Loading...
200187Saint Paul, in accordance with instructions from the Council, appeared with Solly Robins of the firm of Robins, Davis & Lyons, before the Judge in Chambers, of the Ramsey County District Court, the Honorable James C. Otis, for the purpose of ascertaining whether the Court would approve a minor settlement in connection with the cases of Geraldine Fincel, a minor, by her father and natural guardian, Frank A. Fincel, vs. City of St. Paul and the Board of Education of the City of St. Paul, and Frank A. Fincel vs. City of St. Paul and the Board of Education of the City of St. Paul, and WHEREAS, the Court indicated that it would approve such settlement, as is indicated in its Order, a copy of which, is attached hereto and made a part hereof by reference, and WHEREAS, Mr. Robins of the firm of Robins, Davis &' Lyons, has submitted t this Council, for filing in the District Court, Dismissals wit;rejudice of the above captioned actions, and WHEREAS, Mr. Robins has agreed on behalf of his client to furnish'to the Corporation Counsel a letter, signed by the parents of Geraldine Fincel indicating that they recognize that the settlement for the sum of $100,000 is a full, final and complete settlement of all claims involved in both lawsuits and that Geraldine's injuries, both known and unknown, are included in the settlement, and WHEREAS, Mr. Robins has also agreed to file with the Corporation Counsel of the City of Saint Paul, when the same is issued, the Order of the Court setting forth the manner and allowance of disbursements to be made, including medical, hospital and related expenses, as referred to at Paragraph 2 in the attached Order of the Honorable James C. Otis, Judge of Ramsey County District Court, now therefore be it COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays DeCourey Holland Loss Mortinson Peterson Rosen Mr. President, Vavoulis 5M 5.60 2 Council File No. 200187 —By Mrs. Donald M. DeCourcy— Bernard T. Holland — Severin A. Mortinson — Robert F. Peterson — Milton Rosen — Whereas, The Corporation Counsel of the City of Saint Paul, in accordance with instructions from the Council, appeared with Solly Robins of the flrm of Robins, Davis & Lyons, before the rnr. r "•!� rr,re.rrc .thrAp�liirov a Tn Favor Against FA Mayor sr OR5GINAL TO CITY CLERK ` s - - -CITY OF ST. PAUL COUNCIL PA rood • OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK FILE NO• COUNCIL RESOLUTION — GENERAL FORM PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONI RESOLVED, that Chapter 3329 Laws of Minnesota for 1959, approved April 189 1959 and filed April 20, 19599 is hereby adopted and approved by the Council of the City of Saint Paul; be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Council of the City of Saint Paul directs the Board of Education of the City of Saint Paul to pay the amount of the settlement hereinbefore referred to, in the sum of $100,000.00 in accordance with the Order of,, the District Court of Ramsey County with respect to disburse- ments of such sum, upon the signing of such Order by the Honorable James C. Otis, Judge of the District Court of Ramsey County, Minnesota. 1 COUNCILMEN Yeas Nays DeCourcy Holland Loss Mortinson Peterson Rosen / Mr. President, Vavoulis ✓ 5M 5.50 Z -In Favor i a gainst DEC 2 3 1660 Adopted by the Council 19— -DEC 2 3196© Y To the Honorable Mayor and City Council of the City of Saint Paul and the Corporation Counsel Gentlemen: We have had explained to us by His Honor, Judge Otis, and by our attorney, Solly Robins, the effect of a release of any and all claims on our own behalf and our daughter, Geraldine Fincel's behalf, acting as her natural guardians and parents, and haying in mind the foregoing, we hereby release any and all claims of whatever kind, nature or description, known or unknown, in consideration of the payment of the gross sum of One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($100, 000) for and on behalf of any