10-808Amended 7l21/2U10
City of St. Paul COLTNCIL FILE NO. 10-8os
h
RESOLUTION RATIFYING ASSESSMENT By � ,
�
File No. SEE BELOW
Assessment No. SEE BELOW
Voting
Ward In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for
[i'�7
J1007G (108883) weekly gazbage hauling service on private properties during April 07, to April 15, 2010.
A public hearing having been had upon the assessment for the above improvement, and said assessment
having been fixrther considered by the Council, and having been considered finally satisfactory, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That the said assessment be and the same is hereby in all respects ratified.
RESOLVED FURTHER, That the said assessment be and it is hereby determined to be payable in One
equal installment.
Carter
Hazris
Stark
Thune
Yeas Na s Absent Requested��p e o£ F' �cial Services
✓ � By. %'
✓
'� Approved by the O ce Fin ial Se �ces
✓
� By: NA
� Approved by Ciry Attomey
s � By: �,� �`� s�� ��'�
Adopted by Council: Date ��/ ��j//(� Approve y yo for Submission to Council
Adoption Certified by Coun i] Secretary g ����
By: �
Appro�v�-l2y ayo � Date � 7/7 �1C7
/ >i
$Y� �� �—
i� ���
July 21, 2010 City Council Action Minutes Page 20
70. Resolution Ratifying Assessment — 10-808 — In the matter of the assessment of
benefits, cost, and expenses for weekly garbage hauling service on private
properties from Aprii 7 to 15, 2010. [J1007G] (GS 3ll2016-Ward 7) (Legislative
Hearing Officer recommends the following:
1393 Sherburne Avenue— delete the assessment.)
Adopted as amended Yeas — 5 Nays — 0
1E�31F3
City of St. Paul
Office of Financial Services
Real Estate Section
REPORT OF COMPLETION OF ASSESSMENT
COUNCIL FILE
File No. SEE BELOW
Assessment No. SEE BELOW
Voting
Ward In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for
J1007G (108883) weekly garbage hauling service on private properties during April 07, to April 15, 2010.
To the Council of the City of St. Paul
The Financial Services Real Estate Section hereby reports to the Council the following as a statement of the
expenditures necessarily incurred for and in connecfion with the making of the above improvement, viz:
Total costs
Pazk Service Fee
Code — Enforcement Service Fee
Real Estate Service Fee
Attorney Fee
TOTAL EXPENDITURES
Charge To
Net Assessment
$3,400.00
$
$ 805.00
$ 580.00
$ 145.00
$4,930.00
$4,930.00
Said Financial Services Real Estate Section fiirther reports that it has assessed and levied the total aznount as
above asceftained, to-wit: the sum of $4.930.00 upon each and every lot, part or pazcel of land deemed benefitted by
the said improvement, and in the case of each lot, part or pazcel of land in accordance with the benefits conferred
thereon; that the said assessment has been completed, and that hereto attached, identified by the signature of the
Real Estate Manager, and made a part hereof, is the said assessment as completed by said Rea1 Estate Section, which
is herewith submitted to the Council for such action thereon as may be considered proper.
Dated:
S Z -���"
�
Estat� Manager:
I i ' l�.
1� N— 7— � 1 �—?—�l —1 � og
� Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet
FS —FinancialServices
Contact 4erson & Phone:
Lynn Moser
266-8851
on Council Agenda by (Datej:
Doc. Type: OTHER (DOESNT FIT ANY
CATEGORI�
E-DOCUmentRequired: Y
DoeumentContact: KimRanweiler
ConWct Phone: 266-8856
19MAY2010 I Green Sheet NO: 3112016
y
Assign
Number
For
Routing
Order
Total # of Signature Pages _(Clip All Locations for Signature)
Set date of public hearing and approve assmts for weekly garbage hauling service on private properties during Apri107 to April 15,
2010. File No. I1007G
f�"�=_.-�:-7
Recommendations: Approve (A) or Reject (R):
Planning Commission
CIB Committee
Gvil Service Commission
Personai Service Contraets MustMswer the Following Questions:
1. Has ihis persoNfirm ever worked under a contract for this department?
Yes No
2. Has this person/firm ever been a ciry empioyee?
Yes No
3. Does this personlfirtn possess a skill not nortnally possessed by any
currenl city employee7
Yes No
Explain all yes answers on separete sheet and aHach to green sheet.
Initiating Problem, Issues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why):
Property owners or renters create a health I�azard at various Umes througl�out the City of Saint Paul when their property is not kept up.
