The URL can be used to link to this page

08-1355Council File # ��?j' � Green Sheet # 3060141 RESOLUTION Presented by CITY,�JF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA � WHEREAS, the Ramsey-Washington Metro Watershed District (the "Watershed District") has identified an erosion problem in the city of Saint Paul near the intersection of Mailand Road and McKnight Road, also known as the "Mailand-McKnight Road Gulley;" and WHEREAS, the Watershed District hired Barr Engineering to prepare a study known as the "Feasibility Report on Mailand-McKnight Road Gully Erosion: Cities of Maplewood and St. Paul, Ramsey County" (the "Feasibility Report"), a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A and incorporated herein by this reference; and 10 WHEREAS, the Feasibility Report identified storm water improvements that will reduce or eliminate the ll erosion problem; and 12 13 WHEREAS, the Watershed District has agreed to include these storm water improvements in their annual 14 construction program; and 15 16 WHEREAS, the Feasibility Report further identified permanent drainage easements across private properry 17 required for construction of these storm water improvements; and 18 19 WHEREAS, the owners of said private properties have voluntarily entered into permanent drainage 20 easements (the "Easements") with the City of Saint Paul (the "City"), copies of which are attached hereto 21 as Exhibits B1-B6 and incorporated herein by this reference; and 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 WHEREAS, the Watershed District has tendered to the City a Cost Sharing Agreement ("Agreement") to provide payment by the City to the Watershed District for the City's share of storm' water improvement costs in the McKnight/Mailand Project, a copy of which Agreement is attached hereto as Exhibit C and incorporated herein by this reference; now, therefore be it RESOLVED, that the Mayor and Council of the City of Saint Paul do hereby accept said Easements and direct and authorize the proper City officials to record same with Ramsey County; and be it further RESOLVED, that the proper Ciry officials are hereby authorized to execute and approve on behalf of the City said Agreement in a form and content substantially as set forth in the attached Exhibit C. 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 Council File # Green Sheet # �g�135� 3060141 Adopted by Council: Date �.��/��/J� Adoption Certified by Council Secretary By' �� `/, �� l J v /�/d/«/7d✓ B pprove y ay�v Dat�/O � Y� Requeste by Department of: P �c rks By: �. Approved by the Office of Financ' ervices `J � V By: �/7� � Approved bo �ity orney a— � __��_ By: j / ' Approve„d by/ a or fo bm}}�� n to C uncil BY �—I�J�--- �'L�/�—��' '�" , � � Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet � n� �i21� „� �.�� DeparhnenVOffice/Council: � Date Initiated: PW_PublicWorks 30SEP-08 Green Sheet NO: 3060141 Confact Pereon 8 Phone: Deoartrnent Sent To Person InifiaUDate Jce Mueller � 0 bGc Works Division Ma er =�Y' 266-6149 I blic Warks PWlAcm¢Min {/",� ' � ��g� 2 66c WoHcs De artment D'uector �S � Must Be on Couneii Agenda by (Date}: Number 3 ' Attorne Chad Stau} For Routing 4 wancialServices Director Doc. Type: �SOLUTION Order 5 a or's O�ce Ma or/Assistant � 6 ounc0 �_� EAocumeM Required: Y 7 ' Clerk Cti Clerk DoeumentConWM: �aeMuelier � Contact Phone: 266-6149 Total # of Signature Pages _(Clip All �oeations for Signature) Action Requested: Approve resolurion authorizing Ciry' to accept permanent drainage easements and to enter into a cost-sl�aring agreement with Ramsey-Washington Metro Watershed District to construct stormwater unprovements in the McKnight/Mailand Project. Recommendations: Approve (A) or Reject (R): Personal Service Contrects Must Mswer the Foliowing Questions: Planning Commission 1. Has this persoNfirm everworked under a contract forihis depariment? CIB Committee Yes No Civil Service Commission 2. Has this perso�rm ever been a city employee? Yes No 3. Dces this person/firm possess a skill not nortnally possessed by any current city employee? Yes iJo 6cplain all yes answers on separate sheet and attaeh to green sheet. Initiating Problem, Issues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why): There is a severe erosion problem nortttwest of the intersection of MeKnight and Mailand Roads. The City of Sain[ Paul, City of Maplewood and Raznsey County all contribute flows to tlils area. The Ramsey Washington Metro Watershed Dis[rict is prepazed to implement stoimwater drainage system and channel improvements to eliminate or reduce the erosion problem. AdvanqgesHApproved: - Erosion will be reduced or eliminated �,�� . �' DisadvanWges HApprwed:. - None �� Disadvanqges If NM Approved: Erosion will continue 7oWlAmountof $15,000.00 Trensaction: . CosURevenue Budgeted: Y GQ �. Funding Source: SeWer FUnd Activity Number: ��T Pinancial Information: �e City's shaze of the improvement wst is estimated at about $15,000 per the fonunula in the cost-sharing (F�cpiain) ageement. Actual costs cou(d be slightly higher or lower, but sufficient funding is currently budgeted for this work. October 30, 2008 12:19 PM Page 1 �a'�e� �xh"+br�' A � �- l�� Feasibility Report on Mailand-Mcgnight Road Gully Erosion Cities of Maplewood and S� Paul, Ramsey County Prepared for Ramsey-Washingtvn Metro Watershed District February 2D05 � ,� � r � ,`_ = {F� n_ _., ! � �. . I Feasibility Repof-t on � �� 13� Mailand-Mcgnight �oud Gully Erosion Cities of Maplewood and St. Paul, Ramsey County Prepared for Ramsey-Washington Metro Watershed District February 2005 � � ! � 4700 Wes[ 77th Street Minneapnlis, DfN 55435 Phone: (952) 832-2600 Far: (952) 832-260I ��S�i�� Feasibility Report on Mailand-McKnight Road Guity Erosion ( Cities of Maplewood and St. Paut, Ramsey County _ J Table of Contents i .o �,�oau�uon ...................�-�---..............................................-�--�--.............................................................i � 2.0 Back�ound and Drainage Patterns ..............................................................-°°---...-°---°°-•-------........2 3 .0 Eusting Channel Conditions ................................,_......._....................---........................--•--....................4 � 3.1 Keys Factors for Esosion .............................................................................................................6 � 3.'l Runoff Rates and Soils Infonuarion ............................................................................................6 � 4.0 Assessment of Problem ..........................................................................................................................7 ' 4.1 General Remediarion Oprions ...................°-...........-•-°........--....................................................7 3 5.0 Recommended Strategy..°---......_ ............... ........ ................ ....................................................................9 5.1 Ouflet Reconstruction, Selective Channel Repair and glanting ..................................................9 5.2 Increase Stormwater Storage Capaciry in Wetland .................................................................11 � 6.0 Cost Estimate ........................................................................................................................................13 � � P:�Rwmwd_Projects�2362031_0034�LcKnight-Mailand Gulley�FINA�. REPORT DOCS�Fina] Report_02-09-OS.DOC pg-135� List of Tables Table 1 Soil Classificarion Summazy—McKni�ht Mailand Gully Erosion, St. Paul, Minnesota Table 2 Cost Estimate List of Figures Figure 1 Figure 2 Figure 3 Figure 4 Figure 5 Figure 6 Figuce 7 ! � � 1 � f 1 � Mailand Gully Location Mailand & McKnight Drainage Areas Mailand Gully Erosion Outlet Reconstruction Detail Outlet Reconstruction and Planting (Plan) Channel Cross-Section Rock Drop Structure Schematic Profile � P:�Rwmwd_Projects12362031_003�McKnight-Mai]and Gu(ley�FINAL REPORT DOCS�Finat Report_02-09-OS.DOC ll �' I I � 1 68�135 i.0 Introduction The Ramsey Washingtpn Metro Watershed District (District) became involved in an intercommuniry stormwater issue at Mailand and McKnight Roads at the request of Terry Noonan of Ramsey County Public Works. Prior to this contact, the Ramsey Soil and Water Conservation District manager, Tom Petersen, had been approached by landowners in the area seeking help with gully erosion and sediment deposition on their properties. Although all the properties lie west of McKnight Road, in St. Paul, the majority of the drainage area is in Maplewood. (Figures 1 and 2.) 