Loading...
00-314Council File # ct�_3��} ORlG1NAL Presented By Referred To 1 2 3 4 ORDINANCE negative impacts of commercial uses when waiving distance requirements 9 THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: 10 11 12 13 Section 1 14 Section 403.05 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is amended to read as follows: 15 16 ordinance # Green Sheet # � �� t ✓` 17 Sec. 403.05. Distance between bingo halls. 18 (a) Minimum distance establtshed. A minimum distance of hvo (2) miles shail be required between buildings 19 licensed for bingo halls under the provisions of this chapter. This minunum distance requirement shall not be 20 applicable where the license is to be held in a place located in the downtown business district as defined in section 21 411.04(b)(4) of this Code. 22 (b) Waiver of distunce requirement. The minimum distance requirement herein imposed may, to nromote 23 resnonsible ownerslun and accountabilitv_, be waived by the �uncil upon� a finding�bv the council that the location 24 of the nronosed site would nrovide economic develonment bene`fits without siQnificant neeative unnacts on 25 residential or commercial uses:provided, however, that (� the waiver could allow no more than one licensed bin¢o 26 hall within two miles of another licensed bingo hall, and (, such a waiver could not begranted to the fee owner of 2� an existine, licensed bineo hall within a two-mile radius. . �--- -- -- -- - --- -- --- - - - - - - - - � ------ -- -- - --- - - - • . . -- . - - - - - - - - -- -- -- - - -- - - - - - - 1 - -- -- -- - - - --- -- - - -- - - - - - - .:-- - -- - - {�Z�jr�1-���������lylat�llZR�L��t�l�t��C�f���lqltl�l��1L�l�l�I�R�L7��lV���l�iRip 11��L���It��Yl�i R�iV�IU���LR�1 '(�IUIi���tw����l �lA��r ����� . �� t " An ordinance to amend Saint Paul Legislative Code Section 403.05; altering the waiver of distance requirements for bingo halls and requiring City Council to consider significant - _ _ - ' ' ' K:��v.v�ii�ii•d:�+:�vi���riu:��i��r•roei�:� C o -3 ;� 2(c) No consideration for consent to waivers. No licensee under this chapter shall request, accept or keep any 3 consideration in retum for his or her consent to the location of a proposed bingo hall as provided under subsection 4(b) above. No applicant for the location of a proposed bingo hall shall pay or offer to pay any consideration to any 5 person in return for obtaiiuug a consent to the location of a bingo hall in a specific locarion as provided in 6 subsection (b) above. "Consideration" for the purpose of this section means and includes any and all legal 7 consideration, money, real or personal property, promises or contractual obligations, negotiable or other instruments 8 given to or received by any person, including the licensee, his or her friends or relatives, his or her creditors, any 9 other person acting on his or her behalf, and any other person at the d'uection or request of the licensee. 10 (d) Adverse action authorized. The council may consider and impose adverse action against any person, firm or 11 corporation holding any license of the City of Saint Paul, or against any applicant for any such license, after notice 12 and hearing as provided in section 310.05 of the Legislative Code, based on a violation of the prohibitions 13 contained in subsection (c) above, as well as on other violations of law or ordinance relating to such a matter. 14 15 16 17 18 19 �� 23 24 25 26 27 zs 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 Section 2 This ordinance shall take effect and be in full force thirty (30) days following its passage, approval and publication BY� L\ '��'- Approved by By: ■� - ' /�'. Requested by Department of: Office of License. Insoections and Environmental Protection BY: 1,� K�� Form Approved by City Attorne By : �/J Approved by ayor for Submission to Council � V`—` B ; '' � �3Q��� Adopted by Council: Date p o� Adoption Certified by Council Sec etary _,--n-= , � OFFICE OF LIEP Date: GREEN SHEET Robert Kessler February 24, 200o p0 �� 266-9112 No . 