The URL can be used to link to this page

98-473CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL FILE NO. - 1 r��73 FINAL ORDER BY 0 R!� I N A L VOTING WARD 1 4 y�{ � In the Matter of improving the alley in Block 3, Lake Pazk Addition (bounded by Arona, Almond, Snelling an anfield) by grading and paving with bituminous material. V � _ �� under Preliminary The Council ofthe City of Saint Paul having been given as prescribed by the City C�farter; and approved �� r . � � � � `�� public hearing upon the above improvement, due notice thereof WHEREAS, The Council has h d all persons, objections and recommendations pertaining to said proposed improvement and has fully considered e same; now, therefore, be it RESOLVED, That the Co cil of the CiTy of Saint Paul does hereby order that the above-described improvement be made, and the proper City off ers are hereby directed and authorized to proceed with the improvement; and be it FURTHER RES( expensesincunedtherein Yeas Benanav Blakey , 5D, That upon the completion of said improvement, the proper City officers shall calculate all shall report the same to the CiTy Council in accordance with Chapter 14 of the City Charter. _In Favor _Against Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary � Mayor r•_' Public Hearing Date - May 27, 1998 ��°� qd ��17� T.M.S./REAL ESTATE DIVISION Date: March 16,1998 Green Sheet Number: 50109 ontact Person and Phone Number. EPARTMENT DIItECTOR 2 CITY COi1NCII. Peter White 266-8850 mATTORNEY c�iuc ust be on Council Agenda by: Ap1718� 199H fOP 171)GET DIRECTOR OFFICE OF FP7AriC7AL SVCS May 27,1998 Public Hearing Yoxroawssisrnr�a� 1 ovxcn,xESEnxca OTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES �(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNAI'ORE) CT[ON REQUESTED: 1. Set Public Hearing date to discuss the improvement of the Alley in Block 3, Lake Park Addition as shown on the attached map, by grading and paving with bihimiuous material. . Approve said project FILE NUMBER 18873 COMMENDATIONS: nPPROVE (A) OR REaECT (R) ERSONAL SERVICE CON1'RACTS MUST ANSWER THE FOLLOW ING: . Aas the person/firm ever worked under a contract for this department? YES NO PLANNING COMh[I6S[ON A STAFE � . Has this person/fum ever been a City employee? YES NO CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION . Dces this person/firm possess a skill not normally possessed by any YES NO current CRy employee? cm Cot�mnrree Ezylain all YES answers on a separate sheet aud attach. UPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? COUNCIL WARD(S) 4 DISTRICT PLANIVING COUNCIL �� ITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTiJNITY (Who, What, When, Where, Why?): This improvement project was initiated by a pefition signed by 48% of the property owners abutting the alley. VANTAGES IF APPROVED: t,��t`•�'da_ r�E�v°��C�c �a.�.=':^;��f Drainage in the alley will be impraved. �5�� g� ISADVAN"I'AGES IF APPROVED: Normal problems associated with construction such as noise, dust, and general disruption will occur. Also, assessments to cover the cost of the improvement would be levied against the — benefitted properties, payable over a maximum of 20 years. ISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: The current drainage problems would continue. OTAL AMOUNT OF TRA.NSACTION: $ 23�1(O.00 COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CII2CLE ONE) YES NO UNDING SOURCE: A SS0SSII10IItS ACTIVITY NUMBER: INANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIIV) Project to be funded 100% by assessments. 