07-936City of St. Pau1
RESOLUTION RATIFYING ASSESSMENT
In the matter of the assessment of
Operation of the Above Standard Street
the following projects:
18321
18390
18423
18430
18992
18550
18590
18612
19000
18626
18778
18861
190120P
188860P
189060P1
19036
Lowertown Area
Ford-Cleveland Area
Grand-West Area
North Wabasha Area
4th/Minnesota Area
Concord Phase I Area
Wabasha/St. Peter Area
Oniversity-Western-Mackubin Area
W.7 to Munster Area
Snelling-Randolph Area
United/Children's Hospital Area
Como-Snelling Area
White Bear/Beech-Reaney Area
Hamline Oniversity Area
Downtown Acorn Area
White Bear/Larpenteur-Hoyt Area
Preliminary Order:
Final Order:
COUNCIL FILE N0. ����"-'
B ���� � 3S _
File No. See Attached iist
Assessment No. See Attached List
Voting Ward 1,2,3,4,7
Green Sheet No.
benefits, cost and expenses for the
Lighting Systems for the year 2007 for
18336
18392
18925
18939
18525
18588
18607
18634
18709
18859
188030P
19012
190270P
approved
approved
Selby-Western Area
Grand-East I Area
Grand-East II Area
Smith Avenue Area
Se1by Revitalization Area #1
Selby Revitalization Area #2
River Park P1aza Area
E.7th/Payne-Minnehaha-Mendota
Area
City Hall-Court House Area
Landmark Center Area
Dale/University-Minnehaha-Hatch
Area
Suburban/White Bear-RUth Area
Rice/Sycamore-Front Area
A public hearing having been had upon the assessment for the above
improvement, and said assessment having been further considered by the
Council, and having been considered finally satisfactory, therefore, be it
RESOLVED,That the said assessment be and the same is hereby in all
respects ratified.
0�' �3�
RESOLVED FURTHER,
That the said assessment
in one equal installment
be and it is hereby
as per Section 64.04 of
determined to be payable
the Administrative Code.
Yeas Nays Absent
Benanav ✓
Bostrom ✓
Harris ,i
Hel en �/
Lantry r�
Montgomery �/
Thune i/
Adopted by the Council: Date: �� �3 d
Certified Passed by the Council Secretary
By - %
Mayor
� Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet �
l0�43�07 d1��:V
Departmentloffice/council:. Date InRiated:
Pw -�b� o2-A��� Green Sheet NO: 3042511
ConWCtPersonBPhone: _^ .� �
� JuanOrtiz � CY\.f�J
266-8864 _��•�
Must Be on Council Pyenda by (Date):
, 22-AUG-07
Doc. Type: OTHER (DOESNT FIT ANY C
E-Document Required: Y i
Document Contac[: John Saumweber �'�,
ContaM Phone: 266-8857
�
Assign
Number
For
Routing
Order
0 Pub6< Works ' duan Ortiz
1 Council MarvEricksan
2 C� qerk Shari Moore '
I Total # of Signature Pages _(Clip All Locations for Signature)
; Achon Requested: �
� Set date of public hearing to ratify the 2007 operation wsts for the Above Standard Street Lighting Systems as listed on The attached '��.
, resolutions. '�
Planning Commission
CIB Committee
Crvil Service Commission
Must
t. Has this person/firm everworked under a contract for this department?
Yes No
2. Has this person/firm ever been a ciry employee?
Yes No
3. Does this person/frm possess a skill not normally possessed by any
current city employee?
Yes No
Explain all yes answers on separate sheet and atWch to green sheet
Initiating Problem, Issues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why):
Ratification is necessary in order to begin collecting the operation costs.
Advanqges If Approved:
Same as above.
DisadvantageslfApproved:
Benefitted proper[y owners will have operation costs payable via proper[y taxes.
i Disadvantages If Not Approved:
: To not assess [he benefits would be inconsistent with Ciry policy.
� Transaction: $181,976.32
Funding Source: QSSBSSmentS
Financial Information:
(Expiain)
CostlRevenue Budgeted:
Activity Number:
�
•
�. �... � � �I��
August 2, 2007 10:30 AM Page 1
City of St. Paul
COUNCIL FILE NO. �'�I�v�
REPORT OF COMPLETION OF ASSESSMENT Fi1e No. See Attached List
Assessment No. See Attached List
Voting Ward 1,2,3,4,7
Green Sheet No.
