The URL can be used to link to this page

07-560Return copy to: (BJE) PW/Technical Services — Real Estate 1000 City Hall Annex 1' 7 r1- Bv: ' � Director RESOLUTION CITY OF SAINT PAUL, MINNESOTA Presented By 3040252 /� 2 WIIEREAS, Larpenteur Estates Aparnnents, LLC ("Petitioner") is seeking to vacate a portion of Huron 3 Street extending 180 feet south of Larpenteur Avenue (see attached E�ibit A) to facilitate a proposed 4 development on Petitioner's property abutting Huron Street to the east; and 5 6 WHEREAS, in accordance with the City of Saint Paul's ordinance for vacating city streets, (Leg Code, Sec. 7 130.02 (2)), the Petitioner has attempted to secure the support of a majority of abutting property owners for 8 the vacation; and lo WIIEREAS, the owner of the property abutting Huron Street to the west, whose support is necessary to 11 constitute a majority, will not agree to support the vacation; and 12 13 WHEREAS, the Petitioner believes that the vacation would not adversely impact the neighboring owner's 14 access to or use of }us property; and 15 16 WHEREAS, pursuant to Leg. Code, Sea 130.02 (3), the Petitioner believes that a hardship therefore exists 17 and requests that the Saint Paul City Council waive the "majority" requirement; now, therefore be it 18 19 RESOLVED, that the Mayor and Council of the City of Saint Paul do hereby declare that a hardship exists 20 with respect to the proposed petition to vacate said portion of Huron Street, and that the requirement to 21 obtain support from a majority of abutting property owners is hereby waived. 22 23 24 25 2 6 Requested by the Department of: Adopted by Council: Date (]/e/�� 7, c�6D7 Adoption Ce by Co Secretary By: ///ii�i�/�,v/�Sdr� Approved by May . Date � .�6 By: `�'1� � % Form � Councii File # Green Sheet # by City for Submission to Council e ,/ G:�Iteal Estate\Vacations�2007\07-2007 — Hurou St (a) Lazpentew (FriscL)\072007.FIrdshpRes.doc 2� �� s� � Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet Green Sheet � DepartrnenVofficekouncil: Date Initiated: Pw -�li�wo� �-�Y-07 Green Sheet NO: 3040252 Conqct Person & Phone: Bruce Ergelbrekt 266-8854 Must Be on Doc. Type: RESOLUTION E-Documerrt Required: Y DocumentContact: BruceEngelbrek[ Contad Phone: 266-8854 Total # of SignaW re Pages _(Clip All Locations for Signature) Approval of resolution declaring a"hardsLip" to sarisfy perition requirements for a proposed vacation of Huron Street south of Lazpenteur Avenue. iaauons: npprove (a) or R Planning Commission CIB Commiflee Civil Service Commission Initiating Problem, Issues, Opportunity (Who, What, When, Where, Why): Gerald Frisch, of Larpenteur Estates Apartments, LLC, would like to vacate a portion of Huron Street extending approximately 180 feet south of Lazpenteur Avenue to provide an ingress/egress driveway for a proposed pazldpg shucture lils property at 1260 Lazpenteur Avenue West. Mr. Frisch is requesting that the City Council grant a hazdship parsuant to Leg. Code Sec. 130.02 (2) to effectively waive the requirement dtat a majority of proper[y owners abutting a right-of-way to be vacated support the vacarion perition. There are two property owneis abutting this secrion of unimproved Huron Street — Mr. Frisch on the east and another owner on the west. The other owner does not support the vacation. Mx. Frisch believes that the vacarion will not hazm the other property owner's property. ,��„�.. ,�� Advantages If Approved: � u.v�� r �v The vacation petition wiil be allowed to proceed. � U N 1' 4 Z�O7 Disadvantages IfApproved: .. ... . ....