04-112/-F (Y� 5�J/ £_0 - �/��I�/� �. a/JU �
���f til�b �G� �o, aov�
ORDINANCE
CITY OF SAtNT PAUL, MtNNESOTA
�
Conncil File # 04112
Greev 3heM # 100614
5UBSTITUTE
a�u�0�1
3�
1 An Ord'mance establishmg an
2 Examming Committee for the position of Police
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
2i
26
27
28
29
30
31
Chiefpursuant to the provisions of Section 12.12.1
of the Samt Paul City Chazter
Whereas, Section 12.12.1 of the Samt Paul City Charter provides that upon receipt of a notice of a
vacancy for the position of Police C1rie� the Coimcil shall appomt an Examining Committee, and
Whereas, this exammmg committee shall be designated as the Police Chief Examinmg Committee, now
therefore,
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
Section 1
That the Council hereby establishes the Police Clrief Exa�TMining Committee p�suant to the provisions of
Section 12.12.1 of the Samt Paul City Charter.
Section 2
That the followmg people shall be appointed to serve on the Police Chief Examming Committee:
Arth�u Blakey, Jr. Retired Deputy, Runsey Cotmty Sheriff
Gloria E. Bogan, (co-chau) Attorney / Exec. Dffector Legal Assistance of Washington County
Aim Mazie DeGroot, Exec. Director OutFrout Mmnesota
7onathan Paul Granhmd, Wood Machmist, Cabinet Maker
Shelly 7olmson Clme, Exec. Director, St. Paul Domestic Abuse Intervention Project
B.Todd Jones, (co-chau�) Attomey, Robbins, Kaplan, Miller & Caesi
Richard I.eitner, St. Paul Firefighter
7ohn Lescl�, Mmnesota Representative, Assistant St. Paul Attomey
Patrick Edward McCallig, D"n�ectar of Communication, College of St. Catherme
Gayle W. Summers, Community Organizer, Highland District Council
David Allen Tihas, St. Paul Police Officer
Long Vang, Intervention Coord'mator, Hmong American Parinership
Carrie J. Wasley, Youth Program Specialist, Minnesota Dept. Of Public Safety
Lyim A. Wild, St. Paul Police Sgt. Patrol Supervisor
William Collins, Jr. Exec. Director, YWCA of St. Paul
Arnoldo Curiel, Frogtown-Summit Universit Weed and Seed Site Coordinator
SectiOn 3
32 That the Office of Human Resources shall orovide staffto sunoort the Police Chief Exa.,»nin� Committee
33 throuahout all asnects of its work nrocess.
Pt�9llSFkED
MAR 22'04
��-���
34
Section 4
35 That the Citv Attornev Deoartment ofHiunan Riehts and Citv Council Research shall provide staffto
36 support the Police Chief Exawu�ina Committee thtou�hout its work, except thev shall not nazticipate in
37 the C3ndidate intervieW UI'oCeSS. The Saint Paul Police Department sha11 provide data and
technical assistance as requested the Examining Co�ittee.
3 Section 5
That this Ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after passage, approval and
publication.
Requested by Depariment of.
Form Approv Ciry Attomey
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
Adopted by Council: Date !' t `� � L�
,
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
By.
Approved by a� r Date ��
Rv � ���'2�2..(/C/! .�
'• '►
�,,_'� �� : .(.,
GREEN SHEET
o�-�- t�a
NO � t,z L .% 14
Councilmember Lantry u nv,r�rowma� u cneann �
f BE ON COINiCII AG0�6.14 B`f l��
AElIWI
MuMmeWM trtrwstouEV cmrailtic
ROUTING
�� IWIICIRLiCRY1CisOR p11u1pILLafAVIkCTn
❑ WYORIORAtfItTYI[� ❑
TOTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES (CUP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATUR�
ON REQUESTm _ . .� -
An Ordinance establishing an Exam;n;ng Commitzee for the posirion of St. Paul Police Chief
PLANNING CAMMISSION
GB CAMMIT'fEE
CNIL SERVICE COMMiSS10N
IF APPROVED
RSONAL SERVICE CONTRACfS MUSTMLSWER TIIE FOLLOWING QUE57ION5:
F�05 �Fli6 DB��fR1 MtllkBtl 4M¢f 8 WIItfOC� (Of fhi8 dCPBIIRIe�h
VES NO
FlastMS Paewdfitm evu Uem a atY amplayce7
YES NO
Doec thie peiwruhim poseecs a slall rwt namallYP�sessed bY arry curreM cily empbyee?
