96-151LL
ORDINANCE
CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA
Presented
Refesed To
Council File # 9 �-� 51
Green Sheet # 3 S o 9 3
Committee Date
An Aduiiuistrative Ordinance establishing the position entitled
Admiiustrative Assistant as specified by Chapter 12 of the Charter of
the City of Saint Paul, Section 12.032(I� thereof.
7
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN:
Section 1.
That it is appropriate and desirable to establish the position entitled Administrative Assistant
in the Office of Public Health.
Section 2.
That pursuant to Section 12.03.2(H) of the City Charter such position be established in the
Unclassified Service of the City of Saint Paul.
Section 3.
That appoinhnents to such posirion be made with the advice and consent of the City Council
of the City of Saint Paul.
Section 4.
That this ordinance sha11 take effect and be in force 30 days from and after its passage and
approval. ,� � , �
Requested by Deparnnent of:
Office of Human Resources
By: �� •��5��
Form Approved by City Attomey
B ��'�-j�` � �"� 1 �� }qb
Adoption Certified by Council Secretary
By: a �►
Approved by May r a� l
By:
3i�
Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
By: �� � � /Vi'��
91IRI IN4CR
�.�a..� .�. ��i
Adopted by Council: Date� �,�.,� (� `q,q L
a
DEPARTMENT/OFFICE/COUNCII.: DATE INITTATED `�� I S t �
Human Resources O1-10-96 GREEN SHEET No.: 35093
COA"CACT PERSON & PHONE: p I1�tPrtncmwTe mlTTpt.�paTE
John Shockley 266-6482��
Milt Patka 266-6485 �I�N I DEPARTMENT DIlL s crrv couxcn.
NUhIBER 3 CITY ATTORNEY CITY CLERK
� � FOR Z$UDCET DIIZ- 6 FIN. & MGT. SERVICE DIIt
MUST BE ON COUNCII, AGENDA BY (DATE) ROUTING 4 MA1 OR (OR ASST.)
ORDER
TOTAL # OF SIGNAI'URE PAGES_1 (CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNATORE)
acrion aeQtiES�ren: Approval of an Ordinance establishing an unclassified Administrative Assistatjt posirion located
in the Office of Public Health pursuant to Section 12.03.2(I� of the City Charter.
;A� 2 3 1996
k���� ��:�°� <..
RECOMIJ.ENDATIONS: Approve (A) or Reject (R) PERSONAI, SERVICE CONTRACl'S Mi7ST AIVSR'ER THE FOLLOWING
QUESTIONS:
_PLANNING WMMISSION _CIVIL SERVICE COMIvIISSION 1. Has this person/5an ever worked under a contract for this department?
_CIB COMIvIITTEE Yes No
_STHPF 2. Aas this person/firm ever been a ciry emptoyee?
DISTRICT WURT Yes No
SUPPORTS WHICH COiINCIL OBJECTIVE? 3. Does this peaonlfirm qossess a skill mt nom�ally possessed 6y any cuRent city
employee? Yes No
Explain alI yes aoswers m separate sheet aod attach to green sheet
INI1'fATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTUNII'Y (Who, What, Wheo, Where, Why):
This action is based upon a study of a provisional Administra6ve Assistant position currently performing duties
assigned by the City Council. This position is located in the Housing Code Enforcement Division of the Office of
Public Health. � y �, �,�'��'
���`�4i _.:.�_...
��� �� ����
nnvnNracES iF nrrxovEn: An appointed position approved by the City Council will be established that will perform
assigned duties in resoiving constituent concerns surrounding housing code enforcement complaints, improving
housing code operating procedures, assisting in housing code hearing prepazation and coordinating and establishing
neighborhood clean-up and inspection programs. ���� Gq ��„ �
�
nisnnv.arrrncES�nrrxovEn: None. ,��,N ig 1996
�. e �:_�� �� � � �����
nisnnvnrv�rncES iF NoT arrxoveD: No position will be established that is subject to City Council appointment
approval.
