205248A
In
FINAL ORDER IN COND
FINAL ORDER IN CONDEMNATION
PROCEEDINGS f
Council File No. 205248 -. By Milton
Rosen -
Nil in (the matter of condemning and INGS
taking a temporary easement for the
,taking of constructing a bridge for}
- �� ._ __ — - _ ...a•F = --- - - - — _,` •tea -•••�. , «'"'"'���,� �
f tite'te Ol • r of ;zY �, • ��`
! In'"i46 matter of-condemni`�ng afidt'eking Ctemp:orar"y-easement 7 for-th-e•purposevof,
,constructing a bridge for the Short Line•;Road,�'on _th-os.e•�pdrts'of Lots }1 an 2;�w_ r �'S
-• -'� .:t�.. :1--_,._�.�- .'. _. r;•...:t �. v _ J . .i..:, -a -�. __. - .;-� -' -`. .,..,tom- �--'-- r�
�^"' J
t S i Y..�
6`'btI�L6��ryi�1r'Cia � .« i',• .`�. ..f?., '.� i_'� -- -�. }tip � r• r
�% t�t'st' � .�� @�:3.i�J'�3 G.': 1 cFi�`iiC1•�T ;'••.i'? .tl :., :f.t- :i "".t �ii!i :;t_`,t1r2� �G:1 ti:C r ::�;,cr1y
i Cp 'la4dxes �p:k:s �l:ot;c�t'ar�q p� r�nl,llapci2� zs��rri;e�boka� tce2C, l6ur.'. �i 4
tinder Preliminary Order 204237 approved October 51 1961 ,
1� IIntermediary Order 204591 approved October 31, 1961 ,
11 A public hearing having been had upon the above improvement upon due notice, and the Council having
heard all persons, objections and recommendations relative thereto, and having fully considered the same;
therefore, be it I
RESOLVED, By the Council of the City of Saint Paul that the precise nature, extent and kind of im-
r — — 1- ��A�v the_said City is
pro-v , • �,� 1-ti y
t i 6XC6� f�' ;g4E`+9c'°� �j1bG�ili OCC(1J^ 1 '" .. -r.' >i' t �'� i' C. < "^ . : ! •, ' R
} . such,�• uaa�
1-:3i�q 5�G,: zon ,... _
I g.
. , at 9 q, j� �b���a?b�f �'u A'' L o t �� .9 r an�s�g ot� �}�s u9La� 1 us• of
and the Council hereby orders said improvements to be made.
RESOLVED FURTHER, that the following land, lands or easements therein be and the same are
- F{ hereby ordered to be taken, appropriated and condemned for the purpose of making said improvements, viz.: _
` ?t'�':� �..y l w! _ - t� St .�... .. •� h; 7- ii.•ii?�..i('r
'i
CnEij stj' par pri, 1 qs uuZ' gq q i;u� o g LA s62s�QGii r ta. XBi LG' Jr1 j X "'J ?
Jl. ,.. .si a•, G- t ! r t r-r �l i t ' �r' i c • r, c t.
oq f PGrL tX-1 0+11 N� ^h � `NG�3u CO UGLrO 1 2�] �,.r0� r lGXCGb f ^f �1
. �. kn g C7bi Y—oU dJG wsh�s�l�: q u- J: ss2 s� a SUE .� '° zs� o' 2- eu et S ;u
RESOLVED FURTHER, That the Commissioner of Public Works be and is hereby instructed and
directed to prepare plans and specifications for said improvement, and the proper city officials are hereby
authorized and directed to proceed with the making of said improvement in accordance therewith.
Adopted by the Cnnnril nre 2 81961
N
EC 2
1
Councilmen:
Holland '
Loss
..Mcr��••i+ser� --
Petersoh
Rosen '
-M,-- r- rt- cs- rycrr-, ay.,Q -r-. -s
V,t'a
..,;;
* /7 4-- // ;City Clerk.
�n
Mayor.
ifflpl��V�
}
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PUBLIC WORKS
V
REPORT TO COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE
October 16
the Commissioner of Finance of the City of Saint Paul:
The Commissioner of Public Works, having had under consideration the p
ary order of the Council, known as Council File No. 204237
ved October 5s 19 61 relative to
m !- -p U' � \. . r, rte ;!" = ire '4 > rte• ♦ v _�12
i l r \Ir �13 i �.i �_ .. .iE 'i•� i s �' M . - �' y_ }' - ^_
,�•w� \��5�.. l' �•.�i`i� #�Y ��i' Vii. LTi #r"�' ���"ry �q•T ; � � f ` �Y � ` t S' p �M � � � >.•1. 3. ..
i`ux.•E}L1` ..- �r k._. ♦�U�aL�r455 'It sr. Uw r
spa i104;3MG4 ,haw s�1cvr, j otq S *Uqtc
61
having investigated the matters and things referred to therein, hereby
1. The estimated cost thereof is X X X X X
2. A plan, profile or sketch of said improvement is hereto attached
a part 'hereof. ,
3. Initiated by the Commissioner of Public Works
4. Improvement s— Ea.shed for upon petition
tp
OC� Z C'j 00
Commissioner of
made
Works
1.