9j y �� . .. J oy 0 � �o �--; �zo �ZO�s r- T-� i .—i - so� s�zs, 6'0 0� so y �. �-- �� -- t I I I � I � I � � � v1 12 �,�, 13 � 6 14 � 9 8 7 2 5 4 3 2 1�, �!� 12 15 � `� --- �, �� N �m 16 ,� n . ' N k� 17 � N ' n Z /^ 18 a � v� y V 1 W � 19 /zo , So -• ,go S6,TT So Z � � -�- -GANFIELD AVE. � 0 V 6 39 .. .. .. .. .. ,. .. .. ,3y �0 39 13 •�° � v C�� Q �560 `l Y �4 �' O 15 � 12 II 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 I N �15 ti � 16 m• iszo \ � 17 (3z� ` Z q� (za� (i � Cz C2'D (2� (2z� (a ; (L�� (i9� � - - -- U 18 19 �33� � �iz� �� (� C�� a-p �az� (as� �a�-� �q5� (9a) � • . 20 `" ` �' , �--- � f � °` 21 � 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 3 2 33 34. 35� I 6 I � � ---2 ' -2--- �(o� 1543 N . M,� �35� 23 , z.s9 .3y .. . ,. . . , .s9 �o� 3�7 ° ALMOND AVE., zo ^, � i o ,7 39 " . .. V , .. . .. 9 ./ O 9 7 • N ASJ` O �v �. b 12 il 10 9 8 6 5 4 3 �2 I� ��15 I� _ 16 � � � 7 N . �� Q � �_ . � � ' O � s H a. �. �' �. 6�a / �z. s. z E _/ �'�� r�'. � ' � !�' 20 `" I �( � � : , t 1 - �--�F—�— 24 25 26 27 28i �- - - � � 22 ,~ isbt � Area to be improved v 23 • � rzo -3s 2a ---� AL.BAt AVE.,, i - � . . , , � � ,�_ � _ _ _ , . � 9�- y�� CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL FILE NO. � S PRELIlVIINARY ORDER BY �„J ORIGINAL � —18873 as VOTIN WARD_4 In the Matter of Improvingthe alley in Block 3, Lake Park Addition (bounded by Arona, Almond, Snelling and Canfield) by grading and paving with bituminous material The Council of the City of Saint Paul having received the report of the Mayor upon the above improvement, and having considered said report, hereby resolves: 2. 3. That the said report and the same is hereby approved with no altematives, and that the estimated cost thereof is $23,160.00 financed 100% by Assessments. That a public heazing be had on said improvementon the 27th day of Mav. 1998. at 5:30 o'clock �m in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House Building in the City of Saint Paul. That notice of said public hearing be given to the persons and in the manner provided by the Charter, stating the time and place of heazing, the nature of the improvement and the total cost thereof as estimated. COUNCILPERSONS Yeas Nays ✓Benanev ✓�lakey ;/�ostrom �/Coleman ✓FIarris �/Lantry �eiter [In Favor . �Against Adopted by CounciL• Date� ��j �'�;y Certified Passed by Council Secretary By "�_� � � _ Mayor �8 ,�� John Jernberg and Theresa Putzier 1531 Almond Avenue St. Paul, MN 55108 Dear Council Members: We are writing to express ow opposition to the alley improvement project proposed for Block 3, Lake Park Addition. The file number for the project is 18873-5. The estimated project cost is $23,160.00, with an average assessment of $770.25. We oppose the project for several reasons: The first reason is cost. We have a double wide lot resulting in a proposed assessment of $1,540.50. This is more than our property taYes for the year. The second reason is the cause of the damage. We believe that the central cause of the deterioration of the west end of the alley is the use of the alley by large trucks servicing the Shalom Home. The Shalom Home property does not border the