09-1100City of St. Paul
RESOLUTION RATIFYING ASSESSMENT
COUNC ILE N . 09-1100
$ y ^ „�� - � k�
File No. 18744-09 &18746-09
Assessment No. 090150 & 090151
Voting Ward 3 & 6
Green Sheet No. 3075277
In the Matter of the assessment of benefits, costs and expenses for the Arcade/Case and the Grrand/Snelling
parking lots operation and maintenance costs for 2010.
Preliminary Order: 08-1043 approved 09/17/08
Final Order: 08-1137 approved 10/15/08
WHEREAS, A public heazing having been had upon the assessment for the above improvement, and
said assessment having been further considered by the Council, and having been considered finally
satisfactory; now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the said assessment be and the same is hereby in all respects ratified.
RESOLVED FURTHER, That the said assessment be and it is hereby determined to be payable in
one installment as per Section 64.04 of the Administrative Code.
Yeas Nays Absent
Bostrom
Carter ✓
Hanis ✓
Hel en ✓
Lant
Stark
Thune
�
Adopted by the Council: Date: 1 C� �' 'L5Q
Certified Passed bv ti�e C mcil Secretary
�
By ' � ;
/ r
` l'vA �
Mayor
City of St. Paul
REPORT O�' COMPLETION OF ASSESSMEI�iT
COIJNCIL FILE NO. 09-1100
File No. 18744-09 &18746-09
Assessment No. 090150 & 090151
Voting Ward 3 & 6
Green Sheet No. 3075277
In the Matter of the assessment of benefits, costs and expenses for the Arcade/Case and the Grand/Snelling
parking lots operation and maintenance costs for 2010.
Preliminary Order: 08-1043 approved 09/17/08
Final Order: 08-1137 approved 10115l08
To the Council of the City of Saint Paul:
The Valuation and Assessment Engineer hereby reports to the Council the following as a statement of
the expenditures necessarily incurred for and in connection with the making of the above 3mprovement, viz:
Total costs
Engineering and Inspection
Valuation and Assessment Services
TOTAL EXPENDITURES
Net Assessment
Arcade/Case Grand/Snellin�
$ 1,332.0� $ 16,144.00
$
$ 93.00 $ 1,215.00
$ 1,425.00 $ 17,359.00
$ 1,425.00 $ 17,359.00
Said Valuation and Assessment Engineer further reports that he has assessed and levied the total
amount as above ascertained, to-wit: the sum of $1,425.00 for the Arcade/Case pazking lot and
$17359.00 for the Grand/Snelling parking lot upon each and every lot, part or pazcel of land deemed
benefited by the said improvement, and in the case of each lot, part or parcel of land in accordance with the
benefits conferred thereon; that the said assessment has been completed, and that hereto attached, identified by
the signature of the said V aluation and Assessment Engineex, and made a part hereof, is the said assessment as
completed by him, and which is herewith submitted to the Council for such action thereon as may be
considered proper.
Dated
�`��—�� ��
� Valuation and Assessment Engineer
��cb li� �r�`n� //�/7/09
� C�reen Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Shee� �
DepartrnentlOfficeJCouncil: Date Initiated:
FS —FinancialServices 10-AUG-09 Green Sheet NO: 3075277
Contact Person & Phone- Deoartment Sent To Person I iti Date
LynnMoser 0 mancialServices L D1ase�
26fr$$S1 1 ounN Ma Erickson
�� 2 i Clerk SLari Moore
Must Be on Council Agenda by (Date): Number
07-0CT-09 For
Routing
Doa Type: QUBLIC HEAR4NG Order
(RESOLUTION)
E•Document Required: Y
Document Contact: Lynn Moser
Conqct Phone: 266-8851
Total # of Signature Pages _(Clip All Locations for Signature)
Action Requested:
Ratificarion of assessment for the operation and maintenance costs for the Arcade/Case and GrandlSnelling pazking lots for 2010.
File No. 18744 & 18746 Assessment No. 090150 & 090151
Recommendations: Approve (A) or Reject (R): Personal Service Contrects Must Mswer the Following Questions:
Planning Commission �. Has this Derson/firm everworked under a conVact for this depaAment?
C1B Commiltee Yes No
Civil Service Commission 2. Has this persoNfirm ever been a cily employee?
Yes No
3. Does this person/firtn possess a skill not normally possessed by any
current ciry employee?
Yes No
Explain all yes answers on separate sheet and attach to green sheet
Initiating Problem, lssues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why):
Revenue is needed to operate and maintain [he lots.
Advantages If Approved:
Same as above.
Disadvantages If Approved:
Affected properry owners will have assessments payable via property taaces.
Disadvantages If Not Approved:
Pazking lots could not be operated or maintained.