such claims which we have had, now have, or in the future may have, for or on behalf of ourselves or on behalf of Geraldine Fincel on account of that certain accident which Geraldine Fincel sustained on June 5, 1958, at Johnson High School, as is more particularly described in our Complaints filed in the District Court of Ramsey County, Sincerely yours, Frank A. Fincel Josephine Fincel I have read the foregoing and have had the matter explained to me by Mr. Robins, and I agree to the same. --I r- Z � Geraldine Fincel 0 O n n> � w � -n m C7 W Q) A Board of Education Meeting - 5/19/59 - P. 7 1/0oig� Report of Secondary School Report Card Committee, contd. the Reporting Practices Committee after a thorough evaluation of the present reporting system and detailed study and review of report cards used in other systems. Features of the new form were described by Mr. Simmer and Dr. Leino. Other members of the subcommittee present who commented on advantages of the new form were Mrs. Richard Hunt, Co- chairman Education Committee, PTA Council; Gerald McKay, President, Murray PTA; Malcolm Smiley, Princi- pal, Cleveland Junior High School; Claudius Wilken, teacher, Monroe High School; James Palmer, counselor, Murray High School. Both Mr. Hagstrum and Mrs. Bratnober expressed disappointment with the quartile plan. MOTION - After a lengthy discussion of the new form, Mr. Hagstrum moved that the Board accept the report of the committee and adopt the proposed pupil's progress report for secondary schools, and that the Reporting Practices Committee be retained for one year for the purpose of review and evaluation of this system. Motion seconded by Mrs. Paul. Carried. The President thanked the members of the Committee for their presen- tation and for a very fine job in this study. 14 - Consideration of Chapter 332, Special Laws of 1959 - B.F. No. 3101 The President presented the matter of the Geraldine Fincel case. He stated that the Legislature has made it possible for the City to waive defense of governmental immunity. The matter was referred to the City Council who, in turn, has referred it to the Board of Education for a recommendation. The President submitted a resolu- tion for consideration of the Board. MOTION - Mr. Hagstrum moved that the following resolution be adopted: RESOLVED, that having had the matter referred to it by the City Council, the Board of Education, after due consideration, hereby recom- mends that the Council of the City of Saint Paul approve Chapter 332, Special Laws of 1959, in the event and only in the event of a prior and effective District Court Order contingent upon such Council approval of said law, approving and authorizing a settlement whereby the total liabilities of the City and the Board of Education, respectively, shall be limited and defined as to the aggregate amount to become payable by them or either of them on account of the unfortunate accident which provoked such legislation, and that otherwise the Board of Education recommends against the approval of said law by said Council. Motion seconded by Mrs. Bratnober. Mr. Tilsen of Robins, Davis and Lyons, attorneys for Geraldine Fincel, asked that the Board adopt a resolution recommending that the City Council pass an enabling ordinance without any limitation, and later `'"' "" revised'" his' request" to`ficlude`' a maklidixm amount.` / over—/ Board of Education Meeting - 5/19/59 - P. 5 9 - Contract Changes MOTION - Upon motion by Mr. Hagstrum, seconded by Mr. Mielke and carried, the following resolutions were adopted: B.F. No. 3096 RESOLVED, that upon the recommendation of Voigt and Fourre, Architects, and the Consulting Architect, an addition of $59.80 be allowed for the following changes in the construction work at Humboldt High School, Humboldt and Elizabeth Streets, Saint Paul, Minnesota, under Contract No. G -1698 between the Board of Education of the City of Saint Paul and RYDEEN CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, said