alley so it is not being assessed for the project. We think this would be unfair to the property owners being assessed for the project. The third reason is that we think the project is overkill. Simple maintenance of the alley would suffice. Two-thirds of the a11ey is in good shape. The majority of the houses on the east end of the a11ey oppose the project. We hope that you reject the proposal for this year. incerel � �' � �! '� `,�' � John 7ernberg and Theresa Putzier P 5. we l'�ue ci�c�l��e� a�Q�-��o� o�p�� -��e- ��o�cf� %h��e �� " ` � ��.2 OC i �"ct� 2T�'��On �o� ��2 ro'�ecf �av� c� �d W r1U S l Q Y��G � � l� S � �� i+� i M� 4 t l�� G l� 5�� t`��U✓I O��U� � f�- �(v��C�, �� 3 v� aoZ -��d' ��-�,�a.� �� ` / � � /sl S' �w�:� ; ��-G . -" � �%'� �s � l °�'' �'�� . �� a � �� ` , ^ �� .� �� C � /, � ��-�� / Ui/ �D . ;..�2<%Vc'—�,z /��-�i�'C/ � �YVr-C/ � �� , � � ! � l � ( � � �` 1 ,� � -_ _� I � �� /1/V "� � P.��1 � � �� ti ��-� �� J � �.� � - �� -n- .. �� , ��,�, � v ��:�� G�1 L, � ` .� �,,� � �� O i � � - + n J `. UY� �=a'VC-�, ��{ J�P�Q � � � � �x-�� t ��`��'� � � � � � �� '�'�-� - �rJ��a -� � �� -�—��° �-- �� '� �� G'�-e. �� q�-��13 Petition Opposing Aliey Improvement Proposal for Block 3, Lake Park Additio(� By signing the petition below, I am indicating my opposition to the alley improvement project proposed for Block 3, Lake Pazk Addifion. The file number for this project is 18873-5. The esfimated pmject cost is $23,160.00. The average assessment per properiy is $ 77025. OL�{��/1 a �r�_�- 1��,�,.__� � �Nw�� c�a,� ts�� Address �� 7 ss -�- ch � �' isa/ ,41rnD�2� 1�Z� ��i�fc� �- 13� 3' y.�..�Q 15'�3 �1�, o �el �rn . 1`555 �i�YY1�1?;/; �'ti�' Phone # , � L� � �-�- --�� a 9 - �16�7 � �flo-3a� La�f7— �fuo I �'�G � 7D � b y � � z,z59 �� v� —S�10 �!-! (o -833R 6�! 7 —�� (nLIS' �d� g 9 5 , � p�l�+ta� 12 /7.�A--r. , r� �o ..e� /% �n�enU,, iCLt ��..n,.,,.� 1=}.10�_� 14 is 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 t�� c�.�.��n �� y� �3586 1�°39 Azr�o�� A�/F, l��f5-3�� i �� B � ��3 � =a� �� -�� + ��. �'�- G�'� rs��s �. , �� 3� � o� ; �� «� � ` � �� ; � , s C� �' � ,— � ' �� ; , �; /� � . L, � � f �--C c 1�� l '� ; `; G /� � (r� .— G � li � z 1 ti � l; , , .. �/ , �, , . . / �, � , � �� i * �ti � �i �� °�� , � - �� 1�-c�C�� `"� 5��.' .f � d��` �-� � � � - ; -- � ,,�� f � r �� o � �� ° �� . . � � �� CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL FILE NO. - 1 r��73 FINAL ORDER BY 0 R!� I N A L VOTING WARD 1 4 y�{ � In the Matter of improving the alley in Block 3, Lake Pazk Addition (bounded by Arona, Almond, Snelling an anfield) by grading and paving with bituminous material. V � _ �� under Preliminary The Council ofthe City of Saint Paul having been given as prescribed by the City C�farter; and approved �� r . � � � � `�� public hearing upon the above improvement, due notice thereof WHEREAS, The Council has h d all persons, objections and recommendations pertaining to said proposed improvement and has fully considered e same; now, therefore, be it RESOLVED, That the Co cil of the CiTy of Saint Paul does hereby order that the above-described improvement be made, and the proper City off ers are hereby directed and authorized to proceed with the improvement; and be it FURTHER RES( expensesincunedtherein Yeas Benanav Blakey , 5D, That upon the completion of said improvement, the proper City officers