103731 1 EPARTMENT DIRHCTOR ITY WUNCIL � 'Z ITY A71bRNEY ITY CLERK v�cwe ust be on CounCil Agenda by: � ��$T DIRECNR IN. & MGT. SVC. DSR. � SAP 3 xox (ox uszsxaNx) OTAL # OR SIGNATIIRB PAGSS 1 (CLIP AI,L LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) CTION REQUESTED: ordinance to amend Saint Paul Legislative Code Section 403.05; clarifying the waiver of distance requirements for bingo halls and requiring City Council to consider significant negative impacts on both commercial and residential ses when waiving distance requirements. COhV4ENDATSONS: APPROVB (A) OR RESECP (R) BRSONAL SBAVICB CONTRI�CTS MOST ANS➢]&R THS POLIA[PING: PLANNING COMMISSZON CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION 1. Has the peraon/fixm ever worked under a contract For this depar[mentl CIB COM1II�fIT1'&& BUSINESS RSVIEW C1�ONCIL YES NO STaPF � 2. Has this pexaonJ£ism evez been a City employee? DISTRICT COUAT YES NO Does this person/fiYm pos9ess a skill not normally possessed by any SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OsJECTIVSa �uXrent City employee? YES NO laia all Y85 aa�vere on a aeparate sheet aad attach. , INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNSTY (Who, What, When, Where, Why): Currently, the waiver o£ distance requirement for bingo halls requires written consent from operators of bingo halls located within a two mile radius and a finding by the City Council that no negative impact be placed on residential ses. This waiver procedure is not feasible and has never been used because it is impossible to satisfy. VANTAGES IF APPROVED: asier to grant a waiver of distance requirements where the City Council determines that such a waiver is appropriate and necessary. ISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED: one apparent. ISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: aiver would remain unworkable and essentially not possible to obtain. TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED YES NO FUNDING SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER FINAI3CIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN) �A��. � � "� :: � �: � ;� � � ; 3:�, _ . �.� ��°��° ������ ��� ; a 2940 ��s �A� 4i� ��00 ���� F � �€��ll , -_ . . � �� �_�� � �� ������b���_� P���� �a� b. �- ���� �� � ��� �� 07/25/1994 14:57 • - ! � � � ��' L 6517742135 DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 01 C �` �Zt— �v Cd C [ G�/I � �'`� '\ S �� � � /' � ( � 'f - � �� _ ��-��- l • � t � � � � �J� � � � � C b�L ��fZ'�-� /��j ���� ��T l � � �� � �` � at1�l� ������ �� ��� �� � r ! t� `� �� v L ( �-� �� � � � • ������s � �� � � 07/25/1994 14:57 6517742135 DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 02 DISTRICT 2 COMIV�UNIT'Y �OUNCIL SERVING THE NEIGHBORHOODS OF IeORTHEASTERN SAINT PAUL • PARKWAY/GREENBRlER � BFi1 V6R LAKE HEJC�HTS PROSPERIT` HEIGHTS • HAYDEN HE7GHT5 PHwLEN V{LLA4E • LINCOLTI PnRK EAST PHALEN � I-IAZEI PARK FROSr Ln[c6 • H��uaESr ?o: City Councilmembers From: Chuck Repke — District 2 Coa�znunity Council lteeardin�: Item 30 — Pinal Adoption of an ordinance annending the Saint Paul Le�,+islative Code Section 403.05; altering the waiver of distanca requirements for bingo t�alls... � r� L As many of you witl recali the placing of a bingo hall in the Hillcrest Shopping Ce�nter was quite cocm'oversiat. Community members speculated that the number of cars in the parkiag lot of bingo customers would make doing retail in the certer impossible. The attached story from the East Side Review shows the impact of bingo on the mall and �+rill hopefully lead the Council towards making better public policy. The passing of Ronald Jewelers fxom the East Side busirness community is a uue loss to the neighborhood. I hope that yoiu desizes to protect other local merchants will guide youc vote on item 30. 1961 SHERwooD AvENUE• $qINT PnUL • MN • 55 ] 19-3230 • PHONE: (65 ]) 774-2220 • FnX: (651) 774-2] 35 07/25/1994 14:57 6517742135 DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 03 � � � � %fiy. .� .� .._ _ Y !X'. : � , �' i ._-0 _ �. +_ a �� \O ,. � �: /�, 0 � � :� � ��i. ::• 1li� � ` ` � �� � ���r`� �.. � ' ��,,._ M �� � . . �,�� .. 3a = . �' � : �' . �� �,`� �' � ! ' �' `" � - _ ,.. , ..�r�. ': ���'�° W �� 7 '�'c�. -.y,.V� y" 'P �s __� �••TC._ � � � .. � . _, .. �,� �� �' �'. ✓ 0 :. . , y ,. p'� ° ,��' �K. �. C�i� 3: �. �.i . �i � � � � { m � @ 4 c N p m o ���� ��� �m� ��i �° � i 3Y�L n �� �� E I O m � C I q�;.'7. I ��g� g9�� E�¢� �¢ � _ C � � �� . 0 � W Y . ` � , �.z�.� O � .�. ` i 5.�.�. ] 'S. �'✓. =. A a � �8� . �� a'�.4. ' °�' �� ? " �;. , � �.. m 9�0���" ,�o. d� "s�"�'S e ., °. t,_ _ q � �� � . � � o . : . S�3i �t. d.i b • :���' � �• 1 �:- a G, � O t7. C a y .d $ o .!1 3 ,5 `c y ffi �° �=8�— T � d TJ� � a.y �����.�•c- .. � �-�: Y . . � }' ' _ , x-. - i � YJ 07/25/1994 14:57 6517742135 � �. • � � � � � � ` a � �""�� DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 04 r ..�.. L � a�S�.'° °�-� �E � v� ^� GO a <�'p . 0 E v. d C O� �� O� L'... e .s �L a� w '�>t�3 � y � ". _-� °- a °Y�'�$ m �m:��_ �.��i�� �� d •.�� � � C V. O �QW �� � • b. �� q �� GJ y p � g .r t . a � !B u �..��,�' -� 0 � � �m����� y �y3.i.j�.���w� CO'��4+ df• °� °� �� o� p�°o ..Qm t� � x w �� � N u� M� ���' 92 u, � t a+ N a y g � E. G T r. �, � LJ D 7 t� � N vr >� s 5�p' y ai y v'' y n E d��. ,�_+...".t E 3 A.P.