TOTAL AMOUNT OF 7'RANSACTION: $ COST/REVEN[JE BUDGETED:
FUNDING SOURCE: ACl'IVITY NUMBER:
FINANCIAL INFORMe1TION: (EXPLAIl�
7ohn HamiUnn, Dbutar
CTI'Y OF S�]'f PAUL
No�m Coleman, Mayor
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
RE:
Councilperson Dino Guerin
V y� C� Council
atk���
Human Resources
December 22, 1995
J30 Ciry HaJI Annee
25 Weu Faunh Strea
Saint Pau7, �ota 55102-1632
Guy WilliYs position study determination
a�-�st
Telephone: 6Z2-266b500
TDD/TTY 612-2665501
7obline: 612-2666502
Faumni7e: SS2 J92-7656
We ha�e completed the study of the provisional Administrative Assistant position
held by Guy Willits at Public Health. On October 12, 1995 we determined the
position should be allocated to the Management Assistant II class. We received
additional information which warrants the position to remain in the Administrative
Assistant class in an unclassified capacity.
We will process the ordinance and resolution required to implement this
determination.
cc: Nea1 Holton
Jerry SerIling
ac.-ts�
CLASSIFICATION STIIDY REPORT
(RESTUDY)
REQUESTED CIASSIFICATION
INCUMBENT:
PRESENT CLASSZFiCATION
DEPARTMENT � DIVISION:
DATE OF REQUEST:
STUDY CONDUCTED BY:
Open
Guy Willits
Provisionally appointed to the Administrative
Assistant class on 1-3-94 (formerly entitled
Administrative Assistant - Community Services)
Public Health
Housing Code Enforcement
October 19, 1995
Milt Patka
APPROVAL OF CLASSIFICATION � COMPENSATION MANAGER
DATE
BAC&GROIIND
,-> � f� l
iZ - ZZ - �
An initial study of this provisional position was conducted and a
determination was made on October 12, 1995 that the position be allocated to
the Management Assistant II class. That determination was based upon
information provided by the incumbent and the Supervisor of Housing Code
Enforcement. On October 19, 1995 an objection to this determination was
received from Councilmember Guerin's office. Mr. Guerin indicated that the
initial study findings did not adequately reflect the duties and
responsibilities o£ the position in relationship to the City Council.
Consequently, a restudy of the position was conducted.
STIIDY COMPONENTS
In restudying this position, the following components were included:
Interview with Councilmember Guerin.
Interview with Gerry Strathman, Council Investigation and Research
Birector.
Further review of Job Profiles and advisory specifications of pasitions
allocated to unclassified Administrative Assistant and City Council
research positions.
Re-evaluation of the position using the QES system.
�I�-�s�
DZSCIISSION
CouncilmembeY Guerin and Gerry Strathman, Council Investigation and Research
Director, provided job related information from the City Council's
perspective. It was indicated this position was created by the Council to act
as their intermediary in resolving housing code enforcement complaints. The
incumbent has frequent contact with the Councilmembers' offices, the Mayor's
Office and the Citizen Service Office to collect the ever increasing volume of
these complaints. This position fulfills a public relations function to
zesolve the concerns of constituents. The position in question is responsible
for housing code enforcement problem resolution and preparing the necessary
recommendations. This position has been in existence less than one year and
the Council has assigned the incumbent the responsibility of seriously
reviewing and improving the current operating procedures found in the Housing
Code Enforcement Section of Public Aealth. This position assists the
Council's Investigation and Research Director in the preparation required for
hearings that are regularly held to grant citizens an opportunity to appeal
the City's Aousing Code Enforcement decisions. This responsibility has
alleviated supervisors, including the head of the Housing Code Enforcement
section, the Housing Code Inspection Supervisor, from spending up to two days
per week on this task. The incumbent has a role in coordinating and
scheduling enforcement activities to coincide with the clean-up activities of
the 17 neighborhood councils. In addition, the general role as a public
relations person with all of the customers served in Housing Code Enforcement
is continually expanding.
Most of the above information was included in the original study. However,
that study did not adequately reveal the Council's role in assigning duties to
the position or the degree of importance the Council places on the position.
The original study did mention that the Management Assistant II determination
was not permanent as the position was in a state of flux. As an example, this
position is to become the coordinator of a new project still in the
development stage, the Citizen Inspection Program. The responsibility will be
to coordinate 1000 City block clubs involved in teaching citizens how to
conduct on-site housing inspections.
COMPARISONS
Unclassified Administrative Assistants are appointed positions that usually
perform functions such as public relations, personnel, policies and procedures
establishment, liaison, research and project coordination duties. These
duties are performed under the general supervision of a department head
appointed by the Mayor. The additional information provided revealed that the
position in question is performing highly responsible duties in public
relations, research, policy and procedures improvement, and program
development and coordination that have been assigned by the City Council.
These duties are very similar to those performed by unclassified
Administrative Assistant positions.