changes having been requested by the Board of Education and agreement made with the Contractor, and a memorandum of said agreement having been filed with the Comptroller and countersigned by him: Add one L -10 fire extinguisher in room 111; add one 10# CO2 fire extinguisher in room 205; change 5# CO extinguisher in room 111 to 2J gal. pressurized water, and omit 5 #2C0 2 extinguisher from room 204 (B.F. 300 EA 18) $ 59.80 B.F. No. 3097 RESOLVED, that upon the recommendation of Voigt and Fourre, Architects, and the Consulting Architect, an addition of $103.50 be allowed for the following changes in the rehabilitation work at Humboldt High School, Humboldt and Elizabeth Streets, Saint Paul, Minnesota, under Contract No. G -1698 between the Board of Education of the City of Saint Paul and RYDEEN CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, said changes having been requested by the Board of Education and agreement made with the Contractor, and a memor- andum of said agreement having been filed with the Comptroller and countersigned by him: Change in steel angle supports required to support fireproof roof deck for room X9 $ 103.50 B.F. 310 ER 144 10 - Compensation Claims MOTION - Upon motion by Mrs. Paul, seconded by Mr. Mielke and carried, the following resolutions were adopted: B.F. No. 3098 RESOLVED, that out of the Board of Education Fund 15.62, weekly com- pensation of $42.33 be paid Mary Griffin while she is totally disabled by reason of injuries she received on December 15, 1958, while em- ployed by the Board of Education of the City of Saint Paul, and that $245.51 in final settlement for her temporary total disability, to and including January 23, 1959, is now payable; and be it FURTHER RESOLVED, that Mary Griffin be paid the sum of $253.98 out of Board of Education Fund 15.62 in full settlement of her claim against the Board of Education for compensation resulting from her injury of December 15, 1958, whereby she suffered 15 percent permanent partial disability to her left index finger, and that said sum of $253.98 is now payable. / over—/ Board of Education Meeting - 5/19/59 - P. 4 ' 8 - Authorization to Purchase w#hout Bids MOTION - Upon motion by Mrs.' Bratnober, seconded by Mr. Hagstrum and carried, the following resolutions were adopted: B.F. No. 3090 RESOLVED, that the Purchasing Agent be and he is hereby authorized, with the consent of the Comptroller and the approval of the Board of Education, to purchase from the NATIONAL CASH REGISTER COMPANY, 4 Model 21- 204- 1- 3- lR- 8(g) -1, National dash registers for various school cafeterias, at a cost of $2180, less educational discount of $65.40, making a net amount of $2114.60, without advertisement or competitive bids as these are patented articles and no advantage could be gained thereby. Charge Cafeterias - Rep.Ren. & Equip. 1020 -F B.F. No. 3091 RESOLVED, that the Purchasing Agent be and he is hereby authorized, with the consent of the Comptroller and the approval of the Board of Education, to purchase from MONROE CALCULATING MACHINE COMPANY, one Monroe Educator Model LN140E calculating machine for Girls' Vocational High School at a cost of $195, without advertisement or competitive bids, as this is the only source of supply and no advantage could be gained thereby. Charge - 15.81 -75 B.F. No. 3092 RESOLVED, that the Purchasing Agent be and he is hereby authorized, with the consent of the Comptroller and the approval of the Board of Education, to purchase from INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES, services for changing all I.B.M. public school clock systems to daylight saving time at a cost of $280, without advertisement or competitive bids, as this is the only source of supply and no advantage could be gained thereby. Charge - 15.42 B.F. No. 3093 RESOLVED, that the Purchasing Agent be and he is hereby authorized, with the consent of the Comptroller and the approval of the Board