The City is zequised by City code to clean up the property and chazge the property owner for tl�e clean up.
Advantages If Approved: � �
Cost recovery programs to recover expenses for snmmary abatement, grass cutting, towing of abandoned vehicles, demolitions,
garbage hauling, tree removal and boazdings-up.
Disadvantages If Approved:
None
Disadvantages If NotApproved:
If Council dces not approve these charges generat fund would be required ta pay the assessment
ToYal Amount of � g30.00
Transaetion:
Funding Source:
Einancial Infnrmation:
(Explain)
CostlRevenue Budgeted:
AcGvity Number:
��������
�# `� � �fj��
29 property owners wilt be notified of the public hearing and chazges.
May 20, 2010 7:27 AM Page 1
10-808
Ju1y 6, 2010 Legislative Hearing Minutes
J1007G Weekly garbage hauling services from Apri17 to April 15, 2010
1393 Sherburne Avenue
Page 6
Delete the assessment per DSI.
10-808
�
�
a
A
L
a
L
d
W
R
�
i i
{ I
I� I�
� I�
I� I�
j � I�
N IN
I°; IN
I M I M
I I
I I
i ooS S I
oo� � �
O N 69 ^ `
I�� � I
I I
I I
I I
I O O O I
I O .-. '+
I I I
I I
I
IO O O I
I.. O v+ I
�
� �
� �
� �
I I
� w I
C
� .
�
I K � * I
� d N ik N
� � w � � �
I
I � Y � 3 a
m W .�. � I .
� �y O
IC7 rL Q + �:
I
I� I�
�� ��
�` �c
�N �N
�0 ��
�� I�
I O � I a �
�inx �v�Y
.] .]
�u� �um
I .] N I .] rv
I I
I I
I I I
{ I
I I
O �
I � � O � � O
I � 1�4 N I I � 0 F�I N
� '� Ga V � -.=. N Fa 'ct
N L
'� F a C^
I �,�d ol z z� o
'' � �'�
� �
I � 3 7� L� I O �� Q 9 Z
�a40. 0� °�'-� ia� c G� "v
I.^vrn�3: �n�v��3:
s
a
L
_
� �
U �«
� _
o u �
ti �
0
u �
w o
O y
QI �
ti
y R
dq
L
'O C
9 0
T V
� 4
aa
G
�'
V
Q
C
�
v
>
0
c
�
a
G
c
'�
N
E
C
L
L
O
N
�
v
0
s
°o
' � �
F p Q
° z c
�
Q
a��
C�
mo
�oo
I
I�
lo
I�
I�
N
I N
IM
I
I
I
�000 0
000 �
�oo� �
O N f5 N
�
I P £A
I
I
I O O O
O O O
I O .- .-
I�
I
I
O O O
O O O
I N h
�
I �
� �
I _C
C �
9
I � Q �
x °' �
la� " y
I `a w `�'
9 �y O
�c� rx d
I
I�
IV
� `�y
IO
Y
I O ai
If �
i �F
A0
y�
I YL
I I 3 h
I
I M
I O
I I P �
N
I r_t�
� � �
Y ^ � �
1 Ib Q V �
I � � � �
_�
IL: O �
� � � �
13���
�
T
a
F
9
N
�
3
�
l�'�
�
x
U
� r- a l
^
q
r
r
0
�
O
0
N
C
w
0
C
r �
9 Z
��
3�
+ N o
Fed
z �
h
a
. � -
0. �
00
i
I�
I�
I°
�
I N
I "'
N
I N
I I M
I
I
�SoS S
�oo� �
O N Hf ^
Vi
� A ff3
I
I
I O O O
I O ti ti
I
I
I
I O O O
I� O h
�
�
�
I �
�
I N N
w a
C �
� � '� F -
L b
I � Q � ia
�x ro W d
y � C
I,e�w c ''
� i O
�
.
iC7 �L Q :
N >
L.
I F O A
o�z
I�
ti
IC�1F0.m
I "�o�
QVi O
L'1�'pF
I
�
�Om
�
C] .= � -1
I
I
I
I
I O
I �� �
� Y •��+ � N
r, Q y
i� o�
I �°
z>�� "o
� � � � 1�I � �
^ � _ q c
aq � M � �
�0���3�
I a�� ,
0
. o °
!x1 n =
O
z
W
ti
w��
c�.o-
O N
�oo
I
IM
lo
I�
IM
I N
��
I N'
I
I
�000 0
0 0
� oo� �
O N 69 N
� N fA N
H3 V3
I
I
O O O
O O O
I O O .. .-.