shall calculate all shall report the same to the CiTy Council in accordance with Chapter 14 of the City Charter. _In Favor _Against Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary � Mayor r•_' Public Hearing Date - May 27, 1998 ��°� qd ��17� T.M.S./REAL ESTATE DIVISION Date: March 16,1998 Green Sheet Number: 50109 ontact Person and Phone Number. EPARTMENT DIItECTOR 2 CITY COi1NCII. Peter White 266-8850 mATTORNEY c�iuc ust be on Council Agenda by: Ap1718� 199H fOP 171)GET DIRECTOR OFFICE OF FP7AriC7AL SVCS May 27,1998 Public Hearing Yoxroawssisrnr�a� 1 ovxcn,xESEnxca OTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES �(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNAI'ORE) CT[ON REQUESTED: 1. Set Public Hearing date to discuss the improvement of the Alley in Block 3, Lake Park Addition as shown on the attached map, by grading and paving with bihimiuous material. . Approve said project FILE NUMBER 18873 COMMENDATIONS: nPPROVE (A) OR REaECT (R) ERSONAL SERVICE CON1'RACTS MUST ANSWER THE FOLLOW ING: . Aas the person/firm ever worked under a contract for this department? YES NO PLANNING COMh[I6S[ON A STAFE � . Has this person/fum ever been a City employee? YES NO CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION . Dces this person/firm possess a skill not normally possessed by any YES NO current CRy employee? cm Cot�mnrree Ezylain all YES answers on a separate sheet aud attach. UPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? COUNCIL WARD(S) 4 DISTRICT PLANIVING COUNCIL �� ITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTiJNITY (Who, What, When, Where, Why?): This improvement project was initiated by a pefition signed by 48% of the property owners abutting the alley. VANTAGES IF APPROVED: t,��t`•�'da_ r�E�v°��C�c �a.�.=':^;��f Drainage in the alley will be impraved. �5�� g� ISADVAN"I'AGES IF APPROVED: Normal problems associated with construction such as noise, dust, and general disruption will occur. Also, assessments to cover the cost of the improvement would be levied against the — benefitted properties, payable over a maximum of 20 years. ISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: The current drainage problems would continue. OTAL AMOUNT OF TRA.NSACTION: $ 23�1(O.00 COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CII2CLE ONE) YES NO UNDING SOURCE: A SS0SSII10IItS ACTIVITY NUMBER: INANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIIV) Project to be funded 100% by assessments. 9j y �� . .. J oy 0 � �o �--; �zo �ZO�s r- T-� i .—i - so� s�zs, 6'0 0� so y �. �-- �� -- t I I I � I � I � � � v1 12 �,�, 13 � 6 14 � 9 8 7 2 5 4 3 2 1�, �!� 12 15 � `� --- �, �� N �m 16 ,� n . ' N k� 17 � N ' n Z /^ 18 a � v� y V 1 W � 19 /zo , So -• ,go S6,TT So Z � � -�- -GANFIELD AVE. � 0 V 6 39 .. .. .. .. .. ,. .. .. ,3y �0 39 13 •�° � v C�� Q �560 `l Y �4 �' O 15 � 12 II 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 I N �15 ti � 16 m• iszo \ � 17 (3z� ` Z q� (za� (i � Cz C2'D (2� (2z� (a ; (L�� (i9� � - - -- U 18 19 �33� � �iz� �� (� C�� a-p �az� (as� �a�-� �q5� (9a) � • . 20 `" ` �' , �--- � f � °` 21 � 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 3 2 33 34. 35� I 6 I � � ---2 ' -2--- �(o� 1543 N . M,� �35� 23 , z.s9 .3y .. . ,. . . , .s9 �o� 3�7 ° ALMOND AVE., zo ^, � i o ,7 39 " . .. V , .. . .. 