10-232Council File # 10-232
Green Sheet # 3a95716
RESOLUTION
AINT PAUL, MINNESOTA �U
Presented by
WHEREAS, Department of Safety and Inspections has requested the City Council to
hold public hearings to consider the advisability and necessity of ordering the repair or wrecking
and removal of a two-story, wood frame duplex located on propert� hereinafter referred to as the
°Subject Property" and commonly known as 836 JESSAMINE AVENUE EAST. This
pxoperiy is legaily described as follows, to wit:
EASTVILLE HEIGHTS LOT 11 BLK 16
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
34
40
WHEREAS, based upon the records in the Ramsey County Recorder's Office and
information obtained by Department of Safety and Inspections on or befare December 28, 2008,
the following are the now known interested or responsible parties for the Subject Property:
MERS, INC, c/o Flagstar Bank, 5151 Corporate Drive, Troy, MI 48098-2639; Carlos W
Thomas, 15196 Dupont Path, Apple Valley, MN 55124; Wilford & Geske, PA, 8425 Seasons
Parkway, #105, VJoodbury, MN 55125; Payne Phalen District 5 Planning Council.
WHEREAS, Department of Safety and Inspections has served in accordance with the
provisions of Chapter 45 of the Saint Paui Legislative Code an order identified as an"Order to
Abate Nuisance Building(s)" dated November 24, 2009; and
WHEREAS, this order informed the then lrnown interested or responsible parties that the
structure located on the Subject Property is a nuisance building(s) pursuant to Chapter 45; and
WHEREAS, this order informed the interested or responsible parties that they must repair
or demolish the structure located on the 5ubject Property by December 24, 2009; and
WHEREAS, the enforcement officer has posted a placard on the Subject Property
declaring this building(s) to constitute a nuisance condition; subject to demolition; and
WHEREAS, this nuisance condition has not been corrected and Department of Safety
and Inspections requested that the City Clerk schedule public hearings before The Legislative
Hearing Officer of the City Council and the Saint Paul City Council; and
WHEREAS, the interested and responsible parties have been served notice in accordance
with the provisions of Chapter 45 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, of the time, date, place and
purpose of the public hearings; and
WHEREAS, a hearing was held before the Legislative Hearing Officer of the Saint Paul
City Council on Tuesday, February 9, 2010 and Tuesday, Febrnary 23, 2010 to hear
testimony and evidence, and after receiving testimony and evidence, made the recommendation
to approve the request to order the interested or responsible parties to make the Subject Property
10-232
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
safe and not detrimental to the public peace, health, safety and welfare and remove its blighting
influence on the community by demolishing and removing the structure in accordance with all
applicable codes and ordinances. The demolition of the structure to be completed within fifteen
(15) days after the date of the Council Hearing; and
WI�EREAS, a hearing was held before the Saint Paul City Council on Wednesday,
March 3, 2010 and the testimony and evidence including the action taken by the Legislative
Hearing Officer was considered by the Council; now therefore
BE IT RESOLVED, that based upon the testimony and evidence presented at the above
referenced public heazings, the Saint Paul City Council hereby adopts the following Findings and
Order concerning the Subject Property at 836 JESSAMINE AVENUE EA5T.
That the Subject Property comprises a nuisance condition as defined in Saint Paul
Legislative Code, Chapter 45.
2.
�
L�
6.
��
That the costs of demolition and removal of this building(s) is estimated to exceed
five thousand dollars ($5,000.00).
That there now exists and has existed multiple Housing or Buiiding code
violations at the Subject Property.
That an Order to Abate Nuisance Building(s) was sent to the then known
responsible parties to correct the deficiencies or to demolish and remove the
building(s).
That the deficiencies causing this nuisance condition have not been corrected.
That Department of Safety and Inspections has posted a placard on the Subject
Property which declares it to be a nuisance condition subject to demolition.
That this building has been rourinely monitored by Department of Safety and
Inspections, VacantlNuisance Buildings.
That the known interested parties and owners are as previously stated in this
resolution and that the notification requuements of Chapter 45 have been fulfilled.
10-232
78
74
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
••� •
The Saint Paul City Council hereby makes the following order:
The above referenced interested or responsible parties sha11 make the Subject Property
safe and not detrimental to the public peace, health, safety and welfare and remove its
blighting influence on the community by demolishing and removing the structure in
accordance with all applicable codes and ordinances. The demolition and removal of the
structure must be completed within fifteen (1� days after the date of the Council
Hearing.
2. If the above corrective action is not completed withan this period of time Department of
Safety and Inspections is hereby authorized to take whatever steps aze necessazy to
demolish and remove this stsucture, fill the site and charge the costs incurred against the
Subject Property pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 45 of the 5aint Paul Legislative
Code.
In the event the building is to be demolished and removed by the City of Saint Paul, all
personal property or fixtures of any kind which interfere with the demolition and removal
shall be removed from the property by the responsible parties by the end of this time
period. If all personal property is not removed, it shall be considered to be abandoned
and the City of Saint Paul shall remove and dispose of such property as provided by law.
It is fiirther ordexed, that a copy of this resolution be mailed to the owners and interested
parties in accordance with Chapter 45 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code.
Bostrom
Carter
Harris
Stazk
Thune
Yeas r Nays T Absent q y p
Re uested b De artment of:
Safety and Inspections
By:
Form Approved by City Attorney
By:
Adopted by Council: Date �//J� /�%(,�� Form Approved by Mayor for Submission to Council
Adoption Certified by Counc�ecretary By;
BY: /�
�,n,.��r�,%����
Approved a r: at� o
By;
r
10- 32
� Green Sheet Creen Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet
� S � _ Dept. of Safety & Inspections
: Contac[ Person ffi Phone:
� Bob Kessler
266-90t3
15 JAN 2010
Green Sheet NO: 3095716
0
1
2
3
4
5
�' Deoartm entDirecto
� �N Attorne�• i+� L�
� Mayor/ASS7stant l i
�� i
� Ciry Clerk �
_ �= � '��V��
Must Be on Council Agenda by (Date�:
03-MAR-1 C
Doc.Type:RESOIUTiON
� E-Document Required: Y
' Document Contac[:
' Contact Phone:
I �
a Assign
� Number
� For
1 Routing
i Order
��1� � i ��p�
� Total # of Signa[ure Pages �_ (Glip Ail Locations for Signature) j'� ��'�� -. ��� i
�� 55 M �
' Act�on Requested: � i
� C�ry Council to pass this resolution which will order the owner(s) to remove efirepair�the referenced building(s). If the owner fails to �
V
comply wi�h die resolution, the Department of Safety and Inspections is ordered to remove the building. The subject property is �
i locarod nc 836 7ESSAMINE AVE E. '
Rewmmendations' Approve (A) or Rejec[ (R)
_ Plannmg Commission
CIB Committee
Civil Service Commission
Personal Serv�ce Contracts Must Answer the Following Questions:
7. Has this person/firm ever worked under a contract for this department�
Yes No
2. Has this personlfirm ever been a city employee�
Yes No
3. Does this persoNfirm possess a skill not normally possessed by any
Current city employee?
Yes No
Explain all yes answers on separate sheet and attach to green sheef.
_ -.� I
; Imtiatiny Probiem. lssues, Opportunity {Who, What, When, Where, Why):
� This huildwg{s) is a nuisance building(s) as defined in Chaptez 45 and a vacant building as defined in Chapter 43 of the Saint Pz�rf
'�_,agistat��e Code. The owners, mterested parties and responsible parties known to the Enforcement Officer were given av order to
� repair or remove the buildmg xt 836 JE5SAMINE AVE E by December 24, 2009, and have failed to comply with [hose orders.
� Ativantages If Approved:
� The C�ty wtll elimmate a nuisance.
� Disadvantages if Approved:
1 The Cih� will spend funds to wreck and remove this building(s). These costs will be assessed to the property, eollected 2s a special
� .issessmcnt against the pcoperty taees.
� A musance eondition will remain unabated in the City. This building(s) will continue to blight the community.
i
�isadvantages if Not App�oved:
� A nuisance coadition will temaiu unabated i� the City. This building(s) will conrinue to blightthe commnolty.
Total Amount of CosUftevenue Bud eted:
Transac[ion: 9
Funaing source; Nuisance Housing Abatement qctivity Number: 001-00258
Financiai Information:
(Explainl
h January 15, 2010 8:23 AM p ygz �
10-232
DEPARTMENTOFSAFETYANDINSPECTIONS
Rich�d Liyyerl, M�vrage� ofCoAe Ersforcemenl
CITI' QF SAINT PAUL 375 Sackson Slre2c, Suite 220
SainlPrsrel, MNi5l0[-l8Q6
Cnrismpher B Cole�nnn, Mayor
w
January 15, 2010
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARINGS
Council President and
Members of the City Council
Telepfione�65l1GG-39S9
Farsinutc: 65(-266-7?f9
Wrb. wwm.rlpmd.env/ds�
Department of Safety and Tnspections, VacantlNuisance Buildings Enforcement Division has
requested the City Council schedule public hearings to consider a resolution ordering the repair
or removal of the nuisance building(s) located at:
836 JESSAMINE AVE E
The City Counci} has scheduled the date of these hearings as foilows:
Legislative Hearing — Tuesday, February 4, 201a
City Council Hearing — Wednesday, March 3, 2010
The owners and responsibie parties of record are:
Name and Last Known Address
MERS, INC
clo Flagstaz Bank
51 S i Corporate Drive
Troy, MI 48098-2639
Interest
Fee 4wner
Cartos W Thomas
15196 Dupont Path
Apple Valley, MN 55124
Wilford & Geske, PA
8425 Seasons Parkway, #105
Woodbury, MI3 55125
Payne Phalen Distriet 5 Planziing Council
LeslieMcMurray�a avnephalen.ore
C of O Responsible Party
Foreclosure Attorneys
District Councit Contact
An Affumarive Action Equal Opportunity Employer
10-232
8361ESStLV1INE AVE E
January 15, 201Q
page 2
The legaf description of this property is:
EASTVYLLE HEIGHTS LOT 11 BLK 16
The Deparhnent of 5afety and Inspecrions i�as declared this building(s) to constitute a"nuisance"
as defined by Legislative Code, Chapter 45. The Department of Safety and Inspections has
issued an order to the then laivwn responsible parties to eliminate this nuisance condition by
correcting the deficiencies or hy razing and removing this building(s).
The property was re-inspected on January 7, 2010. There was no compliance and the nuisance
condition remains unabated, the community continues to su€fer tha blighting influence of this
property, lt is the recommendation ofthe Aepartment of Safety and Inspections that the C+ty
Counci] pass a resolution ordering the resgonsible parties to eitlier repair, ar demolish and
iemove this building in a timely manner, and failing that, authorize the Department of Safety and
Inspections to proceed to demolition and removal, and to assess the costs incurred against the
real estate as a special assessment to be collected in the same manner as taxes.
Sincerely,
Steve 11�agner
Steve Magner
Vacant Buiidings Manager
Department of Sa£ety and Inspections
SM:cs
cc: David Palm, City Attomeys Office
Mary Erickson, Assistant Secretary to the Council
Cindy Carlson, PED-Housing Divisian
Nancy Homans, Invest St. Pau]
District Counci( — Communiry Organizer
pubhmg(✓J183 12/09
SUMMARY FOR PUBLIC HEARING lo-a32
836 Jessamine Avenue East
Legislative Hearing — Tuesday, February 9, ZO10
City Council — Wednesday, March 3, 2016
The building is a two story, wood frame, duplex on a lot of 4,792 square feet.
According to our files, it has been a vacant building since April 17, 2008.
The current property owner is Mortgage Elec Reg Systems Inc1Co Flagstaz Sank, per AMAl�rDA
and Ramsey County Property records.
There have been nine (9) SUMMARY ABATEMENT NOTICES since 2008.
There have been ten (10) WORK ORDER(S) issued for:
- Improperly stored refuse, garbage and misc debris
- Removal of tall grass and weeds
On November 24, 2009, an inspection of the building was conducted, a list of deficiencies which
constiCute a nuisance condifion was developed and photographs were taken. An ORDER TO
ABATE A NUISANCE BUILDING was posted on November 24, 2009 with a compliance date
of December 24, 2009. As of th3s date this property remains in a condiCion which comprises a
nuisance as defined by the legislative code.
The Vacant Building registration fees went to assessment on April 29, 2009.
