190380ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK ' 190380
• CITY OF ST. PAUL F LE NO1 NO.
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
COUNCIL RES UTION— GENERAL FORM
PRESENTED BY
Comm ISSIONE DATE
RESOLVED, that upon appeal of Mrs. 'Effie Garrett from
the decision of the Commissioner of Parks, Playgrounds and
Public Buildings, permission is hereby granted, under the Zoning
Code, Chapter 60 to 64 inclusive, of the Saint Paul Legislative
Code, for the extension of a non - conforming use on property
adjacent to the northwest corner of St. Anthony and Western
Avenues, described as the south 44 feet of Lots 28, 29 and 30,
Block 14, Mackubin and Marshallts Addition.
��ti13
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays
'Muourcy
Holland
Mortinson
Peterson
Rosen
Winkel
Mr. President, Dillon
W 5 -5e 2
Council File No. 190380 —By Bernard.
T. Holland —
Resolved, That upon appeal of Mrs.
Effie Garrett from the decision of the
Commissioner of Parks, Playgrounds
and Public Buildings, permission is
hereby granted, under the Zoning,,
Code, Chapter 60 to 64 inclusive, of i
the Saint Paul Legislative Code, for �
the extension of a non - conforming
use on property adjacent to the north-
west corner of St. Anthony and West -'
ern Avenues, described as the south
44 feet of Lots 28, 29 and 30, Block
14, Mackubin and Marshall's Addition.
Adopted by the Council December
23, 1958.
Approved December 23, 1958.
(December 27, 1958)
DEC 2 3 1958
Adopted by the Council 19
DEC 2 3 1958
Approved 19-
V /��
—In Favor
_J
Mayor
gainst
OFFICE OF CITY CLERIC,
BUREAU OF _. RECORDS `
386 City Hall and Court House
St. Paul 2, Minnesota
December 18, 1958
JOSEPH R. OKONESKI
Ci +y Clerk
HAROLD J. RIORDAN
Council Recorder
19 380
Mr. Marshall F. Hurley
Corporation Counsel
Building
Dear Sir:
The City Council requested that you prepare a resolution granting the
attached appeal of Mrs. Effie Garrett for the extension of non - conforming
use on the south 4+ ft. of Lots 28, 29 and 30, Block 14, Mackubin and
Marshall's Addition, at thenDrthwest corner of St. Anthony and Western
Aves.
Ve truly yours ,
i�ty Clerk �r
Z e
DEC 18 1955
CORPORATION COUNSEL
MINNESOTA
8<z>
:t; R D O F
+ai+:251- 212.153
...:........................
ZONING, 'CITY
1318 CITY HAIL AND COURT HOUSE
4
OF SAINT PAUL
SAINT PAUL 2,11111411,111601A
December 8, 1958
Mr. Joseph Okoneski-
'City Clerk
Building
Dear Sir:
This is in the matter of•tbe. appeal of Mrs. Effie Garrett,for,the extension of
a non - conforming use on property located adjacent to the northwest corner of
St. Anthony and Western Avenues. This property is described as the south 44 feet
of Lots 28, 29, and 30, Block_ 14, Mackubin and Marshall's Addition. The zoning
has been "B" Residence since 1922.--
The existing building on this site was erected in about 1914, and consists of
a tavern, pool ball-,'and lunch room on the first floor; and three residential
units on the second.floor. The applicant is desirous of. securing permission to
construct an addition to the present building in order to provide a ladies'
entrance to the lunch room, and new sanitary facilities.
The present building line on Western Avenue which was established in 1922 by
the structures in the block which were built prior to -that time,is 8 feet 4 inches.
According to the plans submitted by the applicant, the proposed building would be located
on the property line.
Field investigation discloses that the extension of this present non - conforming use
would be in conflict with future redevelopment, or rehabilitation of this area.
The adjacent land uses are as follows: east across Western Avenue is the Ober
Boys Club; north and adjoining are four one and two - family residences fronting
on Western Avenue; south across St.Antbony Avenue is the new R/W for the Twin
City Expressway; west and adjoining are residences fronting on St. Anthony Avenue.
The Planning Board staff conferred with the Housing and Redevelopment Authority
in this matter, and their conclusions are the same as ours, namely, that the
extension should not be permitted.
It is the .feeling of the Board of Zoning that the granting of this appeal would
deviate substantially from the intent and purpose of the ordinance, and would
be-detrimental-to the surrounding area. Therefore, the Board of Zoning recommends
that this appeal to(extend a presently non - conforming use on the above described
Property be denied.
Sincerely,
Herbert C. Wieland
Planning Director
HCW: FGI _
Encl.
PUBLISHED
T
LETTER OF APPEAL
St. Paul, Minn.
.t October 22, 1958
TO: Honorable Mayor and City•Council
j n T
r,
SUBJECT: Addition of building at 365 North Western. v
lieant: Effie Garrett �
a. Name of A " N
pP
b. Legal Description: South forty -four (44) feet ;of �Iiots
twenty -eight (28), twenty- Lne,.r'(29 ),,,pnd
thirty (30), Block Fourteen (10, Matkubin
and Marshall's Addition.
e. Street Location; Northwest Corner St. Anthony and Western.
d. Present use of Property: Beer tavern, pool hall and lunch room.
e. Proposed use of property Same
f. Purpose of Appeal: To enlarge or make addition to present
building.
g. Need of Appeal: Improve rest room and lunching facilities and
attract feminine trade.
h. Chapter appealing under: Legislative Zoning Code, Chapter 64.03,
Par. b, reading as follows:
"Permit the extension of a non - conforming use or building
upon a lot occupied by such use or building at the time of
the passage of this ordinance, or permit the extension of a
non- conforming use or building upon a lot where such non-
conforming use or building was valid at the beginning of
such use or construction of such building, provided that no
non - conforming use shall be extended so as to permit the
maintenance or operation of any filling station, vehicle
parking lot, retd.l ice store or on -sale beer or intoxicating
liquor establishment in any residential district except upon
a hearing before the Council ten days after written notice to
all property owners adjoining opposite and those on both
sides of the street and streets bordering the site of the
proposed filling station* vehicle parking lot, retail ice
store or on -sale beer or intoxicating liquor establishment,
within a distance of two hundred (200) feet, measured along
the center of the streets or streets."
Submitted herewith are two (2) copies of a Plot Plan showing present
building and proposed addition,
5
.<-- PZ