I
I
I O O O
I� O �n
�
�
I '
•
N
w a.
� �.5 �
I C a .
a Q.N �
, W � N
,'*', w �
N T C
Y
I � w c �
� O
I � � *
I U fx Q a
I�
�z�
ON
IF(.
I 'p0
p .t
I yQ
I �F
h �
0.
I�O
Y
IpF
6
m
i v F
I
`
I �
I �
C
4 c
O
I y� � N
i � �
� zN
I � �� �
, v � 'A Z � r
3-�aop-�
I� ^ O � � 9 �
I�rraaa ��
� � o r � 3 *
Iox��.
0
i N O
L'I��
O < C
z
W
Q
��a
�' m o
� N -�
O O
10-808
N
GO
a
F
F
L
d
R
e
m
�
M
�
O
�.
�
�
O �t
„ c
0
V n 1
Y N
O yy
a lil
:3
y Q
L
i
'p C
Q o
t C
zz
C
fi
y
Q
�
E
d
0
E
'
a
O
0
N
�
a
R
0
i
I
I�
lo
I �:,
��
I N
�
IN
�
�
�
I ° o ° o ° o ° o
I O o vi vi
O N v3 N
�i9
I:H El?
I
�
�
� o ° o ° o
I O .� .-.
�
I
I O O O
I � O v�
I
I
I
I w
� °
a4 �
S �o
� � � �
x °' w
( y � T
I�[=1 c
9 �y O
� 'U� d�. 4
l
I -]
o �
Il w�
INGI
Z N
I°
I
I�O
�
��<
�uz
I 2rv
�
�
�
� � a
yn c
I.� N
s �
� � � O
V J N
I C ov��
I �' Y c� O
z�
I = � � 9
�qa � e�
0
I7U
A
W
E
s
� .T
� t�-
c
'i
r
O
U
�
a
*
N
�
�
C
Y
3
O
.
0
�a °
� �
C/1 O
� C
��_
� T�t
W `� �
* 3�
° o
F Q �
0
�
N
'�'=o
0 0
I
I O
lo
I�
I M
I
N
IN
I N
�
�
l o 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
I O ^ O v� O
p N 59 V
I� V3 � �
I
�
lo 0 0 0
I O ^ ti ti
I N --
I
I
I O O O O
-� -+ O v�
II I
I *
i4
� �
� w �
ao � F�
c �
� a �
j L� Q N �y
I a�i E� T C
I I9 ¢ � � �
<
C7L1aQ �
�
If'�
�re
�
lO 0
I � W
Ij°
i pX
��
N
z
�'z�
��-
�°
I��a
I j f O
�Ca�
I
�
�
�4
I� G
I w E " �
M � N
� C � � N
� O � �
� ^ � �
M `
O pv�i �
o „ U
I 2 � F � � m
I " O � �p L L
��n=ar�
Ic,a
O
z
y
a
�_
. o
I
Ir
lo
� �.
��
I
N
I N
I N
�
�
�
l o 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
I O O h V�
O N F+Y N
I� � �
I
�
l o 0 0
0 0 0
I O .--i '.
I
I
I
I O O O
-� O h
I
I
�
I
�� N
w
c
I C �
9
I � ¢ �
x �' w
I N a . T
�p W �
O
�c7 a Q
I
I��
��E
I��
O
I��
c�x
I W � �1
N�+�
�°�°
3�
��
�
�
�
�
I
I
�
I o�
I �
r'
� 3 ° v
� � �h
�= °'" 3
fa��o
I T � N y
m _
Icaz3w
4
T
m
H
a
�
3
O
0
0
F `�'
� �
� G
d��
� Z L
N a y
�3�
* o rv
o
z
N
�
i oo
i
I
I M
lo
I �:,
I�
IN
a
IN
�
�
� o 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
I O O '�1 v�
O N 69 N
I� � �
I
I
I o ° o ° o
I p p � •--
I
I
I
I O O O
I N V1
�
I *
I �
I w �
c
ou � F
I � a �
� ¢ e�i �
x y �- �,
� � C
� i d `� .°. O
� � O
�C7 C Q * a
I
��s
I O -�
F a.
