Loading...
10-186Amended 2/17/2010 City of St. Paul RESOLUTION RATIFYING ASSESSMENT COi3NCIL FII,B NO. 10-186 B 38 File No. SEE BELOW Assessment No. SEE BELOW Voting Wazd In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for CRT0904 (108766) collection of delinquent certificate of occupancy fees. A public hearing having been had upon the assessment for the above improvement, and said assessment having been further considered by the Council, and having been considered finally satisfactory, therefore, be it RESOLVED, That the said assessment be and the same is hereby in all respects ratified. RESOLVED FURTHER, That the said assessment be and it is hereby determined to be payable in One equal installments. Yeas Nays Absent Adopted by the Council Bostrom Date: ����� Carter � Harris ✓ Certified Passed b the Council Secret Helgen � By: � Lantry �/ Stark �' Mayor: Thune �/� /o � / City of St. Paul Real Estate Division Department of Public Works REPORT OF COMPLETION OF ASSESSMENT COiJNCIL FILE NO. lo-1s6 File No. SEE BELOW Assessment No. SEE BELOW Voting Wazd In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for CRT0904 (108766) collection of delinquent certificate of occupancy fees. To the Council of the City of St. Paul The Valuation and Assessment Engineer hereby reports to the Council the following as a statement of the expenditures necessarily incurred for and in connection with the making of the above improvement, viz: Total costs Water Dept Service Fee DSI Administration Fee Code - Enforcement Service Fee Real Estate Service Fee $13,549.00 $ $ 2,500.00 $ $ 1,000.00 TOTAL EXPENDITURES Chazge To Net Assessment $17,049.00 $17,049.00 Said Valuation and Assessment Engineer further reports that he has assessed and levied the total amount as above ascertained, to-wit: the sum of $17.049.00 upon each and every lot, part or parcel of land deemed benefitted by the said improvement, and in the case of each lot, part or parcel of land in accordance with the benefits conferred thereon; that the said assessment has been completed, and that hereto attached, identified by the signature ofthe said Valuation and Assessment Engineer, and made a part hereof, is the said assessment as completed by lum, and which is herewith submitted to the Council for such action thereon as may be considered proper. Dated: �,��alu '�d Assessment Engineer: �r-s�9 ' ��`�-h�� 10-186 February 17, 2010 City Council Action Minutes Page 8 38. Resolution Ratifying Assessment — 10-186 — In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost, and expenses for collection of delinquent certificate of occupancy fees [CRT0904]. (GS 3087396-Ward 7) (Legislative Hearing Officer recommends the following: 1656 Bush Avenue (CRT0904) — delete the assessment; 776 Desoto Street (CRT0904) — decision forthcoming; anprove the assessment 1322 Desoto Street (CRT0904) — delete the assessment; 569 Lafond Avenue (CRT0904) — reduce the assessment from a total of $432 to a total of $198; 1917 Minnehaha Avenue West (CRT0904) — delete the assessment; 1810 Montana Avenue East (CRT0904) —° °° *'�° ����°°-�°r* reduce the assessment from a total of $262 to a total of $227; 586 Reaney Avenue (CRT0904) — approve the assessment; 979 Sherbume Avenue (CRT0904) — approve the assessment; 615 Snellin� Avenue North (CRT0904) — delete the assessment; and 1142 Van Buren Avenue (CRT0904) — approve the assessment.) Adopted as amended, per the recommendation of the Legislative Heari�g Officer Yeas — 6 Nays — 0 L �l _ �- � � Green Sheet Green Sheet /� �� _ �_ / � /�) 10-186 . v Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet � DepartrnenVOfficelCouncif: Date Inifiated: FS —FinancialServices OSNOV2009 Green Sheet NO: 3087396 Conpd Person & Phon€: Deoartrnent Sent To Person InitiaVDate LyMMOSBt L�im � 0 inantial5ervicec I LmMOSeY 266-8851 l� 1 ounc� M Erickson ' Assign 2. i Clerk Ci C7erk Must Be on Council Agenda by (Date): Num6er For Routing Doa T OTHER (DOESNT FITANY ��d� � CATEGORY) E-DOCUment Required: Y DoeumentContact: wmRanweiler Contaet Phone: 266-8856 Total S of Signature Pages _(qip All Locations for Signature) _ Action Requested: Set date of public hearing and apptove assessments for delinquent Certificate of Occupancy fee. File