'Ihis report summarizes the issue, discusses potential solutions and makes recommendations for 1 cepair and flow mitigation. J 3 ! � � � � � J � � � � P:�Rwmwd_Projects�2362Q31_003�IvIcKnight-MailandGulley�FINALREPORTDOCS�FinalReport_02-04-OS.DOC 1 �� i�� 2.0 Background and Drainage Patterns Historic airphotos show that the land in the study azea was partly aa culfural and spazsely populated > in 1953. In 1974, it was undergoing development, with earth being moved and road networks developing north of Mailand and east of McKnight. By 1985, the lots contiguous to McKnight Road appeaz much as they do today and, by 2002, azeas further east, including Dorland Road, were also fully developed. According to landowner Patty McDonald, her father-in-law, Ted Anderson, noticed drainage changes in the azea in 1977, and the beginning of what will henceforth be referred to as the Mailand gully or "the channel." (Anderson purchased 2191 Mailand Road in the late-1950s.) � Three drainage azeas drain into Mailand gully, as shown in Figure 2. Water enters the channel in two _ ways: (1) overland (from adjacent land and from McKnight Road overflows that proceed down a l dr.veway ai 461 McKnight); and (2) from a pipe that collects runoff from the upstream drainage J areas and outlets in the sidelback yazd of 451 McKnight. (Figure 3.) � The pipe outlet dates from 1965, wLen Ramsey County installed a 24-inch corrugated metal pipe to — convey street drainage entering catch basins along McKnighk Road as well as drainage from the � wooded wetland northeast of McKnight and Mailand. (NOTE: Catch basins are the boxlike below- grade shvctures that collect stormwater runoff entering through grates or other openings along street 3 �urbs, In subsequent yeazs, the City of Maplewood constructed stoLm sewer pipes eastwazd along Mailand � Road and throughout the residential azea immediately east of the wetland. Both these pipe systems contribute flow to the channel. The Mailand Road storm sewer was approved for connection to the � county pipe below McKnight Road in 1977. � Approximately 83 acres drain to the wooded wetland northeast of the McKnight and Mailand �, intersection. (Pigure 2). The wetland, drained 6y a 12-inch corrugated mefal pipe thaf connects to the McKnight Road storm sewer system, has the capacity to store 0.5 acre-feet of water without � overtopping onto McKnight. A 1974 study for the City of Maplewood by Barr Engineering Company estimated that approximately 12 acres of land would drain to the wetland and recommended that the ,� wefland be designed to accommodate 2 acre-feet of flood storage. Although less land than planned drains to the wetland, the available storage and/or discharge capacity is still inadequate to prevent the � � P-�Rwmwd_Prqects12362031_003VbIcKnight-Mailand Gui]ey�FINAL REPORT DOCS1Fina1 Repott_02-Q9-OS.DQC 2. pS �135� wefland from overtopping, even during relatively small rainfalls. All water that overtops the wetland basin flows over McKnight Road, down the driveway at 461 McKnight Road and into the channel. Water draining out of the wetland combines with drainage from the 14.1-acre watershed to the souch. The southern watershed is pLedominantly low density residential land use that slopes north to MaiIaud Road. A storm sewer pipe in Mailand Road drains to the west and connects with the storm drain in McKnight Road before discharging into the gully. The 101-acre uea that contributes overland flow to the channel is evenly split between mowa residential lawns with canopy trees and undeveloped natural azeas. McKnight Road residential lots slope steeply to the west, to a lower area dominated by old field (former farmland, now open herbaceous land dominated by non-native plants) and ecologically degaded woods. All runoff from this area drains to the channel. � � � � _� � P:�Rwmwd_Projects�2362031_0031McKnigho-Mailand Gulley�FINAL REPORT DOCS�nal Repo¢_02-09-OS.DOC 6 �,��s 3.0 Existi � � � � _� Channel Conditions The drainage channel extends from the pipe outlet located at Station 1(Figure 3.) and runs approximately 850 feet in a generally west-northwest direction before emptying in[o a reed canazy grass wetland. While some azeas of the channel aze neazly flat, with na sign of erosion, other segments are severely eroded, with active downcutting occurring as recently as summer 2004, according to McDonald. Erosion is immediately apparent at the pipe outlet, where the homeowner recently placed concrete blocks in an attempt to armor the sandy soil (Photo 1). Beginning approximately 100 feet down-channel, in a segment that veers north aczoss the backyards of 451 and 443 McKnight, the channel cuts down to a depth of 2.5 to 4 feet near Station 2(Figure 3). As water heads northwest, it moves through a small grassed swale running alongside a "mini-berm" that was constructed in the backyard of 2221 Mailand Road to control the flow of water across their property. Photo 1. Outlet on 451 McKnight Road property � P:�Rwmwd_Prqects�23b2031_003�Iv(cKnight,Mailand Gulley\FINAL REPORT DOCS1Fina1 Report_02-09-OS.DOC 4 �=�� At Station 6, north of 2191 Mailand, the deepest gully erosion occurs (Photo 2). Following a sharply curved azea, the water has cut 5 feet into the sandy soils. While some weedy herbaceous vegetation is growing in portions of the eroded azea, the channel is largely characterized by bare soil, open to furthei erosion. The surrounding area is dominated by aggressive vegetation, includino non-native reed canazy grass and smooth brome and native Canada goldenrod. At Station 8, near the channel terminus, a roughly circulaz, depressed sandy area appears to have both eroded and served as a deposition azea for sediment from upstream. The rim of this area, which Patty McDonald describes as a former fire pit, is punctuated by old tires and paztially buried construction debris. Photo 2. The deepest gully erosion (Station 6) � At the terminus of the channel, northeast of Station 8(see Figure 3), the topography is very flat, allowing the water to spread out and infiltrate in a reed canazy grass-dominated wetiand southeast of � the Highwood Hills Elementary School ball fields. No outlet is apparent in this wefland. � Infiltiation, which occurs not only in the wetland, but to some degree throughout the undeveloped _ land in the neighborhood, is one of the most cost-effective and ecologically sound ways of managing � stormwater. Naturally vegetated azeas with relatively sandy soils, like the Mailand Road properties, aze ideally suited for infiltration, which helps dispose of excess stormwater, sustain plants and recharge groundwater. When runoff flows rapidly over the ground and through pipes, it is less likely � to infiltrate, or percolate into the soil. When this happens, the excess water can create flooding � � problems downstream. _ � P:�Rwmwd_Projec[s12362031_003�McKni�ho-Mailand Gulley\FINAL REPORT DOCSSFina1 Report_02-09-OS.DOC � - ' �ss: �;_; -_;-��, .,:��y< n ' �"._-�_ _3.�� '-�:�c \ , k � � �-�-_ � r �� h '� �� ' _ � 1'=�. °_ __ -5.,�3-- J1r �_ ` -_ +�',":�.'�-_"��-t: yy ^: � �. (�' �� 3.1 Keys Factors for Erosion Erosion occurs when the force of water flowing over soil is a eater than the soil's ability to resist that force. The susceptibility of a certain azea to erosion is dependent on three key factors: l. The velociry of water: The faster water moves, the more energy (and erosive force) it has. The slope of the channel usually dictates the velocity of water. Steeper slopes result in higher velocities. 2. Vegetative cover: A vegetated surface generally resists erosion better than bare soil. Plant leaves and stems slow runoff and provide a protective buffer between flowing water and soil; roots help hold the soil in place and encourage infiltration instead of mnoff. 3. Soil type: Certain types of soil resist erosion better than others. In general, silts and clays aze more cohesive (and resistant to erosion) than sandy soils. 3.2 Runoff Rates and Soils fnformation Soil samples were collected and chazacterized at eight points along the channel. Figure 3 shows soil sample locations and Table 1 summar;zes the fiadings. The data indicates that the soils are widely varied, ranging from coarse and sandy to fine and silty. As menuoned above, sandy soils are generally less cohesive and are therefore more erodible than silts or clays. At the most severe erosion locauons, the soils are a mix of sandy and silty soils. In general, the velocity of water flowing over exposed sandy soil should be less than 3 feet per second to prevent erosion. Higher velociries aze permissible if the soil is armored in some manner, either with vegetation, boutders, concrete or soil stabilization fabric. Aydrologic modeling shows that peak flow rates occur through the pipe and channel during short- duration, high-intensity rainfall events, i.e. "gully washers." The model predicts that 20 cubic feet per second (cfs) would dischazge from the outlet pipe (Station 1) during a 10-yeaz design storm (2.1 inches of rainfall in 1 hour). The resulting velocity would be approacimately 4 feet per second between Stations 1 and 2. Further down the channel at Station 6, the flow rate would increase to approxinnately 30 cfs as contdbutions from the surrounding watershed boost the flows. At a flow rate of 30 cfs, the velocity of the water through the channel at Station 6 is approxunately 6 Feet per second. P:�Rwmwd_Projects�2362031_003�'VIcKnight-Mailand Gulley\FINAL REPORT DOCS�F'inai Report_02-09-0S.DOC �/ � / � 4.0 Assessment of Problem The progressively worsening erosion on the Mailand-McKnight proper[ies is most likely due to a combination of factors, including runoff chan�es following development, azea soil characteristics and inadequate storage in the wooded wetland. As the watershed surrounding the channel became more impervious (chazacterized by more roads, rooftops and other hazd surfaces), stormwater flow rates and velociues increased. Water overtopping the wooded wetland contributes to this increased flow. At one time, cohesive topsoil, stabiliaed by plant roots, likely covered the area. Over rime, flowing water broke through a disturbance in the vegetative cover (such as a tire rut) and exposed the sandy, erosive subsoils. Since these soils were not cohesive enough to resist the erosive force of the water, the channel continued (and continues) to erode with each runoff event. 