10-800Amended 7l21l2010
City of St. Paul COiJNCIL FILE NO. 10-800
/,
RESOLUTION RATIFYING ASSESSMENT By C
Pile No. SEE BELOW ��
Assessment No. SEE BELOW
Voting
Wazd In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for
J1003V (108865) towing of abandoned vehicles from private properties during December, 2009.
A public hearing having been had upon the assessment for the above improvement, and said assessment
having been fiirtl�er considered by the Council, and having been considered finally satisfactory, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That the said assessment be and the same is hereby in all respects ratified.
RESOLVED FURTHER, That the said assessment be and it is hereby determined to be payable in One
equal installment.
Bostrom
Car[er
✓
✓
Requested� e f: Finan ervices
��
�_--
Stark
Thune
Adopted by Council: Date ��
Adoption Certified by Counc' Secretary
By:
Approve ayor Date t 7 1 Q
B ���,.�o �. �.e���
Approved by the Office F' Se s
By: NA
Approved by Ciry Attom y
BY� �l ��4� `✓ /� ��L��l�v/
Approved by a or bmission to Council
By:
/ '//
July 21, 2010 City Council Action Minutes
Page 12
62. Resolution Ratifying Assessment — 10-500 — In the matter of the assessment of
benefits, cost, and expenses for towing abandoned vehicles from private properties
in December 2009. [J1003V} (GS 3112156-Ward 7) (Legislative Hearing Officer
recommends the following:
660 Burlin�ton Road — approve the assessment
1054 Forest Street — approve the assessment;
691 Oranee Avenue — recommendation is forthcoming; approve the assessment;
and 782 Rose Avenue East — approve the assessment.)
Adopted as amended Yeas — S Nays — �
io-soo
City of St. Paul
Office of Financial Services
Real Estate Section
REPORT OF COMPLETION OF ASSESSMENT
COUNCIL FILE NO.
File No. 3EE BELOW
Assessment No. SEE BELOW
Voring
Ward In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for
J1003V (108865) towing of abandoned vehicles from private properties during December, 2009.
To the Council of the City of St� Paul
The Financial Services Real Estate Section hereby reports to the Council the following as a statement of the
expenditures necessarily incurred for and in connection with the making of the above improvement, viz:
Total costs
Pazk Service Fee
Code - Enforcement Service Fee
Rea1 Estate Service Fee
Attorney Fee
$3,602.30
$
$ 500.00
$ 200.00
$ 50.00
TOTAL EXPENDITURES
Charge To
Net Assessment
$4,352.30
$4,352.30
Said Financial Services Real Estate Secrion fiarther reports that it has assessed and levied the total amount as
above ascertained, to-wit: the sum of $4 352.30 upon each and every lot, part or parcel of land deemed benefitted by
the said improvement, and in the case of each lot, part or parcel of land in accordance with the benefits confened
thereon; that the said assessment has been completed, and that hereto attached, identified by the signature of the
Real Estate Manager, and made a part hereof, is the said assessment as completed by said Real Estate Section, which
is herewith submitted to the Council for such action thereon as may be considered proper.
Dated: I�e tate M� ager:
� �- � L J tJ __s ���` ' �j✓-_'
� �. � - 7- � - I 4 �'�! -� 7m�1- /d o-goo
Green Sheef Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheef Green Sheet Green Sheet �
Departrnentlq�cefCouncil: L1ate tnitfated:
FS _FinancialServices Zo�Y2o,o Green Sheet NO: 3'112156
Contact Person & Phone- Denartment Sent To Person Init' 1/D e
Lynn Aqosar y 0 inancialSemees Davefieisou �✓' r (�
266-8851 I ityAttornev I Lisa Ve[h
A55ign Z �pancislServices Ma rMKe11
Must e on C ncil Agenda by (Date): Number 3 or's Office Ma •or/Assistant
7 a F��
Routing 4 oaucil M Erickson
Doe. Type: OTHER (DOESNT FIT ANY O�der 5 i Ckrk Shazi Maore
CATEGORI�
E-Document Required: Y
Uocument Contact: Kim Ranweiler
Contad Phone: 266-8856
Total # of Signature Pages (qip All Locations forSignature�
Acfion Requested:
Set date of public hearing and appzove assmts for towing of abandoned vehicles from private properties during December, 2009. File
No. J1003V
Recommendations: Approve (A) or Reject (R): Personal Serviee Contracts MustMSwer the Following Questions:
Planning Commission t. Has this persoNfirm ever worked under a conUact for this depariment?
