210102"I
a
{Heil File No. 210102 —By Frank
ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK 055— p
CITY OF Robert Hanson, theeowner. of P1l COUNCIL
` ,�Ject real estate situated in i FILE NO.
OFFICE OF TFKn 4 Saint 'Pail and described - }
't to C"�' t ' �-�� U per f•
CO CIL ESOLUTIO1 ����n i���; rYlCj}.y,�,� s�
� -�j V_,lltF+3 !:{SPI:t iY"12a
-v, call TTTT BY
COMMISSIONER T .r PUBLISHED
101SOLVED,, upon the pertinent appeal of Robert Ranson, the
owner of the subject real estate situate in the city of Saint Paul
and described as fall.ows:
Subject to present Upper Afton Road and except Wily
18 feet; commencing at intersection of Wily line of
Lot 10 and Oily R/W_ of Old Upper .Afton Road; thence
S. 690 26 3/44 E. 1361 to place of beginning; the
Stly 170 4./ 2/3! to a point 2501 S. of the present
Stly R/W of said Road.; thence E1ly parallel to said
present Stly R/W 931; thence•N1ly to a point on std old
R/W,115" Eily from point of beginning; thence NW11y to
beginning, being part of Lot 10, :Auditor's Subdivision
55, also known as 1594 Upper -Afton Road
2 IT 0,,102
that the provisions of the Zoning Code, Chapters 60 to 64 inclusive,
of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, hereby are determined and varied
to permit the construction ,and maintenance of .a 2 -car private
garage on said premises with .a building line setback�s7istant 3_5
feet from and parallel to the line of Upper Afton Road, upon which
said real restate abuts, and accordingly said permit hereby is granted.
NOV 2 7 1962
COUNCILMEN Adopted by the Council 19—
Yeas Dalglish Nays NOV 2 7 1962
Holland 4-Approved 19—
Loss 6 1
- Mortinsan— In Favor
( l
Peterson Mayor
Against
Rosen
Mr. President, Vavoulis
1OD1 8-82
OFFICE `O'F CITY CLERK
BUR -EAU OF RECORDS
386 City Hall and Court House
St. Paul 2, Minnesota
Mr. Donald L. Lais
Corporation Counsel
Building
Dear Sir:
4" 'j 0
MRS. AGNES H. O'CONNELL
City Clerk
HAROLD J. RIORDAN
Council Recorder
November 231 1962
N OV % 6 1962
CORPORN110'N
The City Council requested that you prepare a resolution granting the
attached appeal of Robert Hanson for permit to construct a two -car
garage at a setback of 35 ft. from Upper Afton Road on property
located on the south side of Upper Afton Road, east of East Dora Court,
as more fully described in the attached letter of the Zoning Board.
Very truly yours
21
City Clerk
CITY OF SAINT PAUL - MINNESOTA 8
..........................
><::r:RD OF ZONING, CITY OF SAINT PAUL
"' •:f.XLRP�.S I.OJ.iS 151- 451 -153 ISIS CITY HALL AND COURT HOUSE SAINT PAUL ],MINNESOTA
November 21, 1962
Mrs. Agnes H. O'Connell
City Clerk
Building
Dear Madam:
This is in the matter of the appeal of Robert Hanson to construct a
two -car garage at a setback of 35 feet from Upper Afton Road on pro-
perty located on the south side of Upper Afton Road, east of East Dora
Court which is described as subject to present Upper Afton Road and ex-
cept Nally 18 feet; commencing at intersection of Wly bne of Lot 10 and
S'ly R/W of Old Upper Afton Road; tbenee S. 690 26 3/4' E. 136' to place
of beginning; the S'ly 170 44 2/3' to a point 250' S. of the present S'ly
R/W of said Road; thence E'ly parallel to said present S'ly R/W 93';
thence N'ly to a point on old R/W 115' E'ly from point of beginning;
thence NW'ly to beginning, being part of Lot 10, Auditor's Sub. 55, also
known as 1594 Upper Afton Road. The property is zoned "A" residence.
The site is presently developed with a single - family residence which
was constructed in 1957, and it is proposed to construct a two -car garage
on the site at a setback of 35 feet from Upper Afton Road. The property
has a frontage of approximately 97 feet on Upper Afton Road and extends
to a depth of 250 feet, resulting in an area of approximately 21,250 square
feet. The existing residence is set back 50 feet, which is the normal set-
back for this property. Because of the topography of the site, the appli-
cant is requesting a setback of 35 feet for the proposed garage, Therefore,
it-is necessary to secure Council authorization for the relaxation of the
required setback.
Field investigation discloses that the area uses are single - family resi-
dences and that the lots vary considerably in depth. It does not appear
that the relaxation as requested would have a detrimental effect on any
other property. The applicant has secured a letter of acquiescence from
his neighbor to the east who would be affected by the setback.
