The URL can be used to link to this page

03-778Council File # �3�� V Ordinance # ��'lJ�kb�2 Green sheet # 3004072 2 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 ORDINANCE CITY OF SAIN'f PAUL, MINNES�TA Presented By Referred To Committee: Date An ordinance amending Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code pertaining to zoning for the City of Saint Paul and the zoning maps thereof: WEIEREAS, Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes §462357 and §64.400 of the Legislative Code, Mary Morelli and East Side Neighborhood Development Company Inc. duly petitioned to rezone 565 and 573 Payne Avenue being legally described as Except part taken for Payne Avenue east 30 feet of south 70 feet of Lot 11 and south 70 feet of Lot 12, Block 2 of Brunsons Addition; and north 30 feet of south 100 feet of Lots 11 and 12, Block 2 of Brunson's Addition, PIN 32-29-22-24-0034 and 32-24-22-24- 0035 from RT-i to B-2 to allow an office-retail development, the petition having been certified by the Planning Division on May 14, 2003, as having been consented to by at least 67 percent of the owners of the area to be rezoned, and furYher having been consented to by at least two-thirds of the owners of the property situated within 100 feet of the totai contiguous property within one year preceding the date of the petition; and WHEREAS, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission held a public hearing on June 5, 2003, for the purpose of considering the rezoning petition, and pursuant to § 107.03 of the Administrative Code, submitted its recommendation to the Planning Commission that the petition to rezone from RT-1 to B-2 be granted; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission considered the rezoning petition at its meeting held on June 13, 2003, and recommended that the City Council approve the petition; and VJHEREAS, notice of public hearing before the City Council on said rezoning petition was duly published in the official newspaper of the City on July, 3, 2003, and notices were duly mailed to each owner of affected property and property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet or the property sought to be rezoned; and WHEREAS, a public hearing before the City Council having been conducted on July 23, 2003, at which all interested parties were given an opportunity to be heazd, the Council having considered all the facts and recommendations concerning the petition; now, therefore THE COITNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: Secuon 1. That the zoning map of the City of Saint Paul, Sheet Number 14, as incorporated by reference in §60301 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, as amended, is hereby further amended as follows: PUSLiSfT�6 That the property at 565 and 573 Payne Avenue, being more particulazly described as: R�� • ib' i �a 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 a3 - n� Except part taken for Payne Avenue east 30 feet of south 70 feet of Lot ll and south 70 feet of Lot 12, Block 2 of Brunsons Addition; and north 30 feet of south 100 feet of Lots 11 and 12, Block 2 of Brunson's Addition, be and is hereby rezoned from RT-1 to B-2 Section 2. This ordinance shall take efFect and be in force thiriy (30) days from and after its passage, approval and publication. Requested by Department of: �t�._ �►'��II�I=... Approved by Financial Services Hy: Adoption Certified kty Council Secretary BY: Approved by By: Form Approved by City Attorney �: �Y � Y v Nl�i�^ � by By: �_� Sf8' 2 9 '� Adopted by Council: �Date � /7—�� Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green �3� Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet , DepartmeM/affice/council: Date Initiated: . � PED 12-AUG-03 I Green Sheet NO: 3004072 Contact Person ffi Phone: Deoartment Sent To Person Initial/Date � � Penny SimiSOn � 0 lannine & Economic Develoo AI Torstenson i�' � 3•0 � � Assign 1 laonin & Economic Develo artha Fuller �_ Must Be on Council Agenda by (Date): Number 2 itv Attomev i i 27-AUG-03 For Routing 3 vor's Office � { Ordei 4 ouncil � i ToWI # of Signature Pages � (Clip All Locations for Signature) � i � Action Requested: � Adopt ordinance to rezone 565 and 573 Payne Avenue from RT-1 Two-Family Residential to B-2 Communiry Business. ( I Reco Approve (A) or Reject (R): Personal Service Contracts Must Answer the Following Questions: /'� Planning Commission �. Has this person/firm ever worked under a contract for this departmenY? CIB Committee Yes No Civil Service Commission 2. Has this person/firm ever been a city employee? Yes No � 3. Does this person/firm possess a skill �ot normally possessed by any i current city employee? I Yes No I � Explain all yes answers on separate sheet and attach to green sheet 3nitiating Problem, Issues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why): I City Council passed marion of intent to rezone 565 and 573 Payne Avenue from RT-1 to B-2 following public hearing on July 23, 2003, in order to allow an o�ce-retail development. Advantages If Approved: � p Will allow the proposed office-ietail development � AUG ? � EOD3 Disadvanta57es If Approved: � �T� �� None �.