9 ./ O 9 7 • N ASJ` O �v �. b 12 il 10 9 8 6 5 4 3 �2 I� ��15 I� _ 16 � � � 7 N . �� Q � �_ . � � ' O � s H a. �. �' �. 6�a / �z. s. z E _/ �'�� r�'. � ' � !�' 20 `" I �( � � : , t 1 - �--�F—�— 24 25 26 27 28i �- - - � � 22 ,~ isbt � Area to be improved v 23 • � rzo -3s 2a ---� AL.BAt AVE.,, i - � . . , , � � ,�_ � _ _ _ , . � 9�- y�� CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL FILE NO. � S PRELIlVIINARY ORDER BY �„J ORIGINAL � —18873 as VOTIN WARD_4 In the Matter of Improvingthe alley in Block 3, Lake Park Addition (bounded by Arona, Almond, Snelling and Canfield) by grading and paving with bituminous material The Council of the City of Saint Paul having received the report of the Mayor upon the above improvement, and having considered said report, hereby resolves: 2. 3. That the said report and the same is hereby approved with no altematives, and that the estimated cost thereof is $23,160.00 financed 100% by Assessments. That a public heazing be had on said improvementon the 27th day of Mav. 1998. at 5:30 o'clock �m in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House Building in the City of Saint Paul. That notice of said public hearing be given to the persons and in the manner provided by the Charter, stating the time and place of heazing, the nature of the improvement and the total cost thereof as estimated. COUNCILPERSONS Yeas Nays ✓Benanev ✓�lakey ;/�ostrom �/Coleman ✓FIarris �/Lantry �eiter [In Favor . �Against Adopted by CounciL• Date� ��j �'�;y Certified Passed by Council Secretary By "�_� � � _ Mayor �8 ,�� John Jernberg and Theresa Putzier 1531 Almond Avenue St. Paul, MN 55108 Dear Council Members: We are writing to express ow opposition to the alley improvement project proposed for Block 3, Lake Park Addition. The file number for the project is 18873-5. The estimated project cost is $23,160.00, with an average assessment of $770.25. We oppose the project for several reasons: The first reason is cost. We have a double wide lot resulting in a proposed assessment of $1,540.50. This is more than our property taYes for the year. The second reason is the cause of the damage. We believe that the central cause of the deterioration of the west end of the alley is the use of the alley by large trucks servicing the Shalom Home. The Shalom Home property does not border the alley so it is not being assessed for the project. We think this would be unfair to the property owners being assessed for the project. The third reason is that we think the project is overkill. Simple maintenance of the alley would suffice. Two-thirds of the a11ey is in good shape. The majority of the houses on the east end of the a11ey oppose the project. We hope that you reject the proposal for this year. incerel � �' � �! '� `,�' � John 7ernberg and Theresa Putzier P 5. we l'�ue ci�c�l��e� a�Q�-��o� o�p�� -��e- ��o�cf� %h��e �� " ` � ��.2 OC i �"ct� 2T�'��On �o� ��2 ro'�ecf �av� c� �d W r1U S l Q Y��G � � l� S � �� i+� i M� 4 t l�� G l� 5�� t`��U✓I O��U� � f�- �(v��C�, �� 3 v� aoZ -��d' ��-�,�a.� �� ` / � � /sl S' �w�:� ; ��-G . -" � �%'� �s � l °�'' �'�� . �� a � �� ` , ^ �� .� �� C � /, � ��-�� / Ui/ �D . ;..�2<%Vc'—�,z /��-�i�'C/ � �YVr-C/ � �� , � � ! � l � ( � � �` 1 ,� � -_ _� I � �� /1/V "� � P.��1 � � �� ti ��-� �� J � �.� � - �� -n- .. �� , ��,�, � v ��:�� G�1 L, � ` .