4.1 General Remediation Options In order to remedy the situation, the key erosion factors need to be addressed. Since it would not be feasible to change the soil, the repair options focus on reducing flow velocities and improving vegetative cover. The Pollowing summarizes the general approaches considered. l. Re-route Maplewood sewers in order to reduce runoff entering the gully. The most expensive and disruptive option, this would also be the least feasible. Addirional work would be required to repair existing damage to the properties in St. Paul. 2. Pipe the water through the gully azea, elimivating the channel altogether. While this would accommodate runoff and solve surface erosion, it would decrease inf'iltration and potentially lead to other problems downstream, in the wedand azea near the school. It would also be expensive and disruptive. 3. Construct a defined channel for the entire lengtfi and armor the channel with soil stabilizauon 1 material. Also an expensive option, this would entail major land reshaping and many tree � removals. Tree removal is an issue from both an aesthetic and soil stability standpoint, due to lost root structure. 1 4. Increase the storage capacity of the basin northeast of the McKnight & Mailand intersecflon � � � to prevent overflows onto McKnight Road and down the driveway of 461 McKnight Road. This would entail tree removal, grading and revegetation. At present, ttris option is not possible because the DistricYs classification of this wetland does not allow it to be excavated to accommodate additional stormwater. However, the wefland is scbeduled for reevaluation in the spring of 2005. If a downward chaage in quality classification occurs, we strongly recommend iacorgorating this remediation option. `j P:�Rwmwd_Projects�2362031_003�2vIcKnight-Mailand Guttey�f'INAL REPORT DOCS�Final Report_02-09-0S.DOC i D�� ( �� l 5. Tnstall eneray (velocity) dissipation measures and repau only the deepest gullies. This oprion would retain the natural appeazance of the azea and pose the least disturbance to soil and [ vegetation. It would both repair the worst erosion and help reduce the velocity of the flow at � the ouflet. It is atso the least expensive remedy. I 1 � � � � � � � � � � � � P:�Rwmwd_Projeccs\236203 t_003VYIcKnight-Mailand Gulley\FTNAL REPORT DOCS�Final Report_02-09-OS.DOC $ ��/ I�� 5.0 Recommended S�rategy A combination of oprions 4 and 5 is recommended: ener�y dissipation at both the outlet and the steepest portion of the cbannel, along with gully repair and increased storage capacity east of McKnight Road. 5.1 Outlet Reconstruction, Selective Channel Repair and Planting Starting at the pipe outlet, an energy dissiparion structure would be installed. The structure would consist of a 60-inch diameter manhole with a 2=foot deep sump that would connect to the end of the ouflet pipe. A lazger (36-inch) outlet pipe placed at a 1-percent slope or flatter, with a flazed end section and grate or trash rack, would extend from the manhole to create the new outlet. (See Figure 4.} The dzop inside the structure would serve to dissipate some of the water's eneigy and velocity. The structure's outlet, placed at a lower elevation than the cunent outlet, would reduce the initial channel slope and spread the water wider, thus reducing its erosive force. The pipe and ' manhole would be covered with topsoil to match the eusting slope of ttie yard and the outlet azea � would be armored with fieldstone riprap. PiopeLly installed and cazefully maintained plantings aze a key part of this strategy. At the oudet, a clearly defined area of tough, deep-rooted native plants would help stabilize soil, trap sediment, camouflage the lazge pipe and reduce the harsh look of the riprap (Figure 5). Some plants could be tucked into soil placed in the voids between individual riprap stones. � The channel adjacent the ouflet, along with one of the deepest eroded azeas (at Stafions 2 and 3) would be graded to form a channel base at least 6-feet wide with a ma,zimum 3:1 side slope � (Figure 6). Implemenung these recommendations will reduce the design storm velocities to approxunately 3.S feet per second. To prevent eiosion at this rate, vegetation and erosion control � blankets wouid have to be installed. ! � 1 � � All disturbed areas not subject to inundation shouid be seeded with non-invasive species; areas where channel flow will occur should be planted with small live plants, or plugs, which will mature quickly and be less easiiy disturbed during heavy rainfalls. In addirion, the most visible upland azeas could receive plant plugs following seeding in order to hasten vegetation development and increase aesthetic appeal. � P Gulley\FINAL REPORT DOCS�Final Repon_02-09-OS.DOC 9 1% . < � . ��i � At Station 5 and 6, where the erosion is the most severe, a rock drop suucture designed by a � pcofessional enQineer should be installed. The scructure would consist of strategically placed boulders and riprap that would allow water to drop 4 to 5 vertical feet without causing erosion. The final product would resemble a section of rapids on a river, though it would not remain wet at all 1: times. (See Photo 3, which shows a constructed rock drop structure in Ba[tle Creek Pazk, St. Paul and �i � f J'; � � Figure 7.) The drop structure would allow the water's energy to be dissipated through the rocky areas and provide a flatter slope from the structure to the channe] terminus. All of the disturbed azeas would be restored with native vegetation. Native plants would help promote a more sustainable channel Photo 3. Rock drop st�ucture ai Battle Creek Park. structure due [o their deep, vigorous root systems and tolerance to temperature and moisture extremes. They would also help to diveisify area vegetation and provide more habitat for birds and other wildlife. Residents could enjoy � the variety of bloom colors and textures throughout the seasons. A short list of plants that might be � appropriate in the sunny restored areas: � � � � ! r. � 6 � P:�Rwmwd_Projects\236?031_003\McKnigho-Maila�d Gulley\FINAL REPORT DOCSIFinal Report_02-09-OS.DOC l� f ��-i�� At portions of the gully near Stations 2 and 3, it will be important to consider more shade-toierant species. Shrub plantings may be appropriate in some locations. Further guidance for planu could be obeained by consulting the District's biolo� st, Bill Bartodziej. He can be reached at (651) 704-2089. Installinn plants in repaired areas of the channel is an important part of the solurion, and offers both aesthetic and cost benefits. But relying on plantings also introduces a degree of risk, especially during the establishment period. Proper installation, regulaz inspection and judicious maintenance of the plantings aze critical if they aze to thrive and thus fulfill their role in helping stabilize the channel. Maintenance, including hand-weeding and possibly spot-spraying herbicide, will be especially important in the fiist 3 to 5 yeazs, when the young plants will be competing with aggressive weeds nearby. This work could be done by a contractor, residents, or a combination of both. ('I`he cost for professional maintenance is included in the estimate at the end of report.) In order to ensure proper access to the site for the purpose of channel maintenance, a perpetual drainage easement should be secured for the entire length of the channel. It is also important to recognize that a number of deer occupy the area, and could pose a threat to new plantings unless special precautions (such as fencing) aze taken. Again, District biologist Bartodziej could provide guidance. � 5.2 Increase Stormwater Storage Capacity in Wetland — Another improvement, which should be completed in conjunction with the measures described above, is an increase in stonnwater storage basin capacity. As mentioned, the District staff will be � reevaluating the class�cation of this wetland in the spring of 2005. If the classification is downgraded, changes to this wetland are recommended. The wetland northeast of the Mailand- McKnight intersection retains little water at this time, but could be redesigned to accommodate more runoff from the north and east. The soil inaterial could be excavated from the parcel to create a pond � with a permanent pool and additional flood storage. Adding storage capacity to this azea would require acquiring the pioperty, which is currently privately owned. Property acquisition issues should be addressed at the time the project is pursued 7 (the cost estimate does not include property acquisition). � `I �i`Y 1 w -� P:�Rwmwd_Projects�2362031 003�McKni�ht-Niailand Gulley\FINAL REPORT DOCS\Final Report_02-09-OS.DOC 11 i �?