��.�. ,,�. � .� Disadvantaqes If Not Approved: ' The proposed office-retail development would not be allowed. F ��+ � p � r7 �� Total Amount of CosURevenue Budgeted: � Tmosaetioa: Fundin5l Source: Aetivity Numbeo � Financial Information: (Explain) � DEPAR'1MQdT OF PLANNING 8c ECONOMIC DENELAPMENT TorryScherde>,IntertmDirectar CTTY OF SAINT�UL RrmdyKelty, Mayw June 3Q; 2003 Ms. Mary Erickson City Council Research Office Room 310 City Hall Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102 Deaz Ms. Erickson: ZS 4PestPourth Street SmntPaul,MN55702 �� Teleplxme: 612-2666565 Pera+imile: 61L228-3314 I would like to confirm that a public hearing before the City Council is scheduled for Wednesday July Z3; 2003, for the following zoning case: Applicant: File Number: Purpose: o B=2 Comiiiuiuty_Busuiess Address: 565N,and 373 �ayqe tl�enue�:i�ort�twest'corner ofi-Iogkins Lega1 Description of Property: EXCEPT PART Tt1KEN FOR PAYNE AVENUE EAST 30 FEET OF SOUTH ?0 FEET OF LOT 11 AND SdUTH 70 FEET OF LOT 12, BLOCK 2 OF BRUNSONS ADDITION; AND, NORTH 30 FEET OF SOUTH 100 FEET OF LOTS 11 AND 12, BLOCK 2 OF BRiJNSONS ADDITION (PIN 32-29-22-24-0034 and 32-29-22-24-0035). Previous Action: Zoning Committee RecommendahonA,ppr"oval, vofe: 7 Q, June 5, 2p03 Planning Commission RecommendationApproval; urianimous vote,;Jurie-13; 2003 My understand'mg is that this public hearing request will appeaz on the agenda for th�Faly 23;'2QD3 City Council meeting and that you will publish notice of the hearing in the Saint Paul Legal Ledger. Please call me at 2bb�&5_54 if you have any questions. Sincerely, Penelope Simi"son City Planner cc: File # 03-299-777 Carol Martineau Paul Dubruiel Wendy Lane MOTICE OF PUBLIC H6AR3NG - The Saint Paul City Council'will con- duct a public hearing on Wednesday, July 28, 2003, at 5:30 p.m in the City Couneil 'Chambers, Third Floor, City Hall-Cossrbhouse, 15 West Kellogg Boulevazd, Saint Paul, MN, to consider the application of Eastside Neigh- borhood Development Co. and Mary Mo- relli to rezone property from RT 1(Two. Family Residential"District) to (Community Business District) to permit retail uses, offices and residen- tial uses at �565 and 573 Peyne Avenue, northwest comer of FIopkins Street. Dated: July 1, 2003 MARY ERICKSON, � Assistant City Council Seeretary (aury 3) _--==—=s 31: PA[IE LEGAi. LEDGER =-- 22066857 , ' p3 �-�� city of saint paul � planning commission resolution file number o3-55 date June 13, 2003 WHEREAS, East Side Neighborhood Development Co. Inc. and Mary Morelli, File # 03-299- 777, have petitioned under tfie provisions of §64.400 of the Legislative Code to rezone property located at 565 and 573 Payne Avenue, Parcel idenfificafion Number (PINj 32-29-22- 24-0034 and 32-29-22-24-�035, legai{y described as EXCEPT PART TAKEN FOR PAYNE AVENUE EAST 30 FEET OF SOUTH 70 FEET OF LOT 11 AND SOUTH 70 FEET OF LOT 12, BLOCK 2 OF BRUNSONS ADDITION; AND, NORTH 30 FEET OF SOUTH 100 FEET OF LOTS 11 AND 12, BLOCK 2 OF BRUNSONS ADDITION from RT-1 (Two Family Residentiai Districf) to B-2 (Community Business District); and -- � WHEREAS, the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission, on June 5, 2003, held a public hearing at which all persons {�resent were giveFl-an opportunity to be heard pursuanf to said petition in accordance with the requirements of §64.300 of the Sainf Paul Legislative Code; and WHEREAS, the Saint Paul Planning Commission, based on the evidence presented to its Zoning Commiffee at fhe public hearing as substantially reflected in the minutes, made the following findings of fact: • 1. The properties include a two-story comFnercial building most recently used for residential purposes and a single-family house at 565 Payne Avenue and a single-family residence at 573 Payne Avenue. The applicants propose to renovate the two-story building, to prouide retai! uses on the first floor and residential uses on the second floor. The single-family residence, also with a legal address of 565 Payne Avenue, would be renovated into commercial office space. The building at 573 Payne Avenue would be demolished and improved with a surface parking lot with eight spaces, serving the retail and office uses. 2. The applicants submitted a sufficient petition of the owners of.twathirds of the parcels within 100 feet of the property stating support tor the rezoing (16 parcels eligibfe, 11 parcels � required and 12 parcels signed), in conformance with Minnesota Statutes 462.357. 