��a2'� Y� 3: � v`-° "'� �; �» v� @� �`p��o+tw ��o�tlp�O�t..C."'°a. �a.�ou�� � O� p u �.+.,»�� Q49 o,, s o r c �� m �5 0 3�°�� a.a �'� m, �� . cx� m�E?av �u .,e � �y ,,����o,�t^ �rY3ro3�;�aoQ. � b°d� ' a O ° 0�'=- o fl N � � � �a U 'L " � � N • � C .� '.. � n � �� �i 3 u.�. � � A N TO. N� � '-° '� w � o, � 1C " � .. w D � S �Vt� a�a .�c .� O 7 � ��� O � ; j G a.�.� �S.-;� u.G . '� O'g p � �'� � � � � 0 � '� � o � `� $ ,3 y � fp (5 �j 'O g C 9 � O C ' tgp ' �, ? ��v 8 3` °' 5 aZ'��a3e��Y�" � s8 `+� u G'^ ti� �� 4 �� 7 a� T W '.Z�� m e� �Kw'�� 1° o � �� n S m� O� c' O x 0 �" ti O� � �. � > N C M N,� N'O V Yi SD O 1 C a� O ,K .0 � � 3 ' � p. . oB a� N � v°� O' : C.1 ,- y � � y � O � �-n = w ,l. . .... , � c� ; eg � ���°� TL ,,•-•,, � ip p� g �� 3'' -.m, � �. o�� 6 �i ° .5� p '�' ; W p � M � T q � qy}( � � N � 3 x' � " oa.�r � � t .� .°° c ,c-.�' 3 .°. d��0 dX p°� � O C r m,Y � Y° .. C�� � oC � Ob � C ' p asy�� �'' v n?.5� `� � . o m � � a y' r �. O C � x � s � '�. "� � w a O F m� 00 O ' O :: m� � '-��� a�=;v �a c ao �� � s � w u o `�Q4 a-� .8 a a. 3 d 'o R d. Q � v�� 3w7 `"� �. rf � M [ x � � u � • � �jj G: $ - O� J�"y u Q�� 6 � � �� � F � % Q � ^ µ � « � ~ �`�.1� > �. � 8 E ° o ��v�•. � p r �� C� �� � � 9��`ew a� � c m � � ' � � � � � � ` � � � � E?`v „' �,,.°�• � ro.° 5 � . � � L �Ii � .� V � ��ti � � "e .�-,sa 8 „ 3 g '' T ° �.. „ :'�' �.,� v- a.� ti� � �"��°' ° ,.. � c 1 i ar i0..:�C�.Q.�-�A � 00 � G C � T O C C� maop E�� $ � S�'.5� '' , tl Q r mr u � ` T +J q- '�G�C N�� ' m'ra� _�,�c o ° 'm°R.c • � L ,-�.•-_ p.M �' °� r ° � A� y �'�`'����; A g d w � � mT �� y �.c �•� �y A'is ,� �S Ci9 y •� y io ¢ m� v'` s� A.G y� 3 s: �p h p O O .�-� O� C p y .� � �p y O 1� T ����u�.=yu � p y l [�+ O V � VJ �'G V• A. C J7 G. � O i.�, O.C.`� T� O w m vl E� . JC �j 3.�7 S c., L'"vvaw um. m > y �o:;'_ °�^ 3 y � �- 9 e, a$�.�'�o.c g' �'+` c w '� .. � C 'v� oaoec��'_ ,C, ��u y �ar m 0 W��Y C CZ � A��F.~p.y(D 7 4 �. O� C � v � O � d � ; �� . ���4 + �3 - j� � �p+r�'O p..r d y>• V � . p� pp � D �C�:� N-S m��bO��..�'G'dW b �..�'•^'�t� � 9: d� � m-� O C V. -p ' O..�3; r w N� '.. m �.°�. y p ,g �:-� o:.v, �; -.°� °a a ' �� yp � 3 . � y �q �e, � m i0��� ' ��b, u.q O' N �000 ���T:: � { Y a CS �t� >`� o?�. e�i ^�° e d � ao �`J' � �{ b� d E 5 a �. :� ���Y'��"�V Ci9 �'Y C1 � ° S� M��'.'� �o. -o'm �a°4�'s�i°dAa. ?u i -m ��:'S:sz�'�v�s'� �o m �.. r r:� y,.,�,ifl. .��., . ��, . ,JI!{!� 0 �i r . m ..�a+n iYi�r� `eti �r..:. m. � � � ^ �. m .' 1 v ,� '° q O� p. <�� D Na ��,� � F Q �'� � 5,:`�"��:i�_�:� �3 m_ t5 � d �'� �''9i o,K �� � 9� o`�:_ g. �`°g�c`�$o,�� S.'��� ° a � �N O "J' ^ .� `y r � � V .� 8 � 8 ; � •� � �" N a k'_��'s� oo._ °�+ :o � G - `o S 0 ��r-� '�c'DOamon � w O d C yyT� '°a.=.3-�Q25H�3�]C9;� 3•-,����"� �z � w= ° -�de� $ W�A. �N .1.. .� !" � . c`cr E�' o,a•�c�? � ,j+ H�� L T� �^ N� V � ''�' ^ `J� �a � 2 . $' � q � r � � y .. c 'y � ws ocmJ'"�^+3� d w .`at� ° �� ,q d �r �a d �C ' ,�, r .Y a0 Z � �=o�` ° �� � �� N.� d y t T � a C ,�� _ � V a... ,K ��, > p p e�-=g '� Y p d� E�9 � O C���.. � �y E �o�4�� .v y— c�,�,'a''„—y m u� u o� �u_... � `° ty,. y "�x'�'Sa� q ��i Council File # ct�_3��} ORlG1NAL Presented By Referred To 1 2 3 4 ORDINANCE negative impacts of commercial uses when waiving distance requirements 9 THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: 10 11 12 13 Section 1 14 Section 403.05 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is amended to read as follows: 15 16 ordinance # Green Sheet # � �� t ✓` 17 Sec. 403.05. Distance between bingo halls. 18 (a) Minimum distance establtshed. A minimum distance of hvo (2) miles shail be required between buildings 19 licensed for bingo halls under the provisions of this chapter. This minunum distance requirement shall not be 20 applicable where the license is to be held in a place located in the downtown business district as defined in section 21 411.04(b)(4) of this Code. 22 (b) Waiver of distunce requirement. The minimum distance requirement herein imposed may, to nromote 23 resnonsible ownerslun and accountabilitv_, be waived by the �uncil upon� a finding�bv the council that the location 24 of the nronosed site would nrovide economic develonment bene`fits without siQnificant neeative unnacts on 25 residential or commercial uses:provided, however, that (� the waiver could allow no more than one licensed bin¢o 26 hall within two miles of another licensed bingo hall, and (, such a waiver could not begranted to the fee owner of 2� an existine, licensed bineo hall within a two-mile radius. . �--- -- -- -- - --- -- --- - - - - - - - - � ------ -- -- - --- - - - • . . -- . - - - - - - - - -- -- -- - - -- - - - - - - 