Loading...
10-536AMENDED 5/19/2010 City of St. Paul COIJNCIL FILE NO. 10-536 RESOLUTION RATIFYING ASSESSMENT B � File No. SEE BELOW Assessment No. SEE BELOW Voting Ward In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for VB1001 (108822) collection of delinquent vacant building fees re-invoiced. s� A public hearing having been had upon the assessment for the above improvement, and said assessment having been fiuther considered by the Council, and having been considered finally satisfactory, therefare, be it RESOLVED, That the said assessment be and the same is hereby in all respects ratified. RESOLVED FURTHER, That the said assessment be and it is hereby determined to be payable in One equal installment. Yeas Bostrom 1/ Carter �/ Helgen � Lantry ,/ Stazk Thune I ✓ S Absent Adopte Date: � Certifie By: ,/ Mayor: � y ihe Council ��/9�adrd City of St. Paul Real Estate Division Department of Public Works REPORT OF COMPLETION OF ASSESSMENT COUNCIL FILE NO. io-536 File No. SEE BELO W Assessment No. SEE BELOW Voting Wazd In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for VB1001 (108822) collection of delinquent vacant building fees re-invoiced. To the Council of the City of St. Paul The Valuation and Assessment Engineer hereby reports to the Council the following as a statement of the expenditures necessarily incurred for and in connection with the making of the above improvement, viz: Total costs Water Dept Service Fee DSI Administration Fee Code - Enfarcement Service Fee Real Estate Service Fee TOTAL EXPENDITURES Charge To Net Assessment $ 90,250.00 $ $ 10,465.00 $ $ 1,820.00 $102,535.00 $102,535.00 Said V aluation and Assessment Engineer fin•tl�er reports that he has assessed and levied the total amount as above ascertained, to-wit: the sum of $102,535.Od upon each and every lot, part or parcel of land deemed benefitted by the said improvement, and in the case of each lot, part or pazcel of land in accordance with the benefits conferred thereon; that the said assessment has been completed, and that hereto attached, identified by the sigiature ofthe said Valuation and Assessment Engineer, and made a part hereof, is the said assessment as completed by him, and which is herewith submitted to the Council for such action thereon as may be considered proper. Dated: � al ti n Assessment Engineer: � J�� /U �'x� a�-„`� May 19, 2010 City Council Action Minutes Page 11 51. Resolution Ratifying Assessment — 10-536 — In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost, and expenses for collection of delinquent vacant building fees re- invoiced [VB1001] (GS 3099796) (Legislative Hearing Officer recommends the following: 435 Banfil Street — approve the assessment; 49 Dale Street North — delete the assessment; 288 Forbes Avenue — delete the assessment; 99� Hazelwood Street — delete the assessment; 1023 Jessie Street— 3pnr{,�-e *_'�= ,.___.__,,._., :; referred back to the June I Le�islative Hearin� and June 16 public hearing; 1126 Jessie Street — approve the assessment; 712 Ma�nolia Avenue East — delete the assessment; 1067 Oxford Street North — delete the assessment; 575 Park Street— delete the assessment; 702 Preble Street — recommendation is forthcoming; approve the assessment; 1246 Rice Street — delete the assessment; 642 Thomas Avenue — approve the assessment; 669 Winslow Avenue — recommendation is forthcoming; approve the assessment: 1406 White Bear Avenue North —°�^��°° *'�° °°°°°^--�°��; laid over to June16; and 877 Woodbrid�e Street — approve the assessment.) Adopted as amended Yeas — 5 Nays — 0 � � � �' �! � l V � � ' �— t �" l D 10-536 � Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Greer► Sheet Green Sheet � Departmen00ffice/Council: Date lnitiated: FS — �nancial Services 23 FEB 2010 Green Sheet NO: 3099796 Contact Person & Ph e: DeoarhneM SeM 7o Person InitiaVDate Lynn Moser � 0 maocial ServSces L an Moser 266-8851 1 000ttl M Erickson Assign Z ' Clerk Ci Clerk Must B on Councii Agenda by (Date): Number . 5 / 1 �f� For Routing Doc. T OTHER (DOESNT FiT ANY Order �� CATEGOR`n " EAocumentRequi�ed: Y � DocumentContaM: wmRanweiler CuttWct Phone: 266-8856 ToW! # of Signature Pages _(Clip AII Locations for Signature) Action RequesMd: Set date of public hearing and approve assessments for delinquent vacant building fees re-invoiced File No. VB I0� I Recommendalions: Approve (A) or Reject (R): Personal Service Contracts Must Answer the Following QuesBons: Planning Commission 1. Has this persoNfirm ever xrorked under a coatract fot this departrnent? ,. CIB Committee Yes No Civil Service Commission 2. Has this peronlfifin ever been a city empioyee? Yes No 3. Does this person/firm possess a skill not normally possessed by any curtent city employee? Yes No Explain all yes answers on separate sheet aad attach to green shee4 IniHating Problem, lssues, Opportunity {Whn, What, 4Yhen, Where, Why): � Pmperty ownecs must register vacant and unoccupied structures with the Depamnent of Safety and Inspection and pay an aimual vacant building fee. Advanpges If Approved: Collection of delinquent vacant building fees. Disadvantages H Approved: Noae Disadvanffiges If Not Approved: The general fund would be required to pay the assessment. Total Amount of Transaction: $�02,535.00 Cost/Revenue,BUdgefed: Funtling Source: Activiry Number: PinanciallnformaGon: (Explain) 91 property owners will be notifted of the pubiic hearing and charges. February 23, 2010 1025 AM Paqe 1 10-536 May 4, 2010 Legislative Hearing Minutes Page 6 4. Summary Abatement Assessments: VB1001 Collection of delinquent vacant building fees re-invoiced in December 2009 435 Banfil Street (VB1001) Mr. Yannarelly stated that the building was condemned by Fire C of O on October 21, 2009 with 22 items being noted on the deficiency list. The properiy was referred to the Vacant Building Program and a file was opened on November 5, 2009 as a category 2 vacant building. On November 5, 2004, a registration letter was sent to pay the 2004 vacant building fees and when the owner failed to pay, a warning letter was sent on December 7, 2009. The total cost of the assessment was $1,070. David R. Busch, DRB #24 LLC, property owner, and Michael Kemp, appeared. Mr. Busch stated that the city had illegally removed the tenants and he did not believe the property should be a vacant building; therefore, he objected to the vacant building fee. Ms. Moermond stated that the building was vacant, the fee was due, and she recommended approving the assessment. 