CIB Committee Yes No
Civil Service Commission 2. Has ttds peRONfirtn ever been a ciiy employee?
Yes No
3. Dces ihis person/firm possess a skill not nortnally possessed by any
current ci(y empioyee?
Yes No
Explain all yes answers on separete sheet and attach to green sheet.
Initiating Problem, Issues, Opportunity (Whq Wha4 When, Where, Why);
Property owners or renters create a health l�azard at varinus fimes thcoughout the City of Saint Paul wLen their properiy is not kept up.
The City is required by City code to clean up the property and chazge the properiy owner for the clean up.
Advanfages IfApproved:
Cost xecovery progams to recover eacpenses for snmmary abatement, grass cutting, towing of abandoned vehicles, demolitions,
gazbage hauling, tree removal and boatdings-up.
Disadvantages If Approved:
None
Disadvantages If Not Approved:
If Councii does not approve these charges general fund would be required to pay the assessment.
— Fc .°
Total Amount of �4,352.30 ����
Transaction CosURevenue Budgeted:
Funding Source: Activity Number. � fi� �� �py��
Fi 6!
Fircanciallntormation:
(Explain) � S� ����� p .
10 property owners will be notified of the public hearing and charges. e g �
}7H�i
May 20, 2010 9:55 AM Page 1
July 6, 2010 Legislative Hearing Minutes
J 1003 V Towing of abandoned vehicles from private property during December 2009
660 Burlin2ton Road
io-soo
Page 9
The property owner, Joseph McKasy, submitted written testimony which is attached and made a
part of this record.
Mr. Essling stated that orders were issued on December 2, 2009 to remove an unidentified
abandoned vehicle from the property with a compliance date of December 11. The property was re-
inspected on December 15 and was not in compliance. A work order was sent to the St. Paul Police
Department who removed the vehicle on an unspecified date for a total assessment of $268. The
orders were mailed to Marcel DukelJames Cork at 660 Burlington Road and to Mr. McKasy at 1135
Park Avenue in Mahtomedi. There was no returned mail.
Ms. Moermond reviewed Mr. McKasy's testimony and indicated that the assessment went with the
property and recommended approving the assessment.
1054 Forest Street
No show; approve the assessment.
691 Oranee Avenue
Rescheduled to July 20.
782 Rose Avenue East
Mr. Essling stated orders were issued on October 30, 2009 to remove an abandoned vehicle which
appeared inoperable and lacked current tabs, with a compliazice date of November 7. The property
was re-inspected on December 9 and was not in compliance. A work order was sent to the St. Paul
Police Department who removed the vehicle on December 13, 2009 for a total assessment of $436.
He presented a photo of the vehicle and said there were two other complaints coneerning vehicles at
this property; August 2005 and May 2008.
Thomas Ruiz, property owner, stated that he was a painting eontract and used his pick up truek for
storage of his materials. As soon as he received the order, he purchased tabs for his truck and
contended that it was operable at that time, He complained that the inspector was very "mean" and
had threatened to tow the car he was restoring out of his garage. He was replacing the engine in the
truck and had removed it when the truck was towed, He said he did not recover the truck from the
impound lot but contended that it should not have been towed off his property.
Ms. Moermond stated that clearly the vehicle appeared inopesable and by his own submission, it
was inoperable at the time it was towed due to the lack of an engine. Therefore, she recommended
approving the assessment.
��c�� � i�fc�.�..�`� io-soo
�
`�MVi�R�I� � REP�L cSTAT�
June 13, 2020
Office of Financial Services
Att. Ms. Vicky Scheffer
25 West 4�' St. Room 1000
St. Paul, Minn 55102-1660
Re: Assessment #108865.
Dear Ms. SchefiFer:
I have received a proposed assessment against a house which has recently
been taken back from a cancelied contract for deed. The house located at
650 Burlington Road (PID 11-28-22-44-0022) was sold on a contrect in 2007
and the contract was cancelled a few months ago for lack of payments and
failure to pay taxes.