I O F
i�s
h=
° z¢
I 4
E%
���
1
I 6 F
�
�
�
� N
I �
m
� �
� �
1 `n G� O
I z Q N
i ^ ^ � '�. F a
I � y� L z 4J
� ^ cpO p
izzm���,a
{� �
I Y` V] G� L Z
�..�� oo a �
� N
�c7-";a>� +>
� N O
o
z
N
�=o
00
10-808
�
d
a
F
N
L
N
bD
C
R
�
W
W
W
O
�'
Q
�
O aG
'� C
O
u �
d o
L �
aa
�
h /
L ~
a c
�e o
T �
a y-
az
u
d
Q
�
m
d
0
G
�.
V
t
0.
0
O
N
�
0
q
0
I
IN
I�
I�
IN
IN
IN
��
I N
�
i
� o 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
I o o vi vi
O N Fa �
Vj
I H3 £A
I
I
�
I O O O
O O O
Ip�....
I
I
I O O O
I� N �
I
� *
:
I �
I � �
� "� F
I � � � �
x �, w �
i m�n e � i 3
m W c �
� o
m
�C7 � � z
I
��
I�
l
lo
��
��
�
I F
I u
�
I
I �
� �
I � o
I � L.y O
� � N
� N � N
��>`z �
O
I 4 C� V�j � O
r = z W � c
I���C7 a,
� _ ,o ...
� H n `L� r�`s �
� ^ � �
c� ln + . :
i
i
a
Q
L
R
V
� F
�
c
L
G
.,
O
❑
d
ti
L
0
- 0 O
o<a
y
���
` 00
I
a
�
I o
�
I "'
IN
I�
N
� ^�
I N
�
l o 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
� o ^ o vi o
v� N 69 O�
-� £A N
I V3 69 fP
I
�{
I
I O O O O
O O O O
I O = .ti .-.
1
I
i0 0 0 0
� -- O �n
I
� �
x
I d
I w a
c �
an '� F�
C � 0 .
' � ¢ � �
Iti G N �
� � E � >. c
� m 4 W ° c �
� y y .4 a
(7Ll�Q :
I �F
0
�oz
F Z
IQ�
O
�� V
��y
I�Q
3r
❑.i�
� Q c �
� �
¢ w_
I
�
� �
I �
I Q
I W
I p z O
� ~ N
� O =
°=x N
I � � 4 N F �
� Z J h
' 14 � '�]' G � F
�<��x��
I °' ,r.�'> N ?c
� C D N'n ��:.
��,C���* ..
°- o
W n \
o
y
¢
m
` P C
I
lo
�o
�M
I�
IN
Iry
�d
I N
�
(o 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
I o o vi vi
O N EA �
I� � �
I
I
I
I O O O
O O O
� •-- ti
I
I
I
I O O O
-+ O Vl
I
I
I
�
� w
� � �
� � � �
x w
� � � �
� k7 C
� C�7 `�.,�' 4
I
I
10
IQ�
I �O
y �
10�
�z¢
G
�c '
I
I�F
I
�
T
�
F�
�
3
O
I �
I �
IG Q
C
IC1 or� O
�� �� o
i� _O N
I��x o
�"s��a��
� � x"�'
4J O � � cC ,-
I
0
* N O
Faa
0
y
u�
L-�O
N o
I
I�
�o
�M
I M
I N
IN
I N
l o 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
I O O � �n
v� N 69 l�
I Elj ff3 69
I
I
I O O O
O O O
I O .� .--
I
I
I O O O
I �-- O �n
I
�
�
I y
w
c
� �
b
I ^3 Q N
65 u N
I x y w
v y
Im k. ❑
-�� � o
C70.5Q
I IX
I
I�
lO
I
�4
I N
,
�s
I
I
�
I
I
I
I� �
I = "'
N
�_ �
� O
I � � N
1-0�
� r
� y =
I i � �
r�
� � � �
'+
�
�
�
�
N
3
O
.
0
E 'q O
� �
z �
��/
IH �
� N
x�m
r t :a
� �
�3a
O'
z
m
4
� V
L o
�
�
a
F
H
L
N
W
R
�
f7
�
W
�
O
�.
Q
�
o�
.. �
ti,
�_
da
�� d
M�
w
h W
dq
L
9 _
>a V
s ',-.
za
�
E
m
C
E
d
>
0
�
a
r�.i
a
O
N
�
N
°
0
,
i
IN
I�
��
IN
I N
N
I N
1 N
�
I
I O O O O O
0 0 0 0 0
�o � o vi o
O N 69 V
Ifi3 69 � 69
I
I
I
O O O O
O O O O
I O ^ ti ti
� N •--
I
I
I O O O O
I .-. ..-. O v�
I
I
I
I °
I �
� w a
c �
I au F•
C � 9 . c
3 w Q N cC
I w � °' w v
I N E.�. T C
I� ¢� L O
� O *
I � Q �i Q iF
I N �
I av
� � a ^
] F
w�0
I 3�a0
I � � O �
m�4
��
�h�F�
�>�°a
�
�
I
�
� W
I �
I d C
I �z c
�., �
° . I � . '1 N
I N �-+ �
� —d �:
� � O N � p
I T � � �"� N C
� O = � �p ,�
�' cu� " ai
� oo.v3c,
C] c r-7 -x� . .
