197334COUNCIL FILE NO -------- c9
-� a__
By--------------------------- - - - - -- ------------------------------
FINAL ORDER
4 �
In the Matter of reconstructing the sidewalk on both sides of Hillside Ave. from
Gordon Ave. to Como Ave. on the north and from Gordon Ave. to Knapp Place on the
south
under Preliminary Order --------- 195$94 ------
Council File No. 197334 —
In the Matter of reconstructing the
sidewalk on both sides of hillside
Ave. from Gordon Ave. to Como Ave.
on the north and from Gordon Ave.
to Xnapp Place on the south under
Preliminary Order 195890 approved
February 16, 1960.
- - -- approved ------------ vFebruary- _16;
ME=ER-AM'SOC. W CIVIL ENGINEERS Am. SOC. OF PLANNING OFFICIALS
G E O "R G E H. H E R R 0 L D
2251 HILLSIDE AVENUE
ST. PAUL S, MINNESOTA
May 08, 1960
Honorable Mayor and Council
City of St. Paul
Am. INST. OF PLANNERS
297334
7
Dear Sirs:
In the matter of reconstructing sidewalks on Hillside
Avenue, Gordon to Como. I have 90 feet frontage on the north
side of 2251 Hillside, i.e., 15 feet, lot 12, 50 feet, lot 13
and 25 feet, lot 14, blk. 43, St.Anthony Park North. (See
sketch attached.)
The northeasterly 21 feet of this walk should be reconstructed
as tree roots have raised and broken the tile and cause water to
stand. The southwesterly 65 feet is just as good as a new walk
could be, perfectly level, no tree roots and only a few hair cracks.
The remaining 4 feet is my one -half of driveway construction, a
driveway joint with my neighbor. The reason there are no tree
roots in this 65 feet is that the elm midway is a replacement
for 2 box elders, broken by.a storm and removed by the city
Forester. The new elm will not have roots in 20 years that might
disturb the walk.
I wish to protest the reconstruction of this 65 feet as it
is unnecessary. I regret that I cannot be present at the hearing.
Reesspectfully,
George H. Herrold
Nll
INN\
N IN'll
Qj
N!
N01
N
N
�I
Cy)
INN\
WE, the undersigned property owners,
preliminary order 195890 which proposes
sidewalk on both sides,of Hillside Ave.
that any property owners who wish their
or replaced should do so on an individu,
NANE
Ila
vat
aA
W r
r
wish to oppose
to reconstruct the
It is our feeling
sidewalks repaired
3.1 basis.
ADDRESS
2 -z-
'�Z- "7.
226/ �/� /�'�d� '`f�� •
-4 a% l
-2, x- 3
2:z F7. 7v44��.,aCR., cz--
i
4
-.7 2 z � r %kE� uee
........ . ................. ....
1
1.9-7334
' 70 - J - CITY OF ST. PAUL ► - -y
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
REPORT OF COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE
_ ON PRELIMINARY ORDER
J
In the matter of reconstructing the sidewalk on both sides of Hillside Ave. from Gordon Ave. to
Como Ave, oh-the north and from Gordon Ave. to Knapp Place on the south, 9�
under Preliminary Order approved February 16, 1960.
To the Council of the City of St. Paul:
The Commissioner of Finance hereby reports as follows:
The total estimated cost of the above improvement is - - - - - _ .52 per sq. ft. for
11 Mono. C one . walk.
The estimated assessment per foot for the above improvement is - - - - $Ex: ra work at extra
cost.
The lots or parcels of land that may be assessed benefits for such improvement, and the assessed valuation of
each lot or parcel as last reported by the Assessor, are as follows:
IIDESCRIPTION
I LOT
IBLOCKI
ADDITION
I LAND VALUATION BLDG.
3, and
I 11
I )
I St Anthony Park North
II 7. 000
Part of Lot 5 east of a line drawn
1
1
from southwest corner of said lot
1
1
I
11
11
to a point on northwest line 20 fel
I
I
II
11from
most west corner of
1 51
43
1 do
800 2,900
II
Part of Lot 5 west of a line drawn
I
I
I
,I
from the southwest corner of said It
I
I
II
11to
a point on the northwest line 201
1
1
11
11feet
from the most west corner,
I:.
I I
1Iand
all of 1
6
16 1
do
975 3,600
1I
I
n
Form B. B. 10 1M 3 -58 4008
' � t
CITY OF ST. PAUL
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
REPORT OF COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE
ON PRELIMINARY ORDER
(B)
IIDESCRIPTLON
I LOT IBLOCKI
ADDITION II
LAND VALUATION BLDG.
71
431
St. Anthony Park North
II 8 875 4,100
H 1
81
431
do
11 875 3, 600
11
Lot 9 and northeast 50 ft. of
1 101
431
do
11 1,750 3,700
11
Except northeast 50 ft.;
1 101
43
1 do (11
1,975 3,800
Lot 11 and northeast 35 ft. of
i 121
431
do ( (11
Southwest 15 ft. of Lot 12 and all 1
131
431
do d
!1 Northeastiof 1
141
43
1 do (,i
1,525 3,200
11
Southwest 1 of
1 141
43
do
11
1 151
431
do (11
1,275 3,600
11
1 161
431
do
11 850 3,250
11
1 171
43
1 do
825
II
1 181
43
1 do
11 800 3, 600
11
1 191
43
1 do
I1 775 7,700
li
1 201
43
1 do
11 75o 4, 800
11
1 211
43
1 do
11 750 4, 400
1,
1 221
431
do
11 750 4,300
11
i 231
431
do
75o 4,000
II
1 241
431
do
75o 4,600
11
1 251
431
do
11 750 2,950
1 261
43
1 do
11 725
1
1 271
43
1 do
11 700 3,900
1�
1281431
do
825 9,400
ilPart
south of a line from a point I
1
1
II
11
on the east line of Lot 27, 70 ft.