No, CRT0904. Recommendations: Approve (A) or Reject (R): Personal Service Contracts Must Mswer the Following Questions: Planning Commission 1. Has ihis persoNfirtn ever worked under a contract for this department? CIB Committee Yes No Civil Service Commission 2. Has ihis persoNfirtn ever been a aty employee? Yes No 3. Dces ihis person/firm possess a skili not normally possessed by any curtent ciry employee? � Yes No Exptain all yes answers on separate sheet and attach to green sheet Initiating Problem, Issues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why): Most commercial properties in Saint Paul require a Certificate of Occupancy in order to be legally habitable. 1'he Ciry chazges a fee for this certificate to cover its costs of inspection. The fees on the attached hearing list were previously invoiced, but remain unpaid. The City is authorized by ordinance to coliect unpaid fees via assessment. Advanpges IfApproved: The City may collec[ the fees to covet its inspection and enforcement costs. DisadvantageslfApproved: � None Disadvantages If NotApproved: The City may be unable to collect the fees to cover its costs via other means (e.g., registered bill)_ TotalAmountof $��049.00 � Transaction: CosftRerenue Budgeted: � Funding Source: Activity Number: financial Information: (Expiain) 50 property ownen will be notified of the public hearing and chazges. November 5, 2009 137 PM p � 10-186 January 5, 2010 Legislative Hearing Minutes 4. Summary Abatement Assessments: CRT0904 Collection of delinquent Certificate of Occupancy fees 1656 Bush Avenue (CRT0904) Page 7 Ms. Shaff stated that the C of O inspection bills were mailed on July 13 and August 12, 2009 to the C of O responsible party, Matthew Johnson in Woodbury. Since the bill was not paid, it went to assessment in the total amount of $262. Jennifer Archambault stated that she had been a tenant at the property since September 2008 and purchased it when the property went into foreclosure. The closing on the purchase of the property was July 26, 2009 and she did not believe she should be responsible far the C of O fees. Ms. Moermond stated that since Ms. Archambault did not receive proper legal notification, she recommended deleting the assessment. 1322 Desoto Street (CRT0904) Tooj Zeb Moua, property owner, appeared. Ms. V ang provided Hmong translation. Ms. V ang stated that according to Mr. Moua, he purchased the property on February 12, 2009 and has been living there ever since. Ms. Shaff stated that according to STAMP, the bills were sent to Tshu T. Yah, the previous owner and that this property was no longer a C of O building. She recommended the assessment be deleted. Ms. Moermond so noted for the record. 569 Lafond Avenue (CRT0904) Antonio Graj eda, property owner, presented a copy of the assessment letter and C of O bill for Ms. Moermond's review. Ms. Moermond noted tt�at five of the billings were from 2007 which was priar to the time the fees were allowed to be assessed; therefore, she recommended deleting the amount of those fees. Ms. Shaff stated that according to STAMP, bills were mailed on July 2 and August 3, 2009. Since the bill was not paid, it went to assessment. She said the correct amount of the bill with the reduction ofthe 2007 fees was $198. Mr. Grajeda aclrnowledged that he had a problem tenant at the property which resulted in multiple re-inspections in 2007; however, he believed he had paid the C of O fee for 2009. Ms. Shaff responded that it had not been paid which was why the bill had gone to assessment. Ms. Moermond recommended approving the assessment reducing the total fee from $432 to a total o£ $198. lals6 January 5, 2010 Legislative Hearing Minutes 1917 Minnehaha Avenue West (CRT0904) Ms. Shaff stated that the department recommended deleting the assessment. 