1/23-1/27/2006 Meetings for thin;week of January 23rd -January 27th Page 1 of 1
The City of Saint Paul
*mtatit Meetings for the Week of
January 23rd, thru January 27th, 2006
MONDAY - January 23rd
Charter Commission 4:30 PM Room 220, City Hall
TUESDAY - January 24th
*Ramsey County Board Meeting 9:00 AM Council Chambers, City Hall/Court
House
Legislative Hearing 10:00 AM Room 330, City Hall
WEDNESDAY - January 25th
RiverCentre Convention &Visitors 8:00 AM RiverCentre Authority Board Room,
Authority Board 5th Floor of the RiverCentre
*Housing &Redevelopment 2:00 PM Council Chambers, City Hall
Authority
*City Council --- see Agenda 3:30 PM Council Chambers, City Hall
*City Council Public Hearing 5:30 PM Council Chambers, City Hall
THURSDAY - January 26th
No Meetings Scheduled
FRIDAY - January 27th
Planning Commission 8:30 AM Room 40, City Hall
* Cablecast live and repeated on Saint Paul Channel 18.
Interpreter service for the hearing impaired will be provided at public meetings upon request.Request can be made by
calling(651)266-8509(Voice and TDD)Monday thru Friday, 8:00 A.M. to 4:30 P.M.A minimum of two days notice is
required.
For more information on any of these meetings, you can send Email to:
citizen.service@ci.stpaul.mn.us, or call the Saint Paul Citizen Service Office at 651-266-8989
http://www.stpaul.gov/depts/meetings.html 1/23/2006
Saint Paul Planning Commission
MASTER MEETING CALENDAR
WEEK OF JANUARY 23-27, 2006
Mon 23
Tues 24
Weds 25
Thurs 26
NO MISSISSIPPI RIVER CRITICAL AREA TASK FORCE MEETING
Fri 27
8:00 a.m. Planning Commission Steering Committee Room 41 City Hall
(Larry Soderholm, 651/266-6575) Conference Center
15 Kellogg Blvd.
8:30- Planning Commission Meeting Room 40 City Hall
11:00 a.m. (Larry Soderholm, 266-6575) Conference Center
15 Kellogg Blvd.
Communications Committee... Annual Report 2005
Annual Meeting .. Planning Administrator's report on achievements during 2005 and goals for 2006
(Larry Soderholm, 651/266-6575)
Report of Nominating Committee and Election of Officers
Zoning OLD BUSINESS
#05-194-750 V F Associates(Goodrich)—Conditional Use Permit and Variances to
allow a 4 unit residential cluster development. 192-194 Goodrich Avenue,between Smith
and Leech. (Patricia James, 651/266-6639)
NEW BUSINESS
#05-223-966 Metro Metals Corporation—Determination of Similar Use that motor
vehicle recycling using a small indoor shredder is similar to other 12 Industrial uses.
2576 Doswell Avenue, SW corner at Highway 280. (Patricia James, 651/266-6639)
#06-000-725 Metropolitan Airports Commission—Site Plan Review to widen a portion
of the river channel and construct a levee. 644 Bayfield Street, adjacent to Saint Paul
downtown airport on the right descending bank of the Mississippi River.
(Patricia James, 651/266-6639)
#06-000-752 Metropolitan Airports Commission—Variances of River corridor standards
to widen a portion of the river channel and construct a levee. 644 Bayfield Street,
adjacent to Saint Paul downtown airport on the right descending bank of the Mississippi
River. (Patricia James, 651/266-6639)
Comprehensive Planning University Avenue Business Outreach Survey Final Report—Informational presentation
(Donna Drummond, 651/266-6556)
Neighborhood& Current Summary of Loeb Lake Small Area Plan and Forty-Acre Study
Planning Committee (Yang, Zhang, 651/266-6659)
Recommendations on the Phalen/Atlantic plan amendment to the Phalen Corridor
Development Strategy Summary and zoning study following consideration of public
hearing comments. (Penny Simison, 651/266-6554)
Old Business Update on Xcel High Bridge Plant replacement
-Presentation on new site plans by Xcel representatives.
(Tom Beach, 651/266-9086)
Fleming\Calendars\January 23-27,2006
Page 1 of 1
Christine Haas - Fwd: Re: Org Meeting
From: Shari Moore
To: Haas, Christine
Date: 1/20/2006 2:57 PM
Subject: Fwd: Re: Org Meeting
Please take the Organization meeting off the weekly meeting list. Just assume they aren't holding them unless
we hear that they are.