3. The proposed rezoning to B-2 is compatible and consistent vvith the propqsed use of the property, fn addition, the proposed rszoning is compatibte and consistent with adjacent B-1 zoning. Payne Avenue is an A-minor arterial in front of the adjacent property. Landscaping would be provided at the rear of the parking lot, adjacenf to residential uses to �he west. moved by ��e�d L� seconded by in favor U�n�ous against _ . �3'1"1`� Zoning Fi(e # 03-299-777 Planning Commission Resolution Page 2 4. The prQposed rezoning is consistent with the provisions of fhe City's Comprehensive Plan. The Generai Land Use P(an map, in the Land Use element, designates Payne Avenue for neighborhood commercial uses. Mnreover, the proposed rezoning meets several of fhe generai purposes stated in 5ection 2.2 of the Land Use etement; these purposes include encouraging private investment, enhancing the quality of place and supporting community well-being, promoting a balance of land uses and taking advantage of trends in urban developmenf, spacifically mixed use. • 5. The proposed rezoning is consistent with the provisions of the �Railroad �siand Small Area Plan. Specifrcally, Yhe Building Conditions Survey Map identifies tf�e subject property as "below average crondition requiring some rehab to sfabilize." Moreover, the Railroad Island Smail Area pian supports, in connection wifh facade improvemertts to commercial buildings along Payne �fivenue, the additian of new businesses where economicaliy feasible and appropriate; such businesses would be consistent with another strategy in the small area - plan, spec�caily, the existing retai!-core on PayFle Avenue at Tedeseo - --� --- � NOW, T4iEREFORE, BE IT f2ESOLVED, that the Saint Paul Planning Commission recommends to the City Council tfiat the petition of East Side Neighborhood Development Company (nc. and Mary MoreliP fo rezone p�operty at 565 and 573 Payne Ave. Parcel Identification Number (PIN) 32-29-22-24-0034 and 32-29-22-24-0035 legally described as • EXCEPT PART TAKEN FOR PAYNE AVENU� EAST 30 FEET OF 50UTN 7Q FEEf QF LOT 11 AND SOUTH 70 FEET OF LOT 12, BLOCK 2 OF BRUIVSONS ADDITION; AND, NORTH 30 FEET OF SOUTH 100 FEET OF LOTS 11 AND 12, BLOCK 2 OF BRUNSONS ADDITION from RT-9 to B-2 be approvec7. " �1 �J �3 • that is permitted azound the colleges. He stated that it is the number of rental properties that is the problem, it is not the students that aze the problem. Capping it would contain the problem that we have now and then we cau work on community efforts and communication with the rest of the problems. 29. Tom Vittori(?), 1894 Igiehart Avenue, Saint Paul, MN. He. stated it is difficult for singie families to buy the big homes and that has not been addressed in the ordinance. It is much easier for someone who is renting to buy them and convert them to student housing than it is for a single family to buy them. A lot of these homes aze older and aze in need of a lot of repair, taYes aze high, etc. There aze a lot of breaks for people who aze renting that don't exist for single-family homeowners. 30. Ellen Watters, Saint Paul Area Chamber of Commerce. Ms. Watters stated the Chamber has not taken a position on this but is very encouraged that there will be some additional conversations about this over the course of the summer. They do have some concerns about the economics of this; what the economic impact on students and the rental housing market woutd be. In addition, the costs of the new ordinance and its enforcement should be considered versus perhaps invesring more in the licensing and code enforcement system that already exists. Additional analysis needs to be done on these issues before any of us can make an informed decision on Y1us proposed `ordinance. As a Saint Paul resident who lives in the neighborhood of Saint Anthony Pazk, wluch for well over a decade been more than 50% rental, the discussion about rental versus home ownership levels concerns her. Ms. Watters stated that in many cities across the country strong neighborhoods aze neighborhoods with a • lot of rental, and she is concemed about the attitude that rental is automatically a denigration to our community. Commissioner Faricy thanked everyone who participated in the public hearing and produced written testimony. She stated ttils ordinance needs a lot more work whether it is passed or not. MOTION: Commissioner Faricy moved to close the public hearing a.nd keep the written portion open until Tuesday, June 17' at 4:30 p.m., and refer this matter back to the Neighborhood & Current Planning Committee sometime in the future. Motion seconded by Commissioner Donnelly-Cohen. The motion camied unanimousZy on a voice vote. V. Zoning Committee Commissioner Field gave the Zoning Committee report of June 5, 2003. #03-299-777 Marv Morelli and ESNDC - Rezone from RT-1 Two-Family Residential to B-2 Community Business for office-retail development. 565 & 573 Payne Ave., NW comer at Hopkins. (Penny Simison, 651/266-6554) Commissioner Rield stated that District 5 recommends approval. No one spoke in support. No one spoke in opposition. The public hearing was closed. The Zoning Committee recommended approval on a vote nf'7-0, with 1 abstention (Mejia). • MOTION: Commissioner Fie1d moved the Zoxing Commitlee's recommendation to approve ihe 13 o3-�z� rezoxing. The motion carried unanimousty on a voice vote. • #03-299-778 Thomas J. DeLisle - Rewne from OS-1 Office-Service to B-1 Local Business for a small groceryldeli. 