In the matter of the assessment of benefits, cost and expenses for the
Operation of the Above Standard Street Lighting Systems for the year 2007 for the
following projects:
18321
18390
18423
18430
18992
18550
18590
18612
19000
18626
18778
18861
190120P
188860P
189060P1
19036
Lowertown Area
Ford-Cleveland Area
Grand-West Area
North Wabasha Area
4th/Minnesota Area
Concord Phase I Area
Wabasha/St. Peter Area
University-Western-Mackubin Area
W.?`"/Madison to Munster Area
Snelling-Randolph Area
UnitedlChildren's Aospital Area
Como-Snelling Area
White Bear/Beech-Reaney Area
Hamline University Area
Downtown Acorn Area
White Bear/Larpenteur-Hoyt Area
18336
18392
18425
18434
18525
18588
18607
18634
18709
18859
188030P
19012
190270P
Selby-Western Area
Grand-East I Area
Grand-East II Area
Smith Avenue Area
Selby Revitalization Area #1
Selby Revitalization Area #2
River Park Plaza Area
E.7th/Payne
Area
City Hall-Court House Area
Landmark Centez Area
Dale/University-Minnehaha-Hatch
Area
Suburban/White Bear-RUth Area
Rice/Sycamore-Front Area
Preliminary Order — appr
Final Order -- approved
To the Council of the City of St. Paul
The Valuation and Assessment Engineer hereby reports to the Council the
following as a statement of the expenditures necessarily incurred £or and in
connection with the making of the above improvement, viz:
Total operating costs $170,145
Engineering and Inspection $
Valuation and Assessment Services $ 11,831
Administration Charge - Public Health $
TOTAL EXPENDITURES
Charge To
Net Assessment
00
32
$181,976.32
$181,976.32
Said Valuation and Assessment Engineer further reports that he has assessed
and levied the total amount as above ascertained, to-wit: the sum of $181,976.32
upon each and every lot, part or parcel of land deemed benefited by the said
improvement, and in the case of each lot, part or parcel of land in accordance with
the benefits conferred thereon; that the said assessment has been completed, and that
hereto attached, identified by the signature of the said Valuation and Assessment
Engineer, and made a part hereof, is the said assessment as completed by him, and
which is herewith submitted to the Council for such act' her�e�, as may be
considere�proper. � / /��� /J�
7 � �
Dated v � D � oo� x'
uation arid Assess�lf7fi`�' Enaineer
ABOVE STANDARD STREET LIGH
FILE # ASMT # COUNCIL DESCRIPTION
18321 0070 2 Lowertown
18336 0071 � Selby/Western
18390 0072 3 Ford/Cleveland
18392 � 0073 2 Grand-Eastl
�.°�..a. .,.. � �;..f..._., : �..- _::.:�..=.v . .:.t, . ::,<
18423 0074 3, 4 Grand-West
- [ � r _r 3, .�r�.� ,�.._. e�..:. ;;.�.:a -
a... . . .
18425 0075 1 Grand-Eastll
�:_,..?vs.6�a:�,s; ;��.:.Y��`:,�'��;..nd..�..�e.m�:ryu... �r'.�'�.';�d.t4'a�._,�uY'�,.,�
1 0076 2 North Wabasha
x.a:- .&'s<#Y:'�S. � `' .':�. _ �e ��' � � Sn�9,:' x.,tr;�:�" asi,�:_=e. :iu�L
18434 0077 2 Smith Avenue
i, =�e�°Pk A,:s F+7 s6: �S�iI�._'8: ` I� �. �a3lt;?k::;. m ' � �� � ... �,:.s'°����� : aR::.. E� .flfi �.t
'�+ S'v' � i
18525 0079 1 Selby No. 1
_ '�, :��,.Fi .�ml�� r ts ' y€:: `: �t�aha .... __ : :§iL�*: � . 4� v�? ��i � ` .:;s?.:xi,'v=i
..a � � ��z{�il. . t
` 18550 0100 2 Concord Phase I
� =r�+.:. ° t,;,; - �u � k� .'::?���
18588 0103 1 Selby No. 2
� x= L
18590 0104 2 Wabasha/St. Peter
r r� .a'�y " ° ? y ,��
18607 0101 2 River Park Plaza
d
18612 0105 1 Univ/Western-Macku
18626 0106 3 Snelling/Randolph
;;
18634 0107 7 7th/Payne/Mhaha/Me
18709 0108 2 CHCH
18778 0109 2 United/Children's
18859 0110 2 Landmark Center
18861 0111 4 Como/Snelling
�'°
188030P 0112 1,5 Da1elUniv-Mhaha-Ha
, r ,,,.