1810 Montana Avenue East (CRT0904) � Ms. Shaff stated that the C of O inspection hills were mailed on August 4 and September 3, 2009 to the property owner, Scott Wilhelm in Maplewood. Since the bill was not paid, it went to assessment in the total amount of $262. She noted that the ownership of the property had been in dispute and there was a federal court ruling that rehuned the ownership of the property to David R. Johnson. David R. Johnson, property owner, stated that he had sold the property on contract for deed to Scott Wilhelm who then defaulted and the property was returned to him. Since he didn't know about the fees, he didn't believe he should be responsible for them, particulazly the $70 administrative fee. Ms. Moermond stated that the assessment went with the property and this was a private matter between himself and Mr. Wilhelm. She recommended approving the assessment. 586 Reanev Avenue (CRT0904) No one appeared; Ms. Moermond recommended approving the assessment. 979 Sherbnrne Avenue (CRT0904) No one appeared; Ms. Moermond recommended approving the assessment. 615 Snelline Avenue North (CRT0904) Ms. Shaff stated that the deparhnent recommended deleting the assessment. 1142 Van Buren Avenue (CRT0904) No one appeared; Ms. Moermond recommended approving the assessment. 10-186 February 2, 2010 Legislative Hearing Minutes 4. Laid over Summary Abatement Assessments: CRT0904 Collection of delinquent Certificate of Occupancy fees 776 Desoto Street (CRT0904) Page 9 No one appeared; Ms. Moermond recommended approving the assessment. � C L C. F F a U � � R R � �J � r 0 e a O T � O C ["i � a; 0 ..a V d 'o a .�, R y q �l ° on a c � L � N C u+ y L d C d 0 L c .�. ' i � � � = O Q .. �L A `m a a O O N � s a i � 7 I O �� I� � N I OD � N � O � l ooc o 0 0 0 0 I lV O O N v� �n N N � N !i EA m V? V3 I I I I O O O N � ti I IN I �000 0 00 i � N I I I ; I � � w � I T G ��G N C F a a�Q a I � w � �� E � C o Q 5"q � � U �l `r-.�' • I� z ,� O� IFF iQo Z o ,�n x ��� I¢ Q I r x I °�" � � I� Ix I� I� � � � �w o N � N �� N o a o �az ^a I�x�� � ���Q� I °�� °3� X R L 0 0 i � � � � N � .ti � .-� �� O � .� � . 0 o O I N I N I N I 'r .y � .�-i i ! i � � � � � � i I I I I O I O I O � i � � � � � o c o c �o 0 o c � c o 0 o c o c ���° � ���° N i I� E1j Vj V� �^� V± V3 N� f I I � I I I I I I IO O O IO O O I O O O O O C I � ,ti .r I � f. .� I I"' {'" I I I I I I I i oSo IoSo I � O N I� O O I I I I I I I I �� I I � � a. � w � I� ° � Ic ° I � fl. N'd 9 I i3 �J �' a I if �wQ � R�¢ � �. i �.5 °3 i o c v >, I 0 6:? c � E�' o. c I� Q W � I� d� � I� ,, � * O m � m * U(� � � UC1 � � � I� I I� F I ls� I�O Iq0 I�QO `°I el�z I�z � No Po o 0 �I>,F �I;F I�;F ����0 + �,�❑ �..�0 O'" Izv�`� O Izrn`� I zv�:G �� O�c w � Onr'�c [��] ���p W _ �W �� �V Up a �l�� ; a ol�2 a I�z . o IZ�c * o IZ�c IZ�a � � � � I I � I I Iw � I � �' � a I I�Hw M � � I � o, I `�' � w o 1 � � � I � ��„IaHa w � I�'Wwo" --' I o ^Iz.aa' ¢ -1 ^ P-� C.7 ,... 7 O .�-� W O Q f:.� `� [.[� O 1¢a¢�z �W��> I�o� �¢ w IQqozo o I��z�� ol�Q¢�o�. o Iq���� � Ix�a�� m���z�¢a o I¢ d¢¢D�a'-�^ o �20yc I�.. oC.� �a � �Q ��'-� t -�, `� ai I �Uy ��� ` v I°w��: 3a' ''oh, 3a oo�3w Imav, > IF-�zww... F � O z m u �, aN ' o 0 i Il i n �i O �� �� � N N �� N � r I O � �C o O o �000 0 ���o � N vl N C1 V3 69 �<A V? I I i I O O O O O O IN - {� I I I ooS ^ O O I �n N I I : I w a T G �y I I p. N '�O C � � 4 � I J C L I � b ti 3 ¢ W O U q w�' � I x I O F m lo° � I FOrv O c ^ F I I O�� a�o z�� �4�� I I 0 � I o I � a � <., a Iz „ � ��, �3 � Iw �oo�� o ��ow x o � �o F an a z� � Ia�z � e Iva�; 3a 10-186 I I N i� I O 7 I N N I N 00 I N I I O I l o o C o lo o c o I �oo � rv�N rn V3 V I<R V? I I I O O O O O O I N �. .. I� I �000 l I— O O I I I IE � � Q I T w X V C cC C � E- � � �' ? a�a 3c,¢ � I J G � I � 9 � 3 � ° Q W O m `ULIw�' W �yo � I I�a � o� �,>Iz° OZ .'I�O 1 � � Q `"o •�'-1� Ip�Nn us � >a� � i� 0 0� � � � I � � I ° I � I � o �� o w3 N I � � � � o z �o�W�� � x�H��� �z„ �° m 1¢N3: F $ O ¢ a^_ a * o 10-186 N � .. c E- __ F a v UO ��" V E � � � O Y G N Q � O y O C ['o � U ' v�. �� a d . pn w R � Q r7 •°- � u �� w � xa d d c � Y 0 L G � � � 0. ._ � C 0 L m G fi � c U v G i 0 0 � 0 � I �� IO I° I M I N N I °,�° �� � O I � o 0 0 0 c o 0 0 l000 o z c� �n ro c f5 Eli I69 EA I I I O O O O O O I � .� - I I O O O O O I ~ �n N � I I N I � 6 w IU G � � a w E � � � U � 4J O F � c `' 0 3 ��QW O i U La 0.' � IZ a �� �o= F I O d I O. C i .t I � Q F I I I � � Iz � ° N � N i� ° o � � � Q I- 'z v o I >^v�� � ��-7 �N co I � �¢ O o a � C4 v' m` C Ix ��°F* 3a �� . ` x i 0 L I � � � � 7 I n �� I� � O � O I O I O 0 0 0 0 I ti I.i l i �j I ti ;'7 I 7 I M 7 I N I N I N I I N i IN I I" N � ^ I� �� �� �� i � I � � i I I i � I � �o 0 0 0 �o 0 0 0 �o 0 0 0 �o 0 0 0 I� O O � I N O O N I V O.