� �,,� � �� O i � � - + n J `. UY� �=a'VC-�, ��{ J�P�Q � � � � �x-�� t ��`��'� � � � � � �� '�'�-� - �rJ��a -� � �� -�—��° �-- �� '� �� G'�-e. �� q�-��13 Petition Opposing Aliey Improvement Proposal for Block 3, Lake Park Additio(� By signing the petition below, I am indicating my opposition to the alley improvement project proposed for Block 3, Lake Pazk Addifion. The file number for this project is 18873-5. The esfimated pmject cost is $23,160.00. The average assessment per properiy is $ 77025. OL�{��/1 a �r�_�- 1��,�,.__� � �Nw�� c�a,� ts�� Address �� 7 ss -�- ch � �' isa/ ,41rnD�2� 1�Z� ��i�fc� �- 13� 3' y.�..�Q 15'�3 �1�, o �el �rn . 1`555 �i�YY1�1?;/; �'ti�' Phone # , � L� � �-�- --�� a 9 - �16�7 � �flo-3a� La�f7— �fuo I �'�G � 7D � b y � � z,z59 �� v� —S�10 �!-! (o -833R 6�! 7 —�� (nLIS' �d� g 9 5 , � p�l�+ta� 12 /7.�A--r. , r� �o ..e� /% �n�enU,, iCLt ��..n,.,,.� 1=}.10�_� 14 is 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 t�� c�.�.��n �� y� �3586 1�°39 Azr�o�� A�/F, l��f5-3�� i �� B � ��3 � =a� �� -�� + ��. �'�- G�'� rs��s �. , �� 3� � o� ; �� «� � ` � �� ; � , s C� �' � ,— � ' �� ; , �; /� � . L, � � f �--C c 1�� l '� ; `; G /� � (r� .— G � li � z 1 ti � l; , , .. �/ , �, , . . / �, � , � �� i * �ti � �i �� °�� , � - �� 1�-c�C�� `"� 5��.' .f � d��` �-� � � � - ; -- � ,,�� f � r �� o � �� ° �� . . � � �� CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL FILE NO. - 1 r��73 FINAL ORDER BY 0 R!� I N A L VOTING WARD 1 4 y�{ � In the Matter of improving the alley in Block 3, Lake Pazk Addition (bounded by Arona, Almond, Snelling an anfield) by grading and paving with bituminous material. V � _ �� under Preliminary The Council ofthe City of Saint Paul having been given as prescribed by the City C�farter; and approved �� r . � � � � `�� public hearing upon the above improvement, due notice thereof WHEREAS, The Council has h d all persons, objections and recommendations pertaining to said proposed improvement and has fully considered e same; now, therefore, be it RESOLVED, That the Co cil of the CiTy of Saint Paul does hereby order that the above-described improvement be made, and the proper City off ers are hereby directed and authorized to proceed with the improvement; and be it FURTHER RES( expensesincunedtherein Yeas Benanav Blakey , 5D, That upon the completion of said improvement, the proper City officers shall calculate all shall report the same to the CiTy Council in accordance with Chapter 14 of the City Charter. _In Favor _Against Adopted by Council: Date Certified Passed by Council Secretary � Mayor r•_' Public Hearing Date - May 27, 1998 ��°� qd ��17� T.M.S./REAL ESTATE DIVISION Date: March 16,1998 Green Sheet Number: 50109 ontact Person and Phone Number. EPARTMENT DIItECTOR 2 CITY COi1NCII. Peter White 266-8850 mATTORNEY c�iuc ust be on Council Agenda by: Ap1718� 199H fOP 171)GET DIRECTOR OFFICE OF FP7AriC7AL SVCS May 27,1998 Public Hearing Yoxroawssisrnr�a� 1 ovxcn,xESEnxca OTAL # OF SIGNATURE PAGES �(CLIP ALL LOCATIONS FOR SIGNAI'ORE) CT[ON REQUESTED: 1. Set Public Hearing date to discuss the improvement of the Alley in Block 3, Lake Park Addition as shown on the attached map, by grading and paving with bihimiuous material. . Approve said project FILE NUMBER 18873 COMMENDATIONS: nPPROVE (A) OR REaECT (R) ERSONAL SERVICE CON1'RACTS MUST ANSWER THE FOLLOW ING: . Aas the person/firm ever worked under a contract for this department? YES NO PLANNING