188860P 0113 4 Hamline Univ
189060P1 0116 2 Downtown Acorn
: b iL���'iali.
18992 0117 2 4th/Minnesota (Plaza
,.
19000 � 0118 3 7th/Munster-Madison
di3tF4
19012 0120 7
190210P 0121 6,'
190270P 0122 5
19036 0123 6
OPERATION COSTS FOR ;
OP COSTS SERVICE FEE
$35,200.00 $2,525.38
$1,560.00 $�04.62
$25,000.00 $1,690.95
$10,000.00 $783.02
$8,500.00
vx��� �.;�;�;�
$3,500.00
_..�^;�stoa?;�;
$1,300.00
$850.00
$1,500.00
$20,652.00
$5,19�.��
$1,540.00
$1,000.00
$5,150.00
$1,200.00
100.00
$1
r�x�z��
$43927
m:..:::;un°v�_
4
$440.31
� � �;_. �.N� �._e
$248.38
�—�—� "" �
$115.58
,:, s�v, ,..� E , r r�
$166.86
a. "m�i'�°ni"ea=:
$80.42
��'
$89.80
$1,402.31
$363.30
$70.96
$82.32
$328.67
$84.00
$149.71
$199.36
$225.69
$87.15
$694.09
$361.74
$240.80
$9623
_,:
$427.12
$223.69
1.831.32
COST
$37,725.38
$1,664.62
$26,690.95
$10,753.02
$5,73927
m.::k. � :F
$8,940.31
CSi?�Ei`.3.�.
$3,748.38
.... s -�,+a;�F .
$1,415.58
� �,:;�. � ri�nmGG
$2,166.86
6' _ _ a
$930.42
^ $1,589.80
1
$1,610.96
$1,082.32
$1,284.00
$1,99971
$3,047.36
$974.59
$1,332.15
10,694.09
$535.00
�°a:�a�
$5,461.74
$3,640.80
$1,696.23
$5.427.12
1�-931�
:•.� � �. .
-
6
p ,��
�
September 17, 2007
�nce again I have received a bili from the City of St. Paul for "historic Omamentai Lighting"
for properties I own in the Lowertown area. White historicatly these lights where intended to
enhance and embellish the historic nature of the properties, they have become biilboards
and signposts for the City.
As building owners, we have worked closely with the Historic Preservation Commission and
various City departrnents to develop properties consistent with their historic character. The
Iighting in the area was intended to build on the work. Not only adding historic nature to the
buildings and the entire area, but also to embellish a certain charm that exists in Lowertown.
We appreciate these efforts and do not dispute the excess charges for this embeliishment, if
in fact that were the case.
While lighting standards and ornamentai historic giobes are nice, they fail miserably at
providing any enrichment to the area since they are used as sign posts for everything from
bus schedules to parking restrictions, to lane marlvngs, etc. What were originally intended
as means of beautifying and Unifying the historic nature of Lowertown has become little more
than an unsightly clutter of signposts and informational builetin boards.
St Paul seems bent on removing alI bi(Iboards around the City and seems bent on requiring �_
property owners in Lowertown to pay for architectural lighting. What they do not seem to see
is the obvious conflict in turning architecturai lighting into the biliboards they seem to abhor. '
Until such time that these lights and light standards are stripped of ail this signage and are
restored to their intended purpose, as an enriching adjunct to an area many of us have
Jabored so long to preserve and enhance, I will continue to refuse to pay assessments for
something that constitutes nothi�g more than sign standards and biAboards for the Gity of St.
