G -Bud Inc., dba Starting Gate, for the premises located at 2516 est 7th Street, Saint Paul (ID # 19509) Dear Mr. Gubrud: I am in receipt of inform -tion that could lead to an action against all your licenses. The •asis for adverse action is that: "On January 2, 1994, search warrant was executed at the premises of the Starti g Gate Bar. You were arrested by the police for possession of controlled substances, including cocaine and marijuana, •iscovered in a basement room of the bar to which you suppli • the keys. In addition, gambling paraphernalia was found, on the licensed premises indicative of sports gambling. Underc•ver officers had previously observed you conducting sports gambl ng activities, and a pen register on the bar telephone indicated calls in furtherance of such activities. The foregoing matters constitute grounds for adverse action against all the license- held for that premises." If you do not dispute t'e allegations or facts, or agree that a violation occurred, but ant to have the opportunity to speak to the Council to argue for the lightest possible penalty under all the circumstances, plea-e call me at 266 -8710 to work out the procedures. If you contest the alleg=tions or dispute the facts, I will take the necessary steps to -chedule a hearing before an independent hearing examiner and pro fide you with a proper notice of hearing so you will know when and w ere to appear, and what the basis for the hearing will be. Plea -e respond within ten days. You may be responsible for costs if I schedule a hearing thereafter and you do not appear and /or contes the facts. Very Truly Yours, // g . -Aa. PHILIP /. BYR Assistant City Attorney cc: Robert Kessler, Dir-ctor Lt. Nancy DiPerna LIEP SIU , - qq-zloq STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BY MAIL COUNTY OF RAMSEY ) JOANNE G. CLEMENTS, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that on May 2, 1994, she served the attached Notice of Violation on the following named person by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope addressed as follows: Dean O. Gubrud 9 -Bud Inc., dba Starting Gate 2516 West 7th Street Saint Paul, Minnesota 55116 (which is the last known address of said person) and depositing the same, with postage prepaili, in th- -sited States mail at St. Paul, Minnesota 4 / 1 I I I P,A , 6 ,/ /al 40 '.. J r.r 'G . CLEMENTS Subscribed and sworn to before me this 2nd day of May, 1994. ! 4 \ • I % tar b it s l ei) KATHRYN JEAN McLAUGHLIN , NOTARY PUBLIC — MINNESOTA 1? RAMSEY COUNTY My Commission Expires Sept 19, 19 '35 X .MN r •