�J V'� I V O C V .'b N N Vl � Vl N � l� V� N V O V� N C- I� V3 H3 N� I� Ji .A N� I� V; Vj � I� V3 :f3 � I I I I I � I � I I I I I O O O I O O O I O O O I O O O I � ...: .Y I C .-. '. � .� .-. I o ._. � i— I .- I I �n I Vt I I � I I I � I O O O I O O O I O O O I O O O �.-. O O I� yl N I O O I� � N I I I I I I I I I I I I s I # I i I + I N I N I N I N I � a I � a � ¢ � a � � G � � � G �y � � C G �� � n � I � ti 6 ro I?� � Q � I?� G 6 � I?� u�-' < � I U C a� � E�' C �� E u � E ai°+ ^ �O F' w"+ G oa 3 o . c " '+ 0 3 oa 3 m �`:�`'� � �`�'� � ��: W O � Q' W O c� v� a`�i * a�i v� v � �n m C m �. ��Q� , I�Qm � �oo� . �ciQa . I I I I F i� I° I�, , la� I� lo IFO��°� p `�o < IF � �� v IO�G�WSq � INe �lo �I° �Iz�'o°Q� ��o�'o F� x F>I° ''��clo w>Iz�o O �p� Oz �� z .' � x Ozr' �q�w � �m y �` � �Zn W I6N < �- ¢ z a �� ¢ � u... � m,� � m � ,� �O W N Im�Z ,� FF .� � .a... 2 iz ;n �+� , a .� a ,Z a a mm�Op O �v� ¢Q wF S' � aF?¢`�� 3'< o��3w o��`��, � o��3v�c.c�7t+ 0��-,3= I � I I I I,a I I,� I c. � I I � I o �, I. U m I v�i I� I� c�j ° o � �"�J�� � ° �C1 �W a' W Jo I z� ��n o I Q v o f 0 a F-� p ���'F v�iv�i c` �"' Z� N I. v�i N I� M, N IW ,_]v' �N' N ����w� ^ I� � ^ �U HoF. .-, ��wY��" ,.., �O.- �Q o ,_] W o �n �.-,� `o z 23 �' o �xa ��,��> IF w�o I�.o�o� IE�-� W Q o 1-Llav�i o Iw ^ o I�xOF o 0 .W.'�Z�a' + cv � � cv¢'�"� � �z �'aE�v � �Z'7E"Z'rz�v� `° I �p� Q� ��:a' �v�?i"a,'Z:o� ���OQU�o9 `W x�' O I 0.. P] �n v`m c' � W o �n m q � � G. in .'3 c �^L O o O�^^ `a v N �n N v7 O� O � Q O W N � o3a 1z°�£ 3°" Iz¢`�°�: 3°" �ac��m: 3a F ,>�, > O y '�v 00 10-186 � u C. F G"� RO R � � W O .Y'. e 0 �� o= F� U ° 0 .. a V N . Q+ r R a a ° on m C V 'i � ° a x L' �' W a a d d O L � .� � 4 0 O .. O CT � �� l� �I T� I� I "' I N N I N ;d N � � o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I co 0 0 00 N �n N � V ff3 I V3 V3 I j000 o I N .� .r I I I l000 I'"°N I I I � * v � ��' c T C ro l i ? � d � ��'E � � `" 'a 3 � � 4 W O �U q � *. I low� ti I Q � F i� s I°�'� � ti a N zN3 I ��F(v ��>�.^�] �m�z� � F I z��o I�00� � � I I � � � � o M � N 0 lao��� ° ���oz° o I WZOao �� �OxQa `� c I°a��: � c 4 � � � a 7 � H r O L � d Q O a U x L 3 0 I � I N I N � 0 � 0 � r� � r� I N I N N N �� N I N I� I� ; r N I N i N i I i I l o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I N O O N I G� � N � I , -. :A 69 N I V3 e9 I I I 1 I �000 oao Ic"_ � i I I I I ISSo �_ao � I I I I I � � � � � W I � � � �* I�.�Q � I 3 W ISCN ' ��. I� �� a Ina w .p 3 x I a�i v� a`�i O I,,*. �ox . I � I� IF I� I� � i°�, i°� ���m� �m,.�] z^�z� z� � ��� ��� O �v0 '=��� jW� .o� ¢ p ol�z Ix¢ � � N � I � rn � a � I ° i � I XU ol °w o 0 I�� o i W z ¢ � 1 �>Fz -I ����z a i p�a,Z!-¢� o �•�'". W i�OF�-� o I QO¢z�� °° [ � Q� �'-^ o'Q=o F �ao'�a I� Cy N� ttl Y. I Q r�`" � ny c3 C IQm��� i � � �ti �ti I O I O �o �o i� �� M M � N I N I� � � N I N � � j000 fl 0 0 0 0 � V O O a t+l Vl N O I N ff3 H3 t+� V? N3 I I I 1 � I i �000 000 I N '+ f. I I I I I � IooS �°N I I I I I I � � � N I CL I I a. � Q � I I* � :s. ;, I U �i N * I � °' a I�¢W � i� IU Ll d a I� 1� �i= �p �p � �i� �i� m>�a_ �w o`IQ IA� z y IFd IF� � M. � m �� INO INO � ola I�° � �� � �� � � I I� I N x I �- 3 I � 3 I° �� ol �,�:� �, I�z�¢ NI F �' ¢ o _ z� �,�',��a a����a a `O W 3 W �av'z 4.: Ix}wz �;: wd�W °p�� ° I W ` � � � � I U � ^ '��I � � � �y I ��3 Q.��a:o �rs`1'jd� �-7•0:0 � + I��w�3w ��° ..,p . ��� � I � �� I� � I N � I N l o 0 0 0 o c o 0 �o o O o �n v� N N I N 69 %i m V3 Vi i � j000 0 �o_.. h I � I IoSo �oo �N I. I I II v >. I kr d I T � X a� Q � I� � � I � E � 3 W z I ° 4 "a O U q w�' . � I NO o Fzvly � W W {a� o I� WI°���M W �1y3=00 m o= N�x� z w oo a ��o�^�- Q IW �""' w� r�,� I°� '� I-F al O O O o O9F. . _ � o ��V 6m":.� � I I I � � � o I z� � I V] � � O � ¢ < � Z o I I ��"�' � � � � N � � W S ^ O r � b �°ra3� IwN3. . W R a, o^ z y w 1 � 10-186 a � = c F £ F a L L bG ^ � U G � � � P W O �' d � a� a� 0 � 5 V 0 �z V N L a � W N C .7 ° � u c � L R R rx a C d d C d d 0 E � � .