49 Dale Street North (VB1001) DSI recommended deleting the assessment. 288 Forbes Avenue (VB1001) DSI recommended deleting the assessment. 445 Hazelwood Street (VB1001) DSI recommended delering the assessment. 1023 Jessie Street (VB1001) No one appeared; Ms. Moermond recommended approving the assessment. 1126 Jessie Street (VB1001) No one appeazed; Ms. Moermond recommended approving the assessment. 712 Magnolia Avenue East (VB1001) DSI recommended deleting the assessment. 1Q67 Oxford Street North (VB1001) DSI recommended deleting the assessment. May 4, 2010 Legislative Hearing Minutes 1246 Rice Street (VB1001) D5I recommended deleting the assessment. 642 Thomas Avenue (VB1001) No one appeared; Ms. Maermond recommended approving the assessment. 1406 White Bear Avenue North (VB1001) 10-536 Fage 7 Mr. Yannarelly stated that a category 1 commercial vacant building which file was opened on July 30, 2008 with the business formerly being Sojourner's Cafe. He noted that there had been three extensions of time granted on payment of the vacant building fee in order for the owner to obtain the C of O: August 7, 2009 — a 60 day waiver; October 8, 2004 — another 60 day waiver; and December 8, 2009 — a 30 day waiver. To date, the property still did not have a current C of O. The vacant building fee was in the total amount of $1,070. Chik Chikles appeazed and stated that the church, Calvazy Chapel, owned the coffee shop. He said the intent was to remodel the coffee shop within six months which now had turned into three and one-half years. He said they did have active building permits and had focused on opening the coffee shop first and then working on the apartment upstairs. They then decided ta complete the repairs to the entire building and had active building permits. He acknowledged that they had been given extensions on the vacant building fee so they could complete the work and had a plumber scheduled to do work at the property the following Monday. He believed the building should not be in the vacant building program as the church did not have the money and claimed that they were "framed" which he believed had been because he had missed an inspection appointment. Mr. Essling stated that according to STAMP, there was a complaint that work was being done without a permit which is likely why it was referred to the Vacant Building Program. He said that there were active permits which had been kept open from 2607. Ms. Moermond stated that the building was a vacant building, extensions had been granted on paying the fee to get the work done and the work still bad not been completed. She recommended approving the assessment. 877 Woodbridee Street (VB1001) No one appeared; Ms. Moermond recommended approving the assessment. �� - 5� May 18, 2010 Legisiative Hearing Minutes Page 13 Laid over Summary Abatement Assessments: VB1001 Collection of delinquent vacant building fees re-invoiced in December 2009 702 Preble Street Rescheduled from May 4. No one appeared; Ms. Moermond recommended approving the assessment. 669 Winslow Avenue Rescheduled from May 4. No one appeared; Ms. Moermond recommended approving the assessment. � u �� F F L y eo w � R � � i � 0 1 �-S a � O � RI O i � � U � V V ; �a a Y i� N =q � e c � O - w m ��-, x' A �a d E a� e d m > 0 a � Q1 Y O O N � i N � m � d � � O � M N � N ti C � O O O � d o d � � � O f} EA � O O j O O — O O N N � �' � � m�� a k. �c t v b �E `� � � 'm � >cax `n� Jj m �o 3^ i� O C= �3 `-w 0 N N � � m `v 3 O « O P O o � � F � r /� ` � ' � O �y hZu. � '# a - � '� � 07 'O ' ''QOa� m v a ci a v� : 3 n�. d � m � O z H J ^ . o b O � V !�] � N w� O O O O O d d o 0 O vi N N O H V3 O EH R9 8 O O 0 0 p _: _: 0 O O O � O C Vl N U v u" w G m„ E L � a cu-4 � c w � � � W m ¢ > p C w N N � F � L O `� g �l � �O ❑� <o m� z m 4J z �" mo G� � � 3hh � � U 4 0 � Q c o 0 � a � O o v`?U � ll : N � 9 � Q ¢ � � 3�N p C W ma'��O a c a 7 = R,99 ° °i w ro c � � T v� c� vJ . w . a � m " o `` z ti 6 F V 0 O � N t7 N � � O O S S 9 o d d d O v� N [� O di �/J O V3 V1 8oS o � � ° o O O O O O O r O O vl N Y � w �,�', c � E C N 'O v c*.Q � G m c] E � �¢w R >Qa �. OY� F� Z°'y xr� J�� nmm 3°� z�� Yv� � " x 'o � �u L=F� x,�¢� i rv 6 Q `s T 4 � m C O . P � m� O` z N u d d * o vq o d � � O v1 � d N � N R] F � `, _. r � m `o v ,.a �V ���m cL r� 9 a a 9 =a°�3a o�n3,. » N O Q N1 N � � O S S O S 6 o d o O v� fv t� O Ni f/3 O W Vi o o ° o, c y 0 O O O � � N N °� �'- a = m �dv ov.Q L d ' '- :a � y W > Q a Z'� np 7 0 �< `y ¢O no � b� �j� y ¢� ' 4 �-'t + T 6 F m N O _ a w > O'� z y W � J 0. 0 � C N N N a � � .- z v� �: a �n � O a � z v m �*'"n� c , y �,�_ ?b e�py P ro � Y<<n° � O � N� W N � O O O O O O O d d d d O � s O � � ° o o ° o o.- - O O O O C O �n N 10-536 m T �+ c:,' a ¢, c � m � U O C �a [.Q w � C U m 9 � 3 m "' O . >oa : ^3��0 a ��rv� sE ..g o ,-,o, _ O m S�Cdw t � N pQ_l0 ��� o� maao_ z ����F� m y0Ur0_ m �..[ jv y ��z ¢ �m aY� U N F- 3wo�o� o "T O �� O m � � °o Fj � N O � q � ^� TN � 3 � ; -�- N o a v N i < o mt�� Z � F ¢ N � g ... Z' v b e'N� M q C c�:�p": � � Q� � V �I m G N , N � � d � I I � F � � � C R , � � I rv � P I ^ E � e" � i O it 07 O � e ' o u ¢`4 •; a _! a` � o �.7 � i p L M U v� r x •w �a i £ � b � N _; a { d m ` F � ! � o � 4 L � I ^ ' o N t7 C� r � O f 1 1N O � � � Ot] N r O �J O O O 7 O O O � h N [� � N3 Vi O A tA � O O ? � � � � ° o ° o, � O O �n N � '� i G op � F � u o D � Q c e� � y E 5 �d� � Q �i _� d CQM c3Y � '>u� � � F .