The URL can be used to link to this page

217732 ,. � ' � � ��.'�`��2 ORIGINAL TO CITY GLERK � '� • -f• _ _ . CITY OF ST. PAUL FOENCIL NO � OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK C NCIL RESOLl1TION—GENERAL FORM f PRESENTED BY P�LISI�I� `��'C , COMMISSIONE DAT RESOLVED; upon due consideration of the pertinent appeal, under the Zoning Code, by Cleon Q�rley, owner of the sub�ect real estate situate in the City of Saint Paul, described as Lots 16 through 21, except the north �+0 feet thereof, Block 6, Winter's Addition to St. Paul, zoned by said Zouing Code in "C" �Residence District, having a frontage of 23�+.7 feet on the south side of Pierce Butler Route a.nd a depth of 9�+•3 feet and an axea approxi- mating 22,132 square feet, that the provisions of said Zoning Code, particulaxly those relating to density and area requirements and restrictions, hereby axe determined and vaxied as and to the extent necessary therefor, in respect of their application to said real estate, a.nd that a special permit he��by is granted to said;appellant and his .successors and assign�, for the construc- ti.on, maintenance, and operation on said real..estate of a presently proposed 23-unit apartment building a.nd that pursuant to said. appella,nt's application therefor, a permit,hereby is gra.nted to said appella.nt and his successors and assi�ns, for the installation, maintena.nce, and operation of a 2�+-ca.r capacity off-street paxking facility on said real estate in con�unction with said proposed 23-unit apartment building, in accordance with the final plans for said, off-street pa�kingrfacility dated April 17, 196�+, hexeby approved and� herewith filed; a1T sub�ect to compliance by said appellant-permittee and his successors and assigns, otherwise, with all applicable municipal ordinances, State statutes, and rules and regulations of public authorities having cognizance. � �� , ' 4.ouncll Flle�No. 21773�By Frank L. ��Loss— . t ��Resolved, Upon due consideration of � • ��ertlnent appeal, under the Zoninc, '<<,�''St Cleon Carley, owaer of tl;''-. " b.�� '.: � �st,�., siz�at,= in,tr.> ci.,r� � � � � �c�t�. F; ,,is�v��';� as �.��s +ip Q ,�ri,,.2t�n:_c� 3... �3.: v:�.�l��.z4 e,n �j J . �.tt�i..�`,:.a_Y,d ,eihczg �.•• �. a . .�_�' �.- ° , �� , '��4� , ,•,'ry� f� :�. • --..�_- • �,'4` l, � COUNCILMEN , � Ad�� ' �PR �� „ . � opted by the Council 19— Yeas Nays � • _ Dalglish . �` � • Holland � * `Approved �� 4 '�� 19— R � ; +- �gs � � Tn Favor ,;. � Mortinson • � Peterson _. � " � , . ' r��b��dT� Mayor �/ (_ �� _ Aga�nst . - (.� �� • - M�.�resident,� ' ' � �� . iorz e-sz " ° ' ��173 �� 7 . . . . . � 3 �36 � y City of Saint Paul, Minnesota � AFPLICATION FOR SPECIAL COUNCIL USE PERMIT (Please print or type) TO THE RDNORABLE �AYOR AND CITY OOUN+CIL 96 the City Clerk ' City of Saint Paul, Minnesota Application is hereby made to install and operate a new � �cross one out) � FILLING 5TATION No. of islands and pumps : No. of tanks and capacity; �PARKING LOT for (customers) (employees) (private use) (public use) (other) (indicate type) Capacity of parking lot To be used in connection with:� � MISCELI,ANEOUS: (indicate type such as Drive-in Refreshment Stand, Used Car Lot, Dry Cleaning Pick-up 3tation, Ice Vendor, etc.) Capacity of parki.ag area: 1 *Location ��-��i�� `�'r-�.� �iy.��`'�''``"`��' Legal Description : .Lot�L-/�j-/$'-//�'� b�/ glock G Addition ��,a Applicant's Name :L7�� j � �"��-� � °V Home or Of f ice Address: �J 1 p' o —' Pbone Number , � � �� a 9�,� / -i�/BY TAE APPLICANT, -1�-6a Signature (date Address . � Phone No.: When completed: file three copies of this application form and three priats o� the preliminary lay-out plans o� the proposed facilitq with the City Clerk, Room 386, City Hall and Court House, Saint Paul, Minnesota � Z-3 6/11/56 ' *EXAMPLE: 1. S.E. corner of Main St. and First St. 2. South side of Main St. between First and Second St. i _ • - , - O F F I C,E �`�U'F �C I T Y C L E R K MRS. AGNES H. O'CONNELL , City Clerk BUREAU �OF RECORDS ' HAROLD J. RIORDAN Couneil Reeorder 386 City Hall and Court House �,� St. Paul 2, Minnesota -�� ''j� t� April 23. 1964. � '�q � es�^; � �'• "'� � ,I�S'� �F �"' �- f qpR 2 3 1964 Mr. Donald L. ?�ais, Corporation Counsel. CUKYU�tAI��I� V�u1Va�.L Dear Sir: , The Council requests that you prepare a resolution granting Cleon Garleyts appeal to relax density standards and application for a 24-car off-street parking�lot at the southeast corner of Pierce Butler Route and Victoria St'reet� according to plans dated April 17� 1964. .