It is now my understanding that the City of St. Paul wishes to add to the cost
of taking back this house and putting it back on the current tax rolls by
assessing $268.08 for removing a car at a time when I did not own the house.
It should be noted that the owner of the house at the time was a man named
Martel Duke that owns other properties in the City of St. Paul and that he
should receive this assessment. The total cost of taking back this house
irtcluding: lack of payments, past due taxes, water bills, repairs, trash hauling
and labor exceeded $20,000. It should be noted that a new contract has
been signed for 660 Burlington with a very decent couple that have two
childre� and exceilent jobs bringing to the neighborhood the stability it
deserves.
1 request that the City Council not allow this assessment against 660
Burlington for problems that occurred under the former ownership.
!oe McKasy
f/ ' ; '!
r'fi� f �!� � �
d
_� .
;
__ _. _ �. .,_ , . . __: � _ -. -.� . ,-_--- - �-
�
�
F
['n
L
S
�R
G
b
W
O
E
¢
M
O �C
h �
O
U 7
d O
y d
W 0.3
�
h �
dq
i
�o 0
�o 0
a �.`-,
o Q
aa
N
d
a
m
d
a
r�
s
La
0
�I
O
N
�
N
n
O
M
0
� �
i i
iN i�.,
'o �
IQ I�
� N � N
I N � N
j� �ti
I� i�
� �
� �
( � o 0 0 0� I
0 0 0 0 0
( ri o o vi o� I
P v� N EP b I
I� � � � 1
I I
I I
I I
I � O O O I
O O O O
I� O'.'. I
I �
� �
{ �
�o o �
I ~ N � I
� �
I I
1 I
I I
� �
� w �
I� = Ix
x
��w¢ � : �;,
� J .5 � w � �
I O'�II a.. e T C I d
� � ¢ � ° � �F
a v� a�i � *,
�Qq�6 . �:
�gz`�' �3z
�rv"�' O �N°�'O
�V �C���
z��� ��y�
��yz�z� �"'z7�
�z0 �
I 3 '�� �3
� F ( F � ( Z -
I°�z- I°�z-
I Z` c �Ovw I zeow
��ti�vs ���
I� O� O V O O
�me.q. �r
� �
� {
� �
{ a { �
� �z oi �z o
� �O o� �O o
V •r � � I N O V �
I � �^/ � M I � �h �� l �
I U ? j� �J O IQ C O
�� ¢ a w ��� �
C7 x°' •� �°° G a� A^�' �°�
I aP'i ..`@G a 0 � `� c I � a� o m� m c
� ��'��3a��s�x` �
I�°�..�� 1�=�a °3a
G
a
.�
� a
0
.�
m
�
L
P.
s.
0
F
>
A
0
?
9
c
�
3
s�
F�
0
z
N
j�
i
i
lo
i�
IN
I
N
IN
��
I N
�
I � o C o x
0 0 0 0 0
( M O O vi m
? Vt N EA �
I � 43 4> Vl
G4 �H
I
I
1
I 00 O O O
O O O O
I cn O - -•
V N
�
�
�
�o 0 0 0
I .-i .Y N i/1
�
�
I
I
� �
I W
�� �
U y �.
I � N 9
�j w � �
° °� u,
I a E .td a,
� c
I m .. � o
i6Q�Q
N
I4 h� ° 1 F
F
OO
�o�o
O _
q°ox
lQO�a
�
�wez..
I<ZX
��
I
F
I ma¢v.
{
�
�
i
� < F
N �
I ^ � [�
I � � � W
�� ^�inv�i �i
�a3
La Lz�O
�'
t�3 i w � Vl
Ive�°��
iF
N
m
a
F
N
3
O
:
0
N
M
O
m�
C
9 '
�2 C
3a
�
z
,�
F�
° z
V
�_
i
i�
io
I�
�
I N
I N
IN
I
l oo 0 0 o w
0 0 0 0 0
I M O O�n ca
P �n N v? V'
I � � � �
I
I
I
` W O O O
O O O O
I� O � �.