Taxation has placed an estimated market value of $20,0�0 on the land and $80,000 on the
building.
As of February 1, 2010, a Code Compliance Inspection has nat been completed.
As of Februazy 1, 2010, the $5,0�0.00 performance bond has not been posted.
Real Estate taxes are current.
Code Enforcement Offfcers estimate the cast to repair this structure is $80,000 to $90,d00.
The estimated cost to Demolish is $8,000 to $10,000.
DSI, Division of Code Enforcement Resolution submitted for consideration orders the property
owner to repair or remove this structure within fifteen (15) days, if not the resolution authorizes
the Division of Code Enforcement to demolish and assess the costs to the property.
rage 1 oT L
10-232
Home Site Map Contact U5
Tax & Property Look Up Information - Quick Info
Home � � Information � � Property_ Look Ug � � Record Loo_k Ug � � Contact Us
New Propertv earch
Back_to Search Results
Quick Info
Propertv Information
Taxpayer Name_and
Address
Va1ue Information
Value Nistorv
Structure Descnption
Sale Information
Sqeaal Assessments
Pro�erty Tax Payment
Information
Property Tax Payment
Histo_ry
2009._Payment Stubs
20q4 Property_Tax
Statement
_2.�09 Value Notice
2008 Propert�Tax
Statement/Value Notice
2_007_ Property_Ta..x
StatementjValue Notice
2006 Property Tax
State_merrtJVelue, Notice
> Quick Information
Go to E-Pav (US Bank Browser Requirements)
Property Identification Number
(PIIV)
Property Address
28.29.22.2Z.0172
836 Jessamine Ave E
St. Paul 55106-2612
Assessment Date Qi-02-2008 01-02-2009
Tax Payable Year
Total Estimated Market Vafue
ToYal Taxable Market Va{ue
Total Estimated Land Value
Total Estimated Building Value
Totaf Property Tax + Special
AssesSments
2009
$143,900
$143,900
$34,000
$109, 900
$3,162
2010
$100,000
$100,000
$20,000
$80,000
Property Class Description Res Non-hstd Res Non-hstd
Year Built 1890
# of Stories 2.00
finished SQ Feet 1596
Foundation Size 812
The Pfat or Section / Township j Range and Legal Descriptian
listed below may be an abbreviated legal description - Do not use
to prepare legal documents
Plat or Section j Township J Eastviile Neights
Range
Legal Description Lot 11 Bik 16
To determine whether your property is
Abstract or Torrens, cail (651)266-2000
Most Recent Qualified Sale OS-2S-1999
Most Recent Qualified Price $63,000
�.e:!/C:\DOCUMB�l\vangmai\LOCALS�l\Temp\KC4Q8AL l .htm 2f 1/2010
CTTY OF SAINT PAUL
Christopher B. Colem¢tt, Mayor
AEPARTMENT OF SAFETY ANB INSPECT[ONS lO-Z3Z
Richard L�ppert, Manager of Code Enforremeni
375 Jackson SLreet, Suite 220 Tetephone: 651-2668989
SainiPauI,MN55707-1806 Facsimile.651-266d979
Web: wwv+s[paul.QOVldsi
November 24, 2009
NIERS, INC
c/o Flagstar Bank
5151 Cotporate Drive
Troy, MI 48098-2639
Carlos W Thomas
15196 Dupoint Path
App1e Valley, MN 55124
Wilford & Geske, PA
8425 Seasons Parkway, #105
Woodbury, MN 55125
Order to Abate Nuisance Building(s)
Dear Madam or Sir:
The Vacant(Nuisance Buildings Unit, Department af the Department Qf Safety and
Inspections, Division of Code Enforcement, hereby declares the premises located at:
836 JESSAMINE AVE E
and legally described as follows, to wit:
EASTVILLE HEIGHTS LOT i l BLK 16
to comprise a nnisance condition in violation oF the Saint Paul Legisladve Code, Chapter
45A2, and subject to demolition under authority of Chapter 4511.
On November 24, 2009, a Building Deficiency Inspection Report was compiled and the
following conditions were observed.
This list of deficiencies is not necessarily all the de�ciencies present at this time. This
building(s) is subject to the restrictions of Saint Paul Ordinance Chapter 33.03 and shall
not again be used for occupancy until such time as a Certificate of Compliance or a
Certificate of Occupancy has been issued. All repairs must be in accordance with
appropriate codes. Changes or additions to the electrical system, mechanical system, or
the plumbing system may necessitate updating or upgrading the systems involved.
AA-ADA-EEO Employer
Novembex 24, 2009
336 JESSAMINE AVE E
page 2
This huilding(s} is subject to the restrictions of Saint Paul Ordinance Chapter 33.Q3
and shall not again be used for occupancy until such time as a Certificate of
Compliance or a Certificate of Occupancy has been issued.
Inspected with Dave Nelmark. Owner was not present. This two-story, wood frame
duplex has severe fire damage throughout the structure and a collapsed roof.
DEFICIENCY LIST
1. Collapsed roof
2. Gutter by extensive fire thoughout
3. Fire damaged facilities
a) Structural
b) Electrical
c) Plumbing
d) Mechanical
4. All walls, ceilangs, floors and contents damaged by fire, fire suppression
activities, smoke and heat.
As owner, agent or responsible party, you are hereby notified that if these deficiencies and the
resulting nuisance condition is not corrected by December 24, 2009 the Deparhnent of Safety
and Inspections, Division of Code Enforcement, will begin a substanrial abatement process to
demolish and remove the huilding(s). The costs of this acrion, including administrative costs
and demolition costs will be assessed against the property tases as a special assessment in
accardance with law.
10-232
As first remed'aal action, a Code Compliance Inspection Report must be obtained from the
Building Tnspection and Design Section, 375 Jackson Street, SuiYs 220, (651)266-8989. This
inspection will identify specific defects, necessary repairs and legal requirements to correct this
nuisance condition.
If ttus building is located in a historic district or site (noted above, just below the property
address) then you must contact Heritage Preservation (HPC) staff to discuss your proposal far
the repairs required by this order and compliance with preservation guidelines. Copies of the
guidelines and design review application and forms are available from the Department of Safety
and Inspections web site (see letterhead) and from the HPC staff. No permits will be issued
without HPC review and approval. HPC staff also can be reached by calling 651-266-9078.
As an owner or responsible party, you are required by law to provide full and complete
disclosure of this "Order to Abate° to all interested parties, all present or subsequent renters and
any subsequent owners. The property sha11 not be so1d, transferred or conveyed in any manner
A'ovember 24, 2009
836 JESSAMINE AVE E
page 3
until the Nuisance Conditions have been abated and the Certificate of Code Compliance or
Certificate of Occupancy has been issued.
The Enforcement Officer is required by law to post a placard on this property wkuch declares it
to be a"nuisance condition", subj ect to demolition and removal by the City. This placard shall
not be removed without the written authority of the Department of Safety and Inspections,
Division of Code Ertforcement. The deparhnent is further required to file a copy of this "Order
to Abate" with the City Clerk's Office.
10-232
If corrective action is not taken within the time specified in this order, the Enforcement Officer
will notify the City Councii that abatement acrion is necessary. The City Clerk will then
schedule dates for Public Hearings be£ore the City Council at which time testimony will be
heazd from interested parties. After this hearing the City Council will adopt a resolution stating
what action if any, it deems appropriate.
If the resolution ca11s for abatement action the Council may either order the City to take the
abatement action or fix a time within which this nuisance must be abated in accardance with the
provisions of Chapter 33 of the Saint Paul LeD slative Code and provide that if corrective action
is not taken within the specified rime, the City sha11 abate this nuisance. The costs of this
action, including administrative costs will be assessed against the property as a special
assessment in accordance with law.
If you have any questions or request additional information please contact Dave Nelmark
between the hours of 8:00 and 9:30 a.m. at 651-266-1931, or you may leave a voice mail
message.
Sincerely,
Steve Magner
Vacant Buildings Program Manager
Dieision of Code Enforcement
cc: Mary Erickson - Council Research
Cindy Carlson - PED Aousing
Amy Spong — Heritage Preservation
otaW135 S(09
U
w
�
d
w
z
�
�
�
�
w
ti
�
M
�
0
0
N
G1
L
R
7
L
�
Gr4
c�
ti
�
❑
�
�
�
�
�
�
>
�
�
�
�
0
0
N
M
U
L
�
�
F
b
�
�
C
'�
�
�
�
�
w
U
�
�
0
V
�
U
�W o 0 0
HdH � � �
N N N
��p `' :
� �
� � �
."'�. F °
¢z �
�� �
._, v� �
.. '-
�
.,z��
�o�
a��a
x
¢
U z" '� �o °�'a `�o
�OF o� o� o� o�
�"" .-i N ti N ti N � N
ri
` � �
� E'q q N� N" N ry N,,,,
a ti .--� � �r
W
A
O�� �
U W ~
P�. � C4 =�
a
�� o �
Z Z �
� ^ 6 _
e w . `� � �.'
��� �� °
..
w�v� � �
� �
a ` a ' � ``-'
� ��
U � � �
.a [•� °
� � z �
� � k'1 r+ �
� �
r1
M
O
A G G
W � �'
� �
U' �r � `� Q.
W F cv � ri �
r.
h �
F��'' � v� � caN � �
H r�j > N .0 p, �� .° s�,
Z W ' � � � � � -.�' v, � U3
�a �Qo o � �az Q �
w U� o` E-�• °�� C7 0� °' �
3 �" �'`" �Q> b ° � a. °
O �
� ri�" �U� o �� w �b � ��
cv w - � >; ,-. ca c� o � � �
W �" �'" � U�� ��� P�,Li..�-1
v �n E�
10-232
�
c
�
10-232
Serial # DEP5AI 63383 1356
Re: 836 JE9SAMINE AVE E
STATE OF MICHIGAN
COUN'PY OF MACOMS
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
��4.+^t�Y\ �UC}��l � , beirg duly sworn, on oath says that or.
{Naiae o'_ Server)
J t�r✓� /—��—�2�ZV 3t I:7� J} [J
(Aafe of Service} (Time o: Service)
sihe} served *he attached: Notice of Pub2ic fiearings
upon: MERS, �NC
cherein named, personaiiy ac:
by handiing to and leaving with:
c/o Elagscer Ba.-.k
Si51 Corpora;.e �rive
Troy, MI 98098
(] the Reqistered Agent of MERS, INC
[} an Officer of MEAS, TNC
[�1 a Managing Agent, someone within MERS, INC whose mar.aaement capac�ty is sucn that
(s}he exercises independent judgment and discretion
�a
a true and cosrect copy thereof.
Su�scribefl and Sworn Co before me
__'�""—_/__�.�} _ J 2 D 10 .
Signature o Notary)
ADAFh GROSH
Notary public, S4ate pf Mich�gyn
Counry of Macomb
A�y Commissfon Ezp;r c 0I, 207
NcBng in tbe CourMy af �Ce _
w>re
* Service was comp)etetl by an indepentlent contractor retained by Metro Legal
�j�(�1Y�. �1��-1
(Title pr Relatior.ship}
��
(Signature of Server)
Inc.
330 2nd Avenue South, Suite 150, Minneapoiis, MN 554�i
T(612) 332-Q202 or {800) A8$-8994 F(61Z) 332-5215
Date:
File #:
Folder Name:
PIN:
April 26, 2008
08 - 060188
836 JESSAMINE AVE E
282922220172
HP District:
Property l�ame:
Survey Info:
10-232
Date: April 26, 2008
File #: 08 - 060188
Folder Name: 836 JESSAMINE ELVE E
HP �istrict:
Property Name:
Survey Info:
10-232
PIN: 282922220172
Date: April 26, 2008
File #: 08 - 060188
Folder Name: 836 JESSAMINE AVE E
HP District:
Froperty Name:
Survey Info:
10-232
PIN: 282922220172
- — ;: �_.
-_ _—��.
_— -----'
10-232
YDate: April 26, 2008 biP District:
Triie #: 08 - 060188 Property Name:
Folder Il�ame: 83fi.b�SSAMINE AVE E Survey Info:
PIN: 282922220172
Date: December 07, 2009
File #: 08 - 060188
Folder Name: 836 JESSANIINE AVE E
PIN: 282922220172
z,.� � - �
. � ___ __,.