Paul.
I'm including a padcet of information that demonstrates my position on this subject Of alt the
light standards that fail within this description of "above standard street lighting" i could only
find 3 or 4 that have not been bastardized by any number of Ciiy signs. While the ligh6ng
standards and fixtures may actually be above sta�dard they are compietely obliterated by
this unsightly clutter and act more as a neighborhood detriment than an asset.
lu . rely,
d ^
David Br o s
366 Jackson Street, St. Paul, MN 55101 Dave Brooks Jaunae Brooks Shana Brooks
Oct 02 07 02:47p James Miller 6512235513 p.l
��� ��
St. Paul City Clerk
310 Ciiy Hall
IS W. Kellogg Blvd.
St. Paul, MN 55102
Re: Lowertown Decorative Lig�ting Assessment
�F.�S'�"�I
(J�-9310
The undersigned objects to the proposed special assessment for decorative street
lighting in L,owertown because
i) the assessment exceeds the benefit
ii) the money is not actually used for the stated purpose and.
iii) the decorative lights are being ruined by the graffiti of city signage.
Please also take this as notice of our intent to appeal any assessment order made by the
City Council.
Property Address:
z�ti Krn s� F
S,4.n,r PRUc Mn1 S�/o�
Parce) Id. Number;
�j2 29 2Z �3 Dp S
7
Taxpayer Name:
10/03l2007 13:03 6512214040 DEGREE OF HDNOR PAGE 03/03
Oct D3 07 11;4Gp Sharm Brooka 661�2�9-1�J43 p,3
(�7-93�
sc �pa� cttv ct�
310 City I�aU
15 W. Kepo�g Btvd.
St. Paul, hfN SS IO2
Re: Lowcrtow�a Decnzative L'ghtiog Asaes.cme�nt
:..,,-
The wndezsi�ned objects to the ptnpoyed special assessment for decor,ative sitset
lightin� ia i,owettowAt because
i) the assessmeut exoeed.g the benefit
u) the money is not actualiy used for. the stated pur,po;� and.
i3i) the decorative lights are beir�g xuined by tye grati of cAty signage,
Piease also take this as notice of our iment to appeal any assessruent ordec made by khe
City Council.
3'!S �q�c.r-5�1.( S�REt�'
Prnperty Adtiresv:
��D S�_� 37.
�� ��N�
o4z S2y- t l �os
3'1S?t�KSe.s 9t-n!e u.�
Pareel ld. Number: �� r
3 91 2� Do 3 �A'�,��
3r2 qya �� Q��
Ta�cpayer Nume:
PRtz 'L SQC�Urty R{,Jf _n:. fn 46.G.•
Print
�f C�qjl,�i 1��2•D7 '�'�� ld�?-��
( I, � ! �E bate
Oct 03 07 10:39a Hrooks Group 651-292-3010 p.3
V l J � � �.Y
St. Paul City Clerk
310 City Aall
15 W. Keliogg Blvd.
St. Paul, MN 55102
Re: Lowertown Decorative Lighting Assessmeat
Madame:
The undersigned objects to the proposed special assessment for decorative street
lighting in Lowertown because
i) the assessment exceeds the benefit
u) the money is not actually used for the stated purpose and.
in) the decozative lights are being ruined by the gr�ti of city signage.
Please also take ttris as notice of our inteni to appeal any assessment order made by the
City Council.
Property Address:
O'Connor Buildins
266 E. 7 Street
Saint Faui, NIlY 55101
Parcel Id. Number;
31.29.22.44.0040
Taxpayer Name:
David Brooks
P" t .�
� a��� � I, � �
;
Signahue Date
Oct 03 07 10:38a Brooks Group 651-29z-3010 p.2
1���931�
St. Paul City Cterk
310 City Ha}I
15 W. Kellogg Blvd.
St. Paul, MN 55102
Re: Lowertowa Decorative Lighting Assessment
Madame:
The undersigned objects to the proposed special assessmeut for decorative street
lighring in Lowertown because
i) the assessment exceeds the benefit
ii) the money is not acivaily used for the stated purpose and.
iii) the decorative lights aze being ruined by the graffiti of city signage.