1236 -1240 E. 7"` St, SW comer at Atiantic. (Penrry Simison, 651/266-6654) Commissioner Field stated no district comment was received. No one spoke in support. No one spoke in opposition. The public hearing was ciosed. The Zoning Committee recommended approval on a vote of 8-0. MOTION: Commissioner Field moved the Zoning Committee's recom�nendation to approve the rezoning. Commissioner Fieid stated there was a letter sent to the Planning Commission which is in opposition to this case, which was the only testimony received on this case. The motion carried unanimously on a voice vote. #03-304-329 ESNDC - Conditional Use Permit for outdoor sales at a farmers mazket. 926 Payne Ave., SE comer at 5ims. (Patricia James, 651�26b-6639) Commissioner Field stated that District 5 recommends approvai. No one spoke in support. No one spoke in opposition. The public heazing was closed". The Zoning Committee recommended approval on a vote of 8-0. • MOTION: Commissioner Field moved the Zoning Cornmittee's recommendation to approve the conditional use. The motion carried unan�nously on a voice vote. #03301-666 Eric Robbins - T'NT Fireworks - Determinarion of Similaz Use and Conditional Use Permit for outdoor sales of fireworks. Midway Mazketplace, 1450 University Ave., SE comer at Pascal. (Joel Spoonheim, 651/266-6614) Commissioner Field stated District 11 and District 13 Snelling/Hamline Commuaity Council recommends denial. No one spoke in support. Two parties spoke in opposition. The public hearing was closed. The Zoning Committee recommended approval on a vote of 8-0. MOTTON: Commissioner Field moved the Zoning CommUtee's recommendation to approve with coaditions the determireation of similar use and conditional use. Commissioner Field stated this consists of a tent that will be set up from June 25"` -7uly 5"' for fueworks that aze legal in the State of Minnesota. These aze non-profit organizations who aze selling fireworks to raise money for a church. Commissioner Kramer stated these permits aze only good for this,year and only on these certain days, so if this doesn't work out the way it is envisioned it won't continue� The motion carried unanimously on a voice votz • 14 o3-z�� MINUTES OF THE ZONING COMMITTEE Thursday, June 5, 2003, 2003 - 3:3D p.m. • City Cou�cil Chambers, 3rd Floor City Hall and Court House 15 West Kellogg Boulevard PRESENT: STAFF: Anfang, Aiton, Faricy, Fieid, Gordon, Kramer, Mejia, and Morton Caroi Martineau, Penelope Simison, Allan Torstenson, Peter Warner The meeting was chaired by Commissioner Field. Mary Morelii and ESNDC- 03-299-777 - Rezone from RT-1 Two-family Residential to B-2 Community Susiness for office-retail devetopment. 565 & 573 Payne Ave., NW corner at Hopkins Penelope Simison presented the staff report with a recommendation of approval for the rezoning. Ms. Simison also stated there was typographical error in the staff report recommendation and a revised staff recommendation had been faxed to the commissioners. Kathryn Paulson, the applicant, handed out and exp�ained the proposed site plan. At the question of Commissioner Alton, Ms. Paulson stated the buildi�g is vacant at the present time and its previous use was rental property; the property had not been not maintained, which resulted in compiaints from the neighbors. No one spoke in support or opposition. � public hearing was closed. Commissioner Kramer moved approval of the rezoning. Commissioner Faricy seconded the motion. The motion passed by a vote of 7-0 with Commissioner Mejia abstaining. Adopted Yeas - 7 Nays - 1 Abstention - 1(Mejia) Drafted by: Carol Martineau Recording Secretary Section Approved by: Litton Field Chair ►__J �3 �z� ZONING COMMITTEE STAFF REPORT • FILE # 03-299-777 1. APPLICANT: East Side Neighborhood Developmenf Co. HEARING DATE: 06-05-03 Mary Morelii 2. TYPE OF APPLICATION: Rezoning 3. LOCATiON: 565 and 573 Payne Avenue, northwest comer of Payne af Hopkins 4. PlN 8� LEGAL DESCRtPT40N: 32-29-22-24-0034 and 32-29-22-24-0035; EXCEPT PART TAKEN FOR PAYNE AVENUE EAST 30 FEET OF SOUTH 70 FEET OF LOT 71 AND SOUTH 70 FEET OF LOT 12, BLOCK 2 OF BRUNSONS ADDITION; AND, NORTH.3Q FEET OF SOUTH 100 FEET OF LOTS .11 AND 12,,BLOCK 2 OF BRUNSONS ADDITION. 5. PLANt3(NG DISTRICT: 5 PRESENTZONING: RT-1 6. ZONING CODE REFERENCE: Section 64.400; Minnesota Statutes Section 462.357 7. STAFF REPORT DATE: 05-21-03 BY: Penelope Simison 8. DATE RECEIVED: 05-06-03 DEADLINE FOR ACTION: 07-04-03 A. ,PURPOSE: Rezone from RT-1 fo B-2 • B. PARCEL SIZE: 7,410 square feet C. EXISTING LAND USE: Commercial buiiding, most recenfly used as residentiai. D. SURROUNDiNG L.AND USE: North: Singie-family residential (RT-1) East: Sing(e-family residential (RT=2} South: Commercial (B-1) West: Singie-family residential (RT-1) E. ZONING CODE CITATION: Section 64.400 (a) of the zoning code provides for rezoning of property by the City Councii pursuant to the provisions af Minnesota Statutes Section 462.357 upon initiation of a rezoning application by petition of @he owners of the property to be rezoned. F. HlSTORY/DISCUSSION: No previous cases for the subject property are on file. G. DiSTRICT COUNClL RECOMMENDATION: No District Councii recommendation was received at the time this staff report was submitted. H. FINDINGS: • 1. The properties include a two-story commerciai building most recently used for residentiai purposes and a single-family house at 565 Payne Avenue and a single-family residence at 573 Payne Avenue. The appficants propose to renovate the two-story building, to (�3 Fiie # 03-299-777 May 28, 2003 Page: 2 provide retail uses on the first floor and residenfiai uses on the second floor. 