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PUBLIC WORKS
V
REPORT TO COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE
October 16
the Commissioner of Finance of the City of Saint Paul:
The Commissioner of Public Works, having had under consideration the p
ary order of the Council, known as Council File No. 204237
ved October 5s 19 61 relative to
m !- -p U' � \. . r, rte ;!" = ire '4 > rte• ♦ v _�12
i l r \Ir �13 i �.i �_ .. .iE 'i•� i s �' M . - �' y_ }' - ^_
,�•w� \��5�.. l' �•.�i`i� #�Y ��i' Vii. LTi #r"�' ���"ry �q•T ; � � f ` �Y � ` t S' p �M � � � >.•1. 3. ..
i`ux.•E}L1` ..- �r k._. ♦�U�aL�r455 'It sr. Uw r
spa i104;3MG4 ,haw s�1cvr, j otq S *Uqtc
61
having investigated the matters and things referred to therein, hereby
1. The estimated cost thereof is X X X X X
2. A plan, profile or sketch of said improvement is hereto attached
a part 'hereof. ,
3. Initiated by the Commissioner of Public Works
4. Improvement s— Ea.shed for upon petition
tp
OC� Z C'j 00
Commissioner of
made
Works
�t
h
M,CHAEL J. DOHERTY
WILFRID E.RUMBLE
FRANCIS D. BUTLER
EDGAR G.VAUGHAN
J.C. FOOT E
RICHARD J. LEONARD
IRVINIG CLARK
HAROLD JORDAN
THEOPHIL RUSTERHOLZ
FRANK CLAYBOURNE
PIERCE BUTLER,M
JOHN L.HANNAFORD
ANDREW G.SCOTT
JOSEPH M.FINLEY
H ENRY D_FLASCH
EUGENE M.WARLICH
TIMOTHY J. HALLORAN
WILLIAM WOOD NELSON
WENfE[4DELL R. ANDERSON
E ,
DOHERTY, RUMBLE & BUTLER
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
1006 FIRST NATIONAL BANK BUILDING
SAINT PAUL I, MINNESOTA
December 11, 1961
The Honorable City Council
City Hall
Saint Paul 2, Minnesota
Gentlemen:
TELEPHONE
CAPITAL 43813
On November 27, I wrote you respecting the matter
of the City's condemnation and taking a temporary easement for
bridge construction for the Short Line road on parts of Lots
1 and 2, Block 21 Dunlap Place Addition.
Thereafter, at the meeting of the Council held on
November 28, this matter was laid over to December 12 for
further consideration.
The purpose of this letter is to advise you that
our clients and the City have agreed respecting the price to
be paid for the easement and a form of easement has been pre-
pared by us and submitted to the City for approval. Mr. Eltor
Dehn, City Valuation Engineer, is out -of -town until Monday,
December 18, and therefore will not be able to review the form
of easement until that date.
We therefore request that you lay this matter over
until December 19, 1961. We have spoken to Mr. Donald L. Lais
Assistant Corporation Counsel, and he is agreeable that the I
matter be laid over until that date.
JLH:ia
cc - Mr. Donald L. Lais
Very truly yours,
DOHERTY, RUMBLE & BUTLER
By J�W _� /);Cv
�r
ar
MICH �EL J. DOHERTY
WILFRID E.RUMBLE
FRANCIS D. BUTLER
EDGAR G.VAUGHAN
J. C. F�OOTE
RICHARD J. LEONARD
IRVING CLARK
HAROLD JORDAN
THEOPHIL RUSTERHOLZ
FRANK CLAYBOURNE
PIERCE 8UTLER,IQ
J CHIN L. HANNAFORD
ANDREW G.SCOTT
JOSEPH M. FINLEY
HENRY D. FLASCH
EUGENE M.WARLICH
TIMOTHY J. HALLORAN
WILLIAM WOOD NELSON
WENJDELL R. ANDERSON
!E
�t
t
DOHERTY, RUMBLE be BUTLER
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
1006 FIRST NATIONAL BANK BUILDING
SAINT PAUL I, MINNESOTA
November 27, 1961
The Honorable City Council
City of Saint Paul
City Hall
Saint Paul 1, Minnesota
Gentlemen:
TELEPHONE
CAPITAL 43813
HUED
9CI NOV 271 PH 3 `S
CITY LE -r!,iw
S41N i°,'qL. HINN.
This firm represents Mrs: Ruth Reid and the Estate of
Harold S. Reid, the joint owners of Lots 1 and 2, Block 2, Dun-
lap Place Addition to the City of St. Paul. We understand that
the Council will hold a public hearing at 10 :00 A.M. on Novem-
ber 28, 1961, on the advisability of proceeding with Preliminary
Order 204237 approved October 51 1961, which proposes to con-
demn and take a temporary easement on a part of those lots for
the purpose of constructing a bridge for the Short Line Road.
We are currently negotiating with Mr. Eltor A. Dehn,
the City Valuation Engineer, and Mr. Donald L. Lais of the City
Attorney's office respecting the granting by our clients to the
City of the type of easement desired by the City. The negotia-
tions are almost concluded and we expect an easement will be
executed within a week. Since it appears that the matter will
be disposed of by agreement, it seemed unnecessary for our clie
to appear and take the Council's time at this hearing.
However, we feel obliged to advise you that if our
clients and the City should fail to reach agreement and execute
an easement, our clients reserve all rights to object to the
condemnation of this easement and to the award of damages there
Very truly yours,
DOHERTY, RUMBLE & BUTLER
JLH :ia By
o �
w 4o°
� lS
GG'
6,5;,
0
..
�c
y�
Z