1 - -- -- -- - - - --- -- - - -- - - - - - - .:-- - -- - - {�Z�jr�1-���������lylat�llZR�L��t�l�t��C�f���lqltl�l��1L�l�l�I�R�L7��lV���l�iRip 11��L���It��Yl�i R�iV�IU���LR�1 '(�IUIi���tw����l �lA��r ����� . �� t " An ordinance to amend Saint Paul Legislative Code Section 403.05; altering the waiver of distance requirements for bingo halls and requiring City Council to consider significant - _ _ - ' ' ' K:��v.v�ii�ii•d:�+:�vi���riu:��i��r•roei�:� C o -3 ;� 2(c) No consideration for consent to waivers. No licensee under this chapter shall request, accept or keep any 3 consideration in retum for his or her consent to the location of a proposed bingo hall as provided under subsection 4(b) above. No applicant for the location of a proposed bingo hall shall pay or offer to pay any consideration to any 5 person in return for obtaiiuug a consent to the location of a bingo hall in a specific locarion as provided in 6 subsection (b) above. "Consideration" for the purpose of this section means and includes any and all legal 7 consideration, money, real or personal property, promises or contractual obligations, negotiable or other instruments 8 given to or received by any person, including the licensee, his or her friends or relatives, his or her creditors, any 9 other person acting on his or her behalf, and any other person at the d'uection or request of the licensee. 10 (d) Adverse action authorized. The council may consider and impose adverse action against any person, firm or 11 corporation holding any license of the City of Saint Paul, or against any applicant for any such license, after notice 12 and hearing as provided in section 310.05 of the Legislative Code, based on a violation of the prohibitions 13 contained in subsection (c) above, as well as on other violations of law or ordinance relating to such a matter. 14 15 16 17 18 19 �� 23 24 25 26 27 zs 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 Section 2 This ordinance shall take effect and be in full force thirty (30) days following its passage, approval and publication BY� L\ '��'- Approved by By: ■� - ' /�'. Requested by Department of: Office of License. Insoections and Environmental Protection BY: 1,� K�� Form Approved by City Attorne By : �/J Approved by ayor for Submission to Council � V`—` B ; '' � �3Q��� Adopted by Council: Date p o� Adoption Certified by Council Sec etary _,--n-= , � OFFICE OF LIEP Date: GREEN SHEET Robert Kessler February 24, 200o p0 �� 266-9112 No . 103731 1 EPARTMENT DIRHCTOR ITY WUNCIL � 'Z ITY A71bRNEY ITY CLERK v�cwe ust be on CounCil Agenda by: � ��$T DIRECNR IN. & MGT. SVC. DSR. � SAP 3 xox (ox uszsxaNx) OTAL # OR SIGNATIIRB PAGSS 1 (CLIP AI,L LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) CTION REQUESTED: ordinance to amend Saint Paul Legislative Code Section 403.05; clarifying the waiver of distance requirements for bingo halls and requiring City Council to consider significant negative impacts on both commercial and residential ses when waiving distance requirements. COhV4ENDATSONS: APPROVB (A) OR RESECP (R) BRSONAL SBAVICB CONTRI�CTS MOST ANS➢]&R THS POLIA[PING: PLANNING COMMISSZON CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION 1. Has the peraon/fixm ever worked under a contract For this depar[mentl CIB COM1II�fIT1'&& BUSINESS RSVIEW C1�ONCIL YES NO STaPF � 2. Has this pexaonJ£ism evez been a City employee? DISTRICT COUAT YES NO Does this person/fiYm pos9ess a skill not normally possessed by any SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OsJECTIVSa �uXrent City employee? YES NO laia all Y85 aa�vere on a aeparate sheet aad attach. , INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNSTY (Who, What, When, Where, Why): Currently, the waiver o£ distance requirement for bingo halls requires written consent from operators of bingo halls located within a two mile radius and a finding by the City Council that no negative impact be placed on residential ses. This waiver procedure is not feasible and has never been used because it is impossible to satisfy. VANTAGES IF APPROVED: asier to grant a waiver of distance requirements where the City Council determines that such a waiver is appropriate and necessary. ISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED: one apparent. ISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: aiver would remain unworkable and essentially not possible to obtain. TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED YES NO FUNDING SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER FINAI3CIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN) �A��. � � "� :: � �: � ;� � � ; 3:�, _ . �.