----� - ZONING APPEAL , . � -- V62y tMlly OLtY'S� Natice 1s hereby given th'�t a public hearing will be held before the City � Council at 10 A.M. on April 23,,1964, � C1tyh�allt a d� CourtCHouse, in he `�1'�— . umnderrCh ptersP�Oa�of�C�eclusverlst. i� Cl@Y•k paul Legislative Code, Zoning�Code, � to relax density standards to permit ' 23 units on an area of 22.132,square feet on Lots 18 through 21, inclusive, except the nortn 40 feet, Block 6, cor�ner SofAPierce�Butlerh Routehand . Victorla St. �� Dated April 9, 1984. `HAROLD T. RIORDAN. City Clerk. � p. (Aprll ld, 1984) �3 k - i ' � - I �� 11111�11�� • N��• iii •�• \h• �• •�� • �� I •r• �. . • N ��.. �� MY 1111 �il� � � �� " . � � � �•• � � � 1 �� / . � .., • �, , . ` :1? � ` � d� 1� � � � � CITY OF SAINT PAUL - MINNESOTA 8� _ . ' �P _ � t _ • �. ...,J��::�:::L'��'.:'�:':. . , � � •�:.':.'r��.•'.:�:•:�:'�'�•�':.•.�....•�:� �`��<;<:::<�:::::�:��'�:R�D` ��O F- Z O N I N G, C I T Y O F � S A I N T PAU L ` '�' :•`'•:•:�X��N�4�bF.F:131-131-133 1713 CITT HALL AND COUIT+HOUS� SAINT�AUL 4�MINN�bOTA . ..... �1 ' � - . ..... . ,. .;. i?i:{v::.•.i•i '...e. ;p - .t . � ' April 20, 1964 ., ° �� . a, - � . . � • , '- Mr.Iiarold J. Riordan � City Clerk ° • ' Building ;� � - Dear Sir; ,� ' � � �� . . . � This is in reply to the referral of Cleon Garley's 1) appeal to relax . ,� the density standards of Chapter 60.24 of the Legislative Zoning Code, ', and 2) application for a permit to install and operate a 24 car off- ' � street parking facility accessory to a proposod 23 unit apartment build- � , ing on property,� located at the southeast corner of Pierce Butler Route � � and Victoria Street which is described as Lots 16 thru 21� inclusive, ex- cept the north '40 �eet thereof, B1ock 6, Winter's Addition. The subject - . _ property was rezoned to a "C`� residence district March 14, 1964. �`. � ' - � The subject pro,perty is vacant and I�as a frontage of 234.? feet on the ' south side of P,ierce Butler Route and a depth of 94.3 feet, resulting . in an area of� approximately 22,132 square feet. Because the area is deficient, it i�s necessary for the applicant to secure Council authori- zation to permi.t 23, units. . � i � �` � , . } The Board of Zoning considered this matter at its regular meeting on ' March 19, 1964: After hearing the report_ of the staff that the building . ground cover.age was only 27.�qo. and that the parking lot plan met all of } the required st'andards, the Board voted to recommend approval of both � � matters in accordance with final plans-dated .April 17, 1964. ' . _ , _ �, Sincerely, :h j � . �. : 3 ' � "1 . . 4i ` " , .� ' 1 " _ .. - ::i.-' = v - ..� . - ,� _ �- - ` _ . B��I " � � B� R. �ei�ecording Secretary � -� Encl. � , ` ` . `! Z. F. 5434' • ' - , ' - + , CC: Mr.Janes � � , . ' ` � I ' : �� - APproved - . � � - � : . � • mber, Boar f Zoning �_ � , , � � � _ _` � ' ' ' � . . ' �� ' `� ' � � �� . f • . -4 � .- , ' � . � _ ' ' � '` � ' • y . ` ' , 9�'� / �• , • � - � 0 4 i " � � � ' - ' _ t � 'j � i , _ ° -. � t • _ � � g ,- • � 1 �` ., , r � ; � - � � . � ; . _ i . � � � _ �- - � � . - �e �"� l � LAW OFFICES � . t' � • + ; �'' � KUEPPERS, STRONG & KUEPPERS �' a � �� _, 1117 COMMERCE BUILDING � i ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA 55101 FRID A. KUEPPHRS CA►ITAL 2-8521 NARRY P. 9TRONG, .,R. � Ma.rch 12 17 V�M FRBD A. KUHPP6R�, JR. 7 OBRALD C. RUMM[L Honorable Mayor and City Council City of Saint Paul c/o City Clerk ° City Hall and Courthouse , St. Paul, Minnesota 55102 Gentlemen: ' On behalf of Cleon 0. Garley and Elaine F. Garley, the awners of the following described property, appeal is hereby made from the applica- tion of the zoni'ng code and requesting a relaxation of Standard 60.24 � which regards density. The ordinance appealed from is Chapter 64.03, Paragraph 1. � The legal description of the premises is Lots 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 and 21, except the North 40 feet of said lots, Block 6, Winter's Addition to St. Paul. The premises are situated at the Southeast corner of Pierce Butler Route and Victor,ia Avenue, and is presently vacant 1and. The property is presently zoned for apartment house use. The Garleys propose to erect a 23-unit apartment