>>> Trudy Moloney 1/20/2006 2:56 PM >>>
No, but they are holding a policy session on Reducing Disparities.
>>> Shari Moore 1/20/2006 2:31 PM >>>
Is the Council holding an organizational meeting on Wed?
file:1/C:\Documents and Settings\Haasc\Local Settings\Temp\GW}00001.HTM 1/20/2006
Jan 19 2006 12: 29PM 651 -223-5198 p. 2
January 19, 2006
CANCELLATION NOTICE AEC
jAN20217
CI ryC(E
PORT AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL
REGULAR BOARD MEETING
JANUARY 24, 2006
Chair Michael Goldner is CANCELLING the regular board meeting scheduled for
Tuesday, January 24, 2006 at 2:00 p.m. in the Board Room of the Saint Paul Port
Authority, 1900 Landmark Towers, 345 St. Peter Street, Saint. Paul, Minnesota 55102.
Ar f •-
Kenneth R. Johnson
President
las
cc: Briggs & Morgan
Leonard, Street and Deinard
Representatives of the Press
Shari Moore, City Clerk
34923.v1
JAN-17-2006 16: 15 CITY OF SAINT PAUL 651 266 8574 P.01/01
SAINT PAUL CNl;l ��, COMMISSION
lit1?1'1,J;ail 112� � I ,eu' ' , I!, G,INNESOTA 55102
SAINT PAUL, ,li��� �� I, .._ `_
RECZ
JAN902006
NOTICE C/T yCLE•R
OF THE
REGULAR MEETING
OF TIC
SAINT PAUL CHARTER COMMISSION
DATE: January 23, 2006
TIME: 4:30 p.m.
PLACE: City Hall, Room 220
AGENDA
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of the Minutes—Meeting of November 21,2005
3. Citizen Comments
4. Reports of the Standing Committee
• Communications Committee—Sig Johnson
• Charter Review Committee—Dick Dolan
o Second Reading of Sections: 12.03.3, 12.04 3, 12.05, 12.06, 12.08,12.12.1,
12.12.3, 12.12.4,and 12.12.5
5. Old Business
6. New Business
• Elections of Officers: Chair, Vice Chair,and Secretary
• Resignation of Dennis Osborn and update on status of vacancies
• 2006 Schedule
7. Other Business
8. Adjournment
Reminder:Commissioners are responsible to contact the Secretary if they will not be able to
attend the meeting by 12:00 noon of the day of the meeting or they will be considered unexcused.
Four unexcused absences could result in removal form the Commission per the Standing Rules.
For further information concerning the Charter Commission,please contact Bill Johnson,
Administrative Secretary,at 612-845-1741.
.e s
PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
TOTAL P.01
jam
fl II
SAINT PAUL CH ° , ' '',:: • COMMISSION
)1 Ill
I ill
,111
SAINT PAUL, • f I' �'l1!Iilt °,INNESOTA 55102
ik-
✓qN� kFd
8
cVyC 06
NOTICE C<i i.fr
OF THE
REGULAR MEETING
OF THE
SAINT PAUL CHARTER COMMISSION
DATE: January 23,2006
TIME: 4:30 p.m.
PLACE: City Hall,Room 220
AGENDA
1. Call to Order
2. Approval of the Minutes—Meeting of November 21,2005
3. Citizen Comments
4. Reports of the Standing Committee
• Communications Committee—Sig Johnson
• Charter Review Committee—Dick Dolan
o Second Reading of Sections: 12.03.3, 12.04.3, 12.05, 12.06, 12.08, 12.12.1,
12.12.3, 12.12.4,and 12.12.5
5. Old Business
6. New Business
• Elections of Officers: Chair,Vice Chair,and Secretary
• Resignation of Dennis Osborn and update on status of vacancies
• 2006 Schedule
7. Other Business
8. Adjournment
Reminder: Commissioners are responsible to contact the Secretary if they will not be able to
attend the meeting by 12:00 noon of the day of the meeting or they will be considered unexcused.
Four unexcused absences could result in removal form the Commission per the Standing Rules.
For further information concerning the Charter Commission,please contact Bill Johnson,
Administrative Secretary,at 612-845-1741.
46 $
PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
January 3, 2006
NOTICE °�-
Jq
CIry CLERK
PORT AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL
REGULAR BOARD MEETING
JANUARY 24, 2006
Chair Michael Goldner is calling the regular board meeting to be held on Tuesday,
January 24, 2006 at 2:00 p.m. in the Board Room of the Saint Paul Port Authority, 1900
Landmark Towers, 345 St. Peter Street, Saint. Paul, Minnesota 55102.