A
L
i
R
�
� a
0
L
�'
.,
C
Q
L
6�
0
O
O'
z
m
y
¢
w ,.,
E� .�
* O
�
i
IN
I o
��
I�
I N
� N
I N
�
I
I
I O O O O
0 0 0 0
I o o vi �ri
O N FA N
I N Vi N
�f3 V3
I
I
I O O O
I Q � •-� �--�
I
I
I O O O
I� N �
I
I
I �
:
f �
u", a
c m
� � F -
C �p 9�
� Q � �y
I v v�-
u '� � 3
I I m W a �
� � O
�C7 a Q '+
I
I
rv
�m
�
��
I�
�
��
J
1>
lO
�
�
�
�
I Fa
I N �
M
I � y� o
I �� �
I � =
� � N
I y � � v
� < Y r O
I � ^ � "^.
U [� l^J
I ^ O T �j �
.7 F `1 � � 9
w o � c
°�°�3a
��000 � . :
0
• p �
i N N
E v e
O ^
Q
w�
o.o`�
• a
�
i
IM
lo
��
I�
IN
I N
l M
�
I
I �
I O O O O O
0 0 0 0 0
lo ^ o vi o
vl N fH O�
--� 69 N
IE5 V3 4^
I
I
I
I O O O O
I O ^ ..+ .--i
I�
I O O O O
O O O O
� �-- O �n
I
I
i
I '
*
I �
� w a.
c ��e`
� co �6 H
� v 9 '�
_ � ¢ � �
� � � �
:`�
xe T �
I IpQ W c �
iy O y
�c7 q d d .
I
�
I 0 r
Y
N "�
I O Nl
I V O
�>o
�zF
iC0
�
�
�
I
I
� � o
� � �
N
�A N
9 � � Z a
> O
�=�� W �'o
I � � � � w
I � F � � � m
m a
9 '� r �.�y 4 C
l���,� � �
1�=�� 3:
0
♦ p �
F ^ r
O V <
z
y
.�'i � _°.
��
t N N
00
i
In
�o
��
I�
I N
Iry
I M
�
I
I
I O O O O O
I ohovi o
v� N fA O�
-� EA N
I V3 fA £i3
I
I
I O O O O
I O ^ -. .�
I '. -
I
I O O O O
I .- .. O �n
I
I
I�
�
I C �
� eo 'E F�
G � ,O �C
I 3wQ a�
x � i (S� 4j
I ao a y � 3
I m Q W C 0
1� .. i O
�C7C]f4Q x'�
I
IF
O
�p
��
��
l
z
I F
¢
1�
�Y�
I ho
�
�
�
I
I G
�U � c
i� ° a �
' � "' Q N
I j Q � p
�z �
I F Y� O� O
I r. C i f,�' r�-� vi r
�- 3 o a f' °°
-o z
�e�i 3 �' 'w c
I�^�� 3}
o
O C O
z
y
��h
c n .�v
io-sos
e
i
S
n
V
10-808
�
d
a
F
F
L
d
R
Q
�
�
�
0
s
a
r
O
O 3G
'r =
� O
U �
d O
O y
w`a
v
y �
d Q
L
�e a
�o 0
T u
a k
aa
C
N
Cl
C
Y
d
0
L
a
..�.
a
c'.
�
0
N
:;
�
0
Q
0
I
I�
��
��
I�
I N .
�
I N
I
I
I
� 000 0
000 0
�oo� �
O N �3 N
Vi
I Vj V3
I
1
I
IooS
�o��
I�
ISoS
I'"N�
I
I
I
I I N
w
❑
G �
9
� � � �
x °' �-
v cd
� ti d
I �y [I] C
9 0
ro
I C7 r� Q
ti
��a
I�G
F
�qp
I�"
.1 �
io�
I
Z
i�c
I
I
I
I
I �
� =d
� "' z
I�`'oo
Ip¢�3
� 3 � � d'
la3_a
,u a � M
i¢���
O
L
i
s
L
�
�
z
C
0
Q
E
.�.