Policy Analyst and Financial Analyst positions are unclassified positions that
q (. -1 s I
perform duties assigned by the City Council. However, these positions are
primarily responsible for collecting, compiling and analyzing data. They do
not perform any public relations, policies and procedures or program
coordination work.
All other professional or supervisory positions performing duties assigned by
the Council are in the unclassi£ied service.
QES EVALIIATION
A new QES evaluation, based upon the additional information provided, supports
compensating the position at grade 16 of the non-represented salary schedule.
:l�A��7
Even though the position in question is located in the Housing Code
Enforcement Division of Public Health, the restudy revealed that the position
is carrying out duties assigned by the City Council. Also revealed was that
the level of the duties and the duties performed are very similar to those of
unclassified Administrative Assistants appointed by department heads. In
addition, all positions performing duties assigned by the City Council at the
professional or supervisory level are unclassified. Furthermore, the QES
evaluation supports placing the position in the same pay grade as unclassified
Administrative Assistant positions.
Therefore, it is recommended that an unclassified Administrative Assistant
position be created in the Division of Public Health and that the appointing
authority should be the City Council.
lohn Hamilmn, D'varar
CTTY OF SAINT PAUL
Norm Coleman, Mayor
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
RE:
I3ea1 Holton
Public Health
� Mi1t Patka
Human Resources
October 12,1995
z�o c;tyx�rra�
25 Wat Fourth Sveu
Sairu P¢u� Mir+naota 55202-Z631
Results of Guy Wiliit's classif'ication study
°►c.—�s►
Telephone: 6I2-266�6500
TDD/I7Y.• 6I2266d501
lobline: 6I2•2666502
Facsmile: 612-292-7656
We haue completed our study of the position held by Guy Willits, provisionally.
The incumbent and supervisor were interviewed, comparisons made with
specifications and other positions, and a QES evaluation completed. Based upon
that information, we have determined that the position should be allocated to the
Management Assistant II class, with the proviso that because of the evolving
nature of the position, another study be done in two years.
To implement this action, please initiate a requisition by Friday, October 27, and
send it through the required process.
If you have any questions regazding this determination, please contact me at
66485.
cc: Diane Holmgren
9c.—�s�
REQUESTED CLASSIFICATZON:
1��(�IIf3i:l�M�Ylii
PRESENT CLASSIFICATIQN:
DEPARTMENT � DIVISION:
DATE OF REQUEST:
STUDY CONDUCTED BY:
CLASSIFICATION ST[TDY REPORT
Open
Guy Willits
P=ovisionally appointed to the Administrative
Assistant class on 1-3-94 (formerly entitled
Administrative Assistant- Community Services)
Public Health
Code Enfoscement
July, 1995
Milt Patka
�i ' _/ �
r��� , ,�1�:� , . � /
APPROVAL OF CLASSIFICATZON & COMPENSATZON MANAGER:
DATE
F7:t�J:Z���I4�l7
The incumbent was appointed to the exempt Legislative Aide class in January,
1992 and assisted a Councilmember until 12-31-93, at which time the council
went on a half-time basis. This action resulted in the termination of the
incumbent from the exempt position and appointment provisionally to the
Administrative Assistant class in the Mayor's Office. The incumbent was
transfered to the Citizen Service Office on 1-7-95 and two months later
transfered to the Health Department. While working in the complaint office,
the high number of daily complaints concerning tall grass, junk cars and
garbage became apparent to the incumbent. The councilmembers and the Mayor's
office also received 10-15 complaints a week concerning the City's neglect of
problems or the manner of resolution of the problems. The City leaders asked
the incumbent to address the complaints directed to their offices by
physically relocating to code enforcement to "get a handle on the situation".
STUDY COMPONENTS
In studying the position, the following components were included:
Review of the profile completed and signed by the incumbent and appropriate
supervisors.
Review of the current specificaitons for Management Assistant I, II and III
and Administrative Assistant.
Znterview with the incumbent and a phone conversation with the immediate
� `-15 �
superviscr.
Evaluation using the QES system.
POSITZON
- Represents the department at various committees and meetings to provide
data on current issues and to participate in developing responses.
Currently involved with the business regulation committee, members of the
business community, and the problem property co�ittee.
- Works with code enforcement supervisors to identify and resolve problems
so to satisfy the public and to improve the department's public image.
Should the present practices, policies and procedures not lead to
resolution of constitutent complaints, the incumbent confers with
management - Health, council or mayoral staff - to resolve,
- Confers with other City Departments to create new computer systems or to
revise established procedures for a more efficient and effective operation
- Acts as liaison between code enforcement and councilmembers, mayoral sta£f,
other units of local government, public and private agencies, the news
media and the general public. Meets with the council staffs once or twice
a week to review and collect new complaints that warrant his attention.
