181553 •
•
Clerk CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL NO. g.k.:U I a a3
ICE OF THE CITY CLERK
COU RESOL TION—GENERAL FORM
,cNTED BY
COMMISSIONER DATF
IF
RESOLVED, that upon appeal of East Immanual
Lutheran Church from the decision of the Commissioner
of Parks, Playgrounds and Public Buildings, an 18t
building line is hereby established along the east 14'
of the vacated alley adjoining the property on the north
side of Rose Street between Payne Avenue and Edgerton
Street, further described as the east one-half of Lot 19
and all of Lot 20, Block 1, Joseph R. Weide' s Addition
and the vacated alley adjoining Lot 20 on the east.
Council rile No 181585--By Milton
Rosen. by request-
Etesolved. at upoan ep 02
Immanuel from:,,
decision of the p over of P _
p grounds ado�,
lg'rulldingerebYb
agthe e�#' of the vacated $ley.
ing the property on the nprrtthh
=Want:side of Bose Street. between Pe e
nc aSIFee+ fiotf Lotot
19 and all of Lot 20, Block 1, Joseph
B Weide.* Addition and the vacated
alley adjoin Lot 2Q on the east.
Adopted by Council February 19.
1957.
Approved February 19 1957.
(February 23. I9E71
°:' 3\
:7S1
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 195_
Yeas Nays ".
DeCourcy ;,,
"fonanzt ' ypluved 195-
Marzitelli ,�
-Mb,.iii�au�� A- Tn Favor 11��'_►� i.
Mayor
Petertin Rosen — /Against
Mr. President, Dillon
5M 6-56 2
OFFICE OF CITY CLERK JOSEPH R. OKONESKI
City Clerk
BUREAU OF RECORDS HAROLD J. RIORDAN
Council Recorder
386 City Hall and Court House
St. Paul 2, Minnesota
RECEIVED Wry
FEB ..
CORPORATION COUNSEL
February 14, 1957
Mr. Marshall F. Hurley
Corporation Counsel
Building
Dear Sir:
The City Council requests that you draw a resolution granting the attached
appeal of East Immanuel Lutheran Church for the establishment of an 18'
building line along the east 14' of the vacated alley adjoining the
property on the north side of Rose between Payne and Edgerton, further
described as the east half of Lot 19 and all of Lot 20, Block 1, Joseph
R. Weide's Addition and the vacated alley adjoining lot 20 on the East.
Y truly o .s,
tr
4,,ty Clerk �_..
iimwetit
takitR.t44 v
r',11 I S 11 ; .1) l j�'J!'y� I l l 1 9C:I7
! 11 11 �i t I� T r 'i .d 0. R
I {{ � 1 ! 1
i 11 i, I
•
,Y,"*"7 f 9- � l � 's 4:. r m 3 r� '"' �P'S��1! r� !� �Ti� #40„:1,4
t - '; � — :• . ► G , I, f; M I N N E S OTA
YA•.::ShYY.•:::::::tY::
A.
::::::;::.•B RD OF ZONING, CITY OF SAINT PAUL
''' v}ii:::“TuNtdiF:211-212-212 1118 CITY NALL AND COURT NOM SAINT PAUL 1.M*NNIS TA
February 6, 1957
Mr. Joseph Okoneski
City Clerk
Building
Dear Sir:
This is in the matter of the appeal of the East Immanuel Lutheran Church
to establish a building line of 18' along the east 14' of the vacated
alley affecting. the property adjacent to the north side of Rose between
Payne and Edgerton streets. This property is described as the east
half of lot 19, all of lot 20 - block 1 - Joseph R. Weide's Addition
and the vacated alley adjoining lot 20 on the East. The zoning is "C”
residence.
The applicants have acquired additional property to the west of the
existing church which is located adjacent to the northwest corner of
Payne and Rose. They are in the process of constructing a new parish
house on this additional property, a detail of which involves an encroach-
ment of approximately 3' of an overhead canopy into the existing twenty-
one foot front yard space of the property adjacent to the north side. of
Rose St.