Please also take this as notice of our intent to agpeal any assessment order made by the
City Council.
Property Address:
Railroader Bnilding
235 E 6 Sfreet
St Paul, MN 55101
Parcel Id. Number:
312922.44.0057
Tacpayer Name:
David Bmoks
Prin �� r1 .
` :tr�� �U�' � a ��
Signature Date
Oct 03 07 10:38a Brooks Graup 651-292-3010 p.l
b�-��1�
St. Patil City Clerk
310 City Hall
] 5 W. Kellogg Blvd.
St. Paul, MN 55102
Re: Lowertown Decorstive Lighting Assessment
Madame:
'£he undersigned objects to the proposed special assessment for decorative sEreet
lighting in Lowertown because
i) the assessment exceeds the benefit
u) the money is not actually used for the stated purpose and.
iii) the decorative lights aze being ruined by the gra�ti of ciry signage.
Please also take this as notice of our intent to appeal any assessment order made by the
City Counc9l.
Property Address:
229 East 6' Street
Saint Panl, MN 55�01
Patcel Id. Number:
31.29.22.44.0056
Taxpayer Name:
Davi@ Brooks
Print .'�I
� -
%�
, v �� : f �. - �' y7
Signature Date
70/03/2007 11;22 FAX 657 297 6543
Oct`03 07 11':11e Shane Brooks
JEFF ANDERSON & ASSOC. � 003/003
651-�98-1943 p 3 .
07-%3l�
St. Paut City Cledc
310 City H�11
15 W. Kellagg Bivd.
St Yaul, MN 55102
Re: Lowertown Decorsave I.ightin� Asaessmeat
i :�.T�
The tmdersigned objects to tha proposed special xssesscaent for decorstive street
lightmg in Lowextawn because �
i) tbe assessment e�cceeda't6e b�ncSt
ii) the money is not actuslly ttsed for the srated piapose and
iii) tb.c decotetive lights are being nuned by the gra#fti of city signage.
Ples&e also take t]�is as notice of oiu ss�tent to appeal any assesament ordet made by the
City Coimcil.
��:. ��
�
1 �� � �. . , . �/�
��i���s_� _s� .
��i-- � u'
'Parce! Id.lHumber:
��_�. iC� ���s�
OCT-02-2007 15=25 KELLEY & 0'NEILL MGMT 1 651 222 3652 P.02i02
St. Paul City Clerk
310 City Halt
IS W. Kellogg Blvd.
St. PauL MN 55102
Re: Lowertown Decorative Lighting Assessment
Madame:
6�-�1�1�
1'he unciersigned objects to the proposed special assessment for decocative streef
i�ghting in Lowertown because
i) the assessment exceeds the bencfit
ii) the money is not actually used for the stated purpose and.
iii) the decorativc lights are being zuiued by the �raffiCi of city signage.
Please also take this as notice of our inteiit to appeal any assessment order madc by the
Ciry Council.
Property Address:
4�8. St. Peter St.
St. Paul, MN 55 ] 02
Parce! Td. Number:
Of� d -��- 2 ( ' ° B `((
Taxpayer Name:
Haixun Building ,�
Print
� �
� �,� ���.. �� � s� �°�..�
iv—a- zoo�
TOTAL P.02
OCT 02 2007 8:59RM
MCCULLOUGH COMPRhIES
651-464-4815
p.l
b�-q3�
ss. Pa,� c,ty ci�
s io c��y x�i
15 VJ. Kellogg Blvd.
St. Paul, MN 55102
Re: Lowertofvn Decorative Lighting Assessment
Madame:
The undersigned objects to the proposed special assessment for decorarive street
lighting in Lowertown because
i) the assessment exceeds the benefit
n} the money is noe actually used for the stated pucpose and.
iii) the decorative lights aze being ruined by the graffiti of city signage.
Please also take tivs as notice of our intent to appeal any assessment order made by the
City Council.
Property Addmss:
f';fb��� S
�f3 LwJ Fn �f.
�1-� YYar.1 55iot
�- Parcel Id. Number:
C`Jl- 9'/O,td 5�
Taxpayer Name:
���e.rt D. i'1'1 �� c� lleu A!�
/o �
Signature Date
V� / •
St. Paul City Clerk
310 City Hall
I S W. Kellogg Blvd.