�'�� Any excavation activities on the property to increase storage capacity would frrst require the removal of many trees. But it should be noted that the area is not ecolo�ically pristine or indeed particulazly heaithy now, dominated by aga essive boxelder, disease-susceptible elm and other species. 7udicious re-planting of the basin, especially the perimeter, could result in a more attractive area that funcrions better both for wildlife and stormwater. � � � � � .: 1 � � � .� P:�Rwmwd_pcojects�2362031_003�ivlcKnighc-Mailand Gulleg�FINAL REPORT DOCS�F'inal Report_02-09-OSDOC 12. be ��(�� 6.0 Cost Estima#e Cost for outlet reconstruction and selective channel repair is estimated at $46,000; costs for increasing basin capacity to accommodate a 10-yeaz storm event is estimated at $74,000. Total estimated project cost is be[ween $109,000 and $139,000. (See Table 2.). T`his cost inclndes all equipment, labor and materials to install pipes and erosion control blanket, all clearing, grubbing and earthwork acrivities, plant installation and four yeazs pLOfessionat znaintenance. P: � Rw mwd_Projects 12 3 62 03!_003V�IcKnight-Mai]and Gulley\FINAL REPORT DOCS1Fina1 Report_02-09-OS.DOC 13 � ..�:�y ?�' '_ . l ' -, - � - _ ; s = � � �� , � �� _ �� . �� _ � -� _ '� ` � � E Y �� „ ri �:" ��t , „ g �x � �,� `� �_ �,� �;, °� F ,� � ,�� - @ln� rv�� C i� K � �� , +v} u'Y 're Y/L. � . . . ` � ��A > C i�' . . �� '�� .r '}" _ - . . � y �,�,.�N � ".� _ �� £"'.. � -i' , " ' �"M'.d' L' "�y . ✓.Q x A � . �4^ � S +�+.� � � � � t X - � . � �� "^�� _ - - ' §��+�i l4 _ _ _ ' .. � �N^ _, d . . `f^sli� l t 1``�- '> T ' . �� Z _ - - - tr; �� k 'S� H� i ✓�� ..� t . �$�'�� . - . �d� � 4 .i � n y3 . �" `-�4.M` "F s '�5.� .. - . M �� # � y � � �t t �� S � 4 �-`k, -�•� � �z 1 � �� 1 � 5 .5 ".'.'-^ � Sse¢: �. ' . - � . .31 �c ; . .` , .. ' _ . x. � =_ :-- z , .�.,.=� � - - - ,.s. V .- z-i ..�. - _ � t��.:,.. _ ' . � s. _ „,,�,.'' _ _ ? ° � I O� / � / �/`� Tables = - - - " ' 7 ' � R y G � �LU�N, 7 T � � 7 Q1 r = (7 = � � C � � V � � �"' y= N � N � a N � • U �� _ c �O Y � U � m m m U 9 C ^ a c c m m tp N m T G � L (p O ti a b m R N 'O U C � W � � L d m � _ o �. " T � N t U O C n m m ° � m � '�mm c y = y � m 0 �O mmE A y C p V y �3 4l L _ U T N T O O C >. � o �] fn -�i V v�a�U u n u u U ul -iU�aUO_ JtAU7 fACqUJ N "O C � m � ,� 't6 C O m �i6 � � m 3 � 3 m O m'- y n � °� o u �-�U N 11 _ II GS�(�� 0 � U C N N � U 0 h I m a m F w U O 0 H ¢ O a w � � ¢ z LL a 0 � (� N O Y � �'J�(" /'/� 0 m 0 c N N @ U 0 ti m a F y U O � F- K O a w K J Q Z LL a 0 � � N V-. O N Tabie 2 Cost Estimate �� i�� 1 � ) � � � 1 � 1 �. � � � P:1Rwmwd_Projects123fi2031_0031MCKnight-Maiiand Gulle}AFINAL REPORT DOCS\Tabie2 Cost_Estimafe E� -. =x': is. '� '��f� �� ,� � - ' •7 .'- :,#.� _ z _ __ ; � � — = ,.,. . . . _ _ .. ,. . . . < _ �_ _ _ �: '. . .' -. �� `� e � _� � . x , � �x � a�'-.'� . „�.�.'��.f - "e . - *!.� -3 i h r'`-. � �' 4 ` _ T� " � X .2� �_ � - c�e.+ �, ' �� - ° �'�. *-'�' �� y '' `�: , �' x fa 5 � a � s� � ,'� 6��, '�'�':; .>:: �T� . �' � � . ' _ "3� `�'� �J'�� _: � �`�. :t � " r' x '� :.; °:� ,� :,: . r s�. � , �,,� �� : � � .-�� f x ' ,: � � � �� !� _ �'�� :- � �., . � z j y�� y 5 �� ' ��' } 4� ' ��i',� u : �> � �� 7 "- �; t r ._ ��..»�e�-.' 3 � L ` � _ _,.. -._.__.�. .._.!`�� Y U 'i N ❑ � N .0 � i 0 � �N � 0 � � W O a i i � N 3 3 � �� C �- 'a O C � lC � �� L � >� > a � y � � � � Q1 N OLL °n 0 � 0 0 0 a � Q o a � N O O O N � Figure 4 �,��C, Outlet Reconstruction Detail GROUND 13 L.F. 30"0 RCP � 1� �— 30" 0 APRON WITH TRASHRACK CLASS III RIPRAP NOT TO SCALE 60" MANHOLE EX. 24" �— REMOVE APR�N AND CONNECT PIPE INT� MANHOLE ENERGY DISSIPATOR �2' SUMP � MINNEAPOLIS. MINNESOTA HIBBING, MINNESOTA � DULUTH, MINNESOTA ANN ARBOR, MICHI6AN _ _ JEFFERSON GIiY, MISSOURI NEENAH CASTING DRAWN CHECKED DESIGNED RwMw� MAILAND—McKNIGH7 GULLY OUTLE7 RECONSTRUCTION , •� ( {/V /� / �i� Figure 5 Outiet Reconstruction and Pianting (Pfan) ' ' L� � � � � � � �I � ! V �� R1pRAP�� PtPE �urLEr � � g'1 �/\ ,4-�Rot�t �� / �g 6 ° /�� .°��°� a �� '1 6�� f � � �D o � �G � 1 �' R,P�� Oo°`� d o C�oo I ; �f ��d D � � V� �� (i � a°o�"° 6 s o � � � � � � `� �� ``�'�d ; i �� , � r � �� v � � , �jjU'� — �NTtN6s �QtavLq \ W �� " _�j, / �' wif�i�lawer5 5¢ed c��lays � v � �`� `}� r � I NoT rb ScAL�E Figure 6 Channel Cross-Section �nttX, s�p� S�OPE 3 ��--( ! L{VE PLVGS Pt�NT� 7 �ROSiDN CpN P>tJ�N K�T � -. . . •• , ��`�`tC�� eXISTlt�t6 6 ` GHAt�n�� S�Dir1G V��T�-TION B orrp �.q � P:UtWMWD Projects�2361001_0034�IcKnight-MailandGu11y1FinalReportDocs�F'igs5_6 , ��',�� Figure 7 Rock Drop Structure Schematic Profile UMING FLOW� C�SS I �I��.P- � �� p �o��.�� Y°< �v0 +a�oa'Qd C1A55 3 BQUL :'i.: Q a , , `'j�� a STILLIN6 \ i ::,_ p, �\ ��`: °g a � q B � AS y 4N ��t�1906 �$ s <y p p 4�"Dnn$�' SAND �'�=<< a:�o_ 6,,,e° ` e e _:t.•_:: a�a :._'^::. ..•. \ ":..;,_`, : \-., �\/\. �ATI VE � i� �\� � �� 501 L �� a p�a$s NOT TO SCALE P.�RWMWD Projects�2361001_003WIcKnight-MailandGully�Fina7ReportDOCS�FigsS_6J �xr;��t �2 (�-(?�� PERMANEPIT [}RA(NAGE EASEMEt3T FOR MAlLAND MCKNiGHT GULLY ftEPAiR 1. Easement Granfed. Ha Thanh Thi Le, 451 NtcKn+gh# Road 8oufh, St. Pavl, Minnesota 55919 (hereinafter called "Granfor"} in consideration of the sum of One Doifar and other good anii vafuabVe considera�ion, to him/her in hand paid by the City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporafion under the (aws of the Sfiate of Minnesota (hereinafter cailed "City°), and in consideration of the faithful pertormance by the City of fhe covenants hereinafter confiained to be kept and pe�formed hy said City, does hereby grant said City a drainage easement and the right, privilege, easement and authority to install, operate, maintain, repair, or remove storm sewers and other surtace water drainage improvemenfs acsoss the foltowing-described real estate owned by #he Grantor in the County o# Ramsey and Stafe of Minnesota, to-wit: See a4tached F�hibit "A" Z. Durafion. The said easement shall be permanent. The easement shail run with the land and e�etend fo and bind the heirs, representafives, successors and assigns of 4he party hereto respectivefy. In the event the City, by resolution ofi ifs councii, determines fhat if no longer requires fhe use of said properfy for the purposes descnbed above, fhen and in such event, fhe easement together with a!I r+ghts and privileges granted therewith, shall terminafe. 3. Covenant of Ownershir�. The Grantor does hereby covenanf that helshe is iawfuiky seized and possessed of the real estate abov�described and has the aufhorify to enfer into fhis Agreement. The Grantor w's![ forever wasrant and defend fitle against fhe claims of any other persaas. ��'l�J� 4. Covenants of Citv. in cansiderafion of the easemenfs granted hereby, the City cavenants as fof(ows: a. The CiEy, upon completion ofi work wi�hin the drainage easement, guarantees fhe site wiil have smooth, cantinuous and posifive s4opes ta provide appropriate drainage. The site shaA be free ofi debris, stones and cobbtes and other deleterious materia4 greater than six inct�es in diameter. The site shali be revegetated using a vegetation native to the state o# Minnesote_ b. The City agrees to assume all fiabi(ity and to indemnify and compensate Grantor for any injury or damage to persons or property, inciuding Grantor's properLy, occasioned by or arising in connection with fhe use of the abave-described easement by fhe Cify. The City further agrees to defend, indemnify and save harmless Grantor against at( actions, c(aims, damages or demand which may be brought or made eifher againsf Grantor or against Grantor's interest in the above-descnbed land by reason of anything done by fhe�City in the exercise or purported exercise of the rights and privileges granfed by this instrument. c. The Ctty, in this use of the above-described properEy, shall comply with aii Federal, State and loca( laws and regufations. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, we have sef our hands fhis ? j__ day of �, _�.�- � �� Ha Thanh Thi Le The foregoing instrumenf was acknowledged before me fhis � day of ,fY1 ch� .� by Ha Thanh Thi Le, Granior(s). �—� . STATE OF MiNNESOTA . ) ) ss. cour� o� i r�, � D�nie� K Stahfrrrann '> �� COTA�� °�d�ti MIfJl�SOTA `. ' hti _� , ni�.ltcJl;?N :�ti•` �;"::_ .�:.� S• t�09 �- i � y �f ��1 _,- ., - � . 2 b$ ��' C[TY OF SAINT PAUL By {ts Ntayor gY < its City Glerk By Vts Finance Director Sy Its City Attorney STATE OF MIh1t�ESOTA ) ) ss. C�UNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of by , the Mayor of the City of Sa2nt Paut, a municipat corporation �snder the taws of the Sfate of Ntinnesofa, on behalf of said municipal corporafion. Notary Fubtic STA�E OF Mi}3NESOTA ) ) ss. C�UNTY OF ) l"he foregaing instrument was acknowiedged befare me fhis day of , by 1 , fhe City Clerk of ihe City of Saint Paul, a municipat corporation undes the taws of the State of Minnesota, on behaff of said municipaf aorporation. Notary Pubfic Q�'��7�� STA�E dF NffNNESOTA } ) ss. CflUtJTY OF ) Fhe foregoing insfrument was acknowtedged before me this day af , by , the Finanee Director of fhe City of Saint Paul, a municipa! corporation under the faws of the 5tate of Minnesofa, on bef�alf of said munici�al corporation. Notary Public STATE OF MINNESOTA ) } ss. GOUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknawfedged before me fhis day of by , the City Attorney of the Ciiy of Sainf Paul, a municipal corporafion under the iaws of the Sfate of Nfinnesata, an beha4f af said municipa{ corporation. Notary Pubfic DRAFTED BY: LAWSOIV, MARSHALL, McDOt�ALD, GAL0INITZ & WOLLE, P.A. l.awyers 1039a 39"' Street North Lake E{roo, Minnesota 55Q42 Telephone: {651) 777-6860 (TAG) L•! C� �(��'�'' EXHIBIT "A" k k .