0
L
A
L
�
L
x
T
�
�
F�
a
�
�
:
0
N
_
�
0
�
� �
'O q
��
3�
..
�oC
O < e
z
m
¢
ae
�_
I
I�
1 0
��
IN
( M
N
� N
IN
I
I
I
� 000 0
oao 0
�oo� �
O N Hi N
ff3
I V3 V3
I
!
I
�000
0
��_�.
I�
lo ° o 0
i� O N
�
I
I
I
I �
c*,
� �
0-0 �
C d
I � ¢ �
x�w
I y �°.
ti �
I m W ❑
-O o
m
� c�J a�' d
lo
IQ
I ❑
c a
I��
I�F
I3 o
❑ ._
IQQ
4
I �N
izo
1
I
I
I
I ^
� m �
I aN
� <o
z�
I��z
����
� N y
� G
i a �,
��3
�
Ir��
•
T
�
m
F
b
A
3
O
>
ca o
Q N
z �
� �
3 `
�
� �
a "' m
p � 9
� � �
�3�
w�C
� < v
z
�
� N
���
-�s
I
I�
lo
��
I�
I N
I N
IN
I
I
� 000 0
000 0
�oa� �;
O N 69 �
fA
I Vi V3
I
I
�000
0
�o�_
I
I
i o ° o ° o
� O �n
1 N
I
I
I �
❑
I � �
-� 9
I� 4 �
�' w
�
� � w �
I ca W
a o m y
�c7�d
��
I�
I
O
� ,
F
I�
Iz
IF
�w
I
1
I
I �
I �
I �
f l va ` .7
�.,
� <°z
��
� oz�
I C M� �
rs n _
�
� �
e� ,n 0.�, N
I���
i
�
�
m
E�
�
@
3
O
.
c
�
�
0
� �
�,
9
2 �
3*
° —o
;°�
F � �
O e e
y
Q
�o�
i o_
I
I M
�o
��
I�
' N
IN
IN
I
I
I
� 000 0
000 0
I o o v; v;
O N 69 N
I� � �
I
I
I
�000
0
IS�
I
I
i o ° o ° o
.� O �n
I N
I
I
M
3t
I d
I � �.
C �y
I � E F~
4 a
�N a N �
Ix u � C
I ro W C �
� o
ro .. .
c7 a Q .
�
I l p
IO
IF
IC7
�r
I �]
�
IF
��
�
f
I
I
I �
i U
I Q o
� ^ A N
I '"'7 cV Qi N
�>o�l a
I U O Z v�j ,r O
�_�_ �
I� ^ r���=
C � � � Z : C
�� °'��"�3c�
f4��,�� ,
oa<
z
ti
6 � O
�
d
a
H
H
L
N
�
R
�R
G
W
�
O
�'
Q
O
O ]f
5 C
O
� 3
d O
L d
,, a
v
y W
v q
i
9 O
>s V
a �.
a �
c
�
v
Q
�
c�
E
d
0
�
6
i
a
Q
O
0
N
�
N
a
�
0
i
f
I�
lo
��
��
I�
i N
lo
I
1
I
�000 a
000 0
�oo� �
O N� 69 N
IfA EA
I
I
I O O O
I p� �--� .-.
I
I
I O O O
I� � �
I
�
I �
#
I �
� � �
w n.
c �
i co'c� F
� � �
� � � �
'.-� � r'-� m
y T G
I � L'a C O
� o
�
�c��¢ :
O
�
s
L
R
�
� �r
C
'�
Ca
P
m
.;
�
I a
I W 4
I�
�F�1
IQ��
F
�o�n
� � N N
I F v O
I I °so
I
I
I
I
I
I O
I (j a
I � `—�F=1
I ����x
I �� = �` 1 � � i
^ V -/�
I � C. � L`.� �
�
I�>Q�*
C
L
Ca
L
L
L
F
W��
O e e
z
ti
6 � o
0
0
N
C
w
�
� �
L Z
�
3�
i
I
I M
�o
��
I N
I N
1�
I M
I
I
�000 0
0 0
�oo� �
O N fA N
f1j
I £i3 V3
I
I
I O O O
O O Q
O � ^
I
I
I
O O O
I N �
I
I
I
I *
i
I d
I � �
tx, a
a m
� on '� F�
C 9 b
{ � Q � c�
x ;w �
m " y 3
I 6 u1 C �
� o
�
ic7a¢ .