� The vacarion petifion will be processed without the support of the property owner abutting the west side of the portion of Huron Sfreet to be vacated. � ueoamnenc selrciorerson minawate 0 blic Works Bruce Eo e@re1R 0 D7 Assign 1 bGc Works Tec6 Srvcs M _ f ��0� Number 2 ubGcWorks De artmentD'uector For Routing 3 ' Attorne Jad Haoson a� Ofder 4 a or's Office Ma or/Assistant 5 ouncil 6 ' Clerk Cti Clerk 1. Has this persoNfirtn ever worked under a wntract for Nis deparlment? Yes No 2. Has this person/firm ever been a ciry employee? Yes No 3. Does this persoNfirm possess a skill not nortnaliy possessed by any current city employee? Yes No Explain all yes answers on separate sheet and attach to green sheet Disadvanqges If NM Approved: The vacafion petition will not be allowed to proceed and the petitioner will not be able to construct an access driveway to a proposed pazldng shvcture on his property. • Trensaction: $ Funding Source: CostlReveniie Budgeted:" ' � i4c � ":s :a : - ?�� , :E � A �_ ,�.. �� '� ' .1 � ,:,._� ��, Fi nancial Information: (Explain) JUN 1 5 2007 .��i v:; 20�7 ��`�'�' ,�� i� � �F May 30, 2007 129 PM Page 1 ��-.S� area �z < _ 3;� E �� _� '=a�. � ° �ras�zsi� °- �esxtc � o (�) � S �� a a 0 r�' � v ac SCipIMERThis map is neither a legally rc�corded rrtap nor a survey and is not irttended L used as one. This map is a comptlation of records, infarmation and data located in various �, wutrty, state and federal offices and other sources regarding the area shown, and is to used forreference ouroasFS onlv. httn:lfmans.rnetro-inet.us/ItamsevCoGISravascrinticarPrintMan.htm �x�►i�i� � i _ r�,nIctg�itles Raad Gentertines {Co�ntY? �t c.«,nty t�� Statc iiRy �! �5 r,l` Paur�Yt Edge w� � st�vct;,� - t�u � P�cd Paiygans �g Ltrres �d L�d j./ L�d 17e5 �,�` Platted Lnt tln�s Parct� hlap l�s Prl_m�y t�m' F9ghway Sdaldds St�eet N�e L.�ts URCES:Ramsey County (A 200�, The lawrence Gr� 5/2I/2047 ��-�� PETITION fi0 VACATE CITY INTEREST I, the undersigned constituting a majority of the owners (or their iegally designated representatives) of the ahutting properties, do hereby petition the Council of the City of Saint Paul to vacate its interests in the property legally described as fallows: That part of Huron Street between the south right-of-way line of Larpenteur Avenue and a line 20.00 feet south of and parallel to the easterly extension of the north line of Lot 5, Block 3, Che2sea Heights. I request this vacation for the following reasons: Approximately su� (6) years ago as part of a settlement of a conflict between City of St. Paul, Lazo Inc., owners of Patrick's Lounge (on-sale liquor establishment on Lots 1 through 6} and adjoining neighbors, Yhe St. Paul City Council authorized the barricade of portion of Huron Street adjacent to Lots 1 through 6 to restrict access by bar patrons on the residential properties south of Lot 6. As a result, said restricted portion of Huron Street adjacent to said Lots 1 through 6 is unavailable for use by the public as a North - South street. Accordingly, Pafirick's Lounge has had the sole use and enjoyment of a public street to the exclusion of neighbors and the publia Currently Public Works Department of the City of St. Paul has and is installing sewer and other