St. Paul, MN 55102
Re: Lowertown Decorative Lighting Assessment
The undersigned objects to the proposed special assessment for decorative street
lighting in Lowertown because -
i) the assessment exceeds the benefit
ii) the money is not actually used for the ststed purpose and.
iii) ttae decorative lights aze being ruined by the graffiti of city signage.
Please also take this as notice of our intent to appeal any assessment order made by the
City Council.
Property Address:
289 5�' Street East
Saint Paul, MN 55101
Parcel Id. Number:
32.29.2233.0044
Taxpayer Piame:
MHCC, LLC
Jason Sheedy, Owner
-__) � �S�-�.�.�,
�-
Print
� v- _
Si ahue Date
Saint Paul City Council
Public Hearing Notice
D�- �13G�
Above Standard Street Lighting
Operation and Maintenance Charges
OWNER OR TAXPAYER
LOWERTOWN
BROOKS
2627 SOUTH
WHITE BEAR
ACQUISITIONS COMPANY C/0 DAVSD
SHORE BLVD
7•ARR MN 55110-3951
PROPERTY TAX DESCRIPTION
R&GLSTERED LAND SURVEY 4171'RACIS A,C & D
FILE # 18321
ASSESSMENT # 0070
PROPERTY ADDItESS
366 JACKSON ST
PARCEL ID
06-28-22-11-0051
THE TIME: WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 3, 2007 AT 5:3� P.iVI.
PUBLIC PLACE: City Councfl Chambers, 3rd Floor City Hall-Court House
HEARING Wri4ten or oral statements by any owner wili be considered by the Council at tlus hearing.
PiTRPOSE To consider approval of the service charges resulting from the excess maintenance costs
for fhe above standazd street lighting in the:
LOWERTOWN AREA FOR 2007.
SERVICE The proposed service chazge for the above property is $360.00. Your finai service chazge
CHARGE will be the amount approved by the City council at the pubiic hearing. The amount
INFORMATION specified on this notice is the amount that is being recommended to the City Council for
approval. Tfie proposed service chazge roll for ttris project is available for review in the
Rea1 Estate Division, 25 W 4� 5treet, 10� Floor — City Hall Annex.
NOTE: THIS IS NOT YOUR BILL. YOU WILL RECEIVE AN INVOICE AFTER 3'HE
HEARING SPECIFYING THE AMOUNT APPROVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL
WTIT� INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO PAY THiS SERVICE CFIARGE.
��
�. /
REVERSE SIDE
NOTIFiCATION DATB 09/14/07
� - ....` ..^:w.`.
Ce�. � . . � � .
_ �
_ ,�
°,.
, __
— ,.
y. 1� ��
� � �
�.
r ` „
�: z, :
,,,� - r
�
�� fi � r.
� � �;
; �.
.' ; ,; � � �!
r'i
n � �
�:,
, ��
� j
�. ' ,
� �,
; �i,
� � ���1
� ; . ,
� ��� \ ,
n � : r r .
��:�
!; ja / �
� ��" [��
� i�i Y ��.:1 f� 6v �.e �� .
y'Y L � � � .
� �� 114_
�� r ' � _�j: ,
� � ,: , �
/ � �': i
(
k
� r b2gti4C.g �y'� , � .
t � �t i
� �i � c��h : � .
a � �
� �; s+��
� ���.v
�:_.;y, , .�.....,._u .v,_. . . ..
.. ... _ . . ��:
� I �'
i*:.. t: �( ,
''" ' n.
:e r y �
G• _ • ;
� � 1.;, `. � �
'l1NIN111��� . .�; .
�` }
:h....�rv m �+'�
. �
. �r' r , _ .. . o �
� � �!_;
�
.�
�
�;- •
�:
� .
�
�
i
■
�
�-,
.. �
,� �.:�;, :ar� .
�'� � � N$ !�
� �#
�'3� � �fu
���,
� ,
0
L�:
k�
r
4-I�AY
� �;�_� t ; �
,, �
F.
pi
� Y �
A�
�
i' p
. � - - �'. i �.
