Loading...
184775i Original to City Clerk . 75 CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL E I NO. OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK COUNCIL ROOLUTION- GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONER— DATE RESOLVED, that upon appeal of Joseph J. Bitter from the decision of the Commissioner of Parks, Playgrounds and Public Buildings, a 20 -foot building line is hereby established on Minnehaha Avenue and a 12 -foot building line is established on Hazel Avenue, on property described as NJ of NJ of Lots 1 and 2, Robert L. Wares Eastern Heights, said property being situate adjacent to the southwest corner of East Minnehaha Avenue and Hazel Avenue, all in accordance with applicant's appeal dated September 102, 1957, and development plan attached thereto. COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays DeCourcy Holland 4qaT2*efl+ Mortinson Peterson R.ns'p.n Mr. President, Dillon 5M 2.57 .2 Council File No. 184775—By. Bernard ` T. Holland— - Resolved, That upon appeal of Joseph J. Ritter from the.' decision of the Commissioner of Parks; - `Playgrounds 1 and Public Buildings, a 20 -foot build-, ing- line is hereby established on Minnehaha Avenue and .a 12 -foot build- ing line is established on Hazel Ave- nue, on property described as, Nli of ' N?', of Lots 1 and 2,-Rober t tWare's Eastern Heights; sald p oP y g situate adjacent to the southwest cor- ner of East 1Vlinnehaha Avenue and Hazel Avenue, all in:;accordance with applicant's appeal dated. September 10, 1957, and development plan attached thereto. Adopted by the Council October 8, 1957. Approved October 8, 1957. (October 12, 1957) ' $1957 Adopted by the Council �cT 195— Approved 195 — In Favor • Mayor A gainst d ' OFFICE. OF CITY CLERK BUREAU OF RECORDS 386 City Hall and Court House St. Paul 2, Minnesota October 3, 1957 Mr. Marshall F. Hurley Corporation Counsel Building Dear Sirs JOSEPH R. OKONESKI Ci +y Clerk HAROLD J. RIORDAN Council Recorder 1-847d5 The City Council requested that you prepare a resolution granting the attached appeal of Joseph J. Ritter for establishment of 20 -ft. building line on Minnehaha Ave. and 12 -ft. building line on Hazel Ave., on property described as N2 of N2 of Lots 1 and 2, Block 2, Robert L. Ware's Eastern Heights, for single - family dwelling. Ve truly yours, , Q7 Cit Clerk MINNESOTA 8, .1/ .. .. - > ..... ItD OF ZONING,- CITY OF SAINT PAUL N.O(.dj.* 31.239.953 WIS CITY HAIL AND COURT HOUSI SAINT PAUL 9, MINNESOTA Applicant has a frontage of 97.15 ft. on E. Minnebaba and 73.11 ft. on Hazel. He is proposing to construct a single family home on this site. This Appeal if granted would allow the construction of the single family bomesto be 20 ft. from E. Minnebaba and 12 ft. from Hazel. The existing building lines are 26 ft. from E. Minnehaba and 4 ft.,fkom Hazel. The adjacent areas is develop- ed with single family homes. The property to the west is a side yard of homes fronting Minnebaba and the property to the south is the side yard of a home fronting Hazel Ave. \ A petition dated Aug. 19, 1957 in favor of a proposed change in buslding line on E. Minnebaba is attached signed by nine property owners. This recorded petition in favor of this change on the part of adjacent property owners verifies the opinion of the Zoning Board that this development if approved will not be detrimental to the neighborhood. In consideration of these factors the Zoning Board finds that the purpose and intent of the Zoning Ordinance would be substantially achieved under the cir- cumstances and that therefore the establishment of a '20 ft. building line on E. Minnebaba and a 12 ft. building line on Hazel may property be established in this instance, all in accordance with statements and conditio s conveyed in applicant's appeal dated Sppt. 10, 1957 and develApmenTplarf aitacbed thereto. C. D.�Loek O vVV Planning Director Executive Secretary Board of Zoning CDL:RJK enc. n ZONING APPEAL .. Notice Is hearing will be held before thpublic October 1, 1957 Council at 10 A.M. on October 3, 1957, in the City Council Chamber in the City Hall and Court House, in the matter of the appeal of Joseph J. Ritter, under Sec. 20 of Ord. No. •5840 (the Zoning Ordinance), for establish- ment of building lines on N?? of N;Z of Lots 1 and 2, Block 2, Robert L. Ware's Eastern Heights, at 20 ft. back_, from Minnehaha Ave. property line, and 12 ft. back from Hazel Ave. prop -' erty line, said. property being situated Mr. Joseph OkoneskI p at southwest corner of Minnehaha arld Hazel Aves., in connection with , l Cit Clerk City i construction of a single- family dwell- Ing on