public utilities in Huron Street. At the present time it appears reasonabie and appropriate to vacate said portion of Huron Street, which is for all intents and purposes no longer used as a pubtic street. I,arpenteur Estates Apaztments, LLC is the owner of adjoining land to the East of said portion of Huron Street proposed to be vacated and proposes to develop a parking ramp on the East side of said portion of Huron Street. No construction is proposed on that portion of Huron Street to be vacated. Laro, Inc. has refused to join in this Petition to vacate city interest. f.arpenteur Estates Apartrnents, LLC believes that its request to vacate said portion of Huron Street constitutes a hardship and does hereby request that the City Council waive the requirement for signatures of a majority of owners, pursuant to Secdon i30.02(3) o£ the St. Paul i.egislative Code. � -1- Certificate of Title Certificate Number: �OQ732 Document Number. 15Q3926 Book: 374 Page: i20 Dist. Court No.: 8384 Book: 499 Page: 80 Dist Court No.: 10522 � , Transfer From Certificate Numbers334451 334452 Originaliy registered the 28th day of September, 1955. Also originaily registered the 26th day of July, 1967. State of Minnesota County of Ramsey ss. This Is to certliy that REGISTRATION Larpenteur Esfates Apartments LLC, 2350 West 7th Street, City of Saint Paul, County of Ramsey, State ot Minnesata is now the owner ot an esiate in See simpte -_.. - In the following described land situated in ihe Parcel 1. `_` ,°=" The West 273 feet of the East 293 feet of LoE E feet oP said West 273 feet, subject to��art the(e � ;: - Parcel2. ,.-.r e'�_,; �ot A, 8lock 2, Chelsea Heights, e�cept the�2i Parcel 3. `" The W sst 71 feei oP the East 364 f�et of Lnt�t e Parcel 4. ' -�-� The West 50 feet of the East 70 feeE ttf the�N6n Subject to an easement of Ramsey G�oUnty for s Subject to a Reservation by the State at.�ilirU��s �:' _ . - � F.. � _ _ a • ��h a . '_= �. 3hicPc2,'Ghelsea Heig�stR��epttfie East 50 feet of fhe North 150 `� ,� ".. � �- ; N :,- ��_: �. _ - �.,,c: �:j' .. - . �'. L_ 2, Chefsea HeigY _=�:,, � e <` t` Subjecf to me interests shown bythe fal[owing memurialsagct'fQ �e to�lowing rights or ehc7i inbrapees set forth In Minnesota statutes chapter 5�8, namely: � <', - �`�-=�;' _-_ _ _ - - - �`� r� 1. Liens, claims, or rights arising under the laws or tfie Consfitution 7taHe�Unit'ed Sfiates;,i*itiich the statutes of fbis state cannot reqWre to appear of record; ' = :; f ; • ; ' : : r, :.': '� i �, '' � 2. Any real property fax or special assessment for which a sale of the'lari'dfi�s not been had at the tlate of the certificate of title; 3. Any lease for a period not exceetling three years, when there is actual occupation of the premises under the lease; 4. AI! righis in public highways upon the land; 5. Such right of appeal or rlght to appear and contestthe appltcation as is ailowed by law; B. The rigfits of any person in possessian under tleed or conVact for deed from the owner of the certificate of title; 7. Any outstanding meehanics lien rights which may exist untler secfions 574.07 to 514.17. MEMORlALS Page 1 of 2 Dxumenf I pocument I DateofRegistration I Number � Type Month Day, YearTime pmount (S) 60692 qgreement � Dec 24,5974 71:00 AM I � 615'11 License Sep18,797510:t0AM 91849 Petition Mar 28,t990 0300 AM I 918491 Mortgage, Sec. Mar 28,1990 09:0� AM 6,025,000.00 Agmtnt 8� Fix. Fn. Stmt. 91849 Assignment of Mar 28,1990 0&00 AM --- Leases and Rents 9184 UCC Mar28,199609:06AM I 1Q797 UCCContinuffiion Jan96,�99550:04AM 1503 Mortgage, Sec. Oct 23,7998 OA:30 PM 5,500,000.00 Agrmnt & Assgn. of Leases & Rents 150392 Asslgnmentaf Oct23,199804:36PM 5,500,000.00 Leases and ftents 152503 Satisfaction of Feb 28,1999 08:00 AM Mort a e 1568681 Assignment of Aug 04,199903:00 PM ,�,.