The more serious complaints are doled to the appropriate Inspector for
resolution. The complaint office sends a listing of those complaints that
are older than ten days and haven't been resolved. This position assigns
these complaints to the appropriate Inspector to complete on Monday
morning. This position does not conduct inspections but assigns and
reviews same with the Inspectors and accompanies Inspector Supervisors who
write up orders on the more serious inspections.
- Coordinates and schedules enforcement activities to coincide with the clean
up activities of the 17 neighborhood councils. Attends the council
meetings to impart information and to receive citizen complaints.
In£ormation concerning the various dates, times, locations, etc. of each of
the clean-ups is compiled into periodic flyers prepared by this position.
In addition, once a citizen receives a write up because of an infraction,
there is a set amount of time to remedy the situation. A lack of action
produces a warning prior to Parks cleaning up the mess at $150.00 per hour.
The incumbent's role is to encourage the citizen to act prior to calling in
the employees from Parks,
- Communicates with elected officials, coffinunity organizations, block clubs
and the public to improve services. Provides input to the legislative
hearing process led by the Council Investigation and Research Dixector.
These informal hearings are held on the first and third Tuesdays of each
month and provide citizens an opportunity to present their cases in an
appeal process. The incumbent provides pictures or tapes of the situation,
an estimate as to how much it will cost to satisfy the complaint and the
time £rame in which to do so. The Director presents his recommendations to
the full council on Wednesdays. The incumbent is also present at these
° lt,-�S�
meetings and may be called upon for fuzther explanation or input.
COMP6&ZSOIGS
The duties and responsibilities of the Management Assistant classes - I, IZ,
and III - are geared to providing various levels of pro£essional work
assisting management by conducting research; preparing reports,
recommendations and grant proposals; being a liasion person and being involved
with public information; and at the III level, preparing budgets.
A position allocated to the Management Assistant II class typically is
involved in conducting research and working in an assigned area. Incumbents
analyze and evaluate information to make findings and report them, usually
with an action recommendation�to management. Assistance is provided in the
researching and drafting of new policies and procedures. Replies are made to
inquiries from various sources which usually requires investigation and the
coordination of information derived from several sources. Incumbents may be
asked to assist in the preparation of contracts, resolutions and
administrative orders and to monitor and coordinate the approval process.
Materials such as presentations and fact sheets are prepared. Incumbents may
also provide sta£f support for committees or be a liaison with vaxious
community organizations, public agencies or other City departments.
The duties of the studied position more closely match those of the Management
Assistant II class as professional work is performed by providing staff
assistance to various aspects of management, The position replies to
complaints received £rom councilmembers, the complaint office and the 17
district councils; prepares clean-up fact sheets; and serves as a liaison with
the councilmembers, Mayor's staff, public agencies and other City departments.
Incumbents in the Management Assistant III class direct a major administra-
tive function at a department. This includes the responsibility of preparing
funding proposals, monitoring expenditures and assigning personnel.
Additional duties of positions in this class include dra£ting legislation,
developing programs, preparing contracts and resolutions, acting as a liaison
with outside groups, and supervising a staff. As this studied position
evolves, it may assume this level of responsibility, but at the present time,
it does not.
The incumbent is currently a provisional Administrative Assistant. Positions
in this class are responsible for supervisory and highly skilled administra-
tive work, which does not describe the studied position. Administrative
Assistants are involved in problem solving and preparing the necessary reports
and recommendations. They review the current operating procedures and
recommend and implement new or modified ways of doing things. They provide
pertinent information to public and local agencies and any information that is
requested by the Mayor's staff, councilmembers and other City departments.
Additionally, Administrative Assistants assist in developing long range plans
for departmental programs and direct any special projects assigned by the
supervisor. Past practice of positions in the Administrative Assistant class
is that they work under the supervision of a department head.
q��`
The job evaluation, using our Quantitative Evaluation System, places this
studied position in PEA Grade 9, the same as the Management Assistant II
class.
RECO24IENDATION
Based on the �ob profile, comparisons to related classifications and positions
and the QES evaluation, it is recommended this position should be allocated to
the Management Assistant II class. This position was created and £illed in
February 1995 and, according to the supervisor, is in a state of development
as new and additional duties are assigned. Consequently, the position has
growth potential and should be studied again when the duties are finalized.