, .. .'. ( ��.
i
y�:..� _
�= � �-:
����� �
, x �
�
-. —
��:;
l�
}� � � ��
" v �'� .
S'
�i ��
q 4��
�.�� �
� �
� ���
i:
8
sc
� �
.' c.
9
�.� 4� � .:e�' .
. � t!' � � ��,- . .
x
� ��
S *K ,n� ,�''"�" {^+
�
� �X � ��p.� .
dtl � � #
� �-a;,�i'. Sr
� _ c � ::
s ,�
F *�
�,�� � � ,
�, � �
a �� �
� � ,.: �. ' ..*, � { ,
� �
�r �
j. � �' -.
�` J k � � 4! R
�� � � , t
� �
��
���
k �
' �
w"' � �
" ��� ._, �,.
��q t.
� � � a l2Fa ?:: ¢: - :
`al , s �'�„r�
� , '
�� � �'� ��
�. - , �
' �',�
%;e ,
� �.:_
7 t,
rA
w��.`� � .
� �; � � �;
- i ��: a � ���
° w v
} ` �'
!" � h �,
�
-` �7�'�,t� y .' ... �' 'x' r�.�', ' �
4 � <
t • �w �Y
*
� . �P
Y �� �
M� 3 �
(��. q y� ' �
'�... . �r+ . N n S. �f'�,w"�
'�i
'T � R � ' r 's` �. '� � �.
�.�� ��x
� 't Y+ # . � .
k � ; � � . r . ..
`f� �y x.:.� . �`
. x: . .� ,� � .
� � n . . �� ��� �� .
�£
��..
� a,, �
� �`�°
iR
� �
}
'� . �
Y�
� �
. � .,
z
.� � -. �;� ,.';
� �
T. 4
��
��
a a �
�. ,� k #
. . .. _. �. ; .. �.i-
:Y _
_ {-.'_
`. �:
^� �
� _f":
�_.
� � �
� . :, � l
� �
i',
�
��
� ,
, ,
,
,
I� �
, ��� r
�- � Y
:��.�r:�.
�
�
"� ...„ �#�+.'„'
�� � �
t��- ,
�
�e
.
, �+^:. _.._. ._,.
e . ... ._... �
�
f
f +
ti : f
a "' �
��
Dapot
�
� �
� � �Ty -
Ov
V' R^'
�._ .�r....�.
b�`
-,�
-' t
��M
,.,�;
6:
a
'
�,�; �< '
��o- bz, .
� x
r ra , .. . . ..� F
� v'�-..- �
. . �:.:�:-r..
��'L:i..l'.
:-..a:nc:
��.
jm! /�a' f
' Y �
. ���. �
`�� ��
�� � � �
-�Yi1Y�
4 ,_. i� r
r i�
+-: �
4 �- �U� �,..'�.
� �.
a
�<'�
. .. t._ � \-�
�-
a ��
'�
��,�
, _ " -'{'J,°ir
� �
�;! � . ...0 `,�j'.
� 4 1 ^'f
l � ��
y \ ^ / � ` '
�A� �"�
1 Y ,
` Y' `� �
--� �`� ?
, j
� ,-�
� �;_ ,,
�::.; >�:: ..
{
l
,, � .
' �
ri� .
i
�_r����. _
i� �
�����
�
I
;� � � � �
� �0 ;1 .
,
'I G '',��
.. �'. 7
� �: Is
i ti
Ir
i
� �...
I � f
vFu
�
t ��� �
t i � �`
� � � � � ��
{+ i�
!� � }
a : s , ,, ; ; . ��,;,�'
� , ,f
� � r ,�
� : � ' � � � � � '"' " , �^''..
> ' �� k °; ��� ' y ' y',�
� � �
j,"��r` _ � E� i r � r�' 1 � , �� t
f.a , � � . �, ,^a � � "' ��,��,a'�
�' `5� .-�� � � , I'�i g �r� ' a � � '� , .e;����� e �
� �!G�7! < � - a . , � P) �. „�, I �r ""` � � . � � ,� � � .