YES NO
la tlua petaaMrm a fat6�ed ve�Ma?
YES NO
UTAOtiNT OF TRANSACTiOlI f COSTRtEVQIUE BU06EIEG (CIRCLE ONE� YEE NO
SOURCH
_, ul►�'��I;IQ.'.!=r_1
(IXPWN)
Council Fi1e # �"1' l4 a
Green Sheet# ��� (`�
ORDINANCE
OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Presented
Referred To
1 An Ordinance establishing an
2 Examining Committee for the posirion of Police
3 Chief.pursuant to the provisions of Section 12.12.1
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
of the Saint Paul City Charter
Date
Whereas, Section 12.12.1 of the Saint Paul City Charter provides that upon receipt of a notice of a
vacancy for the position of Police Chief, the Council shall appoint an Examining Committee, and
Whereas, this examining committee shall be designated as the Police Chief Examining Committee, now
therefore,
THE COUNCII, OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
Secrion i
That the Council hereby establishes the Police Chief Examining Committee pursuant to the provisions
of Section 12.121 of the Saint Paul City Charter.
Section 2
That the following people shall be appointed to serve on the Police Chie£ Examining Committee:
Arthur Blakey, Jr. Retired Deputy, Ramsey County Sheriff
Gloria E. Bogan, (co-chair) Attorney I Exec. Director Legal Assistance of Washington County
Ann Marie DeGroot, Exec. Director OutFront Minnesota
Jonathan Paul Granlund, Wood Machinist, Cabinet Maker
Shelly Johnson Cline, Bxec. Director, St. Paul Domestic Abuse Intervention Project
B.Todd Jones, (co-chair) Attorney, Robbins, Kaplan, Miller & Ciresi
Richard Leitner, St. Paul Firefighter
John Lesch, Minnesota Representative, Assistant St. Paul Attorney
Patrick Edward McCallig, Director of Communication, College of St. Catherine
Gayle W. Suuuners, Community Organizer, Highland District Council
David Allen Titus, St. Paui Police Officer
Long Vang, Intervention Coordinator, Hmong American Partnership
Carrie J. Wasley, Youth Program Specialist, Minnesota Dept. Of Public Safety
Lynn A. Wild, St. Paul Police Sgt_ Patrol Supervisor
William Collins, Jr. Exec. Director, YWCA of St. Paul
Section 3
That this Ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after passage, approval
and publication.
o�- ��a
Yeas Na s Absent
Benanav
Bostrom
Hazris
Helgen
Montgomery
Lanhy
Thune
Adopted by Council: Date
Requested by Department oE
Office of Human Resources
Form Approved by City Attomey
By: � �
Adoprion Cert3fied by Council Secretary
Appxoved by Mayoi: Date
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
�
Council File # 04-ll2
Green Sheet # 100614 (substitute)
Police Chief Ex�n;ng Committee
Proposed Amendment Language
On page two line 37 following the period insert:
The Saint Paul Police Deparhnent shali provide data and technical assistance as
reqnested bv the examinin� committee.
Couucil File # 04112
Green SheM # 100614
ORDINANCE
CITY OF SAINT PAtlt, M�NtiESOTA
Preseuted by
3/IO/�4
1 An Ord'mance establishing an
2 Exammmg Committee for the position of Police
3 Chiefpursuant to the provisions of Section 12.121
4 of the Saint Paul City Charter
5
6
�
G'7
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
Whereas, Section 12.12.1 of the Saint Paul Ciry Charter provides that upon receipt of a notiee of a
vacancy for the position of Police Chie� the Council shall appomt an E�uinmg Committee, and
Whereas, this examuimg committee shall be designated as the Police Chief Examming Committee, now
therefore,
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
3ection 1
That the Council hereby establishes the Police Chief Examnimg Committee pursuant to the provisions of
Section 12_12.1 ofthe Saint Paul City Charter.