COMh[I6S[ON A STAFE � . Has this person/fum ever been a City employee? YES NO CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION . Dces this person/firm possess a skill not normally possessed by any YES NO current CRy employee? cm Cot�mnrree Ezylain all YES answers on a separate sheet aud attach. UPPORTS WHICH COUNCIL OBJECTIVE? COUNCIL WARD(S) 4 DISTRICT PLANIVING COUNCIL �� ITIATING PROBLEM, ISSUE, OPPORTiJNITY (Who, What, When, Where, Why?): This improvement project was initiated by a pefition signed by 48% of the property owners abutting the alley. VANTAGES IF APPROVED: t,��t`•�'da_ r�E�v°��C�c �a.�.=':^;��f Drainage in the alley will be impraved. �5�� g� ISADVAN"I'AGES IF APPROVED: Normal problems associated with construction such as noise, dust, and general disruption will occur. Also, assessments to cover the cost of the improvement would be levied against the — benefitted properties, payable over a maximum of 20 years. ISADVANTAGES IF NOT APPROVED: The current drainage problems would continue. OTAL AMOUNT OF TRA.NSACTION: $ 23�1(O.00 COST/REVENUE BUDGETED (CII2CLE ONE) YES NO UNDING SOURCE: A SS0SSII10IItS ACTIVITY NUMBER: INANCIAL INFORMATION: (EXPLAIIV) Project to be funded 100% by assessments. 9j y �� . .. J oy 0 � �o �--; �zo �ZO�s r- T-� i .—i - so� s�zs, 6'0 0� so y �. �-- �� -- t I I I � I � I � � � v1 12 �,�, 13 � 6 14 � 9 8 7 2 5 4 3 2 1�, �!� 12 15 � `� --- �, �� N �m 16 ,� n . ' N k� 17 � N ' n Z /^ 18 a � v� y V 1 W � 19 /zo , So -• ,go S6,TT So Z � � -�- -GANFIELD AVE. � 0 V 6 39 .. .. .. .. .. ,. .. .. ,3y �0 39 13 •�° � v C�� Q �560 `l Y �4 �' O 15 � 12 II 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 I N �15 ti � 16 m• iszo \ � 17 (3z� ` Z q� (za� (i � Cz C2'D (2� (2z� (a ; (L�� (i9� � - - -- U 18 19 �33� � �iz� �� (� C�� a-p �az� (as� �a�-� �q5� (9a) � • . 20 `" ` �' , �--- � f � °` 21 � 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 3 2 33 34. 35� I 6 I � � ---2 ' -2--- �(o� 1543 N . M,� �35� 23 , z.s9 .3y .. . ,. . . , .s9 �o� 3�7 ° ALMOND AVE., zo ^, � i o ,7 39 " . .. V , .. . .. 9 ./ O 9 7 • N ASJ` O �v �. b 12 il 10 9 8 6 5 4 3 �2 I� ��15 I� _ 16 � � � 7 N . �� Q � �_ . � � ' O � s H a. �. �' �. 6�a / �z. s. z E _/ �'�� r�'. � ' � !�' 20 `" I �( � � : , t 1 - �--�F—�— 24 25 26 27 28i �- - - � � 22 ,~ isbt � Area to be improved v 23 • � rzo -3s 2a ---� AL.BAt AVE.,, i - � . . , , � � ,�_ � _ _ _ , . � 9�- y�� CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL FILE NO. � S PRELIlVIINARY ORDER BY �„J ORIGINAL � —18873 as VOTIN WARD_4 In the Matter of Improvingthe alley in Block 3, Lake Park Addition (bounded by Arona, Almond, Snelling and Canfield) by grading and paving with bituminous material The Council of the City of Saint Paul having received the report of the Mayor upon the above improvement, and having considered said report, hereby resolves: 2. 3. That the said report and the same is hereby approved with no altematives, and that the estimated cost thereof is $23,160.00 financed 100% by Assessments. That a public heazing be had on said improvementon the 27th day of Mav. 1998. at 5:30 o'clock �m in the Council Chambers of the City Hall and Court House Building in the City of Saint Paul. That notice of said public hearing be given to the persons and in the manner provided by the Charter, stating the time and place of heazing, the nature of the