Loading...
212242,A r Orl$inal to-City Clerk `r PRESENTED BY F a W RDINANCE File No. 212242— Ordinance No COUNCIL FILE NO. By Frank L. Loss - 1�u dinance amending the Zoi i,,..hapters 88 to 64, inclusive ORDINANCE NO. 21.2242, .,, •4;.74 ^: �', ,... '. t;..i9J'RG7l!,� V.' ^• m9J. if_ _- Dmjaf ,Cf ham' .+ v }l7 .sift -01d AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING CODE, CHAPTERS 60`TO 649 INCLUSIVE, OF THE SAINT PAUL LEGISLA- T IVE CODE, AS AMENDED, PERTAINING TO USE DISTRICTS, HEIGHT DISTRICTS AND REZONING OF CERTAIN PROPER- TIES IN THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL. THIS IS-AN EMER- GENCY ORDINANCE RENDERED NECESSARY FOR THE PRESER- VATION OF THE PUBLIC PEACE, HEALTH AND SAFETY. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAINT PAUL DOES ORDAIN: SECTION 1 That paragraph (i) of Section 64.03 of the Zoning Code, Chapter 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code, hereby is amended so that the same shall read as follows: Vary any provision of the Zoning Code in harmony with its general purpose and intent, where there are practical difficulties or peculiar hard- ships in the way of carrying out the strict letter of the provisions of this ordinance, so that the public health, safety, and general welfare may be secured and substantial justice done, provided that a change in the boundary of any district except as permitted in this section shall-not be construed as a modification permitted by this section." SECTION 2 This ordinance is hereby declared to be an emer- gency ordinance rendered necessary for the preservation of the public peace, h alth and safety. i SECTION 3 This ordinance shall take effect and be in force upon its passage, approval and publication. ` MAY 31963 Yeas Councilmen Nays Passed by the Council Dalglish Holland Loss Tn Favor Mortinson Peterson Q Against Rosen Mr. President (Vavoulis) Approved MAY 3 1953 • Attest: ; /n City Clerk Mayor 1114 8-82 22 SEYMOUR & O'CONNOR ATTORNEYS AT LAW E-1514 FIRST NATIONAL BANK BUILDING VINCENT L.07CONNOR SAINT PAUL (I) MCNEILV.SEYMOUR MCNEILV.SF-YMOUR,JR. April, 223 1-90 Xto toulb P.—She Mhto, Dirabtor.of Lw 'Office of the-'GOTPOratim Colmsel. Court. 11PUSO., Saint Paul 2j Wniiesota Mr. Harold Riordan Council Roeorder Office of tho city .Clerk court 90asia, Saint Paul �j Minndsota Subject 0 Proposed ()rdin Da. i.atlng the 14bight iiiaits from Paragraph (i) of 500tio, 64.0) e th6.zonum codoe, MOar, Lou and Harold: I am enclosing, to vach of you. a dopy of ray opinton of April, 22.0, 1963 to Mr. Richard , Oxpdway to record. hiii position., with toEipe# to tl* InvaUdity of the proposed ordlnona6* car Mr Richiird otdv� f Wry ttuir I I No, TO Seymour i , '•. _ ;y.