of Education, to purchase from SCIENCE KIT INC., science supplies, at a cost of $627.21, without advertisement or competitive bids, as this is the only source of supply and no advantage could be gained thereby. Charge - Storehouse Stock Revolving Fund 1072 B.F. No. 3094 RESOLVED, that the Purchasing Agent be and he is hereby authorized, with the consent of the Comptroller and the approval of the Board of Education, to purchase from GENERAL BINDING CORPORATION, 6 boxes 7/8" and 5 boxes 3/4" (100 per box) wide -back plastic binding for elementary physical education department, at a cost of $183.15P without advertisement or competitive bids, as this is the only source of supply and no advantage could be gained thereby. Charge 15.22 -39 B.F. No. 3095 RESOLVED, that the Purchasing Agent be and he is hereby authorized, with the consent of the Comptroller and the approval of the Board of Education, to purchase from M. J. CHASE CO. INC., 1 Chase hospital doll, adult size, with tracheotomy and colostomy irrigation, for Girls' Vocational High School, at a cost of approximately $260, without advertisement or competitive bids, as this is the only source of supply and no advantage could be gained thereby. Charge 15.81 -75 rover 7 BOARD OF EDUCATION ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA Regular Meeting Tuesday, May 19, 1959, 3 :00 P.M. I - REGULAR MEETING of the Board of Education Present - Mr. Tucker, Mr. Mielke, Mrs. Bratnober, Mr. Hagstrum, Mr. O'Donnell, Mrs. Paul, Mr. Conner, Superintendent of Schools, Miss Johnson, Assistant Secretary Absent - Mr. Rafferty II - MINUTES - MOTION - Upon motion by Mrs. Bratnober, seconded py Mr. Hagstrum and carried, the minutes of the May 5 meeting were approved. III - CONANT REPORT Mr. Rock announced that today's discussion would take into consideration recommendations 5 and 6 of Dr. Conant's report: Supplement to a High School Diploma and English-Composition Robert Schanke, Assistant Principal, Mechanic Arts High School, discussed the recommendation that each graduate should be provided a wallet -size card con- taining his high school scholastic record, in addition to a diploma, which record would be readily available to employers. Mr. Schanke felt that no individual should be asked to parry this type of personal record, and further that this information would give only a partial history of school Achievements- -that it would not take into account extra- curricular activities, personal qualities, ability to get along, etc. He said that to get a true evaluation the employer should call the school coun- selor who is in a position to fill him in on all details concerning the applicant. Miss Jenny Ann Kloet, English teacher, Highland Park Junior High, discussed the recommendation that half the time devoted to the study of English should be given to English composition. She said that she felt in the development communication should be covered -- reading, organizing material, as well as writing - time devoted to these areas as background to English composition, then she would be factor. of English composition all areas of speaking, listening, spelling, and that if Dr. Conant considered to be included in the period devoted in agreement with him on the time She said that a folder is kept on each student showing samples of work; that it is passed on to the next teacher who Adde to it, and so on, thereby giving each succeeding teacher background on which to measure the pupil "s progress composition -wise. She felt that it was desirable for the teacher to correct themes and discuss papers individually with students, but that because of large enrolments and the time involved, general class discussions, rather than individual dis- cussions in most cases, were a necessity. / over—/ "O.FF-ICE OF CITY CLERK BUREAU OF RECORDS 386 City Hall and Court House St. Paul 2, Minnesota MRS. AGNES H. O'CONNELL City Clerk HAROLD J. RIORDAN Council Recorder vvoI�1 Dec. 27, 1960. F I L E D Mr. Joseph L. Donovan, Secretary of State, State Capitol, St. Paul, Minn. Dear Mr. Donovan: I enclose a certificate of approval by the St. Paul City Council of Chapter 332 Laws of Minnesota for 1959, together with a copy of the resolution of approval and an affidavit of publication thereof. papers. I will appreciate your acknowledging receipt of these With best wishes for a very Happy New Year. Very truly yours,. 