Kenneth R. Johnson
President
las
cc: The Port Authority Commissioners
Mayor Chris Coleman
City Council
Terrence J. Garvey
Briggs & Morgan
Leonard, Street and Deinard
Representatives of the Press
Shari Moore, City Clerk
Tony Schertler, Acting Director of PED
St. Paul Area Chamber of Commerce
Midway Area Chamber of Commerce
Pig's Eye Coalition
Theresa Skarda, Acting City Attorney
Members of the Ramsey County Delegation
RECEIVED
BAN 0 4 2006
crry CLERK
34923.v1
Page 1 of 1
Christine Haas - FW: SPRCVA Board Meeting Notice
From: "Tom Marver" <tmarver@stpaulcvb.org>
To: <christine.haas@ci.stpaul.mn.us>
Date: 1/18/2006 11:36 AM
Subject: FW: SPRCVA Board Meeting Notice
From: Tom Marver
Sent: Wednesday, January 18, 2006 11:30 AM
To: Barb Hoeker (E-mail); Barbara Renshaw (E-mail); Christine Haas (christine.hass@ci.stpaul.mn.us); Curt
Brown (E-mail); Domagall, Jim; Gary Murphy (graphicexhibitsinc@msn.com); Handt,Tina; Hubbard, Susan;
Ibister, Jim; John Kelly (E-mail); Karolyn Kirchgesler (E-mail 2); Larson, Jack; Laura Yuen (E-mail); Marver, Tom;
Rick Nyquist(rnyquist@rivercentre.org); Roberts, Sharon; Ruane, Steve; Security - RiverCentre
(security@rivercentre.org); Shari Moore (E-mail); Stoffel, Mark; Willems, Eric; Zirbel, Mark; Beverly Turner (E-
mail); Charles Paton (E-mail); Dan Bostrom (E-mail); Doug Hennes (E-mail); Edward Christie (E-mail); Eric Jolly
(E-mail); Jaye Rykunyk (E-mail); Joe Reid (E-mail); John Labosky (E-mail); Kathy Lantry (E-mail); Ken Golder(E-
mail); Mary Jo Woolf(E-mail); Pam Wheelock(E-mail); Pat Harris (E-mail); Robyn Hansen (E-mail); Shamus
O'Meara (E-mail); Steve Harper (E-mail); Susan Franson (E-mail); William Cosgriff(E-mail)
Subject: SPRCVA Board Meeting Notice
The next Saint Paul RiverCentre Convention & Visitors Authority board meeting is scheduled for
Wednesday,January 25th at 8:00 am in the RiverCentre Authority Board Room, fifth floor of the
RiverCentre.
Directors:
Please let me know a.s.a.p. if you will or will not be able to attend this meeting so that I am
assured of having a quorum. Please feel free to call with any questions or concerns regarding this
meeting. Thanks.
Tom Marver
SPRCVA Board Administrator
651.265.4866 w
612.760.8410 c
file://C:\Documents and Settings\Haasc\Local Settings\Temp\GW}00001.HTM 1/18/2006
t
JIIIIl
silIkl
il
SAINT PAUL CH ° . @ ' COMMISSION
SAINT PAUL, -.;,t ; � '' `I ,�f',16 1,,INNESOTA 55102
Saint Paul Charter Commission
Regular Meeting
Monday,January 23,2006
City Hall
Room 220
Agenda#1, Call to Order
Bridget Faricy, Chair of the St. Paul Charter Commission, called the regular
meeting of the St. Paul Charter Commission to order at 4:33 p.m.
Commissioners also present included: Jeff Sutter—Maas, Triesta Brown, John
VanHecke, Sig Johnson, Virginia Rybin, Richard Kramer, Richard McCarthy, and
Gladys Morton.
Commissioners with excused absence included: Richard Dolan,Bob Connor, and
Greg Copeland.
Agenda#2,Approval of the Minutes
Richard Kramer moved the approval of the minutes with the following
amendments. One: The"be" in line two of the second page be changed to a"by". Two:
the last two paragraphs under New Business read as follows:
"Commissioner Rybin moved to ask the City Attorney's office for clarification
on Chapter 11 of the Charter regarding the vote necessary for the City Council to enact
tax legislation. The motion was seconded by Triesta Brown and passed on a voice vote.
Commissioner Copeland moved to have his two proposed amendments referred to
the City Attorney for legal advice.No seconded was attained."
