95-419Council Fi1e #
Green Sheet #
CITY
Presented
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
Jc4
39
40
41
42
43
Referred To
RESOLUTION
SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Committee: Date
/�
WIlEREAS, The City Council, by resolution 280932, adopted September 29, 1983,
as amended by resolution 85-326, adopted March 19, 1985, approved variances for the
construction of a building and a parking ramp located on lots 19 through 30, Block 8, St.
Catherine Park Addition to the City of Saint Paul; and
WHEREAS, The City Council, by resolution 86-1462, adopted October 21, 1986,
approved the site plan for the proposed building and parking ramp to be located at the
above described location; and
WHEREAS, The City Council had placed restrictions on the approval of the
variances and the site plan, including restrictions that the northerly wall of the office
building and parking ramp be constructed of a solid wall; and
WHEREAS, The office building and parking ramp were acquired by Hoyt
Development Company, 13400 15th Avenue North, Plymoutb, Minnesota 55441, who has
requested the Council to modify the conditions so as to permit the installation of
windows on the north and west side of the buildings; and
WHEREAS, The Council conducted a gublic hearing on April 19, 1995, to
consider this request for modification of the restrictions, and has decided to allow
windows beginning at six (6) feet from the floor of the office building portion; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, That Resolution 280932, as amended, be further amended in the
following particulars:
(7) The developers sha11 cooperate with tbe abutting neighboring property
owners in the design and the construction of the ramp so as to minimize noise,
emissions of a11 sorts, to provide privacy and preserve aesthetic integrities to the
abutting neighboring property, and the developer shall consistently use state of the
art technology to accomplish the intent of this resolution. The northerly wall of
the office building ma�.he �nstr�rGted-oi xt;�aod�1�;� s� �s to provitie �u�ndt�uzs
beg�ii�� at s�r (6} f��t frt�m ��� ���r:c�f the c�f€ic� 6��lciii�g and the parking
ramp shall be constructed of a solid wall and where requirements for lighting
purposes exist, translucent bricks may be used.
FURTHER RESOLVED, That Resolution 86-1462, be amended in the following
particulars:
4. The northerly wall of the commercial building rnay_�?� cc��,StYUCted pr.
r��n€id�lecl �a. as to pr�vzd�: windtrws begar�ag afi _six {b� f€;et fro-m:the floor c�f thc�
< . _- ,�-
c����r�i�l �yt�i7�iii� and the parking ramp shall be constructed of a solid, opaque
S l
a�a�/
(
1 wall except where requirements for lighting e�cists, translucent bricks shall be 9s`�� y
2 specified.
Requested by Department of:
By:
` � Form Ap oved by
Adopted by Council: Date ��}, a� q�s
—
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary gY: �
By:
Appx
By:
by Ma1E6r for Submission to
By:
__ ___
. �s,� lq
DEPqRTMENT/OFFICE/COUNQL DATE INfTIATED N� 2 8 21 1
City Council. 4/19/95 GREEN STHEE INRIAL�ATE
CONTACT PERSON 8 PHONE O DEPARThIENT DIRECTOR � CITY COUNCIL
Nancy Anderson 266-8564 p���N OCfiYATTORNEY �CT'CLERK
MUST BE ON CqUNCI� AGENOA BY (DATE� RU NGFOfl O BUOGET OIFECTOR O PIN. & MGT. SERVICES DIR
April 26, 1995 OPOEfl �MAVOR(ORASSISTANn �
T07AL # OF SIGNATURE PACaES (CLIP ALL LOCATION5 FOR SIGNATURE)
ACTION RE�UESTED:
Finalizing City Council action taken on April 19, 1995, denying the application o£ Hoyt
Development Company to modify a condition that was required as part of a previous zoning
variance, restricting where windows overlooking adjacent resitiential property can be built
RECOMM£NDATIONS: Approve (A) or Rel� (� PERSONAL SERVICE CONTflACTS MUST ANSWER TXE FOLLOWING �UESTIONS:
_ PLANNING COMMISSION _ qVIL SERVICE COMMISSION 1. Has this person/firm ever worked under a contract for this departmenY+
_ CIB COMMITfEE YES NO
— 2. Has this personRirm ever been a ciry employee?
_ STAFF — YES NO
_ DISrRICT CoURT � 3. Does this person/firm possess a skill not normally possessed by any current city employee?
SUPPORT$ WHICH COUNqL O&IECTNE+ VES NO
Explain all yes answers on separate sheet anC attach to green sh¢et
INITIATING PFiOBLEM, ISSUE. OPPORTUNITY (Who, What, When. Where, Why)�
AOVANTAGES IF APPROVED
DISAOVANTAGES IFAPPROVEO�
DISAOVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVE��
TOTAL AMOUNT OF TAANSACTION $ COST7REYENUE BUDGETED (CIRCLE ONE) YES NO
FUNDIHG SOURCE ACTIVI7Y NUMBER
FINANCIAL INFORMATION (EXPLAIN)
�39
q s -- y ��1
.