7he single- family residence, also with a legal address of 565 Payne Avenue, would be renovated into commerciai offce space. The buiiding at 573 Payne Avenue would be demolished and improved with a surface parking lot with eight spaces, serving the retaii and office uses. 2. The applicants submitted a sufficient petition of the owners of twathirds of the parcels within 100 feet of the property stating support forthe rezoing (16 parcels eligible,11 parcels required and 12 parcels signed), in conformance wifh Minnesota Statutes 462.357. 3. The proposed rezoning to B-2 is compatible and consistent with the proposed use of the property. In addition, ths proposed rezoning is compatible and consistent with adjacent B-1 zoning. Payne Avenue is an A-minor arteriai iri front of the adjacent property. Landscaping would be provided at the rear of the parking lot, adjacent to residen5al uses to the west. • 4. The proposed rezoning_is consistent with the provisions of the City's Comprehensive Plan. The General Land Use Plan map, in the Land Use elemetit, designates Payne Avenue for neighborhood commercial uses. Moreover, the proposed rezoning meets several of the general purposes stated in Section 2.2 of the Land Use element; these purposes include encouraging private investment, enhancing the quality of place and • supporting community well-being, promoting a balance of land uses and taking advantage of trends in urban development, specfically mixed use. I. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on the findings above, staff recommends approvai of the request by ESNDC and Mary Moreifi fo rezone the subject properties at b65 and 573 Payne Avenue from OS-1 Locat Office-Service District to B-2 Community Business District. - ---� . , ._ . _. .. _ - • sa�xr i 9AUL I � - ��A PETITION TO AMEND THE ZONING CODE Depar�inent ofPlannmg and Economic Developmerrt Zoning S`ection I400 City Sall Annee 25 West Fourth SYreet SanttPatt; MNSSZ02-I634 (65I) 266-6589' APPLICANT � PROPERTY LOCATION Property Owner � Address_5 ` .� - City 5f • Ao.�.�-( Contact Person (if ' Address / Location Lega( Descri o�lof t►_ cu�d so 7t �/� Zip TO �IiE HONQRABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL: me Phone _.Qhone (05/ �3 YQ:yh.0 � , 3a` ofS roofaf Lof3 tl¢lZ :nt Zoning _ R-T � ' /1 J Pursuant to Secfion 64.400 of the Saint Paul Zoning ( Q�rdinance and to Section 462..357(5) of Minnesota Statues, { ��' �� t�"V°�`s�° owner of {and proposed for rezoning, hereby pefitions you to � e the above described property from a_ �/ zoning district to a 8� � zoning district, forthe purpose of: �x�i+�� • he.�=ll a�d 6�c.e �a.�,c:r� vbs A�.. � � u�.�.- �,z�.fr,�:�� a,t 5�3 ��,�►..e ` � - � (attach additional sheets if necessary) Attachmeets as required: �Site Plan � Conse�t Petition � �davit Subscribed and swom to before me this �i"�/�, day of 20�_ . v C � Nota Pub c . � . ( �' `: <•.�_,� � ` __< �r� � 1 +��'� J ` 3:.:�.E M ,! ..�.r 1 �' �� • / `. i ��' Page 1 of _ �3'"1.�4 v3 �� ; �� ' � � � � r� i.� �C "� �-wa._ v ..: t � � �� :.n � � �� E � 4 , : '°r-- �-,. ti::6) `Jj � �K . . . ' __. _._.'_„ - . . ' _. , . , i ,�: _ . _ .... ' _�.._ . ' -. r . ._ �'f ., ... .__._ _— ... : ib � " eqe 4-.t�..:.. ._ .. xw..-ax z u-f, a l:.v.a ..� . a �. .,. _. i 7' g s� -; 1 °`. � YI 1 i � ` '�. ". '� �'1 Yaa�� '•— s f �y ' , y. i] � `K d'. a } y � � C ` ?',� ` �:�� 1� � .n ,;:.� }'..Y " y '" ' l!: � �... . ` 4 `v ..-^ t . � R . ^�� \ ..-c-.. _ �Q \��i.�. Y^r, .�a �b+ :ri.�'!?'.T�..'V � J �'F-�` : _ t . 1 '.�". . � \ `� •,r s � � : �' :�.: "s:i_' . � j �r: /1 � .k'�: '�� b�-ZZ� � /�'�� .�__ . _- _ - .,% {" - „ 3 - ='�� :. �-�. -t=:�'m �� - �� :•_ ��-. ., � "- - < '� -r�� - _ `^*` a. L :�, ...�.:-z..�. � -�,. CORNER OF PAY � «r:�z:�M� - - r ,��. ---- -- -- - - __ _ --- ---- _ _-�- O'� � _., ,.:, -� � _ - - � �-�„�� - �� , x_--=- _ �; �- . - v, a ��r �.-�_�.�,�; .,. � => `w"3 �� - . -._ ... a �":� - y � r h - 3 "„ �- � � ��> >.. ..�v�F _...._ �=:�, - �T y 2 � a ...' +LLi'� .�' 9 F:.aS.� .v� ��: '.t^:.syc}_� a-.v' .. �� "� . a� .I �{:.' - ` . a� .3rc�f> - ` - . � � , � ■ . . .�, . ...:,..... . •......'s �I sC�"ri ��.�i � .�._. _ , / • , � 03= �� ;x.� ,', -_ �.. ., ti � r^- � F - �� *'� p .�t w !'i f,._{�Y�Y}�_ �' y f __ ,__ � _ :.. E.__�� L � .._._ �_� . 4 � " ,� a _ , . � _ __. _.____ �. o3-�n� � - - - -- - ------- - _ --- �--�- 'KS�a�F. �r' �.... �. .r . � ..