�„�.� m �.__ ____.�
HP District:
Property Name:
5urvey Info:
�_ �� ��i
_._--�-�— �
��__. ------ �
10-232
;
Date:
�ile #:
Folder Name:
December 07, 2009
08 - 060188
836 JESSAMINE AVE E
282922220172
HP District:
Property Name:
Survey Info:
10-232
PIN:
d5 S" - .. " ' `? a.__. _
ibate: December 07, 2009
rile #: OS - 060188
Folder Name: 836 JESSAMINE AVE E
YiP District:
Property 1!'ame:
Survey Info:
10-232
PIlV: 282922220172
Date: December 07, 2009
�ile #: 08 - 060188
Folder Name: 836 JESSAMIlVE AVE E
HP Distr;ct:
Property Name:
Survey Info:
10-232
PIN: 282922220172
10-232
Dafe: Decem6er Q7, 2009
Fite #: 08 - 060188
Folder Name: 836 JESSAMINE AVE E
PIN: 282422220172
a �`"`✓„`,� ����
�'"�= �, � ��, �t
, =�_... � �'`�.� � . _
HP District:
Property Name:
Survey Info:
.�a._. ,y..
k �TfR"T',83��. ,
?�J
��
� 6. '�� —� ` , -
��,
F
'�.
.
k �T ` -.
,,,:�.. �"..��:' .. .� ��� pf:.
_ ,.�s��- -. . .. . "� . " t,��
.. �. . ` -. e - - ' aa�
,. � - � ^ �'wd ,� � ����;
,�' � #�
� $r
!A ..Sk �
�"T n. L 1._�l ���... j ..
° �$u. �� � 1�.�1.. � � ..t e.
�
� �
10-232
Date: December 07, 2009 Ib� gDisfrict:
File #: 08 - 060188 Property Name:
Folder Name: 836 JESSAMINE AVE E Survey Info:
PIN: 282922220172
10-232
February 23, 2010 Legislative Hearing Minutes Page 2
2. Ordering the owner to remove ar repair the building(s) at 836 Jessamine Avenue East within
fifteen (15) days from adoption of resolution. (Continued from Feb. 9; need copy of the fire
report for review)
Ms. Moermond read a letter from David Mortenson stating that Flagstar had decided it would not be
making the repairs to the property and he would not be attending the hearing. She recommended
ordering the building removed within fifteen days with no option for rehabilitation. She said she'd
received a copy of the fire report estimating a$100,000 loss at the time of the fire.
10-232
February 9, 2010 Legislative Hearing Minutes Page 5
4. Ordering the owner to remove or repair the building(s) at 836 Jessamine Avenue East within
fifteen (15) days from adoption of resolution.
David Mortensen, attomey with Wilford & Geske, appeared on behalf of Flagstar Bank, the
property owner.
Ms. Moermond asked for a report from Mr. Magner. Mr. Magner stated the building was a two-
story, wood frame, duplex on a lot of 4,792 square feet and had been vacant since April 17, 2008.
A code compliance inspection had not been done, the vacant building registration fees in the
amount of $1,000 went to assessment on Apri129, 2009, and the $5,000 performance bond had not
been posted. On November 24, 2009, an inspection of the building was done and a list of
deficiencies which constitute a nuisance condition was developed. An order to abate a nuisance
building was posted on November 24, 2009 with a compliance date of December 24, 2009. To date,
the property remained in a condition which comprised a nuisance as defined by the Legislative
Code. Ramsey County Taxation estimated the market value of the land to be approximately
$20,000 and the building to be $80,000. Real estate taxes were current. Code Enforcement
estimates the cost to repair the building to be approximately $80,000 to $9Q000. The cost for
demolition was estimated to be approximately $8,000 to $10,000. There had also been nine
summary abatements issued to this property since 2008, twn of which went to work arder: remove
improperly stored refuse and debris and cut tall grass and weeds. Code Enforcement recommends
the building be repaired or removed within 15 days. Mr. Magner presented photographs of the
property.
Ms. Moermond asked for a report from Ms. Spong. Ms. Spong stated that this building was built in
1888 and was a late Victorian-era building. There was a loss of integrity with the siding being
covered and the porch being lost. The two block faces were fairly intact and the property was not
located in any potential historic district. She did not believe demolition would have an adverse
effect.
In reviewing the photographs, Ms. Moermond asked when the fire had occurred. Mr. Magner
responded the fire happened on November 3, 2009; however, he did not have a copy of the fire
report. Ms. Moermond asked Mr. Mortensen when his client wanted to knock down the building.
Mr. Mortensen stated that he had talked to his cl3ent and they were in negotiations with the
insurance company. They had also hired a contractor to look at the property to obtain estimates on
the cost of the repairs. He said he had in-depth conversation with his client as to what the
expectations were of the city if they planned to rehab the building and they indicated they were
willing to do the work to save the building. He requested additional time for his client to do the
rehab of the building.
Ms. Moermond responded that the Order to Abate was sent on November 24, 2009, Flagstar had
received personal service of these proceedings on January 20, 2010 and had not done anything with
the building thus far. Sased on that information, she did not have confidence that they were serious
about the rehabilitation of the property. She said that if they did undertake the rehab of the
buiiding, it would need to be converted to a single-family dwelling as the lost size did not support
the structure of a duplex.
10-232
February 9, 2010 Legislative Hearing Minutes
Page 6
Ms. Moermond laid the matter over laid the matter over to Febnxary 23 with the following
conditions to be met: 1) the code compliance inspection must be conducted; 2) the �5,000
performance bond must be posted; 3) obtain a swom construction statement; 4) provide financial
documentation; 5) a work plan must be submitted; and 6) the property must be maintained. If the
conditions are not met, her recommendation was to remove within five days.
MM DD YYYY �oeiete �.7E,�gs _1
� 62210 � U 11 L03J 009 o� � 09-0028589 � 000 �Change
Fpin S:ate IncidenY Date Sxation =nc!den: Number Ba51C
� i[ * * =�[posu�e � �NO Ac.ivi'.y
❑lTeck Nia b Lo indiuce _hat CM1e addcmz fe� c11a �s 4[oviGetl ap [Ae illtlla�d YS_e CeOS:'S ':L2Ct Q311 OQ
B 7�OC3t].OI1�C ��1� xo s a. o a•uc�rn.u� xovuon sp�u:i� . o,� o�uy :: wssavoa : �J
�street address 836 L_� �.IESSPSSINE � AVE ��
�Inteas'�-'ction p�er/mlepost Pre£ix Street or s4gnvay Sereec tvpe Su__nx
❑ Ea ftoat of ��
� iteaz of � SAI23T PAIIL ��, 55196 - L_J
Ant/SUite/ROOm C_Ty Stzte z1p Code
�Adjacent to I I
�Diiecti.oas czoss stzeei ox dvxectaons. as anolicaCle
Incident e* xti.anight is o000
C TYP El Date S Ti.mes E2 Shift 6 Alasms
7.1�- IBiaildiag fite I�eck boxes if Mqath Day Yeaz Hi Misa Sec +��x1 o�t�oa
Inadent T dates aze tne
�e same as Rtarm P-�`�'. aivays equired IC: I I f1� I IriZ �
Aid Given o= Receivedir Date. � atm * 11 03 2009 05:32:24 �- ��--� �
D 5nifc or �a�s oistcict
Ylatoov
1�]MUtual ai.d xeceived � II I �L Le' I�'x,e.a�', uniess cmceiea oz aia noc arr�ve
2 QAUtomatic aid recv. zne,r tvxo xneir � � * L� 03 L 20� 05:34:22 E.
3❑ azd giy State CONTROLLED pPtional� E%cepY foi .,iiaia�a fize5 Special �Jt11C�125
4 C]AUtomatic aid given � � �COntrolled �J �, �11 I ��al opcnon
5�Otllex� aid given Their 1.AST UNIt CLEAtiE�, required excent for wildlantl £ices �� L�
Inudeni Pumbei LaSt ilnit Specaal Speclal
r7 QNOne � � ��� I nal � 20p� j�' •28:36 � Stutly Ink Study �alue
Cleared t -- i � '-�
F' Actions Taken * G1 Resources * Gz Estimated Dollaz Losses 6 Values
Check this box antl skip this
X section i£ an Appacatus or LOSSES: Requized £or all fares if known. Optional
Perso�el £oxm is used. toc non flres. Non
11 IExtinguishment by £ire � ppPazatus Petsonnel Property $`�� 100 � 000 �
Prlmary Ac[ion Taken I1) �
Suppression 0015 �� Contents $�J � OQO � 000
51 �Ventilate � ❑
Atlantlonal Actnon Taken 12) aL' �� �� PRE-INCSDENT VALUE: optional
I I, . I OThei �� �� Pr ��� �� r 0�� � flL10 �
I_J
Additlonal Action Taken (3� ❑ Check box if resource co�nts
include aid ceceived nesovxces. CpLteiyhsy !�' I� QQp � �QQ ❑
u
Completed Modules �1�Casualties�xona gg Aazardous Materials Release I M1xed Use Property
QFire-2 Deaths In7vsies N�NOne NN Not Mixed
❑ 7C StruCtUSe-3 Fire I I j Natural Gas: .ao. ia.a, oo �..�c:w � wuwa +�uoe. �.� A35embly use
❑ Civil Fire Cas.-9 � MCe �`�` ❑ 2� Education use
2 QPropane gas: Qi v,. ,.,t „ „�� e...i� 33 Medicai use
� Fire Sexv. Cas. -5 �� I I I 3❑Gasoline: .,�� �y �� y ��i e a „"'"" 4� �sidential use
�-��--� S1 Row o£ States
❑EMS'6 . 4 � &erosene: � v„�ov �w�< � w .ti,m. .�,�
� aetectos 53 Enclosed mali
❑ $a � ati- � Aequizsd fos Conf.vned Fires. S❑Diesel fuel/fuel oil:.,�ne e,�y r� o: �mni� rjg gus. 8 Residential
OWildland Fire-8 1❑nececcor ai�rza oc�nss 6 0HO"'�'+old solventa: ��,fx,� .p,ii, �a.,n„> „iy 59 OEPice use
�Apparatus-9 '7 ❑�tor oil: � 60 3ndustrial use
mn== o: pe.�ue �oera.n�
Q Personnel-10 2Q�er.�c*AZ a�a „oc ai�e cn� 8 �p�t: °-. p�� ,� r�`_"' < ss g�ss�. 63 Military use
❑ Psson-il 65 Earm use
U❑ Ea,w,ow., 0 L] Other •%m�•.i H.m.e xit,ons ny,;na o. m > zxu.. 00 Othex mixed use
• Pleax e lete fde Aaxtlat £e�
J PsoQerty Use* Stxuctures 341[�Cliai.c,cliaic type in£itmazy 53g QBousehoid goods,sales,xepaixs
342QDOCtor/dentist o£tice 579 QMOtor vehicle/boat sales/repair
131 []���, place of worsha.p 3610Prison or 7ai1, not juven3le 57j Q 6as ox service station
161 QRestauxant or cafeteria 419 1-ox 2-famil dwe11'
saz/Tavern or nightclub � y ''°g 599 Q Business oEfice
162 ❑ r]z9 QMUlti-family dmelling 615 Q Electsic generata.ng plant
213 QElementary school or kindergarten 439 xooming/boazding house 629 Zaborato
❑ � ry/science lab
215 Qaiqh school or junior high 449 Qcammercial hotel ox motel 700 Q ManuPactuzing plaat
241 � College, adssit education 459 []Residential, boazd and caze $19 QLivestock/poultry storage (baxn)
311 Care Eacila fos the a ed
331 Eospital � g 4640aormitory/batracks gg2 ❑NOn-tesidentsal pazkang ga=age
❑ 519[]FOOd and Leverage sales g91 Q Wazehouse
Outside g36 Q Vacant lot 981 Q Construction site
124 QPlaygsound or pazk g3g QGtaded/caze Por plot of laad 984 Q�dustrial plant yard
655 QCxops ox oxchazd 9q6 QLake, rivex, stxeam
Lookup and entez oiopext�y Use coae only af
669 QFOrest (ti.mberland) 951 QRailroa3 sight o£ way you naoe Hox rne�ked a nno_sscy use con:
8Q7 QOUtdoor storage azea 9(Q O:her strset
�i Pxopexcy Use 419 �
919 Qal,mp ox sanita 1• land£ill 9(1 ❑Highwayjdiv3ded Iv.ghway
931 Q�Pen laad or field 96z QResidential street/driveway �1 or 2£am7.1y dwelling �
NEIRS-1 Revision 03 11 99
Sain[ Paul £ace Deoartment eo�in i.invronno nn_n,.+��..,.