� .r w Off, • •..Y' 'fir ':E 'rF "' �� Y '- COPY _ , _ ,1- ,wT - t -. _- i'•~. , i . ' ' - x'i •• ` }v �L.•`s •• - • ., 4• � •'. - �.,'" {, S -- � -_ ty -,t ri` `, r`ts��r. y r h 1 . ? SEYMOUR, & O'CONNOR' 'n' r' ' - ,. - - r•:y ' }. ' '',> •ATTORNEYS AY =LAW ' •'. . y'-, r r� 'y • - , • p' -'. + i �. _ _ - ''y •. E- 1.511, FIRST NATIONAL BANK BUILDING . - VINCENT L- O'CONNOR V. SEYMOUR' '. -9° f - , , , _ : ♦� i, i, • { SAINT PAUL w MCNEL . r "'• V. SEYMOUR; JR.. :i t ` - ,3 -,mot• ._ ►. '.L_ - - _ }• -t - _ . tom• .} ✓ -' •b' }, ,% ' -' 1 , . a ': - •, . •. r -2t �' Cc - - 1 1 S *- C ~T Dpi �.. S {•• \`;.w • ,t' 1 �.''}r .. "i,4 'ti r t i . - , i. 'S SZ ,i ,' - . f' ! -' .h ' n- • •',t., wtt'. H �•' iL1+sLI1si y. •;`. +`+� ' 4_ , s, . �` - ; y ..4 q;! _ •c• : -- i'. ;r.j. y . Firth nd sroid"_ jA .' _ r T`• r ,�••� at~ .,��3.Q U_S .l �Mit 1YOb 'F, _ wt_�t' ''�'r",r 't`t�. C• "•_,r t` ° , y' -3 • j''f ;� •Cat' e Or .fir_,: • ,J4 .ub�e�t ; Appiidati} ;..iidh,R�x..fo,I'ezt - • s , .. ,r�•, _� ,�` ''fbr'r�r�{e�i_�LL��o� �jk, � '�•�iJ�,ri�tySr-0-zoning u�l,c�l3.n�-; ,. `,.- . •�.� � ''4 :� •" _ - - . '' >•, „? }V:'j'. •l5+.- 'rte • t�illg t11V �tl �'h�l'•ki +r2'•a.1!►i7 :3ACS • - -w, :a t_ r' rt'e•' .. Y,• •ry ►+' ' -'• _d6ft Al $01nii'fAls- 'j•-k"- ,.. , �- 'J, a• ,,+_• -`L . •t' >h - ! Deary q�,rYY r ���r��,`, s ! - pr• t y'11' ,Y a,a � ,,? } r I a_. y •*: .•A'' " , _.y{ „' n� 13��ayy1, iecei�Y6C, -tp` A� -1,��r ����y±��!� 6)-*_. a� •.tld�i�'}(9��+Zy'•y�V/�f }OID, �iilot70i' � .��i2�,�r..G`��}.-91:A�1�jQ.�O� n; . _ A t ' , 'Ing 11Y3 A4LJ,�t%- it mY .J. -Ap i1,y 7 ? they City rlVYii y.C� vill''donddei ,46� O 'y, ti �nG�t ` -ime, -dig ` pit a rip G `of_ 'S�nt ri . 64,03 _ the:: zo�,i Code . a ' iQre e t + ht t uri . Y th®ipom' cluti�g h._. ei $W' Sri . he ' h g d -, the, Coder - iii 3' u ge rv#�ch t�h p i QSe ai at ($�r 0 al e, *i6j%d ',t�.k ” r oat ftri�md 'r2fia b�is e. oS.tte'ru, T,t�u3e ' ' SheaYr ti �ztox° "off + hie `;obbiUnp f �'mrch 293 - '1963, �.c� :J�pxf:� ��� �.9��� ter -tom �3�t3r �at�icil be$ • t p ai.a1 'e ;t °''pui�pi�r d to'.h e;tsee o.orarited the rx-t�_ Cr unai!. under • . - - Re's ©Int3 any`, C' Fc',2�; e}?pris'd F_ebrut6�ryt 1g6 ,:er ntriiuthorieed- and , c _ f • _ -- 1f3Vi��.�s -r .'-, �F' st' 3` .