In consideration of the above factors, the Board of Zoning recommends
the granting of the appeal to construct a two -car garage at a setback
of 35 feet fxoil Upper Afton Road on the above described property.
Sincerely, r
HCW:FGI
Encl.
Z. F. 5073
/.(-C .'WJ-6.4
H.C. Wieland, Secretary
Board of Zoning
Honorable Commissioners
City of St. Paul
Sirs:
1594 Upper Afton Road
St. Paul 69 Minnesota
otb s 162
Goer , 9
1�>16Z
I have been advised by Mr. Schroeder, city architect, to write to
you requesting a waiver of city code in observing certain property lines
when building a garage.
I am contemplating building a double garage on my property at 1594
Upper Afton Road. When our home was built there in 1957 it was set back
50 feet from the street line-and faces sideways on a 97 X•250 foot lot.
There is a private driveway bordering our lot on the west klong side)
which goes back to a house on the cliff behind our property which over-
looks Mississippi river and Highway 61. Between that driveway and East
Dora Court to the west are two houses which are only set back 35 feet
from Upper Afton Road. To the east of our property is a house set back
somewhat farther than ours on -a much larger lot. There is no alley at
the rear of any of these lots nor arq between the whole stretch of
Upper Afton Road from E. Dora Court to White Bear Avenue about half a
mile or more to the east.
I would appreciate the council's permission to construct a garage
set in a line with the houses to the west of ours, such a line now
having been established by all the houses between ours and Highway 61,
a distance of about three blocks, and all being the required 35 feet
from Upper Afton Road. I would not be establishing a precedent because
several doors to the east of us is a much newer home, set at the rear
of a deeper lot than ours, and for which the garage was built about
100 feet in front of the house towards Upper Afton Road.
_I will_very.much appreciate your attention and an early reply, to
this matter.
Yours truly,
Robert S. Hanson
five,
CITY OF SAINT PAUL
MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
113 Court House, Zone 2
CApital 4 -4612
November 9, 1962
City Clerk
386 City Hall
St. Paul 2, Minnesota
You are hereby notified that the Council of the City of St. Paul will
consider the matter of appeal of Robert S. Hanson, under Chapter 60,
Legislative Code, for permission to construct a two car garage 35 feet
back from Upper Afton Road on the following described property.
Subjent to present Upper Afton Road and except northwesterly 18 feet,
cojmne sing at intersection of westerly line of lot 10 and southerly
ri.gh t-- of -ivay of Old Upper Afton Road, thence south 69 degrees 26 3/4
minutes east 136 feet to place of beginning; thence southerly 17 degrees
4-4 2/3 mini:.tes to a point 250 feet south of the 'present southerly
right- ?f-ri•e.y of said road.; thence easterly parallel to said present
southerlyy rig:,.t -of way 93 feet; thence northerly to a point on said
old 11" feet easterly from point of beginning; thence
northwesterly to beginning, being part of Lot 10, Auditor's Sub. #55
also lniown as 1594 Upper Afton Road., and that a public hearing wil3,
be held is t're Council Chambers of the Court House and City Hall
Building in the City of 5t. Paul, at 10:00 o'clock A.M. on
November 23, 1962.
JAI&S J. DALOLISH
Commissioner of Finance
File 15862,
The City Charter requires this Notice be sent from the Department of Finance.
e2uou!j jo 4uauwDdea oq; woij 4uas ag aai;ON siq; saam as japop l:o aql
•a3.uu>;� 10 o ?sstuiu .6�8St3 a
--E96T cZ JegmGAoH uo 'ITV 313013,0
00: Oi_ Ile `Inled^; -4S jo SITOMqj., ui 3u?pl?ng_ I1gH':k3 10 pule asnog janoO
ai13 jo saaquivgD I13unoo aq j u?_ploq aq Illm-BuLZleail 3?lgnd v gvgj Pule
' sgeM4S 9doH Ptre uoeag jo .zeu.ao3 gsgngqnos to
P94VOOT saToTclab 06 aoa ToT 2u-[31aed jaea,, s—jjo aq,eAT -id
'e 9'4e redo Pte - TTE'�suE oq gTm,zed .zoi 'seTve aogoyl aadme
•y•g•Q lout oou-mq Jo uot4,eoTTdde jo a914leuz aqj aap?sgoa
it ?A Ind 'IS jo A3 ?0 au3 3o I ?3uno0 atI4 jleu4 pa? jou Agaaalq axle noX
Z96T `6 aagmeAOR ' uu ?X `Z In�.d
aoxv is do IIHISOISSINNO0 SHJ, aO aDI3dO