6L 961 JAN 3 An 10 11 CITY CLFr;I.'S OFFICL" SAINT PAUL, MINN. STATE G7 DEPARnIMT OF 5 ?Al2. FgT" FID DEC 2 8 1960 Secretary of State MINNESOTA £<� ! OFFICE O F CITY CLERK Cif MRS. A6 H. O'CONNELL Cify Clerk BUREAU OF RECORDS HAROLD J. RIORDAN Council Recorder 366 City Hall and Court House St. Paul 2, Minnesota i- Dec. 27, 1960. FILED �I JAN 3 An 10 11 Mr. Joseph L. Donovan, C I1 Y i Secretary of State, ,.. State Capitol SAI Pi c �,UL, MINPJ. St. Paul, Minn. Dear Mr. Donovan: I enclose a certificate of approval by the St. Paul City Council of Chapter 332 Laws of Minnesota for 1959, together with a copy of the resolution of approval and an affidavit of publication thereof. I will appreciate your acknowledging receipt of these papers, With best wishes for a very Happy New Year. Very truly yours, City Clerk STATiL' C7 i DEPAC.:..:Z.NT C; ;.T.4 -. lit 1 1L./ Lj xM DEC `' 8 1960 r Secretary of State P ' With best wishes for a very Happy New Year. Very truly yours, City Clerk STATiL' C7 DEPAC.:..:Z.NT C; ;.T.4 -. lit 1 1L./ Lj xM DEC `' 8 1960 Secretary of State CIT , -- Y "OF SAINT P.AUL MINNESOTA e• 4 OFFICE OF CITY CLERK BUREAU OF RECORDS 386 City Hall and Court Ho.; , St. Paul 2, Minnesota Dec. 27, 1960. i Mr. Joseph L. Donovan', Secretary of State, State Capitol, St. Paul, Minn. Dear Mr. Donovan: - I enclose a certificate of approval by the St. Paul City Council of Chapter 332 Laws of Minnesota for 1959, together with a copy of the resolution of approval and an affidavit of publication thereof. f I will appreciate your acknowledging receipt of these 1 papers. ' With best wishes for a very Happy New Year. 1 Very truly yours, 4 _ City Clerk �� J S: AT- .J 1960 Secretary of State j CITY 0 F $AINT,,PAUL- MI NNE SOTA 1 . J OFFICE OF CITY CLERK MRS. AGNES H. O'CONNELL City Clark �l BUREAU OF RECORDS -HAROLD J. RIORDAN 386 City Hall and Court House Council Rocordar I St. Paul 2. Minnesota 11 f y 1 t 9 Dec. 279 1960. Mr. Joseph L. Donovan. Secretary of State. Stator Capitol, St. Paul, Minn. Dear Mr. Donovan: - I enclose a certificate of approval by the St. Paul City Council of Chapter 332 Laws of Minnesota for 1959, together with a - copy of the resolution of approval and an affidavit -of publication thereof. papers. 1 I will appreciate your acknowledging receipt of these With best wishes for a very Happy New Year. Very truly yours, / G *�, City Clerk STATE UF T�::HISSOTA .4vt DEPARTMMT CF LTATI r U D Its , ; J - `� DEC y � 81960. " f' R i,• �. ,. ` . , Secretary* al 3taTA t' =•grit► rte' —` r. 'li,r't.:�,`� • ,.� :, -. `4 s }- . M I N N E S O T A - r� Iry t OFFICE OF- CITY CLERK MRS. AG H. O'CONNELL City Clark BUREAU OF RECORDS HAROLD J. RIORDAN Council Recorder 386 City Hall and Court House St. Paul 2, Minnesota 6 k Dec. 27, 1960. I Mr. Joseph L. Donovan, Secretary of State, , State Capitol, St. Paul, Minn. Dear Mr. Donovan: I enclose a certificate of approval by the St: Paul City I Council of Chapter 332 Laws of Minnesota for 1959, together with a copy of the resolution of approval and an affidavit of publication thereof. papers. 