A MM DD YYYY [�neleze
�62210 � u 11 03 2009 07 �09-00285B9 � 000 � �� -2
cnanqe Fyte
enxn * state * _�cidenc �ace * staaon inndeai Nua�er * �xoosure * � p �ctiviry
None ��lete if tliere vese an/ sigtu£�cant
$ Prope=ty Details C On-Site Matexials� � o��er.iza,��a��u�ai, e .,e�� or
OD Produets a4=zcultvzal pzoduces or maierials on etoe
eraperty, wne[her o: noi :ney became mvolved
Bntex un to thxee codes. CIIeck one
0�02 Not Resadeatial oz more boxes :or eacn coce enteretl.
$1 � � ❑ 1�HUtk storage ox warehousing
35tamated Number of residential 1!ving Units in �� �NOne I 2 PtOCes9ing oi ma21u£aCtusizig
bui!ding o: oragin whe�e: or no[ al_' vnxi5 p�_site vacenal (11 3 paCkaged goods £or sale
became in+olved 4 Repai.r or SezviCe
1 Bu1k storage ox wa=ehousing
BZ � 003� �EUildings not inwlved L� L I 2 Processi.ng or manu£actsszing
Numbez of bui?dinas involveri oo-s.te maaeriai (2) 3 Paekaged goods £or sale
4 Repais or service
g3 �� �Noae 1 Sulk stosage ox waxehousing
Acres burned �� � � 2�P=ocess oz manss£actuYing
(oucside °Sresl �Less than oae acre on-s�ce maee��ai (3� g Packaged goods £or sale
4 Repais ox servi.ce
Cause o£ Ignition a�an aactozs
D IgSlition � ❑ � e � � i£ � yg � � �zt. �COntributing To igaition
sxip to sectvm c Check all applicable boxes
Dl 24 ICooking area, kitchen � 1 Qxntent�.ou� 1 �z�sieeP �xone
Acea of fice eciqin * 2❑tlaiatentional '2 ❑ Possibly vmpaised by
3❑Failut�e oF equipment or heat soui�ce alcoHO1 or drugs
]�2 60 �Heat £rom other open � 4 Qa�t of naeu=e 3 Q IInattended person
Heat source * 5�Cause vndei invesTagation 4� Possibly mental disabled
U QCause undetesmined a£ter investrgation 5 QPhYSically D15abled
D3 Factors Contributing To Zgnition 6 ���Ple pexsons inwlved
CN � �Undetermined I �
xcem firsc ieniced 1 cneck eoa ir f>re sasez �NOne �
]�' �] Age was a £ackor
❑„as �€;�ea m �i�c LW_� �Undetermi.ned �
ot osa.gin pactos contzibuamg xo Igaitaon (1) Estimat2d age o£ �
DQ ��J ` � peFSOa eavolved
Type o£ satexi&1 Re4�setl only if item £izg[ �� I
first ignited ig�utad mae vs oo er <�o
Factor Coatzibssting ao Ignitlon (21 �. �Mal�' 2�Female
F1 Equipment Involved In Ignition F2 gquipment Power � Fire Suppression Factors
❑Noae 2£ E¢upmant was not inwlved,S]up to I I �
Section G �� EAter up to thxee codes. ��one
� I ` Equipment Powex souzce
� u � �
E k"'p"ent �"°°�pea � Equipment Portability
eise supp�ession factoi (1)
Brand I � 1 �POrtahle
Model f I z❑S���n�Y eir�xlssion factor (2) I
Serial #� ( Portable eauipment nozmally cav be
moved by one peison, is designed t � I I
Year I I be use in mul[iple locatlons, and eire suppressnon facmr f3)
requires no tools to install.
Mobile Pro er Involved Local Use
H1 P tP $2 Mobile Property Type 6 Make
�Pre-Fixe Plan Available
� None �� s�e of tne iafoxmarion presentea in
I � tRrs xeport may be based upon reports
�. � Not involved in igsu.ta0n, but buxn¢d Mobile property type £rom oiLea Agencaes
2❑ Involved in >gxution, but did aot burn ❑Arson iepoxt attached
3❑ Involved in ngait3on and burned �� � � �police repost attached
Mobile pYOperty make � COSDIIPS xeport attached
� �Othes sepoxts attached
i I � �
noblie pioperty ma3ei YE2i
� �u� �
Llcense Plate Number State VIN NumAe�
NFIRS-2 Revision O1/19/99
Saint paul Fixe Deoaxtment aoo.n .+��nr�..�� �o_�..���.,,.
I1 Structure Type * IZ guilding Status *� Buildin *=4 �'Ias-3
zr rire ..as m�,mosee n�iim� o� a 3 g Main FloOZ' Size*
Hei ht stz,�etuze
pa�r ma/mobiie s*su�c,�ze �iece 6
c�,e zese or uis coxm covne raa xmr as pax-e Fue
1� Enclosed Buildinq 1 Q Dnder constrvctaon _° the �n.qtest story
2❑ Portable/mobile structure z❑��''� s opesating
3 � oPPa structuxe 3 � Zd1e, not zosstinely usea 002 u, 001 , 134
4 Q Air SuppoStEd 3ti't1CtUi'& 4❑ Dnder major ienovataoa i5 q���ma�. Totat square feet
rj ❑ Tent 5 Q vacaat and secuxed
6❑OPen plat-£ortn �e.a. ?_e=sl 6�vacant ana vasecuzed 00 OR ,
7 Qi7ndergrovnd stzucture evo=x zreas� O�� aemo±:shed �w °�"� °` _`°°°° � 042 gy �, 027
$❑CoIln¢Ct1VE 3tiuCtUxO (e.g. :ences) U❑IIadetexmined Lsnght in feet Width ia £eet
Q ❑Other tyQe of structuxe
J1 Fire Origin * J3 Number o£ Stories g Material Contributing Most
Damaged By Flame To Flame Spread
�Below GLadE Count the AOOF as pazt oE the hiqhest stozy
��l � C6eck if no .`lame spzead S1Ci-p To
Stoiy of Pite oiigin oR same as matez_ai first ignitea SBCtion L
� I N�mL.r o£ storles v/ mvnor tlamage OF unable to detexmvve
L � — � (1 Yo 2d& flame dama4e)
�2 Fii'e Spx'ead * I I N � t af ssOZ}e6 „./ s,y,uricaz,c a�ye �' � I �
L-- -' - � (25 [o d9& £lau�e Ztem c�ntcihuGVng sost Co flam¢ sp[ead
�. �COn£ined to object aF orlgin ���
2❑CO�1nEd to SooID o£ oLig�R � Nw3er o£ sTanes v/ heavy dynaga D'n �
3❑COnfinEd to £looi O£ origin 25D io ]48 £lame damage) t � �� I
4❑CO�ined to built112ig 0£ Osigin Typ` o£ mat�e�val Con[tibuting Required only i£ ifem
N�mbet oE stories v/ extreme damage mos o sp[ead conii'ibuting
5�Heyond building o£ oiigin �„1 (95 to 100$ f]ame damage) code 1s 00 orOO
L1 Presence of Detectors * j�3 Detector Power Supply j�5 Detectior Ef£ectiveness
(in area ot tke Eire) Rem if detector operated
N QNOne Present 51cip to 1 Qeattery only
section M 2 QAazdwire only 1 QAlezted Occupants, occupants responded
1❑Pxesent 3 QElug in '2 QOCCUpants £ailed to xespoTid
U�Undetermined 4 Q xasdwi.xe with battezy 3 QThere were no occupants
5 QPlug in with battexy 4 QFai.led to alert occupants
6 QMechanical U QUVdetezmiaed
Z2 Detector Type �❑��le detectors 6
1[] smo�ce powex suppiies 1+6 Detector Eailure Reason
. 0 Q��+er Rem if detectox £ailed to operate
2 Q Heat U❑ UndetP*+•+�=d
3 Q Combination smoke - heat L4 DetectOr Operati�n 1 � pO0'PS failure, shuto£f or disconaect
2 Q Improper installation or placement
4�] sprinkler, water £low detectioa 1 QFise too small 3 QDe£ective
to activate q❑�� o£ mai.ntenance, includes cleaning
5❑MOre than 1 type present 2❑pperated 5 �8attexy miss'^g ox disconnected
O�Othet (COmplete Section LS) 6❑gattezy dischaz'ged or dead
3 QFailed to Opezate
U UndeteTmi.ned <COmP1eGe Seetaoa L6) � � O � 1eS
� U Q Undetezmined U QIIndetermined
�j Pzesence of Automatic Esr; System *� Automatic Exting+•;shment
�j Asstomatic Estinm';shment
N�NOne Present �'s� OPeration System Failure Reason
Complete rest A�"�ea is f>re was u2tlun dessgned xanqe Requized af syctem £ailed
1 Qp=esmt of Section M 1 Q Operated s ef£ect3ve (Go to .�ia 1❑ System shut o££
e o£ Automatic Exr;., 2❑OPexated 6 not eE£ective (y.�4)
Typ guishment System * 2 QNOt enough agent dischazged
R red iF £3re was wit2un desi 3 QFire too small to aCtivate
equa gned range o£ AES
1 QWet pipe spxixilcler 4 QFailed to opetata (co m ur5) 3 O�eAt discharged bsst did
Z D i s xinklex 0 Q Other not reach fire
❑� P� P 4 Q Wxong type of syst G�ILL
3 ❑Other spxinklei system U ❑Ondetermined
4❑ Dxy chpmical system S Q Fire aot in area psotected
5 QFOam system M4 Number of Spxisilcler 6 QSystem componeats damRged
fi OHalogen type system xeads opexating 7 QLack of maincexaance
'J ❑ Carhon diosi.de (COp) system �4�sed i£ system operated O❑ �e� �tervention
p QOther special hazard system �� U QUndetexmined
U Undeterm3ned N�mUer o£ spri�,ler hea3s operating �ruc_3 Revisioa O1/19/99
c�;..+ o�„i c:�e no,.arrmo,.« �.......
10-232
�1 Person/Entity Involved �FLAGSTAR BANK �� �� �, -(_� ��
Locai optlon 9uslness name (y� appllcahle) Fzea coae Puone N�er
❑ Cbeck Rh:s 3ox i ` � I � � I `
same aGtlress as ' M.i.,Hs., Hrs. Fvrst Name MI t Name Su£_!x
vnczdent locacion.
*nen sxi xne .n_ee � j151 i L� LCORPORATE � DR ��
dvoliw[e atl3ress Nu¢ber pre.`ix StceeC oi exgnvay S[reec ?ype
l�..es. suf£ix
I I �J �TROY �
_ost o!£nce aox n?c./smte/xowv Cnty
I MI �48098 �-�J
state Zip Code
I �MOre people involved? Check tlais box and attach Snpplemental Fo�s (HFIRS—iS) as uecessaxy
R2 Owner � �� as a etso.. �neoiveaz
❑en cRecic idis box and skip I I t I_ I I—I I
xhe zest o£ this sectnon. f� �—_.1 L+—J
Local P2tion Evsnness n�e (if Spnlncable) pzea Code YTOne Number
u � iu� � u
❑ Check [his box if Hr..HS., IM1=s. evzst Name MI Lasi Name Su£Y�x
same address as
mcident locanon. ' I I I� I I � I I
xnen skvp tLe tnree L—J L__J I_J
deplicaCe address N�em PYe£1x 5[seet oi Hlghway Stieee Type Suf$x
lines. I � �� I �
POSt O£fice Box ApiBuLtelMOm Cnty
u � �-u
Sta[e y1p Cotle
L Remarks
Local Option
THIS WAS A EIRE TO A TWO AND A HALF STORY VACANT DUPLEX. ENGINE #17 WAS FIRST ON 5CENE
REPORTING HEAVY FIRE AND SMOKE IN THE BACK OF THE STRUCTURE. THEY PLACED THEMSELVES IN THE
ALLEY. THEY EXTINGUISAED THE EXTERIOR.