-'- r`J ,. � -.,'r• _i# � + _. •,F - •�"t tt •. - ,er •, rt. - ' �aq�' tih iii? �aptnd3 Of ''x>�; sheer- th@ Eiti31 C,.dunCsi�' �l�iw y i=fiv er "..' F ier tt redap 'the .p Pvaed. ndment .from �� P jvi�iq' oP`�i.�.A* ' Y i�fr2, . ' esnpa�aaririg r 'C3:ty. of the fist ss �ti� iii hear #u3�gpUd u .. i p 3tieny' - ` 14tifi tthei :lw&U0h " eSze :ode' 4h hei ht -,pf buildin ■ to i•' - 4 - 2` ••t V I. Si, w .` t ,• ,• ♦ .• ir4 `� ,• -•_ - `e -`1., i - ' �' '. 4 i •. D • ` -- : _ ' thte' reg;aticf� ,` ' ,a1te fibdd ho v6t to bi ' fide. °err of the � a ± ' . ',;j ' s ` 't � A' t a 't' be F t Of CE! _b �r]!f3 f! clerk '$.'iT thin ObQ+ '' • t' ` "` ' LSbt! Of :Oi+1YlAb'8 b HEb rye. :BAYei? d *e ; , 8 e t of , Z'a1L est+!!'�}!P: s uati@ t � fA4ki..O f, re -est 7 77 ' 11 r abort , 6mphW"i i$ up Aied bq' a the- stipu�.at9.on °�. OorMbnVr i*fertpd, -to ai the "Ganeer�t a .iiu fie ,did; :dfexegru�3�d by= tiia;1�3.ty`, - - > ' qunei ix�' thie Oki* uhieh, o .iui t2 ' 'c$e#, uw mdkei &,b nrid ti ► •p s �ederi r ' tb' the adoptiuri o _ il#I�i etion 'off ?the an�.t�g Codas -Tier ,pr - ted nc h ..{{ �,]�y��}e�}� �,.j .�L,6 �y "�q �,,,,p'�A i to �Zo ih yb t,,j �y� 59' j !, [' a• ` 4_' is L,2Of,1 -!V+Va 1•.i. Ulic�' y � w�eki,7.61•�+". r,J.ia��aMr•!+ iud i' _ �'. 4Y M :VTDCl *i �A �L,�, •� `A..• `. •, " . _ Jaxi. ,; 9 � 3. d thQ igh�h�otat;� -0n U Sec'b�bri ��a ,►s bel ig .�.;, holding C1suvilr ng;" th &t �� rat c�.aee "ai$y Co, ld, note• $d4�tr *011 ,' of we � .. vhiob vou'ld. parmit yi6o .o l " -fraa �Qn:fbg P - 9 r olt9' ta,A6- io3ght 04 -' bi ,diri, Ap ii�e8�4loeix{1+�,ng cah apt ofd :'at,Ito fx'cia =off' propa't_Yr c tt w1:th 'ld4 fset.m ' i�Q Wd,4 a� po,i)i �/ ,p i s - , _ , y - • S +, �r - i - - r`. - •r „ ar iT A .y _ .• •T- rr' �. *Rr t . `!` .. •s. 'i � -. .♦ - r4o- ' yT.y.F- �- `'�••.t��. ? SL-f-MOUR •8c O'CONNOR ',­ • F,: - ' b, i _ , '...;: . 31 y X• -'F%i chard;yA ", Y' 1 - +F2�' * April 2�' isb� - ".r -• -. 'y `{ r ••F'e +.} Y`'` Y, ! _ • ! �r •�` . t .l -- •1. ' .. `ti' * •'+•,rj I •r, "' ,..r ' , 'r �A s' ' ' _. ' 1 • 'SM6'�a+ o�sihim 'tYi4t ha�i =the, counatl `t�i�i ; he e ery =t� prop - sip smsndmont t�•thout Qompliaz 66 ui3 h the - ccmeot -o��u�ti� -appnara to be �. - - "� � prediQated''upodt -hie a9s�nnpti.nn , that. a 'd ®be'�tiSm �h�►t' the coneeat iO4 to ainendmen' , ta'= general p lei $cif thee Zexiit3g odi _iai' uacandat�.# s. ` ' - _' _ . tuts o�►a . rWOU1;d . resu .t in the above a epdaCory author3`satibft u n d e 'ar r tb2.ie being rat7tr4 tFed ffia di:sptbii�g�; 3ie" tii± .oa�i� of euioh gene�rr. i�clmec�ts , the conneent cliuee.: Suah' aOsu� Uc n is+ direct caitrar3r . .O ='tYie deaisioti of the i.nnQeiitbi' Suproa�+ Cbut: fi�i State. ex Dili" Foatar.'