� � � L� =x� . .3z �Wf ` v � '� F v c i 3 0 : . � m� o' z � �� C ^ i N 0 c�v v w ' o '^ o �Q � � y � � J tC �� O L O ..T. � m � `� � z N cp �>'0300 ' G � R < ag��3; i t7 O O rif .r N � � O o O O O O O O O Od�� O bi P p O O po _: .: ° c, ° c, o '- O O V� N U N � u. � � E C N 'U 'O S1 Q m E � < �-' �� � > O u; a`= �� � ` L - = =°x �j� x3�' z J�� i `v � a � F 9 N c 3 Q 0 � o N � w C� tr7 � � U � � � C . � d � � � N � � � Q G 9 m � y � � 9 N C <�NU,� 3; a �� z ti �^ 4 P � N � � O � t5 W � O O O O O O� O O O 069 � O FA 69 ° o, ° o ° o S ^•_ o O o - C O N N N � 4 c. 5 a+ 6 � v a 'O 4+ Q p E � � Q � , Q �: - o �F� 2 � � �'03 ��+0 Y�� n3S ��Oo C � � j N N n m z< 3ta¢� � O O N � � O i m 3 � - o �F� T � � �'03 ��O u0� w3° o� �OQ N � n p rhz` UQF 3Wa� 0 0 Nj � =j a [1 ¢ � .. 4 � 4 O a O c�J 4 � C O � � L E,��N �0 .� � XQ ^0 ° �C o p 1 P 1 4 9 � N T� U O N!/J8 y . ��.,3..'�: P o� z N � a 1 n a . � M O tsl t W � O O �J o O O O p O O O O �n N � O 69 (A O EA Fl3 O O O 0 0 0 o �-- O O O - O O v� N N ` s. = tp v F C y �` 9 W Q c e� � E � ; >oc z F m N � � z��+ 4 �� 4 a ° o N.oC N �0 oz QU . 9 VO�c w � R � F - 9 a ra � 3 Q g o c v� v% N y F c� Y m o N � N'�'3�nC� � C � z � 4 a. ��.. .��L+ �" O (n V] N ll� N W a. �X = . .n '> � 'a -c C O� 'U ... �`y C � � � � N � 0. c m> o `' < �� 6 O • o 10-536 � � � G 1 t v = f � � h M � OL � ` � N �o � �Q c5 � N � O � F I F �I t�L W G � N � 0 j E � I a O � � � � 3 U � o o ° o c G O C O O V1 N h o vi cs o 69 69 ° o,00 ° o � 0 O O O y � N O � y I Q� d `L i I t [i C �.a+, ' c v v « s 'v W Q '� Q ` m E � � s c Q L] ° x � 7 Q � d d � E of % F�� m o`�� N � d a�h N� V p�� d ��� e ;<_ C, �`�=o � Q V z � y m � 033 y = mox� a ot-m i O N � M N 3 N � � 1F T � q m c � � e M P S c O` Z m Q � m �a .$ 0 h N i � W N f � � I o Q � ¢ N � o o d 3�a"' m z m � � E � m���3 � � (n i� F � � e� � �` W N � O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O v�i N � o a va o V3 K 0 0 0 0 0 0 ° a O O O -- o 0 h N N V [Y •L c c "�' v - 6 � Q •� .0 � m¢ � [� m > 0 d ¢[ �=s �z Q C��' ,. C 7��� 0. � N 0 yj0 Naz� � 3�=z �oo< Fa°r Y T d F � � � � _ O Z m m N c_° 0 0 P � m N N F c+ � � � T m r� � •t• O b z 6 m OY `� W V � C N � oF_ r�i>v � E ° o m h `� m �° ti v 0 � � � '� 7 � ° o o ° o � o 0 0 � � FH O R 69 � o 0 'oo > O O - o 0 U Y � L C m �E C V V O L4 Q ' c o� fl F. i C� a W N VI N Ya� a m 5 F- �s � ]� 3 . Fy. � z �O .v >'T Jy ie� ♦ T X F N v` 3 O F = Z m � ao � o � `� O � 4 N � a a � - j y x v m Q V o - ,� � °', y a�'j `^ ^o C ; . - ��,Ziv '�� � (� � C �o�e G �n » + w r. � Q 0 � N OC d .-i 0 o Q 0 0 o c o �n N t� v3 v3 0 �v O O O O S - o 0 v� N L N � 1. C m E � a�i 9 aa.Q ' c e> � E � � 4=u n v� m raa � ;< i � "n v � ..1 i Z �� L y �o � f � �o � I� 00 �� � g ° o o g 0 0 0 0 O H N I� o ss ss o sv v3 O O O 0 0 0 o � 0 p O O - o 0 w N 6 � v m c 3 O N N � LL. G m � � 0 9 v�+.d � C m E � Q a v � Q � ♦ ♦ T 6 F c 3 O � b t ' � o "' n � � ,,°, r , z m � o w > a- o s= m g N Q �Y ¢ J� �m J� G� �'P 6N SF — o �9 0 � � � o � � � O l N !� Q ��`1 _ y fn � � c V�v�i0. .�- m '� .. Q o � p o x ��=5"' o J U > '^ _ G O G v� E C 3 a. -� R7w w w 0 r O y � N o � N a � c o - O � h F o a � v��r� � � � 3 � O p � 'V � m `� c -c= i-� �n h a x �. 10-536 ¢ I � 2 m � a � C. _ ^.� � O t� � W � ) i ' o O o O O O O O E„ O O O O � �n �n N N F � � � � i u m a � e a ' � o 0 0 0 0 0 � �� o ... ... N N � O I � ty � � O O O O O Q � O O �h N � O � W D � � . •• o : � d d � d � y L 6 N Is, c � . m '_ c i '� 'o ., ia b[..q c m � ❑ V '� .0 d � j 'W E N e I ° � � cQ�s1 p sw m >o� : R C '� � y i V lv a _ + e F . u - � � > c o a '' w a � ~ o — v a 6 4 3 ' O �, N � x M F N L N i = O O O ^ �1 W ry � � F' = � y p � h O o E z � � U 9 c � ° � . 3 c � v� O Z y w a " N O 'V� !rl N N : O O O O O O O O O N N I� F9 69 O Vf 0 0 0 0 j O O � N k N N � [L 6 C { � � E' °' E c L W u a Y ' 3 < w O N v � � � � p i' L � �ON s i � j¢[- G 0 � Z �rvC � N W U�F O h O � c! N F+ \ C O h � c �n v'�i O o � o � z ry m V y 4 C � � U �o :o �`-e '- .o v`� . . . �� o '�' Z N u c � n 0 C � N a N O � �t O O O O O O C O O v) N I� O W W O � �A o ° o, o o y O O O O � C C h N iF N L N v LL R � G F no � n � a � 9 w Q � e � � b y 3 Q ? Q � O �O � O � OK N �' �zo .a ¢ z �Om � .� �- y00 ti�a 3¢� N Q M p � N j Q (� h � �>zN w m ¢ � ` � v F U ,� O � G C .-T. � G � 9 Z x `!� c _ � � �rov�. �x m� o' y �r � P � 0 � R N N � N O� � O C O O O O O O O �n N i� O fA fA O i9 69 0 0 0 ° o � O Q O O � N i y N w X 4 c F m c v � � 9v-4 � C y (9 F. � C c ¢t'�.l � >oz = � � F Z V � F�-4 o� z o .'�i F< oQ- ��y r a m G C G � 0. Fr-b V� N �l O L3� N C a O � '� 4�3 ° � � ��lv' �p r� ��.�b s9; � � � � � c > o' Z W �-" m �l p � O , r � � N N d N C O O � O O O O O O O O O VI N h O Vi fn O V3 V3 0 0 0 0 0 0 ° o O 9 O O -- O O ♦ i U � [i o. F � � '� F 4 Q � C y R b �' 3 a� o h � � � 6�. f J � ~� � � SSS !Y� Q � � ��a yo0 yz� w a��' 003� V�� � f � F�- �00 0 � O O V O � � N h � \ ��h� c_ o 'o z z � �Z c � 4 in pr.,p ;;�.�m�9 w e ���w 3n .�• w " o` U ` ' o 10-536 E �I 0 V c v H d OD L F v � � i' W � a d � � N N d N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 S o d d O a�9 � O f5 +A � O O _p O O O O � N p � '� t � O i � R O O O I, Q — O O N N O � m O i '� p � o � U y �O � Y � QI d � w = u c �+ E � � .. w oG. E `� Q " GA E � pq O O i � � ,� ¢ w i m�' "' >Q� xw i d� � �- � ZO j O LL i y O N i d c 60 v - v� i d � J � > � m 3� E z°o u u � O m. � 6� � i a U�� 0 N � e� N N � h a F C w N 3 O i O � � O M ^1 d F � z �� � C N � v�l lJ � CC c n V.