— . = � . CIT�'. OF SAINT. PA.IIL 0-,'"1-1�. _ . f A�'FII?AVIT OF PETITIONER FOR A REZONING • STATE OF MIN2�ESOTA) COUNTY OF•RAMSEY ) :SS � The petitianer, M��`� 1"r ./"! 012F1L 1 , being fust duly sworn, daposes aad statss. that the zonsent petition camains signas�ues of the owaers of at Ieast iwo-thirds (Z13) of aII clig�"bte propexties . within 100 feet of t5e subject property described in tfie.peCdoa and all pcnperty cantiguous to the s¢bjecs Pr�'P�Y that was owaed, pnr�hased, or sotd by the petitioner withia one (1} year preceding rhe date of tha pedtion; petifloner is informcd thac the consent petition must contaiu sigaatures fram each and a!1 owners cf joinfly-owned praperty ia order to constitute cotuent from that property an@ thai failure to obtain consrnc from each aad all owaeis could invalidate she coasent petitiou; petidoner belitves that tha coasent�pesiflon was signed by each of said owners and that the sigaanue are the true and corrccL • si;natures of each and all of the parties so descu�ed. � � . NAME SG S I��7,✓� � i/ ADDRES� G/a-3i�-Sl��-- . ��xorr� rrur�� Sub�cribed and swotn to before me c6is ��n. � y of mat_,�_.200�. • � � ARY PUBL • � �.. • d HEIDI M. NOLCEN � ' �MN�M�IONp�IPIRES ` �h,.� lANSiARY31.2007 toai y . y ... .. � . �_...,.. �,. ��. � �u iV in r�uutC . , CITY OF SAiNT PA�JT.. AFFIDAVIT OF' PE'I'ITIONER FOR A REZONTNG sxA� og M:uv�,car�,� CO(Jl\TTY OF RAtvISEY ) :S5 The pecitioner, ?V-lTkf'P�f.t� �, t'F�U [-56 P� , being fYSt duly sworn, degoses aad states thai the consent perition contains signatures of the owuers of at least fwo-thirds (2/3) of alt eligible ptoperties wirhin 100 feet of rhe subject pro�rty described in the petition aad atl property contiguous to the subject property that was owned, purchased, or sold by the pefiuoner within one {1} year prec�ding the date of the patition; petitioner is infomoed that the consant getition must confain sigffatures from eac6 and all owners of jainfly-owned prbperty iu order to consfitute conseai from thai property aad that failure to obtain consbn[ from each and alI ownets could invalidate the cDnsent peation; petitioner believes that the consent petiafln was sigaed by eabh of said owners and that rhe signature are t6e icue and crniect signatures of each and all of ttre parties so described. l I I / � �.. . , •, � , � , � .. •..•�. ,,..:., �� !If �r.�xorr� rrtnvfs�i Substtibed aad swoin ta before me this �Y of �3 , 20 Oj. �.�.�,e. � ,.Ifr./ . ' DE9RA S. BRARfD�S � NOTARYPiJBUC-YlfiAff50TA N(y COMMiSSfON . . . EXPlREa JAi9.31, 2005 a+i�cwccr+ r. au i¢ 03- �� «� • • � , . ' r- - � . � � , � � � �� O� ' ITION SITP'F`iCIENCY ( x�zo�re sccrP J � �3``1Z� . � � . ` . , �cvP FIRST SUBMITTED - RESUB�SITTED DATE PETITION SUBMITI'ED: DATE PETITIOY RESUB`lIFI'ED: DATE OFFlCIALLY RECEIVEB: DATE OFFICIALLY RECEFYED: FARCELS ELIGIBLE: r � , Pr1RCELS ELIGIBLE: �G � •' . I PARCELS REQUIRED: • I� PARCELS REQUFRED: '/ .r � • PARCELS SIGKED: ' � "' (�3 PARCELS SIG`IED: I / J �y/3 . � . � � �� Q N _ ` � ' � � f � d� . . CHECKED SY: �G'�/�"v - DATE: ° � Zof��N� �IL� �� ZONTNG PETITION L�IST As reQnested, attached is a list of alI property owners within 100 feet of the property which . �you aze r�questing. a zoning application. As a condition of your appfication, you aze required to submit witfi your application a consen# petition sigped by a minimum ta of all the property owners wiYhin 100 feet on the attached list. Only persons listad as "fee owner" or "homesteader" a�e eligible to sign your petition. Persons Iisted as "taxpayer" aze aot eligible to sign your petition since they db not have fu11 ownership of the properiy, A properiy owner may sibn the petition.as many.times as they. are Iisted as an owner within 100 feet. Only one signature per properry is counted as an eIigible signerof the petifion. ALso attached are the petition foim, affidayi�, and application materiats. ! �. �" totai properties are witfiin.100 feet of the properry for 2oning action and eligible to sign your petition. total signaEure�ai�e required for a minimum �,� consent and a safficient petifion to proceed with-your zoning application_ Please return this list along with the ori� p��Il form; affidavit, appIication and any addi6onal supporting infQrmation and tnaterial that is part of your applicatian. * Rezoning petitions must be received and held in the Zoning office 7 working days prior to any application cut-off date. If you have questions about thi�.list or any questions regazding ttus Process� please ca11 the Zoning office at 266-6589. � � F � o3-��g � u �- •' ,p ;: � 3L2YZ� a . �"f°> � Zoz 3 � (s;� 1 . . � 22. �` �� 19, 2 O ,;i 2.� 0g I� � : G �TY o� s� _ � �`t � � { .52 Sa.1b e3{.44 { .- ' � . _ ' ' � � $ .�._ - � . _ �__ _ ��' f w��__��_ �_ _' " ' . �' +t fi � Q � � Q A . �Y7� Po� } ' � �� , : ��:__ � r- � . � � .� s:• . � � �4? ° 4. 3 h #. i-=-- ----- 5. 4 � - i � � . a � . m CzL� - � : _ - s - - b iI . r - � i - � d :-•� ��' . . ' �, �- . � . . � . � � � � �, � . .. . ' ?.D,�S.t r � � ! .�a. s � � ': 4. j'a _ . t��..