09-426City of St. Paul
RESOLUTION RATIFYING A5SESSMENT
covrtca..r � � ��
J ✓ � �
B �z'',��
Y
v
File No. 19030 ��
Amended Sf06(2009
Assessment No. 5096
Voting Ward
Green Sheet No. `�� �O ` �J/ ��
In the Matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for improving the alley platted GREEN
S`I REET (bounded by Hatch, Orchard, Oxford and Argyle), by grading and paving with bituminous material.
Preliminary Order: 06-870 approved 9/20/06
Final Order: 06-969 approved 10/16/06
WHEREAS, A public hearing having been had upon the assessment for the above improvement, and
said assessment having been further considered by the Council, and having been considered finally
satisfactory; now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the said assessment be and the same is hereby in all respects ratified, **
RESOLVED FURTHER, That the said assessment be and it is hereby deternuned to be payable in
twentv equal installments.
** with the exception of the assessment far 1026 Oxford Street North which is waived with the
understanding that if an ancillary structure is ever constructed with access from the rear alley, the
properiy would be assessed accordingly.
Yeas Na s Absent
Bostrom �'
Carter
Harris ✓
Hel en �
Lan ,/
Stark ,/
Thune ,/
G� /`
Adopted by the Council: Date� ��
Certified Passed by the Council Secretary
g ,
Mayor
City of 5t. Paul
REPORT OF COMPLETION OF ASSESSMENT
courrca, r�.E rro. ��" ���
�
File No. 19030
Assessment No. 5096
Voting Ward
Green Sheet No. ��� � � f � �
In the Matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for improving the alley platted GREEN
STREET (bounded by Hatch, Orchard, Oxford and Argyle), by grading and paving with bituminous material.
Preliminary Order: 06-870 approved 9/20/06
Final Order: 06-969 approved 10/16/06
To the Council of the City of Saint Paul:
The Valuation and Assessment Engineer hereby reports to the Council the following as a statement of
the expenditures necessarily incurred for and in connection with the making of the above improvement, viz:
Total construction costs
Engineering and Inspection
Valuation and Assessment Services
TOTAL EXPENDTTURES
Charge To:
Net Assessment
$ 26,208.42
$ 7,862.53
$ 2.384.37
$ 36,455.32
$
$ 36,455.32
Said Valuation and Assessment Engineer further reports that he has assessed and levied the total
amount as above ascertained, to-wit: the sum of $ 36.455.32 upon each and every lot, part or parcel of
land deemed benefited by the said improvement, and in the case of each lot, part or parcel of land in
accordance with the benefits conferred thereon; that the said assessment has been completed, and that hereto
attached, identified by the signature of the said Valuation and Assessment Engineer, and made a part hereof, is
the said assessment as completed by him, and which is herewith submitted to the Council for such action
thereon as may be considered proper.
Dated �"�����
���-; �
C� aluation and Assessment Engineer
� ��� ,�a.� �� �lis loq
� Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet
'� Department/�ce/CounciL- ! Date initiated: �, �/��
FS - FinancialServices ; Zo-FEB-09 Green Sheet NO: 3067117
Contact Person & Phone:
Pete Gallagher
266-6085
Must Be on Council Agenda by (Date): !
15-APR-09
' Doa Type: PUBLIC HEARING
. (RESOLUTION) �
�I E-DocumentRequired: Y �,
j Document Contact: Lynn Moser �,
� '
Assign
Number
Por
Routing
Order
0 Financial Services
1 Conncil
2 Citv Clerk
3 '
4 ;
5 '
Contad Phone: 26G8851
ToW I# of Sig Pag _(Clip All Locatians fuc SignaWr
Action Requested:
Approval of assessment for improving the alley in platted Green Sheet (bounded by Hatch, Orchazd, Oxford and Argyle).
FileNo.19030 AssessmentNo.5a96
Recommendations: Approve (A) or Reject (R):
Planning Commission
CIB Committee
Civil Service Commission
Personal Service Contracts Must Answer the Following Questions:
1. Has this persoNfirm everworked under a contract for this department?
Yes No
2. Has this person/firm ever been a city employee?
Yes No
3. Does this person/firm possess a sltill not nortnally possessed by any
current ciry employee?
Yes No
F�cplain all yes answers on separate sheet and attach to green sheet.
Initiating Problem, issues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why):
Ratification is necessary in order to begin collecting assessments to help pay for the project.