� Assignment of "- _ . - Rents -+ < - 158648 Assignmentof Dec23J99911:06AMF `�,--'" _ - _--- Assignment of - i'' �'�^�� Leases and Rerrts - �� „- �-" _ " � � �':v . _ 158648 Assignmentof I Dec23,1999ll:Qff_AMR-=' `.-� .��=: Assignmentof :`' � �u%"• �„ - i : ��s )irectiveof Oct31,2003LlS:OOAM.° a`" ;° .,� Examiner y _ ��`--- ,` i��" Y J - �.•maj — ' «, �;.� �:,.._ . _.�,,,.,�:: _ » 4 ri>ti''�'';ua.,�+:.;:.: /_ - .. "� _ -".'.��'ixvi�;�=: �` '_ _ m'z _ -.;; j "_ ° c -. _ ._ .. - .'';s..,. ' ro _ 1913431 Mechanics Lien Apr 22,2005 08:00 AM� 7 945264 Mortgage, Assn. �ec 23,2005 04:00 PM of ReMS, Sec. & Fix. Fin. A rmnt. 195696 Satisfaction of Mar 312006 OA:00 PM Running in Favar of York Life Insurance Company. See Document Covers Parcels 1, id 3. ect to License for use of reat estate for benefii of Lot 16, 61ock 2, sea He'qMS AddHionSee Document. Covers ParceEs "I 2 and 3. ity of Ramsey vs. Oscar Gottfried, effiI, Condemnation Case No. i57 COV6IS p21t ot a6DVE P�Opetiy. AISO COV@B ONlef plopOdV eran Brotherhood, a Minnesota corporation eran Brotherhood, a Minnesota corporation. Assigns Leases and 5. eran Bratherhood. U.C.C. no. 9Q-000959 nds time of ll.C.C. document no. 81$493 Reak Estate Investrnents Inc., 12&5 Avenue of the Amencas, Cdy o � York, Sta3e of New York document no(s). 91849'I.O, 918492.0 ies Inc. .0 , as Tri 0 r�.�.�� 9tifls"Ine., a Mirinesota corporation. Claims date of last �qwaSOctobB7Sth 2000. ;"' fk.v�ns of Mi�r;lesota Statutes, Section 508.71 you ie '�}fi�how by memorial on the above or successor ��'`�'gfriCtions agaanst constructiort of strucYUres, walls, �-r¢adaaysoreateii�tiy the instrument filed as Doc. No. �tesi-�y�.k r�cital irrlMe body of said certificate does not �escribedfn said;cert'rficate pursuanf to: MS. Sect. should „r�arry forward ihe memoriai of Doc. No. 527890 ive. 'TE�e memQFitij of Doc. No. 527890 should read: ine�ffior rightaEway over that part of ifie South 20 feet of ; 6Nelsea Hei`yFits running from the East fine of Huran iRe�oded E tine of Lot 37, Bbck 2, Chelsea Heights, far �"s.'37 #tirbuph 36, Block 2 Chelsea Heiphts. M"echapi5al, Ina Claims date of last item of contribution of Teras �Satisfies document no(s). 1503927.0 I � 1N WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto subscribed my name and affixed the seal of my office this 23rd day of October, 1998. Dorothy McGlung Registrar of Titles, In and for the County of Ramsey and SWte of Minnesota. Certificate Number: 500732 Page 2 of 2 Certi�cate of Title Certificate Number:385Q41 DocumenfNumber. 1i484rv4 Transfer From Cerfificafe fJumber: 351797 Originalty registered the 9th day oi May, 19t6. Sook: 56 Page: 255 Dist. Court No.: t964 State of Minnesota t REGISTRATION County of Ramsey f s.s. This Is to certity that Laro, lnc., a Minnesota corporafion, 1318 West Larpenter Avenue, City of Saint Paul, County of Ramsey, State of Minnesota is now the owner of an estate in fee simple in the followirtg tlescfibetl land situated in the Countyof Ramseyana'S'tate'W-Nlinjlg�qta,,to wit Lots 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6, Block 3, Chelsea Heig�,fs:= '..