Three: the "adjourn" in the last line of the minutes be changed to "adjourned". Richard
McCarty seconded the motion and it passed unanimously.
Agenda#3, Citizen Comments
No citizens were present.
46 S
PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER
Agenda#4,Reports of the Standing Committees
Communication Committee report by Sig Johnson
The committee reported that they had secured an appropriate map for the brochure
and will go ahead with the productions of the brochure. Commissioner Johnson also
stated that the Charter Commission web page on the city's web site had been eliminated
and she will look into having that revived.
Charter Review Committee report by Jeff Sutter—Maas
Bill Johnson, Administrative Secretary,review the attached spreadsheet and
packet of proposed revisions.
The following proposed amendments received their second reading: 12.03.3,
12.04.3, 12.05, 12.06, 12.08 and 12.12.5. Sections 12.12.1, 12.12.3 and 12.12.4 were
referred back to committee. Section 12.12 is also referred back to committee with the
anticipations that it will receive its first reading at the next regular meeting of the
Commission.
Sections 3.01.08 and 4.09 were both passed by the City Council and have gone to
the City Clerks office for inclusion in the official charter. Secretary Johnson will follow
up on these changes.
Agenda#5, Old Business
Judith Hanson, Assistant City Attorney,presented the commission with the
attached document regarding the number of votes require by the City Council to enact tax
legislation.No further action was taken.
Agenda#6,New Business
Election of Officers
Bridget Faricy was placed in nomination for Chair. Dick McCarthy seconded the
nomination and Chair Fancy won unanimously.
Sig Johnson was placed in nomination for Vice Chair. Virginia Rybin seconded
the nomination and Commissioner Johnson won unanimously.
Jeff Sutter—Maas was placed in nomination for Secretary. Gladys Morton
seconded the nomination and Commissioner Sutter—Maas won unanimously.
Resignation of Dennis Osborne
Chair Faricy announced the resignation of Dennis Osborn from the Charter
Commission. The Chair will encourage the Chef Judge to fill the current vacancies as
soon as possible with the applicant pool that exist. In addition, the Chair announced that
Richard Dolan does not wish to be reappointed at the end of his term in July 2006.
2006 Schedule
After a brief discussion, the Commission determined that they will meet every
month for the first six months of 2006 and will revisit the schedule in July.
Agenda 7, Other Business
None was presented.
Agenda 8,Adjournment
Chair Faricy seeing no further business before the Commission, adjourned the
regular meeting of the St. Paul Charter Commission at 5:20 p.m.
St. Paul Charter Commission
Charter Review Committee
Amendment Spreadsheet
Date: January 06
Section Number: First Second Third Final Vote Location
1.03 x City Attorney's Office
3.01.08 x 11/05 City Council
4.09 x 11/05 City Council
6.01 x City Attorney's Office
6.11 x City Attorney's Office
10.09 Referred to Committee
11.01 x City Attorney's Office
11.02 Referred to Committee
11.03(1) Referred to Committee
11.03(5) x City Attorney's Office
11.03(4) x City Attorney's Office
11.03 (6) x City Attorney's Office
11.04 x City Attorney's Office
12.03.3 x
12..04.3 x
12.05 x
12.06 x
12.08 x
12.12.1 x
12.12.3 x
12.12.4 x
12.12.5 x
13.03.4(2) x City Attorney's Office
13.03.4(4) x City Attorney's Office
13.03.8 Referred to Committee
14.01.1(4) x City Attorney's Office
14.01.4(2) x City Attorney's Office
16.03 x City Attorney's Office
16.06 x City Attorney's Office
16.08 x City Attorney's Office
17.01 x City Attorney's Office
17.03 X City Attorney's Office
•
17.07.1(1) x City Attorney's Office
17.07.2 Referred to Committee
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
John J.Choi,City Attorney
SAINT
PAUL CITY OF SAINT PAUL Civil Division
014‘ Christopher B.Coleman,Mayor 400 City Hall Telephone:651 266-8710
15 West Kellogg Blvd. Facsimile:651 298-5619
AMASaint Paul,Minnesota 55102
meow
January 23, 2006
Bridget Fahey
Chair, Saint Paul Charter Commission
City of Saint Paul
Saint Paul Charter Commissioners
City of Saint Paul
Dear Ms. Fancy and Commissions:
At the last meeting of the Charter Commission November 21,2005,a question came up concerning
the required votes by the City Council for adoption of the Mayor's budgets. In reviewing Section
10.06 of the City Charter it indicates that the Council shall by resolution,and ordinance if applicable,
adopt the budgets and certify tax levies no later than twelve (12) days before the date requiring
property tax levy certification in accordance with state law, for the ensuing fiscal year.