�r. k : T Cit oi'' Iii nneapolis 2 i. iri; 259• As.. cta'16d bar �Tr., ShEiah�tt an pag6 • of his 'op iii on of March p9tt� _.. x W' "U''Uhg Code'' depend 'for` ,authoriettigh'. entirely# 'upon' enatiliYig y 7. glalatio . SsC. ?�6 X28 -M. .A, et ribq " No authOiaattori for the proposed :• ' smenda_toxy' aotit�f Is 'given. by .a) tt r abo t+� .,quti'ted letatutory_ authority c - di:tional.,upon .oamnplit4de with the, consent'cladea ;•iihich'el#up -the amehdment: '+ r,. ''would diar®gard'..or (b) ari r: proviaioti .pf the nn+�bUng l0,' 'slation diapeiae ng :hsrith coin6li.snce r�t3.th the Qonaent c guar under situat3dn ` not p�ceset�0 here. - ;S^ • • •' _ - .. • � i ' \' }�.' .. t -•.J • .' -M� . + T ' •, T T ' . �- P � R.R. .- l'.3:p my op3n2on that the r Deed �imeneme�ntpuld be in�ra3d and p.., `. - = : lno feativa to 'destroy your rights - iiiplicit in �the'-fo�.lowinga etat t made`: iy } An Lei' -hton v. City, of Mintaea o'13 s if ',. Supp� ' Ola{,aaid ,quoted vitb aipprgva : - a� to ex .re : Foster -y,, y o y ;neapo .ia - dupra *. pa' ?O)i i �dbon- �t�e s are' mtib'lswo citizens buy.--- ��d- �ro�ra • " :•propertY're i�g, orb the reetrietions "prov3iftd by law,"- ',They' • .T have, a riyygli�, to the permaenay and eeour%ty that the `haw should i�thi]o Y'intsrid to appeax at the Coui ci:�.,_me "ing in opposit#,oq _ta the adoption of the proposed ordinaneo;, •1 villa file a copy of 'chid' opinion nth.' r ha .C,orpQration Counsaj' and City Clerk tp record' (a) your positi�zi that t� r p i Pr9pood ndme�►'o would,- if adopted aid, publJohed ' be •invalid, 'and (b) _gouir r iateritico to ahalletxge 'any pezRm$t the. o0netxuQt3pn oi� .ths ppopoeed building , • r R , ', ,to .a he3$ht� in 'exFeee of th( =.hei -got limy to 16n far. the' present, provS lone o the upin ,• E 1 1 .. ': t� +fiery . ,rte you3'�7t ` Cci Mr. ,Looib Pt'Sbeahart "�•.Ditectdr ofRT,aW:Y Ofi'ice .of: the Corpox:atim Counsel ,ant Paul.. 2 'Minnesota• ' � � Idl.�q} Seymou� .' • �'• .,�iaro'ld e�•r�.i3�'d:n} li:OUnQ��.- RecOrd$r ;/ •. 1 • ; ._ .• , . -Office of the _ciaty CL�xk •j • ", saint Paul 2# Minnemota; ' R�•1 - •�.••�, - e } -_ - , ', of `. -` - „ -, rK `. 1 . - •e.- -{R. +' •t s• •ti v3 t - a 1st 2n Laid over to ,y 3rd and app "1 _ Adopted � Yeas Nays eas Nays \Dalglish ollan Holland s� Loss ortinson I ortinson — Pete =son Peterson Rosen „A�} Rosen Mr. President Vavonlis M President Vavouhs 212242 ,8 / �D PUBUSHI.