-7 �3C� ao � a 61 .. C N c�iG�C� �v 9 G � N � � � G �L�...N. N � o z � h w o ° N r O O v N � N N ° o ° o 0 � � o EA O O O O O O O O O O v1 N N a c ri Q c u E u 9 � 4 � v A � �� � m 3 E- �O n; ¢ oz fm U- F� �orv N w m c � C 3 O F ° z y �� C n � O a � ,,, m mo¢ � � M 4 r U O e� a`c c ��'a"o � G � � � ���3a � r .r � a N T N � N ° o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O v� N � O Ni fA O bS 43 O O O O O O O O O O O N � w n. = � d a v_' w Q O P 3 c� Q W > Q 5 DY �. � � a � � � � 6� O °' �y 00 �� � U Z �i i� F w A N � � C c 3 O O [� w O m � �L'� N � a�do¢ - r. �^L'1 =� O QviC7 O � � a � � � � � � L � t� 1 � :3� �o rn� . . C1 z = h m m am M r 0 O N M N N T N N 0 0 ° o ° o 0 0 0 0 O H N h O &9 69 O 69 43 O O O O O O � � � O O d O O O O — O O vt N Y � w u. � � � 9 v �-Q � E `��° a Q W > Q av' j m g z � 3 c � M N N � F e m C 3 O i S .°� O �" z u < �o d _ a o O � O � � � N � � 4 .� ! v' O � � M �O� c — c U y c �c -x �- a v r W�: 10-536 m V O ti � N � CS N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o � s o =9 V3 O S O O � O O O O � O O h N N � u' u. 5 C � Q o c. m E � Q fi7 >f.�� � Y FO µ}��] 4�� w� ufn a ��m m 5m� � zro ¢ O��o � JFO�n z�z= `s t T a F b m 3 O � � z� h �� �r ' o � N O r � ji o �' N F+ N rrz V a rn a m o � � � � T � ^ W ���'" U o d�avzem eu o �" = 3 � 0 C `S� [Q "'� � F C �Ua�...- �: � N E � 4 y� �o' c m c N � V � a � � F F L O � C { R N � : � W O ! E � 4 0.' � O A� N O 1 � �� � o u i L � Q � y . I u A � � G 'i ' e ° C i '+. u y � a 4 ? � { d i � � ° d Q � v � i y � O � a E a a 0. 0 0 N I � M L ( N � � N f � � 0 'i N N N v 3 O O S » o 0 7 V� N [� 7 +n ss o P. Hi D O O � O O j ... � J � o 0 > o 0 = o 0 �n N * V � � w K s, � m pp F [" C y �p V '] W Q � � C �v 0 E �° c �a�, 3 � � � O > CIA' + -� •L' � � F ^ � N - L N �`+ a _ ��:Ma � h y a � � ;�<�� n� T� v� E,,, O ' C q Z O � m j >+o�U . ?�� �'"'�a A c 7� O� z m y u 6 N x � '�l � N T v � !V J O O O �oo 0 >oa o � y N r � ce cs o 9 Vi J O O j � � ? > o 0 � o 0 - o c �n N F Y j LL 6 4 � �J F = N 9 C > W Ci N - G � 0 E ° c � 'o " 3 �Q� O � � O � � Z � �i O � q > N ¢ f� W 2 y m o .0 � o �qhi.�.�, o ��s�3� � 0 3 ��o�'o '- o o c ° v `� � �U=v�. 3 : . 0 0 � .-� N N N ooS S oaa o O h N �^ osv w o Vt 6'1 O O O O O O O � � O ° o, o0 — o 0 x 1> T � w a C � � E F' C y q � `owQ � c � ^� fi `tl c �Qv O � « >QC 'r h �� O m Qm CO� � F 0 F� t-x ��F z _ �`�`° � °80 4 W ` ❑ h � � N � _ ��� u o UWU� d I � h 1 � � b > n `� a: � � � o � _ b � � � � b � � O + ` v �a T A o q c '�3 m-�g v � a m �Omr�31 Qr,c�.+. v 0 r'. � N N � N O O O O 0 0 0 0 O � c�s O fR f� O O O O O O O O g ° o ° o .- o 0 vt N i � N Q � e ro � � '"g E L :_ O L' � C � w � c a� CI P `� c a � 3 � � � O > Q L� i �wr O O�� ro t- u �a0 ° °z� �c AF:n Q N �� 3°M y ��3 �h0 u aS �. ao Z�E -��m 0 3 ��'n'^ O m O b N ^ ,�, a n _ `� �- _z ,��,��° o y � z � � �N � 4 O � � ��v,:3t � M o �: f� N O� N � N O O O O o�o 0 o�o 0 o�n rv r o sa ss o w f O O O O O O O .- --� O o ° o, ° o, — o 0 � V �+ w a ['' � F �n E 9 L�. Q � � c v m E � c a 3 m � W O > Q C . v�'i 0 y� o g� F m o ^' Q 4y >= .�]M 5Q a_ po : � z J F o �s 10-536 +' C U J �� z N u� �� V ` V F u�s a p `�' � N O T fl — n �� o a � y N F _ yS>vc o L] � _ Q z q v ro i p �n �p m Ct o.o E- a my���9� � v �v m L ���°o: � � i � v =1 � i� t � I � � 0 O � � �� � � � N 1� 1� � N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 �,,, o 0 0 0 ' O �n N t� F O FR 69 O 69 V3 �. m � G W � � S P O N 8 � O � � O O O d y � N O 3! Cl o � « � y o w y �O d+ V a` � � fx, c y R V LL ¢ "d ° " m E L °o ° a g ; C = Q w m y +` m v� a�i p,y '� > L] w' �a d e N T� d �_o a ��� N � � �^ E om� � V Q 0 0 � 0 a zy� E ° v° u h � - v , � � ?�'^X 0. � S d'J R` 0 N n N N R i d 0. '� F m c O N O N a h _ L`] C > - s y v� `� v: �+�>�,� o F } � X � � � � � � � c iNCa � �4Lti:a � �.'va c+. a3a `L Z (n w w + Y � � m � a ,p•°� � m 0 H b O .:.� � N O� N � N g o ° o s�'s s o "v9 O O O O O O O O d � k' �. � m E '' v�'.. Q c e� ��E.� �¢w n v� e 7qa: n m . �= � O �a f °O .� C .k Zy� - � 'o � �s m`, 3�`^ .'�i c 43 : T � F m c O s P [U i O� z h a w_ a� S 00 � o N V� O N N V N zQ = �U� p �:: � � >. Q o �<�o mn �� V 9G^ �a a�3c'. �v,¢. � o 0 0 � o 0 0 7 v N � � 6q Vf O sj F9 � O O _ � � j 7 O O 7 O O y Y�i N U � si � L C N 9 a � 4 ^ � « 9 � � c d w m > Q 5 J Y L y �� � � � SZ r� �� S a. v d F m � O w � �i O '- Z w � a- N : ry 0 N O � N y� N �� — ; > �o� z 'o ��z� b . fl � � N L iF m�E° >=°': 3: .�� r M O ti M N O � � N 0 0 0 0 OO O O O O 69 ss O 69 V3 O O O O O O O O O O O -- O O V v �' 4. y ,c � N '�6 c w C C U m E � �E cv m v� `d >Oa' yX Fm u ` �O �' QO .� � � �6 w �., : T F w � > O w S O z y J � : o 0 m 4o W �= � o m y r E O G TN F (� 3 a Q — � n � o�^� o � z' o � � � a a U N � � [� ��n": 3: a � O e5 N N � N 0 0 o S 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ^ �n N h O Yi fA O v3 ZH O O O O O C O O O O p O O O Y � n, c m � c � Q v a CZ E 8 �¢w m v� u > q a � � O t� oY � Q p " 4Q � -� K Z z E� ♦ i T 6 F � 3 O • N O � � � � � = h¢ ro ¢�- o ^ = z� � < m ��nti � � A q � o a O � p�CQ � `v ��^�. 3: 10-536 P F � � ^ y . a 0 � � � i � � m �� � � � � 2 � � O 0 � v V N N i N i t � o o ° o o �,,, o 0 0 0 F o � � O � V3 v m 4 C R � O O O O— O N O � O � j v�. `� � O O O a � — C C Vl N O � C1 0 � i. � u � � O 'rc V ! � _ G � V. cJ � � nn R � 9 [%. Q '� ` IIi 6w ; m O q m �� p . � m ¢ s:� U s � 7 � C�. ` C �i � I a _i i d Y ` C J m m I U '` � L d � E K V 4 a vi � a � w O �. N i � i M N N i � � V G F C � � 3 O a A m i O` z N ¢ 0. m I ° I � O I N N � M � � � � vi E� C: O N � O � ° � � � ^ o i � .x E . c � � .a � ..1 i :a ��i��e�i I .yaov�9 °3c. N 0 0 N N o� N � N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g C N O O E9 bi O fA Va O O O O O O Q • � - •�- <J O O O -- O O Ni N i N N N � [a. R � c m � ¢ C �o u. A c u m v Y�" , 3 w � � O � � L1' t I 0 N � O �� a b V 3�Y � � �VIVJ O <�<zz n � — � ¢ � � � Y N � � � J L � ^. � � cJ � �N°'° jYa rn:.. P m i O" z m w „� �r . � �oo c '� °N n ? �RfA O A b� J O O 7 C O �.� � 0 0 0 � o 0 � O O V} N N v W y c � y 9 O W Q a E � � Q i p a Z � ]I :40 > J .] a>` ,',�z zON° ���� �Ysm � � Q N L�� � E h N r LS .y �OZ� ♦ N N a F D m `u 3 O ♦ ♦ ce u � O" z Q C� � + o � o N p ,� z � P ;�- N � z� - �z o i G O ° a X �.