I
�
�
�o o
I ,-. .-. O v�
I
I
I
�
� �
W
�o �
U � �
I'�
-� w Q „
�> .� � w
I � ¢ W c
a
� m .. A o
��4Qw�'4
I
��
��
I �
IO
��
Iq
��
�>
��
�
{
�
I w
I ;
i �
� Nx
I '' ^ H
N W
I 0 � > � H
�U o�v �
I��=z�
.c U '1"i �
I O � T � !T
� � T� � �
I�x���
%
N
ro
a
F
ro
3
O
.
0
m
w
0
�
� m
C
� 9
��
3a
.'
a
3
x D
h�
° z
�
¢
m
. �
�
�
��
�
��
��
v
I�
JN
I N
IN
�
�
I m o 0 0
o c o 0
I M O O �n
d Vl N lH
I � V3 6A
I
I
I
I 00 O O O
O O O O
� � G .� r.
I�'
�
{
�
I �• -• O v�
�
�
I
�
I N
L-.
�o �
I � N �O
� „wQ °�'
> .5 � c,,
�
I c � W c
� ¢ m o
�2Qaia'
�
�
IV
� w
z
I°
�Q
��=
IyF
�
i�0
` o
�
�
�
I
I
I
I h
0
W
Vi
4
N
�
�
F
ro
c
O
*>
0
d F o
� ^ � �
i °� M
f G » V� w
� U in t/j o
I�.N�� �
I � � G
N �' � In b '6
Ic�aN��
IQ��� 3a
io-soo
0
m
'm '
WO
° z
h
jc
0. V
: a
N
�
0.
F
['n
Y
Y
W
�
�
b
�
O
A
Q
O
O at
r t'
O
N
d O
Y d
a �i
i
y R
;a
a o
a'
.c ��^.
za
c
d
d
d
G
s
>
i
ti
°
a
0.
O
ti
N
ti
�
0
M
0
i .
IO
f�
f o
�
f�
� N
IN
��
�
i
j� o 0 0 �
O O O O O
I� � N � V
I il3 fF. i5 �
�
I
I
�
I co 0 0 0
O O O O
I� O ....
I
I
�
I O O O O
I ..'. N in
�
I
I
I
{
� w
�� C
� � w d �
I> � ��,
❑ �
� v b W ❑
� ¢ � o
�d Q r4 Q
L
L
�
�
�
U
�
m
I
I O �
l
Iqo
��Q
z
�a
��o
I �F
��S
I ti F rv
I
I
I
I
I
I �
I °
� p
I O F V'
I 9 O .^ z
I 3� ��
� �d3a
V U h �
I�>�a
a
u
d
s.
R
L
iF
3F
N
A
F'
�
3
Q
»
W
w o
� N
W h
V �
z o
� �
��m
�
.���
� � �
�3a
at • �
N
�
c
0
�
F Q
O
�
�o
�
�
�
i�
lo
��
��
I N
f �`
N
��
� N
I
1
I MCOO M
� O O O �
O O v� V^
� L. h N :A �n
I M 69 Vj CY
69 fA
I
I
�
I�? O O O
I �O � .-. .-Y
I"'
I
�
I O O O O
I� � N �
�
I
I
I
I *
I N �tl
w a.
I� a m
� y a�i 'a �
� °' c d �
> ... Y w ;,
�� 9 W c 3
6
I N r, A p �
I� Q � Q it
I
�
I�
�a
�a
IO
��
Iy
��
I9
�a
I
I
I
I
I
I
I O
I �° W N
M
I � W V1
N .,�
� r
O �
I 3 � v1 � O
`�4�p �
i�o�a4%
� � � � N Yd n
s
IH��� *.
X
x p
3
m
a
f Q
z
h
a�
3
�
f�
lo
t �°
�
' M
� N
IN
��
M
� oo 0 0 o co
O O O O O
I O� O O vl M
O �n N J3 O�
I th 49 V3 M
Ff3 EA
I
I
�
�O O O O
` oo O � ..
O v�
I M
I
1
I O O O O
I .� .� O V�
I
I
I
I *
3F
#
I d
I w N
IN G
F
I y N '��J' '�
I, w � � �
� o b „ � 3
� � d � o �
�
I Q Q .�4 Q iF
l
Io
I F.