{ �.,� . 1 �'-_ F � � �, r .1 � z s
�� � 4
./ ,i � � f ?., . � � i . . �.u� $
. . �,, ��Y�t .�� 1 � �� I . ' �;, �'' � h
�1�. . . . ��P i I:• � . �
. � V.�� i. . . .
. -� . � . . .�[
:� / ( ' , � }
� . - •
ry� 4 � •
' a . .' .. �:Y - � • t I.�v�`" , .,
. . ° i�k _ - • } ' � ' . �S r ' .
�. "' � � ' . � �� . � , ,
' � .� • '.' � .
N � � .!i . . . .
i
�
� .
.p � : - •E - , r , �a� ; �
:
'
� , � .�. ��,,. - � .� � � _. .��
. . - ___.. _ L "I- it.i � .
,' . ' � ... R � . t x
1 1 I / .
� I .
- . .. .�.... . . M1
. . I . . .. ' `I
6 . . j . . F. _ . 4 , � ... -. ���
� p
a w �
o.. . f ��. � I . 16 ..
� � � ��• � . _ . �j���� ��/� .
f � )
a' 1 , F
'. - 1 . .._ � � � ,
1 � �,
. '�°�,��ac�°a'�....-� .. _ ... . ^ . . . .
�� V - � �_-- �... . .
C j p))jj q � ��
� �f � � � �T �� � � � .
x 1 �f � f J r �f( 1 ri t:� � . � � ' � ?. -
��'! � �'I�l! f' f1�,�1J'�� ,`t1�Ef . . .. �� .� � . ��1 v, `°_ ,a -y �-ew �.,
�r..� . , . : � �';:h�ui �� � s...- . „� �. 1a�������,. x vs'm' " �vy
� .,� , . ' c � � � ,wr.+'ww�+�d � '°t`..
.. . +., r '.e' t � 7 At ti . v - . a-. �' ,. . ti
3 , v
� G Y r . e Y4 �,: � i - s '-
3 1 �" t ,: : 4 . ��� �{��� .� d
y ".- ' ' - d � t �'4� CisY - a � �
A'3 hyi . �. �� �'bl.�YS� n Sffl'' S � �L �
� �^ �.4 'r � ^'p`cy c � c a uar�'7 .v
ti � �'} ,�'7 ' .: +.�<a„} '�``."�� � �'�'r�,t ��. . l E . .
�.' � '" :rv� i }"�' y w �i-
A. �., -; {�: ��. ... � � �' . � � f{r,�` . :
�✓ � ' i . s i "' _ -a.
���� � „w ko
� .. � - .... _ �,.�iz,.�.. '. 7
a�
� ,:�
r �'
`
I 1
' �.; ri
� � `w . �
� � i
/ ,���' I ! I f i �.
s�' ! i
l' <' � r i
�� � � l(•. , � � � � � .
a ;�
l; 1 ' ( r
�� � ' �, � j � . j � ! ( b � '
l i 1 6
�
�J� �/' ' )i ,. ; (i . . , � d �
, �f l
.
� � f ,�'� I `�' ' ' " � � '
, „ �, �. �� ., 4
l� b� �.. % . .
i � � (
1 � �° i I ' y l . .� /
� L �/
� '.i0, � f� � F.
'�� � t. /. f j � ' � .
� ���i ��/ � � �� � .
� �/ .� � �
...� f1� v ; � / � .
��� �,` �
'�� � ` �
, 1 � ; k; �r ;, ;' 1 �� Ar � ,: ` .
� �`�.� �1 . ��'� �,� ` �
`,�� It l� . . ��. _
� � ,., , V�, ;,�
� , �' i�
�� ft , ,
,� � ''' �,
, � � � �
�� j . � �.
�/ � -\ . � Y S
� \ 1 � � �� / � �
� q / �
��'k, f
� ,�: � ; r' �..
G {� ?:�s9
� � %
I 1 %
� � Y
,
�. k Y � , .. ,. :
':� ��
�:� '� a
�� � �
� r
,� r
� i ��
/ `
t _
'� (
� �,�� ,� .
,� . �: i ,;
�,�: .
1
� -:.. �� 1
�� !." ��
� ��
.�1 ��
I —�
i
�
��
; -.t�-
.. •M..