� � a c � A � .. O 'C Cq Ci O Q c� 0 0 N 0 a � � � c, ., 0 �� �~ M IN � N � N II �o 0 0 0 �o 0 0 0 I� � N �v' I M Yf 6i V fA H3 I � I I O O O O O O Ip -. r I I Nt �o I�°N I I * I N T I CJ N F., a T K � l a�a b � � � I U � N � ��¢� 3 O �ULI� z I �� O� �GF I�O �qa I � E% �� �o � I C U rv I Q F � I I � � I U N � �j a ° I � � t%1 ,-. o � F� „� I W N i. V] O a � U � o �a c, � �n � la°�:3 x L 0 L O i i i I I I IM I.. I� I Io I� I� I i �', �n I � I M I � I N � N I N � i � I N � N � N � � i N i N � N I � I I � � i �o 0 0 0 �o 0 0 0 �o 0 0 0 I N O O N m O O w^ N O O N -- �n N co I N �n N C+ � G\ v� N � I M� EP E/3 � �� tA FP. � I� N3 fA N� I I I � � � I I I O O O I O O O I O O O II lV �. .. I c0 .. ,-. I C.- .-. � I'. I ... I I I ( I I I O O O I O O O I O O O I-� O O I-- O O � O N 1 I ' I i I I I I I � I � I = I ; I � I � I � � I w a I � a w c I� c � I� c � �� c � E m � � lo. a �o �n. ai-a 'o �ava a �'.�.Q � �L6 m �w¢ � � � � I� C � IU � � �� � � C �� � .�. C �� � � ❑ ' o Q c7 � o� Cj �' o� r...� � a�i v� e`�i .*.� I I v v� a`�i �' I I v vJ c`�i * UAcG + o�� U�1� I� I I Y Iy I N V N O � �� � I N k ' N F' � �°aN ��p o�z z 0 m 'u� C ¢N m I � IE k. U ' • Q �y>�rv�NZ F>�p .4��..cl<�m ��I��OU� O'"I� O�I[]UF r ti ��m<z � �� N INN a �Ni:.��, ¢ I,� ¢ I��o wo�°�"3 °'ar `''T,�°Cw U � � Q �� C � Z ��u^� z o�me� o�a�t� 8�.-ca�l� I I I I I I I I � � I F, � � �� � � a, I� "' o� �¢ ° o� � C7 '�^ ° �'z �[:j o � I� V � I I z� .�-� O I �7 r'Y�i �� 7 O I U � W O d6 '�^ �wa „' �cL>„�,> �' O F�� O I W Q �� C. O I ti a �� O v� n] 2 o�r�a��, �° r Q A x ��' m w � v� �kC7U'J� c �0¢��O � Iw.'�''�j W c z'"4a'?�a c7 xQ "6�a �d�oT�=o �QO�a^ m c IW zoa,o� m� ��Na� '� � �, Ic�7a°vE-�i°'3: I�`°�* 3a O z � aPo i I i� �o IQ i� � N I N � N r I N � i � o 0 0 0 0 o c c I� o o � V� V� N N I NV3EA m d3 i+A I � I O O O O O O i N '. ._. I O O O lo 0 0 -� O O I I I I � � w a. I �` C ca � F ��w¢ v� F I U C o I� E �° c I � ¢ U O m �UQ� 'a I I� IF lo F z �� � � �Nm I�^ F - i I � �� I�Y o 0 � Q F" v ° N �U o 0 I��j�f=7v�i W G ¢ � / � � � L Ixa I [ � N. � Q� V 9 'd w E M w ^ m � x�F- 3a. Iw U—rn. . + � F � o ^ < aN � � � c � F F a �� L V G L` � lp b P O � Q 0 a � o � F ° G�. p U e C � m O � a, � � a Q � U � 4' '� da x G � � m d 0 � a E � a' � 3 � j c « Ca .�. � L y O o,` a S � 0 � i i lo �o I I N N I� i N I� N I � �o 0 0 0 �o 0 0 0 I 'LJ G O V' v� �n N N l N W Ff m e? V3 I I I O O O O O C I � .-� ._. I� I I I O O O ^ � N I � � I * v v Q T w �c � F ���=d � °c� �� E y c I � � W O �ULI� � 1 lo I� la �¢ � Iy �a ��x iOq � I �� _ lo � l a � O W o ° �� �r� — I z z > °— iQ�o¢ o w I Q q W�� c C7 � W -. '� =o �� � ��� ��* 3a d x F i m` 3 O I �� �o I� i� jN � 01 i N �� � i I �o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � o� O O c0 � O �n N l� I th f/? 69 cn (f3 H3 I I I O O O O O O IO ^ I M I I O O O I -� O O h N I I # � v �a I W fi T � � � � 3 w ¢ c I O � p G U I � E .� c � O � U Ll c�' : � o� 00 I h � � m � �I�� . � ��NO°o �� >�z� O'� I O r� O z m �ati�� ti� Fo ?c l o�°o F, � ' o o aa�3 I � I I � � �., I � � 0 � o � p� .J � N o� O � �� ° �W La �x�� � I V � o � m c O M � I�c�� o,3n*. i i I I Ic� Ir .. �o �o �M IQ I? �M I N I N I N I N i N I N � � I � � ` o 0 0 0 �o c o 0 0 0 0 0 o c c o I f V ^J� O N I W O O W G1 �n N V' N vi N ^ I� b9 EA N� I� V3 E.? � I I I I I I O O O IO O O O O O O O O I C'-. .-. I M.-. f. I I 1 I I I I O O O I O O O I-� O O � O N � I I � I I I � i � : e� � v I T G� n. � w c. U C N I U �' � I�.�a � la4Q � I U �� I U C N � � F. .�. C I o E u C 4+ a 3 `�-� a W 3 �� d � 0 I� d � � IvQ� . jUQ� : lo I IF}M I� ��x a � IF � � m s cIH�_ �I� w��� i �`v '� w��w� O'"I�F� O�' E"� N I�OZ y Ivm aala4o a�i3o w a F' { o IaF+F � I�> o�-�ti o��< i I I ' I i I I I 3 N � I a w � o � o Q � I � N I^ Ox � 1 �> � Iz �N� °— Iz,a,zx o IaU¢z�z o I � ' p�•�� - ` c �n I ' -- ,. Q j � a z<r � H I ° � I pac ¢ . � c`s c �� qm,2 �� c x�,�-�3a ����+��'3a v��v�. � 10-186 i i i ! i� I� jO O 'o i i � ." � .., N N I N I N 'T i G� I N N i C1 iG� N N I � o 0 0 o II � � O O b I I I � � � ry � I I I I O O O I O O O I � r .- I l I � � I O O O I �-� O O I I I � � � � � I I I � G I m c� c law¢ = l� IU � � �; I* I O a� � I 3 i d F-� � O U�� � �� � � # � ti I L. � N Q N N N �I�� I�� . � �o� �a� o��w� I w`'- z oN �o� ¢ 3 3°c w �dT �dY `� F�'`o I��o �1 �] y �} O �` O� o�.,�o in, o � I I I I I Ix a I Ip o I N �� � � � rn IC7 �o ° o I `� o N � ry M ry I�Q�Q �I pzWO' O a°>�¢ ��rw ol�dwz�' o aaH� ,az�'� � iQa�1`� m Q� o0 w U0 . 