+ m x m p 1 � �^ t` 'O ' T �O C O � U '' °— u : 3 : r a 0 � N M N O� N � N � o0 0 i o o c J K � O 9 'A � b O J 9 O J � � O S O S Vl N N C F N �O 4 Q c Y E 5 � � � v Q 6�. h od � C� !- O � O� �s H� ♦ i T X F � O ^ o M O � a O .� �; _ m 0�0.°� > h � C Z . ¢ z � O '� ri .� G F � W o V V ' F c ¢v,aSti o V "_ - T � 'V z¢N��3= m > O� z Q � � �o � 0 0 N N O � N r N S ° o ° o ° o 0 0 0 0 O � � O i5 f9 O O O O O O O J O 0 0 o ^ � N V v �' W C CO t v O 'o W Q ° � O E :°. ;a� > Q C Yy Y � E � (� F f� 4 � �W ws X¢� � C � � �QPt C Q �'� s Oa� 10-536 `v � a F N � O R m S O � z N G 0. � N i � 0 h o � 0 � >in�� o ��a'Q � a � 3 ° O = z�,�Po - �Q b0 C V (V � U C U] Q�� GA L C Q ¢ L � N L:7 � V � c a `� � � e e < �� �� � � W� � v s m C � � � Q rl cccyyy p i � � � 3 M C M N J �U N p� .� O� N � N r � r N N y F � a c m N � 0 q � ° o � � P .7 u � d d o C a` a � y Q a � � '.��. G .� u I ' y R C ? �z E , � 4 E i y C u � � V V L � 0 N � N � N ' t r > o o g 0 0 0 > C O G � v� N I� J Ni N3 O 9 � >SS s .. .: > o 0 � O G w N j " � C ]0 V � � � � C 7 �+ Q ry � 0 9 @ 3 3 ¢ U O ' e �%1 a • >oa : �N ?a � i� ' o 0 „� o y N � � N N � � } „ `n�a' o 3 a � F y : '� j !i] l� ep ��a g . � a�v: '" =3a :o� . �. o 0 0 O O G V� N t^ rH Ev o f�9 �A $80 o :' 0 ° o, o ° o � O O A +� T y (L 6 �y c � � U E C y 'p V O [L Q td �� � E � c ¢ 3 u N � � >ax . aY � '] a %h � N � y a o m� 4dM1 O` z �o m � a aF � e , 0 �; z [U ' lv C Z o �� m � N � O � N C � h � 4: rn�y o S � i � F-� r � o � n 9 s� ��� °"' ° �3a >��,. N �_ ° z y � • ry 0 � � � N T � N N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � C O O O vl N 1� o zv vi o Vi V3 O O O o__ 0 o S o •- j N : e� [i R (i C � " 6. 9 L'+Q � C y m''� � � Q 3 � Q � O 4^ dF h� oz < o„ F.m � � `�'�' O �o N �-. � a YZC N W ° o �° i o � �a a o � �:�ha � i �n n. � in C) i. � m � m o >, �v, F � CL A.L � C a, 3 c. 3 �o : 3 °"' =°'3c x��,� . a � u > O` � �„ O � � C � N N O� N � N 0 o O o 0 0 0 0 OO C O O O Vi � C � � O O O �__ 0 0 0 — o 0 V� N a � T ri " 'R` G F C � a � � Li. C � C � @ J 9 � 3 < U O > O C : O Z Z � J C ui .] N � aY zn a U b � 0 a"• °° o o � O d O ° �° � o, m � r' !� __ �Nm � k. + N J = o E o c 4 Q rn o �w ° o U �G u� �H��w�D�o � m a e� ., c N � O [) N TS 'O II] UT l M � G a U=v�iw '�: a o� z ti a � o 0 '' N O ''. � N T � N 0 0 0 0 O O�O O O vi cv t� ov>vs o 69 Vf O O O 0 o__ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 = c o �n N e � N m � c. a p, c o F C ,y p C 'O LL Q � � C N � 9 � � ¢ �� � O >o� . F' O .� h�m C O�" Z3s �o�'. � 7 � � � `�" r. m � � '�z= � � � .$ r �.'lF ¢o c m p V � y ^ _ O � O L'1 '- i y "�'-, 4 0 �,oz� R G E�4� e C� a U'��v a '. r n ° 'n3a N� > o` z y a J q � 10-536 � C i �I n 0 d m a O O _ � N N O � � I N ( ` Io 0 o S E o 0 0 0 ' O �n N h F o ess, o i � 6 ^ u on e e � � o 0 0 ,o � ry d W O I _ � E d O O O O O O 6 � � O O I O � W O { � '_ 3 Y � V � � N L O � e� T -f 0. i"� 0. � �, c R 1 V � F « w v W Q � v' Q V . C d L R � 3 � � C i °° « � 3 c J a W � s�« 7aa o I � � a q y Q � y �� � a zo z� i � 1�0 � > O� � N3� c ti � Z .�i ra of� a O�f- e a a ¢�° I O � O � i � F � i O = � � � � S N y ? � � " � y v' o M �, oz�� �+ N 4 � � a e *'+ � L m b m c � � .D t� G. N +� N � � � Q N [n i + +�i P vx i O z h Q �o 1 a N v T� A v 300 8 �oo 0 J �1 N t� > N3 FA O rt va 7 P O � � � J O O � O O v� N # N !� � � K L F �0 [- � e, b � � L' 4' N � .0 i a ' o 'a 3 Q W . p q � O � o iy >C 3y 6 - j0 ]� �O Y �zm (�h O 3�� O � O P N M a M � n o � _ � E . 4; t � � O i itl c F' b � � � O r � 9 > � S � q y : N � � .�' s � W g O z m � � h O O � N O� � N �SS o 0 0 0 0 o �n cv � O N 3 K O i'i w O O O o � � O O O O - C O Vl N I � I * I � � [`' % C @ � ' F C � � C b LL Q � � C d � E � 3 z m ¢ W O iw in °' I 9 (a K� : Iz�o I�z> =�� I FOa 0 0> ��O p � F @ N � Q H '"n< Q �t 3 FOa 0 N � O � c � n Y � fn ^ n a z � �'v � j q n o,�j, K U y t >O `� C U � r ^� � � 9 .L T v �p h � 'U Ko�.N�+ � � O h � � 0 � O C 7 N O W N g oo 0 00 0 ooa a O ✓� N l� O 4i H C V+ s 0 0 0 0 O O O O O O O � v N Y U T � � � L � a� E F" L y � 'p O G. C� A � .0 N +a � � c e�¢v O � � � y > q C . '�>�, IVy ��n i O �O Z OM'� Fj2 QO� y�o � i � �F� �� �D o � O t W N � O a ��w � �z� ^ �� � W C C N � �O '09 r m � �T E v,�v C w y N m C ,=r:3: e �� O z h W �� . � O C .-i � a N � N �oo 0 0 00 0 ooa o O v] N h O Vi H1 O Yi EF3 ° q 8 ° o 0 O O O O O O O • V N U [y R {y C � F E e a � o Gv. Q y C V � _ � 9 W � 2 7 � K O i i i � � i � P � N O � � O U] 'O � ¢ `- ��o ^ y� � '� 3�r � �3 E a4 �+ m t 'a c F _ c j � C O � U < M � : 3 : t ` � - '^- O � a� 10-536 -< E � < I � � d m a � 0 v 0 0 � N O� N O� N � o 0 o O 0 0 0 0 r o 0 0 0 > O �r1 N t� F o v3 » o ! w s? � � d CO m C I W L O O O O '- N � O ^ W O � � m � O O O I Q _ h N O ik W O I ' � � 0 v u j y __ � `� � � ,� (y N �. 0.� 4i .� f N u R L [E. Q � ! �, .] A �� � � v °° ° C7 c " 3 � 'y V � N¢ W � ' d� d �� � � x• >oa , d� � � E o Y � �`r ( < .�. e p �.. i E - ps d - �o o �� i Q 25 E �� � zP � a� A' G C � v I � s F�. � O L] O : 3 R ; O p � � l�� � ) � Q N I N � O � E � ^ C �_.� M � � � O � E 3z�� m .�'v � �n '� � c � d . z Sfvp N ° lo o�a... � I=aN�,: �, ; o'�' ¢ a. m � N 0 o ^ N N O � N O+ N ° o ° o o ° o C O O O O vs N r O 69 bA O i» w O O O O � � O O p O � � N m m e� w o. [y � N �o 'E F CJ 'O {I^ Qi N � E � °' °a < � O >oa . h �i r� QO Yy� m �4r x�F �a� 6'p� QZ� m N O O M O O F � O h O � } = � � � j p � Y] � "J �'�°�q�� p 1 M � 'O � p a r „ � 4 a � .�': �> o` Z a a ,' * O 0 � � N Oi N O� N o o ° o ° o 0 0 0 0 O �n N t� o W +a P 69 64 O O O O O O O O O O O O o 0 — O p vl N • � {i o. pp '� F C �� -p L 9 W Q � O E '��° c 4 ¢ U � % � O >caa : �Fz zz ��� F' P� Q i� a� yCr � j j G L ` P F �z. m y O U � O �% m O m N 00 W Q � � � O .� i� N � C �. � Q U N � O z ��� a � o � ¢ � '^ eu . F U c •� O¢_ � � � V ¢vo�>3: 3 C v a �c ° z y w w ,,, 6 y � � �� � 0 � � N O� N O� I � � t 0 0 0 O N O 69 :R G � O O O C O � N � w N e) Lv. ¢ W e m C y � � c �- 4 , m E �" c a ; 0 ¢ � � � � C�i i 0 i u -O 4m v q z ;, a n_ ¢� = s z � � rv j�0 0 0 (1 � Q O Nf O � O. N U C :il a y C W ^ ¢ p W ti O z ° m s r ." ` x°� m0 c w o 3 L' E a am ��_ �c�.�� 3a 3 C � . F � O z h a c P' � : r o . � v 0 0 N N Q. N 01 N 0 0 0 0 c o 0 0 0 o c o O �n N t� O f5 A O �ss vj O O G O O O O � O O O O O O O -+O P i � � � a { C tp C y ¢ C v w � - c y m 3 N a W � >oz '_' O O O O � O � O F ^ L "' ry v f � � V O� Y] 4 O avOz�' a � a � � � � m L J( p' O �M�'O �'a o � °% _ � ` �ra 10-536 S o' 2 y �� L d E a� $ h � I � � � � 0 0 � '� � N y d N 01 � N !o 0 0 0 O O O O �,. 4 O O O O '� O 59 59 O r �,,. .. 69 Y3 W AO P C 9 � O O O L O .� ' N N p I m 0 ; N � t a j O SL � O 7 � � �� O V � Y �` a -� 4 m . � ❑ , C . C w� ❑ i I " '�' d� { x '� �a ! d � � � ; a V I y o ° I I � 6 � � � I � a 0. y � 1 I 0 N � P N � � 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 .- o 0 v� N d u � L C ° c ° � % � F'- ¢ C d C1 9 « cQ n] m > O C � Q X F G Q : i � w O� z � a W� 6 b O O � o � y 9 O �D � � N � � h J � � � � ���0 0 w m m c � dO'^ 00 E 3=��°9 = v �a3a a`�n �. 0 � � � N N � N 7 6 O O � � N � .. H Y? O R b4 � O O D � � � ° o o � � N v m v ' y, c � �E v � d � G pJ 9 � � `cQ [il m i0c �� � L p 3z _ �o n yy�n L �� 1 � m ��N L F , : .z � J iG� �yV L .� t T � i-- A `v 3 O � _ Z � �� O � N O� G� N L O V C � � O Q U z � � � = � �, �, ¢ c 4 � y o �i yUZ ca h C C Z� �0 c �s� , oa F N O � � c U L�r�: 3� ., ., g � N G� N � N O O O O O O O o O N N i� Yj 69 O � O o ° o ° o O O �n N v u n, [s G 00 � C y ¢ 9 [*- M. L u � ° q w > Q L`�' hLt� Q � 9 F F b � o;g �^G- Q 03� y.� n a � Z .n xx- zE oao u�a Z ' � Q 2 � N iF T a F R � S O ? ` a � o� = � �, ' v�', 4 0 Y�z O G � � Y - y cov� � q s v� U,-a�v>: x � u> X y w G � : o 0 � $ � � N a N ^ N O O C G ci o ci 6 O � � O f�? Ui 0 o C O ~ O 0 0 0 0 0 0 �- G O h N v � [[. r- m �E � U '� = [L Q c W E W G¢w m >Llw'�' � m F <1 n0 O� hr =� x� F o� z° �a GL w `v � m a N C 3 O � rv W� O m �n O O N � c�3 � ' d; � ��°¢ o C vl .T. � � � ! h `o ra G �p G 0 - p :� E� H b N G F=�`�3: . 10-536 �� �d C �� m N = � � , a i G i _ �I � { ' , � . F � F L � � C I � I � N � i � i Q � O � GC O > ; :: 'e y � n "' ��o' R' : - � W I -7 � 'L � V C � �� u m 4 M .�. .�. Q `e � 8 t � C ` °' _ i E .� i � � i � • V ! c E i i p a i � I ' a � i ; 0 b M n � � F 3 0 � � v 5 v T � n > o 0 0 � O N O � 6 M O 9 �9 J S O j .� ._ > O O � O C Vl N u � � 4 � y � u E � J � Q � , � c v �y q E � x � � m o ¢ � � , A � N F >oz . ;o i� u -� �� lQ � >inm 3 � - . , . f 1�0 N �oo lN� ) _ �Qa ]-N O O � f� N N d n c O �o af f�� p Q � �yY p�m m ��_ y F E 0 O � O�? a ��y w i � N Q �� 0 0 0, � F o u o�, o � vi � '-� e u. � z o � -� �� v Vy�j� yVl^V � T� vl LL p C'O .i�j L O �,�zU � ��z� � Sv�F"�n °°IU �� `'"' c C� a L 9 p%"� j..]'O� . r� [0 t� ¢°zt.�': Uo�°-3a � O � N G� � � ° o ° o 0 0 O O O C O v� N l� O lA � O cn iA O O O O �- � O O O O � O G N i d T w � k C cp '� F C y�j �p 'O 9 U+ Q � :� � � ro E � 3 Q � >OC O i 0 F � q0 O� � O �` . V °' N V N4 �o a� �2" f p � � F 9 0 . � N i-- m � t`� zx�� � Y h C C <IO � O � � ��<"' m �iil vU'o a 3 O �' N � d .nN4:3: O � • : c O N f �N �� . � 7 R V V � � � o 0 0 � o o c � O N O � fA 69 O 9 � > O O J O O � � _ > O O � O o vl N m 9 (:� 6� C q ��•E � J� [L Q L m 0 5 5 c g W ¢ O tl y � * >pa . 'o )C )y C :� )y ) �� �o� i •=a � V C ? _' .F o ]F+O � 0 � a "� F �� _ =o N '/'I ' 4' pp U] yl � O � m����= 9 m � � � � �'� {a��„ �a " O "' Z N ¢ �� ao : o N O N N C'� N �J 00 ° o 0 0 0 0 0 S � 6�4 O � � S O O O � y O O O O -- O O N . � p. d � � f� � E c °�' -d c 'O 0. Q � B 5 �a FO o " 3 ��� O � .n � i �� N � Q f N �] � zz 0 y��. m�c y�rv y 0^ � m "� � ��O 30� � P o _ � ? �n � N � � � � � O >u,--� � N �'3a— m � a o 0. C y � N W � � � w � � : .�' : m� O� N m � c� O 10-536 � _ 4 J m C r < m a G � T O N ti N N l'S e�i F F � .�. R � p 5 G v � � � � W H O E ¢ o d[ D l i C� p � � � a V � a a� �O G a v O m �G '� F �� � u d� � �� �a E y Y a" m d i a � E n I a' - i i ; I _i � N � �`R N � � 0 0 ° o 0 0 o c c O v� N !� o ua �s o ss v O O O O � � O 0 0 0 -�o 0 vl N � � � w G �aL�-�Q } p N � �Qw w _ m � � :oa J � <a 0. � �] N = 00 o< [- �1 O ¢ ❑ p0^ ry � _5 �z� zF� � + N � a F v N C 0 6 H 6 X� ti Q L o � o 0 o p � � i ' � 1 Q O � ^ N y . � y � O � z -� �o.��� � 4 � '�' _ x `o a-o:o � o � v "w c a O N 0 V� .� N N ?. C� M c o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O v� N h o cav: o +A ss O O O O O o o -- o 0 h N : V T d Q. 6 v ' c F � E _ � a � 9 � ¢ '� G N R] E y c � o � N �R >c�� . � Q F y>w o4 > V O L V: L' On z Y -� z��''�aPi g �3mz � a4�a, � n AZ�pF ��� ,SS¢r¢ �� r� Qc��.4�F� c n o '� N h � M C O ` ,"� � � � N U �' = a p h W � a c �`u za m Q c m� Q r a0 ,, T v � � �L1� ��q� O�O S D5 p L a`.¢"-'v�:3+ M � O e � N N 4+ f5 N1 ° o o ° o ° o 0 0 0 0 O v� N t� o�»� o w � O O O O O O O O P O O -= o c Vi N U � � a � eo � � �i Q C N R7 E' « C Q L[7 ? 0 K O O ..1 F N m 0 � - F } F. F pO0 a�o . q 0 � ,��. c ¢ 'Z �i O u�Q Z C F' ti •c O�� y a �o >�a qZF� r, j ) ¢ s O N � N � 3 C U n i i : T tl x F m 3 O : � n �w i Z O ° N j � � o s m 4 M u o b � FO � O o.-oQ � C'� � � U � N � q�� C] O � �zN m �N R � C = s a��o:o � �Q F � C C 3NN�3a N O O �7 ..+ N N O � � M 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O n N h o v. ss o � � O O O O O O O ~ � O O O 0 0 0 0 h N G. w 4 �a�v o �+. 4 -' C y � � � �¢U >or U� �� O ll �o 4 � Z No OD Q o i T a n c N 0 « F � z N W � , o _ o � V N� � P (� ] h Q vI � r� h O z N Q s ° �x � � a v � c � O V �'O ^) N � O �p �N 3; � N C R .�+ N 3 P � t'� 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O � 6�9 O s5 va O O O 8 ^ p O o -= o 0 V� N N � P' �, c m � � a�i 9 v � Q C Y 0 6 � � ¢ W >oc O O .] 0 � 0 ¢ `v q a m E- m � 0 » P �� Z N 4 ac I c c � � c � � N � N m M � h {!.) ��i O u � � � CO � v�i �O 9 a I �+o � �D q c � � m . � i 10-536 � < �� .�� � V S� � i N i � ` C 1 4 � O 0 - � .. N N d N i � M 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 E „ o0 0 0 O VI N [� F O Y3 F2 O .. a9 f9 ! V � W 1 L i A � � � O O O o -. i .ry O � � Q � � '. E � o o o Q � - O O Y Vl N i O O 3t � ; O � * u ° a v � a o m _� a � � � �' F '' ,. a aLQ � � � � V ,� 'U a. m E � 3 j � � �` l ¢ � � O + • >`ICC 4 I � � b �1� � E om y O Q � , Z Q n0 = O O y - m0 E yyo ' z� P aom 5 a �>rn E g C n � u Uzs � q}C 0 ' ¢_a O N m i a N Kt N 0 � C 1� U � a � - �� "o rnE. u do°v� c n.� eo S n `1 m��� a�n � U � q a L O� N R C �op s F � z N m o , e' i ry � ° o o ° o J C O O > � � O 9 Y> 308 � � o 0 0 0 0 - C O ✓t N U ti A U w n � � n » F � � 9 b J �' Q ty � C Y 0 E � 3 O � 4 q a O a -+ � O c aN m � <�> d N [if Q �. 3 � NF• � ;¢hz _ i��� ° � � � = � � � j -� ' � L . C O * n y V � h � N ry C :o �03+ '.� c �F f? N d t�1 M o o ° o ° o O � N � O N3 V3 'O 59 fA 0 o O 0 0 0 o O ° o ° o ° o �- O O �l N Y . * v U R d v., n v, � m C 2� F y 9 C 9 �+ � W �= C W 6 f° 3 . d `'� O U � N . [} [y�. # L' � � � � c�i zay 0 � ��z y u y � � KO�^ c.,° a�> �V�v o � m C m V y o Q � � 0 9 � � 0 4 � O � � W O � o � U � z����� m y' 9 � � O � N b-3a wc � o� z N m c' a 0 0 � N d � Ni � ° o ° o o = O N O � s�9 ✓3 O i9 fi9 � O O q o 0 _ _ _ � � o 0 � o a ' � N ! e � e� m � u, n � C F eo � Q � O C G N +� E � � 4 � � � O o� �m v � =r�. � o �,; v, i�n> c� v� 4 L1 C � "� Q •`-• ��>�z �: v Y 4 y � � ��c n �p a c"o 'v 3 N a W C J L'._ 'V ...9p � O � O � a'? C � 3 4 �O-f.. � �� o' � �� • � n � v y v � � � �n > o 0 0 � o 0 0 � o 0 0 � 6 9 N K O 9 s9 ] O O ? � � � � o o - b O # `v N N u t'' � 4 C W t-� � LL !� _ C � S C � 0 E 3 3 � 9 w 4 O (n � O > � Q� i i rn � � O o ° N � � F •�- � N � � y U ° - � � v] m 3 v t -,���,, ^ � ` N �[J p0 � 'p '�' = �O � v� � C a'�'Cg s + • P F � ° z N j_ 10-536 G U ¢ � ' C � � � a i t { }r ` � i `h N � � rv) F F ' 6 + � � N � O Q � � � N O � � � `o m m 0 0 0 0 c o o c 0 0 0 0 O P +A O 54 V3 O O O O � O O O O O O O � � N + � m 6 N � � m c 3 O >a � -- i I v i = o" � m E ° - < a� o .. � a w Q � C � , c m c m� �' � a � L� Q �¢w dG m v� m "S � �' � Q -f' � a a v o 3 ,., � =wo j a Y Z � � "'C. e p��i m '_' z ° m � u •i Or3 > _m r a Q�z E N�� a=se r � a a�r O 'I a c`. w 3 �.", rv'o N � a N N C O b n � 0 y G] N � �I N 3 - z a N o a o G cr s U r e�n Y� x.' P �po9 � �N O ` N C " o v�i ��D� 6. zh�z... `s � m" o z 6 �_ O O c .� !�l N G� N !{' � a o o p o 0 o c o O s�9 � O fi9 f.9 O O O O -- -- O O O � p N v � `� � C m E � V O a w � $ � � ¢c� > q K 0 o- F� � O q �-, 4 3 0 a �� y� s �� z v h � `v � a H v m c 3 O 1 n w F_'= z a �� 0 0 o c n (]� N y `j N � ^< _ t N 7 h e � .� v' � ° v .1 in � x � °� � F .. c � " � N � a ` O � O � R 'J A f"' PC fA + V' • � O 0 � N c R NI i o o o > o 0 0 > v1 iV 1� � 69 fn O 9 b9 > O O > - - O O O � O O � V � [ C m N 4 av. ¢ ' � m m E � c ¢tv > A C z O _O � V 4N ac�' Y s�m ��� mz Z¢ o �hz � � � i ` � a x F a n 3 O 0 . w m� z N w S� � y o O - o ` y U � O Q � vo = O e V1 O O ^ "' ,Z `.x, a �gEd c� � - 22 �.��� �. � m � _ �" ��lAx N � 0 � v 1 N � h >o 0 7 o c o J v� N � � '6� Y3 O 9 f/3 D O O > O O j � � > � G O - O O Vl N � Y u ' 4 y C , `- O N E 3 '+- 6 � � � nG� 9 w 'v v+ y > O K �a .� od 3 i. � 6 W F �d O x 0 r�-= 0 h u ,,, c$ ` O 0 � o N []] � O � � 4 �- ; U � Q � � � G � � �R��'.m a U �0 - >a = �'�'a � N L W 3 C M O I� I � � e�' � N 1ry �M 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O Y1 N t� O 69 69 O (i9 (.9 I O O O O CJ O O O O O C O �- O O Vl N � � `° eo E F rj y� vL, ¢ c y m E � � 2� */�-� w J O L+ � � n Z F: O '- - >� �V C Z F F� � � °�F � o m � �P J<� : T o. N H c m O t u> Z ` Q �^_ a 0 O U � O J 9 N C C � a q C v�7 �a = V } L � 6 �' N m =-' � C_] � Fva Fe� �'o� a 10-536 � U a l a� m y = � m c� � F � F � m C W � � � N W O 1 � I q � '+ C O � CO O > ,^, i ° i ' o i v a �i � � + ' y ' a � ❑ L J C �p o a+ i � _ . � u i 5 m �a � � s Q f C ! d � d 0 a p E � � L ; w � O � N 'J'�� N � M o C g o O O O O � N � O��A O iH t/i O O O O O O O � O O 0 O -� O O N N : � [i � % N C �" C y 9 � � � 4 W •� G N � � W 3 m `� O m v� " : >oz n n � � � � U � = m o , p E r°y� 4 C � ° rv � '�' O � '- W [V Ci � � � h � O � Ih N .0 Z � N � �C ao j a- a 3 m> e , M o�n E,.,c� � ^ a o'° - 3 oY °' . �Gcv �� x a O O t� N O� N M 0 0 0 0 O O O O 0 0 0 0 o � � o b9 ' 64 O ^ � O O O O � O O vl N : ♦ d N n [L C R M y E F ❑ � ¢ � a w �, � C N � '� � 3 � 4 N � O >oa . 0 - r z "' 0 F m N j � N 0 a Z m0 � �� zz aa 3� W � oa b ^ o 0 N ; a 9 � [] ^ � v O ? O a ar � o -� o'�� c ofi°`� N O � C a�oZ�3a r � eti N T �i t7 ° o ° o ° o ° o 0 0 0 0 o�� o tA Vj O O O O ^- .+ O O O O : `v d L. 6 [L C A m E �"' a � '� C y R1 � � C 4 �j 3 . ? O 0 � O x w P Q m 0 o ` a �- Z N � m � < ¢Z �� 3� a : ry z= o �d 0 "U a N � b ¢ � N !n V'v [1.� 4� ` �n .-1 O = c�z4 m � ���^ c° N � j U �o :� � o � a R c 0 ° - m>3: ° e � o z �� > 0 C O .=� t� N N� V' M = J O O O �oco 0 7 N N i� � A 4A O f3 y3 > O O � O O j .� .� > � O O � O O � O O ✓1 N » y `v N N y L 6 ' G �p F m U p a oc. Q w j C � � 8 !? c � h 3 � ¢ � O � � C : > lj �a ;° �3 v � N L � N a J O S � ¢ a UI N } � ? Vt (� � 1 � z (%] � 4 � L w 0 ' ° _ ^ > m :Y ' �'z"��a:� ] , ,� c ap �- N C h @ 4 ;w°<:3: $ P o� z h w� L F • a s � M O � N ^J'� � M o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 O N N � O fH d3 O yj Hi O O O O — — O O O �- O C h N : V � � y {i. S ❑, G � e p ' F � � L 9 k Q � = C y m E � 3 v m 4 � O 'n >AZ : Qo � o "� f o < y a 'a" mw`m �sr amg jr.z �"€ , = N o � � v C � p m M r )' [� Q � � Q � N O M y 4. p U M F O R �ac`' Q � c� a � o� e�n ������� av�m:3: 10-536 F � Z h m 4 � : o � � <� e�v ± c v � � � i �, F "f F : L t � 1 C s � m � i � ! o i q � i Q O �t Cl O � « 3 � O W C� L � a W � I �G 1 �-7 a i pp o C F � V 4 y C xa i �a �' i Q a o m ; � d 'L i o U 3 a p ti � p e i d ' R O � N � n i Q� O I N x' I � d N � � � O O V N O � � M O O O O 0 0 0 0 O v� N i� O V3 b4 O � �A 0 0 0 o - -- > o 0 > o 0 o N u � � � � ep ,� C < U A v w 4 C y m � � e a tv � Q � � „ �� o� P "� r ° z� OW � � N ly �.7 � G �N �YE� 4 Y T n F N 3 � y c0 O �3 � N � o3 tl � a _ z � = c o ^� Q���v' o ��v�� � Q C7 C CL �p �j v� O W N F N t3>am:3. � �, _ 0 z W c.°�� : N 0 � � '7 � N T � '7 > o o O � o 0 0 J v� N t^ J 69 69 O A 59 7 0 ° o 7 � � � � o 0 q o 0 ° N d U [y U C L � � o v ?c.Q e � � � y � Q W >C1C LL � � N ?u F �¢s 'R��. :I-n y �Y 3 �Z�o iO :4�0 m � ro `v O it O w� z N w G � . o O o O N O �.. �� � Q N � fn � p _ � > ❑ z o 3 r °� � " c� � � Q V � a o 0 0 � � �oom= 3n�. O � M ..� N O� � M O O O O O O O O O O O O O �n N [� OYi:A O � � o ° o ° o o � " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 v�i N � �J � n L � C � ¢ a u. � C U b � � � fi (xl > O � O Z Q �_ O z° ^� X 0. p z� Na i O :J `� I i, o, F m � O s �� Z L'] � N � P : o 0 O ^ � O N �o � V � y o � - Q h z 0 4z " � � ��¢� � � � ���� o < � � � � c�n��.'�: O O O ti t� N N � M J O O O ^v O O O j o N o J Vi Y3 O A fA � o 0 � o 0 � � � � � o 0 > o 0 � O C vl N v � i. 1 � � e v o �. 4 C EJ a' E 3 �¢•u > � 2�' j a N '3� ;�¢ "� a � F a ' >ozy e�0erv n O!-^ ni�g iz i ° - {L.` . o ( � . i'A�y4 jOQ� ! T � t m `v 3 � w � o' N �� ' o f p az o �j N t� ry z°< - ';�z � � `L � G] C ,�, ��a, � m G m > _ ;3a3-aa - �.� Q C 9��,;3� r O O N (7 N � � M O O fJ O O O O O O O O O G N N [� O fA Vi O Vi Gh ° o ° o 0 ° o� 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � O O h N v U � L � ep F C y Q a t� C {J �' �E R m a � � � C � U � �°v z�a O y .N 'n3 ��O z ,, j y Z - cv V�Um E=y- ♦ T n F � c 3 � f . m lY 'i o' Z n i .�i ,$ ` o I �, o h � O i � � � a � m "'�z - �a°� � m `h m 'o ti p � L _ � `� N rT. L F jVJ'j:G � � � F C ��a�} i 3F 10-536 E � i J� co �� a � a 4 � 4 F F' � ea m e m E � 0 i " a �_ i f O � CS O i � :„ � e V N d O � V i 4 y . =G � C pp O i. � n � •"C W �a � � i y i � � d L G i d d u � v �. ; V i � 4 I I 0 N �, N N � N N O O � e+5 N N � e�1 0 0 o a 0 0 0 0 d o 0 0 O vf N (� o cn � o v3 es ° 000 ° , o o 0 0 Vl N U � 4 4i G � " v 9 �. Q L �U � .- � C a [:� �a ro � � >Oz O F y P o�s �eW �t y z VO� y�} f^ x VZ U[�-� N 6 4-' v � � . � i # w > O� Z N �� c • v O ,�'., m � � � � o ¢ _ p ��� � ...1 O � �L '_ m e� x-0 c c7 0 o P v c `o o P"o 7 iF' d . < 6 � i 'R N N O � N e�I N Ot +.� er1 000 ° o 0 o c o o �� o r:s vi 0 0 0 0 d .- . � ° o, o o — o 0 'n N i a� T v �" K � C F 00 8 F u o � 9 LL Q iy '� E" a� C o �' 3 n<� O . >"aG . � � O Y Z?�u Y �y�°.�mOV ����U _ �aXrypF ¢ - a J � F atz� � -a°hwo �"_ j`�"zo.y" w L ]O�>C�.] Q ) �Fy9°� �� - V rv�� ��S�p.. "' ]FU..tC1m o 4 0 r O M `o ,z�� �a mr7� 4 � -, z ^ 4��z ° 9 � '� � � 6 4 .`a¢1 "p c � M � � � � �n � W �ov� 3a N O O R �f N � � tn O O C O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O 6 6 O ss sv ° o 0 0 o ' � 0 ° o, o o ° N N � ti w = =c�a 'O [L Q � C a> m �` A C � [i� n ¢ > O G �F ^�ZO �F� ��O Z �Q '-�=o "w�z > N �. 9�F � O �zc� ?� Cw S 6�� : T m � a v � `x � o` z h ; F; a� ` rv 0 U 03 , P � O U S y � '_ > o oQ°� r3 � N � >azN ���� ` � � � m m � o Z � L ' f yav� h N C '^"' "�'3a = N � a � o O O N ° ° w m �a5 FJi V Y Y LL LL C oDy E, = a� a ; p _ = i ' m�Y' m `t v] ' N (n y '. 7 q [C � O O O �O 0 � a � .°�.- d � � � 0� E" d a u i � N R � .` O � a a o 10-536 L E Q I � r� _� � h Council File # 10-537 Green Sheet# 3712036 RESOLUTION 1 7 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 Presented by WHEREAS, Mr. Ryan Vernosh received his bachelor's degree from the University of Wisconsm and his Master's Degree from the Universiry of Samt Thomas and be�an his teaching career in Madisoq WI; and WHEREAS, Mr. Vemosh has tau�ht with Saint Paul Pu6lic Schools since 2�04 beginning at Jackson Preparatory Magnet Elementary before moving to his current position in 2006 as a sixth grade teacher in gender specific programming at Maxfield Magnet ElemenYary School; and WHEREAS, Maxfield Magnet Elementary is located within the old Rondo neighborhood, an area comprised of a highly diverse population. As Maxfield works to improve the overall performance for the entire student body, Mr.Vernosh has worked tirelessly with his students to address the achievement gap and improve their experie�ce of social justice; and WHEREAS, through daily activities such as communiry building, sharing, and the morning chant "We Are Some6od}�', Mr. Vemosh continues to i�spire the eighteen brilliant young men he teaches wiYh the philosophy that "all students can and will learn no matter the circumstance. Students living in poverty, students with exceptional needs, students from historically disenfranchised populaYions, all can and will succeed in my classroom°; and WHEREAS, because of his dedicatioq tenaciry, and drive to better the lives of the students he teaches, Mr. Vernosh has been chosen as 2010 Min�esota Teacher of the Year by Educaaion Minnesola with input from students, parents, colleagues and community members. Mr. Vernosh is the second teacher ever from Saint Paul Public Schools to be givzn the prestigious award and he will go on to represent Minnesota in the running for National Teacher of the Year 20I 1 while continumg to use the honor to further discussion about the achievement gap; and W HEREAS, people like Mr. Vernosh are shining examples of what makes the Ciry of Saint Paul and Ward 1 a great place; now THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Saint Paul City Council does hereby proudly and publicly acknowledge the great work and outstanding achievement of Mr. Ryan Vernosh; and BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED that the Saint Pau] Ciry Council affirms the aforementio�ed pride by proclaiming Mr. Ryan Vemosh to be a good will ambassador for the City of Saint Paul and proclaims Wednesday, May 19, 2010 to be forevermore known in the Ciry of Saint Pau] as RYAN VERNOSH DAY Bostrom Carter ITY OF SAINT PAUL, MtNNESOTA ✓ Requested by Department of: By: Approved by the Office of Financial Services Absent ✓ By: Approved by City Attomey � i co i v i i u By: Adopted by Council: Date ��19��/(J Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council Adoption Certified by C uncil Secretaiy gy; By: Approved y Date J L7 7 p� p By: �—