� ��°��° ������ ��� ; a 2940 ��s �A� 4i� ��00 ���� F � �€��ll , -_ . . � �� �_�� � �� ������b���_� P���� �a� b. �- ���� �� � ��� �� 07/25/1994 14:57 • - ! � � � ��' L 6517742135 DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 01 C �` �Zt— �v Cd C [ G�/I � �'`� '\ S �� � � /' � ( � 'f - � �� _ ��-��- l • � t � � � � �J� � � � � C b�L ��fZ'�-� /��j ���� ��T l � � �� � �` � at1�l� ������ �� ��� �� � r ! t� `� �� v L ( �-� �� � � � • ������s � �� � � 07/25/1994 14:57 6517742135 DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 02 DISTRICT 2 COMIV�UNIT'Y �OUNCIL SERVING THE NEIGHBORHOODS OF IeORTHEASTERN SAINT PAUL • PARKWAY/GREENBRlER � BFi1 V6R LAKE HEJC�HTS PROSPERIT` HEIGHTS • HAYDEN HE7GHT5 PHwLEN V{LLA4E • LINCOLTI PnRK EAST PHALEN � I-IAZEI PARK FROSr Ln[c6 • H��uaESr ?o: City Councilmembers From: Chuck Repke — District 2 Coa�znunity Council lteeardin�: Item 30 — Pinal Adoption of an ordinance annending the Saint Paul Le�,+islative Code Section 403.05; altering the waiver of distanca requirements for bingo t�alls... � r� L As many of you witl recali the placing of a bingo hall in the Hillcrest Shopping Ce�nter was quite cocm'oversiat. Community members speculated that the number of cars in the parkiag lot of bingo customers would make doing retail in the certer impossible. The attached story from the East Side Review shows the impact of bingo on the mall and �+rill hopefully lead the Council towards making better public policy. The passing of Ronald Jewelers fxom the East Side busirness community is a uue loss to the neighborhood. I hope that yoiu desizes to protect other local merchants will guide youc vote on item 30. 1961 SHERwooD AvENUE• $qINT PnUL • MN • 55 ] 19-3230 • PHONE: (65 ]) 774-2220 • FnX: (651) 774-2] 35 07/25/1994 14:57 6517742135 DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 03 � � � � %fiy. .� .� .._ _ Y !X'. : � , �' i ._-0 _ �. +_ a �� \O ,. � �: /�, 0 � � :� � ��i. ::• 1li� � ` ` � �� � ���r`� �.. � ' ��,,._ M �� � . . �,�� .. 3a = . �' � : �' . �� �,`� �' � ! ' �' `" � - _ ,.. , ..�r�. ': ���'�° W �� 7 '�'c�. -.y,.V� y" 'P �s __� �••TC._ � � � .. � . _, .. �,� �� �' �'. ✓ 0 :. . , y ,. p'� ° ,��' �K. �. C�i� 3: �. �.i . �i � � � � { m � @ 4 c N p m o ���� ��� �m� ��i �° � i 3Y�L n �� �� E I O m � C I q�;.'7. I ��g� g9�� E�¢� �¢ � _ C � � �� . 0 � W Y . ` � , �.z�.� O � .�. ` i 5.�.�. ] 'S. �'✓. =. A a � �8� . �� a'�.4. ' °�' �� ? " �;. , � �.. m 9�0���" ,�o. d� "s�"�'S e ., °. t,_ _ q � �� � . � � o . : . S�3i �t. d.i b • :���' � �• 1 �:- a G, � O t7. C a y .d $ o .!1 3 ,5 `c y ffi �° �=8�— T � d TJ� � a.y �����.�•c- .. � �-�: Y . . � }' ' _ , x-. - i � YJ 07/25/1994 14:57 6517742135 � �. • � � � � � � ` a � �""�� DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 04 r ..�.. L � a�S�.'° °�-� �E � v� ^� GO a <�'p . 0 E v. d C O� �� O� L'... e .s �L a� w '�>t�3 � y � ". _-� °- a °Y�'�$ m �m:��_ �.��i�� �� d •.�� � � C V. O �QW �� � • b. �� q �� GJ y p � g .r t . a � !B u �..��,�' -� 0 � � �m����� y �y3.i.j�.���w� CO'��4+ df• °� °� �� o� p�°o ..Qm t� � x w �� � N u� M� ���' 92 u, � t a+ N a y g � E. G T r. �, � LJ D 7 t� � N vr >� s 5�p' y ai y v'' y n E d��. ,�_+...".t E 3 A.P.��a2'� Y� 3: � v`-° "'� �; �» v� @� �`p��o+tw ��o�tlp�O�t..C."'°a. �a.�ou�� � O� p u �.+.,»�� Q49 o,, s o r c �� m �5 0 3�°�� a.a �'� m, �� . cx� m�E?av �u .,e � �y ,,����o,�t^ �rY3ro3�;�aoQ. � b°d� ' a O ° 0�'=- o fl N � � � �a U 'L " � � N • � C .� '.. � n � �� �i 3 u.�. � � A N TO. N� � '-° '� w � o, � 1C " � .. w D � S �Vt� a�a .�c .� O 7 � ��� O � ; j G a.�.� �S.-;� u.G . '� O'g p � �'� � � � � 0 � '� � o � `� $ ,3 y � fp (5 �j 'O g C 9 � O C ' tgp ' �, ? ��v 8 3` °' 5 aZ'��a3e��Y�" � s8 `+� u G'^ ti� �� 4 �� 7 a� T W '.Z�� m e� �Kw'�� 1° o � �� n S m� O� c' O x 0 �" ti O� � �. � > N C M N,� N'O V Yi SD O 1 C a� O ,K .0 � � 3 ' � p. . oB a� N � v°� O' : C.1 ,- y � � y � O � �-n = w ,l. . .... , � c� ; eg � ���°� TL ,,•-•,, � ip p� g �� 3'' -.m, � �. o�� 6 �i ° .5� p '�' ; W p � M � T q � qy}( � � N � 3 x' � " oa.�r � � t .� .°° c ,c-.�' 3 .°. d��0 dX p°� � O C r m,Y � Y° .. C�� � oC � Ob � C ' p asy�� �'' v n?.5� `� � . o m � � a y' r �. O C � x � s � '�. "� � w a O F m� 00 O ' O :: m� � '-��� a�=;v �a c ao �� � s � w u o `�Q4 a-� .8 a a. 3 d 'o R d. Q � v�� 3w7 `"� �. rf � M [ x � � u � • � �jj G: $ - O� J�"y u Q�� 6 � � �� � F � % Q � ^ µ � « � ~ �`�.1� > �. � 8 E ° o ��v�•. � p r �� C� �� � � 9��`ew a� � c m � � ' � � � � � � ` � � � � E?`v „' �,,.°�• � ro.° 5 � . � � L �Ii � .� V � ��ti � � "e .�-,sa 8 „ 3 g '' T ° �.. „ :'�' �.,� v- a.� ti� � �"��°' ° ,.. � c 1 i ar i0..:�C�.Q.�-�A � 00 � G C � T O C C� maop E�� $ � S�'.5� '' , tl Q r mr u � ` T +J q- '�G�C N�� ' m'ra� _�,�c o ° 'm°R.c • � L ,-�.