�q��_ �_ _ . � � � _�7 � • i � CRDED AS 32-29- -�. M w Y � .��?.: - ,e, � r � �• ' � ,. $• 9 10 .�. .� � " i `.�: � . . ' , . l .� _ a... - � t • � , • � �� : . :� �: � . �.. ,, � . I. rr ri 30 � � ..- ' tL= . • - �!t � .. "' +� . . . ' . '"'�►/f . ��'S� � � � �. ST. � � . n W �T � ! V � ' � � 1 $ '' �... _ . . E o�e `_ m i o6 � . ' �. . .. oS �5 � �� '� � I65#., i,.» � $ . . . . _ � o •.. 5 4 3 ; ; 2 �. �1 � �. <�� 2 0� . ,� L � � - ��."y' — i r es m � �as � � � i o � � i , � fl2a� °� - i ° (z�� 3 � o � k � � e �._. �� 5 3 � ..� ' ___ � � � .St�. a _ p" � - - �� . � _�� . ' 73 . f'ol (t{i� '� (£12� � '.> ' . . �GL� . �' ' . l' " I � ss t ��_� er::c: ' � _ ad ' , . 1 � ° a� ' . �4 . ' � ". W .� �.�� - � °- " 3 � 2J 1 C a Q � Q O6 '� �� . O6 Q. 6 . . 8 ' � � � 't � �� E �� : � `_ � °� . ' 0$i { .�} a t " ` � . � 75 G5 �5 . °s t � � � �O (ss� te� ` S (ax7. u a u i . � ° x u 39i+- + _.l' � Se 35 � sa � S . � � � .. � .a3 4^° • :; +: o (&) � . . ,. .. .. '1 . T ,� �"�-„ • ,9 � � "•e Q � ( � , � o .. � � ' . � 5 � h + 4 3 2 i �i . � ' . - , _�,�� a � a• o' '• q. ° + � 3 t , •'•�: �a�' � '1Q 't„A.y � ..—� �..�., � `r' GI.� @ '� 74� . . .�y �'YRT lAr2'�c $aC F94i2A� y . 30 �04 � . r �— p � ._ — _ , � �. 3 � ,� � , � ... � o . �R-r..•�• ,��y;c.>" _" "' ' � ' : , ��=. ;>-. .v: -� : .__..;,-. . - " - .�<_ .' w<r.; . .� . _ .i�: j n'�a�.4'.`.;,: �G�' .� � '�t3:`s.� i;r....' - . : �.i',.- '�z:'� .. " T- � w '4 `kc.c.� ; .''+. _ '.,� �t�'u=' ,�£�, r.' �°' '��r, � � •4. _"� ��-�� xc , r.�,r ?f y , x . . - � . _ ' _ ' •�r �� ^ ;'� S � r y . '�'' .,' s � � . � � S '` �� .-`'"�.- {.`�.c;. -. ' , a� � '°"' • _ . � e � • - . ., - _ w -�` .:E _ `� ., . ' " i- ' .... • ... p o yr i' F '•: '` _ . :A _ . ` � J^ �- . . : t.� _ - _ .�'_•: � � -.. �-. ��%� '�''�''_++z:"� . �., _ - �_� _ � - s - ' - - - . �n,.� � . ::#.:• - �ar.'- 1�- .+t2 '`.-,... �'�,.M _ _ ��.' _ v_o - ; �'3 "+�- � c . _ i�.... �.}' _ %"' . '= �:.� � :�� '" ' " � q _' `" �.:..'.. - !� ^.R., " �?�is.'�.�� :�,ze�' ;„. _ .. -.. . _ _ 'j''�� xF.: <��: o- . :• tig ' .:..y. .. . ' 9'...�f' � _f`►t'�: � ' - ^�`i �'k� _ ' _ � : � - - ::i..: _ .."�r"�'..�.;r��' _ �!��'t��. _ : :i'`:".�s�� . .. ,,. .. . .. _ T. - 3 � - �"`" £ � ��'^! . « i;. �� . � s v a r '. �:v+L:�:: a . . :r ' Y,.F-� �' Y`_. �... �,� �_. _ _ "y _ �;' - �: s. . . . �. ia .. . `s�cSU�.c. �. . . ' i . � . _ . s. ��. '� ...X� yt _ �.w ' 3 _ ¢ Y �'�'�. '. �-�� .S��i�.� '` �`, r :'�i✓:.i3°!ti_' �� .. k'.°.iJy' _• � .� :: }' r.. .�� ' L� . � ..`��i : " •" � ^ =- '� : �`�-'i'..�.-:' -�.�_..---•-�' __ .�...�, .�''._^< . -'�'.._�t� '- L��'�� ' � ' _ :' . ,+s. , =' - � - „ _. _ ."`T`�` �... .� - _ � " r�b �_: .Y . . . :: - ". '��s � ~ _' n, .:. .. �..� n . .. _ - • .. �r?'.. li �� - - ��. ..� ..ti . :. . .. ..:w'.a ��'� +�e� - - . � �i� +y �� ' ' `_"t rAl'� . . � _ :.,a'.-. - �-!°+� �' .��. -Y ��Y°_. . - � � -..�~ L_._�_: J.?.:: _ r r. ... _ _ _'R�i..'� _ _ - _ ��: .:. ` y � _ ` l''�. z - - ' .:. - ' " ' 64'.:. 2y .�.5 . ..�rt� _•.'qII.�' �. � - � .' :, v�' � " . i �" ' .' �. .:..` . _ .': _ i a.. .:.-.-. ... ' _ _ '. 'E. . . � . .. �: . .:r'� � -. ..� ' :AY4[ '+'n � �.. . .. � _ ..aP-.' _ t'3.= .. -� ^ �:P_ .3L�} _ >_�. - '-�x. . �'_�" �. . . �. _ . ,� i _ .. _ .. � : .: . '` ��J�r_�'�'i`^" :Yks*�+:.?- - - �¢'l?�_�; '�;��FY+s,i.>�.,;x.v's,>: _ _ - - .. , . ;;;w ��,x �,r.'�:z-?. ," ` . _ , ..i--k'= r �S. ' . — _'� �. " _ � �iya>:,`14.+4.-F �tT. '�1','ud' m .v`:�rV_'•'. v Y :�i r�ia.�,c,_`. ' 'r'"`�i'�.-i.� � ?Y. _ .... _ _ _ 6 . r $� _ . �.�K � ' .+`,�.♦ i_ Y'' '.f. :5.. �:{^" � � ':��_ �'�.'�_4f° :w�� _ .?.,� '-;.^ '�y i . "^ _ ': �: F .. l3eo� ' °si:: .' _ _ . :i'. _ - - o T°3? .'�. . : � , .,`.a�'b. �- '-��`� - - � :�.: � - ' �%q3..:.as - ' a:_:c,'Jy�'F 3'` • - .� � " ,x'�� :=1`�S^�S::yl �'�'• _ /��.y ••.yN _ _ o �. � r::$rt� _�" - :-au -:'f: «�' � �n'; . ¢ �rC:' .. ..... ��. a .: ".._ _ _ .r .. . _ .. ._,^. .. . ��Y � . �'�� '�.�'.=�'C '..W'i*'� : Y"� n �� • . � . ... , %y _ �..�$ ... �!- .. ,w . �:...i V . c '_':i . - s�X' `~ �-iY!w 2.�t�.'a��"''�j^' 4::� . . '.:" \ . .. _ .. ' :.�:ip . e. - . -�'v^ T`±f .��'. - ! � 5 -'T^� s � " � `� £ �v"� „+. '� .`�LL��:/.Y� ��.F �' �� "��'` �t'y'� . v'� .. yf ' ��~ � ( 5 - i £��` �� ..� .. . ��. � . _ __ _ µn. /-/� y� 'v '..12.'�� : .t. � � ��i� � . :. ! . :� . .T+ y '° i.:� ��`� i� S ' �� `'Xi' ' R s �+� � �+ F �� ^` r � � �� ...�. � J �4�'� ��_.__��-.��'�_ .. - _'y'Y .r'._3"'r�''.r X4�C' �` �� . _ _ ......::. '.�..�'.:: a..� ,« `-"'.. . _ _ a .. ... F-. �. `/ y a_ , _ .. .. . - �;a✓f�• �� .Y/-�` - _ ' br� . _i ��. � ��. .�` :�.' ,"� - '�•L,�:.� _'.+?.`. �:. ` a. ' 4 - ,< _ �_ _ .��-_i: '.g� � "u�`.. '.:�'e''='"�: � _ - SS�T.a'�.-�.jy/ :�"'�"'aC' �=``� '� - � ��.$`.:'<=.�.`i'1'�� 'Y". T�,� � `w� 'vC .'!yR. j- :43,c'? .F:� -��, :v!;"t�� ` �� ' i»::��:�� - ' ',�` ..a_.. � ''a?' ' ' - % - �-P'�: ;�� .E�' '.tK:��: - .�':: +'+�. �aJ� '�"�/ � � .. "3 �. �' .' K •8q ' , •.+.yr �i.'� • 1 "—�'"�-•� v3 �.•� —i= � � � � L � � .$� ��a£"��{ p J � � ' u. .. ' $s z '�� 'r. �� .,...' Y` -� � A � i..� ' .. � ��r�yi _ r t H F. i� _ � .