3 .7�'�oa l ��wQ�'o=o �z�a�,��� ��,�,�� 1�=�:3<13�-�: � z h a� a . o 10-186 � � � F L V b� G c F G b r 0 E Q O a � O � H � U = e .. � � d O s. a. � a Y q .a ° o� � a ` m �a xx c d v a C d d e L c � 0. Q 0 0 N ey 0 a i I I� Io �� I� N IN � N �� I N I �o 0 0 0 ico c o co � O �n N t� � th 69 fn M 69 4A I I I I O O O O C O IO y ^ M � � �o 0 0 I � N I I � I � C� a U G cC F � a. a�i •a � a w ¢ � I�=� I `� 8 ° c � O IUQ� : � IN f oj ��� F- F Q� I4O � - `a ��r I�h �z I �6 I I I I � O r, rn O I � � � � I�qO' O �^�N¢ i�pq�O O � �aa3�; �U�Qa.o9 la�w� � _ Iw��: 3: C c Q L � � � 0 L y O E .. c L � d G m L AI v G x L e 0 i I i� lo I .i I N N I N Ci I N i� � N � l o 0 0 0 0 0 o c la� o o � N v� N G� V± V? IfH 4? I I I I O O O O O O I � f. ._. �^ I � 0 0 � O O I Vl N I � � : I � � ro !x. CL I >' C �p I a� a 'o Q .�a I U � tJ � L u C a 3 � ° d W O ro �ULI w' _ � � -� �N ° Iz Iw * � F .. O t I V O Z w .� w {_� y zo w� �°� `"° ��o "ol�a I I I I N � I M O � O m N I v o � � � � �a o � ,� •� Q �s ��'�` v ���W � m I� �z��¢��b � � �4 3a ', a O z v w_ �o i i �.� �.. lo lo � � I � I M I M N t`5 IN iN ' N � N �� �� � N ; N i � � � 000 o � O o o c I�i o o � I �n v� N N I � e9 69 N I fA fA I � I I I I I O O O � II � � � I I � I �000 � I � O O I I I I I I � � � w I U � I � � a II I R v �c � : I � ^- °' m a`� I ° .� � °� I ° � ° ¢ � � �O IU � a > I� i � I IUOF IIUOF � � ¢ � I � ¢ � IF�= I��z I O F F I O � F �`-' z •'-�+ I .`�'. �. F I��� inE� �zFO zZo � � Q � � I � N � � �tio�� ��o�� I I I I Q+ I I� I I� I I� O O I I V O O N d N N � A, ; ._. � o _ o � � o Q v�i �p�,nr � o ��p'z� o I ���p m '''ah�0 �a .-1 � ' ]Vi N �IV] �Vi N bL IOODA- a�Qr- ° �woH��°�'� low�� 3;IH��� 3a i I I �x lo l c i o o �-, � O i O I� i� I N I N � N � N � N � N � C1 C� i N I N i i I � I o 0 0 0 lo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 i IM � N p i� �� N I V� Ff3 Vj � I� V3 if? N� I I I I I I I O O O I O O O O O O O O O �� � � � �� � � � o 0 0 � o° o I °N I��N I I I I I I � � < < I � � � � [: a. I I I c, a � �j C � V G N � m 8 F ' �„ E F" � a. a� •o 'o � o. � a - a �w 1 m �F`� ro IU � ,� I� C ,� �� E:? c I� �E : c °" 3 `� 3 � � � � � � � � � � � �CJCarL » �C�Ca� + �. � II�v. I�°� ��o w �� F o � �� F ��o � ��o�x � F W � _ � F .] � ^ ICF�� � f IO�O� F a. , I � o~ o" q..o a I ��H a I qaF F ` ", o° m� z ro c ='I�"�'�� 0. NI� a �X � F�-a F�- S o I I I I I I I I I Ia o I � o I� U h N I � W � N Lx1 �q��v � �p �"a " loQ�° 0 13 a xado :� �U�'a x � � H � ry a � N �wONqti m �r �¢pa�o:a ���¢��� �oa 1��3: 3a Ixm��: 3: F � O ` y � cPo O 10-186 � b � G G F F 4 L 1 bD � L' R � vJ b r O £' Q R O y O ^� E'q � V � O � � rz d . {�1 � Ca y c .7 ° on � C � L xz ° s v G m m 0 L a r. � 0. 3 � � s i Ca .. 0 ` u O N e C- �, O N ti 0 � I I �o �O �o �o IM IM �� �� N H � N � N � N � N �� �� N N I i i I � � �o o c o � c o 0 0 l0000 0o I N v� N G� I � EA H3 � I I I I I I I O O O I O O O I � f. I I I I O O O I-J O O I I I I I � I I I I I i W I J ��! (tl N �+ y I I � � ¢ * I T U � �N I � �� C I a. a ��Q W O �F I U h U � IR I U Ca cC � I » I� I° �o �o li". �.F. I 0 0. , Q m y ¢ y x liva �Y- ��� ��F- ��E- iz o Qo �¢ �¢a ICQ I�C i mv F i I �Gr F i� I I � I I � I I � I I � I � � � o�,�, � o Ic�w � °I.ax � ° xca F ,.. Fc� .%,w �pQ o�z��°;> a Qaa��t I�r3��Q Iz��x�' wIHH�..a� w ����'¢z ��wwH R aw�F¢� m > Q ¢¢ W � �, I[ � j � z V Q � t6 C I z �� O vr cC �S'. � ¢�w� ��QO�W� � I?ti=�� 3: 13��°>> 3a L R x F O a I N �o I� I� I H i N i� N �ti I M lo 0 0 0 �o 0 0 0 lo 0 0 0 C �n N � I V� yi V3 �' � Vi I I I O O O O O O I � .+ -. I I O O O I -� O O I I i � I � � w ci. T � k� I � f fl, a ¢ c I ° �' `° c� C v � O � •�- C "' '0 3 o ¢ U � : �ULI� e i ��o I„ N�m2 ���U � c I v�i U Q � I � � z I � O ao I I FF o I I 4° F I I I a �za ¢ ,�. I x� � o I � G: N N 0 �xz�° a �c�o¢�w I �C ¢ 7p�� � N H Ci � x � QfY'Q.70 � A�0 �3 � I � zc ���� �'Oa�: f� > O` z � W 4 �q � I IN �o IM I� � N I N i� � M i � � o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 lo c o 0 W �n N �n O e9 V3 I� � I6% 4h I I O O O O O O I p� � .. I I O O O I -+ O O I I � � I � a I G N IaU¢ � o �, ro � o c c� I� � .% C o ¢ W 3 O > I U Q �i !E I la �F � Vti �� Iq � I F p I loc ICF � 1� � U w I �, � � lo �� laz�� o (O.- Q� o ��, N I�Wp o ���c�x �N 2UW o ° 0 �5' W v� � Y i . 