•-_ p.M �' °� r ° � A� y �'�`'����; A g d w � � mT �� y �.c �•� �y A'is ,� �S Ci9 y •� y io ¢ m� v'` s� A.G y� 3 s: �p h p O O .�-� O� C p y .� � �p y O 1� T ����u�.=yu � p y l [�+ O V � VJ �'G V• A. C J7 G. � O i.�, O.C.`� T� O w m vl E� . JC �j 3.�7 S c., L'"vvaw um. m > y �o:;'_ °�^ 3 y � �- 9 e, a$�.�'�o.c g' �'+` c w '� .. � C 'v� oaoec��'_ ,C, ��u y �ar m 0 W��Y C CZ � A��F.~p.y(D 7 4 �. O� C � v � O � d � ; �� . ���4 + �3 - j� � �p+r�'O p..r d y>• V � . p� pp � D �C�:� N-S m��bO��..�'G'dW b �..�'•^'�t� � 9: d� � m-� O C V. -p ' O..�3; r w N� '.. m �.°�. y p ,g �:-� o:.v, �; -.°� °a a ' �� yp � 3 . � y �q �e, � m i0��� ' ��b, u.q O' N �000 ���T:: � { Y a CS �t� >`� o?�. e�i ^�° e d � ao �`J' � �{ b� d E 5 a �. :� ���Y'��"�V Ci9 �'Y C1 � ° S� M��'.'� �o. -o'm �a°4�'s�i°dAa. ?u i -m ��:'S:sz�'�v�s'� �o m �.. r r:� y,.,�,ifl. .��., . ��, . ,JI!{!� 0 �i r . m ..�a+n iYi�r� `eti �r..:. m. � � � ^ �. m .' 1 v ,� '° q O� p. <�� D Na ��,� � F Q �'� � 5,:`�"��:i�_�:� �3 m_ t5 � d �'� �''9i o,K �� � 9� o`�:_ g. �`°g�c`�$o,�� S.'��� ° a � �N O "J' ^ .� `y r � � V .� 8 � 8 ; � •� � �" N a k'_��'s� oo._ °�+ :o � G - `o S 0 ��r-� '�c'DOamon � w O d C yyT� '°a.=.3-�Q25H�3�]C9;� 3•-,����"� �z � w= ° -�de� $ W�A. �N .1.. .� !" � . c`cr E�' o,a•�c�? � ,j+ H�� L T� �^ N� V � ''�' ^ `J� �a � 2 . $' � q � r � � y .. c 'y � ws ocmJ'"�^+3� d w .`at� ° �� ,q d �r �a d �C ' ,�, r .Y a0 Z � �=o�` ° �� � �� N.� d y t T � a C ,�� _ � V a... ,K ��, > p p e�-=g '� Y p d� E�9 � O C���.. � �y E �o�4�� .v y— c�,�,'a''„—y m u� u o� �u_... � `° ty,. y "�x'�'Sa� q ��i Council File # ct�_3��} ORlG1NAL Presented By Referred To 1 2 3 4 ORDINANCE negative impacts of commercial uses when waiving distance requirements 9 THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: 10 11 12 13 Section 1 14 Section 403.05 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code is amended to read as follows: 15 16 ordinance # Green Sheet # � �� t ✓` 17 Sec. 403.05. Distance between bingo halls. 18 (a) Minimum distance establtshed. A minimum distance of hvo (2) miles shail be required between buildings 19 licensed for bingo halls under the provisions of this chapter. This minunum distance requirement shall not be 20 applicable where the license is to be held in a place located in the downtown business district as defined in section 21 411.04(b)(4) of this Code. 22 (b) Waiver of distunce requirement. The minimum distance requirement herein imposed may, to nromote 23 resnonsible ownerslun and accountabilitv_, be waived by the �uncil upon� a finding�bv the council that the location 24 of the nronosed site would nrovide economic develonment bene`fits without siQnificant neeative unnacts on 25 residential or commercial uses:provided, however, that (� the waiver could allow no more than one licensed bin¢o 26 hall within two miles of another licensed bingo hall, and (, such a waiver could not begranted to the fee owner of 2� an existine, licensed bineo hall within a two-mile radius. . �--- -- -- -- - --- -- --- - - - - - - - - � ------ -- -- - --- - - - • . . -- . - - - - - - - - -- -- -- - - -- - - - - - - 1 - -- -- -- - - - --- -- - - -- - - - - - - .:-- - -- - - {�Z�jr�1-���������lylat�llZR�L��t�l�t��C�f���lqltl�l��1L�l�l�I�R�L7��lV���l�iRip 11��L���It��Yl�i R�iV�IU���LR�1 '(�IUIi���tw����l �lA��r ����� . �� t " An ordinance to amend Saint Paul Legislative Code Section 403.05; altering the waiver of distance requirements for bingo halls and requiring City Council to consider significant - _ _ - ' ' ' K:��v.v�ii�ii•d:�+:�vi���riu:��i��r•roei�:� C o -3 ;� 2(c) No consideration for consent to waivers. No licensee under this chapter shall request, accept or keep any 3 consideration in retum for his or her consent to the location of a proposed bingo hall as provided under subsection 4(b) above. No applicant for the location of a proposed bingo hall shall pay or offer to pay any consideration to any 5 person in return for obtaiiuug a consent to the location of a bingo hall in a specific locarion as provided in 6 subsection (b) above. "Consideration" for the purpose of this section means and includes any and all legal 7 consideration, money, real or personal property, promises or contractual obligations, negotiable or other instruments 8 given to or received by any person, including the licensee, his or her friends or relatives, his or her creditors, any 9 other person acting on his or her behalf, and any other person at the d'uection or request of the licensee. 