1 d t F I will appreciate your acknowledging receipt of these With best wishes for a very Happy New Year. Very truly yours, City Clerk C� DEC 11960 Secretary of State 1 CITY -OF SAINT PA -UL- MINNESOTA DuDIIute to Bueinen Office BOARD OF EDUCATION FILERD No. 31o1 ST. PAUL PUBLIC SCHOOLS RESOLUTION— GENERAL FORM 7 DATE C a R�LVED j that having hand the matter referred 'to it P by the City Council] the Board of Educationj after due con - Y siderationj }hereby recommends that the Council of the City of Saint Paul approve Chapter 332, Special Laws�of 1959, in the event and only in the event of a prior and effective District Court Order contingent upon such Council approval of said law] approving and authorizing a settlement Whereby the-total liabilities of the City and the Board of Zducation, respectively, small be limited and defined as to the aggregate amount to become payable by then or either of them on account of the unfortunate accident which provoked such legislation, and that otherwise the Board of Education recommends against the approval of said-law by said Councils Adopted ray 19 1959 iii /sort H. M rkar President, Board of Education S. Conner Superintendent of Schools 1250 8-66 a I • t To the Honorable Mayor and City Council of the City of Saint Paul ,and the Corporation Counsel Gentlemen: We have had explained to us by His Honor, Judge Otis, and by our attorney, Solly Robins, the effect of a release of any and all claims on our own behalf and our daughter, Geraldine Fincel's behalf, acting as her natural guardians and parents, and having in --hind the foregoing, we hereby release a'ny and all claims of whatever kind, nature or description, known or unknown, in consideration of the pa ent of the gross sum of One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($100,000 for and on behalf of any such claims which we have had, nowhave, or in the future may .have, for or on behalf of ourselves or on behalf of Geraldine Fincel on account of that certain accident which Geraldine Fincel sustained on June 5, 1958, at Johnson High School, as is more particularly described in our Complaints filed in the District Court of Ramsey County. Sincerely yours, g-'— Frank A. Fincel J hine Fincel 3- I have read the foregoing and have had the matter explained to me by Mr. Robins, and I agree to the same. n c-� - -i r r" cn 10 y C. M Geraldine Fincel Q� 0 0 rn n n� —n w � -v m N w on I� L w s l9 r)" CIU,PTER 3 Z CERTIFICATE OF APPROVAL OF SPECIAL LAW BY GOVERNING BODY (Required by Laws 19599 Chapter 368) STATE OF MI OTA County of s TO THE SECRETARY OF STATE: t PLEASE TAKE NOTICE That t e dersigned chief clerical officer ( of the v &'.� a DOES HEREBY CERTIFY, that in compliance e with the provisions of Laws 1 _ 9591 CHAPTER 3 3 2- , requiring approval by a on a j t9 vote of the governing body of the a o overnme� a un before it becomes efffective, the es na a govern ng body) at a meeting duly held on the e2 day of ���2►,.- , 19 0/0 , t by resolution C�►r -�r ' .Z o v /97 did of her than resolution, specify) approve said Laws 1959, Chapter 33 , by a majority vote of all of the members thereof: (Aye s noes � ; Absent or not voting ) and the following additional steps, if any required by were chart-_ er �tak n.� .r� A co of the resolution e solution is hereto annexed and made a part of this Certificate by reference V (Off c sgnainofof ter (This form prescribed by the Attorney - General •� Seal and furnished by Secretary of State. 5/59) I' -4 - } ;`• ` ltd. - Y'- . '-` _. ,E. Tr ..",' .�. . _-a, _ ' _ 'claims of her -ia_ them for all' ,e�ipe_ rases ' ari ®:frig out,, of,- "this y accident,P acid �the.'claim, of .both, "plabit1ff'•.e• father and - "" ••` mother. r loss of eerpicee -, 'it befng - intended 'by' =the.- �*`' ' a . • *r- ... '� ij .•'` .• ` _:. '. ._ •f _ '• t 1. _., ._ ;.:y :.. zy�,. ,. .: ,.. ,j4 -'•._ - . ~es t hat parti shin settlement . is a.ohieved, ' •i phall : be . •' . a.-,; ful and teal. settle�entof `all clskime o� .the plaintiff ; r - P ! _ and -her, respective .parents Hawing (heard '.tbe-atateeNente of-'-r 0 '-counael-,= as to' liability, aad 'cgasid ®rin '�th -, extent of � pia;intif %• a injtirieet and their'permanericy.,' the Court 'believes •that, the '� _,.lr,' 4i•• {.. .':, _ '?.. •fit -,*• T.. • - - ^ _ - ^ - _ .