3 � � Q � F N ❑ I IU� 3 �Q"o� m c Iro�°�# 3a I �� � a �� � I� � N C1 I N ti I I M I l o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 lo 0 0 0 N Vl N Gl I [� :/j V3 I� EH 69 I I I I O O O O O O I O -� I I I I O O O I-� O O I I I y� I � I U � �. [�. T C. � � c � [-� Ia�¢ � ❑ w � I o _ a� O � �a 3 ° W O �� Q � i N � y � U C�-. C�i x lo � I � vl> I ,. C �� ��¢ N '� �a a� I} . ° o I m X o I �n � � { � " o w I��a �, ,, �, N � ca4 o 0 0 �z¢� � I��Q� ° L'- h �� L�i C7 2�L.� O � a � �'j �'' v' � ¢p'�� � �W �>, ¢ �.o � �a'�io�r�3w I�UN�.. > � O z ti . n. ; N 0 � � � F F L OL 6 R � � b 0 s ¢ � O jG O 0 F ._ U = 0 .. � ;a �o � d R a° en a C � i � m � x c d d d C � d > 0 � � a 0 O N � 0 'p � I I .. �o I� �� I N I N i� I M I I o 00 0 0 0 0 0 i V O C V t'� 'n N O I N e4 69 r� 69 6? I � I I O O C O O O I N f. .-. I I I looa I -- h N I I � � I � w V � � R w < I 8 C m IO � m o ° � W ( UO� � �°o``'' �a�o ���� lo a IyH'� >�z a mQ�- � m 5 Q a I W y a w ti lu�oo � � � � I Q � � � r7 � Ca .�. 0 .� A v i I� � I N � m I N I N i� I ! I l 000 0 0 0 0 0 I m O O m t� �n N d' cn P di V I E+9 4� 4; I � I O O O O O O I M .- .-- r �� I I IoSS -� O O II I I I � N ( T w a C i � � ¢ � � k. � C V �oD� � 3 ° W O I �¢ m �U Ll rL = � I � ¢ �oz �n IUQ� � Ih 0 + I $, ', � P: O r " y �a,�a �� �� �o io�a ^ y�� s lo�o i � � � rn � � N � I � V� � O Iwz�� � Izz�� ° Q [;] V] [z] �z za> o ¢ �Y� ���� � -n- F Li � F �" '7-. W D'J 'O I� � � � � � � IF�°�: , T m � � 3 O I � O � � o �� � ^ O � � U [ _ . k.. „' W �:: 1��3� � U zx��, I� F O r � � IHy� � y I�°�. L d ['y L O L N O i IN lo io ti I N N �� N IN IM � � l o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N O 'J N G\ v� N V 69 :A N I65 v9 � I � I O O O O O O I � .- - I� l000 -� O O II � � � : I � I � � W R �' C. A �c � H �� la�� � 7 a Q � �,k v �a � � � o ¢ W p � U (� fL � � � lo �.x, z �' � � �zi�. ��>�30 y�l� ao�0 �� I ti� F a m �vQ¢ 6p o �� ��.xoa v 4 O � F o j�AO° I I I � I ° � W N C� O � �Q' O N z ¢H � I��o�W o �a�HZ�� � Q [, � ti Iw � � c �Ua° c v I�W��:. i I I� I° I N M I N N I N IM i `I 000 0 0 0 0 0 I O O O O N v� N 4� I M EA Vj M H3 Ef3 I � I O O O O O O � O -- -- I"' I I IoSo y � N II I � : . I � � � T G � I � � � � 12�¢ b I o w � U � N �� 9 � 3 ° E W O I � m iF �U Ll d = � �o = � � Ir�n�6 ' IhZa. F ,O ` � Q ,� r�ii � I a$� < i=xz �� - ma..� - la��� o l ooaw I I I I � G� � b � I �° ^ O � I � � h � z��z w I� 0 iw "� x�o � � Q b a � m 4 I�.���.. � i IM lo I� I N I N I N I� I M f� o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I�°N � I N EA 6? N fP V3 I � I O O O O O O I N '. f. I I I ISoo I � N I I : I � � ro r. a I � G �d � � � � I�.�Q 3 W � U C U I° s Y 3 o � W Q O � U G - u� < � � � �o¢ rn � W .o�w�� , = I ZNo O N I�UO _ , w� � ao Iiv � r N r�L V] _ e�om� � � � � I � o � � 0 � N I oz o I N � � w I��z�] p �z�aa� � I W 0.�1 W v� m a I�O��3: 10-186 i I I.. lo I �� � N � N �� I I � o 0 0 0 c o 0 0 ��oo � N vi N O� fA :R le9 Vi � I I � I O O O O O O I N f. .ti I IooS I� v� �N I I I � � � I � w a �` C � I � � ¢ C I� � � � a@� � I � ¢ � O � � � * IUO� � l F ^ � I I `� � o � � q � o" I I.. E �F z ;� o N I 4 �ol�� �� i�� o I I = c. � I � � I I N N p� I � O W o 0 � 4 � H � � O � O d �' 6 I�¢W3 0 H z ,� �� O 4 p � � �a�3� �',� �o `a o �c y Ic � c�. C b" m � a �� ' ° o a � � � F E' C R �R G � b r O e a a O j� O C H � a_ 0 a V d e L F � R y Q 'a ' pp R C U i Z" ,n," F4 L v m e E > 0 L 2 � � a 0 0 N ti 0 a I I� lo I� I'" M I N � N I M � i � o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I .hoo �n M � N h 69 69 N IfA fA I I � I O O O O O O I� ti � 1 `" I I IooS I� � N I I I I � , � � I [:. 6 T c � �� c �� F m v d 0' °� � C �w ro I� � � q I o I U q a�'' + II I� �� �� �o I lo �N I� I I � � � � 3 az a � �or� ° I ° ¢ ,� 13N�z o ��aa �zo � �3a��.a ° I � O x M i3 C c-'rn¢�o3o w rn a . . . G L � � � a � . y Ca E `.n 0 L a � d O a x i 0 3 O w " o z v (L Po i a i i i I I� I� lo �� o i o I� �cy I '" i N � j N N � N I N i M I I M � � � I lo 0 0 0 lo 0 o c �o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I vi o o vi � o c o� -� �n N OC I N vl N G\ I�M V3 4? � I^� f9 Y; ^� I I I I I O O O O O O O O O O O O ^ � .--. I N .-. ,ti I I t+i I'. I I I l000 l000 � -^0O I I I I I I I I I ; � � [-'. c. � f : � I� � F �c, "� F H � e � � � � ¢ � � a� ¢ � I� _ � I� C � � � c:? c � O �' :a ^ ° �W o I o �C� O G��. � �U Q K i I I_ I `�'F IY I�� �� �h�� N� � aSCY �� ��z� m��o I'z o�l� IU�.