0
I F. r�
I ���
I W a O
4
j �3�
��o
¢q �
��,z�
C
IV rv'�
I W � U
G y p
I l o°c`�
I
�
I � r_,
I 1�
ly �
I � N � O
� o
i;,�x N
` vl � m � cv
I y � P � �
lo3�z o
� a �, ,, z
^ C J 1�1 [� CO
� o � � / '
I'i' U � � F C
Ip°�n� 3a
o �
� � O
F��
O
y
6 0 �
. o m
I
IN
�o
�M
IN
IN
I N
IN
I
I
I
� 000 a
000 0
�oo�; �
O N F/3 N
FA
I V3 f9
I
I
I O O O
O O O
I O .-- .-i
I
I
I O O O
I � O '�1
I
I
I
I ;
I C �
� "� F
C � .
`� Q y w
x ;w �
� �, c
N
I � w c �
9 0
�
�c�z¢ :
la
a
IF
��
o �—
�O iON
�, F;"
�� z ee
I°M
Y � v�i
I 0.m .�m�
I�w Gp
. o m
�o
I I �
�' - -
I
I N
I �
l�
I v
N �
N �
I � � �
' G � �
N
�- a c z a
I���a a
�
�a� UO� w
� op a �.o
� � � � r
o�
IHN3�
i
I
I�
lo
��
M
� N
Iry
M
I
I
�oaoo
0 00 0
�a�o�
O N 69
Vj
I Vi fA
I
I
I
O O O O
O O O O
I p 0 � .. . +
I r ^.
I
I O O O O
I ~ N N
I
�
I
I
I w
i C
° p E
� y 9
� [: Q v
�x .5 � W
� � E � >,
I � g w c
� o
m �n � „
v .,
Ic�Q�¢
IF
�O
O
IQ
I
lO
z
IV
I^�N
� � �
I
I
I �
I
I �
�., z
i `�
c� N
I ' p
4 = C4
I� N W
� ° ' Z �xl"i
o �, � �
�¢���
� N�C M
,.� �in*
0
°
�
i
T
�
a
F
A
3
O
:
C
0
�
v
�
�
N
F
a m
9 �p
m �
3�
� O
F ^
° z p
W
h
.�] p
10-808
c
i
7
�
10-808
�
�
a
F
H
L
N
R
�W
G
M
W
W
O
s
¢
O
O A
� L
ti �
V 3
d O
�o d
wa
a
,�, m
a, q
L
4 O
T �
a r;,
ai ri
C
m
L
Q
�
d
v
>
0
�
c.
i.�r
a
0�
0
N
�
�
O
<
c
!
lo
lo
fM
I�
IN
IN
IM
�
�
�
�c o 0 0
I o o vi vi
O N 69 N
I�� �
�
I
, O O O
O O O
I O ~ ~
I
I
l000
_o�,
I
I
I
I �
I a> >.
I w n.
G �
� on 'c F�
� 9 'b
� Q a� �
� � �
x � w y
c
� ` c �
� ip O
�
c7d4 .
II F
I�
�5
IF
��
IF
I°
�p
¢
v� ^
I O .
IE+q
I ]n
�
�
�,
�� 3
, , ^ F _
I<= �`�' �
� ' F �'
I z U � 11 N
IY � ° � �
h
r ti � r �
im . �
� x o
I °��
�e U N � 1. CD
I�
r�ii � O ��i, C/J � 'o
��oo�a3c
13��a� , .
c
L
w
Q
i
L
._
� a
.�
A
..
O
A
L
0.
:
3
0
U
�
w
�
•
o
E"ea
o r
�
¢
a „' „'
00
!
I�
lo
{M
M
IN
iry
IM
�
�
� o 00 0
0 0 0 0
I o o �i vi
O N 69 ^
49
I� �
1
I
, O O O
O O O
I O � ~
I
I
IooS
.-a�
I N
I �
#
I �
� �
w �
� � 8 F'
a �
� � ¢ �
"w
� E° � c
I I m w c p
� O
�C7 C Q :
I
IF
I�
l
E
I�
lo
�z
iv
C
I�F.
I �C�
�
� 3
I Q I o
I � �' �
3 0
I � i.r �
� V] N
� 4 0 � �
I� T�� �
..�> o
��;zz �
I � _ � � 9 �
� ,. . a
� - �G � `� v
�
1���� 3�
a
o �
� v <
0
�
�
`c.m
o�
� N
O O
I
�
lo
I�
I�
I�
I
��
� ~
�
�
l o 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
I o O vi vi
O N 6^ N
fA
I4� �
I
I
I
I O O O
O O O
I O .Y .-.