•,4 . tentative settles_ ent figure- is fair, ,reasonable and just, >'Y •' - ' to all = parties concOrne.d': ` Now,, ..therefore, havin�;'heard "'and considered the ,• _ jj' ^.arguatente'`;of couIIael, athe oral' atat ®meats a: plaintiff' aad • her parents,. and based upon the *rittea reports of the doc- - tors the Court being fully •.advised •in the premises, a.. . f _ s ' : ', ' k'j' • IT IS I1SRM_ ..OBDSBBDs 1) '!The - tentative "sett 6fterit`-in. "the "euai of =$100;0'00. . � Is- hereby approved; andA Fran, A: 4 i6c ®1; as tither and f > natural guardian of °Geraldine _Finkel; a minor., isk hereby ; authorized.'and directed to accept_'a sum of $100,000 ae full_ ,. ario final' paymeatP gor `all,- claims, of Geraldine '.Y ncel, .Frank - Finael, ' and''Jo ®ephine, ]d.� 'Fines', arising out ' of the v. ':`_. �• ., injuries. to plaintiff _as'f met" forth in plaintiff's complaint and in Frank. A.r Tincel* a complaint' said 'settlement' to in= - `. ,clod® sn and All claims', ii oh the plaintiff r rind her parents Y w► i � '4. • ti ' `_ t -.�, -1' i4• � -• M1 � ' -- - '.%. .. '';'. aS, _Y -' -;•- ''. •.- ` , l a •' . , - _ r,•,, "•:. • _' - r - ;__ r._ 'y ` - ' may have: in sayi way arising out of 'the above ni riee =7 ThOL manner . and allowance of 'dinbure ®menta to.• _be ftade• for medical; •hb►apitah•aud related ei oenses and the rM• -_-,." -,• r• `' allowance - -for• ati orneys! f ®ee' °and costs; are�';hereby•subject•Yiy •': _ R' t_ o'•the 'fitrther order. "of'� this Court' to be oade :44te,r •formal r. oettlenent is consuvmated. TBIL4. OMB efgnod and `;dated .at °.,$t; Paul oMinnesota,, ; ;` oa. thisy''oi- 73ecemb ®r, 11960.. ;• x' - -,- s'so;, 4 -BY THE COUR' - . y 7 =i; �4 ,. tom: %a•.t .' • ', jl -v _ r_•� „; ^; e- 1 - y'' _ - - - ,r _ _' . -. - .. ' .. ;t. _ Y'. . ' a. `' •. • - . _ C 4 r , _ psi. ^• ., ' . Judge: ,+ ' t • '. •- - • "•_'.. -may �, •, `11' • • -.!••a .6• • _ _ _- ' 'S. ` ' • ,• _•t _ • _. a - •.- •�r'+` - L: - _Y 7,� Y- _ , .. = '"rho+ ,•4 ` ` r f •a;`. •L '.YF - • ,r - ..J::. - STATN' .OF tI ' 1 NN$80TA IN DIB i cr COURT :. COUNTY' OF" RAMSEY - . = SECOND JUDICIAL DI`STRLCT . ' (ieraldiae�Fincel- -a - minor, by her father and natural. guardian, -Frank ' A.' Fincel, .. Plaintiff; ...., _ ORDER , • ' F City • of 3t: Paul` and - th$ ' Board _o! L , _ . 'Sd_ ucation of the."City of 3t.. Pau3 , k. } , •.1. ,a • .. - r-- rr —r —r -- x .. , .. .~On camber 22,' leeOJ; the parties "above' uamed � -. .4 the ° underei ned for mutually .1brought on a petition before - g. - - - i a royal of' a ro Deed [isettlement of the above action by ' aiiior for personal injuries . ;. :. 'Court) Robins '' Davie ,gi Lyons, j #(8.' Robins, YEsq., , is rporation" Appeared':.for. plaintiff ;.,.Robert Swords, q. , Co " Counsel,' -the CitF Of at Paul_,' appeared for both de= .off fendantB,` iacel hnd'Mr, -and ,Nre.: Frank A. P .Geraldine ^�tir-pArents; appeared:personally and'•were ,present before, the •Court." °The' Count^ had befor$. it' reports by. Dr. Robert "I:. - I[errick,_;.neurosurgeon; Dr..Richard J. Johnson,•ortho- ;- _ pectic ®pea alist`,".. attending physicians, as'_aell ,as. various ;. ,. 1 a bills !or and related ser`fices,'` all ^medical, ,hospitals . . .. _- f -. '; ` .f • _ '; teiiniog . to'; pla'inti!!! ea io juries.. ..,. It fully _appears. -that the "plaintiff 'has sustained' „ "•"' a+ elitis with resultant paraplegia, a•.severe- transverse F r _ , ; 'which has resulted in _ ermaII @Dt, paTa• lyBi9 -from-_the ` waist ! , • - - .,- . I • ;- •• '.�. Y • -• _ .'4 down: � - _ _. . .., • � • _ _ • ` '• .: :Y•. •ears 4t .. y ' It further •a• that the parties• hereto have PP ' - 4: - negotiated a tentative 'basis for - settleffien, in 'the sum of - ' loo pm)09, which sum- includes. the ,plaintiff Rs claim, the`' .. RETURN IN 5 DAYS TO JOSEPH L. DONOVAN SECRETARY OF STATE CAN YOU STOLUIVE U.S.POSTACE K ST. PAUL 1, MINN. IN TIME ? �' oec29'60 r %i= �j X04 SLOW DOWN AND ti"N`' P.6.14ETE Mrs. Agnes H. O'Connell FILED City Clerk 386 City Hall & Court House St. Paul 2, Minn. '91 JAN 3 AN 10 CITY c " 'S OFF IC �,.,�' SAIN