� � IO �'�y�a u � , �a 1�3a ��I� i h�Q oim I I Ia I �� o i � U o _ o ,n � � o � � �� U � � � (aNzw � I >.o�, N WY > ¢� Iz � lozx'"� o I� Q O a 'WO' I"�'� � U`�' � O Q oaxH� �wH a, �'� m � ��U a �..a�-.`�03� c I��O� i2 C If�Z.Na� �9 O �O N co a M N (v�a`�i: 3a IQZ3c�� 30. I I� �o I� .. � I N I� I� I I M � o 0 0 0 0 o c o �oo 0 0 00 N �n N Gl 69 69 I4A ifi I I . I O O O M �. f. I I� I I ISoo I� � N I I I I I � i [� � Ila �'w 4 � � � G a� I� E � c 'd 3 � ° 6 "a O � �U Q � *. � � I v I Z ��o _ � �x u��zm o z a �c70 .� �ci�0 m �F ' ° I� ° o o � I � � � o I �� o I �¢a¢ o � o � ����] w � z W o �°F � am¢' � �2N• � a ¢a�H�3c �O w-� rn. � m > o" y ¢ a� C 10-186 i i I I lo I� l o 'o IM �� IN I� r� c5 �N IN � N � N � M � M I � I i �o 0 0 0 ��o o c o I z o 0 05 Iv o o � .�_. � 6�>. � � 6 '��. N I 6? 2? I d± iP I I I I I I I O O O IO O O O O O O O O I N ��. I N.� f. I �~ I I I I ISSS l000 I.-. O O y v�l N I I I I I I I : I � � � � o. w fl. ��� �' G' t�tl �� U G N c�d a� �' F c� c� � a I a w 4 � I a� ¢ � I � ro u a (J C 4] I V f+ N � � ��' � � � � E :a ° c I°� o I o .� I�v� m * Im v� � * UC]� . UC1� < � °� � c I I F �Q I � c I '_ } '1 6 F � i ` �""' C7 I � ^ II � : u v��m�Ca �o o' � z z ���sh F y q z u �Gl w��''�'�zY3o� � °'`° I"�F��o ,<� � w I � Ii+�C�M� ..l o I ��nF.] I I I I I � �a � �� � � � ? a� [.'��-� o I QNe N � N � x W� z ` �� Q o � o I�v�� loo�'z �r-�Qa�'Qa 4. IQE^2� W N O .(Y� (/� O 1��3W�� lozo°�� ��c 5 �w'W Y�.a 5 I x�� O `N � I W 0 W O�i r C Iw3�-� 3� Ic�az� 3°^ �' ° z� �N 0 � = F F v E R � b � 0 � � a � � � O C Ey O a; � .. � v �' a` « R N C 1+� � � V c ` L N N G M1Y d E � Q m d 0 a E 3 a 0 N � .n O v a i I I� i ., I � IM I N IN I I M i Il o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I O C O O N vl N � I (�1 4P. (n. M d fA I � l o 0 0 0 0 0 I ° -. .� I"' I I l000 �-� O O I I * I � N N T w a U � � � � � � � in'°�¢ c � �. � U � i �� H 3 c I O Q W Q IUOw • I ION � ° .xa �qn I�a �u-� c> �zz �3� I 4 , .a � 4 io� i u� 3ti � � � I M I � I � � ��� N ¢ �u o �c7Qa�" O Iz Q �" � c�o �d>4S� c a�3��:� ���q�3c �`.C^.�m c U � � � = c ° .� Ca M4 C a c`. `v x F i. L � I IM i ^" .. � 7 I� I N � N IM � i I� o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � W � N V�i I M fA fA a fA 43 I � l o 0 0 lo 0 0 I��� I"' I I l000 I ~ � N I : � � IJ w X ��.w � � N IU�� I � � � � O ¢ [S] � �U p � s lO I �: 0 „�� � I U F; �z� z I m a �e w� �ar- a�i�s cISO o m z � � � I I � P 0 0 M ° J, I� � ¢� � . o I ¢o�a� � �C]�"7�-o c �¢°a��� �oFoo3a � C] oo v� � > -x i i I I iN lao lo lo �� �M � �.. � N � N I :N i M I I M � i � I �o 0 0 0 �o 0 0 0 I N O O N IO O O O G� v� N � C� �n N V' I� e9 Vj N� I� Ff3 Hi V� I I � � � I lo 0 0 �o 0 0 I c .-: .-: � o .-: ,-: I I M I l I l000 000 I � N Iy O O I I I I � I ; I ; � y � L-�, a. � G o. I c � E� Ic = F � �� @ "��' ?'Gi d c N I�,c � � � � � I O� a�+ L' I O 9 w�+ K o¢ W 3 o E W 3 � I yy. � iF IU Ll � . iU Cl � � N N I � � a I �o �� �o� F oa rlo��w � o �, ��o�" c�Q'<�� • � :,��o 05' °-'w F.'.q ti�o°N z �?�� ° I I��=oa G ip�Fp � I K;W F ,m ZC� a� "� a z c Q .o�' - o '�QIF_� �-�I��-�,p� �o< :o a z o wo � o �v o ��3� � � � � � � � � � N � � W o "' 3 >� o � a�U o IW� N � �W � I'�w3�z¢ o ��4a � o Q W '� � �' I '�-' r� � � � IH��C]4 o I o IQU,z °�° I"�xa c ��.. z a..,H,..9 � ��-.�q �b 1¢Ha� A � �� �o� � � I�o °�. 3P��" 13�o3M3a*°'. u> o z ti w ,� o. � � i I I IM I I� i I N I IM I IN I � N I �� I M I � I I I o o C o I I �N O C N � �n N cn I �+1 J3 4^ V fP fH I I I I � I �o 0 o I I� � ^. I "' I I I I I I l000 I I-� O O I I I � I I „ I � � !y o. � � � � � � � � w ¢ t � I U = � � I I � E :? ° c I I pa�" 3 � I I U Ll a + � I I zi I¢ ¢ I I I�'z� �I IpOF �I zzo �°�. u>� IQpO o�l a � ti ��0 4 � � N �m � �'� ° 'N� �oQO 3 0� I � W 6.t o I i I � I � I � I � I I � o I I � � I N 4 N' I q ��w p o �Q � � I��c� z o I IOUO��,-. i° I ��H�'�"�ati� � �H>��$ � ° I I¢° °�� 3°� I 10-186 000 O O O 01 O O v o 0 �n �n o � N � �bsv� � �w U �+ O� o U C] � � F F w � � � ;? m a � F 0 O d v O r � r H u � L Cy 10-186 � � � G c L F n F L V OL c R � � � r O £ Q a.. o � o � E ° U � 0 .. d u � V . L 41 v R Q y G � � bD m G V L � ° a x _ d s d a s d c � G N � O s. c � U L a h £ G L U . N R a .� � C O . n�- N 0 L V d Q i v O 0. .-. o �' �.�.+ o y N � N % iQ � F � � L y d O Y L � � G py i�C Q Q W Q ` VI O