�: An easement over, under and across the East 140 feet of the South 15 feet and over the West 205 feet of the following property: The South 91 feet of the North 282 feet of the Soufh 562 feet of the East Quarter of the Southeast Quarter of the Northeast Quarter of Section 11, Township 28 North, Range 22 West. PERMANENT DRAINA�E EASEMENT FOR MAILAND MCKMGHT GULLY REPAIR �x�;b;l 3� �}8 1 ->`�_ Easement Granted. Kevin B. lagos; 443 McKnight Road South, Sf. Pauf, Minoesota 55119 (hereinafter ca4led "Granto�') in consideration of fhe sum of Qne Doilar and other good and valuabte consideration, fo him in hand paid by the City of Saint Paul, a municipaf corporation under the laws of the Sfate of Minnesota (hereinafter called "City"), and in considerafion of the faifhfui perFormance by the Cify of the covenants hereinafter contained to be kept and performed by said City, does hereby grant said City a drainage easement and fhe right, privilege, easement and authority to install, operate, maintain, repair, or remove storm sewers and other surface water drainage improvemenfs across the fallowring-described real estate owned by the Grantor in the County of Ramsey and State of Minnesota, to-wit: • See attached Exhibif "A" 2. Duration. The said easement shall be permanent. The easement shall run with fhe land and extend ta and bind the heirs, representatives, successors and assigns of the party hereto respectively. In the event the City, by resolution of its council, defermines that it no longer requires the use of said property for the purposes described above, then and in such event, fhe easement together with alt rights and privileges granted therewith, shall terminate. 3. Covenant of Ownershia. The Grantor does hereby covenant that he is lawfully seized and possessed of the real estate above-described and has the authority to enter into this AgreemenF. Tfie Grantor wifl forever warrant and defend titfe against the claims of any other persons. �s-i�5� 4. Covenants of Cifv. {n consideration of the easements granted hereby, fhe City covenants as follows: a. The City, upon completion of work within the drainage easement, guarantees the sife will have smooth, continuous and positive slopes to provide appropriate drainage. The site shail be firee of debris, stones and cobbles and other deleteriaus maferial greater than six inches in diameter. The site shall be revegefated using a vegefation na6ve to the state of Minnesota. b. The Cify agrees to assume all liability and to indemnify and compensate Grantor for any injury or damage to persons or property, inciuding Grantor's property, occasioned by or arising in connection with the use of the above-described easement by the City. The Cify further agrees to defend, indemnify and save harmless Grantor against all actions, claims, damages or demand which may be brought or made either against Grantor or against Grantor's interesf in the above-described land by reason af anything done by the Cify in the exercise or purported exercise of the rights and privileges granted by this instrument. c. The City, in this use of the above-described property, shall comply with all Federal, Sfate and 1oca11aws and regulations. '""' IN WITNESS WHEREOF, we have sef our hands this �_ day of �cr.h-� , 2 G 3 . ��,n ��=.. �„e--1� Kevin B. Lagos STATE OF MINNESOTA ) � ) ss. COUNTY OF i�Y1,�2 ) The foregoing instrument was acknowtedged before me this �S day of , 0 a , by Kevin B. Lagos, Grantor(s). ��1- i.S�� Notary ublic MAI N. LEE I�totsry Public-Minnesota OamwironEi �n.,knst.2aae 2 y- ��'M� `:_. :;��N��M�;,�,,, 6�'I�� CIT`( OF SAINT PAUL By Its Mayor By its City Clerk By its Finance D'+rectos By �ts City Attomey STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ) The faregoing instrument was acknowiedged before me fhis day of , , by , the Mayor of the City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State of MinneseiR, on behalf of said municipat corporation. Natary Public STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF } The foregoing instn.rment was acknowfedged before me this day of , , by , the City Clerk of the Gity of 5aint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporation. Notary Public 3 �� STATE OF MfNNESOTA ) ) ss. GOUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowiedged before me this day of , by , the Finance Directar of the Cify of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of fhe Sfate of Minr+esota, on beha(f of said municipal corporation. Notary Public STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ) � The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of , , by , the City Attomey of the Cii}r of Saint Paul, a municipaf corporation under the {aws of tfie State of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporation. Notary Pubiic DRAFTED BY: LAWSON, MARSHALL, McDONALD, GALOWITZ & WQLLE, P.A. Lawyers 10390 39' Sfreef North Lake Elmo, Minnesota 55042 Telephone: (651} 777-6960 (TAG) � �� EXHIBIT "A" A 20 foot easement over, imder and across that pazt af the faIlowina descrcbed property: The North 80 feet of the 3outh 45I feet of the Easf Quarter of tfie Soufheast QuarEer of the Northeast Quarter of Section 11, Township 28, Ranga 22, RamsaY County, Minnesota. QPhich lies wiHun 10.00 feet each side of a centerline described as commencing at tfie sonthwest comer of the above descr�ed property; thence Nortb 89 degrees 55 minutes 51 seconds East, assumed bPa 'rn,�o, along the south line of said above descn'bed property, a disiance of 72.57 feet fn the poiut af be rnino of the centerline in be descnbed; Ehence North 23 degrees OQ mmutes 00 seconds West a distance of 18.53 feet; thence North 42 degrees 41 mimrtes 60 seconds West a distance of 86.04 f�t to the norEh Iine of said above descn�bed property and said Iine there terruinafing. The side lines of said easement aze prolonged or shoreened to tenninate at the nortl�, south and west lines of said above descnbed property. �xh,bif Q3 PERMANENT DFtA{NAGE EASEMENT ��yl�/� FOR MA(LAND MCKNIGHT GULLY REPAIR . 1. Easement Granted. Jerry P. Mac Neil and Trudy L. Marshali, 435 McKnight Road South, St. Paul, Minnesofa 55119 (hereinafter called "Granto�') in consideration of tfie sum of One Dallar and other good and valuable consideration, fo himlher in hand paid by the Gity of Saint Pauf, a municiQaf corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota (hereinafter called °Cit}r'), and in consideratian of the faithful performance by the City of the covenants hereinaffer contained to be kept and performed by said City, do hereby grant said Cify a drainage easement and the right, privilege, easement and authority to install, operate, maintain, repair, or remove storm sewers and other surface wafer drainage improvements across the foltowing-described real estate owned by the Grantor in the County of Ramsey and State of Niinnesota, to- wit: See atfached Exhibif "A" 2. Duration. The said easerr�ent shafl be permanent. The easement shall run with the land and extend to and bind the heirs, representatives, successors and assigns of the par[y herefo respecfively. In the event the City, by resofution of ifs council, determines that it no longer requires the use of said property for the purposes described above, then and in such event, the easement togefher witli all rights and privileges granted therewith, shall terminate: 3. Covenant of Ownershio. The Grantor does here6y covenant fhat they are lawfully seized and possessed af the real estate above-described and have the authority to enter info this Agreement. Tf�e Grantor wiEl forever warrant and defend titfe V v /( / 'l l againsf fhe claims of any ofher persons. 4. Govenants of Citv. in consideratian of the sasements granted hereby, fhe City covenanfs as follows: a. The City, upon completion of work within the drainage easement, guarantees the site wili have smoofh, confinuous and positive slopes to ptovide appropriate drainage. The sife shatl be free of debris, stones and cobbles and other deleterious material greafer than six inches in diameter. The site shafl be revegetated using a vegetation native to the sfafe of Minnesota. b. The City agrees to assume a{I (iability and to indemnify and compensate Grantor for any injury or damage to persans or property, including Grantor's property, occasioned by or arising in connection with the use of the aboue-desccibed easeme�t 6y the City. The City further agrees to defend, indemnify and save harmless Grantor against all actions, claims, damages or demand which may be brought or made eifher against Grantor or against Grantor's interest in the above-described land by reason af anything done by the City in the exercise or purported exercise of fhe rights and privileges granted by this instrument. c. The City, in this use of fhe a6ove-described proper[y, shall comply with all Federal, State and tocal faws and regutations. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, we have set our hands this day of �� STATE OF MINNESOTA CQUNTY OF ) ) ss. ) � Trt�dy L. ar atl � � r - T,�e foregoing insfrument was acknowledged before me this ��' Yl �� , Zo�; by Jerry P. Mac Neif and Trudy L. M� �� day of ° ULYSSESHARRISJR �� NotaryPublic Minnesota ' My�pnunissronExp'rtesJamiary37,Y010 �� l �� CITY OF SAINT PAUL By Its Mayor By its Cify Ciesk By its Finance Director By Its City Attomey STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUt�lTY OF ) The foregoing insirument was acknowledged before me this day of , , by , the Mayor of the City of Sainf Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the Sfate of M+nnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporation. Nofary Public STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrumenf was acknowledged before me this day of , , by , the City Clerk of the City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State ot Minnesota, on behatf of said municipal corporation. Notary Public 3 D8 -I �� STATE OF MINNESOTA } ) ss. COUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowlsdged before me fhis day of , , by , the Finance Director o# the City of Sainf Paul, a municipal corporation under the iaws of fhe State of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporafion. No#ary Public STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of , , by , the City Attorney of the City of Saint Paul, a municipa{ corporation under the faws of the State of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporation. Notary Public DRAFTED BY: LAWSON, MARSHALL, McDONALD, GA�OWiTZ & WOLLE, P.A. Lawyers 1039Q 39 Street North Lake Elmo, Minnesota 55042 Telephone: (651) 777-6960 (TAG) � � �! ��/ EXF1[BIT "A" An easement over, nnder and across diat part of the foUowivg descn�bed properEy: Tbe North 11I feet of flte South 562 feet of tfie East Quarter of the SoutheasE Q�azEer of the Northeast Quarter of Section Il, TownsUip 28, Range 22, Ramsey County, Minnesota, except part faken for McKnight Itnad. VThich lies southwesterly of a line described as commencing at the southwest comer of tiie above descn'bed property; #hence Notth 89 degrees 55 minutes 51 seconds East, assvmed bC3liLlg, along the sonth line of said above descnbed pmperty, a disfanee of 21.32 feet to tfie point ofbeginning of ttie line to be described; thenee North 42 degrees 41 minutes 00 seconds Wesf a dicfance of 2636 feet; thence 5outtt 78 degrees 00 minutes 00 seconds West a distance of 3.62 feet to the west line of said above described property and said line there tPrm�na.ting. , �Xd�',�;f ��j PERMANENT DRAINAGE EASEMENT b J�� / l� /J FOR MAILAND MCKNIGHT GULLY REPAiR Easerr�ent Granted. Pefer Thai Yang and Mai See F. Yang a/k/a MaiSee F. Yang, 2221 Mailand Road, Sf. Paul, Minnesota 55119 (hereinafter calied "Granfor") in consideration af fhe sum of One Doliar and other good and valuable consideration, to him/her in hand paid by the City of Saint Paul, a munic+pal corporation under fhe laws of the State of Minnesota (hereinafter called °Cify"}, and in consideration of the faithful performance by the City of the covenants hereinafter contained to be kept and performed by said City, do hereby grant said Cify a drainage easement anci the right, privifeqe, easement and authority to install, operate, maintain, repair, or remove storm sewers and ofher surFace water drainage improvements across the following-described real estate owned by the Grantor in the County of Ramsey and State of Minnesota, to- wit: See attached Exhibit "A" 2. Duraiion. The said easement shaff be permanent. The easement shafi run with the land and extend to and bind the heirs, represenfatives; successors and assigns of the parly hereto respectively. In the event fhe City, by resolution of its council, determines that it no longer requires the use of said proper(y for the purposes described above, then and in such evenf, fhe easement together with all rights and privileges granted therewith, shall terminate. 3. Covenant of Ownership. The Grantar does hereby covenant tf�af they are lawfully seized and possessed of the real estate above-descri6ed and have the aufhority to enter info fhis Agreement. The Grantar will forever warrant and defend title �/�� agains# the Gaims of any other persons. 4. Covenants of Ci#v. In consideration of the easements granted hereby, the Cify cavenants as folfows: a. The City, upon completion of work within the drainage easement, guarantees the site wit{ have smooth, continuous and positive slopes to provide appropriate drainage. The site shall be free of debris, stones and cabbles and other deleterious material greater than six inches in diameter. The site shafl be revegetated using a vegefation native to the state of Minnesota. The City agrees to assume ail liability and to indemnify and compensate Grantor for any injury or damage to persons or property, inciuding Granto►'s property, occasioned by or arising in connection with the use of the above-described easement by the City. The City further agrees to defend, indemnify and save harmtess Grantor against all actions, claims, damages or demand which may be brought or made either against Grantor or against Granfor's interest in the above-described land by reason of anything done by the City in the exercise or purported exercise of the rights and privileges granted by this instrument. c. The City, in this use of the above-described property, shall comply with all Federal, State and iocal taws and regulations. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, we have set our hands this t�a'� day of J�h.� ,2�6 . Peter Thai Yang , � �. Mai See . ang a/k/ �a F. Yang STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF The foregoing instn m,� , � , ��r ng, Granfor(s). � ��/�` l� �� t -J �� ) ., ) ss. �ent as acknowledged before me this � day of ^ T- and Mai See F. Yang atkla MaiSee F. '2/14'/�T r1L`t B� l2 ' ".-�a�,cFU( �r � a ' �� -�� 2 �.�i,; ELIZa6€fiM�NNMOLDREM �� Nota Public � N�- �Y ��, Minnesota My Comm55ion Expir¢s January 31, 2 b� �� '��, Peter Th i Yang STATE OF MINNESOTA ) (�) ss. COUNTY OF Z The orego ng instrument was acknowledged before me �-by Peter 7hai Yan�, G�tor(s�� /% • � . ��;�� arv Public LISA h4. CLASEN H�OTARY PU8L9G "AiMNESO �A Phy Comn�is�ion ExGres 9-31-2009 3 og-135� CITY OF SAINT PAUL QI � �'�l �'�l STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ) its Mayor Its City Clerk Its Finance Director Its City Attorney The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of , by , the Mayor of the City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota, on beha4f of said municipal corporation. Notary Public STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of , , by , the City Clerk of the City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota, on �ehalf of said rrsunicipai corporatson. Notary Public G! ��'�%� EXHIBIT "A" The East 130 feet of the South 562 feet of the Soufheast Quarter of the Southeast Quarter of the Northeast Quarter of Section 11, Township 28, Range 22 West. U:1CLI ENl1RW MW D. MI1Mailand-McKnightlYang.Agreement.wpd � �xh�b� �` I35" PERMANENT DRAINAGE EASEMENT bg '�� FOR MAILAND MCKNIGHT GULLY REPAIR 1. Easement Granted. -CatiBniceAn�erson, 2150 Mailand Road, St. Paui, MN 55119 (hereinafter caffed °Grantor�) in consideration of ffie sum of One Doltar and other good and valuable consideration, to him in hand paid by the City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of fhe State of Minnesota (hereinafter cal}ed "City"), and in consideration of the faithfui pertormance by the City of the covenants hereinafter contained to be kept and performed by said City, does hereby grant said City a drainage easement and the right, privilege, easement and authority to install, operate, maintain, repair, or remove storm sewers and other surface water drainage improvements across the fo!lowing-described real estate owned by the Grantor in the County of Ramsey and State of Minnesota, to-wit: See aftached Exhibit °A° 2. Duration. The said easement shall be permanent. The easement shall run wifh the fand and extend fo and bind the heirs, representafives, successors and assigns of the parfy hereto respectively. In #he event the City, by resolution of its council, determines that it no longer requires the use of said property for the purposes described above, then and in such event, the easement fogether with all rights and priviteges granted therewi4h, shal[ terminate. 