�--' = a��.._= �-" '''� ,�-`, < _-� a ;��w -� Subject to restrictions contained in dacume�lt`np. �>' a� 4> , _ . `" � r .., ,.,' .... ,. °, j , > .�,,, Subjec[ W the interests shown by fhe following me�5nria{sa�i��_p#�1'p.'-t6UGwfrrg`[gh�s`�[`�ieuay�nce$ set forth in Minnesota statutes chapter 508, namely: .:.'- ° :,` ;,;_ �,;_:'E;,,�} ; '",�. �. Liens, daims, or rights aristng under the laws or the CtSn;i)it�etian of the United Slate3;�Yihic'�j the sFat'vtes ot this state canrwt require to appear of record� : :: ; � ; `°:', ;.'a�'°�. s;,:� -' = :�_. 2. Anyreal properEyta�c or special a5sessment for �h��as�'3�f f�ie'land has not,beEpF��ke date`;oE,the certificate of title; 3. My lease for a period not exceeding #hree years; wheirtt�er�i�acCUa�oectYp�,i�Y�l�,,.��€es�3es uni3�� the I�se; i .._r-_..._..,_ w , 4. Atl rights 1n public highways upon the I;nitl; -' ��"- ° 2; `�, =;;�;+=.,.,,=.:,�a�r.�r ;; _= 5. Such right of appeal or right to appear �tp cont�st the appNCtiqc�n;as is allo�ed 4j��Wr<�; ,,�,,, ;; ;�-: 6. The righ3s of any perso� in possession pr�der deed orlantcac� for�deecftfqtn Fhe 4w,iY6�f-_atl,�te certif(c�Y6 of titie; , 7. My outstantling mechanics Ifen rights which may g�:'uYe'I��ec�n�.;�ug�fxiSo s�l�d.Y7: : r Document Document Date of Registrat Number Type Month Day, Yeak.l 38883 FinalCertif�cate Apr01,79580220 Easement � IYOv Easement Nov'16,195909:OOAM Morigage Feb 08,1972 � 1:30 AM 1�4845 Mortgage,Assn. Mar64,499710:Q0 of Rerrts, Sec. & Ffx Fln. A rmnt. 316490 Directiveof Sept9,199701:00 Examiner 75998 Directiveot May01,200072:06 Eraminer PM � a.• =a �� nt � � �. '_,,� �,�iuiining in Favor of :�_ =: , �bor7e_biopertv. ��?ds; cuts and fills in ifie gradirtg of alley adjoining opes, cuts and fills in tBa grading of streaf adjoinin��. ty of Ramsey vs_ Oscar Gottfried, etal, emnaGon Case No. 286657 rs Lot 7 of above properry. covers other propertv. nuniry National Bank, a Un4ted States corporation mberance created by the instrument filed as document no. 441348 not affect the tand �fescribed in saitl certYcate and you are aiso :ed to delete from future certificates of title for said land both ihe ance to said encumbrance and the memorial of this directive. mnbrances created by QocumeM no. 566887 are no longer :ive. Qelete reference to said tlocument and this direcfive on future cates of title. ids time of payment of mortgage document no. 1 t48455. Page 1 of 2 IN W1TfVESS WFfEREOF, i have hereunto subscribed my nams and affixed the seal of my office #his 4th day of March, 1997. Registrar of Fitles, In and for the County of Ramsey and State of Minnesota. '*' _--�,:_,��=� � t:`�_' ;�, - - 'a� �..5� ` v �� ° - ° � a �'Y - - .v <�r,, ��-_� _ - _••�_ ..k3�5. ?a'..k+3 �•v _ _ - . - � _ _ _ }� = - M - _ _ �_"-" . i "" � tt . - �:.� . ��l�Y� �_ '` ,-; � �if; --v --_$s.Q'+_�''��a�-r.`,�is��-` . y "�ia:� :i :vatY,�. ' _r�nh'� F :_-� __ _ .�.r:.it - ' _ :_:c:'�. _ ' `�._'� �� --_—�'_-.' ' _ _ ' '.`i - --�_5�:�' 's_=5 �,-`;� _�x �- 'i:a --- _ '� ':y'_ `^^.. o _ ' - >"x'_ _ o. n ' _ ",i'� _ �a -,r`` ' _ ' ' ' =" y _ _ _ <.'�,�;y .... . _ , _ _ _ x j' .. ,.. __ ., v � __ .�r: ,�V' �� _ ' - _:.:., 'F' .�:`�,� ° ` w k� '�'" � : y, 3 .r�,n:. ' � � �' �, �, � _ '� ' �'±r4' ' ,.;a.R��E ' " ' .� ' • - n�'.�a.= .... _ _ Certificate Number: 38504t Page 2 of 2