��� . �
�--����-
`i 1 c�� 9�-� s/�
- � � ,���� ��� ����,
� u� � �'� br�� �
��� �� �/s�.�
��� / � ��� ,
, ��.�; D� ��.e��.,��.�e � �-�-e_
�� ���� � ;�
���� �� � �s �� � �
.�.� � � �� .
�-r��.�� �,,� �� ��-��c-�'� �� \���
, _r,� U:�-�� � �-��� :
�� ���� �� � ���
,
Cr,r�— �9�—yc.Q -Pv�l� �cr—e-- , _
r ��� �,-� ' � �-
, �'� � �c�/yti���
��7:��� � ��� ��r
� ��� �- ��c � J��
�e;�J�2v� �,u:e��-�-.cc.�.- � 2� ��=�k�
l�G . { iGCQ a
�
�t// � �����
��� �� �
� s^i�,�
.
The Highland
Business
Association
April 13, 199`
Mr. Mike Harris
Third Floor
City Hall
24 West Reliogg Bivd.
St. Pau1 MN 55102
Dear Mike:
C�5_�l1`l
����uvi��
�pR 1 4 1995
�k 39
Brad Hoyt's variance request to add windows to the Parkway Plaza
property was unanimously supported by the Highland Business
Association's Board of Directors at our meeting this morning.
Aithough we sympathize with neighbors' privacy concerns, we believe that
the residential and commercial value of the entire community wi11 be
greatly enhanced by the completion of this property and a timely leasing
of its commercial space. If Mr. Hoyt, aPter evaluating the property,
believes windows are needed to secure tenants for this property,
we support him.
Please call me to let me know if there is anything else we can do to
ex�edite the introduction oF Parkway Plaza to our community.
Sincerely,
1 r :�
�
Barbara Ducha
Executive Director
Highland Business Association
cc: Brad Hoyt
P.O. BOX 16244 • S7. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55116 • 612-699-9042
m
zl Agrit 1995
Rx'zaa H liyytedt
20$Ys Watson lvemie
St Pau;. MH 55ZIfi
!fir i+tike &i.rris
FAX 256-8�7lt
R&: kCJ�D :�J�17.L
xcrr n��
Deer a+t� rdasri.s,
T atn sarit3.ag to nrge �oa to suppoz� Brad f?o 3n �.a
reqneet to r•emong t$e coyeu�,nts or_ the Fard I9a11 ccnaexui,ng
windo�re cn tt,e uorth side, aad �y other propoaals �.e r�g
hase cvhic& he fee2s wi11 expefii.te the cwr_ule�i.oa aad leasix�
aY the oni�dirg, Tt�e �reigtixnc�a3 oas ha d this buildi3g
smpt� for too long.
As s Hig�. re�-derit and, T ha�se, a ftxt�,ara teaarrt, y�
believe tts qviek coac7.usion of this rGatter wi17, greatly
bP-nifit the com�vnitp.
I wi1T, not be able to at:enl3 aext wesks meeving� but
pleaes caL1 upon me at ax� tizze if rou i�.aoe r.nv qne�tsons,
I r�.n
:ours tru?y f
� IiZ���
Jr .�
, r ( -t �. ,� /'�
?� tf
Br�.an H Nysiedt.
CC: dF3
�s - y �°�
d
� s - `�� ��
�C4C-�L'Fdx*:•]I3 787t Cat4+�.hCtCs �, � , ����7�������
l+ ' f1
�oit4 - s'E�Sc%J rro"'� k.yi.�-ar�'vS � �t�
�:a,t+.ct �vc;lGFfvf+/:s? �' :.c. ���� ,
�I�Y'.Y. Q /� f ��L:'l9 A 6 �� '7 �. L�� y
s s,� - �z ��- 1t�1'et�GC�I G�rir�p �
L° s s t-� 4 s � F.�' r=i �°`iY°�i eusr�ss c� ��
3129145
Jaitn i . Bessessn. Pr2si�ettt
E3enct�rnsrK '
33 tOt�t Avsnue Souii^
Suit2 tQ(}
Nopkins, MN 5;;343
Dear .lot�r..
T�is (Qtter +s ;o ciariry thei p.spen M�dicaf Graup intends fcr the parties - Asper
i�edica( Gr�up P.,S. an� Hoyt �svelopmerst fo engage �n good faith �ag8tiatians as we
ax�mine tne affi�e space availabie flr+ tt�e tt;ird flocr of 2139 Ford Parkvtay 'sn St. Pa�E.
We dc, �,o�never, reccgnize thaf ti�ris tctEer of ?ntent is non-6indirg.
1;1r'a laak `o;ward to ��r��rking with You.
Sin�ereiy
/` w
y� j�
WI{�i8[i1 bzii8y '�rS.Q.