3. Covenant of Ownership. The Grantor does hereby covenant that he is IawfuAy seized and possessed of the real estate above-descri6ed and has fhe authorify to enfer infio this Agreement, The Granfor wili forever warrant and defend title against the claims of any other persons. ��1 �/`J"J 4. Covenants of Cifv. fn consideration af the easements granted hereby the City covenants as follows: a. The Gify, upon comple6on of work within the drainage easement, guarantees the site wili have smooth, continuous and posifive slopes ta provide appropriate drainage. The site shafl be free of debris, stones and cobb[es and other deleterious materia( greater than soc inches in diameter. The site shalf be revegetated using a vegetation native to the state of Minnesofa. b. The City agrees to assume all liabi[ity and to indemnify and compensate Granfor for any injury or damage to persons or properfy, including Grantor's property, occasioned by or arising in connection with the use of the above-described easement by the City. The City further agrees fo defend, indemnify and save harmless Grantor against alt actions, claims, damages or demand which may be brought or made either against Grantor or agains4 Grantor's interest in the above-described land by reason of anything done by the City in tfie exercise or purported exercise of the rights and privileges granted by this instrument. c. The City, in this use of the above-described property, shail comply with all Federa(, State and local laws and regulations. tN WITNESS WHEREOF, we have set our hands fhis �_ day of �v.v�. , Z�� c arl8ruce nderson STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this _� day of �, Z�Q , by Carl Bruce Anderson, Grantor(s). . ;�:�. RITA J. ANDEf2SON f //�`��%�- (/�L.F� NOTARYPIigLIC-A+�� Notary ublic � EXP RES JAN! 3S' 2010 � 2 d�� CtTY OF SAINT PAUL By Its Mayor By ifs City+ Clerk By Its Finance Director By Its Cify Attomey STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUMTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of , , by , the Mayor of the City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesofa, on behaif of said municipa( carporation. Notary Pubiic STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF } The foregoing insfrument was acknawledged before me this day of , , by , the City Clerk of the City of Saint Paul, a municipal carporation under the �aws of the State of Minnesota, on 6ehalf of said municipat corporation. Notary Pubfic 3 Si'ATE OF MINNESOTA } ) ss. COUNTY OF ) ��'I �� The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of , , by , the Finance Director of the City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of ffie State of fvlinnesota, on behalf of said municipat corporafion. Notary Pubiic STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. CaUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of , , by , the City Aftorney of the City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporation. Notary Public DRAFTED BY: LAWSON, MARSHAL�, McDONALD, GALOWI�Z & WOLLE, P.A. Lawyers 10390 39'" Sfreet North Lake Elmo, Minnesofa 55042 Telephone: (651) 777-6960 (TAG) � �� EXH[BiF "A" An easement oaer, uuder and across thaf part af tfie following descn'bed property: The West 65 feet of the South 562 feet of fiie Souffieast Qr.iarter of the Souttteast Quaiter of tfie NorHteast Quarter of Seciion 11, Tawnship 28, Range 22, Ramsey Cotmty, Minnesob- Wluch lies northerly and easterly of a line descn�ed as conlmencing at the northeast comer of the above desenbed pmperty; thence South 0 degrees 15 minutes 23 seconds Fas� assumed bearing, along the east line of said above descnbed pmperty, a distance of 2333 feet to the point of bea nnin g of the line to be desenbed; tlzence North 4b degrees degrees 30 minutes 00 seconds West a distance of 27.80 fee� fhence Nortii 1 degree 36 minufes 14 secofids Fast a distance of 4.17 feet to the north line of said above described property and said line there tarnvnating. A 20 foot easement over, under aad across that part of the following described property: The East 130 feet of the West 195 feet of the South 562 feet of the Southeast Quazter of the Southeast Quarter of the Northeast Quarter of Section 11, Township 28, Range 22, Itauisey Connty, Minnesofa. Which lies within 10.00 feet eacfi si@e of a centerline descn'bed as convnencing af i�e northeast corner of the above descnbed properEy; thence Soath 0 degrees I S minutes 23 seconds East, assumed bearing, along the east line of said ahove described property, a distan.ce of 86.63 feet to the pomt of be. �g n�g of i�e centerline to be described; f3�ence So�th 84 degrees 00 arinutes 00 seconds West a distance of 736 feet; thence North 86 degrees 30 minutes 00 seconds BJest a distance of44.00 feet; thence Nortfi 46 degrees 30 minutes 00 seconds VJest a distance af 104.06 feet f.n the west 2ine of said above descn'bed pmperty and said centerline there terminating. T7ze side Iines of said easement are proIonged or skortened to terruinate at i�e east, north and west Iines of said above described properly. �x%��'�it r3 6 PERMANENt DRAINAGE EASEMENT �� FOfi MAiI,.AND MCKNtGiiT GUlLY REPAiR 1. Easement Granted. Tina Mae Johnson, 395 McKnight Road South, St. Pau1, Minnesota 55119 (hefeinafter calEed °Granfos�) in cansideratian of the sum o# One Dollar and other good and valuable consideration, to her in hand paid by the City of Saint Paul, a mu�ieipal corparation under the laws of fhe State of Minnesota {hereinafter called "City"), and in consideration of fhe faithtul perfarmance by the City o# the covenants hereinafter confained to be kept and performed by said Cify, does hereby granf said City a drainage easement and the right, privilege, easement and authority to install, operate, maintain, repair, or remove storm sewers and other surtace water drainage improvements across fhe following-described real esfafe owned by the Grantor in the County of Ramsey and State of Minnesota, to-wit: See attached Exhibit "A° 2. Duration. The said easement shali be permanent. The easement shall run with the land and e�end to a�d bind the heirs, representatives, successors and assigns of the party hereto respectively. In the event the City, by resolution of its council, determines that it no longer requires the use of said property for fhe purposes described above, then and in such event, the easement #ogether with ali rights and privileges granted fherewith, shall terminate. 3. Covenant of Ownership. The Grantor does hereby covenant that she is iawfuliy seized and possessed of the reai estate above-described and has the.authority to enter into this Agreement. The Granfor will forever warrant and defend titfe against the claims of any ather persons. l� /� �� 4. Covenants of CiN. !n considerafion of fhe easements granted hereby, #he Cify covenants as fofiows: a. The City, upon compfetian of work within the drainage easement, guarantees the site wili have smooth, continuous and posifire siopes to provide appropriate drainage. The site shall be free of debris, stones ar�d cobbles and other deleterious maferial greater fhan s6c inches in diameter. Tfie site shali be revegetated using a vegetation na#ive fo the state of Minnesata. b. The City agrees to assume ail liabi(ity and to indemnify and compensate Gran#or for any injury or damage to persons or property, including Granfor's property, occasioned by or arising in connect+on with the use of the above-described easement by the City. The City further agrees ta defend, indemnify and save harmless Grantor against all actions, claims, damages or demand which may be brought or made either against Grantor or against Grantor`s interest in the above-descri6ed land by reason ofi anything done by the City in the exercise or purported exercise of the rights and privileges granted by this instrument. c. The City, in this use of the above-described property, shall comply wifh all Federal, State and local laws and regulations. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, we J �wsi , �. STATE OF MINNESOTA CQUNTY OF 9� �^/ have set our hands this �3� day of � Tina Mae Johnson ) ) ss. ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this �3 `—` day of T,,,,�.t. �� by Tina Mae Johnson, Grantor(s). fl�'J./'I!!!l��Jll!!lI I!l!!IJ!!� � .r�'' . ` � : • - ^� - ti '�,�': _ � I��- • : � • ` �J./'_/'�IIIlI-rJJIl1lJ'I�/IIJIJlJ.iYJ �� ofary Public , I� o�-I�� CfTY OF SAINT PAUL Ets Mayor By its Cify Clerk Its Finance Director By Its City Afforney STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. couNrr o� __ ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged befare me this day of , , by , the Mayor of tfie City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota, on behalf of safd municipal corparation. Notary Public STATE OF MiNNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged befare me fhis day of , , by , the City Clerk of the City of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporation. Notary Public 3 STATE OF MIN{�4ESOTA ) ) ss. C011NTY OF ) �� The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of , , �y , tfie Finance Director of the City o# Saint Pau1, a municipal corporafion under the laws of the State of Minnesota, an behalf of said municipal corporation. STATE OF MlNNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ) Notary Public The foregoing insfrument was acknowledged before me this day of , by , the City Attomey of the City of Saint Paui, a municipai corporation under the faws of the State of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporafion. I�:a�i � : LAWSON, MARSHALL, McBONALD, GALOWITZ & WOLLE, P.A. Lawryers 10390 39`" Street