10 (d) Adverse action authorized. The council may consider and impose adverse action against any person, firm or 11 corporation holding any license of the City of Saint Paul, or against any applicant for any such license, after notice 12 and hearing as provided in section 310.05 of the Legislative Code, based on a violation of the prohibitions 13 contained in subsection (c) above, as well as on other violations of law or ordinance relating to such a matter. 14 15 16 17 18 19 �� 23 24 25 26 27 zs 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 Section 2 This ordinance shall take effect and be in full force thirty (30) days following its passage, approval and publication BY� L\ '��'- Approved by By: ■� - ' /�'. Requested by Department of: Office of License. Insoections and Environmental Protection BY: 1,� K�� Form Approved by City Attorne By : �/J Approved by ayor for Submission to Council � V`—` B ; '' � �3Q��� Adopted by Council: Date p o� Adoption Certified by Council Sec etary _,--n-= , � OFFICE OF LIEP Date: GREEN SHEET Robert Kessler February 24, 200o p0 �� 266-9112 No . 103731 1 EPARTMENT DIRHCTOR ITY WUNCIL � 'Z ITY A71bRNEY ITY CLERK v�cwe ust be on CounCil Agenda by: � ��$T DIRECNR IN. & MGT. SVC. DSR. � SAP 3 xox (ox uszsxaNx) OTAL # OR SIGNATIIRB PAGSS 1 (CLIP AI,L LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATURE) CTION REQUESTED: ordinance to amend Saint Paul Legislative Code Section 403.05; clarifying the waiver of distance requirements for bingo halls and requiring City Council to consider significant negative impacts on both commercial and residential ses when waiving distance requirements. COhV4ENDATSONS: APPROVB (A) OR RESECP (R) BRSONAL SBAVICB CONTRI�CTS MOST ANS➢]&R THS POLIA[PING: PLANNING COMMISSZON CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION 1. Has the peraon/fixm ever worked under a contract For this depar[mentl CIB COM1II�fIT1'&& BUSINESS RSVIEW C1�ONCIL YES NO STaPF � 2. Has this pexaonJ£ism evez been a City employee? DISTRICT COUAT YES NO Does this person/fiYm pos9ess a skill not normally possessed by any SUPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OsJECTIVSa �uXrent City employee? YES NO laia all Y85 aa�vere on a aeparate sheet aad attach. , INITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNSTY (Who, What, When, Where, Why): Currently, the waiver o£ distance requirement for bingo halls requires written consent from operators of bingo halls located within a two mile radius and a finding by the City Council that no negative impact be placed on residential ses. This waiver procedure is not feasible and has never been used because it is impossible to satisfy. VANTAGES IF APPROVED: asier to grant a waiver of distance requirements where the City Council determines that such a waiver is appropriate and necessary. ISADVANTAGES IF APPROVED: one apparent. ISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: aiver would remain unworkable and essentially not possible to obtain. TOTAL AMOUNT OF TRANSACTION $ COST/REVENUE BUDGETED YES NO FUNDING SOURCE ACTIVITY NUMBER FINAI3CIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIN) �A��. � � "� :: � �: � ;� � � ; 3:�, _ . �.� ��°��° ������ ��� ; a 2940 ��s �A� 4i� ��00 ���� F � �€��ll , -_ . . � �� �_�� � �� ������b���_� P���� �a� b. �- ���� �� � ��� �� 07/25/1994 14:57 • - ! � � � ��' L 6517742135 DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 01 C �` �Zt— �v Cd C [ G�/I � �'`� '\ S �� � � /' � ( � 'f - � �� _ ��-��- l • � t � � � � �J� � � � � C b�L ��fZ'�-� /��j ���� ��T l � � �� � �` � at1�l� ������ �� ��� �� � r ! t� `� �� v L ( �-� �� � � � • ������s � �� � � 07/25/1994 14:57 6517742135 DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 02 DISTRICT 2 COMIV�UNIT'Y �OUNCIL SERVING THE NEIGHBORHOODS OF IeORTHEASTERN SAINT PAUL • PARKWAY/GREENBRlER � BFi1 V6R LAKE HEJC�HTS PROSPERIT` HEIGHTS • HAYDEN HE7GHT5 PHwLEN V{LLA4E • LINCOLTI PnRK EAST PHALEN � I-IAZEI PARK FROSr Ln[c6 • H��uaESr ?o: City Councilmembers From: Chuck Repke — District 2 Coa�znunity Council lteeardin�: Item 30 — Pinal Adoption of an ordinance annending the Saint Paul Le�,+islative Code Section 403.05; altering the waiver of distanca requirements for bingo t�alls... � r� L As many of you witl recali the placing of a bingo hall in the Hillcrest Shopping Ce�nter was quite cocm'oversiat. Community members speculated that the number of cars in the parkiag lot of bingo customers would make doing retail in the certer impossible. The attached story from the East Side Review shows the impact of bingo on the mall and �+rill hopefully lead the Council towards making better public policy. The passing of Ronald Jewelers fxom the East Side busirness community is a uue loss to the neighborhood. I hope that yoiu desizes to protect other local merchants will guide youc vote on item 30. 