The Planning Board finds that this is a very minor encroachment and that
the structure itself is well within the y rd limitations. All of the
property owners in the block which involvlomes on the north side of
Rose to the west have agreed to this minor change.
In consideration of the fact that this proposed canopy will not damage
adjacent properties in any way and the fact that the proposed canopy
would imrove the utility and service of this church structure in a
manner consistent with the general public interest, the-:Zoning Board
recommends that this appeal be granted. /
zoN1Na wrri AL S' e y
I+TeRtee is en that a public ,
CDL:FS w�mtri ae hebfore the ci�y. C. eks
the City Council Coun i lain the Planning Director
Enc. !Cittyy Hall and Court House, in, the Plannin
matter of the appeal of East Immanuel
Lutheran Church,under Sec.20 Of Ord.
No. 5890 (the Zoning Ordinance) fo,. Executive Director
the on the p his abuilding Board of Zoning
20 and the vacated alley Adjoining Lot
20 on the east, Block 1, Joseph R.
Weide's Addition, at 18 ft. along the
east 14 ft.I situated on of the north side Rose
Ave.between Payne Ave.and Edgerton
St„ for the Purpose.of constructing
a brick support for a canopy over the
main entrance to the new addition to
{
I their church.
Dated January 25, 1957.
JOSEPH R.OKONESK r
I, /,,,,/llll"
City Clerk.
(February 2, 1957)
•
•
.
P E T I T I O N
To the Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council.
Court House, St. Paul, Minnesota.
We, the undersigned property owners on the North side of Rose
Street between Payne Ave. and Edgerton Street, St. Paul, have
no objection to the 3'-O" brick projection beyond established
building line. This projection is lO'-6" high and supports the
front entrance canopy of the new Parish House for the East
Immanuel Lutheran Church, 1173 Payne Ave, St. Paul, Minnesota.
I �..a. ':; d 4 # '"� 0 1
2)) z 77,, / .4,4,,u,/e--C z 4_ 9S . t�i�-�—�'- 7 7
i )Z /t2 ..5�3 aw
r
_. arhat c 7
rkt4 / .41-4 OS 8 P.44.12_,
Date
°.2°(' q(I 1/1/S
i
F 3Sgt._
'East 3mmanuet tutiteran fturcIt
111.1 1IN SAINT PAUL
. I
;, PAYNE AND ROSE AVENUES
I p II�II{1�I .
::;i :•- •-•-•. G. H. HUGGENVIK, PASTOR 600 E. ROSE AVENUE
Jan. 21, 1956 rl`
in,
TO THE HONORABLE CITY COUNCIL a''y
ST. .PAUL, MINN.
GENTLEMEN :
We the undersigned hereby appeal to submit the
following dates. in regard to establishing a new building
line at 181ft. no inches from the property line.
The East Immanuel Lutheran Church Parish House
addition is located on the East 2 of Lot 19, all of
20 and the vacated alley adjoining lot. 20 on the east,
block one, Josep« R. Weides addition, situated on the
North side of Rose Street between Payne Ave. and
Edgerton.
Our frame building has been removed for the p,�rpose
of constructing our new Parish House addition.
Because of the location of windows, partitions, etc,
in the existing building, and the north property
line at the vacated alley, we found there was no
alternative but to project the brick support for the
main entrance canopy beyond the building line.
Under section 20 Par. J. of the building gone
ordinance, we hereby appeal the setback requirement
under section 16 of the same ordinance. The present
building line established by the existing residences
in the block having been built prior to 1922 is 21ft.
no Inches. We hereby appeal to establish an 181 ft.
building line along the east 1L.ft. of the vacated alley.
Very truly yours,
RFUFAY -15: 7i East Immanuel Lutheran Church
JAN ? 1 ,_ .. , byf J
m i l l I
rani,, Minnesota
rani, 1Vli
Weavr. ; 'T}-1 1 S Fey t.4 cAta s o ri- G Nat_ n"Qe - T>is 0
y't