North Lake Efmo, Minnesota 55042 Telephona: {651) 777-6960 (TAG) Notary Public � �� -«�' E3CHlBfT "A" A 2A foof easement aver, under and across i3�at garE of the following descn�bed pmperCy: 'The North 220 feet of the South 782 feet of the East IIatf of the 5outheast Quarter of the Nordteast Quarter of Secfion 11, Township 28, Range 22, Ramsey Cotmiy, Minnesofa, except the South 180 feet of the East 165 feet therea£ Which lies within 10.00 feet each side of a cenferliae desen'bed as commencmg at Che sou4iwest comer of tfie above descn�bed properCy; thence North 89 degraas 55 minutes 51 seconds East, assumed bearing, atong tflie south line of said above descnlsed pmperiy, a distance of 55.06 fee� thence Soutfi 46 degrees 30 mim�#es 00 secoads East a d.istance of I 1.00 feet to the point of begmning ofthe centerline to be described; thence North 46 degrees'30 minates 00 seconds West a distance of 11.00 fee� thence North 1 degree 36 minutes 14 secoads East a disfiance of 31.22 feet; thence I�Iorth 60 degrees 60 minufzs 00 seconds West a disfanee of 40.SQ feet; thence Sout$ 77 degrees 15 muiufes 00 seconds West a dista.uce of 21.61 feet to the west line of said above described properLy and said centerline there ferminating. Tfie side lines of said easement are prolonged or shortened ta termmate aE the soui� and west tines of said above described properiy. �xhibif C - og�i �� C{TY OF ST. PAUL. CITY OF MAPLEWOOD. RAMSEY COUNTY AND RAMSEY-WASHINGTON METRO WATERSHED DISTRICT COST-SHAR[NG AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT made and entered into this day of 2007 by and between the City of Sf. Paul, a municipal corporation (hereinafter called "St. Paul"), the City of Maplewood, a municipaf corporation (hereinaffer calied "Mapiewood"), Ramsey County, (hereinafter called "Couniy°) and the Ramsey- Washington Metro Watershed Dis4rict, a municipal corporation (hereinafter calied "District"). WITNESSES: 1. Purpose. In cons+deration of fhe mutual beneftt given to all parties, the parties hereby seek to share the costs of the implementation of needed improvements in the McKnight/Mailand project involving the modification of the storm water drainage system and channel improvements northwest of the Intersection of McKnight and Mailand Roads. It is understood and agreed that the parties have received adequate consideration by the mutual 6enefits given to each party by virtue of the cost sharing arrangemenf. 2. Responsibilities of the Parties. A. Citv of St. Paui. The City of St. Paul shall pay for 33.3% of the cost of the channel stabilization. This is estimafed to cost approximately $8,800.00. Furthermore, St. Paul shall provide maintenance of the channel with cost sharing from the District paying &6.6°l0 of the maintenance costs and St. Paul paying 33.3% of the maintenance costs. B. Cify of Nlapfewood. The City of Maplewood shafi construct the refention pond on the Northeast corner of McKnight and Mailand Roads which shall be completed in the year 2007. The City of Maplewood shaii pay for 66.6% og 4he costs �if #h� �hanr�ei stabilization (approximately $17,600.00), and 50% of the cost of the energy dissipater (approximatefy $3,500.00). C. Ramsey Countv. Ramsey County shall be responsible for the replacement of storm sewer pipe from McKnight Road catch basin to the enargy dissipator and 50% of construction cost of the energy dissipator at the pipe outlet (approximately $3,500.00). b8 - f �'�� D. f�amsey-Washi�gfon Metro Wafershed District. The District shaft prepare feasibility studies and facilifate discussion of project responsibility and cost sharing issues and determinations. The District shall cost share wifh the City of St. Paul in future projecf maintenance as outlined ai�ove for 66.6°l0 of the maintenance costs with the City of St. Paul being responsible for 33.3% of the ma+nfenance costs. Furthermore, the District shall be responsible for coordinating the contracts for the channel sta6ilization project, the District shall pay the confractor and shall be responsible for administering and addressing any warranty +ssues. Furthermore, the District shalf invoice Ramsey County, the City of St. Paul and the City of Maplewood for their portion of the construction costs. 3. Riqht of Access. Landowners have provided Easements fo the City of St. Paul to grant access fo the proper#y to construct the project. The other named parties herein, to the extent necessary, shall act as agents to the City of St. Paul when seeking to enter on to the property to construct or otherwise maintain fhe easements as outlined herein. 4. Binding Effect. The terms and provisions of this Agreement shall be binding on and inure to the benefit of the heirs, representafives, successors and assigns of the parties hereto and shall be bind'+ng on all future owners of all or any part of the property and shall be deemed covenants running with the land. References herein to Landowner, if there be more than one, shall mean afl of them. Each party hereby agrees to hoid the other party harmless from any and all liability arising from the acfions of the other and shall indemnify any other party for any costs incurred by another party as a resuit of another party's actions. 5. Notices. Whenever it shall be required or permitfed by this Agreement that notice or demand be given or served by either party to or on the other par[y, such notice or demand shall be delivered personaliy or mailed by United States mail to the addresses hereinafter set forth by certified mail. Such notice or demand shall be deemed timely given when delivered personally or when deposited in the mail in accordance with the above. The addresses of the parties hereto for such mail purposes are as follows, until written notice of a change of such address has been given: As to the City of St. Paul: City of St. Pau1 Public Works Dept. 900 City Hall Annex St. Paul, MN 55101 2 ��( �� As fo fhe Cify of Maplewood: City of Maplewood Public Works Department 1902 County Road B East Maplewood, MN 55109 As to Ramsey Counfy: As to fhe District: Ramsey Counry Public Works Director 1425 Paul Kirkwold Drive Arden Hilis, MN 55112 Ramsey-Washington Metro Watershed District 2665 Noel Drive Little Canada, MN 55117 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the City of St. Paul, City of Maplewood, Ramsey County and the District have caused this Agreement to be duly executed on the day and year first above written. GITY OF ST. PAUL '� Mayor By Its City Cierk � � 3 Its Finance Director Its City Attorney ��I J�� STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF ) ) ss. ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of , , 6y , the Mayor of the City of Saint Paul, a municipai corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota, on behaif of said municipal corporation. Notary Public STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF ) ) ss. ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of , , by , 4he City Clerk of the Cify of Saint Paul, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporation. Notary Pu STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF ) ) ss. ) The foregoing instrumenf was acknowledged before me this day of , , by , the Finance Director of the City of Saint Paul, a municipai corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporation. Notary Public STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ) The foregoing instrumenf was acknowledged before me fhis day of , , by , the City Attorney of the City of Saint Pauf, a municipal corporation under the laws of the Sfate of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporation. Notary Public 4 �� STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF(�� The laws by CITY OF MAP BY�I� Its and By Its ) ) ss. ) i before me this �� day of '_, _ and � z-J , the and �� of the City of aplewood, a unicipal corporation under the State of innesota, on behalf of said municip I o fbn. Notary Pubfo ��:-� HUGH A. KANTRUD � Notary Public - s Minnesota s ""° ,� My Commission Eepires Jan. 31, 2010 b`��[�� RAMS COUNTY � / / By _ � �� t J`. i�c�� C.oc�-u �a.nc.�2.f and STATE OF MINNESOTA } ) ss. COUNTY OF,��E�L� ) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this � 7 � day of �, �07 , by t/1 ��f and , the and of Ramsey County on be If of said Ramsey County. /1..�d-�,L�T Gf � ��r-a-u.r.G✓ ' Notary Public � ROBEFfiTkA. CRANCER �IY�ION� ' JANWRV3f,Y010 Recommended for Approvai by: � �� Ftamsey County Engineer 0 b� �I�� RAMSEY-WASHINGTON METRO WATERSHED DISTRICT By .� �-aw�. � � Its and g �� C/ J✓ / STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF � ) ss. ) � The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this � day of _ , OD �' , by RoQer E. Lake and Robert Johnson ,th@ President and Secretarv of the Ramsey-Washington Metro Watershed District, a municipal corporation under the laws of the State of Minnesota, on behalf of said municipal corporation. ` �TRACEY ANN 3AI,OYYITZ F ;�—� ' Notary PuDMc \.�. 1, Minnesota My Canmission Eepires January 31, 2010 DRAFTED BY: LAWSON, MARSHALI, McDONALD, GALOWITZ & WOLLE, P.A. Lawyers 10390 39 Street North Lake Elmo, MN 55042 Telephone:(651)777-6960 (TAG) �_.��_ , :�,__��` � , �� - 7