Toql Amount of
Trensaction: � CosVRevenueBudgeted: Y
Funding Source: ASS6SSf112lItS Activity Num6er.
Financial Information:
(Explain)
August 10, 2009 11:21 AM Page 1
d
�
G
�
�
�
R
C
�
O
0
0
s
0
e �
m o
., ;,
0
u �
N y
L �
0.
.°�+
N �
�o
e y
C �
d t:
x�
�a
W
E
m
Q
�
7
�
a
.�.
�
0.
Q
0
0
N
O
�
M
a
i
I
IO
�
L] I O
��
��
L IN
� N
I�
I
I
I
E �o 0
0 0
Io 0
h h
LI N N
��
��
1
� �S
� �o
IN
I
I
�, I S
a ��
a I
�
�
� '
U �
I t N
� =' a
e � c �
� E..,
o I
a �
�L I � �
" c �
q �' 3
6 � a'"i �
d I c +
:. O >
I
�yH
lo o
w
`� O
F �'^
G �qn
° ��z
L I��
�
Ca.ioo
L INQ�
IQW
I
I
I
I
�
� oo a
�� N �
v �
� x z,� v�i �
%��z��W o
R ¢
F
a`� ¢ x � ... � W U e�
Y ¢ r 7 � z � '� 'p
C I '�'�Soarn3a� m .
Izx�w..
i
I
I�
�o
��
��
I
1 N
I�
I
I
I
� o 0
0 0
�o 0
� h
i� �
I
I
I
lo
IN
1
I
I
lo
��
�
�
� *
(�j t
I � T
�G c
�� �
I � �
�� 3
�� O
a
�O :
I
�ooz
IH w��w
I�QOOFF
�qW��00
I °O
m„
p N N � N
�
2�'�a
3x
���s
� �
I� ¢ O F � y
I
1
I
I
� � � °o
I� o �
x � � �
� W � � �. W p
������a
�o � m�
�
� _
I rT'�QaC n c �`d
IU �OFrn3a
��c.'a.�na
i
I
IM
lo
� e }
��
� N
' N
la
I
I
I
l o 0
0 0
lo 0
Vl N
I� �
I
I
I
Ig
'O
I
I
I
IS
��
�
�
� �
v �
U
Y
I� 6
I � F
�` a
N �
I '� 3
� `tl O
c �*
�O .
I
F�
F�
�° Wo
I�F
Ip6
o ao3
1¢aoz
f7<M�
I����
�
z
�
��e�
I?SN�yN
I � ¢ � 6 W
I
I
I
I N
� �
�
�� rn
��
w � a
w'
.d
�r� �`-
���q• o
�� �Or�nv W i�o a�o
�
�.a z�0'r+ `m C
13°�m�
i
I
I�
lo
��
��
IN
IN
la
I
I
I
� ° o
�� �
Ifn E9
I
I
1
Ig
I�
I
I
I
lo
�—
�
�
�
� �
v �
I C T
I a; m
a �
I� F
�
9 C
I� A
I � 3
�� O
c ;
�O .
I
IyF
lo o
w
I �O
�
�6a �
�<N
I���
�z�°
IO<F
I��p
I � ¢ ¢
I
I
I
� �
�
I � � o
I ¢� �
�UU��� m
I°'v�0 rn �
j zF - 3C�w �.:
a ,��, W o �a �
I � �
� � x ,. ] Q � O 9
��z°'"a
O rn�w
IatiN�...
0
0
�
�
�
�
U
❑
C
G
�
�
0
.`
v
0
�
0
F
0
0
�i
�
�
y
�
U
L
R a
F .._ y
Y
a�i s�. a�i
• R x
�aw
Wco
09-1100
d
a
a
L
R
R
�
N
.ti
O
s
a
0
�
� �
�
a
U =
d O
y d
a. a
�+ Y
Fa Q
b0 C
° o
L '
N �
x�
°a d
E
d
Q
d
E
�
c
.�.
�
a'
a
° o
N
..°.
�
�
N
N
a
�
�
I�
lo
�o
N
I "'
, N
IN
� 0
�
�
�
l o O
O O
� V <
h h
I h h
h h
I Vj 69
I
I
Ip
Ih
�h
i
I
io
I"
I
I
I *
t
C %
�� `v
Iw a
I � �
Ib 9
I � R
I I � 3
` � �
�
�O :
I
IF
I o
w
��
��
I�
�z
�
IQO
I��
I ^
I
I
I
I
�
�� � o
I .`�', `° y N
a d, w a
{ Otr]O> M
U>� t�
�a¢�o
� �.`-�., Q 2 ?, c
��z�a a
w � ,.a a �•, ,n
� � O Q � b �
I QO F1' O � �
����t 3a
�
�
�
O
A
d
L
L
m
F
L
0
�
�
I�
Io
` o
M
I
IN
I N
��
�
�
�
IO O
�v v
h h
Ih h
h h
IfA Hi
I
I
I
I�
Ih
I
I
IS
I'�`
I
I
I
I �
U X
� `v
�°�' c
I� F
I 9
I � �
1
d
�� 3
I� �
I � "
O +
I
lo
�w
I<
� a
u
I�
��
a
� H
I 7 O
��a
,�m
I
I
I
I
I
� : o.