ENGINE $7 LAID AN ATTACK L2NE TQ THE INTERIOR. SQUAD #1 LFID AN ATTACK LINE TO TAE ATT_IC
LEVEL. ENGINE $9 DIP A FORWARD I..AY TO THE ALLEY FROM THE EAST TO RELAY TO ENGINE #17 AND
ASSIST WITH EXTERIOR EXTINGUISHMENS. ENGINE �r17 HAD A POWER LINE FALI, DOWN ON TO THEIR
APPARATt3S AND TAEY WERE THEN TEMPORARILY OUT OF SERVICE. ENGINE #17'S CREW THEN UTILIZED
BNGINE #7'S SECOND PftE-CONNECT.
ENGINE #8 WAS UTILIZED FOR FIRE OPERATSONS. THEY DID A BACK LAY INTO ENGINE #7. ENGINE #7
I RELAYED INTO LADDER #7 WHSCH WAS PLACED IN FRONT OF THE BOILDING. LADDER #7 RELAYED INTO
�I, SQUAD #1. LADDER #� PUT THESR AERIAL S3P. THEY ALSO LADDERED THE SECOND FLOOR WITH MULTIPLE
� GROUND LADDERS. LADDER #7 CONDUCTED THE PRIMARY SEARCH AND VENTILATED THE STRUCTURE.
� LADDER #22 WAS PLACED IN THE ALLEY. THEY PUT THEIR LADDER TO THE ROOF AND ASSISTED WITH
OPENING IT 6P A13D CAECKING FOR FIRE EXTENSION IN THSS AREA. LADDER #18 AND ENGINE #18 WERE
SENT AS RIT. LADDER #18 ASSISTED C�3STH OVERFIAUL THROUGAOUT THE STRUCTURE. ENGINB #18 DID A
COMPLETE WALK AROUND AND MAINTAINED AS RIT.
CHIEF #2 WAS SAFETY OFFICER. FIRE INVESTIGATOR MINKKINEN WAS ON SCENE FOR INVESTIGATION.
MEDIC #4 STAGED FOR PART OF THE INCSDENT AND THEN WAS PLACED IN SERVICE. THERE WERE NO
INJURIES. BOARD-UP WAS CONTACTED. THIS INCSDENT WENT OVER SHIFT CHANGE AND CHIEF 3'A'
TOOK OVER AT APPROXIMATELY 0730 HOURS.
Authorization
�3163 � �MCCUE, MARK T ��i50 I �C3 � 11 Oa 2009
Offacei 1n cha
rge ID Sngnatuxe Posit:on or xNtk Assignment Month Dzy Yeax
sox`� � �MCCUE, r�EUC T � �1so � �c3 1�� U 1 2ooal
same
s O££SCex Member makiny _eport ID Sigratuce Posntron oi xank AssnJnment MonC➢ Day Year
chaige.
MM DD �ne�eez
A YYYY �_� 1
� 62210 � u 11 03 2009 07 � 09-0028589 � 601 �cx�19e sasic
�vxn * scace.k xaciae.,x nace ,* sca«oa xa�iaeoc sw�ez * exms�e *
�NO AcYivity
❑CAeci Ctia Gox 2o IDdi.afG tM< Se a�ese �a- :tf incidepC ia pcovldeC pn CLe W�ldlant Eice CeL5u5 ?iaCt
B LOCat].On* nad+a= m s.�aeo e-uc�m.nv� u�sso� sa�ci__�.c:o�•. os� ou f=; F�ue:ann �_�a. 0311 - Q�
�Street addzess I ' �SSAMTNE
�Intersection 840 u � � AVE �
NimSeUNSlepost Pie_.x Stieet oi Eig�vay Stiee: 9}ne Su._ix
�Ia fxont oE
Q�r of �� �SAINT PAUL � LMN� 55106 -�_�
Ant/SC1te/3ooa Ciry 5:ate yyp �ode
p�;a��t � 1 I
�Directions
Cross stzeet or tlirectlo�s, as a cincabie
C Incident Type ic �1 Date S Ti.mes M��4nt is o000 E2 Shift 6 Alarms
�.11 �evilding Eiie ' checx boxes it � �ca1 option
mcvdent Twe tlates are the ➢ay Yeaz Hx 1.in Sac ���
same as Ataxm �M always semurea
D Aid Given or Received# Ddte. �� * 11 03 2009 05:32:24
Shift oi �a nist_ict
Platoon
1 OMUtual ai.d IeCeiVed I ' �NN. =equssed, ualess canceled ox did not aznve
2 Qautomatic ai.d recv, anei��xn eir� � �iva7 * t 11 03 2009 05:34:22 �.
seaee co�xxcma,.,*n oac,onai, e=capc eor wiiaiaaa ri:es S ecial Studies
3 Q��al aid given p
�] �Automatic ai.d given � I �COntrolled �J �) �j L__J Locai optnon
5�OtheT aid g.iven Sheir �+SR tm*i2 cZEUtE�, required except for vilaia:+d cires 1 1 � 1
Z7 �NoIIe Inndenc Number •.oat Uyyyt Special spec na1 I
� CleazBd ��'� u 200� lo' • 28:36 � S[utly IDq Stvriy valve
F' Actions Taken * G1 Resources * G2 Estimated Dollar Losses fi Values
� �eck thxs box antl skip �t=is I,pSSES: gsq�yred £or all fires nE knovn. tional
section if an Apparatus �P
12 I$31V8QB S overhaul I Personnel £oim is used. £oz non fizes. N�
Yrlmaiy Action Takev (1) Appazatus PETgOI1SiE�. pioperty �G�1 � ��2 � 7�� �
Suppression 0015 �� Contents $L� 000 000
u� , - - ❑
Additional nction Taken (2) EM`S L_� �� pRE-INCIDENT VI�7.IIE: pptsonal
o�e= � � $u,u-u ❑
u � � u u p= = o00 ooa
Atlditlonal Actnon Takee, (3) ❑ Chgck box i£ resouxce commts
incmae aid receioed resources. Coateats y Q�� � 000 � 0�0 �
Completed Modules �1*Casualties�xone $3 Haya�3ous Materials Release = M�xed Use Property
QFixe-2 Deaths Iajvsies N QNoae IRZ Not Mixed
� X Structure-3 Fire I ' 1� Assembly use
Servire � L�,� 1 ONatuzal Gas: ,v,,, y„k, n , „,,,, ,� e „ v , c ,�,,,a � 2� Education use
�Civi.l Fixe Cas.'4 2 PsoPane gas: Qy �. �„ ;,, n� se¢ yzuy� 33 Medical use
�� Fire Serv. Cas.-5 Civilian�_� �� 3 Q�soiine: ,.n,ae p„y �� p,�r.nx �w�Q 4� Residential u5e
❑EMS-6 4 Q Xeioaene: f b,,. �� ��,.� ,�,�, 51 Row of stores
� BazMat-7 � Detectox 53 Enclosed mall
Aequized For Con£inea eixes. 5 QDiesel £ue1(Euel oii:,.�,;� ��,� p,��e 58 aus. s aesidential
�Wildiand Fire^8 ❑ 6 �HOUSehold solvevts_ ��,.
1 nececco= u�cea o�cupa„<s � 59 o££ice use
�Apparatus-9 7 [�MCtoz oi1: 60 =ndustrial use
�Personnel-10 2❑Detector a>a not azert cnem %:ae my,M >: �ze.vz �u,� a �
g ❑P � t _ : 63 Mi.iit use
im P+�2 eam tutali➢g < 55 galloa 6� $3t16 U96
�ALeOA—Il [J ❑ Untnom Q Othet: ae�+•i eamac aetiom my�una es miu : sss+i .
❑ pv �� �� � �� Fem 00 Othex mviced use
�J Property Use* Structures 3410clinic,cli.IUC type infirmary 53g Qgousehold goods,sales,repairs
342Qnoctoz/dentist o££ice 579 QMOtor vehicle/boat sales/repair
' 131 Q��ch, place of wosship 361 Pxison or ail, not uveni.le
❑ J 7 571 Q Gas or sezvice station
161 Q�s��ant os cafetezia qlg 1-or 2-Eami.l dwellin
162 QSaz/Taveax or nightclvb � y g 599 � ausiness o£fice
213 QElementary school ox kindergazten 429 ���- g �.ly dw�lli.ng 615 Q Electric genexating plant
439 Roomin /l�oaxdia house 629 Q LabosatoryJsci.ence lab
215 Q6iqh school or junior hagh 449QCa�ercial hotel or motel 700 ❑Manufacturiag plant
241 QC011ege, adu].t educatioa 459Qxesidentiai, boazd and care 819 QS.ivestockJpoultry stozagelbaxn)
311 Qcaze £acility Por the aqed 464 Qnormitosylbazxacka 882 ❑NOn-seaidential pazkin
331 �$osp�r.a�. 519 Food and bevei g �� ge
� age sales gg7, ❑ Wasehouse
Outside 93 ( Q Vacant lot 981 Q Construction site
12A QPiaygrouad ot paxk 938 �=aded/caze Eor plot o£ land 984 Q=ndustxiai plant yard
655 []Crops ox oschazd 946 QLake, xivex, stream
669 Forest (tambexl.axad) noo�p ana ence� Pzoperty Ose roae o�i �.
BSS QRaa.lxoad sight o£ way you have xOx cteckea a pronerty ose nox:
607 �outdoor storage azea 960 QOthex street pronesty Use 419
919 QDUmp or sanita �, landfill 961 QN=-ghway/divided ha.ghway
931 Q�P� land or field g62 ❑gesidential street(dciveway �l or 2£amily dwelling �
NFIRS-1 Rev�.sion 03 il 99
c,,.,« o�„i �,.o ne...,_«mo�« .__
in_�z�
A MM DD YYYY 'V V
62210 u 11 03 2009 07 �09-0028588 � 001 ❑ �� -2
FDID Sta[e � ❑��-'�9e
* * _nciaent �a:e * stexvon xnciaen: xumbez * �;nosuze * � NO Activity Fire
$ Property DEtai.ls (,' On-$it0 Materials�xone ca�iece �t u,ere �+e=e a.,y si4.�,ri�a„c
amoun[s of co�ercial,indus[rial, eneryy o:
OD p=OC�liC'CS agrscul[ural plotlucts oi materiais on [ne
oropecty, whe[net oz no[ they became tnvolvetl
a'r.tex un to thzee codes. Check oee
Bl ��02 �NOt ResidP�tiy1 0: r�ore box_s °or _acr. cade ente�ed_
1 sulk storage or wazehousing
cs[inated Nvmber of resitlentia2 2ivi�g ¢�its _n �� �NOne I 2�ProceSSinq oa maiyta�gc�y
bui�cing oP origin vnetner oz not a21 uni[s pa_gise vz:eriai (il 3 Hackaged goods £ox Sa1e
became involved 4 REpaiL or seivice
1 �BUlk storage or wazehousi,ng
B2 �_� �Hui.ldings not involved �J I � 2 Processiag or manvfacturing
N�.iber of buildings involved on-siCe �cezia'_ {2) 3 Packa4ed gooas fox Sale
4 Repait or sexvice
$3 �.. � �NOne 1 Su].k storage or wazehousing
Aczes buxned �� � � 2 Pro�essinq ox manu£actuxing
(outside £ires) �Less than one acre on-site mateaiai (3) 3 PaC.kaged goods for sale
4 Aepair or aexvice
Cause o£ Ignition
D Ignition �' �HUman Factoxs
�Cheek box if uis is m exposuse xepoxG. COatribu�':^' To IgIIitioa
skvp to aeetvov G Check all applicable boxes
j�l 76 �Wall sur£ace: ezterior � 1 Ozn�'��� 1 �r,sie� �NOne
t ea of £ixe csvgin �. Z�i)xunkentional 2❑ Possibly impaired by
3 QFaiiure of equipment or heat source alcohol or drugs
D2 81 �Heat £rom direct £lame � 4 �r�t oF nature 3 �o�tt�aea p�son
Hea[ source * S QCause under iavestigation 4� Possibly mental disabled
U Cause undetermineC a£ter imi¢stigation 5 QPhysically Disabled
D3 1z IExterior wall coverinq � E2
Factors Contributing To Ignition 6 ��tinie persons >n„oi..ea
Item fimsc igaited * 1 Check Hoz yf fise aprea - NOIIe
❑�s confaned tn ob�ect 7, 1 � �Exposure £ire �� � D `°as a t'actor
o£ aiigin eaccor contrinutvng ao xgnieion (1) Estimated agE of �
�4 99 ' �Multiple tVpes of � person envolved
Type o. material R"'�N+rerl only ¢£ ¢{pm £nrst � I I
fizst lgnited ignite3 c�de is 00 ox <i0
Factor contributing To Igni[ion (2) ]. �Male 'Z �F�male
Fr Equipment Involved In Ignition E+ Equipment Power G Fire Suppression Factors
�HIone If Equipment vras not inwlved,5lup to
Section G �� � I Entea up to t3.ree Codes. �NOne
� � I cquipment Povea sovrce
equ�amenx m.,oi�ea � Equipment Portability �.� � �
I Fire suppression factoz (1�
Brand I 1 QPoi'�le
Motlel I I Q�Stationaiy � I I
? xe suppressaon factor I2)
Serial p' I Portable equioment normally can be
moved by one person, is designetl t � I I
q edi I ' be u5e in multiple locations, and
requiies no tools to install. Fxre suppxession Pactor (37
Fjl Mobile Property Involved Local Use
$2 Mobile Property Type 6 Make
�Pre-Fire Plazx Available
�NOne � I so� or ue i,�o�uon pmse�tta in
' thvs report may be based vpon seportr
1� Not involved m igziitton, but bvrned Mobile property typ¢ fx� other Agencies
2� Eavolved in ignition, but did not burn ❑PL9on L'epOxt attaChed
$❑ Zm.olved in igaition and burned �_� � ' �POlice repoxt attached
Mob118 nroperty make � COLOnet i'epOLt att2.C11E'd
(�othex reports attached
i oblie oronez[y mooel I Yea Y I
i vicense ?Sd[E NYmbec I 5� �VIN Ntwbei I
NE'IRS-2 Revasion 01/19/99
r�x�r�
Il Structu=e Type �t =2 gui.lding Status * z3 Buildi.ng * I4 Main F1oor Size* I'�'Z�'
xr eire .as xn enciosea cuiiuzns o a Stxuctuze
�=caniei�wie ,c.-„�rnse �iece Height
tl+e zest of rnis fo� covn: ue aooa as parc Fire
1� Enclosed Suilding 1[� IInder construcrion of ine niynesc sw�
2❑ Poxtable/mobile stsucture 2 Q Occwied s ooerating
3 Q�a strnctuxe 3 Q=�1.e, aot routinely used $e �0 u� �Ol $40
�S ❑ IInder ma"or renovation w n�� or .mi,.a.