1961 SHERwooD AvENUE• $qINT PnUL • MN • 55 ] 19-3230 • PHONE: (65 ]) 774-2220 • FnX: (651) 774-2] 35 07/25/1994 14:57 6517742135 DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 03 � � � � %fiy. .� .� .._ _ Y !X'. : � , �' i ._-0 _ �. +_ a �� \O ,. � �: /�, 0 � � :� � ��i. ::• 1li� � ` ` � �� � ���r`� �.. � ' ��,,._ M �� � . . �,�� .. 3a = . �' � : �' . �� �,`� �' � ! ' �' `" � - _ ,.. , ..�r�. ': ���'�° W �� 7 '�'c�. -.y,.V� y" 'P �s __� �••TC._ � � � .. � . _, .. �,� �� �' �'. ✓ 0 :. . , y ,. p'� ° ,��' �K. �. C�i� 3: �. �.i . �i � � � � { m � @ 4 c N p m o ���� ��� �m� ��i �° � i 3Y�L n �� �� E I O m � C I q�;.'7. I ��g� g9�� E�¢� �¢ � _ C � � �� . 0 � W Y . ` � , �.z�.� O � .�. ` i 5.�.�. ] 'S. �'✓. =. A a � �8� . �� a'�.4. ' °�' �� ? " �;. , � �.. m 9�0���" ,�o. d� "s�"�'S e ., °. t,_ _ q � �� � . � � o . : . S�3i �t. d.i b • :���' � �• 1 �:- a G, � O t7. C a y .d $ o .!1 3 ,5 `c y ffi �° �=8�— T � d TJ� � a.y �����.�•c- .. � �-�: Y . . � }' ' _ , x-. - i � YJ 07/25/1994 14:57 6517742135 � �. • � � � � � � ` a � �""�� DIST TWO COUNCIL PAGE 04 r ..�.. L � a�S�.'° °�-� �E � v� ^� GO a <�'p . 0 E v. d C O� �� O� L'... e .s �L a� w '�>t�3 � y � ". _-� °- a °Y�'�$ m �m:��_ �.��i�� �� d •.�� � � C V. O �QW �� � • b. �� q �� GJ y p � g .r t . a � !B u �..��,�' -� 0 � � �m����� y �y3.i.j�.���w� CO'��4+ df• °� °� �� o� p�°o ..Qm t� � x w �� � N u� M� ���' 92 u, � t a+ N a y g � E. G T r. �, � LJ D 7 t� � N vr >� s 5�p' y ai y v'' y n E d��. ,�_+...".t E 3 A.P.��a2'� Y� 3: � v`-° "'� �; �» v� @� �`p��o+tw ��o�tlp�O�t..C."'°a. �a.�ou�� � O� p u �.+.,»�� Q49 o,, s o r c �� m �5 0 3�°�� a.a �'� m, �� . cx� m�E?av �u .,e � �y ,,����o,�t^ �rY3ro3�;�aoQ. � b°d� ' a O ° 0�'=- o fl N � � � �a U 'L " � � N • � C .� '.. � n � �� �i 3 u.�. � � A N TO. N� � '-° '� w � o, � 1C " � .. w D � S �Vt� a�a .�c .� O 7 � ��� O � ; j G a.�.� �S.-;� u.G . '� O'g p � �'� � � � � 0 � '� � o � `� $ ,3 y � fp (5 �j 'O g C 9 � O C ' tgp ' �, ? ��v 8 3` °' 5 aZ'��a3e��Y�" � s8 `+� u G'^ ti� �� 4 �� 7 a� T W '.Z�� m e� �Kw'�� 1° o � �� n S m� O� c' O x 0 �" ti O� � �. � > N C M N,� N'O V Yi SD O 1 C a� O ,K .0 � � 3 ' � p. . oB a� N � v°� O' : C.1 ,- y � � y � O � �-n = w ,l. . .... , � c� ; eg � ���°� TL ,,•-•,, � ip p� g �� 3'' -.m, � �. o�� 6 �i ° .5� p '�' ; W p � M � T q � qy}( � � N � 3 x' � " oa.�r � � t .� .°° c ,c-.�' 3 .°. d��0 dX p°� � O C r m,Y � Y° .. C�� � oC � Ob � C ' p asy�� �'' v n?.5� `� � . o m � � a y' r �. O C � x � s � '�. "� � w a O F m� 00 O ' O :: m� � '-��� a�=;v �a c ao �� � s � w u o `�Q4 a-� .8 a a. 3 d 'o R d. Q � v�� 3w7 `"� �. rf � M [ x � � u � • � �jj G: $ - O� J�"y u Q�� 6 � � �� � F � % Q � ^ µ � « � ~ �`�.1� > �. � 8 E ° o ��v�•. � p r �� C� �� � � 9��`ew a� � c m � � ' � � � � � � ` � � � � E?`v „' �,,.°�• � ro.° 5 � . � � L �Ii � .� V � ��ti � � "e .�-,sa 8 „ 3 g '' T ° �.. „ :'�' �.,� v- a.� ti� � �"��°' ° ,.. � c 1 i ar i0..:�C�.Q.�-�A � 00 � G C � T O C C� maop E�� $ � S�'.5� '' , tl Q r mr u � ` T +J q- '�G�C N�� ' m'ra� _�,�c o ° 'm°R.c • � L ,-�.•-_ p.M �' °� r ° � A� y �'�`'����; A g d w � � mT �� y �.c �•� �y A'is ,� �S Ci9 y •� y io ¢ m� v'` s� A.G y� 3 s: �p h p O O .�-� O� C p y .� � �p y O 1� T ����u�.=yu � p y l [�+ O V � VJ �'G V• A. C J7 G. � O i.�, O.C.`� T� O w m vl E� . JC �j 3.�7 S c., L'"vvaw um. m > y �o:;'_ °�^ 3 y � �- 9 e, a$�.�'�o.c g' �'+` c w '� .. � C 'v� oaoec��'_ ,C, ��u y �ar m 0 W��Y C CZ � A��F.~p.y(D 7 4 �. O� C � v � O � d � ; �� . ���4 + �3 - j� � �p+r�'O p..r d y>• V � . p� pp � D �C�:� N-S m��bO��..�'G'dW b �..�'•^'�t� � 9: d� � m-� O C V. -p ' O..�3; r w N� '.. m �.°�. y p ,g �:-� o:.v, �; -.°� °a a ' �� yp � 3 . � y �q �e, � m i0��� ' ��b, u.q O' N �000 ���T:: � { Y a CS �t� >`� o?�. e�i ^�° e d � ao �`J' � �{ b� d E 5 a �. :� ���Y'��"�V Ci9 �'Y C1 � ° S� M��'.'� �o. -o'm �a°4�'s�i°dAa. ?u i -m ��:'S:sz�'�v�s'� �o m �.. r r:� y,.,�,ifl. .��., . ��, . ,JI!{!� 0 �i r . m ..�a+n iYi�r� `eti �r..:. m. � � � ^ �. m .' 1 v ,� '° q O� p. <�� D Na ��,� � F Q �'� � 5,:`�"��:i�_�:� �3 m_ t5 � d �'� �''9i o,K �� � 9� o`�:_ g. �`°g�c`�$o,�� S.'��� ° a � �N O "J' ^ .� `y r � � V .� 8 � 8 ; � •� � �" N a k'_��'s� oo._ °�+ :o � G - `o S 0 ��r-� '�c'DOamon � w O d C yyT� '°a.=.3-�Q25H�3�]C9;� 3•-,����"� �z � w= ° -�de� $ W�A. �N .1.. .� !" � . c`cr E�' o,a•�c�? � ,j+ H�� L T� �^ N� V � ''�' ^ `J� �a � 2 . $' � q � r � � y .. c 'y � ws ocmJ'"�^+3� d w .`at� ° �� ,q d �r �a d �C ' ,�, r .Y a0 Z � �=o�` ° �� � �� N.� d y t T � a C ,�� _ � V a... ,K ��, > p p e�-=g '� Y p d� E�9 � O C���.. � �y E �o�4�� .v y— c�,�,'a''„—y m u� u o� �u_... � `° ty,. y "�x'�'Sa� q ��i