improvement and the total cost thereof as estimated. COUNCILPERSONS Yeas Nays ✓Benanev ✓�lakey ;/�ostrom �/Coleman ✓FIarris �/Lantry �eiter [In Favor . �Against Adopted by CounciL• Date� ��j �'�;y Certified Passed by Council Secretary By "�_� � � _ Mayor �8 ,�� John Jernberg and Theresa Putzier 1531 Almond Avenue St. Paul, MN 55108 Dear Council Members: We are writing to express ow opposition to the alley improvement project proposed for Block 3, Lake Park Addition. The file number for the project is 18873-5. The estimated project cost is $23,160.00, with an average assessment of $770.25. We oppose the project for several reasons: The first reason is cost. We have a double wide lot resulting in a proposed assessment of $1,540.50. This is more than our property taYes for the year. The second reason is the cause of the damage. We believe that the central cause of the deterioration of the west end of the alley is the use of the alley by large trucks servicing the Shalom Home. The Shalom Home property does not border the alley so it is not being assessed for the project. We think this would be unfair to the property owners being assessed for the project. The third reason is that we think the project is overkill. Simple maintenance of the alley would suffice. Two-thirds of the a11ey is in good shape. The majority of the houses on the east end of the a11ey oppose the project. We hope that you reject the proposal for this year. incerel � �' � �! '� `,�' � John 7ernberg and Theresa Putzier P 5. we l'�ue ci�c�l��e� a�Q�-��o� o�p�� -��e- ��o�cf� %h��e �� " ` � ��.2 OC i �"ct� 2T�'��On �o� ��2 ro'�ecf �av� c� �d W r1U S l Q Y��G � � l� S � �� i+� i M� 4 t l�� G l� 5�� t`��U✓I O��U� � f�- �(v��C�, �� 3 v� aoZ -��d' ��-�,�a.� �� ` / � � /sl S' �w�:� ; ��-G . -" � �%'� �s � l °�'' �'�� . �� a � �� ` , ^ �� .� �� C � /, � ��-�� / Ui/ �D . ;..�2<%Vc'—�,z /��-�i�'C/ � �YVr-C/ � �� , � � ! � l � ( � � �` 1 ,� � -_ _� I � �� /1/V "� � P.��1 � � �� ti ��-� �� J � �.� � - �� -n- .. �� , ��,�, � v ��:�� G�1 L, � ` .� �,,� � �� O i � � - + n J `. UY� �=a'VC-�, ��{ J�P�Q � � � � �x-�� t ��`��'� � � � � � �� '�'�-� - �rJ��a -� � �� -�—��° �-- �� '� �� G'�-e. �� q�-��13 Petition Opposing Aliey Improvement Proposal for Block 3, Lake Park Additio(� By signing the petition below, I am indicating my opposition to the alley improvement project proposed for Block 3, Lake Pazk Addifion. The file number for this project is 18873-5. The esfimated pmject cost is $23,160.00. The average assessment per properiy is $ 77025. OL�{��/1 a �r�_�- 1��,�,.__� � �Nw�� c�a,� ts�� Address �� 7 ss -�- ch � �' isa/ ,41rnD�2� 1�Z� ��i�fc� �- 13� 3' y.�..�Q 15'�3 �1�, o �el �rn . 1`555 �i�YY1�1?;/; �'ti�' Phone # , � L� � �-�- --�� a 9 - �16�7 � �flo-3a� La�f7— �fuo I �'�G � 7D � b y � � z,z59 �� v� —S�10 �!-! (o -833R 6�! 7 —�� (nLIS' �d� g 9 5 , � p�l�+ta� 12 /7.�A--r. , r� �o ..e� /% �n�enU,, iCLt ��..n,.,,.� 1=}.10�_� 14 is 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 t�� c�.�.��n �� y� �3586 1�°39 Azr�o�� A�/F, l��f5-3�� i �� B � ��3 � =a� �� -�� + ��. �'�- G�'� rs��s �. , �� 3� � o� ; �� «� � ` � �� ; � , s C� �' � ,— � ' �� ; , �; /� � . L, � � f �--C c 1�� l '� ; `; G /� � (r� .— G � li � z 1 ti � l; , , .. �/ , �, , . . / �, � , � �� i * �ti � �i �� °�� , � - �� 1�-c�C�� `"� 5��.' .f � d��` �-� � � � - ; -- � ,,�� f � r �� o � �� ° �� . . � � ��