4❑ Ai.i suppotted structuze � as ez ��'_ Total squaze £eet
$❑ TEnt 5� Vacant and secuied Q �
❑� P 6 ❑Vaca.nt aad unsecurea �
6 latfosm ce.s. n_ezs� '
7 ❑eeing de�olisfied
7 QUnderground stiuctuie ��..ock azeas) P ' °�� °= °'O""
� O Q other '�'°" �+^^ u L__I BY I i
$ Connective structure � � � 1 �__a .
0 Q ottier type of structure U❑ Und¢termined �gnt in feet w>ar.t� in t�t
J1 Fire Origin * �j3 Number o£ Stories g Matezial Contributing Most
Damaged By Flame To Flame Spread
00 ❑8elow Giade Count the AOOF as part o£ the highest story Ski To
Check >£ no Hame spread P
St02'y o£ EiSe oLi(JSil OR same as material fsrst ignitetl S2CLlon L
� Nimbei oE stnries w/ manos damage OA vnable to dete^mine
(1 t0 2d§ £lame tlamaqe)
J2 Eire Spread * N � r � s w � gy � � F{1 �_� f �
S❑COn£ined to object of origin � 125 to C9t Y1ame tlyvaqe) Stem caatnbvtmg mos[ to .lame spread
2❑COn£iaed to xoOm oE orig�.n 1 1 N� oE stoxies v/ heavy tlamage Vn �
3❑COn£ined to Fioor o£ origin �—� (50 to �E8 flame damage) t �� I ,
4❑ Conf3ned to bw.lding o£ origin Type o£ matezial contn➢utmg Req�nretl only if itea
I Nwnbea of storyes v/ e%treme damage most o£ f}a0e spiead Conttibuting
r 3 �Seyond buildtng o£ osigin 1�� p5 to 1oD& £lame rLVOage) cotle ss 00 ox<oo
I,1 Presence of Detectors.k j�3 Detector Power Supply j,5 Detector Ef£ectiveness
(In azea oF the fire) Rerni+rgd if deteCtoi opeZ'ated
N QNOne Present Skip to 1 Qeattery only
section M 'z Qgazdwize only 1 QAlerted Occupants, oc�vpants responded
j QPSesent 3 Q P1ug i.n 2 QOccupaats £ailed to respond .
U LA] Undetexmi.ned � Q$azdwire with battery 3[]�ese were no occupants .
� 5 Q Plssg i.n with battery 4 I] Failed to alert occupants
6 QMecLanical U QIIndetermined
T,2 Detector Type �❑��le aetectors s
1[�smoke I�`� supplies Ts6 Detector Failure Reason
Q QOther Requixed if detector Eailed to opesate
2 Q 8eat U �Undetexmined
3 Q Combination smoke - heat S❑ POwei failure, shutoEP ox disconnect
L4 Detector OpeZ'ation 2 Q�pxopex installation or placement
4�] Sptuilcles, watex Elow detection 1 QP'ire too sma11 3❑nefective
to activate 4 Q Lack o£ ma.i.ntenance, a.ncludes cleaning
5 More thaa 1 type presesst
2 Qoperated 5[�Hattery missing or disconnected
(COmplete Sectioa L5)
O[]Other 6 OBattery discharged or dead
3 Q Failed to Operate 0 Other
LT ❑Undetermi.ned <Complete Section l6) ❑Uadetermiaed
LJ Q Undetesmined U �
Mj Presence of Automatic Extinguishment Sy9tem �. � Automatic Extinm'; s�ent � Asstcma}yc Extinm': shmeat
N❑None Pxesent System Opesation System Failure Reason
COIDplet2 ie3t R�'vred i£ fvre was vithvn deszgned range �q�ixea i£ system failed
�- � PLeS � t of Section M 1❑�P�rated fi effective (6o to MG
2 QOperatzd 5 not effeCtive �q�l �System shut o££
Type of Automatic Extinarn 5].stem * 'z QNOt enough agent discharged
Regvired if fire xas mithin designed range of AES 3❑Fire too Small to aCtivate
1 QWet pipe spninkles 4 QF'ailed to operate (co to 135) 3 ���t discharged but did
2 � Dry pipe sprinkles 0 Q other not reach fine
3 Q 0�1aer sprinkler system U QOndetexmined 4 Q W=ong type oF system
4❑ Dxy chemical system 5❑ Fixe not in azea protected
S QFOam system �j Number o£ Spxinkler 6 QSystem comaonents damaged
6 Qftalogen type system $g� OPerating 7 OLack o£ maintenance
Required i£ syst�n operatefl 8❑MdRll31' $ISteNERt10R
�❑Cazbon dioxide (COp) system 0 QOthes
Q �Othex special hazazd system L I ❑
U Undetermined Numbe= OF spzinkier neaas operatinq U II�g�_���,agi� O1/19199
10-232
Person/Entity Involved � �
incal Optvon Huaness nzme fif apgliczkle)
u - u-u
AiEa CoE2 PhoeG Y�llyhCi
� Ceeck 'hns 3ox a.` � � _ � � � � ��
same adtlie55 a5 '���• Ers. cst Nav.e M? Last Name Su:$x
_ncnaenc locat>on. I
?hen sklp �the Chiee � I 1 '
dunlicace dCess h�ei p St_eet ox ?ighuxy I S:ieet �
__ es.
'%Pe Sc.:ix
� � u �
?os. o£f+_ce aox P.{�L/Smte/aoo� �:�
u u-u � . �
Stace yip �de
�MOre people involved? Check this box aad attach Supplemental Forms (NFIRS-1S) as aecessary
'j Q� ❑ Same as persoa lnvoloed?
x:�en cnecx ttis mx aad skip ID��g pROPERTIES LLC � 612 - 338 - 6219
The rest o: YC1s sectlon.
Local ootion Busvness name (i£ Anplira'ole) Azea Cotle Phone Avmbez
u � iu� � u
Check this box a£ A1I..M5.. M[s. Firse Name MI Lasc NRme Suf£1x
same aadress as
incident locaCion. f(j71 � L� �SIBLEY MEMORIAL � HWY ��
TSen sY.sp t�e tbiee
duplicaie atltlYess Nvmbei Pyefix Stre¢[ oi Hvqhvay Stieet Type SuPfix
11nes.
I I �_� ,WEST ST PAOL �
Past offnce eox APt./SUnte/Raom City
u �55��8 ,-��
SCate Znn code
L Remarks
Local Op[ioa
FIRE EXTEN520N TO EXTERIOR VINYL SIDING DUE TO MAIN FIRE AT 836 JESSAMINE.
ESTIMATED DOLLAR LOSS CHANGED FROM $10,000 TO $2,7D0 ACCORDING TO STATE FARM INSURANCE
COMPANY AND THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY. 12/03/2009 SU
[� Authorization
� 3163 � � MCCIIB, MP,RK T
OE£icex in rhaige ID Slgnatuze
I150 � �C3 � il 09 2009
Yosi<ion oz iank ASSiqnment MontA Day Yeai
io `,t �� 3163 � LMCCUE, MARK T
same
:s O££icez Membei making cepott ID SignaYUre
:n cnarqe.
�150 � �C3 ��11� u � 20
Pos¢t1o¢ oz xank Ass1tJ[lment Montti Day Tea[
10-232
Ms1 DD
XYYY ❑neiexe xF'xxs 1
62210 u 11 03 2009 �7 �09-0028589 � 002 ��,.,i�ge easic
�in * s[ace �, mcaaent oaee * s-.auov muaen: uimber * : oosu;e *
❑ �o acn�,,c
❑Ctl[ck Chia box m.�uwm uz- rn= aet�.� �o: :.ns., �:,c_aeo: �. a:o.za�e e� me w.ieim= � ensus Trac�
B LoCltloniC emem. m s�RO� a�:,ie:,-�u.� ;,o�uan sa«���ese�•. a�< a:ix ==c w�z�a t.��. I � � 031�. - QO
�Street addtess 832 L� I
� JESSP.2ffNE I AVE � �
Iatersectioa ,;�yez/azieoosc nreeix sxreec o_ �iynway
QIn £roIIt o£ S:ree[ xype Su.`fix
� ttear of �� � SAZNT PAi7L �� J 5510 6 -� J
P.eC.lSeite/ROOS CiYy State Zi? Code
QAdjacent to I I
�Directions
c.oss s,.reet o. rLr=ccnoas, x nolicx�l
C Incident Type * El Date & Ti.mes ��ght is o00o Ez Shift 6 Alarms
111 Lsuilding fire � cneck ooxes �f Month Da Yeaz ar Min sec 1 °cai opc�on
Inc!dert T e dates zre tue Y I (�,'
- SdIDE 25 ALdLID �� d1M3}�5 SP(]IllZ2G �(! � I�/11 D3
Aid Given or Received* na ��'m * 11 03 2009 05:32:24 � ``-
D Shift or Alarms Du:nc[
Yla[oon
1 OMUtva1 aid seeeived ��� requssea, uniess cancelea os aia noc arnoe
2�isutomatic aid tew. �� � �'rival * 11 03 2009 05:34:22 �.
The1r EDID TEevr
3 ���az aid given s co�^rqor.uen optionai, ex�eot coz „>>�uaz,a rires Special Studies
4 QAUtomatic ai.d given I I �Controlled L� L_� �1� ' iocai option
5❑Other aid given xneir �.AST UNxT CLEppED, xeqvarea excene for wilalana `.a:es �� �-�
N ONOR@ Incldent Number Z.d9t IInit SpeGial Special
� Cleazed 11 L03I 2009 10:28:36 stvay inx scudy vawe
F' Actions Taken * G1 Resources * GZ Estimated Dolla= Losses 5 Values
� Check this box and skSp tAis j�pSSES: Re d foi all fvies if know. Optional
section f an Apparatus or for�noa Eires.