��
�o
�Q
�<
Ig
��
�Q
I
I
I
I
I
I W
I ^ O
� � o
� � N
I d � .�
I ^' � �
I N J�� O O
�� �x
I c� c� � Ft � �
IW�^�a
� v � c' � O �
y � o � c
I.M'
�
y
�
�
F
° z
m
a
6�. b
3
'
I�
I�
I°
I,�
` M
N
f °'
N
iti
�~
I
I M O � O M
� O O O M
I 'V O O v� �'
�n vt N 69 rn
I N � 6? t��
V3 69
I
I
�
� M O O O
M O O O
I Vl � -. .�
I
I
I
I O O O O
I .-Y .-i N Vl
I
I
I
{ �
i
I N cC
[.. � � N �
� "' � -p 'p
I � w d m �
> _ � �
� 0 9 � � 3
�c`t� E O
.a /� �y O x
I � H �+ Q f
I�
�3a
I�,�
�w�
�y-'
I�O
IO�
Iq p z
�<�
I V O
� w
I �ow
I
I
I
I
I
I w o
�> o
N
i � °� z �^
Y N O �
I � � M
I L Q v� EI O
�U ° � � N `�
�
�
I �3���'�
���a�3a
�F-�ninx a .
8
z
v
a
F�
° z
y
J �
io-soo
10-800
�
d
F
F
4
d
a
�
�
b
�
0
e
¢
�
o�
ti=
0
V �
d O
L d
aa
v
" R
L Q
�o 0
q O
.n w
c� a
m
�
v
a
L
�
`>
0
s.
a
.�-�
°_
a
a
�
0
a
N
C?
h
°
I
i�
io
(�
l�
I N
1�
N
��
{ ~
��
� �o 00 �
0 o c o 0
I M O O �/+ �
N v� N 6s C�
1 m f :A m
� �
I
�
�
l oo 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
I N O -, -.
I"'
I
I
l0000
�-_o�;
I
I
I
I
I �
� w
�m °
�
�F � a
� � � � N
' G � w
a �
�b v� v
q W a
� � � a
�¢Qa�'4
I `' =
�F
I a O
F
� � � �
I�°�
3 -
{¢Ga
O
�¢O�
^' F
�zE
i�a
�
�
�
L
.�
� «
c
0
V
�
..
0
'C
A
a.
d
T
�
�
E-�
m
V
3
O
:
N
Q
�
�
, �
F x
° z
w
a�
3
� �
� W
I [r o
i �z �
m ry
� O � �
�
� � M
y M �
I � v� � O
I��z3 �
m a� � '� M
�>3�M�9
�°�
Ix..�� .>
i
E"�
i
C
i
I
I�
f�
I
c5
� N
� N
IN
I�
, N
I
I w o 0 o co
0 0 0 0 0
I^ O O v� c0
� N FA c0
O FA Yi O
1 ^.°
�� �
�
�
� oo 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
I � O .. .-
I°
I
!
l0000
�__
I
I
1 *
:F
I �
I w �
�m ° �
� s v v� �
� � 4Li Q �
� L' N �
�a a W � G
� a d _ O
m R y o �
.n v� m
Id Q C4 d i
I F
I Q � �
�qZ�
I��
l y ��
F� E,
� ' 4 �
J
�
�w�
lu°¢
IaF
o��
����x
�QOO�
�mF.ia
�
�
�
� �
�
� � W o
I � � N
I N � �
V � F�I `
I a � e� �.,
Vl /
I N p7 �/-r C'� W
�r'"� � �
� y � W � �
a N = �
C
��Fq o� m C
I�a3�
x
a
z
�
� 6
O
�
w�
a$
0 0 0 0
M O O O
N O O O
O O O v�
�O � N� E/3
�
�
w
� �
� � ¢
a� W
, C N
R
b � W
� � ...
m� A
Q Q �r
a�+ Y Y
F- E- �°-
W
N
�
Q
Y
F
0
M
�
t?
v
us
N
V
L
V �
C ` ^ m, R"
Fm�
U S G
� � YE
. o a W
P.°o