1
1
1
11
Ilfrom
the northeast corner thereof
1
1
1
11
11
to a point on the west line of Lot
1
(
1
11
II
kContlnued on next page)1
TOTAL
1
FORM e.s.11 zoo 3-51 8
Ii
CITY OF ST. PAUL
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
REPORT OF COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE
ON PRELIMINARY ORDER
(B)
IIDESCRIPTION
LOT
B
ADDITION II
LAND VALUAT ASSESSED
II28.
(Continued from preceding page
50 ft, from the northwest corne
I 1
1I
Ilthereof;
part of Lots 27 and 128
138 I
St. Anthony Park, Minnesota
II $ 1,100 $ 4,500
III
Part lying north of a line from a 1
I 1
11
Loint on the east line of Lot 27, 1
I
I
11
1170
ft. from the northeast corner 1
I
1
II
iithereof
to a point on the west line)
I
I
Lf said Lot 28, 50 ft. from the I
I
I
11northwest
corner thereof of Lots 271
1
1
11
!land
128
138
1 do
11 450 3,100
1
11
138
I do
11 600 5,600
!!Lots
2 and
1 3
138
1 do
11 1,400 8,000
,(Lots
4, 5 and west of
1 6
138
1 do
11 2,400 5,150
IiExcept
east 25 ft.;
1 1
137
1 do
11 600 2,150
I
25 ft. of Lot 1, and except
1
1
1
1I
i1following described part: Begiruz-
I
1
II
Iiat northeast corner of said lot thence
south)
II
lialong
east line 27 ft. 4 inches theLe
1
1
11
llnorthwesterly in a straight line tol
I
1
1
,11northerly line of said lot at a
I
I
I
II
i1point
16 ft. southwesterly from
I
I
1
11
(place of beginning thence to begi"g,
I
I
Il
kot 2; also southerly 80 ft. of
3
13?
1 do
1,825 3,650
IiAll east of a line drawn from a poi!
t
I
I
lion east line 27 1/3 ft. from the
I
I
1
II
(!northeast corner to a point on the
I
I
I
II
!north line 16 ft. from said corner
I
1
I
II
ii �Qontinuect on next page
1
TOTAL
FORM 8.9.11 OW 3•59 8
4
t
CITY OF ST. PAUL .
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
REPORT OF COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE
ON PRELIMINARY ORDER
(C)
II
LOT
I I
BLOCK
ADDITION
I II
VALUATION
UDESCRIPTION
LAND BLDG.
Dart of Lot {2 and except south 80
I
I I
11
11
ft.: L
1 31
37
ISt. Anthony Park Minnesota
11 K 8=K0
�, 7 8
IlExcept
south 80 ft . ;
1 41
7
1 do
-3-,
li -7' 3, no
IlThat
part north of a line drawn at
I
1
I
11
11right
angles to the west line from
I
I
I
!!
11a
point thereon 106.25 ft. from
1
I
!
!inorthwest
corner of
1 51
37
1 do
q7K 11,100
IlExcept
south 104.42 ft.;
1 61
37
1 do
� 600 3_,800
ilExcept
south 155 ft.;
1 7137
1 do
11 550 2,600
!!Except
south 155 ft.;
1 81
37
1 do
II 575 3,000
I!
1 9
1 37
1 do
II
1 10
137
1 do (11
4,100 135,900
1
1!
1 11
1371
do (1!
II
I
I
I
II
!I
I
I
I
II
1
I
I
I
II
11
I
I
I
it
II
I
I
I
II
!
1 TOTAL
II $42,975 9269 800
The Commissioner of Finance further reports that he has investigated all of the aforesaid matters,
and hereby submits the foregoing as his report thereon to the Council, together with the report made
to him in reference to said matter by the Commissioner of Public Works.
Date o �. ';>2. ".c
Commissioner of Finance. 11.0
Form B.B. 12 1M 3-68 �8
}
Hillside - Gordon to Como'- north side
n n n Knapp Place - south side
a
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PUBLIC WORKS
REPORT TO COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE
Dist.. 14o. 2
,Ie � 76
Feb. 23rd. , 19 60
To the Commissioner of Finance of the City of Saint Paul:
The commissioner of Public Works, having had under consideration the
preliminary order of the Council, known as Council File No. 195890 ,
approved Feb. 16th, 19 60 relative to reconstraetir_
the sidewalk on both sides of Hillside Ave. from Gordon Ave. to Como Ave. on the
north and from Gordon Ave. to Knapp Place on the south._
and having investigated the matters and things referred to therein, hereby
reports:
1. The estimated cost thereof is $0.52 per sq. ft. for no.--conc. walk h"
thick. Extra work(Excay., fill, cone. rem'd, rootcutting, drive crossings.etc.)
at extra cost.---- -
2. A plan,•profile or sketch of said improvement is hereto attached and
made a part hereof.
3. Initiated by the Commissioner of Public Works x
4. improvement is asked for upon petition
4 , f4.
N
Commissioner of Public Works
� 6
tI ��y