house upon the lots. The ground area is approximately 22,132 square feet. The ordinance ap- pealed from wouTd require 23,000 square feet for the proposed building, or 868 feet more ground area than is available at the site. The proposed building must be so constructed as to hold 23 units, whether or not all of such units are installed. The ground area for 22 or 23 units is the same. The effect of the limitation in this case is to substantially in- crease construction costs per unit and reduce the return to the Garleys without any particular advantage to the neighborhood. Only three two- bedroom units are included in the proposal (the other 20 units are one- bedroom units), '.and hence, the actual population density will not be very great. The existing land use directly South is exclusively residential and con-, tains single and duplex dFrellings. The premises to the West and to the � North are presently industrial. It would therefore appear that the neighborhood will not become overpopulated, notwithstanding the proposed modification of density sCandards as to the building. G 1 ' Attached hereto is a plot plan showing side yards, front and back yards, which we believe adequate and consistent with the development of the City generally, and sufficient parking space for a 23-unit building. ' Very truly yours, . KUEPPERS, STRONG & KUEPPERS /f � ' . FAKjr:�k BY . ' � ; CITY OF � SAINT PAUL � MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court Housa 55102 224-4612 '�°� April 10, 1964 City Clerk File 16386 Page You are hereby notified that the Council of the City of St. Paul will consider the matter of the application of Cleon Garley for appeal to relax density standards of Chapter 60.24 of Zoning Code to permit 23- units on an area of 22,132 s�uare feet on the following described property: Lots 16 through 21 inclusive, except the North 40 feet, Block 6, Winters Addition. The property is located on the southeast corner of Pierce Butler Route and Victoria Street. A public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the Court Houae and City Hall in the City of St. Paul at 10:00 a.m. on April 23, 1964. JAME:S J. DALGLISH Commissioner of Finance I � , ; , � t I ' � I ' I CITY OF � SAINT PAUL MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 113 Court House 55102 224-4612 �� Ap�'il 10, 1964 City Clerk File 16387 Page You are hereby notified that the Council of �the City of St. Paul will consider the matter of the application of Cleon Garley for permit to install and operate a 23-�ar off-atreet parking lot accessory to a 23-unit apartment building on the following described property: Ea- cept the Noreh 40 feet, Lots 16 through 21 inclusive, Block 6, Winters Addition. The propertq is located on the southeast corner of Pierce Butler Route and Victoria Street. A public hearing will be held in the Council Chambers of the Court . House and City Hall in the City of St. Paul, at 10:00 a.m. on April 23, 1964. JANIES J. DALGLi�Ii Commissioner of Finance I. LAW OFFICE8 RANDALL, SM1TH S� BLOMQUIST W-2581 FIRST NATIONAL BANK BUILDINO GLARENCE B.RANDALL�1882-1963� DONALD B.SMITH SAINT PAUL I, MINNESOTA � MORITZ J. BLOMOUIST " PERRY M.WILSON,JR. 224-9487 JOHN P.VITKO DANIEL W.O'BRIEN � ROBERT P.��ST - April 22� 19CJ� • { � �� City Council o� the City of St. Paul � Gentlemen: � ' � sRe: Appeal of Cleon Gaxley to relax density � standards of Chap. 60.2�+ regard3,ng Lots 16 - .21, Block 6, Winter'.s Addition We repre'sent `Molin Concrete Products Company� owner of the block ad�oining the above Garley property on the west. Molin Concrete Products Company daes not ob�ect to the construction of a.n apaxtment building .on the Gasley property but wishes to preser�re its present ' ' . � , rights of �use of its own property. For �at least 30 years the Molin property has been zoried for � light industry and has been used by the Molin family in. the .concrete � . � products manufacture business. �The 'Molin property ad�acent to the , ! Garley property is now without buildings and has been used over the years primaxily for storage of Molin'.s products. However� Molin has plans for the construction of �uture light industry buildin� or build- ings on ,such property. At that time it does not want to have ob,jection ' by the apartment house owners or occupan�s. � Yours �yery truly, � S�MITH & BLOMQLT�bT _ � .�/G� . �M�7B:m� . � i , � � �