I
I
I
IoSo
�o�
I N
�
I
I �
�
�
c
°�° E
9
� Q m
� � � �
x
� �
IA W c
� c�7 a Q
I�
3�
N
l a�
�a�
�m"�
I��
�o�a
�oz
�=
y
�zp
I'LQm
�
�
�
I
I
I
� �
I G �
�
� N
I.� � g
I ^ \ l�(
I� �z
U m �
I T = � -
��3�
e w a
�
l���
#*
x
>.
m
k
H
�
�
�
3
�
�
> c
d °
N
z �
� �
F 4
0
� [V
3 N�
� � Z
-. � �
c�3c
� . ,.
0
F Q 7
° z r
m
w
��m
, �o
� N �
0 0
!
I�
lo
{�
I N
IN
� N
I M
�
�
�
� o 00 0
0 0 0 0
I O O v� �n
O N 64 N
EH
Iff3 f9
�
I
I
' G O O
O O O
I O � ~
1
I
I$$S
�..
I
I
I
f t
� �
� �
� an " H
� a C
I� ¢ y ro
x Y w �
c
�
I m W c �
� � o *
�C7N�, 4 :
I o
IOF
Ip�
ti � v
I j y n
I Q O .�1
I��
I��
I��o
� a � y
I p Q O
I
�
I
I�
1� g,� o
�� c, � o
'd �
I^ � N
I _ �z ;
O T�
3 � � �
I,�.Yx� O
jo o�� H �
a o � �
�r�-=
� � ° o �` � ` c�i
��
I w ° U � + :
o
W � �
oa<
�
<
a�
a�
�
U
QI
H
F
L
Y
�
R
m
�
M
W
�
O
�'
Q
O
O 3t
h C
O
� 3
d O
L d
a a
w
y
�
R O
T �
a �;
za
�
e
h
Q
V
V
�
�
0.
0
O
a
N
O
Q
0
i
I�
I O
I�
I M
IN
I N
IN
I
I
I
�S000 0
I o�oh o
O � N tA V
� 69 N
I£A Z9 H3
I
�
�
l o 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
I O ^ , .-i .-�
I.ti !+
I
I
I O O O O
I.-. � N V�
I
I
I
I
I
�
I �
� °
m �
� v 'a
�u.d v
�,° ,5 � w
I E a+ T
�
I�a6w c
� O
�c7qaQ
l
IwF
��o
��¢
I
Iz�
zo_
�OO;
OF�
�
I�Q°
I Q 4 2
�
�
�
I Fy
� �
� �
� A
.� �
I � �
I _a' " � q
� �°-v�i Q
IY�zz
� . O F.
O
1 ��
I� �_0.
Ica�c °�
Q
til
L
a
e
d
s
� 3
� �
0
L
A
E
..
0
.
Ca
L
L
L
iE
#
rl
a
m
F
�
N
3
�
+
0
N
w
C
��
C
i a
.^
3
0
m=
O `�
z
�
�r
G ti
� N
O
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
ovio �n
0000^
v_ w v�
� 69 4H H3
�
CiJ
� �
� L.
F �
� �
W �
R ¢
c� o
tC R
F F
ti
C.
G
.�
Q 4i
N �
W �
O
�¢
� �
F F
0
0
0
a
F/3
�
�
U
R h a
E'�a
U �
� � K
'o� �
6�N O
io-sos
C
s
SUSPENSION ITEM
7/21/10
L
Presented by
Council File # 10-809
Green Sheet # 3116046
RESOLUTION
SAINT P,�(UL, MINNESOTA
WHEREAS, the settlement set forth in the Settlement Agreement and Release, attached and incorporated
hereto as E�ibit "A", will result in a fixll, final and complete settlement and release of the legal action
commenced in Ramsey County District Court, entitled Town and Counhy Club of St. Paul, Minnesota, and
State of Minnesota by Town and Counhy Club of St. Paul, Minnesota vs. City of Saint Paul, Civil Court
File No. 62-CV-10-5553; and
The Council having considered the same;
9 BE IT RESOLVED, that the proper City officers are hereby authorized and directed to take a11 actions
10 necessary to execute and file the appropriate settlement documents, attached and incorporated hereto as
11 Exhibit "A".
Requested by Department of:
Adoprion Certified by Counci Secretary
By� �' �n
Approve M or: ate �� 7/D/C)
BY� Z-e`�—�
By:
Approved by the Office of Financial Services
By: �
Approve y ity Att �
B n
Appro e y Mayor for Submission to Council
By: