180079 18i )079
Original to City Clerk ,
CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL NO.
• • OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
R LUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE R / DATF
RESOLVED, that upon appeal of Mr. and Mrs. John C.
Colestock from the decision of the Commissioner of Parks,
Playgrounds and Public Buildings, and upon the favorable
recommendation of the Board of Zoning, permission is hereby
granted, pursuant to Ordinance No. 5840, as amended, to remodel
a duplex at 499-501 South Brimhall Avenue, also described as
Lot 1, Block 2, Haley's Addition, into a triplex.
_-- - --
ZONING APPZ*L Council rile No. 180079—BY Bernard
T. Holland—,
Resaed ') a ' b_
Nettie! is here tetiVr that a lutblic and Mrs. �o C•
hem wlll b! held before the Cityy decision of the otter.
Coon at 10 A.M. on October 18. 19�, playgrouride
in the City Hall and Court House, in upon Board o ng pa
thengltierofthemep�wlofMr. and p 1 a
Mrs: John C. 840, (the under Sec. $0 hereby Rr " to 9
of Ord. No. -5810. (the Zoning` Orlin- 1Ro. Sb�O g �Ave-
mace), for permission to remodel a duplex at 1 ypt 1. a.
to l., at 499-801 So. Addition,in on yalso fit a tigt _,
1,$lock 4.Haley's Addition,into a Council
rtober 19,
triplex. Adopted
Dated October 2. 1958 proved tuber 19, 19668.
JOSEPH R. OKONi ,k ( pyet l7,1988)
(October 6, 1966) 1
leCT 19 1956
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 195_
Yeas Nays
DeCourcy �' 1. 9 156
Holland Approved 195_
- L.) '
Mortinson _In Favor S)146A,1 1(2(Lek,
Peterson U U Mayor
Rosen Against
Mr.President, Dillon
5M 6-56 Z
t.J::.: NhS•::Y I • 1
ti::::: °:::;:: ARD OF ZONING, CITY OF SAINT PAUL
,,, :?::?:UIW fiO i 2$1.202-2q 171$CITY NALL AND COURT NODU SAINT PAUL 2,MINNIWTA
October 10, 1956
Mr, Joseph Okoneski
City Clerk
Building
Dear Sir:
This is in the matter of the appeal of Mr. and Mts. John Colestock for permit
to remodel an existing duplex to accommodate three families, located at the
property known as 499-501 south Brimhall. This property is described as
lot 1 - block 2 - Haley's Addition. The zoning is "A" residence.
This appeal is taken pursuant to section 2-, paragraph "0-2" of the Zoning
Ordinance which provides that the Council may authorize the remodeling of
homes in "A" and "B" residence districts which were constructed prior to the
enactment of the Zoning Ordinance, to accommodate not more than four families
provided they have a gross foundation area of not less than 1,000 sq. ft, and
there is a finding to the effect that the intent and purpose of the Ordinance
would be secured by granting the appeal.
The property under consideration has a frontage of 93' on Brimhall and extends
a depth of 122.' There is an existing duplex on the property which was con-
structed prior to 1922 but moved on the site in 1924. It has a gross foundation
area of approximately 1500 sq. ft.
The applicant's plans have been approved by the Building Department and are in
accordance with existing standards as to density and floor area per dwelling
unit. There will be no external modification of this building as a result of
these changes. There is space on the site to meet the off-street parking re-
quirementspf the Zoning Ordinance.
There are commercial uses to the west and north across an alley: there are
single-family homes on both sides of Brimhall: there has been a filling station
permit issued recently diagonally across the alley.
Field investigation discloses •no objection to this proposal from the standpoint
of adjacent land use provided that the applicant's plans andt the requirements
of all City ordinances are strictly complied with.
In consideration of th®se factors, the Zoning Board recommends that this appeal
to remodel an existing duplex to accommodate three families be gr: ,t
S66413,
CDL:FS C. D Loeks
Planning Director
Executive Secretaer��,",
Board of Zoning` t'
OFFICE OF CITY CLERK JOSE 44 I
' ■ City Clerk
BUREAU OF RECORDS HAROLD J. RIORDAN
Council Recorder
386 City Hall and Court House
St. Paul 2, Minnesota
e
C0 +r' 4:` %o.i .N CVUNSE
October 18, 1956
Mr. Marshall F. Hurley
Corporation Counsel
Building
Dear Sir:
The Council requested that you prepare a resolution granting the attached
appeal of Mr. and Mrs. John C. Colestock for permit to remodel a duplex
at 499-501 So. Brimhall Ave. , on Lot 1, Block 2, Haley's Addition, into
a triplex.
Very truly yours,
0.44L)--"L
R
City Clerk
f, ,...
Si,
,,t,r-Vt1,1,\ A
R
i viii''
i {f
I I 1 I c t
'
4 ! i i 1{ ... li
r .._" .. _._2 '
. _
p II 4� •, r t i
C T ._ _O F It i-----#.: E S O T A
?`.r..r. ,- :„tasai k...-,—....., .mot ,.t+ au:' °:rr i"
S rW, 12 q J• C. CO1,ESTOCK /1', '' efi
0 /501 SO. BRt.HA2L
44,:;,,,,a 4,"gle„..,...,ter. PAUL ir./7-;vi,
OFF I ,;: FILED CITY CL2R
F c "r i' �,� K FILE
K `
-..- _... 3 5 45
/ � (CANT �`.'-.._.�.. ___,._..
G- L(i.�- r-ei Y F.1�'56 BUG 28 pM = 35
/ ,-
SAif ;Alt, / /
i - 40- , G
6
d„,, ,,,,,,, ,- f-- ,, 9- (so/ 3
P.3 ids�. -i .....t. -TG X s--r '
7-4 ,-,....„, Le..:z}z_Ziaater.„._-_,,
a_tri.vd," ,,_r_:..&v.ar.„ „„,...e.e,...arez_ _,...,_„,
A.. ef...r-._j c=7 Wu.e. 9.z.--/-*,--, e -41.-444. ,
d; d r74,0.--7,- /. --„e... .e,h
xK; �,- A.6,,
,1,,r,,,.". / 4 ' 7/ ..hrjeme.
.:.e...e, ee-ge.,, ____ _ de.. 4-- '..."--,-- -"" - - -—
tfw--'-e--. 4 -4,4Ar.4.4.5. ./..7..z_z_i_ ___ _,..A.,
4,1 rte. i..
ITY CLERK FILE
•
APPLICANT
1d•C
'
•
J'W4') •m ,
`I - e
�.r0-yrvd
✓rle9
0
•
O -
k
a �
93 fT t.P o .•.T., G P
JcA,ce
.11 /144 ,o,r.
A/A C Co Le g sCK
yyy— Ono/ f:, 4611C,,,e/y v<<
J7. PA. 4. .1A
b ; D 6
-NNITAI `S 'U1dd %IS
y0/ ./ /.09 - bh
11VHWI2IS *OS IOS I
N3OZS3103 .0 'l
< e "L > ;,
r
1""'-, I s i
4
v J ,
..
N )
,
t i�
u /
,__
._.._..__
1 i
1
I
..... .1.-3 r
/ ' 1 1 li----
ki
N ti .
NV
-
I 111
, 4., .,..
. NANA r
iii.,„,,
, ,
� —
..,. l5aak .\-4
NN.\\\s :, 01
N.... 1
, I,
, .- ..--- - li, - . 1
_ _,..,,s, j . i 0 I
., sAyMa�
s \\ ,, . P
2 1 it y
a i
v
r
1
1
- „ ..g. , // < 4 J
,i / , fr
I. ,
• o r .r'
0
( V - a/ b $
filiNni 'Vida IS // by tai/..18, /os' -d b*
TIVHN1I2I8 'OS WS v i
xOO1S31OD '0 '[
- a' 1
X "1.......---41 ��t
- ,
U2
u
, 1 /f r'4° ' 94d
Pal .roly a.,c p4,
' t/i9 / aSO' d
y. " 1 1 � r
i
f
r` .
1,1
A
+ 41 /', I
0 IM / , qa
‘ . .. - .._ i
�, Wp
•
I
1
\\\\, ; - ' q i( „ va _ `0 < , :: 1 ,. :ii
':".\.\\9,\1, _ \ -1 - \AA'
ttt \',.\:‘,,,,s 0 'S U {
1 i t • \\-\\---I i / ' \ , Z 1,, Th,d
C/ i
a G 11
+
x 9 il�' v►T`'1'\
Ii 1' i
Y i