�EO - �saen t�9edicaf vroup P.A_ and
�EO - As�en FEus HeaE!h t+istw�rfc
raUSfr�css ^��;r�-7
1J^_ 1 E�R,4�AI�A u�::i.4e+�!eD E.�SF • S?;tTc 2�0 • SF. Dr;Ut. Aai'V �1!'Aal21
�S-�\�
Hayt Devalopment
9uite F 134015th Ave.
Plymouth> MN 55441
Brad and John,
Apsi11$, � 995
1've had an es�ai�fishsd business in Ft�htsnd Par4c tor touRsen years, tt is my
goat Eo rema9n in �-lightand Park.
Currentiy i`m interested in leas+ng 55Q0 square test of space in ;nur Forc!
parkway bulld3ng. In order ta provide natural light and a comfortable and
productive atmasphera for my staff, it is imperative th�t wir�daws t�s instalied
on the nor� side of tfiat buildin� on the second floos.
I sincerely hope thet your e#to+ts to moue farward on this issue wili ba
succsssful.
I look forwarc! to an updats at your eariisst conveniesice.
Best Regards,
(��y�t,? t§G�'Ir�.
Randi S. Johnsan
Tivofi Too, inc.
664 Cleveiand Ave. Sa.
St. Paul, MN 551 i6
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm CoTeman, Mayor
OPFICE OP LICENSE, INSPEC'ISONS AND � S �"� ��
I;NVIltONMENTAL PROTECITON /�
Rober! KessleY, Di�ector �( �
d
BUIIDINGINSPECllONAI�D Telephone:612-266-900I
DESZGN Facrimile: 612-2669099
350 St Peter SYreet
Suite 310
Swnr Pau1, M'nmesota 55102-ISIO
February 27, 1995
Ms. Nancy Anderson
City Council Reseazch Office
Room 310 City Hall
Saint Paul, MN 55102
Deaz Ms. Anderson:
I would like to confirm that a public heazing before the City Council is scheduled for Wednesday, AprIl
19, 1995 for the following zoning case:
Applicant: Hoyt Development Company
File Number: 95-049
Purpose: A request that the City CouncIl modify a cond'ation that was required as part of
a previous zoning variance. The condition restricts where windows overlooking
adjacent residential property can be built.
Location: 2145 Ford Parkway
I have confirmed this date with the ofFce of Councilmember. My understanding is that this pubiic
hearing request wIll appeaz on the agenda of the City Council at your earliest convenience and that you
will publish notice of the hearing in the Saint Paul Legal Ledger.
Please call me at 266-9086 if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
��
Tom Beach
Zoning 5ection
�,_,. ._. _.,._�u°a
r+ {�
�... .; e Go "u � w�
_ .._�_:�:_-:..
, -. _- .-- - - - --`° - _,d
� . � _ e AOTICE9E -y,'._,--r_� -.,.:,-,�,r-.F.
. � ` ' : ; u.r: r-^--..__:�_ �. .. , .,.. , .,
The Saint Paui Ciry�Council,will conducY a�putilic.hearing oa�:Wedriesday,
Apr�-19,;-T3�5,�a£ 3i3Q p.�. isthe City Couacit Chambus,.3'hicd Bloor, CiEy FE�t,
fb�oon"s'r�ei Development Companyio modify a coadition.M�at
was'required as pazt of a previous zoning vaziance, restricting where windows
overlooking-adjacent residential property can be built at 2145 Ford Pazkwaq.
Dated: March.&9'. Y995 � '`'
NANCY��AIQDERSON � � . " . �
Assistant Cify Council Secretary � �
_ . , (I�arch 31, 1995) � _ ' �i
��
�:_.
�
4 9 2
� _
�
MICHAEL J. HARR[S
Counci7member
MEMORANDUM
CITY OF SA�NT PAUL
OFFICE OF THE CITY COUNCIL
TO: Council President Dave Thune
Councilmember Jerry Blakey
Counciimember l�larie Grimm
Councilmember Dino Guerin
FROM:
DATE:
6Y�L:3L��l�9
Councilmember Bobbi Megard
Councilmember Janice Rettma
Councilmember Mike Harris
April 19, 1995
Item #39 - Hoyt Development Company
# 3°�
�S -y��
The Hoyt Development Company has made an application to modify a condition required as part
of a previous zoning variance restricting where windows could be place on the building located at
2145 Ford Parkway. This issue is on for public hearing, item #39, on this afternoon's agenda. I
wanted to let you know in advance that I would like to hear public testimony on both sides at
today's meeting, and then will make a motion to lay this item over for a week to allow for further
neighborhood input.
Thank you in advance for your consideration.
c:
CITY HALL
Nancy Anderson, Assistant Council Secretary
THIRD FIAOR
SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA 55102
612/266-8630
s.g -R.� <e
Pdnred on Reeyded Paper