Advantages If Approved:
Same as above.
Disadvantages If Approved:
Proper[y owners will have assessments payable via property taxes.
i Disadvantages If Not Approved:
�� To not assess the benefits would be inconsistant with City policy.
I
Total Amount nf $36,455.32
Transaction:
Funding Source: ASSBSSmeflfS
Financi al Information:
(Explain)
CostlRevenue Budgeted: Y
Activity Number:
�
February 20, 2009 2:07 PM Page 1
�
�
�
a
�
7
a
�
� g
a
�
�
m
O
N
�
�
�
�
�
�
O
0
N
O
�
�
i M
�o
qiti
H � O
.� � M
E � �v
a�
w ��,
Pa i N
� 1 I
a�m
a�N
I 1
1 �
N
� �
�o
,�
O
� M
� N
� M
� N
1 �
� N
I �
� N
� �
�o
,�
r O
I i M
� N
i �
��
I 1
i rn
� N
I �
i N
�m
i o
rY
� O
i M
� N
i M
� ry
I �
i ry
1 �
i ry
ir
�o
,�
O
� M
i N
� ri
� N
1 �
�N
' I �
� N
im
io
I N
O
i �
i N
i ri
� N
1 �
� N
I �
� N
i rn
�o
1 N
i p
� �
� N
i M
� N
i �
N
I I �
� N
U] � O II O � O II O i O II O � O II O � O II O � O II O � O II O
N� o ff o � o n o i o n o � o n o � o n o � in u�n � m n in
z � . �� • . II • . II . • 11 - • II • • �� • � � II •
a � h II !� i W II C � C 11 C � f� il L� i I� 11 I� i Itl II �fl � tfl II ifl
O � n n r � u> n in � m n in � t� u t� � t� n t� � f+ n.v �,� n,�
�� d� i� C � Ol II 6i i Ol 0 Ol � d� II C �� II C � N II N � N �� N
� �I � - II � - II � � II � - II � � � II � - II
��i II ri i N II N � N II N �.i il .-i � ri II .i i N II N � N II N
R.' �+/1 II LT i u} II V? i L} il U} � Ut I� t/? i vY 11 t? i LY II LT � U} II LT
O� II � 11 i 11 II i �I 11 11
F� if f 11 � 11 II II il it
U i II II II II II II ' II
�� II II II II II II II
w� n n i u n n n n
m�io �o ��o io �io �io �o
Eio io io �o �o io io
r-� � o � o � o � o i o � o � o
z� o i o � o � o i o ��n i m
D �
� m � o � o i in i in i r � t�
Fk � N � Ifl i Ifl i N � N � t'1 � t`t
� I
H
U I I I I 1
Q I
w I � I
1
[] �I O ' I O � O � O �I O I O I � O
� i W 1 N I W � 0 I Q� I UJ 1 W
O I O I O � O � O I O � O
I • �
1 O� 1 O� 1� 1 T 1 p1 1 T I O�
E i�n i in � in � in � in � in ��n
H 1 i I
� I I I I
1 I
1
� I
I
1 1
I �
I
I 1
I I
I
I �
[I] I I I
� I I I
I , I
z� �
� �
a � �
o�� �r �r �a� �a� �r �a�
E i W i W i W i W i W i W i W
u�a �a �a �a �a �a �a
wi� ia i� i� iy �� ��
�
i
i i Cu W
� � O O
w W v w � w w w i w
��no � �no a� � �no � mo � u�o � �no a � mo a
z � � � - a a
o� ar � ar x � aa� a� � ar � ar � aa� �c � ar �C
��at-+ �aH a �aH �aH �aF �aF �aF
F� W H I[i] H (l� i[x] H .Y. i W H I[xj H i[x] H (] i[x� H ❑
a�wu �wu �mu a�wu �wu �mu z� �wu 2�
��a �a m �a m �a �a �a �w
U� FCx2 � FCx�F � FG'xZin i�x2 ��x2 � rCxZm i�x2rn
m�UE.z �UH O �UEZ �VE2 �UH2 �UE2 �VE2 C
W i H C H�] H H N y� � H y� H E C � H E C
Q 1 Q 0�i � I Q � Fi I❑ 0.S.i 0 � Q z Q� GN I Q Q.7'-� C 1 Q ��i �<M i Q �� �
>+ i�F �' � 2H C] � 2H .a � r�C E ^�L i r,CF ,�' � 2E .] i�F .]`.0
E i z.7.7 F �2.7� ��� zax � zaa zaa �`�zama zaww�
fY � HO,'� W � FO� � E07 � NO�fA � EO�P] � FO]O W � FO�O
W �'j� H f�' � 'jv H (f. N � 'j.� H Q' d' I 7.a H F4' �'j+ H 6i � 'Zr H Fl �'.7i H �' O
a�wHa� �wHa �wFa �wFa�o �wNa� �wHaNro �wFa�.,ti
O� L') H � U' H m � CJ H UI �(9 H i C7 H i C'J H \ I U' H \
cZ � CGQ •E � fYCI •E � aLl •E � fY Cl •E � [KQ •F � fYLI ��E � fXCI •tiE
w i FCqEO � FCQEO ��CQEO � 4 CQ EO � FCC1F0 �
� c�ama � m�cma � m�cma � mama � m�c�na � ma�za �� ma�n�n
� � � �
�
� � � �
� �a �
�� �� �� � �� � �� �� �
� Z O� O i O� N O� N O i� O i O
"j I � I N 1 I W i (n
I' p� I N I O� I M m i M CO I H N I m
� a M N. � M rl i[y M rl I N rl I OJ r { i t ] M rl 1 !") �-I
O � O I[y' O I I O O O O
��i N O� N O i[Q N O i C O I C O i!7 N O i N O
Pi ri ri � rl ri i Q� �-1 �-I I U] N `i � U� Ul rl ri rl i ri 'i
i i
W t r� � M � O M � �n + �n � M �'Z� ri
�� 7 E ��� � E o�� � p.' o F •• W E•• W �� � rn o F •• i O o E ••
E � >2tn W� >2 W� 2 Ftimw i HE��n W
CL i UI Cn tfl Q i UJ Ifl Q ��h' U1 lfl �� F� -'�'. �� R�. � Q i H Cn LI1 � I Ul U] Ifl Q
� � u�w � x �nw � H �,w � w � � a �nw �
u� w
�x w am�aw am�a w acn� omau�� ❑m v��w w au��xw am
F�a azra�oazrrc�w aza�a�zx�ra�zce�Fa�N azr��oazra
��c �.�cn � Ea��c� � x rEC� � oaac� � oaam �nr�c� � hr�c�
a� x c� ac� � c� xc� � c� ac� � �naoxc� � mao c� � q�c� ac� � c� ac�
o� aaFC2 � E�Ka�C2 ��waa42 � a.+a�C2 � aHawz � r.tia�C2 � hcxa�Cz
� r� �!y (� '.7 H� .�J H t �.] C(' " H I O C) fC H I O[J �. a H �'j Ul f�' '".J H i F(' "�J Fi
w' � p W FCmq �� 1�n0 � FCw' FCrnQ i W inQ i W,NC] � W 2 /.�[�C] i 2 r1tnQ
w ��Ccerna<nz � a�naMZ � axmaNz � z�-+zNz ��z�zc9z � rxr+ra�,z � w�na�z
z�aoM ow��M ow��wN ow�x�,zow�xNZaw�Qa� ow�a.�+ ow
3� rLOOHr+w �£oEr+w � rLOoEtiCL � Oviri�-f W� O�ni-+r.�w i zW oF�a oHtia
O� 7'�.'�-ftns • i W,�cn« x� w�.+cnx • i hrvi£x � i hc�'i�a a� r.�N.i�� x i ,ymx •
i
I
I
I
I
�
I
1
D 1-y�
N
�
�
a
�
7
L�
�
a
�d
�
�
�
0
�
�
�
�
�
�
0
�
N
0
�
�
N
i p
t �
O��
H i O
'N � M
F i �+
a I I
W � M
SL � N
� �
a �o�
a�N
i �
i N
� � O il O
E � �n»u�
z � ���
a � � II �
O � rf II 'i
� � N 14 N
� II �
� N II N
a �+ir nm
O � u
E � II
U � II
� � II
w� n
U1 � o
E�o
H i O
z ��,
l J �
i r
a � M
� �
EI I
�
W 1
� ti
i N
i ti
� O
� rl
� ry
� M
� N
� �,
� N
i �
� N
� O II O
� �n n ui
. „ .
i N il LIl
� N II rl
� N II N
� II �
� N 11 N
� vrnvt
II
II
II
�I
ii
�o
io
� O
� �
i r
�M
� N
� N
i ti
O
I I M
� N
� rl
� N
��
N
i �
� N
i � II m
� w n m
.„ .
i � �i m
� m �I �
� O 11 O
� II �
� N II N
i vrnm
II
II
II
II
II
�o
�o
i �
� M
i �
� M
I
� �
i N
i ti
t O
i M
� ro
� �
r N
I I
� rn
� N
i �
i N
� O II O
� N II N
.„ .
� C il �
i � II �
� P 11 P
t � II �
i � II �
� v}nz�
II
II
II
II
�I
�o
�o
i O
�o
i N
��
I f
I
� �
i ti
� ti
� O
� rl
� N
� M
� N
1 �
� N
i �
� N
i O II O
� o n o
� . „ .
����
� P I� h
� C 11 C
� II -
� N II ti
� m n �
I�
il
II
II
II
�o
io
� O
I O
� �
� N
I
� b
i N
i ti
� O
i �
� N
I �
+ N
I �
N
� �
� N
� O II O
i o u o
� . „ •
����
� P �� L�
� -} fl C
� II �
i ti II ri
ilnnut
1�
II
II
II
II
�o
�o
� O
I p
i �
� N
I
�y-�a��
W� O � O � O I O � O � O �
[ti i W i W i QJ i �'J � m i 6�
a i O O i O i O � O i O
I T I O� r O� I O� I I Q� I N
F� N � N ��(1 � tfl � t11 � N
H I I
2�
a
i i i
i
�
i
i i
i i
�i i
i
W i i
� i i � �
i i i
z � � �
C4
O i?i i N i,>� i,'a+ i,>+ i T '
EiW iW �W �W �W iW
u�a �a �a �a �a �a
rL�a �a �a �a �a �a
w i r.� i r�C i rj i r.� i y i F(' i
I I
i i i H E,y W i W i
w i W i i m W U] N O O
O O H W E W F
O� Z F O E O � O H O �
W .7 W .7 w w .7.+EW w wa w w a
� cno a � cno a � �no ��no mwa � u�o c� � mo c�
p �� ar � � ar � � ar �� as� o �- zmca �- zmq �
H ar H,� � ar H.�
aH q �aH ca �aH �aF xw �aH z �aF z
H� W H 2 i W H z � W H i W H F W W U O I W H W W � W H W W
W � fYl U r� i W U r.� � W U � Rl U Fu f�.' RC N � 0.l U W W � W U CL W
H i W i p, � R, � w O L9 > > w O.] O � w O rl O �
Ri W � N W • N G] i W m U1 � [x7 � O W O �
V � �x2ti � �xz ,� � �x � �,xz �n.] W Cum � ��2l.k[u3 � �x2a'mS
m� U N 2 d' � V N 2 a� V H� d' � U E 2 FC O O ti � U H 2 O � U E 2 O �
[[�{ � H E � � H F GN � H � 1 .Y [L� 1 H [y {i] Ei 1 H [L [S] F
Q� q �.F-�� I Q��� I QQE I QDE •C�FUI I Q�E .T�iUI I QQF. r T.U]
�� ZH .7a � ZH .7a 2E+ a � zE W roz W F � 2E FH � 2E EH
fC FC (.0 FC � O t-I H O I fC • W '.z a� FC - W Z v �
F� zaww zawro� zaw � za zma za Hwa� za Hwc�
a' � H O� O � N O 7 O � F O� � E O� H� W.1 � F O�� m W � F O�� m w
W� 2 r+ FC ,y i 2 H rC ri i z f+ FC a� i,Z r-� FC w cx w �k a� i 2 H rC .y [x aG i 2 H FC .-� a' ^.4 �
W� W H WN.i � W H WNti � W EW�-i � W Ea x0 W C� W E4L 2C7.7 � W ELL 2U' .] �
O� C9 H \ � C9 H \ � �') H i C'J M O E'� W I��'J H W[I] p] I�J H Cq [t] (p i
C4 � C4Ca •.�f+ � C4Q •�H � F4C] •F � C4C1 •a 0.' W O:.' � C4C1 • W U � 0.'q • W U
a��qH O � FC�H O� FC lE0 � FCL1F �nOx .7 � FCqH>C[KFC<v � r.�q FiCa'rj�n i
� UlFLm2.7 � mFCUlUIrI � ma,'U1a � mFCU13�W E+3 W� U1FCUl W C�>N � U1FCU] W U' >c� �
i
i �
i 2 i i r�' �i Q' i
�C �
� m �o � io � m � a � z �o � 2 �o �
i,7 0 0� o i o � W o W o i
I (fj I I I (.� I [i] I I [I]
m� �o� w� ro �a ro�a � �
� cC rvi ,� � m .i � r� � � W ,y ,y i x �o ,-i i x io .a
� W o i o i o ul cn [-i a F v �
� C9 N O � N O � N O � O N O � N O N O
a �a � �� ,� �� � �,�x ti ., �� ti � �� � ti
w� w M � H M �, n z M z�,
� � � � �
N� m o E •• � m o E •• � a o N ^� a o w •• � rx o .• � a o •• �
FC � Z E.ti[11 W i HF�tR W� W F�U]G. � W W.-a7w � W E.-1 w i W H.� w �
a� W u] in O���n �n O� W�n �n O� 2 > in FC O � x ul ui O � x �n N O �
� c� a�n w � a �, w �� �, w � c� ��n � � �n � � �n
� c�ww au� � aw a�n ��w am � r� x� ;� az�� � a azwa �
H� pc�azr�C aza+�C � c�aza��c � a xz��C �
� �aw�c� � �rEC� � rEC� U�N � �d o�z � �d o�z
x� wc� ac� � oc� xt� � ac� ac� � w F �cc� aw c�c� aw c�c� �
o��nmaa�¢z� aaaz� xa�cz� aaxz �EaxaNz �saxa�z �
� wza5 � � caa� � � cea� � � aax.� � tioa�n� �oau��
a�,aw s.�ca , a�nca � m �„�❑ � ww a,,n 3 amca 3 acnca �
w � ac7,-ra.iz � wviao2 � �,-�aoZ � ..?��a�v2 � z a'o�owr.C2 � �aca�oar.�Z
2� RCC7�-1 o W i.70 O W �£O O W z3N O W � cnON 2 W � U]ON z W i
3� x.'� o E.1 a i qoF'+ W�]o E.-+W � r.�r-CoE� a �]Oo[-i�a i�OoE,'� a i
O� UC7.� m« x � RNCn *� � m,y cn+ + i q tn�-tu1* • � cRC� m�* � cn C�.-i cnx • i
��
�
A,�
M �,o
W >+ i M
C� E � cv
a a
a w�M
Pi i ry
O
a � o�
a�N
��
�
� N i
I
� I C 11 C
F � �n 11 �n
z � .��
a�����
o�����
������
�II
� � � II �
ri a � �n{n
O n
a E� n
W U � u
� m � ii �
rL �n � o
5 E�o
H i O
z��
� a
� ��
o a
N Q I
F � i
ii U i
Q
E W
£
c11 W � o
m E i m i
a a��o
�� �
o H � �
(h N
O � I I
�
N
I '
E �
W i i
7
O
a �
a �
a �
o w� �
w �
F z� �
�
H �
a o�a�
F�w �
z � � a
N w � FC �
a
�
w i c i
5 [u N
O
E i w m
2 � � O F E �
w z� wo
s o�ar a �
w �+ � aF m �
o a�mu �oc�
W' i—t i W W W
a a 5�w • x �
~ W i UEHE �C� i
U Q 1 Q ��y p� 1
�-+ E E+ h c� �
.] .'a� i _ U1 q �
w F � za �CF �
a a�W�a���a�
O � C� i-a h 'J �
x � aq •wua �
a � �qFaFCx �
� cnfCcnm>H �
� �
� �
i 2 �D i
� o�
w� �
� cn rS io r+ �
� '.� x ri i i
o a�xz aw°�
i W� C� H[] M�
o a� � za>o� ••
N a � �aa� u, �
� � � aa �nQO �
N �C � �Ur
0
E �U�x£U� i
� o � �"�aaoz �
� S[KO� H �
t� GL' � W Q N q �
d' W � ZEN4LNz �
z�xEN ow�
� S � oP oF.+a �
,-i O��-i U1 .-� CA * r i
N I� N
M II C1
• II
� II �
� II �
s n m
�n
io n �o
Cl II M
�II�
�
n
N
W
a
�
�
0
H
�
a
w
U
�
a
E
a
S
w
x
W
0
�
E
o a
H u
V C4
W FC
o °i
C w
a �
09- �a