N �
I� p O
W o 'y �
m
� � a Q �
lo�3z o
x
� � � ti � � �
I Q W � V�i � N
I�°Q.
�
�
IN
�o
IN
I "'
IN
IN
� O
�
�
�
I O O
O O
��'v �
I co m
v3 V]
I
I
I
�p
I�
�
I
I
lo
I�
i
I
I
I *
f
U +F
� �
I� 0.
�� �
9
�� �
v
�.� 3
IY �
a
�O ,'t
I
I
�
Ix
��
IF
�°
�W
�F
I�
I�
'�
I
�
I
I
I
I P A
N �
N
N �
� �.�.,
� ¢ �n Q ti
I�z�Q o
� �
Iz �_� � a
� Q � a 9
� aar , m �
hH�3a
�- v] � a
�
�
I�
�o
I
/'S
I "'
IN
IN
' O
�
�
�
I O O
O o
I co m
� �
� m w
43 fA
I
I
I
Ip
I�
�
I
lo
I"
I
I
I *
(�j k
� v
I� a
�� F
I� 9
I � �
�
�� 3
, L �
� �
�O +
I
�
I
�w
Iq
�o
��
I F
l�
IN
I
I
I
I
I
�
I � a
I � O
N �
N N
� � W �
y W ° � `�'
I��¢� �
� V� q� z o
F� ¢
I H 4�,.�w �
� +-1 �'-� �r � v � L'
��j"-�7�'o�ao m c
l°���: 3:
�
�
I�
�
I�
I "'
!H
I�
� O
�
�
�
IO O
I v� �n
0 0
� _: �
I Y� 43
I
I
Ip
Ip
I�
I
I
1S
I''
I
I
IV '
�� �
I � �.
I � F
I 9
I �' �
v
I � 3
Iw �
� �
( O +
I
�
�u
��
IF
�°
�w
IF
I�
IN
I
I
1
I
�
�OO
I�N
�
I�H °
za �� o
IoNN7 r\
��3�¢ �
a V
�� � � � o
ja��w" m
� �j � 7.. 'p '.
Iz N °a- '�3c ' � ° '.
� .� !. � � �
�
� 09-1100
1�
lo
IN
IM
IN
I N
� O
�
�
�
I O O
O O
I h h
0 0
� r: �
I(A fA
I
I
IO
Ip
��
I
I
lo
I'"
I
1
I �
Y �
�
�
I - `°
C �'
�� F
9
I� �
C �
�� 3
I4�i �
p � . �
� C� +
f
I
�
u
��
I �;
�°
��
�
1
I�
'
I
I
I
I
I O o
1a W o
I z •' � i b� N
I O � N � t�l
I°3�¢ �
O
� � v � '.� o
� W Z 5 � �
�'� � w M �
G
� a��/..9:6
Iz c�v�'.�o3a
� .� -� � e •
N
b�D
0.
�
a
m
�
ti
O
�'.
a
0
�
� '�
., ;
.. 3
V n.�
d Q
Y �
a a
d
aW
�°
e �
e
•� .
m �
d
xw
� ��
e
d
a
�
£'.
0
6
H
u
a
a'
0
N
0
�
N
a
I
'�
IO
I�
I M
��
I
lo
I
I
I
� o �
0 0
�o 0
I� =
I � �'
�
�
Ip
Ip
I�
I
I
IS
I�
I
I
I U *
IN N
I� �
� � I � �,
I� g
I� �
I � 3
� :°. O
� *
�o >
I
f
I
�°m
I�j
�O�
�zo
I�a
��o
F j
I �Z
I
I
I
I
�
IQ W o
I �
o � N � m
�'�30¢ r
C7
Io�Nz o
���d�m"' _
� a � 2 � ;b
' H N a �O i� Cn
�.7 �. e .
m
0
�
s
� R
� �
_
.
O
E
�
O
L
d
C
m
�
d
K
�
�
0
L
d
3
O
O
�
M
.-�.
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
b
[�U
0
.�
0
�
f�^
O
�
M
r
�
�
u
R �
F v a
� a
y L y
L '�� W
R.h o
09-1100