210852I
ORIGINAL TO CITY CLERK
' CITY OF ST. PAUL
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
COUNCIL
FILE NO.
—
RESOLVED,;upon the pertinent appeal under the Zoning
Code, by E. Lawrence Anderson, as owner of the subject real estate
situate in the City of Saint Paul, having a frontage of 85 feet on
the west side of Chatsworth Street and a depth of•111 feet, classified in
"B" Residence District and described as follows
Lots'-,,4, 5,' and 6 and the south 10 feet of
Lot 3, Sub. of Lot 36,Como Villas;
divided into two separate parcels of equal area, each with a frontage
of 42 1/2 feet and an area of 4,717 square feet, that the provisions
of said Zoning Code be determined and varied as necessary therefor
and that a separate permit be granted in,respect of each such division
of said premises, for the erection and maintenance thereon of a two -
family dwelling structure, subject to compliance otherwise with all
applicable municipal ordinances and State•Statutes.
ZONING APPEAL
Notice is hereby liven that a public
hearing mill be held before the City
Council at 10 A.M. on January'3, 1963,
in the City Council Chamber in the
City Hall and Court Housd; in the
matter of the appeal of E. Lawrence
Anderson, under Chapters 60 to 64
inclusive, St. Paul Legislative Code,
Zoning Code, for relaxation of density
standards to permit construction of
two duplexes on insufficient area on
south 10 ft. of Lot 3 and all of Lots
4t 5, 6, Sub. of Lot 36, Como Villas,
on west side of Chatsworth between
Orchard and N.P. Ry. Tracks. '
Dated December' 12, 1962.
AGNES H. O'CONNELL,
City Clerk.
(December 15, 1962)
COUNCILMEN
Yeas Nays
Dalglish
Holland
Loss
Mortinson
Peterson
Rosen
Mr. President, Vavoulis
IOM 6-62
in
W
In Favor
A gainst
Council File No. 210852 —B Frank rank L.
Loss—
Resolved, Upon the pertinent appeal
under the Zoning Code, by E.-Lawrence 10
%tAnderson, as owner of the subject real
e tate situate in the City of Saint Paul,
having a frontage of 85 feet on the
west side of Chatsworth Street and a
depth of 111 feet, classified in "B"
Residence District and described as
follows:
!-
feet of of Lot 3, Sub: of of 36, Como
Villas;
divided into two separate parcels of
42 � feeteand d an with
rea of 4,717tsquare!
feet, that the provisions of said Zoning
Code be determined and varied as nec-
{ essary therefof and that a separate per -
q mit be granted in respect of each such
division of said premises, for the erec-
tion and maintegance thereon of a two -1
family dwelling struotdre, subject to c
'compliance otherwise with all aliplic -1
able municipal ordinances and State
Statutes.
19Adopted by the Council January 18,a
Approved January 18, 1963.
(January 26, 1963)
JAN 18 1963
Adopted by the Council 19—
JAN 18 1963
App oved 19—
Mayor
I
�f
OFFICE OF CITY CLERK
BUREAU *OF RECORDS
f
386 City Hall and Court House
St. Paul 2, Minnesota
a,
Mr. Donald L. Lais ;
Corporation Counsel
Building
r.
RECEIVED
JAN 17 1963
MRS. AGNES H. O'CONNELL
City Clerk
HAROLD J. RIORDAN
Council Recorder
CORPORATION COUNSEL
January 17, 1963
Dear Sir..
The City Council requested that you prepare a resolution granting
the attached appeal of E. Lawrence Anderson for relaxation of the
lot area requirement for two family residence use on all of Lots 41 52
and 6 and the south 10 feet of Lot 3, Sub. of Lot 36, Como Villas,
on the west side of Chatsworth St. between Orchard St. and N. P. Ry.
tracks.
ry truly yours,
�O
4iy t
Clerk� /
CITY OF SAINT PAUL - MINNESOTA 8
...........:.............
.........................
........................
............:.::...
151- 252-2$3
Mrs. Agnes
City Clerk
Building
Dear Madam:
ZONING, CITY
1313 CITY HALL AND COURT HOUSE
H. O'Connell
OF SAINT PAUL
SAINT PAUL Z, MINNESOTA
January 3, 1963
This is in the matter of the appeal of E. Lawrence Anderson requesting
the relaxation of the lot area requirement for two - family residence use
on all of Lots 4,5,6 and the south 10 feet of Lot 3, Sub. of Lot 36 Como
Villas. The property is classified in the "B" residence district and
has been since 1922.'