72 I581vAge fi OVOihaul ' aerso�el fosm is usea. None
Piimary Action xaken ti7 APPazatus aersoruiel ptopesty $'�� � 002 , 000 �
�' � suppression 0015 �_�COatents $�J 000 � 000 �
Rdditional Action Taken (9 E � `�J �� p�,"—$�C=pgjT �ipLVE: pPtional
O'FS]0S ' I I C � ' � , � ❑
� I `�--' `�-' BrcPerty y ��� Q��
Add¢tlonal ActiOn ^.aken (3� ❑ Check box If xesoume mmts
inclvde aid rCCeiced resWrces. COIIt2S1tS $�� � 00� � QQQ ❑
Completed Modules �1*Casualties�xone $3 Hazazdous Materials Release = Mixed Use Property
�Fire-2 Deaths Iajuties N❑NOne NN Not Mixed
X Structure-3 ' Fire ZO AssemUly use
I ' I '1�Natur8l Gas: mo. ix.t, a� � e.�.n.x .�to�
�Civil Fire Cas.-4 service L�J L� z � " IIOa4ay .° 20 Educat3on use
P 4� �<zi ss,. s�e �.. � e� �a s=.�i� 33 Medical use
�Fire Serv. Cas.-5 �,vilian�J L� 3 QGasoline: ,.�n,u� �,u s„k ,,. p��,y� = , a .""' : 40 Residential use
EMS-6 � 51 Row of stores
�2 Detector 4 xerosene: f,,.a n,a,� �e�c a: w=«.ei� .�.�
� flazMat-7 53 Enclosed ma11
aequizea co� co�tinea e��es. 5�Diesel �uel/£uel oil:.,v,;u� �. �, i„�i� 58 eus. s Residential
�Wildlaad Fire-8 1❑ net � to aieL e��� 6 QBwaehold solvents: a�ieta« �.v, m�,�,m 5g OEfice use
�X I+PPazatus-9 '] ❑MOtoz oil: x.m m�+,� � e=�� �c.s,.=x 6� Tndustrial use
�aersonnel 20 netector ana aot aiert tAem 63 Militaxy use
8 QPaint: E� "°," � um� < ss g
�z�son-il UQon.t,w.m OQOther:se�aza�=.�c�e„�Ra>�mv..>ss�., 00 OYhex
Pi�.e �i� ue e.uwe :e�
J PrOpeTty Use* Structures 3410Clinic,clinic type in£iFinazy 5390gousehold goods,sales,xepairs
342❑Doctor/deatist office 579 ❑MOtor vehicle/boat sales/zepaix
131 Q���h� place of worship 361 Prisoa or
� jail, not juvenile 571 Q Gas or service station
161 QRestauYant or cafetesia ¢yg 1-or 2-Eamil dwelli.n
� X 4 599 Q�si.ness ofPice
162 []$�1Tavern os nightclub 429❑M dwelling 615 �Electric generating plant
21,3 ❑Element 1 school ot kindezgazten 439QROOmi.ng/boarding house 629 QLaboratoxy/science lab
215 QHigh school ox jvxsior high 449❑COmmezcial hotel oz motel 700 Q2�aauEacturiag plant
241 QC011ege, adult edsscatioa 459QResidential, boazd and caze 819 [�1'd.vestock/poultxy stosage(barn)
311 QCare facility for the aged 464 Dormito /bazracks Non-residenti,al
331 Aospital � � 882 ❑ pazking garage
❑ 5190Food aad beverage sales gg1 QWarehouse
Wtside g36 Qvacant lot 9B1 Q Constxuction site
12Q QPlayground or pazk 938 QGraded/caze for plot of land 989 Q Industrial plant yaxd
655 QCrops ot ozchazd 9t]6 QI,a}:e, river, stream
669 QForest (timbezland) 951 Railnoad xi ht o£ wa zoomup ana ence: a Property Use �oae onzy �z
807 Outdooi stoia azea � g y you have xoT cneckea a pxoperty Ose box:
❑ � 960 Other street
919 QDUmp or sanit� 1• laad£ill g61 ❑gignway/divided highway p ��� �se 419
931 ��P�+ land or field g52 ��sia�t�az street/driveway �1 or 2 family dwelling �
NE'IRS-1 Revision 03 il 99
c,.... o�..i c,..e n,._,..�___�
1U-232
j.1� MM D� YYYY �oelene
u u u u u u� � u❑ '�� - 2
62210 MN 11 03 2009 07 09-0028589 002 Chanqe pire
ecxn * s.ate � :nciaenc na:e * sczc>on ���iaenc x�ner * c�mosure 'k � no acc_o'�
NOIIe co¢qilete i: Uere vere any sag[u!S<a�c
$ Pxoperty Details C On-Site Materials�f � of covxerual,antlustr:al, e e-� o _
OS Produets ayilcul[ural piotiv¢s ot materlals m Ciie
_ oper[y� vnetn?z oi not [ney Decame anvolvetl
'cnter up to three codes. Check one
0001 Not Residential or nore �oxes °w eaci code enterec.
Bl � � ❑ 1�Hulk storage ot cnuehousi.ng
2s[amat=d Nvmber of reside,t:aZ 1i✓:ng vnits in LNNN 1 INone I'L ProCessing or mamyfaCtui'ing
�uilding of origin whe�er oz �o: aZl uni[5 p�_s�te cate^a1 (17 3 packaged goods for sale
became invo2ved 4 Repaix oz service
1 Bulk stoxage ox waxehousing
$2 �_� �Buildings not involved �� L I 2 ProCess'^g or manu£aCturing
Nu.-�Der oE buiidings :nvolved on-site macesial (21 ,3 packag�d goods for sale
4 Aepaix or service
$3 L__� �NOne ' I 1 Bulk storage ox warehousing
Acres burned L�I � � 2 P ���� g � °i �����
(oueside fizesl ❑�ss than one acxe �-site material (3� g 8ackaged goods for sale
4 Repair or service
Cause of Ignition gvman Factors
D Ignition El �� m; yf � is �� S,.ro ��rt. �Cantributuig To Ignition
Sk>p to seccvon G Check a11 applicable boxes
Dl 76 �Wall sur£ace: exterior I 1 �_°�"�°� 1�z,�ie� �xone
nxea o£ fxre oxigin * 2❑17n.iDientional 'Z ❑POSSibly impairsd by
3 QSai.lure o£ equipment on heat soutce aleohol or dsvgs
DZ B1 �Heat £rom direct flame, � 4 �a�n of natvre 3 D Unattendzd pecson
�eat source * S❑Cavse undzc investigation 4❑POSS>bly mental disabled
U�Caus¢ undeterminsd a£ter investigation $❑Physically Disabled
Factors Contributing To Ignition 6❑M�ltrple persovs �n,.oi,.ea
D3 gg �MUltiple items £irst � L''2
Item fisst i lted 1 �eck Hwc it £vre spxea ❑NOnO �
m * ❑was �o�inea to ot�ect 71 7 Ase was a factoc
L_� �Exposure £ire
oE oc�in pactor conizibuting xo xgnitioa (17 � Estimated age o£ ' 1
J son envolved �--J
D 4 T� lerial xequvsed o�Y iE item fvist ' I I I Pe=
£izst iqnieed vgnited code rs 60 or <l.a u '
Factor Contributmq To Ignntion (2) 1❑�10 Q�F�ale
E , 1 Equipment Involved In Ignition E+2 Equipment Power G Fire Suppression Factors
�NOne if Equipment Nas not involved,Skip to � I
Section G u Eates Up to three codea. �NOne
I I� I Equvpment eover Source
L.-1
svuiamens x.,,,oi..ea � gqiyipment Poi't7bility U � �
Fize supp[ession facYo[ Q1
Brand � � 1 ❑POStable I I
Model I � Q�Stationazy p3=e Supprissnon facmr !2I I
Serial #� I Portable eqmpment normally can be
moved bY one pexson, is tlesigved t � I I
I I be use in multiple locations, and suppressaon factor p)
Year requires no tools to install. Fire
Mobile Pro ert Involved Local Use
�. P Y $2 Mobile Property Type 6 Make �pie Plaa Available
� None �, I so� or cna ,�o�e,.e� a�senrza ��
tkis xeport may be based upon zeports
�. Not involved in igzv.tion, but bvrned
Mobile property type Fxom other Agencies
�L ❑ Involved in iqni.uon, but did not burn ❑2izson repoit attached
.3 Q Involved in igcuti.on and burned L_� � I ❑POlice reporC attaChed
Mobile pxonexty make � COSOIIES neport attached
�othez zepoxts attached
� � � I
moblae pxoperty motlel Yeai
� �u� �
License elate Numbex State 'JiN N*mbez
NFIRS-2 Rev3sioa O1/19/99
I1 Structure ey� 10-232
TYP =2 Building Status * Tg guilding *=4 �yin F1oor Size* �'=�"
ir c e vae In ertclosed buvldv�y o a
portable/mobile scr„�cuze ��i Height structu=e
:Ae xest o: this :o� count [he ROOF as part Fire
�. � EnCloSed Bvi.ldiag 1❑ under coasL.�ction o£ tne tnghest story
2 Q Portable/mobile structure 2❑ Ocevpi� s op�ating
3 QoPen staicture 3 Q Id1e, not routinely used =0 00 u� 001 600
4❑ P.i.r supported stzucture 4❑ Under major r¢novation w=�� =a =m� Totai srnure Peet
$ Tent 5� Vacan: and seeured �� �""
�i Q�pen plat£orm 6 Qvacaut and vnseeuzed � �R
fe.a. oie-s7
7 IIxide2 ound StruCtUre 7 Q Heang demolished ,�._, p^y' e _ a �
8 ❑ st' �wozk azeas� O❑ orher neaa, s�� L�1 ,�_� BY �---i • L�.��
�COI3IleCt1V2 StSl3ctll2e �e.y. feaces)
0❑ Other type o£ stn3cture V Q Undetexmtned Lenght in £eet Widtt� in Eeet
J1 Fire Origin * J3 Number o£ Stories R Material Contributing Most
Damaged By Elame To Flame Spread
002 �Below Gxade Count the AppF as parG o£ the kughest story
� Check i£ no £l�e spzeaa Skip To
StoYy o£ fire OZigin � H�t of stozies w/ mvnor amaqe oR imable aetetmine st rgnited y�e1tiop I.