� . � . -x 5�� ° S � "� �4 > ` / "blt. S.. .y�1� F �`M � GF�" -�. ..� _` .>�.�� • � � � �,+� ` i ` _<. �� Y i �j. /'/� 5 � - � s ��Y'= : � .y .( - ro'J+.�- h� ' � v . �y. � .c°`c°^ - .ii "�r-'�� ` 't�.._ .'^Se•'+� %° °r � w � 'h :'S''� ,y `nw � ^ .� � :t p ��`.. ��4�y� ..T: '� •a-aN` 'Y+...�" s.ecY' K: f• ��.. j_�-� _ - ".{::� . : .a.�x: �.^ 3 T-e""�"ibT�'4`.�K� .y?"��- Y".:_�"�u�1"�. � .� . �.�'Xd^J '� �v _ � . `..".� `� c;`�uciA� v,' 1�� Zc: ." _ _ ""_ ;.:4 ' -��".2.��=. � •;�;> ``r�E� _ _.�: 4 �:� : : -�. - � -��.�= ��-: ° 3- � �f.�' - ,�-� ,� ` , y= , = �� :_� ' + v Y+�+ - .'; �: j� � '..� + _NJ�"�' � ��v� . �: .?a�"y��' .��'S' �.1 . � .: a._ . . � i...i •Y�2 y", _ _ ' :-,.� <' � ...F � '.�,.,.�_" ?�ei�"-�'�=� ".�.�`1- .:�3 ,,, x �, ._ . . .� ,.s� �s- " _ v 4'i- T�. � �.: ?:.�� - '�r� <1.4i , M - } h: _.� .'..�.::: . h s�� : �A� _ . ? �'s s. - � 2� "*'.�+--` �` � ':ti'i°"_'�` . ' - _°':`.` � . "`:,,�< .3 , :`-�_�rx:- �...�. ` ��'r �`°•'4��.g,a�,_:.x�� `..�17� '_.�'.�_ �, _ " ��,"� . �' ' i. Tga... - ....� • � N. � : � ' :� ' r �r' '1 .a '��:�. :�4..b� ' ._�.i.r�_`J.:. '��' �,'�`',"�. a'...:�� . ..�_�. , . ."�`_*�:.�°- _ ..;,—_'�'' �—�-�,'.�? r �' ; ��z�<, �:'�:r��,<-�:",. ..:.�;' . . . a • �' � ,_ �;� ;�• �� 4 '� ~ �� -,f' " ` � ."'a, .,. . . . .a . _ . .-� s`— _ a... , . c;�, :.'�'a - ' �'.'., • �S "_ s :-c•• _� ': =.°•� ��t" .'__ '�P � yy� : i . .�+- .+'E� ' ' _, � . ... . __.�_ _�,�� . _' y�'d',.''. �j. : - :��`. ':::. �_c '�13: �� _ _ � , _,... tt . . _` . .�K_ . � l �� '.''! ' i . ..: �.. . .. ::m ` 'b ro3u:P�1'3°id..'!.�.�., _ _ Y�.�::T ..: "i `. " .'.3�"= : �'et - �:t3.��..;h: r:: � .d'�.y'r'-,% '�-'��,c°;x�"� `� ( '.Y. e�. ' 1 �� - �Po� 'rrc _z�,>S'v'3i ��- � _ - v.T'y. '�i'. _ ,/�'.. ,.. _ _ '`zi'`.x' _ ��..: � _ . .. . :: , ... ., � � :... ,...:.-� _ _ - �� . _ : ' .. • / • . e• 4 �'.'.. ;' . . _ �,� `�.[i:. _ ��j.�. .. `�� _ '�:?_. '_...G::F"�"b.$ "' .'. _ � �si .� `.,�.'�....._�.�r: . `1 .�;: _ =- .=6 �-_ ,�.- _ �-�a�,-�'. <.: , ..,. _r-:z.: -- '��>_ -r',�«�� ''�.�.'o- �4.s ,:t. ��- . 'r,.'' � - - w,?Y�e..: : ? . - -.�. ��.p ..y_', ��. -_ ' ,:a+�i.l n.. .. � -��C .ti� �4. .Ya.,;._ N''::�' T�JG' , _S: � �� :. �ca � .y�� '�`-��" � S J '�: : �.. � ,��^.s_. ��' '.�" . _ _ .: _+�..... _ v,� . :.. '� �, �� `. . � . v , , . . n �.-_,- i �� T ��.+'.:: �. .:�;`±':�-�:: � 7:-dx ��.K:�.�=�� ^ : :�:�:it�_��:_�_. -�.�_,1- ;.�'�_,��' _ ..�=�..��_ _ s�•: -:a;:` ��:: _ -': - ;;�-: s',.' ��'�;�.. -'-%r�`:'��. �� Yl..i.-.�, rs1'i��'� "„' ^i'''e:� `- - �.:.a � ',�,�°_'" . s:'"' �k.:':s '`Yv:' = . •,.�. . r=.a.,:�e: "'� ' r.X.r'�` ti "i5 -_ s.x.:= . i > a'� ::?-. . _ �s . � .: =5°.� i�..e�s} �}' '�i�a�F _ .... ��n� . � R !+'r"'.b�"� y'`:� `. � :�.. �r. :n: � �"l.�'V v'n.. . i:�.�'� � _ � �y"el---�.'l�� w ��a: ,. ?�� :'' �-�[r � .`��"s.: <':];•,^£°+ 'E. �4-_.... F : . ,. _ .';'.:?"'. :3'.; .. _ . ..,. �z._:r , _ <. � � � _ o � y,Ta^.,;._ _�.�ix��_�'Y �'.t.�i..,�.': � 'S.. �' .. ': .. a :r�.i.'"'t:." ir�S.vi-'_ . - 9 '?Ei' T �:.. o. C��. ,��'- _ -> 1 s . u � . . . :y.,:.. +i ' y �:�' .. y �:�':i_�: RL { A'��{ �+iS'G'a...'�.'�i�R�:.:'.-'F:1��'�".V�C� � - 0 �_ _T'w ' � � ` `f; :J .�Et�.'.45 ..�J?#' � .i '" � a , r. '. i.4 }�F'A- � S'. b � v • �"l�i� �'t'y�;a i' . ��}y..i�:� ° -i t r - �� tit/o�".f�yy� � ; � ' x =f .. 5: �}� '3Y �' 'Y' 'C' %" _ �t ir." .� _ . �� ' ^'T "' v' ::�' � a '�i +- �� y? .' .�":W<.:a"ar. .T ::�ai"'��T'.�.ti.� •�§ � _ " a. � .s: ''r� :#.: �: � :.^,�M, '�.�`:.-�'. �: ';�. -'-"s^:l � "_ .a� "'.""�:i � ' ��y'��' .'�:..: "i`�. ��~' • �:.:��„iy' �� . � - �S::.i3.1' a; -. lY l _!'� �3- 'x- :a :. t,:>. -;: _.;_ �,� :�s.=' .� .. _ , -. ' `;�,.» ' '' ."�`''u-rr�:�--rr. _' :� ? q',:?-:.. '� `� - `'"; ...6. _ ,'a4;i,,.,•< .'.. J.�J'_.. �z�^� .. ..s. , 'y}'`c�-.,., �� ..�. . : � n. ->:n8�. °?'::-.• � : ^.. v `, � . a��y...':rx:�t-.��i.: . " ::=.i. .. .s. ~ t . �.. • . i � ' ' . � . � _ . � _ : ; _ �� }4 �� . � •.�. � �, +�. _ _ ' �.+.e T �. . r_. ,' � : - '.: ��, "" y � ; :< . ='t�.: _ �.,: :.�.. z�_�� x � � _��a?s'�. a .a�s,'.�.._ =.. �;,,J' . - �a-� � - � v" . , � .-. .u" � '� _ °'- 2 _ 'a`s� .;�: d» �5,,, '^�:.��.": .�;:�.�.. '��"..s; ' ,<'- �'c � � :" �� ;� �{��° _-- -- - - -= r . � ' � :, ,r . . . .- .. . �:: .. .�. - - �2�tc�,r�r ' �► `� � J�:oOSF -�; �-Z..:. LE k � � �ATE / �� .td D�ST�_ A,tA° � . , �� ec=_r�o �____�__� zoning dislrict tvundary ��T1Z subje�t Prop'- �Y n� c, �h � +. n comma:=ia: + .�,> in�usuia: . V vzczi: 0 on. farrcity �i � h:ro (amiif . �¢(� inctltipi_!a.'stily . �,' � � - .��.�.:;:.,.;�..-�^-=�:. �- a �� ; ��: j : `'�' � ; � ' � � � ;L;�"--�! � tO3=1-�� t • .: CITEZEN PAR7ICIPATION P1.ANNING DISTRICTS ' � 1.SUNRAY-BATTLEGREEK�HIGHWOQD �� 2.GREATER•EAST SIOE � � � ' 3.WEST SIDE � � . � YTON'S BLUFF .. . 5. NE-PHALEN. NORTH END 7.THOMRS�DALE � .� 8.SUMMIT-UNIVERSITY � 9.WEST• SEV6NTH � � � 10. COMO . � - 11_HAMf.INE-MIDWAY ' � • ' 12.ST. A�tYiiONY l3.MERRIAhf PK.-LEkI�FGTON HAMLINE .d3�Z�.`�� .� � 14.GROVELAND-MACALESTER • . � _. . 15. H16t+tAND. . . . . 16:SUMMIT HILC � � � �. � . � . 17. oo�r�tbwr� . : . . . . � � CITIZEN PARTICIPA7I0 .DIS RICTS