182428 Original to City Clerk 82428
• CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL NO.
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE
/ •UN-RESOLUTION—GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
COMMISSIONE• / t►�l-.. i DATE
RESOLVED, that upon appeal of Out Saviour Lutheran
Church from the decision of the Commissioner of Parks,
Playgrounds and Public Buildings, a fifteen foot building
line is hereby established on Lots 8 and 9, Block 2,
Knauft 's Addition, located on the south side of Beech
Avenue between Johnson Parkway and Clarence Avenue.
Council File No. 182428—By Bernard
T. Holland—
Resolved, Our
Saviour Lutheran That upon r
Chuch appeal from of the
decision of the Commissioner of Parks,
Playgrounds and Public Buildings, a
fifteen foot building line is hereby
established on Lots 8 and 9, Block 2,
Knauft's Addition,located on the south
side of Beech Avenue between John-
son Parkway and Clarence Avenue.
Adopted by the Council April 23,
1957.
Approved April 23, 1957.
(April 27, 1957)
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council�� 2 3 la 195
Yeas Nays
DeCourcy
Holland Approved —195-
Marzitelli
In Favor
Mortinson
ee
Mayor
Rosen Against
Mr. President, Dillon
5M 2-57 2
OFFICE OF CITY CLERK JOSEPH R. OKONESKI
City Clerk
BUREAU OF RECORDS HAROLD J. RIORDAN
Council Recorder
386 City Hall and Court House
St. Paul 2, Minnesota
(CJtI
I _
April 11, 1957 89428
Mr. M. F. Hurley
Corporation Counsel
Building
Dear Sir:
The City Council requests that you draw a resolution granting the attached
appeal of Our Saviour Lutheran Church for the establishment of a building
line on Lots 8 and 9, Block 2, Knauft's Addition, at 15 feet back from
the property line on Clarence Avenue.
Very truly yours, .
COLAYL
City Clerk
3
f":\_
I 1., , Ok
111111.6111 1 ..•
•L . •.. ,O. •...
I
err0 I,
Ill
0 •••13... i , i '
11 :11 :r, , Of :: rinniinn 1 , . _
` 1 ,
i ��I CITY OF SAINT PAUL - MINNESOTA
I
•
111 , 41.91 T Y P -L A N N I N G BOARD OF A I N T N T P A U L
1315 CITY HALL AND COURT HOUSE SAINT PAUL 2, MINNESOTA
April 11, 1957
5')
Mr. Joseph Okoneski
City Clerk
Building
Dear Sir:
This is in the matter of the appeal of the Our Saviour Lutheran Church
to establish anew building line on the south side of Beech between
Johnson Pkwy. and Clarence. The property under consideration is
described as Lot 8 and 9, Block 2, Knauft's Addition. The zoning is
"A" Residence.
The property is presently vacant. It has a frontage of 468.54 ft. on
(-? Beech, 200 ft. on Margaret, 262.75 ft. on Johnson Pkwy. As explained
N, in more detail in the applicant's letter dated January 31, 1957 and
S r the plans filed February 5, 1957, the applicant's propose to construct
a new da;). school building some 50 ft. east of the existing parsonage
which is located adjacent to the southeast corner of Johnson Pkwy. and
Beech Avenue. The applicant's plans call for this building to extend
t . to within 15 ft. of Beech Avenue for a distance easterly to a point
N
some 200 ft. east of Johnson Pkwy. The existing building line on this
portion of Beech Avenue is 27 ft. and therefore the applicant's are
'V requesting a relaxation of this building line to accomplish this purpose.
In reviewing this proposal the Board takes note of the fact that the
applicant's own the remaining property to the east which extends some
268 ft. beyond the proposed school building to Clarence Avenue. There-
fore it is the Board's conclusion that this proposed building line change
would have no effect on the use and enjoyment of adjacent property which
is owned by others. If this relaxation of the building line is granted
the applicant's will be able to move the location of the building 12 ft.
to the north of where it would be otherwise. This re1ltionship produces
a much more desirable effect on the adjacent residential property to the
east which fronts on Margaret Avenue. There is at present a single family
home on this site which presumably would benefit from the additional
light and air that results from moving the school building to the north.
In view of the fact that the applicant's are the owners of all of the
property fronting on Beech St. in the block under consideration and that
no adverse effect results on adjacent property the Zoning Board recommends
that this appeal to establish al5 ft. building line along Clarence Avenue
be granted as it applies to Lots 8 and 9, Block 2, Knauft's Addition.
Very truly your. i
C. D L o k e4,./
Planning Director
Executive Secretary
Board of Zoning
CDL:RJK
. • •
ALBERT G. PLAGENS ARCHITECT TIIe•NONI CAPITAL • 9040
$ AVINUI ST. PAL K I MINNESOTA
Jsaa.ry 31. 1957
T . (*email of the City of Saint Taal
Saint Peal. NiaMNta
O.at 1.s»s t
Ohio erne. 1, planaisg • see Christina Dal
Steel for Oa Mien: Lathersa O>ari; la regard
to this plsaaiag we r.js.st the action of the
Oesaell of tD. City of Saint Paul ao to tPe ootsblie&
soot of a sew b ildiag lime. / fi
?he property eff.etol Is lots le. A to .7 is-
S
elusive , block IS t, ' Jts Ate hies, City of Saint
Peel. Mian.seta sal lsest•t on Boost Arouse.
C
Our request 1e to eet.bli eb a arm building l i me
for lets 1e. 1 I. 12 ia.ls.ivo co follows;
NOR SIDS lO1tODIlO &ZOOK AM ON 15 feet
Iaswiag you will give this Jest oeseit.rati.a.
1 resale
Sta..rely rears
Albert B. Tiag.a
'i r Are►itoot
oat
A.I.Sefr.err• City Arseite.t -�
Mv. V. A. L .
Va. I. Sehalt$. Mair>!s& QTY CLEIC FILE
A1� Ap•
4� w .. qtr
17 ICI 3 /
•
C .
it
ALBERT G. PLAGENS ARCHITECT TE EPHONE CAPITAL 6-3040
r
379 UNIVERSITY AVENUE ST. PAUL.3, ?S11NNESOTA 0r
January 31, 1957 r SAS 3\ p* , 20
'orja
The Council of the City of Saint Paul_
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Gentlemen;
This office is planning a new Christian Day
School for Our Saviour Lutheran Church; in regard
to this planning we request the action of the
Council of the City of Saint Paul as to the establish-
ment of a new build.in f line_. 4t1"
.r
The property affected is lots No. 1 to 17 in- SS
elusive, Block No. 2,Knaufts Addition, City of Saint
Paul, Minnesota and located on Beech Avenue.
r/ ,
Our request is to establish a new building line �'�
for lots No. 1 to 12 inclusive as follows;
FOR SIDE BORDERING BEECH AVENUE - 15 feet
Knowing you will give this just consideration,
I remain
Sincerely yours,
f��I/
(/ Albert G. Pie: .5
AGP;r Architect
cc;
A.E.Schroeder, City Architect
Rev. W. A. Lemke
Wm. H. Schultz, Chairman CITT CLERK FILE
/ 420,4,
APPLICANT e .''._S'9--.0
F