(3 to 2G& flase davage)
J2 Fire Spread * � I i, I
N�mDer of storaes v/ svgu£imnt damage �-----�
25 to d9& £lama Item con[sibvtln9 mOSt to f!ame spieaC
�. Con£ined to object o£ ocigin � �9e)
2�Con£inM to room o£ origin � p�r of scones w/ h¢avy damage p,�
3�COn£ined to Flooa o£ origsn ISO to '!48 Ylame damzge� t � �� I I
Q❑COnEined to building o£ osigin �yPe o£ matexial conYxibut>ng Rewired only if item
I � xiaeber of sWries v/ extcem¢ dynag¢ most of flame spzeatl contribu[>ng�
5�Heyond bvilding o£ origin {_ f"!5 to 1008 £lame eamsge� mde s o0 r<'ro
Ty1 Presence of Detectors * 1,3 Detector Power Supply j�5 Detector E£fectiveness
(In azea oE th¢ Eice)
Required i£ detector opesated
N�NOne Preseat Skip to 1❑ Sattery only
sectioa M 2 Q Hazdwise only 1 QAlezted oceupants, occupants responded
1 QPresent 3❑ plug ia 2 QOCCUpants Failed to respond
U� Undetermined 4 Q Hazdwize with battery 3 Q�ere wexe no occupants
5 Q Plug ia with battezy 4 Q Failed to alest occupants
6 Qatechaxiicai U Qtmaetexminea
I,2 Detector Type �❑M„��le detectoxs s
1 Q Smoke
powez supplies L6 Detector Failure Reason
Q❑othen - Rem af detector failed to operate
2 � Aeat Lj Q Undetermined
1 Power £ailure, shuto££ or disconnect
3 Q co�ovinat�.on smoke - heat j�4 Detector Operation
2 Q Improper installation or placement
4 Q Sprinklet, water £low detection �- Q Fi.xe too small 3 Q DeEective
to activate 4 O Lack o£ maiatenance, includes cleaning
5❑ More than 1 type present 2 Opesated
❑ 5❑ Hattery mi.ssaxvq ox disconnected
(COmplete 3ectlon L5)
O DOther 3 Q Failed to Opezate 6 �Battery dischazged or dead
U QUndetermtned <Complete Section L6) � �
U Q Undetesminefl U Qundetermaned
� PLesenCe oF AutomatiC Extinguishment System * p�ytomatic E%+;n
1`Z3 q�.shment M5 P,utomatiC Extinguishm_nt
N QNOne PseSent SYs� Operation System FailutE ReasoII
Complete rest R�"i:ea sf rire ..as .,�tt.,.� aes�y.,ea :ange qeqpysed if
system £ailed
]_ QPresent o£ Sectioss M � QOPexated 6 effective ��o co ai4
� * 2 Q aperated s aot ef£ective �y�l Q System shut off
1�pe o£ Automatic F�ctinm'.shmr_nt stem
Requirnd yE fire vas within designed rang¢ oE AES
3 Q Fire too small to activate 2 Q Not enougL agent dxscharged
1 QWet pipe spra.nkles 4 QFailed to operate (co to afs) 3 �I'geT dischatged but did
2 Q Dzy pipe spzinkler 0 Q otlaer not reach £ire
3 Q other sprinklex system U �undetermined ¢[] �rong type of sys
4 � nry �t,emioai system 5 Q Fire not in azea protected
5 Q Foam system M4 N��r of Sprinkler 6 Q System components damaged
Heads Operating 7 QLack oF inaintenance
6 Q�3alogen type system
�� Carbon dioxide (W p) syst� Reausred iE system operated 8 QM�ua1 Intervention
0 [� Other
0 ❑Other special hazai�d system ❑
U IIndetesm.ined N�F sprinkler heads opex�ating U �� geV1sion Ol/19/99
;aint Paul sirp nwa�rment
i n ���
Rl Person/Entity Znvolved � I � J_ L�_�_ J
Local Option Busvness name (vf appivcaSle)
?Se2 COOe PLo!,e YLL+Sei
❑ ChecY. ?his 3v.t i£ ��S Mrs I EicST Name I � � I �
52IDe dtlGL¢55 5 N.i LaSi NdIDe Su££1X
1 ¢¢RC SOC2LiOR. I
:hen sk:o {];e [4iee I ' �
duplicx.e ac�2iess ,�, l�l
3ines. __ :?x S.Ceei or -lghvay SLr �
I I � I SUf.ix
Post Of$ce 3ox �Y./Stz[e/3oom � :ty '
u u—u
s.aze ��P �de
� More people involved? Check this boz anrl attach Supplemeatal Fo�s (NFZRS-15) as necessazy
K 2 Owner � Same as oerson aavolved?
xhea me�x m�� nox a�a �x�P (MENDOTA PARTNERS Li�C � 651 — 247 — 369Q
The :es[ o£ thls section.
Locd1 OpCaon Husmess name (i£ Applvcable) Area Code PSOne NumCei
u � iu� � �
❑ Check thvs box nf Mc.,HS., Hrs. FixsY Nave HI Last Name Suffnx
same addYess as
inciasnt!oweion. �2104 ( u �FORD
rhen kip ahe [hree N�er rretix stzeet oz H1gRway I P � �
auplicate daress
lines. Sczeet Sype 5u£fix
� I 2�1 (SAINT PAUL �
eost of£nce Hox �t./SU1te/AOOm City
� 55� 16 �—u
5cate Zin Code
j� Remarks �
Local Option
FIRE EXTENSTON TO EXTERIOR VINYL SIDING DUE TO MAIN FIRE AT 836 JESSAMINE.
Authorization
�3163
OE3icei m charge ID
i,MCCUE, MARK T
Signature
�150 I �C3 � 11 04 2009 I
Posvtnon oz rank Asslgnm.ent Mon:h Day Teaz
'�. eox`;c � � 3163
s�ame
s OfE¢rei MemDel making repoY ID
1n chaiqe.
�MCCUE, MARK T
siqnature
�150 I �C3 I�11J u 2009I
Positlon o_ rank Asslgmnent Month Day Yeai
10-232
Saint Paul Fire Department
FIRE INCIDENT DISPOSITION
INCIDENT NCtI�SR: 928589 DATE OF INCIDENT: 11-03-09
TSME OF INCIDENT: 0532 POLICE CASE #: 09-234-942
INVESTIGATOR(s): Minkkinen, Duraine
II3CIDENT ADDRESS: 1.836 3essamine Avenue E
2.840 Jessamine Avenue E
3.832 Jessamine Avenue E
OCCTSPANT: Vacant pgp�
��R: 1.Flagstar Bank pgp�;
2.Danmark Prop LLC 2.612-338-6219
3.Mendota Part. LI,C 3.651-247-3690
ADDRESS: 1.5151 Corporate Drive,Troy MI 48098-2639
2.971 Sibley Memorial Highway,West St Paul,MN 55118-5109
3.2100 Ford Parkway/Suite 201,St Pau1,MN 55116-1950
PROPEATY DAMF:GED: 1.Duplex AREA OF ORIGIN:SE l Floor (836)
2.Duplex Extension to exterior vinyl siding
3.Single Family Dwelling of 840 (east) and 832 (west)
DAt�IflGE ESTSI�TE: B�lding 1.100, 00�
2.10,000 Vehicle Other(Describe)
3.2,000
Building 1.125,400
VALUE: 2.126,000 Vehicle Other(Describe)
3.125,200
Damage Estimate
CONTENTS ONLY:
INJURY/DEA.TH � No � Yes
(if yes, explain)
SMOKE DETECTOR/ Smoke Detector Present: � Yes � No
SPRINRLER Detector Funetioniag: � Xes � No � Unknown
INFORMFITION: Sprinkler System Present: � Yes � No
Sprinkler Heads activated: � Yes # � No
FIRE CAIISE: � Accidental � Juvenile/Incendi.ary
� Incendiary � Chi1d (under 10 years o1d)
� Natural
� Undetermined/Under Investigation
SYNOP5IS: Flames showing from rear of vacant house,origin in l Ploor
kitchen (SE corner). Neighbors stated 2 adult males seen
entesing and leaving house frequently for at least 1
montn,notified police last week. Extensive overhaul required
due to balloon construction and duration of fire prior to
discovery.
10-232
DISPOSITION:
E-mail only
Narrative written
Report to Follow
� Hold Scene
� Scene Released
of Evidence
�FSS Fo*_�;n '141 (06/10/09)
10-232
PAGE 1 OF 4
FIRE INVESTIGATION REPORT
INCIDENT N0: 928589 DATE: 11/03/2009 TIME: 0532 HOiJRS
ADDRESS: 836 JESSAMIIdE AVE E INSURANCE C0: UNKNOWN
DAMAGE ESTIMATE: $100,000 CN#: 09-234-942
$10,000 (840 Jessamine) -
$2,000 (832 Jessamine)
SYNOPSIS: On Tuesday, November 3, 2009, at 0532 hours a report of a dwelling fire was
received. The location of the incident was 836 Tessanvue Avenue East with fire extansion to the
exteriozs of the adjacent homes at 840 Jessamine Avenue East and 832 7essamine Avenue East.
The origin of fhe fire was within the first IIoor kitchen, southeast corner. 'I'he cause of the fire is
undeternuned pending further investigation.
PEOPLE: Properry Owner, FLAGSTAR BANK, 5151 Corporate Drive, Troy, Michigan,
48098-2639,1-800-945-7700.
840 7essamine Avenue Owaer, DANMARI� PROPERTIES, LLC., 971 Sibley Memorial
Highway, West St Paut, Mianesota, 55118-5109, 612-338-6219.
832 Jessamine Avenue Owner, MENDOTA PARTNER3, LLC., 2100 Ford Parkway, Suite
#201, St Paul, 55116-1950, 651-247-3b90.
9-1-1 Catler,
Neighbor, DON TELIN, 835 Magnolia Avenue East, 55106, 651-776-5766.
Engine #17 Captain, STEVE Sf3APIKA.
Engine #7 Captain, JOHN HAGEMAN.
BACKGRO UND: I received notificafion of the fire via the Communications Center. I
responded to the incident scene to begin my fire investigation. At the time of my arrival, fire
companies were in the process of extinguishing tke fire.
PROPERT'I' DESCRIPTION: TTie building of fire origin was a two story, wood frazned,
upper and lower duplex of balloon construction. The exterior contained vinyl sidiag over asphalt
siding over wood lap siding. Interior finishes contaiued latk and plaster. The roof contained
asphalt shingles. Approximate exterior dimensions were 42 feet Iong by 28 feet wide. The
address side of the properiy £aced north. Entry way doozs were located on the north side with
two separate entry way doors on the south side; one for the first floor and exterior wooden steps
leading to the second floor.
io-232
Fire Investigarion Report
836 7essamine Avenue East
Page Two
According to the property records, the duplex was a registered vacant building. Xcel billing
records indicated no power and no gas services to either the first or second floors.
The exposure properly to the east at 840 Jessamine Avenue East was a two story, wood framed,
balloon constr�cted duplex. The e�erior contained vinyI siding and the roof contained asphalt
shingles. The address side of the property faced north. Enhy way doors were located on the
north, east, and soutlz sides of the first floor. According to property records, the duplex was a
registered vacant building.
The exposure properry to the west at 832 Jessamine Avenue East was a two story, wood framed,
bailoon constructed single family dwelling. The ea�terior contained vinyl siding and the roof
contained asphalt shingles. The address side of the property facad north. Entry way doors were
located ori the north and south sides. The structure had a reatty company for sale sign posted on
tlie north side.
EXT'ERIOR EXANIINATION: Visual examina#ion offhe properiy o£fire origin at 836
Jessamine Avenue East noted blackening of the exterior from the first floor southeast comer
upwazd, to the roof on the south and east sides. The fire damage extended to the south eicterior
wooden stairs. Smoke staining to the vinyl siding was visible above the windo on the north
and west sides.
Inspecrion of the property located at 840 Jessamine Avenue East noted melting of the vinyI
siding on the west side. All entry way doors were secure. No other fire damage was noted.
Examination of the property at 832 Jessatuine Avenue East noted melfing of fhe vinyl siding on
the east side. No other fire damage was noted.
INTERIOR EXAII�IINATION: Visual exaznination of the proper[y of fire origin at 836
7essamine Avenue East
Fire damage extended throughout the first floor to the dining room and entry way hall. Fize
damage was also noted upward along the north entry way interior stair�vell.
Due to the bailoon construction, fire damage extended upward within the lath and plaster exterior
wall spaces to the second floor and downward along the wood framework of the basement
ceiling.
10-232
Fire Investigation Report
836 Jessamine Avenue East
Page Three
No interior fue damage was noted to the pmperties of fsre extension at 840 Jessamine Avenue
East or 832 Jessamine Avenue East.
INTERVLGWS: Engine #17 Captain, STEVE SHAPIRA, stated:
• E na n e #17 was the first amving ftre company and positioned their muck in the alley to
the south of 836 Jessamine Avenue East.
• The entire soutk side of the structure was ful�y involved with fire.
• E�eriox flame height was above the roof line.
• Engine #17 crew members began ea�tingnishing the fire, but had to discontinue operations
due to the electrical service liae from the pole to the entry mast on the house dropping
across their engine.
Engine #7 Cantain. 70HN HAGEMAN stated•
• Engine #7 positionad their truck at the address sida of the structure.
• Fn�mne #7 firefighters forced enhy through the north door and advanced a&re line into
the structure.
Neiahbor, DON TELIN, stated:
• He lives across the alley, to the south of the fire dawaged house.
• The pmperty has been vacant for about a yeaz.
• He has seen two males going in and out of the building for about the last sis months,
• He thaught they must have a key because they were able to open fhe door.
• He knew the house was supposed to be vacant
� He called the po2ice last week when he saw the two males at the house.
10-232
Fire Investigalion Report
836 Jessamine Avenue East
Page Four
He would describe the iwo males as light skinned black males, approa�imately mid-30's.
One of the males was tatl and husky and the other was short
He has seen tiiem on bicycles on the south side of the house.
PHOTOGRAPHS: Digital photographs were taken.
CONCLUSION: After exanunation nf the fire scene, interviews conducted, and evidence
collected, the cause of the fire is uridetermined and will remain undetemvned pending further
ot�is hre resuited m extenor pmperty ciamage�o e� o tne east ana r.o tn�
This incident will be referred to the Saint Paul Pofice Deparin�ent for fizrther investigation.
A. Mivkkiven, Fire Inve tigator, C Shift, i l/17l2009
AM/su