The combined lots result in a frontage along the west side of Chatsworth
Street of 85 feet and extend to a depth of 111 feet, resulting in an area
of 9,435 sq. ft. It'is the applicant's intent to divide the property into
two equal parcels of land each having frontage of 42.5 feet and an area
of 4,717 sq. ft. Under the "B" residence zoning requirements, the pro-
posed lots would meet the required minimum lot width of 40 feet but each
lot would be deficient in area by 283 square feet as the minimum lot area
requirement is 5,000'sq. ft.
Field investigation discloses that the subject property is approximately
5 feet above the street grade of Chatsworth Street and that basement gar-
ages would be desirable off Chatsworth Street. This would then provide
additional yard area at the rear of the lots normally used for garage and
parking purposes. The surrounding area uses are predominately single -
family with a two - family use now under constructicn to the south and one
two - family use to the west. It further discloses that the applicant's
request is reasonable and would be in keeping with the purpose and intent
of the Zoning Ordinance.
In view of the above findings, the Board of Zoning at its regular meeting
of December 6, 1962'recommended the granting of the applicant's request
as submitted.
4
Very, truly yours,
c�--t
Herbert C. Wieland, A.I.P.
e., HCW:FS Director of City Plannin
I j Secretary, Board of Zo 4
a
1 ng
P4 L-.1;
.E
_ November 27, 1962
The Honorable Mayor and City Council O
C/0 City Clerk- 4 -
Room 386, City Hall and Court House
St. Paul, Minn. b
Zoning Appeal
Applicant- E. Lawrence Anderson
The property in question-is the South 10 feet of Lot 3, and all of
Lots 4,5 and 6, Subdivision of Block 36, Como Villas. This is three
25 foot Lots and 10 -feet of another lot - making a total 6f85 feet .
of frontage on the West side of Chatsworth about halfway between "
Orchard street and the Northern Pacific tracks and is currently a `
vacant lot.-
_ I propose to build two - duplexes on this property, each on a lot 421
feet wide and 111 feet�'deep. The property meets all zoning requirements
except the density, If this block were of average size with lots of
120 ft deep it would alees meet this requirement.
I feel that the proposed use of the property would be the best utilization
of this land and would be an asset to the general area. To follow the
current'zoning 0 would,be ,able to build one of the duplexes on a lot
45J feet wide and 111 feet deep. This would leave 39J foot of frontage
and only 25 feet of this is a full platted lot and all that could•be
built is a single family home 19-feet wide. Since meeting the
requirements of the current zoning'would not be wise'I feel the construction
of the proposed duplexes would be the highest possible use of this -land.
Adequate off street parking is provided by garages in the basement and
in the driveways.-
Respectfully submitted by I- IL E D
E. Lawrence Anderson
1642 Skillman-
` St. Paul, Minn. ;9�2 VIM "0 �'� 04
511
B. KNUU
-.EN R' ALTY CO
-6100 '
^
, "r. J v
� lint G'•
M esoto
R ea! il .o
;r'Ir. rr
'rr•
.. { •'rnf r :ri � tr'r
1' -'r,,(f ,lI Iif(� rr, _
• r ,, .,
^
r r 4 I�•t• i! 'e'r�14
' ... 11H ,. r i •
i.'raaH ,a, h It
�`ii►•
.c
'rF (a +,lt.bt'F t„r
r'r
. .,.(... rr,r,r,t'
r
�nrv•.. r,r ,rrl(,
» r ., �
rr ',r ,'
••r
r:
• fir'rr• 1. ,' ,, ,,,.N II•'i• �
1 a 'Crl, \� �. � r; -�...,
f
Real Estate
Mortgages -
�'' Construction
Insurance
P? �r
PXw4dua Rea&y �.
ff,
2190 COMO AVENUE
ST, PAUL 8, MINN.
Ras. MI 45608
B KN���SRN �u� M! 435�1
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE
St. Paul 2, Minn., Deoombov 21, 19962
You are hereby notified that the Council of the City of St. Paul will
consider the matter of appeal of F. Lawrence Anderson for
relaxation of density standards to permit construction of two
,duplexes an insufficient area on south 10 feet of Lot 3, and
. -ail 'of Lots It, 52 6 sub of Lot 36, Como Villas on the west
side of Chatsworth between Orchard -and N. P, Ry.,., tracks
and that a public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the -
Court House and City Hall Building in the City of St. Paul, at 10:00'
o'clock A.M. on January 3, 11637
JAMES J. DALGLISH
8 File 15901 Commissioner of Finance.
The City Charter requires this Notice be sent from the Department of Finance