Looking at Chapter six of the Charter entitled Legislative Procedures section 6.03.1, it reads that
ordinances require an affirmative vote of at least four(4) members of the council. Section 6.03.3
entitled Resolutions,states that except as otherwise provided in this Charter,resolutions shall require
an affirmative vote of at least four(4)members. Section 6.03.3,specifically refers to acts of council
regarding budget adoption and revision,certification of the tax levy,emergency appropriations and
other matters. The last sentence of Section 6.03.3 reads; "Except as otherwise provided in this
Charter, resolutions shall require an affirmative vote of at least four(4)members."
I have not researched the entire Charter to establish all the instances where greater than four(4)is
required,but on a quick review I have found the following; Section 6.06 for Emergency ordinances
a unanimous vote of all city council members is required, Section 7.07 requires an affirmative vote
of five(5)members for a Special election,Section 10.06.01 (where this Commission had questions)
AA-ADA-EEO Employer
requires a unanimous vote of all of the members if there is a budget amendment prior to certification
of tax levy,and Section 10.11 requires five(5)votes for the issuance of obligations. There certainly
may be other instances where there is a requirement of more than four(4) votes.
The Council's authority relative to budget issues comes from the city Administrative Code sections
56 and 57 which I have provided.
In reading the minutes from the November 21, 2005, meeting of the Charter Commission, in
conjunction with the letter that I received from the Chair of the Commission, my understanding is
that the Commission's question is how many votes are required for the council to enact tax
legislation. The answer is that a vote of four (4) members of the council is needed to adopt the
budget and to certify the tax levy. In the event there is to be a revision of the budget after its
adoption,but prior to certification of tax levy,the council by resolution adopted by unanimous vote
of all of its members following a public hearing for that purpose,may amend the budgets,provided,
however,that the council may not reduce the appropriations for any debt service or for meeting any
existing obligations of the city.
I hope this sufficiently answers your questions.
Since ly,
dith A. Hanson
Assistant City Attorney
City of Saint Paul
AA-ADA-EEO Employer
21 January 2006
Ms. Judy Hanson
Saint Paul City Attorney
400 City Hall
Saint Paul, MN 55102
Dear Ms. Hanson,
At the November 21, 2005 meeting of the St. Paul Charter Commission, the Commission
requested an opinion from the City Attorney's Office on the following question:
It appears that read together, Charter Sec. 10.06.1 and Sec. 11.04 requires a
unanimous vote of the City Council in order to increase taxes. However, under
current Council practices, only a majority vote is required. Is this an example of a
situation where state statute would supercede the Charter or are current Council
practices in violation of the Charter?
Thank you, in advance, for your assistance with our inquiry.
Regards,
Bridget Faricy
Chair, City of Saint Paul Charter Commission
2220 Bayard Avenue
Saint Paul, MN 55116
Phone: (612) 817-8011
St. Paul Charter Commission
Charter Review Committee
Amendment Spreadsheet
Date: January 06
1 Section Number: First Second Third Final Vote Location
1.03 x City Attorney's Office
3.01.08 x 11/05 City Clerk's Office
4.09 x 11/05 City Clerk's Office
6.01 x City Attorney's Office
6.11 x City Attorney's Office
10.09 Referred to Committee
11.01 x City Attorney's Office
11.02 Referred to Committee
11.03(1) Referred to Committee
11.03(5) x City Attorney's Office
11.03(4) x City Attorney's Office
11.03 (6) x City Attorney's Office
11.04 x City Attorney's Office
12.03.3 x x 1/06
12..04.3 x x 1/06
12.05 x x 1/06
12.06 x x 1/06
12.08 x x 1/06
12.12 Referred to Committee
12.12.1 x Referred to Committee
12.12.3 x Referred to Committee
12.12.4 X Referred to Committee
12.12.5 X x 1/06
13.03.4(2) x City Attorney's Office
13.03.4(4) x City Attorney's Office
13.03.8 Referred to Committee
14.01.1(4) x City Attorney's Office
14.01.4(2) x City Attorney's Office
16.03 x City Attorney's Office
16.06 x City Attorney's Office
16.08 x City Attorney's Office
17.01 x City Attorney's Office
17.03 X City Attorney's Office
17.07.1(1) x City Attorney's Office
17.07.2 Referred to Committee