said property. Building Dated September 16, 1957. JOSEPH R. OKONESKI, City Clerk. Dear Sir: (September 21, 1957) This is in the matter of the appeal of Joseph J. Ritter to establish a new building line on the property adjacent to the southwest corner of E. Minne- baba and Hazel. The property under consideration is described as the north half of the north half of Lot 1 & 2, Block 2, Robert L. Ware's Eastern Heights. The zoning is 'IA's Residence. Applicant has a frontage of 97.15 ft. on E. Minnebaba and 73.11 ft. on Hazel. He is proposing to construct a single family home on this site. This Appeal if granted would allow the construction of the single family bomesto be 20 ft. from E. Minnebaba and 12 ft. from Hazel. The existing building lines are 26 ft. from E. Minnehaba and 4 ft.,fkom Hazel. The adjacent areas is develop- ed with single family homes. The property to the west is a side yard of homes fronting Minnebaba and the property to the south is the side yard of a home fronting Hazel Ave. \ A petition dated Aug. 19, 1957 in favor of a proposed change in buslding line on E. Minnebaba is attached signed by nine property owners. This recorded petition in favor of this change on the part of adjacent property owners verifies the opinion of the Zoning Board that this development if approved will not be detrimental to the neighborhood. In consideration of these factors the Zoning Board finds that the purpose and intent of the Zoning Ordinance would be substantially achieved under the cir- cumstances and that therefore the establishment of a '20 ft. building line on E. Minnebaba and a 12 ft. building line on Hazel may property be established in this instance, all in accordance with statements and conditio s conveyed in applicant's appeal dated Sppt. 10, 1957 and develApmenTplarf aitacbed thereto. C. D.�Loek O vVV Planning Director Executive Secretary Board of Zoning CDL:RJK enc. n September 10, 1957 To the Honorable, the City Council St. Paul, Minnesota Gentlemen: I hereby appeal for the establishment of building line on the north one -half of the north one -half of Lots 1 and 2, Block 2, Robert L. Ware's Eastern Heights, at 20 ft. back from the Minnehaha Ave. property line, and 12 ft. back from the Hazel Ave. property line, the property being situated at the southwest corner of Minnehaha and Hazel, this being in connection with the construction of a single- family dwelling on said property. Very truly yours, Jo eph J. Ritter 1893 E. Minnehaha Ave. SEP 1 D Ci! � 0 1957 Sai $lui v 6 'b -A d� inne$o a 1u fxr SIR Au&st 19 j 1957 vo tite, Hahox-034 pity: Cdmc --sault Pau9,a "esqta aeal re'Oy appeal ear der Seca A) for 20 (j of ti2d Z=i,!3g QrdA= 0, Voi.$8W , 0 Pl. --the Ostablishmilt of bUilditg lite -on tie' North bb,eobalf of the rt &'-IOU" gii3d, 2k -Mmk 2* Rob6tt;Lw Wake's 4i&tsp at 17�rt�!.F Easteft V line the or, the. purpose ,,qmp i, l4le-fiftil, lvq!. .-Avellk I property. prqpqrty;6 MU property: 10 situated �6t the'ioitt'oVesi C' qrtot of, tru • very 'I;y your tv, hL.o C".' 7d..�cla.G.( C?'Z 'PNAA 3 ' i � ^ To the Honorable City Council Saint Paul, Minnesota Gentlemen: �� "•rye ��A 1�- Unc z OF CITE ILED CLERK 9957 AUG 19 AM 11 30 SAINT P!qj,,_ M,NNi S lITA CLERK August 19, 1957 I hereby appeal, under Sec. 20 (j) of the Zoning Ordinance No. 5840, for the establishnent of building line on the North one -half of the nortq Re -half of Lots 1 and 2, Block 2, Robert L. Ware's Eastern Heights, at 15 ft." rom the Minnehaha Ave. property line for the purpose of constructing a single - family dwelling on said property. This property is situated at the southwest corner of Minnehaha and Hazel. 2060 E. 5th St. PRosp ect 4 -4492 WARREN L F®RSEERG St. Paul 6, Minn. Registered Land Surveyor PLAT OF SURVEY OF PROPERTY OF Jose h Ritter. o Lots 1 and 2 described as follows i l { I I /,�' tj .2, I Aid!; 2 1 1957 C1,1 y �':.ti2vYri1j Sai; -t Paul, Minneso Et CERTIFICATE OF SURVEY I'hereby certify that on , 19 I surveyed the property described above and that the above plat is a correct representation of said survey. d 0� Scale: I inch 3 n feet. O— Indicates Iron Monument. 2060 E. 5th St PRospect 4 -4492 WARREN I. FORSBERG St. Paul 6. Minn. .Registered Land Surveyor PLAT OF SURVEY OF PROPERTY OF Joseph Ritter. described as follows : North one-half of .he No h one -half of Lots 1 and 2, Block 27 Robe -T . :a-arA-1 4 East*— Heights, St. Pauli Minn. 47, 4�� bl ti s 11 N CERTIFICATE OF SURVEY I hereby certify that on ,get C% Z'5, 19 I surveyed the property described . Scale: 1 inch 3 d feet. above and that the above plat is a correct representation of said survey. O— Indicates Iron Monument.