Section 2
That the followmg peop]e shall be appointed to serve on the Police Chief Examu�ing Committee:
Arthur Blakey, 7r. Retaed Deputy, Ramsey County Sheriff
Gloria E. Bogan, (co-chaff) Attomey / Exec. Director Legal Assistance of Washington County
Ann Marie DeGroot, Exec. Director QutFront Minnesota
Jonathan Paul Grazihmd, Wood Machinist, Cabinet Maker
Shelly Johnson Clme, Exec. Director, St. Paul Domestic Abuse Intervention Project
B.Todd Jones, (co-chair) Attorney, Robbins, Kaplan, Miller & Csesi
Richard Leimer, St. Paul Firefighter
John Lesch, Mmnesota 1Zepresentative, Assistant St. Paul Attomey
Patrick Edward McCallig, Director of Communication, College of St. Catherine
Gayle W. Summers, Communiry Organizer, Highland District Council
David Allen Titus, St. Paul Police Officer
Long Vang, Intervention Coordinator, Hmong American Partnership
Carrie J. Wasley, Youth Program Specialist, Minnesota Dept. Of Public Safery
Lyim A. Wild, St. Paui Police Sgt. Patrol Supervisor
Williazn Collins, Jr. Exec. Director, YWCA of St. Paul
Arnoldo Curiel. Froatown-Swnmit Universitv Weed and Seed Site Coord'mator
Section 3
That the Office of Human Resources shall provide staffto support the Police Chief Examining Committee
throughout all aspects of its work process.
35
36
37
38
K3S
Section 4
That the City Attomey, Department of Humau Rights and City Council Reseazch shall provide staff to
support the Police Chief Exanvning CommiYYee throughout iYs work, except they shall not participate in
the candidate interview process.
Section 5
That tivs Ordinance sha$ take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after passage, approval and
publication.
Yeas Na s Absent
Benanav
Bostrom
Harris
Helgen
Montgomery
I.antry
Thune
Adopted by Council: Date
Adoption Certified by Councii Secretary
�
Requested by Department of:
Form Approved by City Attomey
�
Approved by Mayor for Submission [o Council
Approved by Mayor; Date
,
r'�
TO: �i1P Cll"y COL1riC11
From: The Undersigned Citizens
� ��
4" / ����
j-//D�
We, the undersigned hereby express our disappointrnent and frustrarion upon learning
that the Police Chief Examining Committee, as it is currenfly proposed, does not include
a member who is representative of the Hispanic popularion of St. Paul.
We want the process of selecfion of a new chief to be one that includes the entire
community. For a police force and a citizenry to work well together, it is unportant that
the citizens have a sense of connection to their police force, to their police chief. Having
citizens participate in the selection of their police chief is a good thing. To not include a
representative of a fast growing segment of the population, one with a lot of young
people, seems to us a mistake.
Hispanics make up 7.9% of the population of St. Paul, according to the Wilder
Foundation. The West Side has a Hispanic population of 32%. The Committee as it is
proposed contains 15 people. We urge you to consider adding one moze. If none of the
Hispanic applicants were fully suitable, we urge you to seek out one who is qualified.
r
' ': Oh/-/i�
' Citizens of Saint Paul -��d ��
Nam Address
d
� .�-2i"G � / � �' ST. S�i: /�A✓�
z ' 3° i r J3�I'n/�r L ST -S7
.- � r��.� f�- Sr �w
� � ��-e.Y e�t��2 �ZZ � Y'� .75/�
�� 1.(� �2 � —
<< <, < < < < <i
FZ�e �S'�G,�.�- q�3 P�tl� �e �S'� �tti .� s�oy
L��i � � �-�sS/I�b
_ � S
; , s �,.��
-�c;s t� �. �� F� s�'1 o�r
ll� ��'b G�.�z �. . �.c ��o v
[ � � U G ✓ �� ` � ��
� - � � S(/�'
�inm�c. �'�. -:.��a.eLre�- a►q 5�c�w�kvt i 3� 69 ��, Pa,t�- �'�l �s
.
53 , �/�oZ
�=, � �, �� �. (� � -� � � � � � � �. � Pr� � � 5��
�' ��r� �� ��srr�-
, �p
e
(� �'t p O � K /�/P, ( 5
_ /��
'�2.- ^✓1�J� ' L 9 � J; ��r,•, s�r J' � 7 N s s�t,y
� � _ � S S ,�?i � �cC ttSaoc�,�-� MnJ
` �r�-= 3a �t . Sf, " � ss'�� �s, �.s
.�-�-°��.'�— �� � ��.�� � . �w� � �� �s<o �